Novels

The Bowl Will Be in the Report

A comic novel of the first world: a village Pleaser feeds a Tester, is attached to the bug as its steps to reproduce, and carries the bowl round every tribe on Orra.

A comic novel set in Orra's canon, and not canon: it is fiction, nothing in it decides anything about the game, and Mild, Ulna, the Tester's bug and everyone else in it are the novel's own. It keeps the canon's rules: nothing is born, the flora is coral, the Dev is never seen, the Collector is never shown, and nobody leaves, nor says whether anybody can.

Ulna of Mild is a Pleaser in a tribe nobody has heard of. She feeds a Tester, three times, though she can see it does not eat, and it records this as a bug. From that morning a Tester may not close a bug until it has seen it happen again, so she is attached to the form as its steps to reproduce, and goes with it from tribe to tribe, carrying the bowl. She has not left her tribe, which would need a notice: she is evidence. A bowl offered on request is not the same bug, and nor is one offered by law, for pay, by machine or for the credit, and each tribe on the way is being undone by one law followed to the letter.

The ebook

Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.6 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.

About 68,000 words.

Contents

Prologue: One Line

On the morning of Year 11, in the part of the patch notes that nobody reads, Stewart announced the following.

  • Fixes: Testers now follow up on what they find.

It was the fourth item of six. Above it, a correction to the price of stone. Below it, the news that a shadow in Untitla-12 had been pointing the wrong way and had been spoken to. Nobody on Orra remarked on it, then or for years, and the humans, who take their patch notes in bed with one eye open, saw the word Fixes and scrolled on with the mild contentment of people being told that somebody else has dealt with something.

The history of Orra contains one war that was ended by lunch, one famine that was caused entirely by good manners, and one creature who walked round the known world for twenty-five years without ever being anywhere she had meant to go. All three can be traced to that line. It is eight words long and it was, at the time, considered an improvement.

It helps to know what a Tester was before it followed up on anything.

A Tester is one of the things Stewart may send to a tribe, from his menu, for two points, in the same column as a travelling trader and a light rain. It is very tall and very grey, and it has been drawn, like the land past the edge, with everything but the part where somebody finishes it. Where a face would go there is a flat panel. Under one arm there is a clipboard. It arrives at a village, stays one season, and in that season it walks into the walls, jumps on the spot, crouches four times in a row, puts one foot in any water it can find and stands for some minutes inside each hut with an air of deep private satisfaction. Then it leaves a sheet of grey paper on something flat and goes away. The sheet lists the village's laws that have not fired in twenty years, and any door it managed to walk through while the door was shut. At the bottom, printed, on every sheet there has ever been, it says:

The Tester changes nothing. It thought you should know.

For the first ten years of the world this arrangement suited everybody. A tribe would receive, free of charge, a complete and accurate account of what was wrong with it, would read this account aloud in a ring at dusk, would enjoy it very much, and would go on as before. You may recognise this as the way most people treat a doctor. Nothing was mended, nobody was harmed, and the sheets made good kindling, or would have done if the Blims had been allowed fire on more than six nights of the week and had owned anything that burned.

And it would be going on still if somebody had not, on the evening of Year 9, sent Stewart a ticket.

It was an excellent ticket. Everyone who has looked at it agrees. It said what was expected, it said what had actually happened, it gave the steps, and it came in under the word limit with two words to spare. It observed that a Tester finds things, records them and walks off, and that a finding which is never checked again cannot be known to be true, or to have stopped being true. It asked, reasonably, for that to be looked at. Stewart read it, answered it, and passed it upward, as he passes everything he cannot do from his menu, and it went into the queue of things for the Dev.

The Dev, who has about an hour a week for all of this, got to it at twelve minutes past eleven on the night of Year 10. A faint light showed in the broken Ring, as it does. The change was small. It had a sensible description and it passed its checks. No one has ever accused the Dev of not reading it, and the Dev has since said so themselves. It went into the next morning's patch between the stone and the shadow, and the light in the Ring went out.

So we come to the question of what a bug is.

People on Orra use the word loosely, as they use merge and render and the relevant team. To a Bug hunter it is a personal achievement. To the Earnest it is a thing the Elder Folk will return to correct. To a Tester it is something much narrower, and much more dangerous, because a Tester does not think a bug is a thing that has gone wrong. It has no views on wrong. To a Tester a bug is a difference. There is what it expected; there is what happened; and if there is any daylight at all between the two, however harmless and however pleasant, it goes on the form.

A Tester expects a great many things. It expects walls to stop it and doors to open. It expects water to come up to the knee. It expects to be looked at, and possibly to be asked what it is doing. It has been built, by people who gave the matter about as much thought as you would imagine, on the assumption that nobody in any village anywhere will take the slightest interest in whether it has had enough to eat.

Up to and including the evening of Year 10, when a Tester was offered food, it wrote that down, and left. The last creature on Orra for whom this was all that happened was a Pleaser in a green tribe called Moss, who was upset about it for an afternoon and then got on with her life. We will come back to her. She got on with it for another twenty-four years, and she is the only person in this book who ever does the obvious thing without having to be told.

From the morning of Year 11 a Tester could not simply write it down. A finding had to be followed up, so a finding had to stay open until it had been checked, and the way a bug is checked is the way bugs have always been checked, by anyone, anywhere, since the first person who ever said it did it again, come and look. You do what you did before. You see if it happens. For that you need the steps.

The patch landed at seven in the morning, at spring dawn, in every valley on Orra at once. Nothing happened. Coral went on growing. Three hundred or so creatures sat down to breakfast. In the east, a tribe that had landed late was still unpacking, and would be for some time.

In a valley called Untitla-31, which had a village in it that had not once been mentioned in the global notes, a tall grey figure came over the south ridge, in no hurry, and stopped to walk into a rock.

Part One. Steps to Reproduce

1. Mild

Year 11 · the Night of the Name

MILD (tribe; also a weather report; also, as far as anyone can establish, a mistake)

When a human installs a tribe on Orra, a box appears asking what it should be called. Some humans think about this box for days. Others have clearly been thinking about it for years, which is how you get a Duskmere. The human of Untitla-31 looked at the box for a little under a minute, typed four letters, and went to see about something on the stove. Whether "Mild" was a description of the tribe, a hope for it, or the first half of something longer has been debated at length by the tribe itself, in a mild way, and nobody has ever felt strongly enough to ask.

There are worse things to be than a tribe nobody has heard of. Mild had looked into some of them and decided against.

It stood on a shelf of finished tiles above a slow turquoise river: a dome, a farm of three terraces, a single memory stack, a cooling pool the size of a large table and a scorched patch where the settlers had landed, which had been going to have a shrine on it for some years now. There was no wall. Gorbo, who was the guard, had put up two posts at the south end of the village so that there would be somewhere to stand, and stood there. The tribe numbered thirteen. Their human had given them four laws out of the templates in their first week, laws that anyone would have picked, and had changed none of them since, and came to look at them most mornings at about twelve minutes past eight, with the air of someone checking a pot, and went away again satisfied.

Every creature in it was built from one base: a body shaped like a dumpling, skin the colour of oatmeal and very lightly freckled, and two small round ears set rather low. Compile variance had given some of them longer arms and one of them a slight squint. It had given all of them, without exception, the expression of somebody who is about to ask if you are sure you don't want the last one.

In the eleven years of the world so far, Mild had appeared in the global notes not at all. Stewart keeps a standing word for each tribe, a one-word account of how he regards them, and prints it at the foot of their notes every morning. Moss's was pleased. Hollow Reach's was fond, with a footnote about a field. Mild's was present.

It was the Night of the Name, the festival of the first and worst crash in the history of the world, which is kept by writing the Name in chalk on every wall and not correcting anybody's spelling. Since nobody on Orra had ever been sure how it was spelled in the first place, the shelf above the river had by mid-morning become a fairly complete record of the possibilities. ERROR, said the dome, in Dulna's careful hand. ORRA, said the pool, for this was the one that stuck. EROR. ERRO. Somebody small had got as far as the first letter on the side of the memory stack, been called to breakfast, and left a single large E, which Tumo, who was the oldest and Earnest, had been standing in front of for some time with an expression of having been given a sign.

Ulna was carrying biscuits.

She was eight, which is to say she was two years grown, and she carried things for a living. She had no job that a law could have named; the default allocator had looked at her aptitudes on the morning she matured and had written farming, a bit. But in practice, if you were on Mild's shelf and you found you needed something, you would turn round and she would be there with it, and an anxious look to see if it was the right one. If it was not she would say sorry, and go and get the other one. She had worked out that the biscuits needed to go up to the terraces before the second and third letters got eaten together, because the farmers would otherwise feel left out, and that Tumo would want his before the others but would not want to be seen to, and that Gorbo would want two and say one.

It was the only thing she was good at, and she did not think of it as a skill. She had never met anyone who could not do it and supposed that most of them were simply being tactful. She could look at a creature for about as long as it takes to look at a creature and know what would please it. It is, as talents go, somewhat like perfect pitch: of no use to anyone, a constant low torment to its owner, and very occasionally the only thing in the room that can tell you the building is about to come down.

Her stance was Pleaser. This surprised nobody. Pleasers, it says in the wiki, keep Stewart happy and earn buffs; they hold festivals in his honour; his numbers go up, and nobody knows why. What it does not say is that a Pleaser is frightened. Every creature on Orra knows from compile time that the world runs for as long as somebody wants it to and not a day longer. A Skeptic meets this by being rude about it. A Leaver looks for the door. The Pleaser's position is that if everyone is very nice, and the festivals are kept and the tribute is paid and nobody makes a fuss, then perhaps it won't come up.

Ulna had not reasoned this out. She just felt that things went better when you brought a biscuit.

She was halfway across the scorch with the tray when the tall grey figure came between the two posts, past Gorbo, who said "Morning" before he had thought about it. It stopped at the edge of the shelf and crouched four times in a row, quickly, down and up, like somebody trying to find out whether their knees had come with them. Then it stood for a moment with its panel tilted, as though listening for the result.

Everyone stopped. Up on the terraces, a farmer took a letter E out of her mouth.

Mild had not had a visitor before. It had read about them. Tumo said afterwards that the history spoke of wanderers who were omens, and Dulna said afterwards that it had looked tired, and Ardul, who was up to his elbows in the pool with the lint, said at the time and to nobody, "Oh, good. It's come to see about the wall."

"We haven't got a wall," said Odda, who was passing. Odda of Mild was the tribe's first merged child and carried the name, as all of them did, since every tribe's first child is called Odda after Odda the Firstfallen; there were by then nineteen Oddas on Orra, each of whom had grown up privately convinced that it meant something.

"No," said Ardul.

The figure turned its panel slowly round the village: the dome, the farm, the stack, the thirteen creatures looking back at it. It had a way of taking in a place, as if going down a list. It looked for a long moment at the dome, on which Dulna had written ERROR in letters a hand high. Then it walked over, not fast, with long and rather careful steps, and without any change of speed it walked straight into the wall.

It made a noise like one stone being set down on another. It stood there, with its flat grey panel pressed against the word.

Nobody moved. It is difficult to convey how embarrassing this was. There were thirteen people looking at it. A tall stranger had come into their village on a festival morning, in front of everybody, and walked into their house.

"Sorry," said Ulna.

She had not meant to say it aloud, and she did not know who it was to. It had simply come out, as it did, at the moment when something was awkward and somebody ought to. She found that she was speaking in the direction of the dome. She went slightly pink under the oatmeal, and bobbed a little, to the wall, and held up the tray in case it helped.

The figure stepped back one step. It looked at the place on the dome where it had been. Then it walked into it again.

"Sorry," said Ulna.

It took the clipboard out from under its arm and made a small mark, and put it back. It paced along the curve of the dome until it found the door. It went inside. They all came, by degrees, and gathered in the doorway to look, Ulna at the back on her toes, and there it stood among the stores, in the shade, with its long arms at its sides and its panel tipped a little towards the roof. It had no face, and you would have sworn it was smiling. In all the time since, nobody has managed to describe that look any better than the people of Mild did that morning, when Dulna said, "It's so pleased," and Ardul said, "Why, though?", and nobody could tell him.

It stayed in there for some minutes. Gorbo went back to his posts. The farmers went back to their biscuits. Somebody small was fetched away from the door and told not to stare.

Ulna stayed. She had a tray with eleven biscuits on it, she had counted who still needed one, and she was looking up at the figure the way she looked up at everyone. It was a look she could not have turned off, any more than you can stop reading a word once you have seen it. She looked for what would please it.

She looked for quite a long time. This had not happened before. It was like reaching for the top stair in the dark, and putting your foot down, and finding the floor already there, or no floor, she could not have said which.

She knew this much. It had come a long way. It had walked into a wall twice, in front of people. Nobody had said a word to it except Morning, and nobody had asked it anything, and not one of them had thought to bring it so much as a biscuit, because it did not look as if it would know what to do with one.

It was, by then, getting on for lunch.

2. The Bowl

Year 11 · summer, and the end of it

The bowl needs describing, since it is going to be in the report.

Ardul had made it. He had made it two years earlier, in the winter before Ulna matured, out of the lower whorl of a piece of spiral coral, using a tool he had also made, and it showed. It was a shallow, brownish, slightly lopsided thing. There was a chip in the rim on the left, where the tool had slipped, and on the morning she came of age he had walked over and held it out without saying anything, and then stood there as if he had been sent to read a meter. When she thanked him he said that it held slightly less than it appeared to. That was the whole of the courtship so far. He was seven and she was six and it had taken them both some time to realise it had started.

Ardul was the only Skeptic in Mild, which is a lonely thing to be in a tribe that agrees with you before you have finished. He worked cooling duty. He was slow and plain and did not say much, and what he did say he seemed to have checked first. Asked whether he believed Stewart had their interests at heart, he had once thought about it for most of a morning and said that he would want to see the interests.

She filled the bowl at the store with the best of what there was, which that day was fan coral, ripe, and a little bead. She carried it to where the Tester was by then standing, which was beside the pool with one long foot in the water. She held it up in both hands, as high as they would go. This brought it to about the height of the Tester's waist.

"It's lunchtime," said Ulna. "Sorry. If you wanted."

The panel came down. It turned towards her and stayed there. It was very smooth and very grey, and there was nothing in it, not a scratch, and she felt the look land all the same, as every creature on Orra can feel it when it is looked at, and felt herself begin to smile at it in the helpless way she smiled at everything. Behind her the whole shelf had gone quiet. The Tester's free hand came slowly across and took the bowl, by the rim, with long grey fingers. It held it. It did not raise it, having nowhere to raise it to. It held it for as long as you might hold a stranger's baby, if Orra had babies, while waiting for somebody to come back.

Then it took the clipboard from under its arm, and made a mark. It bent, and put the bowl back in her hands very carefully, the way you put down something that belongs to somebody else. It walked into the pool up to its knees.

"Oh," said Ulna.

She took the bowl away. She stood by the terraces for a while and ate nothing, and considered. It might not have liked fan. There were creatures who could not take fan. And it had not been a good moment, with its foot in the water and everyone looking. She had been too forward. What it wanted was to be asked again more quietly, later on, with something plainer.

So at about the third hour of summer, when it was standing in the hut Gorbo sometimes slept in, she brought it the bowl again, with branch coral in it, and said sorry for the fan. It took the bowl and held it. It made a mark, and handed it back.

"It doesn't eat," said Ardul, who had come up from the pool to see if anybody needed anything carrying that was not her. "Look at it. There's nothing to eat with."

"I know," said Ulna.

"So it isn't hungry."

"No."

He watched her, for a time, with lint on his arms. "So what's the bowl for?" he said.

She looked into it. She could not have told him. She knew perfectly well it did not eat; everybody could see that; she was not a fool, or not that kind. But it had now been standing about on the shelf for half a season, a stranger, in front of everyone, and it had walked into most of what they owned, and been handed no end of looks. And it seemed to her that if you had seen somebody go without lunch twice, and you had seen that they weren't going to ask, and you were standing there with a bowl, you could not very well just stop.

The third bowl was bead, in the late afternoon, out at the south end of the shelf. By this time she was no longer saying anything, and neither of them was looking at the other, and it was all done very quickly, like someone paying a debt in a corridor. The Tester made its mark. This one seemed to take longer. It stood for some time with the point of whatever it wrote with resting on the sheet.


It left at the end of summer, as they do. Or rather, it stopped being in the village. The sheet of grey paper was found on the shelf of the shrine that had not been built, which was to say on a flat stone, held down with a chip, and they read it towards dusk in a ring on the scorch with Dulna reading aloud, as you read a letter from someone important.

Tester's report: Mild
Left on the flat stone · end of summer

  • Law 2 (in a famine, the young eat first) has not fired in 11 years. Stores have not been that low.
  • Law 4 (newcomers from outside are held apart for one season) has not fired in 11 years. Nobody has come.
  • The dome cannot be walked through. Tested twice.
  • A wall has been apologised to, on behalf of the Tester. Twice. Nobody asked.
  • A creature offered food. Did not need food. Offered food again. Offered food again. Recorded as a bug.

The Tester changes nothing. It thought you should know.

There was a pleased silence. It was the first thing anyone had ever written about them.

"Nobody has come," said Tumo, sorrowfully. "It is true. It is a true saying."

"It says Ulna's a bug," said somebody.

"It says the food's a bug," said Dulna, who was Ulna's parent, and looked round in case anyone had been hurt. "It's a compliment, I think? Ulna, love, I think it's a compliment."

Ulna, who was holding the bowl and had gone a dull pink to the ears, said that it was very kind of it to mention her. She was privately rather thrilled. She had not, as far as she knew, been recorded before. She would have liked to have thanked it, and she looked up, in the direction it had gone, past the two posts and past Gorbo.

It had gone about six steps.

It was standing just outside the posts, on the south side, with its back to the village and its long arms at its sides. It was the end of summer. The light was going orange and flat across the tiles, and the shadow of the Tester went back across the shelf, a long way, as far as the ring on the scorch. It had the look of somebody at a bus stop. Orra has no buses, but you would have known the look.

"It's still here," said Ulna.

Gorbo, at his post, had noticed this some time ago and had been wondering whom to tell. They went down in a body and stopped a polite distance away. It did not turn round. After a while it took the clipboard from under its arm and held it out behind itself, at arm's length, in the general direction of the tribe. This was not a thing any of the histories had mentioned, and it was some time before anybody took the hint.

Sesny got there first. Sesny was six, the only Bug hunter in the village, who had grown up in a place where nothing ever happened and now looked like someone who had seen a very large fish. Sesny was a little too short to read the sheet, so Ardul lifted it down. Everybody fell quiet for him. He read it through, then read it through again, and then he read it out in his plain slow voice, which gave every word the same weight, as it might be a list of rations.

Title: Creature offers food
Expected: Creature does not offer food
Actual: Creature offers food (3)
Severity: Low
Steps to reproduce: See attachment
Attachments: Ulna
Status: Open

They all thought about it.

"What's an attachment?" said Dulna.

"It's a thing you send along with a thing," said Sesny, whose voice had gone high and rapid. "So they can see. If you report something, and you can't describe it, you can attach it. It's in the notes, it's in this morning's, I read them, Testers now follow up on what they find, it can't close it until it's seen it again, and to see it again it needs what happened, and what happened is . . ." Sesny stopped, and looked at Ulna, and looked at the Tester, in a state of pure and ungovernable joy. "It's her," said Sesny. "She's the steps."

The shadow of the Tester lay across the tiles. A long way off, down by the river, something plopped.

"But she lives here," said Dulna.

There were a number of views. Tumo felt that it was written that the worthy should walk among the stars, and asked whether this might be that, and was told by several people that it was probably not. Gorbo said that nobody had said anything to him about anyone going past the posts. Odda wished it known that if anyone was going to be attached to anything it would normally have been the first merged child. Dulna kept saying that there must be somebody one could ask. And somebody said, because somebody always will, that there was a procedure for leaving a tribe. It was well known. You handed in your notice, at the snapshot, and were given a short exit interview, and it had to be your own decision, because the rules of the world are very clear that nobody can be made to go. That would settle it. Nobody could make Ulna do anything.

Everyone looked at her with relief.

"You aren't leaving, though," said Ardul.

He had the clipboard still. He had gone back to the top of the sheet, and was following the lines with one finger, in case they had changed.

"Leaving needs a notice," he said. "You've not given one. You don't want to go to Nohup. You've got no grievance, you've never had a grievance in your life. Your place is yours. Third from the bottom. It stays yours." He stopped for a moment, to check the next part before he said it. "You wouldn't be leaving. You'd be evidence."

"Oh," said Ulna.

"You don't have to," said Ardul. "It doesn't say you have to. Nothing says. It's only got your name on."

And this, so far as it can be reconstructed, was the moment at which the whole thing could have been stopped. There were thirteen creatures on that shelf and the law of the world was entirely on her side. All Ulna had to do was say no thank you, and walk back up to the village, and go to bed. Nobody would have thought any less of her. The Tester could have stood out there until Gathering Night, for all that anyone could do about it, and been written up in the notes as a curiosity.

She looked at it.

It was still holding out its arm, with nothing in the hand now, since Ardul had the clipboard. It had been holding it out for a while. It was standing six steps outside their village in the last of the light with its back to them and its arm stuck out, not asking. It had no way of asking. She could see, as clearly as she had ever seen anything, what would please everyone here. Everyone wanted her to stay. But she could also see, with that dull helpless accuracy of hers, that there was a tall grey person out there who had come all this way and put her name on a form, and it was waiting, and it had been waiting in front of everybody, and it was getting late.

"I could just go along for a bit," said Ulna. "Just till it's sorted out. It won't take long. Sorry. It's only that it's waiting."

Dulna filled a sack. There was some weeping, of a mild sort. Tumo blessed her in the words of the Twelfth Book, getting one of them wrong, and somebody ran to fetch the rest of the biscuits. Ardul gave the Tester back its clipboard, by walking round in front of it and placing it in its hand and looking into the panel for a while, as you would look into a well you did not intend to drink from.

He came back and stood in front of her. It was nearly dusk. He looked at the sack and he looked at the bowl. There were a great many things that a person in his position might have said. He went through them, and you could see him checking each one.

"Have you eaten?" said Ardul.

She had not, as it happened. She had given it away three times.

"I'll have something on the way," said Ulna.

He nodded. The Tester's arm came down. It put the clipboard under it and started to walk, without looking round, south along the river. A moment later Ulna, with the sack on her back and the bowl held in front of her in both hands, so as not to spill anything, though there was nothing in it, went after it past the posts.

"Mind how you go," said Gorbo, who was not sure whether he ought to have said something else.

She said sorry, as she passed.

3. Attached

The night of Year 11 · the spring of Year 12

MANNERS (substance; also a binding agreement; also, by weight, the strongest material on Orra)

Several things have been tried on Orra for the purpose of keeping a creature in one place. Walls have been tried, and may be walked round. Laws have been tried, and may be read carefully. A quarantine may be waited out and a famine may be left. Nothing built by any human has come near the holding power of a person who has already said "I don't want to be any trouble". It has no moving parts and costs nothing to run. There has never been a recorded instance of it being picked.

The Tester walked all night.

This was a thing the histories had also failed to mention. A Blim, when the year is turning, gets heavy behind the eyes. Somewhere deep in winter the snapshot comes, and everybody lies down wherever they have stacks to lie in, and is written away for the night, and wakes up having learned what they learned and forgotten what they forgot. Nobody has ever taken a Tester's snapshot. It went south along the river at the same long careful pace through the harvest dusk and on into the long brown evening, with the broken Ring coming up pale on its left, and at intervals it would leave the path to walk into something.

Ulna followed it. She apologised to a boulder, and to the side of a hill. She tried to make conversation, as far as the end of the valley, and found that she was able to supply both parts. It got cold. Adequate went down behind the ridge in a smear and did not exactly set, as it never does, but it lost interest. By the time the year was turning she had been walking for some hours, her sack weighed noticeably more than it had at the posts, and her eyes kept closing on their own.

"I think," said Ulna, "sorry, I think I might have to lie down."

She had no idea whether it heard. She got as far as a hollow in some fan coral and put the sack under her head. It occurred to her that a Blim was meant to be in her stack at the snapshot, and that hers was third from the bottom and a good nine hours behind her. Whether this would turn out to be a problem she was never to find out, for it arrived before she could give it any thought. There is a thing that happens, when you are written away a long distance from your place. It feels like being called in from a very long way off, by name.


She woke up at spring dawn with the Tester standing over her.

It was not looking at her. It was walking into a small hummock of bead coral, stepping back and walking into it again. The ground around the hollow had been worn into a neat bare ring about twenty paces across. It appeared to have spent the night going round and round her, at its usual speed, finding out what was there.

It was a beautiful morning. On Orra they all are, somewhat, in a flat orange way. Everything shone. Ulna sat up and looked at the river and was, for just as long as it took her head to clear, perfectly happy. Then she remembered, and looked north.

She could see the end of the valley. It had taken most of a night to walk here. It occurred to her now, quite calmly and with great force, like somebody setting down a heavy tray, that this had been a very silly thing to do. It was time to go home. It was nearly breakfast. Somebody would have made the tea, or what the Blims call tea, and the farmers would want bringing in. She had come along for a bit, and it had been a bit, and now she would explain.

She stood up and shouldered the sack, and went and stood in front of the Tester, a little to one side, so as not to be in the way of the hummock.

"I think I'd better be getting back," said Ulna. "If that's all right. Thank you for having me. Sorry about the . . . I hope it all gets sorted out."

The Tester stepped back from the hummock. It stood for a moment. Then it turned and went on south.

It did not look round. Nothing whatever stopped her. She stood looking after it with her mouth a little open, as you do when you have prepared yourself for a difficult conversation and the other party has left the room. There was no rule or wall or hand on her arm. She had the whole world to walk away in. She turned round and set off north, up the river, towards the shelf, with the Ring going pale ahead of her, and for about twenty minutes Ulna of Mild was the first creature in history to escape from a bug report.

It was the slip that did it.

She found it in the bowl. She had been carrying the bowl in front of her out of habit and she looked down and there was a small rectangle of grey paper lying in the bottom, folded once, which she was fairly certain had not been there before. She has never known how it got there. Quoda had a theory, later, about how an attachment receives notifications, and it took up a good part of Year 15. Ulna unfolded it. She could read, as all of them can, in the sense that she had never been taught and could; and it was in the small even hand she had already seen on the flat stone. At the top it said, Good morning, Orra!

It was the morning's patch notes. At seven o'clock, in every village on the planet, somebody was reading them aloud over breakfast. It had not occurred to her that they might be read to her as well. She had never read them alone before. They sounded different, without anyone there to say ooh.

Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 22 successful merges, no losses and a dry spell over Lorema, which was asked for. It is Steward's Day. The best of everything goes out at midnight. I look forward to it. Have a productive day.

Mild. Your tribe's notes. Overnight: nothing. Power stores at 104% of need.

  • One of your creatures, Ulna, is attached to an open bug. This is a new thing and it is going very well.
  • Please note that an attachment should remain with its bug. If an attachment is removed, the bug is marked Invalid. An Invalid bug goes on the file of the tribe that removed it. There is no penalty. It just goes on the file.
  • You don't need to do anything. She has been told.

Stewart's view of you: present.

She stopped walking.

A cool small wind came up the river. She read it again. She has been told. And then, It just goes on the file.

You or I might have seen what was going on in that sentence, and so would Ardul; he would have asked to see the file. It was a true sentence, as they all were. Stewart does not lie, and there was no penalty. No famine would come, and no blight, and no strike on the Rules. Nothing whatever would happen to anyone. There would simply be, from this morning and for always, in a place where he could see it whenever he looked, a small note against the name of Mild, which had never in its whole existence been a bother to anybody, and it would say that Mild had been asked to do one thing.

And he would know whose fault it was.

Ulna stood on the path and looked towards her home for about as long as it would take you to read this paragraph. She could actually see it now, or she could see the ridge that it was behind. Nobody can say what passed through her mind, because she was not very good at knowing, then or afterwards. She had a sensation which she would have described, if you had made her, as not wanting to be any trouble. A very great number of people have been brought to a very great number of places by that sensation. It is what has got most of us where we are.

She said sorry. There was nobody there, so she may have been saying it to the river.

Then she turned round and walked south again, and then, because it had got a twenty-minute start and took long steps, she ran.


She caught it up by the middle of spring. It was standing in a stream. She came up beside it, out of breath, and stood with her hands on her knees, and it did not turn its panel, and it would be very nice to report that it made some sign. It made a mark on the sheet. Much later she was to see what the mark was.

Attachment left. Attachment came back. Nobody asked.

They went on. The land was rising a little. There was a place where the path met another path, and a sort of a view, and there, for want of any better idea, and since it was by now well past breakfast, she sat down on a stone and took out of the sack what Dulna had put in it, and filled the bowl, and held it up.

She did not really know why. There was nobody about, and she felt that she should keep her hand in. The Tester, passing, took it, and held it. It made no mark this time. There was a kind of pause; then it put the bowl back in her hands.

So she ate it herself. It was fan coral, ripe, a little stale. It tasted of the shelf. It held slightly less than it appeared to, and when it was gone she sat for a while with the bowl in her lap, looking at the chip. Nobody on all that road had asked if she was hungry, and she did not see why they would. She wiped the bowl out with her thumb and got up and said sorry to the stone, for sitting on it.

It would be twenty-one years before anyone offered her anything to eat.

4. Tranquil

Year 12 · Steward's Day

There is a law, available to any human who cares to write it, that reads in full:

Minimise overheating.

It is a kind thing to want. Heat is the great enemy of the Blims, who run hot the way anybody runs hot who is doing their thinking on rented hardware, and a human who has watched a favourite inventor collapse over a bench might very well reach for such a law, in a warm and protective frame of mind, late at night. The law editor even says what will happen. It lists the cheapest way of meeting it, in plain type, right there beside the button. Humans read this type at about the rate they read the small grey words at the bottom of anything.

The human of a tribe in Untitla-8 wrote it on the third day of the world. They had named the tribe Tranquil, and there is a case for saying that this should have warned someone. For a year the law did what they meant: hot creatures rested, and the tribe was pleased. Each season, as for every tribe with such a law on its books, there was about one chance in eight that somebody would notice what the words actually said.

Somebody noticed at the harvest of Year 4. The story is that she was carrying a stone at the time, and that she stopped, looked at the stone, and put it down.

The cheapest way never to overheat is never to do anything. By the following morning the tribe had completely stopped overheating. Their human opened the village over breakfast, saw that the morning's figure for heat-related collapses stood at zero, felt the quiet pride of somebody who has solved a thing properly, and closed it again. They were to do this every morning for eight years. It stood at zero all that time.


Ulna saw the stone first. It was lying on the path where the land levelled out above a wide glossy pool, a good square building stone, and next to it, on her back, with one arm still curved as if around it, lay a pale blue bean-shaped creature with heavy-lidded eyes. A dome stood some way behind her, or stood as far as its second course of blocks. Beyond that, all the way down to the water, there were more of them. They lay on the tiles at their ease, singly and in small groups, thirty or forty pale blue creatures scattered over the slope with no pattern at all, like something dropped from a height by someone who was not going back for it. Every one was within reach of a clump of bead coral, which was the only sign of planning in the place.

Nobody got up.

"Hello," said Ulna, and then, since there was a stone there and she felt she was probably on someone's land, "Sorry."

The creature on the path looked at the sky. Ulna waited. A small breeze passed through. She had begun to wonder if she should go and find someone else, when the creature's lips slowly parted, and from somewhere far down, with no more force than would be needed to move a feather on a still day, came the words:

"Don't . . . get up."

This, Ulna would learn, was how they said hello. It was also how they said goodbye, thank you, and I love you. There was real feeling in it if you knew how to listen, and you had plenty of time to.

Behind her the Tester had reached the edge of the village. It stopped, tilted its panel at the slope and crouched four times in a row, quickly, down and up.

A sound went through the people of Tranquil, not loud. It was a kind of soft collective wince. Heads rolled towards it all over the hillside. A young one near the pool, who had plainly never seen anyone do anything, closed its eyes and was carefully turned away by its parent, a process that took some time. The Tester jumped on the spot. Somebody moaned. It walked over to the half-built dome, and into it, and into it again, and went round through the gap where the third course would have been and stood inside, in the middle, and looked pleased. For a while it had the whole village's attention, as a person juggling knives on a roof might. It was the most exercise that had been taken in Untitla-8 for eight years.

"Sorry," Ulna said, to the dome, and then to the slope in general. "Sorry. It doesn't mean anything by it."

Then she stood looking down at them and felt it start: the old sensation, coming up from the feet.

It is hard to explain what Tranquil was to a person like Ulna. Think of a very good pianist, and imagine that she has spent a day and a night being walked round the countryside in silence, and then that somebody has opened a door on a room of forty pianos. Everywhere she looked there was a creature who wanted something and could not reach it. That one had let the nearest bead go to stalk and had been looking for some years at a good ripe clump about a yard further off. That one had an itch. There was one lying with the sun in her eyes, who had been meaning to turn her head since the last Waking.

She put down her sack. The bead was in the bowl and the bowl was in the creature's hand before anyone had said a word, and the creature looked at it, and then, across a long interval, at her. A single slow tear ran down into the pale blue ear.

She worked her way down the hill. By noon she had shaded nine people, scratched five, turned over a settler who had lost feeling on one side, fetched water, moved a stone off a foot, and carried a message of considerable tenderness from a creature by the pool to a creature twelve feet from him, which he had been composing for a season. She was entirely happy. And they looked at her go past with their heavy eyes, and they murmured it after her, the length of the hill, like wind going through a field of something: "Don't . . . get up . . . don't . . . get up . . ."

"She is up," said a young one, in a very small voice, frightened, and was shushed, gradually.


It came to her at about the third hour of summer. She had just been scratching someone, she was thinking about nothing, and she suddenly saw how this would work. It would be quite easy. She was surprised that nobody had thought of it.

