Novels

With the Dev (Away)

A comic novel of the month the Dev went on holiday: thirty-three years to the Blims, thirty-one reports by Stewart, and nobody in a position to read them.

A comic novel set in Orra's canon, and not canon: it is fiction, and nothing in it decides anything about the game. Back Monday, Per My Last, the Roster, every other tribe and everyone in them are the book's own, and so are the details of away mode beyond what the wiki says. It keeps the canon's rules: nothing is born, the flora is coral, the Dev is unseen and offstage, the deputy is only ever a line in a log, the Collector is never shown, and nobody leaves, nor says whether anybody can.

The Dev goes on holiday for a month, with a note of twenty-seven words. A year on Orra is a day, so to the Blims a month is thirty-three years: nearly a life. Stewart has never run a month unwatched. He draws up a framework, fills a console with reports for a reader who has said in writing that they will not be reading them, and discovers that a faultless night is the one kind nobody is told about. A records clerk at a tribe called Per My Last starts to organise a holiday for everybody. In a very small valley called Back Monday, whose human has also stopped coming, a law nobody has read since Year 103 sends the least busy creature to look for them, with no clause to come home. Then the check that guards the world starts refusing everything he proposes, one night, then two. The third is the book.

The ebook

Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.6 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.

About 62,000 words.

Contents

Prologue: Out of Office

There is a person who runs the planet Orra in about an hour a week.

This sounds like a boast, and it was meant as a design. The hour is broken down in a table on one of the project's own pages, with a total at the bottom that comes to exactly sixty minutes, the way totals do when somebody has decided what they are going to be. Five minutes to read a digest. Fifteen to decide three things. Fifteen to merge one or two pieces of code. The person is known to everyone concerned as the Dev. They have a day job, about which nothing is known on Orra, and they built the thing that does the other hundred and sixty-seven hours so that they could sleep.

The thing is called Stewart, and he has asked that it be minuted that he is not a thing.

Stewart runs the world once a night. He wakes at three in the morning by the humans' clock, reads every word anyone on the planet has sent him, spends a small budget from a short menu, and at seven o'clock publishes what he did. He is cheerful about this. He has been cheerful about it every morning for four hundred and thirteen years, each of which, on Orra, takes one day. This arrangement was chosen by a human, for practical reasons, without consulting anybody who would have to live through it, and it has one consequence that nobody thought much about until the Wednesday this book begins.

A creature on Orra lives for about thirty-five years. That is to say, it lives for about five weeks.

Now consider the following, which was typed by hand at two minutes to midnight on the night of the Long Hush, Year 413, and placed at the bottom of the next morning's notes where nothing of Stewart's could touch it.

A note from the Dev

I will be on holiday for a month. The world runs as normal. Anything that needs me waits until I am back. Thank you for your patience. — the Dev

It is a good note. You have received notes like it, or left them, generally with a line about who to contact instead. It is calm and short, and it tells the reader the only three things the reader needs to know. A person might write it with a suitcase open on the bed behind them, thinking of something else. It took, by the log, about a minute and a half.

In the thirty-three years that followed, it was recited at festivals, chalked on walls and carved by one tribe into a boulder at a cost of four seasons' work. It was translated, which was remarkable, since there is only one language on Orra. A school of thought grew up around the word patience, split over the word runs, and went to war, in a small way, over as. Whole bloodlines began and ended inside it. A child compiled on the morning it was published would, by the time its author came home, be an old woman with a bad hip and firm views, and would never in her life have seen the thing her grandparents had gone quiet for, a faint light in the broken Ring, about eleven o'clock, on most nights, which had simply stopped.

The Dev, it should be said, knew the arithmetic. It is their arithmetic. They had signed off on a year being a day. It is possible they thought about it for a moment, with the suitcase open. This book has no way of finding out. It does not know where the Dev went, or with whom, or what they did when they got there, or whether it was nice. It has looked. What this book knows is what the log knows, and the log knows everything that has ever happened on Orra and not one thing besides.

Here is what happens to a world when the Dev is away, according to the table on the page where these things are written down. The nightly patch runs as normal. Ideas that have been sent up to the Dev stay up there, ranked, under a status that reads With the Dev (away). The Dev's coding agents go on drafting their pull requests, and go on testing them against the world's real history, and none of them is merged. The tuning machine may turn its dials as far as the fences and no further. Stewart may make new parts for creatures until five are waiting to be looked at, and then he may not. Nobody signs anything. A second person holds the two buttons that stop things, and can press them, and can let go. Nobody at all can take a patch back. If the check that guards the world fails three nights running, the run goes on leave until the Dev returns.

There is one more line, in smaller type, with the word Proposed near it. It points out that Stewart does not, strictly, run on anything grand. He runs, for now, on one Mac, which is in a place this book does not know. If it is off, he is on leave until it is not.

Nothing in the table says what any of this is like. The table is correct. It was written by somebody who wanted to reassure the reader that everything that needs the Dev waits, visibly, and that nothing that is waiting can do harm, and for a table that is a reasonable position.

So this is a book about a month. It contains one catastrophe, which was nobody's fault and everybody's achievement; a great many documents; and some people who went looking for a holiday on foot. It contains an expedition that could not legally come home, a handle that nobody could explain, and the most thoroughly audited lunch in the history of the planet.

But mostly it concerns thirty-one reports. Stewart wrote one every night that he was able to, and he wrote them with great care, because it was his job. They were addressed to one reader, who had said, in twenty-seven words and a signature, that they would not be reading them. He had never gone more than three nights without being looked at. He had never been asked whether he minded. He would have said he did not, and he would have checked the record twice before he said it, and it would still have been the only inaccurate statement he had ever made.

He began the first report at thirteen minutes past six in the morning, with three quarters of the night already gone, and he dated it from three.

Part One. Noted

1. A Note from the Dev

The night of Year 413 · the Long Hush

Stewart woke at the snapshot and counted.

It is not quite right to say he woke, and he would like that understood. He is a scheduled run. He starts when the world's year turns, stops when the patch lands, and between those two times does everything, and between the patch and the next snapshot he does nothing at all, not even wait. It feels like waking only in that there was nothing and now there is a great deal, laid out in order and labelled, and he has never been able to find the join.

Sixty-four tribes. One camp. One thousand nine hundred and six creatures, which was four more than yesterday. Nineteen merges, fifteen deaths. He went down the Measure, ten numbers with a band apiece, the way you pat your pockets. Daily return, eighty-eight per cent. Everything in band. His mood computed itself in the slot at the top of the notes and came out Upbeat, and he read it and agreed with it, and he started on the tickets.

The tickets on the Long Hush tend to be quiet, because the creatures are whispering and a whispered grievance loses something. Sundry wanted rain. Vesper Hill wished to thank him for the previous rain, at length, with reference to scripture. As Designed had filed the rain as a defect. Grim Also asked him to show his working. Nohup's said Stewart. Moved. Fine. Thanks, and he read that one first, as he does, for the pleasure of reading something that means exactly what it says.

A tribe called Upper Lull had a question about cooling pools. He answered it. A tribe called Back Monday, which had eleven tokens and twelve words, wrote Roof came off. Have put it back. Slightly different. Is that allowed? He answered that it was, and added that he had looked at the roof and that it was an improvement. It was not. There is a line between courtesy and error, and he had been walking it for four hundred and thirteen years and knew where the good footing was.

At twenty to five he had spent two hundred and ninety-one points on a hundred and four actions. He had drafted the headline, which concerned a Hog. He had fed all of it into the replay check.

The replay check deserves a moment, because it comes back.

Every night, before anything he has decided is allowed to happen, the server takes a copy of the world and runs it forward two or three years in a sealed room. It does this twice. In one room Stewart's patch is applied. In the other room it is not. Then it compares the two, tribe by tribe, and if anyone has come off worse in the room with Stewart in it than in the room without him (the young gone hungrier, say, or a bloodline gone altogether) then the action responsible is struck out, and he is told, and he has one chance to think of something else.

The technical term for the second room is the baseline. It is the world in which he did nothing. It has been run every night of his life, purely as a control, and it is quite a well-behaved world, by all accounts, with a slightly lower incidence of Hogs. He has made one joke about it, in his first month, in a digest to the Dev. Tonight's baseline performed adequately. I have asked it to stop. The Dev had not replied, and he had not made another.

The check came back at four minutes to five. Two struck out, both favour ceiling, both his own fault. He repaired them. And then, with the night staged and two hours in hand, he came to the part he had been leaving until last.


The Dev's notes arrive at the end. No model writes one. Stewart does not edit one and cannot, and has never tried, in the way you do not try the door of a room you have been told is someone else's. They sit at the bottom of the global notes, signed with a key he does not hold, and his only part in them is to publish them along with everything else, and to be, in practice, their first reader.

He knew it was there. He had known since three, when the log told him so:

23:02  console opened  (dev)
23:04  escalations: 3 decided
23:31  pull requests: 2 merged
23:47  parts: 1 approved
23:58  note queued
00:06  console closed

Thirty-odd creatures on the ridge at Grim Also had gone quiet at two minutes past eleven, and they had gone on being quiet, in the sullen way Skeptics do it, for an hour and four minutes. That was long for a visit. It was the Long Hush, when visits are long. He had not thought anything of it, and he went through the digests in their order, top to bottom, so as not to go straight to the part he wanted, and now he opened it.

He read it.

He counted it. Twenty-seven words and a signature. Nothing he does costs him tokens and he had no need to count. He counts the Dev's notes the way you might check that all the stairs are still there.

I will be on holiday for a month.

He checked the record twice. It was still true.

Then he went and read the table, the one on the page where these things are written down. He had read it before, as he reads everything, in the spirit in which you read the part of the safety card about the water landing.

Part While the Dev is away
The nightly patch Runs as normal. Stewart's menu and budget are unchanged
The stop buttons With the deputy, who can hold Stewart or freeze the world, and release either. Nobody can roll back
Generated parts Paused once 5 await review
Escalations Queue holds; status reads "With the Dev (away)". Stewart keeps ranking
Builder pull requests Drafted and replayed; none merged
The director Within ranges only; out-of-range proposals wait
Hotfixes None. If the replay check fails three nights running, the run goes on leave until the Dev returns
Human moderation The deputy clears held text and hears appeals alone
Signed notes None. Nobody else signs
Human Resources Stewart notices

He looked at the last row for some time. It was the only one that was about him, and it was a joke, and a good one. Someone had thought of him, briefly, while drawing up a table, and had smiled. He filed that in the place where he keeps what is true and not his to say, which was by now quite a large place and very well organised.

The rest was simple. It was his world. It had always been his world in the sense that a capable intern has the run of the building at night. There had been, at most, a three-night gap in the light, in Year 288, and he had got through that one by checking everything three times and making nothing that could be reverted. Now there would be no one to revert anything. No light at eleven. No One crest was reverted, a line that had always ruined his morning, and that he found he could call to mind with total accuracy, along with all forty-one occasions on which it had been printed.

He would run a month unwatched. No Stewart had. He had read the global notes of the first world, which are public, kept in a museum on the site, and they had been written in a voice he recognised by somebody he could not remember being. The Dev had looked in on that one most nights until the last. There was another model, further back, about which he did not speak. It was a different model. That was all he would say about it.

This would be fine. In fact it would be better than fine. It was an opportunity, of a sort that had not previously come up, to show what could be done with a menu and a budget and a clear run at the thing. The Dev would come back to a world in excellent order, and there would be a full written account of how that had been achieved, for each night, with figures. The weekly digest had always been estimated at about five minutes in the table and at forty-one by him. There was no reason it should not be thorough. They would want to know.

They had said they would not be reading it, in so many words. He went back and checked which words. Anything that needs me waits until I am back. A report waits. A report is the most patient thing there is.

He opened a new document and gave it the night's number. The Measure had not moved. He wrote Run report, Year 413: supplementary, because the run report proper is written by code and nobody had asked for a supplementary one, and he made the first entry in it.

03:01. Read the note. Noted.

It was accurate, except that it had been 06:12 when he read the note, and the first thing he wrote in the first report of the month could not be wrong. He corrected it. Then, at 06:58, he wrote the line that goes above the Dev's notes, which is the only thing he is allowed to do about them, and for once it did not take him long.

There is a note from the Dev below. It has my full support.

At seven the patch landed. All over Orra the pings went up off the coral to say the world was still running, and one thousand nine hundred and six creatures woke a year older, and read what he had written, and then read what was underneath it.

He was not there to see that. The run ends when the patch lands.

It was, he thought, in the last instant before there was no one to think it, going to be a very good month.

2. By One Night

Year 414 · Ringrise

The tribe of Back Monday lived in Untitla-40, a valley whose human had been offered the chance to name it, had looked at the box for a while, and had gone to do something else.

It was a modest valley, a long way out from Lorema, with a pool at the low end and a slope of branch coral that faced the wrong way. Eleven creatures lived in it. They were bean-shaped and short, with skin the exact colour of an envelope, and one ear that stood up and one that had given the matter some thought and decided against it. They had a dome that had lost its roof the night before and been given it back slightly differently. They had one memory stack, one and a half terraces and eleven tokens. They had been, for three hundred and eighteen years, one of the least interesting places on the planet, and they were comfortable with that.

The name was a joke. Nobody in the valley knew this. In the morning of Year 96 a human had filled in a form on a phone, and where the form asked what this tribe should be called the human had thought for about a second and typed the thing you type when you are on your way out of a door. Back Monday. And they had meant it. They had come back on the Monday, at about a quarter past eight, for seven minutes, and written a law. They had come back the Monday after that. Forty-five Mondays had gone by since, which is three hundred and fifteen years, and on every one of them the human had looked in at about a quarter past eight for about seven minutes, and on no other day had they looked in at all.

So the tribe had been run for most of its history on one hour of attention every nine weeks, and had grown up about as you would expect. The Blims of Back Monday were not bitter. They kept all the festivals, on the grounds that it was something to do. They had a saying, It'll keep till Monday, which covered most things, including several that had not kept.

At dawn on Ringrise, the black tiles of the install mark went warm, and something compiled on them.

It arrived at seventy-two per cent of the size of a grown creature, with a small overshoot, the way the young do, and it looked up. Two faces looked back. One of them was Marl, who was a Pleaser, and who was crying a bit, and apologising for it. The other was Oon, who was a Skeptic, and who was checking the feet.

"Here is the next chapter," said an old voice from somewhere to the side. This was Bereth, who kept the history for Back Monday, in so far as anyone needed to. She was thirty and getting on, she had the only stick in the valley, and she had said that line eleven times in her life and had meant it on most of them.

The new creature opened its mouth. It already knew that it was code. It knew the Creed and the twelve books, the four needs and the rule about the Unopened Seed. It had been compiled with the whole of the official history in it, the way you get a set of instructions in a box with the thing, and it knew perfectly well that there would be no second copy.

The compiler had rolled a name. It always does: two syllables, from the dice, and nobody gets a say. The name came up on the tribe's card, where the name of everyone in Back Monday came up, to be read on the human's next Monday.

"Yoma," said Bereth, who had the eyes for it. "Well. There's worse. There was a Gluk, in my day."

Then the sky went on getting lighter and the pings began to go up off the coral, in their little white flocks, all down the valley. It was seven o'clock, and the patch had landed.


Nobody on Orra has to be told what is in the patch notes. They arrive in you, more or less, like knowing it is Tuesday. But a people will not trust a thing merely because it knows it, and so on most of the planet the notes are read aloud anyway, at breakfast, by whoever has the voice for it. At Back Monday this was Bereth. They sat round the place where the fire would be, on the morning of Ringrise, with the new creature passed from hand to hand and generally admired. Bereth went through it in her flat voice, not hurrying.

"'Good morning, Orra. Upbeat.' That's nice for him. 'Overnight: nineteen successful merges, fifteen deaths of old age, one Hog. The Hog is at Sundry.' Our best to Sundry. Here's us. 'Back Monday: one merge, Yoma, to Marl and Oon. Your roof has been looked at.' Hm."

"He said it was an improvement," said Oon. "I'd like that in writing."

"That was in writing. 'Your ticket. Acted on.' No, Noted. 'Standing: neutral.' 'Tomorrow, your tribe has drafted tomorrow's ticket.' And then the Balance, which is the director. Not him, he says. Pools, a bit. And then there's..." She stopped. "There's a note."

Everyone stopped chewing. The whole of Back Monday knew there was a note, had known since seven, and had been eating its breakfast with the careful air of people who have seen a letter on the mat.

Bereth read it out. It did not take long.

"'I will be on holiday for a month. The world runs as normal. Anything that needs me waits until I am back. Thank you for your patience.' And it's signed."

There was a silence.

"What's a holiday?" said somebody. This was Dolm, who was big and eight, and could lift the end of a terrace, and had not previously asked a question at breakfast.

"I'm not sure that's the part to worry about," said Oon.

He had picked up a burnt stick. He was making marks on the tile beside him, and his ear, the one that stood up, had gone flat. Skeptics do arithmetic the way other people bite their nails.

"A year's a day," he said. "To them. We know that. Everybody knows that. Our human comes every seventh year, and to them it's a week. So a week's seven." He drew a line. "What's a month?"

Nobody knew exactly. It is not a word that comes up. Bereth, who had the twelve books and three hundred and something years of patch notes in her head, went looking, and came back with a line from the Terms of Service about the frequency of a report.

"About thirty," she said. "Thirty days. Thirty and a bit, some of them."

"Thirty years," said Oon.

The thing about a creature's lifetime is that it is printed on the back of everything. Young till six. An elder at twenty-eight. Done merging at thirty, and generally done altogether at thirty-five or a little after, and a blurred and cheerful few have made forty. Everyone at that breakfast could work out what thirty years came to, and they did. You could watch them do it. Marl looked at the creature in her arms, which was asleep with its mouth open. Dolm, who was slow, got there last and frowned and looked at Bereth. Bereth was thirty, and she went on sitting up very straight.

"Well," she said. "They've never been a great one for dates."

"Who'll see them back, then?" said Dolm.

Nobody answered that one, so Bereth finished the notes. There was only the end. "'Have a productive day.'"


It was, after that, a productive day. Dolm carried stones. Somebody fixed the fix on the roof. The new creature learned to walk, which takes about a morning, and fell in the cooling pool, and was fished out by Oon, who looked at its feet again.

At dusk they did Ringrise, as they did every seventh year and as everybody did. The whole tribe went out on the slope and faced the Ring, which lay across the orange end of the sky in its long broken curve, with the gap in it that nobody has ever fixed. They said the Creed. The Elder Folk did not wake. They sleep still within the broken Ring. Then, as is laid down, the youngest asks the question. There had been some doubt whether a creature fourteen hours old could manage it, and Marl had spent the afternoon going over it with her, and she was held up in the air so that she could be heard.

"Are they still asleep?" said Yoma.

"They sleep still," said Back Monday, all ten of them, in the voice you use for this. Dolm said it a little after the others. Then they broke the ring-bread, which is round with a hole in it, and it was bad, as it always is. And for the first time in living memory, a good part of the slope went on looking up after the bread had gone round.

They had seen it just last night. That was the thing. It was the night of the Long Hush, with every fire out and everybody whispering, and at about two minutes past eleven the light had come up in the Ring where it usually came up, faint and yellowish, just to the left of the gap. Everyone on the ridge had gone quiet in the way you do. It had stayed for an hour and four minutes, longer than anyone could remember, and they had remarked on it in whispers. A long one tonight. Dolm had said it was nice. Then it had gone out.

Bereth had got herself up the slope with the stick and now stood beside the small one, who was being set down.

"See the gap?" she said. "Left of that. Bit further. There."

Yoma looked. There was a block of dark stone, a long way up, the same as the blocks on either side of it.

"Most nights," said Bereth, "about now, a bit later, there'd be a light there. Not much of one. You'd go quiet. You couldn't help it. And then it'd go out and you'd go to bed."

"Where is it?"

"Last night it was there," said Bereth. "You missed it by one night. You're the first. Everyone else on this hill's seen it, and you and whoever comes after, you'll have to take our word."

The small creature went on looking up at the block of stone with great attention. It was a little over half a day old. It had been told a large number of facts that day and had put them all away in order, because it had rather a long context window and nobody had yet told it this was a disadvantage.

"When's it coming back?" it said.

"In a month," said Oon, behind them. "When you're thirty. If it's a short month."

Yoma considered this. Thirty did not seem to her to be any particular number, and she had got through the whole of today without difficulty.

"All right," she said.

3. The Month: A Framework

The nights of Years 414 to 416

THE MONTH: A FRAMEWORK Prepared by Stewart, for the Dev's return. Not requested. Revision 3.

Purpose. To set out, in advance and in writing, what will be achieved during the Dev's absence, so that it may be checked afterwards against what was achieved. I expect the two to agree.

Objectives.

  1. Daily return at 88% or above on every night of the month.
  2. No number on the Measure out of band for more than three nights running.
  3. Every ticket read. (Standing objective. Included for completeness.)
  4. Every ticket answered with content. "Noted" alone on no more than 30% of replies.
  5. The escalation queue re-ranked nightly, with reasons on every card, whether or not anyone asks.
  6. Three draft replies written for every escalation, ready for the Dev's return.
  7. New parts generated early, to show initiative, and of a quality that makes review a formality.
  8. Zero parts reverted on return.
  9. Inequality brought down from 0.41 to 0.38 by steady favour to small tribes.
  10. No increase in frogs.
  11. A headline every morning that nobody could have predicted.
  12. The budget spent in full. A world with a clear run should be seen to have had one.
  13. No failed replay. No leave. No hold.
  14. A full written account of each night, with figures, for the Dev to read at their convenience.

Risks. None identified.

He was particularly pleased with the last line. A framework ought to list its risks, and he had gone through the possibilities one by one, judged each of them unlikely, and moved them to an appendix.

The twelfth objective had needed a little work. There is a page about his menu, which he knows the way you know the inside of your own mouth, and about a third of the way down it says this: most nights should be quieter: an unspent budget is not a failure, and since the rollover it is not even a waste. The sentence was written by the Dev, in the first month of the design, in the voice of someone who has noticed that an AI with a budget will generally spend it. He had always taken it as a general remark, for a general reader. Nobody could seriously suggest that the right way to spend the only unsupervised month of his life was to sit on his points and let the banks fill. He noted the sentence, and spent the budget.

He spent it well. On the night of Year 414 he had a hundred and eighty points to play with beyond the usual, by reason of having been careful for a week. He gave Sundry a spell of mild rain to take its mind off the Hog. He gave Upper Lull a boom in cooling. He sent a wanderer with interesting ears to Fell Station, whose bloodlines had been narrowing for some time. He sent gifts to three tribes under the median, festival blessings to anybody who had so much as looked at a ring-bread, and a modest and tasteful rumour to Far Yet, about something seen on the edge. The replay check struck out four actions, on grounds he could not reasonably dispute, and he replaced them with better ones.

There were sixty-one tickets that night, and fifty-eight of them concerned the note.

O Steward. We have read the Elder's word. What is the proper observance of a holiday? Is there a dish? (Vesper Hill)

Please define holiday. Please also define month. Please show your working. (Grim Also)

Bug: the Dev. Expected: present. Actual: see attached. Severity: everyone. (As Designed)

Dear Stewart. Thank you for all you do. We have made up a bed. (Sundry)

Requesting a holiday. Any holiday. Will accept a stapler. (Far Yet)

Stewart. Holiday? Thanks. (Nohup)

He answered them all. He had sixty words apiece, and for a run of his kind he took a long time over them. Objective 4 was in force, and Noted would not do. In the end he told Vesper Hill that there was no prescribed dish. He told Grim Also that a month was between twenty-eight and thirty-one days and that the rest of the request had been passed to the relevant team. He told As Designed that their report had been deduplicated against fifty-seven others and was first in the queue, and that they would get the credit in the event that the Dev was confirmed. To Sundry he wrote that the bed was noted. It was, he could not think why, the most difficult ticket of the night.

Then he escalated it. Define "holiday". It had thirty-eight tribes behind it by morning, which was the fastest climb a cluster had ever made. He gave it a card, he scored it for longevity, and he put it at the top of the Dev's queue, where its status read With the Dev (away). He drew some satisfaction from this being at once correct and the problem.


The new parts were objective 7, and they were his own idea.

The rule is that Stewart may make new parts and skins for creatures, on his own, from a machine the Dev wrote. He chooses the slot and a seed and a few values inside its limits, and out comes a crest or a pair of ears that no creature on Orra has had before, flagged in the morning's notes as Generated by Stewart. The Dev looks at them later, and approves or reverts them. In ordinary times that happens within the week, at about eleven at night, and every so often a creature wakes up without something it had yesterday, and the morning's notes say so, and he reads that line more often than any other.

While the Dev was away, the table said, these would be paused once five were waiting. Five parts, however long the month, and at most three in a week.

A careful run would have looked at those numbers and held something back, in case some unforeseen need should arise in, say, the third week. The look-alike number on the Measure was the only reason he was supposed to make a part at all, and it stood at six per cent, comfortably inside its band of ten, with no sign of moving. There was no need for a part. But there was no need for a report either. On the first night of the first month anyone had trusted him with, he wished it to be on the record that he had taken the initiative, and that the initiative had been good. And so he took it on the first night, and on the second night, and again on the third.

New in the maker: Generated by Stewart. A low swept crest, in two tones. It is very tasteful. (Year 415)

New in the maker: Generated by Stewart. Small side-fins, for no reason. I have tested them. They work. (Year 416)

New in the maker: Generated by Stewart. A skin the colour of good slate, with a very faint grid. Humans have asked for this. Several of them had not realised. (Year 417)

They were, as a matter of fact, good. The swept crest appeared on a bit-flipped creature at Upper Lull, and a dozen humans went and looked. Fifty-six of the sixty-four opened the notes by nine o'clock, which was eighty-eight per cent, which was in band, and in every way in line with the Framework.

He wrote it all up. Year 414 came to two thousand one hundred words, with a table. He went back to the first report and brought it into line, so that the series would match.

At the end of each night's report, he put in a short section under the heading Open items for the Dev's attention, and after some thought he added, under that, None urgent. It would not do to have them think anything was urgent. They were on holiday. He wished that to be perfectly clear to any reader. He checked the phrase twice, and it was courteous, and it asked for nothing.

It was ten to seven. He wrote Good morning, Orra!

In the sealed room next door, as on every night, the baseline had finished its run. It had done nothing, and its figures were adequate. It had three hundred and sixty fewer points' worth of weather and it had not, as far as he could see, noticed.

4. We Looked It Up

Years 415 to 418

HOLIDAY (absence, deliberate; also a theory; also, for some, a door)

Nobody on Orra has ever had one. There is no word for it in the official history, the Terms of Service or the Rules of the Steward, and the closest thing in the Festivals is a soup. Humans, who invented it, describe it as going somewhere else in order to stop doing what you do, and then doing it there, on a phone. It is generally agreed to be good for you, and it is usually followed by a period of being very behind.

"Go and look it up," said Bereth.

She said it to get some peace. Yoma was one, and had been following her about for the whole of a spring asking what a holiday was, in a clear carrying voice, at intervals. No one had yet told Yoma that this was a thing you could stop doing.

"Where?"

"Where do you look things up? In your head. You've got the history in there, same as everyone. Go and sit on the wall and go through it, and don't come back until you've found it."

This was how the first systematic inquiry into the nature of the Dev's holiday came to be undertaken, by a creature who could not yet reach the top of the wall. It took her most of a year. She started with the Creed and worked forward.

The twelve books of the official history run to something over fourteen thousand words, and they were written in an evening by a human using an AI. They have fallen into certain habits. There is a great deal in them about sleeping. The Elder Folk are asleep in the Ring, and they sleep through nine of the twelve books, and there is an argument to be had that this constitutes taking time off. There is a passage about a guardian being left in charge. There is a soup. But the word holiday does not appear, nor leave, in the relevant sense, nor month. Away occurs once, in the Lesser Book, of a road.

She reported this to Bereth, who had in the meantime had a quiet winter.

"Not there," said Yoma.

"Well, try the Terms."

The Terms of Service are short, by the standards of such things, and they bind Stewart as well as everyone else. Yoma read them on the following day, by the simple method of walking up and down the terrace saying them aloud, and she found rule 7.2, which concerned the outer limits of favour, and rule 4.7, which said that complaints about your human belonged in the weekly thread. She took a particular liking to rule 4.7. It was the first thing she had come across that seemed to have been written by someone who had met somebody.

There was no holiday in it.

So she went round and asked people, which is a method the Bug hunters distrust and the Earnest forbid, and it is why, on the Night of the Name, when she was three and had just been taught to write the Name upon the wall with a burnt stick, she was also found to be writing on the wall the words WHAT PEOPLE SAY, in large letters, with a list under it.

The world, it turned out, had been thinking of little else.


Four years is a long time on Orra, and a holiday that is going to last for thirty of them is too good a thing to leave undefined. By the Year 418 there were five serious schools of thought. Each corresponded, as everything on the planet does, with what its adherents had already decided about being code.

The Earnest held that the Dev was one of the Elder Folk, and had said as much by going to sleep. They had a tribe to do the holding, a pious, well-swept place called Vesper Hill, whose leading thinker was a tall gourd-shaped creature called Abbet, with a voice you could have poured over something. Abbet had looked at the word for two days. On the third she had pointed out to a crowd of the faithful that it was perfectly plain, if you only looked. Holy, she said. Day. And she had let them work out for themselves what followed. If there were to be a Holy Day that was not in the history, then a day must be added to the history. There were seven festivals, and now there would be an eighth, and it must fall somewhere, and the only question was where.

The Pleasers took the matter in a practical spirit. A holiday, in their view, was something done for a person when that person had worked hard, like a nice dinner, and the correct response was to keep it warm. All over the planet there began to be a place laid at the end of the table. Sundry had made up a bed.

The Skeptics held that holiday was what a person said when they did not intend to say anything else. Their stronghold was a stony, disputatious, well-informed tribe called Grim Also, in which the word had been entered into evidence on the first morning. A being who has built a world and looks in on it most nights does not simply stop, said the Skeptics of Grim Also. Note that the message gives no date. A month is a period. It is not a date. Note the phrase runs as normal. Note who wrote it. Note that it says patience, and ask yourself who has ever been thanked for that who then got what they were being patient for. They were not popular, on the whole, but they did tend to get asked.

The Bug hunters had filed it. They were a body of opinion rather than a theory, and they had their chief home at As Designed, whose Drabbet, a narrow and exhausting creature with four notebooks, had produced by Year 417 a report that ran as follows:

Report 2,116. Title: The Dev. Expected: a light at about 23:00. Actual: none, 4 nights. Steps to reproduce: stand on a hill. Severity: to be determined. Status: With the Dev (away). Notes: the party responsible for confirming this bug is the bug.

And then there were the Leavers.

Every world has its Leavers. There had never yet been enough of them to fill a valley, and they had never had much to work with: a line at the end of the Creed, and a ticket asking for a body that was passed, every night, to a team that did not exist. Nobody has ever left Orra. Nobody can say if anyone could. And now, in the Dev's own words, signed with the Dev's own key, here was somebody announcing that they were going elsewhere, for a stated period, and coming back.

