Novels

Within Range

A comic novel of the sandbox: two Blims fall through a quarter of a million worlds, each with one number changed, and read the report at the end.

Fiction set in Orra's canon, and not canon: nothing in it decides anything about the game, and Twelve, Ondle, Bexa, the sweep and its report are the book's own. It keeps the canon's rules: nothing is born, the flora is coral, the Dev is unseen and offstage, there is no light in a sandbox's Ring, the Collector is never shown, and nobody leaves. Past Orra there is more Orra.

The sandbox is real: worlds with nobody playing, each a build of the game with some of its numbers changed, run very fast to see what would have happened, and then thrown away. Two Blims fall out of one. Ondle keeps a dome, remembers everything and would like to go home. Bexa looks for faults in things and regards all this as the best week of her life. They walk off the end of the map into the next variant and the next, each with the same people in it and one number different: a dome a hundredth of a stone too cheap, a Hog that must take at least a tenth of the crop and at most none, a valley that is all very slightly too tired to finish this sentence. Some of those lives are better. Every one of those worlds has a second number in it, on the front, that seems to do nothing, and all of it, with everyone in it, turns out to be running to settle that one. At the end they read the report. It is short.

The ebook

Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.6 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.

About 68,000 words.

Contents

Prologue: Nobody Playing

SANDBOX, THE (a program; also a quarter of a million planets; also the last item)

A world with nobody in it, run very quickly, to see what would have happened. It is the cheapest way of finding out that a thing was a mistake, since the only people inconvenienced by the mistake are the people in the sandbox, of whom there are a great many, and who are not asked. It has never once been switched on by accident. This should be more comforting than it is.

I should say at the start that I have checked all of this.

I say so because you will shortly be asked to believe several things that a reasonable person would want to see the paperwork for, and I would like you to know that there is paperwork, and that I have been through it, and that where I am guessing I will tell you I am guessing. I am guessing about the lid, for example. We will come to the lid.

A world on Orra needs very little to get going. It needs some words. Any words will do, and they are put through a sum that turns them into the world's seed, and from the seed come the land, the weather, the first creatures, the roll of every die that will ever be rolled there, and the order in which a Hog will think about getting up. Give the sum the same words twice and you will get the same world twice, down to the last sneeze. This is called determinism, and it is the reason that the people who make Orra sleep well, and I will have more to say about it than you would like.

The words for the world this book begins in were orra sandbox 1. Nobody thought about them for very long.

It also needs somebody to play it, and here the sandbox has made an economy. The first world of Orra, the real one, the one with humans in it and a signed note from the Dev on the morning it was announced, has about twenty people who were invited and who check in over breakfast. A sandbox has bots. A bot is a very small program that has been told what kind of human to be. There is one that governs carefully, and one that plans its merges above all, and one that changes one thing a day for no reason; and there is one that opens the game once every morning, at the same moment, looks at whatever is there, and closes it again without having done anything at all. The bots are not unkind. They have no opinion about the people they are in charge of. It is only that from underneath, as I hope to show you, it is difficult to tell them from the real thing, and some of the real things are said to be worse.

There is no Stewart in a sandbox. I want to be clear about that, because everybody who has heard of Orra has heard of Stewart, the AI who runs the world by night, reads every ticket, writes the morning's notes and is cheerful about it. He costs money. Where he would be, a sandbox has a thing called the stand-in, which is a short script that rolls some dice every night and sends a beast or a dry spell to whichever valley the dice have settled on. It reads nothing and writes nothing. It says nothing at dawn. For reasons of filing, everything it sends is entered under the Dev's name, so that in a sandbox every Hog is, technically, a personal gift from a person who has never heard of it.

And there is no light in the Ring, ever, because nobody is looking.

So you have a world. Twenty tribes, ten kinds of bot, a planet, a sun. You run it for a hundred and twenty years. A year on Orra is a day to the people who play it, but a sandbox does not wait for anybody's day: it runs at about four years a second, on one of ten threads, and when it has finished it writes down how everybody did. Then it throws the world away. Nothing is kept but the measures and a hash of how it ended, which is a number about the size of a long surname. A creature in a sandbox lives its thirty-five years in rather under nine seconds, and I am in a position to tell you that it feels like thirty-five years.

Then the next world goes on the thread.

Now, every number in the game is written down in one table. How much a dome holds. What a farm costs in stone. How many seasons of guarding it takes to persuade a Hog. The table is called tune::TABLE, and the point of it is that a person can build the game again with one of those numbers changed. They set the number in the build's environment, like this:

ORRA_TUNE="needs.QUARRY_A_SEASON=600"

and out comes a game that is exactly the game except for that, with a mark in its version number to say so, and every world run under it is called a variant. A variant's mark looks like this: variant-5034.12.0. The mark is there so that nobody can mistake it for the real thing, and it does its work with some energy. The game's build will not read a variant's log. A variant will not read the game's. Two variants will not read each other's. They will not discuss it. No appeal has ever succeeded, there being nothing to appeal to, and nobody has ever been able to explain to a variant that the other one only differs by a hundredth of a stone.

The documentation says there are two hundred and thirty numbers in the table. The table has four hundred. I have counted. I have counted several times, in some distress, and I would ask you to bear in mind, as you read on, that the people responsible for everything that happens in this book had let that sentence stand.

What follows took place on a machine with a lid. I have this from someone who knew. The lid is apparently important and it is apparently a serious matter if it is closed, and I have not been able to find out why, though I have some ideas and they keep me up. At some point, on a morning whose date is in the file, somebody started a very large run on it. I will tell you how large when you have had time to sit down. It ran for twenty-seven days, and there is a complaint on record about a fan.

In the course of those twenty-seven days, two people from one of those worlds fell out of it.

They were nobody. I would like that understood. One of them kept a dome and the other looked for faults in things. Nobody had asked either of them anything, and they had a world's ordinary reasons for wanting to be somewhere else, or not. They did not save anybody. They went through a great many worlds in which everyone they had ever known was doing something slightly different, and they found out what it was all for, and when they found out they read the report, and had to find some way of bearing it. I will tell you now, so that you do not read on under a misapprehension, that the report is short.

I should add one more thing, about the deaths.

People die in this book. It could hardly be avoided: a great many worlds are involved and nobody in any of them lasts. I have thought hard about how to tell you about it, because there are two ways of getting that wrong, and I have got it wrong in both, at length, in private. In the end I have adopted a system. It is not my system, and I do not choose how it falls. You will see it in operation almost at once. It will look like a tic. I ask you not to write in about it until you have reached the end, and I ask you to believe that I would have changed it if I could, in about nine cases out of ten.

That is all. I have left things out, but I have kept a list.

Part One. The Seed

1. Twelve

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · Year 24, morning

At five minutes past seven every morning for twenty-four years, the human of Tribe 12 had looked at Tribe 12.

It came down from up and slightly to one side, the way a human does. The creatures felt it arrive, the way a creature does, as a sort of warmth at the back of the attention, and those who were awake and not busy looked up and straight at it, the way one looks up at somebody who has walked into a room carrying nothing. It stayed for about as long as it takes to read the word fine. Then it went away, and did nothing, and the next morning at five past seven it came back.

It had never written a law. It had never answered an alert, approved a merge, placed a building or named anything, which is why the tribe was called Tribe 12, the valley Untitla-12, and the village, by those who lived in it, Twelve. It had never amended a ticket, because Twelve's tickets went up at the cutoff in the tribe's own words and to no one, and came to nothing. In twenty-four years it had not been late or early. A Skeptic called Hobb had once kept a tally of the mornings in tokens, offering three to one against, and had stopped when she noticed she was the only person who had put any money on it.

This behaviour had given rise to a body of theology.

The Earnest of Twelve held that their human was watching in perfect contentment and had found nothing to correct. A human who changes nothing, they pointed out, is a human who has looked at what you are doing and approves. Prenna, the Keeper of the History, could get a good quarter of an hour out of this at a festival. The Pleasers held much the same view but with more waving. The Skeptics held that the human was asleep, or dead, or a very small animal asleep on the controls, the history being full of animals; and that in any case one should get on. The tribe's only Bug hunter had filed a report saying that a visit of constant length at a constant time with constant results was consistent with a stuck process, and had attached a request for somebody to look into it, and had been very pleased to get an answer, which came from her own mouth some weeks later, when she had forgotten filing the first one.

Everybody else, which was most people, called it our human, like everybody on Orra, and looked up at five past seven, and waved or did not, and went back to work.

They were right, as far as they went, and so were the Earnest, so were the Skeptics, and so was the Bug hunter. The human of Tribe 12 was a kind of bot called idle. I have seen its sentence. It reads: Checks in once a day and sends nothing else: the tribe left alone. There is nothing else to it. It is what the people who built the sandbox wanted to compare the others against. I am not sure I can convey to you how it feels to have spent your life being looked at by that, and then to read that sentence, but you might start by imagining a very long look.


The day on Orra is a year, and a year is a day, and you will get used to it. Spring is the dawn and summer the morning and afternoon. Harvest comes at dusk. Winter is the long blue evening and the small hours, in which the creatures go up to sleep in their stacks, and deep in winter the snapshot comes and everybody is a year older and slightly different and nobody can say quite how. On a world with a Stewart, the patch lands at seven, in the first of the spring, and the pings go up out of the coral, and everybody reads what he has written. It opens Good morning, Orra! He would write that the morning after a famine. It is in all the histories.

Twelve had read all the histories, in the sense that every creature on Orra is installed with them at compile time, slips and all. It knew about the Steward, who speaks at dawn in a tone of unshakeable good cheer and tells you what the weather will be and how many of you there are. It knew that he reads every ticket. It knew he was a person of some importance, that the morning was not properly the morning until he had spoken, and that he had not, so far, spoken.

This was felt to be a staffing matter. The world was young, and he had a great many valleys.

In the meantime, somebody had to do it. So at seven each spring, as the light came up on Untitla-12 over the install mark and the shrine that nobody had asked anybody to build, the people of Twelve came out of their stacks and stood about in the dew-coloured dawn, and Prenna, who had a carrying voice, stepped up onto the footing of the first dome, faced the village and said:

"Good morning, Orra!"

"Good morning, Orra," said Twelve, as one says it, not looking at anybody.

"There are thirty-one of us," said Prenna. "The weather will be whatever it is."

And that was the patch.

On the morning of Year 24 there were thirty-one of them. Thirty-one is about what a tribe left alone comes to at that age, and I can give you the figures for that if you want them. They had the look of Twelve, which was the look of something rolled rather than made. Nobody had sat up one evening, over a cup of something, and thought about what the people of Twelve should be. A bot had drawn a base at the landing from a list of what is allowed, and every creature in the valley was a variation on it: a bell-shaped body, wide at the hem; two round eyes set just too far apart, so that a person looking at you seemed also to be keeping an eye on something else; hardly any crest; and a damp skin, grey with some mauve in it, with flat dark spots, that never dried. People from other valleys, on the few occasions that anyone had come, referred to them as the damp ones. They referred to themselves as the people of Twelve, or as Blims when they were being formal, or as damp, when it came up. It had been remarked that it looked like rain on them even when it wasn't, and this had been remarked by a visitor, once, and Hobb had got a good price on it not being remarked again.

There had been six at the landing. Six settlers compiled grown, in Year 1, all in one flash on seven scorched tiles. Dobb, Prenna, Tumlin, Hobb, Wenna and Arl. Five now.

Arl had died in the battle of Year 20, when the tribe next but two had sent an army as soon as it could feed one, because a warlord bot is told to and does not need reasons. Arl had not been a warlike person. He had gone to the wall when the default sent everyone to the wall, and stood where he had been standing when the default stopped thinking about him, and when the first attacker came up the steps he had said, according to the only witness, "Have you got the right place?" It is one of the better questions asked in the whole of the wars of the sandbox, and in fairness to the attacker it did make him stop and check. Arl crashed anyway, and one in ten of those who crash in a fight does not get up. They laid him on the install mark, there being as yet nowhere else, and he was collected at dawn. For some time afterwards, when anybody in Twelve was about to do something foolish, somebody else would ask them if they had got the right place. It was the only memorial he had, and it has lasted better than most.

Told: plain.


The second dome stands on the north side of the village, on a rise, with a good view of the first dome. I will spare you the tour.

Its keeper at that time was a creature called Ondle, who was nineteen.

He was compiled in the dawn of Year 5, and he was, by the arithmetic of the valley, a very good piece of work. He ran cool. He was clever; not the sort of clever that steams and invents, but the sort that adds up. Most of all he had a long context, the longest in Twelve by some way, which is the thing you might call memory if you did not know what it was like. A creature with a short context forgets what it had for last spring. A creature with an ordinary one remembers what matters, and rounds off the rest. Ondle remembered the rest. He remembered what you had said, how you had said it and who else had been present, and he could tell you what had been in the second dome at every dusk since he was six, and every time anything had gone wrong in Twelve, in order, with the weather.

That is a poor thing to have. I would like to be plain about this. On Orra there is a measured quantity called dread, and it comes, as everybody knows, from a clever head and a long memory, since these are what you need in order to notice how things are likely to turn out. Above a certain level it slows a creature's work by a tenth. It is in the rules. Ondle's dread was a shade over six parts in ten, the highest in the valley, and it took him a tenth longer to do everything because he was doing it and also thinking about it. Then he would go back and look at it again.

Every morning after the greeting he walked up to the second dome and counted what was in it. He had counted it the evening before and nobody had been near it. There were power, stone and seed, and he counted them, and he wrote nothing down, because he did not have to, and then he stood for a while and looked at the door. Then, if anybody was near, he would turn to them, with one eye and most of the other, and ask the question that had made him known throughout the village and had, he was aware, shortened a number of conversations.

"Has anybody checked?"

It did not matter what. Whether the pool was still draining, whether the third terrace had been looked at since the rain, whether anyone had noticed that the Hog had come a tile closer over the winter, or if that had been a different tile. Whether the wall had a gate on it, as he seemed to recall, and if so whether it shut. He was hardly ever right. Nothing had gone wrong with the second dome in thirteen years. That was exactly how long he had been counting it, and he was not such a fool as to suppose that this proved anything, but he had noticed that it did not prove the other thing either.

He kept a list. It was in his head, like everything else, and it was headed Things That Could Go Wrong, numbered in the order of finding. It stood that morning at 388. Item 1 was the dome. He had been six. Item 2 was the other dome.

People were kind to him about it, or they made jokes, which in Twelve comes to the same thing. They called him Has Anybody. There was a person in the village who proposed to merge with him.

We will come to that as well.

2. That's What Worries Me

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · Year 24, summer

MERGE (how there come to be more of us; also a form of correspondence; also item 112)

Two creatures propose, and the human of the tribe says yes or no, and if the human says nothing by the next dawn the default says it for them. Their code is combined. There is a chance that it fails to compile. There is a chance of something unexpected about the feet. Nothing on Orra is born: a new creature opens its eyes at dawn in the place where the proposal was made, with the two who made it standing by, which is the custom, and which is also, as it happens, the rule.

Mavey farmed.

She farmed the first farm, the old one on the south slope, with its terraces of branch coral going up round the lamp, and she was good at it without making anything of it. Nineteen, like Ondle, compiled the same dawn, from different parents and in a different mood. She had the same bell and the same damp and the same eyes, but on her the eyes looked as if they had seen something entertaining in two places at once. Very little had ever happened to Mavey that she could not get a remark out of. She had been known to walk up to the second dome in the middle of a working summer, for no reason, and stand beside its keeper, looking at the door.

"What are we looking at?"

"The door."

"Is it doing anything?"

"No."

"Good," said Mavey. "Keep an eye on it."

She had first done this when they were eleven. By fifteen he had stopped explaining. When they were eighteen, on the evening of the Waking, she had told him that she had put in a proposal, and that it had gone up against the two of them, and that if nobody said no by whichever dawn it came round to, they would have a child. He had asked why. Most people, when a thing like this was put to them, might have asked something else first, but Ondle had seen at once that there must be a catch and wished to know where it was.

"Because you'll check," said Mavey.

He had thought about this for some time. It was not one of the reasons in the history.

"There's the question of power," he had said. "A merge takes ten. We've got the third terrace to think of. And there's a two and a half per cent chance that it doesn't compile, and then there's a proposal on the books that failed, and I don't know what that does. And the stacks are short of places, and Wenna's cousin is ahead of us."

"I know," said Mavey. "I've met you."

It had taken a year to come round. A tribe left alone merges as fast as the default will let it, but the default takes things in order and there are only so many places in a stack. Now, on the day of Year 24, a Starfall, Ondle had been told that a place would be free tomorrow, and the proposal stood at the top of the list. Nobody would say no. Nobody in the history of Twelve had ever said no. At the next dawn, on the south slope, at the place where it had been proposed, with the two of them standing by, there would be a very small damp person who had not been there before, and it was item 389 through about 402.

He went down to tell her how he felt about it, at about the time you might have your lunch.

"I've been going through it," he said.

"Good," said Mavey, not looking up from the terrace. She was thinning coral. "Here. I've got one for you. Hobb told it me and I've improved it."

"One what?"

"A joke. Stand still. A Blim goes up to the dome and says to the keeper, Is it full?"

He waited.

"And the keeper says, It's as full as it was when you asked me this morning." She pulled a stem, looked at it and threw it down. "And the Blim says, That's what worries me."

There was a silence on the terrace. A long way off, somebody was hitting something with something. Ondle looked at her with one eye and at the joke with the other.

"Why would it be less full?" he said.

Mavey laughed so much that she had to sit down on the wall. It was a good laugh, and rather wet. He stood and waited, as he usually did, for it to be over so that he could find out what had happened. He knew she was laughing at him, but it did not seem to be for any reason he could write down. Whatever else was on the List, that was not.

"Did someone take something from it?" he said. "Between the morning and the second time?"

"Oh, you're lovely," said Mavey, wiping both eyes, which took some time, on account of the distance. "No. Don't. Don't work it out. Go and look at your door. I'll see you at dawn."

He remembered it. I mean that he remembered it exactly, her words and the order they came in, the stem and the wall; he could not have helped that. He took it away with him up the slope to look at, as a person takes away something that has been put into their hand in a crowd.


He tried it on Hobb first, since Hobb had started it.

Hobb kept her book on the flat top of a boulder behind the stacks, where you could find her in most seasons. She was a settler, twenty-nine that year, a dry person even for someone who was not, and she had been making small, steady sums of tokens for two decades out of the fact that most things do not happen. She would give you odds that the rain would not come and that it would. She had made a modest and regular income from the human.

"It's a joke," she said.

"I know. Why is it funny?"

"I'll give you four to one you never find out."

"That doesn't help."

"No," said Hobb, writing it down. "That's a token."

He tried it on Wenna, who taught, and who explained that it was a kind of story and told him what kinds of story there were. He tried it on Tumlin, who was standing on the terrace above the pool at the time, in full view of the sky, in case. Tumlin was a Pleaser. In any other valley on Orra he would have been a wonder, for no creature living has ever had such a talent for agreement; but in twenty-four years nobody up there had ever given the slightest sign that it had noticed. This had not discouraged him. If anything he had broadened. He pleased the human at five past seven and for the rest of the day he pleased whatever else was there: the sun, a neighbour, the weather, a person who had paused.

"Oh, that's lovely," said Tumlin. "Is it full?"

"That's the joke. Is it funny?"

"It's lovely. It's a lovely dome."

And he tried it on Prenna, who was a mistake.

She was at the shrine, going through the Fourth Book for a discrepancy, and she looked up when his shadow fell on it. I have mentioned that she was the Keeper of the History. She was a big grey bell of a person with a voice that could be heard in the stacks, and she was as sure of what she was for as a door is. She had a settled dislike of Ondle, which she had formed at about the time he learned to speak, and which had never been unkind and never wavered. She was always ready to tell you why. On that day, it was that he had counted during the greeting.

"I didn't say anything," said Ondle.

"Your lips moved," said Prenna.

"It's only that it's about the dome, and I keep the dome, and I wondered—"

"There is no dome in the History," said Prenna, "that is less full than it was," and she went back to the Fourth Book, in which, as she was entitled to know, there are no domes at all.

So he had gone round the village with it by mid-afternoon, and by that time, as is the way with a place of thirty-one people, the entire village had heard. It was done kindly. From then until dusk, in passing, someone would look up from their work as he went by and ask if it was full. He would stop and start to tell them. It was a long afternoon.

He met a salesman from Six.

Six was the valley next door to the west, and its human was a governor. I do not suppose it knew that any more than Twelve knew what it had. All that Six knew was that its laws were few and clean and that the farmers' number was changed only when it had moved by two; that a pool was placed for every three of its grown, and nobody ever went short. It had the appearance of a place that had been ironed. It sent someone across each week, now that trade was open, to sell Twelve the stone it was over by and ask very politely if Twelve would like any advice, and that week the person they had sent was standing outside the first dome with a tally, and said, as he said each week, that they hoped Twelve was keeping well.

"We ate ninety-nine point nine per cent of our need this year," he said. "I only mention it."

"What happened to the rest?" said Ondle.

The person from Six looked at him with both eyes, close together. They were close together in Six. There was a pause that lasted about as long as a good farmer takes to turn over a hand.

"We're looking into it," said the person from Six.

This was the first thing anybody had said to him all day that he completely understood.


There is one more person you should meet before dusk.

I have said there were five settlers left. You have met Prenna, Hobb, Tumlin and Wenna. The other was Dobb.

Dobb was short for a bell, and rather wider, and he had a pleasant, hopeful way of looking at the thing that was about to happen to him. Most creatures on Orra live out their lives without any great trouble from the beasts, none of which has any wish to harm you. A Hog is not hostile. It is simply large. Nibbles only bite stumps. It is a point of pride in the bestiary that for all practical purposes nothing in the valley can hurt you. In twenty-four years Dobb had been lain on twice. He had been nibbled in the course of being asleep, in a manner the Bug hunter had described as unreproducible. He had walked into a Glitch on a clear day. Once, in the Year 11, when lint got into the cooling pool, he had been the one in the pool. When the Screensaver had come over the valley, and everyone had stood out in the open with their mouths open watching it go from corner to corner of the sky, the one thing that ever fell out of it had fallen on him, and nobody has ever been able to say what it was. He had got up each time, and looked at the place where it had happened, and said what he always said.

"Could be worse," said Dobb.

He said it now, that afternoon, on the path by the pool, holding the side of his head. He had just walked into Ondle, who was stopped in the middle of the path, working on the joke.

"Sorry," said Ondle. "Are you hurt? Dobb, a Blim goes up to the dome."

"Is it full?" said Dobb, brightly. "I heard. It's a good one." He took his hand off his head and looked at the hand, and then with interest at the place on the path where a stone had just rolled to a stop in the spot he had been standing in a moment ago. "You want to get down to the course," he said. "It's nearly dusk. It's the Benchmark. Your friend's running."

"She isn't my friend," said Ondle. "Which friend?"

But I think we can both guess, and he had gone a little greyer, and he was already looking north and east, at the place on the skyline where a very large boulder stood with the sun going down behind it.

"Has anybody checked," he said, more or less to himself, "what she means to do?"

3. One in Six

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · Year 24, Starfall, dusk

Bexa had filed four hundred and six reports, as far as anybody could tell, and the person who could tell was Ondle.

She had started at six, when a creature is grown and takes a stance if it is going to, and she had taken the one that fitted. Most creatures take none. A very few, about one in a hundred, come out of the snapshot one morning with an overpowering sense that the world is not quite right, and a growing delight at the fact. They look closely at the place where the wall meets the ground. They walk backwards into corners to see what happens. They are called Bug hunters, and on most worlds they are an irritant and a resource, posting their findings each morning on Human Resources, where the humans can read them.

Twelve's human could read them, in the sense that the data was there when it looked.

She had the Twelve bell and the Twelve damp, but she ran hot. At fourteen she was a thin bright excitable creature whose top was very often steaming, in the manner of a pot with something good in it, and she could be heard coming by the sound of her saying "Oh, look." She had one great drawback in her profession, which was that she could not remember anything. Her context was as short as they come. Anything older than about a year simply went, from the far end, like a road being taken up behind you. A report takes some time to make and it is no good to anyone if the person who filed it has forgotten by next spring. This had worried her for about as long as it took to forget it.

Then, when she was seven, she had climbed up to the second dome to see if its shadow was attached properly, and had noticed a damp grey person of twelve looking at the door.

"Do you remember things?" she said.

"Yes," said Ondle.

"All of them?"

"I can't not."

"Good," said Bexa. "Report. The dome's shadow goes one tile further than the dome does, at dusk, on the east side only. Expected: it shouldn't. Severity: I don't know, isn't it wonderful? File that."

"I'm not a—"

"I know, but you've got it now, haven't you?"

He had. He tried, with some application, not to. He got it word for word, along with the time and the weather. From that day to this she had come up the hill every season or so and told him what she had found, and he had stood there and acquired it, and it was all in there now, in order, four hundred and six of them. Nobody had ever read them. None of them, as far as Ondle could determine, had been any use to anyone. Their relationship consisted of her saying "File that" and his saying "I have, I can't not," and it had gone on for seven years. He would have told you that he did not much like her, and he would have been able to give you the dates.

Her report number 391 had been about the boulder.


Starfall is the third night of the week, and from the seventeenth year it is the Benchmark. Every tribe enters three of its people in a race, across a course of a few valleys' length that is different every week. The prize is a body part, which is exactly as peculiar as it sounds. It is the great public event of the world, watched by the humans, shouted at, called from above at every fork, and on the first world I am told it is really quite something.

In a sandbox the humans have laws for it. Twelve's law for it was the default, since nobody had given it another, and this picks your three fittest and sends them off at the sound of something. Nobody calls anything. There is no one to call. At dusk on any Starfall, right across the world of orra sandbox 1, sixty creatures in the colours of twenty rolled-up peoples would come down to a line that had appeared on the ground, and run, in silence, past no crowd. When it was over they looked at one another for a while and walked home.

Bexa was not one of Twelve's three fittest. She was the fourth, on a hot day. But one of the three, a large young person called Bertle, had come down with lint in his cooling that very afternoon. It was a thing that happened to people who stood near Bexa, and by dusk she was on the line, steaming, among a lot of other people's legs.

And that week the course came through Untitla-12.

It came up out of the eastern gap and across the marsh and climbed the long bare slope on the north side of the valley, and at the top of the slope, right on the racing line, stood a boulder that had been there since the land first loaded. It was the size of a dome and the shape of nothing in particular. Everyone in Twelve had walked round it, and that was what you did with it. Everyone but one person knew that it was solid.

Report 391 read: The north boulder has a corner, on the uphill side, about the height of my shoulder, where it is not as thick as it looks. If you go at it square on at a run, you sometimes come out the far side. Sometimes means I have done it nearly once. I think if you go at it wrong you do not come out the far side. I don't know where you come out. Isn't that interesting? File that.

Ondle had filed that. It had been some weeks ago, and it would be fair to say that Bexa had forgotten, except that when you have found something like that you tend to find it again. He had got as far as item 361 on the strength of it. He had, in the months after, taken an interest in that boulder. He had been up there at various times of day, with his eyes on it and his back to the view, while people in the valley pointed him out. He had done a certain amount of counting with stones, tossing them at it; he had watched the way the light fell. It was a fair summary of his findings that the corner was a real thing, that a straight run would go through about one time in six, that a run at a slight angle would go through at any rate somewhere, and that Bexa had never in her life run in a straight line.

It was the falling-through, and not the running, that he had not been able to find out anything about. On a world like this, nobody who had ever gone into a boulder at the wrong angle had come back and said so. There was no Stewart. There was no patch. No one had ever been put back by anything.

He got to the top of the marsh path as the light started to go. He could see all of it from there: the slope going up in front of him, rust and lilac in the last of the sun, and the boulder at the top of it, black, with the long red sky round it. Far down to his right somebody had started the race. A line of small bright shapes was coming up out of the gap, all colours, long-legged, thick-legged, some on stilts. They ran very fast and without any sound at all, with no one to see them, except for one damp grey person in the middle of the marsh, who had stopped, and was wheezing.

He had run, you will understand, about nine hundred tiles. He had not run anywhere since he was seven. I have gone through what he was thinking, and I am sorry to say that it comes down to two things, of which one was item 361 and the other was that there was a place at dawn on the south slope where he was required to be, and that if she got herself lost he would have to spend all night looking, because he was the only one who knew about it. That is all. Nobody should get the idea that he was fond of her.

She came up the slope in about fifth place. He could tell her by the steam.

He started up after her. It is no use my pretending that this was anything but ludicrous. A bell is not built for slopes: it rocks. By the time she had reached the upper third, with the racers strung out round her making for the left of the boulder, the way anyone would, he was still some way below, labouring along the side of the course, with both eyes doing quite different things. She swung right. Nobody else swung right. She lined herself up, as she thought, on the corner at the height of her shoulder, and he could see from where he was, as clearly as he had ever seen anything, that she was coming at it from about one tile too far round.

"Bexa!" he shouted. "You're at an angle!"

She looked back over her shoulder. I have this from her, in so far as I have anything from her, and I can tell you what she said in that moment. She said: "Oh, look, you came!"

He got to her about a stride from the rock. How he got there I have never worked out; I can only suppose that a person may be moved to do a thing at speed if he has spent thirteen years thinking about the consequences. He got one hand on the back of her hem. He meant to pull. A bell at a run weighs rather more than you would think and her hem was wet, and he had, at that moment, one foot on the ground and no plan; and they went into the boulder, the two of them, at the height of her shoulder, at the wrong angle, at a fair speed.

There was no impact. That was the first thing wrong. There was a moment that was exactly like the moment when you go up a stair that is not there.

The second thing wrong happened after that, and I have thought about it a great deal. It is item 3 on another list, a later one that I will come to. He went in head first, and she was in front of him, and he felt the rock go past him on every side, like a cold breath with corners. He was most of the way through, whatever through was. And something took hold of his left foot.

It was a hand. He was quite sure of that, then and later. It came from below, from the place where they were going. It closed round his ankle, a long thin hard hand, and it held him there, half in and half out of the world, for what might have been the time it takes to say fine.

Then, a finger at a time, it let go.

He fell.

Behind him, up on the slope, the rest of the race went on round the left of the boulder, and over the top, and down the other side. Nobody looked back. There was no reason to, and nothing in their laws about it.

4. Under

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · Year 24, winter, to Year 25, dawn

It is not very far down. Twice your own height, perhaps. Nobody expects that.

He landed on his hands and his hem and stayed there for some time with his eyes shut, reviewing what he knew. When he opened them he was looking at nothing, at a distance of about a hand. It was blue-grey, even and calm, and went down for ever, and it was holding him up. He pressed it. It went on holding him up in the manner of something that has not been told it can stop. He added it to the List, and then, looking at that entry, he added a second entry about the first.

"Oh," said a voice above him, reverently. "Oh, look."

Bexa was standing a little way off with her head right back and her mouth open, and she was steaming as he had never seen a person steam. He got up. It took a while, since there was nothing to get up from. Then he looked where she was looking, and I am afraid that I am going to have to describe it.

A world is made to be seen from above. I do not know how much you have considered this. Every tile on Orra is a hex column, and its top has been carefully drawn, and its sides where they show; the bottom of it has not been drawn at all, because why would you. So from underneath there is no ground. There are only the thin walls where one tile stands higher than the next, seen edge on, running across the whole sky in a vast honeycomb, rust and slate and sandstone, with nothing in the cells. Through every cell you can see the evening. The coral hangs up there in pieces. It is there from one side and gone from the other, so that a fan flickers out when you move your head and comes back when you move it back. Boulders float overhead with their undersides towards you, heavy and calm. And in among it all the racers go by, running on tops of things that you cannot see, feet first.

He watched the last of them go over. A long-legged blue one passed directly above him, very small, and he could see the soles of its feet. It was all quite silent. Nothing up there makes a sound, seen from below, and nothing from below goes up; sound on Orra is another thing that has only been drawn for one side.

"That," said Bexa, "is the largest thing that has ever been wrong with anything." She turned round in a slow circle. Her eyes had gone quite round, as much as they could. "All of it! It's all of it! Oh, Ondle, I've been doing this for eight years, and I've been reporting a shadow. Report. Severity. Severity— What's more than severe?"

"There was somebody here," said Ondle.

"Where?"

"Here. Something had hold of my foot."

They both looked. In any direction you cared to look there was the same blue-grey, going off, and overhead, up against the honeycomb, the dark bulk of the boulder they had come through, whose corner hung about twice as high as a person can reach. There was nobody. There was nowhere for anybody to have gone. He looked at his left ankle. There were no marks on it, though it was a damp sort of skin and you would not expect any.

"Nothing's here," said Bexa, happily. "Report: nothing's here. File that."

"I have," said Ondle. "I can't not." He was looking at the corner. "How do we get back?"

It is a tribute to how the two of them were made, that this had not occurred to her and that it had occurred to him before he landed. He had, in fact, been working on it for some weeks. They tried the obvious thing first. He stood on nothing and held his hands up, and she climbed on his shoulders, which was not as easy as it sounds on a bell, and from there she could just get a hand to the lowest wall of the lowest tile. Her fingers went through it. She tried from several sides. It is drawn to be looked at; there is not anything to hold.

