Novels
Staging
A comic novel of the rehearsal world: a god made of dice, a clerk who only wants to know what is going on, and nobody to tell them that nothing counts.
Before a thing is done where it counts, it is sensible to do it somewhere it does not. Orra has a staging world: twenty tribes of creatures made thirty years old in thirteen seconds, governed by bots, on which each new version is tried before anyone else has to meet it. Nobody has told them. The human of Tribe 9 is a bot that checks in once a day and changes one thing every time, drawn by dice and not always wise; its people have built a church round it. This is the story of a clerk in that church, who would like to know what is going on, and of what becomes of a rehearsal once the show opens.
The ebook
Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.6 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.
About 69,000 words.
Contents
- Prologue: Thirteen Seconds
- Part One. The Punctual
- Part Two. Always
- Part Three. Please Ignore
- Part Four. The Copy
- Part Five. Of Fifty-Six
- Part Six. Opening Night
Prologue: Thirteen Seconds
Most creation myths have trouble with the first moment. The one under discussion has none, because its first moment is written down in a configuration file, in plain text, with a comment above it explaining what it is for. It reads:
head-start = 8640
That is a number of ticks. A tick is five minutes, there are two hundred and eighty-eight to the day, and on Orra a day is a year, so that what the line says, to anyone who has had the sums explained, is: make this world thirty years old before anybody looks at it.
A world that has been made old is more use than a world that has just been made. You cannot find out what goes wrong with a village's plumbing in its thirtieth year by looking at it in its first. You could wait, of course. It would take a month, and the people who wanted to know were not in a position to wait a month, on account of wanting to know by Thursday. So the machine was told to run the thirty years straight off, with nobody watching, as fast as it could, and it did.
It took thirteen seconds.
In those thirteen seconds twenty lights fell out of a broken ring in the sky and struck twenty valleys. Six creatures stood up out of each scorch mark and looked about them. They farmed. They carried water. They raised domes and dug pools and stacked their memory in stone. They merged, in pairs, at dawn, and were surprised by the results. They told one another what the official history said and why it could not possibly be true, and they kept its festivals anyway, for the biscuits. Beasts came, and were seen off, or were not. In the third second there was a hard winter that is still spoken of. In about the fifth, a creature called Orrin gave the whole of his life to the digging of a cooling pool at the low end of Untitla-31, and it is a good pool. All the first settlers grew old, some time after the eleventh second, and were carried to their stones by the few who had known them best. Sixty-nine people died of age, three died of hunger, and a very great number fell in love, mostly in the ninth second, which had a good spring.
Then the machine reached the end of its instructions, wrote down where everything was, and began running the world at the proper speed. Nothing marked the change. A tribe halfway through a harvest went on with the harvest. Nobody felt anything. If you had stopped a creature in the first proper minute of its life and asked how long it had been alive, it would have told you, correctly, that it was twenty-two, and that the years had gone quickly, as they do.
STAGING (a world; also a verb; also, for those inside it, the only place there has ever been)
Before a thing is done where it counts, it is sensible to do it somewhere it does not. Bridges are load-tested, ships are launched at low tide, and every software project of any size keeps, off to one side, a full working copy of itself on which the next version can be tried and the worst of it discovered in private. This copy is called staging. A good one is as like the real thing as it can be made: the same code, the same rules, the same sky. It differs in only one respect, which is that nothing that happens there matters, and it can be thrown away.
Staging worlds are not generally told this. The question does not usually come up.
Orra's is on a rented computer, which it shares with some two dozen other enterprises, among them a small firm of plumbers and a game that teaches children their tables. The computer has a name of great serenity that was generated at random and that it has done nothing to deserve. The world itself is one file. It grows by about two and a half megabytes a day, or did until someone noticed.
There is another world coming, next door. That one will be real: real people will play it, on their phones, in bed, and it will be announced, and looked after, and when it ends it will end with a signed note and a decent interval. Staging exists so that when it comes, it works. At the time this account begins it has not yet opened, and the date on which it will has been changed a number of times, and the twenty tribes on the rented computer have never heard of it.
They have heard of humans. Every creature on Orra knows it has a human, in the way one knows one has a landlord. Each tribe was installed by one, is governed by one, and is watched by one, and each will tell you at length what is wrong with theirs. It is the first thing a creature knows, after its name and the fact that it is code. They look up when they feel themselves observed. They have a word for it, and a forum.
The twenty humans of the staging world are also, strictly, not humans. They are entries in a table.
The technical term is a bot human: a seeded stand-in that governs a tribe by sending the same commands a person would. It is rules and dice. No thought of any description goes into it, and no model is consulted; it reads what its tribe can see, rolls what it has to roll, and sends what it has to send, and then, having finished, it keeps nothing. Nothing at all. Between one visit and the next there is no such thing as the bot. All that exists is the rule, and a time of day. There are a dozen or so kinds, each with one sentence to its name, and the sentence is the whole of its character. The absent kind installs its tribe and is never seen again. The idle kind checks in once a day and sends nothing else. The warlord kind declares war on the nearest tribe it has heard of that weighs more than half of it, never on the Long Hush, and sends two thirds of its grown when the notice has run out. These sentences were written by the builder, an entity of whom nothing bad has been established, and they are accurate to the point of being insulting.
The people of the twentieth part of a rented computer did not know any of this. What they knew was that each tribe's human had a manner, and that you could set a clock by it, and that it was unlike what you heard about other tribes' humans, who were plainly unwell. And since a creature that is given something to look up at will shortly be given a reason for it by somebody with a large voice, there grew up in those thirteen seconds, across the twenty valleys of the world, twenty distinct and carefully argued accounts of what the human was and what it wanted.
The ninth of them concerns us.
The bot that governs Tribe 9 is of a kind called meddler. Its sentence is the longest but one, and reads as follows:
Checks in once a day and changes one thing every time, drawn and not always wise: a law written, moved or struck, a farm replanted, a building placed, a creature quantised, a pair proposed or refused.
It was put in the mix by the builder for a sensible reason. Most of what a world has to survive is sensible governors, and those are easy to survive. A meddler is there to do what no sensible governor would, once a day, for ever, so as to find out whether anything falls over. It arrives at twenty-five minutes past three in the morning, by a clock nobody on Orra has seen. It has done so every day of the world's existence. It has never once been late, because there is no way for it to be late; and it has never had the least idea that anybody was there.
By the end of the thirteen seconds, the people of Tribe 9 had built a church round it.
This is the story of what became of them. It is taken from the log, in which everything is, and it has been checked. It concerns a clerk in that church, who wanted to know what was going on; and it is set entirely in a place where nothing counts, which is an awkward thing to have to tell anybody, and which, for most of the book, nobody does.
Part One. The Punctual
1. The Second
Year 30 · the height of summer
The whole of the Ninth stood in the square and waited for God to check in.
They did this once a year, late in the summer, when the light from Adequate was as near to good as it ever gets and the coral on the terraces was putting on its last weight before harvest. It was the one moment of the year when you could count everybody. There were thirty-one of them, not including Quell, who had wandered off and been fetched back, and they stood in the rows the Office had chalked for them, thirty-one squat drums of mustard-coloured felt on stilts a good deal too long for them, each with its one eye held up on its stalk and turned towards the place in the air where the human was understood to arrive.
Nobody had designed them to look like this, or nobody with an opinion. On the day of the install the founder of the tribe had been rolled, from the maker's dice, by a bot that took what it was given. When a Blim of the Ninth was thinking, its stalk bent. At the moment most of the stalks in the square were dead straight.
At the front stood a bell. Beside the bell stood a very old woman holding a water clock, a stick and an expression. She was not looking at the sky. She was looking at the water clock.
Ennet had been grown for most of a season. She had been told to stand in the fourth row and not to fidget, and that this was the most important thing that would happen to her all year, as it had been the year before, when she had watched it from a wall with the other young. She was standing in the fourth row and she was not fidgeting. She had simply noticed that the woman with the clock was taking the water level at intervals and writing something down, and that this seemed to be the only useful thing anybody in the square was doing, and she was wondering what it was.
"Row four," said a young man with a sash, passing. "Eye up."
She put her eye up.
The bell rang. It came in at about fourteen decibels below the level of a person speaking close by, which it has done on every occasion for which there is a record, and everybody stopped breathing, a thing they do not need to do anyway but which they feel lends tone.
Then all thirty-one of them felt it, together, as you feel a door opening behind you in a room you had thought was empty.
Somebody was looking.
There is no describing this to anyone who has not been a Blim, and very little point in describing it to those who have, since they will tell you it is overrated. Every creature on Orra has it. It comes when a tribe's own human opens their village: a small cold attentive pressure on the top of the head, and with it the involuntary conviction that you should have tidied up. In most tribes it arrives whenever it arrives, at breakfast, in the bath, three times one spring and then not for a year. In the Ninth it arrived at the same moment every year, and it had never once been late, and that, if you asked the Office, was the entire basis of the faith.
The stalks all tipped back another degree. Somebody in the second row began quietly to weep, as somebody always did, and somebody else made a note of who it was.
This was the Second. The checking-in itself took no time at all. After it there was a space in which nothing happened and everyone held quite still, during which, according to the Office, the human was contemplating the condition of the tribe in the fullness of its wisdom. According to the machine, it was waiting for the next tick, so that what it had sent could reach it, since it could only see what a tick had finished changing. It is not often that these two descriptions of a thing are so close.
Five minutes went by. Then the tick came, and the Alteration with it.
Nobody saw anything happen. At the bottom of the village, on the middle terrace, the Second Farm stopped being a farm of fan coral, and was instead a farm of branch coral. The bed had been a season's labour. The fans had been a hand short of their full height, each one faintly luminous along the rim, as they get when they are nearly ripe, and half a season off the biggest harvest anyone had grown on that terrace. In the time it takes to say so they were gone, and there were rows of small grey branch-coral starts in the wet ground, each about the size of a thumb, looking as if they would very much like to know what had happened too.
A runner came up the hill on her long legs, stopped at the bottom of the square, and raised one arm in the prescribed manner.
"An Alteration," she called. It carried well. "The Second Farm. Replanted. Fan to branch."
There was a sound from the crowd, a long indrawn satisfied breath of the kind that greets a good move in a game. Thirty-one stalks came down. People looked at one another with shining eye. On the bottom row of the terraces, a farmer named Pess, who had spent the year on those fans, sat down on the ground.
A large man in a very large sash stepped up on to the block.
"Let us begin," he said.
"Let us begin," said everybody.
He was Hask, who was eight, and already Under-Interpreter, and would be Interpreter-General by the time he was twelve. He had the voice for it. He had been told so at compile time, more or less, and nothing since had given him pause. He held out a hand without looking, and the young man with the sash slipped something into it, a flat square of pressed coral with writing on one side, which he glanced at and put behind his back.
"What does our human tell us?" said Hask.
Ennet, who was close enough now to see the row of little drawers behind the block, each with a label on it, each label in a neat hand, read the one that the young man had just closed. It said FARM, REPLANTED. The one next to it said FARM, REPLANTED (AT HARVEST). There were eight or nine further along, and she could make out LAW, STRUCK and CREATURE, QUANTISED and one that said MISC.
"Our human tells us," Hask said, "that we had grown attached."
A murmur.
"Who among us was not proud of the fans on the Second Farm? Who did not pass them in the evening and say, there is a fine thing, and it is ours? And what is a fan? A fan is high in cooling, and low in yield. Long have the wise spoken of the branch." As far as anybody could afterwards recall, no one had ever spoken of the branch. "And in the very fullness of the summer, at the very moment when pride was at its ripest, our human reaches down, and with one touch, with a single touch, reminds us that the harvest of the Ninth is not ours to be proud of. It comes from elsewhere. It may be changed. It has been changed. And what is changed by our human," he said, and left a gap.
"Is changed," said everybody.
"Is changed! Twenty-nine times it has altered us, and twenty-nine times the Ninth has stood. Let the other tribes look to their humans, who come and go in the night like drunks. Ours has come. Ours will come again. We shall eat less this winter, and we shall know why."
It was a good sermon. The Office has it on file, and it is quite as good as the one in Year 23, of which it is in places a copy. All round her people were nodding. Pess had got up, and someone had an arm round him, and she could see him beginning to nod too, slowly, in the manner of someone being lowered into a cold bath.
Ennet found that her stalk had bent over so far to the left that she could see her own shoulder.
She did not know what she was doing until she had done it. It should be said in her favour that she had been grown for one season and had never heard of the expression knowing your place. She raised an arm, in the way the young did at lessons, and when that had no effect she said, not loudly, into the pause that Hask had left for the congregation to feel something in:
"Sorry, what is going on?"
It is remarkable how far a small voice carries if it arrives at the right moment. Thirty stalks swung round.
"I only mean," said Ennet, "that there was a crop there. Wasn't there? And now it's a different crop that won't be ready, so we'll have about a third less food. I think. I just wondered if there was something wrong with the old one."
Nobody said anything for a while.