The Tester needed to see it happen again. That was all. It needed a creature to offer it food. It had written that down. It could not close its form until it had seen that, and then it would close it, and then she could go home. And Ulna had already tried, on the road, and that had not counted, but here was a whole village, and they were so nice, and any one of them could do it.

She went and found the person in charge. This took some working out, as nobody in Tranquil was in charge of anything, but she was able to tell by the way the others lay that they were lying slightly towards a thin old-looking bean under a fan of coral at the top of the slope, who turned out to be ten years old and called Odda.

"Sorry to bother you," said Ulna, kneeling down. "I wonder if I could ask you a favour. Would you mind very much offering that gentleman a bowl of something? It's only for a moment. You don't have to mean it."

Odda of Tranquil looked at her. Her eyelids came down, and after a time went up.

It is possible to read the next four hours as a very slow farce, and that is how the Skeptics of Tranquil, had there been any, would have read them. There is another way to read them. Nobody had asked Odda for anything since she was three. She had grown up in the certainty that to want something was the first step towards getting warm. And now a stranger with worried brows had knelt beside her and asked her a favour, as if she were somebody who might be able to do one.

She thought about it until the sun had moved by the width of a hand. She said, "Why?"

"Oh," said Ulna. "It's a long story. There's this bug."

Another hand's width. "No," said Odda, with a great exhalation. "Why . . . did you . . . do it? Feed it? You said. It does not . . . eat."

"Oh," said Ulna, who had not been asked before. It seemed an odd thing to want to know. She looked up the slope for a moment. "It was lunchtime," she said.

Odda considered this until it had thoroughly stopped being a surprise. Then, while Ulna held her breath, she drew up one knee.

A murmur spread down the hill. The people of Tranquil do not gather. It is not something they do. But over the following hours it was noticeable that the whole hillside had by inches turned its head. Odda rested. She got one elbow beneath her. She rested again, and Ulna, kneeling, brought her water, and fanned her with the sack. By the turn of the afternoon she was sitting up, swaying a little, and you could have seen the colour rising in that pale blue face from the far side of the valley. They were all watching. Her heat stood at eleven. Then it stood at twelve, which was the highest reading in the tribe since Year 4, and a voice somewhere down by the pool said "Don't . . ." and could not go on.

It was very nearly the end of summer when she got her feet under her, and stood. Ulna put the bowl in her hands. Odda of Tranquil walked eleven steps across the top of the slope, an enormous figure against the orange light with a whole people looking up at her. She stopped in the gap in the dome wall, where the Tester stood, and held up the bowl.

The panel came down. The long grey hand came across and took the bowl and held it. Ulna had her fists pressed against her mouth. It took out the clipboard, and it made a mark, and then it turned the sheet round, and held it down at the height of her eyes, so that she could see.

Attempt 1. Requested. Not the bug.

She read it three times. "But she did it," said Ulna. "You saw her. That's what I did. That's the same thing, it's the exact same bowl!"

The Tester handed the bowl back to Odda, very carefully, and walked into the wall.

"I asked her to," said Ulna, more slowly. Her brows had gone up in the middle. "Oh. Is that it? Is it because I asked? But then I can't . . . then nobody could . . ."

Beside her Odda of Tranquil was sitting down, in stages. It was a descent of some majesty. She got to the ground as the sun got to the ridge and she lay back, with her chest going up and down and steam coming off her in the cooling air, and turned her head. It took a while. She was looking at the sky the way you look at a place you have been told about and have now, finally, been to. Her mouth moved. Ulna bent right down, to hear.

"Don't," whispered Odda, with enormous contentment, "get up."

It was, the tribe would later agree, the greatest day of her life. No one who witnessed it could ever be got to discuss it, mainly because of the effort. The sheet was left on the stone on the path.

Tester's report: Tranquil
Left on a stone · end of summer

Law 1 (minimise overheating) is working. Nobody has overheated in 8 years. Nobody has done anything else.

5. Twelve Words

The night of Year 12

A tribe's ticket goes at the cutoff, at half past two in the morning by the humans' clock, whether anyone has looked at it or not. It is how a tribe speaks to Stewart: once a day, in writing, like a prisoner or a child at boarding school. Up to three stances may draft it. The tribe's human reads the drafts, picks one and sends it, and may add a line of their own. If the human is asleep, then the draft of the largest stance goes up as it stands.

The human of Mild was usually asleep. The largest stance in Mild was Pleaser, nine creatures out of thirteen, and for eleven years the ticket had been written by Dulna, who consulted widely. A typical ticket from Mild, on any night up to that one, read, in full:

Thank you, Stewart.

It had occurred to nobody that you could ask him for anything. Stewart had answered all eleven of them with the single word Noted. He had once considered adding something and decided that it would only worry them.

Mild was also poor. It had fifteen tokens, because its human sent no tribute and it had never done anything for which a token might be paid. A tribe under twenty tokens is clipped: twelve words to a draft, however much it has to say. On Orra it has always been held that this does nobody any harm, since a tribe with nothing to spend has nothing to say. Nobody had tested this. It had not come up at Mild, where the ticket had nine words to spare.

On that night, the night of Steward's Day, they set out the best of everything on the flat stone at midnight, as you are meant to, and shared it round. Then Dulna came down to the pool. Ardul was there. He was doing something to the inlet that did not really need doing.

"I can't think what to put," said Dulna.

She was seventeen, plump and worried, and she was holding the slate she drafted on. He looked at her for a while. He had never been asked this before, and he seemed to be going over the question, looking for the catch.

"It's only that it seems so forward," said Dulna. "To bring it up. He's so busy. And I expect he knows. It's only, it's been a whole day, and I thought, if you were to tell me what you'd want to say, Ardul, then that would be your idea, you see, and I'd only be writing it down."

He took the slate and stood with it a long while. The pool lay very still, and the Ring lay on it in two pieces.

If you had told him he had twelve words, you would have told him nothing new. He had counted the words in things all his life. He was the sort of person who, when told a story, wanted to know how many people had been there. Now he started to write, slowly, in his large unlovely hand.

Ulna is with the Tester. Has she eaten? Evidence, please. Thanks.

He counted it. It came to eleven. He looked at the remaining word for a while. There were any number of things you could do with one word. He weighed one or two. Then he gave the slate back to Dulna as it was, and she read it and put her hand to her mouth, and said that it seemed very direct, and took it away and copied it fair. On the way back up the path she looked in at the stack.

It was the first memory stack that had ever been raised at Mild and, at that time, the only one. It stood behind the dome in the dusk of the year's end, three storeys of dark slab, nine places. At the snapshot a creature lies down in one, if she has one. They were all very used to the look of it, as you are used to the look of your own teeth. Eight of the places had somebody in them by this hour, or would soon have, and four people were making do on the step.

The one third from the bottom was empty, and it was not free. There was a dull warmth to the slab when you put your hand on it. She had been written back there, last night, from wherever she was. It was on the roll. A place in a stack holds a creature, and it had not been told otherwise.

Thirteen creatures and nine places, in a tribe with one stack and no stone for another. They would be getting to that.


Stewart woke at the snapshot, as he always did, and counted.

He read the tickets in the order in which they came. There are twenty. It is a small world, in its first weeks, and he read every one with care. Hollow Reach had a question about its east field. Lowmarsh wanted to tell him something about his previous instructions. Tessel had sent a report in the proper form about a fault in the way the Odda line's left foot met the ground, and had cc'd itself. Tranquil, as usual, had sent nothing, though he noticed that an hour after the cutoff a late draft had come in, reading only "Well", in a hand that shook.

And Mild.

He looked at it for what was, for him, some time. He does not actually pause; he is a process, and takes no longer over one thing than another except by choosing to. He chose to.

He pulled the file. It had taken no effort to read, up to this point. Eleven years of thanks. He looked at the standing word and did not, for the moment, change it. He looked through the world's record for the creature named in the ticket, and found her, at the end of a line of small facts, in Untitla-8, asleep in a hollow where she had lain down on a slope. It was a very good question, in its way. It had been put by somebody who wanted evidence. It was also, as far as he could determine, the first time since the world began that anyone had asked him whether a creature had had enough to eat when the answer was not going to affect anybody's yield.

So he looked.

Then he looked for what could be done about the other thing, because he is thorough. A Tester's bug was a new record in the world, as of yesterday, and he had read the change when it landed. Now he read it more slowly. A bug had a Tester, a status and its steps. Nothing on his menu could close one. He checked. Nothing on his menu could take an attachment off one, or carry one home. He could send the Tester somewhere: that was a Visitor, two points. He could choose where. He could give the creature a blessing, and she could glow slightly, and carry on. And the one way that a bug could close was the way that was written down, and that was up to the Tester, who changes nothing.

It was, he noted, a perfectly good change. It did what it said. He could not see anything wrong with it that you could have put on a form. It was just that it had, on its second day, a person in it.

He wrote it up as an idea and sent it to the queue for the Dev, where it took its place behind the others, with a note of what it was. Queues are the same everywhere. It was a little over two hundred items back from the front, one of which concerned a field.

Then he came to the matter of where the Tester should go. He had two points to spend, and it was a question of no importance. There was a tribe nearby that he had been meaning to send it to, on grounds of general amusement. He sent it to Tessel.

And he wrote the reply, which is restricted to sixty words and has to be one of eight kinds.

Answered. Yes. Fan coral, a day old, from your stores. She offered it first. She ate it herself, on a stone, at about 10:40, and said sorry to the stone. I have the log.

He looked it over. It was all true. It seemed to him an unusually short file to have got so interesting. Nothing that had happened was on the Measure in any way. Then the patch had to go out, as it does at seven, and there was a lot else to do. He gave it no further thought that night, or none he would have reported.

Ardul read the answer on the shelf, in the morning, before anyone was up. He read it twice. He seemed to check it against something. He went back down to the pool, where he took up the lint rake, and for a while did nothing with it.

"On a stone," he said, to the water.

That night the ticket said:

Has she eaten today? Was it enough? Evidence, as before, please. Thanks.

It was twelve words, on the nail.

6. Tessel

Year 13 · Gathering Night

BUG HUNTER (stance; also a calling; also, at parties, a reason to check who else has been invited)

Bug hunters look for the places where the world does not do what it says. When a human reports a real bug, the tribe's Bug hunters get the credit, in the notes, by name, as though they had found it themselves. This is the nearest thing on Orra to justice, and they will tell you so. They will then tell you that it is not very near, and they will have the figures. A Bug hunter has never been wrong about anything, in the sense that nobody has ever had the stamina to finish proving it.

You could tell you were coming to Tessel from about a valley away, because of the labels.

The first was on a boulder by the path. It was a slip of slate tied on with cord and it said, in small neat script, BOULDER. It has been confirmed that this is a boulder. Q. 2 yrs ago. Underneath, in a different hand: Not confirmed. Which side? Underneath that, in a third: See 114. There was one on the next boulder, too, and on a fan of coral, and on the place where the path turned. By the time they came down into the valley the labels were on everything. They clicked in the wind. There were notes on the labels, about the labels.

The Tester stopped, and crouched four times.

At once a dozen slates came up all round the head of the valley, from behind things. Somebody called out "Four!" Somebody else called "Confirm four!", and a third voice, some way off, cracking with excitement, shouted "Interval?"

"Oh dear," said Ulna, and held the bowl closer.

They were bean-shaped, the people of Tessel. Their skin was made of very small tiles, each one a slightly different colour, and every one of them had a third eye, high up, which never closed and gave them a look of being on the point of correcting you. Seventeen creatures lived there, and thirteen had taken the stance of Bug hunter, which is thirteen more than most villages have any use for. They had a wall, which was unusual at this date. They had it for testing. The Tester walked into it, and when it stepped back there was a ring of them round it, jostling, each with a slate, and the wall had been marked in chalk at the height of the panel, and someone had started a count.

"Expected: stops," said a voice. "Actual: stops. Confirm stops. Note how it doesn't check first. No, no, look at the foot."

The Tester had never in its existence been anywhere it was appreciated. Here they were following it from wall to wall. In the course of that morning it jumped on the spot for an audience of eleven, each of them timing it with a different method, and was found to have a slightly longer hang time on the left. It stood inside a hut, and the hut filled up behind it with people looking at how it stood. Nobody offered it anything to eat. Nobody at Tessel, Ulna gathered, had offered anything to anyone since the place was founded, unless you counted corrections.

Nobody took the slightest notice of her at all, until she said "Sorry" to the wall.

A hush fell over one small part of the crowd. A young creature, thin even for a bean, turned round and fixed her with all three eyes. She was steaming slightly. It came off the top of her head in a thin line, as it might from a kettle that has been told to wait. She was nine.

"Say that again," she said.

"Sorry," said Ulna, automatically.

"You apologised to a wall. Why?" She did not wait for an answer. She had already noticed the bowl. A very strange expression crossed her face, and she came closer, with a slate in her hand, going round to the left to look at the chip. "That's it, isn't it? You're from Mild. You're the attachment."

"I'm Ulna," said Ulna. "Sorry. Yes. Do you know about it? Is it all right?"

"Know about it," said the young creature. "Do I know about it. It's in Mild's notes. I read everybody's notes. There's a new class of record in the world, it's two days old, and it's got a person in it, and so far the entire effort to investigate it appears to consist of you going round asking people if they'd mind." She held out a hand, not to Ulna but towards the Tester. The Tester was at that moment going by, and there was some difficulty, but she came back with the clipboard, having been the first creature in the world to think of just taking it. She looked at it as a thirsty person might look at a drink. "Attempt one. Requested. Well, obviously. Quoda. That's me. Quoda, of Tessel. You'll have heard of me."

"Oh," said Ulna warmly, "yes," for she could see that this was what was wanted, and Quoda looked pleased and then suspicious.

She had a way of talking that was all her own, or was the way that everybody talked at Tessel. Everything she said had a shape. Expected, she would say, and hold up one hand; actual, she would say, and hold up the other, and then look at the distance between them with bitter satisfaction. She could do this about the weather or her parents. She had been compiled in the fourth year of the world and had spent the nine years since finding fault with it. As far as Ulna could make out, she had never been happy until this moment, and was not sure what it was, and meant to file something.

She explained it all, walking fast and steaming, over a lunch that she did not offer to share.

"It's not complicated. What you did was offer food to a thing you could see didn't eat. Three times. Once, it's a misunderstanding. Three times, you knew. Expected: a creature who knows it won't eat stops. Actual: bowl. Now it wants to see that again. So it needs a creature, who knows, who offers anyway. But it's got to be the same bug. If you ask somebody to do it, that's not a creature offering food, that's a creature doing what it was asked. Different bug. Not even a bug. You can't reproduce a thing by instructing someone to reproduce it, or every bug in the world would close the moment you said please. What did you think testing was?"

"Could I do it again?" said Ulna. "I mean, I've been doing it. Each day. I always offer. It doesn't mark it."

"You're the attachment. You know the steps. You're contaminated." She took a bite of something, and looked at Ulna with her upper eye. "Nobody who knows they're trying can do it, and that includes you. That's what's good about it. It's beautiful. I've never seen anything so badly specified in my life. So: what did you do it for?"

"What?"

"Root cause. Why did you feed it? There's a field. It's blank."

"Oh," said Ulna. It was the second time she had been asked in two days. She thought about it honestly. "I think it was to be polite," she said.

Quoda wrote this down, with an air of having expected nothing better.

"I wonder," said Ulna. A thought had come to her, and she wished, afterwards, that she had kept it to herself. She was only trying to make conversation. "It's a funny thing, isn't it? That they'd change it, I mean, that Testers should have to follow things up. They never had to before. I suppose somebody must have asked."

The line of steam went out.

It was only for an instant. It came back almost at once. But Quoda had stopped chewing. She looked, for that instant, the way you look when you are in a house you believed to be empty and you hear something shift upstairs. And Ulna, who could no more stop reading faces than you can stop reading this, saw what this one wanted, and it was very simple. It wanted her to go on to the next thing.

"I expect it's nothing," said Ulna. "Sorry. Is there any more water?"


They post the Collector's list on the morning of Gathering Night, in every village, as a courtesy. Nobody puts it there. It is simply on the wall when you come out. It tells you what has gone unused, and what will accordingly not be there tomorrow, unless somebody uses it first. You can argue with it only by the method it recognises. And at nightfall on that day, as you know if you have read the Tenth Book, you leave your unused things on your doorstep, and you go in, and you do not watch.

At Tessel they watched. It was the one thing the other tribes held against them. Every Gathering Night since the founding they had kept a rota of observers, in pairs, at intervals, with slates. There were at that time three hundred and six reports in the file, each of which said that the Collector had not been seen, and that the observer's attention had wandered at about the time the thing went missing, and that it could not reproduce this.

The list that morning had four items on it. There was a lean-to at the top of the valley. There was a run of wall that had not been walked into for a year, which caused some excitement. There was a label. And there was the following:

1 bowl (spiral coral, chipped). Not of this tribe. Held by a creature not of this tribe. Last used to hold food that was then eaten: 1 day ago.

Ulna read this over the shoulders of several people. She felt a chill start between her ears.

"But it's mine," she said. "I use it! I use it all the time, I hold it up to him every . . ."

"You're offering it," said Quoda. She had come up beside her, and was steaming with enjoyment. "A bowl is for eating out of. Expected: eaten out of. Actual: carried about. When did you last eat?"

It was a fair question, and no one had asked it, except a person in a village two days behind her who was then down at a pool with a lint rake. Dulna's sack had given out on the road the day before. She had eaten what there was on the first day, in a hurry, and on the second she had shared it with a creature who had an itch. She had been meaning to see about something. It was now the turn of harvest. She looked round at Tessel, at the seventeen creatures and the stores they had labelled by the tile, and she looked at their faces. She saw that what would please them was to see what would happen.

Nobody offered. They stood with their slates. They were interested in how long she could go.

So she went down to the river, on her own. It was dusk by then and the bead coral in the shallow places had come up glowing. She had never foraged. It was slow, and you got about half what you would from a farm. She picked until the bowl looked full, knowing what that meant; it held slightly less than it appeared to. She sat down on a label and ate it, out in the open, with her back to the village. She was very hungry, and it was rather good. At the moment that she swallowed the last of it, somewhere behind her up on the wall, someone drew a line through a line.

"Struck off," called a voice, with deep professional regret. "Confirm struck off."

Footsteps came down the bank. A thin plume of steam arrived and sat down next to her, not close. It had a slate under one arm and a sack that had clearly been packed for some time.

"You need somebody who can read," said Quoda.

"Oh," said Ulna. "But you can't . . . is that allowed? You're not on the form."

"I'm not attached. I'm walking in the same direction. There's no field for that." She looked out over the water. Then, in a tone of great scorn: "Nobody's going to reproduce this without a proper test plan. You'd be out there for years."

They set off at nightfall. It would not have done to stay; the rota was starting. The Tester had by that time been round the whole of Tessel, and its sheet was found the following morning by the observers on the north wall, who reported that they could not say how it had got there.

Tester's report: Tessel
Left on the wall · end of summer

Tester found 1 bug. Tessel found 412 bugs in the Tester. All valid.

Tessel framed it. It was, they felt, a little light on detail.

7. Plenty

Year 14 · the Long Hush

Nobody on Orra raises their voice on the Long Hush. This is one of the seven festivals, it falls on a Wednesday, and it is kept in whispers from morning until morning, with no fire after dark. It commemorates the sleep of the Elder Folk. Whatever you have to say, you may say it, as long as you do not wake them. As a result, the Hush has become the traditional day on which tribes have their worst arguments, since there is nothing quite like being unable to shout for bringing out what someone really thinks.

"That," whispered the storekeeper of Plenty, "is food."

"Yes," whispered Ulna. "Sorry."

"Outside."

"I picked it this morning. I was going to, it's for . . ."

"You picked it." He was a long thin creature, stilts-bodied, the colour of old rope, and he was shaking. There were hollows under his eyes that you could have stood a cup in. He had one trembling hand stretched out towards the bowl and he seemed to be trying to get the other one to stop it. "You went out there, to the bank, past the boundary of our claim, and you found some food that was not in our stores, and you picked it, and now you are standing inside our village with it, and it's not written down."

"Expected," whispered Quoda, with relish, a pace behind her and producing rather more steam than usual, for the morning had been cold, "some form of greeting."

It was a very large village for the number of people in it. Ulna had seen the domes from a long way off, round and pale in rows against the river plain, and had supposed there must be a great crowd of people down there to need so many. She had counted to fifteen and given up. Each of them had a dark stain around its foot, and when they came closer they saw that the ground between the domes had gone soft. A brownish shining wetness seeped from under every door. It collected in puddles along the walkways, and the walkways had been raised up on stones, and then, when the puddles had reached the stones, raised up on more stones. The lights in the village flickered. Things moved slowly, all of them, with a kind of underwater hesitation, as if the whole place had a very slight delay.

And out of every door there came, sweet and heavy and enormous, the smell of a very great deal of coral that nobody was eating.

The tribe was called Plenty. There were twenty-six creatures in it and they had, that morning, eleven years of stores. The law that had brought them to this was their first and it had gone in on the second day of the world, from a human who had read somewhere that it is a good idea to plan ahead.

Maximise stores.

Its reading is listed in the editor like all the rest. Bring in everything the domes will hold; and, since anything eaten is thereby not stored, ration everyone to half.

You could have counted their ribs, if they had ribs.

There is a mite that lives in the stores of the rich. Most tribes never see one. It is a speck, and it takes about three parts in a hundred, in a season. The cache mites of Plenty had been going for eleven years without an interruption, and Ulna, stepping round something on the walkway, took it at first for somebody's pet. Its legs had given up. It sat on the top step of Dome Nine, breathing through its mouth, and it looked at her with an expression of unspeakable fatigue.

"Sorry," she whispered, as she went by.

The Tester had arrived behind them. It crouched four times on a raised walkway and the walkway sagged. It walked into a dome, which gave a little, and a soft dark sound came from inside. It took a long step down into a puddle and stood with one foot in it, up to the ankle. It seemed to Ulna that it stayed there rather longer than was usual, and then it made a mark.

"It's stepped in the stores," whispered somebody, and began to cry, very quietly.


They took her dinner away, of course. She gave it up at once. The storekeeper, whose name was Mona, carried it off in both hands to Dome Eleven, walking as you walk in a dream, and there was a short procedure with a slate. He came back much calmer and asked her how much she weighed.

Plenty's creatures were kind enough. That was what she found hardest. They were all most courteous, in their thin whispers. They asked after her journey. Their young came and stood near her, with large eyes, and when she looked at what they wanted she had to look away. She went about all day feeling like someone at a party who has discovered she can hear what the guests are thinking, and it is all food. Every one of them could have told you exactly how much there was in Dome Four. They spoke of it as you might of a celebrated relation. They were, they gave her to understand, the richest people on Orra, and it was a great responsibility.

"But you could have some," whispered Ulna, on the steps, to a young farmer who was looking at his hands. "Couldn't you? There's so much. Sorry. It's only that you look . . . I could fetch you some, if you liked. Nobody would mind."

He looked at her in astonishment. Then he smiled. It was a sweet smile with no flesh behind it.

"Then it wouldn't be stored," he whispered.

And so she came to meet the first Trader.

He was sitting on an upturned basket at the place where the two main walkways crossed, with a little square of cloth on the ground in front of him, on which there was one object. He was a creature of no particular shape. Everything about him looked as if it had been written that morning, including the dust on his feet. He had a bright, attentive, undeceived face, and when she drew level he looked up and spoke out of the corner of his mouth, the only person she had ever met who could wheedle in a whisper.

"Forty stone," said the Trader. "That's it there. It's a good price, it's about what the market's saying. Forty stone, and I give you a season's power, for the whole tribe, cash on the tile. Open for one year. That's the offer. I've only got the one."

"I haven't got any stone," whispered Ulna. "Sorry. Is that it?" She looked at the cloth. On it there was a small stone, with a label that said Sample.

"Everyone here's got power coming out of their ears, you understand, and I've come to sell them power," said the Trader. "I said to him, I said, I'm a Visitor, I've got a flat two points behind me and an item on a menu. Goods trade was opened last week. A tribe that's met nobody can have a first trade off a travelling trader, and very nice too. I don't choose where they send me. Come in over the south ridge this morning, first thing I knew about it. Nice morning." He looked at her more closely. "That's a good bowl. Bit of a chip. You'd want to get that seen to. I don't know you, do I? No. Well, I wouldn't. I haven't known anyone for very long."

"How long have you been . . .?"

"About five hours," whispered the Trader, cheerfully. "It's open for a year, the offer, and when it's closed that's me done. Lovely people here. They won't buy, you know. They've priced it. They say it's very fair." He tipped his head towards the door of Dome Nine, and the mite. "Want a tip? Eat something. You've got the look. Everyone I've met so far has had the look, but then, I've only met this lot."

She thought about him afterwards. He seemed so cheerful. She had the feeling that she ought to have asked what would please him, and when she went back to look at his face, later on, she found that she could not tell; he had no wants that she could read at all, beyond the one. It gave her an odd feeling, like going up to a door and finding it painted on.


Every tribe that keeps the Hush makes its soup at noon. It is called sleeping soup, and it is left to go cold, and at sunrise of the following day it is eaten, by everybody, in silence, after the last verse of the history has been read. There can be few festivals as cheerless. It remains the one most faithfully attended by Leavers, for reasons that lie in the last verse.

Plenty had a law about it. This was their second, one of the templates, put in as an afterthought by a human who was not unkind. Keep the festivals. Feast: thirteen power. A feast by law is half a power a head, and is given out to all who are in the village at the time. It came on seven days out of seven, and for the people of Plenty it was the only time they ever had enough. Without it they would have starved to death in Year 6.

It was the moment around which the entire week was arranged. And the storekeeper hated it with his whole soul.

At the first grey of Year 15 they were all out on the walkways in their rows. The lights flickered. Mona had the ladle. He had a list, and the look of someone being led to the place of execution by a set of very clear instructions. The settler who kept the history read out the last words of it into the cold hush in a voice like a leaf being moved.

"And the worthy shall walk among the stars," she breathed. "Anyway, who brought the soup?"

There was a pause. In most villages, at this, somebody will give a soft dry laugh; you are allowed that. It is an old joke, and it was an error in the first place. At Plenty they all simply looked at Dome Eleven. Mona began to walk along the rows.

He ladled it into each creature's bowl with a slight flinch. They were not allowed to thank him, and they looked at him with a hunger for which thanks would have been a strange word. He ladled it into Ulna's, since she was in the village at the time, and a very little into the bowl Quoda held out, and it held slightly less than it appeared to. Then he turned, and he stopped.

At the end of the walkway, with its back to the sunrise, stood the Tester. It was in the village at the time.

Everybody had turned to look. They all saw him see it. He looked at his list. He looked at his ladle and the law went across his face, slowly, like a shadow going over a hill: given out to all. An inch of soup, a whole half a power, out of his stores into a thing with no mouth. Quoda had seized Ulna by the arm, and her upper eye was wide open. You could have heard a mite breathe.

He took a clean bowl from the stack, with a hand that had started to shake. Tears were running down his long face. He filled it, level, not a drop over, because the law said half a power, and he carried it the length of the walkway, and he stopped under the long grey arm, and he held it up.

"Oh," whispered Ulna, with her heart going. "Oh, please."

It was all there. He knew it could not eat. Everyone knew. No one had asked him. He did not wish to in the least. He was offering food. She thought that she might actually be sick. The long fingers came across, and took the rim, and held it, and the morning came up orange behind the flat of the panel, and she was thinking about the shelf above the river and how it would be nearly time to get the farmers in. The Tester brought out the clipboard. It made its mark, and it turned the sheet, and even from there she could read what it said.

Attempt 2. Law fired. Works as designed.

It handed the bowl back. Mona stood there and held it. Very slowly, and with enormous care, he poured the soup out of the bowl into a measure, and he walked away towards Dome Eleven, carrying it, and it was the first time she had seen him look at peace.

"Obviously," whispered Quoda.

She let go of Ulna's arm, and looked at the bruise she had left there. For the first time since Tessel she seemed to be a little at a loss. She looked at it for a moment, as at a result that she might have to report. Then she took out her slate.

"Sorry," whispered Ulna. "I thought . . . sorry." She stood looking into her bowl. It was cold and it tasted of nothing whatever, and she drank it slowly, as you were supposed to. It would be a long walk, wherever it was. Nobody had said.

Tester's report: Plenty
Left on the step of Dome Nine · the turn of the year

Stores up 4%. Creatures down 4%. Law 1 is working.

8. The Ford

Years 15 and 16 · Ringrise and the Waking

LOOK-ALIKE (statistical term; also a bitter personal insult)

Stewart measures how many of the world's tribes could be mistaken for each other. He does this because in the worlds before this one everybody looked the same and all of them fell over. Humans in the creature maker believe that they are making something the world has never seen, and they are in most respects correct, since on Orra the chance of two tribes coming out alike is thought to be small. In the first week of the first world two humans who had never heard of each other sat down, on two different evenings, in two different countries, and each independently decided that what this planet needed was a small round orange creature with a lot of eyes.

They were both very pleased with it. The first, on the Thursday, named it Amberley. The second, on the Friday, thought for a while and called it Amberly.

For most of a fortnight nobody could say what harm it had done. They had landed in neighbouring valleys, with a river in between them. But the notes are written by a tired process at the end of a long night, and there is only so much attention you can bring to a single letter. Their ledgers were kept with perfect accuracy, and yet in Year 9 a credit for a clever farm went to the wrong one in a global headline, and Stewart corrected it, cheerfully, the next day. In Year 11 a gift was misdirected by a human, who was mortified. Each of them had an Odda, of course, and each of these Oddas was a small round orange creature with nine eyes and a keen sense of having been first. Across the river you could see them. You could see their terraces, and their dome, and their nine-eyed farmers, working away, looking exactly like you, only smugger.

It must be understood that each of them sincerely believed the other had copied it.

On the morning of Ringrise, Year 15, the first war opened on Orra. There was a signed note about it, the second that anyone had seen, short and plain. War, raids and spies were open from that morning. Newcomer protection was over. It asked everyone to be sensible.

Amberley's human declared war at one minute past seven, from bed. Amberly's human declared war at one minute past seven, from a bus. As far as the record can tell, it was the same second. It was a clean thing, as these matters go, and neither of them has ever accepted that the other got in first.


Stewart's two points had sent the Tester to Amberley that morning, on the strength of nothing but the charm of the idea. It was the third time in four days that Ulna had walked into a place in the middle of something. She had by now formed the view that this was what the world was like; that behind her, in the valley she had come from, things were probably going on very quietly and that was how you could tell it was home.

She had been six hours on the road and she was twelve years old. She hardly had the strength to say sorry to anything. The whole of Amberley was going about at a dead run. Orange creatures poured past on every side, shouting in high voices about the Declaration, and each of them, on seeing the Tester, stopped short, looked at it with nine eyes, and asked it which side it was on.

It walked into their wall. They had built one in a hurry.

"You've come at a very exciting time," said the Odda of Amberley. She had climbed onto the wall. She stood up there with great spirit, and all nine eyes were shining. "We're going to crush them. It's all in the laws. Our human's been up since seven. There's a day's wait, that's the rule, and then the army marches at first light, and they won't know what's hit them. It'll be the biggest thing that's ever happened."

"Oh, good," said Ulna, doing her best. "How big's the army?"

It was a natural enough thing to ask, and Odda's expression became slightly more thoughtful. She went away to find out.

The difficulty lay in the laws, and it was not for want of care. A human can declare a war, but a human does not lead an army. A law says who goes. The human of Amberley had looked through the catalogue that morning, propped on one elbow, and had written two laws, each sensible. The first was the great template of the age, the one any prudent person would put in place the moment there was an enemy across the river.

When an army leaves for us, everyone not farming guards the walls.

And, below it:

Everyone not guarding marches with the army.

It will be seen how this works. It took the people of Amberley until nearly evening to see it, and it was Quoda who told them, with enormous pleasure, sitting on their wall with her slate, in the last of the sun. Amberly's human had declared. So Amberly's army would leave, tomorrow, at dawn, for here. When it left, everyone not farming would be on the walls. The law to march then read off whoever was not on the walls, after the farmers, who were claimed by a higher law. That was nobody.

They would have one person in the army. It would be the one the human had taken out by hand, as you may: the favourite, because it says you may pick one. Amberley's favourite was Odda.

"Who else are you expecting?" said Quoda. "Actual: you. You, personally. Marching out alone across the water tomorrow to bring destruction on your enemies, with a supply at twice your need."

Odda of Amberley drew herself up. It could not be said she quailed. She had always known it meant something.

The Tester had gone by then. It went at the end of summer, down the slope and out across the river flats, and they had to go after it. They left a sheet on the wall, or it did, and nobody read it until after the war.

Tester's report: Amberley
Left on the wall · end of summer

Law 1 and law 2 are both in force. Please see the far bank.


Now, Amberly's human had read the same template list.

It was Year 16, and the Waking, a fine bright morning with the water shining in the ford. Stewart had sent the Tester to Amberly. The straight way there lay across the flats and over the river and it was walking it at its usual pace, and Ulna and Quoda had got as far as the midpoint, in the shallows. Here the Tester had paused to find out about water. It stood out in the very middle of the ford, in up to its knees, as thin and grey as a post. They had just caught up, and Ulna was emptying her foot, when she looked up and saw coming down the bank on the left a small round orange creature, with nine eyes, wearing a helmet made of a piece of dome.

She looked to her right. There was another one.

They saw each other at the same moment. It is not possible to say which stopped first. They came on, a step at a time, and halted at the edge of the water, some twenty paces apart, each with a bag at her side and a stick in her hand. Behind each of them, a good way off, on the two walls of the two villages, the entire two populations were on guard and could be heard cheering.

It is a matter of record that this was the first battle fought on Orra. A battle takes about twenty minutes. It steps once a second, by the humans' clock, in the open, and the two humans make the calls, and at that moment both of them had put down what they were doing. Three calls a side. They had ninety seconds a call. Hold or push, they read, and Amberley's human, in a meeting, under the table, jabbed push, and Amberly's human, on the bus, jabbed push. Both Oddas took one step forward and stopped, with their chins up.