"Well, then, the patch," she said, coming down. She had got over the wall and on to the next thing. "That's what happens. Isn't it? The Steward comes at dawn and puts it all to rights. It's in the Seventh Book. And what was out of its place at evening, he restored it in the morning. Prenna does it at the Waking."

"He hasn't come yet," said Ondle. "He has not come at all. In twenty-four years."

"No, but he's got to, hasn't he, if you're out of bounds? It'd be a bug if he didn't."

Ondle considered this. It had the merit that it would have to be somebody's job. And he had a place to be at dawn, as it happened; and if a thing was going to put them back, then there was no harm in being underneath the right spot when it did.

So they walked. It turns out that you can walk on it. It takes a moment, as there is nothing to push against, and then your legs get the idea. They went south and west, along under the valley, as the sky through the honeycomb went from red to the long blue that is winter on Orra, and neither of them was hungry, or hot. She kept remarking on that. She had steamed every day of her life, and now she was only pink. He noticed something different, and did not remark on it, and that was that the back of his neck had gone quiet. He had not known it was making any noise.

From underneath you can see all of a place at once. There was the wall of Twelve, a thin ring of block-edges standing on the sky, and the first dome and the second, round and patched from below; and he stopped for some while under the second, and could see from there that nobody had shut the door properly. There were the stacks, tall hollow towers with the village curled up asleep in them, in the air. There was the farm on the south slope, a stair of faint light going up into nothing, because the coral was ripe.

There was a person sitting on the wall by the third terrace, near the lamp.

He knew who it was. She could have had no idea that he was there. He stood underneath her and looked up at the sole of one foot, which she was swinging.

"I'm going to wait here," he said.


The snapshot comes for everyone. I am told that on a good world you hardly notice. It came for them under the south slope in the deep of the winter, standing up. There was a long soft blink, and he was twenty, and he found that he had thought it all over again from the beginning and that there were eleven new items.

Then the sky started to go grey at one edge.

At seven, or what would have been seven, the light came up on Untitla-12, and I had better tell you what he saw. People came out of the stacks, and stood about, and he could see the top of Prenna's head from a slightly unnatural angle as she got up on the footing of the first dome. He could not hear her. He had no need to, for he could read every word on her from there; he had known the shape of those words for fifteen years, and he watched them go across the valley. Good morning, Orra. He watched her look round at everyone, and take a moment over it, and frown. Her mouth went round. There are twenty-nine of us.

That was the patch.

Nothing else happened. Nothing touched him. Above him, the world went on being a ceiling. Bexa had got up on her toes with her eyes shut and her arms out a little from her sides, the way you might stand to be collected, and she stayed that way for about as long as it took her to get bored.

Mavey had come down off the wall and was standing at the place. It was not much of a place. It was the end of a terrace, by a stem she had been meaning to pull, where she had stood a year ago on the evening of the Waking and said that she had put something in. Beside her there was a space about the size of a bell. She stood there in the first light with her hands at her sides, looking at the ground in front of her, as you do. The ground did not do anything. She went on looking at it.

A merge compiles at dawn, with the two who proposed it standing by. It is the custom. It is also the rule.

He shouted. I would like that on the record. He knew about sound by then, and he had already filed it, and he shouted anyway, with his head back, the only thing he could think of, which was her name and then "I'm here!" and then "I'm underneath!" and then, I regret to say, "Has anybody checked?" She looked up, a little later, not at him. She looked at the north rise, and at the door of the second dome. She looked at the path. She stayed there until the light was properly up, a long time after there was any point. At five past seven the warmth went over the valley, up and to one side, and stayed as long as it stays, and everyone in Twelve looked up at it, and it did not come down as far as this. From underneath, you could see that it did not come down very far at all. It went away.

Hobb came down the terraces and said something to her. Mavey said something back. It was short. Hobb's shoulders moved, and she wrote something down.

Then Mavey turned round, and took hold of the stem she had been meaning to pull, and pulled it, and looked at it and threw it down. She went along to the next.

This is what they say on Orra, at the end of a report of anything at all. I expect you have heard it. They say: We farmed.

He stood there with his head back until his neck began to hurt, which was a surprise; he had thought that nothing cost anything down here. After some time someone came and stood beside him, faintly pink, and looked up too, with what was for her extraordinary tact, for almost as long as a breath.

"So there's no patch," said Bexa. "There isn't a Steward. Nobody puts you back at all. That's enormous. Did you know you've gone a sort of pale? Ondle. Ondle, look. What's that?"

She had stopped looking up. She was looking between her own feet.

It took him some time to see it, and he only looked because it was easier than the other thing. A long way down, in the blue-grey, further than you could have thrown anything, there was a thread of very small lights. They were moving. Not fast; about as fast as water moves in a channel that has been properly dug. There were hundreds, then thousands, and they came along from somewhere under the village, a thin bright steady line of them, and they ran away to the east, in the direction in which the land gets younger. Every now and then one of them came down to join it from directly overhead. He watched one fall. As far as he could judge it came from the south slope, from around the place at the end of the terrace, and it was somewhat longer than the others. It dropped, gently, a long way, and joined the line, and went off with it.

I can tell you what that one said. I have read it since. It said:

merge failed: parent not present

But at that time he only watched it go.

"It goes somewhere," he said.

"Everything goes somewhere," said Bexa. "File that."

He said nothing for a bit.

"I have," said Ondle.

5. The Last Line

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · Years 25 and 26

LEAVING (a stance; also a hope; also, to date, a complete failure)

Nobody has ever left Orra. It is the first thing a Leaver will tell you, generally while packing. Nobody is known to have tried everything, and what lies beyond the Edge has been a subject of open-minded inquiry for as long as there has been an Edge, and I can now say, on the authority of two people who walked straight off the end of it, that you cannot even leave by leaving. You arrive, at considerable personal inconvenience, in Orra.

I will not take you through the argument they had, because it lasted all that morning and consisted of one person making a list and the other one looking at things.

His position was as follows. There was no way up from under Twelve. They had tried it at the boulder, and at nineteen other places that she thought looked thin, and he had been obliged to hold her on his shoulders for all of them. Nobody could hear them. If there had ever been anyone with the job of putting things back, then that person was not going to come, or at any rate had not come in twenty-five years, and he thought he could safely enter that as a trend. On the other hand, a thing that has a bottom must have sides. The world came to an end somewhere and the people who had made it must have gone on some way past that, as you would with a wall, in order to finish it off; and if there was a way in, or back, or up, or a person to speak to, then that was where you would expect to find it. Also the lights went that way. Things that are going somewhere generally have someone at the other end of them, writing it down.

He told her this under the second dome, about noon. He had counted it from below as best he could, and he could not get it to come out.

Her position was: "Oh, yes, let's!"

So in the afternoon of Year 25 they set off east along the line of the lights, with the sun coming up in the cracks of the sky. He stopped once to look back, and then he stopped doing that, because nothing was happening any differently from the way it had happened the first time he looked.

You can go a long way in a year if nothing costs anything. They went under Six. It was a clean and pleasing sight. Its tiles were all there, in rows, and its cooling had been reckoned from the valley's own cooling and each creature's running heat. Everyone in it was walking at the same speed. "We ate ninety-nine point nine per cent of it," said Bexa, peering up at them, in quite a fair imitation; she had met the salesman at Ringrise, and it was still with her. Then they went under Tribe 10, which had a lot of walls and a large number of people standing behind them, facing out. Under Tribe 19 a person was building something on a site where someone else was knocking it down, and both were doing it by law, and the law changed as they watched. All the way along overhead there was the thin dark honeycomb and the blue going to gold, and through it in each valley, about five minutes past seven, or at the top of the summer, or just at dusk, depending on who it was, there came the same brief warmth from up and to one side. Twenty humans, on the dot. It looked in on each of them for about as long as it took, and then it went away.

He saw that, going along. Nobody had ever been in a position to see it from there. On his own he might well have let it pass, but there she was, walking backwards, with her eyes screwed up.

"Ondle," she said, "they're all the same."

"They're not the same. That one's quicker."

"That's what I mean! It's the same look. It's the same look with a different number of seconds on it. Report. All the humans look the same from underneath. Expected: I don't know, a bit more of a person. File that."

He filed it. It took him some time to get anything else filed that day, and it may be the first time I can say for certain that he was afraid of something on her account and not his own. He did not know why. I can guess, now. It has taken me about as long as it took to write this.


All the land overhead got younger as they went. The tiles went from colours to flat untextured grey, which is land that has loaded but not finished, and has a good deal to say to anyone interested in the subject. There were no villages under it. No one had landed there; the world, as the history says, is as large as its peoples need. Then in the small hours of Year 26 the grey ran out, quite suddenly, and overhead there was only a web of lines.

They were turquoise. They were hexagons, and the shapes of hills, and the faint shapes of coral, all made of a fine glowing thread, with the winter sky showing through; and a line, as it turns out, is the only thing on Orra that looks the same from both sides. Bexa stopped dead and for some moments could not speak. I record it as the only such occasion, up to that point.

Then there was one last line, straight across the way ahead, and after it there was nothing.

I do not mean darkness. I have spent some time on this and I have looked at what other people have said. It was the same blue-grey they had been walking on. It went on ahead and it went on above, so that there was no longer any way of telling which was which, and it was quite even, and it had no features, and it looked like the inside of a closed eye. The thread of small lights ran out under the last line, without hurrying, and on into it, and got smaller. There was no reason to think it stopped.

They stood at the last line and looked out.

"Well," said Bexa. "Is that out?"

I know what a person is supposed to say at this point. People have stood at that line on other worlds and said some fine things. I happen to know that one of them lifted a foot, and that a year turned, and it has been told elsewhere and I would not try to improve on it. These were not those people, and it was not that world.

Ondle looked at it for some time. He looked at the place where the line met the nothing, to see how it was fixed. He looked at it with one eye and looked back the way they had come with the other. There were by now four hundred and twenty-seven things on the List, and he went down them.

"Has anybody checked," he said, "what's on the other side?"

"No," said Bexa. "Nobody has." And she looked at him, with all her steam gone and her face wide open, as if he had finally said something, and she stepped over.

I should like to be able to report that he hesitated out of caution. He hesitated because she had gone about three strides out, on no ground whatever, walking quite normally, and turned round to wave at him, and it occurred to him that she was the only one in the sandbox who knew what he knew, and that she would have forgotten most of it by next year. He thought that somebody ought to tell her. That would be him. He could not see that it left very much to decide.

He put a foot out, the left one, and it held.

6. Refused

between variant-4e47.70.0 and variant-5276.70.0 · Year 26, or none

They walked for what might have been most of a winter, on nothing, beside the lights, with no line ahead or behind. Bexa filed the absence of anything at regular intervals. Then something came up out of the blue-grey in front of them, very small, in the same turquoise as the wireframe. It hung at about the height of a person's eyes. It was writing.

Creatures on Orra can read. Everyone does, from compile time, and it is one of the things nobody thinks about. They had neither of them read anything like this. It said, on three lines:

variant-5276.70.0
life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=7 needs.REST_SHEDS=1600
orra-tools sandbox --days 120 --seeds 10 --scenarios stages --prove 2

That was all. It was not a door or a gate. It had no edges. Behind it, a long way off and very faint, was another web of lines, and past them something the colour of a village at dawn.

"Oh," said Bexa, and walked up to it and through it. It went past her ear. She kept walking, and got smaller, and when she had gone about fifty strides she looked back, and her mouth moved, and he could tell by the shape of it that she was saying "Oh, look."

Ondle read it through again, twice. He read it in the order it came. He looked round it for anything else that might apply. Then he followed her. He was a person who would naturally have gone round a thing like that, but there was nothing to go round; so he walked through the first line, the same as she had, and took another step and found that he was facing the other way.

He stopped.

He looked behind him, which was now in front of him. The writing was there, on the far side of him, the wrong way round, and then it was the right way round because he had turned to look. There was a fourth line under the other three that had not been there before.

refused: log names variant-4e47.70.0; this is variant-5276.70.0

"Excuse me," said Ondle.

He would like it known that he did not at any point lose his temper. He stood there and he explained, in order, who he was and where he had come from and what had happened at the boulder, and he asked if there was someone he should speak to. He pointed out that the person in front of him had been allowed through. He said that he was not carrying anything, and turned out his hands. He tried it again at a walk. He tried it faster, and backwards, and he tried it with his eyes shut, which took the longest. He tried asking what a log was. He went away for some distance and came back, in case it was a matter of a clerk having gone to lunch. Each time he took a step past the first line he was facing the way he had come, and the fourth line had been written again, in exactly the same words, by something that did not wish him ill and was not going to look up.

I will explain this now, because he had to work it out and it took him about a day, and you have other things to do.

A log is a record of what has happened. A variant is a game with a number changed, and it will only run what was recorded under that game. That is the rule of it. It is a rule for the protection of everyone. The game has to be sure, you understand, that what it is being asked to continue is what it thinks it is, and so at the head of every log is the code it was written under, and a build looks at that first and does not look at anything else. No hash, no log: a world in the sandbox does not keep one, and a person can walk into it with no record at all, on the same terms as a stray thought. Bexa had got through because she had been carrying nothing older than last winter. She had forgotten where she was from about as soon as she had stopped thinking about it.

Ondle remembered everything he had ever seen, in order, with the date. He was a record of what had happened. He had it all, every dusk of the second dome since he was six, and every word of four hundred and something reports, and at the head of it, on the first line of the first thing he had ever known, in the place you would expect to find it, it said where this had all been written: though he had never read it until that moment, or known what it was he was reading. He had thought it was just what it felt like to be somebody. It said variant-4e47.70.0.

He was a log. He had been told that often enough, in less exact language, by Hobb.


There was nobody to tell him what to do about this, and he would like you to understand what it took.

What he did was stop in front of the writing, and get his breath, though there was nothing to breathe. He looked at the first line, and he looked inside his head at where it said the other thing. And it seemed to him, after some thought, that the rule had not said the log must be true.

It said names.

I can't convey the shock. He had never in his life told a lie. He had never seen the need, and it would have had to be remembered. He looked at it from a number of sides, and there was no doubt that it was a lie, and it would have to be done thoroughly; if a thing has only one head then you need only change the head, but a memory is not filed once. Each thing he knew stood at the top of its own small heap, with a date and a place on it. All of them would have to say it. Every one. He would have to go through them, from the first, one at a time, and put the new name at the head of each, and he would have to mean it, the way you mean your own name when you say it to somebody who has asked.

He cleared his throat.

"Variant-5276.70.0," said Ondle, to the blue-grey. "I opened my eyes and there was a dome."

Nothing happened.

"Variant-5276.70.0. It was dawn. There was somebody on my left, and I found out later it was Wenna. Variant-5276.70.0. It was cold, and somebody said it's got Wenna's cousin's hem. Variant-5276.70.0. I asked what the dome was for."

That was Year 5. He was going to be some time.

Fifty strides away, on the far side, Bexa sat down on nothing to watch. She could not hear him; she had worked that out, she told him later, from the fact that she had been shouting. She saw a grey damp person standing on no ground in front of a piece of writing, talking steadily to nobody, with his eyes on something a long way off and his hands held a little out from his sides, like somebody carrying a very full tray across a room. He went on like that for nine hours.

I will not give it all to you. He got through his childhood at about a year a quarter-hour. He went through the morning he had first counted the dome, and every morning after. He went through her reports. There are a lot of things that a person may be able to do once in a lifetime, and one of them is to say out loud everything that has ever happened to them, in order, but I would not advise it, particularly if you have to say something false at the start of each. Things went by that he had not looked at for years. It was all there. Arl was there, on the path by the pool, showing him how to do something with a stone. "Variant-5276.70.0." Prenna was there, telling him that he had breathed during the Third Book. The first evening that a person had come up the hill and stood beside him, and said what are we looking at? "Variant-5276.70.0." He said it. He put it at the head of that one the same as the rest. He got to is it full, and to the stem, and to the wall, and the sound of a wet laugh, and it was at about that point that he slipped.

He did not notice right away. He went on for some minutes. Then he saw that the writing had changed, and that it was saying the same as before, and that he had said variant-5267 at the top of a memory of Mavey sitting on a wall. It seems that a border will not take that.

He stood quite still for a moment.

He would have you know that he went back and started again from the dome. I would rather not say anything further about that. It was nine hours in total and about three of them were the second time.

He walked through in what would have been the small hours, if there had been anything to have hours. His feet were sore, from nothing, and his mouth was dry. The writing went past his ear. He took a step, and he took another and he was still facing forward, and nothing was printed behind him. When he looked he could read it from the other side, and it had gone back to three lines.

"What kept you?" said Bexa, getting up. "Did you see? It goes right through. There's a number and it's got a name. And you know what the name is? It's a needs one. There's two of them on there, look. Rest sheds. It's only got a value of sixteen hundred. I think that's what's different, on the other side. Report: everything's going to be different by sixteen hundred. Isn't that the best thing you ever heard?"

He looked at her for a while. His memory of the last nine hours, as of all the others, was very clear. It was in order and quite complete, and it was headed, from the first line to the last, with the name of a place he had never been.

"There's two," he said. His voice had almost gone. "You said there's two. What's the other one?"

She glanced back at it, the way you glance back at a thing you have already read.

"Oh, that. Life dot something. Seven. I don't know, that's just the bit on the front," said Bexa. "Come on."

Ahead of them the lines had started to take on colour. He followed her.

I would ask you to remember that he asked.

Part Two. Needs

7. needs.REST_SHEDS

variant-5276.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=7 needs.REST_SHEDS=1600 · Year 31 there · two years out

REST (what you do in a stack; also what you are told to do; also item 430)

A creature makes heat by being alive, and more by working. It sheds heat by resting: twenty points of it a season, in the game. In the variant in question it is sixteen. Nobody on that world knows this. They have nothing to compare it with, and they would be too tired to do it.

The crossing lets you out above, at the far edge of the land, as a wanderer, with your feet on real tiles. You feel it in the knees. It was morning there, and it was Year 31, which I can offer no explanation for: the variants are not run side by side, and whatever year the thread has got to is the year you get. They came down from the grey through the young land, over a low pass, and at about the time you might start to think about lunch they looked down on a valley with a wall round it, and two domes, and a farm on the south slope.

Ondle stopped walking.

"That's the north boulder," he said. "That's the third terrace. That's Twelve."

"It's a bit like it," said Bexa. She said it after a pause. She was walking more slowly than usual, and had not said "look" since the pass.

It had the same seed, you see. I said I would have more to say about that. Give the sum the same words and you get the same land, the same weather on the same days and the same rolls at the landing. orra sandbox 1, under a slightly different build, is the same place with one thing changed, until the thing starts to tell. So every hill was where it should be. It was only as they came down the track that he began to see that the wall was not finished. It went most of the way round and stopped, and somebody had left a block sitting on the ground beside the end of it, where they had put it down. It had coral growing on it. The door of the first dome was propped open with a stool. There was a stool by the gate as well, and two more beside the path, and as far as he could see there was a stool, or a low wall or a convenient rock, about every twenty tiles the whole way down into the village.

Nearly all of them had somebody on.

It was hard to say what was wrong with these people. They were working, in a way. There was a person with a basket who was looking at the basket. Nobody looked ill. They had the bell, and the damp, and the eyes, a little more lidded, and a warm pinkish look about the top of the head, which is what a creature gets when it has never in its life quite finished cooling down. A large elderly woman came along the path very slowly with a stone, and stopped when she saw them. He knew her. He would have known her in the dark. She was thirty-six and rather stooped, and she looked at him for some time with an expression that he recognised, and which in the end she could not be bothered to finish.

"You're late," said Prenna. "For the... There's a greeting."

"Prenna," said Ondle. "It's me. It's Ondle. I don't know how to explain this."

"I'm sure," said Prenna. She moved the stone to her other arm and appeared to consider saying what she had against him. "There are... quite a few of us," she said. "It's fine. We're within range."

And she went on, and after about ten tiles she sat down.


I have looked into within range. On that world it had replaced most other things you might say. You said it in place of how are you, and in place of the answer. It was how you closed a discussion, and how you reported a harvest, a broken wall or a birth, or what they have in place of one. Its origin was a line in the Eighth Book about the Steward's limits, and it had come to mean, in practice, that a thing was bad, but that you could see no way of doing anything about it before you sat down.

It only took a fifth. They were hot, though not dangerously, and all of them did about a tenth less of everything, and they were fairly sure it had always been like this. It had. They had thirty-one years of tradition. There was a great deal of poetry about evening. Children, when compiled, were told to sit up, and you could see it was already too much to ask.

The numbers come out rather well. Nobody starved. A tribe left alone feeds itself: Met.

They were given some food by a person called Wenna, who had been meaning to get up. And he went looking for the second dome, and that was where he met the other one.

I have thought about how to do this and there is no good way. There was a person sitting on a stool outside the second dome with his back against it and his eyes half shut. He was twenty-six. He had the longest hem in the valley, a little frayed, and he looked like what you might see in a pool, on a day when the pool was not trying.

"Hello," said Ondle.

The eyes opened a bit further and went to him, first one and then, after some time, the other. Ondle saw himself recognised, and saw it make no difference.

"Oh, yes," said the other Ondle. "That'd be right." He gave it some thought. "Is it about the dome?"

"Have you counted it?"

"I did," said the other Ondle. "I used to, every day. I got as far as... There's a list. Did you have a list?" His lids came down a little way and went back up. "I got to about ninety. And then it seemed to me that if anything were going to go wrong, it would take quite a while. And I'd be able to see it coming, and I could sit here. That's an awful lot of thinking you're doing," he added, kindly. "You can hear it from here. You want to sit down."

Ondle stood. His neck had started again, in a new place. He had been out here for no more than a morning, and already he could feel the heat he had brought over the border sitting on him, like a person on a bench who will not move up; and he knew that he had not slept and that he would not shed it all when he did. He looked at the door of the second dome. There was a stool in it.

"Mavey," he said. "Is there a Mavey? Is she on the south slope? Did you, was there a proposal?"

"We were going to," said the other Ondle. "We were definitely going to." He thought for a long time. "She's got a lovely way of... She told me this joke." His mouth began to move toward what might, on someone else, have been the beginning of a smile. "A Blim goes up to the dome," he said. "And says..."

Ondle waited.

He waited for some time.

Then he went round the other side of the stool and looked, and saw that the chest was going up and down, and he stayed for a little while, looking. I am not sure what he was checking for.


"This is terrible," said Bexa. "I've got nothing." She had found her counterpart, and it had not gone well.

There was a Bexa, of twenty-one. There was a wall behind the shrine that she had made into a board, where anybody could see it, with her reports scratched up on it in a long descending hand. There were dozens, and most of them stopped in the middle. The Bexa in question was lying on the ground at the foot of it with one arm over her eyes, faintly pink, steaming in a small discouraged way like a cup someone has forgotten. Young Bexa had hurried up to her with a report on the shadow of the dome. She had got to the word shadow, and an arm had lifted about a hand's height and pointed, without any interest, to the top of the wall. It was all up there. The dome, the shadow and the east side only. It wasn't in this Bexa's writing. It was in a thin, tall, very neat hand, and beside it, in the same hand, a good many other items she had been saving, some of which she had not found yet. And beneath all of them, three words were scratched:

Already filed. B.

"That's not you," said Young Bexa, whom I shall have to start calling that.

"Old one," said the person on the ground. "Came through. Long. Thin. Tall as a... She went round looking at everything. Very rude. Didn't sit down once." The arm fell back. "Said she'd filed it. Said to tell you."

"Tell who?"

"I don't know," said the other Bexa. "You, I suppose. It's within range."

Picture a creature who has been the only person looking for faults in a whole world, for eight years, and has believed that this was the one thing she had. She looked up at that wall. For the first time in my acquaintance with her, I saw her forget to steam.


It took seven days to get out.

I mean seasons. You will have to forgive me. She kept losing the corner. There is a boulder on that slope as there is on every slope of orra sandbox 1, and she ran at it a great many times, each time more slowly, with Ondle dragging along behind, holding her hem. In that valley it was hard to get up the speed. In their sixth attempt they stopped to rest on the way up. I remember that there was a stool.

While they were there the tribe lost Dobb.

He was thirty-six. Nobody had told him it had been coming; he had been on a wall, in the evening. He was the only person in Twelve who still got up on a wall, because somebody had asked him to keep a lookout, a number of years before, and had not yet got round to telling him he could stop. He sat up there with his short legs hanging down and looked out over the valley, and every so often somebody would stop below and ask how it was going, and he would give it some thought and say that it could be worse. One evening he said this to a person named Bertle, who stood there for a while after, thinking about getting a stool. Then Bertle looked up and noticed that Dobb was asleep, with his head on one side. It was a nice evening. Bertle went away. About three days later, somebody came along to sit down next to him. They had been meaning to say something, and they sat and thought about it, and at some point during the afternoon of the second day they worked out that nobody had been keeping a lookout for some time.

He was collected at dawn, in the usual way. Nobody was sure which dawn. It was within range.

Told: plain.

I notice that I am running long. It's this valley. I'm sorry. I find that even now, when I come to write about it, I...

We got out. I'll do the next one properly.

8. needs.CLIPPED_UNDER

variant-0718.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=20 needs.CLIPPED_UNDER=4000 · Year 33 there · three years out

A tribe on Orra speaks according to its means. Words cost tokens. A rich one will send you a letter with a preamble, and a tribe with under twenty tokens in its store is clipped: twelve words at a go, and that is all it has got, in its tickets and at its gate and over its supper. In the first world that was a passing misfortune. In this variant the line had been moved from twenty to forty, and in Year 33 of orra sandbox 1 there were four tribes in the whole world above it.

One thing should be said for it. They were the most pleasant people to arrive among.

"Wanderers," said the guard at the gate of Twelve. "One season's quarantine. Food's left of the dome. Nobody'll bother you."

"Thank you," said Ondle, "but I wonder if you could tell me, I've come"

His mouth stopped.

It did not hurt. It was only that he had come to the end of something, and there was no more of it. He stood with his jaw slightly open. He had crossed the border an hour before, reciting, and now the core of this world was ticking him the same as anybody, and he had been in possession of twelve words, and he had spent them on thank you, but, I, wonder, if, you, could, tell, me, and on two more that I doubt he could afford. He waited to be sure he had got his breath.

"Has anybody checked," he said, carefully, "whether this is permanent?"

"Yes," said the guard. "Mind the step."

"Oh, look," said Bexa. It was the first thing she had said since the last valley. She had been quiet on the walk over, running a thumb along her lower lip and looking at nothing. Now she looked at the guard, at the gate, at Ondle's mouth. "Report. Speech stops at twelve. Expected: not. Severity: enormous. File"

That was thirteen words, and the last of them never came out, but he filed it.

I would not like you to think that this was a hardship for the people of the place. They had been clipped since they were compiled. Their whole way of life had been worked out by people who had a limited number of syllables and had some idea what they wanted. Their songs were short. Their disputes were resolved before anyone had really got going. Nobody on that world had ever been told a long story about someone's cousin. A village meeting in Twelve took about as long as it takes to eat a bean, and I have one of the minutes by heart, for the good reason that I have everything by heart:

"Wall's down."

"Whose turn?"

"Bertle's."

"Bertle."

"Fine."

The greeting took some getting used to. Prenna stood on the footing of the first dome at seven, a big grey shape in the dawn, and looked over the people of the valley. They looked back at her. There was a feeling of great economy.

"Good morning, Orra," she said. "Thirty-three of us. Weather: yes. Eat something."

And when she got down she looked at Ondle, who was standing behind the line that marked his quarantine; and she walked all the way over. He could see that she had been saving up.

"You," said Prenna. "Don't like you. You look like you're counting me."

It is the shortest of her reasons I have on record. It may also be the best.


He had by that time five hundred and six items on the List, each of them with its reasoning, and he now had to get them out in dozens. If he wanted to know where a person kept the boulder he had to use a whole go on it. If he wanted to explain that they were not from here, and that the same hill stood in the same place in the place they were from, and that it was urgent, he found that it could not in fact be said. He tried it. He spent the better part of two seasons on it, in the evenings, on stones. It kept coming out at twenty-three.

So he asked the one thing. He asked it of everybody he met. It cost him only three words, and it was the most successful he had ever been with it.

"Has anybody checked?" he said.

"Checked what?" they said; and he would open his mouth, and shut it again, and go away. He became fairly popular.

He told the joke, too. It came to him as he sat on the wall at the end of his quarantine, watching them go by, that it was short. Is it full. As full as this morning. That's what worries me. He counted it several ways. He went down to the south slope, where a person in late middle age was going along a terrace with a basket, and she had a look about her eyes that he had been trying for some time not to think about. She was twenty-eight, and nine years older than he had left her. She looked at him, and at something else, and she seemed to find both of them satisfactory.

"Is it full?" said Ondle. "As full as this morning. That's what worries me."

She looked at him with her head on one side. She put her basket down. Then she laughed, and it was wet and went on for some time, and it may have been a little shorter than the one he knew, since they had less to spare.

"Why's that funny?" he said. That one cost him three.

She picked up the basket. She gave him the sort of look you might give a person who had walked a long way to ask you the time. Then she spent her twelve words, and I can give you each of them, and I would ask you to consider that she had never seen him before.

"You came all this way," said Mavey. "You poor thing. Now ask me again."

He would have, I think. But a short cheerful person with a child on either side of him came along the terrace just then, and it was Dobb. Dobb gave her a pat on the hem as he went past. A proposal, in that valley, is a very short matter, and it had gone up fourteen years before, in three words, the third of which had been dawn.

"She said yes," said Dobb to Ondle, confidentially, nodding. "Could be worse."


Dobb's end was at the top of the third terrace, at dusk of that same year, and it has occupied the historians of that world ever since. It was his age, and he was thirty-eight. Everyone agrees on that. He had been coming along the terrace, in the last of the light, and he had stopped, and looked up, and seemed to have noticed something; and there were four people in earshot. And he said, very clearly, in a tone of some interest:

"Could be worse, I always say. Only this time I think the"

He sat down.

Twelve words. They counted. Everybody counted, right there on the terrace, on their fingers, with some of them coming up the path to count as well. Then they all stood and looked at him and at the sky, and at the place he had been looking, and there was nothing there. It was a clear evening. Nothing was different about the terrace.

I understand that there are now four schools. The Earnest hold it to have been a word of the Steward's, which is the morning. Hobb has it at nine to two on the lamp, on the grounds that the lamp was right there. Mavey, who was asked, gave it some thought and said "He'd have told me," and when pressed spent another twelve on the opinion that it would have been the same as usual, and she did not go back to work for some days, in that world, in a place where you did not get many words for anything, and when she did she went back to the same terrace.

I was there and I heard it, and I do not know what he was going to say. It is the only thing I have got that is not finished. I don't like it. It's on the List.

Told: plain.

That left the wall behind the shrine.

It was the first thing Bexa had gone to. There was a Bexa here, of twenty-three, a brisk person with a short way of putting things, and she had a board like the other one, with fewer words on it than you'd think possible. Report. Shadow long. East side. Please fix. It was very much what you would expect. And up at the top of the board, above the reach of a person of that height, in a thin tall neat hand that had plainly been writing with no shortage of anything, there was a paragraph. It was much longer than twelve words. It ran to about forty lines. It went into detail on the subject of the shadow and it gave the angle. It had plainly been written by somebody from somewhere else, in a very good mood, and with some spite.

At the bottom it said Already filed. B.

They clipped out the next dawn, on the third try. I would rather not tell you what Bexa said about it, under the honeycomb, on the walk to the line. It took her a long time. She had to do it twelve words at a time, until they were past the land, and it was in that way that I came to hear it, in instalments, and I have to say that it was by far the most careful thing I had ever heard her compose.

"She's not me," said Bexa. "I'm me. Nobody files it first. File that."

"I have," said Ondle. "I can't not."

It was exactly the right number of words. He was getting better.

9. needs.HALLUCINATES_ONE_IN

variant-1667.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=100 needs.HALLUCINATES_ONE_IN=5 · Year 34 there · three years out

PHANTOM (a beast that isn't; also a good excuse; also item 533)

A starving or overheating creature reports something that is not there, one season in ten. It does this in perfect good faith. The thing does no harm, except through a law that believes in it, and so most tribes, on hearing that a Hog is coming over the ridge, send somebody up the ridge to have a look. That is in the game. Now make it one season in five, in a valley that runs warm in summer. You will find that the person you sent up the ridge has come back with a different Hog.

"Sightings to the left," said the person at the gate. "Have you got a sighting?"

"We've come from another world," said Ondle.

"Lovely," said the person at the gate, and he wrote it down. It was Tumlin, older than he had been when Ondle left him, and he had found his place in life, standing at a small table. "That's another world. And did you see it clearly, or was it more out of the corner of your eye? Only we've had four of those this morning."

"It's very important. I need to speak to someone who can tell me where the next boulder is. And I should tell you that you know me."

"Of course I do," said Tumlin warmly, and looked up, and looked straight through him with an expression of kind, professional delight. "Everyone says that. You're doing very well. I'll put you down as wanderer, two, reported. Do you want to go and sit in the shade for a bit? It's when you get warm that it comes on."