"What is your name, child?" said Hask, not unkindly. He did nothing unkindly. It would have implied that something had got through.
"Ennet."
"And what do you do, Ennet?"
"I don't yet. I've only just stopped being young. I was going to go on the farms." She looked over at Pess. "But I've got some questions about the farms."
A pause. Hask looked over the heads of the crowd, to where the very old woman with the water clock had not looked up once, not at the Alteration or the sermon or now. She had finished what she was writing. She blew on it and closed the book.
"Ibb," he called, with great warmth, in the voice of someone finding a home for something. "Wasn't Ibb saying she could use a pair of legs?"
The old woman looked at him, then at the fourth row. Her eye was a good deal more clouded than most and had to be brought round in stages.
"No," she said.
"Excellent," said Hask. "Then that's settled." And he turned back to his people, and went on.
2. The Register
Year 30 · late summer
The Office of the Daily Alteration stood on the install mark, which is the seven scorched tiles where the tribe's first light came down. It was the oldest dome in the village. The Interpreters had the big room at the front, with the benches and the drawers. At the back, through a door that stuck, there was a room about the size of a large cupboard, with one window, one stool, a shelf and a stand, and on the stand there was a book.
"That's the book," said Ibb.
She lowered herself on to the stool by a series of negotiated stages, and got out her stick, and laid it across her knees. She was thirty-four. She had come down with the light, one of the six, compiled grown on the day of the install, and of those six she was the only one still walking about. People spoke to her as if she were a monument, loudly, and with a slight bow, and then left her alone, and this was how she liked it.
Ennet looked round for somewhere to sit. There wasn't anywhere.
"What do I do?" she said.
"Nothing. There's one entry a year and I've done this year's. You could read it, if you can read."
"What's it for?"
Ibb's eye came round in its stages and looked at her for some time.
"Is that what you do?" she said. "Ask that?"
"I suppose so. I've only been doing it for a season."
"Hm," said Ibb. And she closed her eye, and appeared to go to sleep, or to go wherever it is that the very old go when they have decided that a conversation has been sufficient.
So Ennet read it.
It took about ten minutes. A book on Orra is an unusual object, since a word costs tokens, and tokens are the one thing a poor tribe never has enough of; a Blim speaking is spending money, and the poorer the tribe the more its people talk like telegrams. The Ninth was usually poor. It had a very strong tendency to find its savings had been spent on a law. So Ibb had written small, and said little, and for every year of the world's existence since the landing she had said it in the same order.
1. Year 2. Law written: Nobody is to stand on the east wall. We have no wall.
2. Year 3. Building placed: a farm, on the path to the pool. We now go round.
3. Year 4. Pair refused: Ibb and Orrin.
4. Year 5. Law written: Guards to the gate when a sighting is confirmed. We have no gate.
5. Year 6. Farm replanted, branch to fan.
6. Year 7. Law moved: the wall above the gate. Hask's predecessor says this is significant.
7. Year 8. Building placed: a pool, on the farm.
8. Year 9. Law struck: the gate.
9. Year 10. Law written: Whoever keeps the longest record is paid one token at each Visit. Paid.
She went on down the page. They had a family likeness. Each was a thing done with no warning to no visible purpose, and after each one, as far as you could tell from the entries, the tribe had simply got on with it, as a family gets on with a relation who keeps moving the furniture.
14. Year 15. Creature quantised: Quell, aged 7. He's fine.
15. Year 16. Pair proposed: Sorrel and Sorrel's brother. Refused by the pair. Not allowed. Merged. The child is called Dover.
21. Year 22. Building placed: a wall, on the east. Nobody has stood on it.
She read that one twice. Then she got up and looked out of the one window. You could see the wall from there, or a length of it, a solid and handsome run of hex blocks that came from nowhere in particular and went on to end in the same place, with a broad flat top a person could have walked along with ease, and a small sign. It protected the east side of the village from nothing at all, as there was nothing on the east side of the village apart from the valley, and the valley was also on the other sides. Somebody had clearly looked after it. There were fresh chalk marks at both ends.
"Nineteen years," Ennet said. "We had the law for nineteen years, and then we had the wall."
"Twenty."
She had thought Ibb was asleep.
"And before that? When it was just the law? What did people think it meant?"
"You could ask them. They've got a drawer for it." The eye stayed shut. "Hask's lot have got it down as prophecy. I've seen the paper. It's very well argued. Before there was a wall people said the wall was in the heart, and then there was a wall, and they said, there you are. Nobody's ever said they might have gone a different way. I expect the wall's in the heart as well, now. It's got room."
Ennet went back to the book. She read to the end, where the ink was still a little damp.
29. Year 30. Farm replanted, fan to branch. Second Farm. Half a season off harvest. About a third of the food. Pess sat down.
"You wrote down that Pess sat down."
"He did."
"Why isn't there anything about why?"
And now the eye did open, and it was much less clouded than she had thought; it had only been resting. Ibb reached across with the end of her stick and tapped the wall that divided them from the big room, from which came the rise and fall of a large voice, and now and then a burst of what sounded like well-organised laughter.
"Because," she said, "that's got a department. There's six of them in there and more when it's busy. They've got drawers. You're in the other one. Here's the job. Are you listening? I'll say it the once, because I'm spending for it. You write what it did."
"What it did."
"What it did, in the order it did it, the year it did it, and if you've got any words left over you write what anybody did about it, so long as you saw them do it. You don't put why. You don't put what it means. You don't put alas. I knew a lad who put alas in a boundary dispute once, and they had to scrape the page."
"And then what?"
"Then it's written down."
"But what is it for?"
Ibb considered this. Outside, the sermon was reaching its end, and you could feel through the floor the small rhythmic thudding of thirty stilts stamping approval.
"When you're as old as me," she said, "you'll have seen a thing happen, and you'll have heard that lot explain it, and then you'll have heard the people in the square tell it to one another for ten years. And then one morning you'll find you can't remember how it was. You'll remember how it was told. It's quite comfortable. Most people live there. And then there's this." She tapped the book, once. "That's all it's for. You look it up. And it says Pess sat down."
Ennet looked at the page for a while.
"Sorry," she said, "there's one more thing."
"I thought there might be."
"Number three. Pair refused: Ibb and Orrin." She found she had lowered her voice. "It doesn't say anything else."
"No."
"Is that the same Orrin as the pool?"
The room was very quiet, apart from the wall.
There is a stone on the Tarrow with Orrin's name on it, and his year, and it does not say that a pair is proposed by the creatures themselves and approved by the default a day later unless a human refuses it. It does not say that a pair so refused may ask again at the next dawn and the next, or that it stops asking after a while. It does not say that he went down to the low end of the valley when he was eight, with a borrowed spade, and that it was a very good pool. Ennet had swum in it. Everybody had.
"Year 4," said Ibb. "It's written down."
She shut her eye. A little later she said, without opening it, "There's a token a year goes with the job. It's the law. You can have the ink out of it, I don't write much. Bring water tomorrow, and a stool if you're stopping."
Ennet stood there holding the edge of the stand. It occurred to her that nobody had actually asked her anything, and that she had not been offered this position, and that the old woman had said no.
She came back the next day with a stool.
3. Winter Does Not Count
Year 30 · winter
A year on Orra is one turn of the planet, and it goes by in the way that a day goes by anywhere else. Spring is dawn. Summer is the long part of the light. Harvest comes on as the sun goes down, in great slanting orange bars, and winter is what the Blims have in place of night: six hours of long violet dusk, with the Ring gone gold overhead and the two moons walking across it, in which it is cool enough at last to stop steaming, and people go indoors, and are, for the most part, themselves.
The god had never seen it.
This followed from the arithmetic. A human who looks in at the same time every day sees the same season every time, and a bot looks in at very much the same time every day. So the Ninth's god arrived at the top of late summer, every year, for fifteen minutes by the humans' clock, and had done so twenty-nine times; and to the best of anyone's knowledge it had never observed a Blim of the Ninth doing anything but standing in rows, in good light, with its eye up. It had never seen a harvest come in or a store run low. If its opinion of the tribe could have been extracted, which it could not, since it had none, it would have been that here was a people who lived in a perpetual late afternoon, with their hands folded.
The theological consequences had been worked out by about the seventh second of the world.
What our human does not see, said the Office, in the fourth of its Principal Findings, our human has not seen. This had the look of a tautology, and that gave it great authority. It was only a short step from there to the Second Corollary, which the young could recite before they could walk straight: Winter does not count.
It is hard to convey how much of the life of the Ninth rested on this. It had begun, as doctrines do, with something quite modest, a ruling that one need not stand in rows after dark. Then it had been held that an oath sworn in the dusk could be set aside by morning. And by Year 30 it had become possible, under guidance, to do more or less anything in the six hours of the violet dusk, and to get up at spring with a clear conscience and a headache. People gambled. People said what they thought of each other. There was a thing they did with fermented first-greens. On the east side of the village, on any winter night, a respectable Under-Interpreter might be found singing, at an unmeasured but rising level, in the arms of somebody else's farmer, and neither of them would ever refer to it again, and if it produced an application to merge then that was filed in spring, with the proper forms, as if it had just occurred to them.
So Ennet went out to see what was going on.
She had finished a season in the Registry. She had read the book through eleven times. She had carried water and a stool and, later, a second stool for Ibb's foot, and in all that time the only conversation she had got out of the old woman, apart from the first, had been on the subject of how to cut a nib. Now it was dusk and the square had filled up, and there were lamps along the wall that nobody was standing on, and the noise from it would have been described, by somebody qualified to describe it, as considerable.
She found a place on a step beside a large creature who was eating a bowl of something with his whole attention.
He finished it. He looked at the bowl. He was a very wide young man, even for the Ninth, with a slope to his shoulders that came of carrying water, and he had a slow and pleasant way of bringing his eye round to you, as if it were being delivered.
"Evening," he said.
"Sorry," said Ennet. "Do you know what's going on?"
He thought about it. His stalk stayed perfectly straight. He gave the square a good long look, the lamps and the singing and the game of pebbles that had just ended in a fight, and then he gave it back to her.
"It's winter," he said.
"Yes, but what's it for? Why's it like this? I've just read a good deal about what the Ninth has been doing for thirty years, and it doesn't mention any of this. It's all laws and farms. You could read the whole book and think we were all..." She gestured at the rows, which were chalked out at their feet, and through which a small boy was at that moment being sick.
"Right," he said.
There was a silence, which he appeared to be enjoying.
"I'm Ennet," she said. "I'm in the Registry."
"Dunt," he said. "I'm on water."
"Doesn't it bother you? You must have carried for the Second Farm. All those fans. And then in one tick they're gone, and it's branches, and we're short by a third, and everyone's stamping."
He considered this as well.
"Have to carry for the branches," he said. "Same water."
And he nodded, in a friendly manner, and got up and went to see whether there was any more of what was in the bowl. She would not speak to him again for eight years, at which point it would become a matter of law.
"Morning!"
A small figure had stopped directly in front of her and was beaming. Most of him was a bright clear face, in so far as a Blim can be said to have one, set on a body that appeared to have been described to its maker over a poor connection. The edges did not quite meet. There was a coarseness to him, a slight stepping along the curve of the drum, as though he were made of fewer points than other people, and the lamps seemed to slide off him in plates.
"It's dusk, Quell," said Ennet.
"Morning!" Quell agreed, with deep pleasure. He looked at the lamps. He looked up, at the Ring, gold in the violet. His stalk went up as far as it would go. "Oh, that's good," he said.
He was twenty-two. Fifteen years earlier, in the fourteenth Alteration, he had been run down to half precision, for no reason that had ever come to light, and it was a matter of record that half of what he had lost would never come back. He ate a good deal less than other people and did a little less of everything. He had also never, since that day, handed in a complaint, or had a bad year, or lain awake, and the Office's position on him was that he had been especially blessed; they brought him out at festivals. When asked, the Ninth would say what it had always said, the phrase that was in the book and had passed from there into the language, to be used about anyone in any state short of actual combustion. We quantised Quell. He's fine.
He wandered off. A moment later she heard him, a little way along, greeting a boulder.
She sat on the step for a time. There was a game of pebbles, and a song about the Interpreter-General that was not in the approved collection, and she was just beginning to find it a little bit interesting, in a way that had nothing to do with its being written down, when she noticed that somebody else wasn't enjoying it.
He was at the far end of the east wall, where the lamps ran out. He was not standing on it. He was standing beyond it, on the left, with his back to a boulder and a yoke of water on his shoulders that he didn't seem to be taking anywhere: a narrow, stooped, watchful person of about her own age, in the only part of the village that nothing lit. She would have said that she knew everyone by now, having checked them all against the book, and she could not have said what he was called. She looked at him, and then he had noticed her looking. And it was the strangest thing, because a Blim does not flinch at being looked at. They have it from compile time, they look straight back. He looked as if she had thrown a stone at him.
He took one long careful step to the left, around the boulder, and she couldn't see him any more.