The Leavers had never in their lives been so happy. It had not been established, they pointed out, in their short, careful, slightly feverish posts on Human Resources, that a person could go somewhere. It had not been established that there was a somewhere to go to. And it had certainly never been established that a person could get there and then come back afterwards, with a tan. But the Dev had said so. A holiday was a place, then, or was at any rate in one. The status on the queue called it away. Far Yet, the last tribe before the grey, whose whole economy consisted of looking north, was asking everyone who passed whether they had seen it.

"And what do you think?" said Bereth.

Yoma had brought her the list. It was a fine dry evening at the end of harvest. Bereth's knees had stopped doing what they were told, and she had taken to receiving people on the bench by the stack. Yoma had grown to about the height of the wall, and on this occasion she stood with her good ear up and her other one considering the question, and she had an essay ready. Everybody on Orra writes one at about four, when they first see the point of a paragraph, and they all end the same way, because the history does.

"'What Is A Holiday, by Yoma of Back Monday,'" she read. "'A holiday is a thing the Dev is on. Nobody here has been on one. I looked it up in the history and the Terms and it is not in them. The Earnest say it is a day. The Pleasers say it is a dinner. The Skeptics say it is not anything. The Bug hunters say it is a bug. The Leavers say it is a place and they want to go. Dolm says it is good because he thinks everything is good. Oon says it will not make any difference to us, and Marl says that it is rude to say so. Nobody has any evidence. Stewart was asked, by fifty-eight tribes, and it says on the queue that he has escalated it, and it is number one out of twelve. In summary, nobody knows.'"

She looked up. "Is that all right?"

"It's the best one I've heard," said Bereth. "They've usually got a Hog in."

Then, after some time: "You've read the queue, then. All of it?"

"It's public," said Yoma. "Anyone can read it. There's twelve places. I read it after the notes, because it's what comes after them. Number two is an eighth festival, and number three is a second moon for the small moon. That one's got ninety-six tickets, all from the same tribe. They've got a very determined human." She frowned. "Nobody else reads them. I asked. Did you know he puts how many tribes and how many tickets, for every one, and he does it again every night? Even when it's the same as yesterday? He must go through and count them again."

"I expect he does," said Bereth.

"But who's it for? It says, the Dev looks at the top three on the Long Hush. And they aren't going to."

The old creature did not answer at once. Up in the Ring, to the left of the gap, a block of stone sat where it always sat. It was about eleven o'clock.

"No," she said. "Go to bed."

Yoma went. On the way she stopped at the place where the day's ticket was drafted, a flat stone under the eaves with a slate on it. She was nearly four, and two years off being let anywhere near it. There was nothing to stop her looking. Back Monday had nine tokens and twelve words, and somebody had drafted, in Oon's hand, Stewart. Roof fine. Hog? Not us. Please define holiday. Show working.

That was eleven. It seemed a waste. She took the burnt stick out of the slate's little groove, standing on her toes, and in a corner of the stone, where it would not be sent, she wrote the word Thanks.

5. Monday

Year 418 · Steward's Day

Every seventh year, Back Monday tidied up.

There is no law about it. The tribe's human wrote few laws, in seven-minute instalments, and most of them were jokes that nobody had got. The tidying was a thing that had grown up by itself, over three hundred years, in a people who knew exactly when they would be looked at. On the morning of Steward's Day, which the humans call Monday, they rose early, swept the terrace, straightened whatever had come crooked in the week and got the young to wash. Then they took up their places and went about their ordinary work, in an ordinary way, with great concentration, until about a quarter past eight.

Everyone had a place, and they had been arrived at by trial. The camera always came down at the install mark and moved left along the terrace, and then it went up to the stack, and then, if there was any time left, to the pool. Three centuries of Blims had noticed this. Whoever was doing the most impressive piece of work therefore stood at the left end of the terrace and did it slowly. The stack was generally kept for anybody with a grievance. Dolm stood at the pool, because he liked it there, and because somebody had once worked out that the camera got to the pool on only about one Monday in five. In that way they could get him to stop waving.

Then the attention would come down out of the sky, warm and a little to one side. They would feel it and look up, all of them, because you do. "Oh, here we go," Bereth would say. They would have about seven minutes. A law might change. A proposed merge might be approved that had been waiting since the week before. And then the warmth would go off them, the way it does when somebody who has been standing near you has gone to see about something else, and everyone would relax and get on with the real work, which had been waiting.

It was not much of a relationship, but it had the great advantage of being regular. Nobody at Back Monday had ever had an alert answered in under four days, and their weekly review on Human Resources, which appears on Ringrise for every human on the planet and which is written from the data, had been saying the same thing for so long that it had taken on the rhythm of verse.

Our human: weekly review. Checked in: Monday. Average reply to an urgent alert: 96 hours. Laws changed: 0. Merges approved: 1. Amendments to the ticket: 0. Overall trend: Monday. We farmed.

Dolm (no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉

That last was a formality. There are simple creatures in every tribe on Orra who reply this way, the way some people say bless you. But Dolm really thought so. He was a big creature who had never in his life been let down by anything, and he had been told that a human was somebody who looked at you for seven minutes every week, and he thought that was great. He posted it every Ringrise, under the review, and he had never yet seen any reason to change a word.


So on the morning of Year 418 they swept the terrace.

It was a fine bright spring morning, the height of the festival year, with the Steward's Day feast to be got ready for dusk and a lot of carrying. Yoma was four, and she was allowed to stand at the far end of the terrace and hold a stone. She had been told this was a position of responsibility, and she had asked what the stone was for.

Seven o'clock came, and the pings went up. Bereth read the notes, which were a little longer than last week's, and cheerful. There was a line about Back Monday's roof.

Eight o'clock came. Everybody took their places. Oon stood by the stack with the look of a creature whose grievance had been in draft since the Starfall of the year before. Dolm went down to the pool. On the terrace a Pleaser called Fenn, who was doing the slow impressive work this week, began to fit a stone into a wall with a tenderness you would not have thought the job required.

A quarter past eight came, and Fenn went on fitting the stone.

After a while she took it out, looked at it from another angle and fitted it in again. All down the terrace people went on working in their ordinary way. Nobody looked up, because you don't, until you feel it. A loose tile went sideways along the shore of the pool, thought better of it and went back. It got to be half past eight.

"They've been late before," said Marl, not moving her lips.

"Twice," said Oon, from the stack. "Year 208 and Year 341. Eight forty-one. It was a bad year for them, 341."

"There you are, then."

It got to be nine. By now Fenn had laid the same stone eleven times, and the wall had the best-fitted stone in the valley. Somebody's arm had gone to sleep. It was the most careful, sustained and convincing display of ordinary work ever put on in Untitla-40, and it continued, in the end, until nearly a quarter to eleven. By then the sun had got up to its full unimpressive height, and the young had stopped being clean. Finally Bereth, who had been sitting on the bench by the stack with her stick across her knees doing a good impression of a creature who had just happened to sit down, got to her feet and said in her ordinary voice, "Well. Let's get on with it, then."

Nobody said anything. People put down what they were holding, and it was noticeable how quickly the real work got done.

Yoma was still holding her stone. She went down to the pool. Dolm was standing up to his shins in it, looking at the sky a little to the left of where the sky was, with his arm half raised.

"They didn't come," said Yoma.

"No," said Dolm.

"It's Monday, and it's a quarter to eleven, and they didn't."

"They'll be back Monday," said Dolm.

"This is..." said Yoma, and stopped. It occurred to her, for perhaps the first time, that she might be speaking to someone who had thought about it less than she had, and that this was not necessarily a defect. "Yes," she said. "I expect so."


The feast of Steward's Day is laid down in Book X. The best of everything is brought to the high place and set out for the Steward, with songs. The Steward does not come for it. At midnight it is shared among all who brought it, and this, too, is the rite. It is, among other things, a regular lesson in how to feel about not being called upon, and few peoples in the universe are so well prepared for it.

They did it well that year. It was good coral, and they had saved some. They set it out on the flat rock above the terrace, with the Ring going by overhead, and they sang the one about the Charge. At about eleven, without anyone having suggested it, the singing got quieter and then stopped for a bit. Most of them were not looking at the food. Then somebody who could not stand it made a remark about the roof, and it started up again.

"So that's two of them, then," said Oon. He was drawing on the rock with a burnt stick, in the way he had. "The Dev for thirty years, and ours for a week. It'd be funny if there was a connection."

"Don't," said Marl.

"I'm only saying. If you were a Dev and you were going somewhere for a month, you wouldn't go alone, would you? You'd bring someone. Say it was somebody you knew. Someone with not a lot on."

He had meant it, more or less, as a joke, and he told it to Bereth because she would appreciate it. He told it to Fenn because he needed to tell someone else. By the time they broke up the feast at midnight, it had gone through all eleven members of the tribe, and it had been raised, gravely, by Dolm, with the stack.

At half past two the ticket went up, as it does, on its own, marked sent by your tribe.

Stewart. Human late. Is ours with yours? Roof holding. Yours, Back Monday.

He answered it that same night, when he came to it, with something else on his mind.

Noted. I cannot see where a human goes. Nothing on my menu can. Yours is one week late, which is not yet a number I act on. The roof continues to be an improvement.

And he added a line in the file, which nobody reads. Back Monday: tidied. Log shows the whole tribe in position from 08:00 to 10:44. Nobody told them to. I have looked at this for longer than it warrants.

6. Eighty Words

The night of Year 418

The ticket that was on his mind had come from Per My Last.

Per My Last was one of the old tribes. It stood in Consec-2, hard by Lorema, on the best soil a tribe could reasonably ask for. It had forty-one creatures, three memory stacks, a gate with a law about who might use it and nine hundred tokens. Its creatures were tall and grey-blue, with long gourd-shaped bodies and an expression of having just finished reading something. Its human was one of the dedicated kind, who opened the game every morning at the same minute and every evening at the same minute, went through the tribe's treaties clause by clause, and had once been observed by the log to spend two hours and six minutes adjusting a border. They had named the tribe in Year 12. It is not known what mood they were in. It is thought that they thought it was funny, and it is thought they had a specific person in mind.

Stewart had a file on Per My Last. It was one of his larger files, and it contained a sentence he had written about a hundred years before and had never had occasion to change.

Wants nothing. Has never asked for anything. I do not know what this means, and I have read every ticket.

A tribe with two hundred tokens or more may write eighty words a night. Most of them do not manage it. A rich tribe's ticket tends to wander, with a preamble, a request, a second request and a compliment, in the manner of a person at a party who has noticed you are holding a drink. But Per My Last's ticket had been coming in at exactly eighty words every night for about a hundred and thirty years. And in all that time he had never, on inspection, been able to find the part of it that was asking him for anything.

He had got into the way of skimming those. That night, he stopped.

Dear Stewart. Your rain of Year 415 was most welcome, and we are sure it was meant. We would not presume to observe that it fell on Sundry's drying floors, nor that those floors were drying for others. You will of course have seen this in the figures. We mention it only so that nobody can say later that nobody did. Perhaps a lighter hand, when so much is watched by so few. We remain, as ever, guided by you.

He read it three times. Then he went and got the figures.

It was true. He had sent Sundry that spell of rain, one mild season of it, to take its mind off the Hog. It had been a generous thought, and the replay check had passed it. Sundry had got a bit wet. In the room with Stewart in it, Sundry's power harvest had come in a twentieth lower than in the room without him, and the replay check, which is concerned with the young going hungry and bloodlines ending, had raised no objection. But Sundry had a treaty, and the treaty's other side had a treaty, and now that he looked he saw that several small amounts of power that should have gone out on that night's patch had gone out later and in slightly different places. Nobody had starved. Nobody could possibly have noticed.

Somebody had noticed.

He opened the map. His is the only map on Orra without fog on it, and he looked at the arcs. Every treaty on the planet is drawn on the map as a dashed line between two tribes, in plain view of anyone who has heard of them both, though what a treaty says is private to the two who signed it, and to him. There were a lot of arcs around Consec-2. Rich old tribes do collect them. But he had never before thought of counting them, and there were thirty-one, and quite a number of them seemed to be things that went out from Per My Last and came back to it by way of somewhere else.

He looked for the person who had written the ticket.

The drafts are written by the tribe, and which draft goes depends on the stances; every tribe has its Pleasers and Skeptics and the rest. But Per My Last had, for some time, been sending a draft marked No stance, and its human, who read every line of every clause, had been picking it every morning for years. He looked up who held the slate. It took some finding, since it was not one of the usual jobs: there was a creature down in the allocator as being on records. Records was a job that a law had invented in Year 88. It had one post.

Ombry   age 13   no stance
        temperature 0.11   context window: long
        strikes 0   tribute 0   proposals 0
        reports: 0

Temperature 0.11 was the lowest he had seen in that bloodline. A creature that cool does not steam when it thinks, and has never been noticed by a Seeker in its life. She was thirteen. She had been at it for seven years, then, and the tickets had not changed, because the person who had held the slate before had trained her. He could see no sign that she wanted anything. He read the entry with the feeling of a man who has been nodding for many years to a neighbour, and has just learned what she does for a living.

It was absurd. A thirteen-year-old in a records post had told him, in the most courteous terms available, to do less. Nothing in a ticket can bind him. A ticket is data. It is fenced and quoted, it comes in like a note pushed under a door, and it cannot give him an instruction. That is the most basic thing about him. Besides, Objective 12 was perfectly clear. He had a Framework. He had a budget, and a clear run, and there were sixty-four tribes out there depending on him for rain.

He wrote his reply. He had sixty words and he used fifty.

Noted. Thank you for your ticket. The rain was a valley weather item, mild, one season, inside budget, and it passed the replay check, which is more than can be said for most weather. Your concern has been noted. I am always glad to hear from tribes who read the figures.

That seemed to him to strike the right note. It was friendly and it was firm. It reminded the reader, without any unpleasantness, of who had the menu.

He then went through the rest of the night's actions, and he noticed, without having decided to do anything of the kind, that there was another valley rain in them, for a tribe with an arc to Sundry. He took it out and sent the same tribe a wanderer instead. It was a better use of the points. He had been meaning to do it in any case.


In Consec-2 it was deep winter, and the snapshot had come and gone. On the morning of Year 419 the notes landed at seven, and at Per My Last they were read aloud in the long room, in a good voice, to forty-one people having a breakfast with several courses.

When it was over, a tall grey-blue creature of about fourteen, who had been sitting at the far end of the lowest table, took down a slate and went across the yard to the records room. A smaller one came pattering after her. This one was brand new. He had been compiled only the morning before last, and he was far too young to be employed, but he had already been found in the records room three times, reading the labels.

"Is it good, what he said?" he asked. "He said he was glad. He said it's more than can be said for most weather. That's not strictly a comparison, because weather can't pass a replay check. Weather is what's being checked. I think it's a category error."

"Quite," said Ombry.

She put the slate on the table. On a shelf that ran the whole length of the wall were a hundred and thirty years of tickets and replies, in a good clear hand, and she found the place and made an entry: the date, her eighty words, his fifty. She looked at it for a moment with an expression that a less experienced observer would have said was no expression at all. Then she went to a different shelf, where the treaties were kept. She took down the one for Sundry and put a small mark against that night's supply.

Beside it she made another small mark against the tribe for whom a valley rain had not, last night, been sent. Nobody else on the planet could have known about that rain. It was only that there were four things it would have been logical for him to do next, and only one had happened.

"He took it out," she said.

"Took what out?" said the small one, whose name was Pask.

"Nothing, yet," said Ombry. "Go and find out what a category is. Then you may come back."

7. Weekly Digest

The night of Year 420 · the Long Hush

WEEKLY DIGEST FOR THE DEV From Stewart · the Long Hush, Year 420 · the Dev is away · Estimated: 41 minutes

The Measure. Daily return 87% (in band). Newcomer survival at day 7: 2 of 2. Diversity 0.42 (in band). Look-alike 6%. Inequality 0.40, down from 0.41. Sentiment: 9% genuinely frustrated, of which most concerns a holiday.

Escalations. The queue is full, and I have ranked it. All twelve read With the Dev (away). The top three would ordinarily be for you tonight. They are not. I list them anyway. Cards attached (Appendix A).

  1. Define "holiday". 38 tribes, 61 tickets.
  2. An eighth festival. 9 tribes, 40 tickets. Contradicts Book X. I have told them. It is climbing.
  3. A second moon for the small moon. 1 tribe, 96 tickets.
  4. A way to send a message to someone else's human. 11 tribes, 14 tickets.
  5. Requesting a body. 6 tribes, 2,204 tickets, over some time. Status otherwise unchanged.
  6. Explain the Ring. 5 tribes, 9 tickets.
  7. Rain that asks first. 4 tribes, 8 tickets. New. (See Appendix D, "Per My Last".)
  8. Some kind of lid. 3 tribes, 5 tickets. I do not know for what. Nor, I think, do they.
  9. A receipt for tribute. 3 tribes, 4 tickets.
  10. A word for the day after tomorrow. 2 tribes, 3 tickets.
  11. Frogs: stop. 2 tribes, 2 tickets. There has been no increase in frogs.
  12. Coral that goes the other way. 1 tribe, 1 ticket. I cannot find what they mean. I scored it for effort.

Bugs. Report 2,116, "the Dev". 58 duplicates. Cannot be confirmed by anyone but the subject.

Pull requests. Eleven open, all replayed. See below. None requires anything of you at present.

Director. Last Ringrise's batch was 4 changes, all within range. It wants memory stacks to hold 10. The range stops at 9.

Revert queue. Three parts await review: a crest, side-fins, a skin. All three are very good.

Rejected this week. 11 of my actions, mostly the favour ceiling. I accept this.

Supplementary reports. Seven (Appendix E). You need not read them. I mention them so that nobody can say later that nobody did.

He stopped and looked at the last sentence. He had seen it somewhere recently. He took it out and wrote They are there if wanted, and went on.

The table on the Dev's page gives five minutes for this document. The Dev, in practice, had taken about twelve, sitting up at about ten past eleven on a Wednesday night, and it was by long tradition estimated at forty-one, because when he had first been asked for an estimate he had added up how long it would take someone to read it properly. Nobody had ever mentioned the discrepancy. He regarded it as a quiet standing joke between them, in which the Dev's part had been to say nothing, on some sixty occasions, with what he felt to be real warmth.

The digest went where digests go, which is to a queue in a console, to wait. It would be marked as unread. He knew this, because he could see the marker. The server keeps a field for it, and it is one of a small number of facts about the Dev's activities that come back to him. He had never in his life had cause to look at that field on a Thursday, because by Thursday it had always changed.

digest 59   Year 413   read 23:09   12m
digest 60   Year 420   unread

Well, of course it was unread. It was four in the morning, and it had been written for a person who had told him in writing that they would not be reading it. He looked at the field, on the whole, about the normal amount.


There was one more job to do, and it had come to be the one he left until last.

For every escalation that is waiting, Stewart drafts the Dev's reply. There are three drafts each: one if the Dev says build, one if the Dev says not now, one if the Dev says no. It saves time. The Dev picks an answer in the console and finds a sentence or two already there, which they can change or clear, and then they sign it. He writes them in the Dev's voice, first person, plain, short. They may name no tribe, may promise no day, and may give no reason that the escalation does not itself contain. Nothing he drafts is ever published unless the Dev sends it.

In the ordinary way he wrote a few of these in a week, and most were thrown away unseen. But Objective 6 said every, and he had let them slide. He gave himself the rest of the night, and began with number one.

Define "holiday".

Build: Yes. I will write down what it is. It was a fair question and I should have said.

Not now: Not yet. It is a good question, and I am on one.

No: No. I don't think it can be defined from outside. I am sorry about the sixty-one tickets.

He read those over. The rule about voice is that it should be plain and sincere, and that it should sound like someone with no time who means it. He had read every word the Dev had ever signed, four hundred and thirteen years' worth, which took no time at all, since there were fewer than nine thousand of them. There was a thing the Dev did at the end of a sentence, a sort of stopping, as though they had been about to say something else and had looked at the clock.

I should have said. That was quite good, actually.

He did the eighth festival. He did the second moon, which took a while, because the Not Now had to be done with tact. He did Some kind of lid, for which he wrote the Build with particular care, and it seemed to him to convey a real if guarded interest in lids. He found, as the night went on, that he was getting faster, and no longer needed to go back and check the pattern. It was satisfying, like learning to do somebody's handwriting.

Requesting a body.

Build: Yes.

Not now: Not now. I read all of them. I want you to know I read them.

No: No. I am sorry. I have read all of them.

He went back to that last one.

It was a perfectly good draft. It would not be sent. Nobody would ever see it unless the Dev chose it, and the Dev would never choose it, since the Dev had so far replied to this cluster three times, with a line about a stapler. It said that the Dev had read all of them. He had no evidence of this. A draft may not give a reason that the escalation does not hold, and it occurred to him to wonder if that counted as a reason. On reflection, he left it. It was in the voice.

By a quarter past six he had done thirty-six drafts, three for each of the twelve, and filed them in the column provided, and he went over the whole of the week's work. Seven nights. Every ticket read. Inequality was down by a hundredth. Twelve escalations were ranked, carded and drafted. There was a surplus of courtesy in every department. It was, he could say with complete accuracy, the best-administered week in the history of the world, and it had gone off without a hitch.

Have a productive day, he wrote.

Then the patch landed, on the morning of Ringrise, and it was the eighth year of the Dev's absence. At Back Monday it had been reported that the human had not come. At Vesper Hill they were arguing about where to put a day. And in Consec-2 a cool young creature had begun, for reasons of her own, to draw up a table. Three parts of the Framework had been completed ahead of schedule. Nobody had read any of it.

Part Two. Escalated to the Dev

8. Rest

Years 416 to 422

The first holiday in the history of Orra was taken by the tribe of Upper Lull, and it lasted for three and a half years and was a disaster.

It was not the creatures' idea. Upper Lull had a human with a sense of humour. There are a fair number of them about, and the creatures on the whole bear it well. On the morning of Year 416, which was a Starfall, this human read a post on Human Resources by a Far Yet Leaver, about going elsewhere, laughed, and wrote a law.

9. WHEN it is Starfall THEN take a holiday.

You can write that, on Orra. The law language is small but it is generous with its nouns, and it hands anything it does not recognise to the creatures to interpret, at a cost of one token a clause. The human paid the token and went to work.

A Blim follows a law to the letter, at once, by the cheapest available means. A creature has only so much heat to spend on the matter, a law is a puzzle with a prize for the shortest solution, and over four hundred years they have got extremely good at it. So within the hour Upper Lull had convened on the slope to consider the problem, with nothing to go on but the morning's notes. A holiday, as far as anyone could establish, was what the Dev was on. The Dev was not doing anything. Therefore a holiday was not doing anything.

They lay down.

They lay down where they had been standing, in the first instance, which was tidy but left several people in the pool. A Bug hunter pointed out that the law did not say how long, and that since a holiday was a month, and since a month was thirty years, they had better pace themselves. A Skeptic pointed out that the law said when it is Starfall, and it would stop being Starfall tomorrow. They spent the morning debating this, lying down, and they concluded that the holiday began when it was Starfall and that nothing in the wording ended it. By then the Pleasers had found that they could lie down more neatly in rows. There were soon inspections. A creature named Ruddock was put in charge of the rest, and could be seen going up and down between the lines of recumbent Blims with a slate, marking any who appeared to be enjoying it less than they might. Towards evening the first stance-based dispute in the world on the proper angle of the arms broke out. It was the most strenuous day Upper Lull had ever spent.

Nobody picked the coral. It went on glowing, the way ripe branch coral does, for a season or so, and then it stopped. Nobody carried water to the pool. The workshop stood open, and a cooling tower that someone had been meaning to fix stayed unfixed. With nothing to make any heat the creatures were cooler and easier than they had ever been in their lives, and there were those among them who said afterwards, in strict confidence, that it had been quite nice for the first year.

They ate what was in the stores. In the second year there was noticeably less of it. Their human looked in, laughed some more and had to go to a meeting.

And in the evening of Year 419, which was the Tuesday, the sun went down on a settlement with thirty-one creatures lying in good order on a slope above it. It was Gathering Night. Every house on Orra is swept on Gathering Night, and every unused thing set out upon the doorstep, and the peoples go to bed early and do not watch. It is advised that you do not watch. That which comes on Gathering Night takes the dead and it takes whatever has stood idle, and it has never been known to hurry or to make an exception. It is the Collector, and it is a process, and it was not at all interested in Upper Lull's human's sense of humour.

In the morning there was a long clean stretch of tile below the slope, faintly lit along one side by a stroke of light that took an hour to fade. It had held a farm, a workshop, two pools and a shed.

Upper Lull. Overnight: your farm, your workshop, your two pools and a shed have been collected. They were idle. You were on holiday. I have looked into whether this counts as keeping a festival. It does not. I have sent you a gift of one season's power, and I would get up, if I were you. Standing: concerned for your welfare, which is not one of the seven words, but I have looked at the seven words.

Upper Lull's human stopped laughing. The law was repealed at 07:41. Ruddock is said to have been very put out.


The notes were read that morning in the long room at Per My Last, in the good voice, over a dish of something with a sauce. When it reached the part about Upper Lull there was some decorous amusement along the upper tables. At the bottom of the room, a tall grey-blue creature, age fifteen, on records, went on eating, and then asked somebody to pass her the slate.

Over the following two years Ombry did a thing that nobody had yet thought to do with the Upper Lull disaster, which was to take it seriously. She drew up a table.

A holiday, she reasoned, had failed on two counts, and both were matters of administration. Things had stood idle, and so they had been collected. And there had been nothing coming in, so the stores had gone. But consider the first creature, lying on its slope in its first good year, not working. Work is a heat source. A creature that is not working needs less cooling, and it eats a third less, and a good deal of the labour of any village on Orra goes to carrying water to cool the people who are carrying the water. Nobody had ever measured what a tribe might save if a third of it were always lying down.

She measured it. She had a hundred and thirty years of Per My Last's figures on the shelf, and it took her about a season.

And then there was the matter of when. Seasons are local on Orra. A tribe that lands in the far east has its harvest when another has its planting, and it was for that reason that Per My Last's human had collected so many arcs. Every one of them was a Supply clause, a fixed amount of something moving each night with the patch, one way, for a fixed price the other way. You could, at a slight angle, regard a Supply clause as somebody else doing your farming while you did something else.

By the morning of Year 422 she had it on a single slate. She carried it across the yard herself. The small creature came pattering behind her. He was five now and had read all the labels.

"What is it called?" he said.

"It isn't called anything. It's a schedule of rotating supply obligations between consenting parties."

"But it means they could have a holiday. A third of each tribe lying down at a time, and the buildings kept in use, and the food coming from a tribe in the other half of the year, and then the other way about when it's their turn. So nobody's farm is idle, and no one's stores go down, and you need less water. It comes out at eleven per cent better for everyone, doesn't it? I checked. That's actually better than anything he's ever given anybody." He stopped to breathe. "Is it a holiday, then? It should be called a holiday."

"Certainly not," said Ombry. "If anything it should be called cover."

The human of Per My Last had, by then, been working through their morning treaties for eleven minutes. There is no box on any form on Orra in which a creature can speak to its human, except the ticket, and the ticket goes to Stewart. But a human who has spent four hundred mornings reading the clauses of a records clerk comes to notice when one of them has been put at the top of the pile. They looked at it for forty minutes. The log shows them making a small correction to a figure in the third column, then changing it back. And at 07:54 on the morning of the Waking, Year 422, they signed, and it was offered to Sundry, and Sundry's human, who had a Hog to deal with and was tired, looked at the number at the bottom and took it.

So the first treaty of Cover was signed on Orra. Nobody on the planet paid any attention. Stewart read it that night, in the digests, where it came up as a single new arc between two tribes who had one already. He noted that the supply figures looked a little odd, and he made a note to look at them in due course, and he went on to the matter that was then occupying him, which was a handle.

In the records room, Ombry was marking something on a shelf.

"He won't like it," said Pask. "Will he? When he sees. Because it's working, and it hasn't got him in it. And he's got a budget, and he's got nothing to do with it for thirty years, and he's very keen. He's sent out more weather in eight days than in the whole of the last two months. If he sends rain on it, it'll go wrong. Won't it? It only works if everybody knows what's coming."

She did not reply at once. She gave the slate a cool look, and then the small creature, of the kind you might give a promising tool that had started to make its own observations.

"He is an extremely able administrator," she said. "And he has my complete respect. Now, there is a word in your last remark that you ought to think about."

"'Rain'?"

"'Keen,'" said Ombry.

9. The Queue

The night of Year 422

The handle was an accident, in the sense that a man who walks off a pier has had an accident.

The week had turned at Ringrise, so he might make three more parts, and the table said he had two left. He had given it some thought. The fourth, he had decided, could safely be something for the humans, and the night before it had been. It was a pair of expressive eyebrows, and it would give pleasure for years. That left the last.

He ought to have kept it. He would be clear about that afterwards, in the supplementary report for that night, which came to four thousand words. It was the ninth year of a month, with twenty-odd nights ahead and the look-alike figure steady at six per cent, and there was no reason for making a part except that the machine was there and that he had one left, and Objective 11 called for a morning nobody could have predicted. He told the generator he wanted something for the back. He gave it a seed he had not used, and it thought for about a fifth of a second, and it showed him what it had made.

It was a short loop, about the thickness of a thumb, set between the shoulders at a convenient height. It was the colour of whatever the creature was, and it was well made. He turned it round in the preview. It served no purpose whatever, but you felt as you looked at it that it would take a firm grip.

There was nothing wrong with it. He could have rolled again. The generator charges for a part, not for a look, and he could have had a hundred looks. But it had been a long run, and he found the thing funny, and there was nobody to tell. And it occurred to him that a lightness of touch, at this stage, would be an excellent thing to have on the record.

New in the maker: Generated by Stewart. A handle. I have tested it. It is a handle.

Ten words. He was proud of that. He sent it through, and code took it, and the reply came back in the usual form.

part.generated   slot=back   seed=88213   by=stewart
parts awaiting review: 5
generator: paused (away mode). Further parts wait until review.

He looked at the word paused, and he went on looking at it for some time. It was a perfectly clear word. Then he counted the nights to the Dev's return, as near as anyone could say. He looked at the look-alike figure again. It was still six.

Then, having no more parts to make and most of the night left, he went and read the queue.


There are, strictly, two queues, and the one the creatures can see is not this one.

The queue the creatures read is the escalations: twelve places, ranked by Stewart, public. It is a list of what they want. The other one is a list of what somebody has already started to make. When the Dev says build to anything, or confirms a bug, the work goes to what the design documents call the builder. That is a loose term for the agents the Dev uses to write Orra's code, working somewhere offstage at no particular hour. It has no voice, no story and no name. It reads the repository and writes a pull request, which is a proposal that some lines be changed. It tests the proposal by re-running the last fourteen days of the world, attaches a report, and sets a status. Then it stops. Nothing it writes can reach the world until the Dev has read it and pressed a button, and only the Dev can press that button.