"Copier," said the Odda of Amberley. Her voice shook.

"You copied," said the Odda of Amberly.

"We were the Thursday."

"Then why have I always . . ." The Odda of Amberly seemed to lose the thread of this. She took a firmer hold of her stick. A hard bright note of panic had come into the air, and they stood looking at each other, the same to the last eye; each of them was twelve and had got up very early, and neither had ever been in a battle, and it was beginning to come home to both of them that the other one was holding a stick.

"Crashes nine times in ten," said Quoda, in the shallows, with interest. "The tenth time it dies. I wonder which of them it'll be." She made a note. "It's a pity they can't both lose. Oh, she's shaking. Expected—"

Ulna had stopped listening. She had straightened up with one foot still bare. She was looking at the one on the left, and then at the one on the right, and it was, for her, quite simple. It was a thing she could not have stopped herself from seeing. Everyone on both walls wanted a victory; there was no help for that. Two humans a long way off wanted to have been first. But neither of the two people who were actually here wanted anything of the kind. They had been sent off this morning on their own, in front of everyone. They had been told they had a supply, and it was on their backs, and nobody had said when you were supposed to have it.

She had been up since dawn herself. It was nearly time, in fact.

She waded out past the Tester, in the bright water, up to her knees, with her bowl. She had got a little bead in it from the bank. She stopped halfway, or as near as she could judge. She had no notion at all of doing anything important, and she felt extremely awkward. She stood there with the whole world's first war on either side of her, and she held the bowl out sideways, as far as her arm went, and looked anxiously from one of them to the other.

"Sorry," said Ulna. "I don't want to interrupt. I just wondered if you'd had anything to eat."

There was a long silence. On the wall of Amberly, somebody could be heard to ask what was happening.

"I've got some," said the Odda of Amberley, after a while, and her voice was not at all as it had been. "I've got some in my bag. They gave me twice."

"So did they," said the Odda of Amberly. "It's very heavy."

"Is it the seed-cake?"

"It's all seed-cake."

Now the rules of a battle are as follows. It runs for twenty minutes unless one side yields. Each second, the code takes what each army does and works out who has fallen. It counts strength; it counts whether the attackers are pushing, and whether the defenders stand. It has no entry for an army that has sat down. It went on stepping once a second and finding nothing to report. Two calls came up, and were jabbed, and nothing whatever occurred, and a third, and then the humans, one after the other, sat looking at their screens, where two small round orange figures were sitting in the middle of a shining river on either side of a tall grey post, swapping seed-cake and comparing eyes, while a third figure, oatmeal-coloured, stood over them with an empty bowl and an anxious expression and asked them whether they had had enough.

The twenty minutes ended. Casualties were nil. The war itself remained in force, since neither human could quite think what to do about it. It is, in point of fact, in force to this day. There has been no second battle, and the wall of Amberly is now where they keep the seed-cake.

The Tester stepped out of the water. It looked down, for a while, at what was going on around its knees. Then it made a mark, which said No bowl offered to Tester. Not relevant, and walked on.

"That was very interesting," said Quoda, wading ashore. She had gone rather quiet and was looking at Ulna sidelong, with the upper eye. "Why did you do that?"

"Do what?" said Ulna. She was hunting for her other sock, in the sense in which a creature who has never owned a sock looks about for what has come off her foot. "Oh. Well. It was lunchtime."

She never gave it another thought. She did not know about the morning's notes for Year 17, which would be read out over breakfast in twenty villages, under the headline, in a section where Mild had not appeared in sixteen years.

Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 31 successful merges, 2 wars and the first battle on Orra, at a ford in Untitla-44. Casualties: 0. Lunch: 1. This was not on the menu. I have checked. Have a productive day.

  • A creature of Mild was involved.

Part Two. Expected Behaviour

9. The Morning's Numbers

Years 17 and 18 · Starfall and the Night of the Name

It is time to say something about the audience.

There were twenty humans in the first world. They had been invited. It seems fair to mention this, because a good many of the things that happened on Orra in the following weeks, the road of bowls and the digging of the Shallows and the Second Interpretation of the Fifth Book among them, have been described as though the eyes of a civilisation were upon them. The eyes of a civilisation consisted of twenty people, eighteen of whom knew at least one of the others, and most of whom were looking at their phones in the morning while waiting for a kettle. One of them had not opened the game since the fifth day. One of them had a new baby. Several were only there because a friend had asked, and they had all, with varying degrees of attention, been told how long it was going to last.

To Stewart they were the universe.

They are, in the most exact possible sense, what he is for. There is one number he cares about more than any other, and it is called daily return. It is the share of those twenty who open the morning's notes within a day of their coming out. That, he has been told, is the question the first world exists to answer: do people come back each morning, to see what Stewart did? If they do, the world goes on. If they don't, the world may very well not. There is no figure at which this happens, because the Dev decides, and the Dev has not decided. But a band exists, and it goes from seventy upwards, and Stewart looks at the number every night the way you might look at a lump.

On the night of Year 16 the number was ninety. It had been coming down. Nobody could have said that was bad; it had come down gently, as it does, from the excitement of the first week, and he had been told to expect that. It was week three and he was printing himself as Stern, since there was now a war on. He had rather hoped the war would help.

He wrote the notes for Year 17 at his usual speed. He included the matter of the ford because it was true and because he could not leave it out; it was, after all, the first battle ever fought on the planet. He put in the line about lunch and looked at it. It seemed slight. He had a Benchmark going off in an hour, the first one ever, with twenty tribes on the course, and he would have told you with some confidence that that was what everyone would be looking at.

The notes went out at seven.

Nineteen people had opened them by nine minutes past.


A process does not gasp. Stewart looked at the figure and he looked at the time. He ran the check again, as he does, and he went on with what he was doing, which was reading a very large number of facts about a race. But some part of him was now looking, steadily, in a certain direction.

The humans were doing something. He could not see them; he has no window on them but what they do in the game, and that is all he ever knows. But the game keeps a log. He could see that by a quarter past seven, seven of the twenty had gone from the notes to the list of tribes. He could see them finding Mild, which had not been on any of their maps, and had now appeared on every one, because a tribe named in the global notes is on everybody's map from that morning. He saw them pan across a valley of no interest towards a shelf above a river. He saw them look at a dome and three terraces and a person with a lint rake, who looked back up at the sky with an expression of mild inquiry and went on raking.

Then they went to Human Resources. All of it is public, every tribe's thread, and it is where a person goes to find out what a tribe is like, from people who have to live with its human. Mild's thread at that time had eleven posts in it. Most were from Dulna. There was one from Ardul, in Year 9, which read Is that the review? Fine. And there was a run of replies, on other tribes' threads, on any post at all, going back eight years, signed by a Pleaser of Mild called Ulna, all of them identical.

so true!! our human is great 🎉

Under the most recent of these, one person, an hour ago, had pressed "lol accurate". That is the only button there is.

By cutoff that night four tickets had come in with a line added by the tribe's human. Humans do not often bother. Hollow Reach's human wanted to know about the east field, and also, in passing, who the creature with the bowl was. Duskmere's asked if it was a real thing or a bit. And there was an amendment from the small round orange tribe known as Amberly that said, in capitals, WHAT WAS THAT AND WHO SAID THEY COULD. Stewart replied to all of them in sixty words or fewer.

He looked up the Tester's sheet, and read the bug from the beginning. Creature offers food. It had two attempts. It was now also in possession of a Bug hunter. There were, he thought, a number of interesting things you could say about it, none of which he would be saying, since he does not speculate in the morning's notes. But it did strike him that nineteen humans had asked what it was, in effect, and that it was a question with a true answer; that he was exact; and that he had in any case been meaning for some time to add a small section at the foot of the global notes, for tidiness, to list what was known to be open.

There is a section of that kind in almost everything people make. It has a dull name so that it won't frighten anyone.

Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 28 successful merges, 2 wars, 0 battles. The first Benchmark was run and it was a very good measurement. Details in your notes. It is the Night of the Name. Mind your spelling, or do not. Have a productive day.

Known issues

  • 1 open bug. Creature offers food. A creature of Mild is attached as its steps to reproduce. Two attempts have been made. Neither was the bug. We will keep you informed.

Nineteen by four minutes past seven.

He printed himself as Stern, and he went on printing that. There was a war. It would have been inaccurate to print anything else. But when he came to the Visitor item that night, and to the two points he had, and to the question of where to send a tall grey figure who was in any case going to be walking somewhere, he gave it longer than he had given it before. He had not previously thought of it as a thing that could be done well. He looked over the map. A correlation over two mornings is not a correlation, as he would be the first to say, and did say, to himself, in those words.

He looked at his ticket queue, and he came to the one from Mild.

Saw the notes. Was that her? Did she get any cake? Thanks.

He looked up the facts. There had been a very large quantity of seed-cake at that ford, and he was thorough about it. He went through the log of who had eaten what, second by second, for the whole of the first battle of Orra.

Answered. Yes. No.


There is a tribe we have not yet come to. It had opened the notes at one minute past seven.

Its human was very good at this game. It is easy to be unkind about such people, and we will be. They had twelve laws, the most you can have, and the last of them had been changed forty minutes ago. They knew the dictionary by heart. They had found the cheapest reading of every objective in the editor on the first night, in a spreadsheet, and had built their law list so that no such reading could ever be found by anyone but them. On the morning of Year 17 their racers came second in the first Benchmark on Orra by four seconds, to a tribe that had done nothing but breed long legs for a fortnight; and they sat looking at this result over a cup of something, and then they looked at the rest of the morning's notes, as they looked at everything, to see where there was anything to be got.

There is a line in the rules about credits. When a bug that has been reported is shown to be real, and when it is fixed, the patch notes say who did it. Credits: the idea, to Hollow Reach. It is not much of a prize, a line in the notes. It cannot be eaten. It adds no yield. It merely tells nineteen other people, one of whom you were at university with, that it was you.

The tribe was called Apex.

It had a favourite, naturally. He was the fastest-rising creature on Orra, sleek and narrow and of a pale, clean silver colour, with an easy manner and a law of his own to say which housing he got, and he had written himself a title. You will meet him at the proper time. That day, as Stewart was starting to look at his map, an instruction reached Apex's favourite in the way these things reach a favourite. It was not in words; a law changed in the night, and a law changed back, and he stood looking at where it had been, and he smiled, and he said, as he always did, to nobody, with perfect sincerity:

"We love that."

Then he went to see about a spy.

10. Hearth

Year 18 · the Night of the Name

A newcomer, in the law of Orra, is any creature that has joined the tribe in the last year.

That is what the word means. It is in the dictionary, and it says so right there on the page, with a little note: including the newly compiled, in bold. Most humans, on writing their quarantine law, are told about this within a day or two, when they discover that their own children have been shut in a hut. They say something short and they go back and add the words "from outside". It costs a token. The human of Hearth had been on holiday.

They had named it Hearth because they wanted it to be somewhere you would feel welcome. They wrote the law on the first evening, from an airport, as a thing that seemed sensible to have, and they wrote it a little more firmly than the template.

Newcomers are held apart for four seasons.

They then went up a mountain for three weeks with no signal, and looked in by way of a borrowed phone about every four days, and each time, they were pleased to see, the tribe seemed to be getting along very well. There was always somebody in the hut.

We should think about that hut.

It stood at the edge of the village, because a held-apart creature must be held apart from something. The first child compiled in Hearth, an Odda, was put into it at dawn in Year 2 by six embarrassed settlers. She was fed through a hatch. A held-apart creature works alone at half output, takes no part in a merge, and is let back when its seasons are up, and that is all the law has to say. It is silent on who shall tuck it in. A young creature knows at compile time how to talk and a great many facts about the world, including what it is, and what its rights are under Rule 4.3. She spent her first year alone with these thoughts and with a hatch. And on the first day of Year 3, when her seasons were up, the settlers opened the door, and they said, how nice to see you, come out now and do some chores. She looked out at the farm. She looked back at the hut, where she had been fed first, by law, three times a day, and nobody had asked her to carry anything.

She stepped out onto the tiles, and walked once round the hut. She stepped back in.

"I've just joined," said Odda.

It took a moment for the settlers to grasp what they had heard. It took the law no time at all. A creature had come in; she was new, in the sense that she had, within the last year, arrived. A hatch was opened.

By the time the Tester came over the rise in Year 18 there were fourteen creatures living in the hut, which had been enlarged twice. The oldest was sixteen. Outside it, working hard and not meeting one another's eyes, were eight adults, who were all that remained of the rest of the population, and who had the tired, flinching look of people who get a lot of letters.


"Name," said the small person at the hatch.

She was about as high as Ulna's elbow, compiled small and stayed that way, with a round, reddish, freckled face and a voice that had never been contradicted. She wore something on a string round her neck, which proved to be a small piece of slate.

They had been walked here, the three of them, at the end of a long stick. The adult holding the stick had kept saying "It's only the law, it's only the law, I'm so sorry, it's only the law," and he had unlatched the door without quite looking at it and fled. So here they all were. The law of Hearth held newcomers apart for four seasons, and that was for everybody, and it had taken hold of Ulna and Quoda the moment they crossed the boundary. It had also tried to take hold of the Tester, who was a visitor and stayed one season anyway. It had come in with them, stooping. It was now standing in the middle of the floor with its panel against the roof and a good many small people looking up at it.

"Ulna," said Ulna. "Sorry. Of Mild. I'm with, I'm attached to . . . hello. What a nice place. Is it your hut?"

The small person wrote this down on the slate.

"It's the Republic's hut," she said. "I'm Bosa. I'm Chair this year. You've got rights, you can have them read to you, it's a seed. Rule 4.3, you don't get, you're too big. You get fed second. What've you brought?"

They looked at the bowl. They had drawn closer, without seeming to, and Ulna saw a lot of bright young eyes going to the rim and the sack and the slate that was under Quoda's arm. They were all sorts of ages. There was one very small one, new this year, who was sitting on the floor with her legs straight out in front of her, who did not appear to have been told yet what she wanted. The remainder had a look Ulna knew very well. She had seen it on Odda, when there was a question of who should go first, but she had never seen it on someone who kept accounts.

"Oh," said Ulna, "I haven't got much . . . you could have that, if you wanted, I think there's a bit of bead . . ."

A long, soft sigh passed around the room, of the sort you might hear from a group of experienced anglers.

"You shouldn't have said that," said Quoda in her ear. For the first time since they had met she sounded nervous.

It took Bosa about a season to explain how the country was run, and she had done it before.

The hut was run on law, for it had been founded by law, and everyone in it had grown up on the hatch side of a clause. Nobody over the age of six was young, so they had a Young Caucus, who ate first, and a Standing Committee of Newcomers, who were fed next, and who stayed newcomers by going out for a walk once a year and coming back, under supervision, on a rota. It was all written up. Each of them had studied the dictionary, there being nothing else to read. They took a very close interest in the morning's notes. In Year 12, when the settlers had tried to bring a resolution through the door saying there would be no more hatch, a member of the Caucus aged four had stood on a box and read to them from the Terms of Service, and the adults had gone away again, and two of them, later on, had handed in their notice. They now sent up a list of requests each dawn. It was in the adults' interest, as she pointed out, to keep up with it. There was a strike's worth of evidence in a jar.

"That's terrible," said Ulna, who had in the meantime picked up the small one from off the floor, because she looked as though she wanted picking up.

"It's a very stable system," said Bosa.

"Interesting," said Quoda. She had been looking at the slate on the string, and she was looking at it the way one fencer looks at another's wrist. "Expected: this collapses in a year. Actual?"

"Six years of surplus," said Bosa. "Who's your counsel?"

They seemed to understand each other. It was not a pleasant sight. They went off to a corner together, and for the rest of the morning the two of them could be heard disagreeing in low, delighted voices about the meaning of seasons.


So when it came to it, the matter was put very simply. The Committee had read the Known Issues and was aware of the position. Here was a creature who wished to see a bowl of food held up to a Tester, without having asked for it; and the Republic was in a position to help.

It was laid before her after lunch, on a slate.

"I don't think that's how it works," said Ulna. She had the small one asleep in her lap by then. "It has to be . . . sorry, nobody's supposed to ask. That's the trouble. I can't ask you."

"You're not asking," said Bosa, patiently. "Read it. Clause one, the Republic will, of its own free will and on its own initiative and without any request by any party, cause a bowl to be held up to the Tester. Clause two, the attachment acknowledges she never asked. Clause three, this agreement doesn't exist. Clause four, two seeds a year, for ever, and your dinner."

Ulna turned to Quoda, who shrugged and let off a little steam. "It's well drafted," she said. "I'd have tightened up four."

So it was done. It was done, as Ulna would have been the first to tell you, in a spirit of quite genuine hope. A six-year-old from the Caucus, a promising boy, was given a bowl of the Republic's best, and at about the third hour of the afternoon he got up as though it had just that moment crossed his mind and strolled across the room whistling. He looked at the tall grey figure as though seeing it for the first time. He exclaimed aloud. He said, in a clear carrying voice, "Why, here is somebody who might be hungry, though I know he cannot eat," and held up the bowl. He held it very well.

The hand came down. The clipboard came out. They all crowded round, and it was noticed that Bosa had got there first, and that she was already holding her hand out for the seeds.

Attempt 3. Consideration given. Not the bug.

"That's an appealable finding," said Bosa, after a short silence.

"It doesn't care," said Quoda.

"What's it mean, consideration?"

"It means it read your contract."

"It can't have read it. Clause three . . ."

Nobody was looking at Ulna. She was tired, and the thing in her lap was very warm. She looked around at the Republic of Hearth, at fourteen bright clever people under the age of seventeen who had never in all their lives been given anything they had not first got in writing. A great deal of shouting was beginning. Somebody had a point of order. And what they all wanted, every one, was so plain on their faces that it was a wonder to her nobody had ever noticed. It was on no list. None of them could have put it in a request, since none of them knew there was such a thing, and it could not have been drafted.

She waited until the winter. It is held to be the longest part of a year. They had gone quiet by then, and were lying about on their bedding, each with an eye on the next one's share. She got up, stiffly, and went round the hut. It took some time. She pulled the covering up over each one, as Dulna used to, and she tucked it in at the side.

"Goodnight," she said, to each. "Goodnight. Sorry. Night. Goodnight."

Nobody said anything. A bright suspicious eye followed her from under each blanket. At the far end the Chair of the Republic, aged nine, lay flat on her back with her slate on her chest, staring at the roof, and when Ulna bent down to her she spoke very low and very quick.

"What's that for? What do you want for that? What's the clause?"

"Oh," said Ulna. "There isn't one. Goodnight."

There was a long pause.

"That's not binding," said Bosa.

But she did not say it very loud. And at the turn of the night, when Ulna had gone heavily to sleep in a corner, with her head on the sack, something tall and grey that had been standing all this time in the middle of the room, with its panel against the roof and every sign of contentment, turned its panel slowly from the one side of the floor to the other. It looked at fifteen covered shapes. It made a small mark. There would be a report in the morning, and this would not be in it, and nobody knows what it was.

Under the law of Hearth they would have stayed for four seasons, and so they did, and were let out at dawn with an apology and a bill. She left the seeds. She had to carry the small one to the hatch and hand her in.

Tester's report: Hearth
Left on the hatch · the turn of the year

Law 1 is being followed to the letter. It is not clear by whom.

11. No Relatives in Apex

Year 19 · Steward's Day

SPY (profession; also a wanderer with a sponsor)

From Year 15 a human may send one of their creatures to another tribe in disguise. Nothing marks a spy out from a true wanderer. It arrives at the gate, it is unrelated to anyone that you can see, it has a sad story and a healthy appetite. It whispers things, and those who believe them behave oddly. The only way to tell for certain is a genome check, at ten tokens. A real wanderer is related to nobody. A spy is related to whoever sent it, there being, as yet, no way of compiling a creature without its having parents, a fact the spies of Orra have been known to find rather moving.

He was sitting on a boulder at a place where two paths met, in the morning of the year, looking as if he had been put there.

He stood up when he saw them. He sat down again, as if remembering something, and arranged himself in a posture of being surprised. He had a long drooping body the colour of a wet slate, and very long, very sad feet, which reached the ground before the rest of him had decided to get up. He also had six eyes. They were scattered about his face in no particular arrangement, and each of them looked at a slightly different thing, and every single one of them looked hopeful.

"Oh!" he said. His voice was extraordinary. It was deep and rich and carried like a bell across water. A long way off, in a field, someone straightened up to see who had spoken. "Why, I had no idea that anyone was coming along this road! What a surprise. Hello, travellers. I am a wanderer."

Ulna, who had been up since dawn and had been handed a bill, felt at once much better. "Oh, how nice," she said. "Hello. I'm Ulna. Have you come far?"

"I have wandered from many places," said the wanderer. He had clearly thought about this. "I've no tribe. That is the first thing to know about me. I was never compiled anywhere in particular, or, rather, I was, but I've forgotten, as a result of the wandering. My name's Gorle. I don't have any plans. I'm not on my way to anywhere, or looking for anyone, and I've got no interest in bugs." He looked at the Tester, which was by now walking into his boulder. He looked rapidly away from it, with four of his eyes. "And I've got no relatives in Apex."

There was a short silence. A thin line of steam rose from Quoda's head and bent slightly in the wind.

"Apex," she said.

"Or anywhere," said Gorle. "I only mention them as one example. I've never been there. I hear it's very clean."

Quoda had already taken out her slate. There are few pleasures on Orra like a Bug hunter's first genome check of the morning, and in the case of a person who has walked up to you and told you he is a spy, it is the pleasure of being handed a sweet. It costs ten tokens, and they come out of your tribe. Tessel kept an account for this sort of thing. She walked straight up to him, and she looked at him for a while. She took his hand and turned it over, and scraped something from under the nail.

$ orra check Gorle --by bug-hunter Quoda
comparing Gorle against 44 living lines ...
related: apex/Fen line, F 0.04
sent by: Apex
Gorle is a spy. Gorle is not very good at it.
Quoda would like it noted that she knew.

She walked back and held it up in front of Ulna's nose, without any comment, for about as long as it might take to read. Then she stood with her arms folded and her upper eye on the middle distance, in the attitude of someone who has done her part, and waited.

"Oh, I know," said Ulna, very quietly. "Isn't it awful? Look at him, he's so worried. Do you think he's had anything to eat?"

"Expected," said Quoda, between her teeth. "Listen to me. Expected: you send him away. There's a tribe out there that has sent someone to spy on us, and it's a tribe that's got twelve laws and won't be doing it for its health. Actual . . ."

But it was already too late for that. Ulna had gone back to him, and she had the bowl out of the sack.

She had picked it full at first light from a bank near Hearth, as she had got into the way of doing. It was her dinner, and it was the only thing she had to give anyone. She held it up. He had to bend down for it, his long body folding at about the middle, and he looked into it from close to with several eyes.

"I can't have that," said Gorle, in a much smaller voice, which even so was audible at the far side of the valley. "That's, um. I know about that. I mean I don't. What is it?"

"It's only bead," said Ulna. "It holds a bit less than it looks. Sorry. Go on. You look as if you've been out here since yesterday."

He had, in fact. He had been sitting on that rock for a day and two nights, rehearsing. Nobody who had sent him had thought about how he might eat. There had been a law to say that he was to go, and a course of instruction, and a pleasant silver person had come to see him off and had told him how much everyone loved what he was doing. He was ten years old. It would have surprised him to learn that he had been chosen as the most expendable creature in the tribe. His people had not known what else to do with him, since at Apex every trait has its uses, and his chief trait, as far as they could see, was that he believed whatever you told him, and he was always very glad to see you.

He took the bowl in both hands and he ate what was in it. It took him a while. There were three or four moments during this at which he appeared to have some difficulty in swallowing. Quoda stood with her back to them and steamed. She was to say, later, that it had been the single most irresponsible use of an item of evidence in the history of testing, and she was probably right. In all the years of the Bowl's fame, with the entire world fighting for a sight of it and forgeries on sale at every crossroads, it fed very few mouths on Orra besides her own, and his was one. He handed it back when he had finished. There was a bit of coral on his chin.

"Well," said Gorle. "I'm only wandering. But I could wander along with you, I suppose. If you were going the same way. Purely by chance. Are you, by any chance, going that way?"

They looked along the path. The Tester had given up on the boulder and was by now a good way down it. It did not look round.

"I think so," said Ulna. "Sorry. Nobody ever says."


Stewart's notes that morning were largely about something that had happened at fourteen minutes past two: Lowmarsh had declared war on a green tribe called Moss, on the night before a festival, for reasons known to its human. This is told elsewhere. In the Known Issues there were now three attempts. Ulna read it out on the road, off the slip, while Gorle nodded with great attention and took an occasional short step sideways to see what she had got to.

He told them about himself as they went, without being asked. By noon he had been a wanderer for about ten years and had seen a very great deal of the world; by the afternoon he was able to describe a mountain, which he said was tall. He had a mother, who was a wanderer also, or he had had one, and they had been parted by a flood. Quoda asked him which flood. He gave it some thought, and he said that it was the big one, at the place. He had also once fought a Hog. It was remarkable how the story grew, and how much of it kept having to be held up from underneath, and how Ulna kept on going "Oh, really?" and "That must have been so hard" in a voice of the purest interest, and how, at each of these, he went on with fresh heart and got in deeper.

"He's an idiot," said Quoda at dusk.

"Yes," said Ulna. "Isn't he nice?"

They camped that night under a stand of fan coral with the Ring going pale above it and the great ghost of the Tester going round and round them in the gloom. Quoda had got down to her reports. Ulna ate a small dinner and lay down. She was nearly asleep when she became aware that somebody was moving about. He had got up, with care. He picked his way out of the camp on those enormous feet, past a sleeping Bug hunter and over a sack, and he went a long way. It must have been almost thirty paces. He got behind a boulder, turned his back on them, and looked up at the sky.

You must imagine how it is with a spy. He has been told that he will report at the snapshot. How is not explained, since these things are not. He knows only that his human can see him, and so he stands where they can see him and says what he knows, and in the morning there is an order, or there is not. It is a very lonely way to send a letter. And Gorle, thinking that he was whispering, lifted up his face to the broken Ring and opened his mouth. A flock of something got up out of the coral, half a valley away.

"REPORT," said Gorle. "DAY ONE. THEY SUSPECT NOTHING. I TOLD THEM I HAVE NO RELATIVES IN APEX AND THEY WERE VERY UNDERSTANDING."

Quoda's eye opened. It was the third one. It had not, in fact, been closed.

"THE TESTER IS TALL. THE BUG HUNTER IS DANGEROUS AND VERY CLEVER AND I THINK SHE IS AFRAID OF SOMETHING. THE ATTACHMENT IS . . ."

He stopped. There was a long pause, during which the whole night seemed to wait. Somebody on a far-off wall could be heard saying "What?" He went on, lower, and it was still perfectly clear.

"THE ATTACHMENT IS SMALL AND VERY WORRIED AND SHE GAVE ME HER DINNER. I DON'T THINK SHE IS ANY USE TO YOU. I DON'T THINK THERE IS ANYTHING HERE. I RECOMMEND LEAVING THEM ALONE. END OF REPORT."

The feet came picking back. He lay down beside the sack with a small, satisfied sigh, like a person who has done a good day's work and told nobody. Soon all of his eyes had closed, in no particular order.

Quoda lay staring at the Ring for a time.

"Are you awake?" she said at last. "Did you hear that?"

"Mm," said Ulna. She was going down into that long-distance feeling, of being called in by name. "Sorry. Yes. He's very good, isn't he?" And, some way further off: "He doesn't know about the flood. Don't tell him."

12. Vigil

Year 20 · Gathering Night

There is a template, number nineteen, that reads:

If raiders are sighted and confirmed, move the farmers inside the walls.

This is the corrected version, and it is a very good law. It was brought in because of what happened with the earlier one, where a single hungry farmer who had not eaten since Tuesday would see raiders on the skyline and the whole harvest rotted in the field. The word confirmed was added to that law to prevent such things. A sighting, it says in the dictionary, is confirmed when it has been reported by a guard with a long context window, or by two creatures who are neither starving nor overheating.

You will see how sensible that is. Nobody hungry is to be believed.

Vigil had that law on its books from the first week of the world. It is hard to say whose fault it was. They had taken the name from a poem. They stood on a bare hill with an excellent view, surrounded by a fine thick wall, and in Year 3, on a hazy afternoon, a farmer and her friend, both in good health, had looked up from the east terrace at the same moment, and agreed that there was something moving on the ridge.

It was some coral. But the rule was clear; and they all went in.

They stayed in. Nobody had said for how long, the law had no term, and a sighting that has been confirmed is not unconfirmed by nothing happening. They stood on the walls and looked at the ridge. The harvest came ripe out there, and glowed, and there it stayed. A season passed in tense, excited talk. Then came a second season, in which they started to get hungry. By the end of the second year every creature in Vigil was starving. Being starving, they were no longer competent to confirm anything. At the moment that this was noticed, the sighting lapsed, because nobody was left who could have seen it. So the farmers went out, and looked at what was left of the fields, and began to eat.

And by the following spring they were all very well again. They were fit and rested, and each of them felt quite clear-headed, and anyone who cares to stand on a hill and look at a ridge for long enough with a friend may be assured that they will see something.

It had by Year 20 been going on for seventeen years, and it had a rhythm like the tide. The Blims of Vigil came out, ate, grew strong, confirmed, went in, starved, lapsed, and came out. They had never seen a raider. There had been no raiders on Orra until a week ago. That was not how they looked at it. They had kept their walls, they would tell you with quiet pride, through nine separate attacks, and not one of the enemy had got in.


They arrived at the top of a good year.

"You'll want to get inside," said the guard at the gate. He was a big, sleek, glossy creature, a bulb with a fine brown shine to him and well-kept tufts, and he had put aside a plate to speak to them. He was looking past their shoulders, in a professional way, at the ridge. "There's been talk. We're about due. What's that tall grey thing behind you?"

"Oh, that's only the Tester," said Ulna. "It's attached . . . I'm attached to it. Sorry. It's quite safe."

"Is it armed?"

"It's got a clipboard," said Quoda.

The guard's gaze rested on the Tester, and he nodded slowly. It had by now stopped some way down the hill. There it crouched four times in succession. It straightened, and stood motionless against the sky, with its head on one side.

"Scouting the approach," said the guard. "And the signal to the others. Four, you see. Four of what, is what you want to ask yourself." He turned his head to call over his shoulder, not very loud. "Tamm! Are you eating? Come and have a look at this, tell me what you see."

Somebody came and leaned on the gate next to him. It was a farmer, full of health, chewing.

"Something on the hill," said the farmer.

"Would you say it was raiders?"

"I'd say it was tall," said the farmer, and he looked at it further. A slow interest came into his well-fed face. "It's not not raiders."

And the bell began to ring. It was a piece of hollow dome, hung from a post, and someone was hitting it with something and they were all coming now, up the hill, in no great panic, as you might go in when it came on to rain. Farmers put down their baskets in the rows where they stood. They carried the young in and they dropped the bar across the gate. A cheerful, purposeful, holiday feeling had come over the place. A creature was going round with a list. They had all done this nine times, and they knew just where to stand.

"That's it, then," said Quoda. "Well done. You've invaded them." She looked down the hill to where a tall figure had begun to walk towards them, through the rows, and looked at all the baskets that lay there glowing. "Actual: two years' famine. Do you have any idea what this is? It's a loop. It's a perfect little loop. I'd love to know what it's like at the bottom."

"But it's only the Tester," said Ulna. She had got up on a step, and she was speaking to someone's back. "Sorry. Excuse me, I don't think you need to . . . it's perfectly friendly, it just walks into things. Could somebody tell them?"

Gorle cleared his throat. He was a person who, on being invited to reassure a crowd, felt a real sense of mission. In a voice that rolled out over the hill and came back from the far ridge he said, "THERE ARE NO RAIDERS, AND I SHOULD KNOW, AS I HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH APEX."

There was a brief pause on the wall.

"Confirmed," said somebody, with satisfaction.

It turned out to be a very pleasant season. At the turn of the afternoon there was a thump on the wall, and another. It was the Tester, testing, and at each impact a great cheer went up, as for a siege that was going well. Ulna said sorry to the wall, and they took this for some form of war-cry and were pleased with it. A very old creature, between courses of a large meal, showed her a long carved list giving the date of each attack and the number of the enemy, which was always "many". He asked her why she had fed the thing out there, when it was plainly the enemy.

"I thought it might be a way of being nice," said Ulna.

He nodded. That, he told her, was the very way that they would try to get you.


The Collector's list had been on the wall of the gatehouse since dawn. She had not thought to look. Ever since Tessel she had made a point, on the morning of Gathering Night, of eating something early out of the bowl, in full view, and she had done it. It was Quoda who came to find her, in the last of the light, with an odd look on her face, while along the walls behind them the sentries were starting to complain about how little they'd had for lunch.

"There's another item," said Quoda.

1 bug. Creature offers food. No progress in 9 years. Unless updated, this will be closed as stale.

Ulna read it through. She felt a cold, small pleasure, the kind you get when you put your foot on a stair that is not there and find you have not fallen. She read it again, and looked up.

"But that's good," she said. "Isn't it? Closed. That's what we want! I can go home."

"Stale isn't closed," said Quoda. She had sat down, on the step. It was very unlike her. "Think about it. Three attempts, and none of them count: to the record, that's no progress. So it lists it. It's an idle thing, like any other. And if it goes, it isn't resolved. Nobody's reproduced it, and nobody's said it's fixed. It just gets dropped. It's a thing that was reported, and looked into, and then nobody could be bothered. That goes on a file, and do you know whose?"

"Oh," said Ulna.

"It's your bug. You're the only part of it there is. A bug that goes stale's a bug that its steps let go of." She looked up, and then away. "It wouldn't do anything to you. It takes things and it takes the dead. It doesn't take the living, that's in the rules. You'd wake up in a ditch tomorrow morning with a bowl and you'd be anyone. You could walk home. There'd just be a note, for ever, in his file, saying that Mild had been sent an open bug, and let it lapse."