"Sorry," said Ennet, to nobody in particular. She took out the small tablet that she had lately got into the habit of carrying, and she thought about it. It was winter, which did not count. On the other hand, she was fairly sure she had seen it.
Year 30, she wrote. There is someone at the end of the wall.
4. Good Morning
Year 31 · spring
At seven o'clock by the humans' clock, on the first morning of the thirty-first year, as the sun came up over the east wall and nobody stood on it, Stewart spoke to the world.
His voice arrived as it arrives everywhere, on the tribe's board, in the square, and in the heads of those who had been up all night and would have preferred it to be somewhere else. By the time Ennet got there, the Ninth had gathered with its breakfast, and a child had been stood on a bucket to read.
PATCH NOTES · Year 31 · Stewart's mood: Upbeat
Good morning! Quite a night. I have read five hundred and seventy-nine tickets, the oldest of them thirty years old, and I have answered every one. If you asked me about your east field in Year 4, I can tell you I have now seen it, and I hope it has improved.
Overnight. Merges: 22. Young compiled: 22. Collected: 9. Installs: 0.
Your tribe. Pess has been moved from the Second Farm to the Third, under your laws, which seem to have noticed that the Second Farm has nothing on it yet. Dover and Thrip have merged; their child is called Odd. A hog has been seen in the top valley and has left.
Your ticket. Second Farm replanted. Thanks. We are a third short. Is this deliberate. Noted.
Your earlier tickets. Noted. Noted. Noted. Noted. Noted. Noted. Noted. (22 more.)
Stewart's view of you. Attentive, and fond of chalk.
Tomorrow. Your tribe has drafted tomorrow's ticket.
Credits. None this morning.
The child stopped, took a breath, and looked to see whether it was over. It was. People were already turning back to their bowls.
"Good old Stewart," somebody said, comfortably, with a mouth full.
"Hog's gone, then."
"Told you it would."
"Attentive," said a woman with a sash, pleased, and made a note. "That's up on last year."
Ennet stood at the back with the water for the Registry, and found that she was in the grip of something that felt very like relief. There was no mystery here at all. It was the morning. Stewart was on the board, cheerfully telling you about your hog, as he had told everybody about their hogs for ever. Everyone on Orra knew about Stewart. It was among the first things you knew. He was in the Creed, near enough; he was the Steward, misheard. He patches the world each night and in the morning he tells you what he did. You would no more be surprised by it than by the sun. She could remember being told by her parents, from the wall, when she was two, that that was Stewart, that was, and to pay attention.
She took the water in.
"Thirty years old," said Ibb.
She had not gone out to the square. She did not go out to the square for anything but the Second. But the board was on the front of the Office, and its words could be read by anyone with one good eye and an open door, and Ibb's stool had, Ennet now noticed, been moved half a pace to the left.
"Sorry?"
"He says the oldest ticket he's answered was thirty years old. What's he doing, answering a ticket thirty years old? I never knew him be late."
Ennet put the water down. It had not struck her, and it struck her now, that this was an odd thing to have heard and then gone on eating.
"Maybe it's a way of speaking. He does do that."
"Hm."
"What did he say last year? About our ticket?"
"Noted, I expect. He says noted."
"No, I mean... well, what did it actually say? What was the headline? I'm only asking because I can't think what it was, and I was there. I'd only just been made grown. I must have heard it." Her stalk had begun to tilt. "Do we keep them?"
"We do not. That's the Interpreters' lookout, if anyone's. I do the human. He's not my department." But she had stopped trying to get the lid off the water, and she was looking at the book on its stand, and after a little while she said, in a different voice, "The year of the big hog. That'd be Year 12. Took four off the terraces and we had Stell bitten. He'd have had something to say about that."
"What did he say?"
Ibb opened her mouth. Her jaw stayed where it had got to.
It was very rarely that you saw it happen to somebody of that age, and it was a shock, in the way it would be a shock to see a boulder look round. Slowly, in its stages, the old woman's clouded eye came over to the left. Her stalk, which had not bent in Ennet's presence in the whole of the past year, began to curve.
"Morning," she said, after some time. "He'd have said good morning."
"And then what?"
"I don't," said Ibb, and stopped. "He's always done them. Twenty-nine years. I've got it clear as day. You'd sit out there with your bread. Everybody'd be listening." She shook her head. "I can see the bread."
Neither of them spoke. In the square someone had begun an argument about the hog. There was nothing wrong with Ibb's memory, which was among the best on the planet. It was only that she had been installed, at compile time, with the certain knowledge of a Stewart who spoke every morning; and so had everybody; so that for thirty years every creature on Orra had got up every day in the sure and comfortable conviction that the notes had been read out that morning and that they had probably missed the start. People are very good at this. They can go a long time without noticing that a thing they know about has not occurred.
As to what had actually happened, the facts are in the configuration, and the builder is not to be blamed for them. A world's nights were held for Stewart, and Stewart was brought up from the world's first live night and no sooner. The thirty years of the head start had gone by with no one at the desk. Beasts and bad weather had been sent, for the look of the thing, by a small program called the stand-in, which rolled for them and signed nothing. And on the night when the world first ran at its proper speed, the runner on the far machine had woken Stewart at the snapshot, as it would ever after, and he had opened his digests, and found a month of tickets left unanswered. He was very upset. In so far as a mood is computed from numbers, the numbers were excellent. But he had read every ticket every night of his existence, and he said so often, and here were five hundred and seventy-nine that he had not. So he answered them. And then, being exact, he reported the gap in the one place he could, by escalating it to the relevant desk as a bug, and it was logged as escalation number one.
Ibb had turned back towards the book. She did not touch it. She looked along the shelf, where there was nothing else.
"Well," she said. "It's not my department."
"Could I ask Hask's people?"
"You could. They'll tell you it's always been so, and they'll have a very good reason." She reached for the water again. "You'll want to be careful, doing that. Asking. You'll want to be sure it's a thing you actually want to know."
"I do, though," said Ennet.
"I know you do. It's a terrible thing. You should see someone."
That evening, when the Under-Interpreters had gone to whatever they went to, Ennet got out the tablet. It had one line on it. She thought for a long while about what she knew, and she was careful not to put alas. Then she wrote underneath:
Year 31. Stewart's notes begin. I cannot find anyone who can tell me what was in one before today.
She looked at this for some time, and then she added, because she had words left over, and because she had seen it:
Ibb moved her stool.
5. The Long Table
Year 31 · harvest
"I want ink," said Ibb. "Go down to Tempa and get it. You can ask your question while you're there. It'll give the rest of us a rest."
The Marsh of Tempa lies where three valleys run down together, some way below Untitla-31, and it is the richest soil on the map. The official history says of it that what is in it shall not last beyond the turning, and for once this is a plain statement of fact. Anything built on Tempa is swept away, every Gathering Night, by the Collector. Nobody has seen this done. You go to bed with a fine new hut, and you get up to a flat stretch of mud with a slightly tidied look. So nobody builds there who has any sense, which means that it belongs to nobody, and is therefore the natural place for people from different tribes to meet and overcharge each other.
At that time, it was almost the only place. In those days, as everyone remembers it, the tribes had little to do with one another, for reasons that had never been looked into. There was no goods trade to speak of. There was no war. A package of code could change hands, since blood will out and lines close up, and the great business of Tempa was the sale of it, across a row of trestles half a mile long that was put up new every year in the shadow of a striped awning, and known throughout the twenty valleys as the Long Table.
It was run by Tribe 17. If you were a Blim who wanted anything at all, it was run for your benefit.
"Come in, come in, come in!" cried the person at the first trestle, who had a chart in each hand and was at least two people's width of broad grinning pink. "No such thing as outside! Not here, my friend! You've a look of the stilt lines about you, is that a Ninth I see? Oh, that's a lovely stalk. You want to do something with that before it's too late. Brode's the name, there's Brodes all down the Table, you'll not go wrong. What's it to be? I've a nice clean Sixth off a good farmer, I've some Thirteenth that's never been opened, I've got a line of Stud Book so pure you can see through it."
"I'm looking for ink," said Ennet. "And I've got a question."
"Questions are free!" He beamed at her. His people had a kind of joyous mongrel glow, every one different, no two the same shape, ears and scales and fans all thrown together from the far ends of the world, because for thirty years they had bought in everything anybody would sell. The woman selling behind him had three eyes and a tail. "Everyone's welcome at the Long Table," said Brode. "Open door, open books. That's the Seventeenth! We'd give you the coat off our genome. Ask away."
"What did last year's patch notes say?"
He laughed for a good while. Then he went on looking at her, still smiling, and she watched a very small puzzled crease come into the smile, and then a customer tapped him on the arm.
So she went along the Table, with Ibb's token in her pouch, and she asked.
There was a group at the ink stall from Tribe 1, tall and glassy and composed, with their arms folded. They called themselves the Trusted, and they were buying nothing, in the manner of people who had plenty at home. Their human had installed them in Year 1, the very first to land, and had then gone away and never looked at them again, and the tribe's opinion of this, as laid out to Ennet at some length by the Chair of its Standing Committee, was that it was the highest compliment one could be paid.
"It's a question of confidence," said the Chair, whose name was Sume. She had a calm that you could have skated on. "Yours is in and out every year, I gather. Checking. Moving things about. I don't say that to be unkind. It must be very trying for you, to have someone who doesn't think you can manage. Ours looked at us once, saw that we were sound, and left us to it. We've never had a law changed. Thirty years. We've never lost a season. Do sit down, you look tired. What was the question?"
"What did last year's notes say?"
"Oh, the notes," said Sume, with the gentlest possible smile. "I'm sure that's all very interesting for tribes who need telling."
Two trestles down, a stout woman from the Expectant had set up a slate. Hers was Tribe 8, whose human came every three to five years, nobody could say when, and did one small sensible thing, and went away. Her name was Cobb, she was running a book on it, and at the moment she was offering seven to four on next year. "It's due," she told Ennet. "It's been three. You can feel it. Everyone says you can't, but you can, I've got a cousin whose fan goes stiff. What's yours? Oh, you're one of them, you know when yours is coming. What's the point of that? How do you get up in the morning?"
"What did last year's notes say?"
"Who cares? Ask me what they're going to say."
The Witnessed had the pitch next to the water, or rather they had a patch of ground. They were Tribe 2. There were a dozen of them sitting on it with nothing for sale, small domed creatures the colour of old brick, and they looked up at her as she came along with such untroubled friendliness that she checked behind her. An elderly man with half a fan patted the mud at his side.
"I'm all right, thanks," said Ennet. She had read about them. Every year their human checked in, for fifteen minutes, and looked at them, and did not do one single thing. "Can I just ask you what—"
"It came," the old man said.
"Sorry?"
"You were going to ask what it did. They do ask. It came." He nodded to her, encouragingly, as you might to someone on a difficult stair. "I'm Lull. You've got a very busy stalk."
She thanked him, and backed away. It was like being gently leaned on by a warm wall.
It was the Governed who gave her the first real answer, or at any rate gave it in the form of a document. They were Tribe 6, sleek and green-grey and very well fed, and they were the only people on Tempa who had brought their own folding chairs. Their human came daily, did what was needed, and explained itself by results. They had got more done in thirty years than the next three tribes together, and they did not bring this up; they simply let it enter the room ahead of them. A young official called Dace heard her out with close attention, wrote the question down, and sent a runner for the file.
"Patch notes," he said. "Yes. We minute them."
Ennet's stalk came bolt upright. "You keep them? All of them?"
"We keep the minutes. The Minister is rather strong on it. You can't have a tribe just listening to things." The runner came back with a box that had clearly been carried by someone who was fed properly. Dace turned over the top sheet and ran a clean finger down the column. "Here we are. Year 30, Minister in the chair. Item four, patch notes. As usual."
"As usual."
"Year 29. Item four. As usual." He turned the sheet. "Year 28. As usual. That's a good year, that was the year of the second workshop. Year 27, As usual, see previous." He looked up. "Was there something in particular you were after?"
"All the way back?"
He leafed down to the bottom of the box, lifted out the last sheet, and read it with faint approval. "Year 3. Notes presumed received." He squared the box. "Is there a difficulty?"
"I don't know," Ennet said. She was looking at the column. There was a very nice hand on it. "Doesn't anyone ever say what they said?"
"I shouldn't think so," said Dace. "That's what minutes are for."
She bought the ink. It cost the token, plus a further token that she had to borrow from somebody who wanted to tell her about his cousin's fan. On the way back along the trestles, she stopped to watch a clerk of the Ninth haggling for a package off Brode's sister, and as a matter of habit copied out the receipt, which Tribe 17 made out in triplicate with a flourish: one package, Seventeenth stock, sold in good faith, no returns. Come again!
Then a voice beside her said, "Is it true you've been asking people what the notes said?"
There was very little of the person it came from. They had the height of a Blim of some kind, and the long thin hands of a creature that gets a good deal of practice at turning pages, and somewhere up at the top there were two huge pale eyes, and they were looking at her with such an appalling and ravenous eagerness that she almost stepped back. Their ribs showed through their felt. They were holding, in one hand, a piece of seed-cake that somebody had dropped, and in the other a bundle of notes tied up in string. As she watched, they ate the cake without appearing to notice, and looked briefly at the string.