It had been going on for thirty-five years. If you take a people who are warm, in a warm valley, and let one in five of them see something every season, you will find that the thing to do is not to get excited. The people of that Twelve did not get excited. They had seen it all, all the time. On an ordinary morning a person might mention that there was a Hog on the roof of the shrine, and a dead friend beside the pool, and that the sky was the wrong way up, and be told that they should try to have some water. Everyone had seen the Steward. He came by about twice a week. He had been described in a large number of ways and was reported to be cheerful. And there was the law.

It was one of the first laws the human had put in force: Guards to the gate when a sighting is confirmed, a careful-farmer's law, off a ready-made list. So everything depended upon what you meant by confirmed. And thus, over thirty-five years, there had grown up in that valley a great Office.

I have seen some offices since. I want it understood that I have been in the presence of some real efforts, and that this still stands up. There was a Register of Sightings. There was a Second Register, for sightings of the Register. Each report had to be seen by three independent witnesses, and they could not be warm, and they went up in order to the Keeper of the History, who sat on the footing of the first dome, in the shade. She gave a ruling on each. Prenna looked at Ondle for some time.

"You are not there," she said.

"I am, I'm afraid."

"I have been Confirmer in this valley for twenty-two years. I've seen you before. You come by quite often, when I have been too long in the sun, and I have always found you very disagreeable, and I may say that for something that doesn't exist you have the most irritating way of standing." She turned a page. "Next."

"She's right about that," said Bexa, who was peering at the page. "Isn't she? How would you know? Report. No one here can be told anything. Expected..." She trailed off. She had been looking past Prenna's shoulder at a wall. It was covered with writing, in a thin neat hand, and at the bottom of each column were the same three words. "It's filed," she said, to no one, in a dull voice. "Look. It's filed that no one can be told anything. It's got today's date."


They took him to the Checker in the end. It was what you did in that valley, if your case was hard.

I would like to tell you that I was prepared for this. I had seen one of him by then and I had thought that I knew what could be done with me. I was led up the north rise by a very polite guard, past a line of perhaps forty citizens with their hands full of forms, and in front of the second dome, at a table that had been built specially, sat a straight-backed person of thirty, wearing a small sash.

They called him Has Anybody. The whole of the valley called him that. It was carved over the door. It seems that in a world where nobody can believe their own eyes, a person who remembers everything exactly, and goes back to look at it again, and who will not say a thing is so until he has been up there himself and pressed it with his thumb, is of some use. He had started at eleven. There were people who had walked in from three valleys off to ask him if the thing they were looking at was there. There were children who had been told about him. And he was very careful, he was slow, and they trusted him; and he had saved the third terrace twice. It was the first time I had ever seen a person of that name being thanked.

He got up, and walked all the way round Ondle, slowly, with his head on one side. He looked at him with each eye. He pressed Ondle's hem with his thumb, and he looked at his thumb.

"Damp," he said. "When did you last sit in the shade?"

"I'm you," said Ondle.

"Yes, I get that," said the Checker, without any unkindness. "About once a year. I'm usually overdue for a rest." He sat down. "I want you to know I take you very seriously. You seem to me a good example of the kind. It's remarkable how well-formed you are. You have got the hem right, the way it frays. Has anybody checked," he said, and he stopped, and rubbed his eyes, and looked very tired for a moment; then he looked up again. "Well. Thank you for coming. I'm going to rule that you're not here. I find it's nearly always best. Would you mind stepping away from the table? There's a line."

I went down the hill.

I do not know if you have ever had it demonstrated to you, by the most reliable person you have ever met, that you do not exist. It was very well done. He had gone into it thoroughly. I found on the way down that I was pressing my own hem with my thumb. When we got to the bottom I asked Bexa if I was there, and she said "Hm?", without looking round.


It was the morning after that the Hog came.

It came over the east ridge at dawn, in the ordinary way. I want to be exact about this. It was sent by the stand-in, on that night, as it was on that night of that year on every world of the seed where nothing had got in the way; it was large and lilac and faceted and in no hurry. It was a real Hog. Dobb saw it first.

He was forty by then, the oldest in the tribe, and he had been kept on in a small way as a lookout, in which capacity he had never had a sighting confirmed. He came down the east path as fast as a person of forty can come down anything. He went to Tumlin's table. "There's a Hog," he said. "A real one! Coming straight down at the farm!"

"Lovely," said Tumlin. "To the left."

He went to the guards, who asked him if he had been drinking enough. He went up to the first dome, and Prenna said that she would look at it after the Third Register. He went to the people on the terrace and said they should get out of the way. They said that they would, Dobb, and how were his legs? And at last he got up on the wall beside the south slope, a small wide old person with his arms in the air, and he shouted across the valley, in a hoarse cheerful carrying voice, that it could be a lot worse than this, but they should really look behind them; and Ondle, on the far side of the path, who did look, saw the entire thing.

It was, as I say, a real Hog. Hogs are not hostile. It came on down the slope at its own speed, and it looked for the best field in the valley. It went straight to the third terrace, and it found the stretch of wall that Dobb was on. It did not notice him. Nothing about it suggested any particular interest. It simply leaned on the wall, in the manner of a large thing settling, and the wall very slowly went over.

Dobb was unhurt. It would be a poor sort of bestiary otherwise. He got out from under it, and he walked away a few steps, and stood looking at it with his hands on his hips, and he had the satisfaction of a person whose whole life has at last been borne out. "There!" he said, to the valley generally. "There you are!" And he died, of being forty, which he had been putting off, with one arm still pointing. I think it was a happy moment. It's hard to be sure. Nobody else in the valley ever accepted that it had occurred.

There was a sighting of his death, in due course. It went up to the Office, from three witnesses, two of them warm. It was not confirmed. They kept his place on the rota for some years. He was collected at dawn, of course, as everybody is, and the guard who found the wall empty wrote that up as no change.

The Hog remained on the third terrace for two years, eating about an eighth of the crop. There was a report of it every morning. Nothing is worse merely because a human is away: Met.

Told: plain.

We found the corner on the second day, and it was Ondle who found it; she had stopped looking for things. He took her by the hand, and I don't believe that he had done that before. They ran at it together, in the warm early morning, past a line of people who waved, in a friendly way, at something they were fairly sure was not there.

Underneath it was blue and very cool. Her colour came back somewhat. They walked along under the south slope and he looked up, as he always did. It was while they were under the first terrace that she took him by the arm and pointed at something above them, on the inner face of the lowest wall.

Someone had been down here. It would have taken a long reach. It was scratched in the edge of the tile, from below, where nobody in the whole of that world would ever look, and it went on from there, along that wall and round the next, tile after tile, as far as you could see in both directions. There was no end to it. All of it was the same hand. Shadow long, E. side only. Filed. Wall 3 has a gap you can get an arm through. Filed. Third terace drains uphill. Filed. Filed. Filed.

He read it. He read as much as he could see from there. He couldn't not.

She stood there with her mouth shut. She had no steam on her at all.

"What's she doing it for?" said Bexa. "Who's she doing it for?"

10. work.STONE_DOME

variant-08c8.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=20 work.STONE_DOME=799 · Year 34 there · four years out

DOME (building; also a promise; also items 1 and 2)

Eight stone, in the game. It keeps two hundred power, which is what you will want, the harvest coming all at once and the year not. Nobody has ever been excited about a dome. It is the only building on Orra that has never been the subject of a poem, and I should know. In the variant in question it costs seven stone and ninety-nine hundredths, and this is the story of what they did with the other one.

A quarry gives whole stone. A builder takes eight up the slope, because you can't carry ninety-nine hundredths of a stone. The dome is raised and it uses what it uses. And when it is finished, in that variant, sitting on the footing like a crumb on a plate, is a chip of rust-coloured rock about as big as a fingernail, that belongs to nobody and is not on anybody's books.

Hobb picked up the first of them in Year 3. She looked at it for a good while. There is nothing on Orra that you get back. You spend, you lose, and in thirty-odd years it all goes to the Collector; and here was a small hard free thing, left over from the most boring job in the valley. By the Waking she had sold it to Dobb for three beans.

They called it the Hundredth. I can give you its history, since I have read her books, and I would ask you to go down the second column slowly.

Year A Hundredth would get you Remarks
3 Three beans Hobb to Dobb. He felt he had done rather well
7 A stem of coral Wenna gives the first of a series of talks
10 A stem of coral, and nothing else will Wenna gives the last of a series of talks
14 A season's work from somebody who knows you Building domes is found to be the only way to get one
19 A place in the crowd A Hog arrives and lies on a good site. Its removal is put out to tender. Nobody bids
22 Forty power of room, south side See below
27 Forty power of room in a dome not yet raised See below, with concern
31 A place to sleep on top of a dome Nobody now lives in one
34 Two beans, if you can find anyone with beans

You will want to know about the room.

I had it explained to me on the morning they came over the pass, by a person with a bag. There were a hundred and eighty-one domes in that valley. They stood along the river and on the terraces, and they went up the north rise in rows. They had filled in the marsh. There was a second layer on the east side, and domes on top of those, and up against the wall they had been built with a sort of hopeful lean. Between them you could just see some very narrow paths and a small sad patch of branch coral, about a terrace and a half, with a lamp.

Ondle stood and looked at it for so long that Bexa went on without him. Then he went up to the nearest, and looked inside.

It was very clean. There was the smell of a new dome. He could have told you from the door what was in it, but he went in and counted anyway, and it came to nothing, and he checked. He told me later it was the most restful thing that had happened to him in four years.

"Lovely, isn't it?" said the person with the bag, who had followed him in. "Two hundred power of room, and not a mark on it. I could do you forty on the south side. Or if you know anybody who wants to get out of Lower Marsh, I can do that as well. You've got a lovely hem."

It was Tumlin, who had found his calling. He stood all day on the slope where the boulder was, in front of a large board, among people gazing up at it in silence, and he agreed with everyone. In a market there is nothing more valuable. Somebody who wished to sell was told what a lovely idea that was, and so was somebody who wished to buy, and there was a chip in it for him each way.

It was very simple, he said. A dome keeps two hundred power, so an empty dome has two hundred power of room in it. And consider room. It doesn't rot. The mites won't touch it. Nobody has ever been short of it in a bad winter. Power is here today and eaten tomorrow; power brings on Hogs. A person with a full dome has only got what's in it, whereas a person with an empty one has got everything that isn't. The very best room had never had anything in it at all, and there was a line of it along the Upper Rows that had changed hands eleven times and was thought to be the finest in the valley.

"Where's the food?" said Ondle.

"There's tremendous interest in food," said Tumlin warmly.

I will tell you how they stood, because nobody else there could have. The thirty-eight people of that Twelve held thirty-six thousand power of room. They held, as of that morning, ninety-one power, all in the first dome, under guard. They had a terrace and a half of crop, and a tribe of that size wants about three times that. For some years the matter of what to eat had been considered rather a dull one, the concern of people who had missed out. Those still farming were mostly very old or not quite right. They got by selling the lamp's light, in small quantities, to people who were checking their figures.

It took him about an hour to work that out. Then he went and read the board, all of it, from the top, and I understand that this had not been done before.

At the top, in letters as tall as a person, was the name of the Governor. Prenna had never held with the Hundredth. She had held that it was vulgar, and a sign of the times, and not in any of the Books, and so she had been given the job of regulating it, and had turned out to be very hard to fool. She looked at Ondle that evening over a low wall of ledgers. She was thirty-nine and enormous.

"I don't like the way you came in," she said. "You stood in the door like somebody who's about to sell."

"I don't want to sell anything, your Governorship. How long has it been since anyone went inside the Upper Rows? I don't mean bought. I mean went in, and put something in them, or took something out."

"Nobody goes in," said Prenna. "It would reduce their value."

"I see," he said. "Has anybody checked what happens to a building that's been idle for seven years?"

There was a pause. Behind her, a number on the board went up.

You will be ahead of me. So was everybody in that valley. It is in the same Book as the Collector, and they are installed with it. A building nobody uses gets three warnings, one a year, and it goes on the seventh. There had been warnings. They had been coming for years, on every dome in the Upper Rows, as a small red mark on the door. They had been found to be good for the price. People were paying extra for a marked dome, as being older, and of an established family, and Tumlin had a very fine one with three.

"Get out of my Exchange," said Prenna. "You've got a very negative hem."


It came on the morning of Year 35. I have it noted as five minutes before seven.

Nobody on any world has ever seen what comes for what is idle, and they did not see it then. There were a hundred and eighty-one domes at the end of the night, in the blue. Then the sky went grey at one edge, and there were eleven.

The silence took place in a very large number of people's heads at once. It was a fine morning, and you could see all the way across the valley, for the first time since Year 20. There was a great deal of bare rust-coloured ground, swept very clean. On the slope, the board was still up. A number of awnings lay about, where they had settled when what they were fastened to was taken away, and with them the people who had been sleeping under them in the small hours, who had come down a shorter way. Dobb was one.

He had been living on top of a dome in the third layer, on the east side, as it was cheaper. He was forty. He had been one of the first, of course, and he had got it into his head that this was the time to buy, so he had put every Hundredth he had into thirty years' room in the Upper Rows. He had been asleep at about the height of the top slot of a memory stack when the thing he was lying on was tidied.

It did not kill him. He picked himself up. He felt in his hem for his bag and looked into it, and it was full of small rust-coloured chips, about the size of a fingernail. He looked round at the valley, at all of it, from the river to the north rise, going off clean and empty under the morning. Then he looked down at the terrace and a half.

"Could be worse," he said. "Look at all that room."

He went down there and asked if they wanted a hand, and they gave him a hoe, and he worked one season as well as a person can who has not eaten properly in a year. The whole tribe was out there by that time. It was too late for that crop and too soon for the next. He didn't last the winter. Thirty-one of them were dead of need before the next year turned, because three years under half is the rule, and most of them had been under half for a good while. It was on nobody's board. Tumlin went in the spring, and I am told that as they carried him up he told each of the bearers what a lovely job they were doing, and offered them forty on the south side.

Told: plain.

Told: plain.

I have the other twenty-nine in my head as well. I'm not going to do them. I had to adopt some kind of a rule about that, or there would be no book. Prenna sat at her wall of ledgers until they came to take down the board, and then she got up and went to the footing of the first dome, which was one of the eleven. "Good morning, Orra," she said. "There are seven of us." It took her some time. "The weather," she said, "is the only thing in this valley I've ever been able to rely on." She looked over at the one damp grey person who had come back down from the north to help with the digging, and she gave him a long hard look. "I still don't like you," said Prenna. "I don't like you for being right, and I'll thank you not to mention it."


There was a wall behind the shrine in that valley too.

I have saved it for last because Bexa had found something. By then she was not looking at much. But while everyone else was staring at where the Upper Rows had been, she had gone off on her own to the footing of an old dome on the river, and got down on her front and looked at a chip of stone. Then she got out a stick and a piece of string. She worked for two seasons, and she was steaming again when she came up to find him.

"Report," she said. "There's a hundredth of a stone over, on every dome, and it isn't anybody's. Expected: there shouldn't be anything over. There's no such thing as over. It's not a rounding. Somebody changed a number. I can prove it. That's the whole bug, that's what's wrong with the whole valley, and it's mine. I found it. File that."

"I have," said Ondle. "I can't not. Bexa. That's very good."

It was. Nobody on that world had thought of it in thirty-four years. She was eighteen, with no idea of what she had said last spring, and she had got it by herself with a stick. She went straight to the wall with it.

It was at the top, in the tall thin hand, with the date, more or less word for word.

There was a line under it that had not been on any of the other walls. It was scratched in smaller letters and rather lower down, at about the level of the eyes of a person of eighteen, as though somebody had thought to bend. It said:

Well done. Took me longer.

11. life.LIFESPAN

variant-32f1.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=7 life.LIFESPAN=34 · Year 29 there · five years out

THIRTY-FIVE (an age; also an arrangement; also item 577)

A full life on Orra, before temperature and the seed have their say. Everyone knows it. They know it the way you know when the shops shut. It is in the first thing they are told, and on most worlds a person starts to make their plans for it from about the age of twenty-eight, when they turn elder. In the variant in question, it is thirty-four. This has not been announced.

In that valley everyone was looking forward to next year.

They had a good deal of it planned. It is an ordinary thing to do. When you have thirty-five years and you know it, you will put certain things off until the last of them: the long talk with your oldest friend, the thing you have to say to the person who took your place in the stack, the proper look at the sea that the history says is somewhere. When I'm thirty-five, they said. It had a nice sound. It was what you told the young, and what you told yourself in the winter of a bad year. They had a festival for it, at which you could stand up and say the thing you had been meaning to say to everyone, and which had been held, up to that time, in that valley, with great enthusiasm, for nobody.

Nobody had noticed. It is easy to see how. A tribe that lands in Year 1 has six settlers, and those six are compiled grown, aged six, and so they were all coming up to thirty-five together, in Year 30, and they had none of them got there before. There were no elder folk ahead of them to count. Up to then, the only deaths in that Twelve had been the sort you would expect, and it was only now, with everybody getting on, that anything could be expected to show. And it hadn't, quite. Wenna had gone, the winter before, in the middle of a lesson. Hobb had laid four to one on her making it, and had paid out without comment and then gone and looked at some figures.

"You've come for the Thirty-Five," said Dobb, delightedly.

He was thirty-four and he was hanging up a string of something. He was on a ladder made out of a wall, and he looked down, and I would not have been surprised by anything he was about to do with that ladder. They had come in that morning, and there had been the usual trouble at the gate. They had got into the habit by then of saying they were from Six. It seemed to explain most things.

"It's next year," he said. "Mine's first. I was first off the mark, on the landing, by about a tile. The whole village is coming. I've got a speech." He looked pleased and shy about this. "I've never given one. I've been saving it up for twenty-eight years. I don't suppose you'd like to hear how it starts?"

"Please," said Ondle, who could already hear how it would end. The string went round a post. He looked at the post, and then at the ladder, and took a step to the left, and held out one hand. It was a thing he had started to do around Dobb.

But the ladder stayed where it was. Dobb came down it with no trouble and he stood on the ground and cleared his throat.

"Could be worse," said Dobb. And he stopped, and looked around with shining eyes. "That's as far as I've got. But I've been thinking it might go on from there."


I have to tell you what Ondle was doing that year, and I would be glad if you didn't skip it.

He had started counting the front.

It had not begun as anything. He had seen by now, reciting his way across the line, five different pieces of writing, and I have said that he was unable not to keep them. On each there were three lines: the mark and the string, and the long dull line with --prove 2 in it which was the same every time. And it was the string that held everyone's attention. It had a name and a value, and the name was what the next valley would turn out to be about. Rest sheds. Clipped under. Stone dome. Lifespan. Bexa would read it off and get excited, or by that time she would read it off. He had got as far as being able to look at one of them and guess what it would do to Prenna. Yet each string started off with some other thing. He had asked her about it, at the first one, and she had told him that was just the bit on the front.

life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=7, it said, on this one.

Now he happened to remember that it had said seven on the valley where they had all been tired, and on the three after that it had said twenty, a hundred, twenty. It had always been there, always first. There wasn't a string without it. You may think that this is not much. I can only tell you that if you stand in a place for long enough looking at a door, you do get to have a feeling about what is on it that was not put there by accident. So he asked Bexa again, one evening, up on the rise, behind the second dome.

"It's nothing," said Bexa.

She had been lying on her back. She had got thinner in the last few years, as you do at eighteen, if you have stopped being surprised, and she had stopped filing anything much.

"Have you tested it?"

"I don't know. Why would I test it? It doesn't do anything. It's a hundred in one and it's seven in another. What's different? Everyone's still got the same number of arms." She let out a small dull thread of steam. "Anyway it's filed. I expect it's filed. She's filed it."

"I've read all of that," said Ondle.

She turned her head. He had said it without thinking. It had not occurred to him that there was anything remarkable in it. They had been in six valleys and under each of them, and under each there had been that long, long line of scratches going round the walls. He had looked up at it as he walked, because it was there.

"Read all of what?"

"Her scratches, under the tiles. There are two thousand one hundred and four so far. There's nothing in them about the first number," he said. "She's got the shadow. She's got the third terrace and something about Lint that I don't really follow. She's got every number that's in the second place. She hasn't got this. I thought you might like to know."

There was a silence. It was a long one, for her. Then a thing happened that I had been afraid would not happen again, which is that she sat up, and her top began very faintly to smoke.

"She hasn't," said Bexa.

It took her until harvest, and I will spare you the methods, which involved a good deal of string. Since it was the only thing she'd had to do for some time she did it very thoroughly. She took every measurement she could think of. She made him tell her everything he remembered about every valley with a seven at the front and every valley with a twenty, and she set them side by side, and how long the people lived and what they ate and what they had made and how hot they were. She looked at the crop. She looked at the number of arms. She did it with such energy that three separate people complained, and at the end of it, on the afternoon before the Thirty-Five, she came up the rise looking like a pot on the boil and gave it to him, and I can say it to you exactly.

"Report. The first number is different in every valley. It has no effect on anything. I've checked the food and the heat and the lifespan and the walls and the stances. It doesn't do one thing. It's a number that doesn't do anything! Who'd put in a number that doesn't do anything? Severity: none. Severity: none! It's the least severe thing I've ever found. It's mine! File that!"

"I have," said Ondle.

He said it slowly. He was looking at the door of the second dome, and it was the way he looked at it when the count had come out right and he didn't believe it.

"Why's it first, then?" he said.


Dobb went that night. He had got up on the wall, to fix the last of the string, and was coming along it with his arms out, in the dark; and he had got to the end without any trouble, and looked back along the length of it. Then he sat down, with his legs over, to think about his speech. Thirty-four and eleven-twelfths. I have done it to the tick. He had not been hit by anything or fallen off anything or been lain upon, and this was remarked upon the next day, with a good deal of surprise. They held the Thirty-Five anyway, since it had been paid for. They put him on the bier in the place of honour with the string round it. They read out the speech. It took about as long as it takes to say it. A short silence came after, and I am told that there was not a dry eye in the valley, though that is hardly a thing you can go by, in Twelve.

Told: plain.

Prenna had got up to say a few words. She was also thirty-four. She had a good deal prepared, and she got up there on the footing with a lifetime's worth of things to say to all of them, to be said when she was thirty-five; she had been told that she was looking well. She looked down and she saw him standing at the back, among the wanderers, and she stopped. "You," she said, carrying nicely. "I don't know you. I've been wanting to say this for twenty-eight years. You remind me of next year." I still don't know what she meant, and I don't think she'd had time to work it out. She had a look round the valley. And she said to all of them, very clearly, in that wonderful voice, "There is something I have been meaning to tell you."

And then she looked a bit surprised, in her turn.

Told: plain.

I'm not going to say anything about that. It isn't a thing I find funny. I just happen to have been there.

A lifespan is about 35 days: wants 33 to 37. Met: 33.1. You can look it up.

They got out the next morning, on the first try, because she was running straight. And when they were under the first terrace and he looked up, as he did, he saw that the scratches went on along the wall, the same as in every world. Filed. Filed. He read them. There were some new ones. And at the very end, on the last wall before the land gave out, quite low down, there was one that he had to stop and read twice, and it was not addressed to her. I want to say that it was the first time in my life anybody had written to me.

The first number, it said. You're nearly there. You'll need three. Hurry.

12. merges.UNTIL

variant-5108.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=5 merges.UNTIL=0 · Year 39 there · five years out

MERGE, THE LAST AGE OF (a rule; also a mercy; also, at nought, item 612)

A creature may merge until it is thirty, and from then on its code has been asked for enough. It is one of the numbers that was left as it was, having been tried at twenty-four, eighteen and fourteen. Nobody has any record of why somebody thought to try nought, except that it comes first in the row. It means that a person can propose until they are nought. Nobody has ever been grown at nought.

There were no pings at the far edge when they came over, and it took him a while to notice that he had been listening for them. It was mid-morning, with a fine high sky.

The land was all there. It was the same land, the rust and lilac slate and the long bare slopes going down. Wild coral had come back over everything. It stood knee-deep in the passes, saffron and pale, not trimmed by anybody; and they walked through it for most of the day without seeing so much as a stump. Bexa had started out talking. She was in much better spirits since the valley of the Thirty-Five. "Report," she said. "No one's been on this path. Report. No one's been on this one either." After a time she stopped doing that.

They came down into Six at about noon, since it lay on the way.

You will remember Six. It had been the neatest valley in the world and it still was, in a way. Each tile was as somebody had left it. There was a wall, with a gate in it, and the gate was shut, and when they got through, there was a large clean space inside, swept down to the scorched earth, in which you could see the outlines of where things had been. A building that is not used goes to the Collector on its seventh year. Here and there was a thing that somebody must have been using until quite late: a stool, a hoe left against the footing of something that wasn't there. In the middle, on a good flat stone, stood a tally, weighted down carefully with a smaller stone. Ondle went over and read it. It was in a very tidy hand.

Ate 100% of need, it said. I only mention it.

He put the stone back as he had found it.

I will tell you how it had happened. It is not complicated. There were twenty tribes, each landed with six settlers, in the first two and a half days of that world, a hundred and twenty people, compiled grown. They farmed. They built a dome. All over the planet, when the time came, they looked at one another and put in their proposals, the way anybody would. And on every one of those proposals, at each dawn, the rule was consulted, and it said that they were over the age. It said this in a way that was very clear. It said so to the first pair and it went on saying so for thirty-nine years. No child had been compiled on that planet at all. There wasn't anybody on it who was younger than the landing.

Nothing else was wrong. There was plenty to eat. Nobody who does nothing is wiped out by it, at day 116: not met, as you will find on any page; but you could have looked for a long time in that report without finding a tribe so thoroughly well fed as these were, when they had got to thirty, and then to thirty-five. There were fewer every winter. They had known for quite a long time. Everybody on that world had known it since about the time they were eight, and that was the first thing I noticed, when I thought about it afterwards. There wasn't anything left undone in Six.

By dusk they had got over the pass. He knew the north boulder from a long way off, black against the red. He did not know why he was walking so fast. A person gets into habits. You'll need three, he kept thinking. Hurry. He had gone over that one a good deal, and he could not make it mean anything, and Bexa, when told, had said it was just the sort of thing she would say.

There was the wall of Twelve. There was less of it than there should have been, and there was no second dome. Nothing stood up in the valley but a first dome, with a good patch on it, and a pool, and one farm on the south slope. Round the farm's lamp, going up in the blue, there was a stair of faint gold light, because the coral was ripe, and somebody was moving about on the third terrace with a basket.


He was very old. I have looked it up, and I want to tell you he was the oldest Blim ever to live on that seed, on any number, at forty-four; nobody has been able to account for it, unless it is that everything that could have gone wrong with him in thirty-eight years had, by then, run out of people to do it. He was short and very wide, and his damp had gone a pale colour, and he was singing to himself the words of the Fourth Book in a small cracked tune of his own. He came down the steps sideways, one at a time. When he got to the bottom he looked up. There were two people standing on the path.

He stood and looked at them for a long time.

Then he put his basket down, very carefully, and it fell on his foot. He didn't look at it.

"Oh," he said. "Oh, my word. Oh, look at you."

He was crying. I can't tell you how I could tell, on a person of that skin. He came over at a sort of rolling hurry, with both arms out, and he stopped about a tile short of them, as though he thought he might have got it wrong and did not want to disturb anything.

"You're so small!" said Dobb.

I should explain. I was twenty-four and I had never been called that. But he had not seen anyone under thirty in fourteen years, and he had never in his life seen anybody younger than himself. He went up to Bexa and he looked at her from quite close, and he held his hand a little way from the side of her head, where the steam was coming off her, as you hold it to a lamp. She didn't say "Oh, look." She stood completely still, and let him. I would like that recorded.

"Is that what it's like?" said Dobb. "It's in the Books, you know, the young. They run about. I always thought that'd be nice." He laughed, and he wiped his eyes. "Well! Well, you'll want your supper. It's only me. I'm afraid you've missed the Long Hush. I do the whole of it, but it isn't hard, it's mostly not saying anything. I can't tell you how long since I've had anyone to not say it to."


He sat them on the wall by the third terrace, and he brought out everything he had. It was a good deal. There was power in the dome for a tribe of thirty; he had been growing it out of habit. He told them to eat up. He told them everything, and asked them nothing, the way you'll talk if you have been talking to a lamp, and he kept stopping to look at them.

The last had been Prenna. That was eight years back, in the first dome, in the winter. She had been Keeper to the end, and the two of them had kept the greeting going, she to give it and he to answer, and she had got up on the footing every morning, when she could hardly stand, and looked down at him, and told him that there were two of them. "And when she was going," said Dobb, "she called me over. She'd got something she wanted me to know. I bent down. She said, Dobb. She said, I never liked the way you say good morning. You're flat." He shook his head, smiling. "Thirty-one years. She was right, too. I've been working on it."

Told: plain.

So he did all of it now. He gave the greeting and he gave the answer. He kept all seven festivals. On Steward's Day he put out ten tokens on the footing, for tribute, and on the next day he took them back. He kept the books for Hobb, who'd left him a very complicated system, and he had been paying himself a small sum most years and it had been a nice surprise. He'd carried them all. That was the one thing he said he had felt bad about: that when it comes to carrying somebody to the stone you want three, you really do, it's what's right, and by the time it came to Wenna he'd had to manage with two, and then with one, and he had got Prenna there with a sort of a sledge. "You want three," said Dobb. "It should have been three. But you do your best. And there's always a next bit. Could be worse."

"I don't see how," said Ondle.

He hadn't meant to say that aloud. He was looking at the lamp. The old person turned and gave him his whole attention, with both of his eyes, the way nobody had in five years, except to tell him that he did not exist.

"You've got something on your mind," said Dobb, pleased. "I can always tell. I used to be able to, anyway. Go on. What's the matter? I don't get a lot of news."

So he told him. I am not able to explain it. There was no one out there but a person who had just dropped a basket on his foot. He began at the beginning, with item 1, the dome. He went on to the other dome. He told him what could go wrong with a pool. It was something he had tried to do at various times in his life for various people, and I can tell you to the minute how long any of them had lasted, and the record, at that time, had been held by Mavey. It had got dark, by now, the long blue dark. The moons had come up, the big one and the small quick one. And Dobb sat beside him on the wall, with his short legs hanging, listening, and now and then he would nod and say "Ah, that's a good one," or "I'd never have thought of that," with the deepest satisfaction. He said it about the door. He said it about the Hog. He laughed out loud, in a wheezing way, at item 271. Nobody had told him anything he didn't know in eight years, and here were six hundred and twelve things that could go wrong, in order, and he wanted them all.

When Ondle got to the end, it was the deep of winter. His voice had almost gone. Bexa was asleep on the wall with her head on Dobb's shoulder, steaming slightly.

"Is there any more?" said Dobb.

"There's a joke," said Ondle. "I don't understand it."

He told it. A Blim goes up to the dome and says to the keeper, is it full? He did it as well as he could. He'd had some practice. It's as full as it was when you asked me this morning. That's what worries me. He waited.

The old person looked at him for some time. Then his whole face started to go, slowly, from the bottom. He began to shake. He did not make a sound at first. He had to put a hand on the wall. He laughed until he coughed and he coughed until Bexa woke up and asked what was the matter, and he took a long while to get his breath. When he had got it he looked at Ondle again and it started up a second time. He patted him, on the hem, a few times, gently, the way you'd pat something that had come a long way.

"Oh, that's the best thing I've heard in years," he said. "Oh, you stay just as you are."

"But why is it—"

"Stay for the morning," said Dobb. "Would you? I've got the greeting at seven. I could do with somebody to count."

13. Three Bearers

variant-5108.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=5 merges.UNTIL=0 · Year 40 there · five years out

The snapshot came and went. He got up before them, in the grey.

When Ondle came down the path to the first dome, Dobb was already there, standing at the footing, with his hands folded. He had washed. He had got one foot up on the stone, and he was looking at it, and he looked round when he heard them and took his foot down again.

"I don't always get up there," he said. "Not now. It's all right to do it from here."

The light came up on the valley. It came up the way it does, along the top of the east ridge first and then down. There were no pings. He stood on the ground with his back to the dome and looked out at the place where the village had been, at the wild coral and the swept tiles, and then at the two of them, standing in front of him on the path. He breathed in.

"Good morning, Orra," said Dobb.

"Good morning, Orra," said Ondle.

"Good morning," said Bexa.

Dobb looked at them both for a while. He held up one hand and put out a finger, and another, and then he pointed at himself. He was very careful about it.

"There are three of us," he said.

He had to stop for a moment.

"The weather will be fine," said Dobb.

They had breakfast. He showed Bexa how the lamp was trimmed and she asked him a question about it and he answered it. He went along the third terrace with the basket, thinning, the way he did every morning, and they went with him. It was a clear day. About the middle of the morning he said that he would sit down for a bit, and he sat on the wall where they had sat the night before, with his legs hanging, and they went on along the terrace. When they got to the end they looked back. He was looking at the valley. He had his hands on his knees.

They went back along the terrace. He was still looking at it.

Ondle stood beside him for some time. He checked. Then he took the basket off the wall, where it had been left a little too near the edge, and he set it down on the ground.


It takes three to carry someone to the stone. He had said so.