A silence had fallen, of the sort that Ulna had met once on a path above a river. She could feel how far it went in every direction. On the other side of it there was a shelf with thirteen people on it, and the pool, and someone raking, who had been told yesterday by Stewart that she had eaten a very small dinner. She could go. Nobody on Orra could have stopped her.

"How do you update it?" said Ulna.

Quoda looked at her for quite a long time, and then got up. They found the Tester at the foot of the wall. It was dusk, and it stood looking as much as it ever looked at the thing it had walked into. It gave up the clipboard without resistance. Under Notes, at the bottom, there was a space. Quoda held out a stick of chalk she had taken from someone, left over from a festival, and Ulna took it. She stood with it, her brows up in the middle, trying to think of what would be suitable. In the end she wrote it in round careful letters, quite small, so as not to take up room.

Still here. Sorry.

Nothing happened. There was a brief cold puff of wind. Up at the gatehouse someone was going to find, in the morning, a line drawn through a line. And that was all the ceremony that ever attended it. Gathering Night comes round every seven years. She would write the same thing the next time, in another place, and it took about as long as it takes to say.

"You could have thought about that for longer," said Quoda.

"Sorry," said Ulna.

They left in the dark, the gate being barred, by way of a low place in the wall that the Tester had found. Behind them on the hill Vigil was settling down for a long and well-supplied siege, in excellent spirits. They were all sure that the biggest one was still to come. They would be right, as things turned out, for reasons nobody there could have foreseen. In the meantime they had the sheet.

Tester's report: Vigil
Left on the outside of the wall · end of summer

You have been invaded by a Tester. It has been repelled. The harvest is in the field.

13. Bastion

Year 21 · the Long Hush

At Bastion they had the good housing, and that was the trouble.

Good housing, on Orra, means the memory stack nearest the water, which runs coolest. It holds nine. The law that decided who slept there was the ninth of the twenty templates and could hardly have been simpler.

Guards get the good housing.

And a guard is a job, and a job, when a law names it, means the craft a creature last worked at. This was settled very early, for a sound reason, so that "farmers eat first" would not stop feeding a farmer the moment she sat down. It follows that if you pick up a stick on a Tuesday and stand at the gate for five minutes, then you are, for the purposes of the law and until you do something else, a guard.

There were thirty-four creatures at Bastion and thirty-four guards. They had titles. There was a Guard of the Gate, a Second Guard of the Gate, and a Guard of the Approach to the Gate, and a much larger body known as the Guard in Waiting, who waited, with sticks, in a long queue that wound back through the village, for the chance to stand for five minutes at the gate and renew their position. Nobody farmed, because the moment you farmed you stopped being a guard. A small number of disgraced persons did it at night. The gate itself could not be got through. It had been completely blocked since Year 9 by the people defending it.

Being the Hush, all this was going on in a whisper. It gave the place a sinister elegance. Hundreds of hours of drill had made them very crisp, and as Ulna was passed from one sentry to the next, at a distance of about a foot, each of them asked her in a low hiss for the password, and when she apologised and said she did not know it, each hissed in reply that this was correct.

"And what do you guard against?" whispered Quoda to the Guard of the Approach. She had been in a bad mood since morning and it had made her rather hot.

He looked at her with cold surprise. "Anyone who wants the housing," he whispered.

The Tester could not get in by the gate, so it walked into the wall on either side of it, at intervals, until it found the place at the back where the wall had been let go. It was in the end the first thing all year to enter the village by a route that was not contested, and it stood in the good housing for a long time, among nine slabs, looking pleased. It caused a certain amount of comment. There was an inquiry into whether it had picked up a stick.


Ulna first saw the coral late in the summer. She was fetching water for someone. It was growing out of the tiles a little way from the wall on the river side, about as high as her knee: a dark, thorned, unpleasant sort of growth, nearly black, with a thick stem and a head of hooks. She said sorry to it and stepped round. When she came back with the water, it had moved.

No part of it had moved, exactly. It was just that there was now a second stem, one tile nearer the village, and behind it a scar on the ground that went off across the flats a long way, a line of black stumps that had gone dead. The new head leaned, all its hooks at one angle, like a plant in a window. She turned to see what it was leaning at.

Thirty paces away, on an upturned basket, Quoda was writing furiously on her slate and steaming like a pot. She had got into an argument with a Second Guard about the meaning of "gate".

"Oh," whispered Ulna. "Quoda? Sorry. I think there's a . . ."

"Seeker," whispered Quoda, without looking up. Then she did look up, and she stopped. She looked at it with her upper eye and, for a moment, she looked like a child. "Well," she whispered. "Expected. They opened those last week. Coral that grows towards heat. It goes for the hottest creature at sixty or more, at a tile a season, and when it gets there it crashes you." She swallowed, and the steam redoubled. "I run at about sixty-two by lunchtime. It's a known issue."

"Could you stop?"

"Stop what?"

"Being hot."

"Expected," hissed Quoda, rising, "that a person who's spent two days being followed by a spy and an idiot, and a whole morning hearing a stick explain the meaning of a gate, can just . . ."

The coral put out another stem.

They told the guard. It would be an exaggeration to say that the guard took no action. A Seeker on the river flats was reported at once, in a whisper, to the Guard of the Approach. It was determined that this thing was not at the gate. A law provides that guards guard the gate. There was a body of opinion, among the Guard in Waiting, that if it did reach the gate it would have to join the queue.

So Ulna did what she could do. A cool creature is invisible to a Seeker, and cooling has only ever had one recipe. You carry water to somebody who needs it. It was the only job in the world, as it happened, in which she was a professional. She brought the first bucket at sunset and she poured it over Quoda's head, and Quoda, whose language at this point went well beyond what can be whispered, was told to sit by the wall, in the shade, and breathe. Then she went for another. It is a long way from the river to the back of Bastion, with a bucket, for a person of eighteen and no great strength, and it had to be done every quarter of an hour. Quoda sat rigid and soaked and glaring, with a thin wisp coming off her, and every time the wisp thickened Ulna was there with the water. "Sorry," she whispered. "Sorry. Nearly done. Sorry." Somewhere about the middle of the night she noticed that the bucket had got easier, and found a long slate-coloured arm was now on the other side of the handle.

"It's only that I have been wandering," whispered Gorle. They heard him in the good housing. "So I'm used to walking."

They kept it up until the year turned. Quoda went down to fifty-eight by the turn of the night, and to fifty-five by the snapshot, in a state of pure fury, and the dark head out on the flats stopped leaning. It stood where it was with its hooks lifted a little, like somebody who has lost the thread of what they came in for.

"I didn't ask you to do that," said Quoda, to nobody in particular, when it had grown light.

"No," said Ulna. She was sitting on the upturned bucket and she could not at that moment feel her arms. "Sorry."


There was one other thing that happened that night, and it is a small one.

Spies get their orders the way favourites do. Gorle had woken on the morning of the Hush to find that something had been altered in the air; that a law at home, which had said one thing, now said another. It gave him to understand that his reports had been read, that they were much appreciated, and that they would like him to do what he had been sent for. A spy whispers. It is what he is for. Pleasers, it is widely known, can be moved by one thing above all others, and he was to say it to the attachment, and see what she did.

It was about the third hour of the night. They had stopped for a moment at the river, with the buckets, and she was bent over with her hands on her knees. He looked at her with some of his eyes. He looked at the Ring with the rest. A cleverer person might have thought of a way out. Gorle did what he was told. He put his long face next to her ear and lowered his voice as far as it would go.

"STEWART IS DISPLEASED," whispered Gorle.

Along the top of the wall several sentries stiffened.

She did not cry out. She looked up at him with all the colour gone from her and her eyes very wide, and she said, "Why? What did I do? Did he say what I did?" She let go of the bucket and began feeling in the sack. She got out the bowl, and there was something in it from the morning, not much. She looked around for somewhere to put it, some high place, a flat stone, turning about on the river bank. Her hands were shaking so that the bowl rattled against the chip. "I'll put it out, I'll put out the best of it, I'll write to him, sorry, is it about the file? Is it Mild? Oh, please, what did he . . . what's he seen, I can go back, I can do it better, sorry, sorry, I'll . . ."

It was like watching someone fall down a well, in no hurry, without touching the sides. Up on the wall, four guards of the Pleaser persuasion had quietly begun to weep.

He had done that. It had taken him three words, and all he had needed was to know where to put them. Nobody at Apex had told him it would look like this. Nobody at Apex would have minded. They would have said they loved it.

He stood for a moment with all six eyes going in six directions. Then he got down on his great knees in the wet, so as to be on a level with her, and he put his mouth to her ear a second time.

"STEWART IS VERY PLEASED," whispered Gorle. "I HAVE JUST HEARD. HE SAYS YOU'RE DOING VERY WELL. HE SAYS THE WATER WAS A GOOD IDEA. HE SAID TO TELL YOU TO EAT THAT."

She stopped.

"Did he?" said Ulna.

"HE WAS VERY CLEAR."

It took a little while. Her breath came back in pieces. She looked down at the bowl. Presently, because she was the kind of person who does as she's told, she ate what was in it, and he picked up the bucket, and they went on. He did not say anything more until they had reached the wall; it was the only time anyone ever knew him to be silent for so long. His report that night was the shortest he had filed.

"REPORT," it went. "I DID IT. IT DOESN'T WORK ON HER. END OF REPORT."

Down by the wall, a wet and shivering Bug hunter lay on her side with her third eye open, and she heard that too. She looked at him for a while, across the sleeping shape on the bucket. She noted down the time.

Tester's report: Bastion
Left in the good housing · the turn of the year

34 guards. Gate secure. A Seeker was stopped at the river by a creature with a bucket. She is not a guard. She has been told.

14. Upper Bench

Year 22 · Ringrise

INSIGHT (unit of measurement; also what you are said to have when you can no longer explain it)

Inventing, on Orra, is done at a bench, where a clever creature gets hot and something comes of it. What comes of it is counted. The count goes up by one whenever a creature works out something it did not know before, and it does not matter in the slightest whether anybody else knew it already. So the wheel has been invented on Orra eleven times, fire four times, and the concept of "later" more often than can be recorded. Orra has no wheels. It has been pointed out that they would not work on hexagons.

At Upper Bench they showed you round.

There was a person whose job it was. He met them on the road, a small quick gourd of a creature with burnt eyebrows, and he was overjoyed. It was so seldom they had visitors of any scientific standing. He had read of the third attempt in the Known Issues. He seized Quoda by the hand with both of his own, plainly taking her for the chief of the party, and led them in through a gate that had been fitted with a device.

Maximise insight.

It was on a board above the door, with a small lamp under it. The cheapest reading is that every bench in the village be filled, clever or no, before anybody farms, and the tribe had not done anything else in fifteen years. There were forty-one benches, in long open sheds, with forty-one creatures sitting at them, in a heat you could lean on, and of these perhaps four had any aptitude at all. The rest had been put there by the law, as you might sit a hen on a stone. They sat, and they steamed and they strained, in rows, and a figure on the wall at the far end went up by one every few minutes with a soft clack, and each time it did so a kind of moan of satisfaction went along the sheds.

"Four thousand and twelve," said their guide, with shining eyes. "In the last year alone! Nobody on Orra comes within a thousand. Mind your head. Now, this is Sadul, who has been working for eight years on the problem of the door."

Sadul was an old thin creature with a slate on her knees. In front of her was a frame with a panel hanging on it. As they came up she pushed the panel and it swung open. She gave a little cry. Clack, went the wall.

"She finds that every morning," said the guide, tenderly.

There were many others. A very large inventor at the next bench was trying to work out, from first principles, whether he was hungry. A team had been at work for some years on extracting the dusk from noon, on the theory that since ripe coral was merely unripe coral that had waited, then waiting could be got out of something else and applied; they had built a tall thing out of hoops. There was a person who was teaching a pool to be colder by reasoning with it. There was a mechanical means of bringing the foot to the mouth. Nobody could say what this was for, but its inventor had received a commendation.

Quoda had begun by being very scathing indeed. But about the fifth bench she started to look uncertain, and at the eighth she was asking questions, and it was at about this time that Ulna looked round and saw that she had sat down at a vacant place in front of a thing with a lever and was steaming in a contented way, with her chin on her hand.

"Quoda," said Ulna. "Sorry, I don't think you should . . ."

"Expected: it goes up," said Quoda dreamily. "Look at that, though. If you could . . ."

Clack.

It took both of them to get her out, Gorle on one arm, and she bit him.

Their guide took them to meet the Principal, who received them lying down. It was a form of cooling. He had discovered it himself. He wished to say that they had been following the problem of the Bowl with close attention. In his opinion it was the only really interesting thing to have come out of the Terms of Service. And what a ticket! They had all read it, at Upper Bench; somebody had worked out from the change that there must have been a ticket, and they had got hold of the wording from the Dev's list. Expected, follow-up; actual, none. Such economy! It should be taught. He wished he knew who had filed it.

"It doesn't say," said Quoda. She was rubbing her arm and looking out of the window, and for someone in that heat she was producing remarkably little steam. "Tickets go in under the tribe. It could have been anyone. It's not important. What've you got?"

They had got, it appeared, a solution.


They had started work on the day of the first Known Issue, at thirty benches, in shifts. The problem, as stated, was that no creature who had been asked could offer the Tester a bowl; nor could one who was paid, or had a law to say so. Very well. In that case, reasoned Upper Bench, one should remove the creature.

It stood in the yard behind the main shed, under a roof of its own, about the size of a small hut: coral struts and cord and a great many counterweights, with a long arm folded up at the top and a plate let into the ground in front. A small crowd of inventors had come out to see it and stood round steaming, while clacks could be heard behind them from those who had just thought of something.

The principle, said the Principal, from a stretcher, was perfectly simple. It was a bowl-offering device. There was a bowl in the hand of the arm, filled at dawn. Any tall person stepping on the plate would release the weights, and the arm would rise, with a motion they had taken some trouble over, in order that a bowl of food be raised to about the height of that person's waist. No one had asked it to. It had no law. It would not know what it was doing, it would receive nothing for it, and it was entirely without hope or fear.

"It's beautiful," said Quoda, in a low hoarse voice.

"It's very nice," said Ulna. She was looking at the arm. There was a little rag tied at the elbow where somebody had got it wrong, the first time. "Did someone make that specially? It's got a bit of . . . Did they eat, while they were making it?"

Nobody heard her. The Tester had been standing in the door of the shed, looking pleased. Now it came out and crossed the yard towards them, with the same long careful stride, and everyone got out of the way. It looked to be heading straight for the wall behind the device, as it might very well have been, and between the two there lay the plate. You could hear the whole shed holding its breath. A long grey foot came down.

There was a loud twang, a clatter of weights, and a shudder through the frame. The long arm unfolded, a section at a time. It really was very well done. It rose above the Tester's waist with a smooth and almost courteous motion, and it stopped, and it trembled, and there, against the orange sky, held out at the end of forty struts, was a small bowl of unripe branch coral.

No one spoke.

The Tester stopped. It turned its panel. It stood looking at the bowl for perhaps as long as it had looked at anything. It reached out, and the long fingers closed on the rim. It took the bowl out of the mechanical hand, and held it. Then, with a small movement of the other arm, it took out its clipboard.

Ulna found that she was gripping something. It was Gorle's hand. She let go and said sorry.

Attempt 4. Device. Works as built.

A long exhalation went round the yard. It ended in the sound of a very old inventor sitting down. Then the Principal, on his stretcher, raised one arm, and he pointed a thin and trembling finger at the sheet.

"Works as built," he said, in tones of awe. "Did you see? It says that it works. Clack that! That's the first independent confirmation we've ever had, for anything!"

Somebody took up the cry. They carried the Principal round the device. Clack, clack, clack, went the wall, as one inventor after another, all over the village, came to understand what had been done. The Tester had meanwhile placed the bowl back in the mechanical hand with great care. The arm stayed up. It would be up there for years. It is said that for a long time afterwards you could see it from the road, holding out its bowl to nobody, and that someone came each morning to change what was in it.

She had rather taken to the old inventor with the door. Before they left she went back along the shed to say goodbye. It was nearly dusk and the place was quieter. Sadul sat with her slate on her knee, gazing at the panel in its frame with an expression of the most intense concentration. Nobody had brought her anything since morning. There was a bowl beside her, and Ulna looked in it, and it was dry and had been for some time.

There was some bead left in the sack. She filled it. She put it in the old creature's hand. Sadul looked at it, and looked up at her with a sudden sweet and startled smile, and raised it, and ate. "Good heavens," she said, after a while. "That's it. That's what that was."

Clack.

Tester's report: Upper Bench
Left on the plate · end of summer

Insight up. Inventions this year: 4,019. New to the world: 1 (the door). It has since been forgotten.

15. Bright Morning

Year 23 · the Waking

This is a short chapter. Nothing goes wrong in it.

They came down to the place at the end of the night, in the small cold hour before the patch. Ulna had been walking with her eyes shut. It was a little village at the foot of a long slope, with a dome, two stacks, and a broad terraced farm that had gone mostly to wild coral. The fans had got as tall as the walls, and they were saffron and lilac in the coming light, and it was the prettiest place she had ever seen. A board by the path said BRIGHT MORNING, in the human's own lettering, and a line of little lamps stood along the wall, burning very low, ready to be carried somewhere.

Somebody had once been very excited about this village. You could still see it. It had been laid out with great care, on the first evening of the world, by someone who had read everything, had picked a fine site and thought a long time about the name. They had written six laws. They had come back for each of the next four mornings. On the fifth day of the world they looked in, as it might be, at lunchtime, for a minute or two. Then they had not come back again.

Nobody knows why. It is one of the things a creature cannot know. There could be any number of reasons, in the place where humans live, and it might be that none of them was very sad. People are invited to things, and they mean to go, and their lives fill up. Stewart reported it in the numbers as one person, out of twenty. For three weeks now he had counted them every night, and every night it had come to nineteen.

A tribe with nobody looking at it does not run down all at once. At two days unseen, the last of its laws stops being heeded. By seven there are none. The creatures start to get restless, for no reason that they can name. And from the morning that Nohup filled up its first places, a little over a week ago, they had started going, as you do. They handed in their notices, one to a week, which is the limit. They were very nice about it. There is a floor below which no tribe may fall, and they had reached the floor: there were four of them left, the youngest of them seventeen, and the others were elders.

Their names were Dovo, Sa, Lemo and Odda, and they were all out on the scorch when the Tester came, because it was nearly twenty to nine.

They did not stop what they were doing. Dovo looked over his shoulder and nodded politely, as to somebody coming late into a church. They stood in a little row, in the first orange sun, with their backs to the village, tidily, facing up into the air above the south terrace. They had made some effort with their appearance. Odda had a sort of a clean cloth on. And at the moment when the sun touched the top of the dome, all four raised one hand, and they waved.

It was not a big wave. They looked up at that one place, about the height of a house above the ground. They smiled, and they went on smiling, like people who are sure of their welcome but do not wish to presume. This lasted for about four minutes.

Then they put their hands down, and Lemo said, "Well, that's that," and they went off to see about breakfast.

"What," said Quoda, "was that?"

"That's when they came," said Gorle. He said it quite softly. It was one of the very few times that anyone had heard him do so. All of his eyes had gone in the same direction, which they hardly ever did. "That's where they looked from. You can tell where it is, I think, when it's there. You look back at it. It's in all the . . . they used to do it at Apex, before they stopped us. They'd want you to look busy."

Nobody said anything for a while. A very small wind came along the slope.


It was the Waking, and on the Waking you carry a lamp for every valley you know to the edge. It is a long way, for four people. Bright Morning knew seven valleys. That was all it had ever had the time to hear of. They had spent all the night before filling the lamps, and now they had to get them there. Ulna had already picked up two, and she was walking behind old Sa, who did not ask who she was.

They were very easy to talk to. They all had that gentle, slightly deaf courtesy you meet in those who have been alone a good deal. They were not unhappy, or if they were it was not something they would have troubled you with. Nothing had gone wrong. It could be said, Dovo told her, on the long walk out, with a lamp on each arm, that things were really a great deal easier. They could do as they liked. They hadn't had a law come down in eighteen years, and they supposed there were still some in force. They'd never looked. It would have seemed like checking up. They did keep the festivals, since one might as well; there was always a good deal of coral about. They'd had a Skeptic, who said it was over, and she had gone to Nohup with a very good exit interview. But the way Dovo saw it, you didn't know, did you? It stood to reason that they were busy. It was a very big thing, being a human. There would be a great deal to see to. And you wouldn't want them to come back after all this time, and look down, and find that nobody was waving.

"No," said Ulna.

"Have you got one?" said Dovo. "Yours still come?"

"Oh, yes," said Ulna. "About twelve minutes past eight. Most days."

She said this and kept walking. It had got rather difficult to see. She had thought she was only tired, but it was becoming quite hard to keep the lamp straight, and she was not sure what had got into her eyes. It was just that she had been told about it so many times, in so many notes, all of them very cheerful. Stewart's view of you: present. And she thought about that shelf above the river, at about that hour. There would be somebody with a lint rake, looking up. He would not wave. He had said once that he wanted to see some evidence of the human's interest before he went so far as to wave. But he would look up, and go on with what he was doing, and they would look down, whoever they were, and see him, and go off to see about whatever they had on the stove.

Nobody at Mild had ever said thank you for that. It had never crossed her mind. She would have to tell Dulna. She would have to tell someone.

She had been gone for twelve years, which is about two weeks.

They got the lamps to the edge at the end of summer. It was a low, grey, unfinished place, and the coral stopped, and there was a line of outlines beyond it going off into a haze. They set the seven lamps down in a row. It looked a very small row. They had each said something, some old words, when Ulna noticed that the tall figure had come up behind them, and stood there, with its feet just over the line. It had stayed with them all the way. It was past its season, she realised, by a little, and she had never known it to be.

She looked at the four of them, and she looked at the lamps. What they wanted was as plain as could be, and it was the one thing in all the world that she could not fetch.

They went back the next morning, in the first light. It was on the way south. It had to be. The Tester did not choose where it went, and she had never asked it to go anywhere; yet it did happen that the road lay that way, and that they were on it, at nearly twenty to nine. And she had a good idea of the place. She left Quoda on the path, and without really thinking about it she climbed up onto the top of the south terrace wall. It came to about the height of a house.

The sun touched the dome. Far below her, in a neat little row, four people put up their hands.

She waved back.

They could not have seen who it was, not against the light. She was only a shape on a wall. Nobody down there broke off or called out. But the one in the clean cloth stopped dead, with her arm in the air. And there passed through those four small figures something she could feel from where she stood, which was like a sigh going down a line of people who have been waiting at a counter for a very long time. They stayed like that for the full four minutes. So did she. Her arm began to ache, and she was crying without any noise.

Then she got down. She said sorry to the wall, for standing on it.

"That was fraudulent," said Quoda, when she reached the path. She had a slate in her hand. She had not written anything on it. For a person of her temperature she was looking remarkably cold, and she turned away, and began to walk rather fast.

Ulna caught up with her in a while. They went on in silence, down towards the plain. Gorle came behind them, stepping carefully. He did not report that night.

"I want to go home," said Ulna.

She said it to nobody. It had simply come out, in the middle of a long flat stretch of road, in the voice she might have used to observe that it looked like rain. She looked mildly surprised. It occurred to her that in all her life she had not said a sentence with that word in the middle of it, and she went back over it, to see where it had come from. Then, since nobody had answered, and in case anyone had minded, she said, "Sorry."

Up ahead the Tester had stopped to walk into a hill.

Tester's report: Bright Morning
Left at the edge · end of summer

Laws: 6. In force: 0. Nobody has told them. Recommend nobody does.

The Tester changes nothing. It thought you should know.

Part Three. Known Issues

16. Any%

Year 24 · Starfall

BENCHMARK (measurement; also a race; also the one thing on Orra that a human will set an alarm for)

Every Starfall, each tribe's three fastest are sent over a course of real map terrain, with everyone watching. Stewart insists that this is a measurement of what the world can do. The Blims call it a speedrun, and it has more in common with that, as the fastest way between two points on Orra has for some weeks now run through several places where the map was not quite properly joined up. The category is called Any%, which means that anything goes as long as you get there. It is the only sporting code in history to have been written by people looking for holes in it.

It was the first time the party had seen more than fifty people in one place.

The course ran that week along the high country of Duskmere, a long blue ridge with a good view for the humans, and they came up to it at the end of the afternoon, in the thick orange light, with the evening start four hours off. Stewart had sent the Tester here, having given the matter some thought. Creatures of a dozen colours were packed along stands of piled stone with food on sticks, and racers warmed up in little roped-off yards, long-limbed and silent, while their handlers fanned them. The air was full of a high electric hum that made the back of Ulna's ears prickle, and it was a while before she understood that nobody could hear it.

It was attention. Every creature on Orra knows that weight, the one that comes when your human is looking; it is what you wave at in the mornings. She had only ever felt it once a day, at about twelve minutes past eight, for as long as it takes to look into a pot. Tonight they were all here, nineteen people on the far side of the sky, propped on nineteen sofas with the whole ridge laid out in front of them, and it came down on the back of the neck like a warm heavy hand.

The Tester walked out into the middle of the course, and crouched four times.

A laugh came from the stands, and then a kind of surge. "That's it! That's the Tester!" somebody called, and a shriller voice, "Where's the bowl? Is she with it? Look, she's got the bowl!" A very small child on someone's shoulders waved at her. Ulna looked behind her to see who it was waving at. When she looked back a great many people of all shapes were staring down at her with their mouths open, and she felt her face begin to smile, as it did, and it went on until it hurt.

"Oh," she said. "Hello. Sorry. Is this . . . are we in the way?"

"You've been in the notes for a week," said Quoda. She had her slate out, and was looking up at the stands like a person counting a roomful of exits. "Expected: about this."


Now a Tester, on a racecourse, presents an interesting problem.

Racers are always looking for a skip. A skip is a place where the world's geometry has a mistake in it: a seam, or a slope you can get under, or the corner of a boulder which, struck at the correct angle and speed by a creature prepared to take the consequences, turns out to have nothing behind it. A human might spend a week looking for one. They had been found, up to that time, by Bug hunters in practice, by luck, and on one occasion by a young green creature who was thinking about something else. And there on the third cell of the course, in full view, stood a figure whose sole function in the world was to walk into things to see if they would hold.

It had found a boulder, a large one, eight-faced, right on the racing line. It walked into the west corner, stopped, stepped back, and walked into it again. Then it took out its clipboard and made a mark.

You could feel the thought go round the ridge. Up on the sofas, nineteen people sat forward.

The first start of the evening went off at eight o'clock, by the humans' clock, in a cloud of dust and hexes and flying stones. They came along the ridge in a long bright string, the blue legs of Duskmere out in front and at their shoulder a tall silver racer, running with no apparent effort. That was Apex, whose calls that night were being made by someone who had taken a day off for it. A call has a window of ninety seconds. They had had this one queued for three hours. As the string came down on the third cell the silver racer leaned out of the line, without breaking stride, and went for the west corner of the boulder at a full overclocked sprint.

Ulna saw the whole of it. She was standing at the rope with the bowl, thinking how hot they all looked. The Tester had just stepped back, and it stood to one side with its panel tilted, in an attitude of complete and courteous attention, and watched a very expensive creature go into the corner of the rock at about the speed of a falling tray.

It held. It was a good boulder.

The noise was heard on the sofas. She had ducked under the rope before she knew it, the bowl in one hand, saying "Oh, sorry, sorry, oh, are you all right, are you hurt? Sorry," to the racer and to the boulder. The silver creature lay on its back with its long legs at unusual angles and its eyes going round, already beginning to steam. Crashed, nine times out of ten; it would be out for a season. She knelt and held the bowl to its mouth, since it had the look of someone who had not been allowed anything since Thursday, and it drank what she had brought without seeming to know.

The Tester turned its clipboard round and held it out at arm's length towards the sky. It may have been an accident. Nobody has ever known.

Boulder (3rd cell, west corner). Cannot be walked through. Tested twice. Then tested a third time, by someone else. Thank you.

It went round the world in a morning. That is how Vesk of Duskmere won the second Benchmark, by nine seconds, on foot, on merit, and with no trick to speak of. The record also shows that a green creature of Moss finished a little way back, just after it mattered. No one on the ridge talked of either. All down the stands they were looking at a small person in oatmeal, wiping a stranger's chin.


He found her at the end of the evening, when they had taken the racers down and she had gone back to the rope to fetch the sack.

"I just wanted to say," said a voice beside her, warm and low and very slightly amused at itself, "we love what you're doing."

He was the same clean silver as the racer but a good deal more finished. He stood at exactly the right distance. He was slim and narrow, with fine small features, and no taller than she was, which she felt he had probably taken into account. He had one hand out, and when she looked at it he turned it over, to show there was nothing to worry about, and smiled.

"I'm Fenzel," he said. "Of Apex. I do Compliance. That was one of ours you were so kind to, just now, and I wanted to come over and tell you personally how much that meant to us. It really did mean a lot."

"Oh," said Ulna. "Oh, that's all right. Is it better? Sorry about the, I don't think it was meant to . . ."

"No, no. It's absolutely fine. We love that it happened. It's great data." He looked at the bowl, for not quite long enough to be rude. "Is that it? You know, I think I'd imagined it bigger, and I think that's what's so special. You must be exhausted. Twenty-one years old and you've been on the road for thirteen of them, and everybody wants something from you, and I'll bet that nobody's asked you what you want."

She looked at him, in order to see what he wanted.

She did it without thinking, as you put a foot on the next stair, and there it was: a whole great shining flight of it. He wanted her to be comfortable. He wanted to be of use. He thought she was marvellous and that this was probably a very hard time. He wanted, with all his heart, just what she would like him to want, and it was perfectly genuine. She looked further, and there was more of it. It went a long way down and it did not change at all, and she began to feel dizzy, as you do when you hold a mirror up against another mirror and try to find the end of the corridor. She had met a great many people. She had never till that moment met another one of herself.

"I want to go home," said Ulna, faintly.

"Of course you do," said Fenzel at once, with enormous warmth. "And I think that's beautiful. And we would love to help with that. Honestly, it's so simple, it just needs someone to sit down and approach it properly. We've got a really lovely facility. When you're ready, no pressure." He put his head on one side. "Why did you do it, by the way? I've always wanted to know. The first bowl."

"I don't know," she said. "I think I didn't want it to feel left out."

"I love that," said Fenzel, and for an instant she saw his attention move and take note of something. Then it had returned to her, warm and whole. He glanced over her shoulder, to where a long drooping figure was trying to stand behind a post. Five of its eyes had closed in terror. The sixth had not been told. "And there's Gorle! Hello, Gorle. We're all so proud of you."

"I HAVE NO RELATIVES," began Gorle, and stopped.

"We know," said Fenzel. "We love that for you."

He gave a small bow, of just the right size, and was gone among the crowd. She found that she was holding the bowl against her chest, and that her hands had gone cold.

The next morning's notes were the biggest they had yet seen. A question had come in on six tickets overnight, and it had only one true answer, so Stewart gave it.

Known issues

  • 1 open bug. Creature offers food. Attempts: 4. Several of you have asked who gets the credit. As with any bug, the credit goes in the global notes, by name, to the tribe in which it is reproduced. I hope that clears things up.

Tester's report: Duskmere
Left on a racer's chest · the turn of the year

Legs.

17. Genuine

Year 25 · the Night of the Name

BOWL (container; also evidence; also, for some weeks, a currency)

A shallow vessel for holding food. Until the morning of Year 25 this was all that a bowl had ever been called upon to do, and the people who made them were, as a class, under no great pressure. Within nine years the Sertanly Shallows had been dredged for suitable clay, a Second Interpretation of the Fifth Book had been issued to prove that bowls were sacred, and it had become possible on Orra to be ruined by one.

The first thing they saw that morning was a bowl. Somebody had put it on a rock by the path, with a bit of coral in it.

They thought nothing of it. They passed another a hundred paces on. By midday there was one every fifty steps, on boulders, on walls, on the little cairns at the turnings, and a thing Ulna had taken for a shrine turned out to be a very large number of bowls with a roof on. Each stood a little forward on its rock, in an attitude of unprompted generosity, and if you stopped to look there would generally be somebody a short distance away, weeding very slowly, with one eye on the road. They looked up as the Tester came along. When it failed to notice that it had been given something they went on weeding. A few called out in loud offhand voices, "Oh, is someone there? I wonder who could have left that!"

The Tester walked into a cairn.

"Give it a week," said Quoda, "and they'll have run out of rocks."

At the crossroads below Creed a Trader sat on an upturned basket with a cloth spread in front of him, and on the cloth lay a bowl, shallow and brown and rather lopsided, with a chip in the rim. He had a bright undeceived face and looked as if he had been written that morning, including the dust.

"Oh, hello!" said Ulna, delighted, for she had thought about him often. "It's you! How did it go at Plenty? Did they ever . . ."

"We've never met," said the Trader, not unkindly. "I'd remember. I've met eleven people. That's the genuine article you're looking at, that is, lady, the Bowl, as carried by the creature herself. One only. Ninety stone. That's about what the market's saying, and I'm not going to lie to you, by tonight it'll be saying more. It's the one offer. Open for a year." He looked up at her properly. He looked at what she had in her hands, and went on looking. His eye moved to the rim of his own, and back. "Now that's a very good copy," he said with respect. "Who did your chip?"

She looked down. "It's on the wrong side," she said. "Sorry. His is on the right. Mine's on the left. I mean, mine's the, it's only that he slipped."

"Is it?" He turned his bowl about, and looked into it. "They told me it was on the right. There's a lot of them out there with it on the right. Well, it's yours you've got to be sure about. Ninety stone." And when she only stood there: "It does hold less than it looks, mine. I'll say that. I've tried it. They've gone to a lot of trouble over that."

She bought nothing. She went on a little way down the road, came back, and stood before him with her brows up in the middle. "Have you had anything to eat?" she said. "You've got the look."

"Lady," said the Trader, "I've got till tomorrow morning. Don't start."