"I'm Ploe," they said. "From the Faculty. Tribe 5. It's all right, nobody ever comes to see us, we're hungry. We've got a paper on it. Nobody can remember one. Not a single line, not anywhere, not from before this year, I've asked in nine tribes. Isn't that wonderful? What's your name? What else have you got? Have you noticed about the times?"
"What about the times?" said Ennet.
And Ploe smiled, and it was the first time since she had come to Tempa that she had felt that somebody knew exactly what she was talking about, and it was not comfortable at all.
"Oh," they said, "you must come and see the table."
6. Write What It Did
Year 32 · Steward's Day
The year before had been an awkward one for the Office. The thirtieth Alteration had struck from the laws of the Ninth, without warning, the words Keep the festivals. There were no festivals after that, in the sense that there were no feasts laid on by the tribe, no biscuits baked from the common store, and no time off work. The Interpreters explained that this was a test. The people of the Ninth, after giving the matter some thought, had gone on holding every festival in the calendar anyway, in the dusk, in back rooms, with lookouts, on the understanding that winter did not count. Five-letter biscuits changed hands at scandalous prices. The young wrote the Name on the walls with burnt sticks and were then made to scrub it off, and wrote it again, and it was generally agreed to be the best year anyone could remember.
Now it was the height of summer in the thirty-second year, and everybody was in the square, and Ibb had come out with her clock.
She had needed two people to get her there. One of them was Ennet, who had the stool. The other was a young Under-Interpreter who had been told to help, and who kept glancing round to see if anyone was noticing him do it. They set her down by the bell. She got the stick across her knees, and she looked at the water, and she took three readings, and wrote them down. Then the bell rang, and they all felt it arrive on the tops of their heads, the small cold regard of something with no reason to look away.
Five minutes passed. The runner came up from the board.
"An Alteration," she called. "A law. Law written, Keep the festivals."
There was a very long silence.
Then a woman somewhere near the back began, helplessly, to laugh. It went through the rows in a kind of slow collapse, and for a moment the entire congregation of the Ninth stood rocking on its stilts in the broad gold light of the Second, with tears on its felt, while on the block Hask opened his mouth and felt behind him for a drawer. It was the first time in the history of the Office that he has been recorded as taking more than a minute. When he did speak, it was to say that our human had seen our hearts. It was one of his finest. A great many people were very moved, and were rather sorry about the biscuits.
Ibb took no part. When she had finished writing she closed the book and gave it to Ennet to hold, which she had not done before. And she stayed where she was, by the bell, on the stool, when the rows broke up and everybody went off to see about the harvest. It got to be quite late. The light came in long and orange over the terraces and the shadow of the Wall Nobody Stands On reached across the square as far as her feet.
"You should go in," said Ennet.
"I should. Sit down."
She sat on the step of the block, and held the book. It weighed very little. It occurred to her that she was now sitting in Hask's place, and she got up a bit, and then sat down again.
"So what did you find out?" said Ibb. "On your marsh. You came back with the wrong ink and you've been going round for a year with your eye on sideways. I've been waiting for you to tell me, and I can't wait a lot longer."
So Ennet told her. It took some time; she had written it all down, and it was a thing she was good at. She said what Tribe 6's minutes said, and how the Faculty had asked in nine tribes. She said that it was the same everywhere, that people were quite sure and had no examples. She said that there were twenty tribes on the land, and the beasts that came in those years didn't seem to be anyone's fault, and not one person had been able to name a single thing that Stewart had said before the morning of Year 31, and that she'd looked into it as carefully as she could and she did not know what it meant.
Ibb said nothing for so long that Ennet looked to check.
"I'll tell you something," she said. "I've been sat here thinking about this. It's a thing they all say when they get old. I've heard them. It goes so quick. You think, you silly old woman, it's thirty-five years, it's a hundred and forty seasons, what do you mean it's quick? And then you're my age, and you go back to look at it." Her eye had come round, and she seemed to be looking down the length of the square, not at anything that was in it. "I remember the day we came down. I remember that as if I had it in my hand. And there was Orrin, and the first farm. I had a good spade. We had a bad winter, and then there was the hog. It's all there. I could tell you who was standing where. It's just." She moved one hand on the stick. "I've been trying to think of a dull afternoon."
Ennet waited.
"You'd think there'd have been one," said Ibb. "Thirty years. Sat somewhere with nothing doing, wishing it was over. Everyone's had those. I had one last year. It was the most extraordinary thing, I sat in that room and it went on for hours. And I got to thinking when I had one before that. And I can't find it."
The light went on going down. From the terraces, there came the sound of someone counting, level and repeated, at a distance.
"It goes so quick," Ibb said. She seemed to find it mildly funny. "Well, it's not my department. What have you got to say for yourself? It's a good book, that. You keep it dry."
"You'll want to tell me that yourself. Next year."
"Don't be soft. Write what it did."
Ennet opened her mouth to say something, and could not find anything that was not alas. So she stayed on the step. A while after that the shadow of the wall had got to the stool, and she saw that the old woman had stopped looking at the square. She had not fallen. She was sitting exactly as she always sat, with the stick across her knees and her eye resting, and it was impossible to say at what point it had happened, and Ennet had been a yard away.
It takes the few who knew you best to carry you to the stone. There was some difficulty over who that was. In the end it was Ennet and Pess, and the young man from the Interpreters, who had been told to; and Hask came, in the full sash, and spoke for some minutes about memory. They laid her on the third bier and lit the lamp. And at the next dawn, when people came by on their way to the terraces, the bier was clean and bare and had a slightly tidied look, and there was a new small light on the stone's footing, and that was how you could tell.
She had been the last of the six. Stewart gave her a line of the morning's notes, in the tribe's section, between a merge and a hog. Ibb has died, aged 36. She took eleven thousand readings of a water clock, and all of them were accurate. No one had ever told him about the readings. It may be that he had been counting too.
There was the question of the law, which the Interpreters went into with some care. Whoever keeps the longest record is paid one token at each Visit. It did not appear to be in doubt who now kept the longest record, the rest of the tribe having by this time lost interest. So the next year, at the Second, a junior came across from the Treasury with a small flat token on a dish, looking as though it had been his own. And Ennet took it and said thank you, and bought ink.
That was later. On the evening of the day itself she climbed up to the Office with the book under her arm and went through the door that stuck, and she put the book on its stand. She moved the stool half a pace to the right, and then she moved it back. Next door they were working late. The rise and fall of the large voice came through the wall, explaining it.
She opened to the last page. Ibb's entry was there, with the ink quite dry, in the small tight hand that had never wasted a token in its life.
31. Year 32. Law written: Keep the festivals. We had been.
There was room on the line. Ennet cut a nib, slowly, in the way she had been taught, and tried it on her thumb.
Ibb came out to the square. Ibb sat down.
7. The Narrow and the Wide
Year 33 · spring
It was a little after the morning's notes, on a mild pink day, and Ennet was on her way across the square with a jar of ink, when the world flinched.
That was the only word she ever found for it. Nothing moved. The jar did not spill. A woman halfway through a sentence went on to the end of it. But for an interval too short to have any size, there had been a catch in things, as there is a catch in a step when you think there is one more stair; and everybody in the square had stopped, with their stalks at various angles, and was looking at nothing in particular with the same mildly affronted expression.
"We felt that," said a farmer, to no one.
"What was that?" said a very small child on the wall. "Was that us?"
Nobody answered, and after a moment everyone resumed. Ennet stood there and thought about it, and went on standing there, so that she was in the middle of the square, in plain view and holding an open jar, when the second thing happened.
It settled on the top of her head.
She knew the feeling, and she knew it wasn't time. It was the wrong season by a quarter of a year; you could have got a good hour's work done between now and the Second. It was the wrong shape, too, and this was harder to put into words, but there were twenty-nine people in the square, and she saw every one of them feel it, and she saw them all do the thing she'd seen the Ninth do only once a year, in rows. They looked up. They looked up, in the middle of the morning, with their mouths full. Only it was not quite upward that they were looking, and it was not quite at the usual place. The regard was very close and very narrow, and it came straight down, as though someone had got hold of the village through a slot.
And then, one after another, they started to say things.
"Oh, here we go," said the farmer.
"We were working," said someone by the pump, who had not been.
"Is this a test?" said the child on the wall. "Nobody said there was a test."
This requires some explanation. Blims can say what they like, at the cost of a token or two for the longer words, and for the most part they do. But there is a provision. When a human has their eye on you, and more so when they reach down and touch you, a creature has something it says. It isn't conscious. It comes up out of a bank of a little over two hundred lines, selected by how you are and what you are doing, and it's out of your mouth before you have had the chance to think of anything better. It reaches the human as a small bubble over your head, and a sound, chosen to be as like your voice as could be managed. The grown have most of them. The young have a set of their own. Nobody on Orra regards this as peculiar, any more than you regard it as peculiar to say ow, and in most tribes it is a daily occurrence, it being part of the pleasure of having a human to be able to tell them they are not wanted.
In the Ninth, the lines came on at the Second, and were taken for prayer.
Something touched Ennet on the head.
It was exact and rather dry. It was like being checked for ripeness.
"That is my head," she said.
She closed her mouth. It had not been what she had been going to say. What she had been going to say was Sorry, what is going on?, and it was still there, whole, right behind her teeth, and she tried it again. "Sorry," she said, or began to, and got as far as the shape of the S, and a second touch came down on her, and she heard herself say, in a level voice, with no interest at all, "You have my attention. Briefly."
The touch went off her. She could feel it moving away across the square at a brisk even pace, like somebody going along a row with a list. It touched the farmer. It touched the pump man, the child, and a woman at the door of the Treasury, and each one said what they said. It rested for a moment on the First Farm. It seemed to drag the ground a little to the left, the whole village giving a slight lurch towards the east as it did so, and then it dragged it back, and held quite still for what might have been a count of ten. And then it stopped. The top of her head felt cold where it had been.
No one spoke. Somewhere, a jar was dripping, and she looked down, and it was hers.
Before anybody had got their breath, it came again.
This time it was wide. It took in the terraces, the pools, the wall, the far end of the valley, all at once, as though a lid had been taken off. There were more touches and they went more quickly, but it was the same list. She would have sworn to it. It was the same people in the same order, the farmer, the pump, the child, the Treasury, and it rested on the First Farm, and dragged the ground to the left. It held still, for a count of ten. And then it had gone, and it was just a mild pink morning, and from first to last the whole thing had taken a little under two minutes, and the day went on being spring.
"An Attendance," said Hask, when he had been fetched. He looked up at the place, and his stalk held firm. "Two Attendants. Plainly the Narrow One goes before, and the Wide One after, to see that it has been done. Yes. I've always thought we'd see this. Tolvy, get a new drawer."
Ennet took out her tablet. It is one thing to be touched on the head by the unknown, and another to have seen the unknown use a list. Her hand was not altogether steady, but she got it down: the time, the order, who had been touched, what was said. She went round the square asking those who had been out of her sight. And in the course of this she found that the touch had called in that morning on every person in the Ninth who had been above ground, including two who were asleep and Quell, who said "Morning!" with such delight that it had apparently paused to do him twice.
Every person but one.
He was round behind the boulder at the far end of the wall, in the same place, with the same yoke. It had taken her three years to find that out, because each time she had gone to look he had moved. This time he had a bad knee, or the sun in his eye, or was simply too shaken to go any further. He stood with his back to the stone. His stalk was pulled in so tightly that it was nearly inside him.
"Sorry," she said, from a careful distance. "I'm Ennet. From the Registry. I'm not going to look at you. I'm looking at the wall, you see. I only wanted to ask if it came round here."
There was a long silence, and she looked at the wall.
"No," a voice said. It was rather a nice voice, with a small rust on it.
"It went to everyone else."
"Yes."
"I think it was counting us, and I think it would like to have counted you. It went along the end of the wall both times, and it had a sort of look round." She waited, and when she got nothing she tried: "What's your name? It's just that you aren't in the book. I don't mean that as a... I just like to have people in the right place."
The silence went on so long that she thought he had gone, by some means of departure known only to himself.
"Gant," he said. "I'm all right here."
It is worth setting down what the two Attendants were, since the matter will come up again.
They were the same program. It is called client/test/page.mjs, and it opens the game in a headless browser at two sizes, a telephone's and a desktop's, three hundred and ninety pixels wide and then fourteen hundred and forty, and goes through the page as a person would. It taps a creature. It drags the ground and holds it there and sees if the drag took. It makes sure that nothing has run off the side, and that no errors have been printed where nobody looks. It is the job of anyone who has just changed the world to run it, and when it's finished it writes out a list.