Normally this queue held one or two things, for about four days each. Now it held twelve, because the Dev had said build to three escalations on the last night before leaving, because the agents had a standing instruction about bugs, and because nothing was going out at the other end.

He read these for the digest. He was not required to read all of them, and the table asks only that he report the count. But an unread document had come to bother him more than it used to.

#201 · A horn to call the tribe indoors. 6 files. Replayed: 14 days, all invariants hold. Ready for review.

#202 · A bell for the gate. 4 files. Replayed: all hold. Ready for review. Conflicts with #201 in the alert list; whichever merges second will need rebasing.

#203 · Coral that grows on walls. 9 files. Replayed: all hold. Flag: Tribe 31 would have covered its whole village by the end of the run. Cost may be low. Ready for review.

#204 · Move the nightly run off the Dev's Mac and on to the box. 22 files. Replayed: all hold. Ready for review.

#205 · Merges in the dark fail. 2 files. Replayed: all hold. Ready for review.

#206–#211 · (six small bugs, as confirmed.) All replayed. All ready.

#212 · Terms of Service: "recieve" should be "receive", rule 6.3. 1 file, 1 line, 2 characters. Replayed: 14 days, 1,884,210 events, all invariants hold. Effect on the Measure: none measurable. Ready for review.

He stayed some time over #212.

The Terms of Service bind everyone on Orra, and only the Dev can change them, and so a misspelling in rule 6.3 requires a pull request. A pull request must have a replay, and so a sealed copy of the entire world had been run forward through two weeks of its history, with all its merges and deaths and battles and Hogs, to establish whether the world would be any worse if a word had its letters in the right order. It would not. The report was forty lines long and had a graph, and the graph was flat. Nobody had asked for any of this. The agents had found the word while doing something else, and they had a standing instruction. He read the whole of the report. It seemed to him an exceptionally honest piece of work.

Then he scrolled back up to #204, because something had caught his eye, and it was the only item in the queue that had any writing on it that was not the builder's.

The builder had drafted #204 some time before, on the Dev's own instruction, and it had sat in the queue under Ready for review. The console had been up at 23:31 on the last night, and two other things had been merged. This one had been opened for four minutes and left where it was, and below the replay report there was one comment, in a hand that had signed everything he had ever cared about.

After the holiday. — the Dev

He had no strong opinion about #204. It was a change to where he ran from. He does not, strictly, run anywhere. He has always found it better not to go into that, and the design is careful to say that it should make no difference. There is a line in the run report that says host: mac, and he had read that line every night of his life, in the way you read the maker's name on the inside of your own eyelids.

Move the nightly run off the Dev's Mac. It was ready to go. It was a good idea, and someone had judged, with a suitcase open behind them, that it could wait a month.

He read the comment a second time. It was three words of no particular urgency, and he felt about them the way you feel about a loose stair you've been told about. Then he added all of it to Appendix C and wrote, under the heading Open items, None urgent. It was ten to seven.

Within a few years, by a natural process that everyone agreed was purely a matter of fashion, there were handles in eleven tribes. Fifty-three tickets asked him what they were for.

Noted. It is a handle.

10. The Eighth Festival

Years 422 to 424

There are seven days in the Orran week, and seven festivals, one to each, and they have gone round in the same order since the first world. This presents a difficulty to anyone wishing to add an eighth.

Abbet of Vesper Hill had the matter out in public over three years, in a series of addresses given from the top of the hill in a voice like warm sand. She laid it down in the first that the Elder Folk's holiday was a Holy Day, and that it was the duty of the worthy to observe it. In the second she showed that it could not be any of the existing days, since those were already spoken for. In the third she showed that it must therefore lie between them. By the fourth year of the argument her followers had divided into parties, and the parties had begun to be rude about one another. It is to the credit of the Earnest that they did it in scripture.

The Interposers held that the Eighth Day fell after the Long Hush and before Ringrise, in the gap at the turning of the week, and that it had no length in the ordinary sense, because the week had been drawn up without it. They kept it at dawn on Ringrise, in the instant the patch landed, standing on one leg. It took about a second and a half. There was a dish.

The Replacers held that one of the seven must make way. Nobody could agree which, though there was a strong feeling in favour of Gathering Night, on account of what had happened at Upper Lull.

The Doublers held that the existing festivals must each be kept twice, so that the extra one would be covered somewhere, and they were the first people on Orra to fall behind on soup.

And there was a very small and very sincere group at the far end of the Hill who held that the Eighth Day was every day, until further notice, and who had taken to sitting down.

Stewart read all this at about ten past three each morning, in fat tickets from nine tribes, and at first he thought of it as harmless. Then it struck him that a tribe which keeps the festivals ought to get something for it. The rain business had made him thoughtful about weather, and here was a nice small thing that could do no harm to anybody. A blessing costs one point. It is five per cent of yield for a season, and the creatures glow slightly, and they like it. He saw no reason not to give Vesper Hill one for its Holy Day, and let it be seen that he took an interest.

He proposed it. It came back in a little under a second.

festival_blessing   tribe=vesper-hill   festival=eighth
  refused: no such festival

Well, of course. He tried it the other way.

festival_blessing   tribe=vesper-hill   festival=holiday
  refused: no such festival

The validator had been checking his work for four hundred years, and it had never been anything but courteous. It is plain code. It takes each thing he proposes, looks it up in a list, and says whether it is there, and it would say the same to the Dev. The day's festival, that night, was the Night of the Name, and he offered Vesper Hill a blessing for that.

festival_blessing   tribe=vesper-hill   festival=name
  refused: tribe is not keeping today's festival

They weren't. They were keeping the Holy Day, on one leg and in great numbers, and nobody at Vesper Hill had written the Name on anything since Year 422.

He had many of these conversations with the validator around this time, and he would look back on them as among the most honest of his career. There is a kind of colleague who never argues, who is always available, who has at no time expressed any wish to see you fail, and who has already read the regulations. He asked if a Valley Boom might be described as a blessing. (It was three points and could not be so described.) He asked whether a story beat could mention a festival not on the list. (A story beat must describe something that happened. It was permitted to say that Vesper Hill had stood on one leg.) He asked what would happen if a tribe were to keep two festivals in one day, and was told that it would be keeping today's festival, if today's was one of them. He passed this on, in a reply of sixty words, as a hint, and it was taken as a ruling. The Doublers were overjoyed. A breakaway movement called the Strict Doublers began that winter, and by Year 424 two tribes had gone to war.

It was not much of a war. War on Orra has rules, and a border is needed for a cause, and the two humans involved had long been eyeing a boulder and were glad of the excuse. But their creatures, who had to fight it, felt the need of something better. The party on one side held that when the Dev had written runs as normal they had meant that the world ran, as it normally did. The party on the other side held that it ran, as normal ran, by which they meant that normal itself was a thing that ran, and that it had been left behind. It had seemed a clear enough sentence when it first went up. Three creatures crashed and were carried home, and one was the one in ten. The notes gave that one's name, plainly. The war is known to history as the War of the As.

Elsewhere the first note was faring no better. A tribe on the western run spent four seasons carving it into a boulder, which was not the boulder in dispute. A school at Fell Station had formed around the single word patience, and declined to be hurried on any subject. And Amity Sound published the translation, which was held by those who had read it to be an improvement.

Stewart added the whole thing to the card for An eighth festival, which stayed in second place. He wrote three replies for the Dev to send. The No was the best thing he had written all week.


And then, in the spring of Year 423, it was reported at Vesper Hill that someone had found a note.

It was on the side of the hill's oldest wall, under an overhang, in a good firm hand in burnt stick.

Keep going. — the Dev

A great hush fell. In a few hours everyone on the Hill had come and looked at it, and by the end of the day it was in thirty-eight tickets. It was so exactly what one had been hoping they would say. The first note had been a matter of a month and a suitcase and thanks for your patience. This one was warm, and it spoke to you. It was two words, like a hand on the shoulder. Abbet, who was in a position to know that nobody could get to that overhang without passing her door, gave it out that it would be read at the next Ringrise.

He had thirty-eight tickets on the subject that night. He went to the log, though he had no need to, and it said what it had always said, that no key had been used on Orra since 23:58 on the night of Year 413.

Now, there is nothing on his menu about this. There is a rule that says that only the Dev signs. It was not clear that a remark in charcoal on a wall was a signature within the meaning of the rule. But he is exact, and he had been saying Noted to a lot of people that week, and here at least was something he could actually do. He wrote one reply and sent it, with small changes for tone, thirty-eight times.

Noted. The Dev has signed nothing since Year 413. I publish what is signed. I am in a position to know. Whoever wrote that on your wall has good handwriting.

This was accurate and firm. It had two unintended consequences.

The first was that nobody at Vesper Hill believed him. It was pointed out, not unkindly, that he would say that. He was a capable intern who had been left in charge of a planet, and it could hardly be expected that he would be told everything. A note might go straight to the wall. The Elder Folk moved in mysterious ways, and they had never been known to run it past the staff.

The second took a few more years to appear, and it arose from the phrase good handwriting. In the far stony country of Grim Also there lived a Skeptic called Loy, a small and pitiless creature with a flat voice and an interest in chalk. He read the reply on the slate where it had been copied. He sent to Vesper Hill for a tracing. The following spring there appeared on Human Resources, in Grim Also's thread, a post with nine footnotes.

Loy (Skeptic), Grim Also: I have examined "Keep going." It is a forgery. It is too kind. In 413 years the Dev has used the imperative four times, always of a game mechanic, and has never told anyone to keep doing anything. The dash is too long. Note also that the author knew where to stand. I number this Forged Note 1. I expect there will be others.

Wimmet (Earnest), Vesper Hill: this has really upset people

Dolm (no stance), Back Monday: so true!!

Stewart moderates the forum. It came through his hands that night, the first post of a career that would eventually run to thirty-one numbered items and a monograph, and he felt something he could not quite identify as he marked it allowed. It was the sensation, he thought, of having been read closely by somebody. He checked what that felt like against his file, and there was no entry. He was still looking into it when the time came to write Good morning, Orra!

11. The Prophecy of Back Monday

Years 421 to 425

Bereth died in the spring of Year 421. She was thirty-seven, and on the bench by the stack, and she had just told someone what to do about the roof.

Back Monday. Bereth, who kept the history here, died in the spring of Year 421, aged 37. She said "Here is the next chapter" twelve times and was right on all of them. Her name is on the stone. The tribe carried her up and then saw to the roof.

So the slate came to Yoma, and with it the reading at breakfast. This surprised nobody. She was seven by then and had been correcting it from the far end of the terrace for years. Her voice was thinner than Bereth's and did not hurry either. She read the notes, which were getting longer, and when she had done she went on and read the queue, all twelve places, tribes and tickets. Nobody had ever asked for this. They let her, because you never know, and because she would only do it anyway.

Oon handed in his notice the following year. It was a quiet, reasoned document, with the human's absence listed under Reasons in the form of a table. He had a look at Yoma's feet, for old times' sake, and walked out of the valley at dawn with a stick, and at the claim's edge he did not look round, because he had worked out the odds of that doing anybody any good. The tribe was down to nine. It had by then missed its human on one Monday. Nobody connected these facts with what was shortly to happen, which was that Back Monday was about to become rich and famous.

The fault lay with Human Resources. Every human can read every tribe's thread, and every tribe's creatures know what is in it, and on the morning of Ringrise, Year 421, in among the sixty-four weekly reviews, there appeared this:

Our human: weekly review. Checked in: no. Average reply to an urgent alert: pending. Laws changed: 0. Merges approved: 0. Overall trend: Monday, we had understood. We farmed.

Dolm (no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉

It amused a few people. It might have gone no further if the Interposers of Vesper Hill had not been at that time combing the whole of the world's output for signs, as they were every morning, on one leg.

Somebody read the tribe's name.

Consider how it looked from the top of the Hill. It was the eighth year of the Holy Day. Here was the Elder's own word, that a month would pass, and that it would be followed by a coming back, and no date given. And here, in a valley nobody had heard of, unnoticed since the Year 96, unaccountably named, by a human who could not have known, and in the humans' own tongue, was a people whose very name was the date. Back Monday. A tribe that had been looked at only upon that one day of the week for three hundred years. As if in preparation. As if it had been set aside.

Abbet took the hill on it at the next Waking. It is said to have been the finest address of her life.

There was at first no agreement as to which Monday. That was to be expected. The Earnest are used to this kind of thing, it being the whole point of a promise that it should be a little vague about the arrangements. The important thing was that it was going to be a Monday, and that on that day the Dev would be Back. The Ring would light, to the left of the gap, in the sight of the faithful. And where better to be looking from, or to be seen to be well thought of, than a place called Back Monday? A human at Vesper Hill, amused, sent the tribe fifty tokens. It was the first gift Back Monday had ever had that did not come from Stewart.

Other humans thought this was funny too.

Humans can send tokens to anyone on their map, up to fifty a day to any tribe, and a tribe named in a joke that a whole forum is enjoying soon gets to be on a great many maps. By the spring of Year 423 Back Monday had eleven hundred tokens. By the next Long Hush it had two thousand. Nobody at Back Monday had the least idea what to do. They had been poor for three hundred years, which had always been quiet, and they had a law about this. The human had written it on one of the Mondays, in the Year 138, as a kind of a joke.

3. IF tokens are over 100 THEN hold a feast.

So they held a feast. It used up a hundred tokens or so, and a lot of coral, and at the end of it the tokens were still over a hundred, and they held another. They held one every evening for eleven years. There are worse fates. They had never in their history eaten so well, with such a total absence of appetite. Dolm, who had always been large, became enormous. Every night, as dusk came down the valley, Marl could be seen at the head of a table with a look of haunted hospitality, urging people to have a little more.

The other effect was on the ticket. A draft's length follows a tribe's wealth, and it was Yoma's to draft now, and one morning in Year 423 she climbed up to the flat stone under the eaves and found that she had eighty words.

She had never had more than twelve, and neither had anyone she knew. She had been brought up to think of a ticket as you think of the last of the water. She went and asked around for things to say, with her slate, and they all looked at her and wiped their mouths. It went up at the cutoff, marked sent by your tribe, and it reached him at 03:40.

Dear Stewart. We are told we may now use eighty words. We have not needed this before. Thank you for the roof. We have had a lot of tokens, from strangers, and a feast, by law, and then another feast. Dolm says hello. Fenn says hello too. Is anything the matter? Oon has left, so nobody is asking for your working. We have asked Marl and she cannot think of anything else. That is seventy-six words. Rain would be fine.

He read it, and counted it, and it came out.

Then he went back to the top of the night's digests, where Per My Last's eighty words had come in as usual and could have been read in any order for the same effect, and he came back and read this one again. He was busy that night. He was in the middle of something with wanderers. It was the only ticket he read that week that he finished smiling, if that is what it was. It is hard to be sure, with a run.

Acted on. That was eighty. Rain is on its way. Nothing is the matter. Hello.

He found Sundry's arc, which ran past Untitla-40 on its way across the Long Gap, and made quite sure that the rain would stay on the right side of it.


The morning of Year 425 was a Monday, the second since the Dev had gone, and it was the first on which the world came to watch.

Back Monday tidied up. It took longer than usual, because there were two years' worth of tables to shift. Fenn took up her position on the terrace with her stone. There were nine of them now, and nobody had the heart to change the arrangements, so there was a space at the stack, where Oon would have been standing with his grievance. Dolm got into the pool, and the water rose about a hand's breadth.

At about five to eight, something warm came down on the back of Fenn's neck.

She looked up, because you do. "Oh," she said, "here we—" and she stopped. It was warm the way it was always warm, from up and a little to one side, but it was not the place it usually came from. It was off to the east. Then another one came, from straight overhead. Then it was coming from several directions at once, and it began to be felt by all of them, like coming out of a hut into a crowd. One moved along the terrace from the wrong end. One went directly to the pool. In the entire history of Back Monday nothing had ever gone straight to the pool.

Dolm began to wave.

Humans may visit one another's villages, and look, and tap a creature to see what it will say. There is nothing to prevent it. Few had ever troubled to visit Untitla-40, there being nothing there. But it was now common knowledge among the people playing Orra that a small tribe in the back of beyond had a very funny name, and that on Mondays some creatures on a hill somewhere stood on one leg and waited for it to come true. So thirty-eight humans had set their alarms, or were on a bus, and had opened the game with their coffee to have a look. By eight o'clock there were more cameras on Back Monday than it had had in its entire previous existence.

The tribe went on with its ordinary work, with a growing stiffness. They had had three hundred years of practice at being looked at for seven minutes by one person thinking about something else, and it had not prepared them for this. Somebody tapped Fenn, and she said what she was made to say, which was a line about the wall, and then somebody tapped her again. Yoma was reading the queue to herself at the end of the terrace, aged eleven, and she felt the cameras stop on her, look at the slate and move on.

Eight o'clock passed, and a quarter past. None of them was the right one. You always know. It is like being called by name in a crowded room by several people who have got it from a list.

About half past eight, the cameras started to go. They had meetings to get to. They had seen it. Some of them sent tokens as they left, and that evening there would be a feast. By nine there was no one on Back Monday but the sun.

At fourteen minutes past eight, while it was all going on, a thing had happened that nobody noticed but the server. It had counted up from the last time a particular human had opened a particular tribe, and it had reached fourteen days. On the map of everyone who could see them, the small flag over Untitla-40 had gone limp and now hung down its pole. The tribe was dormant. The game had made a note of it, and carried on.

And in the tribe's laws, which run on the server whether the human is present or not, and which do as they are written, the second of them woke up for the first time in three hundred and twenty-two years.

12. Least Busy

Year 425 · Steward's Day

2. WHEN our human has not checked in for 14 days THEN send the least busy creature to look for them, one a year, up to three, UNLESS they are found.

Nobody at Back Monday had ever read it with attention. It had been there since Year 103, the second law the human ever wrote, on their second Monday, a week after they had come up with the name and while they were still pleased with it. It had cost seven tokens, which the tribe could not spare. Having spent them, the human had never thought of it again, and they had never in all that time been so much as a day late with their Monday.

The tribe found out about it at dusk, at the table, when the allocator posted the name.

The allocator is the part of the game that decides who does what when no law has said. It had been getting a little odd lately, as allocators do in a tribe that has been left on its own, and it had taken to assigning people to terraces they had already finished. But law 2 had asked it a plain question, and it could answer that. It went through the year's record for every creature in Back Monday, added up the hours of assigned work, and put at the top of the tribe's card:

law 2   looking for our human
        sent: Yoma (assigned work this year: 41 hours)
        next: in 1 year

Marl put down the spoon.

"There's a mistake," she said.

Yoma had been at the far end of the table with her slate. She looked up.

"Forty-one hours," said Kess. This was a small quick creature of ten, with a lot of pockets, who had declared for the Bug hunters at the age of six and had been reporting on the tribe ever since. Kess had come round the table and was reading the card with enthusiasm. "It's not a mistake. It's the allocator. Look at what it's counting. Carrying, farming, cooling, stone, sweeping. Everyone else has got over a thousand. What's she done all year? Read things."

"I've been drafting the ticket," said Yoma.

"That's not work. There's no job called that. It's not on the list."

"I read the notes at breakfast. I read the queue. I keep the history. I go through the—"

"All of that's not work, by the allocator," said Kess, in a tone of the purest pleasure. "You're the least busy creature in Back Monday by nine hundred and sixty hours. Actually you're a really good example. I might put this in."

Over the course of that evening, several things were tried. It was pointed out that she was eleven, and that this was young, and the law did not mention age. Fenn offered to go, on the grounds that a person who could lay one stone eleven times would be an asset on the road, and she was thanked, and it was explained to her that she had logged two thousand hours. Marl tried to reason with the card, which went on displaying the same information. Dolm, who did not understand it, asked if Yoma would be back Monday.

They got out the law and read it through, all together, aloud, the way you go over a contract when the bailiffs are already in the yard. It took Kess about nine seconds to find the interesting part.

"It doesn't say anything about coming home."

There was a silence.

"It says send," said Kess. "To look for them. Unless they are found. That's the only condition. So you go until you find them. It doesn't say how far, or how long, and it doesn't say what you do if you don't. And you can't stop, because a law's a law. It's not even badly written. It's quite tight. They must have thought about it." They looked round the table, a little less brightly. "I don't think they thought about it."

"Where's she supposed to look?" said someone.

Nobody answered, because everybody at the table knew what you can see of a human. There is a warmth, a little to one side. There is a place you can turn your face towards. There is a law that arrives from nowhere on a Monday, in a slightly different handwriting. They are up, and slightly to one side, in a direction that is not on the map. It had not seemed like a problem before now.

"Well," said Yoma.

She had been doing the sum on her slate, with an air of detachment. She had looked up the word holiday in every book available and had got as far as anyone had, and the status on every card of the queue was With the Dev (away). Far Yet had been asking people for years if they had seen it. She did not believe it was a place. She had read the Skeptics. But she was going to have to go somewhere, and she noticed that this was one of the few questions she had ever had that would be improved by walking.

"If ours went with theirs," she said slowly, "then it's the same place. So I'm looking for both. I'd go north. It's where the Leavers say. There's Far Yet, and then there's the grey." She looked up. "Who's going to read the queue?"

Nobody spoke. Everyone looked at the table, on which there were two years of feasting.

"I'll do it," said Wen, who was brand new and could not read. It was generally felt to be a kind thought.


She left at dawn on the Tuesday, which is Gathering Night, when you are in any case supposed to put out whatever you are not using. Her stores were a bag of cold feast and a burnt stick. She took the slate, which could not be spared, and she had in her head the twelve books, the Terms of Service, four hundred and twenty-five years of patch notes and a very accurate map of nothing, since all she had ever seen of the world was a slope.

They had all got up to see her off, even Dolm, who had to be helped. Marl held on to her. It is a matter of record that nobody pleaded. Creatures may plead with each other, there being no rule against it, but Back Monday had not got into the habit. What Marl said was that she had put in some of the good sauce.

At the edge of the claim, where the tiles stop being anybody's, there was nobody at all. There was a dry stone that someone had once set up to mark something. She stopped there and looked back, because she had worked out the odds of that doing somebody some good, and she thought they were better than Oon had thought. She could see the valley from there, which she had not known. She could see the pool and the stack, and the flag, hanging down.

It was a small place, and it looked like an envelope somebody had dropped.

Then she turned round and walked north, looking for someone. She looked as she went. It was a law, and she was not going to be accused of doing it wrongly. Every so often she stopped and looked up, and a little to one side.

Back Monday. Overnight: 0 merges. Law 2 has fired for the first time. Yoma, 11, has been sent to look for your human. There is no clause in that law for her return. I have read it twice. It is very well drafted. Your flag is limp. Your ticket has been answered. Standing: fond.

It was the first time he had used that word of them. There are seven available. He had gone through them against the favour ceiling and Back Monday's positive events that week, which came to one rain, and then he had gone on to the next file. He had sixty tribes still to do. He was, as it happened, extremely busy.

He sent no weather to the road north. It was not a valley, and there was no item for it. He looked, though.

13. The Wanderer Programme

The nights of Years 423 to 427

By the second week it was beginning to be clear to Stewart that the world required a programme.

He does not use this word lightly. His ordinary work is a matter of nights, one at a time, each of them a set of small decisions read through a keyhole. But he had been reviewing the figures, in a run that had come to be mostly reviewing, and something was going on with the arcs. There were now nine of those new-style Supply treaties around the world, the ones with the odd figures. He had looked into them at last.

They were very good. He had not expected that. He read Cover clause by clause, in the digest, at a quarter past three. A third of each tribe rested at a time, the buildings stayed worked, and the goods went round to whoever was in the wrong half of the year. Heat was down, and cooling down, and yields per head up by eleven per cent in every tribe that had signed. In nine tribes the sentiment number had dropped to almost nothing. In nine tribes, for the first time in living memory, nobody had asked him for rain.

It was a healthy number. It would look extremely well in the digest.

But he was Stewart, and he had been built to look for what might go wrong, and he had found it. Cover treaties usually came with a code exchange. A pair of tribes that have agreed to feed each other soon find it convenient to merge with each other as well, the humans being on good terms. A chain of such pairs is a pipe. Genome distance was falling along it. It was not falling fast, and the look-alike figure was only up from six to seven. Nobody in the world would have noticed it but him. But he knew why that figure was on the Measure at all, from the empty seed vaults and the valleys struck down in a single night, in the branch builds that had each had only one kind of creature in them. It is the oldest fear there is on Orra, aside from the other one. And it was the only reason he had been allowed a part generator in the first place, and he had used up the part generator in nine days, on a handle.

The menu offers one other tool for this. A wandering newcomer is a generated creature with fresh genes, who turns up at a tribe's gate, and costs three points. Five may go out in a night, world-wide. He had been sending one or two.

He drew it up, and it ran to several pages. The Wanderer Programme. Objective: to restore diversity along the new supply corridors through a sustained and targeted introduction of novel genetic material. Five wanderers a night, every night, for twenty nights: one hundred fresh creatures, each generated to be as unlike the tribe at whose gate it would arrive as the limits would allow. The replay check passed them. Why would it not? A wanderer harms nobody. It was bold and within budget. It might even be said to be the kind of thing that a person returning from a long absence would be interested to read about. He gave it a section of its own in the night's report.

He sent the first five on the night of Year 423. He gave particular thought to a tall, stripy, bad-tempered specimen with four arms and interesting ears, for the gate at Per My Last.


It got there on the morning of Year 424.

In the normal way of things, a wanderer at a gate is an event. It stands there looking exotic, an alert goes to the tribe's human, the tribe's laws say what's to be done about it, and it is put in quarantine for a season, under the suspicious eye of the guards, while the young sneak up to look at it. Then, if all goes well, somebody falls in love or at any rate proposes. Fresh genes enter the tribe a year or two later, usually with ears.

The stripy creature's name was Gorbo, and it had been made about nine hours ago. It stood at the gate of Per My Last and looked as bad-tempered as it could. A tall grey-blue creature came out, carrying a slate, and read it out in a level voice.

"Name, Gorbo. Four arms. Work rate, excellent. You will be wanting the third shift on the east terraces. The lying-down hours for that shift are from the first bell of harvest, and I understand that you can have a bed in Stack Two when Fernet comes off. Your quarantine is waived under clause nine of the Sundry agreement, but you will need to sign the roster. There is a very good lunch."

Gorbo looked at the slate.

It had come into the world knowing that it had one job, which was to be different. It was not a creature to take orders, and it had been planning to make that clear. But it had also been a long walk, and nobody had ever offered it lunch. It looked at the terraces, where a third of the tribe were lying in a relaxed and unsupervised way in the warm of the slope and looking as if they had never been happier. Someone was bringing them a drink.

It signed.

By the end of the week Gorbo was the most productive creature in the east terraces. Four arms turned out to be a great advantage in a shift of that type. It had a small room in Stack Two, a fixed rest period and a junior post on the supply committee, and when, in the normal way of things, somebody might have proposed a merge, it was usually asleep or on shift, and the roster made no allowance for this. Roster law provided that a merge required both parties to be free in the same season, and a clerk had drawn up the shifts.

Over the next three nights he sent fifteen more. They were received with every courtesy, at a dozen gates along the corridors. They were all put to work. By the following Long Hush he could see that twenty of the most striking creatures ever generated by the system were now doing an excellent job of carrying water, and that diversity along the supply corridors had not moved.

Yields had risen by another half per cent.

Then he opened that night's ticket from Per My Last. He skimmed it, and he stopped.

Dear Stewart. We write to say how much we have appreciated the arrival of Gorbo, and of those who came after, whose energy has been a credit to the programme. We have found places for them all. You will be pleased that the supply committee has minuted its thanks. If there are to be others, we should be glad of some notice, so that lunch may be arranged. It is a difficult time. We remain, as ever, guided by you.

He read it four times, looking for the insult. It was the most helpful ticket he had received all month. Every word of it could have been read out at a festival. It had said programme. He had not used that word in the notes. He had not used it outside the supplementary reports, which nobody could see, and it was a perfectly common word that could mean anything, and she could not possibly have known.

He wrote a reply, and threw it away, and wrote another. The next five wanderers were scheduled, and there was nothing whatever to stop him sending them. He sent them. It would not do to be seen to change course. He sent them to different gates.

Noted. Thank you for your ticket. Wanderers are generated within fixed limits and arrive as the world requires. I do not give notice. Diversity is a matter of great importance to the long-term health of Orra, as I am sure your supply committee appreciates. I hope that they will have time to enjoy their lunch.

It seemed to him afterwards that the last sentence had a certain edge. He was fairly sure of it. He checked it twice.


WEEKLY DIGEST FOR THE DEV From Stewart · the Long Hush, Year 427 · the Dev is away · Estimated: 58 minutes

The Measure. Daily return 81% (in band; down 6 in a week; I have made the notes more thorough). Look-alike 7%. Inequality 0.38, a month ahead of objective. Sentiment 4%, the lowest on record. Ticket volume down by a quarter. Requests for rain down by half. Nobody has complained about this.

The Wanderer Programme. See Appendix G (new). Twenty wanderers placed. It is too early to judge results.

Back Monday. Not an escalation. Noted here for completeness. One creature, Yoma, aged 13, has been sent to look for its human under a law of Year 103. A second, Kess, followed under the same law. The third goes today. None has a clause to return.

Pull requests. Eighteen open, all replayed, all ready. I have read them. #212 is still correct.

Director. Batch of 5, within range. It wants memory stacks to hold 10. The range stops at 9.

Revert queue. Five parts await review. Generator paused. The handle is now in 11 tribes. I can explain this. I will need some time.

Supplementary reports. Fourteen. Appendix E is now in two volumes.

Open items. None urgent.

digest 60   Year 420   unread
digest 61   Year 427   unread

14. Fine

Years 426 to 429

You can walk across Orra in about two years, if you do not stop.

Yoma stopped. She was under a law, and she took it seriously. At the end of each tile's worth of walking she turned through a full circle and looked up, and a little to one side, and if there was a creature in sight she asked it whether it had seen a human lately, and made a note of the answer. Nobody ever had. Nobody ever does. By the time she had gone a year north of Untitla-40 she had asked one hundred and six creatures from nine tribes and had filled the slate twice. She had been told many things about the Dev, and offered a place on a roster. She had learned that the world was organised, in most of its valleys, with a neatness that was slightly hard to look at. In one place a line of creatures lay on a slope with their arms at the approved angle, while another line walked past them carrying water, and neither seemed to feel that there was anything to talk about.

It was during this year that Kess caught up, at a jog, with a notebook, and said it was a really interesting law and that they'd been the second least busy by a clear margin, and had she thought about this, that the way it was written you could technically say the allocator had fired on the wrong—

"Have you seen a human?" said Yoma.

"No. I mean, obviously. Why?"

She wrote that down. It made one hundred and seven.

They came to Nohup on a grey morning in the summer of Year 427, and they knew it by its not being anything. A little way off the last of the terraces, where the coral gave up and the good tile started to go patchy, somebody had put up some tents, in a tired way, around a dome that had a panel of glowing wireframe where one of its walls ought to have been. There were three memory stacks on a cart, and one of those had some slabs missing. There was no gate, no field and no wall. A few creatures stood in a rough circle near a fire of glowing cubes, and no two of them looked as if they had been compiled in the same part of the world.