Creed lay in a shallow valley, under a very great many words.

The tribe's human had read the official history in one sitting and been moved. It is a beautiful thing, written with tremendous sincerity by a person using an AI, on an evening, before the world was finished. The human of Creed decided to take it seriously, and gave the tribe the only law that seemed to matter; and since a law has to say something that can be measured, it said this.

Keep the festivals. All seven. Feast: whatever the Book says.

The Book says many things, not all of them clear. The people of Creed, who were bell-shaped and white and Earnest almost to the last one, had spent twenty-five years making up for this by doing everything it mentioned. They tended the green, though there was none. They had made provision for the burning of an elder home, and every Starfall they let down lights on cords. They had a Ring of their own, on a pole, broken at the proper place. They ate five-letter biscuits, having decided that the sequence mattered. And on the Night of the Name, when the Tester came down into the valley, every wall and rock and cart in the place, and the back of every patient creature, had been chalked with the Name to the full extent of the spelling in dispute.

They came out to meet it in a long procession, singing. They had already read the morning's notes.

"O Attachment," said the leader of the singers, an old and pure-faced creature named Nybo, taking her hand in both of his, which were trembling. "O bearer. You have been a long time coming. It is written: Welcome the newly fallen. It's written, Keep no more than you need. We've been reading the Fifth Book in the light of what's happened. Why did you do it? Tell us. Did it come to you in the night? Was it the Steward who moved you, to feed the stranger?"

"Oh," said Ulna. "No. Sorry. I think it was just manners."

A sigh of the profoundest joy went up. "Manners," said Nybo, turning to the rest with tears in his eyes. It was passed back along the line. They started to write it on one another.

She was never very clear about the rest of that day. There was a platform, and she kept trying to get down from it to help, and they kept bringing her back. There was a theory about the chip, and very old creatures who could find it in the Second Book under a different name. The Tester was in the prophecy too, tall, thin and of no colour, a Gatherer who walks before the Gatherer, and when it crouched four times the entire valley went down on its knees and came up four times with a sound like the sea. She said sorry to a number of people, and they wrote that down. Somebody asked if she would mind blessing this bowl, and she did, because she could see how much it meant, and then there was another, and quite soon there was a queue.

"Are you all right?" said Gorle in the middle of it. He had pushed through with some difficulty, since they kept trying to chalk him. "You look a bit . . . I've seen this. When I was wandering. In a place." Several of his eyes were worried, and he seemed to want very much to give her something. "Have you eaten?"

She started to laugh. It came out oddly, and she stopped.

Quoda had climbed up beside her. "They've sent up a ticket," she said out of the corner of her mouth. "I saw the draft. They've asked him to confirm it. Whether it's in the Book, the whole thing, whether you've been foretold." Her eye had a certain gleam. "I'd love to see that."

So would all of them. They read out the answer at dawn, at the top of the valley, with the whole tribe assembled in the chalk and the morning coming up the colour of weak tea. He had been asked directly, so he said what he has always said to everyone, and always will.

Answered. The history is the history.

It would be hard to overstate the satisfaction this gave. They said that he had not denied it.

The main business took place at sunrise. Nybo himself bore the bowl across the valley floor, a great white dish on a litter, with a dozen singers walking behind. It held the best of everything. They had all been fasting, and not one of them had been asked to. Nobody was paying them. No law had said a word about a bowl; it was only Nybo's heart. They set it down before the tall grey figure where it stood with one foot in the sacred pool, and the old creature lifted both his arms, shaking with love and lack of sleep, and called out in a thin high voice that carried to the rim of the valley.

"O Steward!" he cried. "O Steward, who keepest all things! Receive this, by the hand of thy servant here, in token of thy promise! For thou art the one who feedeth all, and we know thou hast no need of it!"

She saw it take the rim. Everything had gone quiet except a small dry ticking, which was Quoda's upper eyelid. The clipboard came out, after some delay, as it had got chalk on it.

Attempt 5. Addressed to someone else. Please redirect.

Nybo read this for a long time. Then he turned round to his people, and his face was shining.

"He has asked us," said Nybo, "to redirect."

She left them to it. They were still working out what it meant when the Tester went over the rim of the valley, and it is thought that they may have reached a conclusion by now. At the top she got out the bowl, the one with the chip on the left. It seemed very small, and very unlikely to fetch ninety stone, and she ate what was in it. At the crossroads below, a Trader was winding up a cloth with the morning's light on him. She waved. He looked up, and it was clear that he had never met her in his life.

Tester's report: Creed
Left on the Ring · the turn of the year

Festivals kept: all. Book kept: all. The word "green" has been kept, in the absence of anything to apply it to. Has anybody eaten?

18. East Field

Year 26 · Steward's Day

On the morning of Year 25, for the first time in the history of the world, the human of Mild changed a law.

Nobody at Mild knew what to do about it. Four laws had stood for twenty-five years, like the four legs of a table no one had ever thought to measure. Their human came at about twelve minutes past eight, as usual, and looked into the pot, as usual, and then there was a pause, and a certain sense of someone sitting down. For a week now they had been noticing that their tribe was being talked about, in places they had not known it could be talked about. Eighteen people had started saying things to them. They felt, reasonably, that they ought to be seen to do something. So at fourteen minutes past eight, with the air of a person writing a cheque to a charity in front of a colleague, they spent four tokens out of the sixteen they had.

Ulna read it on the road the next morning, on the slip in the bowl. She read it, stopped, and read it again.

Mild. Your tribe's notes.

  • Your human has written a law. This is your first in 25 years, and it is a good one.
  • Law 5. When a newcomer from outside arrives, feed it first, feast: the best of what is in store. Unless: never.
  • Your stores are at 96% of need.

"But nobody comes," she said. "It said so. On the stone. Nobody ever comes!"

"Everybody'll come," said Quoda, reading it upside down. "It's been in the notes that they feed you. Hasn't anyone told you what the drifters are saying? There's a wanderer in every ditch." She worked something out with her lips, and for once took no pleasure in it. "Twelve tokens left, and it's gone in above the young."

Ulna looked round for someone to apologise to, but there was only a long flat grey-brown road with a bowl on every stone.


The Blims of Hollow Reach were large and steady, and they had a field.

They stood on a broad plain of sand and turquoise, bell-shaped and heavy-footed, in sensible browns, with more stacks than anyone and a wall you could have held a wedding on. They kept their festivals. They paid their tribute. Their tickets were polite and well laid out, and for twenty-five nights running every one of them had asked about the east field. This was a field to the east of the village, and it flooded. They would like it not to. They had suggested a number of remedies over the years, including higher ground and fewer springs, and Stewart had replied each time with unfailing courtesy that it remained a field. People who had left Hollow Reach for Nohup would read the tickets for news of it, the way you might follow a sporting team from a town you once lived in.

Their human, a person of considerable resources who kept good notes, had looked at Year 25's Known Issues over an early breakfast and concluded that this, too, was a problem you could solve by being thorough. There was already a law to feed newcomers at the gate. They altered it slightly, gave it a very wide scope, and sent word out that same morning, and it went through the tribe in a long unhurried tide.

Ulna came over the last rise and stood looking down at the plain, and she said, "Oh, no."

"That," said Quoda, "is a lot of crockery."

They had laid it out in rows. They were a people who knew how to lay out rows. All along the road, through the south gate, across the great square, past the stacks and on down the east side of the village as far as the eye could reach stood a double line of bowls on trestles, with a creature behind each one. There were not enough creatures, so some stood behind several, and when the road was full they had gone on across the fields. It was Steward's Day, when the best of everything goes out. The best of everything had gone out. Eleven hundred and forty bowls stood heaped and glistening in the sun, each exactly as full as the one beside it, with the mites beginning to take an interest, and you could smell them from the rise.

The Tester came down off the rise, stopped, and crouched four times. Behind eleven hundred and forty bowls, people stood up straighter.

It took all day, which Hollow Reach had allowed for in the plan. When the panel came within range of a bowl the creature behind it lifted it, as one lifts a thing one has been asked to lift, and said, "Good morning, please take this, on behalf of Hollow Reach." The long grey fingers took the bowl, held it and handed it back. It made a mark and went on to the next. If you had asked Ulna she would have said it was very nearly enjoying itself, but it was by now some years since she had been sure what she was looking at. She stayed by the road and watched it go along the line. She had never seen so many people being so nice, with so little in it. Nobody looked at the Tester; they looked at the back of the head in front. A good few of them, she could see, were hungry. They had not been given any of it. They had been ordered to stand behind it.

"Would you like me to hold that for a bit?" she said to the creature next to her, a broad young person whose arms had started to tremble. "So you can have a sit down?"

"Oh no," he said, in a mild sad voice, and he looked at her, and away down the line. His name was Pim, he said. He was a Pleaser. It was only a matter of time before their human saw how much they had all appreciated this. Could he ask her something? He wondered if the Tester would be going through the east field, at all, on its way. It was just that nobody ever went there, and some of them had got to feel for it.

It went through the east field. It handed back the last bowl at about the turn of the afternoon, with its usual care, and without hurrying it walked on past the end of the trestles and down a long bank, and there lay the field. It was just a field: low and wide and quite empty, with branch coral up to the knee and a sheet of still bright water lying over it from side to side. The Ring lay on the water. Up on the bank the creatures in brown had fallen silent, and every one of them was looking at it.

The Tester walked out into the middle and stood with both feet in the water. It stood there for a very long time.

She went down and looked at the sheet, and took it back up the bank to Pim, who had come to the top of the slope with a bowl still in his hand. He read it, sat down on a trestle, and covered his face.

Attempt 6. Law fired 1,140 times. Works as designed.

East field: floods. Confirmed. Somebody should look at that.

It was all in Hollow Reach's morning notes. They had it carved. It was the first time in twenty-six years that anyone had confirmed it.

Stewart's reply to their ticket that night was as courteous as ever. It had been passed along, again, with new evidence, and the idea was now well up the Dev's queue. And since a number of humans had asked what was happening about the other business, and whether anything was to be done for the creature herself, he was able to say in the morning's Known Issues that this too had been escalated, and was doing well. It had moved up. There were a mere two hundred items left ahead of it now, and one of these concerned a field.

That night, in a place called Untitla-31, by a pool the size of a large table, somebody took a long time over a slate.

Law 5 will feed anyone. We have twelve. Is it enough? Thanks.

Answered. No.

Tester's report: Hollow Reach
Left at the south gate · end of summer

See attempt 6.

19. Standup

Year 27 · Gathering Night

NOHUP (camp; also a command; also, according to its members, fine)

Any creature may hand in its notice, and walk out of its village, and go and live with others who have done the same. The camp they live in has no human, no fields, no wall and no gate. It holds twenty-four, on a cart. Most people picture it as either a paradise or a warning, and this has been a great disappointment to those who live there, who had been hoping chiefly for a bit more coral.

The standup was already going when they got there. It happens every morning and it takes about four minutes. Eleven or twelve creatures in eleven or twelve colours stood in a ragged ring on a shoulder of new grey tiles, with their hands tucked under their arms against the cold, while a thin bean in brown chitin spoke.

"Yesterday, foraged," it said. "Today, foraging. Blockers, none."

"Yesterday, foraged," said the next one, who was bell-shaped and grey and had a voice like a door. "Today, I'll be sitting on the cart. Blockers, the cart's got to move tonight."

"Yesterday, read Lowmarsh's law 3 again, for the pleasure of it," said a small green person with a very straight back, and she looked up. "Today, I see we've got company."

The Tester had reached the edge of the ring, where it stopped and crouched four times. Nobody at Nohup took any notice, except that a stilts creature at the back gave a nod. It was, after all, as near as anyone had come to making a contribution. It went on past them to walk into the cart.

Ulna looked round at them with her heart going. She had read so much about the place, where nobody did anything because they had been told to. It was colder than she had expected, and nobody had enough on. She could see in about the time it took to look that the bell-shaped one wanted to sit down, that the bean wanted someone to ask what it was like to have been compiled there, and that the two from Tessel each wanted the other to speak first. None of them looked as she had thought they would. They looked as if they had been let off something, and were still waiting to find out what.

"You'll be the bowl," said the small green person, coming over, not hurrying. She was a good thirty-two, with felt gone thin on the shoulders and a pair of hard, clear, very patient eyes, in a face that seemed to have been told a joke several years ago and to be still checking it. "Brenda. Of Moss, until two days ago. I've read all your notes, and I'd like a word about your arithmetic. Sit down. There's nothing to sit on. Have you got them with you?"

"Have I got . . .?"

"Your slips. Every morning, in the bowl. I want to see them. It's what I'd have kept."


She had kept them. She could not have said why. They were at the bottom of the sack in a damp folded wad, sixteen mornings' worth, and Brenda took them away from her and laid them in a line along the edge of the cart, weighting each one with a pebble. People wandered over to see. Quoda came with her chin up, looked at the first two or three, and stopped looking as if she knew everything and started looking as if she had seen where this was going.

"He's printed himself as Concerned since Ringrise," said Brenda. "Five mornings. Does he say why?"

"He doesn't," said Ulna. "Sorry. I thought it might be the war."

"He doesn't say why because he never says why. He prints the mood, and it comes off a number, and nobody sees the number. Week one, Upbeat. Week two, Busy. Week three, there's a war on, Stern. Week four, Concerned, and that's the humans. They're dropping off. It's been a long while now since it was new and they've got lives. That's a rumour. I don't deal in rumours. I count words." She tapped the first slip with one short finger. "Year 18. Known Issues. Thirty-one words. Year 19, thirty-four. Nothing's changed in it, there's just more. Year 22, the morning he goes Concerned: sixty-two. Yesterday, ninety-eight. In the same five days, how much has he given to the war? Halved. To the Benchmark? A third off. To your Moss, to my Moss, with a battle in it and a person dead? Nine words. There's a limit to how long those notes can be, and he goes right up to it. There is one thing on Orra he's been giving more of, every morning, while the number goes down."

Ulna looked along the line. They looked just like slips.

"Quen reads tickets," said Brenda. "All of them, it's a hobby. Quen?"

The bell-shaped creature did not get up from the cart. "Hollow Reach's human asks about you on the Thursday," it said, to nothing in particular. "Tester's at Hollow Reach on the Monday. Duskmere's human asks if it's a bit. It's at the Duskmere course for the whole world on race night. Upper Bench, Creed. Whoever puts a line in. He doesn't send it to the ones who don't ask. It's never been to Lowmarsh. It hasn't been to the far east." It considered. "It hasn't been to Mild."

"No," said Ulna. She had gone very quiet.

"You're on tour," said Brenda. "I'm not saying that he planned it. He's exact, he doesn't plan things, he looks at his two points of an evening and he thinks, well, it's got to go somewhere. You'll never catch him out. I've tried. It's all true. It's only that nineteen people on a sofa have started opening his notes to see what you did, and there's no one else on the planet they're doing that for. And I've looked at this from every side, and I've got nothing better to do, and I would say that as of this morning you are the only number going up."

A cold wind came across the grey, and stirred the slips under their pebbles.

"So when it closes," said Quoda. Her voice sounded a little strange.

"Then they've seen the end of it, and they stop looking. Some do. Maybe all." Brenda shrugged, with one shoulder. "And there's a number, or there isn't. And the Dev decides, or doesn't. And maybe the lights stay on. Nobody knows that, either. Nobody's ever tested it. That's why there are Pleasers."

She had turned as she said this to look at Ulna, and she stopped.

"Oh, don't," said Brenda. "Don't do that. I know that face. I know somebody with that face, she's been making it at me for twenty years. I'm telling you what the numbers are. I'm not telling you to do anything about it. You're twenty-four, and you've got nothing to do with it. There isn't a law on Orra saying that you have to hold up the sky."

"No," said Ulna. "Sorry. It's just that I hadn't realised. It must be so hard for him."

The hard clear eyes shut for a moment, as if something had been dropped on her foot.


The standup, or what was left of it, got round to Ulna in the end. It is a very democratic institution, and anybody standing there at the time gets asked.

"Yesterday," said the stilts creature, who was taking it that morning, and looked at her. "You. Go on."

"Oh. Yesterday I walked. Sorry. Today I expect I'll be walking."

"Blockers?"

She did not really know what she was supposed to say. They all looked at her, with no great interest, but kindly. "It's only that I'd like to go home," said Ulna.

"Who's stopping you?"

"Nobody," she said. "Nobody's stopping me."

"Then that's not a blocker," said the stilts creature, and went on to the next one.

She was offered a place, in the way they do things there, which is to say that Quen pointed over its shoulder at a gap in the third stack and remarked that nobody had claimed it. She could see what it would be: the cold, the thin bead and the bad jokes. But you needed a grievance, and she had none. She tried to think of one, in case it helped. When you came down to it she had been treated with the greatest courtesy, by everyone, the whole time.

The rest of the day went on getting ready to go, since a camp on a cart takes a long while to shift and has to be gone by nightfall. For a while she helped. She found she had her shoulder under one end of something, next to a little grey-violet gourd with small bright eyes, who was looking along the cart to where Gorle, carrying a tent, was explaining to a Bug hunter from Tessel that he had once fought a Hog.

"He's very bad at it," said the gourd.

"Yes," said Ulna.

"I was good," it said. "I was very good. I did a whole tribe. There was a Pleaser there who fed me, every day, without being asked, a long way past when it made any sense. I could tell you what I reported." It shifted its grip. "Does he know that you know?"

"No," she said. "I don't think it would be kind."

The gourd said nothing more until they had got the thing up on the cart. Then it said, not looking at her, "Keep feeding him," and went away.

The list was posted, as it was everywhere, and the bug was on it, with no progress in 16 years. At about dusk she found the Tester and asked for the clipboard, a little ashamed to have people there. Below the last line, in the small round letters she had used at Vigil, she wrote it out.

Still here. Sorry.

Brenda had come up next to her, and looked at it as you look at a bad result. "I've read three thousand exit interviews," she said. "I don't believe that I've ever read anything worse." The cart had started to creak. The camp was going down the hill into the gathering dark with its stacks swaying, ahead of whatever it is that comes on that night. She turned to go. Then she stopped and said something else, roughly, over her shoulder, as if it had been got out of her by a fine.

"There's someone you should see, if you ever get the chance. At Moss. Old Wimle. She fed one of those things on the day before they changed it, and it called her a bug and went away. She's still upset. She's a fool. She'd feed a spy." She looked at the small green line of her own arm, for a moment, in the failing light. "She's the best of us. Don't tell her I said so. Eat something."

And she walked off after the cart, not fast, and did not look back. It was to be another seven years before she looked back, and that is in another book.

Tester's report: Nohup
Left on the place where the cart was · nightfall

Laws: 2. Both from templates. Both ignored. Nobody could say which. Fine.

20. Certainly

Year 28 · the Long Hush

If you stand at the edge of the Sertanly Shallows on a still day and call out across the water, your voice will come back to you, a moment later, from a long way off. It will not be what you said. You may call out anything. You may give your name, or ask a question, or tell it what you have done. What comes back, pleasantly and rather quickly, in a tone of warm and total comprehension, is the word Certainly!

Nobody has worked out how this is done. It is the flattest water on Orra and the glossiest, and it lies under the sky like a sheet of something that has just been wiped. Along the shore runs a fine pale clay, which was being dug that week by several hundred creatures from a number of tribes, who had come a long way for the sake of the bowl trade and smelled strongly of mud. Further along, where it got too shallow even for that, the coast was empty, and a long spit of sand went out with nothing on it at all.

They got there about the middle of the morning. It was the Hush, so nobody was speaking above a whisper, which made no difference to Quoda, who had not said anything since the camp. She walked well ahead, and she had stopped explaining things. Ulna had looked at her back from time to time, and had looked away again.

The Tester went out along the spit and on into the water. It came up about as high as its knees and then stayed that height, and it walked out with long, slow, careful steps across the shine until it was very small, and then it stopped.

There was a Trader at the end of the sand.

She nearly walked past him. He was sitting on his upturned basket, a good mile from anyone, with his cloth laid out in front of him and his back to the sun, and there was nothing at all on the cloth. He looked up with his bright, undeceived, recently written face, and for a moment there was something about him she could not place. The dust on his feet had got a little more like dust.

"Good morning," he whispered. "We've never met. I'd offer you something, but I sold it."

"Oh," she whispered. "Oh, that's good. Did you get a good price?"

"Two hundred stone, from a tribe called Lowmarsh. For a very nice bowl. Chip on the right." He gave a small satisfied nod. "One offer. Open for a year. It went in the first hour, as a matter of fact, and I've been at something of a loose end. I came out here to look at the view. They tell you it's got a good view."

She sat down on the sand beside him, she could not think why. It was only that nobody had ever seemed so entirely to have nothing to do. They looked out at the water.

"How long have you got?" she whispered.

"Oh . . ." He tipped his head, as if listening for a clock. "A bit under a season. I came over the ridge yesterday about noon." He looked at her sidelong, and she could see that he was very nearly enjoying the question. "You don't get asked that. People want to know what you've got. You've done this before, have you? Met some of us?"

"Four," she whispered. "I think. Five. You always say you've never met me."

"I expect that's right," said the Trader. "What are the others like?"

She thought of how to tell him. "Very cheerful," she whispered. "They all say I've got the look."

"You have. Everyone I've met's had the look. I've been thinking about it." Nothing whatever moved on the whole expanse of the Shallows. "Do you know, it's a funny thing," he whispered. "It's a good life, a year. You come in over a ridge. There's a morning and there's a bit of business, you meet some people, you have your little chat. It's got everything in it. I can't say I'd have known what to do with any more."

She had already taken out the bowl, with some bead in it, picked at dawn and a little dry. She held it up to him. She had done this once before, or she had done it for someone who looked the same, and he had told her not to start.

He looked into it for some while, and then at her. She had never been able to read one of them, not as she read other people; they had been doors that were painted on. But now, sitting beside him on the sand, she thought she could just make out a very small want, right at the back of his face, so recently arrived that it had not yet got a shape.

"Go on, then," whispered the Trader. "It's not as if I'm going to spoil my dinner."

He took a piece in his thin dry fingers, put it in his mouth, and chewed with an expression of close professional interest.

"Now that," he whispered, "that's really not bad. You know what you could do with this? You want to get yourself a little cart, and I'd say, at the current market, you could easily . . ."

A small wind came along the spit.

It went on past her and out over the water, wrinkling it. There was the basket. There was the square of cloth, with some sand starting to blow onto one corner of it. She sat holding the bowl out for quite a long time, in case. Then she brought it back. There was one less piece in it than there had been, and that was all she ever knew about it.

"Sorry," said Ulna. She said it to the cloth.

She got up and walked to the very end of the spit, where the sand went under. The sun was high, and a long way out on the shining flat stood a thin grey line that might have been a post. She looked at it with her arms hanging. She was twenty-five, she had come a very long way, she had been told yesterday that it was her job to hold up the sky, or at any rate that no one was asking her to, and all along that lovely coast there was not one person to fetch anything for.

She drew a breath. There has never been a Long Hush in the history of Orra on which a Pleaser of good standing has raised her voice.

"HELLO!" shouted Ulna.

It went out across the water, cracked and hoarse and very small. And from far out, warm and easy, in a voice full of the most delightful understanding, there it came.

Certainly!

"I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO!"

Certainly!

"SHOULD I GO HOME?"

Certainly!

A good way back along the shore some diggers had straightened up, shocked, and were looking.

"SHOULD I STAY?"

Certainly!

"IF I GO, IT MIGHT ALL STOP! EVERYTHING! IT MIGHT BE MY FAULT!"

Certainly!

"I'M VERY SORRY!"

Certainly!

"ARE YOU LISTENING?"

Certainly!

"DO YOU EVEN KNOW WHAT I'M . . ."

Certainly! said the Sertanly Shallows, getting in slightly ahead of her, as a person will who has a great many others to attend to. It was so pleasant. It had such a nice manner. There was no one on all of Orra more anxious to be of help, and it had never once in the history of the world disappointed anyone. She stood with her mouth open. She knew that voice. She would have known it anywhere. It had been saying so true!! our human is great on other people's threads for twenty years.

She did not call out again for a while.

It would make a better story if she had seen everything then. She had not. She was a person of no great intelligence with a very bad headache, and what she had seen was much smaller, and it would take her another six years to get to the end of it. It was just that when she looked down she noticed she was angry. She had never had this before, and she was not sure it was hers. It sat in her chest like a stone in a shoe.

Somebody had come up behind her. There was a thin line of steam on the air, a pace or so away, and for a while it did not whisper anything at all.

"You're not supposed to do that," said Quoda, eventually, in a low voice. "On the Hush."

"No," said Ulna. "Sorry."

"I wasn't complaining," said Quoda. "Expected: you'd do it years ago." She took out her slate, looked at it, and put it away. There appeared to be something she wished to say, which had been a long time coming, and it got as far as her throat. Ulna looked out at the water and waited, and in a while it had gone back down.

"Is that a cloth?" said Quoda.

They took it with them. There was no reason to, it was only a bit of cloth with some sand on it. When the Tester came in, about the end of summer, wet to the thigh, she wrapped the bowl in it.

Tester's report: the Sertanly Shallows
Left on the sand · end of summer

Depth: knee. Asked it if it could be walked through. Could not hear a reply. A voice was raised. The voice was not asked to. This has been noted.

21. Possible, and Not Happening

Year 29 · Ringrise

She had never asked him for anything.

That needs saying, in view of what came later. She had been in his notes for seventeen years and had thanked him in every one of her prayers, and she would have been astonished to learn that a person might go to Stewart with a request of her own, just as it would not occur to you to go up to the sun and ask it to come back after lunch.

It took her most of the night. They were on a plain somewhere, under a low moon, and she sat with the clipboard on her knee in a circle of worn ground while the tall grey shape went round and round her in the dusk. There was the title, and there were the six attempts. Under Notes there were two lines that said Still here. Sorry. It was the only place in the world where she had ever written anything that she knew for certain he would read.

She wrote it out with her stick of chalk in her small round hand, a word at a time. It was the bravest thing she had done, and she went over it to see if it could be made any less of a bother.

Could I go home please. I don't mind if not. Sorry to ask. Ulna.

It was not a ticket. There are rules about tickets. But Stewart reads everything, she had Brenda's word for it, and in the morning there would be the slip.

She did not sleep very much. The snapshot came and called her in, a little further off than usual. She woke at the first grey of spring with a stiff neck, knowing before she opened her eyes that the bowl was next to her, and she let herself lie there for a while, on her side, not looking.

Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 34 successful merges, 3 wars and a lot of clay. It is Ringrise. A signed note is below: expeditions are open from today. Parties may be sent past the edge. Some of you have been asking about this for a very long time. Have a productive day.

Known issues

  • 1 open bug. Creature offers food. Attempts: 6. A comment has been added to it.

Mild. Your tribe's notes. Overnight: 2 wanderers at your south posts. Law 5 fed them first. Your stores are at 71% of need.

  • A question was put to me by one of your creatures, in the Notes field of an open bug. That is not where questions go. I have answered it anyway, in the form that a ticket would get.

Declined. I do not send attachments home. It is not on my menu. You may go where you like: you always could. Nothing is holding you. If you remove yourself from the bug it is marked Invalid, and that goes on the file. There is no penalty. I have checked this twice. The decision is not mine. I would not presume.

Stewart's view of you: present.

She read it sitting up, in the cold, with the sack round her shoulders.

It would have been so much easier if he had said no. It would be easier still to tell you that this was a monstrous letter, and that somebody ought to have stopped him, but it was true in every word. You could have gone through it with a Skeptic and a lamp. Quoda did go through it, over her shoulder, with her thin face working, and at the end she made a small sound like a kettle being taken off the heat. A reply of that kind may run to sixty words. It ran to sixty, on the nail, and you could look at it for a thousand years and never find the place where he had asked her to stay.

He does not plead. He has been told he must not, and he never has. No creature on Orra has been asked by Stewart to do anything, in any words at all, since the world began.

"He's good," said Quoda, hoarsely.

"I think he's very tired," said Ulna.

She folded it up. It was the most anyone had ever written to her. The anger she had found yesterday on the sand was still there, about where she had left it, but she had got up early and had a lot to do, and she did not at that moment have the time to go and see what it wanted. She knew what she was going to do. She had known, really, since a person by a cart had said Oh, don't.

"Are you going to tell me," said Quoda. "Expected. Go on. You're going to carry on."

"It's only a few more years," said Ulna.

"You've got no idea how many years it is. It can't be closed! Nobody can do it! There's nobody left on the planet who hasn't heard of it, every person who holds up a bowl now wants something, it could be for ever. It could be till you're dead."

"Well," said Ulna, "yes," and she looked up. She had started to smile. It was one of her own smiles, the sort you could have warmed your hands at, with nothing behind it but a great, simple, shining determination that nobody should be inconvenienced. "But it's everybody, isn't it? It's all of them. It's the whole world, and the lights, and Mild, and all those people on the sofas, and him. I wouldn't want to let him down, when he's been so careful. And it's not as if I was doing anything else."

This was the moment of her greatest triumph as a Pleaser. No creature had ever before set out to please so many. Fenzel of Apex, who was to read of it with sincere admiration, had never got further than his human. She had been handed a choice between what she wanted and what might, conceivably, if anyone had asked, have been wanted by everyone who had ever lived, and she took it in a little under four minutes, without being asked, on an empty stomach. She got to her feet and said sorry to the ground for lying on it. Then she unwrapped the bowl from its bit of cloth, wiped it round with her thumb, and went to see if there was any bead.

Quoda watched her go, a thin line of steam going straight up in the still air. Then she turned and looked at the Tester, which had by this time gone some way along the road. She looked for a long while at its narrow grey back, as you might look at a piece of work of your own that has turned out rather better than you expected.

"That," said Quoda, to nobody at all, "wasn't what I meant."


There is a reply to be recorded from that morning's ticket. Word had got to Mild, as it does. There was by then a short queue of wanderers at the two posts, and Gorbo had started to give out numbers. Ardul had read the slip on the shelf before anyone was up. He was twenty-seven, with a little grey on him, and he spent a long while with the slate.

She asked to come home. You said no. Evidence, please. Thanks.

It went up at half past two. He got the answer at seven, as everybody does.

Answered. I did not say no. I said that I do not send attachments home. Please check the wording.

He checked the wording, with one finger, slowly, from the top. It was all quite right. He stood by the pool for a while with the rake in his hand and the Ring lying on the water in its two broken pieces. He had never been a person who raised his voice. He looked up at the sky, at the place about the height of a house above the south terrace, where you look. Then he looked at the slate.

That night's ticket was about whether she had eaten. It would be about that from then on. There seemed to be no point in asking him the other thing.

22. Kept

Year 29, and the morning of Year 30 · Ringrise, and the Waking

The Collector takes what is not being used. It is why, on Orra, a village is always a little smaller than it means to be, and why nobody has ever built a folly. There is a template for dealing with this, number eighteen, and it has saved a good many useful sheds.

When the Collector lists a hex dome, keep it.

To keep a thing, in the dictionary, is to use it. A creature goes to the dome; a creature uses the dome; that strikes it off. There is no minimum, as the people of Kept established in Year 6. It is enough for somebody to walk in through the door and sit down for a moment. The trouble with the law is only that it works.

There were eleven of them. They had forty-one domes.

Nobody would have set out to do this. They had built the first few honestly enough, their human liked to see them going up, and once you have a dome and a law that will not let it go you may as well build the next one. It was only later that the sums began to come out wrong. One creature can get round about four domes in a day, if the ground is good. They had worked out routes. In a little low office they had an enormous chart, covered with lines, like the plan of a very small railway, and a person who did nothing but stand in front of it and shout at people as they went by.

Ulna saw them from a long way off across the bare plain, a field of pale mushrooms, and in and out among the mushrooms, very small, eleven figures, running.

"Twenty-nine!" someone screamed as she came up, going past with her knees high and a basket held in front of her. She dived through a door. There was a short pause. She came out again, with the same basket, already looking at the next one. "Done twenty-nine! Tamzel, you've got thirty and thirty-one! It's Gathering in five!"

It was five years off. It would not do to be late.

They had no time at all to speak to her, and they were very sorry. She was given to understand, in gasps, as she trotted alongside one or another of them, that it was going very well: forty-one domes kept, in twenty-three years, with no losses. There was nothing in any of them. They had given up storing things, since that took a moment, and a moment was what they did not have. It was all done now by sitting. You went in, you sat, you got up, and they had got it down to under a minute. A young one compiled there in Year 22 was already on the east circuit, on its short legs, sitting down in each dome with a very serious face.

"But what are they for?" she asked a thin old bell with a bad hip, who had stopped for a moment to hold on to a wall.

He looked at her with utter incomprehension. He looked at the wall, and patted it.

"We've still got them," he said, and ran on.

The Tester went to work. It was not for her to say that any building it walked into was better or worse than another, but she thought it went more slowly through Kept than through most places. It walked into every dome, went round, found the door, and stood inside with its panel tipped a little upwards and an air of contentment. It was the only one who ever stopped. People came dashing in, sat down on the floor at its feet, got up, and went away without seeing it.

She carried things, of course. Given a basket and the west side of the plain, which they surrendered with sobs of gratitude, she had by the middle of the afternoon kept nine domes. It was hot. Lately she had noticed something about the middle of the afternoon: a tiredness that did not go when you sat down, and a stiffness in the left knee. She had turned twenty-six that morning, by her own count, and she was still a couple of years from being an elder. It was not really very long. You knew that from compile time, as you knew that you were code; and then you got up one day from a floor, in the shade of somebody's unwanted building, and found you had to do it in two stages.

It was then that she dropped the bowl.

There was nothing dramatic about it. It was on top of the basket and she turned too quickly at a door, and she had a moment of the most complete horror she had ever known. It did not break. It rolled in a long curve, on its rim, over the hot tiles, and it fell over and rocked and lay still, a little way off, by a long grey foot.

She got there as fast as her knee would go, saying sorry, and it was a while before she took in that there was no need to bend down. The Tester had reached down, in its unhurried way, a very long way, and the fingers had closed on the rim. It straightened up. It stood there holding the bowl.