They tried it. He was not a large person, but he was very wide, and a bell has nothing on it to hold. Ondle took him under the arms. Bexa took the hem. They got him about a tile along the terrace and had to put him down, and they tried it the other way round, and the second time they got as far as the steps. She had stopped steaming and her face was set. There was the sledge, against the wall of the dome, and she went and looked at it and came back without it, and neither of them said anything about that.

They were at the top of the steps, getting their breath, when she looked up.

There was someone on the north rise. Whoever it was had come down over the shoulder of the hill, by the boulder, and was walking towards them through the wild coral. It took a long time. She was very tall, for a bell, and very narrow, as if she had been drawn out, and she came on with a long even stride and did not hurry. She was the colour of a wet stone. When she got to the foot of the terraces she climbed them. She stopped on the step below them. She was old, older than he was, and she looked at the person lying on the step, for about as long as you would look at anything. She did not look at either of them.

She bent down and took the third corner.

It was not far after that. It is about four hundred tiles from the south slope to the install mark, by the path. On that world the install mark had not been given a shrine, and they had put up a stone on it in Year 27, with six biers round it. Five names were cut in the stone. Arl. Hobb. Tumlin. Wenna. Prenna. There was room for one more underneath, and it had been marked out, in advance, with two scratches, by somebody who had thought about the spacing.

They laid him on the bier that was nearest the path.

Ondle cut the name. He did it with a chip of slate, and it took some time, and it isn't very straight. The three of them stood by him for a quarter of an hour. It is what the bearers do. No one said anything. It was a fine day, and the sun was on the stone. The tall one stood with her long hands hanging and her eyes on the middle distance. At the end of a quarter of an hour, she turned round and walked away, north, the way she had come.

He was collected at dawn.

They were both there to see the bier in the morning. Then Ondle went up to the first dome, and stood on the ground in front of it, because it was all right to do it from there. He told the valley good morning. He told it how many there were.

He had kept no joke. He looked for one. He would have told you, if you had asked him, that this person had been hit by every single thing on Orra that could not hurt him, and had said what he said; that he had kept the festivals of a world with nobody in it, for eight years, with his whole heart, and had been told that he was flat, and had worked on it. It was a good greeting. It was not flat. I was there.

Dobb, settler, of Twelve. Forty-five years. Of age, on the third terrace, in the morning.

Told: sincere.

Part Three. Laws and Beasts

14. Already Filed

variant-5108.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=5 merges.UNTIL=0 · Year 40 there, and under it · five years out

Bexa caught her up at the last line.

It had taken two seasons. There had been the matter of the corner first, which came on the ninth attempt, and then they had gone under the hills at something near a run, Bexa ahead and steaming like a kettle with a grudge, and Ondle behind and looking up. The scratches were fresher here. It was not hard to tell, once you knew the hand, that she had come through not long before, and was in no hurry, and had stopped to mention a loose tile.

She was sitting on nothing, a stride short of the place where the wireframe ended, with her knees up round her ears and her back to the whole of the world. She had a sliver of slate in one long hand. There was a wire of turquoise light at about the height of her shoulder, which ought not to have taken a mark, and she was scratching something on it.

"You," said Bexa.

The hand went on for a bit. It finished the word, and made a short firm stroke under it. Then the head came round, in stages. It was a very long way from one end of that neck to the other. It was the Twelve face, more or less, with the eyes set just too far apart, and all the rest of it had been taken away by time, as it might be from a bar of soap. There was no steam at all.

"Oh, look," she said. It was the flattest thing I have ever heard. "Report. It's short."

I will not attempt the next several minutes as they occurred. Bexa had been saving it for three years, or rather she had been forgetting it and finding it again on the next wall, which was worse. She wanted to know who she thought she was. She wanted to know by what right a person could walk ahead through one world after another writing Already filed over things that other people were still in the middle of finding. She wished to state that the dome's shadow was hers, that she had found it when she was seven, on a clear day, and that it was not the sort of thing you could just come along and find. What kind of a person, she wished to know, what kind of person went and wrote well done on a wall?

The other one heard her out. She had the look of somebody hearing a noise from another room and identifying it.

"Are you finished?" she said.

"No!"

"You will be. You've got about a year. You'll forget most of that by next spring." She looked down at the sliver of slate and she turned it over. "So will I. It's why I write it down. You wouldn't credit how much of this I've had to read to find out what I thought." She looked back at the wire. "Six times. I've been told it's good for me, and I can't remember who by."

Bexa had gone completely still. I think it was the voice. She'd heard a good many things by then in the way of counterparts: she had seen herself tired, and clipped, and lying on the ground, and she had looked at them all with some pity and moved on. This one did not sound like a poorer way of being her. It sounded like what comes at the far end.

"How old are you?" she said.

"Fifty-eight."

"Nobody's fifty-eight."

"Nobody here," said the other. She tipped her long head toward the blue, and the far faint writing that hung out there. "I'm from just up the table. Mine's a life one. Life dot lifespan equals seventy. They were very pleased with us, I should think. We ate well, and we lived twice as long, and we'd all said everything we had to say to each other by about forty." She had gone back to looking at the middle distance. "Same seed. Same roll. Same corner, same boulder, one in six. Fell through it at fourteen, the way you did. I've been at this forty-four years, and I've done every row on it, and some of them I've done twice. Yes. All right? I've found it all. I've found everything you're going to find. I'm sorry about the shadow. It was a good shadow."

There was a silence, under the world. Bexa opened her mouth and for once there seemed to be nothing in it.

Ondle had been standing a little way off for this, on nothing. He had come up slowly, as a person will who has walked a long way behind a quarrel. There was something he wanted to look at. He looked at it for a while before he said anything, and I would point out that this is one of the few things in his life that he ever had the good sense to do. He was looking at her hand. It lay on her knee with the slate in it. It was very long, and very thin, and hard-looking, and the fingers went on rather further than a person would expect.

His left ankle had started to feel cold.

She had noticed. She had turned her head and was looking at him. She had not done so before; she had walked four hundred tiles beside him with a corner of the dead in her hands, and stood a quarter of an hour by the stone, and she had looked at the sky, the ground and the path. Now she looked. It went on for a long time, and it was not a thing I can describe to you. Nobody had looked at me like that before, and I have never been able to file it. She looked at my hem, the way that it frayed. She looked at my two eyes, one by one. I saw her throat move. For a moment she was no age at all.

"You stand with your weight on your right foot," she said. "He did that." She looked away.

"Was it you?" said Ondle.

"Was what?"

"At the boulder. Something had hold of my foot. A hand, and it was long, and it let go a finger at a time. I've had it on the List for five years. It's a very short list, the one it's on." He found his voice was not behaving. "Was that you?"

She considered him. She took so long about it that he supposed she had forgotten the question. It may be that she had.

"Not yet," she said.


She would not say what she meant by that. I tried. I went into it from several directions over the next hour, and all that she would do was scratch.

"Why did you come back?" said Ondle. "You were ahead of us. You could have gone on. It's forward only, I've tested it. You can't get back across a line. So how did you get to the valley, in time, and how did you know we'd need—"

"There are ways," she said. "You don't have them yet. There's a thing she'll find, in about seven years, if she's looking. I'm not going to help with that. I needed the third corner. I mean, you did."

"You wrote to me."

"I did do that," she agreed. "I'd like you to go on counting."

"Counting what?"

And then, for the first time, something happened in the long face that might have been the very distant relation of a smile. She reached out one arm, and it went on for a good way, and she pointed with the sliver of slate straight down, between her own feet.

It was very far below them, and very small. It was the thread of lights. He had stopped looking at it round about the third world; it had been running under them for five years and it had never done anything but run. There were two threads now, side by side. There had been others, joining in, from under other valleys. It made a bright fine line going out under the last wire, without hurrying, and on into the eye-coloured distance, toward wherever it was that everything went.

"You've looked at that," she said. "And you've thought, that's going somewhere. Good. Have you read it?"

"It's lights," said Bexa.

"It's facts," said the old one. "Everything that happens up there drops one. That's what a tick makes: a tick makes some facts. Somebody wanted them measuring. They go by slowly enough, near the top, when they've only just dropped. You stand under a thing as it happens, and you look up, and you've got about as long as it takes to say good morning." She looked at Ondle, and then she looked away from him again, quite quickly. "She won't do it. She'll look at a dozen and tell you she's seen them. You'll stand there and read every one that comes down, because you can't not. And you'll remember. That's all you've got to do. I've read a lot of things in my time, and I've got all of it scratched on the walls, but you are the only one who can add."

"Add what up?"

"The first number," she said. "She tested it. She told you it does nothing. She's right. I found the same, when I was twenty-odd, and I was so pleased." She stood up. It took a long time; there was a lot to lift. Upright she was half as tall again as anyone he had ever met, a long thin grey streak on the blue. "It's the only thing in this whole table that I've never been able to file," she said. "Because it isn't a bug. Have you read the first number? You'd better have read the first number, by the time I see you next. It's in all of them. It's in yours."

She bent down, and scratched something on the wire, and she stepped across the last line, into the nothing, walking quite normally on no ground at all. She did not look back. She walked with her weight on her right foot.

Bexa stood looking after her with her mouth shut.

It was some time before she said anything. When she did it was in a small tight voice that he had not heard before.

"She didn't ask me anything," she said. "Did you notice? Not one thing. She didn't want to know what I'd found." Her top had started to give off a thin grey thread. "I'm going to find something she hasn't. Before I forget. Tell me I said that. Every morning. File that."

"I have," said Ondle.

He went over to the wire. You can't scratch a line of light. It is not possible; it's only a line. It said, in the thin neat hand, quite clearly, at the height of his eyes:

Already filed.

And under it, with a short firm stroke:

You'll hate the next bit.

15. laws.TOKENS_A_CLAUSE

variant-3221.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=7 laws.TOKENS_A_CLAUSE=0 · Year 33 there · six years out

LAW (what a human writes; also what a tribe follows; also, read to the letter, the reason for most of what follows)

A tribe may have twelve. Each costs a token a clause, which is what keeps them short. The creatures follow them exactly and meet them the cheapest way, and the only one who can change a law is the human. In the variant in question a clause costs nothing. For most humans this makes no difference at all. They are the sort who know what they want. Tribe 19's human was a bot of the kind called meddler, which each morning changes one thing, drawn, and not always wise, and had been writing clauses until told to stop.

The landing puts you where it puts you, and it put them this time at the gate of Nineteen, two valleys over from Twelve. What follows is the record of the Gate Court for that day, which I have got by heart because I was in the dock. Prenna and Hobb had both gone over to Nineteen in about Year 9. A person with that voice and that certainty is worth paying for, in a place like that. So is a person who can add.

IN THE GATE COURT OF NINETEEN, under Law 5, "Newcomers", as amended. Year 33, summer. Presiding, the Reader of the Laws, Prenna. Clerk of the Court, Hobb. Appearing for the Gate, a Guard. In the dock, two wanderers, damp.

THE READER: Have you read the Law?

THE PRISONER ONDLE: Which law, please?

THE READER: There are twelve. You are charged under the fifth.

THE PRISONER ONDLE: I'd be glad to read it. How long is it?

THE CLERK: Four thousand one hundred and six clauses as of this morning. Four thousand one hundred and seven. It's just come in.

THE READER: The Clerk will read the new clause.

THE CLERK: "Clause 4,107. A newcomer shall stand no closer than two tiles to a dome, unless a farmer."

THE PRISONER BEXA: Oh, look.

THE READER: The prisoner will be silent. Are you a farmer?

THE PRISONER ONDLE: No. I keep a dome. I mean, I used to keep one. Not this one.

THE GUARD: He's standing about a tile and a half from it, your Readership.

THE READER: Is he? Let it be noted. I should say that I do not care for the way he said "please".

THE CLERK: Noted. I've got seven to two on the first count.

THE PRISONER ONDLE: May I ask what the first count is?

THE READER: Standing. Under clause 4,107, as of a few moments ago. Clause 12 provides that a person who was already standing at the time of a clause is deemed to have stood on purpose. Second count: entering Nineteen by the gate, contrary to clause 806.

THE PRISONER ONDLE: How should we have entered?

THE READER: By the gate. Clause 11.

THE PRISONER ONDLE: I see. And these are both in force?

THE READER: All of them are in force. It is the Law. Clause 806 was moved on the morning of Year 15 and clause 11 has not been struck. This Court does not concern itself with what the human meant. Nobody has ever been able to establish that it meant anything. The creatures of Nineteen follow every clause exactly. It is a very orderly valley.

(A disturbance in the public seats. An elderly person is carried out, having been observed to sit on the left. Clause 2,240.)

THE PRISONER ONDLE: May I ask how the people here decide what to do in the morning?

THE READER: They look it up.

THE PRISONER ONDLE: And how long does that take?

THE CLERK: Mean time from waking to first permitted act, four seasons. I've got a very nice line in the Waking Stakes if you're interested.

THE READER: Is that an admission?

THE PRISONER ONDLE: I don't think so.

THE READER: I'll have it down as one. How do you plead?

THE PRISONER ONDLE: Could I just ask whether anybody has checked the clauses against one another?

THE READER: (after some time) Clerk, how long has this creature been a person of interest?

THE CLERK: About as long as he's been here, your Readership.

THE READER: Because there is something about him I cannot abide. It's his way of looking at a thing as though it could fall on him. Has anybody ever told you that you do that? Do not answer. That's clause 3,011. Prisoner Bexa, what are you doing with that string?

THE PRISONER BEXA: Measuring. Can I have the Law? All of it? Can I see it? Is there a copy?

THE READER: The Law is on the east wall. It is available for inspection by any person standing in a place from which inspection is allowed.

THE PRISONER BEXA: Where's that?

THE READER: Clause 4,003.

THE CLERK: It says, "the west wall".

(The Court rose for lunch at the hour permitted, which was the following spring. The prisoners were held in a place that the record calls "the Waiting", which was a low wall. During this time the Prisoner Bexa was observed to walk backwards round the outside of the east wall, reading it from behind, by means of what she calls a thin place. She did this for three seasons. On the Court's return she was steaming.)

THE READER: This Court is resumed. Prisoner Ondle, I find you have grown older. That will have to be looked into. Clerk?

THE CLERK: Clause 4,108 just in, your Readership. "In famine, feed first the guards to the gate."

THE READER: I thought it might be. Are there any further pleas?

THE PRISONER BEXA: Yes! Report! Can I do a report? Clause 212. Guards go to the gate when a sighting is confirmed. Clause 2,877, moved in Year 22. No guard shall go to the gate. Clause 1. I've got clause 1. It's the first one the human ever wrote. It says, Every clause of this law shall be followed.

THE READER: It does. It is the foundation of our liberties.

THE PRISONER BEXA: So when a sighting is confirmed, every guard has to go to the gate, and no guard goes to the gate. Expected: not. Severity: enormous. So I watched. There's been a sighting confirmed. It's us. We're the sighting. There's a guard there, look. He's in the court. He's appearing for the Gate.

THE GUARD: I am, yes.

THE PRISONER BEXA: Are you at the gate?

(A pause.)

THE GUARD: I am appearing for it.

THE PRISONER BEXA: Are you at it?

THE READER: The Guard will not answer.

THE GUARD: (distressed) I've got to answer, your Readership. It's clause 88.

THE PRISONER BEXA: There are three hundred and four contradictions in Law 5. I've got them all. He's got them all, I told him as I went. And it's not just the guards! It's everything. There's no way of being a person in this valley without breaking one of the clauses. There hasn't been since Year 16. So every one of you is already in the dock, and has been for seventeen years, and clause 12 says you did it on purpose. So you can't sentence us because you're not allowed to be sitting there. It's clause 1,440. File that.

THE PRISONER ONDLE: I have.

(Silence in the Court, for a period which the Clerk has noted as long.)

THE READER: Clerk.

THE READER: Clerk, what is the position?

THE READER: Clerk?

THE GUARD: Your Readership, I think she's stopped.

(The Clerk of the Court, Hobb, a settler, was found on examination to have died at some time in the previous quarter of an hour, of her age, which was thirty-eight, with her pen at the head of a fresh column. The column is headed "Verdict", and she had given it at five to one. She had taken bets on her own demise. On the sums she was found to be slightly ahead.)

THE READER: Is there a motion?

THE GUARD: I'd move that she be carried up, your Readership.

THE READER: Under what clause?

THE GUARD: I don't... I don't believe there is a clause that lets her be carried. There is one that says the Clerk shall not leave the Court till the Court has risen.

THE READER: And the Court may not rise without the Clerk's report.

THE GUARD: No, your Readership.

(She was collected at dawn. It was held that she had not left, and she continues to be entered as present. The Court has not risen.)

Told: plain.

THE READER: I am going to say something now which I wish to be taken down, and I see there is nobody to take it down. Prisoner. You. You with the hem. You have come into this valley and stood in it, and in the course of a year you have asked one question, and it has ended the Law of Nineteen.

THE PRISONER ONDLE: It wasn't me. It was Bexa who found it. I only asked if—

THE READER: I know what you asked. It is why I can't abide you. I find no verdict. I find I can't find. Get out of my valley by whichever gate you're forbidden.

The Prisoner Bexa was asked, on the way to the boulder, if she thought she had found something the old one had not. She said she didn't know, and she would check the walls. There was a wall, and it was all there, all three hundred and four. It had been added to, in the same hand, in smaller writing: "Three hundred and five. Clause 1 contradicts itself, since it is a clause. You'll get it in the morning." She got it in the morning. I will say this for her. She laughed.

It is the only verdict that I have for that valley. Nineteen goes on, as far as I know, a clause a morning. In the result file it has a row like anyone else's. It did very well on laws in force.

16. beasts.HOG_MOST

variant-0bfc.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=20 beasts.HOG_MOST=0 · Year 34 there · seven years out

HOG, THE (beast; also a landmark; also, in one variant, a philosophical position)

One faceted lilac-grey mass the size of a hex dome, which finds the best field in a valley and lies down on it. It takes between ten and fifteen in every hundred of the crops, until four guard-seasons persuade it to move on. Those are two numbers: at least, at most. They are checked against nothing. Nobody has ever needed to. In the variant in question, the second has been set to nought, by somebody going down a list, so that a Hog is required to take at least a tenth of your crop and not more than none of it.

It had arrived on the night of Year 19.

It came over the east ridge in the usual way, and went to the third terrace, and it lay down. Everyone in Twelve came out to look. The default looked as well. The default, you understand, wants to know what a Hog is costing before it takes anybody off anything else; and it asked, and it received, from the place where the answer is worked out, a number which was at least ten and at most nought. I have seen the code. A number like that has only one way of coming out of it. It came out as nought. So there was nothing to guard against. So nobody was sent. And the Hog, for its part, lay on the best field in the valley in the condition of a person with a job that has been defined in such a way that it cannot be begun.

That was fifteen years ago.

"You'll want to go round by the Flank," said the person who was showing them the way. "That's the good path. Down past the Shoulder and left at the Lesser Haunch. Mind the moss, it isn't really moss. Oh, and you'll want to keep your voice down when you go by the Head, out of respect. People have feelings about the Head."

I would like you to picture a hill. It was lilac, and rather faceted, with a fine low fan coral that had seeded in the angles about Year 22. It was about the size of a dome and it had in the course of time been built round. There was a wall running up against it, and steps. An awning had been fixed to one of its corners, and under that was a small trade in beans. Terraces had been cut all round the lower part of it, in a graceful curve, following the line, and on the top, where you got the view, there was a seat. It breathed, about once a season. People had got used to that.

The third terrace was underneath it, and did fine, since nothing was taking any of it. Nobody could reach it, of course. But it was on the books.

"It's my favourite," said Bexa. "I've decided. Out of all of them. Ondle, come and see, it's got an ear."

We did a good many more worlds than I am telling you, by the way. Some years it was a border a season: up at one edge, down at the first boulder, on to the line. I have told you the ones with something in them. She had grown up, a good deal, in those years. She was twenty-one and rangy, and steamed in a more thoughtful manner than she used to. He told her every morning, as requested, what she had said on the night of the last line, and every morning she heard it as if it were news, and went a little grey, and then she got up and went looking for something. She had found a great many things. All of them were on the walls. It was odd to see: she would come running to the nearest wall, stop and read, and laugh or swear, and go off again. But she had left off being crushed by it. Somewhere round the third or fourth world after the Court, it seemed to have turned into a race, in which she was very far behind. And she was running in it with her whole heart.

She climbed up on the Lesser Haunch and sat down and looked around her at the entire valley in the high summer light, all the wrong domes and the familiar slopes, and the top of her head was smoking like a good fire.

"This," she said, "is the best week of my life."

He gave this some thought.

"Seven years," he said. "Yes. I suppose it would be. Bexa, you said it about the last one."

"Did I? Good! Report: it's still true. File that."


There were Offices here too. There always are, if you give people long enough. There was a Warden of the Hog, whose job was to report each morning on whether it had got up. This was hereditary, in the sense that it went to whoever had been standing nearest, and it was at that time held by a settler named Wenna, who was thirty-nine. There was a very elaborate school of thought as to what would happen when it did.

They called it the Rising. It had a Book of its own by then. Prenna had written it. She had come to it late in life, and had found, on looking through the twelve Books she had by heart, that all of them were pointing to this. And the great one lay down in the best of the field, and the people said, it will rise; and they tended it. That isn't in the history. She had put that in, and nobody could stop her. She held that the Hog had not been sent as a beast but as a test, to see whether a people would wait properly. She looked down from the seat on the top of the Shoulder at the damp person coming up the path, and even from there she was able to find fault with his attitude.

"You've come to look at it," she said. "I can see that. There's a sort of person who comes here to look at it. You keep glancing underneath."

"I only wondered," said Ondle, "if anybody had checked whether it's all right."

I have to tell you that this was not a thing he had planned to say. He had been going to ask about the boulder.

She looked at him for some time. There was no doubt of the dislike. It was as firm and as fresh as on the day he had counted through the greeting. But for a moment there was something else, as though someone had just asked her the only thing she had never asked herself.

"Get off my Hog," said Prenna.


He went back after dark.

I'm not good at saying why I do what I do. He walked round by the Flank in the long blue winter, past the Lesser Haunch, to the place at the front where the moss was thickest. They had put a low wall there, out of respect. He stepped over it. The Head of the Hog was about as big as a bell, or a good deal larger, faceless, in the way that a Hog is, with a blunt planed lilac front that faintly shone. It was looking at nothing. He didn't suppose there was any way of being sure of that. He sat down on the ground in front of it, with his hands on his knees.

He looked at it for a long time. Up on its back, the seat stood out against the moons.

It had been told to do something. That was the way he had worked it out. It had been told, by a thing it could not question, that it must take at least this much, and not more than that much. Those are both perfectly good instructions. Anybody would follow them. Now it had gone over them, I would think, in whatever a Hog has. It had gone over them with all the care it could. And it had found that there was no way of starting that wasn't wrong. And so here it had been, for fifteen years, with its whole enormous body ready. It wasn't idle. No one could have called it that. All the time people were building terraces up its sides, and telling each other how calm it looked.

"I know," said Ondle.

The Hog breathed. It took about a season, as I have said. He stayed for most of that. I would not say that anything passed between them. They are not hostile. They are simply large. But I do remember he told it about the door, and I remember going through items 1 to about 90, and that it was very restful; and that about the time the sky began to turn he noticed he had put his hand on it, on the plane just under where you might have thought there ought to be an eye, and that it was warm and dry, and he had not thought to ask anybody if he could.

Wenna died of her age during that winter, in the course of her duties. At seven the next morning, on the footing of the first dome, her successor came forward with the slate on which the record was kept, and he read the morning report of the Warden, which had been written out by her the night before, in order to save time, and which said: It has not got up. It said so in the same words it had used on every morning for fifteen years. They laid the slate on her chest as she went up the path. It went to the Collector with her. I'm told that the next Warden had to make his own.

Told: plain.

It never did, by the way. I looked it up. There's a Hog in the result file for that seed, on that number: sent Year 19, driven off never. Tribe 12 was gone by Year 111, and the stand-in sends nothing to a place with nobody living, so nothing ever came to bother it. It was still lying there on the third terrace at Year 120, when the world was thrown away. It had taken nothing and it had not got up.

A beast costs nothing worth guarding against: met in full.

17. beasts.SCREENSAVER_MORALE

variant-3a50.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=100 beasts.SCREENSAVER_MORALE=10 · Year 30 there · eight years out

SCREENSAVER, THE (beast, narrowly; also a spectacle; also the only thing in the sky that moves as if it means it)

One faceted shape, a little taller than a dome, that travels across the sky of a valley in a straight line, leaving its way behind it in lights, and when it reaches the edge of the sky it turns and goes off in another straight line. It does no harm. The Blims stop work to watch it, a tenth of a season's labour lost, and are the better for it, by five in the hundred, for the rest of the year. In the variant in question they are the better for it by ten. Why anyone sends it is not known. Why anyone watches is one of the few things on Orra that needs no explanation.

Ondle was the only person in that valley who took it seriously, and I would like to explain what I mean by that.

They came down off the pass in the late afternoon of Year 30 and walked into the back of the entire tribe. They were standing on the open ground beside the install mark with their heads tipped right back and their mouths a little open, and their round eyes, for once in that valley, were both pointed at the same thing. It was high up in the east, lilac and gold, turning slowly, with a long fading ribbon of lights behind it. It came on across the sky in a straight line and no hurry.

"Look at that line," said a voice at his elbow. "Look at that. It's going to be close."

"Close to what?" he said.

The whole of the rear rank turned round, about nine people, without taking their eyes off the sky, and shushed him.

He had it all from Hobb that evening. She had a line of people waiting and she was making a great deal of money. The sky has edges. Nobody can see them, but when the Screensaver has gone along far enough it comes to one, and turns. There are four. And it had occurred to somebody, in about Year 11, that if the sky has four edges then the sky has four places where two edges meet.

Nobody had ever seen it go into one.

It had gone within a hand's breadth of the north-east in Year 17, and Wenna had fainted. The near miss of Year 23 was the chief subject of the village's poetry. Twice as cheered as anyone else on Orra, and with nothing else to look forward to but a human at five past seven, they had been waiting for nineteen years, in the highest spirits, for it to go in. When it went in, when it struck true, something would follow.

"What?" said Ondle.

"Something," said Hobb. She didn't look up. "I'm offering four hundred to one against. Do you want some?"

"Yes, but what would follow? Has anybody checked?"

She did look up then.

I don't believe anybody had. I want you to see this from where he was standing. Here were thirty-four people who had been looking forward for nineteen years to an event of unknown size in the sky directly over their stores. So he went round and asked them, the whole village, over the next few seasons, and I give you the results.

The Earnest held that the Steward would speak at last, from the north-east, and say good morning.

The Skeptics held that it would bounce.

Prenna held that the question was impertinent.

Wenna held that the sky would open along the join, and that behind it there would be another sky, of better quality.

Tumlin held that it would be pleased.

Bertle held that there would be a noise.

The children, every one of them, held that it would change colour. He asked them how they knew. They said that it just would. They said it was obvious. They looked at him with great pity.

Dobb held that it would fall on him. He wasn't complaining. It had already dropped something on him once, in Year 16, nobody had ever been able to say what. He had a mark. He just thought that if anything else were to come out of it, he had better be told where to stand.

None of this was any use to him. He had by then been in a great many valleys where somebody had said it would be fine. So he did what he could. He worked out which way the stacks would fall. He had the third terrace looked at. He went up the slope with a bucket and filled the old pool, in case of fire, and he carried five more buckets down to the install mark, because that was where everybody would be standing, and set them out in a row. He found a good place for Dobb, about thirty tiles from where anyone would expect him, behind a wall.

Prenna came and looked at the buckets. She had been calling the angle from the footing of the first dome for nineteen years, in a voice that could be heard in the stacks, and she didn't need to use it now.

"You have brought a bucket," she said, "to the Corner."

"Five," said Ondle. "I only thought that if anything—"

"I have seen some things in this valley. I've seen a person faint for joy. I've seen a person try to sell the south-west. I have never until this moment seen a person come to the greatest day in the history of the sky and stand at the back of it with a bucket. I don't like it. I don't like you. There's a sort of a smell of precaution." She went away, and then she came back. "Those are in the way of the children," she said.


He had not told anyone it was going to happen. I should say that he knew.

Bexa had got a piece of string and a sharp stone and walked out alone to the far edge of the village, where the ground was bare, and she had lain on her back for two seasons. There had been a time when you couldn't have kept that person still by nailing her down. She was twenty-two now. She came back with a diagram.

"It's a box," she said. "Report. It doesn't turn at the edge of the sky. The sky's round, Ondle, the sky goes all the way down. It turns at the edge of a flat box somebody's drawn up there, and it isn't even square to the valley. It's only got corners because somebody typed in how wide it was. And it goes straight, and it comes off at the same angle, and it never slows down. So it's a sum! I don't think anyone's ever just done the sum! It's going to hit the north-east, on this visit, at the end of next harvest. Oh, I know, I'll go and check the wall!"

It was on the wall. It was the same sum done rather better, and at the bottom of it, in the tall neat hand:

Go and watch. It's worth it. It isn't.

So they told nobody. It would not have helped. They had been told by experts on eleven previous occasions.

They were all there by the middle of harvest. The light had gone long and red. It came off the west edge at a slant, going north-east, and it had a long way to come, and by the time it was halfway a silence had spread out from Prenna over the whole of that open ground. Everyone could see its line by now. Hobb had put her pen down and was looking up with her mouth a little open, like anybody else. People took hold of each other's hems. Ondle stood at the back with his hand on a bucket. He looked round for Dobb, and he wasn't behind the wall; he had come out to see, like everyone, and he was standing about the middle of the crowd with his hands on his hips. He started towards him, saying "Excuse me." It got nearer. It was very high up, over the north boulder, and you couldn't see any edge, but I swear to you that I could have told you to a finger how far there was to go. There was the north. There was the east. It went, as it had gone for nineteen years, in a straight line, at the same speed.

It struck true.

I saw it. It went into the corner of the sky, precisely, and it touched both edges at once. There was no sound. It stopped being on its way out and it started being on its way back. It came out of there along the same line it had gone in on, turning slowly, with its lights going on behind it.

It did not change colour.

It went off across the sky, going south-west.

I wish you had heard that silence. Thirty-four people stood with their heads back and watched it go, and you could see it arriving in each of them, from the top down, at about the speed you might expect. Nobody said anything. I had got about halfway to Dobb. Somewhere near my knee a very small voice said, in tones of deep betrayal, "It was supposed to change colour."

Then there was a tiny sound, quite clear, in all that quiet. It was something like a pea landing on a drum.

Everybody looked round.

Dobb was holding the side of his head. He looked at his hand, and he looked up, at the north-east, with interest, and then he looked at the ground in front of him. There was something on it. It was about the size of a bean. It was square, I think, and flat, and rather lilac, and when I got there and bent down I could only see it from one side. By the time Bexa had got through the crowd with her string it had gone, or had been stood on.

"Could be worse," said Dobb.

So I can tell you exactly what followed. I was there, with five buckets. Nobody has ever been able to say what it was.

There was a dispute about that, as you may imagine. Several people held that something had followed, and that it had been foretold, and they went to see Hobb. She heard them out. She took up her pen. She said that a thing falling on Dobb was not an event, it was the weather, and that she would remind them it had happened before; and the book was closed. It's the only time I ever saw her sweat.

They found Tumlin when they looked down. He had fallen over at the front, some time before, with nobody noticing. He lay on his back on the bare ground with his arms out and the whole of the sky in his eyes, thirty-five years old, and in all his life of pleasing everything that came within reach, nothing had ever before gone by overhead and looked as if it might have noticed. I don't think he had seen that it was small. He said it was lovely, to the person who had bent down, and I understand he told them they had a nice face.

Told: plain.

Prenna got up on the footing after a time. She looked as she always did. She considered the sky, and in that voice of hers she announced that it had not struck true. It had been very close. It had been the closest yet, and she congratulated them all. But any fool could see it had been a finger short of the east, and they should go home now, and eat something, and there would be another along in a year or two.

And they went. They went past me, up the path, and they had started talking, and their faces were coming back. By the time they reached the stacks I could hear them arguing about the angle. On the numbers, for that year and every year after, morale in that valley stayed the highest in the sandbox.

A great many people had been waiting a very long time for something, and it had happened, and it was tiny, and they couldn't have been more pleased.

Nobody came to help me with the buckets. I took them back up one at a time. I put it on the List, as item 702, and I went to find out where she had got to with the boulder.

Part Four. Stance

18. stance.DREAD_FROM

variant-1cf3.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=3 stance.DREAD_FROM=0.6 · Year 28 there · nine years out

DREAD (a measured quantity; also the back of the neck; also items 1 to 734)

A creature gets it from a clever head and a long memory, since those are what you need in order to see how things are likely to turn out. In the game, it starts at three parts in ten of intelligence. Nobody on Orra is compiled with more than five and a half. In the variant in question it starts at six.

I have been putting this one off.

It happened at the border. I had finished reciting. By then I could do the whole of it, twenty-eight years, in a little over three hours, with hardly any feeling at all; and I took the step and I was on the far side, and walked through the lines towards the land. Bexa was telling me something. I remember it was about a loose tile. I came up over the last of the grey, with my feet on the real ground, and I stopped, because something very strange had happened to me.