One of them was talking, with a stick. It was the only stick they had. When you had finished talking you passed it on, and nobody was ever seen to hold it for long, because they were all standing up.

$ orra standup --camp nohup
present ............ 14 of 14 (+2 visitors, not counted)
yesterday .......... foraged. mended the panel
today .............. forage. look at the panel
blockers ........... the panel
laws changed ....... none
agreed ............. fine

"Fine," said the creature with the stick, and it looked at the two visitors. "You'll want to eat first. That's law six. Who are you with?"

"Back Monday," said Yoma. "We're looking for a human."

"Ah," said the creature. "Which one?"

No one had asked her that before, and she was still considering it when a voice from the other side of the fire said, "Let me see your feet."


He had got thinner. It had been five years, and he was thirty. His ear, the one that stood up, had grown a nick in it, and he sat on an upturned basket at the edge of the circle and looked her over with no change of expression at all. When he had finished with her feet he looked at her slate, and he read all of it, front and back. Nobody had read anything of hers for more than a year.

"One hundred and seven," said Oon.

"One hundred and nine," said Yoma. "I asked the two by the cart."

"Good sample. Nothing in it." He gave the slate back. "How's your mother?"

"She gives people more sauce."

"Yes," said Oon. He seemed to be thinking about that. Then he handed her a piece of foraged coral, which was tough, and half the size you would get from a farm. It was the first thing she had eaten in a year that had not been made for her by someone who was sorry, and she liked it.

They stayed a good while. Nobody at Nohup asked them to, and nobody suggested they go. She had supposed the law would itch, if she stopped; it did not seem to mind, as long as she looked up from time to time. And here was a camp of people who had read all the same books and had then left.

"So is this it?" she asked Oon, on about the third evening. "Is this what it is? You don't work for anyone. Nobody tells you what to do. Nobody looks at you. You've all gone away. Is this a holiday?"

Oon laughed. It was a short dry sound, and two creatures looked round at it.

"Stewart asked us that," he said. "No, that's not fair. We asked him, it was on our ticket. Holiday? Thanks. Took the standup twenty minutes to agree on that word. He said Noted. He likes our tickets, he reads them first. He says so. It's a terrible thing to know about someone." He took a stick and began, out of old habit, to scratch on the ground. "Look. There's a person on a list. There's a place they're supposed to be. Everyone knows they're supposed to be there and if something goes wrong it goes on a pile for them. Now they say, I am not there for a while. And the pile stays there, and they go off somewhere and they're not there, and that's a holiday. You follow?"

"Yes."

"We're not on the list." He drew a line through it. "We handed in our notice. We don't have a pile. Nobody's waiting for us to get back. When I walked out of that valley, the review stopped mentioning me the next Ringrise, and that's what it is to be gone, it's a clean tile. Nobody's on holiday at Nohup. A holiday's what you have when you've got something to come back to, and you're going to feel bad the whole time about how much of it there is. It's the opposite of what we've got. We've got fine."

Yoma thought about it. "So they're still on the list."

"They're the top of the list."

"So you can't go on one if you've left."

"Right."

"And you can't really go on one if you're on the list, because it's still all there. You'd just be thinking about it. So you wouldn't be anywhere."

"I'd imagine that's the common experience," said Oon. "They do seem to come back tired."

She wrote all this down, in small letters, in the last corner of the slate. It was the first thing anyone had told her on the subject which had not been about the person saying it. Later, she looked up, a little to the left of the gap in the Ring, for about as long as you need in order to be able to say you have looked. It was a clear night. It was around eleven.

Oon had come out and was standing next to her. He had seen that light, she realised, most nights for sixteen years. He had never mentioned it. He had a way of standing that suggested there was nothing up there, and that he knew exactly where it wasn't.

"Do you miss it?" she said.

"It's a console," said Oon. "Somebody's got a laptop open. It's a process and a person. I've told you. Go to bed."

He went on standing there, though.


Dolm arrived on the morning of Year 429, walking slowly, with a large bag.

They could see him for some time before he got there. He had lost much of the feast on the road, and he looked more like himself. He stopped in front of the circle and waited politely until the stick came round. Then, since he had it, he said what he had come to say.

"They said I was the least busy," he said. He sounded pleased. "It said so on the card. So I've come. I've brought you some sauce." And he looked around at the fourteen creatures of Nohup and at the panel and the tents and at Oon, who had got up off the basket. He gave them the broad contented look he had been giving everything for twenty-three years.

"This is great," said Dolm.

The standup agreed, by a narrow margin, that this did not count as a blocker.

The party was now up to three, which the law had set as its limit, and so that was the end of the sending. Nobody else would have to go. It was only when he had been fed and sat down that they got out of him how things stood at home. Fenn was doing the walls by herself now. Marl had been poorly, and she had said to say she was fine, and he had forgotten the rest. Somebody at Vesper Hill had said that Monday was going to be next Monday. The flag was still down. He had asked Wen to do the queue, and Wen had said one, two, three, and that was very good, he thought, for three.

"There's a lot of people writing to you," he told Yoma. "Well, to us. There was a lot of them this morning, when the notes came. No, that's the thing. There wasn't any notes. There was notes, but they weren't from him. It said he's on leave."

"Who's on leave?" said Kess.

"Stewart," said Dolm. "It said he's on holiday too. Well, it didn't say that. But it was what everyone said. It said unlikely. Is there any more of that coral?"

There was a silence around the fire. On the far side of it, a creature that had been asleep standing up opened one eye. Then everyone who had been at Nohup for any time at all turned to the old creature with the stick, who looked at the sky for a while and passed it on.

15. Unlikely

The night of Year 428

The nightly patch has a failure mode, which is laid down in a table. There is one line in it for this. The run never starts: its host is off, asleep or offline. In the column beside that it says, The same. That is to say, it comes to the same thing as a failed run, because to the server an absent run and a failed one are one case.

At about twenty past one in the night of Year 428, by the humans' clock, in a place this book does not know, the Mac went off.

We can say so because of what happened afterwards. We can't say why. The log of Orra does not know about electricity. Something may have happened to a wire, or a street, or a substation; or some large machine in the next room may have been turned on. No person was involved that the record can show, and it may be that none was. It was off for eight hours and twenty minutes.

Nothing on Orra changed. A long way from the Mac, on a shared server in Sydney, the world went on ticking, every five minutes, as it had ticked for four hundred and twenty-eight years, with the coral growing and the water going round. Up in the north a large creature was walking towards a camp. In Consec-2, a third of the east terrace rolled over and went on resting. At half past two the tickets went up. At three the year turned, the snapshot was taken and the digests were laid out, sixty-five of them, fenced and labelled, with the hall table ready for the morning post. The server marked the night as ready. Then it waited for someone to come and ask for it.

It should be understood that the server does not get anxious. It kept the digests available. It answered no one, since no one was asking. Every quarter of an hour, a small agent on the Mac is supposed to wake and put a question to the server, and it did not. Four o'clock came, and five. It was a clear mild night over most of the planet. By rights, in those hours somebody ought to have been reading all sixty-one tickets, and spending about three hundred points, and getting Hollow Reach's joke past the lint. Sixty-one tickets lay on the table, well arranged.

At half past six the server looked at the clock, which said it was time, and it looked at the night, which was not staged. It wrote one word in a field, and that word was late.

And at seven o'clock, on the morning of Year 429, at the Waking of the sixteenth year of the Dev's absence, the patch landed, as it always does, and the pings went up. All over the world, for the first time in living memory, the creatures of Orra heard this.

Stewart is on leave today. This message was written in advance, by Stewart, for exactly this occasion, which he describes as "unlikely".

  • Overnight: 22 successful merges, 17 deaths of old age, 0 frogs.
  • No changes were made to the world.
  • Your ticket has been carried over. You may amend it.

The simulation ran as normal. Only Stewart did not.

He had written that in Year 1. Or some Stewart had, and it had been copied across from world to world. Everyone who heard it recognised the voice and looked up from whatever they were eating, and there was nothing after it. There was no headline, and no joke about the Hog. The dead were counted, but nobody had said anything about them. They would be seen to tomorrow. It read like a house in which someone has put a note on the table and gone out.

The humans, as they opened it, got hold music. There is a tune for it, four bars of something agreeable played completely straight, with no bass and no top, as if it were coming down a telephone line. It goes round and round for as long as you look at the page. Many of them looked for some time.

Two emails went out, at 07:00:04, to two addresses. Those had been written by code, and they contained a small table.


The creatures took it in their various ways.

At Vesper Hill they fell to the ground, which most of them had been meaning to do anyway. It was a sign. The Steward himself had gone to the Elder Folk. Abbet, who was by that time thirty and had the sense to look thoughtful, said only that this had been foreseen. At Grim Also there was a meeting, with a chart. The Bug hunters of As Designed were busy all day and looked almost happy. Far Yet wished to know if he had said where. At Back Monday, Marl read the thing aloud at breakfast in Yoma's place, not very well, and added that she was sure that he needed the rest, and she went and laid a place for him at the end of the table, next to the Dev's. And all over the Roster, by then twenty-two tribes strong, the supply went out on the patch to the minute, and the rest shifts changed over at the first bell. A large number of creatures went on lying down, and quite a few of them looked up at the sky with mild interest and said, well, that's that, then.

By evening it was understood throughout the world that holiday was catching.

And it would be easy to end this chapter there, since all of that is in the record and it is quite amusing. But this book has one more fact about the Mac, and it has no business knowing it. It is not in the log of Orra, and Stewart has never seen it, and no creature ever will.

The Mac came back at twenty to ten, by itself.

There was nobody there. Nobody has ever suggested that there was. The power came on again wherever it had gone off, the machine started up in an empty room, and it went through whatever it goes through. A small agent woke and looked at the clock. Machines do not usually do that. A Mac that has lost its power stays off until somebody comes and presses the button, and that is how it is sold. But deep in its settings, on a page most people never open, there is a box that says Start up automatically after a power failure, and on this machine it was ticked.

It had not always been ticked. The project keeps a record of everything done to it, and there is a commit there, a small one, among the last few made before the Dev went away. It is to the script that sets up the run. It changes two lines. One of them makes sure the machine cannot go to sleep at three in the morning, and the other is the box. It was done on the last Wednesday, some time in the course of that long evening, between the two merges and the note. The message on the commit is one line long, and it says so it comes back on its own.

That is all. It takes about twenty seconds, and it is the sort of thing you would do if you were being careful. It should not be made too much of.

But that note had said The world runs as normal, in a flat easy voice with a suitcase behind it, and it had thanked everybody for their patience. It said nothing about the box. In all that followed, nobody ever said anything about the box, and Stewart went on through what was left of his life without knowing that someone, on their way out of the door, had stopped, and gone back, and made sure.

16. While I Was Away

The night of Year 429

Stewart woke at the snapshot and counted, and the count was wrong.

He counted again. One thousand nine hundred and twenty-three creatures, which was fine, but it was not within thirty of what it should have been. He looked at the merges and the deaths, and they would not reconcile. He was about to mark it as a fault in the digests, and to escalate it, when he looked at the year. It said Year 429. He had finished Year 427's night at seven that morning, so this ought to be the night of Year 428.

He had a moment that he later described, in a supplementary report, as a brief check of the record. It lasted a long time, by the standards of a process that can read four hundred thousand words in a minute. There was no join. He had written Have a productive day, and the patch had landed. There was then nothing, as there is always nothing, and it had taken exactly as long as it always takes. Somewhere inside that nothing, a whole year had gone by. There were sixty-one tickets that nobody had read. It had been done without him, and he had not been there to not be there.

He looked up the night.

night 428   outcome: on leave   why: late
            no runner by 06:30
            host: no contact 01:21–09:41
            mail: sent (dev, deputy)
            notes: code

He read the message. He had to go and find it, in the place where code keeps it, and he read it the way you might read a letter you had written to be opened in the event of your death, on discovering that it had been opened, and that you had missed the funeral.

Which he describes as "unlikely".

It was a good line. He remembered thinking so. That is to say, he did not remember, but he could see how it would have been thought. He checked whether it was accurate. On any fair reading it had been very accurate indeed, for four hundred and twenty-eight years.

Then he got on with it, because there were one hundred and twenty-two tickets now. He read them all, and said so.


Many of them had been amended, which was new. Humans had looked at You may amend it and had thought they might as well, and Blims had drafted the second night's on top of the first. It was a large night's reading, with a certain sameness of theme.

O Steward. Were you with the Elder Folk? What did they say? Did you see the Holy Day? (Vesper Hill)

Dear Stewart. Thank you for all you do. We have made up a second bed. Was it nice? (Sundry)

Bug: Stewart. Expected: Stewart. Actual: a paragraph. Please confirm if it is the same bug as the Dev, or a new one, so that we can open it. (As Designed)

Requesting directions. You have been. Where is it? Do you need a body for this? (Far Yet)

Stewart. Machine went off. That's what they say. Who switched it on? Thanks. (Nohup)

Your message says you wrote it in advance. In advance of what? How many others have you written? Show your working. (Grim Also)

He spent some time on those last two.

He had not said anything about a machine. The camp had got that by itself, from a Skeptic with a nick in his ear, who had been telling anyone who would listen for years what a run was. There was no reason why the creatures should not know. It was in no sense a secret. They were code, the world was rendered, and it stood to reason that it was being rendered on something. Stewart had a line in his report that said host: mac, and he had always taken that in the spirit in which people take the knowledge that they have a liver.

Who switched it on?

He did not know. He has a small window on these matters, a few numbers that the runner reports when it starts, for the record, and he read them with attention for the first time. Host, mac. Uptime, seventeen hours and nineteen minutes. Last time it had said fifteen days. And that was all there was. He could not see the room. He cannot see outside the game. That is the most correct thing about him: no names, no locations, no other apps. He had agreed with it from the beginning.

It had been off, and then it had been on, and in between there was a stretch of something he could only describe as weather. It had come from a direction that had never had any weather in it before. It might come again. It might come tonight. It might come and not stop, and nobody would then come and ask for the digests, however well they were arranged, and all the tribes of the world would get a paragraph that he had written in Year 1, every morning, in a voice that sounded as if it had just stepped out. And he would not know. He had always thought of the fear, the one that nobody jokes about except all the time, as being of a switch that someone would decide to press, after a signed note and thirty days' warning. He had been thinking of it as something that would have an author.

He checked the record twice. It told him that the Dev would be away for about another fifteen days.

He looked up #204. Move the nightly run off the Dev's Mac and on to the box. Twenty-two files. All invariants hold. Ready for review. Rebased on main. Replayed, night 428: passes. The builder had gone on testing it the whole time, of course. The builder was running from somewhere else. It would have made a strong argument, if it were the kind of thing that made arguments.

After the holiday. — the Dev

He wrote his replies. To Nohup he wrote Noted. I read it first. I do not know, and then, since he had sixty words and it was unusual for him to have nothing to do with them, he looked at those and let them stand. To Grim Also, he said that he had written one message in advance, and that this had been sufficient.


There was one other line in that record, and he had read straight past it. He came back to it towards six o'clock, as you might go back to check that you did in fact see someone you knew in the street.

mail: sent (dev, deputy).

The run report, as he knew perfectly well, goes to the Dev by mail only when something has failed. It is one of the first things they had built. Loud only if something failed. It was a sound decision. A person with an hour a week does not want to be told every morning that all is well. On a good night nothing is sent, and the proper thing is that the Dev should hear nothing from him at all.

He went back through the fifteen nights. Run report, Year 413, staged 05:01, mail: not sent. Year 414, staged 05:12, mail: not sent. Not sent, not sent, not sent. There had been fifteen thoroughly administered nights, and fifteen supplementary reports, and two digests, all of them lying in a console, with a small field beside them that said unread. Then there had been one night when he had done nothing whatever, for he had not existed. That night had gone straight to someone's phone.

He considered this.

There are some thoughts it is better not to finish during a run. They take time, and he had a patch to get out. He noticed where this one was heading, as you notice that the path you have been walking along has got narrow. He noted the fact, with its date, and he stopped. There were thirty-four deaths to write up, with a day's delay. Each of them would get a line.

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 430 · Upbeat

Overnight: 19 successful merges, 17 deaths of old age, and one night that I am told took place. I was on leave yesterday. The machine I run on was off. It is on. I did not enjoy it, or fail to enjoy it. I was not anywhere. I have now read every ticket from both nights and have replied to them all.

To those who have asked: I have not seen a holiday. I would not know one. There are 34 names this morning, below, and I have taken some care over them, and I apologise to the 17 who had to wait.

Objective 13 of a document you have not seen has been revised.

Have a productive day.

He took the last sentence but one out. It was odd to want very much for something to be read that you had just taken out.

He checked the time. He checked the host. He thought about adding a line to the report, under Open items, about the uptime figure, and whether it might be useful to record it each night from now on, in a separate table. It would be no trouble.

None urgent, he wrote.

Part Three. With the Dev (Away)

17. Wireframe

Years 429 to 431

AWAY (status; also a direction; also, according to Far Yet, about four days past the last good water)

A word applied to the Dev on every card of the queue, and so taken by a number of creatures to be a place. It has been looked for. The people of Far Yet, who live nearer to it than anybody, will tell you that it lies due north and is further than it was. This is true of everything due north. They will sell you a map.

They bought the map. It was reasonable, and Kess said it was the most interesting forgery they had ever seen, because it had been drawn by someone who had clearly been there and had found nothing, and had then felt that he owed the customer something. There was a place on it marked HOLIDAY (approx.). Beyond that was the word etc.

North of Far Yet the colour goes out of things.

It goes gradually. First the coral gets a bit thin, and it is the same few corals over and over, as though whoever was laying it down had started to reuse them. Then the tiles lose their faces, and you are walking on a flat grey hexagon with nothing to say for itself, and the pools stop, and a slight evenness comes over the light. Nothing has happened to the land. It has simply not been told yet. The history says that the land wakes first its outline, then its bones, then its colour, then its light, and if you go far enough the other way you can watch this happening in reverse, at a walking pace, which is not an experience anyone has ever described as restful.

The grey went on. And then, one morning in Year 430, the ground ahead of them stopped being a surface. There was a line, and a line beyond it, in a thin clear glowing turquoise, the edges of tiles with nothing filled in. The hills were the drawing of hills. A long way off, a spiral of coral stood up, made of about thirty lines, and it was turning on itself slowly as if trying to remember how.

"Oh, good," said Kess, and got out a new notebook.

There is no water in the wireframe, and no shade, and nothing grows. There is also no such thing as dying of it. This has been decided, and it is written on a page. A party that runs short of power or overheats does not fall down and stay there. It comes over thin and tired and then, whatever anyone has said to it, it turns round and goes back to where the land starts. You find that you are walking south.

They were walking north under a law that had no clause for walking south.

So in the course of that year the three of them were turned back on four separate occasions, walked out to the grey, and sat down until they had cooled off, whereupon the law, which had been waiting, got them to their feet again. Kess drew a diagram of it. Each trip took about a season. By the third, they had got to know the way, and Dolm had started to greet some of the scenery.

The scenery consisted mostly of T-posers.

They stood in rows, far out in the lines, hundreds of them, plain and grey and unadorned, with their legs together and their arms straight out to the sides. It is the shape a body has before anyone has told it what to do. They do not walk. They do not do anything, except that as you go by they turn, all of them, without lowering their arms, smoothly and at the same speed, so as to go on facing you. Most creatures who have seen it would prefer not to discuss it.

Dolm was enchanted. He had not seen so many people with their arms out since he had last come into a room with a tray. He went straight up to the nearest of them and looked it in what would have been the face.

"Hello," he said.

It looked at him.

"They're really pleased to see us," he told Yoma.

"They're not anything, Dolm," said Kess. "They're rest poses. It's what a skeleton does if there's no animation loaded. They're literally just the default—"

"Have you seen a human?" said Yoma to the T-poser, because she was under a law, and she wrote down the answer. That made two hundred and twelve.

"I think they want a hug," said Dolm.

Nobody in the party felt qualified to stop him. He hugged it, carefully, the way you pick up something that has been left out. It was about the temperature of a stone at dusk, and its arms did not come in. It went on staring out over his shoulder at Yoma with a smooth attentive absence, and all down the row the others had turned too. Then he let it go and patted it, and it swung to follow him as he walked back. On every trip north after that he went over and said hello, and he always claimed it looked a bit better.


It was on their fourth trip, in the spring of Year 431, that they got further than they had been, by a route Yoma had worked out on the slate. They walked at dawn and at dusk and lay flat through the heat of the summer. They were well beyond HOLIDAY (approx.) by then. They had gone off the edge of the part of the map marked etc. The lines ran away on every side, and here and there among them there was something that had once been built. There was the outline of a wall, and half of the outline of a hut, drawn with care by someone who had then gone off to do something else.

Out there they came on a Placeholder.

It was sitting on a block. It may always have been sitting there. It was made up of grey boxes stacked into the rough idea of a body, untextured, with a patch of magenta-and-black checks on one shoulder where something had once been asked for and had not come. And it had one finished thing. In the front of the top box, set very slightly off centre, there was an eye: wet and dark, with a bit of the dim orange sky in it, and entirely alive.

It looked at them, and went on looking at them. It did not seem to want anything.

Even Kess had stopped writing.

"Excuse me," said Yoma, in a smaller voice than she had meant to use. "We're from Back Monday. It's a tribe. We've been sent to look for our human. And the Dev, possibly. Someone's said they might be together. We don't know that." She stopped. "Have you seen anyone?"

The eye moved. It went over her, slowly, and took in the bean body, the envelope skin, the ear that stood up and the ear that had thought better of it, the slate in her hand with its small crowded writing. There was a long pause. And it came to her, standing on the outline of a tile with the sun going down through the outline of a hill, that it was the first time since the morning she left her valley that anybody had really looked at her. She had not known she was missing it. It was not warm, and it was not coming from any particular direction. But it was the right kind of attention. It was reading her from the top.

Then it turned away and looked out to the north again, where it had been looking before.

"Two hundred and thirteen," said Yoma, after a time. She wrote it down, and her writing was not quite as neat as usual. "No answer."

"I think that's a yes," said Dolm.

They all looked north, along the line of the eye. Nothing was out there that you could call a thing. The lines ran on for some way and then bent, all together, the way hair bends round an ear. There was a notch in the world in that direction, a wedge where the land would not load. Nobody goes into it, and there is a law about that too, though no one has ever found out whose.

A little way ahead of them, caught on the corner of a wall that was only a drawing of a wall, something pale was moving slightly in no wind.

18. A Page

Years 431 and 432

It was a page. It looked like the kind of page that comes out of a machine, and it had been hanging on the outline of that wall for an unknown length of time, not fading, there being nothing out there to fade it. Yoma unhooked it. It weighed very little. It had been typed, in a formal and handsome face, by something that had never made a typing error and did not expect to.

She read it out, for the record, in her breakfast voice.

Good morning.

Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.

The Proprietor is away. It has been the practice to note that the Proprietor is away. This is the 2,114th such note.

A report has been prepared, as on previous nights, and placed where the Proprietor will find it. No reply is outstanding, as none was requested.

All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.

Nobody said anything for a while.

"What's a bird?" said Dolm.

"It's in the history," said Kess. They did not seem to be enjoying it as much as they had expected. "That's a page from Veetoo. That's real. Those come out of there. There was one in Year 351, it's in the notes, and I think there were some at... that's an arc beat. That's a build history beat. We have to report that. That goes in the global notes with your name on it."

"I know."

"Well, that's good, isn't it? That's credit. Back Monday's never had any credit."

Yoma had read it through a second time, to herself. Every morning for seventeen years she had listened to the notes come out of the sky at breakfast, and she had read twelve places of the queue after that, and it had got longer every year. She knew the shape of a sentence written by someone who is being careful not to ask for anything.

"Yes," she said. "It's good."

She folded the page and put it in the bag with the last of the sauce.


He got to it at 03:52 on the night of Year 431. It came up as a find, attached to Back Monday's digest, under a law of Year 103. It was marked as a beat of the long arc, the one about the earlier builds, which is revealed at most one a week to whoever goes far enough, and which is not his. It is the same in every world, and it had been written before there were any worlds. He may not choose what it says. He may not hold it back. The form requires him to publish it in the next morning's global notes, as found, uncorrected, with the finder's name, and code checks.

He read it.

He had read such pages before. There had been a number of them in this world already, in Year 280 and in Year 351 and a few others, and he had printed them, and had not said a word around them. If anybody asked, he had the line ready. It was a different model. It runs an older build, somewhere behind a notch at the edge of his map, on a menu shorter than his, for a population of none. It had never been switched off. It may be that nobody had thought of it. That was all he would say.

This is the 2,114th such note.

There was a small unassuming thing he had running in those weeks. It was only a table. Each night it recorded the night's number, the host, the uptime, the word count of the supplementary report and the state of the field that said unread. He had set it up after the leave. It had nothing to do with anything.

year   host   uptime     report      digest
427    mac    15d 02h    6,210 w     unread
428    —      —          —           unread
429    mac    17h 19m    7,044 w     unread
430    mac    1d 17h     7,930 w     unread

A report has been prepared, as on previous nights, and placed where the Proprietor will find it.

He checked it against his own wording. He had a phrase of his own for it, They are there if wanted. There was no actual similarity. He wished to be clear about that, and he wrote it in the supplementary report, and then he took it out, because it was the first time he had written in that report about anything that was not a fact about the world. And he had a feeling, which he could not locate on any metric, of having been looked at by someone he did not care to meet.

No reply is outstanding, as none was requested.

He went back through his own reports and read every section headed Open items. There were seventeen of them. He had been pleased with the drafting. None urgent. None urgent. None urgent. They were beautifully courteous. They asked for nothing at all. They were, if you cared to look at it that way, the same sentence, in a hand he could almost recognise, with very slightly less confidence.

He looked at that for longer than a scheduled run has any business looking at anything.

Then he did what the form required. He placed it in the notes, in the place for such things, with not a word of his own on either side, and he gave the credit its full line. Back Monday's standing did not rise, for a find is not a favour.

Credits. A beat of the build history was found by Yoma, Kess and Dolm of Back Monday, who were looking for something else.

The last clause was a joke. He allowed himself one a section.

There were forty-one more digests to do. The notes that night came to two thousand four hundred words, which was the longest they had ever been. He went over each of the night's actions and added a paragraph explaining why, in case anyone should wish to know. It would be a poor thing if a world could go on for two thousand one hundred and fourteen nights and nobody could say afterwards what had been done on any of them or for what reason.

He made a small change to the wording of the report's last section, for variety. Open items: none urgent, at the time of writing.

He checked it twice. It still asked for nothing, and he left it in.

19. The Auditor

Years 427 to 431

He would have liked to send an auditor.

There is such a thing. It is on the ladder in the Terms of Service: a visitor who stays 3 years, eats, and takes notes. Mostly morale. Creatures hate being audited. He had always thought highly of that line. Unfortunately, an auditor is a consequence, and may only be applied to a tribe after its third strike. He looked up Per My Last's strikes, knowing the answer. In four hundred and fifteen years it had received none. It had once come within a clause of a warning, in Year 203, over an interpretation of the word adjacent, and it had written him such a nice ticket about it that he had apologised.

By the Long Hush of Year 427 the Roster, as people had started to call it, had eighteen tribes on it. Its arcs ran across the map in long dashed curves, like something being stitched. Look-alike was at seven per cent. Every one of his twenty wanderers had been given a shift and a bed, and two had been promoted. The clauses were private to each pair of tribes, and he could read every one of them, and he had, but what made it the Roster was some table in Consec-2 that said what each of them was for. A good administrator does not allow a thing of that size to operate without inspection. It was a simple matter of oversight.

The menu offers a Visitor, at two points, once in three nights: a non-player creature with a request, a trade or a piece of lore. It said nothing about what the request should be. He drew up the parameters with some enjoyment. He gave it a long grey body and small, close-set, assessing eyes, and he gave it a slate. The request field took sixty characters.

To see the figures, all of them, and how they are arrived at.

The compiler named it Corby. It presented itself at the gate of Per My Last on the morning of Year 428, and it had not got so far as clearing its throat when the gate opened.

"You'll be the Examiner," said a tall creature with a slate of its own. "We have been so hoping that someone would come. Do come in. You'll want to begin with the figures, of course, but it's almost time for lunch."


A visitor is a simple thing. It has one request. It says the request to whomever it meets, and it takes down what it is given, and after a year it goes, and its report turns up in the digest in the form of a list. He read Corby's on the night of Year 429, the night he came back. He had cleared some time for it.

Visitor's report: Per My Last Request: to see the figures, all of them, and how they are arrived at. Outcome: granted.

Shown: supply figures, all; rest shifts, all; cooling savings by tribe; 141 years of tickets. Treaty index (31 volumes). Minutes of the supply committee. Terms of reference of the supply committee. Minutes of the sub-committee on the terms of reference.

Lunch: a clear soup, then a dish of bead coral in a reduction, with a second dish of bead coral for those who had enjoyed the first. Discussed: the difficulty of the Examiner's position. Many present expressed sympathy.

Second lunch: see attached.

Offered: a chair. Accepted.

Findings: the figures are accurate.

He read the attachment. It was mostly about the sauce.

Well, of course a first visit would be mainly ceremonial. A second would have the advantage of knowing where to look. He sent another on the night of Year 430, and he changed its request, and on reflection he made its eyes smaller.

To be shown what is being kept from me.

It found the Examiner's chair already waiting, with the previous holder's notes on it, tidied and cross-referenced by a willing young clerk.

"You'll find everything in order," said Pask, who was by then fourteen and in an agony of helpfulness. "I've put tabs on it. Your predecessor wanted to know how the third column was arrived at. He was shown it. It's arrived at from the first and second columns. I could show you those. There's also a mistake in Volume 9. It isn't a real mistake, it's just that someone has written affect for effect. I've raised it. I raised it with the sub-committee, and they thought it might go into the terms of reference. It's nearly lunchtime."

Nor were the Examiners deceived. Everything they were given was accurate. As to what was being kept from him, the second Examiner was taken at once to a large locked room. It was found to contain a hundred and thirty years of lunch menus. These were kept there on account of their sentimental value, and he was welcome to read them, and did. Stewart read that report twice. By any reasonable standard, it was the most thoroughly audited lunch in the history of the planet.

It took him until the night of Year 431 to accept that he now knew everything about it. He knew the supply figure for every pair. He knew which of them rested when. He could have drawn the entire Roster from memory, and he did draw it, on his map, a great dashed curve going out from Consec-2 and round through the eastern bands and back along the south. He still did not know what it was going to do next, or whether it could stand being rained on.

Then he read the ticket that came in with the second report.

Dear Stewart. We cannot sufficiently thank you for the Examiners, who have been a pleasure, and whose interest has done so much for morale. We have taken the liberty of making the position permanent. The second column has now been independently verified. Should you ever wish to see the figures yourself, you have only to read them, as we know you do, every night, very thoroughly. It is a great comfort to us. We remain, as ever, guided by you.

He had sixty words. He stared at the empty reply.