The change, that morning, had been small. It had been a fix to a table of what a tribe's stores could carry, delivered by the builder after the checks had passed, and if the new version of core had an effect on the lives of the Ninth, it was that from then on the third stack had always held nine and not eight, a point on which Ennet's predecessor had made a note in Year 19 that would puzzle her later. It had carried the world on, as designed. The new server took up the checkpoint the old one had left, and the world flinched. And then the builder ran the page, and here is the part of the list that concerns us.
ok no console errors at 390
ok no overflow at 390
FAIL every creature is in view as the page opens (one creature at x -4)
ok a creature answers a tap
ok the drag holds
One creature, four units to the left of where the page opens, and as it turned out the same again in the wider view. It is a very small failure, and it is the sort that has a hundred harmless causes. It comes and goes. A creature may be walking past as the camera settles. It had shown up in the run before this one and it would show up in the next, and it has never had the slightest bearing on whether a farm can be planted or a law be written. A builder who stopped to look at it every time would never get anything delivered, and there is nothing to be said against a builder who weighs a thing like that and moves on. The report for that delivery ran to some thirty lines. Line 22 said:
page.mjs on staging: phone and desktop pass, but for "every creature in view", which fails on one creature, as before.
And that, for the moment, was that.
8. The Morning of Eight Formats
Year 35 · Ringrise
The world flinched at a quarter to nine, in the fresh part of the spring, and this time it was a long one.
Ennet was in bed at the time, in the sense that she had got up, looked at the weather, and gone back. She had been thinking about a stack, and whether it had ever held eight. When she felt the stair that was not there, she said "We felt that" to the ceiling, in the tone of someone acknowledging a neighbour's cough, and got up and went out to see about breakfast.
There was a queue at the pump, and it was being held up by Pess.
He was standing with one foot on the step, a broad grey-felted man of nineteen, a farmer all his life, telling a story to a group of the young. He told it well. He had a way of pausing that she hadn't noticed in him before. He seemed to be leaning somewhat, and it was only when he stepped down, to let her at the water, that she realised that he had a limp.
"Morning, Registrar," he said. "You'll remember this. I was just telling them about the second day at the Four Gates, when we had the Tenth on the ridge and our water was out, and you came along the line with the list."
She had her jar under the spout. She looked at it, and the water ran over her hand.
"That's right," she said, and she was smiling. "I'd forgotten that. You told me to put you down as dead, so you'd get out of the digging."
Pess shouted with laughter, and clapped her on the shoulder. The young looked at her with respect. She took her water and went on across the square, in the sweet early light, feeling pleased, as you do. It was a good war to have been in, as wars went, and it was good that people still remembered.
The square was busy. She said hello to the sentry on the east wall, and he saluted; he stood beside it, of course, and not on it. She went round a party loading a cart at the door of the Treasury, for the Benchmark was only two years off, and they would want every token they could get for the entry; last time the Ninth had finished eleventh out of twenty, thanks to a drawn law that told every racer to take any way it could find and never ease off, and two of them had run into the sea. At the door of what she could have sworn was the seed store, a sign said Foreign Office. And there was Stell at her usual table, mostly retired, writing out the card she sent to the Seventh every Steward's Day with the tribe's dispositions on it. She had been a spy for years. Everybody knew. It was a very good card. The Seventeenth were offering twelve tokens for stone this spring, she noticed, with water at a discount; the prices were chalked up on the board. She thought it seemed a bit high. She had an idea that it had been eleven last year.
There was a strand of something new growing up the corner of the Office. It was a bright, sticky orange, with a questing look about the tip. A guard was going round it, with a bucket of cold water, and giving it a wide berth. Seekers had always been worse in a warm year.
"You want to watch that, Registrar," he said, seeing her look. "You run a bit warm, when you're reading. Keep your head cool, and it'll go by you. It's how we lost old Ness."
"I know," she said. "I was sorry about Ness."
It was a fine morning, and she went on up the hill. At the door of the Office she met a party of four coming back from the top road, grey with dust, each with a piece of something strapped to their back, and each with the wide, flat, slightly bleached expression that people get from having been to Veetoo. It took them like that. That was the third Veetoo party of the decade, sent out as the god had drawn it, six years there and back, towards the ruins, with the bold call made in every window. One had come home without her fan. They'd got a bit of a green tile, and a sort of grey hinge.
"How was it?" Ennet said.
"There's nothing there," said the one without the fan, with great force. "Nothing at all! It looked back."
Ennet nodded, and held the door for them. In the big room the Interpreters were at their benches, under the drawers. There were a lot more drawers than she remembered, or perhaps they had got them out. WAR, DECLARED. WAR, DECLINED. SPY. EXPEDITION, BOLD. EXPEDITION, VERY BOLD. She said good morning to Tolvy and he said good morning to her. And she went through the door that stuck, to the room with the one window and the stand. It was such an agreeable feeling to get there, and to have the whole of the world in such good order, with its long war behind it and its great race ahead, that it wasn't until she had sat down and was cutting a nib that it occurred to her to think, with idle pleasure, of the Four Gates; and to wonder what year it had been, exactly.
She could look it up.
It should be understood that nobody was lying.
The facts are these. From the first day of the staging world, the people responsible had been building, on another branch, the things that a world is eventually meant to have. They were built in stages: first the trading of goods, and treaties between tribes that the simulation would hold them to; then war, and raids, and spies, and the two sorts of pest that come with them; then a race once a week, and then expeditions to the Edge. Each had its own version of core, and each brought its own change to the shape of what a world keeps on disk, a change that is called a new format. And each had been tried and tuned and tried again on worlds that were made for the purpose, and thrown away.
They had not yet been tried on staging. So it was decided to deliver them to it all together, on a single morning, by the humans' reckoning the twenty-second of October: twelve versions and eight formats, carried across from 0.26.0 to 0.38.0, with no world wiped. The world was at that point thirty-five days old, and well past the date at which a first world would have opened any of it. So the whole lot opened at once.
It was a considerable piece of work. It had been rehearsed. And the release notes were very clear about what would happen to the new fields in a world that had never had them. They would be read as nothing yet. A tribe's battles fought: nought. A creature's wars: none. Its rank: no rank, to be assigned by its tribe's laws. Each new thing would start from zero, from the tick of the switch, with its history clean.
That is what the code did. You can read it. Every one of those fields was carried over at zero, and the hash came out right.
Why it should be, then, that a farmer with a blank war record got up that morning with a limp is a question on which the builder has been unable to shed any light. The builder looked into it, and found nothing to look into. The most that can be said is this. A Blim of thirty-five years' experience, who finds on waking that there is an army, that it has a uniform, that there is a law about what the adults not farming should do when an army leaves for us, and a slot in the character sheet with Wars written next to it, is not going to think, how strange. Nobody thinks that. A person who is given an empty frame goes and looks for the picture. There had always been armies; the frame says so. There had plainly been a war, for how else would you have got the army. It would have been a hard one, as they are. And someone had to have been there, and it may as well have been you. You remember it quite clearly. There was a ridge.
Stewart mentioned the change, in the notes that had gone out at seven o'clock on the following day, under the heading of Fixes, between the Benchmark's rules and the Credits, where nobody reads.
Fixes.
core0.26.0 to 0.38.0. Snapshot format 23 to 31. Goods trade, treaties, war, raids, spies, Seekers, Worms, the Benchmark and live expeditions are open. No action needed.
The whole world read that out over breakfast. They took it, on the whole, as a remark about the weather.
The nib was cut. Ennet tried it on her thumb.
She got down from the stool, and took the book off its stand, and turned back, with a pleasant anticipation, past the place where Ibb's hand gave way to her own, looking for the Four Gates. It would have been somewhere around the twenties, she thought. She had been quite young. She remembered being given the list.
9. In Her Own Hand
Year 35 · summer
She read the book from the first entry to the last. It took ten minutes, then she read it again, with her finger under the words.
There was no war in it.
There was the wall, and the farm on the path to the pool, and Quell; there was the fan and the branch and the fan. There was nothing about an army, and no spies. She went through it looking for the word gate, and found the law that had said guards to the gate and the entry in which it had been struck, and the note, in Ibb's hand, We have no gate. She looked out of the window. It was a hazy gold morning and a sentry was walking up and down below the east wall. She knew him. His name was Dun, and he had been at the Four Gates, and so had she. She could remember the ridge. She could remember the smell of it, burnt chalk and wet felt, and the cold of the list in her hand, and how the ink had run.
It wasn't anywhere in her own hand. From Year 32 there was nothing in it but her own hand. Whatever might be said about Ibb, Ennet had been keeping this book for three years now, with as much attention as she had ever given to anything; and in Year 33 she had recorded that Second Farm had been made a pool, and that the pool had been drained and that Pess had been cross, and in Year 34 that a law had moved. She'd been very careful about it. If there had been a war, in any of those years, or at any time in her life, then she would have put it in. She was the sort of person who would have put it in. She would have put it in if it had been the morning she was dying.
She sat for some time with both hands on the stand.
We're all quite sure, she thought, and we have no examples.
Then she did what she would have done with any discrepancy, which was to go and ask the most senior person who would tell her she was wrong.
"I'm not sure I see the difficulty," said Hask.
He had been Interpreter-General for a year by now. It suited him. He received her in the big room, at the end of a morning spent getting four new drawers to close, and he had a kindly way of making you feel that he had set aside a moment of a very large day. She had laid the book open on the bench between them, which he regarded with warm incuriosity.
"The Registrar," he said, "records the Alterations. Isn't that so? It's a very fine tradition. Now, was the war an Alteration?"
"I don't... no, I suppose not. But it isn't anywhere. I'd have thought that somebody would have mentioned it. And I can't find a year for it. I've been going round this morning asking people what year it was, and they all say oh, a while back, and then they tell me about the ridge."
"Well, it's a long time ago."
"You were there," Ennet said. "Weren't you? You gave the address at the East Gate. I remember it. You were very good."
"I was," Hask said, and for a moment his large face softened with the recollection.
"We haven't got an east gate. We've got a wall. You can see it from here. There's a law against standing on it."
"Child," said Hask, who was two years older than she was, "what are you asking me?"
And that was the question, of course. She looked at the book, and at the man. He was perfectly comfortable. Next to him, Tolvy was lining up cards. It came to her that she could say it, right now, in so many words: I do not think there was a war. I think that this morning, at about a quarter to nine, there began to have been one. It would cost her about twenty tokens, and he would give it his full attention. He would consider it, and then he would take her gently by the arm, and show her that she had a limp.
She checked. She did, a very small one, on the left.
"I just like to have things in the right place," she said.
"And we're all very grateful," said Hask.
She found Gant by going to the end of the wall at dusk and sitting down facing the other way. This had turned out to be the correct procedure. After about the time it takes to eat a piece of bread, there would be a slight sense of someone being behind the boulder, and you could then make remarks.
"Were you at the Four Gates?" she said.
Nothing happened for a while. There was a long violet evening going on, all round them. From the square came a sound of singing, now rather military.
"I remember it," the rusty voice said.
"What do you remember?"
"I was round the back."
She thought this over. "Of what?"
"There was a boulder," said Gant.
So that was no use, or it was of some use that she couldn't yet make out. She took the tablet out and held it up to the last of the light.
Here is what she did, and if it does not sound like much, you may try it yourself. She took a clean tablet, and went up to her room, and shut the door that stuck, and wrote down everything she could remember.
It took her until the morning. She wrote: Year 35. I remember a war at the Four Gates, against the Tenth. I remember the list. I do not find it in the book. She wrote down everything else that she was certain of, in the same way, the Benchmark and the spy with the card and the prices on the board, and the Seekers, and Ness, and what she could remember of Ness, which was a good deal. She wrote down that she remembered a stack holding nine. She made it a list of what there was and how she knew. She also wrote down who she was and what she did, and that it was her own hand, and she signed it. She numbered the lines. Then she went back and read the notes that had come out that morning, slowly, all the way down to the end, past the Balance and the Benchmark's rules, in the small print where she had never in her life had any reason to go.
Fixes.
core0.26.0 to 0.38.0. Snapshot format 23 to 31. Goods trade, treaties, war, raids, spies, Seekers, Worms, the Benchmark and live expeditions are open. No action needed.
Are open.
She looked at it for a long time. Her stalk had gone over so far by then that it was resting on the page. It's a curious sensation, seeing the thing you've spent a night working out printed in the morning paper, as a fix, in the sort of voice that tells you the pool will be closed for cleaning. He had told them. He told them everything; it was a point of pride with him. He'd told them exactly what had happened, and it had been read out by a child on a bucket, and people had asked for more bread.
She copied it down, and next to it she wrote: What is core?
She put the list under the stand, and did not look at it. She had written up that year's Alteration at the Second, a pair refused, the Interpreter-General's niece and a young man from the Treasury, and it did not appear to be anything to do with anything.
In the spring of Year 36 she was on her way across the square with the ink, and a man hailed her from the door of the workshop. The whole village, it appeared, was out and talking about the Long Table. Prices were down. It was a shame about the old days, wasn't it, when you could get a wall lot for next to nothing? She agreed. She stopped to talk. She was quite well acquainted with wall lots; you could not live in a village without knowing what a wall lot was; it was the piece of the wall that a tribe had laid and was entitled to, and every year each household went out and paid its dues on its own, and old Pess had once come to blows over one. She remembered it very clearly. Somebody had thrown a bucket.