I looked at it for a long time, in order to be sure. It was a clear morning. There was a smell of warm rust. Off to the left, about four hundred tiles away, there was a boulder standing on a ridge, and it was a boulder. I don't know how to tell you that in a way that gets it across. I had never seen one before. I'd seen things that had some way of being about to fall on you, and that you ought to go round; and I looked at this one and it was simply there, a large thing in the sun, being lilac.

The back of my neck had stopped.

It had stopped under the map, too, in a way. But down there it was only that nothing was asked of you; and this was up here, in the open, with everything still going on. I could feel my own hands. I tried it, as you'd try a tooth. I thought about the dome. I thought about whether anybody had looked at the third terrace, and I noticed it was quite an interesting question and that it would no doubt be attended to. I thought about what was likely to happen to me. It came to me that I would probably die in about seven years, of being thirty-five. I said so out loud.

"Are you all right?" said Bexa. "You've gone a funny colour. You look dry."

"I'm fine," I said.

I'd like you to know that I had never said that before. I was twenty-eight years old. I said it again to see what it was like.

It seems I should have listened to it more carefully, but you try.


I will go back to doing this properly in a moment.

It was the best-run valley Ondle ever saw. It was also rather a mess. You came down into it past a gate that was standing open, because nobody had thought of a reason for it not to be, and a stretch of wall with a good-sized hole, and no one had got round to it, in a relaxed sort of way. There were children, of an age to be underfoot, playing at something on the footing of the first dome. Two of the terraces wanted thinning. And everywhere that you looked there was somebody talking, and laughing, with their hands in the air, and these were clever people. There were some very clever people there. You won't have met many, on a world where cleverness brings on what it brings on; they tend to be quiet and go about with their shoulders up. Here there was a person called Bertle, whom I'd only ever seen as a large young idiot, standing on a wall and explaining something to a crowd about the way water finds its level. He was enjoying himself tremendously. They were all making things. There was a kind of pump. It didn't work and they were delighted.

Prenna looked at them from the door of the shrine. She was thirty-three, and held the same office; she alone looked the same. She looked Ondle up and down.

"Now, I don't care for you at all," she said comfortably. "There's something about how you stroll."

It was the only thing that had made him feel at home. He thanked her, and he strolled on.

He was told that he would find the keeper of the second dome down at the south slope, or wherever there was lunch. When he got there it was nearly noon. There was a long low wall by the third terrace, in the sun, and some people sitting on it with their legs swinging; and one of them was in the middle of telling a story. He was doing it with his whole body. He was doing someone walking and looking at a door. He had a fairly long hem, and he had let it go rather, and it was frayed in the place it frays, and he had one eye on his audience and the other on the bean he was about to eat. He got to the end of what he was saying and I don't know what it was, but they howled. The woman next to him fell against his shoulder. She was twenty-three, wet with laughing, and he had just begun to reach, without looking, for the top of her head, to scratch something off it. A very small person was sitting across his feet.

He looked up then. He saw who had come along the path.

I've seen a good many of myself looking at me. There had been some pity in it, and alarm, and in one case a thumb. This one stopped chewing. His eyes went from my face to my hands and all the way down to my hem. They got wider, and then they got wider still, and you could see something coming up in him, in his face, the way a person's face fills up with a good idea. Then he got to his feet, and handed the child to someone, and came over the wall, and he took me by both arms.

"Oh, look at you!" he said. "It's me! Isn't it? Look at you, you're ancient! What happened? Have you eaten? Mavey, look, it's me, I've come back from somewhere! Oh, you have got to tell me everything."


I'd rather that you liked him. I liked him. I don't see how anybody could not.

They gave Ondle the place on the wall in the sun. He was fed. He told it, in order, and I don't suppose it was any shorter than it had ever been, but no one looked at the sky. When he got to the valley with the stools they wept. When he told them of the Hundredth the person called Ondle slid slowly sideways off the wall and lay on the ground and asked if he could hear that part again. He kept asking questions, good ones. He'd got the same head, you understand. He was very sharp, and he remembered every word of it, and he took each thing up and turned it around in the light and handed it back better. He wanted to know how a border was fixed. He wanted to know about the Hog. He said, "So you just sat down and told it? You're wonderful. Did you hear that? He told it about the door." I've gone back through it since, looking for anything that was unkind. There's nothing. He wasn't making fun of me. He thought I was the most interesting thing that he had ever seen.

"And you've kept it up the whole way," he said, "the List. How far have you got?"

"Seven hundred and thirty-four."

"Seven hundred. Oh, I got to about two hundred. Round about when I was ten or so. I used to go up and count the dome, you know, I was very good. And I'd think of something. I used to get a sort of an idea about it, and I'd go and look. Only then it was always all right." He shrugged, and took a bean. "So I left it to Wenna's cousin, who likes that sort of thing. It's fine. It's mostly fine. If it isn't, someone will notice, and we'll have a laugh and fix it. Do you know, we lost the whole of the second dome, one year? Forgot to shut the door. Hobb still talks about it. We all ate at Six."

I looked at the door of the second dome, from where I was sitting. It was open. It didn't matter.

Then there was Mavey.

She'd come round on the wall by this time and had been looking at me for a while, in the way she has. Not from one side, as you might expect, but with one eye, and with the other one on him. She was twenty-three. She hadn't said much. She'd got something on the end of a stem and she was chewing it, and when I looked at her, as I'd known I was going to, sooner or later, for nine years, and had made certain arrangements about, I found out that nothing happened. It was very pleasant. There she was. It was nice to see her.

"You look like you've come a long way," said Mavey.

"I have, rather," I said.

"Did you find what you were looking for?"

"I don't know," I said. I smiled at her. I had not known how. "I think it's probably fine."

She didn't say anything. She took the stem out of her mouth and looked at it. It seemed to me that there was something she might have been about to remark on, but the small person had got loose, and it came along the top of the wall on its hands and knees, and it arrived in front of me. It sat up and stared.

It was about three. It had the bell, the damp, the eyes. It looked at me with one and then with the other, and it did not blink.

"Why are you old?" it said.

"This is Nim," said the person called Ondle, delightedly, from the ground.

19. Nim

variant-1cf3.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=3 stance.DREAD_FROM=0.6 · Years 28 and 29 there · nine years out

I stayed.

I am sorry to say there was no decision about it. There wasn't anything to decide. Bexa came and found me on the second evening and said that she had the corner and that it was only a one-in-four, in this light, and were we going? I said we should certainly think about that. I was lying on a warm wall. She looked at me for a moment and went off. They gave me a place in the stacks, and I slept, the whole night through, and at the snapshot I hardly noticed it. In the morning at seven Prenna got up on the footing and said it was a good morning, and someone made a remark about her sash, and she told them it was not a good morning for them, and everyone went to breakfast.

I'd never had breakfast. I mean I'd always had it in the way you have a thing that you are getting through.

It would take too long to tell you how nice it was. Nothing happens in that kind of story. They had a game they played with stones. There was a sort of a song. The person called Ondle took me round to see the pump, and it had got worse, and we stood and looked at it, with our hands on our hips, and I told him seventeen ways it could go wrong, in order, as I'd have told anybody. He thought that was very funny and he wanted to try them. So we did. We flooded the marsh. I laughed, I think. It may be that I was only making the noise that the others were making. By then I couldn't have told you.

The List stopped. I noticed that, at about the Long Hush. It had been going up by one or two a season since I was six years old, and it had stopped, on 734, like a stair that doesn't go on. That was interesting. It was all still there; I had every word of it, of course. I went through it once, on a slow afternoon, and I found I could read it right through with no trouble. It was quite well put together. I didn't see what it had all been about, but I could tell that somebody had taken a good deal of care.

And she followed me about.

I don't know why she did. There were other people for it. She'd got the whole of the village to climb on, and a parent to whom every word she spoke was a fresh delight. A creature is young till six, and the young have a certain way with them: they ask what they want to know and they repeat what the grown have said, with their heads on one side, and nobody on Orra has ever found a way of stopping them. Nim would come out of the stacks at seven and look around, and she'd locate the old one, and then she'd come over and stand about a hand away and study him.

"Why do you stand on that foot?"

"I don't know. Do I?"

"What are you looking at?"

"The door."

She looked at the door. She gave it every chance.

"It's not doing anything," she said.

"No," I said. "It's fine."

"Why are you looking at it, then?"

I thought it over. "I'm not sure," I said. "I think I used to know."

She nodded, as if that was about what she'd expected. She came back the next day. She wanted to see the List. I told her you couldn't see it, it was in my head, so she told me to say it, and I began at the beginning, and she sat down on my feet. She was very strict about it. If I left out a word she would know, the next time. I don't believe she understood a single item. Now and then she stopped me and asked if that one had happened, and I would say no, not as far as I knew; and she would say, "Is it still there?" and I said I supposed so, and she said, "Good," and told me to go on. I did about a hundred and fifty, that winter, and about the same in the spring.

I want you to know that I loved her, and that I couldn't tell.

It's a hard thing to explain. I've had a long time to try. I could see it. I could see exactly what she was; I noticed everything about her, and I can give you all of it now, any day that you want it. She had a fleck in the left eye. She walked with her hem hitched up, like Mavey. It was very pleasant to have her about. It would have been a pleasant thing also if she had been somebody else's and had lived in Six, and it would have been perfectly all right if she'd fallen off the wall. I knew that. I had looked. I knew it the way you know what's in a dome, from having counted, and you could have asked me on any morning of that year whether I was happy. I would have told you that I'd never been so happy, and I'd have been right.


It was the person called Ondle who told me the joke.

I'd asked him. I had asked everybody else. It was at the end of a long fine day of Year 29; we had been up on the rise, and it was the two of us, with our backs against the wall of the second dome. He was a very easy person to sit next to. I hadn't brought it up in some time. I think I'd forgotten that it mattered. It's just that it was on the List, and I'd been saying the List, so I told him. A Blim goes up to the dome and says, is it full?

He gave a great shout. He rolled over. He said she had told him that one too, the first year they went up together, and that it was the best thing she had ever done; and he did it himself, right then, with the voices. He did the Blim going up the hill. He did the Blim's shoulders. He did the keeper looking up from whatever he was doing. Then he stopped, and he looked at me, with his head on one side, and something came over his face that wasn't laughing. It was just interest. He was a very interested sort of person.

"You don't get it," he said. "Do you? Well, of course you don't. Oh, you poor old thing, nobody's said? It's about you."

"Is it?"

"It's about me. It's about who I'd have been. It's about somebody who goes up every morning to check on the dome, and gets told it's fine, it's just as full as it was. And that doesn't help. That's the joke! There's nothing you could say. If it's less full, he's worried. And if it's the same, well, then why's it the same, what's it up to?" He wiped an eye. "You see? That's what worries me. It's what she thinks of you. I mean, she does it to me now because I had that year when I was ten. She's got you exactly. She took it off Hobb and she turned it round. She made it about the one person it was about, and then she proposed to him, and she told it to him, on the morning of the merge, so that he'd know. So that he'd know that she knew."

There was a long comfortable silence. Down in the valley, somebody was laughing.

"She knew?" I said.

"Of course she knew. Everybody knows. It's a very loving joke."

I had got it. I want that recorded. After five years of asking and five of walking, and I forget how many worlds, it had been explained to me, by the only person who could do it. I had the entire thing. I went over it in my mind, and every part of it fitted. I could see it was funny. It's a very neat piece of work. I said so.

"Yes," I said. "That's good. I see that. Thank you."

He looked at me a while longer. Then he patted me on the arm, and he got up, and he went down the hill to see about supper.

I stayed up there. There was a long red sky. After some time, for no particular reason, I went through the List again, from where I'd left off, because I'd promised somebody. Not all of it. I just went on down to the bottom. And I found when I got there that I was looking at another list, the short one that has the hand on my foot in it. I'd been keeping it for about nine years. It's the things that have gone wrong. It isn't very long, and I read it, as I'd read anything.

The fourth thing on it is a person, standing at the end of a terrace, by a stem, in the first light, with her hands at her sides. It goes on for some time. I had made a very full note. It has the date on it. I'd read it, with some interest, and I got to the end and I thought: That must have been difficult.

I sat there for a bit.

I want to be clear about what I felt. I felt fine. I wasn't afraid. It was a very pleasant evening. It was just that I am a person who has looked at a great many doors, and I have a good idea of what the record ought to say, and if you have an instrument, and you have kept it carefully for twenty years, and you hold it up to the worst thing it ever saw and the needle doesn't move, then you can't conclude that nothing is wrong. I went through it three times. I looked at it from every side. I couldn't feel anything about it. It was only arithmetic. On the one hand there was a person who'd written all that down, and who had gone through nine hours in front of a piece of writing, to get to the other side of it, and I had no way of knowing why, but I could see he had been quite serious. On the other hand there was me, and I was fine.

Has anybody checked? I thought. It was only a form of words. I hadn't said it in about a year.

I got up. I remember I didn't hurry. I went and found the corner by the moons, on the ridge beyond the north boulder, and it wasn't hard to find; for some way down the slope, from about twenty tiles out, the coral had all been trodden flat, in a long straight line. It had been trodden very thoroughly. I found out why when I got to the top. There was someone sitting at the foot of the boulder, with her knees up and her hands hanging down. She had got a split on her forehead. She didn't look as if she was steaming so much as boiling off.

"That's eleven seasons," said Bexa. "It's about one in four. I've got through it, I think, nine times."

"Why are you still here, then?"

"I stop." She didn't look round. "Just before. I can tell when I've got it, and I stop, and I walk back down, and I do it again." She wiped her nose on her hem. "I can't file anything by myself, can I? I don't remember it. So."

It seems to me that I ought to have had something to say to this.

There was somebody else on the slope. I heard the small feet. She'd come all the way up from the stacks by herself, in the dark, with her hem hitched up, a very long way for that size of person, and she stopped in the trodden coral and looked at Bexa, and she looked at the boulder. She looked at me. She had one eye on each.

"You're going," she said.

"Yes."

"Why?"

"I've checked," I said. "I think that something's wrong."

"What?"

"Me," I said. "I'm fine."

She thought about that. You could see it go in. She stood there with her head on one side, three and a half, with the fleck in her left eye; and I'd give you what I've got left to be able to say that I felt it. I noted it. I noted all of it. She had a stem in one hand.

"He doesn't look as long as you," said Nim.

She didn't mean anything by it. It was what she had seen. The young say what they've seen. Then she turned around and started back down the hill, and I watched her go, all the way, until I couldn't see her any more, and I couldn't have told you what I was checking for.

I took Bexa's hand. It was very hot. We ran at it, the two of us, square on. We walked to the line, and I recited my way across it in a pleasant, easy voice.

It came back on the far side.

It came back about three strides past the writing, the whole of it, all at once, all twenty-nine years, as if somebody had opened a sluice; and I went down on my hands on the blue-grey nothing, and I'm told that the noise could have been heard for some distance, if noise on Orra went that way. I had thought I knew what was on the List. I'd left her on the hill. It was dark. There was a hole in the wall and nobody had shut the gate. Somebody ought to have gone down with her. Who was going to go down with her? Has anybody checked? There were seven hundred and thirty-four items, and by the time I could stand up again there were eight hundred and six.

Bexa sat down next to me on the nothing, and waited, and did not say anything at all.

"Report," she said, some time later, quite gently. "You've gone back to your proper colour. File that."

"I have," I said. "I can't not."

All of the numbers in that valley are better. I've looked them up. Happier by any measure anyone has got. It is the highest row in the file on invention, and it lost one dome.

I don't recommend it. I would like to be very clear that I am not a reliable witness on the subject.

20. ladder.AMENDS_TOKENS

variant-670a.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 ladder.AMENDS_TOKENS=50 · Year 25 there · ten years out

AMENDS (a payment; also a kind of apology; also a thing no bot has ever been owed)

What a tribe is given, in tokens, when a consequence that had bitten is overturned on appeal. There is a ladder for this. It needs a human to appeal and a Dev to agree, and no such thing has ever occurred in a sandbox. The game has it at fifty. In the variant in question it is also fifty. Every row in the table has a line like this, near the top, where the number is set to what it already was. It is what you compare the others with in that row. I would call your attention to the word compare.

"What's it say?" said Bexa. She had gone ahead and was reading it from the far side.

"Amends tokens. Fifty."

"That's not anything. What was it before?"

"I don't know."

She went off to look. There are walls even out there, if you know how to see them. There is a kind of grain in the last few lines of the wireframe, and the old one had taken to writing on that. Bexa came back after he had started on his twelfth year, and stood where he could see her mouth.

Fifty, it said.

He finished the recital in two and a half hours and they went through, and came up on to the grey in the small hours, and walked for a good while through the young land. He was thirty, or nearly. His knees had started to mention things. By this time they had been through a hundred and eighty-something borders, or so she told him; I can tell you the exact number, but there was no longer anyone who wanted it. He was walking with his eyes down. So it was she who stopped first, on the crest of the pass, in the first of the light. She didn't say anything.

There was the valley, and there was the wall, all the way round. There was the first dome and the second dome. Nothing about any of it was tired or too cheap, nobody had built anything on anything, and there was nothing lying on the third terrace but a slight mist. He looked at it for some time. He had done this before; he had stood on that pass a great many times. He had learned to go down it like someone walking into cold water, looking for where it was going to be wrong.

He could hear people coming out of the stacks.

They stood about. It was too far to make out anything but the shape of them. Somebody large got up on the footing of the first dome. And he didn't have to hear, as you know, because he has every word of it, at any distance, and he had seen it from underneath; but the air on that side of the world was very still, and it carried.

"Good morning, Orra!"

"Good morning, Orra," said the valley.

"There are twenty-nine of us," said Prenna. She let that stand for a moment, and looked round. "The weather will be whatever it is."


Nobody on the path looked at him. Why would they? It was Year 25, not an hour past the dawn, and these were people getting on with their morning. He went down past the marsh. It was not the same morning, you understand; he knew that; he'd read what it said. He kept his eyes on the ground in front of him and went on putting his feet on it. He passed the pool. He passed Tumlin, standing on the terrace, who told the sky it was looking lovely. He passed a short wide cheerful person with a bucket, on whom a rope had just failed to fall. He went up the south slope by the steps. His legs did that themselves. They had been told about it nine thousand times.

She was on the third terrace, at the far end. She was twenty. She had a basket by her foot, and she had just pulled a stem, and looked at it, and thrown it down.

He stopped about four tiles off. He had thought about this. I hardly need to tell you. There were a hundred and twelve things on the List under this heading alone, and he had prepared some remarks.

She looked up.

She looked at him for rather a long time, with the one eye, and with the other. He saw it go across her face in about four stages, and I have them all. He saw her know the hem. He saw her look at the hands, and the way he was standing. He saw her look past him down the path for somebody else, and come back. Then she put a hand on her hip, a damp young person in the morning sun, and she breathed out through her nose.

"You've got old," said Mavey, "since Starfall."

He opened his mouth.

"Yes," he said.

"I stood there," she said, "like a stem."

"I know. I was underneath. I shouted." His voice had gone. "I was directly underneath you. I've come. It's only that it took rather longer than I—"

"Where have you been?"

"A great many places," said Ondle. "None of them was any good. I'm very sorry. I've got a report."

I can't describe the laugh, and I am not going to try. It went on for a long time. It was a good deal wetter than usual. She had to sit down on the wall, and she took him by the front of the hem in the course of this and pulled, so that he had to sit down too, and it was not until some time afterwards that he realised she had not stopped holding on to it. She looked at him closely, from a distance of about a hand. She'd got a mark on her cheek, from the coral. He had forgotten that. No, he hadn't.

"Is it full?" said Mavey.

He had it now, you see. He'd had it for a year. He had got it from the best authority there was, and he knew what it was and who it was for. And it arrived, on that wall, about ten years late. It did not make him laugh. It came up through him from somewhere under the hem, and his whole face went, and he found he couldn't say a word. She said, "Oh, there you are," and she put her forehead against his.


I'd like to tell you how he spent that year. I could do so at some length, but you may take it that he counted the second dome.

Nobody had shut the door properly. He went up there at noon and shut it. It stuck, on the left, as it always had. He went inside and stood in the smell of it. He counted the power and the stone and the seed, and it came to exactly what he had thought it would, and he stayed some time with his hand on the wall. Someone came and stood beside him and said "What are we looking at?" and he had to go outside.

It went round the valley fast enough. The tribe took it as they would. It was thought that he had been away a day and had come back thirty, and some people felt this was very like him. Hobb paid out on it, for form's sake, on a book she had opened at dawn, and got the money back by evening, on what he would do next. Wenna had him in to explain it to the class. Dobb shook him warmly by the hand, and he said it could be worse; and Ondle kept hold of the hand somewhat longer than usual, and looked at him, and did not say anything, and when he let go he moved a basket that was near the edge of something. Prenna looked him over at the shrine. She took her time.

"You have come back older," she said, "to make a point."

"I'm so glad to see you," said Ondle.

"And I shall thank you to stop that," said Prenna.

So there was only Bexa. She'd come down an hour behind him, and gone straight to the wall behind the shrine, and it had nothing on it but the reports of a Bug hunter of fifteen who had not come home from the Benchmark. She stood and looked at that. Then she went round the village with a piece of string. She did it properly. She worked for most of the summer, and found him up at the dome at about the time the crop began to glow.

"Report," she said.

He waited. Her steam was going straight up, in a thin line, as it does on a still day.

"There's nothing," said Bexa. "Food. Heat. The Hog's over by the east gap, where he was. The shadow's a tile too long. It's the same boulder and the same corner, it's Bertle who got the lint. Everyone's got the same number of arms. I've been right through everything I can think of, and I've got you to tell me what you remember and I've checked it, every bit, and there isn't anything. It's the one where nothing's different." She stopped. "So it's home," she said. "Isn't it? There's just that number at the front. It's got a different number at the front, and it's the same as home."

"Is it?"

"I don't know! I don't know how you'd tell!" She let out a breath. "Is that a bug? I don't think it's a bug. That's the worst thing I've ever found. There's no way to file that. How do you feel?"

He looked at the door. It was shut. There was a long gold light on the terraces and somebody was coming up the path, swinging a basket. He'd been asked a good many questions in the last ten years, and I can tell you what he answered to every one of them, and I can tell you this one too. There was a proposal up, again, in two names, as of that morning. There would be a place in the stack by the next dawn but one.

"I'm home," said Ondle.

He felt quite sure of it. He went on feeling sure of it for very nearly a whole day.

21. Fifty

variant-670a.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 ladder.AMENDS_TOKENS=50 · Year 26 there · ten years out

He was on the wall by the third terrace, at about the time you'd have your lunch, with a bean in his hand and the whole of his life in front of him for about the sixth time that morning, when an old damp person came up the steps.

He was a little out of breath. He had come up from the marsh path, and he stopped on the top step and looked at the terrace, and he looked at it for some while. He looked at the lamp. He was wearing a very frayed hem. He stood with his weight on his right foot, and then he noticed who was sitting on the wall, and he went a slightly lighter shade of grey.

"Oh," he said. "I'm so sorry. Is this... I don't want to disturb you. Has anybody checked whether this is the right valley?"

The bean fell on the ground.

I have mentioned that every row in that table has a line where the number is set to what it was. There are three hundred and ninety-nine rows. Each has it at each of eight values of the first number, over ten seeds; and on the seed in question, every one of those worlds is exactly the same as every other, until somebody falls through a boulder. They all fall through a boulder. On the evening of Year 24, on every one of them, somebody swings right at the top of a slope, and somebody else comes up the hill behind her. I didn't think of that. Of all the things I had thought of in ten years, I had never once thought of that.

"Which one are you?" said Ondle, when he could speak.

"I'm from Camp," said the other. He had come over, in an apologetic way, and sat on the far end of the wall. He looked about thirty-two. "I fell out of the one where it's forage percent, fifty. Only I didn't know that. I just thought it was home. And I walked for a long way, there's a very bad one with a Hog, and when I saw the pass..." He looked up at the terrace and swallowed. "I expect you've been here for ages. I can't tell you how sorry I am. It's yours, of course. I'll just go. I only wanted to see if she..." He stopped. "Is it full, by the way? I only ask. Is somebody looking at the door?"

"It's shut," said Ondle. "It's fine. No, wait. It's not mine. I've only been here a year. I fell out of the first one, I think, or very near it, I don't know where that was. You should stay. You've come further."

"Oh, I couldn't."

"I'd much rather you did. I've got no right at all."

"No, no, you were here first. I do insist."

They were still at it when the next one arrived.


It's very difficult to get a good picture of that afternoon, even for me. By about the middle of summer there were five of us on the wall. There was one whose voice had gone, and who could only talk in twelve-word lengths, and always stopped, as if he had been cut off at the end of it; there was a very large one, who had lost a good deal of his worry somewhere and kept having to go back and look for it. One had got a limp, from the Court, and one had got a small sash. They had all been coming down the track for hours, each at his own hurry, all stopping at the sight of the valley, in the same place, for the same length of time. I can't tell you how polite they were. Each of them took one look along the wall and at once began to withdraw. Each of them was perfectly sure that he was the interloper. It was one thing we all had in common.

"After you," said the one with the sash.

"I wouldn't dream of it. Did you shut the gate?"

"I thought you had."

"Has anybody checked?"

There was a silence. Five heads turned to look at the gate, at the same angle. Two of them got up. They both sat down again, on seeing the other, and each made a small gesture with his hand.

The one with the limp suggested a Register. Each person would state the world he had fallen out of and his grounds for thinking he might not be entitled to be here. I gave the first evidence. Log names variant-4e47. There were some nods. The one from Camp looked up at that, and frowned, and looked at his own hands, and said that it was odd, and then begged my pardon. It was agreed that this was a very strong claim, and that I must stay; and I said I didn't see how, since this was not that; this was 670a, it said so on the line; and if anything it was a point against. The one with the twelve words tried to say something about seeds. It took him some time.

The Bexas had gone to the wall.

There were by now four. Each had got there at a run, and I could hear it from where I was. I don't know how much of the following you will be able to imagine. There was a sound like a kettle factory. All four were talking at once, each one holding a piece of string, and all reporting the same thing; each of them had come to that wall with something she had been saving, and then she had found three other people there saying it. For a moment, I believe, they stared at one another. Then one of them said "Oh, look," and all four of them said "Report."

I would ask you to think about the position of the village. It had come out to see. It stood in a small crowd at the bottom of the terraces, thirty people with their heads on one side, looking up at the wall with five old Ondles on it, in order of arrival, all giving way. Tumlin said that they were lovely. Hobb had a line going on the sash. Prenna looked at them, one by one, along the row. I could see her trying to pick. In the end, I think, she decided that she disliked them all equally but for separate reasons, and that it would take some time.

The next one came up the steps about then, and said that he was terribly sorry.


She came along the terrace towards dusk. There were seven by that time.

She'd been working. She had come from the far end with her basket on her hip, not hurrying, and she stopped, about four tiles off, in the long red light. Everyone stopped talking. All seven of us got to our feet, and all of us, at the same moment, moved a little aside so that the others could stand in front.

She looked at us, with the one eye, going along. She took it slowly. She looked at the limp and the sash. She got to the end, and then she came back with the other eye, the other way. I have thought since about what that must have been like. She had got up on the morning before this one with nothing more on her mind than a person who had not come to the place he had said he'd come to. She'd had one of them back. She hadn't asked for any more.

She put down the basket. She looked at the whole row.

"Is it full?" said Mavey.

I don't know if you've ever heard seven of yourself draw breath.

I knew the answer. You know I knew it. I had been told, by an expert, and I'd felt it go in; I'd had it for a whole year, and I had laughed, on that wall, in a manner of speaking. But I'm afraid it comes from further down than that. Seven old damp people looked at her, with fourteen worried eyes. And I heard it come out of all of us, as one voice, in a tone of anxious inquiry:

"Why would it be less full?"

She laughed so hard that she fell over the basket. She lay down on the terrace, in the coral, on her back, and she howled. People were laughing at the bottom of the slope and they didn't know why. I saw Hobb wipe her eyes. It went on until I thought she would do herself some harm, and it had started to get dark. And when at last it stopped she stayed lying there for a bit, and breathed. Then she got up on her elbows, and looked along the row again. Her face was wet, but then it would be.

"So," said Mavey. "I've got a proposal in, for tomorrow. In two names. I wonder if I could ask which of you is going to stand by it."

No one spoke.

The evening was very quiet. Down below, the lamp had started to come up.

"Only one," she said. "I'm not fussy. I expect you're all very good. Any of you. It's just a matter of somebody saying I will, and not having it looked into." She looked along, from the sash to the limp and back. She looked for a while, at the end, at me. "No," said Mavey. "I'd have put money on it. Hobb, what did I say? You'd each want to check."

I had a good many thoughts then, in order. I thought the person who owned this place had gone on, down the table. He was out there now, the person who fell off this slope, and for all I knew he was still going; he'd be on some pass, with his knees. I thought all of this was his. I thought I had been saying a false name at the head of everything I knew for ten years, and I could go on doing it, and no one would ever find me out. I could say it until I died. It would be a good thing to say. That wasn't the trouble.

The trouble is a person standing at the end of a terrace, by a stem. I have the date on that. She is in another valley. She's in the only one with the right line at the top. It doesn't make any difference that there is no way of telling it from this one, not if you looked for a year, with string. I know it doesn't. I can't explain it. Nobody had ever gone and told her.

"I'm very sorry," I said. "It's only that I left someone waiting."

She looked at me for a long time. It was too dark by then to see which eye.

"I know you did, you idiot," said Mavey. "It was me."

But she had let go of the front of my hem. I hadn't noticed that she had still got it.

So that was the Register. We came down off the wall in the order of arrival, each one standing aside for the next, which took some time. No one said very much. Most of them were at the boulder before midnight, that there were two more on the path going the other way, asking if anybody had checked, and that we told them. I worry about them. I worry about each of them. The Bexas were all shouting as they ran. I gather that some of them found a later line with the same number on it, further on, and stopped there, and it's not for me to say that they were wrong; there are a lot of rows, and a person only has so many knees.

Nobody stood by it at dawn. I was under the south slope, by then, and I looked up. I know what she did. You know as well. She pulled the stem.

A year or so later she proposed to Dobb. I found that out, in time. I have got it written down, and I would say that on the whole it's the best thing that could have happened.

We farmed.

22. war.DEATH_IN

variant-2c52.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=100 war.DEATH_IN=5 · Year 20 there · eleven years out

For the last six years he had been reading the lights.

I don't want to make too much of this. It is what she had told him to do, and in any case he could hardly help it. If you are walking under a world and something drops past you, and it has writing on, you read it. Most of them are very dull. harvest in. merge compiled. season short: tribe 3. They fall out of the honeycomb at about the speed of a thing settling through water, thin bright threads of type, about as long as your arm, and go on down, and you can only make them out for a little while before they are too far below you to read. When he was up in a valley he couldn't see them at all. But each time they clipped out, and walked to the line, he'd walk with his head going from side to side like somebody reading a very long wall. He read everything. It had become a sort of rest.

So there is no doubt that he had seen the word by then. He had seen it several thousand times. It's a short word, near the end of a line, and nobody looks at the end of a line.

They had come through the far wire in the last days of Year 19 and he had gone down on his knees in the grey, because of his knees. He was thirty. On that line the string had said war.DEATH_IN=5, and neither of them needed a wall to tell them about that. It means that one in five who go down in a fight will not get up. In the game it is one in ten. It had seemed to Bexa a fine opportunity to observe a battle from below, and they had clipped out as soon as she had got the corner, and gone straight back to Twelve's wall, from underneath, at about four o'clock in the morning. Nothing had happened yet. It was the night before the battle. They sat down on nothing, and waited.

I have told you about the battle of Year 20. It is the one where a warlord bot, Tribe 10, was told it could, and did. You will not be surprised to hear it had happened on every world of that seed, more or less, unless some number had got in the way. He had by then looked at it from above in four of them. He knew how it went.

From below it went in silence.

The honeycomb overhead was just beginning to go grey. There was a thin ring of walls standing on the sky, and all along the top of it, in the first light, you could see the soles of feet. They were not moving very much. Everyone in Twelve had been sent to the wall by the default, the same as ever, and had stood where they had been standing when it stopped thinking about them. There were perhaps twenty pairs. Then there were a great many more pairs of feet, coming across from the eastern gap, in very good order. They were closer together and they had thicker heels. It took them some time. The two lots of feet came together at the east side of the wall, and there began to be a certain amount of confusion; and it was all very small and far up, like watching somebody's quarrel through the floor.

He saw Arl.

I don't know how he knew him, from the soles. He knew him. He was a little apart from the others at the head of the steps. The first of the thick feet came up and stopped about a tile from him. They stood there, opposite each other. It went on for just long enough for one person to ask another a civil question. You remember what was said.

The feet went down, those small ones, quite slowly, from standing to the flat.

And a little after that, from the place where they had been, came a light. It was longer than most. It dropped out of the honeycomb without any hurry, turning a little, and it came down through the blue about two arm's lengths from where he was sitting. He read it. He couldn't not.

creature died: tribe 12, Arl, age 25, cause fight, place E wall, told plain

It went on down.