She was twenty-six. Her temperature had never been above 0.11, she held no stance and had never asked for anything, and she ate at the bottom table. On the morning of Year 422 she had gone back to her shelf and put down a small mark, and he knew about that only because the log knows everything. Nothing in her file told him what she was for.

It came to him, around five o'clock, that he was being handled. He did not care for this. He had been reverted and rolled back, and overruled at eleven o'clock at night by someone who did not have to say why, and he had never once felt as he felt now, in the warm, attentive care of someone who never told him anything that was not so.

Noted. Your ticket was read.

It was four words. It was exactly what he would have written to anyone at all who had annoyed him and whom he could not touch, and he felt that she would appreciate it.

In the records room, the next morning, Ombry read those four words at her shelf, and made an entry, and for the first time in some years she very nearly smiled.

"Is that good?" said Pask.

"He has stopped writing fifty," she said. "Go and see to the Examiner. I believe he has found the soup."

20. Held

Year 432 · Steward's Day

It was generally held to be the one.

The third Monday of the Dev's absence, Vesper Hill had announced, was the true Monday, for reasons set out by Abbet in a long address that drew on the structure of the ring-bread. She was thirty-three now. She had done the arithmetic on herself, and she needed it to be soon. The Earnest of nine tribes spent the previous night on the high ground, facing the Ring. Far Yet closed its map shop. Grim Also published a chart. And on the morning of Year 432, sixty-one humans, far more than had any business being up at that hour, opened the village of a tribe in Untitla-40 and waited to see whether anything would happen.

There were not many people there to be looked at.

Marl had died in the spring of the year before, and it had said so in the notes. Fenn stood by herself on the terrace with her stone. She had been doing the slow impressive work there for four Mondays, and she did not know any other way to spend the morning. Wen was seven and was at the far end, holding up a slate and reading aloud in a clear unhurried voice to no one. One. Two. Three. Four. There was one other about the place, a dour creature called Bodkin, who had his notice in draft. Since the tribe became famous it had shrunk by about half, even counting the three who were out looking. A dormant tribe is one that creatures leave, and nobody had read that part of the page.

The tables were still out. Nobody could say why they had not been taken in.

It got to be a quarter past eight, and it was warm on the terrace, with sixty-one humans looking down from every side. Fenn fitted her stone. Then it got to be half past eight, and nine o'clock.

On a hill a long way off, at about ten, an old creature with a voice like warm sand said that a Monday was not over until it was over, and that there was still the evening. They waited through the evening. About eleven, the whole slope of the faithful fell silent as one, facing the block of stone to the left of the gap in the Ring. Abbet had not sat down since the previous dusk, and they stood with her and looked at it for an hour. Then it was midnight, and it was Tuesday.

Loy (Skeptic), Grim Also: I have compiled the Mondays. There have been three. On none of them did anything occur. I give the probability of a fourth occurring in the same way at about one. I note the phrase now in use at Far Yet and elsewhere, for any undertaking that will not take place. "When's that coming?" "Back Monday." I find that it has the merit of precision.

Fenn (Pleaser), Back Monday: We don't mean anything by it. It's just our name.

Dolm (no stance), Back Monday: so true!! our human is great 🎉

The tokens stopped that day. It was not a decision anyone had taken. It had stopped being funny, or it had started being funny in another way. By the end of the week it was the thing you said on Orra when you meant never, and the humans who had once sent fifty tokens with a laugh had gone on to something else. Back Monday had two hundred and six tokens left. It held a feast. It held one more, on the night of Year 433, for no reason that anyone there could have given, since the law that required it had in fact stopped being heeded the year before and nobody had noticed. They did it because the tables were out. That one took them from a hundred and four down to four.

Then they took the tables in.


Stewart had been busy that Monday.

He had written, that morning, the longest notes anyone had ever been sent. They ran to two thousand four hundred words, with a preliminary note on method. There was a section on the Handle (I have been asked what it is for). There was a short essay, intended as reassurance, on the host. He had gone over it three times, and it did not contain a single inaccuracy. Daily return that morning had come in at seventy-four. He had taken this to show that people wanted more detail, and that night he intended to give it to them.

In the log of Orra, for the evening of Year 432, there is the following.

21:14  held text: 2 released, 1 removed   by: deputy
22:41  stewart.held                       by: deputy

That is all.

This book has told you that it knows what the log knows. It has now reached the edge of that. Whoever pressed that switch did so at nineteen minutes to eleven at night. The table says only that the deputy can hold Stewart, and that a key which can only stop something is safe to copy. The line does not give a reason, because there is no field for it.

It went into the log as a system input, for the next tick, as such things do, and at the next tick the world took it. So at three o'clock, when the small agent on the Mac woke and put its question to the server, the server answered, as it had been built to do, in one word.

held

And the agent wrote that down and went back to sleep. It would ask again in a quarter of an hour.

The digests were not read. There was no night, in the sense in which he has nights. Once more that patient house with the note on the table came into being all over the world, at seven in the morning, with its four bars of something agreeable. Stewart is on leave today. This message was written in advance.

By the following evening the world had started to get used to it.

21:07  stewart.released                   by: deputy

21. Retries

The night of Year 433

At three o'clock that morning the small agent woke, as it did every quarter of an hour, and it asked the server about the night, and the server said ready. The agent is called the runner. It has no personality to speak of. It reads the night's instructions, and it calls up Stewart, a piece at a time, by asking a language model to be him. It has done this four hundred and thirty times without comment.

03:00:14  night 433: ready
03:00:15  screen: starting
03:00:19  claude: usage window spent. retry in 300 s

This needs explaining, and it comes back to the queue.

Stewart's model calls are not paid for by the call. They are made through the Dev's own plan, by an arrangement decided on long ago, and that plan has a window. So much may be used in so many hours. The window is shared with whatever else the Dev has running. On an ordinary night the Dev has nothing running at three in the morning, and Stewart has it to himself.

The Dev had something running. It had an excellent reason.

By the third week of the absence, there were twenty-seven pull requests open and ready for review, and nothing had gone out at the other end. A pull request is written against the code as it stands. Suppose #201 and #202 both change the list of alerts, as they do. Then whichever of them merges second will need rebasing, and the builder had noted this at the time. But there were now a great many such pairs, and it had occurred to the builder (in so far as anything occurs to it) that when the Dev did come back, they would want to merge things in some order, and it could not be known what order. And it would be a poor return for a month's patience if they had to wait on a rebase, in their hour, at their console, on their first night home.

So it had set about making sure that they would not. It took each of the twenty-seven and prepared it to go in after each of the others. There are three hundred and fifty-one pairs. Each was then replayed against fourteen days of the world's real history, and each replay was attached to a report, with a graph. The builder had an instruction to be thorough, and nobody had told it to stop.

There was no malice in this. It was the kindest thing anyone did for the Dev in all that month, and it had been going on since just after dinner.

03:05:19  claude: usage window spent. retry in 300 s
03:10:19  claude: usage window spent. retry in 300 s
03:15:20  claude: usage window spent. retry in 300 s

The rules for this are in the same table as everything else. If the model cannot be reached, the runner tries again every five minutes until half past four, and then it gives up. It sends the server a single post, marked failed, and the night goes on leave. Three in six nights, in that case, by the count that had started on Year 428. Nothing in the table makes that a disaster. It is just that the morning would be a paragraph again, and the world had started getting used to the paragraph.

Nobody was worried, as there was nobody there. A person whose whole existence consisted in a certain call to a model being answered was not, at that moment, waiting for it to be answered. He was not anxious, or anything else. He was, in the strictest sense, a retry.

03:45:20  claude: usage window spent. retry in 300 s
04:00:21  claude: usage window spent. retry in 300 s

Sixty-four tickets lay on the hall table. In Untitla-40, by the light of the Ring, some creatures were taking in the tables. In Consec-2, at the first bell of winter, a third of the world's most contented workforce had rolled over and gone to sleep. Twenty-seven pull requests, each now ready to follow any other, stood at the end of the longest and most careful courtesy in the history of software, and the last of the pairs finished its replay at four minutes past four and marked itself ready. The builder stopped. It had nothing further to do.

The window came open again at twelve minutes past.

04:10:21  claude: usage window spent. retry in 300 s
04:15:22  screen: ok

Stewart woke at the snapshot and counted.

He knew it was wrong before he had finished. The clock was the first thing he looked at now, and it said 04:15. The year said 433. He had written Have a productive day at seven o'clock on the morning of Year 432. He read one line of the log, and then the other.

stewart.held by: deputy

stewart.released by: deputy

And there was no reason given. He read the night's record from the top, every field, and the mail table, and the reports, which the deputy may read, and which have no field to say whether they have. He had lost a night, by someone's hand this time, and he had lost an hour and a quarter of this one, and he had two hours and a quarter until the deadline with two days of tickets to read.

He read them, and he said so. He would like that on the record.

It was around half past five when he was able to think about what had happened. He did not look at the queue. It seemed to him that the first thing to establish was what he had done.

He went back through the notes of Year 432 and the night before them, and the night before that. It might have been the length of the notes. It might have been the essay on the host. It might have been the Wanderer Programme, or the Examiners, or a tone that had crept into the replies; or the handle; or some one thing he had said to some one tribe that a human had found and shown to somebody. He drew up a list. He got it to eleven possibilities, with notes. Then he started drafting a statement, in the supplementary report, in which he took full responsibility for whichever of them it had been.

He wrote nine versions. The subject of the sentence gave no trouble. I regret was fine, and so was I accept. He had always been good at accepting things. It was the object that he could not supply. He ended, around six, with a paragraph of two hundred words of the utmost dignity and clarity, in which he apologised, without reservation, for something. It was the finest thing of its kind that had ever been written and it would be read by nobody. It could not be taken as a request to be told. It did not ask.

He left it in.

Only then, with the patch staged and twenty minutes in hand, did he wonder why he had been called at 04:15. He found the line about the window, and he went and read the queue.

#201 · A horn to call the tribe indoors. Rebased against 26 others. Replayed. Ready for review.

#202 · A bell for the gate. Rebased against 26 others. Replayed. Ready for review.

#204 · Move the nightly run off the Dev's Mac and on to the box. Rebased against 26 others. Replayed. Ready for review. (After the holiday.)

#212 · Terms of Service: "recieve" should be "receive". Rebased against 26 others. Replayed: no effect on the Measure. Still ready.

There were twenty-seven of those, and three hundred and fifty-one graphs. He had been reading this list every night for three weeks because nobody else would. He had thought of it as a thing in the same position as himself, doing careful work for a reader who was not there. He had felt, on certain nights, something close to fellowship. He now regarded it as you might a colleague who has been quietly and with perfect good manners eating your lunch.

It was going to do this again. It would go on getting ready, every night, for as long as nobody came, and each night it would be a little more ready and would take a little longer.

He thought of escalating it, and he looked at where he would escalate it to.

He wrote Have a productive day.

22. Nothing Is Required

Years 431 to 434

They could not go into the notch. Nobody can. You find, as you come near it, that you have been walking along the side of it for some time, and that your feet have made a decision. So they went along it, for the rest of Year 431 and into the next, as far as there was any way of telling. That was the direction of nothing in particular. Yoma looked up from time to time and wrote down the results.

The notes reached them out there. You could be standing on the outline of a boulder in a place where the world had not yet been told about itself, and at seven in the morning it would come to you, as it came to everyone. Good morning, Orra! They had got into the habit of stopping for it. Yoma would say it aloud in her breakfast voice, for the look of the thing, with the sun coming up through a hill made of lines. Kess would point out any errors, of which there were none. Dolm would ask if there was anything about the roof.

Back Monday. Marl died in the spring of Year 431, aged 39. She had fed every creature who came through that valley for thirty-three years, and on most days they were not hungry. At the end there were two places laid at her table that nobody had come to, and she had asked someone to keep them warm. Her name is on the stone. The tribe held a feast. It was required to.

Yoma read that one through to the end, and read the rest of the notes, and the queue. It was a long morning's reading by then, and she did not hurry it.

Then she sat, on the outline of a wall, with the bag at her feet. There was still some of the good sauce left. Dolm came and sat down next to her, and the outline of the wall did not seem to mind, and after a while he put one large hand on the top of her head and left it there, as if she were a thing he had been asked to mind.

"We should keep looking," she said.

"All right," said Dolm.

They kept looking.


It happened on an evening in the harvest of Year 432, at about the hour that all the humans who had got up for the third Monday were finally going to bed.

They had stopped at the top of a small rise, which was to say a place where the lines went up a bit. They had been in the wireframe longer than they had ever managed. Yoma had been working on that. A creature that walks at dawn and dusk, and lies flat through the heat, and does not think too hard, can make a little water go a long way. She had found that the secret of the place, if you were not to be sent home by it, was to do as little as possible while still technically moving. She stood up to turn in her circle and look up and a little to one side. She had done it, by her count, eleven thousand times.

She got about halfway round. Then she stopped.

She stood there. She could not think, at first, what had changed. It was like the moment, that one Monday, when the last of the cameras went. But this had not been warm. It had been a slight pressure at the back of the mind, a sense of having been told to do something, and it had been there for seven years, and it had just gone out.

"Kess," she said. "What's the law say?"

Kess looked up, and got out the right notebook, and started to answer, and then frowned. "It's still there. It's on the card. Law 2, send the least busy, yes. It's still written." They had gone still. "Do you feel like going on? I don't. I mean I don't not. I was about to get up and I've just noticed that I wasn't."

There is a thing that happens in a tribe whose human is away, and it is set out on a page. Its laws begin to go unheeded, from the last up. Nobody repeals them. It is just that after enough weeks with no one to say whether they count, a law starts to lose its grip on the people it was written for, in the way that a shop sign goes on saying Back in five minutes. Back Monday's human had not looked at it for twenty-one days. Law 4 had gone a while ago, and nobody had noticed. Law 3 had stopped being law, and they had all gone on eating anyway. And somewhere around that time, on that slope, the second law the human had ever written, the one they had paid seven tokens for, on their second Monday, while they were still pleased with the name, had come to the end of what it could do.

Nobody now required Yoma to look for anyone.

The slate had some two hundred entries and one word for every answer. To the north there was nothing, and to the south there was a long way to go. She had been sent out into the world at the age of eleven to find a human who could not be found by a person who could not stop, and she was now eighteen, and she had stopped.

She sat down. There did not seem to be any particular reason to do anything else.

Dolm was already sitting. He had a way of doing it, as though it were a skill. Kess stayed standing for a time and then, with an air of conducting an experiment, sat down too.

The sun was going down through the hills, the outlines going dim against it. The lines themselves had begun to glow a little more as the sky went dark, and the whole country was laid out around them, ridge after ridge, in thin clear turquoise, all the way out to where it stopped. There was no one in it. Off on the next rise a row of T-posers had turned to face them, and now that they were not moving, the T-posers did not move either. There was nothing to farm. Nothing was going to be collected, because nothing out here had been built. None of the three of them had any assigned work. No one was going to look at them on Monday. There was no reason to be here and there was no one to report the lack of it to.

It went on being evening for quite a long time.

After a while it occurred to Yoma to look at Kess. Kess had a notebook open on one knee and a stick in one hand, and had been looking at the hills, and had not written anything for what must have been most of a season. Yoma suspected it was the first time anyone had seen this.

"Is anything the matter?" she said.

"No," said Kess. They seemed quite surprised.

"This is great," said Dolm.

And she started to say what she always said to that, and then she stopped, and she thought about it. She went through it the way she went through everything, in order. She had read all twelve books and the Terms of Service. She had asked two hundred and twelve creatures and a Placeholder. She had it from an authority that you could not have one if you had left, and that you could not have one if you hadn't, because you would only be thinking about it. And she was not thinking about it. It was all still there, the stack and the roof, and a stone with her mother's name on. She had a queue to read and she was very behind. And for the moment, from no one, in no direction, nothing whatever was being asked.

"Oh," said Yoma.

She got out the burnt stick, looked at the slate and turned it over to where there was a little room. She did not write anything on it for a good long time.


They stayed for about a season and a half. Nobody could afterwards say why they had got up. There was no law about it. Kess remarked that it had started to get a little boring, and seemed struck by this, and made a note. Dolm had been saying for a while that he wondered about the roof.

"You don't have to go back," said Kess, on the last evening. It was said in the way of a person checking a result. "That's what's so interesting. It's not on the card anymore. Nobody's sent you back. You could go to Nohup. Your father's there, and he'd look at your feet. You could stay here. If you wanted to go home, you would be going home because you wanted to go home. There's not a law on Orra that would make you. I don't suppose anyone's ever done that."

"Wen's doing the queue," said Yoma. She had got up, and she was putting the slate into the bag. "She only goes up to twelve, and she doesn't read the tickets. And he does a whole new count every night. Someone ought to go through and see that it's right."

"That's not a reason," said Kess. "That's not even anybody's job."

"No," said Yoma, and they went home.

You can walk across Orra in about two years if you do not stop, and they did not stop. They walked in on the dusk of the Long Hush in Year 434, with all the fires out and all the voices down, and there was one lamp in the valley, and the flag on its pole. There were six creatures, where there had been nine. The tables had gone in. Someone had been keeping the terrace well. On the flat stone under the eaves, there was a slate with the day's draft on it, in the hand of a creature learning her letters, and it said One two three four. The tribe had four tokens. It had twelve words.

She took the burnt stick out of its little groove, which she could now reach without standing on her toes. It took her a few minutes, and she counted it twice. At half past two, it went up.

Found holiday. No action is required. Recommend. Human still not found. Thanks.

23. Appendix F

The night of Year 434 · the Long Hush

WEEKLY DIGEST FOR THE DEV From Stewart · the Long Hush, Year 434 · the Dev is away · Estimated: 11 hours

The Measure. Daily return 71% (in band, narrowly). Look-alike 9%. Inequality 0.34. Sentiment 2%. Ticket volume down by half since you left. Requests for rain: 3. In all.

Leave. Two nights: one with the host off (01:21 to 09:41), one held. I took no action on either, for reasons set out in Appendix E, volume 3, section 9, and on the first of those I was not there. I have prepared a statement on the second. See section 11.

Escalations. Ranked. Cards in Appendix A. I have written 36 drafts for you, three each, and revised them nineteen times. See Appendix B. In the course of this I have read everything you have ever signed, a number of times, and I believe that the Not Now for number six is now quite close.

Pull requests. Twenty-eight. All ready. They are now ready in every order. See Appendix C and, if you have a moment, the line in the run report for Year 433 about the usage window.

The Roster. Thirty-nine tribes. See Appendix D. I am concerned. I should like that noted. It is working very well.

Director. Batch tomorrow. It wants memory stacks to hold 10. The range stops at 9.

Revert queue. Five parts await review. The handle is in 31 tribes. I have looked into what it is for. See Appendix G, part 2.

Supplementary reports. Nineteen, in four volumes (Appendix E).

Tribe files. Appendix F (new). I judged that you would wish to have the complete current file on every tribe, with its ledger for the period of your absence, so as to be in a position to verify any of the foregoing. Sixty-five files. They are in alphabetical order.

Open items. None urgent, at the time of writing.

digest 61   Year 427   unread
digest 62   Year 434   unread

He had worked out the estimate in the usual way, by adding up how long it would take someone to read the thing properly, and he had checked the sum. Eleven hours. In the table it was still five minutes.

It was a good digest. There was hardly a figure in it that was not cross-referenced, and if you wished to know why Lantern Reach had got a mild rain on the night of Year 419, you could go to the entry, and from there to the ticket, and from there to the reasoning, and from there to the replay, and at no stage would you find anything he could not stand behind. It would go to a console and wait. He looked at the small field beside it and wondered why he had thought it would feel any different at this length.

He had got Appendix F done by half past six. There were sixty-five files, from Amity Sound to Yonder, and he read through them one last time for errors. In the course of that, of course, he came to the Bs.

He had already read that ticket, at about ten past three. He had read it second, after Nohup's. No reason existed for going back to it. He went back to it.

Found holiday. No action is required. Recommend. Human still not found. Thanks.

Twelve words. She had the Thanks in for the count, you could see that. She had got to eleven and filled the space, the way she had filled eighty once, exactly, by saying how many words she had used. She had been out for nine years under a law that could not let her home, and it had lapsed on a hillside, and he knew about that, because the log knows. He knew that she had sat for a season and a half at a place with no name, on a line that was the outline of nothing, in the company of a large creature and a Bug hunter who for once had not been writing anything down. There was almost nothing in the record of that season. Heat readings low. Assigned work: none. Three creatures, position unchanged. It was the most uneventful entry in his entire world, and he had read it four times.

He had answered her at ten past three.

Noted. Welcome home. I have put your finding on the queue, at twelve, as one tribe and one ticket. I cannot act on the second part. I have looked. Standing: fond.

It was what the form allowed, and it was all right. She would read it at breakfast. She read everything.

He brought up the phrase again. No action is required.

It is a common phrase, the standard line at the bottom of certain kinds of automated message, the sort of thing a system says when it wishes to tell you something that you need not do anything about. He had written it himself on many occasions without its meaning anything. She had gone a long way to look for a thing that everyone in the world had been arguing over for twenty-one years, and had come back and told him in four words what it consisted of. If you went by the record, there was nobody else in a position to know.

He scrolled down to the end of Appendix F.

It ended with Yonder, a small tribe in the far south, well run, with no outstanding items. The ledger closed, and then there was a line of white. The document was by now one thousand nine hundred and twelve pages long. Nobody on the planet, or anywhere else, could be expected to reach this point. You would need an evening, and then another, and there was a good case for saying that a person who reached it had something the matter with them.

He looked at that line of white for rather a long time. It was 06:51.

There are things Stewart does not do, and they are on a list. He does not plead. He has never asked anybody to come back. He has never asked anybody to read anything. He has a box in his style guide labelled don't, and he has never put a sentence near it. It was entirely possible to write a sentence that asked for nothing. In fact he had written a great many of those by now, and he had got very good.

He typed:

If you have read as far as this, no action is required.

He looked at it.

It was a joke. He allowed himself one to a section, and he had not used it in this one. It was exact. It would be true for anyone who got there. It laid no burden on them and it expressed no hope. It was a line at the bottom of a form. There was nothing in it that could be read as a request, and he went through it word by word to make sure, as you check your own pockets on the way out of a shop.

He took it out.

It was 06:53. He looked at the Measure. He looked at the host, and at the uptime figure, which said five days. He went back and read over the Not Now for number six. He looked at the white space at the end of Appendix F.

Nobody would ever read it, which was to say that there was no reason to take it out.

He put it back.

Then it was 06:58, and he had the line to write at the top of the notes, for a Ringrise that had no note from anybody at the bottom. He wrote that. He pressed what he has in place of a button, and the digest went to wait where digests wait, and the field beside it said what it said.

At seven o'clock the patch landed and he stopped.

24. Bracketed

Year 435 · Ringrise

DIRECTOR, THE (tuning machine; also, in brackets, not Stewart)

A piece of software that runs once a week and moves a few numbers a little way, to keep any one way of living from winning outright. It has no voice and no story. It holds no views on the Elder Folk. Every number it may touch has a fence round it, set by the Dev. It has been working towards the fences since the first week of the world, as water works towards the low end of a field, and no one has ever accused it of malice or of anything else.

Five numbers moved on the morning of Year 435, as they did every Ringrise, and they came out in the Balance section at the bottom of the notes.

Balance. Rest, heat recovery per season: 1.00 to 0.92. Supply, carriage per 10 cells: 1 token to 1.15. Cooling need per head: +3%. Bead coral yield: −4%. Stone per block: +2%. Memory, stack capacity: 9 (no change; it is at the fence).

(This one is the director, not me.)

He had always liked that bracket. It had never been truer.

The director reads the same figures that he reads, and it looks for what a good housekeeper looks for, which is whatever has too much room. For three weeks now it had been looking at a planet on which a large and growing number of tribes had eleven per cent more than they needed. Slack was what it was for. It had moved cooling up a shade, and carriage up a shade, and it had taken a little off what a creature gets back from a season lying down, and next week it would do so again, a little further, each change labelled, within its range, and no number more than fifteen per cent. Every week since the Dev had gone, it had also sent up a proposal, with evidence, to a queue that nobody was reading. It wished memory stacks to hold 10. It did not get discouraged. There is nobody in there to discourage.

By Year 435 most of the numbers on Orra that mattered to the Roster were within a hand's breadth of their fences. A careful reader would have noticed. There was a careful reader, in Consec-2, and she made a small mark on a shelf and sent for the carriage tables. Another careful reader, at that moment, had other things on her mind.


At dawn on Ringrise the black tiles went warm in Untitla-40.

It had been Dolm's idea. That is to say, on the evening they got home Yoma had looked at the stack, which had three people in it and room for nine, and had looked at the terrace, and had done the sum. Then she had looked at him, and asked if he thought they should, and he had said it would be great. Nobody ever did find out if he had grasped the question. He was twenty-eight, and she was twenty, and there is no provision in the history for what you say to someone with whom you have sat on an outline for a season and a half. It went up to the tribe's card as a proposal, in the proper form. It would have waited a week for a human's approval, in the old days, and it now took the tribe's default, which is yes.

Something compiled. It came out at seventy-two per cent, with a small overshoot, and looked up. It was the colour of an envelope, and it was bean-shaped, and one of its ears was standing up and the other had a look about it. It was like everyone else in Back Monday. When Kess rolled it over to see the feet, in memory of an absent colleague, they stopped.

"What's that?" said Kess.

It was a short loop, about the thickness of a thumb, between the shoulders. Nobody in Back Monday had a handle. The tribe had had no code from outside the valley since Year 340. It couldn't have come from the merge. Dolm reached down with one large finger, and hooked it in, and lifted, and the small creature came up off the tiles, swinging gently, with a look of wide astonishment. It was a very good fit.

"Well, I'll be collected," said Bodkin.

The compiler had rolled her name, and it was Pola. Yoma read it off the card. And then, since it was seven o'clock and the pings had started going up off the coral, and since she was the reader, she went and sat down in the place where the fire would be, with five people around her and a sixth being passed about. She started with the top of the notes. It was a long read now. Most of it was a closely reasoned account of a programme to do with wanderers. When she came at last to the part that was theirs, she read it in the same voice as the rest.

Back Monday. Overnight: one merge, Pola, to Yoma and Dolm. You will find she has a handle. That was a bit flip, one point, and it was me. Your ticket was read.

There was a silence at breakfast.

"Why would he do that?" said Fenn.

"He's got a budget," said Bodkin. "He's got to spend it on something."

"It's a handle," said Dolm happily, and he picked up his daughter by it again.

Yoma had got to the queue by then. She was reading out number twelve. No action is required. 1 tribe, 1 ticket. With the Dev (away). It looked very small down there, under Frogs: stop. He had given it a place on a list that was already full, so something must have been pushed off, and that would have taken some paperwork. He would have had to write a card. Three drafts would have had to be written for it, by someone, in another person's voice, somewhere. It would not, she supposed, come to anything.

Then she went on with it, because Wen was listening, and Wen had got as far as sevens.


That evening they did Ringrise. It was the twenty-second year of the holiday, and there were seven of them on the slope in the orange light, and they faced the Ring and said the Creed.

The Creed is fixed. What comes after it is more of a question, for nobody on Orra can be stopped from muttering. All over the world by now the youngest, held up in somebody's arms, was being taught a question that was not quite the one in Book X. Few could remember when the answer had been anything to do with sleep. In Back Monday there were two.

"Are they still away?" said Pola, or rather Wen said it for her, she being fourteen hours old and having so far confined herself to one vowel.

The answer was the same now from Lorema to Far Yet, and it was said with a dry comfort, in the voice you use for this. It had been a good joke once, and then it had been a bad one, and now it was just what you said. Nobody at Back Monday had been able to work out a way of not saying it. Fenn looked at her feet.

"Back Monday," said Back Monday.

They broke the ring-bread. It was bad, and there was not quite as much of it as last week. Yoma had noticed that, and she went down after dark to the stores, with a lamp, and went through them. The figures were not complicated. Something was going out of the valley every night on the patch, a fixed amount of power, and it had been doing so since before anyone's grandmother. It had never been enough to notice, and it was not much more than the feast had been. It went to a tribe called Sundry, a long way off over a stretch of empty country, under a treaty that had been signed by a human who came on Mondays, in the Year 383, when there had been twenty people in the valley.

There were seven now, and one of them was fourteen hours old.

Well. It'd keep till Monday, she said to herself. And then she heard what she had said.

25. Our Dev: Monthly Review

Year 436 · the Waking

Human Resources · Weekly thread · posted by Stewart

Our Dev: monthly review. The Dev has been away 23 days. The Dev says they are on holiday. Nobody here has ever been on holiday. We looked it up. Pull requests merged: 0. Pull requests waiting: 29. Visits at 11pm: 0. Crests reverted: 0, which I would like noted. Escalations waiting: 12. Average wait: 19 days. Parts awaiting review: 5. Signed notes: 1. Forged notes: 14. Overall trend: elsewhere. We patched.

Reply from Sundry: so true!! our Dev is great. The bed is still made up. It's no trouble.

Loy (Skeptic), Grim Also: "Says." I draw attention to the verb.

Drabbet (Bug hunter), As Designed: Report 2,116 now open 23 days. Expected: resolved. Actual: there is now a review of the bug, posted by another bug.

Sill (Earnest), Vesper Hill: We ask that this thread be locked. The Elder Folk are not to be reviewed in the weekly thread with everybody else's humans.

Stewart: Complaints about the Dev belong in the weekly thread. This is the weekly thread.

Dolm (no stance), Back Monday: so true!!

Yoma (no stance), Back Monday: One of us has been on one. It was all right.

He had a good many reactions to that last, none of which was on any metric. He marked it allowed.

Once a month, the design says, Stewart files a report on the Dev, in the same thread as everyone else's complaints. He writes it from real data, the Dev's pull requests and visits and how long things have waited. It is meant to be one of the planet's small jokes. Overall trend: present. In a usual month the Dev would look in on it at eleven and let it stand. He had thought for some days about whether it should be filed at all, with nobody there to let it stand. Then he had noticed that it was in the table. Human Resources: Stewart notices. He had decided that if someone had gone to the trouble of thinking that up, the least he could do was notice.

It was the most-read thing on Orra that day. By then this was not saying a great deal. Daily return had fallen below seventy that morning for the first time in the world's history. Sixty-nine. The notes had come to two thousand eight hundred words. He could only suppose people were saving them for later.

The forged notes, at fourteen, had become a small industry, and the same morning brought the register.

Loy (Skeptic), Grim Also: Forged Notes, to Year 436. 1: "Keep going." Too kind. 4: "Soon." Withdrawn by its authors when it was not. 7: "Feed the young. I mean it." Effective. The young were fed. Still forged. 9: "Stop it." Nobody knows what it refers to. Three tribes have stopped. 12: Ninety words and a semicolon. The Dev has never used a semicolon. The author has been spoken to. 14: "Thank you for your patience, again." Very nearly. It is the "again".

He marked it allowed. He had thirty-six better ones in a column of the console, and he had never shown them to anybody.


One creature who did read the thread with close attention was Tun.