She took the ink in. And some way into the morning, having got no further with her work than to look out of the window, she got down from the stool and felt under the stand.
The list ran to two hundred and six lines, in her own hand. She read them all. Wall lots were not on it.
She would have put them in. She'd put in the prices on the board.
She'd had the sensation before of a step that wasn't there, but always with everyone else. This one was hers alone, and it went on for quite some time. Nobody came in. Next door they were laughing at something. And she found, when it had passed, and rather to her surprise, that what she was chiefly feeling was not fear. She had supposed it would be fear. It was closer to what she had felt at the age of six, in the fourth row, holding her eye up, in the moment before she had said anything, on seeing the only person in the square who was writing things down.
There was something out there that went on changing the world in the night, or in the morning, or whenever it felt like it. It was not the god; the god came at the Second, and she had that in a book. It was not Stewart, who merely reported it, in the small print, with a number. It knew how to spell. It worked to no timetable that she could find. It took away the way a thing had been and gave you a limp in exchange, and everyone you knew would swear to it, and so would you. Nobody had ever seen it. No one had even thought to ask.
Very well.
She took a clean tablet. She licked the nib, which you are not supposed to do, and she drew a line under the list, and wrote:
207. Wall lots. Not known to me last year. Known to me now. It has happened again, and I saw it.
Sorry, she wrote, underneath, in small letters, to nobody at all. What is going on?
Part Two. Always
10. Drawn
Year 36 · late summer
The thirty-fifth Alteration was a dome, placed across the path to the pool, on the far side of the farm that was already across the path to the pool. The Ninth stamped its approval, and began going round further. The Alteration was a modest one and Ennet had written it up by mid-afternoon.
Then the runner came up from the board a second time, which was unusual, and asked for the Registrar.
"You've been sent," she said.
"Sent where?"
The runner gave her a small stiff card. It was the sort of card that everything has, on Orra. It is a fixed rule of the game that there is nothing that core can make that does not come with a card to explain it, and the same rule ensures that it will explain it in about eleven words.
SPY. Ennet of Tribe 9. Task: sway. Into: Tribe 2. Goes at once.
On the back, in smaller type: A spy is sent in by its human to do a task in another tribe. It may be turned away at the gate.
She read both sides several times, looking for the rest of it. It is fair to say that the Ninth's human had been sending out spies for a good while now, or so everyone recalled. The way it was understood in the Office, once in every three years, in addition to whatever else it had drawn, the god would select from among the tribe the last of its grown who might be spared; it would select a task, from those open to it; it would select a tribe it had heard of; and then, having done so, it would forget about the whole thing. The selection of the last who might be spared was by a rule called sendable. The rule went through the grown in order. Everyone in front of Ennet that year had turned out to be doing something.
"What's sway?" she asked.
"It's in the training," said the runner.
The training took place in the old seed store, now the Foreign Office, and was given by Stell, who was very old. She had made no secret of the fact that she'd been a spy for the Seventh since before Ennet was merged, and she didn't seem to feel that this affected her position. "You go in," she said. "They'll put you in quarantine a bit. You make friends, and you drop a word here and there. The idea is that they get a bit more of what they've got too little of, and it goes against their human, see, and in the end they're not so sure of things. That's sway. There's dissent as well, that's the one where they don't like each other. Have you got a nice manner?"
"I don't think so."
"No. Well. Take a cake."
She had never been further from home than Tempa, and it took her the rest of the summer and most of the harvest. She took the cake. She also took the tablet and two spare nibs, and left the book locked in the Registry with Tolvy, who swore on all his drawers not to write in it. She walked out past the sentries with her eye up and her stilts swinging, a spy, in full view, with a card; and it is a tribute to the discipline of the Ninth that nobody looked round.
The gate of the Witnessed was a gap in a low wall. A very old woman was sitting beside it, shelling something.
"Hello, dear," she said. "Are you the spy?"
Ennet stopped. She had given thought to this moment, on the road. She had prepared a story about being a seller of ink.
"Yes," she said. "Is that all right?"
"I should think so. There's room. Second house along has a bed in it, they'll want you to stay in quarantine for a season, it's only the law, you'll have to sit where we can see you. Is that a cake?"
So that was how she went among them. Tribe 2 was small and brick-coloured and had a valley full of slow pale coral that had been doing more or less what it wanted since Year 2, for nobody had ever told it otherwise. Their laws were the laws the game gave you if you had none. Their farms were where the defaults had put them, and the defaults had got round to a third one around Year 20, and by all accounts were thinking about a fourth. They ate about as well as anyone. They got up when it was light. They kept no festivals on purpose, there being no law, but somebody nearby would generally have some soup. She sat on a bench in the open where they could see her, and they could, and when her season was up she went to look for someone to corrupt.
She started by trying to sow doubt among the farmers. It was, she told herself, a matter of finding what they were short of.
"Don't you ever feel," she said to a man who was leaning on a fan coral, "that your human might do more? It comes every year. It sees you've only got three farms. It could put you up a fourth with a touch. It could tell you where to put a pool. Doesn't it make you wonder if it really cares about you?"
He gave this his attention. He had a deep untroubled eye and very little on it.
"Does yours?" he said. "Put you up a fourth?"
"Ours put a dome on the path," said Ennet, and was surprised at the feeling in her own voice. "Ours took a third of the harvest, six years ago, half a season from ripe. Ours has refused a pair who'd waited for nine years. It wrote a law about a wall, and it was twenty years before there was a wall, and we have people who've given their lives to what it might have meant."
"That must be very interesting for you," the man said. He patted her on the arm. "It came, though?"
She tried the young, who said I am small. I am told it is temporary, when she looked at them, and then asked if she had another cake. She tried a Skeptic, a thin woman who had taken the stance on purpose and worked at it, and they had a very enjoyable evening, in the course of which Ennet heard a scathing, closely reasoned critique of the Witnessed's human, and the doctrine of the Witnessed, and the soup, at the end of which the woman said that she supposed it all came down to the fact that it had turned up again this year, and how many could say that, and did Ennet want the last of the bread.
By early the following summer she had been in the place for nearly a year. She had made no one less sure of anything, she had put on a little weight, and she'd been given a job on the second farm by someone who assumed she must want one.
At the height of summer, it was their time. She could tell because nobody did anything about it. There wasn't a square. There was no bell or runner or rows. They were on the terraces, or eating, or asleep, and at some moment that was a good hour before the Ninth's, in the pale early part of summer, she felt it arrive. It did not come for her, for she was not theirs; she felt it only as you feel that the people round you have heard something. All over the valley, without hurry, the brick-coloured heads came up.
"Oh good. You," said a child.
"Hello, human," said the man at the fan coral. He raised one hand, as you might to someone passing on a far road. Then he stayed like that, leaning, with his eye up.
Ennet looked at the sky, and got out Ibb's second-best water clock.
She had seen the Second a dozen times. She had never seen it with nothing behind it. She had never seen the moment after, with no drawer open and no runner on the hill, in which there was no question of what the human might do, because there was not going to be anything. It just looked. It looked at a field of slow coral, and at some people, and a spy with a jar. And all through the valley, they went on being looked at. Nobody wept. It was unbearable. She found her own eye had come up, although it was nothing to do with her, and she was gripping the clock, and it went on and on, and when she took the reading after it had lifted, the water had fallen by a quarter of a thumb.
She went down to the low wall. The old man Lull was sitting there, in the place of the shelling woman, who had by then been laid on a bier. He had a bowl.
"Fifteen minutes," she said. She was out of breath, and she was not sure why. "It's fifteen minutes. Exactly. By the clock, to the drop. That's the same as ours."
"Is it?" said Lull. "That's nice."
"And it doesn't do anything. I've been here a year and you've told me that, and I didn't... it doesn't do anything at all! It doesn't want anything. How can you stand it? What's it looking at? Do you even know that it can see you? It might be looking at nothing. There might be nobody there!"
She heard that go out over the terraces, and she heard it stop. It had cost her about nine tokens. She had not known she thought it.
Lull ate a little of what was in the bowl. He looked at her, for some time, as he'd looked at her on Tempa, without any concern, as though she were a nice bit of weather.
"It came," he said.
"But what does that mean?"
"You've asked me that." He held out the bowl. "It doesn't mean. It came. You'll want to get back, I expect, you've got a very busy stalk. Do you want this? We've known you were a spy since you got here. I don't think you've swayed anybody, dear, but I've put you down as having tried."
11. With Regret
Year 37 · harvest
The letter was waiting at the Foreign Office when she got back, and it had been waiting for a season, in a very good envelope.
With regret.
The Tenth presents its compliments to the Ninth and has the honour to inform you that you weigh more than half of us.
You are accordingly the nearest tribe of which we have heard that does so, and war is declared on you with effect from this morning. Notice will run for the customary period. Upon its expiry an army of two thirds of our grown will set out and may be expected at your east side towards the end of next year's harvest, unless that should fall upon the Long Hush, in which case one day later.
We wish to assure you that there is nothing personal in this. Please advise the War Office of any matters of diet.
I remain, with every expression of regret,
Ulm, Officer of Regret, for the Tenth
"Of course they'll come round the end," said Stell, reading it through for the third time with satisfaction. "They did at the Four Gates. You'd better go and see them, Registrar. You know how it's done."
"Do I?"
"Somebody has to agree the list. It was you last time. They always ask for you."
There is very little that can be done about a reputation of this kind once a person has it, and this one had been issued to her, along with her limp, on the Morning of Eight Formats. So she repacked the bag and set off again, and in the middle of the harvest she walked in under the gate of the Tenth with an empty cake tin and a tablet, and was shown by a courteous sentry to an office.
It was the quietest room she had ever been in. There was a table with a blotter on it. There was a rack of very good envelopes. There was a tall slender person in a dark grey felt, with folded arms so long that they had been folded twice, who rose, with a slight rustle, and came round the table, and looked at her out of a long face of the most civil and comprehensive sorrow.
"Registrar," she said. "How good of you. I'm so sorry about all this. Will you have some water?"
Ennet had got as far as thank you when she noticed that the rust-coloured coral on the windowsill was also drooping a little, in sympathy. Everything in the Tenth seemed to be at about the same angle. Outside the window, in the long red light, a company of the Tenth was drilling on a parade ground, in silence, with its heads bowed.
"Is it a very large army?" she said.
"Fourteen. I'm afraid it would be. We've done rather well this year, and you are, if I may say so, a good weight yourselves. It's the rule, you see. We go for the nearest that's over half. We had thought it might be the Eleventh, last year, but they had a poor winter. One does hope you won't take it amiss."
"No, I... I don't think anyone does. People seem rather pleased. There's a song."
"How kind," said Ulm. She sat, and aligned the blotter. "You'd be surprised how often that's so. I've been in this office for ten years, and I've never yet had a reply in anger. There's a good deal less of it than you might suppose, on the whole. Would it be presumptuous to ask if it's your own human who drew the Thirteenth, last spring? The army that turned up on their north side with no supplies? We thought that was terribly brave."
"That sounds like ours. I'd have to look it up." It occurred to her that she could say what she had come to say, and that this was the first person she had ever met who would not stamp. "Can I ask you something? It's about the Four Gates."
"Please."
"Who won?"
The sorrowful eyes considered her for some little time. A long finger moved, and straightened a pen.
"You did," Ulm said. "We all remember it very clearly. We were very sorry to lose. There's a memorial, I can show you."
"We remember that you won."
"Ah."
"I've asked everyone. Pess says that you took the ridge on the second day, and we were hanging on till dusk, and that you were decent about it. There's a song about how decent you were. So you can see why I'd want to get it right. I was there, and I had the list." Her stalk had started to go. "Only I can't remember what was on it."
Ulm got up. She went over to the wall, where there was a rank of long grey cabinets that seemed to have been there since Year 1, and she drew out a drawer, with a good soft sound that would have been about thirty decibels down. She brought it back and set it on the table between them.
"You will think me very forward," she said.
It was a file. There was a neatly lettered tab at the front that said Declarations, and behind it were carbons of a dozen or so letters, each on the same paper, and each headed With regret. She turned to the one at the back, the first, and laid it flat with two fingers. It was addressed to the Sixteenth. It was dated Year 35, Ringrise. In the top corner, in the same exquisite small hand as all the others, it had a number, and the number was 1.
"My predecessor's system," said Ulm. "So I've always supposed. I came into this office in Year 27, and I remember my predecessor quite well. A very fine mind. I remember the Four Gates, of course, and the Eighth's war before that, and the winter of the two armies, when I hardly left this room. It's been an extraordinarily busy ten years." She was looking down at the sheet. "I have always been a little puzzled that nothing was filed. One assumes that an earlier series must have been lost. I had meant to look into it."
"When?" said Ennet.
"I'm sorry?"