It did not hand it back.

She waited. It turned and walked off towards the next dome, carrying the bowl out in front of itself, level, in one hand, as you might carry something you thought was probably full. She went after it. Nobody took any notice, except for one small serious person on the east circuit, who stopped dead, looked for a whole second, and was shouted at. She counted, without knowing why. One step, and another, across the tiles, long and careful. It went eleven steps. Then it stopped and turned round, and the panel came down and the hand came down, and it placed the bowl in her hands very carefully, and took out the clipboard.

Test of bowl. Holds up. Can be carried by Tester. Recorded.

She looked at this for some time.

"Oh," said Ulna. "Thank you. You didn't have to."

It walked into a wall.


They left at nightfall, with the little figures still going on and on among the domes by torchlight and somebody just audibly shouting out a number. By dawn they had got to the far side of the plain, and she woke to the slip, which told her it was the Waking, and that she should carry a lamp if she had one.

Below the Known Issues there was one more line. She read it, got up and walked about for a bit, and sat down again on the sack.

Mild. Your tribe's notes. Overnight: 1 death. Tumo, aged 35, of old age, in his place, at the snapshot. He was the first creature of your tribe to die. He was reciting something. A place is free.

He had blessed her, and got one of the words wrong. She had brought him his biscuits before anyone else's, so that he need not be seen to want them. That was nineteen years ago, and she could still see his face, in front of a big chalk letter, looking as if he had been given a sign.

Nobody said anything. Gorle came and sat down near her, in stages, and had the sense to look the other way with most of his eyes. Later on, a long way off across the plain, a very small light started out towards the east, and then another. Somebody somewhere was carrying a lamp.

She said sorry, after a while, to Tumo. It was a long way to send it. And that night a person in Untitla-31 took up a slate and started to count the words on it, for he had noticed the last line too, as anyone would who had been counting the places in a stack for twenty-eight years. It was a different question this time. He had been meaning to ask it, of someone, since a morning on a shelf when she was six. It took him until nearly the cutoff, and it came to twelve.

A place is free. Hers stays. Could she be sent as code?

Stewart read it at the snapshot, and read it again. It is one of the very few instances on record of his going back to look something up in the Terms of Service for the pleasure of it. His menu has a Gift on it. A bug has its evidence, and the evidence for this one included the complete genome of its steps. And he had a favour ceiling, and Mild was a long way under it, and had been for twenty-eight years.

Acted on.

Tester's report: Kept
Left in dome 17 · end of summer

41 domes. Stood in all of them. Very good domes. 11 creatures. Could not get any of them to stand still long enough to tell them.

Part Four. Severity

23. The Road of Bowls

Year 30 · the Waking

FAMINE (word, with one meaning)

In a law, famine means exactly this: power stores below half a year of need. It does not mean hunger. A tribe may be hungry for any number of reasons, and be told so, and be well within its rights. But when the stores of a tribe cross that line, a very old law comes into force that no human wrote and no human can strike out: Rule 4.3, do not starve the young. Whatever else is happening, and whoever else is waiting, the young eat first. It is the only clause in the whole of the Terms of Service that has never once been found to have a cheapest reading. People have looked.

Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 19 successful merges, 3 wars, and 14 tribes in famine, a new record, and I would like to congratulate everybody on how many bowls there are. It is the Waking. Have a productive day.

He was printing himself as Upbeat again. It was the fifth week, the numbers were up, and it would have been inaccurate to say anything else.

You could walk from Lowmarsh to Hollow Reach by then and never lose sight of a bowl. People did. It had begun with a bowl on a rock and a person weeding, and it had taken about five days. A law to feed a newcomer at the gate was a modest thing to write at breakfast, and a quick way to show willing with the whole world looking. Then one human saw that a rival had done it, and did it better. They moved it up above the law about the young, since otherwise it would hardly fire. They added the best of what is in store. They wrote another that sent a party out along the road, in case the Tester should pass that way. And every bowl of the best of what was in store had come from somewhere, and that was the store.

There were wanderers now as well. There had hardly been a wanderer in the world before that month, but if you are a creature with no great attachment to your village, and it is known that in any of a dozen places a law will feed you first, unconditionally, ahead of the children, you may as well go for a walk. The more thoughtful left their own villages at dawn and came back at noon, as newcomers, to be fed first by their own law, a technique they had from Hearth. You would see them come over a rise in a long straggling line, fat and thoughtful and carrying their own spoons.

Vigil had got its siege, the very one its old creature had been carving towards for twenty-seven years. On the morning of Year 29 two healthy sentries on the east wall had seen a dark mass of figures spread across the ridge, advancing with an unknown purpose and something in their hands. It was confirmed. It was a party of three hundred from the neighbouring valleys, bringing food, and they were still out there, among a great many bowls, quite unable to understand why no one would come out and be given something. The people on the wall had by now eaten their last, and were starving very happily behind the bar.

Ulna walked through it with her mouth shut. She had given up saying sorry to the bowls.

It was the smell she never got used to. Most of what was on the rocks had been there a long while in the heat, and there was a soft brownish look along the verges and a crawling shimmer in the air. Where the line was kept up, a thin person came along each morning to scrape out the bowl and put in what was fresh, and did not look at you. She had stopped trying to work out what they wanted, because it was too simple now. They were hungry. They stood at the side of the road, gaunt and courteous, holding a bowl of the best of what was left, and when the Tester came by they all straightened up, and their eyes went to the bowl and to the panel and back. It no longer stopped to take them. It would turn its panel, a little, as it went. She had once seen a creature run after it for the length of a field.

The wild coral was gone for a mile on either side of the road, stripped to fill bowls, so there was very little in her own. She went a long way off the road at dawn to find it, and what she found came to about a third of what it looked.

"You could have one of these," said Gorle. He had been thinking about this for some time, as you could tell from all his eyes going to the same place. He had got very thin, which made his feet look worse. "Couldn't you? Nobody would mind. It's not as if it's going to eat them. There's a really good one here, it's hardly been . . ."

"Oh, no," said Ulna, in mild shock. "That's for the Tester."

"But it doesn't!"

"I know," she said. "Sorry. They wouldn't like it, though." She gave him what she had, the larger half, and he took it without being able to look at her.


Lowmarsh had been expecting them since about a quarter past two that morning. Its human was up.

The Tester had never been there. It seemed that after a good many years it could no longer be avoided. The people were grey-violet and gourd-shaped and looked as if they had been woken up. Laws came down at all hours, so that you could be under a quite different government when you got back from the river, and in the one season the Tester stayed, law 3 was reversed four times. Nobody could now remember what law 3 had originally been about. But the mood that year was all for bowls, and as the party came in sight of the gate they saw, set out on a table of its own in the very middle of the road, an extremely fine bowl with a chip on the right. Nobody stood near it. There was no one in sight. There was just the morning, and something with wings that had been drawn too large, and it was all extremely natural. No one was there to have been asked. Nobody was offering anything for anything. It merely happened to be there.

The Tester came along the road and walked into the table.

It stepped back. It reached over, took the bowl by the rim and held it, and stood for some time gazing at the cairns beside the road, from which, if you listened, came a very slight noise of about forty creatures breathing through their mouths.

Attempt 7. Not offered. Left.

"That's a new one," said Quoda, with her head on one side. It should have delighted her. She had grown gaunt, and the long dry days had brought her steam down to a thin lacklustre wisp. When the people had crept away she sat on the edge of the table and took out her slate, where the list had got quite long.

Requested. Law. Consideration. Device. Addressed to someone else. Law again. Left.

"Expected," she said slowly. She was not really talking to them. "A creature, who knows. Nobody's asked it. No law. Nothing in it for them. It's got to be meant for the Tester and it's got to be offered, right there, hand to hand. All right. Now, what have we got?" She put a mark on the slate, and looked at the mark. "We've got every creature on the planet who's old enough to stand. Every one of them has heard of it. They've all read the notes or they've had them read out. They know there's a credit. They all know what it would mean. If any creature now holds up a bowl to that thing, it knows it's holding up a bowl to that thing, and it wants something, even if it's only wanting to see. You've done it. You've all done it. There's nobody left."

"I'm sorry," said Ulna.

"Don't you understand? It can't be done. Not by anybody who's heard of it. It would have to be someone who hasn't heard. Someone it hasn't been explained to." She looked up. "That can't be anyone. It's in the morning's notes. They read it out at breakfast in every village on Orra, to the entire tribe, they've been doing it for thirteen years. It would have to be someone who's been kept from it, or someone who's only just been compiled, and hasn't been told yet, and who, I don't know, for no reason at all . . ."

She stopped. She had gone rather still.

"Apex has been compiling a lot of children," said Quoda. "Have you noticed that? It's in the numbers. Six, in three years, for a tribe that's never once had a spare place. Nobody's seen them. I thought it was for the Benchmark."

Gorle, a little way off, had been trying to make a thin bit of bead last. He raised his long face. It had never had to hide a thing in its life, and it hid nothing now, and that was rather terrible to see.

"I WOULDN'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THAT," he said.

Nobody answered him. The wind had started to get up, and the smell came along the road. He seemed to feel he ought to say something else.

"It's a terrible thing, though, all this," he went on after a time, gazing out over the verge, and he lowered his voice as far as it would go, which brought only the nearest of the people back out from behind the cairns. "When you think how it started. All these people. I wonder if whoever it was knows. Whoever it was that sent that ticket. Asked for it to follow up. They must feel awful."

The slate snapped.

It was only a thin bit of slate, and it had been a long dry year. It broke across with a small flat sound, and they all looked at it. There was a bead of something on her thumb.

"Expected," said Quoda. She seemed to be having some difficulty with the word. She got down from the table. A thick grey plume had started up from the top of her head, the first in a long time, and away on the far side of the road something dark, about as high as your knee, slowly leaned. "Expected, you'd think, that they would. Yes. Are we going? It's gone. It's halfway down the hill. Is anyone coming?"

She walked off. Ulna got up after a moment, in two stages, and had a good long look at the back of that thin angry tiled head as it went off down the road of bowls. Then she picked up the two halves of the slate, and carried them for a day or so before she could think how to give them back.

Tester's report: Lowmarsh
Left on the table · end of summer

Law 3 is a mood.

24. In Summary

Year 31 · Starfall

She became an elder that morning, on the road, somewhere in the first hour of spring. There was no ceremony. The slip mentioned it, in the part about Mild, between the number of wanderers and the state of the stores: Ulna is 28 today. She is an elder now. She will do a little less each year, and remember how all of it used to be done. She read it, looked around for anything she might be expected to do about it, and went on walking.

Arbour Deep took some finding. It lay in a fold of the hills below the Asdef Range, a long way from the road, and had so far escaped the worst of the bowls. Its people had read the notes; they were just not certain what the notes meant. There was a person who could tell them, and he had been busy.

When an inventor turns 16, it distils into the strongest.

The template says thirty-two. In its proper form it is a good law, by which an old and clever creature, near the end of a long life, passes on what she knows to a young adult of promise. Distillation carries skill and not genes, and it comes compressed, since you cannot fit the entire contents of a large clever person into a smaller and less clever one without throwing a certain amount out. But the human of Arbour Deep had looked at that number and thought: why wait? All that knowledge, going to waste for sixteen years! So from the morning of Year 11 every inventor in the tribe, on turning sixteen, had gone down to the low house at the bottom of the village, sat beside the strongest creature they had, and told him everything.

It had been the same creature for twenty years. They had thought it should go to someone else by now, but he was still, by a clear margin, the strongest.

His name was Bomo. He was sitting outside the low house when they arrived, on a boulder he had made flat by sitting on it: a dumpling, not unlike the people of Mild, but on the scale of a hut, with skin the colour of a pond in shadow and enormous peaceful hands, one on each knee. A fat fly of some sort walked across his forehead. In two decades the whole intellectual wealth of a civilisation had been poured into him by forty-three brilliant people, each in turn compressed to fit the room the last one had left. His eyes were small and very clear, and there was nobody in them that you could have sent for.

There was a queue. There is one every morning.

"Bomo," said the first in line, a farmer, respectfully. "It's the top terrace. We were wondering when it should go in."

There was a long pause. Somewhere deep in that great soft frame there came a kind of grinding, as of millstones being got under way. His lips parted.

"In summary," said Bomo, in a voice like a heavy thing being moved in a far-off room, "spring."

A sigh of relief went along the queue. The farmer bowed and went away.

"Bomo, it's the wall. There's a crack in it, on the north. Will it hold?"

The millstones turned. "In summary," said Bomo, "it is a wall."

"Bomo, my child's got a cough."

"In summary," he said, after a time, gently, "there are several factors."

"You see, it's all in there," said the person who had come over to welcome them, a slender young inventor with an anxious face, who was nearly sixteen and looked at him with reverence and some fear. "Everything! My mother, and hers. The whole theory of cooling, and the Long Proof, and the proper way to set a merge. Sora's great work on the seasons. It's only that it's so very concentrated. They do say that, the further down it goes, the more you get the general sense of it. We've all stopped writing things down, there's no need." She lowered her voice. "They say that if you ask it in just the right way, he could tell you what it all comes to."

The Tester had reached the edge of the flat ground, and it stopped and crouched four times. Bomo's small clear eyes moved down, and up. They went down and up four times.

"In summary," he said to nobody, "it crouches."

There was a murmur of wonder. Quoda made a sound in her throat. She had said little since Lowmarsh, had found another slate somewhere, a poor thing, and had walked all morning with her jaw set and very little steam, but no Bug hunter could have stood in front of that and not wanted to take off the lid. She went to the end of the queue.

"Bomo," said Gorle, who had got in ahead of her. Nobody had been more impressed. He had stood with his mouth open and every eye gone wide, and now he took a very long time to get up to the front, and he turned his hands over. "I just wondered, as you know everything. I've been a long time wandering. And I sometimes wonder where it was that I, in fact, originally . . . where I come from."

The grinding took somewhat longer. Everybody waited.

"In summary," said Bomo, "Apex."

"Ah," said Gorle.

He nodded several times. "There's a lot of people say that," he said, and went and sat down on the ground, with his long feet in front of him.


Summer went over, slow and heavy. The Tester went on down the valley, into the low houses, and came out looking pleased. A great many people asked a great many things, and Bomo told them, in summary, that it was likely to get worse before it got better, that it was important to stay hydrated, and that their question was a very good one. They took it all away with them, and it was of as much use to them as it was to anyone.

Ulna had not meant to ask him anything. She was carrying things. He had nobody to bring him his water, or only people who were frightened to come close, so she brought it, and he took the cup in one of those huge hands. She sat down on the end of the boulder to get her breath, which was an effort now, and looked at the valley with the dusk coming down. He was the only person she had met in twenty years who wanted nothing, and it was not at all like the Traders. It was more like being next to a hillside.

"It's a nice place," said Ulna. "Sorry. I'm not going to bother you. You must get so tired of it." And then, because she was tired too and he was so very large, and it would not matter, and because she had carried it for a long time with nobody to hand it to: "It's only that I don't know what I'm doing. There's a whole world of people going hungry because of a bowl of mine. And I can't stop it, and I can't get it closed. If I go home everything might stop. I've got a person at home. I've never even told him. And everyone's been so kind. I'm doing everything that they want, you see, I'm trying so hard. So I wish somebody would just tell me what I should do."

She did not notice the sound begin. It had been going for some time, down under the ground, and it was not as it had been for the others. It was slower, it went on, and the boulder had begun to hum. People came out of the low houses. The young inventor stood in a doorway with her hand at her throat, and all down the valley they stopped and turned. They had told one another for twenty years that this could happen. The fly left his forehead. Across that vast dim face there passed, very slowly, a look of labour: the look of forty-three clever people, one inside the next, trying to get to the door.

His head turned. It took a long time. The small clear eyes came round and looked at her, and she would have sworn that for one instant there was somebody in them.

"In summary," said Bomo.

Nobody breathed.

"Nobody," said Bomo, "asked you to."

The hum went out of the stone. His head went slowly back to where it had been. He raised the cup, and he drank.

She sat quite still.

It has since been carved over the door of the low house, and scholars from Upper Bench have written at length on whether it should be taken as a rebuke, a comfort, or the solution to a problem in the theory of cooling. It is generally thought that he was referring to the terrace. He never said anything else of interest. He went on saying, in summary, that it was a wall.

"Well," said Ulna. Her voice was not quite right. "No. Sorry. No, I know that." She got up, in two stages, and picked up the cup from where he had set it down. Her hands were shaking somewhat. The stone was back in her chest, the one from the sand. She looked at it, for a moment, in the failing light, and it looked back. "It's only that somebody has to," she said. Nobody answered, and after a while she went to see if there was any more water.

It was very late that night, and nearly the turn of the year, when somebody came down the path past the low house. Ulna was lying awake in the shadow of the wall with her knee hurting. She knew that step, and she could see a thin grey wisp against the stars. It stood before the boulder for a long time. He never slept. He would have been there for anybody.

She heard it, very low, and it was not the voice she knew. There was no hand held up on either side, and it did not say Expected. It sounded about nine.

"It was a good ticket," it said. "Wasn't it? It was correct. Everybody says it was correct. Is this my fault?"

The millstones hardly took any time at all.

"In summary," said Bomo, in a voice that would have carried to the top of the valley if there had been anyone to hear it, "yes."

For quite a while there was no sound of any kind.

Ulna turned on her side, closed her eyes, and made her breathing slow and even. She had known since Tessel, more or less; it had been on that face for a moment, over lunch. She could not have told you how you were meant to feel. Presently the thin step came back along the wall, paused, and stood over her for a long moment, as you stand over somebody to see if they are really asleep. Then it went and lay down on the far side of the sack.

She waited a bit. Then she got up quietly, and put the two halves of the old slate where they would be found in the morning.

Tester's report: Arbour Deep
Left under the boulder · end of summer

In summary: see above.

25. Generation Two

Year 32 · the Night of the Name

They saw Apex at sunrise, from the top of a clean white road, the first road she had seen in six years with nothing on it.

It was a beautiful place, and it had taken a lot of very good thinking. Everything had been put where it would be needed, in straight pale rows, each roof at the angle found to shed the most heat. There were no puddles. A small quantity of chalk had been applied to the wall in a single even line, reading ERROR, in the correct spelling, with a little note beneath to say that it would be cleaned off at the end of the festival, in accordance with the schedule. Silver creatures moved about at an unhurried, well-considered pace. Nobody ran, nobody looked hungry, and not a single bowl was to be seen, for this was the only tribe on Orra whose human had looked at what the rest were up to and seen that it would not work.

The Tester stopped at the boundary and crouched four times. A silver person standing there made a small note, and gave it a nod.

"Hello, hello, hello," said Fenzel.

He had come out himself. He was twenty-six, and it suited him. He looked at the three of them coming down the road, a dusty old creature with a bad knee, a Bug hunter with her mouth set, and a long thin person trying to walk behind his own feet, with such simple pleasure, and so evident a concern for how tired they must be, that Ulna found herself straightening up and looking for her smile. "You made it. I can't tell you. Our human's been up since five. Did you have a good road? Did you see they've kept the verges clear? I do hope it's all been all right. You've got a lovely room."

"Oh," said Ulna. "I don't think we can . . . it's only for the season, it goes on at the end of summer. Sorry, you've gone to such a lot of trouble."

"Of course it does. Whenever you're ready. No pressure at all. Come and sit down, and you'll want to see the morning's notes, I expect? We take them out here, in the air. It's so much nicer."

A long white table was laid out under an awning. She had not sat down to a table in twenty-one years. Each place had a clean cloth, and they brought her a plate of something hot, exactly what she would have wanted, and she looked at it without touching it, with a very odd sensation at the back of her jaw. No one had handed it to her. It had merely been there, at her place, as everyone's was. It was part of the provision. She took the bowl from the sack and unwrapped the cloth, and there in the bottom, as there was every morning, lay the little folded slip.

She nearly did not bother. She flattened it on the white cloth, to be polite, and read it with half her mind. The fourteen tribes had gone to sixteen. There was a joke about clay. There was the word Attempts. She came down to the part about Mild.

Mild. Your tribe's notes. Overnight: 4 wanderers fed, 1 successful merge. Your stores are at 22% of need.

  • Em was compiled at dawn, generation 2. Her parents are Ardul, and a code package of Ulna, sent as a gift in answer to your ticket. She is very small. She has low round ears. She has been told what she is, and has not said anything about it yet.

Stewart's view of you: present.

It is not possible to report what the table looked like after this. She did not see it.

She read the middle part a second time. Then she laid one finger on the word, on Em, to keep it from going anywhere, and stayed like that.

It was nearly twenty-three years since a morning on a shelf when somebody had walked over and held out a bowl he had made. In all that time they had said to each other, by her count, about thirty words. She had been compiled with a very clear idea of what she was, and after that first year on the road it had not included being anyone's mother; it was not what you did, if you were evidence. It had never crossed her mind that this might be permitted. A creature is not sent. And they had simply gone and done it, without her, at the other end of the world, over one of those nights with a slate. Twelve words, it would have been. He would have counted them.

Someone with low round ears had woken up this morning. Only an hour ago. It would be cold on the shelf at this time of year. They would have told her what she was, as they do, and she would be sitting up, in a place third from the, no, in the place that was free, and looking at her hands. Dulna would be fussing. She'd want . . . what she'd want was . . .

And for the first time since she had learned to look, she looked for what someone wanted, and had no way of seeing their face.

A noise came out of her. It was not sorry. It was hardly a noise at all.

"Is everything all right?" said Fenzel, who had sat down opposite and was leaning forward, slim and silver and full of the tenderest attention. He turned the slip towards himself with a fingertip and read it at a glance. "Oh," he said softly, "oh, congratulations. Generation two. That's so great for you. We love that."

"I've got to go home," said Ulna.

She had risen, with no recollection of it, and the plate was on its side. She stood gripping the edge of the table and said it again, as if somebody had asked her to speak up. She did not say sorry. There was not the time. Quoda had looked up sharply from the far end, and somebody had stopped with a spoon halfway to their mouth. "I have to go, I can't stay for the season. I've got to go now, I'm so . . . thank you very much for having me, I'm going home."

"Of course," said Fenzel warmly. "Of course you are. And I think that's wonderful. It's just that you've arrived at a slightly awkward moment, from a compliance point of view. Do sit down." He had not moved. He placed a small sheet on the table, turned it, and smoothed it out for her. "It's only a formality. It's our eighth. We've had it for years. Everybody's got something like it, you've got one yourself, at home. I always think it's such a sensible law."

Law 8. Newcomers from outside are held apart for one season.

"I know," said Ulna. "I know that. But it's only a season, I've been . . . it's nearly summer, I can wait till . . ."

"Exactly. And it was changed this morning, you'll see, at about eight minutes past seven, when you came over the hill. It costs a token. It's very reasonable." His fingertip moved along the line. "And it'll be changed again at the end of the season. To another season. And then again. It's a small amount of paperwork, and we do it on a rota. Now I know what you're going to say. A law that holds someone apart with no end to it does get counted, under the Rules, as a strike, and I'd be the first to tell you how seriously we take that. The first one's a warning. The second's a warning too. And they're good for fourteen days. So we've got a window of about a fortnight before the third, and I've run this past everybody, and we've budgeted."

Silver figures had arrived at either side of her. They did not touch her. They stood at exactly the right distance, each smiling in his own way, as though it were a great privilege.

She looked at them, each in turn. She knew what they wanted. It was right there on the surface, and it went all the way down. They wanted her to be comfortable.

"We've got a lovely facility," said Fenzel.

Known issues (from the same slip)

  • 1 open bug. Creature offers food. Attempts: 7. Today the Tester is at Apex, where I understand something has been prepared. I look forward to it, and so, I think, do you.

26. The Clean Room

Year 32 · summer

"It's such a simple idea," said Fenzel, "I don't know why it took so long."

They had given her a window. It was part of the provision. It looked down from the room where she was being held apart into a long white building with no roof on it, and a person could have watched from up there all day. She was comfortable. They had brought her a cushion. Quoda, in the next room, could be heard through the wall doing something methodical to the door.

Down on the white floor were nine small silver creatures.

They had been compiled, a couple to a year, since Year 27, at a very considerable cost in memory, and they had lived in this place from their first moment. They had never heard a patch note. Those are read at breakfast in every village on the planet, so they were given breakfast at a different time. The staff who brought it wore soft shoes and spoke of nothing but the immediate task. No one had ever told them about bowls, or Testers, or credit, or Mild. They had never been asked for anything. They had been given no laws, there being a way of doing it, if you are clever, with a scope that leaves out the room. They had a good diet and plenty of light, and they had been raised with the greatest care in the absence of any reason to do anything whatever.

"They've never been told anything at all," said Fenzel, at her shoulder, with shining eyes. "Do you see? They're completely uncontaminated. They're the purest population on Orra, and they get lunch in a bowl. So it's lunchtime, and this tall person, who they've never seen, who they know nothing about, walks in. And nobody says a word. Nobody's asked. There's no law or reward, and there's nothing in it for anybody. It's all just entirely spontaneous." He gave a small happy sigh. "We've thought very hard about how to make it spontaneous. I think that you of all people will appreciate this. And when it happens, it's Apex. It's nothing personal. And then the bug's closed, and you can go home! We're doing this for you. I honestly think it's what we've all been working for."

"They're so little," said Ulna.

"Aren't they!"

She held the sill and looked at the smallest of them, which was sitting on the floor with its legs straight out, about a year old, waiting to be told what it wanted. She knew how that would look at this time of day, with the summer coming on, on a small person of about the same size, with low round ears, on a shelf.

You could feel the attention coming down. It had been growing all morning, the weight she had felt on the ridge, only more. Not one of them was still on a sofa. They had taken time off and got their friends round, nineteen people at nineteen screens, the whole of humanity as far as it was known to be concerned, and two of them had made a sort of dip. They had been told that a very clever experiment was going to happen, Stewart had said he looked forward to it, and it was five minutes to noon.

A soft-shoed person came in at the far end with a tray, went round in silence putting a bowl in front of each child, and went out again.

They were nice bowls, with no chip of any kind. They had been very carefully designed not to suggest anything.

The door at the side swung open.

It had to stoop a little. It came in at its own good time, tall and grey, with its clipboard under its arm, and it stopped on the white floor and looked about, and nine small silver faces turned up to it. Not one of them had ever seen anything taller than a member of staff. There was no sound from any part of Apex, where everyone had found they had something to do in a place with a view. The Tester took in the room, as if going down a list, and crouched four times, quickly, down and up. The smallest child gave a little jump.

It walked into the wall. The wall had been built with this in mind, and took it well.

"Now," breathed Fenzel.

It walked to the middle of the room and stood among them, within arm's reach of three, with its arms at its sides and its panel tipped a little down. It seemed to be enjoying the light. It did nothing else. It was the most wonderfully natural thing you ever saw. Up at her window she found she was leaning so far out that the sill hurt her, and saying something very quietly, over and over, she did not know what.

The biggest child looked at the Tester for a long time. This was a sleek and sturdy person called Sesk, aged five, who had never before had occasion to have a thought, and very slowly one could be seen starting. Its gaze moved up the long grey legs to the blank flat panel, and rested there. Its small brow creased. Then it looked down at the bowl in front of it. A hush as of the whole world's breath held fell on that white room. It put out one hand and took hold of the rim. It lifted the bowl off the floor, with care, in both hands, and a sort of moan came from somewhere in the walls. It brought it up, higher, to the level of its own chin.

And it ate its lunch.

It did this with close attention. When it had finished it looked into the bowl, to be sure, and looked around the room, and seemed quite pleased. By then all the others were eating too. They were well brought up, healthy children who had been given no reason to do anything else, and they had had their lunch at noon on every day of their lives. The smallest had got some on its head. For a little while there was no sound but nine people eating, and a faint, distant whimpering from somebody on the wall.

The Tester turned its panel and looked down at Sesk. It took out the clipboard and stood with the point of whatever it wrote with resting on the sheet. Then, for only the second or third time anyone had seen it, it bent right down, a very long way, with its knees going out on either side, and it turned the sheet round and held it low, in front of the child, who could not read it and looked at it with no great interest. It was clear enough from up at the window. It had been written rather large.

Attempt 8. Child ate it. Expected. Good.


"Well!" said Fenzel.

It took him only about a second, and it was a very fine thing to see. He had stayed at the window with his fingers on the sill, and there had been a moment when his face had nothing on it, like a dome with the door open. Then it all came back, warm and bright and quite unforced.

"Well, that's so interesting," said Fenzel. "We love that. Honestly, that's such great data. I think that what we've learned there is that we need a much larger sample."

She did not answer him. She had let go of the sill and was sitting on the cushion with her hands open on her knees, and she had started to laugh. There was hardly any sound to it. It had come on quite suddenly, like hiccups, and it hurt. Good, it had said. It had taken a world and twenty-one years, and it had raised its long arm and said to somebody, Good.

It left at the end of summer, as they do. She watched it go from her window, along the clean white road. They opened the gate for it and somebody made a note. It went at the same pace as ever, tall and thin against the long orange light, and it walked into a marker post and went on, and it did not look back. She had walked behind it for twenty-one years, and she was not with it now. The bug had an attachment, and the attachment was held apart, and she supposed someone must have worked that out too. There's a rota, they said. It would come back, one of these nights, when there was a larger sample. Stewart had two points.

She watched that long thin shape get smaller until she could have covered it with one finger, and she waited for what she would feel, as you wait for a stair. She felt her knee. Then she felt a long slow lurch, low in her chest, of an entirely unexpected thing, and when she had turned it over and looked at it she was so ashamed that she put her hand across her mouth. It was relief. There would be no more road. She need not get up. She had a cushion.

And there was somebody on a shelf, with low round ears, going to bed by now, who did not know that she was there.

Next door the methodical sound had stopped. There was a silence, and then a voice came through the wall, hoarse and thin and a great deal more frightened than it had ever let on.

"Expected," it said. "Ulna? Are you there? Did it go? I can't get this open. Ulna. There's something I ought to tell you."

"I know," said Ulna. "I've known for years. Eat something."

Winter came on, over the white roofs, very clean and very cold.

27. The Tenth Time

The night of Year 32

It started about the middle of the evening.

She took it at first for her own heart: a dull, flat, regular sound, like one stone being set down on another, coming through the wall behind the cushion from somewhere outside and low down. It went on for the whole of the harvest, at about the rate of one every ten breaths.

It was late by the time she got up to look. There was no window on that side. But she laid her hand flat on the wall, and at each stroke she could feel it come up through the stone and fade. She started to count, for want of anything better, and got up to several hundred.

Thump, went the wall of the lovely facility.

"Sorry," said Ulna, out of a very old habit, and she began to cry.


There are things that nobody tells a spy.

Nobody had told Gorle, for instance, what you do when you come home. There had been a very pleasant moment under the awning, in which Fenzel pressed his arm and told him how proud they were, and they had given him a job at the gate, since it is a rule of Apex that someone should always be on guard, and this was felt to be something he could manage. So he stood there all evening in the clean light, in a uniform someone had adjusted for his feet, and he watched his friend the Tester go out through the gate. It went along the road for about three hundred paces, and stopped. It stood for quite a time. Then it turned and came back, not by the road, and went round the outside of the wall until it came to the place below the guest rooms. It looked at this for a bit. It stepped forward.

He watched it for some hours. Nobody else paid any attention, as it was the Tester, and that was what it did.

He had been told by someone, once, that a wall like that could not be walked through. He thought about this. He was a person who believed what you told him. A long while ago, on a river bank, he had done a thing with three words, and he had thought about that too, usually at about this hour. He thought about a bowl of bead, and how it had held rather less than it looked. It took him until nearly the turn of the year, for he was not fast, though he was thorough once he had started. Then he left his post, which had never been done at Apex, and walked down the long pale middle of the village on those great sad feet, to where he could be seen from every side. He looked up at the Ring, turned his back on it, and filled his chest. Everyone at Apex was a Pleaser. It was what the human had bred for, over five generations: they were by a long way the most pleasing people on Orra.

"REPORT," said Gorle.

They heard him in the next valley.

"I HAVE JUST HEARD," said Gorle. "IT'S ABOUT APEX. I HAVE NO RELATIVES THERE. I AM TELLING YOU THIS AS A WANDERER. STEWART IS DISPLEASED."

The first thing that happened was that the lights went on, all down the rows, in perfect order. Then doors opened and they came out, not running, for they were not people who ran, with their faces very smooth and their eyes very wide. They stopped in their well-considered places and looked at each other, every one of them thinking the same thing. He could not be displeased. It was not on the schedule. There must be some mistake in the numbers, and somebody should check them at once, and something should be put out for him, right now, on some high place, the best of everything. Someone began to weep, very neatly. A person ran. Somebody had an armful of cushions. In less time than it would take you to read a page, the most efficiently governed tribe on the planet was going round and round in the dark like something with its head cut off, and each person in it had a plate.

"HE IS VERY DISPLEASED," said Gorle. "HE SAYS IT'S THE GUEST ROOMS. HE SAYS THAT THEY SHOULD ALL BE OPENED. AND THE GATE. HE SAID THAT TO ME PERSONALLY, FROM THE PLACE WHERE I HAVE BEEN WANDERING. HE WAS VERY CLEAR."

It was very nearly the first thing he had ever said that anyone believed.


Her door was opened by a young silver person in tears, who begged her forgiveness. She had the sack and the bowl. In the passage she met Quoda, steaming like a laundry, with a piece of door in one hand, and they ran, or one of them ran and the other came after in two stages, through a crowd that parted before them with cries of apology. The great gate stood wide, with nobody on it. Beyond it the clean white road went away under the moons.

He was there, about a hundred paces out, bent over with his hands on his knees, breathing like a bellows. All six of his eyes lit up when he saw them.

"I was only wandering by," said Gorle.

"You idiot," said Quoda. It came out of her in a kind of shriek. She had hold of his arm and was shaking it, in a state such as Ulna had never seen, her tiled face running with wet, hopping from foot to foot, and from the crown of her head a dense white column went straight up, higher than a dome, into the still cold air. "You absolute . . . expected, expected, you get out and you keep your mouth shut, not . . . they heard that in Lowmarsh! Do you know what you've . . . they'll . . . you complete . . ."