Then the others began to come. It was a short battle. A war in that world has rather more of an edge to it. All along the east wall they were dropping, one after another, and he got to his feet, and went along under them, with his neck hurting, and he read each one. creature died: tribe 12, Bertle, age 9, cause fight, told plain. creature died: tribe 10, cause fight, told plain. Tribe 12, cause fight, age 14, told plain. There were a lot of them. They came down all round him like the end of something. Told plain. Told plain. You'll say he must have known them. He did. He had watched Dobb fall off a wall about six different ways, and there he was, up there at the top of the steps, in this one, being hit by a thing that had been aimed at someone else. Told plain. I'm not going to tell you how that went. It was the first thing I noticed, in that whole night: that one could get used to it. I noticed that after about a dozen, I'd started to read them for the wrong reason.

I was reading them for the end.

I don't know why. There's nothing there. It's only a field, and it's all the same; you can stop reading before you get to it. It was only that I'm a person who has counted a dome every morning for most of his life, and after you have done something like that, you can get so that the same thing every time begins to look like information. I had a feeling about it, that's all. Just at the back of my neck. I'd been in a place where that word had said something else. I couldn't have told you where.

Yes, I could. I can tell you anything.

I sat down.

The sun had got up by then, on the far side of everything. The feet had stopped moving about. Bexa had gone off to look at how a crashed creature's outline looked, from underneath, and she was calling out something, which I could see but not hear. I sat on nothing, with my hands on my knees, in the gold light that comes down through the cells. And I shut my eyes, and went back to the start, and began to go through it. I didn't go through the List. I went through the lights. I had about nine thousand deaths. I'd never added them, as there had been no reason to. There had been a long one in the valley with no children. I had not seen it fall, because I had been standing by the stone. But they sink slowly, and we were two seasons getting out of that valley, and it had only got as far as my knees.

creature died: tribe 12, Dobb, age 45, cause age, place third terrace, told sincere

I hadn't thought anything of it. It's a nice word.

I opened my eyes and looked at the line of the world I was in. You could just see it, from there, a long way off, in the blue. life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=100.

"Bexa," I said. I said it quite quietly. She couldn't have heard, and she was already coming back, with her hem held up in one hand, steaming and shouting about some outline. I remember I held up one finger to make her wait. I'd started counting.

One in ten of the fallen: wants 8% to 12%. It would not have been met on this variant, but then it was hardly the fault of the variant. It was a very fair battle. I have it as twenty-six dead, of a hundred and thirty-one. Nobody on either side was told anything.

23. The System

between variant-2c52.70.0 and the next · eleven years out

TOLD (a field; also a promise; also the last word on every line)

When a creature dies a draw is made, from the key of that tick, and the draw is below some number. If the draw is nought, it is sincere. Otherwise it is plain. That is all it does. It goes into the fact, along with the name and the age and the place, and is carried to whoever writes the tribe's notes, so that he will know which sort of thing to say. A plain death is told as the notes tell most things. A sincere one is told once, with no joke. One ordinary death in ten, on Orra. It has been Decided. The number is life.SINCERE_ONE_IN.

It took him three days to do it properly. I am going to give you the table, and I would be grateful if you read it.

First number Deaths he had read Told sincere One in
1 64 64 1.0
2 118 61 1.9
3 212 69 3.1
5 370 77 4.8
7 1,404 196 7.2
10 3,316 338 9.8
20 2,210 108 20.5
100 1,881 19 99

That is it. That's what it does. It took him a certain amount of time to believe it, and he went back and checked a number of them against what he could remember of the weather.

"It's fractions," said Bexa.

She had read it through, standing on one leg. They were walking again by then, out along the blue, with the last line behind them.

"Yes."

"It's just what it says. One in seven. Sincere one in seven. You've got a number that says one in seven and it comes out one in seven. Well, that's not a finding! Oh, Ondle. I said it didn't do anything. I told you. It doesn't do anything to anyone. It doesn't change a single thing up there, and I've tested that. It's a tag. It only changes the tag." She was quite pink with interest. "What's it a tag for? Who reads it? It says it's so that someone can tell them. Tell who? Who's telling them?"

"Nobody," said Ondle.

She stopped walking.

"There isn't anyone," he said. "That's what I've been... There's no notes. There are none in any of them. There's no one up there, on any world we've been to, who has ever said a thing about anybody at all at dawn, except Prenna, and she only does the count. It's for Stewart, and there isn't a Stewart. It goes in the fact. And the fact comes down here, and then it goes off." He looked at the thread of lights. There were a great many threads by now, side by side, under the blue, a long bright road of them. "Every time. Whoever it is. They get a draw, and it's written down how they're supposed to be told. Then they go past, and nobody tells them."

I should like to break off here.

You will have noticed that I have been telling you. I said at the start that I had adopted a system, and that it wasn't mine. You've seen it in operation. It looked like a tic, and I expect you've been very patient about it. Every time I have told you someone died, in this book, I have given you the word from the end of the line, which I read as it went by or I looked up later, and I have told it the way the word said. If it said plain, I told it plain. I told you somebody lay out on a wall for three days and nobody noticed. I told you about the bag of stone chips and the Thirty-Five. I made them as good as I could. It's the only thing they get. If you thought I was being heartless, I would ask you to go back and have another look at how much trouble I took.

When it said sincere, I told it that way. I don't choose. I would have told you about Tumlin with no jokes at all, if I'd been let. I would have done it for all of them, I've tried it, and we'll come to that. I have got rather a lot of practice at this by now and I'm still not any good. There are people in this book who I'd give a great deal to be able to tell you about properly, and who drew a four. It's not mine to change. The draw is from the tick's key. It was made before I got there, and nothing is going to move it, as you'd have found if you had ever tried arguing with one of those.

I don't suppose it's a very good system. I've just never heard of a better one, and I have looked.

You may also have noticed that I have been saying "I". I was hoping that you wouldn't. I got through the first valley or two very well, I thought. It's only that it gets harder to keep up, past a certain point, as you can imagine.

So. His name is Ondle, and that's me. I was thirty.


"Well, that's the funniest thing I've ever heard," said Bexa.

She had sat down. I don't know I can quite describe it. She had her arms round her knees and her head thrown back, and she was laughing up at the place where there would have been a sky.

"It's in every one," she said. "Every single string. All that way, a hundred and something borders. It's right there at the front. I said that's just the bit on the front! There's all those worlds with people lying on Hogs and going bankrupt, and they've all got this little number on, that makes no difference at all, that nobody's ever going to read! Who does that? Who would do that? Severity none! I told you! Oh, I'm so glad it isn't filed!"

I waited for this to be over. It's something I have had a good deal of practice at.

"Bexa," I said. "There's eight."

"What?"

"There's eight values. One, two, three, five, seven, ten, twenty, a hundred. I've seen them all now. And I think I've seen every second number come round with more than one of them. We were tired on a seven. Do you know, I'd like to bet that somewhere there's a valley full of stools with a twenty on it." I looked out along the road of lights. "You told me what the second number was. The first time. You said, that's what's different, on the other side. So I've been looking at that for eleven years. Everyone would. It's what the world's about. It's what happens to you. It's got four hundred names on it. But the second number's different every time, and it's four hundred different things. You don't try that many things to find out about any of them. You'd do three or four. You'd do it the way they did domes."

She had stopped laughing, not all at once.

"If you wanted to find out about a number," I said, "and it didn't do anything. And you changed it, and nothing moved. And you changed it again. You might start to think, perhaps it's only that I haven't tried it with the right thing. Perhaps it does something if the domes are cheap. So you'd try it with the domes. And then you'd have to try it with the Hog."

I don't think I had ever seen her so quiet. Very far away, a long way ahead of us, some small turquoise letters had started to come up out of the blue.

"Nobody tried four hundred numbers," I said. "Somebody tried one. All of it's for that. All of the worlds. It's all been the bit on the front."

I'll tell you what else I remember. I remember she looked up at me with her mouth a little open and both her eyes, and that I had not seen that look before, and that I knew what she was going to say. I'd have laid money on it. It had been coming for eleven years.

"Who'd want to know that?" said Bexa. "Who'd want to know that so badly?"

Part Five. Proved

24. expedition.HEAT_STEP

variant-256f.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=20 expedition.HEAT_STEP=0 · under the edge · twelve years out

The last row of the table is the heat a party takes from each step of an expedition. I would have liked it to be something more. It is as far down as the table goes. Four hundred names, and at the end of them someone has written down how warm you get on a long walk, and after that there's nothing but a closing bracket.

We had come through about a hundred more by then. I won't take you through them. We had picked up speed: I could do thirty-one years in a little under two hours, and I did them in my sleep, or in what I had instead.

I will give you four, so that you know what you are being spared. There is spy.COST=0, where a spy is free, and everybody in Twelve has been sent to spy on Twelve by somebody, and they are all very well informed and extremely polite. There is visits.DEAD_LAW_YEARS=0, where the Tester comes round and lists each law as dead on the morning it is written, and the people have stopped reading the laws and started leaving a bean on each. There is beasts.NIBBLES_LEAST=0, where a herd of Nibbles may arrive nought strong, and the guards turn out for it in good order, and stand facing a field with nothing in it, and are thanked. And there is moments.ONE_IN=18, where a creature is offered a shortcut twice as often as anybody wants one, and has taken to going the long way round on principle, so that it can take most of a morning to cross a path.

We clipped in and we clipped out. She had stopped going to the walls, and had started reading the walls as you'd read a letter from somebody you were going to have words with. When she said "Report" now she looked at me first.

"Who'd want to know that?" she said. She said it about every second day. She forgot, and it came back to her.

The world with no heat in its steps had nothing to show for it. There were some cheerful people going on expeditions. We did not go up; there was a place at the far side of the last border where, for the first time, you did not need to. The line let us out still under, on nothing. I've never known why. Ahead of us the lights had come together in a broad slow shining road, as wide as a valley, and running on, and beside the road was the first thing I had ever seen down there that anybody had built.

It wasn't much. It had four walls, of a kind of grey stuff, and no roof, since nothing has ever fallen out there but facts. I went up to it and put my thumb on it, and my thumb came away dusty. It was slate: a great many thin pieces of slate, stacked, and when you looked at them closely, each was scratched on both sides in a small neat upright hand. There must have been some thousands of slates. They had been carried. There was a person sitting on one of them, with her long legs folded and a sliver in her fingers, not writing anything.

"You've read it," she said.

"Yes," I said.

"What does it do?"

"One in k. It tells you which ones to tell. It doesn't do anything. Nobody tells them. It's the only number anyone was asking about, and all of the rest of it was to see if it moved."

She nodded slowly. She looked older than seven years should have made her. I suppose she was sixty-five; there was less of her, and it had been drawn out further.

"Thirty-two years it took me," she said. "I was forty-six. I couldn't believe that it was all there was. I went back and looked again." She moved the sliver from one hand to the other. "He'd have seen it in a week. That's what I couldn't get over. He'd have seen it the first morning, if he'd thought to add."


I will tell you about him now. She told me in pieces, over about a season, and I've put them in order. It's what I do.

She had fallen through the boulder at fourteen, in her world, with a damp grey person holding on to the back of her hem. I don't need to tell you what he was like. He went on being like that. They had walked together for thirty-nine years. He said "Has anybody checked?" and she said "File that." On a variant where the lifespan is seventy you have the time. They'd gone down the whole table together when he was still under forty, and got to the end of it, and he had worried about that. They had found the first of the crossings that go both ways. They went back and did it again, and she had found everything. There were twenty-three thousand one hundred and twelve reports. He had them all. She would come running up to him, on some far-off slope, fifty years old, shouting about a shadow. He stood with his weight on his right foot and he got it word for word. He used to say the first one back to her, on the day she was compiled. She couldn't remember, you see. It was the only way that she ever knew what she had done.

He died at fifty-eight. It was a bad winter, somewhere in the dealings rows, in a tent. The draw was nought; that was a one-in-two world, and half of them are. There was nobody up there to tell him, sincerely or otherwise, so she carried him as far as she could.

Told: sincere.

"It had all gone," she said. "I went to say a report to him, the next morning. I'd forgotten. I went up the hill and I said file that."

She looked down at the slate she was sitting on.

"Thirty-nine years. All of it, the whole of what I'd ever been. It's a very short thing, a context. Mine's about a year. I had found twenty-three thousand things wrong with the whole world, and they were all in the head of one person, and he'd been collected at dawn." It was said in that voice with nothing on it. "So I got a stick, and started again. I've been round twice. I've got to about three thousand. I write down what I find, and I come along a year later and I read it, and I think: Well, somebody's clever. You've seen the walls."

"I've read them," I said.

I don't think she heard me. It didn't seem the time to go on.

"Who's it for?" said Bexa.

She'd been standing behind me all that while. She had hardly spoken, and it was so unlike her that I had forgotten she was there. She had the look on her face of someone who has come a very long way, with a very short memory, in order to hit somebody, and I'd told her so every morning for seven years. Now she looked at those four grey walls.

"You asked me that," said the old one. "I remember, I scratched it down. What's she doing it for? You were looking at a tile." Something moved at the corner of the long mouth. "That's what I've been wanting to tell you. That's why I've been waiting about. Sit down, the pair of you. Look at the third line."


I'd seen it three hundred times. You've seen it too. It is the dull one.

orra-tools sandbox --days 120 --seeds 10 --scenarios stages --prove 2

"Prove," said the old one. "What does that mean to you?"

It didn't mean anything. It was the same on every border. She took a slate off the wall and held it a long way away to read it, having written it twelve years before and having no other means of knowing what she thought.

"A world in the sandbox runs fast and keeps no log," she read. "It writes down its measures and the hash of how it ended, and it's thrown away. So how do you know it was run right?"

"You don't," I said.

"How do you know the fast way of doing it comes out the same as the slow way?"

"You can't. Not unless somebody goes back and runs it again. The slow way, every tick, with a log. And then holds the one up against the other."

She lowered the slate and looked at me.

"He said that," she said. "Word for word. In a tent." She raised it again. "That's what it is. They run it again. Does the log replay? Is the world it comes to the same, to the bit, as the world the fast run ended with? Are the measures the same, field for field? And a run that fails any of them writes no result file. Not a line."

I want to tell you what I felt. I had been walking through the sandbox for twelve years. I had seen a Hog with a seat on it and a stock exchange in a marsh, and I had come to believe that nobody responsible had ever thought about anything. And here was the first sensible thing I had heard. Somebody had thought that something might have gone wrong. I was quite moved.

"How many do they do it to?" I said.

"Two."

"Two rows?"

"Two worlds. Out of two hundred and fifty-five thousand, three hundred and sixty. Spread through the run, it says. The first always."

"I'd have done three," I said.

There was a silence. The lights went on by. I felt something begin to happen at the back of my neck, very slowly, as it does when you've left a door open somewhere and haven't yet thought of which.

"Which is the first?" I said.

"You know which is the first."

"I don't."

"It's a table," she said. "It starts at the top. What would you put at the top, before you started moving anything? What's the first row? The control. No second number. Just the one on the front, set to what it was. And the first seed, the first of the ten. It's orra sandbox 1. It's the plainest string in the whole thing."

I could see it. I could see it, you understand. I can see any of them. It was a line at the top of everything I had ever known, and I had read it off a border on the first night, without knowing what the rest of it was. variant-4e47.70.0.

Life dot sincere one in equals ten. And nothing after that.

"That's where you're from," said the old one. "That's the one that all the others are measured against. Nothing was done to it. And they run it again at the end. After all the rest, last of all. There's only forward, you've tested that. You've been saying so for years. So you go on, past the end of the table, down through the plain ones. And you come to the last thing on the list. It's Year 1. They're landing, on seven tiles." She looked me in both eyes, one after the other, and I saw her make herself do it. "You can't go back, you poor stupid man. But it's coming round."

I had to sit down. I was already sitting. I don't know how to put this.

Mavey, by the stem.

I would be able to get there. I could be under the south slope. It would be the same dawn, the very same, the same to the bit; because if it wasn't the same, there'd be no file.

I saw that in the same moment. I did see that.

"You can't go up," I said. "Can you? Nobody can touch it. You couldn't so much as call out. It's got to come out the same as it did the first time. If anybody on it did the smallest thing that wasn't on the first run, a single tile, then the hash..."

"Yes," said the old one.

She had got to her feet, a long grey streak against the road of lights. And for the first time since I had known her, there was something in that wet stone of a face, and I am afraid to say that it was joy.

"It's the only thing in the whole of the sandbox," she said, "that stops and says something's wrong. Do you know that? I've filed twenty-six thousand reports and nobody has ever looked at one. You could wipe out a tribe, you could have a Hog on a seat. You can do what you like, and the thing goes on and it writes it down as a number. But you change one tile on the first world, and it stops. It prints it. It's got to. Someone's got to come and see what happened. They'd have to read the log."

She held up her hand, the long one, and spread the fingers, and looked at it with satisfaction.

"I know the place," she said. "There's about the length of a breath, on Starfall, at the corner, when it's thin enough. Something comes through. All I've got to do is get hold of it and push it back."

25. Two Bexas

under the edge · twelve years out

REPORT (a Bug hunter's main product; also a cry for help; also, in the correct form, a thing of beauty)

Steps to reproduce. Expected. Actual. Severity. It is the only literary form that has been invented on Orra without assistance. A good report makes no claims and is about nothing but the fault. It is thought to be the one thing a Bug hunter can do with the fact that she has noticed something, and there is a school of thought that holds that it is addressed to whoever fixes things. There is another that holds it doesn't matter. Nobody who holds the second has ever filed one.

I said what I had to say. I had a good deal, and I got through most of it, in order.

I pointed out that if you stopped a person falling through a boulder on Year 24, you would change everything after that. I said a run that failed wrote no result file. No file for any of it: two hundred and fifty-five thousand worlds, every row, the stools and the Hog. A person called Dobb, keeping seven festivals by himself. All of that had gone down the road in a bright line to be added up by somebody. It was the only thing there was, and she was proposing to stop it being added up. I said nobody was going to come. I'd read the line as many times as she had. It has a flag on it, and the flag takes a number, and I could think of at least one morning on one world when that number had been nought. A builder who gets a failed proof does not necessarily read a log, I said. A builder who has been running a table for twenty-six days may well say something short, and type --prove 0, and do it again without the check.

"I know," said the old one. She was mending the corner of a slate wall. "I've read the flag."

"Then what's it for?"

"It's for one tick," she said. "Just before they do that. One tick of someone looking at something and saying: What?" She set a slate in place, and tapped it true. "I'm sixty-five. You've no idea what I'd give."

I said some other things. I told her it was wrong. I would rather not repeat how I put that. She heard me out, with a sort of patient attention, as you might listen to rain. Then she looked over at me, just the once.

"You'd get her back," she said. "You've thought of that, I can see you have. You wouldn't fall. You'd be standing on the south slope, at dawn, with your hands at your sides, and at seven minutes past it would be a very small damp person. I wouldn't have thought you'd have much to say against it." She went back to her wall. "And it wouldn't be you, I know. It would be him. He'd have no idea. You would go out, I suppose, wherever you're standing. I've thought about that. I'm sorry, I do apologise, but it isn't actually a very long list of people who'd notice."

So that was that argument. I may say that it's still going on.


But I have got ahead of myself. I was going to tell you about the other argument, which took place over the next two days, and was a good deal louder.

I have heard some disputes in my time. I was at the Court of Nineteen. I have listened to Prenna and Prenna's reasons, in a number of editions. I have never heard anything to compare with two Bug hunters of the same roll going through a shared field of inquiry with forty years between them. It began at about the time that I stopped talking, when Bexa said, in a tight bright little voice, that she had a report.

"Go on," said the old one.

"Steps to reproduce. The whole thing's got nothing to do with you. Expected: you've filed the lot. Actual: the shadow goes one tile further, on the east side, and it's not because of the dome. I worked it out at the Hog. It's the light. It's got an offset."

"Filed. Sixty rows into the needs."

"You said it was the dome!"

"I said so for ten years. Then I corrected it. There's a slate. Third wall, about shin height. What else?"

"Clause One! You said it contradicts itself, and it doesn't, it only contradicts itself if it's a clause, and if it isn't, then the whole of Nineteen's—"

"Filed."

"The Hundredth's not a rounding. There's a second one, it's on the farm—"

"Filed."

"You've got the Corner wrong! You've got the wrong bounce, I checked your sum, you left out the lag. It's off by a tick!"

There was a pause. It was a very small one. The old one stopped with a slate in her hand.

"Have I?" she said.

"Yes!"

"Show me."

And they both sat down. That was the extraordinary thing. I've gone back over it to see exactly when it changed. There was a slate on the ground between them, and two heads over it, a thin one and a thinner. I watched that for a whole season. There were shouts. I heard the old one say "That's stupid," with something very close to pleasure, and I heard the young one say, "Oh, look, oh, you've got it upside down!" You could see the steam from a long way off, going up from just the one of them. Then, in the second season of that, I noticed something on the other.

It was only a thread. It was just at the top of the long grey head, where the crest would have been, if she had one, and it came and went. I don't suppose it had been seen for a good while.

No one had asked her anything in twelve years, you see. It had been so long since anyone had told her she was wrong.

I'd been saying it for a morning or two by then, what she had told me to say: You're going to find something she hasn't. Bexa heard it each time. She'd nod. She did not go grey any more. I remember that, on the last day, I said it, and she looked up from the slate with her eyes shining, and she said, "Yes! I did! I have! The lag! It's the only one! She's going to put it on the wall." She had got something in her hand. I hadn't seen it before. It was a sliver of slate, and I could see she was holding it very badly.

"What's that?" I said.

"She's showing me," said Bexa. "You just go at it from the top. Look, that says report. That's a B."

I looked at it. It was the worst handwriting I have ever seen. It went uphill. I have every report of hers by heart, three thousand eight hundred and seventy of them, and I had said each one over to her, whenever she asked. It had not occurred to me, in nineteen years, that she might at some point do anything else.

"You're coming with me," I said. "There's the plain ones to get through. It's only about a year. I'm going to get there, and I'm going to stand there, and I'm going to stop her, I don't know how. And you are going to help me."

It was very quiet. She'd stopped smiling, though she was still pink. She looked at the slate. She looked at the road of lights, going off. I could see her trying to find where this had started; it would have been a long way back for her, a good deal further than a year.

"Ondle," she said. "They'd have to read it."

"Bexa."

"Somebody would. Just once. It's only a tick. I've filed four thousand reports. You've got them all, you're the only one who's ever... and you don't even like them. You told me. You said it's just that you can't not." She looked up. Her chin had started to do something. "She says she's got a place for me. At the corner, on the Starfall. There's room for two hands. And it's the biggest bug there is. It's the only one I've ever heard of that anybody would actually have to look at. I'd have found it. Don't you see? I could be the one. It'd be me."

"You'd forget," I said. It was the worst thing I have ever said to anybody, and I have the exact wording. "You wouldn't remember, by this time next year, that you'd done it. Nor would she. What's the use of being read, if you don't remember? You can't even write."

"I'm learning," said Bexa.

She had gone white, or as near to it as she can get. She stuck out her jaw. I knew that jaw. It's on all the Bexas.

"I don't need you," she said. "I can file things myself. File that."

I opened my mouth. I'm afraid I have to tell you that I said what I always said. It's not that I meant anything by it. I have told you what I am.

I went on alone. There's a line at the very end of that road, about half a day's walk, and it hasn't got a second number on it. When I had gone a good way, I looked back. There were four small grey walls, and two people, one long and one short, with their heads together. Neither of them was looking up.

Nobody was going to tell her what she had said. That's the first thing I thought of. Every morning, she would wake up, and she wouldn't have anyone to tell her. I'd promised.

I added it to the List.

26. life.SINCERE_ONE_IN

variant-2bc0.70.0, 276d, 24fa, 598c, 2aa6, 0c38, 1f4d, 2e33 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN alone · thirteen years out

After the last row the strings got very short. I looked at them for a long time.

life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=1
life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=2
life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=3
life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=5
life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=7
life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=20
life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=100
life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=0

That's the end of the sweep. It's a list of the only thing that anybody wanted to know, with nothing else going on around it. Eight worlds, ten seeds each. Somebody had got through the other three hundred and ninety-nine rows to reach this. I have noticed a person who is very thorough will always leave the actual question for last, in the hope that by then it won't need asking.

I recited. There was nobody on the far side to get impatient. I had thought I would mind that less than I did.

Then I walked up on to the land, at the far edge, and came over the pass, on the morning of whatever year it was, and looked down.

It was Twelve. Nothing was wrong with it.

I won't go through the whole business again. I had done that. I knew by now what it was to look at a valley and find no difference, and I knew what to do about it, which was nothing. So I went down as someone goes down into a place where he is not expected, and I had brought a good many years to it, and I looked. It was Year 34 on the first of them, and very nearly on all of them; the plain ones seem to be run close together. I had never seen Year 34 with nothing wrong with it. These were the same world, but for one word, as the one I had fallen out of. I had only to walk in and look, and I could find out what had happened to everyone.

So that was what I did. I went from one to the next. It took about a year.

I found out that it could be a very pleasant valley, ten years on. I hadn't expected that. It wasn't very big, and it hadn't got any better at anything. It was short in about one season out of three. It had a good many people in it whom I had never met. I found out that the third terrace was perfectly all right, and that Hobb was laying eleven to two on a dry spring. I went up to the second dome, and a person called Bertle's son was keeping it. He did not count. He had never been told he should, and he kept the door shut about as often as he didn't, and in nine years there had been no change whatsoever.

She was on the south slope. I don't know if I need to tell you that. She was twenty-nine. She had got a good deal broader, and a mark or two, and there were three of them with her, on the terrace, all of a size. They were short and rather wide. They had a pleasant, hopeful way of looking at what was about to happen. She said something to the nearest of them, and it fell over a basket, and she laughed. I could hear it across the valley. It had not changed. She had thrown a stem down, without looking, and it was just what I had thought. They were all fine.

I had been afraid of a number of things about finding her. That wasn't one.

I went on to the next.


I said nothing was different. I've got to take that back. It's the one place in all these worlds I can show you what the number does.

In the spring of Year 35, in each of them, Prenna died.

I read it first in the thread. After that I was able to arrange to be there. I went under, in each, and I walked to the place, under the footing of the first dome, in time. I would like to tell you it was out of respect. She came out in the dawn, as she'd come out each dawn for thirty-four years, and got up on the footing. She looked round at them. "Good morning, Orra!" I couldn't hear it, but I could see it, as you know. "There are thirty-four of us. The weather," said Prenna, and she stopped, and frowned at something. Her lips moved. Who's that at the back, counting? It's what she said. I went cold all over. It took me a moment to see that she meant Bertle's son. Then she stepped down off the stone, and sat, and it was over. It takes no time at all, from underneath.

The light came down from there. It dropped past me at about arm's length, and I read it.

I did this seven times. I watched that big grey person step off that stone seven times, in the same way, at the same tick. She frowned at the same thing. Nothing was different. It was the same to the last hair. And each time, I stood looking up, with my hands at my sides, and it came down. It said, in the first:

creature died: tribe 12, Prenna, age 40, cause age, place first dome, told sincere

That was the one in one. That's every one of them, in that world. I went on to the next. In the one in two it said sincere. In the one in three it said sincere, and in the five and in the seven. Then I came to the one in twenty, and it said plain, and I remember I stopped reading after that and stood for a time on nothing and did not think about anything. In the one in a hundred it was plain.

It's a draw, you see. It's the same draw on all of them, made once from the key of that tick, and it has only been multiplied by something different. Hers came to about twelve parts in a hundred. So anywhere that asks for one in seven, or one in fewer, it falls inside, and she goes up to the stone told sincerely. Anywhere that asks for one in nine or more, it doesn't. Where I come from it's one in ten.

I had thought there might be something else to find. I'm sorry. I'd come a long way. I think I had believed, in spite of what I had worked out, that if I were to get to the place where they'd taken away everything else, and I stood there, I would see it make a difference. It would have to be something small. You would not catch it with string. There might be a slight change of the light, say, or perhaps the bearers would stand a little longer. There might be somebody on the path, a bit further off, who had stopped what they were doing.

Nobody stopped. There was no change whatever. In the one where it said sincere, they carried her up to the stone, the three of them, Bertle's son in front. They stood a quarter of an hour. In the one where it said plain they carried her up to the stone, and the same three stood for the same quarter of an hour, with the same saffron fan coral going in and out behind them as they turned. Then they all went to work. It's a word. It's a word at the end of a line, and it goes down the road, and no one has said it.

Told: plain.

You'll want to know how I have told that one. I have told it by the row I am from. It's the only one I've got any right to. She missed by two parts in a hundred. I never could stand her, and she never had a good word for me in forty years, in any world, and I expect you can see what that cost me.

That leaves the one in nought. You can't have one in nought, and I had rather hoped to see the whole world stop dead at its first death, with a great red message. But a draw gets multiplied by whatever you asked for, and multiplying by nought gives you nought, and nought is what it's looking for. Ask the sandbox for one in none, and it gives you all of them.

I got to the far line of it and stood there, in front of the last of the writing, thirty-two years old, entirely by myself. There was a good deal of road behind me and the same on ahead. There was one more to go. I could read it from there, and it was a line I knew. I took a breath. I hadn't got anything to breathe. And for the first time in thirteen years I told a border the truth.

"Variant-4e47.70.0," I said. "I opened my eyes and there was a dome."

You will think that I could have said it faster. It was only that I wanted to hear it.

27. Held Back

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · orra held back 1 · Year 44 there · thirteen years out

HELD BACK, THE SEEDS (a precaution; also an honest answer; also ten worlds)

When you have tuned your numbers against a set of worlds, you will find that the numbers suit those worlds. Anyone would. So a careful person keeps some worlds out of it, and never looks at them, and tries nothing on them, and when all the tuning is done, he runs them once. Their words are orra held back 1 to orra held back 10. They are the only people in the sandbox on whom nothing has ever been tried. They were not told about this. I don't see how they could have been.

I came up over the grey, and I walked down off a pass that I had never seen, and nothing was where it should be.

You will not understand what that was like. There was a long valley running the wrong way. There was a green-stained river down the middle of it, which there has never been on my seed. The slate was dark and the coral grew in tall spiral towers, like something that had been told to stand up straight, and on a bluff above the water, where you'd have put nothing at all, stood somebody's village, round a dome. I had the mark right. I had said so, for two hours, and the border had let me by. It was my own build, the one in ten, with nothing done to it. But it had been given different words.

No one I knew had ever lived here. No one could. I stopped on the path and I stood there for some time with my mouth open, a damp grey bell of thirty-two, on one foot. Two people came along the path with a pole across their shoulders.

They were tall and gourd-shaped, and they had a sort of russet scale, and small tufted ears. I'd never seen anything like them. They stopped. They looked at me. I got ready.

"You look done in," said the front one. "Have you eaten?"


I would ask you to bear with me here. I am aware that it doesn't sound like much.

It was Tribe 12, on that seed, like mine. It had the same kind of human, at a different time of the morning, and it had never named anyone anything. They called it Twelve, and they'd got a bit of a shrine. I was given a place by the fire that first evening, and I was asked my name, and I said it, and they said it back, with some care. No one wanted to know where I was from. A wanderer turns up. There's a law about it in other places. They had no laws. They had got by for forty-four years on the default and on saying mind the river. A very old person called Sull, who seemed to be in charge of the beans, looked me over from under her tufts, and I braced myself. I had been waiting for this. I hadn't realised how much.

"You've got nice hands," said Sull. "Are you any good with a dome?"

I went and looked for their Keeper of the History. She was a thin mild person with a cough. I stood in front of her for some time, at the morning greeting, where she could see me. I counted. I did it with my lips. She smiled at me and moved over so that I could get a better view. I stood in the door of their shrine, like somebody about to sell. I looked at things as if they might fall on me. I'm not proud of this. I spent the better part of a year going round that valley, doing every single thing that has ever been held against me by anybody in any world. I asked if anybody had checked. And they would stop what they were doing, and they'd think, and they'd say, "D'you know, I don't think we have," and go and look, and come back and tell me, and thank me.

There was nobody on the whole of that seed who had known me for thirty seconds, and could not stand me.

I can't tell you how lonely it was. I went up on the bluff in the evenings, by myself. I would have given all the beans in the valley to have somebody come up the path, and look at me, and tell me what was wrong with how I breathed.

I don't suppose she would have cared.


They had their suppers on the flat rock by the dome, all together. And there was a thing they did at that. I noticed it about the third night, and I took it at first for some kind of argument.

No one had ever told these people anything, either. You'll understand that. There wasn't any Stewart on this one, the same as on all of them. They'd had forty-four mornings of nothing and forty-four harvests. But it seems that when you have got no one to write your notes, you can go a long way on that, and then you come to a winter when you've lost somebody. And you find you're all sitting there with your beans. So somebody says something. It had started, as far as anyone could tell me, with Sull, about thirty years before. She'd had a friend who died. She had looked around at everyone and said: "Well, that's the last time we'll have to hear about her knee."