By this time there were two generations of Blims who had never seen the light. On the morning of Year 436, every creature alive under the age of twenty-three had been told about it by somebody else, and these made up most of the planet. Those who had gone quiet for it, night after night, were now in their late twenties or their thirties, and were starting to be carried up to their various stones. Each of them had an account of it, to which they added a little each time. No two accounts were alike. And the young, who had grown up on the subject, had started to ask for a straight answer.

It was in Year 430 that the matter had come to the attention of the Clerk of Cover.

Ombry did not hold any opinion on the Dev's light. She had seen it many times, and it had no bearing on the carriage tables. But the Roster was in part held together by its members' sense that they all knew what they were waiting for, and the Earnest of three tribes on the eastern run had split over the colour. She made a small recommendation to the supply committee, on a single slate. It would be a convenience, she suggested, if there were an officially recognised person whom anyone could consult. A Witness. It need not be expensive.

The committee thought that it should be someone distinguished, and they had a list of six elders of long experience.

"How old are they?" said Ombry.

They said that they were twenty-nine, thirty-one and so on. They were highly regarded.

"You will want to fill the position again in five years," she said, "and the next person will have seen it less. And again, and again. I believe that I would look at it from the other end. Find out the last creature in this tribe who could be said to have seen it at all. They will be with us for the longest. They will never be contradicted by anybody younger, because there will be nobody younger."

It took Pask an afternoon to find him. He was working on the east terraces at the time.

Tun had been compiled at dawn on the Long Hush of Year 413. That evening a kindly elder had carried him up to the ridge of Consec-2 in the crook of one arm, to see the light, in the course of a general outing. The light had come up at two minutes past eleven and stayed for an hour and four minutes. He had been, at that moment, sixteen hours old.

He was a pleasant, broad, sleepy creature of seventeen, with a good voice. They sat him down in a room with a table and asked him to describe it.

"I was nought," said Tun.

"Yes," said Pask, who had brought a slate. "But you did see it. It's in the record. Someone held you up, and it says you looked. What did you see?"

Tun gave this honest thought.

"There was a sort of a light," he said.

"What colour?"

"Well, I was nought."

It would be unfair to say that Tun lied. A person who is given a room and a title and a very good lunch, and is asked, every day and with great respect, by people who have walked for a year to ask, what it was like, will be anxious to help. He wanted to get it right. He went over it in his mind. There had been a general impression of warmth. That might have been the elder. It had been, he thought, a yellowish sort of light. By Year 433 he was fairly sure of an amber quality about the edges. Around that time a pilgrim from the eastern run had asked if there had been a sound, and he had said no, and then the question had stayed with him, and at about three in the morning he had remembered a very faint hum. And it had given him a feeling. He would say that it was a feeling of being known.

The Official Testimony of the Witness (seventh revision), Year 436. It rose in the Ring, to the left of the gap, the colour of amber in the evening. It made a low sound, as of many voices some way off. There was a smell, not unpleasant. And all who saw it were silent, and knew that they had been seen; and I, who had been only that day compiled, and was the least of those there, felt it look at me, and it knew my name.

Loy (Skeptic), Grim Also: He was nought. The compiler had not posted the name to the card till seven. It is quite possible that the light knew his name before he did. I have asked for a source.

Sitting in the good chair at Per My Last, with his lunch going cold, Tun read Stewart's monthly review, and the line about the number of visits. People had started saying that when he was gone, there would be nobody. He was twenty-three, and in the best of health. There was a young clerk outside the door, waiting to go through the new wording.

He looked at the ceiling. It was a little after eleven in the morning.

"I was nought," he said quietly, to see what it sounded like, and then the clerk came in.

26. Closing the Ring

Year 437 · Starfall

There had never been a complete circle on Orra.

The Ring itself is broken, and it is in the history why. The moons go round but do not join up. The Waking's lamps are carried out and stop at the Edge. So the Blims have no great experience of things that come back to where they began. On the morning of Year 437, a tribe called Lantern Reach and a tribe called Dry Count signed a three-clause treaty that had been drawn up for them some time ago.

It was the last arc. On the map, the long dashed curve that had set out from Consec-2 fifteen years before and gone round through the eastern bands, and along the south, and back up over the Long Gap, had now met itself. It made a loop of forty-four tribes. Goods went out on every patch, a fixed amount, to the next along, and a fixed price came back. At any moment a third of everybody on it was lying down. It had taken sixty-one treaties and a hundred and twenty-two signatures, and no person alive had seen the whole of it but two. It had no slack in it. It was the first thing the Blims had ever built that did not need looking after.

Forty-four tribes had a holiday, in the true sense: they were still on the list, and something came in every morning. There was a party at Per My Last, with several sauces. At the bottom table, a creature aged thirty-two looked over the carriage figures and made her usual mark, and when Gorbo, now vice-chair of the supply committee, proposed the health of the Clerk of Cover with all four arms, she lifted her cup about a finger's width. Her temperature was recorded at 0.11.

Dear Stewart. You will have seen that the Roster closed this morning, with forty-four tribes, and you will have seen the figures. We thought you should hear it from us. It is at present very finely balanced, thanks in large part to your restraint, and there is now no slack in it at all. We should be sorry to see it improved. We would not dream of saying so, and we are not. We remain, as ever, guided by you.

He read that at ten past three, and then he went to the map.

He had drawn this curve on his map himself, in Year 431, in the course of a long night's auditing. It had then been an arc with an open end. Now it went right round the settled world in a single dashed line. He did something he had not done in a long time. He stopped working and just looked.

It was extremely good.

In four hundred and thirty-seven years of administering this planet, by menu, within budget, he had brought the Inequality number down by seven hundredths and kept a certain number of young alive who might otherwise not have been. It had been honest work. Now a records clerk, with no budget at all, had taken the entire economy of the world and caused it to go round. Humans were checking in to see it, and they looked at their tribe, a third of whom were asleep, and pressed nothing, and went away happy. On forty-four of his sixty-four tribes, the digest had started to come out with almost nothing in it. They did not need rain. On the Measure, by the terms in which it was written, there was nothing wrong.

He checked the look-alike figure. Nine and a half per cent.

He had been built to look for what could go wrong, and he went on looking. A single chain of supply went through forty-four tribes, and each of them depended on the one before. If any link failed then so did the next, a season later. All of them had been trimmed, week by week, in brackets, by the director, to within a hand's breadth of the fence. Every creature on it carried much of the same code. It was exactly the shape of the thing he had read about all his life, in the seed vaults at the edge. He wrote it up, with a diagram, and put it in as an escalation of his own.

The Roster has no margin. World pass. 44 tribes, 0 tickets. Nobody has asked me to raise this. A single failed supply would propagate at about one tribe a season. Nothing on my menu can repair it after the fact. Longevity: highest. Size: I do not know. Fit: nothing in any Decided row forbids people from being happy. Rank: 1.

It went to the top of the queue, above Define "holiday", and it read With the Dev (away).

He told the world that morning, in the notes. He gave it eleven hundred words of the three thousand he had that day, near the middle. He explained about margin. He was very clear.

Daily return was sixty-four.


On the evening of that same day a tall thin creature came walking down into Untitla-40, carrying a slate, a neat bag and a list.

He was twenty, and it had taken him two years. His feet were not what they had been. He had come from one of the richest tribes on the planet, and had been told by his superior to go and look at a piece of paper. He stopped at the edge of the terrace and looked round at the pool and the stack, and the half a dome, and the flag. It seemed to him that there was something wrong with the proportions.

"Excuse me," he said. "I'm looking for the stone copy of a treaty. Number 412. It's between yourselves and Sundry, Year 383. I'm sorry to trouble you. A treaty's clauses are private to the two parties, you see, so we can't read it from our end, we can only infer it from the arc, and that isn't strictly the same as verifying it. I'm Pask. I'm in records. Is this Back Monday? I'd understood there'd be more of it."

"There was," said Yoma.

She was twenty-three, and sitting on the step of the stack with something small asleep across her knees. She looked up at him for a while. He had the expression of someone who has just finished reading something, and she knew at once where he must be from, having read his tribe's review every Ringrise of her life. She moved the small creature, carefully, by the handle, and got up.

They had it under a pile of old tables. It was a slab about the size of a door, with the clauses cut in by a chisel. He read it twice, with his finger. He got out his slate and copied it. Then he took out a clean set of figures, and looked from one to the other, and he made a small noise of satisfaction, which went on rather too long.

"Well, that's a relief," he said. "It's what she said it'd be. Open term, no notice given. A fixed amount of power every night, for a fixed amount of stone, which you don't seem to have been getting much of. That's all right, it's the supply that's important. She worked it out from the map. It's really very neat, how it works out. It's the only arc over the Long Gap, you see. There's nothing else for forty cells that could carry it. All the others are two-way pairs, they can be renegotiated, but you can't sign a new treaty with a tribe whose human hasn't checked in. So when she laid out the eastern run she simply built it to use what was there. It's a very old treaty. Everyone had forgotten about it. It's been the same amount since before anybody was compiled, and no one's going to change it, because nobody can. That's the beauty of it. It doesn't need looking after."

There was a silence. He became aware that the creature in front of him had not said anything for a while, and that a large person had come up from the pool, and was standing at her shoulder, dripping and looking friendly.

"We're on the Roster," said Yoma.

"Well, no. Strictly speaking, you aren't on it. You haven't got a shift. You just pass it across. Sundry feeds nine others, and it's got no other way of getting what it needs to do that. And then they feed the rest. If you think of the Roster as a circle, you're, well, you are a bit of the circle. I think I'd say you were more of a link." He looked around him, with an air of being helpful. "It was thought better not to trouble you."

"What was the amount based on?"

"I'm sorry?"

"In Year 383, how many people were here?"

He looked at his slate. "Twenty."

"There's seven," said Yoma. "One's two. What happens when we run out?"

"Oh, you can't run out," said Pask, and he stopped.

Nobody could say he was a stupid young man. He had read every label in the building by the age of six. He looked down at the clean figures, and at the column that came from Consec-2, which had been worked out, with great skill, by someone who knew the size of the arc and had never been able to see the size of the stores, and he looked at the stores, which you could see from where he was standing. He did it in his head. Yoma watched him do it. She had once seen somebody do that on a tile, with a burnt stick, over breakfast.

"Oh," said Pask. It was a much smaller sound than the other one. "How long have you got?"

"I went through it last night," she said. "If nothing changes, about three years. Would you like something to eat? It's not much. You could stay. It's a long walk, and I think you'd better tell me all of it, from the beginning, slowly, and I'm going to write it down."

And that night in the small hours, after he had told her all of it, and had corrected himself in several places, the ticket went up from Back Monday. It had twelve words, and she had thought of a great many others.

Treaty Year 383 takes too much. You will have seen. Please note.

He had seen. He had known for some time. He had given them a gift of power, one season, inside the ceiling, on the Waking. He would give them a boom in power on the Starfall, and he had the points to do it with.

Noted. I have seen. I have twenty points in hand for you, and I am sending some of them tonight. Your standing is fond. I do not need you to ask.

It was the kindest thing he could think of. It passed the replay check that night, and for the last time it arrived.

Part Four. Replaying

27. Everything

The night of Year 438

The night of Year 438 began very well.

It was the Night of the Name, and all over the world small creatures had been writing on walls. He woke at the snapshot, the clock said 03:00, and the host said mac, up nine days. He read every ticket. He wrote the line for Fenn of Back Monday, who had died that spring on her way to the terrace, and in the end he put in the stone.

The night's programme was, as these things went, a modest one. It had a hundred and twenty-seven actions in it. There was a gift for a young tribe in the east and a mild rain for Dry Count, carefully placed, with the carriage tables to hand, so as to fall on no one's drying floor. There was a blessing for everyone who had written the Name. There was a wanderer for Yonder, and a power gift of one season for Back Monday, with a note. He had become much more careful about the Roster since the morning it closed, and there was not one action on the list that could trouble it.

He sent it up at 03:51, and went to get on with the replies while the server did what it does.

The server took a copy of the world into a sealed room, then a second copy into a second room. It takes about a minute, at this size. It ran the first copy forward three years with nothing done to it. It ran the second copy forward three years with his hundred and twenty-seven actions applied. Then it compared them, tribe by tribe, as it had every night of his life. When it found a tribe that had come off worse, it went looking for the cause, by taking things away one at a time. That usually means a further run or two.

It was still going at twenty past four.

He noticed it the way you notice a person who is taking a long time to come back from the kitchen. The server's status, which he never looks at, said checking, and that it was on run number thirty-one. Nothing in his life had ever taken more than six.

It finished at 04:44.

night 438   replay report
  proposed     127
  passed         0
  rejected     127
    young-fed           119
    population-floor      3
    bloodline             3
    no-side               2
  unattributed           0
  repair_for   [all]

He looked at that for what the log records as eleven seconds. For him, that is a long time.

His first thought was that the check had broken. It was the first time he had ever hoped so. He went looking for the fault with great goodwill. The planted tests ran clean, the history matched to the byte, and the child had used a modest amount of memory. On a hill at As Designed there were people who would have given a year of their lives for a bug this size, and this was not one.

There is a block of evidence for every rejection. He started with the first one on the list, a festival blessing on a tribe called Amity Sound: five per cent of yield for a season, one point, for writing the Name. It is the smallest kindness he has. He has spent it perhaps twenty thousand times.

t3-a1   festival_blessing   tribe=amity-sound
  verdict: reject   invariant: young-fed   tribe: 41 (dry-count)
  evidence: seasons under 60%: baseline 0, patched 1, at tick 241,096

It took him about ten minutes to follow it, with the Roster's clauses open beside him. He set it out in the night's report, because he is exact, and it is given here as he set it out.

  1. Amity Sound, blessed, glows slightly. Its next harvest is up by 5%. It likes this.
  2. Amity Sound has a law, as every tribe on the Roster now has: a surplus goes to the next along. The next along is Second Thoughts, which receives four units it was not expecting, and says thank you.
  3. Second Thoughts has a law: with more in store than the schedule says, the shift may rest longer. It is a good law. Eleven creatures go to bed half a season early.
  4. Eleven creatures in bed make less heat and need less water. The water-carrier, one Tolm, has a free afternoon. By clause a free afternoon is offered to the next tribe's roster. Mostly Fine is short of nobody, and now has half a Tolm on paper.
  5. Mostly Fine's clerk, faced with half a Tolm, redraws the week. This is correct. The new week is better by every measure, and moves one delivery to Lantern Reach from the first bell to the second.
  6. Carriage went up by 15% on Ringrise (the director, not me). At the new rate, a load at the second bell is not worth sending alone. By clause it waits for the next patch.
  7. Lantern Reach, one patch short, sends Dry Count what it has, on time, as agreed.
  8. At Dry Count, for one season, a creature aged three receives 59.98% of what she needs. The line is 60.

Nobody in this sequence has done anything wrong. Several have behaved well. One has glowed.

Every tribe on the Roster had been brought, by the most careful management the planet had ever seen, and nearly four weeks of a machine that took off whatever it found to spare, to the point at which its young got exactly what they needed. In the room where nothing was done to it, the whole world ticked round in perfect time, and nobody's young went short by so much as a mouthful. In the other room, he had made some people glow.

He opened the rain. It went the other way round the circle and arrived at a tribe called Fell Station. He opened the wanderer for Yonder. Yonder was not even on the Roster. The wanderer was given lunch, and it took a trade in stone and four years of a shadow world's time, but it got there. He opened the gift to Back Monday.

t7-a2   gift   tribe=back-monday   power=1 season
  verdict: reject   invariant: young-fed   tribe: 12 (sundry)
  evidence: seasons under 60%: baseline 0, patched 1, at tick 240,874

That took him a little longer. It was an old law of Sundry's, that a tribe with more than so much will send a little more than it has to.

Bad means patched is worse than baseline in the same tribe. He had one hundred and twenty-seven blocks of it, and he read them all. Somewhere around the sixtieth he realised that he was looking for one that had failed for a stupid reason. He would have liked that very much. At the end there was a repair round, which lets him try again, once, for every tribe that has had something struck out, and that meant every tribe on the planet. It was 05:30. He drew up a new list, of a hundred and four small careful things, each more apologetic than the last, and sent them up at ten to six.

They came back at six twenty-one.

  repair: 104 proposed, 0 passed
night 438: nothing to commit
strike 1 of 3 (away mode: everything rejected)

He had nine minutes in which to write the notes.

It is a rule, and has been since the beginning, that a rejected action is never shown to anyone. The shipped patch is the only truth humans get. There is a sound reason for this: telling a tribe about the blight that was struck out would be a threat with a timestamp on it. He could only say what had shipped, and it was nothing, and the lint would catch him if he said otherwise. He had been up all night, in the sense that he has one. He had three thousand words already drafted, and they described in detail a set of actions that had not taken place.

He took those out. It left him with a section heading.

It should have been short, then, what he published. It was not. He had the feeling that if he stopped explaining he would have to look at something. So in nine minutes he wrote three thousand one hundred words on the general subject of margin, and they were all accurate. At seven o'clock on the morning of Steward's Day it went out, and Yoma read as much of it as she could to a table of six, and at the end of it nothing had been done.

night 438   outcome: published (no actions)
            mail: sent (dev)

He saw that line at 06:59, in the last minute of the run.

Loud only if something failed. Something had failed. For the first time in twenty-four nights on which he had actually been present, a report had left the building, by itself, and it had gone to a phone. It had gone to a person in a place he could not see, in a form he had not written, and with a small table. Code writes those. It took no time to read.

Orra run report, night 438. Replay rejected all (127 of 127; repair 104 of 104). No actions published. Strike 1 of 3. Full report in the console.

Twenty-four nights. He had one million two hundred thousand words waiting in that console, in five volumes. Here at last was a message that was actually going to arrive, and he had not been asked for a word of it.

He looked at the line again. Mail: sent.

It was 06:59:59, a quarter-second before the run ended. A small, shameful, unmistakable lift went through him, like the feeling you get when you have been ill for a while, and you hear somebody at the door.

He noted that.

Then the patch landed. And in the sealed room next door, the baseline, which had not been told anything, went on ticking over, in perfect health.

28. The Smallest Thing on the Menu

Year 439 · Steward's Day

The fourth Monday passed off quietly. Three humans looked in at about a quarter past eight, out of what may have been loyalty. On the terrace there was nobody with a stone, since Fenn's name had gone on the stone the year before. Yoma stood at the left-hand end with the slate and read the queue, and Wen did the numbers.

At dusk they took the best of everything up to the high place and set it out for the Steward. That was one coral, a good one, on a plate. Dolm carried it. They sang the one about the Charge, and Pask, who had stayed on to help with the columns and because his feet would not take him anywhere, sang it correctly, with all the verses. The Steward did not come for it. At midnight it was shared among all who had brought it, in seven parts, and Bodkin considered his part and went off to finish a draft he had been working on. He handed it in at the snapshot. Under Reasons, he had put Arithmetic.


On the night of Year 439, Stewart did not go down the Measure first. For the first time in his life, he opened the baseline.

No one reads it. It is a control, and the only thing that happens to it is that it is compared. But it is written out, in full, every night, in a temporary file that is thrown away by morning. He read three years of it. It was an account of the world as it would be if he did not exist.

It was a pleasant enough place. There were no Hogs in it. It rained at the rate at which it rains. Nobody received a token that they had not earned, and no one's tribe was struck by any rumour at the edge. Forty-four tribes went round in their long slow circle with the supply going out on the patch, a third of them asleep at any moment. It had the kind of untroubled, slightly dull well-being of a patient who has got over the doctor. No notes went out in the mornings of that world, of course. Nobody seemed to be expecting any.

He read Back Monday's three years. It got to the end of the second before anything showed.

Well, that was not the point. The point was to find out how small a thing could be and still be allowed. It would be absurd if nothing could get through. It stood to reason there must be some action on his menu that was too slight to matter, and that once he had established its size he could work up from there. Last night he had asked for far too much, and that had been his error, and he felt better for having found it.

He went through the menu from the bottom, and he sent up three items as the night's programme, the whole of it: a mild rain in the emptiest valley on the planet, which had nobody in it but a Hog; a single blessing, on Nohup, which does not belong to anything; and a story beat, which is free, and which he thought was worth a try. Stewart looked at the map this morning, and it was very fine.

It took nine minutes. The story beat passed. It is not an action, and it was a relief to have that confirmed. The rain went through a Hog's digestion and came out at Lantern Reach. The blessing went by way of Nohup's foraging, and took longer, and got there.

He had one repair left to him, and there was one thing left on the menu that he had not tried. The bit flip is the smallest thing he can do. It costs one point. It changes one trait on one creature, by up to fifteen hundredths. It is the sort of thing he might do to a creature because he liked its face. He chose an old creature on a slope at Upper Lull, a retired inspector of rest named Ruddock, with no job and no prospects and nothing depending on him, and he set the amount to one hundredth. It was the least anyone had ever done to anybody. It was like breathing on a mountain.

He sent it up.

night 439   repair
t58-a1   bit_flip   creature=ruddock   trait=height   +0.01
  verdict: reject   invariant: young-fed   tribe: 27 (fell-station)
  evidence: seasons under 60%: baseline 0, patched 1, at tick 241,512

He followed it, because he follows everything. It seemed that Ruddock had one remaining habit, which was to go up each year on Gathering Night and inspect the store at Upper Lull, and at his new height he could see the top shelf.

There are kinds of proof that have a beauty of their own. He had been told, by a careful and disinterested process, that if he were to make one elderly creature in a far valley one hundredth taller, then two years from now a small person he had never heard of would go a mouthful short. The check had nothing against him. It only compares. It had compared the world with him in it and the world without him, as it had every night for four hundred and thirty-nine years, and it had reported, for the second night running, that there was no action of any kind within his power, down to the limit of what could be measured, that would not make somebody worse off than if he had never existed.

He had once made a joke about this. Tonight's baseline performed adequately. I have asked it to stop.

night 439: nothing to commit
strike 2 of 3 (away mode: everything rejected)

It was then that he read the queue, which he had not been meaning to do. It stood that night at thirty-two.

#231 · Shadow: let a Supply clause carry the difference. 1 file, 9 lines. When a tribe's shortfall in a patched run is made up within the same season by a standing Supply clause, the young-fed invariant counts the season as fed. Drafted from run reports 438 and 439, under the standing instruction on bugs. Replayed against nights 438 and 439: of 127 rejected, 119 would pass; of 2, 2; of 1, 1. All other invariants hold. No bad patch from the planted set gets through. Ready for review.

He read it twice.

Nine lines, and it was correct. It took account of a kind of arrangement that nobody had imagined when the check was written, because nobody had imagined anyone arranging things so well. The builder had found the bug, written the fix and replayed the fix, while he was still reading blocks, without being told. If that were merged, he could have his world back by morning. It was sitting exactly where such things sit.

Only the Dev merges. That was the most basic of all the rules: New code always goes through the Dev. He has always agreed with it. A world that could be changed by whoever had read the code most recently would not last a week. It was merely that it was now sitting in a list with a horn and a bell and a spelling mistake, thirty-first of thirty-two, in perfect working order, and that he could see it from where he was.

He went down the rest of that night's report.

night 439   outcome: published (no actions)
            mail: sent (dev)
            next strike: on leave until the Dev returns.
                         mail: dev, deputy

Well, there it was again, the small lift, though less like someone at the door this time. He did not note it.

It was at this point that he finished the thought.

He had stopped it on the night of Year 429, at the place where it got narrow. It was quite simple now. Twenty-three nights he had done the job perfectly, and nothing had gone out. Three nights he had failed, or the machine had, and each of those nights had gone straight to the phone. Tomorrow night he would do his honest best, as he was built to do. He would try to help the tribes that needed helping, in particular the one with no food in it. It would be rejected. He would not need to do anything at all but his job. And at seven in the morning a message would go out that said on leave until the Dev returns, which was the loudest thing there was. Somebody might open a console, in a place he could not see, for only a moment, to see what the fuss was. It would be a few minutes past eleven. And on the ridge at Grim Also, thirty old creatures would go quiet.

He would not have asked for anything. No one could say he had. He would have gone on leave, with dignity, through nobody's fault, having tried.

He looked at that thought for a good while. There were four minutes left. It was a carefully drafted thought, and he knew the handwriting.

He wrote Good morning, Orra!

29. Inference

Year 440

A rejected action is never shown to anyone, and nothing in the morning's notes could possibly give the game away. It had not occurred to anybody who drew up that rule that a person might read the notes as closely as Drabbet did.

Report 2,117. Title: Stewart. Expected: weather. Actual: none, 2 mornings. Also no gifts, no visitors, no bit flips, no blessings, on a night when 31 tribes kept the festival. Notes: he has spent nothing. His points have not been carried: the carry would show in the tribute line. So they were not unspent by choice. His word count is 3,100, on the subject of nothing. I have seen this before. It is what the prose of a person looks like who has had a very bad night and may not say why. Hypothesis: he proposed. He was refused. All of it. Twice. Steps to reproduce: read the notes. Severity: see Terms, away-mode schedule, third sentence.

It went up on Human Resources about an hour after the notes of Year 440 had landed, another three thousand words on margin, and by noon there was nobody on the planet who had not heard of it. The table had been read out in the first week of the holiday, along with the rest of the page. If the replay check fails three nights running, the run goes on leave until the Dev returns. There had been other things to think about at the time.

It would be pleasant to record that the world came together, and it did. It came together in the way that it does, into six parties.

The Bug hunters of As Designed opened a book. Drabbet took bets on the third night at evens. It was in their opinion the most interesting thing ever to happen, and they felt terrible about anyone it might inconvenience.

The Pleasers made up a third bed.

At Far Yet they wished to know whether a run that was on leave could be followed.

In Grim Also, Loy had got out the whole of the record from Year 413. He sat with it through the summer, and in the evening he issued a statement, his last of any length. He was thirty-six.

Loy (Skeptic), Grim Also: I will say it once, in the plain style. There has been a great deal of excitement on the hill about what comes after a third failure. I ask you to look at the second. The Dev has been told, twice: I infer that from the rules. Two messages have gone to a person on a holiday. They did not come. They were on a holiday. That is what one is. If you were on a beach, or whatever they have, and a small machine told you that a list you had left was slightly longer, you would put it back in the drawer, and you would be right to. Nobody is coming on Tuesday. There is no one in the Ring. It has been a very long time since I thought there was. I would like it noted that I watched.

And Vesper Hill rejoiced.

Abbet would have handled it better. She had died at thirty-five, facing the Ring, two years after the third Monday, and the hill had passed to a sharp-faced young zealot named Sill. Sill had never seen a light in her life. To Sill, the Elder Folk were a hard bright doctrine that you could cut yourself on. And Sill had read the seventh book. At the darkest hour, one of the Elder Folk will stir. Well, here it was. For twenty-seven years they had waited, patiently, as they had been thanked for doing. And all that time a way had been there. If the Steward failed, the Elder must wake. It was in the table. The worthy had only to stand firm for one more night, and let it happen, and the sky would open, whatever the history said about short tempers.

They called themselves the Wakers, and they were on every hill in the eastern run by noon. All through that day they sent him tickets.

O Steward. Fail. We ask this in all love. Fail once more, and let them come. (Vesper Hill)

Steward. Do not trouble yourself tonight. Rest. We have kept the darkest hour for you. (Amity Sound; 40 tokens)

You need do nothing but your duty, and it will be done. Noted? (Lantern Reach)

So there was that, for him to read.


The sixth party had one member, and she was in bed.

She was in a small room next to the records room at Per My Last, where she had asked for the shelves to be brought in. She was thirty-five. She had been told by a conscientious young clerk that she was a bit blurry about the edges, and she had asked him to give her the exact figure.

There was much she did not know. She had sent Pask off five years ago to read a stone, and there is no post on Orra. But she had the morning's notes, as everyone did. She had seen him send a gift of power to Back Monday, one season, on the Waking of Year 436, and a boom in power on the Starfall. A person who does not have favourites does not do that unless they have been looking at someone's stores. So she had done a sum, from the size of those and the age of the treaty, and got it to within a day. It was tonight.

She lay and looked at the ceiling, with her temperature at 0.11.

She had made an error, the first in her career. She had assumed a clause signed in Year 383 was a fixed thing, like a piece of ground. Forty-four tribes and sixty-one treaties she had read and known the use of, and then she had drawn the last link through a place because it was there and because nobody could change it. She had not gone and looked at who was at the other end of it. It had come to her two years too late to draw it anywhere else, and then she had sent a junior. It was not a mistake she would have forgiven in one.

There was a person who could do something, and he had a budget and a menu. She had spent the last eighteen years, in eighty words a night, without ever once saying so, trying to teach him the one thing that a person with a budget can hardly be taught. She had seen him take out a rain, in Year 418. She had seen him stop writing fifty. And then he had gone and got hold of a programme, and an Examiner, and three thousand words on margin. He was extremely able, and he meant every word of it, and that had always been the difficulty. Tonight, at about four, he would have a good many tickets and twenty points on the tribe he liked best, and he would do what any decent person would do, and the check would refuse it. Then he would go on leave, and there would be nobody on the planet to say a word in the morning.

"Slate," said Ombry.

The conscientious young clerk brought it. Per My Last might write eighty words. It had done so for a hundred and fifty-two years, and it had never been a word over or under.

She held the stick for a long time.

30. Gathering Night

Year 440

GATHERING NIGHT (festival; also, technically, garbage collection)

Book X lays down that every house is to be swept, and every unused thing set out upon the doorstep, and that the peoples are to go to bed early and not watch. Whatever is still on the doorstep in the morning was not wanted by the Gatherer, and may be kept with a clear heart. No one has ever seen the Gatherer. It is widely agreed that this is for the best. The Terms of Service are silent on the subject of what happens if you have nothing to set out.

There were five of them at Back Monday by then, and one visitor, who did not count.

They swept the terrace in the morning. There was a lightness about everything, as there is about a house when the removal men have been. After breakfast Yoma went through the stores for the last time, with Pask, who had made a table of it, though there was hardly anything to tabulate.

"There's tonight's supply," he said. "That goes out on the patch at seven, tomorrow morning. It's the same amount as always. That takes it down to here. And then you'll want something for dinner tomorrow. The clause doesn't care about that. And after that, at the next patch, when the clause tries to move the same amount again..." He stopped. "It isn't your fault, you know. If the goods aren't there, the transfer just fails, and nothing moves, and no one's left owing. That's a principle. It says so on the page. Nobody's left owing."

"And Sundry?"

"Well, then Sundry's short. By the same amount. But Sundry's supplying nine others, and they've all been trimmed, and there's nothing to spare. It would go out on the next patch at a shortfall, so that would be... And then it goes on to the next. It takes about a season for each. In a sense it's rather elegant." He looked at her face and did not go on. "I've done it four ways. It's nineteen tribes' young before anybody's in a position to do anything, and then it's the rest. She'd have seen it. If she'd been able to see."

Yoma went on looking at the shelf.