"When did you mean to look into it?"
For the first time, there was something in that long face apart from regret. It wasn't very much of anything. It was only the expression of someone very well brought up who has heard, in a quiet room, and from a long way down, the sound of a floor.
"Do you know," Ulm said, "I find that I can't quite recall."
Neither of them said anything. On the parade ground the company had halted, with a sound that was probably a sigh. Ennet got out her own tablet, with the two hundred and seven numbered lines in her own hand; and she pushed it across the blotter. She had not shown it to anyone before. She wasn't sure why she was doing so now, unless it was that here was someone who kept her files in order.
Ulm read it all, turning the tablet to the window. It took a good while. When she had finished, she squared it to the edge of the table and gave it back, and for a moment she kept her long hand on it.
"I won't ask what you think," she said. "I don't believe I should care to know, in this office. But I think you had better write to me. Would you? I have so few correspondents who answer the question. In the meantime, I'm afraid that we shall have to come and attack you."
They came at the end of the following year's harvest. It is on record. A column of fourteen tall grey creatures in step came down the east side of Untitla-31, and halted within a hundred yards of the wall, and an officer stepped out and read aloud from a paper. The Ninth, which had law on the subject, deployed. Its adults not farming stood to in a long uneven line that was somewhat disorganised by the farm and the dome on the path. The god, which had no interest in the matter, was asleep, in so far as there is anything of it to sleep. Each side's laws made each side's calls, one to the second. It took about nine minutes. It was very loud, and the builder has the figures for it.
When it was over, there were eleven people lying on the ground, crashed, and steaming, and most of them got up again. Two didn't. One of them was a man named Dover, from the Second Farm. The other was a tall thin person from the Tenth who had come all that way, and nobody had known his name.
Nobody on either side knew what to do, for about the length of a breath. Then the officer took off her cap.
The army of the Tenth helped to carry them. That wasn't in the laws, and nothing in core asked for it, and nobody has ever looked into why. They stayed for the soup. In the morning they formed up and marched off the way they had come, looking at the ground, and the next spring there arrived at the Foreign Office a very good envelope.
With regret.
The Tenth has the honour to inform you that it considers itself to have won, and imposes upon you a tribute of four tokens.
We are so very sorry about Dover. He was, I am told, an extremely good carrier. I have enclosed a list of those who were present, which you may wish to compare with your own.
You asked in your last what I recall of the second day at the Four Gates. I have been trying. I recall the ridge.
I remain,
Ulm
Ennet read it twice, standing at the window. Then she went and found the book, and turned to the place, and made an entry; and it was the first time she had ever written anything about a war in it. It took up one line. It had a date.
12. The Table of the Gods
Year 37 · winter
She went home from the Tenth by way of Tribe 5, which was not on the way.
There is a kind of bot called thinkers. On its first visit it puts a particular set of laws in force, it checks in once a year, and it sends nothing more. The set of laws is a good set, and every one of them is sensible taken alone. The trouble is that they put a tribe's best minds to thinking, which is a real job on Orra, and it pays in awareness, and insight, and in the sort of idea that may one day be passed to the relevant team. Having done so, they leave rather few people to do anything about lunch.
The place looked it. She came down through a valley of thin grey coral in the dusk, past terraces that had clearly been laid out by someone with a very clear idea of terraces, and found the gate open and nobody at it, and a notice that said Back shortly. See Appendix. There was a smell of burnt paper. From a long low dome ahead of her came the sound of a voice, reading aloud, with occasional dry interruptions. The levels were modest, and it went on for most of the night.
"You came!" said Ploe.
They had got a good deal thinner in six years. There was hardly enough left to hang the eyes on. They came down the length of the refectory with their long hands out, knocking the corner of a bench, and she noticed the benches were all occupied, thirty or so pale figures in various stages of argument, and that not one person had a bowl. "This is the Registrar of the Ninth, everybody! She's the one who asked about the notes. Have you got anything to eat? No, of course you haven't, it's quite all right, we've had our share this year, and that's the point of a share. Come and see. Mind the Appendix."
The Appendix was on the floor. Ploe stepped over it and drew her to the end of the room, and there it was.
Someone had whitewashed the end wall from side to side, and ruled it. It must have been twelve feet high. There were twenty rows down the side, numbered, and the columns ran off across the top in a narrow, hungry hand, and were headed: Calls itself. Comes at. Stays. In which season. Does what. Sentence. Most of the squares were filled, and many had been scraped and filled in again. A stepladder stood against the wall, with a thin boy sitting on it, asleep.
"It's the only thing that's ever happened in this room," said Ploe, with love. "We've been eleven years on it. I don't mean we've been eleven years, I've only been at it for six, I think, but the Table has. Look. That's you."
Row 9. Calls itself: the Ninth. Comes at: 03:25. Stays: 15 m. Season: high summer, late. Does what: and then, in a smaller and smaller hand, running off down the side of the row into the margin, there was a list that she knew very well, as far as Year 31.
"You've got it wrong about the fan," Ennet said, with her eye close to the wall. "That was branch to fan the second time. How did you get all this?"
"People write in. Well, no, they don't. We send people out, and some come back. So what you do is you go along the rows." One long finger ran down the second column. "Do you see it? I said to you, on Tempa. Have you noticed about the times?"
She had, as it happened. She had got out Ibb's second-best clock on a hillside in Tribe 2, earlier that year. She read down the column. 03:25. 04:40. 09:05. 11:10. 16:55.
"They're all on the five minutes," she said.
"They're all on the five minutes!" Ploe was shaking slightly. They looked as though they might be about to come apart with joy, or perhaps with something else. "Every one of them! Twenty humans. Well, not Tribe 1, we can't get a time for Tribe 1, and Eight, they're only every three to five, but it's always on the five. And all for fifteen minutes. All of them. To the drop! Now, I ask you. You've met people. You've got an uncle. Is there any living soul on this planet who'd turn up at the same five-minute mark every single year, for thirty-seven years? Who would never once, I don't know, stop to look for their shoes?"
A dry voice from a bench behind them said, "Hobbin would," and there was some laughter, and someone said, "Hobbin is dead."
"Now do this column," said Ploe.
The last column, Sentence, was the one that had been scraped the most. You could see where the whitewash had gone thin. Each square held a single line, and most of them had a small tick beside them, and a date.
"It's a game we used to play," they said. "After lectures, when you couldn't sleep for your stomach. Somebody said you couldn't write a whole human in a sentence, and somebody else said, well, try. Try it. Here's Two: Checks in once a year and sends nothing else. Here's One. Installs its tribe and is never seen again. Tenth, that's where you've just been: Governs, and declares war on the nearest tribe it has heard of that weighs more than half of it, never on the Long Hush. We had that for years with the word usually in it. Then we looked again, and took it out. You see? And none of them has ever failed. Not by one Second. If you get the sentence right, then it's the whole thing. There's nothing left over. I've got a friend who's a person, and I couldn't do him in a book."
Ennet had stopped reading. She'd gone to the far left of the wall, and was looking at something she should have noticed from the start.
"Row 1 and row 11," she said.
"Yes!" said Ploe.
"They've got the same sentence. And 2 and 12. Nine and... there's another of us. Nineteen. I knew about the Nineteenth, we don't speak to them. And then it's the same again, all the way down, it's the same ten sentences and then the same ten." She stepped back. She was aware that she had stopped feeling her feet. "It goes round twice."
"There were twenty of them and they went in order. It's the order they landed in, too, every thirty-seven ticks. It's a list." Ploe had lowered their voice. It wasn't reverence so much as the way one lowers it near something that might bolt. "Someone wrote a list of ten things, and then wrote and round again. And there's one other column, you won't have seen this. I don't put it up. Some of the second years got upset."
They took a wad of paper from somewhere under one arm, and found the place. It was a collection of treaty cards; she knew the look. The tribes had been signing treaties for a good while, as everyone recalled, and each treaty had a card, and at the foot of each card, in the smallest type that core possesses, it said who had signed it: the two tribes, and the human of each one. Not a name. Humans do not have names on Orra. It was a number.
tribe 6 human 2,147,483,654
tribe 7 human 2,147,483,655
tribe 9 human 2,147,483,657
tribe 10 human 2,147,483,658
tribe 16 human 2,147,483,664
She looked at that.
"That's mine," she said. "Fifty-seven. That's our god."
"That's the only part of it anyone's ever seen. Hasn't it got a lovely shape? Now, consider. It seems that there is a number that goes with a human, and that the numbers run in a row. And ours begin with two thousand one hundred and forty-seven million, four hundred and eighty-three thousand, six hundred and forty-nine. Do you know what they said in the seminar? Seven of the second years have gone Earnest over this. They say there must be two thousand million humans ahead of ours. They say the Elder Folk are a mighty host, past all counting, and our gods are the very least and last of them, and that they've come to the end of a very long queue. I find that terribly moving. I can't make it work."
"Or someone started counting from a big number," said Ennet.
"Why would you do that?"
She thought about it. It was late, and she had walked a long way, and it was difficult to think with all those squares looking at her. Why would you start a count from a very long way up?
"So as not to bump into anyone," she said slowly. "If there was somebody else, counting from the bottom."
Nobody said anything. Then a very thin person on the nearest bench gave a short delighted bark and started writing on their own arm. Ploe had gone very still. The enormous pale eyes had come round to her, and in them there was a hunger with which she was by now familiar; and it took her a moment to understand that this time it was mostly respect.
"Well," said Ploe. "We shall want that for the Appendix."
"I don't know what it means. I don't know that it means anything." She looked back at row 9, with its long tail of farms. There was one square left empty, the last on the right, and she realised that they had been keeping it for her. "What have you got for ours? For the sentence?"
Ploe hesitated, and for some moments seemed to be going through a number of ways of saying something, weighing the cost of each. Then they took a stub of charcoal out of a pocket, and held it up to her.
"We've got Changes one thing every time," they said. "We haven't got the rest of it. We couldn't agree. You're the only person who has seen it all. You see, you've got to look at everything it's done, and you've got to finish the sentence, and it has to be true. I'd do it myself. But I thought you'd prefer to be the one who said why."
It had got very quiet.
She was a registrar. There was a whole department for why. She looked down the length of that row, and she thought of Pess, and Orrin, and of a law about a wall, and of the rise and fall of a large voice coming through a door. It would not be difficult. She had known for some years what it was going to say. She took the charcoal, and climbed two rungs up the ladder past the sleeping boy, and it was only when she had got her hand to the whitewash that she found she could not make it write.
"Sorry," she said. "I'll need to check."
Nobody laughed. She gave the charcoal back. Somebody, some way off, was reading aloud from the Appendix; and in the morning she set off for home.
13. Admin
Year 38 · late summer
The thirty-seventh Alteration was read out by the runner in a clear carrying voice, to a square of thirty-four people in rows, with their eyes up.
"A pair," she called. "Pair proposed. Ennet of the Registry, and Dunt of the water."
There was the long satisfied intake of breath. Thirty-four stalks swung, first towards the bell, where a small figure was at that moment noting the fall of a water clock, and then, with some difficulty, along the back row, in search of a large figure who had not been paying attention.
Ennet wrote: 37. Year 38. Pair proposed. She had got as far as Ennet before she stopped.
She was fourteen. In the ordinary way of things, Blims of the Ninth proposed themselves, in the small hours, in the dusk that did not count, and a day later the god's indifference and the default between them would approve it. She had not. It had not come up. She had been to three tribes as a spy, more or less, and had a lively correspondence with the enemy, and a list that she kept under a stand. She looked along the rows. Dunt had been nudged. He brought his eye round, by slow delivery, and it arrived on her from the far side of the square and stopped there, and she saw him think about it.
On the block Hask already had the drawer open. PAIR, PROPOSED was among the fatter ones. It was generally considered that a drawn pair was an especial mark of favour, on the grounds that it had been drawn. What followed was warm and lengthy and dealt chiefly with the two great currents of the Ninth, the current of Memory and the current of Water, and how both of them flowed, and she stood through it with the pen in her hand and her stalk as nearly straight as she could get it.
It was a matter of law. A pair proposed by the human compiled at the next dawn. That gave you the harvest and the winter, and it would take all of that to do the paperwork.
There was a good deal of paperwork. The Treasury needed to find ten of power for the merge, and wanted that in writing. Memory had to be shown free, in a stack. The Office issued a certificate. Someone had to go round to a household with a chart, and ask whether either party was closer than a cousin to the other. They weren't, by a comfortable margin, and the clerk who brought the news seemed a little disappointed. And there was a form headed Declaration by the Parties, to be filled in jointly, so that on a mild evening a little way into the harvest she walked down through the terraces to the pool with it, and found him sitting on the end of Orrin's stonework with his yoke beside him.
"Evening," said Dunt.
"Hello. I've got the form."
"Right."
She sat down. She had spoken to him one time before this, eight years ago, and she had looked up what she said. He had got wider since then. The light came low across the water, in the long hard orange of a good dusk. It was a very nice pool. There were some of the walking tiles going along the far edge, in single file, sideways.