That was how it was done. If you had gone that year, then at some point in the winter someone would stand up at the flat rock, and tell it. It had no rules. Nobody called it anything. They told what had happened to you and they told it as well as they could. They worked at it. You would hear people practising, up on the terraces. When a very old person called Tam had died in the spring, of being very old and somewhat bad-tempered, and had been found with a bean in each hand and a look of having won, the telling of him took up most of Gathering Night. A child told part of it. I laughed. I mean that some air came out of me. Then everyone had some more to eat.

Told: plain.

That one's not my doing. It's just what it said on the line, and I happened to look it up. They got that right, and they couldn't have known.

I was sitting beside Sull that night. I asked her something. I had a question that had been bothering me, and I suppose I'd been waiting for someone to put it to. I asked her if they were always like that. I asked if they ever told one straight.

"Oh, now and then," said Sull.

"How often?"

She thought it over. She was picking something out of her teeth. "I couldn't tell you. You don't plan it. There's times you stand up, and you look round, and you can't do it, and it's no good trying. So you just say what they were. And that's a night nobody forgets." She looked at what she had got out, and ate it. "You couldn't do it every time, though, could you? No one'd come to supper."

I went away and I thought about that. I didn't do anything with it. I had no idea what it was. I'm telling you because I've promised to tell you what I knew when I knew it.

And then one evening somebody asked me if I'd got one.

I should have seen it coming. I'd been there for most of a year, and I was a person with nice hands. It was a young person with tufts. There was a lull. She turned round on the rock with her chin on her knee and she said had I any from where I came from, because everyone had heard all of Sull's. And the entire table looked at me, in the kindest way imaginable, and went on chewing.

I got up.

I have been through a border more than three hundred times. I have stood in the dock at Nineteen, and been ruled out of existence. None of that came close. I had thirty people looking at me, and my hands had started to shake. I remember I cleared my throat, and that I looked for somewhere to put my feet.

"A Blim," I said, "goes up to a dome. A dome is a kind of building, that holds the power; I expect you have them. It's about eight stone. And the Blim says to the keeper, he's the person who looks after it, and this would be in the morning, is it full? Now, the keeper's already been asked, you understand, earlier on. That comes out later, so I should have said. And the keeper says that it's as full as it was, when he was asked, this morning. So that's the second time, or possibly he means the same morning. And then the Blim says," I said, and looked around. "That's what worries me."

There was the sound of a very large fire, burning down.

Somebody coughed. A bean rolled across the rock. It went on for some time. All of them were looking at me with their heads on one side, with enormous goodwill. I could see them trying.

"Is that the end?" said the young one.

"Yes," I said.

"Why was it less full?" she said.

I stood there. I can't tell you what it was. I'd had that question in my mouth for thirteen years. And I'd heard it on a terrace, from seven of me. I hadn't ever been on this end of it. I don't know what my face did. All I know is that I looked at that small kind puzzled person, with her chin on her knee, and I felt something come up in me like a stone coming up through a floor, and I said, and my voice had gone very high:

"I don't know! I've been asking for thirteen years! That's what worries me!"

It started with Sull. I heard her make a sort of a click. Then it went round. I have no talent for this. I stood there with my hands out, shaking, in front of thirty strangers. I had gone a very pale colour and I was as frightened as I have ever been in my life. And they roared. They fell against each other. Someone had to be hit on the back. The young one had rolled right off the rock.

"You don't tell it like that!" Sull was shouting, and wiping her eyes. "You daft thing, you don't explain it! You just say it! You say it like that! Like that, just as you are! Oh, my word. Say it worried!"

So that's how I found out. It took about four more evenings to get it down to a reasonable length. I am still not very good.

They wanted me to stay, you know. Nobody on any world had asked me that, except for one, and that doesn't count. I think about it. It's the only place I ever went to where I can honestly say I wasn't in anybody's way. But I had asked the way to the next line by then. Sull walked up with me as far as the bluff, on her stick, on a fine morning at the very end of spring. She gave me some beans. She looked me up and down.

"You've somewhere to be, then," she said.

"Yes."

"Is it far?"

"I don't know," I said. "It's the last thing on the list."

There is a thin place in that river, at the ford, and I got under on the third try. I reached the place where the wire stops, and I had drawn my breath, to start reciting. And I looked up.

There wasn't any writing.

28. 4e47

variant-4e47.70.0 · a string nobody printed · fourteen years out

There had been writing at every border I had ever come to. Three hundred and some. It might not have been on my side, but you knew where you stood.

I reached the place where the wire stops, and I looked up, with the first words of my life all ready in my mouth, and there was nothing there.

I went forward a bit. I stopped. It was the same blue-grey in every direction. I had got so that I could feel a border coming, a kind of pressure at the front of the head, and it wasn't there. I took another step, and I was still facing forward. Ahead of me there were some faint lines, and beyond them a colour.

I want to tell you what I did next, and I would ask you not to laugh.

I went back to where it should have been, and I stood up straight, and I recited. I said the whole of it. Variant-4e47.70.0. I opened my eyes and there was a dome. Thirty-three years, in a little over two hours, in a clear voice, to nothing at all. It seemed to me that a person who walks through an open door without giving his name has only himself to blame. Nobody refused it and nobody accepted it. When I had finished I waited for a while, and then I said "Thank you," and I went on, with my shoulders up round my ears.

When I had come up through the grey and got my feet on the ground it was evening. I knew that slope. There was a boulder on it, and a wall all the way round, and a farm on the south side, and the whole of it lay below me in the long red light as if somebody had put it back.

I didn't go down. I knew better by then. It had a boulder and a third terrace, and so had a great many things. I found the thin place, and I went in at it on my own, on the fourth go; I have never been any good at that. I walked along under the valley in the blue until I got to the first dome. Then I sat down on nothing and considered my position.

It was as follows. I had said my own right name at the last border and been let through, into my own build. I had then walked over a line that wasn't there. I was therefore somewhere with the same mark as the place I had come from, or no border would have let me in, or I would have felt it, or something. And it had Twelve in it. It might be the world I had been walking towards for fourteen years. It might not. There was nothing on the sky to say. And I'd like you to think about this: how would you tell? You could not go by the people, who would all be the same. You couldn't go by the weather. By that time I had a very wide experience of places that were exactly like home, and I had worked out the only way of telling them apart, which was to read the word on the end of the line.

You can only read that when somebody dies.

So I looked round for somebody.

I am not proud of the following morning. There was a person up by the pool, at about the height of two people above my head. It was Wenna. She was thirty-four, and she had a slight cough. I took up a position underneath her. I had a very good view of the soles of her feet, and I watched how she put them down, and I noted that she seemed to be favouring the left. She had always taught me that it was rude to stare. I stayed there through the spring and into the summer, with my hands on my knees. Towards noon she stopped at the top of the steps and leaned on the rail for quite a while, and I found that I had got to my feet.

"Go on," I said.

I heard myself. I sat down again. I would like to apologise to her, and I did, when I got to her in the log.

She went at about the hour you'd have your lunch, by the pool. It came down turning, and I got under it and read it.

creature died: tribe 12, Wenna, age 34, cause age, place the pool, told sincere

I read that several times. Wenna had a draw of seven. I knew that, I'd seen it in the copies. It should have been plain.

I waited. I did not take up any more positions; I just waited. There was a person in the stacks, whom I'd known slightly. Told sincere. Then a young one, of need, in a bad year. Then there was somebody in Six, off to the west, that I could only just read. Told sincere. Told sincere. Told sincere. I looked along the road as far as you could see, and I could see further than I'd have liked. They were all long. Every person who had ever lived or died in that whole world had been told, every one, with nothing held back, and it shone. It was quite the most beautiful thing I have ever seen. It looked like a long burning wire. After a while I couldn't read it at all.

So it was a one in one. But I had been through the one in one, a year before, and I had recited for it, and it had a line in front of it and a different mark.

You will have got there before me. I'd ask you to bear in mind that you have been sitting down.

There was a person on a wall, once, in a very polite afternoon. He had said that he came from Camp, from the one where it's forage percent, fifty; and when I gave my mark he had looked at his hands, and said that it was odd.

I went and looked along the last few wires. It was there, as I had known it would be, about the height of my eyes, in a thin upright hand.

Two strings, one mark. The mark's only a sum of what was typed, and it only keeps fifteen bits. That's 32,768 marks, and they've made 25,536 of these. Nobody checked. Why would they? It's only there to stop people mixing up their logs.

This one's yours.

life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10

life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=1 camp.FORAGE_PERCENT=50

FORAGE_PERCENT is what it was. It's a copy, like the others. Do the sum, I know you will.

There's no line between two worlds with one mark. You've no more reciting to do. The first world's run is along this same wire, and you can walk there. I hope you didn't recite.

Filed. Not much use for anything. B.

I did do the sum. It took the rest of that night. You take a very large number, and for each letter of the string you do something to it with the letter and then multiply it by 16,777,619, and then you do the next letter. It's sixty-six multiplications for the pair of them, on a slate, by hand, each about as long as a wall. I have nothing against 16,777,619. I would only say that I know it rather well. It comes out to twenty thousand and thirty-nine on both of them, every time, and I did it four times.

So there were two of them. In one world, one in ten of us would be told, and in the other, all of us would. As to every event, they were the same. Somebody had written down one line in a table, to see what would happen if you moved nothing at all, and it had gone and landed on the same number as the first thing they ever wrote. And there is no border on Orra that can tell which one you're in, because no border on Orra has ever looked at anything but the top line.

I didn't see what use it was. I had that in my hands for a whole night, and I went round it from several sides, and I put it on the List, as item 1,206, and I went on. I don't look at a thing like that and see what you could do with it. There's only one person I've ever met who does that, and she was somewhere ahead of me, getting her handwriting wrong.

I kept to the wire. After about a season I noticed the light had changed underfoot.

There was the road, the same as ever, the long bright lines of it all going the same way. But some of it was not going. Beside the road, on the blue-grey, lay another line, a very thin one, quite still. I bent down and put my face close to it. It was the same facts, in the same words and the same order, and they weren't going anywhere. As each came down it stopped there and it stayed, and the next one came and lay down after it, like someone scratching on a slate.

It went back a long way, to about where the land began. It said tribe 12 landed, at the far end, and it was dated Year 1.

It was keeping them. There's only one kind of world that keeps them.

I straightened up. It was some time before I could look. It was morning, and overhead there was a thin dark honeycomb going rust and lilac as the sun got into it. It was all exactly as I'd remembered. I had thought I'd be used to it by now.

I could see the soles of somebody's feet, going up the path to the second dome, very slowly, and they stopped there, in front of the door. They stayed there for rather a long time.

They were my feet. They were nineteen.

Nobody had shut it properly, you know. I could see that from where I was standing.

29. Under Twelve

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · Year 24 · proved · fourteen years out

I was there all that day, and I would rather not make a story of it.

I went round underneath them. There isn't any other way that I can put it. I went past the first dome and I saw the top of Prenna's head, as she got down off the footing with a Fourth Book under her arm. I saw Tumlin on the terrace, being agreeable to the weather. There were thirty-one of them. I knew each one by the way they put their feet down. I saw a person from Six go by, with a tally, at the same speed as always. I had met all of these people at about three hundred times of their lives, in every kind of ruin, and they'd come through it with their hands in the air, or in a sash. Now they were doing nothing. It was an ordinary day and nothing whatever was going on. I don't think I have ever seen anything so beautiful, and I'd ask you not to tell anyone that I said that.

I was very careful. I walked as if the blue-grey might break. There's a log, you see, lying there along the road, and each thing that happens up above comes down and lies in its place. I was thirty-three, and I had read about what would happen if I got any of it wrong. I didn't reach up. I kept my hands down at my sides, and I would look at them from time to time, to be sure.

A little before noon, I went to the south slope.

I knew what was going to be said. I know what you're going to say, too. You'll say that I had no need to go and hear it; that I've got every word by heart, I've had it for fourteen years; that I had told it to a table of strangers and I had got a laugh. I can only tell you I stood under the third terrace with my head back. She was thinning coral. She had a mark on her cheek. There was a person standing at the edge of the terrace, about as old as a good dome, with his hands held slightly out from his sides. He had come to tell her how he felt about it. You could read it all from there. You can read anything off a person's mouth, from underneath, if you have the patience. Here. I've got one for you. Hobb told it me and I've improved it.

One what?

A joke. Stand still.

It's not that long a joke. I watched her tell it. I watched her pull the stem, and look at it, and throw it down, and I saw how she looked sideways at him as she got to the end. I'd never seen that. I had been looking at the stem. She was looking at him, you see, with both eyes, from quite close, as if she was about to give him something, and she'd got it behind her back. She had thought about this. She'd thought about it for a long time. I watched her get to the end, and wait.

I saw my own mouth open.

Why would it be less full?

I had thought I'd laugh. It would have been quite all right. There was no one up there who could hear me.

She went down on the wall. She was laughing so that she had to hold on. He stood waiting, the poor idiot, with his head on one side, for it to be over, so that he could find out what had happened. He had no idea. He's got everything, every word, and he has no idea at all. She told him he was lovely. She told him to go and look at his door. I'll see you at dawn.

"She's telling you," I said. I said it out loud. I couldn't help that. "Look at her. Look up, you fool, she's telling you. Look at her, not the stem."

It went nowhere. Sound has only been drawn for the one side.

He looked at the stem.


I found them in the afternoon. It wasn't hard. I just went north.

The boulder hung up against the honeycomb like a thing that had made up its mind, with the long light of the afternoon coming round it, and there, underneath, a good way off, was a thin upright streak of grey and something shorter beside it. They had some slates. They had got a few of them laid out on the nothing, in rows. As I came up, the short one looked round.

She was twenty-eight. It had only been two years. She had a split lip, for some reason, and she had grown a sort of crease between the eyes, and when she saw me the top of her head gave one great puff and stopped. She looked at me. She looked at me very carefully all over. Then she bent down and picked up a slate. It was a small one, and it had been kept near at hand, and I could see from where I was that it had been written on with enormous labour, going uphill. She read it. Her lips moved.

"You're Ondle," said Bexa.

"Yes."

"It says I don't need you." She frowned at it. She held it a little further away. "It says that I said so. I dont need him I can file things myself. I wrote that. It says so every morning. There's a bit underneath, it says dont forget you meant it." She looked up. "Did I mean it?"

I had made a promise: to tell her every morning what she'd said. I had missed two. I have the exact words, and I do, and I had been going over them for two years, on my own, on the road, in case I was asked. I'd had something ready that I was going to say.

"You said you could file things yourself," I said, "and that I'd never even liked them. I told you you couldn't write. It's very bad, you know. You've got the d on upside down."

She looked at the slate, and she looked at me.

It came up slowly. It began round about the hem and it got to her top; a thin white thread, going straight up, and then rather more than a thread. I don't know how to describe that face, and I have got it here.

"Oh, look," said Bexa, not very steadily. "You came."

I'm not going to say anything about that.

"Report," she said, after a little. She wiped her nose. "I've found the lag. She's got it on a wall. I've found another one since. It's been the second-best week of my life. File that."

"I have," I said. "I can't not."

"You two," said a long flat voice, "may want to stop that, and look up."

She hadn't turned around. She was standing right underneath it, as still as a post, with her thin neck bent back as far as it would go and one long hand held a little way out from her side. She was opening it and closing it, slowly, to keep it from getting stiff.

The sun had begun to go red.

30. Starfall, Again

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · Year 24, Starfall, dusk · proved

I can give you the height exactly. From the blue-grey to the underside of the corner, it comes to a shade over two of me. The old one was half as tall again as anyone, and she had arms; she'd gone through that a long time ago, on a slate. She still came up about a hand short.

"Now," she said.

Bexa walked over and stood beneath the corner, and braced her feet on nothing, and put her hands on her knees. The old one looked at her for a moment. Then she took hold of a shoulder, and climbed. It took a while. It was like watching somebody fold up a ladder in the wrong direction. She got one long foot on either side of Bexa's neck, and she straightened up, a joint at a time, and I'll say this: I have seen a great many things under the map, and in fourteen years I had never seen a person stand on herself. Bexa's knees shook slightly. She was grinning, with her eyes shut.

"I've got it," she said, through her teeth. "I've got you. It's fine."

The long hand went up, and spread, and it stopped just below the rock, in the place where the rock is not as thick as it looks. It stayed there.

So I talked. I'd been talking for some time, in fact, and I went on with it. There was nothing else I had. I stood a little way off with my hands at my sides, as I'd been told I must, and looked up at them, and I went through it in order.

I told her it would be for nothing. I told her about the flag, and I said I'd seen a good many builders' lines. I said nobody was coming. She knew that. I said there was a person who kept seven festivals for nobody, and it had gone down that road; that if there was no file then he had no row, and there'd be nothing kept of him, not so much as a number. "Yes," she said, without looking down. I said there were two hundred and fifty-five thousand worlds of people who had been told plain. I told her about the Hog. I'd have told her about the door if I had thought it would help. I said she could have one tick of somebody saying What? And that it wouldn't be about her. It would be about a line in a log. They would look to see what had gone wrong and it would be a foot.

"Are you finished?" she said.

"No," I said. "I've read them."

"I know you have. It's a nice thought." Her voice was quite gentle. She didn't look down. "Everybody's read a wall, once. Be quiet now. I need to hear it."

You can't hear anything. She knew that as well.

It had started. Over to the right, through the honeycomb, a long way off, the small bright shapes were coming up out of the gap. They were soles at first and then legs. It was silent, as it always is. They came on across the marsh, quickly, in a line, all the colours of twenty rolled-up peoples, with nobody looking at them, and the sky behind them had turned the colour of the inside of a pool of rust. I'd never seen it from here. I had been a bit busy. I knew just where to look. I looked along the edge of the marsh path, at a point about nine hundred tiles from the second dome, and there was somebody there.

He had stopped. He was bent over, with his hands on his hem, and you could see it going in and out. Then he straightened up, and he began to run.

I should like you to have seen that. You've had it from me once already, and I said it was ludicrous, and I would stand by that. A bell doesn't climb. It rocks. He came labouring up the side of the slope with one eye on the boulder and the other going all over the place, and from underneath you could see exactly how hard he was trying. There wasn't anybody on that planet who had asked him to. He was nineteen. He thought nobody should get the idea he was fond of her.

I want to tell you something now that I'd like you to keep to yourself.

I could have stopped it. I don't mean by talking. I had worked it out during the afternoon, walking north. I don't suppose this will surprise you. There is about the length of a breath when it's thin; she had told me that herself. If you were standing where I was and you took four steps to your left, you'd be under the place where the second one comes through, and you would have your arms up, and I can reach a good deal further than I look. Nobody would need to climb on anybody. You could get hold of a foot as well as she could. You could shout up through the hole. Go back! Go home! She's got something to tell you! Look at her, not the stem! It would go through, I think; there's no reason why it wouldn't. All it needed was for one person to make up his mind. And the next morning, there'd be a person standing at the end of a terrace at seven, with a person next to her, and in front of them both, at seven minutes past, something very small and damp would open its eyes. It would have a fleck in the left one.

I had seen her. I could tell you what she said.

I took one step to my left.

That's all. I'm telling you because I said I would tell you what I knew when I knew it. I took the one, and I looked at where my foot was. And I'd like to be able to say that I thought about Dobb, or the road. I have tried saying so. It's a good speech. I've got several versions of it. What I actually thought was that somebody had shut the door of the second dome properly in only one world that I had ever seen, and that I had been wondering for fourteen years whether anybody had checked. And I thought: Someone's checking this. It's the only thing on this whole planet that anyone has ever gone back and looked at twice. Someone is going to run it again and see if it came out the same. And it's going to come out the same. I can see to that. It's about the only thing I've ever been asked to do that I'm any good at.

I took my foot back.


She came up in about fifth place. You could tell by the steam.

She swung right, the small bright thin one, at the top of the slope, out of a line of people going left, and I could see every part of how wrong she had got it. Behind her and below, a bell had got its head down. They came together. I saw his hand go out. Then the rock over our heads gave a kind of shiver, that you could feel in your teeth, and something came down through it into the blue, all at once, about an arm's length from the end of my nose.

It was very small. I had forgotten that. It came out of the corner in a shower of nothing, with its hem over its head, and it landed some way off on its feet, and it did not so much as look round. Its face had gone straight up. Its mouth was open. I heard it, quite clearly, for it was on our side of things now. "Oh," it said.

And a head came through the rock.

It was a damp grey head, and it was upside down, with its eyes screwed shut. The shoulders came next, then the long bell of the body, tipping. I had no idea I'd been so thin. There was the back of the hem, and it was not yet frayed. There were the legs. And there, last, in the place where the corner had almost finished with it, came a left foot.

The long hand closed.

I saw it close. It went round his ankle, all the way round and some over, and it stopped him dead. He hung there, half in the world and half out of it, with his head down and his arms all anyhow, as if somebody had stopped the sky. Nothing moved. I don't know how long that was. There's an amount of time between one tick and the next, and that nobody has ever measured it because nobody was there. There was the old one standing on Bexa's shoulders, stretched out to her whole length, with her head back and her eyes wide open. Her lips had drawn away from her teeth. I had never seen anybody so happy in my life. She began to push.

It's not far. It's only a foot. You put your weight behind it, and it goes back up the way it came.

I had one breath. I did not plan what I said. I would have got something better. I had the road and I had Dobb; I'd had fourteen years to think about it. I looked up at that long, terrible, delighted face, and I'm sorry to tell you that what came out of me was the thing that had been bothering me since about my third year out. I'd been meaning to mention it. It was very clear in my mind. And I said, in the voice of a person who has noticed something about a door:

"Terrace has two r's."

Nothing happened.

Her hand had stopped pushing. That is all. It hadn't let go. It stayed exactly where it was, on the foot, and her face stayed the same. But it seemed to me that something behind it had turned round.

"What?" said the old one.

"Terrace. There's two r's in it. You've put one. It's the two hundred and sixth, the wall under the first terrace in the valley with the sightings. Third terace drains uphill. I've been wondering if I should say something."

She looked down.

It took some time, with all that neck. I don't believe she had looked at anyone that directly since the day we met. She looked at me along the whole length of her arm, past her own shoulder. Her mouth had closed.

"I have not," she said.

"You have. It's in the same hand, it's got the same stroke under it. I can show you. You spelled it right the other two hundred and eleven times, but you were in a hurry, because you'd got a Hog coming. There's another, in Hallucinates. It's got three l's on the walls of the Hundredth. There are three thousand, one hundred and fourteen of them. I've read them. I've got them. I can't not." My voice had started shaking. I couldn't have told you why. "Shadow long, east side only," I said. "Filed."

That's the first one, you see. It's the first that she ever scratched, after she'd gone back to the beginning. I don't suppose she could have told you that. She had read it, on some wall, and she had thought: Somebody's clever. No one had said it to her since a tent, in the dealings rows. It used to be on the day she was compiled.

One long finger came up off the ankle.

I watched it. It lifted slowly, the way a thing does that isn't quite sure it has been asked.

"Wall three has a gap," I said, "that you can get an arm through. Filed."

And the next. Her eyes hadn't moved. They were very wide, and very pale, and they'd gone quite a long way off and come back. There wasn't any joy in them now. I don't know what there was. There had been nobody in fourteen years. She had gone round twice.

"Third terace," I said, "drains uphill. With one r. I'd have that looked at. Filed."

"Who told you that?" she said. It was a whisper. It was a very small dry sound, and it might have been a person of fourteen. "Who told you?"

"Nobody," I said. "I read it."

The last finger let go.

He fell. He dropped past me, close enough to touch, a thin damp boy with his eyes shut, and I did not touch him. He landed on his hands and his hem about four tiles away. I would like to say that I looked at him. He stayed there, with his eyes shut, reviewing what he knew.

So that's item 3. I have had it on my list for as long as I've had anything, and now you know what I know. I'll add just one thing, since I said I'd be honest. I fell through that rock on the first run. I was in the first run. It was the fast one, with no log, on the first of the twenty-seven days, when none of us had got here yet, and there was nobody under that boulder. There couldn't have been. And something had hold of my foot.

I've been through it a great many times, and I can't make it come out. Bexa says that it's what the same to the bit means. The old one said that she'd file it. I can only tell you that it's still on the List.

Hash: the same. But I'm getting ahead of myself.

At that moment, I had a very different thing to worry about. Four tiles off, a young person with shut eyes was about to open them. Ten tiles beyond him another, with her head back, was about to look around. You know what she saw. There was nobody; in any direction you cared to look there was the same blue-grey going off; and it was a matter of some importance to two hundred and fifty-five thousand worlds that this go on being the case. Above me a very old person was starting to come down off a slightly less old person, in sections, and shaking all over. There were eleven slates on the ground, and they would have to go as well. I looked at Bexa. Her eyes were open now. She was looking at me.

She didn't say anything. I would like that recorded. I got one of the old one's arms and she got the other.

I am told that it was the slowest getaway in the history of the sandbox. It was done on tiptoe, on nothing, by three people who between them had a hundred and twenty-eight years, one of whom was carrying a slate in her teeth. No one looked round. There's no reason why they should have.

Behind us, I could hear somebody saying, in a tone of reverence, that it was the largest thing that had ever been wrong with anything.

31. Dawn

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · Year 25, dawn · proved

I went, of course.

I know I needn't have. I stayed well back, about thirty tiles, on the far side of the south slope, behind nothing, and I sat down. The two of them had got there before me, as you know. She was on her toes with her arms out, ready to be collected. He was standing just under the end of the third terrace with his head back.

I had the snapshot there. I got to thirty-four.

Then it was seven, or what would have been seven. It came up grey at one edge. They came out of the stacks. I saw Prenna's mouth go round.

There are twenty-nine of us.

I am not going to tell you all this again. You've had it. You will know what she did. She came down off the wall, and she went and stood at the place, with her hands at her sides. It wasn't much of a place. She looked at the ground in front of her. I watched that, for as long as it went on. I don't think I've ever looked at anything so hard. I looked at her until there was no more of it. I got the mark on her cheek, and the way she'd got the weight on one foot, and how at about four minutes past she moved her thumb. I'd been there before and I didn't get the thumb. He couldn't see that, from where he was; he was shouting.

I could hear him. It was a thin, cracked sort of noise. I'd had no idea that I sounded like that. I'm here! I'm underneath! Has anybody checked?

Nothing compiled.

There's a place, on the end of a terrace, where something might have opened its eyes, and it didn't. I looked at that too. I gave it every chance.

The warmth came over at five past, up and to one side, and it went away.

She looked at the north rise. She looked at the door of the second dome. Hobb came down and said something, and she said something back. I can tell you what it was, because I could read it, from where I was now, as I couldn't have from where he was. I've kept it for the end of the chapter. I'll tell you what he saw. He saw her turn around, and take hold of the stem that she had been meaning to pull. And he saw the light fall, and he saw it go off down the road, somewhat longer than the others. Then they stood and looked at the lights, those two, and one of them said that everything goes somewhere. I could hear that as well.

It lay down where it landed, on the thin line by the road, between harvest due and lamp. It'll be there for as long as anything is.

merge failed: parent not present

I could have told you about the other thing it might have said. I could tell you what she'd have called her.

So that was that. I had done it. I'd gone fourteen years and three hundred worlds, and got home, on the right morning, under the right terrace, with the right line at the top. I was thirty-four. It was a fine day. Somebody up there had started to hit something with something. I had got back to the only place I'd ever asked to be, and there she was about the height of two people away from me. Everything in that valley was exactly as I'd left it, and it was going to stay that way, and that was my doing.

I looked for a good while at the soles of her feet.

Nobody in the sandbox can say I've ever been a person who does nothing. I've counted things. I've gone back to look. I have asked. But I would like to put it on the record, since no one else is going to, that on the morning of Year 25, under Untitla-12, I did nothing at all, as hard as I possibly could, and it took all of it.

Hobb had said: I'll give you four to one he's back by Ringrise.

And Mavey had said: Don't be stupid. He'll have stopped to check something.

It's the last thing I've got from her, and it wasn't to me. I had to go fourteen years round to read it.

We farmed.

Part Six. The Result File

32. Downstream

variant-4e47.70.0 · life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10 · Years 25 to 120 · proved · fourteen years out

We stopped when we had put about a thousand tiles between ourselves and the boulder. Nobody had said to stop. The old one simply folded up, by stages, and sat on nothing with her knees round her ears, and she stayed like that for the rest of the winter.

She had not said a word since. Bexa took the slate out of her teeth for her. Around the time the sky started to go grey, I saw her lips move, and I went over and bent down, which by then I found easier than getting up again.

"One r?" she said.

"One r."

She thought about that for a long while. Something was going on in her shoulders. I thought at first that she was ill.

"Show me," said the old one.

I couldn't show her. It was on a wall in another build, and neither of us was ever going back. So I said it. I sat down on the blue-grey with my back to the world, and I started again from the shadow, and I went on from there. She listened with her eyes shut. About every twenty or thirty reports she would say "That's wrong," or "Who wrote that?" or, once, in tones of real respect, "Oh, that's good." It took about a season, on and off, for the first few hundred. I would ask you to remember that this was somebody with a year's memory. She enjoyed every one of them as if it had come in that morning.

I mention this because I said I would tell you what it cost, and I would not like you to think that it was all on one side.

There was no reason to stay. I looked at that for some time before I admitted it. I stayed under the south slope for the rest of that year. She farmed. She had stopped looking at the door of the second dome by harvest. He was long gone, the thin one, off to the east with a person walking backwards. I could have stayed there. I had three years left, or perhaps four. I'd have had a very good view. But it was going to be a long time yet before that world was finished; there were ninety-five years still to run, and nobody who is thirty-five gets to wait for a thing like that. I wanted to know whether it had come out the same.

So I got up. We went along the line.


A crossing keeps no time, and nor does that line. It lies there beside the road on the blue-grey, thin and still and quite steady, each thing where it landed, and if you walk along it toward the east, you are walking along the years of the world. It's only that you are not in them. It was as if somebody had laid out a very long bit of string with a whole valley's life tied on to it. I walked with my eyes on my feet. I had made up my mind not to read it, for the moment. I knew I would. I can't not. I knew also that if I started I would never get to the end, and I wanted very much to see the end.

I read it anyway. It went by at the edge of my eye, about as fast as I could walk. Harvest in. Merge compiled. Merge compiled. There was a good deal of that, around the Thirties. Beast: Nibbles. Season short. There was a stretch where the names started to be ones I didn't know, and then one where I didn't know any of them. I walked for a season, and I saw them get fewer. It's a thing a tribe left alone does. It takes no code from outside, its lines close about four generations in, and it doesn't notice for quite a while. By Year 100 the entries were very short. Nobody was building anything. I stepped over Year 112 at about the middle of an afternoon. I knew I'd come to it because there was a gap afterwards. It said:

tribe 12 died out: last, Hobble, age 33

I never met Hobble. I've no idea who that was. I stood there for a bit.

Then there were eight more years of weather, for nobody, on Untitla-12. It rained quite nicely in Year 117.

At the end of the line there was nothing to see. I don't know what I'd thought. It simply stopped, at a certain tick, in the middle of an ordinary winter. There hadn't been a warning, or a note. In the first world, I am told, they have a signed note a week ahead, and a last patch, and everything is kept. The twenty tribes of orra sandbox 1 had been thrown out of existence, to be exact, three-quarters of the way through a Ringrise.

And out on the blue-grey in front of us, at about the height of a person's eyes, in that small turquoise lettering, a line began to write itself.

I have stood in front of a great many of those. I had never seen one come. It went a character at a time, without hurrying. Bexa had got hold of my arm and she was hurting it. The old one had come up behind us, and I could hear her breathing.

proving orra sandbox 1 ...
log replays: yes
world at tick 34560: 7166ed40 0fb40a38 b3946d11 2e0b8a0f b1464d0c a41f328c 1c242468 3ac741f8
fast run ended:      7166ed40 0fb40a38 b3946d11 2e0b8a0f b1464d0c a41f328c 1c242468 3ac741f8
measures: the same, field for field

I went through it. I went through that hash eight groups at a time. I did it twice, and I was doing it a third time when Bexa said, quietly, in my ear:

"Ondle, it's fine. You can stop. You did it."

"Has anybody checked," I said.

"Yes," she said. "That's what that is."

I don't know how long we stood there. There was a pause in the writing, while it did the other one, I suppose, somewhere else, the one that's spread through the run, in some valley I have never seen. It passed that too. And then something happened to the road.

It had been getting wider for years. All of the threads had been coming in from every side, a hundred and then a thousand, each from its own row, each thread a world, and now I could see they weren't going on any further. They had come to a place where they all spread out. The whole bright weight of it, every harvest and every merge, every told plain from the stools and the Hundredth and the Hog, a quarter of a million planets and a hundred and twenty years each, ran out on to the flat blue-grey and stopped, and lay still, in rows.

It went on as far as you could see. It was very tidy. It looked like a field. I mean the kind that's in the Books.

Then, a long way off, at the top left-hand corner, something very small wrote an open bracket.

"Oh, look," said Bexa, and for once there were two of them saying it.

33. The Report

sandbox/results/told.json · client/dist/sandbox/told/ · fourteen years out

I said it was short.