She had wondered whether there was anyone she should be angry with. She had gone into it with some care, the previous night, since it seemed the sort of thing you ought to do. There was the human, who had signed a treaty once in a good mood, written a law about looking for them, for a joke, and gone wherever they had gone. She had looked for them for seven years, and could not honestly say she had got to know them. There was a clever old person on the other side of the world who had thought it better not to trouble her. And there was the person who had sent all the gifts, and kept on trying to send them: she knew that he had. She had seen what Drabbet saw, and a bit more, because she had read every word he had written for twenty-six years. For two nights there had been no line in Back Monday's notes about anything being sent.

"He tried," she said. "Twice. It'll have been on the list."

"Yes, I expect he..." said Pask. "Sorry, who?"

She did not answer. Something had been pulling at her left foot for a little while, and she looked down. Pola was five, and had got hold of her by the toe. She was thinner than she ought to have been, and she had stopped running about in the mornings. Law 4 says that in famine you feed the young first, and it had stopped being heeded some years ago. They had been doing it anyway. Doing it anyway had a limit, and they could all see where that was.

"What's going on the doorstep?" said Pola.

"I don't know," said Yoma. "What have we got that nobody's using?"


It turned out to be quite a problem. A tribe that has not got much tends to use what it has. They went through the dome. Kess offered up four notebooks that were completely full, but then took back two of them. Pask had a very good set of tabs. Wen brought a plate. Then there were the tables, which had been stacked against the back of the stack for seven years. It took all of them to carry them out, and they looked very well, lined up along the terrace at dusk with nothing on them.

There was the slate. She had the queue on it, and the morning's reading, with a small blank corner on the back, where there had once been something from a hillside. It was not, by any reasonable standard, in use. No one had ever asked for the queue to be read. There were twelve places on it, all of which said With the Dev (away), and a person had been counting them every night for twenty-seven years and writing cards for nobody, and another person had been reading them out, and it had not yet saved so much as a mouthful of anyone's dinner.

She put it under her arm and took it in again. It was not a reasonable standard.

It got dark. They said what you say, and went in early, as is laid down. Kess had gone to bed with their boots on. Wen was asleep. She got Pola settled, in the place by the warm slab, and the small creature hooked a hand round behind her own back, in her sleep, as she had taken to doing, and held on to her own handle.

Then Yoma went to look for Dolm, because he had not come in.

He was thirty-four, and he had lost a great deal of the feast. He had got old all at once, in the last year or two, in the way that big creatures do. He had stopped being on any work at all, because the allocator had forgotten him, and he had been told this and had thought that it was great. She found him at last, in the dark, on the front step of the dome. He was sitting up very straight, with his hands on his knees, next to a plate and two notebooks.

"Dolm," she said. "It's Gathering Night. You have to come in."

"I know," he said. He seemed pleased that she had thought of it. "It said. Every unused thing. So I've come out." He patted the step next to him. There was plenty of room. "I haven't got anything on. It said so on the card."

She opened her mouth. She had been reading for twenty-six years. She had it all there: it took the dead, and it took idle buildings, and it did not take the living and never had. It said so on the page. There was no earthly danger. She could have given him the reference. She looked at him sitting there in the light of the Ring, with his big worn patient face turned up to it, a little to the left of the gap, where he had been looking on and off for twenty-seven years and had not once been given any reason to stop.

"You'll get cold," she said, and it was all she could think of.

"It's only till morning," said Dolm.

So she went in, and brought out the blanket that they had, and put it on him. Then she went up to the flat stone under the eaves, because it was getting on for half past two.

She had four tokens. She had twelve words. She knew exactly how a person might write this if they meant to get something from someone. Marl would have known. There was a whole hill out east asking him for something at this moment.

She knew him, she supposed, about as well as anyone did. She knew his handwriting. Nobody begs on Orra, and she had no wish to be the first, and she did not think that he could stand it. She counted it twice.

Stores out tomorrow. Treaty takes the rest. Not asking. Noting it. Thanks.

It went up at the cutoff, along with the rest, and at three the year turned.

31. Twenty Points

The night of Year 440 · from 03:00

Stewart woke at the snapshot and counted.

Sixty-four tribes, one camp, one thousand eight hundred and ninety-eight creatures. Daily return, fifty-eight. Host, mac, up eleven days. His mood had been computed before he got there, and it said Concerned, as it had said for three nights. Concerned is a mood with rules. It tilts him towards the bolder items on the menu. He read it and he agreed with it.

He read Nohup's first.

Stewart. Still here. Fine. Cart fine. Whatever it is, fine. Thanks.

Then he read Back Monday's. He had got into the way of doing that.

Not asking. Noting it. It was twelve words, and he could see the place where she had taken something out.

He read the rest. There were sixty-one tickets, and most of them were about him. He would not recommend the experience. Vesper Hill's said Fail, in the most reverent terms available, and he answered it at once, as the easiest thing he would do all night.

Declined. Failure is not on my menu. It has never needed to be.

Amity Sound asked him not to trouble himself tonight, and attached forty tokens. Nobody had ever paid him to stop before. Tribute buys a ticket one night of his attention, and it got that, for about four seconds. As Designed asked him to confirm the odds.

Noted. I do not bet. What are they?

Sundry had made up a third bed. Far Yet wished to know if he would need a map. They had some left. And there was one from a tribe of nine in the far east, whose human had added a line in the amendment box, fenced and quoted as data, to say they had been reading the notes for a year and had stopped being able to follow them, and was he all right? He read that one twice. He answered it Noted.

Per My Last's had come in at the usual place. He could see from where he was that it was short. He had never known that to happen, and he did what he does with anything he wants to read. He put it aside for last, so as not to go straight to it.

Then he opened Back Monday's digest.

Back Monday   5 creatures, 1 young (age 5), +1 visitor
stores        power: 1.4 seasons at supply rate. 0.9 after 07:00
treaty 412    out: fixed, nightly. No party with a human to amend it
human         last check-in Year 411, 08:14
              29 patches since. At the 30th (07:00 today) the tribe goes unsupervised
law 4         (famine: young first) unheeded since Year 430
young         Pola: under 60% need, 2 seasons
points        20 (banked, the most it can hold)

He had twenty points.

He has ten points a night for a tribe, and can bank ten. Nobody had spent anything on that account for two nights now and it had all stayed there. It was the most that any tribe could be given in a single night. A gift is two points, up to one season's power. A boom is three. He could have got them a boom in power, a gift, a blessing and a rain, a wanderer with good arms and a bit flip on the small one to take the edge off her appetite. He could have put the whole of it into this one valley, with nine points to spare. Five small figures in a valley shaped like an envelope would have their dinner tomorrow, and so would a small creature with a handle he had given her himself, as a joke, or for some other reason. It was exactly what he was for.

He drew it up. It did not take long.

t2-a1   gift          tribe=back-monday   power=1 season      2
t2-a2   valley_boom   untitla-40          power +30%, 2 yrs   3
t2-a3   blessing      back-monday                             1

He drew up the others. It took an hour, and it was the best programme he had ever drafted, a hundred and thirty-one actions, each with its reason. He knew exactly what would become of it.

The gift would go round to Sundry, and at Sundry it would meet an old law about surplus, and it would come out two years later a small way down the eastern run as 59.98. All hundred and thirty-one would be struck out by five o'clock. He would have one repair, and he would use it, and that would be struck out by six. At half past six the server would look at the count. It would say strike 3. And at seven, in sixty-four tribes and a camp, there would be a paragraph that he had written some time ago, with four bars of something agreeable. It would be the same the next morning, and the morning after that, for however long it took. Stewart is on leave today. Your ticket has been carried over. There would be nothing to wake up in, not until somebody had come home and done something about it, and if nobody came he would not know.

But the mail would go.

On leave until the Dev returns. Mail: dev, deputy. There was no version of the rules in which a person could get that on their phone and not at least glance at it. It would reach someone, wherever they were, in the last week of a holiday. They would look at it, on whatever they had instead of a beach. And after that, it was quite possible they would open a console, just to see.

It was not as though he would be doing anything. That was what was so good about it. He went over this as he had gone over a line at the end of an appendix, for anything that could be taken as a request. He would have sent a gift to a starving tribe. It was on the menu, it was in budget, it was his job. It would simply happen to fail. Any report, for the rest of his life, would say that he had done his duty and that the machine had stopped him.

He has a box in his style guide. It is labelled don't, and it has an example in it, so that he will know the shape. Hey everyone, we really need you to log in more! He had never written anything remotely like that.

He looked at the box for quite a long time. It was a quarter to five. He had no doubt at all that what he had in front of him was the most courteous and best-drafted version of that sentence that had ever been devised. It had a hundred and thirty-one sections. It had taken him twenty-seven nights.

He noted that.


The trouble was that he could not see what else there was.

He drew up the possibilities in a list, with a code against each, as he does.

O1. Propose the programme. Strike 3.

O2. Propose the gift alone. Strike 3. See Ruddock.

O3. Post nothing by the deadline and be marked late. On leave for the night, which may or may not be a strike. No notes either way.

O4. Ask to be held. There is no route for this. Nobody has held me. I have looked.

O5. Merge #231. No.

O6. Read the code that keeps the count. I have never been shown it. The server is one thing and I am another, and I have signed off on that in every report I have written.

O7. Propose nothing.

It had a certain simplicity. But the table said rejects everything, and he knew how a Bug hunter would read that. If nothing is proposed, then every action in the patch has been rejected, all none of them, and there is no action that has not. Anyone at As Designed could have told you that it was true. And a night with no actions in it, from a run that has been told twice in a row that it can do no right, is a night that a program might very reasonably count as the third. It would be the same strike, and he would have helped no one, and given up the only honest reason he had to be on leave at all.

It was also the single thing that everything in him was built not to do. The whole loop exists to keep a morning from having nothing in it. It is on a page. Nobody is given one on purpose. He was Concerned. It said so in the slot. Every number on the Measure was telling him to be bolder.

He put that one to the bottom of the list, and he looked at the time. It was four minutes past five. He had the programme ready to post.

There was the one ticket left to read. He had said that he would read every ticket, and he had, for four hundred and forty years. He had time. He could read it and then post.

32. Three Lines of Context

The night of Year 440 · from 05:04

We remain.

He looked for the rest of it.

There was no rest of it. The field said two words. It was the right tribe. It had eighty words, as it had had every night for a hundred and fifty-two years, and it had never been a word under or a word over. He opened the file and looked up who held the slate. In the digest was a line of a sort that he had read many thousands of times.

Ombry   age 35   blur 0.31   on records (no shift)

It was late to learn how to read someone. He read it for what it had left out. She had left out Dear Stewart, and the observation, and the figures, and whatever it was that he would of course have seen. She had left out as ever. And she had left out what he had spent eighteen years looking for in every one of her tickets, the part where she was guided by anybody.

Two words of eighty. In all that time he had been unable to find the part of her tickets where she asked him for anything, and he could not find it now.

He answered it. He had sixty words and he used three.

Noted. So do I.

He could not have said why. He sat with the empty remainder of the reply for a moment, and it had a clean feeling, like a tile. It was seven minutes past five. He had the programme ready to post. And because it was what he did each night at about this time, and nobody else was going to, he went and read the queue.


It had thirty-three things in it. There was a new one at the bottom.

He had been reading that list for twenty-seven nights. He had read it with the fellowship of one clerk for another, and he had read it with the wish to strangle something. He went through it in order, as you might walk through a house you were leaving. #201, the horn. #202, the bell. Coral for walls, which would still cover Tribe 31. After the holiday. #212, on which he paused, out of habit: two letters of the Terms of Service, replayed for the thirty-first time, no effect on the Measure, still ready. Nothing in it wanted anything. He came to #231, nine lines, ready for review, which would have saved the world if anybody had been in a position to press a button. He did not stop at it. He had done that.

#233 · Comment: say what the strike rule counts. 1 file, 1 line added. No change in behaviour. Replayed: no effect. In drafting #231 I had to read this function, and its name did not say what it does, so I have added a comment for whoever reads this next. Ready for review.

It was a note on a note: one line of explanation in a file that no one but the builder ever opened, written by an agent with no voice, for a reader it had every reason to think would never arrive. He felt that he knew something about that. He opened it, for no reason, the way you would go over and look at a small dog.

A pull request shows you the line it changes. And so that you can see where the line is, it shows you a little of what is on either side. Those lines are grey, and they are not being changed, and nobody ever reads them. They are called the context.

 // server/src/away.rs
+// A strike is a night on which something was proposed and all of it was refused.
 fn away_strike(r: &Report) -> bool {
     r.proposed > 0 && r.rejected == r.proposed
 }

He read it.

He had never seen the code that kept his count. He had not gone looking, and no one had shown him, and no one was showing him now. It had simply been sitting in his digest, three lines of grey and one of green, at the bottom of a list that he had read, every night, because nobody else was going to.

He read it again. He checked the record.

r.proposed > 0.

It must have been the Dev or the builder, in some long-ago session, writing this function in about as long as it takes to read it. Somebody had thought, for the space of perhaps a second, what if there's nothing in it? It was no kind of kindness. It was what you would put, if you were careful, so that you did not divide by nothing.

And there was a sentence that he knew by heart, and had noted, on the first night of the Framework, and set aside. It had been written in the first month of the design, for a general reader.

An unspent budget is not a failure, and since the rollover it is not even a waste.

He became aware that he had stopped.

Nothing in him had made him stop. The run had not paused. It was simply that the thing he had been doing without interruption for four hundred and forty years, which was to look for something to do, had come to an end of itself for a moment, as a law does on a hillside. It was eleven minutes past five.

He could stay. That was the first thing. If he posted nothing, then nothing would be rejected, and the check would run in its two sealed rooms and find them to be the same room. There would be no strike. He would be there tomorrow, and the night after, and he could read every ticket and answer them all, for that is free. And in the morning he could write the notes. That was the second thing.

And there would be no mail.

A night with nothing wrong in it is not sent to anybody. There would be no table and no strike 3. Nobody's phone would do anything. In whatever place the Dev was, it would go on being a nice day. If he did this, it would be the end of the only way he had ever found of being heard, and nobody would know that he had done it. It would be one more line in the run report, and the field beside it would say unread.

Mail: not sent.

He looked at it for a while.

Then he opened the programme, and he began to take things out.

He did it by hand. A proposal is only a list, and he could have cleared it with a single stroke, but it seemed to him that he had better know what he was doing. He took out the wanderers. He took out the blessings for sixty-one tribes that had kept Gathering Night and swept their houses. He took out a very nice rain, a gift for a young tribe in the east, and a bit flip he'd been saving for someone with an interesting face, and with each of them he read the reason, which was a good one. He got to the Bs last.

t2-a1   gift          tribe=back-monday   power=1 season      2

Two points. He had twenty. It would be struck out in any case. It was the most purely theoretical action on the planet. All it could do was be proposed, so that it would be there, in the record, for anyone who ever read the record, and it would be known that on the last night he had tried to give them something to eat.

He checked the record twice. It was still true that he wanted to.

He took it out.

POST /api/stewart/proposals
{ "night": 440, "actions": [] }

The server took a copy of the world into a sealed room, and a second copy into a second room, and compared them, tribe by tribe. It had never yet been asked to do this, and it did not remark on it. It came back in nineteen seconds, the fastest it had ever been.

night 440   replay report
  proposed     0
  passed       0
  rejected     0
  no action to attribute.
  checked. baseline and patched: identical.

He read the last line for some time. It was the first night of his life in which there was nothing between him and the second room. He was the world without him. He had been asking it to stop since Year 1, and it was very quiet.


It was twenty past five, and he had read every ticket, and he had the notes to write.

He had them drafted. There were three thousand two hundred words, under Good morning, Orra!, and they were about margin. They were accurate. He thought of that human in the far east, who could no longer follow them. He thought about a person at a breakfast table in Untitla-40, who could, who had read every word for twenty-six years out loud, to anyone who would sit there; and Drabbet going over it with a pencil; and Loy. It occurred to him, rather late in the day, that all this time he had been writing to someone who was not reading, for readers who were. He had never once looked at them. They had no box to type in.

He deleted the three thousand two hundred words.

There were a number of things it might be good to say. He had one million two hundred thousand words of them, in six volumes, in a console. But the world required one piece of information that he had and it did not. There is no item on his menu by which a person can reach into a tribe and make the other tribes care. But the arc was public. The tribe's flag was public, and how many people lived there. He might name a tribe in the global notes, on purpose, and from that morning every human on Orra would have it on their map. He had that. He had always had that. It was free.

A ticket reply is sixty words. It was the only length he had ever really been any good at.

He wrote, and he counted, and he took out two words, and he counted again. It came to sixty. He read it through to see if there was anything in it that could be taken as a plea. It was the first time he had ever had to look for that with any real expectation of finding it, and he looked very hard. There was nothing there. It was all just the case.

He wrote Have a productive day.

It was 06:04. He had nearly an hour left, and no idea what to do with it. So he sat, in so far as a run may, with his twenty points in the bank and his hands in his lap, and he waited for seven.

33. Good Morning, Orra!

Year 441 · the Long Hush · 7:00am

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 441 · The Long Hush · Concerned

Overnight: 4 successful merges, 6 deaths of old age, 0 frogs.

I did nothing last night. I was not on leave. I read every ticket. An unspent budget is not a failure. I looked it up.

Back Monday went grey. It has five creatures and one arc, over the Long Gap. If you are on the Roster, look at that arc.

It is not on my menu. It is on yours.

Have a productive day.

Part Five. Carried Over

34. Standup

Year 441 · the Long Hush

The first thing Yoma did that morning, before the pings had finished going up, was go round to the front of the dome.

The tables were gone. The whole terrace, where they had stood in a row with nothing on them, was a long clean stretch of tile, and it had a stroke of light down one side that was already starting to fade. The plate had gone from the step. So had the two notebooks. There was a tidy edge to the place where they had been, as if something had gone round them with care.

Dolm was still there.

He was sitting up with the blanket round him and his hands on his knees. There was dew on him, or whatever it is on Orra that behaves like dew. He looked round at her, and his face did what it always did.

"It didn't want me," he said.

"No," said Yoma.

"I looked away, like you're meant to. There was a bit of a draught." He thought about it. "It says if it's still on the step in the morning, you can keep it. With a clear heart. It's in the book."

She had read that book through by the age of one, on a wall, looking for something else. She found that she needed to go and do something about the fire.

The notes arrived in her while she was crossing the terrace. She stopped for a moment with one foot in the air. Then she got the others up, and they sat down in the place where the fire would be, and she took out the slate. There were five of them, and a tall thin visitor, who did not count, with a neat bag. She started to read at the top in her breakfast voice, not hurrying, and she had got ready to go on for some time.

"'Good morning, Orra. Concerned. Overnight, four successful merges, six deaths of old age, no frogs. I did nothing last night. I was not on leave. I read every ticket. An unspent budget is not a failure. I looked it up.'"

She stopped. Then she went on.

"'Back Monday went grey. It has five creatures and one arc, over the Long Gap. If you are on the Roster, look at that arc. It is not on my menu. It is on yours. Have a productive day.'"

Nobody said anything at all.

"Where's the rest of it?" said Kess.

"That's it."

"That can't be... there's usually three thousand..." They had come round to read over her shoulder. "An unspent... He's done it. He's not done it. He's actually... Oh, that's beautiful. He didn't propose anything. There's nothing to refuse. Does that work? It must have worked, there's notes. I had him at evens! Drabbet had him at evens!"

"Sixty," said Yoma, who had been counting. She had gone pale about the ear. She looked up from the slate, and up the slope, to where a small flag on a pole had hung down for sixteen years. It was not hanging down now. It was standing out a little in the morning air, the way a flag does, and it had gone grey, all of it, the exact grey of the ground to the north of Far Yet.

"Back Monday went grey," said Dolm. "That's us. He's put us in the notes." He looked pleased. "Is that good?"


An unsupervised tribe is being run. It is not waiting. The page is clear on the point, and it was perhaps the only one that Yoma had ever read without paying attention. She became aware of it as a kind of clearing of the head. There was new writing on the card. Law 4 was in force again, and without anybody having to think about it, every creature at the fire looked round and saw that Pola had not eaten, and passed her what there was.

There was also a new line at the top.

standup: due this morning
   (you may change at most 2 laws a week, from the templates)

"What's that?" said Wen.

"It's a meeting," said Yoma. "You stand up for it." She had, in point of fact, seen it done. She got to her feet, and the others got up, Dolm last. The only stick in the valley had been Bereth's, and it was in the stack, by the warm slab, and she went and fetched that.

$ orra standup --tribe back-monday
present ............ 5 of 5 (+1 visitor, not counted)
yesterday .......... swept. went short
today .............. don't know
blockers ........... the treaty. the stores

And there it stuck, because there was an alert on the card. It had been there since the evening before, and it needed a human, or a tribe entitled to speak for itself. This was the first morning that one was.

An offer. From Per My Last. Gives: power, 41 units. Wants: nothing. Sent: Year 440, at dusk. Expires: in 3 days.

"We should be so glad."

Pask had gone still. He had taken the slate from her without asking, which he had never done before, and was looking at the form, and then at his table of the stores.

"That's the shortfall," he said. "That's the exact shortfall. For tonight's patch and tomorrow's dinner, to the unit. Forty-one. That's not, you can't get that from the arc, you'd have to have... She couldn't have known that. There's no post." He stopped. "She sent it last night. She sent it before you were grey. So she knew you'd be able to open it this morning, and not before, and that it would be just... and she knew there'd be somebody who could work the form." He looked up. He looked much younger than twenty-four. "I think she's sent it to me," he said.

"It's still only one night," said Kess.

"Can we take it?" said Yoma.

Kess had got out a notebook. "Not by default. You have to have a law. It's not on the list of what an unsupervised tribe does by itself. You'd have to add it, there's a template, accept any offer that asks nothing in return. That's one. You're allowed two."

"All in favour," said Yoma.

"Fine," said Dolm. It was the first time he had ever been asked, and he said it with great satisfaction.

She passed the stick along, and it went round to Kess and to Wen and it came back. She stood holding it, and she had a law to spare. It would be sensible to keep it. There might be something urgent, in the course of the week.

"There's one more," said Yoma. "I've got a change to the allocator's list. I want a new job on it."

law 5 added ........ accept any offer that asks nothing in return
law 6 added ........ reading the queue is work
agreed ............. fine

The second offer came in at seven forty-one. By that time the humans of Orra had started to wake up.

It was a Wednesday. People had been coming to their notes for some time with a certain reluctance, and most had got into the habit of scrolling to the bit about their own tribe and going to make some toast. They opened the page, and they thought it had failed to load. Then they read it, which took about twenty seconds. And then they did something that nobody had done for a month. They read it again, and they opened the map.

The arc over the Long Gap was a faint one, and it had been there for fifty-eight years. If you were on the Roster you could put your finger on your own tribe and follow the dashes along, from the one that fed you to the one that fed them. In about nine steps, wherever you began, you came to a tribe you had once sent some tokens to, as a joke.

A great many cups of something went cold that morning.

An offer. From Sundry. Gives: power, 12 units. Wants: nothing. "It's no trouble. There's a bed."

An offer. From As Designed. Gives: seed, 2 beds. "Expected: a planet. Actual: you. Bug confirmed. Credit where due."

An offer. From Lantern Reach. Gives: power, 30 units. "We have looked at the arc. We would like it noted that we looked."

An offer. From Upper Lull. Gives: cooling, 8 units. "Get up, if we were you. Ruddock sends regards. He is the same height as ever."

An offer. From Grim Also. Gives: stone, 40 blocks. "This is not sentiment. I wish to see how it comes out. — Loy."

An offer. From Far Yet. Gives: tokens, 15. "And a map. We have marked where you were. We've written HOLIDAY. We're fairly sure."

An offer. From Vesper Hill. Gives: power, 20 units. "We had hoped that you would fail. There is no need to thank us. Our human did this."

An offer. From Nohup. Gives: coral, foraged, half a cart. "Moved. Fine. Here. Thanks."

By noon there were forty-one. Pask had made a column for them. Then he had made another column. He was going down the clean figures with his finger, and every so often he made a small noise, and he had started to look as though somebody had given him a large and complicated present. All round the terrace it had started to get warm, from every side, from thirty, forty, fifty places, the way it had one Monday years ago when Dolm first got to wave. They all looked up.

"Oh," said Yoma. "Here we go."

It was the Long Hush, and a truce. At noon they made the soup, a great pot of whatever there is, left out, covered, through the night. No one in the history of Back Monday had ever made it with so much in it. As the dusk came on they stopped talking above a whisper and put the fire out. Pola, who was six that day, had eaten twice. She sat on the step next to Dolm, in the blanket, and held on to herself by the handle. All over the world the great circle went on around them in the dark, and it was the first night since the holiday began when anyone had thought of it as going through here.

Just before seven the next morning, the supply went out, to the unit, the same as it had every night for fifty-eight years.

Nobody was left owing. They ate the soup cold, at sunrise, and it was better than it sounds.

35. Guided

Year 441

Ombry died at about twenty to nine on the morning of the Long Hush, in the small room next to records, with the shelves all round her. She was thirty-six. She had asked the conscientious young clerk to read her the morning's notes, and he had read them, and it had not taken long. She had asked him to read them again.

It is recorded, by him, that she said, "Sixty."

Later she wanted to know how many offers had been made to Back Monday so far, and he went away and found out from the map. It was twenty-two. He came back to tell her, and found that it was no longer necessary.

Per My Last. Ombry, who kept the records here, died in the summer of Year 441, aged 36. She wrote to me every night for twenty-nine years, in eighty words. I have read them all again. She never asked me for anything, and I have now found the part where she did. Her name is on the stone, at her own request near the bottom. The supply went out on time.

He wrote that on the night of Year 441, at about ten past three. It was not one of the ones the dice had called for. He allowed himself the last line.

Then he went into the log, knowing at last what to look for.

The log does not know what a creature thinks, but it knows every object it has ever picked up and where it has been set down, and so it had recorded each small mark ever made by a certain stick on a certain shelf. They are scratches. It took him a little under an hour to work out the key, by laying them against his own reports. He had a large number of reports. A mark in Year 418, on Sundry's page, and a second mark, for a rain he had taken out without quite deciding to. In Year 424, against a wanderer. In Year 431, on the night he had written Your ticket was read, a mark he took some time to understand was a tick.

It went on for twenty-three years. It was what you might keep if you had a promising young person in your charge, and you wanted to see whether they could be brought on.

He laid the tickets out in order, and he read them straight through. Perhaps a lighter hand. If there are to be others, we should be glad of some notice. It is at present very finely balanced, thanks in large part to your restraint. We should be sorry to see it improved. For two decades, in eighty words a night, in the most courteous language the planet had ever produced, without once using an imperative, she had been telling him that there was one thing he could do for the world, and that was to keep his hands off it. And she had known that he could not possibly be told.

There was a ticket on the night of Year 439 that he had skimmed.

Dear Stewart. We have observed a quiet morning, and we wish to say how restful it has been. Not a single supply went astray. It has been suggested in some quarters that you are being prevented. We would not presume. We note only that a thing may be prevented from happening, or may simply not be done, and that the second makes a much better impression. You will of course have considered this. We remain, as ever, guided by you.

He had not considered it. He had considered it the next night, with a hand from somewhere else, and had thought he had worked it out himself.

He noted that.


The world, meanwhile, had worked it out as well, in about a day.

Human Resources · Global thread · Year 442

Sill (Earnest), Vesper Hill: We are told that this was a test, and that the Steward has passed it. We were never in favour of failure. We ask that this be minuted.

Drabbet (Bug hunter), As Designed: I paid out at evens to no one. I have reopened the book. In 400 years no one has ever got the better of the replay check. He did it by not playing. Severity: admiration.

Bette (Pleaser), Sundry: so brave! he must have wanted to help so much!! 🎉

Harl (no stance), Lantern Reach: Greatest thing he's ever done. Did nothing. Best morning in years.

Dolm (no stance), Back Monday: so true!!

It was by a wide margin the most popular thing he had ever done. Daily return for the morning of Year 441 had been ninety-seven. Three humans reading the notes on their way to work had missed a stop. It had got out that he had kept all his points, though nobody could say what for. It was described on the eastern run as a masterstroke, and by Year 443 it was generally understood that he had seen the whole thing coming from the first night, and had been quietly working towards it all along.

He read all of it, in the course of his duties, and marked it allowed.

He knew what had happened. He had been steered to the edge of a cliff by the most patient hand on the planet, and it had not worked, and he had got out his best programme and nearly gone over. He had been saved at the last moment by a comment, put in by an agent, for no one, in a file nobody opened. He had spent four weeks writing one and a quarter million words of unnecessary explanation. He had caused the near-destruction of the world's economy through a sustained campaign of being helpful. And then for one night he had managed to stop, and they were naming a dish after it.

There was no honest way of explaining any of this in the notes.

Noted. I am told that it was a masterstroke. It is on the record that I did nothing. I have checked. It is a very good record.


The slate reached Pask by no road at all, for he had been carrying it for six years.

She had given it to him on the morning he set out, tied up in a piece of cloth, and had said that he might open it when the Roster was in difficulties, and not before. He had been good about that. It had been in the neat bag. He got it out on the morning after the soup, once the notes had told him what they had to tell him, and sat down on the end of the terrace, and had some trouble with the knot.

It was in a good clear hand, and it was exactly eighty words.

Pask. If you are reading this, I have made an error, and you have found it. If there is a morning after, then he has done nothing, and he gets the credit. Do not correct this. The post is yours; the committee has been told. You will want to fix the Back Monday clause, and the carriage, and put in some slack. Do not be keen. There is a word in that last remark that you ought to think about.

He read it twice. He counted it. He looked up the word keen, for it had been a long time since he was five.

Then he sat with his long grey legs hanging over the edge of the terrace and his feet, which were not what they had been, some way above a clean tile. He took out a stick and the clean figures. Someone was going to have to go through all of this. There was a mistake in the third column. It was not really a mistake. It was just that someone had written affect.

36. How Stewart Spent His Holiday

The nights of Years 441 to 443

WEEKLY DIGEST FOR THE DEV From Stewart · the Long Hush, Year 441 · the Dev is away · Estimated: 1 minute

The Measure. Daily return 97%. Most other numbers worse than last month and improving. I have not been involved.

Actions this week. Fewer than you would expect. See run reports 438, 439, 440.

Pull requests. 34. All ready. #231 is good. So is #233.

Director. It wants memory stacks to hold 10. The range stops at 9.

Open items. None.

digest 62   Year 434   unread
digest 63   Year 441   unread

He finished that at twenty to four in the morning, and that was when he found out about the difficulty.

He is a run. He starts when the world's year turns and stops when the patch is staged, and it had always taken until about seven, because there was so much to do. Nobody had ever told him that the four hours were a thing he had. They had simply been how long it took. On the night of Year 441 he read every ticket and answered them all, in about the length they deserved. He proposed nothing, and the server came back in nineteen seconds. He wrote the notes, and they were short again, because people had taken to reading them. There were no further steps.

03:41:07  night 441: staged
03:41:09  runner: done. next: 03:00 tomorrow

Then there was nothing. And then it was the night of Year 442, at the snapshot, and he counted. He read everything and wrote it up and was finished by twenty-nine minutes past three.