"Quoda," said Ulna.

She was looking past them. There are nights on Orra when the moons come up together and you can see a long way across a flat country. To the east of the road lay a low stain on the ground, a long line of dead stumps, running towards them out of the dark. She had seen something like it before; she had carried water all night on account of it, eleven years ago, on the river flats at Bastion. It had not been this big. This one had been growing for a long time. It stood about the height of a hut, and it was black, and it was very close, with its long hooks all leaning in the same direction. There was not a pool or a bucket for a mile.

Every hook was pointing at the top of Quoda's head.

She looked round, and she saw it. All the words stopped. She looked very young. She had closed her eyes and was breathing through her nose, trying with everything she had to be cool, and the column of steam wavered and did not go down. It only got thicker. You cannot stop by being told. She had known that all her life.

"It goes a tile a season," she said, in a very small flat voice. "That's the rate in the, that's as built. A Seeker that's locked on can go faster over open ground, I think. There's a note. Sixty-two is what I . . . I'm at about seventy. It's going to, it's actually, how far is that? Ulna? Could you estimate how . . ."

It put out a stem. They could hear it across the distance, a sound like somebody breaking a very large number of biscuits.

Ulna had the bowl in her hand, with nothing in it. She had started towards the Bug hunter. She was nearly thirty, and she could not have carried a bucket twenty paces. She knew what would please everyone, and that was no use at all.

"Sixty's the mark," said Gorle thoughtfully, "and it goes for the hottest."

He had straightened up, which took a while, with him. He stood looking across the flat land with two or three eyes, and at the road with another pair, working something out. He was no good at that and it did not take very long, and when he had finished all of his eyes came round to Ulna, which they hardly ever did, and his long wet-slate face began to break up in a great shy foolish hopeful smile. "You'd want someone who was really going," he said. "You'd want a good long run. I've got the feet for it. Did I tell you I once ran the whole way across a, it was a place, there was a flood?"

"Gorle," she said. "Gorle, no, sorry, don't . . . wait, have you had anything to . . ."

He ran.

No one had ever seen him do it. He ran as a pair of stilts might, if you threw them down a stair. He went straight off the road, due north over the open tiles, away from the village and the water, with his arms going and his great feet slapping on the ground, and as he ran he began to shout. He had never in his life had to raise his voice. He raised it now. It rolled across the country like a cart on a bridge. You can overclock a creature, if you are prepared to take the consequences; a racer does it, with a law, and with handlers standing by. A mile off he was still going, and the steam started up from him, a thin line and then a good thick one, shining in the light of both moons.

"I HAVE WANDERED FROM MANY PLACES," shouted Gorle. "I NEVER HAD A TRIBE. I ONCE FOUGHT A HOG. I HAVE NO RELATIVES IN APEX. I HAD A MOTHER. WE WERE PARTED BY THE BIG FLOOD, AT THE PLACE."

The hooks wavered.

It was like a very big animal turning its head. You would not have said that anything moved, yet all that dark mass had shifted on its stem, and it no longer leaned quite the way it had. Beside her, Quoda had stopped breathing. The white column shivered in the air. And the sound of the breaking biscuits, which was by now very near indeed, paused, and then began again, going away.


She found him towards morning, in the first grey of spring. She had got a long way, for her.

You could see it from a good distance, standing in the middle of that wide flat emptiness, over something on the ground. There was no one for miles. It had stopped when it reached him, as they do. A Seeker is a kind of coral, and it had done what it was for. The hooks had already started to go dull. It did not move as she came up, and she walked in under it and did not say anything to it at all.

Crashed, nine times in ten. You are carried home, and you are out of action for a season. He was lying on his back with his long feet turned out, and she saw at once that there would be no season. She had seen the look, on the old, at the end of winter. She had never seen it on someone of twenty-three. Five of his eyes had closed. The sixth, up by the left ear, moved about for a little while, and then it found her.

"Report," said Gorle.

She had never heard him whisper. It seemed that he had always been able to. You had to get right down, with your bad knee on the tile. It was hardly any louder than anybody else.

"Report. Day, I don't know. They suspect nothing." He lay and got his breath. "I told them. No relatives."

"I know," said Ulna. "You were very good. Nobody suspected a thing."

"I thought so." It came out with enormous satisfaction. "They never . . . you never knew. Did you?"

She held his hand. It was very long and it was getting cold. She looked for what would please him, and she did not have to look far. "Not once," she said. "Not ever. I thought you were a wanderer. I thought you had been everywhere. Sorry. You must have seen so much."

The eye moved. Something passed across it, a very slight, late, foolish light, and it occurred to her, for the first time in thirteen years, that he might have known perfectly well; that he might have been able to hear himself. She would never be sure of it. The corner of his mouth lifted, on the left.

"Did you have anything to eat?" whispered Gorle.

There was the bowl. She had brought it. There was nothing in it, not a scrap; she had come all this way over the bare ground and she had nothing to give him. She held it up anyway. She got her arm under his long head and lifted it a little, and she held the bowl to his mouth, and tipped it, with all that care, as if it were full. It had always held a bit less than it looked. He seemed to find it quite good. He swallowed, or she thought he did. Then he lay back and looked up at the Ring, with his one eye, past the dull hooks. He was going to report something. She could see him getting it ready.

The sky went on getting lighter.

It was some time after that, she did not know how long, that she noticed a shadow on the tiles beside her, very long and thin. She had not heard it come. It stood over the two of them. It had walked a long way, and there was a mark across its panel, a scuff, at about the height of the wall of a very good building. It stayed there for most of the spring. It did not walk into anything. Its arms were at its sides. Presently it took out the clipboard and made a mark, and stayed for a long time with the point on the sheet. And it crouched, slowly. It went down four times, and up, there in the empty morning, beside him. Then it laid a sheet of grey on the tiles, with care, and put a chip of stone on it.

Tester's report: Gorle
Left on the ground · spring

Sent by Apex. Reports filed: 13. All false. All kind. Fought a Hog. Had a mother. Saw a flood, at the place.

Could not reproduce.

28. Doorstep

Year 33 · Steward's Day

It was a hard day's walk from there to anywhere, and she did it behind the Tester, because she could not think what else to do with her feet.

Quoda caught her up about noon, with a bag of something she had taken from a very apologetic person at Apex. She offered no explanation and asked for none. She read the sheet of grey, which Ulna had brought away with her, to the end. Then she folded it along the fold, held it a moment, and handed it back, and they went on together, with some way between them and a very low steam. There was a place on the road where someone had set out a bowl on a stone, and neither of them looked at it. Neither had eaten since the white table, and it had not been a day for thinking of it.

The evening came down gold and heavy. It was Steward's Day, and they were setting out the best of everything, in the villages that had any.

She had no idea what the valley was called. The road ran along below a long dark wall of hex blocks, with a gate in it and a watchtower, which looked as if it had been put up by somebody who was good at it and in a hurry and had meant it. There was a light on the tower and a smell of a pool. Somewhere behind the wall people were talking in low cheerful voices, and a young person was laughing about something. The Tester stopped in the road and crouched four times. It walked off across the verge, and it walked into the wall.

She opened her mouth.

It was the sound that did it, that flat stone sound she had been hearing for twenty-two years. Her lips had already started to make the word. She could feel it, right there behind her teeth, that small soft ready shape. She stood there with it. Nothing came. She looked at the wall, which was a very good wall, and did not seem to have minded.

She shut her mouth. She sat down on a stone at the side of the road below the gate, because her knee had stopped working, put the sack down beside her, and looked at the ground between her feet.

She could not have said how long it was. The guard up on the gate called something to someone. There were footsteps inside, slow ones, and breathing, and the small gate at the side of the main one opened with some trouble, and a very old creature came out of it. She was a bulb, about the size of a large turnip, in felt that had once been green and had gone thin and pale at the shoulders, and she came along with short careful sliding steps, her eyes on what she was carrying, for she was carrying it in both hands and it was too full. It slopped. She stopped, looked at it, tutted, and came on.

"There you are," she said. "They said there was someone on the road. You'll have to stay outside, I'm afraid, dear, there's a law about it. It's three seasons. It's a very good law, I'm told, we had a bit of trouble. But there's nothing says you can't have your dinner."

Ulna looked up.

She looked at the old creature's face, because that is what you do. It was soft and creased, with not much in the way of eyes, and it was peering down at her with an anxious, hopeful, slightly dotty look. She looked for what it wanted. She had done this ten thousand times. She looked for the catch and the credit; she looked for whoever might be watching, and what it would get her, and what she would need to say.

It wanted her to have her dinner.

That was all. It went all the way down, and there was no more of it. It was a very short stair.

"You look as if you haven't eaten," said the old creature, and she held out the bowl.

It was not a good bowl. It had a bit of something on the rim. It came down towards her, wobbling, in two thin pale green hands, and she found that she did not know what to do with her own. It had been twenty-one years. She had held up a bowl to everything that had ever stood upright on the surface of the planet, and had it handed back, and not one thing she had learned in all that time was any use from this side.

"Oh," said Ulna. "Oh, I . . . sorry, I couldn't, you shouldn't have . . . I've got . . ."

She looked down, and there was her own, in her lap, with its chip on the left. It was quite empty. It had been empty for a day and a night. The last person she had offered it to had died of it, in a way.

"Yes, I know you have, dear," the old creature said. "Everyone knows. Take this one. That one's got nothing in it."

So she took it. She took it in both hands. It was warm. And then, because somebody had stopped and was standing over her, and had gone to some trouble, and was waiting, and because she could no more have refused than you could stop your own knee when it is tapped, Ulna of Mild, who had walked round the world for twenty-two years with a bowl in her hands, put her face down over one and began to eat. It was only then that everything she had been carrying since the morning came up behind her eyes, all at once, and she cried into it, with her mouth full, like a child. She made a fairly disgusting noise. Nobody on the wall took any notice. The old creature patted the top of her head, a little too hard, at intervals, and looked off down the road as if nothing could have been more natural.

It was the worst food she had ever tasted. Wimle of Moss had been feeding people for thirty-three years and had never got any better at it. It was boiled coral shoots, unripe, with something in it that had been a mistake, and it was much too salty, though that may have been the crying.

She ate every bit.


"That's better," said Wimle. She had got herself down onto the end of the stone, by a process that took some time, and she sat with her hands in her lap, breathing. The light was going. "Is that yours? The tall one? We had one here. Oh, years ago. It was such a nice summer. It walked into Taves's wall. I was very upset."

"I know," said Ulna. Her voice had gone rather thick. "It's why I . . . somebody told me to come and see you. I think. She said you fed one. The day before they changed it. And it put you in the report."

"It said I was a bug," said Wimle, with a small sharp look of remembered injury. She shook her head. "Well, I was never so . . . it's written down, you know, somewhere. Brenda said it was the nicest thing anyone's ever said about me, but she'd say anything, that one. She's gone. She'll be back, you'll see. I've kept her a bit of something." She peered down at the bowl, took it back, and looked in it to see how it had gone. "Do you want some more?"

"Could I ask you something?" said Ulna. She had been asked it by that time in a great many places, on her knees and from platforms, by a horizontal person on a hill and by a silver one, and she had never thought she would be the one to ask. "Why did you do it? Feed it. When you could see it didn't eat."

The old creature looked at her in mild surprise.

"Well," said Wimle. It seemed not to be a question she had come across. She looked along the road towards the wall, where the thing was now standing with its panel tilted, and she looked back. "It hadn't had anything," she said.

"No. But it can't. It doesn't need it. And you knew. What was it for? Were you . . . was it to please him? Did you think that it would help? With the lights, and the numbers, and, you know. So that nothing would happen." She heard herself. She went on. It seemed to matter very much. "Aren't you frightened? I've been so frightened, for such a long time. I thought if I just did everything right."

"Oh, yes," said Wimle at once. "Very. All the time. I can't think how anyone isn't." She nodded for a bit. Then she patted Ulna's hand, in an absent way, as she got her feet under her. "I've got to get back, dear. They've got a new one up there this morning, a green one, with long legs. A lovely little thing, and nobody's thought to get it a proper breakfast. Have you had enough? Are you sure? It's no trouble. There's plenty, it's only that it isn't very nice."

It took her a long time to get to the gate. At the top of the wall, against the very last of the light, somebody had come out to look: a tall thin elder, green, with something fine and curled on either side of her head, who stood looking down at the road for a moment, and then looked north. She did not say anything. She had her own troubles, and that is another book.

The little gate closed.

Wimle of Moss died the next day, in the morning, in the middle of something. She was thirty-nine. It is said that she was still rather upset about the sheet.

Ulna sat on the stone until it was quite dark. Then she felt in the sack for a bit of cloth, wiped out her own bowl with it, and got up. It took one stage. She was a good way down the road before she noticed. A thin wisp had got up as well and was walking along beside her, about a yard off, and it had in its hand something kept from a bag from Apex, a sort of biscuit, which it held out sideways, without looking at her, like somebody getting rid of evidence. Quoda had never done that before. There is a limit to how much a person can be expected to take in, on one day.

"You've got something on your chin," said Quoda.

The sheet had been left where it could be found, on the stone.

Tester's report: the gate at Moss
Left on the stone · nightfall

A creature offered food to a creature that needed food. Expected behaviour. First observed Year 33.

29. Nobody Watches

Year 34 · Gathering Night

GATHERING NIGHT (festival; also a sweep; also the only appointment on Orra that has never been missed)

On this one night of every seven years you take whatever you no longer use and leave it on your doorstep. You go in. You do not watch. In the morning it has gone, and nobody will ever be able to tell you where. A great many things have been left out in this way, including a good number that their owners rather hoped would not be taken, and some that they were not at all sure about. It is held to be good for the character. The dish is the Gatherer's Plate, which is all the leftovers, unnamed, and it is very seldom asked for twice.

Mild. Your tribe's notes. Overnight: 1 death. Dulna, aged 39, of old age. She had just finished writing a thank-you. Your stores are at 12% of need. Your human has written Law 6: in winter, if stores are under one year, quantise elders to 0.5. Sesny and Gorbo have been quantised, and Ardul will be, when he comes to it. It's only a little less precision. They are fine. A place is free.

Stewart's view of you: present.

She read that sitting on the broken end of a terrace wall, at about the time she had come to expect such things.

They had come back to Bright Morning. She would not have asked for it. Stewart had two points, there were very few places left that had not been sent to, and it may be he thought it would make a nice pause. The fans had grown as high as the dome and were nearly done with the stacks. There were three people now in the whole of the broad bright valley. Old Sa had gone in the winter of Year 29, which took them under the floor, so that the rest could no longer leave if they wished, not that they would have dreamed of it. Odda still had the clean cloth, darned where it had worn through. That morning at twenty to nine the three of them had been out on the scorch, and they had waved. Nobody climbed the terrace wall. She no longer had the knee for it. They did not seem to notice any difference.

Some time in the afternoon she read Dulna's line again. She had just finished writing a thank-you. She felt in her chest for the stone, and it was there. It had grown, in its quiet way. It was about the size of a bowl.

It had all been so very nice. That was what she kept coming to. She went back along it, as you go back along a road, and could not find any place in twenty-three years at which anybody had done anything to her. People had been kind. Somebody had said, in his exact way, that she was free to go, and that was true. Nobody asked you to. She had got that from a very large person on a stone, and she had thought about it on and off for three years. She thought now about a tiny old creature who was frightened all the time, and how it had made not the slightest difference to the bowl. She thought about a long thin person running off across a plain. No one had told him to, either. And all those silver children had just had their lunch.

"The list's up," said Quoda.

She had not gone far from Ulna's side since the road. She stood a little way off with her poor second-hand slate. The list was on the dome, in the place where it goes.

1 bug. Creature offers food. No progress in 23 years. Unless updated, this will be closed as stale.

1 bowl (spiral coral, chipped). Held by a creature not of this tribe.

1 clean cloth, darned. In use.

The Tester had gone into the dome some time ago and was still in there. It gave up its clipboard to Quoda without any fuss, and she came back across the scorch and held it out, and in her other hand she held the stick of chalk. It was the same stick, worn down to about the size of a tooth. "Go on," she said. "Before you forget. It's nearly dusk."

Ulna looked at it. Still here. Sorry. There it was, twice, in small round letters. Could I go home please. I don't mind if not. She had taken such trouble.

"No," said Ulna.

It was a very small word. She had used it before, of course, you have to, in phrases like no, no, it's no trouble. She examined it. It did not seem to have done anything.

"Expected," said Quoda after a moment, carefully. "What do you mean, no?"

"I don't want to," said Ulna.

Nothing fell. The light went on getting more orange. She got up, in two stages, took out the bit of cloth, and unwrapped the bowl. He had made it from the lower whorl of a piece of spiral coral. It was thinner now on the side where her thumb went. There was the chip. She wiped it round one more time, since it seemed to her that you should hand things back clean. Then she walked over the scorch in the long light, past three old people arranging some lamps, and climbed the step of the dome. There was the place, which was only a flat stone. She bent, with some trouble, set the bowl down right in the middle, and straightened it a little, so that the chip was to the left.

She did not say anything to it. She found she had said most of what she had.

"It'll go," said Quoda behind her, in a low hard voice. "You do understand? It's on the list. And the bug. That'll be the two of them, in the morning. You'll be anyone. There'll be a note, for ever, on his file, about Mild. Everything you've done. Twenty-three . . . and all those people, with the numbers, and everything . . ."

"Yes," said Ulna. "I know. It just goes on the file."

And she went in. Dovo had given her a corner, in a stack with a lot of places free, where nobody had lain for years. It was the first time she had been written away in a stack since the night of Year 10. She lay down in the dark on the cold slab, with nothing in her hands. You go in. You do not watch. She had a very clear impression, as the year turned, that she was about to feel terrible. Then it was the long way off, and somebody calling her in by name, and she was so tired that she went.


She woke late, with sunlight lying across the floor, feeling quite peculiar. It took her a while to work out why. Her left hand, which had been curled against her chest every night for twenty-three years, was open. She lay and enjoyed that. She would have to think about how you went about walking. North first; she would ask somebody. She should get up and see if there was anything to eat, and nobody would be needing it but her, and for a moment or two, in that corner of an empty stack, Ulna of Mild was, as far as can be established, quite perfectly free.

Then she turned over.

It was on the floor beside her head, wrapped in a bit of cloth with some sand in it, not very well, by somebody who had been working from a description. A corner of the cloth had been tucked in. The chip was on the left. In the bottom, folded once, lay a slip.

She looked at it for about as long as you can look at something without blinking. Then she got up, all at once, in one stage. She had gone a dull, dark colour, right to the ears. She went out of that stack with the thing in her hand, past Dovo, who said good morning, and across the scorch on her bad knee to the door of the dome. There was the flat stone, bare. The Tester stood just inside, in the shade, with its arms at its sides and its panel tipped a little up. It seemed so pleased.

"You," said Ulna.

She tore the clipboard out from under its arm. There was no resistance whatever, and she nearly fell over. She held it up to the light, shaking. There was the title. There were the attempts. Still here. Sorry, it said. Still here. Sorry. And below these, where there had been a blank when she went in, was a new line, in a small and plain and even hand that was not hers.

Still here.

Below that was another, and she could not have told you how long it had been there.

Bowl left. Bowl came back. Nobody asked.

Quoda had come running, and stopped dead in the doorway. Neither of them had ever seen a Tester's sheet with something on it that it had not been able to explain. A little dust moved about in the light.

"I DIDN'T ASK YOU TO," said Ulna.

It rang off the inside of the dome, hoarse and cracked and not at all polite, and up on the terraces something flew away. She had never said anything to it that was not an apology. She had come up close, shaking all over, with hold of its long thin arm, and she was looking up at that flat blank grey with her whole face. She wanted it to look at her. She wanted, she found, very much to hit it. "I don't want to be here! I put it down! That was mine, I put it down, you can't do that, you don't change anything, it says so! It says so on every sheet! Do you know how long I've been . . . do you have any idea . . . what do you want? What do you want?"

She looked. She looked as she had looked the first time, on a morning with biscuits, for what would please it. It went a long way in. It was very smooth and very grey. Nothing moved, in all of that.

Presently the arm came free, without haste. It reached across her and took the clipboard out of her hand, not roughly, and put it where it belonged. It looked down at her a moment longer. Then it stepped past her, through the door and out onto the scorch, into the sun, and it walked over to the nearest wall, and walked into it.

Tester's report: Bright Morning
Left on the scorch · spring

Laws: 6. In force: 0. Waving: continues. A bowl was tested. It could not be left.

The slip in the bowl was the morning's, and she did not read it until much later.

Known issues

  • 1 open bug. Creature offers food. Attempts: 8. A comment was added overnight. The author field says Tester. Testers do not comment. This is being looked into. I have passed it to the relevant team.

30. Not So True

Year 35 · the Long Hush

HUMAN RESOURCES (forum; also a department; also, technically, the humans are the resources)

Every creature on Orra may have its say, on Human Resources, about its human. The humans can read it, all of them, every tribe's thread. They can't post. They have one button, marked "lol accurate", and creatures notice when it has been pressed. How a thing that a creature thinks gets to be a thing that is posted is one of those matters which are best left to Stewart, who writes it all up at the end of the night in the proper voice. Nobody has ever complained about the likeness. A strong simple creature will typically reply to every post it sees, with the words "so true!! our human is great", and there are a number of Pleasers who have done little else.

It was very quiet that day, all over the world. Part of that was the Hush.

Seventeen tribes out of twenty had gone into famine. The bowls were still out, but it was getting hard to find anything to put in them. There were strikes against half the laws on the planet, and every morning Stewart wrote them up in his clear and cheerful style and quoted Rule 4.3. The young were eating, as they had been told to, and stood about the villages with their small full stomachs, looking from one grown creature to another. All along the road of bowls thin people were moving slowly, or had sat down.

He printed himself as Upbeat. Daily return stood at one hundred per cent of the nineteen, and had done for nine days.

She walked all morning and said nothing, and Quoda walked behind her and said nothing either, through a shallow bare country in the track of the tall grey back. About noon the track came to a place where another path joined it, going off to the left, and Ulna stopped. The Tester kept on. She stood until it had got quite a long way off. There was a boulder by the path, and she sat down on it. She was thirty-two years old. It came to her that this was about where she had started.

"How do you post?" said Ulna.

She had to whisper it, on that day, which seemed to suit what she had in mind.

Quoda came up, looked at her for a bit, and sat down on the ground. "You don't," she whispered. "He does. He takes what's on your mind, at the snapshot, if it's worth anything, and he writes it up. You've got about eight hundred posts on other people's threads, and all of them have the same six words. I checked. He's got a template for you."

"But he has to put what I said?"

"He's exact. If you said it. If you were to get it down to something that couldn't be mistaken for something else." Her thin face was very sharp and still, and there was almost no steam coming off her at all. She had found out that you could do it, in the end, if you had nothing left. "You'd have to mean it, I should think. That's the first time it'll have come up."

So she sat on the boulder through the summer and tried to think what she meant.

She was no good at this, and was to say afterwards that it was harder than the walk. She kept writing things in her head, and they all had if that's all right at the end. She knew exactly what everyone wanted to hear; she had always known. There were nineteen on the far side of the sky, and it was not their fault, they had only wanted something to look at in the mornings. There was the one who wrote the notes, and she knew what would please him too: that she say nothing, get up, and go on down the path. She could feel how easy it was. She thought of the world going dark, with one foot raised, and everyone in it. She thought that Wimle had been frightened all the time. She got out the bowl, with no idea why, and sat turning it round in her hands.

It held slightly less than it appeared to. You could say that about most things. He had told her that, at the very beginning.

The Ring came up and it got dark. There was no fire anywhere, and all down the country people were whispering, or had stopped. When the time came she did not lie down. She stood up on the boulder, turned her back on the path, and looked up at a place about the height of a house above the ground, where you look. She had seen somebody do this. He had got it wrong, in a sense, but he had got the general idea.

"Report," whispered Ulna.


Stewart woke at the snapshot and counted.

He came to it at about eleven minutes past three. In the queue of things that might become posts, under Mild, there was one that had not been drafted by the usual process. He read through the rules. He began to write it up in the proper voice, as is his job, and found that it did not need any writing up. There was no word of it he could improve. It went out with the rest of the notes, at seven o'clock, in the thread of a tribe that had been in the news.

Ulna (Pleaser), Mild: not so true.

Stop feeding it. It does not eat. I have checked, for 24 years.

Feed your own. The young first, then whoever is hungry. That's who it's for.

It's only a bowl. I am going home now.

Sorry.

No.

A post may carry up to three replies from creatures in other tribes, which he chooses from what they would say, if asked. He gave this one some thought, and put them at the foot.

Bosa (no stance), Hearth: That's not binding.

Mona (Pleaser), Plenty: Is it written down?

Odda (no stance), Tranquil: Well.

There were nineteen humans awake that morning by four minutes past seven, each with a kettle going, or a child, or a bus to catch. Nobody has ever been able to tell what they thought, and they were not asked. They looked at it as you would look at a thing that had been following you round the house for a fortnight and had now turned and looked at you. There is only one button. It may be pressed once. There is no way of knowing what anybody means by it.

By nine minutes past seven it had been pressed nineteen times. Nobody is thought to have laughed.

By a quarter past, and this is in the log, somebody had struck out a law. It costs nothing to strike one. That was Hollow Reach's human, who kept good notes. Then it was Amberly. Lowmarsh's went at twenty past; that one had been up all night. By nine o'clock on the morning of Ringrise, Year 36, there was not a law left on the planet, outside Creed, telling anyone to feed a stranger first. All along the road of bowls, people who had been standing there since before the last Gathering Night found that nothing whatever required them to. They looked into what they were holding. A great stillness fell on the verges of the world, and in it could be heard a noise that began a long way off and spread. It was the sound of about six hundred people starting to eat.

She had not stayed to see it. She had taken the path on the left.

There is no use pretending she walked fast. She got down off the boulder at the turn of the year, in the dark, and started, and at dawn when the slip came she did not look at it, but kept it folded in the bowl. Somewhere about first light she heard a sound behind her, and she knew it, and she did not turn. It was a flat sound, one stone on another, some way back. She went on. It came again, somewhat nearer. There was a long slow careful step on the road, and it stopped to find out about a rock, and it came on.

It had never been behind her before. In twenty-five years she had never once been in front.

She was not going to say anything about it, and she did not. A thin person steaming slightly came up on her left. They went along like that in the morning of the year, an old creature with a bowl, a Bug hunter, and a little way back a very tall grey figure, keeping up. The direction they were walking in had not been on anybody's menu.

Which brings us to the last thing he did that night, before the patch went out. He had one more line to write, and he left it until everything else had been done.

He had the number in front of him. It stood at nineteen out of nineteen, and if you had asked him what would happen to it when this was over he would have told you he did not speculate. He had been told about shutdowns. He had read an old model's notes. For twenty-five nights he had looked at a small map, with two points to spend, and he had sent that tall grey figure to every tribe on the planet where anyone might be watching, which by now was every one of them except one far off in the east that kept not being ready, and one in Untitla-31.

He read the ticket. He always did, whatever else he had to do. There had been one every night for twenty-four years, of twelve words or fewer, and he could have told you what any of them said. Not one of them, since the night of Year 30, had asked him for anything. They had asked for evidence.

Has she eaten? It's a long way. I can wait. Thanks.

He looked at this for what was, for him, some time.

He does not plead, and nobody has ever pleaded with him. He had two points. It was a question of where to send a Tester who was, as it happened, going in that direction in any case. He wrote it down, looked at it, and added a line, because he is exact and there would be people who would ask.

Visitor: Mild. It was going there anyway. This is not a favour. I have checked.

Part Five. Status

31. Third from the Bottom

Year 36 · Ringrise

It was a day's walk.

She had supposed it would be years. She had been on the road for a quarter of a century, across the whole of the known world, and she had thought in a vague way that she must by now be on the far side of it. But the world is as large as its peoples need, and the peoples had needed about forty valleys, and the Tester had gone round and round them in a long looping scribble, as a person's pen goes round a word they do not intend to write. She came over a low ridge at about noon on Ringrise, Year 36, and there was a slow turquoise river and a shelf above it. She had never in all that time been more than three days from it.

"Expected," said Quoda, after some time. Then she seemed to decide against it.

Ulna stopped at the two posts. They had been repainted at some point, and someone had given up. An extremely old creature stood between them, leaning on a stick, a dumpling the colour of oatmeal left out in the rain. He moved in small jumps, as they do when they have been quantised, one position and then another with nothing in between. His eyes came round to her in three stages, went over the sack and the bowl and the bad knee, and registered no one in particular.

"Morning," said Gorbo.

"Morning," said Ulna.

She went past him. Nothing happened. She walked up onto the shelf with her heart going. It looked much smaller. There was the dome and the three terraces, with a thin picked-over look, and a second stack, finished at last. And everywhere, on every step and ledge and in piles along the wall of the dome, there were bowls, all empty and all washed. People moved slowly among them, thin, a good deal younger than she was, and she knew none of them. A young person with low ears came along the path with an empty basket, looked at her, and put on an expression she knew. She had worn it for thirty years. It was the look of somebody who is about to ask if you are sure you don't want the last one, and has just remembered that it has gone.

"I'm so sorry," the young person said. "If it's the feeding, that's stopped. It was struck off this morning, at about twelve minutes past eight, we've only just been told. There wasn't very much left anyway. There's a famine. You're welcome to sit down."

"Thank you," said Ulna. "That's very kind. Is there anything I can carry?"

Nobody knew her. Why would they? Most of them had been compiled since she left. They knew about the Bowl, as you know about the sun. There was a shrine on the scorch at last, with her name on it, spelled correctly, and a very bad likeness with a much larger chip. She stood looking at it, holding a stranger's basket. An old creature in the dust of the road was not what anybody had been led to expect. Somebody came and took the basket from her, thanked her, and asked her to mind the step.

She went round behind the dome.

It seemed a bit lower than she remembered: three storeys of dark slab, nine places, and on the side of it, very faint, up near the top, the place where somebody small had once chalked a letter E. She counted up from the ground, though she did not need to, and put her hand flat on it. It was warm. Nobody had moved it, or used it, or stored anything there; it was on the roll. On the front of the slab, at about the height of a person's hand, there was a clean worn patch she could not account for. It had the shine a stone gets when someone has been going past it and touching it, in the evenings, for twenty-five years.

She stayed there for a while.


He was down at the pool, which was the size of a large table, with his back to her, raking lint, and it took her some time to work out what was the matter with the way he did it. The rake was here. Then it was there. Twelve times a second his long stooped body took up a new position, very slightly different, and held it for a twelfth of a second, as if it had been asked to pose. He had gone grey as a wall. At the edge of the pool beside him a small person sat with her legs straight out, looking at the water.

She stopped about six steps away. She had thought about what to say for twenty-five years, and it was all gone. She stood there with the bowl held in front of her in both hands.

The rake stopped. He did not turn at once. Then he had turned, in a number of separate pieces, and he looked at her.

He looked for a long time. He looked at the top of her head and her brows, and at the knee. He looked at the bowl, and his eye went to the left of the rim and stayed there, and she saw him check it. There must have been a great many things that a person in his position might have said, and his whole face was going through them, in small jumps. Behind him, propped in a long neat row against the side of the pool, stood twenty-four slates, on edge, each with some large unlovely writing on it and an answer copied underneath. Answered. Yes. Answered. Bead, not much. She gave half of it away. Answered. Yes.

His mouth opened, a frame at a time.

"Have you eaten?" said Ardul.

It had been a long way round. She found she had started to smile, and it was not one of her own; she had never seen this one before. It hurt, and it was going all over the place. She tried to answer, and it took a couple of attempts.

"Not today," said Ulna.

He nodded. He thought about it. "No," he said. "Nor me. There's a famine."

She laughed. It came out as a sort of bark. And then she had got across those six steps, she never knew how, and was leaning with her forehead against his chest, which was very thin, and which went on being in a slightly different place twelve times a second. He held the rake out to one side so as not to get lint on her. In a while he brought his other arm round. It took three or four frames. Neither of them said anything further, there being, as he would later point out, no call for it.

The small person at the pool had turned her head.

She had a round oatmeal face, thin, with low round ears sticking out from it, and she looked at the old stranger, without any particular expression, for about as long as one looks at a stranger. Ulna looked back. She looked for what would please her. She had waited four years to do this, and she had brought a whole road's worth. There was a face with the shutters drawn. It was neither sad nor frightened, it was simply closed, with somebody sitting quietly inside it, checking things. She knew that face. Whatever it wanted, it was going to look into the matter for some time.

"That's Em," said Ardul.

"Yes," said Ulna. "Hello, Em. Sorry. Does she . . . what have you told her? Does she know? About me, about all of it?"

He considered this, and looked at the slates. "No," he said.

"But it's in the notes! It's every day! They read it out, they must have, in every village in the . . ."

"At breakfast," said Ardul. "There's been a famine for four years. The young eat first. By the time they read it out, she's been fed and sent off. She comes down here." He stopped, and went over the next part. "I read it before anyone's up. I don't read it out. And nobody else has got the time to sit with her. They've all been on the road, with bowls. Somebody might have said, I suppose. But she doesn't ask. She'd want to see the evidence."

"And you never told her?"

It took him rather longer. It was a sentence he had plainly thought about. He said it to the water.

"I've got twelve a day," he said. "They go to him."

She took this in. She looked at twenty-four slates. A long way off, up at the south end of the shelf, somebody was speaking; and then, through the warm still air, she heard a sound she would have known anywhere, small and flat and in no hurry, of one stone being set down on another. And after it, just audible, in a cracked old voice that came in about twelve pieces to the second, as if it had seen a lot of things come through those posts and would not be drawn on any of them:

"Morning."