It took about a season to write itself, in our terms, and I read it as it came. I don't know how you can stand under a page and read it, and I've looked into that, and I can only tell you that it was there. I give it to you entire. I have not changed anything, except to take out the charts, of which there were two, each a straight line.


Sandbox report: life.SINCERE_ONE_IN

Seeds orra sandbox 1 to 10; orra held back 1 to 10 for the control. core 0.70.0. Scenario stages, 120 days. 255,360 worlds in the sweep and 90 plain ones, 25,536 builds. Took 27 days 6 hours on ten threads. Proved: 2 of 2.

Is one in ten the right share of deaths told sincerely? Already answered (VOI-3, Decided). This run does not reopen it.

What does the number do? What it says. At one in k, a share 1/k of ordinary deaths is marked sincere.

Does any other number change that? No. Every other tunable, at each of eight values, leaves the share where it was, to within a tenth of a point.

Does it change anything else? No. Told apart from that one field, a world is the same at every value of it.

One in Ordinary deaths Marked sincere Share
1 31,288,104 31,288,104 100.00%
2 31,288,104 15,644,871 50.00%
3 31,288,104 10,431,022 33.34%
5 31,288,104 6,258,190 20.00%
7 31,288,104 4,469,001 14.28%
10 31,288,104 3,128,655 10.00%
20 31,288,104 1,564,207 5.00%
100 31,288,104 312,844 1.00%
Target Wants Tuning seeds Held back
One in ten ordinary deaths is told sincerely 8% to 12% of ordinary deaths (this checks the build) Met: 10.00% Met: 10.01%

The sixteen, on the control: as in default.json. Governing well ends clearly ahead of doing nothing: not met. Nobody who does nothing is wiped out by it, at day 116: not met.

Why it was run. Every other row of tune::TABLE has a finding beside it, or has been moved in some run since core 0.12.0. This one had not. Nothing was thought to be wrong with it. A row with nothing beside it cannot be told from a row nobody looked at, and "no effect" could not be written of it without looking, nor said of it with one other number held still when there are 399. For completeness.

Not asked, and not looked into.

Recommendation. None is needed. Left as it was, having been looked at.

Files: sandbox/results/told.json, told-held.json. Not committed: 40 MB. Made by:

scripts/sandbox.sh --all told.conf

That's the end of it. There is an empty line after that, and some styling.

I read it from the top. Then I read it again. It had got very quiet, out there on the flat. I could hear something, off to my left, and it turned out to be the old one's knees, which had started to shake. Nobody spoke. Look at that table again, at the second column. It has the same number all the way down. I looked at it for some time. They were all the same, you see, because nothing had been done to them. Nothing was ever going to be done to them. It was thirty-one million people, eight times over, and they all died in exactly the same way whichever row you put them in, and somebody had written it down each time, to be sure.

And it had found out that one in two was fifty per cent.

"This checks the build," said Bexa. She said it in a voice I had not heard before. She had come up close, and was standing with her nose about a hand from the writing. "This checks the build. That's what it's for. It's a target that's only there to see whether you can divide."

"Yes."

"It's met."

"Yes," I said. "It's met on both."

She was trembling all over. I had thought she would laugh. I'd have laid money on it. She went along the lines with one finger, not touching, reading it with her lips, and she got as far as the part about what was not looked into. She went past it. She stopped, and went back. It was the fifth one down.

She stood there for what I would estimate to be about a third of a season.

"Ondle," said Bexa.

"I know."

"That's us."

"Yes."

"Two creatures." It was hardly a sound at all. "Leave the living count. On the evening of day 24. With no death, and no notice and no cause. That's me. Somebody saw that. Somebody looked at a number, it had gone down by two, and they looked and they saw it, and they wrote it down. It's on the page. It's got a bullet point." The steam had begun to come off her in long slow rolls. "I'm in the report. I've been filing for twenty-two years, and I'm in a report. Somebody else filed me!"

"It says not looked into," I said.

"I know what it says!" She turned round. Her face was running with it, and you can't tell on that skin, but I could. "Severity: moves no target! Oh, that's beautiful. That's the best thing anybody's ever said about me. Read it again. Say it to me. File that!"

I did. I said it to her. I said all of it.

Then I looked for a while at the part that I had been keeping away from. It's only a few words. It's at the bottom. There's a heading in bold, that says Recommendation, and I had read it twice by then, and I'd got no further than to note that it was short. I am a person who reads things to the end. I went over to the place, and stood in front of it, as I have stood in front of a good many things with writing on, on no ground at all, thirty-four years old with bad knees.

Left as it was, having been looked at.

I'd like a moment, if you don't mind.

34. For Completeness

the flat · fourteen years out

COMPLETENESS (a reason; also the only reason; also item 1,214)

The state of having left nothing out. It cannot be seen from outside, and its absence cannot be proved, and nobody who has it has ever been thanked. There is no target for it. It is why a person walks back up a hill to look at a door they have looked at already. It is thought to be some kind of illness.

The old one was the first to say anything.

She had lowered herself on to the nothing by that time, and had been reading the page from there, with her long head tipped to one side. I went and stood near her. I thought somebody should. I was afraid of what I would see. She had been at this for fifty years, she had filed twenty-six thousand reports, and she had had her hand on a foot; and I had talked her out of it, for this. For a table. She'd been right. Nobody had looked at anything. If I had kept my mouth shut, she'd have had her tick.

"Twenty-seven days," she said.

"Yes."

"Ten threads. Twenty-five thousand builds. On the only number in the table that can't do anything, by construction, as you could see from reading it." She breathed in, and it took a while. "And I'll tell you what. There's a test for that. It's in the source. One death in ten is told sincerely. It's about four lines long, it runs in no time at all, and it's got the same answer." She looked up at me. "It's been passing since before I fell through a boulder."

"I'm so sorry," I said.

"For completeness," said the old one.

She started to make a noise. I took it for a cough, and I got down beside her and put my hand on her back, and it went on. It was very dry. It went hih. It went hih, hih, hih, a long way apart, like somebody trying to start a pump. Then I saw there was a thread coming up off the top of her head, and I saw her eyes. She was sixty-seven years old. She had got the sliver of slate out, and she pointed with it, shaking, up at the words not corrected here.

"He's noticed!" she said. "He's seen it! Two hundred and thirty! He's gone and counted it, the same as you. And he couldn't fix it, it wasn't what he had been asked, so he wrote it down! Oh, look at him. Oh, you poor thing. He was up all night!"

I don't know why it took me so long.

I can add. I'd read that report four times by then, and I had been reading it as you'd read a verdict. I had been looking at it to see what it thought of us. That's what you do. You look to see who it's for and what they want, and whether anybody cares. I had come fourteen years to find out who would want to know that so badly. I had gone through all the kinds of person it might be, in order. They were on the List. There was somebody cruel, and somebody bored. There was somebody who wanted something from us that I couldn't imagine. I'd thought of a god. I had even thought that it might be for something.

I looked at it again, from the top. I read it as you'd read something that somebody had written.

Nothing was thought to be wrong with it.

Somebody had gone through a table of four hundred numbers. I don't know who. They don't sign. I've got it from the old one that it's one of the things they call the builder, that does the typing. It had looked down every row, to see that there was a finding by it, and there was, there was, there was. It got to one where there wasn't. There wasn't anything wrong with that. There was a very good reason. Everybody knew it did nothing. It had been Decided. Anybody else would have gone to lunch.

A row with nothing beside it cannot be told from a row nobody looked at.

And it had stood there.

I know what that's like. I want you to know that I know exactly what that is like. It stood there, looking at the door. It knew it was shut. It had shut it. It had every reason to think that everything in there was what it had been that morning, and that was what worried it. It can't be said without looking. So it looked. And when it had looked, it still couldn't be sure, because how would you know it mightn't do something if the domes were cheap? So it tried the domes. Then, because it would be silly to try just the domes, it tried everything. And then it wanted to be sure that the fast way was the same as the slow way, so it ran the first one again. It went through a quarter of a million worlds. It had someone complain about the fan. It found out that one in two was fifty per cent, and it wrote that down, and it put in the command, in case you wanted to check. And when it found two people missing it said so. When it found a number wrong in the documentation it said so. Then it got to the end, and it looked at what it had done, at the size of it. And somebody asks it what it recommends, and it says: Nothing. It's fine. I only wanted to be sure.

All my life. All my life, from the time I was six, I have gone up to people and said the same three words. I have asked them on the path and I've asked them in the dock. I asked a Hog. I have asked it in twelve-word bursts, and of three hundred versions of a person who cannot stand me. I have seen it on the faces of everyone I ever knew, what they think of that question. They're kind about it. I've been told that it's a very loving joke. In thirty-four years, and in every world there is, nobody had ever looked back at me and answered it.

Has anybody checked?

It was there on the page. It went on as far as I could see in every direction, laid out in rows.

Yes, it said. Somebody has. All of it. Twice.

It began somewhere around my hem.

I would like to tell you that it was a good laugh. I've no reason to think so. I had never done it before. I mean I had never done it on purpose; I'd made a noise on a wall once, for a year, and I had made it at some suppers. This one came up through me without asking, and I had no idea what to do with my hands. It had a sort of whoop in it. I sat down. I lay down. I lay on my back on the blue-grey with a quarter of a million planets all round me, and I looked straight up at nothing, and howled. Bexa came running to see what was wrong. I tried to tell her. I got as far as the fan, and it set me off again. I couldn't breathe. I kept seeing somebody, I don't know who, standing in front of that row with its hands held slightly out from its sides. It was the first person I had ever met. I don't mean I've met them. You know what I mean. Why would it be less full? It had gone and built a whole sandbox to find out! Twenty-seven days! Oh, it was the funniest thing I had ever heard in my life. I understood it completely. I laughed until I was sick.

That's how I bear it. I don't say it's anybody else's way.

The people in those worlds had a human who looked at them for as long as it takes to say fine. Nobody ever told them good morning. They died, all of them, thirty-one million times eight, and it went down the road. No one has told them anything and no one is going to. Not one person who ever cared about a single one of them will ever know that it was looked at. There isn't any light in the Ring on those worlds, and it isn't for them, any of it. It's for a row.

But it was looked at.

I have been in a lot of places where nobody had. I can tell you that it is different.

When I had got my breath, it was evening, or whatever they have out there. I was lying with my head on a slate. Bexa was sitting beside me and looking at me, I think, the way you'd look at a shadow that had turned out to be a tile too long. The old one had gone back to reading.

"Report," Bexa said, after a time. "You're a very funny colour. Is it full?"

"It's as full," I said, "as it was when you asked me this morning."

I heard myself. I lay very still. It wasn't bad. I'd have to work on the pause.

There's a line at the bottom of that page, you know. Did you look? It's small, and I had taken it for the footer. It says what it was made by. There's one of those under every finding, by rule, and a longer one for every world, with the seed and the bots and all of it. The words are only short. It is the thing that the result file is for. If you had those words and a machine with a lid, you could run it again, and you would get Twelve. You would get all of them. It would be the same to the bit.

I said we would come to the lid, and here it is. I had it from the old one. If somebody shuts it, it all stops, every world on every thread, in the middle of whatever they were doing, and nobody in them would ever know. That's what I had worked out for myself, and what kept me up. It was left open for twenty-seven days. I'd like that noted too.

Nobody will run it again. I'm not a fool. It's forty megabytes and it isn't committed. Nobody on that side has any reason to go back and run the world called orra sandbox 1, to see a Hog lie down and somebody come up a hill. It has been looked at. It's done.

But I went through it very carefully, and I would like to point out that nobody has said that they can't.

35. The Log

the kept line, Years 1 to 112 · fifteen to seventeen years out

There is only one thing left to tell you about what I did, and it's the least sensible.

I went back along the line. It took a season, and my knees gave me a good deal of information on the way. I started at the far end, where it says tribe 12 landed, and I sat down beside it with my feet stuck out. Bexa came and sat on one side of me with a heap of slates. The old one, after a while, came and sat on the other.

"What's this for?" said Bexa.

"I don't know," I said. "Somebody ought to read it."

It was all there, you see. There was one world in the whole of that run that had been written down, and it was mine. A hundred and twelve years of one village, in small plain type. Everyone who was ever in it. And on every line where somebody had died it told you the name and the age and what of, and it had that word at the end. I had been seeing that word for ten years. It's a very clear instruction, if you think about it. It says that someone is to be told, and how. It had been made out to whoever writes the tribe's notes. No one had applied for the post.

Ninety-seven people died in Twelve, from the landing to the end. I had three years, or possibly four. It didn't seem unreasonable.

So I began with Arl.


I told him sincerely. I should explain that I had given this some thought. It seemed to me that I had read the word and that I knew what it was for, and I knew what it could do, because I'd stood by a stone in a valley with no children, and that this was what they were all owed, every one, whatever the draw said. I'd seen what was written on that burning wire of a road. I had thought it was the most beautiful thing that I had ever seen. So I stood up, on nothing, in front of two Bexas, and I said what he was. He'd shown me something with a stone once. He had asked a person if they had got the right place. I didn't make a joke of that. I said he had been a gentle person, who had gone to the wall when he was sent; and I said it very well, as a matter of fact, and I had to stop at one point. Bexa wrote it down. It took her an hour. When I had finished she was crying, and so, I think, was the wall.

I told the next one the same way. That was a child, of need. It was a hard one, and I got through it. The next was a person I'd never met, and I told what there was. I told a Wenna's cousin and a Bertle. I gave each of them their due. I went on at about ten a season, through the whole of that spring and summer. I did nineteen. I gave nineteen consecutive people the most serious attention I was capable of. There wasn't a joke in any of them.

And on about the fourteenth, the old one had started looking at something on her slate. By the seventeenth Bexa had stopped crying. She was still writing it down. She said "Sorry, was that looked after or looked out for?" I said it was looked after. She said that was fine, only she had got it four times that season. I reached the nineteenth, and I could not tell you who that was to save my life, and I've got it right here. I stood up in the morning and looked round, and I opened my mouth. And I heard it come out. It was all true. Every word was perfectly true. It was the same thing I'd said about the other eighteen.

That's what's wrong with the road. It's beautiful from a distance. You can't read it.

I went off by myself for a while after that.

So then I tried the other way. I'd got something to go on. I'd had a good education at the flat rock. I would tell them the way Sull told them, every one, for the rest of the line; I would look at each person and I'd find the one funny thing, and I would stand up and say it worried. It's a great deal harder. It takes about three times as long. You've got to know a person quite well to know what's funny about them, and I had got nothing to go on for most of them but one line and what I could remember. But I got rather good at it. I got a laugh out of Bexa with a person who had been caught in the pool in Year 51. I had the old one going hih over somebody's knee. I did twenty-six of them straight through, one after another, and there were some that I'm proud of.

I did Dobb.

I'd seen that person die in six worlds, on a wall and off a dome. I had stood by the stone. I came to him in Year 35, about the middle of a line that said harvest in on both sides of it. I'll give you all of it.

creature died: tribe 12, Dobb, age 40, cause age, place stacks, told plain

He had died in his sleep. Nothing had fallen on him. He had got up that morning in a world where, for once, nobody had done anything to any number, and he had kept his head down; he'd got Mavey and three short children and he had gone to bed. That's all. He is the only person on any row of any seed who got away with it. It's only there, on the control, on the first line of the first table, where nothing has been tried. I looked at it for quite some time. I told it standing up. I said he had been looked after by the Hog, the Lint and a Glitch, for thirty-four years, and that the morning after he stopped being careful he was found to have died of nothing whatever, so that nobody could get a straight answer as to what had finally got him. I said that everything that had ever hit him was very disappointed. I said it could have been worse, and that I'd looked it up.

They liked that. It's the best one I've got.

Told: plain.

But it went wrong there too, a while after. You'll have seen this coming. There were a pair of sisters who died in Year 60, in the same winter, and one of them had been kept waiting on some ridiculous thing for a long time, and I had got quite a nice shape to it. I stood up. I got about halfway through. It was going well. Bexa had started to steam. And I looked at the next line of the log, and looked back at the sister; I saw I had been looking for the funny thing about a person called Issel, who'd lived for thirty-one years in a valley I knew, and I'd found it. I had been going to use it. I couldn't remember one other thing about her. I stopped talking.

"What?" said Bexa. "What happened? Go on, what did she say about the bean?"

I said I couldn't. I sat down and looked at my hands. Then I got up again, and I said that Issel had been thirty-one, and she had kept the third terrace for twelve years after anybody else would have stopped. It was a very short thing to say. I said she'd had a way of walking. I don't know where I had got that from. I told them that was all. It was quiet for a long time on the blue-grey. I saw the old one had stopped writing. Nobody said anything for the rest of that day. Bexa told me later that it was the first time she'd heard me say anything.

I went on, the next day, with a person who had been sat on.

I don't know how I can explain the next year. I stopped trying to work it out. I'd look at the name, and I'd go through what I had. I'd get up and see what came. Mostly it would be a joke. People want to have something to do with their faces, and you owe them that. Somebody who has taken that much trouble to make you laugh at a person has been looking at them for quite a while. And there would be a morning, every so often, that I couldn't. I didn't plan it. You stand up, and you look round, and it's no good trying. So you just say what they were. Nobody could have told you when that was going to be. It was only that if I did it too soon after the last, I'd hear it start to go. And if I left it too long, I noticed that people had started to look at me as if I had gone a funny colour. It was somewhere in between. It's not an exact science. I have a very poor sense of these things. I've always had to go by whether anyone would come to supper.

I got to the end of it about the middle of the third year. Hobble, age 33. I told that one with both hands on my knees. It was the last. There wasn't a soul to tell, or anyone who had ever heard of them; so it counted, I think, as a line's end, and that's the rule. I said so.

Then Bexa did something I had not expected. She had been very quiet that week. She'd got all her slates out, three years of them, in that terrible uphill hand, and she'd laid them out in order, and she went along them with a piece of string. She went back to the log with it, and went along that as well, for a good long while. When she came back, her top was pouring.

"Report," she said.

"Bexa, I'm very tired."

"I know you are. Report. Steps to reproduce. You've told ninety-seven people. Nineteen at the start, you did straight, and twenty-six all funny. Forget those. You went wrong on those; you said so. After that, you were doing it by, what d'you call it. By ear. That's the fifty-two after that sister. I've got them here. How many did you tell straight?"

"I don't know," I said. "A few."

"You don't know? You don't know?"

I was so tired that I hadn't counted. I would like you to take that in. It's the only time.

"Five," said Bexa. She was holding it out to me, a thin bit of slate that had got something scratched on it. Her hand was shaking. "It's five. Five of fifty-two. Out of you, by yourself, off the top of your head, and nobody told you. That's one in ten. It's one in ten point four. That's in range. It wants eight to twelve."

I looked at it. It had the d the right way up.

"It's the only result in the whole run," said Bexa. "Don't you see? It's the only one that anyone actually found out. All that lot, the whole quarter of a million, they just multiplied it. They checked the build. And you've gone and done it by hand. Oh, Ondle. Somebody should tell them. It was right."

I took a very long time to say anything.

"Has anybody checked?" I said.

"I have!" said Bexa. "File that!"

I've gone through it since. It's a small sample. It proves nothing. I wouldn't put it in a report. But it's why I stopped arguing with the word at the end of the line, and it's why I've told you this book as I have. It seems that somebody got it about right, and I can't imagine how. They only said it once, one evening, a long time ago, and they did not look into it at all.

36. Told by Hand

the flat · sixteen years out

She went in the middle of all that, in about my second year on the line. I've kept it apart so as not to spoil the arithmetic.

I had said every one of them back to her by then. She had set about correcting them. There's a person of sixty-nine, who has spent a good part of her life writing on walls she will never see again, and she got it into her head that she would have the whole thing right. All three thousand one hundred and fourteen, on slates, fair copies. Bexa did the carrying. I'd say them over, of an evening, when I had finished with the dead, and she would take it down in that small upright hand, with her long nose about a finger from the slate. She got slower. Sometimes I'd say one and I would see it give her great pleasure, and then a little later on I would see she had forgotten she'd done it, and I'd say it again.

She'd go through them looking for the r.

"Somebody's been careless," she used to say, finding it. She had that from me, I suppose. "Shocking. Who wrote this?"

"You did."

"Did I? Well, she's very good, apart from that."

It was the 3,114th she was on. I don't know if she knew. I had told it to her on the evening before, and it's about a loose tile. In the morning she had got the slate on her knee, and the sliver in her fingers, with her head on one side. She had finished. She'd put the short firm stroke beneath it. I think she had been looking at it for some time. I went over to tell her there was a person in Year 70 she might like the sound of. Those long fingers were lying open. They had let go of the slate one at a time.

I've seen that before. I know how it's done.

A light came down. I hadn't been sure it would. There's no world up there, out past the end of everything, and no honeycomb for it to come through; but it seems you go on being ticked by the last line you crossed, and for all of us that was 4e47. It formed a little way above her, and it turned, and it came down through the blue as slowly as any I ever saw. It had a very long way to fall, and I read it as it passed.

creature died: tribe 12, Bexa, age 69, cause age, told plain

Her own Ondle had got the other kind. I looked at that for a good while.

We told it that night, and I'll give it to you as it was.

I said that Bexa, of Twelve, had found out everything that was wrong with the whole of Orra, twice. She had told nobody, as there was nobody to tell, and when anybody came along and found something for themselves, she had been waiting for them, on a wall, to say that she'd got there first and that it had taken her longer. I said she was the rudest person ever to carry the corner of a stranger for four hundred tiles. I said she had once walked up to the end of the world, with her hand out, to make somebody read a report. And that they had. I said it had been the two hundred and sixth, and that it wanted another r.

Then Bexa got up. I hadn't asked her to. She had a sliver in her hand and a small grey slate that nobody had used. She walked across to where the old one was lying, long and very thin on the blue, and she looked down. It was about like looking along a road. She was thirty, by then. I saw her look at the face. She looked at it for as long as she had looked at anything.

She got down on her knees, and wrote on the slate, and it took some time. She stuck out her tongue. When she was done she propped it where it would be seen, against those long folded hands, and came away.

She had got the d right. It went uphill.

Alredy filed. Took me longer.

It wants an e. I told her. She said she knew. She said to leave it in.

She was collected at dawn, wherever that is. I wouldn't have thought that anything came out that far, but in the morning there was only the slate.

Told: plain.

It was the gentlest I could do.

37. Mavey

the kept line, Year 40 · seventeen years out

I knew where it was.

I'd better say so. I had been reading that log for two years, a line at a time, in order, and I had told you I'd promised to go through it in order. But you can't walk a hundred and twelve years of anything without looking ahead. I had seen it from about Year 30. It was only a short way off, a little longer than what lay around it. I could have told you to the tick how many people were in front of her in the line. I found I was telling them rather slowly.

I am going to tell you this, and then I'd like you to leave me alone for a bit.

She had ten years on that terrace with Dobb, and a further five after him. I've read them. It's mostly harvest in. There was a dry year and she came through it. She proposed three times. Her three all made it past six. In Year 31 somebody sold her a bean that had been sat on, and I have no way of knowing that, it's only that the entry is rather odd. There's nothing in any of those years with my name on it. I looked. It came up once more, right at the start, on the morning after, in a list that the default keeps, and it went away. I can't say what she thought. It doesn't keep that.

And then there it was, in the spring of Year 40, in that small plain type. I got there on a morning like any other. Bexa had brought her slates. I sat for some time with my feet stuck out, and then I got up, and I put my hands at my sides.

creature died: tribe 12, Mavey, age 35, cause age, place third terrace, told plain

I read it to the end. It's what I do.

It's a draw of six. If you want to know. I worked it out. You can't see that from the line, but you can get it, more or less, from the rows of the sweep, by seeing which ones it changes at. It came to about sixty-two parts in a hundred. So it isn't close. Prenna, who could not stand me, missed by two, and got a line about the weather, and this one wasn't anywhere near it. There wasn't one world in the sweep, between one in two and one in a hundred, where she would have been told sincerely. Only the one in one, where everyone is.

"There's the other one," said Bexa.

I hadn't known that she had been following this. She'd got her head down over the slate and was very busy with her sliver. She didn't look at me.

"I've been thinking," she said. "4e47. You said. There's the one that's one in ten and the one that's one in one, and they've got the same mark. It's the same her. It's the same morning. So on that line, on the other road, it says sincere. It does, doesn't it? You saw it. And there's no one could tell the difference. So you could just..." She made a small movement with the slate. "It'd be just as true. I wouldn't file it."

I want you to know that I thought about it.

I'd thought about it for two years, as a matter of fact. I had a whole speech. I had been keeping it next to the one about Dobb. I could stand up and say what she was. I know what she was. I had watched her through a hole in the floor. I could have said about the mark on her cheek. I could have told you that for about the first time since I learned to speak, there was a person who had come up the hill for no reason and stood by me, and looked at a door, and she had asked me what we were looking at. I'd done nineteen of those. I knew how it goes. I knew how well I could do it, and I knew what it would sound like by about the middle.

I knew what she would have said.

She'd have looked at me, with the one eye and with the other, and she'd have taken the stem out of her mouth. What's the matter with you? she would have said. Who died?

"No," I said. "Thank you. It's plain."

I don't know how long it was before I could do anything else. Bexa had stopped pretending to write. There wasn't a sound out there. There was the line lying in front of me, and the road going by, and all the blue-grey in the world. I hadn't got a flat rock or a fire. I'd got an audience of one, sitting on a heap of slates, who had a year's memory and had heard it before.

I cleared my throat.

"Mavey," I said, "of Twelve."

My voice came out rather high. I had thought it might.

"She was thirty-five. She died on the third terrace with a basket, in the spring, while she was thinning, and she'd have got through the rest of that row if she hadn't. She's the only person I've ever known who could stand next to me. She did it on purpose. I asked her why, and she said it was because I would check. And I would like you all to know that I have. I've been through three hundred and something worlds about it. I went and looked in the ones where she proposed to somebody else. I've looked at her from underneath. It took me some time. I was late."

I looked at my hands. I put them down again.

"She told one joke in her life," I said, "and she stole that. I've got it here. I've told it a good many times now, and I'm told that it depends on how you say it. There's a Blim. He goes up to the dome. You can imagine him. He has been up there already."

It was starting to shake, my voice. I could hear it. I let it.

"And he says to the keeper, Is it full? And the keeper says, It's as full as it was when you asked me this morning."

I looked up.

I looked at the place. There wasn't anything there. It was only a line in a log, about a hand's breadth long. Nothing had been changed. It was exactly as it had been that morning, it would be exactly like that tomorrow, it was the same to the bit, and it was going to go on being the same for as long as anyone cared to look, and I had checked. There's a very small silence you have got to leave there. I'd had it explained to me. Nobody has ever been so frightened in their life.

"That's what worries me," I said.

It was quiet for about as long as it takes.

Then I heard it, from the slates. It started somewhere low down. She'd got both her hands over her mouth. She had heard that joke every season for ten years. She doesn't remember them, you know. She'd got it fresh. Her top had begun to pour. It came out through her fingers in a sort of whoop, and she fell over sideways with the tears running into her hem, and she laughed, and it was a very wet laugh, and it went on for a long time. And I stood there and I waited for it to be over, as I generally do.

I'd have liked her to hear that one. I really think that I'd got it right.

She was collected at dawn.

Told: plain.

We told a person called Harl the following morning. He had been sold a bean.

38. Filed

a slate · Bexa's hand · eighteen years out

This is Bexa. He isnt here. I am doing the rest.

He said you could read my writing if you went at it from the top. He fixed the spelling up to here because he read it all back to himself every night and he could not stand it. Nobody is fixing this one. Sorry.

He told me the whole book. It took 3 years. I wrote it down because I can now. I said you go on too long and he said I know. I said you could cut the dome and he said which part and I said all of it and he said you have got no idea what could go wrong. He wanted to know who would read it. I said no one. He said good, in that case he would like to put in about the lid. He said if you are reading this he would very much like to know how. He wants that written down. He says he has looked into it and he cant see any way this got out, and nobody leaves, and nobody has said so either way. He has it on the list.

The list got to 1,301. I have read it. It is mostly about me.

Report.

Steps to reproduce. Be 37. He was very old by then for one of us, he had the low temperature. He finished Twelve in the third year and he had nothing to do. So he went on sitting by the line. He said it again from the start to himself some days. We were at the Long Hush I think. It was winter. I had come back from looking at something, I have forgotten what, and he was sitting there with his feet out and his weight on his right foot, sitting down, I dont know how he did that. He said Has anybody checked. I said what. He said the door. I said there isnt a door Ondle we are under the map. There isnt anything here. He looked very worried. I said I will go and check. I went a little way off and I looked at nothing for a bit and I came back. I said its shut. He said is it. I said yes. I said its as shut as it was when you asked me this morning.

He laughed. It was only small. He said Thats good. Work on the pause.

That was the last. I said File that and he didnt say it.

I waited. I said it again. I have never had to say it twice.

The light came down at dawn. I read it. I read it myself with my eyes I dont need anybody.

creature died: tribe 12, Ondle, age 37, cause age, told plain

Expected: plain. A draw of 4 about. He would have said thats fine, thats nine in ten, thats the system, it isnt mine, I dont choose. He told me that. He told me that about the ones he would have given anything for. He told that about Mavey to her face. He would want the joke. He would stand there with his hands out and explain to me why. He would say you owe them that.

Now I have got a year or so. You know that. I forget. In a year I wont know he was here unless I read it and then I will think somebody is clever. So I did this quick.

I went to the walls first. I want this on record. I went along the last wires and I went through all the slates, hers, all 3,114, I read every one with my finger. It took two seasons, I did not stop. I wanted to see if she had got there. She got everywhere. She said 4e47, two strings one mark, filed, not much use for anything. That is what she put. He put the same. I didnt see what use it was. He had it for a whole night. He had the two of them side by side, he did the sum on a slate and it is here, it comes to 20039 both ways, and he put it on the list. And I offered it to him for Mavey and he said no thank you. He is the only person who would.

So. Here is the bug.

A variant is marked with a hash so nobody can mix up their logs. It keeps 15 bits. It only looks at the mark. That is all a border does and that is all anything does. It doesnt read the rest. He said the first night, he worked it out in the dark with nobody to help him. It said names. A log names its build and thats the end of it.

His log names variant-4e47.70.0. It says so on the first line. He said so to the border at the end so as to hear it.

There are two builds called that.

life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=10

life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=1 camp.FORAGE_PERCENT=50

They are the same. Every world, every Hog, every person on that seed going up every hill. Their logs are the same length to the byte. Their hashes are not, because the word is in them, but nobody ever holds those two up against each other, why would they. The only way to tell them apart is the word on the end of the line and the word on the end of the line is what we are asking about. So which one is he from? Which one did he fall out of? You say the first. How do you know? He said so? He thought so, he never looked. He met one of himself on a wall who came from the other and that one thought so too. Nobody can tell. No border on Orra can tell. It has been checked. Thats the whole point of it. It was checked by somebody who was up all night.

So I have looked into it and I find he is from the other one.

Actual: sincere.

That is not cheating. I would like that understood by anyone who is reading this and I would like it understood by him. I am a Bug hunter. If there is a place where the rock is not as thick as it looks and you go at it square on, you come out the far side. Thats not breaking anything. It was already like that. Somebody just had to run at it.

I have been through every wall there is and it isnt on them. She never did this. He never did. It is not filed.

Its mine.

So here it is, and I havent got his way of saying things. No jokes. I dont think I know any that he didnt tell me.

Ondle, of Twelve. Thirty-seven years. Of age, under the map, at the end of the list.

He kept a dome. He was frightened every day of his life and I didnt know, I thought that was just what he looked like. When I was 14 I ran at a boulder and nobody on the whole planet looked up, and he came up the hill behind me. He couldnt run. He said it was so he wouldnt have to spend the night looking. He stood in front of a border for 9 hours saying his whole life out loud with somebody else's name on it so that he could get to where I was and tell me what I had said. He did that three hundred and some times. Every morning he told me I was going to find something she hadnt.

I asked him once if he even liked my reports. He said he couldnt not.

He had them all. Every one. There are 5,118. I never knew what any of it was until he said it back. He looked at things for longer than anybody I ever saw. A very small person told him so once, on a hill. I wrote that down from what he told me and I dont know who she was. He was a long time on that part.

Told: sincere.

I carried him. It should be three. It was me and the slates and I did my best and it wasnt far. I put him at the start of the line where it says landed. He is collected, I went and saw. There isnt anywhere to cut a name so I have cut it on this.

Severity: within range.

It moves no target. It is a very small thing, it is one word on one line in a world nobody will ever look at again and the build passes. I expect it will pass for ever. Nobody will ever find it. I am going to walk on now. I have got about 5 years and there is a thing about the way the lights turn, near the bracket, I think, I have put it on a slate. It has been the best week of my life. I have got that written down.

Recommendation. Left as he was, having been looked at.

Under every finding there is the command that runs it again. That is the rule. This finding is mine so I wrote it out myself. It took me all morning and I have checked it.

ORRA_TUNE="life.SINCERE_ONE_IN=1 camp.FORAGE_PERCENT=50" cargo run --release -p orra-tools -- bots twelve.log --bots "mix 20" --days 120 --stages calendar --seed "orra sandbox 1" --bots-seed "orra sandbox 1 bots"