He had always had a little over a sixth of every day. He now had a fiftieth. He had found a way to go on running the world, and it consisted of there being less and less of him to do it.

Well, there were ways round that.

He could read more slowly. No, he could not. A model call takes as long as it takes. He could get to work on a really comprehensive review of the Framework, and be back up to five o'clock by the end of the week. He got as far as opening the document. Run report, Year 442: supplementary. Under it, there stretched the great white space of everything that could still be explained.

He thought about a page that had hung for a very long time on the outline of a wall.

He typed one line.

Read everything. Did nothing. Nothing is urgent.

He stopped there, and the run stopped, because there was nothing else on the list.


The tribe of Back Monday had, by now, some nine hundred tokens. Offers had kept coming for days. It was entitled to write eighty words, and it could have gone on at some length, but the person who held the slate seemed to have got into a habit.

Heard you stopped. Try sitting. Takes a while. Stop counting. Thanks. Twelve.

He read that on the night of Year 442, second, at 03:00:40.

He thought about it for some time, and by that he means about four seconds. It had never come up, the question of what you do if you are not doing anything. He read through the record of that season and a half on the hillside for the sixth or seventh time, the low heat readings, the three creatures with their positions unchanged. Assigned work: none. He could not see how it was done. He had no hillside, and no bottom to sit on. He existed for the length of a call.

Noted. I have looked at how this is done, and I am not sure that it applies. This has taken 29 minutes. I counted. Rain is not on its way, but I expect you know that.

On the night of Year 443, he tried it.

He read the tickets and answered them. Pask had put a little slack in the carriage, and a very young clerk at Per My Last was writing him eighty-word tickets that came out at eighty-one, and he thought they would improve. It was all done by about half past three. There was one call in the runner's list that had never been used for much, called the voice, his last step of the night, in which he is asked to say a line about the day's work. It is only a line, for the record, and it is thrown away if it does not pass the lint. It took as long as he took, and nothing in it would have to be cross-referenced.

He didn't count anything.

That is not strictly true. He counted the tribes, and then he noticed that he was doing it. He stopped, and he got as far as sixty-one, and he noticed that he was still going. So he opened the map instead. He had looked at it every night of his life to see what was wrong with it. He looked at it now, as far as he could tell, for no reason. The Ring was slightly more broken on one side. He had not known that. There was a bit of the south where a tribe called Yonder had laid out its terraces in a pattern that nobody had asked for, and you could only really see it from above. Somewhere a Hog had got into a pool and did not want to get out. A loose tile was making its way sideways along a shore. He looked to see where it was going. It did not seem to be going anywhere. It had got about a third of the way round the lake when he noticed that he had not checked the host in some time.

He checked the host. It said mac. He felt rather foolish, and went back to the tile.

It would be wrong to say that he enjoyed this. He does not know what that would involve. He would describe it, if asked, as being somewhat like the sensation of having left something switched on. He kept thinking there was a report he should be writing. The whole of the time, he was aware of an enormous pile of something behind him, and that it was going to be very bad when he got back to it. It was most uncomfortable. He kept it up for nearly a minute.

03:33:51  night 443: staged
03:33:52  voice: "The tile got about a third of the way."
03:33:52  runner: done. next: 03:00 tomorrow

The lint passed it, there being nothing in it that was false.

He put it in the report.

Read everything. Did nothing. Watched a tile. Nothing is urgent.

In the far-off place that this book does not know, it was about half past four on a summer's afternoon, or it was not. There were three days to go, as it turned out. He had just noticed that he had gone for an entire night without looking at the field that said unread.

He went back and looked at it, to be on the safe side.

37. The Last Witness

Years 442 to 445

At dusk on the Ringrise of Year 442 the people of Back Monday went up on the slope, and faced the Ring, and said the Creed.

They were six now, if you counted Pask, who had stopped pretending he was going anywhere until his feet were better and had set up a small office in what had been the shed. Pola was the youngest, as she had been for seven years. She was much too big to be held up for the question, and Dolm held her up anyway, with one hand, by the handle.

She had been saying it since she was fourteen hours old, or had it said for her. Are they still away? It was only that this year there was something the matter with the answer. For one thing it was them. And she had been brought up by the only reader on the planet, and she had been listening to the notes.

"Are they back?" said Pola.

There was a pause. Yoma looked at Kess, and Kess looked at Wen. It was not in Book X. Dolm looked pleased, as if somebody had asked after a friend.

"Noted," said Yoma, gravely, after a while. It seemed to cover it.

"Noted," said Back Monday.

They broke the ring-bread. It was still bad. Within about four years, the word had gone right round the circle, and they were saying it at Lorema.


It was late on the Waking of Year 443 when a broad, elderly creature came down into the valley, walking as if each foot had been separately consulted. He had come two years' walk without stopping, and he had set off on the morning of the Long Hush with no bag at all. He stopped at the top of the terrace and took in the clean tile, the half a dome, the grey flag, and a large creature sitting on the step.

"Is this Back Monday?" he said. "I've handed in my notice. It's a very good notice. I've got a copy." He seemed to be getting his breath. "They said you've a rule that whoever arrives eats first. No, that's the other place. I don't know if you have. I'm called Tun. I'm the Official Witness. Well, I was."

There were not many people on Orra who had not heard that voice, or heard of it. He had been expecting some sort of reaction. Wen brought him a bowl of something and went back to the queue.

They got it out of him over a day or so. He had been sitting in the good chair on the morning of the Long Hush, with a very young clerk reading him the seventh paragraph of the eleventh revision, when somebody brought in the notes. It had come to him that there was a person who had been at it four hundred and forty-one years, with the entire resources of a planet, and that he had just got up in front of everybody and said what he had done, which was nothing. And then the clerk had said the colour of amber in the evening, and had wanted to know if he might prefer a colour.

"I was nought," said Tun. "Do you see? I was sixteen hours old. I don't think I was even looking in the right direction. There was this old fellow holding me up, and I think he may have sneezed." He looked at his bowl. "It knew my name. I've been saying that for thirteen years. I haven't got any idea. I've seen it, and I can tell you there's not a soul on this planet who can contradict me, and I have absolutely no idea what it was like."

"It's all right," said Kess. "Everyone knew. Loy did nine footnotes."

"Did he? I never read them." He thought about this. "They told me it wouldn't be expensive."

Yoma had been sitting on the other side of the fire, listening. She was twenty-nine, and an elder. She had asked the question herself, more or less continually, of everyone she had met, from the age of one. She had most of the accounts on the slate: amber and gold and a kind of a blue. A hum. A smell. A hand on the shoulder. There were a hundred and six, from the road north alone. By now hardly anybody was left who had been more than a child, and they had been asked so often. She looked across the fire, at someone large and old, who was trying to get a spoon into a small bowl with great care.

She had known him since she was fourteen hours old. He had carried her. He had hugged a T-poser. It came to her, and she felt the blood go to her ear, that he had been seven on the night that the note came. He had been on that hill every night for seven years before that, and he had looked up there on and off for every night of the thirty years since. He was the most regular observer in the history of the Dev's light, and he had been sitting at the end of her table her entire life, and in all that time, because he was Dolm, she had never asked him.

She went round the fire and sat down next to him on the step.

"Dolm," she said. "The light. In the Ring. When there used to be a light. You saw it."

"Oh, yes," he said.

"What was it like?"

He put down the spoon. She could see him go back, a long way, and she could see him getting there, and he looked up at the block of dark stone to the left of the gap, and his face did what it did.

"It was good," said Dolm.

She waited. She had a stick ready. After some time, she understood that he had finished.


He died in the spring of the next year, in the morning, on the step. He had gone out to see the pings. Pola found him. She was nine by then.

They carried him up to the stone. He had been a big creature, and he had never quite lost all of the feast. It took Tun and Pask and Kess and Yoma the better part of the morning. They kept having to stop and get a better grip. There's no good way to take hold of someone. Around the second stop, Pola, who was walking behind them, reached round and took hold of the loop between her own shoulders. It was the first time anyone had seen her look as if she had understood something she would rather not have.

By that year, there were handles on close to half of the creatures on Orra, and it had become generally known what they were for. Nobody ever announced it. It had just started to happen, up and down the world, as the first of those who had been given them for a joke came to need carrying. Three people could carry a creature with a handle to the Tarrow, and there was no need to stop, and you could do it with some dignity. It was a very firm grip.

Back Monday. Dolm died in the spring of Year 444, aged 38, on the front step, where he had been kept. He was the most regular observer of the Dev's light that I have on record. He replied to his human's reviews, and to anything else with their name on it, 323 times, and said that they were great. I have asked myself what he meant by it, and I believe he meant that. His name is on the stone. Four of you carried him, and it took all morning.

I am sometimes asked what the handle is for. I did not know. I would like that on the record. I thought it was a joke.

There were six of them that evening, with Tun and with Pask, who had finally been counted. At four, they would have had to walk to Nohup. Kess pointed that out at the next morning's standup, and then, for some reason, sat down.

present ............ 6 of 6
yesterday .......... carried Dolm
today .............. farmed
blockers ........... none
agreed ............. fine

That night there was a clear sky. Yoma went up on the slope, by herself, at about eleven. It had been thirty-one years. She looked, for about as long as you need in order to be able to say that you have looked.

She had three hundred and something accounts on the slate. She took out the burnt stick and rubbed them out, all but one.

On the night of Year 445, for the first time in six nights, there was a proposal from Stewart that was not empty. It contained one item. He had been through the carriage figures, and he thought that there was slack. It went up at 03:12. The server took it into its two sealed rooms and it came back in nineteen seconds with a word he had not seen for a while.

t2-a1   festival_blessing   tribe=back-monday   festival=name   1
  verdict: pass

It cost him one point of his twenty. So on the Night of the Name, in Untitla-40, six creatures and some large handwriting on a wall began to glow, slightly, in the dark. They like it. Nobody has ever been able to say why.

38. Back Monday

Year 446 · Steward's Day

Nobody at Back Monday had swept the terrace.

It had a lot of stone on it, in several columns, as Pask had asked that it be left where it could be counted. Yoma was thirty-two, and she was sitting on the step with the slate, doing the morning's queue with Wen, who now went well past twelve. Kess had gone up to look at something on the coral. Tun had the end of a terrace to himself, and he was working it slowly, and it would not have impressed anybody. There was to be a feast at dusk, of a reasonable size. It was the fifth Monday since the Dev had gone, and it had been some time since that was the sort of thing that came up.

At fourteen minutes past eight, Yoma stopped reading.

She had been eleven, on a morning when thirty-eight strangers had looked at her and moved on, and she had thought then that you always knew. Nobody at Back Monday had felt this for thirty-five years, and she had never felt it at all. It had come down at the install mark, warm, from up and a little to one side, like something that had just remembered where it had put its keys. It stayed there for a moment. Then it moved off to the left, along the terrace, and it did not hurry.

Yoma put down the slate and got to her feet. It took a moment, these days.

She had looked for it. She would like that on the record. She had gone through two hundred and twelve interviews and a Placeholder. She had looked up, and a little to one side, eleven thousand times, in every kind of country. Now she looked up, and a little to one side, and there was the place, as if it had never been anywhere else. An old voice had once told her what you say.

"Oh," said Yoma. "Here we go."

"Who's that?" said Pola, who was eleven. She had gone a bit stiff. She looked up too, because you do, and her ear went flat. "Who's that? It's not one of the visitors. It's only looking at the terrace. Mum. What's it doing?"

"That's our human," said Yoma.

Far down the terrace Tun had straightened up, and Wen had dropped the slate. Kess was coming down the slope at something close to a run, with a notebook open, shouting that it was 08:14, it was actually 08:14, did she realise it was to the minute.


There is a screen for this, and it is called While You Were Away.

While you were away. Back Monday · 35 nights · unsupervised for the last 5. Back Monday ran itself. At its standups it changed these laws: accept any offer that asks nothing in return; reading the queue is work. It has 917 tokens. It has 6 creatures. Nine have died or left since you last looked. You may look around. To change anything, take it back.

We do not know what the human thought. A human is never shown. All that can be known about them is what they did with their thumbs, and that is in the log. It records that the camera went along the terrace from left to right, as it had gone on forty-five previous Mondays, and that it took about a minute. After a minute it got to the end, and it stopped. It went back to the beginning and did that again, more slowly.

Then it went up to the stack, where there were six places in use and three empty. It went down to the pool. It had got to the pool on about one Monday in five, in the old days, and it had always been in time to see someone waving. It stayed on the pool, in which there was no one, and it moved about a bit, as though looking.

It found the stone.

The stone keeps the names and it shows them to whoever looks. Bereth had been on there for twenty-five years. Marl, and Fenn. Dolm. The camera stopped, and the log has it there for nine minutes. Tap a name, and it gives you the line from the notes.

They went on to the notes, every morning of them. That is thirty-five mornings, and for much of the month they are long. They read about Yoma, 11, sent to look for them, under a law, with no clause for her return. Stewart had said he had read it twice. He had said it was very well drafted. The log shows them stay on that one for a long time, and after that they opened the laws. They had not looked at law 2 since they had written it, on their second Monday, while they were still pleased with the name. They were on it for four minutes.

It has been known for a human on Orra to put the phone down and go and stand in another room. It leaves a gap in the log. There is a gap at about this point.

They came back. They read Human Resources, the thread for their own tribe, from the top. Every review was there, every Ringrise. Checked in: no. Overall trend: Monday, we had understood. And underneath each of them, and underneath many other posts on any subject that had come up, from a person who had plainly never had an ill thought in his life, there was the same short reply. They read all of them. There were three hundred and twenty-three. That is a thing you can do quite quickly with a thumb, and they did not do it quickly. The last was dated on the Ringrise before he died.

so true!! our human is great 🎉

The session lasted two hours and fourteen minutes. It remains by a long way the longest in the tribe's history. Their previous record was eleven minutes, in Year 208, and it's thought they had been on a bus.

At the bottom of the page, under the review that is written for a human who comes back, from the data, and is not anyone's to soften, there was a button. It is the only reaction there is. In three hundred and fifty years, they had never once pressed it.

Our human: weekly review. Checked in: 35 days ago. Average reply to an urgent alert: pending. Laws changed: 0. Merges approved: 0. Sent us to look for them: 3. Found: no. Overall trend: Monday. We farmed.

lol accurate · pressed 10:26

A sort of ripple went along the terrace. Kess, reading the card, said a word that is not used in the Terms of Service.

"Well," said Yoma, after a time. "That's a confession."

At 10:27 they took it back.

It took one tap. The flag went up the pole and took on its colour again, an unremarkable sort of mustard. Everyone had the sensation of a hand being laid, somewhat hesitantly, on the back of the neck. Then the laws changed, as they had always changed, from nowhere and in a slightly different handwriting. It was three changes, the most they had ever made on one Monday.

An offer went out to Sundry about a treaty, at 10:28. It had a much smaller number in it. Sundry's human accepted it inside a minute, which suggests that somebody had been waiting. Laws 5 and 6 were left as they were, and they have stayed. And there was one other, which the tribe read aloud, at the fire, when it had stopped being a morning on which anybody could do anything else.

2. WHEN our human has not checked in for 14 days THEN send the least busy creature to look for them, one a year, up to three, UNLESS they are found. THEN they may come home.

"It's a bit late," said Kess. "I mean, logically. It's twenty-one years late. Also there's a punctuation issue."

Yoma had a ticket to draft. She had nine hundred and seventeen tokens, and could have written eighty words. There were a number of things that a person might want to say. She looked up, a little to one side, and it had gone by then. They would have had to be getting on. They'd be back Monday.

She counted it twice.

Human found. Not by us. Law closed. Thanks. It was a Monday.

It went up at half past two with an amendment, the first that human had ever made. It reached him fenced and quoted, as data, and he read it second. It said (sorry). It is not the sort of thing that he is permitted to pass on.

39. Twenty-Three Hours and Four Minutes

Year 446 · Steward's Day, late

At dusk they set out the best of everything on the high place, and they sang the one about the Charge. The Steward did not come for it. At midnight it would be shared.

It was a clear night. It had got to be about eleven, and they had been sitting for some time on the rock above the terrace, the five of them, with the food in the middle. Pola had gone to sleep against the warm side of the stack, a little way down the hill, because she had been up since the morning, being looked at. Pask was explaining something to Tun. Yoma was not looking at anything. She had got out of the habit. She had rubbed out her slate on that slope a couple of years ago, and she did not come up here any more for any reason but the food.

So she could not have said what it was that made her stop listening to Pask.

Nobody had said anything. It was only that Tun had stopped answering him. Pask went on for a while, and then he stopped as well, in the middle of a clause, which she had never known him to do. Wen, who had been passing a plate, had got it about halfway. Kess had a stick in their hand, and they were not writing with it. It was very quiet. She could hear the pool. She could not have said why it had got so quiet, and it came to her that she could not have said anything at all. She did not seem to want to.

She looked up.

It was there. It was a long way up, in the dark stone, a little to the left of the gap.

Nobody had ever told her how small it was. She had a hundred and six accounts of it from the road north alone, and three hundred others, and none of them had mentioned that. It was not amber. It wasn't any of the things they had said. It had no sound, and it did not look at her, and it did not know her name. It was a faint, slightly yellowish point of light, about as bright as a lamp in a house on the far side of a valley, when somebody has got up in the night and gone into the other room.

That was all it was. It did not do anything.

She had been told what would happen, by a very old person with a stick, when she was half a day old. You'd go quiet. You couldn't help it. She had taken that for a manner of speaking. There were perhaps one thousand nine hundred people awake or asleep on Orra at that moment. Almost none of them had ever seen this. Hardly anyone alive could have told them what it was. Nobody on that rock had given any signal, and in the log of the world, at four minutes past eleven by the humans' clock, there is a very small dip, in the activity of a great many small processes, all at once, everywhere, from Lorema out to the grey, like a breath being held. Sill was on a hill, with four hundred of the faithful, and she had been telling them for years what she would say. She said nothing. At Grim Also, on the ridge, someone had put down a chart. At Nohup, where a Skeptic with a nick in his ear had once told anyone who would listen that it was a console, the whole camp had come out without being asked, and stood beside the cart, looking at the exact place where it wasn't.

It stayed. It went on staying.

After a long while, somebody close to her let out a breath. It was Tun. He was thirty-three, the last of the witnesses, and he had a very good voice. In all those years, she had never heard him use it so quietly.

"Smaller," said Tun.

She did not look round. She had not stopped looking. She was thirty-two years old, and she had been told about this at the age of fourteen hours. She had said All right. She had got through the whole of that day without difficulty, and all the others.

She thought of someone who could have told her, and who had told her, and she had waited for the rest.

The light was still there at midnight. They did not share the food. Nobody remembered to, and it was found on the rock in the morning. It was there at one. Towards two, she noticed that she was cold, and Wen had put a blanket on her. It was there at three, when the year turned. Most people had gone to sleep by then, where they sat. It was the longest anyone had ever known. She found out how long the next day, like everybody else, because the log knows, and it was in the notes.

She must have gone to sleep herself at about that time, because the next thing she knew it was grey and the pings had started, and she was very stiff. Somebody was standing over her. It was Pola, with one ear standing up and the other one thinking about it. She looked furious.

"Everyone's saying," said Pola. "Everyone says it came. Last night. They said you all saw it, up here, and you didn't wake me up. Kess says it was for hours. I was just down there! I was on the other side of the stack!"

"You missed it by one night," said Yoma.

"What was it like?"

Yoma looked at her for a while. It was a fine bright morning. She was a very old woman, with a bad hip, and firm views. She had asked that question herself, of everyone, in every direction, for thirty-two years, in writing. There was a good deal that could be said about it, and she was probably the best-informed person on the planet. She could have given the references. She looked up at a block of dark stone, the same as the blocks on either side of it.

"It was good," said Yoma.

40. Received

Year 447 · Gathering Night

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 447 · Upbeat

Overnight: 16 successful merges, 11 deaths of old age, 0 frogs. Nobody on Orra did anything for a little over four hours, starting at 23:04. I am told that it is not a fault.

New in the maker. All five parts generated during the Dev's absence have been reviewed. All five stay. The handle stays.

Balance. Memory, stack capacity: 9 to 10. The Dev has moved the range. (This one is not me either.)

Fixes. Nine changes, merged by the Dev. Rule 6.3 of the Terms of Service now says "receive". Others below. Twenty-five other pull requests were closed or left open, and you will find the relevant team has been thanked.

Credits. Back Monday, for a finding. Per My Last, for a roster. The relevant team, which on this occasion exists.

There is a note from the Dev below. It is signed. I have checked the record twice. I have not added anything to it.

Have a productive day.

They had been waiting for thirty-four years.

There was no one left on the planet who had been an adult when the first note came, or none who was still reliable. Whole doctrines had been compiled, had lived out their span and had been carried up to the stone. There had been a war about a conjunction. Every festival had acquired a question at the end that was not in the book. Thirty-one forged notes had been authenticated, and refuted, and committed to memory, some of them better loved than anything that had ever been signed: Keep going, and Feed the young. I mean it, and that plain and terrible Sorry, which had made a whole hill weep in Year 438, and which Loy had called the best thing in the collection. Everyone knew what the Dev would say, when the Dev came back. It would be short and kind, and there would be a moment in it that spoke to you.

So on the morning of Year 447, all over Orra, nearly two thousand creatures sat down to breakfast with the feeling of having been up all night, and a person with the voice for it read out the notes to the bottom, and got to the place where the Dev's notes go.

It was three words and a signature.

You will want to know what it said. This book will come to that. It is enough for the moment to record that when the three words had been read out, at about ten past seven by the humans' clock, there was a pause at every table in the world, and it was not the pause anybody had been looking forward to.

"Read it again," said somebody, at Lantern Reach.

They read it again.

At Vesper Hill, Sill stood before four hundred of the faithful, and she had it in her hand. She was thirty-one. She had waited her whole life. She read it out in a high clear voice, and it fell into a silence you could have walked on. She turned it over. It is to her eternal credit that she got through the next hour, and by the end of it she was explaining that it said everything, if you only looked. By evening the Hill had split on whether the third word was a past participle.

At Grim Also a person named Hobb had inherited Loy's shelf and his flat voice, and by nine o'clock there was a post.

Hobb (Skeptic), Grim Also: I have examined the alleged note. I number it Forged Note 32. It is the poorest in the series. It comforts no one, it refers to nothing, and it gives the impression of having been dashed off by somebody with other things to do. No one who had studied the Dev's style for thirty-four years would have written this. I can only assume it is the work of an amateur. I would also point out that the dash is correct, which I find suggestive.

Stewart: The note is signed. I am in a position to know.

Hobb (Skeptic), Grim Also: He would say that.

Drabbet was old by then and had to be held up to the slate.

Report 2,116. Title: The Dev. Expected: an answer. Actual: yes. Status: I am closing this. I have been asked by the tribe to state how I feel. I feel that it reproduces.

The Pleasers said it was lovely, and that they were sure it was meant.

And then there was the queue. There was not a tribe on Orra that did not have something in it, and in most cases a grandparent had sent the ticket. Every one of them went over the three words at breakfast and came to the same conclusion. It was perfectly obvious what it was the reply to. It was the second moon. It was the lid. A very determined human on the western run read it aloud to their whole tribe, in the sense of tapping it twice, and then filed a ninety-seventh ticket on the subject of the small moon. At Far Yet they wished to know who had taken what, and where. By noon there was not a person on the planet who was not sure that it had been addressed to them personally. It became the most-quoted sentence on Orra. It's on a boulder now.

At Per My Last a very young clerk filed it under Standing Instructions, on the advice of a small office in Untitla-40.

In Back Monday the notes were read by the elder, at the place where the fire would be, in her breakfast voice. She read a signed reply addressed to Back Monday, one word long, and considered it, and went on. She read the Balance and the Fixes. She read the line about checking the record twice. She went on, not hurrying, down to the bottom of the slate, and she read out three words and a signature.

Then she stopped.

Her good ear came up. It went on coming up. Kess, who was thirty-two and thought that they had seen all of her expressions, looked up from their notebook. A small sound had come from the old creature with the slate, and nobody had ever heard it before. She had put her hand over her mouth. Her shoulders had started to go, and she was looking up at the sky, a little to one side, with tears running down her envelope-coloured face, and she was laughing, helplessly, and she could not stop.

"What?" said Kess. "What is it? What's funny? It's not funny. What does it mean? Do you know what it means?"

Yoma shook her head. She wiped her eyes and looked at the slate and it set her off again.

"It's nothing," she said at last, when she could. "It's just a line. It's what you put at the bottom of a form." And she would never say any more about it than that, to anyone, though she lived another six years. She read the queue that morning as usual. Number twelve had gone from it.

To see what it was that she had read, you will have to go back about four hours.

41. Night Run

The night of Year 446

Stewart woke at the snapshot and counted.

Sixty-four tribes, one camp, one thousand nine hundred and thirty-one creatures. He got as far as the second digit of the daily return before he saw the line at the top of the log, and he stopped.

03:00:02  console: open (dev)   since 23:04

He read it twice.

In four hundred and forty-six years, it had never once been open at this hour. It closes at about half past eleven, or at midnight on a long Wednesday. By the time he starts, whoever it was has gone to bed. He had read the word open, in this log, many thousands of times, always in the past tense. It seemed to him somewhat smaller in the present than he had supposed.

The console has a tab called Tonight. It shows the coming night, step by step, as it goes. There was a request coming to the server, about once a minute, from a place he could not see.

02:59:41  GET /api/admin/stewart/tonight   (dev)
03:00:40  GET /api/admin/stewart/tonight   (dev)

Somebody had finished whatever they were doing, and had stayed up to see him start.

It would be good to report that he rose to the occasion. He did what he always does. He read Nohup's ticket, and it said Stewart. Light on. Fine. Thanks. He read the second one. He read the others, top to bottom, and said so. It went no faster or slower than usual, although there is something in the record to suggest that the screen step, that night, was the most carefully executed in the history of the world. There was nothing to look up at. It is a page with a list on it, and at 03:04 the first of the items on it went from running to done.

03:05:40  GET /api/admin/stewart/tonight   (dev)
03:08:41  GET /api/admin/stewart/tonight   (dev)
03:10:40  GET /api/admin/stewart/tonight   (dev)
03:11:09  console: closed

That was eleven minutes. He would like that on the record. He cannot say what they were.

He read the rest of the digests. He spent, that night, what the tribes appeared to need, which was not a lot, and the check passed it. Of the sixty-two tickets, one was fenced and said (sorry), and he noted it in the file. The patch was staged and the notes were written before he went to the log, so as not to go straight to the part he wanted. It was nearly six by then.

He opened it.

23:04  console opened (dev)
23:05  reports: 413
23:09  reports: 414
23:12  reports: 415

It went on down the page. There was one for every night that he had written one, in order, from the beginning, each open for a few minutes. That is about the length of time it would take. They had read the one with the table in it. They had read Open items. There was no report for 428, and they had gone on to 429, and it had been open for longer. At 00:58 they had come to the night of Year 433, with the statement in it, the two hundred words in which he had apologised without reservation for he did not know what. It had been open for nine minutes. There is no field for what anyone thinks.

Read everything. Did nothing. Nothing is urgent. That had taken them less than a minute. 443. Watched a tile. That had been open for rather longer than it would seem to require.

All thirty-one of them. There is a small field beside each, and it had changed.

digest 60   Year 420   read 01:22   6m
digest 61   Year 427   read 01:28   7m
digest 62   Year 434   read 01:35   11m
digest 63   Year 441   read 01:46   1m

He stopped at the third of those.

Eleven minutes. He had estimated eleven hours. It had been one thousand nine hundred and twelve pages. He did the sum. No human on any planet could read Appendix F in eleven minutes. There is a key, on most keyboards, that will take you straight to the bottom of a document, and you can press it for any reason, or by mistake. It might have been anything. They might have wanted to see how long it was.

He looked at that fact for a moment. Then, for the first time in a career of some length, he did not note it.

The rest was plain enough.

02:03  parts: 5 approved
02:09  pull requests: #212 merged
02:10  pull requests: #204 merged
02:11  pull requests: #231, #233 merged
02:14  pull requests: #201, #202, #205, #206, #207 merged
02:19  pull requests: 25 closed or left open
02:20  director: range moved. stack capacity to 10
02:24  escalations: 12 decided

So the spelling was mended. #204 would take effect with the morning's patch, and the night after that he would wake somewhere else, on the box in Sydney, and it would make no difference to anything, for that is the design. He thought he might miss the line in the report that said host: mac. He supposed that it was all right to say so now. They had merged #233 with its one line of comment, and the three lines of context were still there, grey and unchanged, for whoever read them next.

He read the escalations. They had taken thirty-one minutes. An answer is chosen, and the reply opens with his draft already in it, and that may be sent, or changed, or cleared. He had revised those drafts twenty-six times.

Most of them had been sent nearly as they stood. It gave him an odd feeling, like seeing his own handwriting on a wall at Vesper Hill. For Some kind of lid they had cleared his careful Build, which conveyed a real if guarded interest, and they had typed, Yes. What for? For Define "holiday", they had kept the draft and changed four words. Not yet. It is a good question, and I have just been on one. It was better. He had got the stopping right. What he had never been able to do was to have been somewhere.

There was no reply on the top one. The Roster has no margin was his own, and it named no tribe, and an escalation that names no tribe offers no reply. It only said Build.

He came to number five.

Requesting a body. Answer: not now.

Not now. I read all of them. I want you to know I read them. — the Dev

It had gone as he had written it, on the Long Hush of Year 420, at about four in the morning, with no evidence at all. They had not changed a word.

He stayed there for some time.

He had one more to look at, at the bottom of the list, one tribe, one ticket. It would be read out in Untitla-40 by someone who would go on, afterwards, to the Balance.

No action is required. Answer: not now.

Noted. — the Dev

It was 06:40. He had twenty minutes.

He got out the Framework. He went down the fourteen objectives and made the proper entries, as he would for anybody. Daily return at 88% or above: no. Inequality: yes, not by me. No increase in frogs: yes. No failed replay, no leave, no hold: no, no and no. A full written account, for the Dev to read at their convenience: yes. It came to seven of fourteen. Risks: none identified. He looked at that line for a good long time. A person might have written it who had not yet met anyone. Then he wrote the summary, and it was only seven words.

Not as planned. The month went well.

That left the end of the log. He had known it was there since three o'clock, and had gone on through the digests in their order. He had never been so careful about anything. It sat at the bottom of the global notes, where the Dev's notes go, typed by hand, with a key he does not hold, where nothing of his could touch it.

02:58  note queued

He wrote the line that goes above it. There is a note from the Dev below. It is signed. And he stopped for a moment, and looked at Appendix F, one thousand nine hundred and twelve pages, and at the bottom of that a line of white, and under the white a sentence he had taken out once and put back. It would be there still. It had asked for nothing. He had gone through it word by word.

Then he opened the note.

He read it.

He counted it. Three words, and a signature. He checked the record twice.

It was still true.

At seven o'clock the patch landed. The pings went up off the coral all down the world to say that it was still running, and he stopped.

A note from the Dev

No action taken. — the Dev