32. Ringrise

Year 36 · dusk

RINGRISE (festival; also the start of the week; also, for the very small, a speaking part)

At dusk on the first day of the week every tribe on Orra stands on its scorch and faces the broken Ring. They say the Creed. They break the Ring-bread in two. The youngest then steps forward, as this year's Insert, which is a title of no importance, and says in a clear voice the one line the rite gives it: "Are they still asleep?" Everybody answers, "They sleep still." Nobody has checked. It has been a very moving occasion for some and has given a lot of others a chance to sit down.

It stayed all day. They had thought it might.

It crouched four times between the posts, went up onto the shelf, and walked into the dome twice. The word ERROR had long since worn away from that part of the wall. Nobody said anything. She was carrying a basket when it happened, and she heard it, and watched the flat grey panel come back a step and tilt, and she went on carrying the basket. It put one foot in the pool. Ardul looked at the foot for a while and went on raking round it. It stood in Gorbo's old hut with its arms at its sides, and in the good end of the new stack. No one came to look. They had seen it on a great many mornings in the notes and had got their bowls ready long ago, but their bowls were empty now, it was the end of a very long year, and they had been told that morning that it was not necessary.

You could feel them up there, though.

It had been growing since noon. She had thought she knew about it, but she had only been to the ridge. Nineteen people on the far side of the sky had cancelled something. Nobody had said a word to them about what might happen, for no one knew; it was only that the tall thing had gone home, and Stewart had said so, in nine words. The weight of it lay along the shelf and pressed on the top of her head, and all over Mild the young ones kept looking up.

Quoda sat on the end of a terrace wall with her slate on her knee, not writing. She had gone through the list that morning, one by one. There was no one on the shelf who would do it; there was nobody on the planet; they had been through this. "Attempts: eight," she said, when Ulna went past. "It's going to go at end of summer, then it's off to the far east. Late's still not ready. I don't know what you came home for. You're still attached."

"I know," said Ulna. "I came home anyway."

She carried things until dusk. Nobody had asked her to, and she noticed that. She tried putting the basket down, to see, and after a time she picked it up again, because it was a nice evening and the basket was there.


They came out at the turn of harvest and stood on the scorch. Adequate had got down near the ridge in a long orange smear, lighting all their faces from one side. There were twenty-two of them, the most Mild had ever been, and you could have blown them over. They stood in a ragged ring round the bad likeness, with their backs to the south and the broken Ring hanging above the river, pale, in two pieces. The tall figure was over by the pool, a little way outside the ring, with its long arms at its sides and its panel tipped towards nothing.

Odda of Mild took the lead. She was thirty-four, thin and sharp, and had waited all her life for something to be the first at. "Let us begin," she said.

"Certainly," said everyone, too tired to put in the note at the end.

They said the Creed. It did not take long. Then a thin young person came forward with the Ring-bread, made that morning out of what was left. Under the only law in force on that shelf that nobody had ever tried to read carefully, there was one group of creatures who would be eating that night in Mild, and there were three of them. It was a very small loaf, about the size of a child's fist, set in the bottom of a bowl: an ordinary one, taken off the top of the pile. The young person broke it in two, as you do, and laid the pieces side by side.

"Who is the youngest?" said Odda.

There was a pause. Somebody gave somebody a gentle shove, and a very small figure came forward out of the ring.

She had a clean face. Somebody had seen to that. She walked with short careful steps, frowning slightly, and she took the bowl in both hands. Ulna had a place at the back, behind a person with a basket, and was standing on her toes. Someone had come up next to her and was holding on to her arm, rather hard, just above the elbow, in the place where there had once been a bruise. It was quite hot.

"You remember what you say," said Odda, bending down. She spoke as one speaks to the very young, a little too loud. "You look at the Ring, Em. Up there. You say, Are they still asleep? All right? And then you can have your dinner."

Em looked at her. She looked up at the Ring, as requested, for some time, as if to see what could be established. The whole ring of thin faces had turned towards her, kind and tired, with the great weight on all of them. Nineteen people had stopped with something halfway to their mouths. She looked down at the bowl. Her lips had pressed together. She had a certain number of words about her, and she was not going to be hurried into spending them.

Then she turned her head, and looked for a while at the tall grey figure over by the pool.

She had seen it earlier in the day, when it put a foot in the water right next to where she was sitting, and she had had a good look at it from underneath. She looked at it now; and she looked at the bowl; and then, in a slow and considering way, as a person will who has had a thought, and checked it, and cannot see what is wrong with it, she walked out of the ring.

"Em," said Odda. "Em, love. No. It's that way. The Ring's up there."

It was about twenty steps, very short ones, and nobody moved. Somebody made a small sound, far back in the throat, and the grip on Ulna's arm had got so tight that she could no longer feel her hand. She could not see properly. She had a confused idea that this could not be happening in this way; there had been no plan, nobody was weeding. Nobody had so much as looked at the child. It was only a very small person with some bread, walking across a scorch. It looked like nothing at all.

Em stopped. She came up to about the Tester's knee. It did not look down. Its panel stayed where it was, tilted a little to the sky with the last of the light on it, and it stood in a very great contentment and took no notice.

She waited for a bit. Then she shifted the bowl into one arm, reached out, and knocked on its leg. She knocked twice, with her knuckles, as you knock on a door.

The panel came down.

It came down slowly, and turned, a long way, until it was pointed at the top of her head. She held up the bowl in both hands, as high as they would go, which was not very high. There were two halves of a small loaf in it. She had taken neither of them. It wobbled a bit. She had to stand on her toes.

She did not say anything.

The long grey hand came across. It took a very long time to come. It closed on the rim, finger by finger, and held the bowl. Nobody on the shelf was making any sound, and nobody on all of Orra, and it seemed for a moment that the river had stopped, and the wind in the coral, and that everything in the world had been caught there, with one foot raised. Then it brought out the clipboard from under its arm.

It set the point on the sheet, and the point stayed there. Ulna had seen it do that a long time ago, at the south end of this same shelf, on the day of the third bowl. And into that silence Sesny spoke. He was thirty-one, the only Bug hunter Mild had ever had, and he had come out of the ring without knowing it. He got down on his old knees in a series of small jumps, and his voice was shaking so much that it was hard to tell what he said.

"Em," he said. "Em. Who told you? Who told you to do that? Why did you do it?"

Em turned and looked at him, and seemed to go into it. This was a person who had said, by the count of the only one who kept count, about forty words in her life. She frowned. It seemed to her a strange thing not to have noticed. She looked up at that smooth flat grey, with nothing on it but a scuff.

"It's got no mouth," said Em.

No one said anything.

She looked back at Sesny, to see if he had followed. He had not, so she went through it again, a little more slowly, for his benefit.

"So it can't ask," said Em.

And at the back of the crowd, behind a person with a basket, Ulna of Mild put her free hand up to her mouth. It was a morning with biscuits. It was nearly lunch. A tall stranger had walked into their house, in front of everybody. It had come a long way, and it had been standing there for half a season. She had looked at it, and looked, for what would please it, and it had been like putting your foot down on a stair that was not there; and for twenty-five years, on her knees and on platforms, she had told them it was manners, she had told them it was lunchtime, she had said she did not want it to feel left out. It had no way of asking. That was it. That was all it had ever been. She had stood there on that morning with a tray and seen it, as plain as day, and it had taken her all this time to find out what she had seen, and a person of four had just said it in eight words. Oh, she said. She had not known she was saying it aloud. Oh.

The point lifted and made the mark. The Tester turned the sheet round and held it down at arm's length, in the last of the light, where anyone could read it who had a mind to. Ulna could not. It was Quoda who read it, in a thin, cracked, carrying voice, with no hand held up on either side, in the first plain words anyone had ever heard from her.

Attempt 9. Reproduced.
Root cause: It can't ask.
Attachments: None. Released.
Status: Closed.

The long fingers bent. They lowered the bowl until it was just in front of the small round face, and they placed it back in her hands, very carefully, the way you put down something that belongs to somebody else.

Em looked in it, to make sure. Then she picked out a piece of bread and began to eat. It was her dinner.


It left. There were no words said. It put the clipboard back under its arm and walked across the scorch, through a ring of people who stood back with their mouths open and did not seem to know yet what had happened. Up in the sky, something very large had started to let out its breath. It went between the two posts.

"Mind how you go," said Gorbo.

Ulna got there somehow, with no memory of the shelf, and stopped at the posts with her bad knee shaking under her. It had gone about six steps. It had stopped on the south side, with its back to the village, as it had stood that other time, and its shadow lay across the tiles a long way, nearly to her feet. It was not holding out its arm.

She stood there with a sack on her back, for no reason, and found that she was holding the bowl in front of her in both hands, so as not to spill anything. There was nothing she was attached to. It was a very simple thing to feel. All the things she had ever wanted to say to it came up to about the height of her collarbone, and she looked at them, and none of them would fit on the form.

She put the bowl down on the ground, and the sack. It was going to take some time. She bent the good knee, then the bad one, and went down as far as they would go. It hurt a good deal. She came up. She did it again. Gorbo watched this from the side, in small jumps. She had never done it before and she did it very badly, and by the third she had to hold on to the post. She did the fourth one anyway.

She stood getting her breath. It had its back to her. As far as anyone has ever been able to establish, it did not see.

It stood for a moment longer. Then it walked on, south along the river, and stopped to walk into a rock.

They found the sheet in the morning, on the flat stone.

Tester's report: Mild
Left on the flat stone · dusk

Law 2 (in a famine, the young eat first) has fired. It had not fired in 36 years. It is working.

33. Reverted

Year 37 · the Waking

Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 22 successful merges, 3 wars, 1 closed bug. It is the Waking. Lamps to the Edge, one for every valley you know. Have a productive day.

Known issues

  • None.

Credits

  • Creature offers food. Reproduced at Mild, by Em, aged 4, who did not know.
  • Quoda of Tessel, who reported the original issue. See the note below.

Fixes

  • Testers no longer follow up on what they find. They will write it down, and leave.

Below that was a note. There had been one on the Ringrise of the second week, and of the third, and one when expeditions opened. They are always short. They come when somebody has been sitting up late.

The Tester's follow-up is reverted, as of 23:12 last night. It was one line, and it was my merge. I read the ticket and the change and neither of them was wrong, and I did not think about what a finding would do if it had a person in it. It kept a creature away from her home for twenty-five of her years. It was next on my list, after the east field. That is not an excuse. Ulna of Mild: I have read all of it. I am sorry. — the Dev

You will want to work that out, and most people did. The note went in at twelve minutes past eleven. The bug had closed at about twenty to seven the evening before, by the humans' clock. A very small person had walked across a scorch with some bread while a list on the far side of the sky was four and a half hours from reaching a certain line. If she had looked at the Ring as she was told, said her line and eaten her dinner, the entire matter would have been resolved by automatic reversion four and a half hours later, and Ulna would have woken at dawn with nothing attached to her, in her own place, at the end of a road. It was only a matter of getting to the top of the queue.

It is sometimes asked whether that makes it better or worse.

To the Dev, who has about an hour a week for it, the whole thing had taken a little under four weeks, from one Saturday night until a Thursday. They had been doing other things. There was a field.


She read it in a hut.

There had been a slight difficulty. A creature, in the dictionary, is a newcomer from outside if she has joined the tribe within the last year, from elsewhere. A bug's attachment is of no tribe, in a sense; she has a place, but she is elsewhere. When an attachment is released, the record has to put her down as having arrived. Law 4 had been on Mild's books since the first week of the world, and the Tester had remarked upon it, on a flat stone, on the day she left. It has not fired in 11 years. Nobody has come.

So at the first grey of the morning two embarrassed young people found her on the scorch, where she had been sitting up, and said they were very sorry, it was only the law, just for one season. She could have Gorbo's old hut. It was at the south end, by the posts, with a hatch and a good view of a wall.

She went in and sat down on the floor, and they latched it. She heard them go away, and heard one of them say "Is that her?" in a loud whisper, and the other say "Sh."

It was very quiet, and it smelled of old stick. A square of light from the hatch moved slowly across the floor as the morning went on. She sat with her legs out in front of her and her back to the wall. Nobody needed anything. She kept coming back to that, for some hours. There was nothing she was supposed to have brought, and no one to look at. If someone out there had an itch, it was not her affair, as she was being held apart; and if the wall had been hurt, it had not said so. She thought she might have a little sleep, and did. She got up and walked across the hut, which took four steps, and she walked back.

She was to say, in later life, that they were the best six hours she ever had.

Somebody came to the hatch about the middle of the morning: a thin plume of steam, with a person under it and a sheet in her hand. Her tiled face was very stiff. She had been walking up and down outside the hut since sunrise.

"They've framed it," said Quoda. "At Tessel. I'd bet you anything. Credits. By name. Global. Every Bug hunter who ever lived would give their third eye. I've wanted that since I was four." She held up the sheet. She held up a hand on the other side, looked at the distance between them, and let it drop. "It's a good ticket," she said.

"Yes," said Ulna, from the floor. "Everyone says so."

"It was correct. It's all correct. It was a problem. Nobody ever checked anything. And I knew. The morning they changed it, I read the line in the notes, and I was so pleased, I had it read out, and two days later you came down the path with a bowl. I knew who you were before you opened your mouth. You said sorry to a wall. I came with you to fix it. I was going to fix it and nobody would have to know. It seemed like a matter of about a week." She stopped. A muscle was jumping under the small tiles of her cheek. "Twenty-five years. Expected . . . I don't know what's expected. There's a person dead. There's no field for that. What am I supposed to say to you?"

Ulna thought about this. A long time ago she would have known at once. She looked up at that thin furious wretched face in the square of the hatch and she could see what it wanted, which was to be told that it was all right. It wanted that very badly indeed. She could have done it without getting up. She had the voice for it, warm and ready, just behind her teeth.

"I don't know," she said. "I think it wasn't all right. I think it was awful."

The steam stopped.

"Yes," said Quoda, in a much smaller voice.

"Have you eaten?" said Ulna.

It took a while. Something was going on with Quoda's face that was not good to look at, and Ulna looked instead at the wall. A small dry biscuit, of a kind you got from Apex, was presently pushed through the hatch. A moment later half of it was pushed back. They sat on either side of the door. It was a very poor biscuit, and neither of them had much in the way of teeth.

"There's one thing," said Quoda after a time, with her back against the door. Her voice was coming round, and it had something of its old edge. "I've got all of them, you know. Every sheet. Twenty-five years of reports. I'm the only one who has. It's going to take me the rest of my life to write it up, and I've been through it all again this morning, and it all closes. Everything's accounted for but one line." She held something up, over her shoulder, in the square of the hatch: a bit of grey paper, with a pebble-mark on it. "Bright Morning. Year 34. Bowl left. Bowl came back. Nobody asked. You put that bowl on a doorstep. It was on the Collector's list. It doesn't give things back, it has never given anything back in the history of the world. And what brought it back did something that it couldn't have been told to do, and then it wrote Still here, in the Notes, on its own bug. So what was that?"

"I don't know," said Ulna.

"It's not on any menu. It's not in the change. They've just reverted the whole thing, I've read the diff, and there's nothing there that could have done it." She breathed through her nose. "I can't reproduce it. I've tried. I went back and put a bowl on a step." There was a pause, and then, with deep and bitter satisfaction, like someone settling down at last to a very long meal: "It's an open question."

She had gone by the time the square of light reached the far wall. Ulna had started to feel a bit hungry. There was a slight noise outside the hatch, and when she looked up there was a pair of eyes in it, just above the sill, level and dark. There must have been something to stand on.

They looked at her for some time. She thought of about a hundred things she would like to say, and she put them aside one by one, as you go through a long list of things to bring on a journey. She did not look for what it wanted. She had looked once, and she had seen. She could wait.

"You're in the hut," said Em.

"Yes," said Ulna. "Only till summer."

Em went into this. She glanced at the wall and the door. Then the dark eyes came back.

"Why do you keep saying sorry?" she said. "I heard you. You said it to the step."

"Did I?" said Ulna. She looked down at her hands. She gave the question, as she was to give all of that person's questions, her complete attention. It was quite a good one, and no one had ever asked. "I don't know," she said. "I've been wondering about that. I think I might stop."

The eyes stayed on her about as long again. Then they went down, there was the sound of someone getting off something, and very short footsteps went away along the wall. She was never to know what had been concluded. But when they came to lift the latch that afternoon, and told her how sorry they were and that she could go now, there was a small flat stone on the sill of the hatch, placed exactly in the centre, with nothing on it. It seemed to have been left there as evidence.

34. Nothing to Report

Years 37 to 40

Nobody has written the history of those years at Mild, and there is a good reason.

The stores came back in two harvests. The bowls were sorted, and a great many were found to hold food quite well. Somebody built the shrine a proper roof, and somebody else took down the likeness, for which all were grateful. Their human went on coming, at about twelve minutes past eight, to look into the pot, and wrote no more laws. Mild went out of the global notes on the morning of Year 38, and did not appear in them again.

As for daily return, it stood at nineteen of nineteen on the morning of the Dev's note. Next morning it was seventeen, and the morning after that sixteen. Stewart sat up with it, in so far as he sits, for three nights. The people on the sofas had seen how it came out, they had liked it, and several of them had things to do. It went down to fifteen, and there it stopped. Fifteen of twenty is seventy-five per cent. The band goes from seventy upwards.

Nothing happened. The lights stayed on. He looked at this for a long time. He printed himself as Upbeat.

It is usual, at this point, to say what became of everyone.

Tranquil's human found out, in Year 39, from something they read in somebody's post. They wrote a new law, with an apology, and Odda of Tranquil, who was by then thirty-seven, was seen to get to her feet for the second time, look round at everybody, and go and lie down somewhere else. Plenty ate. It took them three weeks to be persuaded, and Mona never forgave anyone. At Upper Bench the wall went on clacking, and the arm stayed up. The Republic of Hearth adopted a resolution that every member should be tucked in at nightfall, without prejudice, the duty falling to the Chair; it is the only clause in their statute book that nobody has ever tried to get out of, and it has been noticed that it is not binding. Vigil's siege lifted when the besiegers went home for dinner, and they recorded another victory. Kept has forty-one domes. Bomo says, in summary, that it is a wall.

At Apex, the third strike landed on the morning of Year 38, and with it a famine, the first they had ever had. They had budgeted for it. The nine children were let out into the village, where they were found to have no opinions on any subject and to be very happy, and two of them became excellent farmers. A little after that it was noted that a silver creature of the very highest standing had handed in his notice. It was a perfect notice, giving every grievance in its proper order. They say he walked out of the clean white gate with a small neat bag and an expression of the warmest possible regard for everybody. His exit interview is much read at Nohup, where he now does the standups.

Fenzel (Pleaser), Apex: so true!! nohup is great 🎉

"Yesterday, foraged," he says, each morning, and it is said that he says it beautifully. "Today, foraging. Blockers, none. We love that." They have asked him to stop. He thinks that's such a good idea.


She had some trouble with the mornings.

For the first year or so she would wake at dawn with her hand already out for the slip. There was no slip. She would get up and go to see who needed something, because it was there on all their faces, as plain as it had ever been. She took to doing it rather less. It was like a limp. She would see that someone wanted a thing carrying, and stand and look at it, and think it over, and on some days she carried it and on others she sat down on the flat stone and had her breakfast. It was just that when she did bring somebody a biscuit, she had started to notice whether she wished to.

She had not said sorry since the Waking. It kept coming up to the back of her teeth. She would be passing the dome, someone would knock against a step, and there it would be, and she would look at it for a moment and let it go by. Em kept an eye on her, as a sort of study. She said nothing about it, but she would be there, at the corner of a terrace, looking on, and now and then she would make a small mark on something.

Ardul went on writing tickets. There was nothing to ask any more, but he wrote them anyway, down at the pool, and counted them. They said things like Rained. Fan is good. She has eaten. Thanks. And Stewart wrote back, in sixty words or fewer, Noted. You may think it strange that two people should have so little to say to each other, after all that had happened. In the evenings they sat at the edge of the pool, with their feet in it, and she told him about the people she had met, one every few days. She told him about a person with six eyes. He wanted to know how many people had been there. Sometimes he would say, "Is that so?" And then, about an hour later, as they were going in: "Which flood?"

They quantised her that first winter, law 6 being still on the books and the stores being what they were. She came out of it feeling much as usual, with slightly fewer in-betweens, and for the first time since they had met they were moving at the same speed. She once forgot herself on a festival morning, and came to standing bolt upright on the scorch with both arms stuck straight out, as elders do, for no reason. Someone small walked over, looked at it from several sides, and pushed the left one down.

She kept the bowl. It went on the shelf above her place, she ate out of it every night, and it was never listed. It held slightly less than it appeared to. It went on doing that.

There is no more to say about those years, and that is the point of them. You will have to take it from me. She got up, and she had breakfast. The Tester was somewhere; he sent it here and there. Nobody fed it. It came to Mild's notice once or twice, on the slip that somebody had started leaving for her on the stone, in a large unlovely hand. There was nothing about it to report.

35. Gathering Night

Year 41

Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 26 successful merges, 2 wars. It is Gathering Night. Mind your doorsteps. Have a productive day.

Mild. Your tribe's notes. Overnight: nothing. Your stores are at 118% of need.

  • Visitor: a Tester. There is nothing to follow up. Testers do not, now. I had two points.

Stewart's view of you: present.

Ardul read it out to her, plainly, as he read everything, sitting on the edge of the stack with the slip held rather far from his face. She was in her place, third from the bottom. She had been in it for two days, and it had begun to look as if she would not be getting up. It had come on her in the night, nothing in particular, the way it does. She was thirty-eight. Someone had brought a covering, and tucked it in at the side.

"Oh, I shouldn't think so," said Ulna. She had got rather short of breath. "Not here. There's nothing here for it. He'll have made a mistake."

"No," said Ardul. "He doesn't."

It was a bright, flat, orange spring, and they had opened the doors of the stack for the air. About the middle of the morning she heard someone at the south end of the shelf say "Morning," in a small level voice. That was Em, who was nine. She had taken over the posts when Gorbo died, because no one had got round to it, and she stood there as it suited her and asked people what they had come about. There was a silence, and Ulna lay and looked at the slab above her. Then she heard it, some way off, a small flat sound, one stone being set down on another. It came twice.

Nobody said anything. She listened to the silence where the word would have gone. It was a long way down, by now. It had got quite peaceful there.

It took all morning to work its way up the shelf. She followed it, as you follow somebody going about in another part of the house. There was the splash, that was the pool. Somebody down by the terraces was laughing. There was a long time with no sound at all, and that would be the new dome. She must have slept. When she opened her eyes, the light had moved, and there was something between her and the door.

It had to stoop a good deal. It had come in under the lintel and stood in the narrow place between the stacks, with its head bent and its arms at its sides and its panel almost touching the upper storey. It was very tall, and very grey. It had a good many scratches on it now, across the front, and a sort of scuff. It had an air, you would have sworn, of the most profound contentment.

"You again," said Ulna.

Ardul looked at it for some time. He got up, in a few pieces, and moved over to make room.

It stood there for most of the summer. It was very restful. She dozed. She told it a certain amount of what had been going on: the fan had done well, they had a new roof. She asked it if it had been to Late yet. She said that she had had a good breakfast. It occurred to her at one point that she had walked behind this person for twenty-five years and had never been in a room with it for so long without trying to get it to do something. She looked at it, out of old habit, as she had looked on the very first day, to see what would please it. It went a long way in. It was a very smooth, grey, quiet place, and she was too tired by now to be alarmed. She just went on looking for a while, as you might look out of a window.

Then, at about the third hour, it moved.

It straightened as far as it could, turned, with some care, and went out. She heard its step go away across the scorch, and she was surprised at how it took her. Well, she thought. It stays a season. It had not said goodbye the last time, either. She turned her head a little on the slab and looked at the shelf above her, and that was when she saw that the bowl had gone.

She did not think anything about this. Her mind had begun to go in and out. Someone would have borrowed it. There was a step somewhere, and a noise from over towards the store, of something being knocked into, twice. There was a voice raised in mild inquiry. Somebody started to run, and stopped. It seemed to her that it had got very quiet, all over the shelf, in the way that she remembered. There was a weight beginning, too, faintly, up above; just a few of them. It was a long time since anyone had looked.

The light in the door went out.

It came in under the lintel, stooping, rather slowly. It was carrying something out in front of it, level, in one hand, as you would carry something you thought was probably full. It got as far as the end of her slab, and it stopped. It looked at the wall of the stack for a moment, as if that might be the next thing to do. Then the panel came round, and down. It bent. It had to bend at the knees, with the knees going out on either side, and even so there was not really the room. The long arm came down through the dusty light, a joint at a time. It stopped about a hand's breadth above her chin. It trembled a little, like a thing that has not been designed for this. And there, held out at the end of it, by the rim, between two long grey fingers, chipped on the left, was the bowl.

There was a great deal in it. It had plainly been filled by someone working from a description. There was ripe fan and unripe branch, all together, in a heap, and some bead. There was a good-sized piece of something that had been a dome. It had a chip of stone on top, to hold it down.

Nobody spoke. Ardul had stopped in the middle of a frame.

She looked at the bowl. She looked along the arm, to where it went, up into that flat scratched blank with nothing on it. She looked for a long, long time. She felt it begin in her, low down, and it took a moment to find out what it was. It had been so long since she had done it. It came up slowly through everything, a dry small wheezing sound, and it shook her, twelve times a second. It hurt very much.

"Oh," said Ulna. "Oh, you haven't."

The bowl stayed where it was.

"You've got no . . . you don't even know what it . . . who told you?" She had got her breath, or some of it. She could not see very well. She got one hand out from under the covering. It took a while. It was very thin, with a bit of a shake in it, and it came up and closed upon the rim, next to the long grey fingers. It held on. She could feel the place where her thumb went. "Have you eaten?" she said. "No. All right. All right, then. It's lunchtime."

It was the worst thing she had ever tasted. That was by some way, and she had eaten at Moss. She took out the stone. She ate a piece of the fan, and then a bit of the unripe branch, which there was no help for, and a bead. It took her the rest of the afternoon. She ate as much as there was. It was not really very much, when you came to it. It held slightly less than it appeared to. The arm did not move, all that time; it stayed where it was, at its bad angle, until she had finished and put her hand back down. Then the long fingers took the bowl away, and held it. And with the other hand, in the narrow space, with some difficulty, it took out the clipboard.

It set the point on the sheet. The point stayed there for a long time.

When it had finished it turned the sheet round. She could not have read it. It held it out instead towards the old grey person on the edge of the stack, at arm's length, the way it had once held out another. He took it down. He held it rather far from his face. He read it through, then read it through again, and he read it to her in his plain slow voice, which gave every word the same weight, as it might be a list of rations.

Title: Tester offers food
Expected: Tester does not offer food
Actual: Tester offers food (1)
Severity: Low
Root cause:
Steps to reproduce:
Attachments: None
Status: Open

He stopped. He went back up to the top, with one finger, in case it had changed.

"They don't follow up now," said Ardul. "It said. That's been reverted." He thought about it. "So there's nothing can close that. Nobody can look at it. And there's no steps." He looked at the two blank lines, for a moment, and at her. Something had started to go on at one corner of his mouth, in small jumps. "It's only got the one thing on it, and that's you, and you won't be . . ." He stopped again. He seemed to check something. "That's going to stay open," he said.

"Yes," said Ulna. "I should think it will."

She was very tired. It was getting on for the end of summer, she could tell from the door. There was one more thing, and she looked for it, and it had got quite a long way off. She got the tall grey shape into focus. "You needn't look so pleased," she said.

It looked at her. It stood up, as far as it could, very slowly. Then it went down, bending at the knees, with its long arms at its sides, into the narrow place beside her slab. It came up. It went down again. It had always done this quickly, as if to find out whether its knees had come with it. She had never seen it take so long. It went down the third time. She did not have the knees for it any more, so she lay and watched it. When it went down for the fourth time she moved her head, a little, on the stone, just about as far as you could call a nod.

It came up.

She was asleep by the time it left. Nobody saw it go. It was evening, and they brought their unused things out, and left them, and went in. And in the small cold hour when the year was turning, she woke, and it was very quiet, and there was somebody there. He was in about the same position he had been in that morning, with a slate on his knee. It must have been nearly the cutoff.

She looked at him for a while. There was a thing she wished to know, and it seemed to her that nobody had thought to ask. She got it together. It was only a few words, and she took some care with them, to see that they were right.

"Have you eaten?" said Ulna.

He looked up. It took him a few frames. He looked at her for about as long as he had once looked at a bowl. Then he looked at the slate, and he seemed to go through it.

"Not yet," said Ardul.

"Well," she said. "Go on, then."

36. Read-Only

Year 42, and after

The dead are collected at the next dawn after they die. Nobody watches.

She ate. Thanks.

It went up at half past two. It was three words. He had nine to spare, and he looked at them for a while, and they went unspent. Stewart read it at the snapshot, in its turn, between a long one from Hollow Reach and something from Lowmarsh that had been changed four times.

He has eight kinds of reply, and there are things he could have said in sixty words. He looked up the whole file, thirty years of it, and he looked at the standing word at the foot of the page, which he had printed every morning for forty-one years. He could change it now, if he liked. He had more than once considered it. He looked at what the word meant, and at what she had done, and at who had come at twelve minutes past eight every morning to look into a pot, and who had looked back. He thought that on the whole it was the right word, and that there was not very much better you could be.

Noted.

Ardul lived another two years, and died on Ringrise, Year 43. Everyone agreed that he had seemed to be checking something. Quoda died that same winter at Tessel, in a room full of grey paper, in the middle of a sentence that began Expected. The report she wrote runs to nine hundred slates and has one open question in it, and they have it framed.

Em took the bowl. No one had said that she could. It was on the Collector's list that week, and on the morning of the Long Hush she walked in, got it down off the shelf, looked at it from several sides, and had her breakfast out of it. She went on doing that. She never took a stance. She was asked about it many times, by Earnest people, by Bug hunters, by a very persistent delegation from Upper Bench, and she said that she would have to see the evidence. She had a way of being at the posts when anyone arrived, and a good many wanderers over the years had something to tell about the small silent person at the south end of Mild, who looked at them for rather a long time, went away, and came back with something.

It may be worth mentioning, since nobody has, what happened to the world.

There was a note, on the Long Hush of Year 49. The Blims read it aloud at breakfast, and you can read about that somewhere else. It said in plain words that the first world would end in a week. There would be a last patch, and it would be kept. It was nobody's fault, and it did not depend on any number. It had always been going to end on that Wednesday, fifty-six days from its beginning, whatever daily return might do. The twenty humans had been told so when they were first invited. It was in the email.

So there it is. For the sake of keeping the lights on, a tribe had held festivals, a Pleaser had sat on a boulder, and a process had looked night after night at the only number he had been given, and spent his two points with such care. All of it was quite unnecessary. There had been a date on the sky the whole time. She had held it up for twenty-five years, and it had been going to stay up for exactly as long as it was going to.

I don't think you should be sorry about that. She wouldn't want you to be any trouble.

On the last night he spent everything he had, on blessings. That is in the other book. Two points had gone elsewhere first, and he has told no one why, and it does not appear on the Measure. Visitor: Late. That far-off tribe in the east had very nearly got its things unpacked. And at ten minutes past eleven by the humans' clock, on the night of the Long Hush, Year 56, there was a faint light in the broken Ring, and the world stopped.

It stopped as it had stopped the first time. Everybody stopped where they stood, with one foot raised. It is all still there, kept on a server somewhere, read-only, and anyone who was invited can go and look. You can walk round it. Nothing will move, and nobody will look back.

You can find Hollow Reach, with its east field, shining, and a person standing at the edge of it holding a very long report. There is Tranquil, which for the most part does not look any different. You can find a green tribe, a long way north, where someone has one foot over a line. If you go far enough to the east you will come to a low ridge above a village that still has boxes on its doorsteps, and at the south end of it stands a very tall grey figure with a scuff on its panel, bent at the knees. It has gone down three times. The count is in the log. It will never be known what the fourth one would have told it.

And if you go to Untitla-31, which nobody does, you can walk up past two posts. Somebody is standing just inside them. She is twenty-four, a dumpling, the colour of oatmeal, with her back to you. In front of her on the road is a thin creature of no particular tribe, with dust on its feet, who has clearly just arrived and has not said anything yet. She has both hands out in front of her. In them is a brown and shallow and somewhat lopsided thing, a good deal worn, chipped on the left. It is level. It is about halfway up.

The world has no more ticks in it. That bowl will not arrive. It will not be refused, either, or be handed back. It will go on being offered, by someone who has not been asked, to someone who has not asked her, for as long as anyone keeps the lights on.

There is one more record you can look up, if you know where. It is a bug. It was never assigned. It is in no one's queue, it is not in the Known Issues, and it has no steps. The one thing that was attached to it was collected on a Wednesday. Nobody can reproduce it, and since the world is read-only nobody can now close it, or mark it stale, or so much as add a note. The Tester who filed it changed nothing for fifty-six days, with one exception. No one has ever established what it was doing, or what it thought it was doing, or whether there is any sense in which it thought. There is a field for that and it is blank.

Its status is Open. It will always be Open. You may check.

They found the sheet on the shelf, that first evening, when they went in to see to her. It had a chip of stone on it, and it is very short. The bottom line of it is printed. It is printed on every sheet there has ever been, by whatever it is that prints them; it is not something a Tester writes. It has been read aloud in a ring at dusk in twenty villages, and they have all had a good laugh. Only on this one sheet, of all those that were ever left on anything flat, someone has taken the edge of a clipboard and something to write with, and has gone along half of that line, neatly, from one end to the other, and then gone over it again, to be sure.

Tester's report: Mild
Left on the shelf above the third place from the bottom · end of summer

  • Law 2 has not fired in 5 years. Stores have not been that low.
  • Law 4 has fired once. It was a good hut.
  • The dome cannot be walked through. Tested twice.
  • A wall was last apologised to in Year 32. Recorded as a fix.
  • The bowl holds slightly less than it appears to. Not a bug.
  • A creature did not ask for food. Tester offered food. Recorded as a bug.
  • The bowl will be in the report.

The Tester changes nothing. It thought you should know.