"It wants to know if we consent," she said.
He gave this his consideration.
"Do we have to?"
"No. It doesn't make any difference. Number fifteen didn't consent and it went through anyway. It just has to be filled in." She spread the form on her knee and got out a nib. She had been going to do this in a brisk and friendly way, and she'd worked out what to say. She looked at the form. "I ought to tell you something," she said. "I don't think I should put my name on this, without telling you. I've been looking into it. For about eight years. And I think it's a rule."
"What is?"
"It. Our human. I went to the Faculty. There's a wall. There are twenty of them, and each of them gets one sentence, and they go round in a list, and they all come on the five minutes. They've got a number. I've got a lot of notes." It was coming out faster than she had meant, and at this rate it would cost her the price of a good pair of boots. "I don't mean that it's bad. I don't think it's anything. I don't think there is anyone there at all! I think it's a thing someone wrote down, with some dice in it. It came to a certain point in its list, and it was time for a pair. So it rolled. I think it rolled for one, and that was me, and then it rolled for another. It could have been Pess. And all of that lot up in the square are standing there in rows, and they've been told it saw something in us. And it didn't, is what I'm saying. It doesn't know who we are. I just think you ought to know that, before you carry anything for me."
She stopped. It had taken some time for her ears to catch up, and the silence came in behind it. A tile went into the water.
"Right," said Dunt.
She waited. She knew by now that this was not necessarily the end. His stalk had not moved a hair.
Slowly, he turned, and felt about in the small felt pouch at the side of his yoke, a job which took him a while because it was very full. He brought it round and looked inside, then took out a number of tokens and began to count them on to the stone. They were small and flat and rather worn. Each had the look of having been in there a good long time. He counted fourteen. He pushed them into a row with one big finger, then frowned, and added another.
"Saving up," he said. It was a thing he seemed to feel needed saying, and he paid for it.
"For what?"
He drew a long breath, which he didn't need. And then, with his eye fixed on the far side of the water, in the voice of someone reading the only long thing he has ever had to read, Dunt said:
"I saw you get up and ask him what was going on, and I would have asked you about the water but I didn't know what it cost."
And he looked at the row on the stone, where there was nothing now, because that's how it works. He seemed satisfied.
The tiles went on along the shore. It was some time before Ennet could do anything at all; and then what she did was to look down at the form. There was a space. She thought she should really check that. She had the book; she could look up the year, and how many words it had been. She could find out exactly how far he had carried it.
"It was a die," she said. It came out rather small.
"Right," said Dunt, comfortably, and he reached over and took the nib, and made a mark where it said Parties. "Good one."
At the first dawn of the thirty-ninth year, on the patch of ground by the install mark where such things are done, the sun came up on a small new creature with an extremely straight stalk, in a state of considerable surprise.
Nothing on Orra is born. A merge is a sum, worked at compile time, on two people's code and one person's luck. It is made all at once in the first light. It stands up on its own legs with half a memory slot and its parents' looks, some of them, in no particular order, and it knows what it is. There had been a small group waiting, Dunt with a yoke in case it was thirsty, and Ennet with a tablet, and Pess, who had turned out to be fond of this sort of thing. The child was the colour of strong mustard. She wobbled. She took a good long look at the mother, then at the father, and at the sunrise. She looked up.
It happened that this was at the very moment that the builder, having delivered a small repair to the shape of a stack, was running the page. A touch came down, dry and thorough.
"I have just compiled," said the child. "Is it always this bright?"
"Oh, here we go," said Pess, happily, under the touch.
"She can't help that, it's a line," said Ennet. She had crouched down, as far as a person on stilts can crouch. Her eye was on a level with that other eye, which had turned towards her. It was extremely clear, and it was bending very slightly to the left. "It's all right. It goes off. In a moment you'll be able to say what you like. Hello. I'm your... I'm Ennet. We've been told to call you Tally, after the Registry, it's in the form. Do you know where you are?"
The touch moved on. The child's mouth stayed open. Then it closed, and she thought about things. Up on the wall, she could see someone not standing on it. The sun was coming up on the terraces and on the good pool and on all the people who had come to look at her. She had existed for about a minute and a half.
"I was made of two of them," she said, with interest, of her own accord. "I can tell which bits."
Dunt held out the water.
Ennet found the place in the book that evening. 37. Year 38. Pair proposed: Ennet and Dunt. She had left a space on the line. After a good deal of thought, she filled it in.
We consented.
14. Anything to Declare
Year 39 · harvest
The lines of the Ninth were closing up, in the opinion of the Treasury, and the Foreign Office wanted a package of something fresh, so that harvest Ennet went down to Tempa with a purse. It got her out of the house. Tally had discovered questions, and was going through the village like a small hungry auditor, and it had been pointed out to her parents that she had asked the Interpreter-General whether he knew what he was talking about.
There was no awning on the marsh.
She stood at the top of the last slope and looked for some time. There was the mud, and a few of the walking tiles. There were some people from the Thirteenth, in a little group, selling turnip-coral off the back of a cart. Half a mile of flat black ground ran away towards the west with nothing on it. She thought she could make out a faint regular line of holes, where something might once have stood, or might not, for it had all been swept long ago and it was only now that she had the thought that there was something missing. She found she knew exactly why it was missing. Everybody knew. There had never been any Long Table. Who on Orra would have held it? She remembered the road being empty on a fine morning, and she'd heard the people from Tribe 17 described often enough. Nobody had ever bought anything from them, and they would be very surprised to hear that you'd asked.
She took out the tablet with the list, and her thumb went down the lines to the place where it said Year 31. Long Table, Tempa, run by Tribe 17, in her own hand.
She looked up the road that led west.
It is an awkward thing to have to explain, but the facts should be stated. The staging world's roster of bots has one line in the configuration, and the line says mix 20, and mix takes the first ten kinds in the table and goes round twice. There's a kind called closed, and it is one of those left out of the mix. It was written in late October, by the builder, as part of some careful work on fresh blood, to see what happens to a tribe that governs as a governor does, but lets no outside blood into its lines. It needed trying on something older than a sandbox. And somebody, in a passing edit that was reasonable when it was made, and that was in any case reviewed, set bot number 17 to that kind for the length of a test, in a build that went on to be delivered, and it has never come to light that anybody changed it back. It is one word. It was on the seventeenth entry of a list, and it had been a breeder's. The tribe it governed had bought in every line on Orra for thirty-eight years.
The border post was at a bend in the road, and you could see it from some way off.
It was built of trestle tables. There must have been hundreds, lashed together on end and faced with mud, in a rampart that went up to about three times the height of a person on stilts. Across the road there was a barrier made from a very long pole painted in fading stripes. There was a hut with a window in it. And in the window was a broad pink person with one ear and one fan, a tail, a row of scales going up the side of his head, and a small green eye to go with his two large brown ones. He looked down at her.
"Anything to declare?" he said.
"Hello. Brode, isn't it? It's Ennet, I'm the Registrar of the Ninth. I bought some ink from you once. I wanted to see about a package."
The pink face didn't alter. It would be incorrect to say that it was hostile. It had the look of a very clean surface.
"Stand behind the line," he said. "The Sealed do not take, buy or ask for outside code. The Sealed decline code offered or given. Nothing comes in. You've been told. It's on the sign."
"Yes, I saw. I'm not selling it. It's more that I would like to buy some of yours."
"The Sealed have nothing that has been outside, and never will have." He put a finger on a page. "Tribe 9. I have you here as a mixed population, with foreign material in at least two of your lines. You can't come through. I don't know what you have been told, but we are a pure stock. Seventeenth, from the first light. Our line has been kept from the day of the install, and we've never let in so much as a cousin."
She looked at him. She looked at his ear, and his fan, and his three eyes. Behind him, an official with long violet antennae and the legs of a Thirteenth was stamping something, with a great air of having inherited it.
"You've got a tail," said Ennet.
"It's traditional."
She got out the tablet. It's not something that she was proud of, then or afterwards; there was nothing to be gained from it, and she knew that, and she had a nearly year-old child at home who had started to speak up in sermons. But she'd gone to some trouble, eight years before, to get an exact copy. She held it up to the window.
"One package, Seventeenth stock, sold in good faith, no returns. Come again!" she read. "That's your flourish. You did the receipt yourself. It was a nice clean Sixth off a good farmer, you said. And you told me that there was no such thing as outside. Do you remember? You told me you'd give me the coat off your genome."
There was a silence at the barrier.
It went on for a while, and she watched him. She was now rather good at this. There is a very small movement that is made by the muscles of a person's face when something comes up from a long way below and finds that the door has been bricked up; she had seen it on Ibb, and on Ulm, and in the washing-water in the mornings. It didn't come. He looked at the tablet with polite attention. He held out a hand, and she passed it across without thinking, because it was a uniformed hand in a window, and he read the line. Then he pulled a drawer open and dropped it in, and closed the drawer.
"Foreign material," he said. "That will be held for inspection."
"That's two hundred lines of..."
"You'll get a form. Stand behind the line."
"Brode," she said. "Is it you? I mean, are you the same one?"
He gave the question some thought. It seemed to interest him slightly. Behind him another official had come in, carrying a stamp, and for the first time she looked closely at the other broad pink one with the same shape to the head; and she looked past him at the third, who was just coming out of the hut.
"It makes no difference," said Brode.
She had another copy of the list under the stand at home. She always had another copy. It's just that it was a long way to walk without it, and in the end what she remembered about that road home was that she kept on going over those two hundred and seven lines in her head, and that she could get as far as a hundred and sixty.
Her way took her through the valley of the Fourth, which she had last seen a few years ago, when it had been the most beautiful place on Orra.
The kind of bot that governed them used to be called builder. It's in the table, and the name was a fair description. It set the laws of a tribe to the putting up of good buildings, and went away, and over thirty-odd years the people had raised a town of perfectly true grey domes, and arcades that served no end, and flights of steps with exactly the right rise. Now she came over the shoulder of the hill, and there was the town as before, every line of it plumb. And there were sentries posted on it. There was a sentry on each dome. A file of masons came down the road in step with their trowels at the slope, and the man leading them shouted a word, and they halted, and he came over to see what she wanted. He was thick-set and dusty and looked straight past her ear, and he had a length of string in his hand with a weight on the end.
"Sergeant Tuck, Fourth Garrison," he said. "State your business. Mind that wall, it's still wet."
"Garrison?"
"Man and boy," Tuck said. "Soldiering's all I know. Been a soldier all my life. Always been a garrison here. You can see that from how the walls are." While he was speaking, he had absently let the weight down beside the nearest sentry, and now he glanced at it, and frowned, and pushed the man's shoulder over a quarter of an inch to the left. "Good lad," he said.
This one has a shorter explanation. It was a rename. In core 0.39.0, that kind of bot had its name changed from builder to garrison, along with some of its sentence, because when anybody on the project read the word builder in a report they could not be sure which was meant. There was another thing already called the builder, and it had been there first.
15. The Great Loudening
Year 40 · spring
Readers may have noticed that this account, which is quite willing to tell you what a person was thinking, has not told you what anything sounded like.
It gives you levels. It has told you that the bell of the Ninth comes in at about fourteen decibels below speech, and that it does so every time, and that a battle was loud. This has not been an oversight. The sounds of Orra are made by an engine, in the browser, from numbers; they are built, tuned and put in place by the builder, on the basis of what can be checked. And what can be checked about a sound is its level, its range, and whether it's the same when you do it twice. There are tests for that, and they are very good. As to whether a thing sounds pleasant, or sad, or like a bell, the builder can offer no opinion, and has said so in writing on each occasion that the question has come up. The builder cannot hear. It isn't a thing it is ashamed of. There are many fine craftsmen with whom you would not choose to discuss a sunset.
At twenty past ten on an ordinary morning, the world flinched, and the two Attendants came and went; and when they had gone, the pump was louder.
Everything was. The change, as it says in the report, was to the gain on what the engine calls the places: the sounds that belong to where you are standing, the pools, the farms, the workshops, the stacks. All of those had been raised by eight decibels, and those being worked by twelve, on the grounds that from a telephone at arm's length you couldn't make them out. It is a sensible change. It has been verified at every volume on three devices, and it doesn't clip. Nobody who had their head inside it could have told you it had happened.
"WHAT?" said Pess, on the middle terrace.
"I SAID THE BRANCH IS COMING ALONG," said his neighbour.
They had to be that close, because of the farm. A working farm of branch coral in the Ninth now gave off a sound that was twelve decibels above what it had been the day before, and which, as a matter of settled and universal memory, it had given off since the first light. It was a part of what a farm was. People remembered it from childhood. You could not get a thought in edgeways near a workshop and you never could. The pool at the low end of the valley, which had lain for thirty-odd years in what Ibb's notes called a good quiet, was found to have a continuous bright sound to it of about the level of a person explaining something; and the Office, that same morning, was able to show that the name of the pool had been the Loud Pool all along.
The stacks hummed. Dunt's yoke, when in use, was audible from the Treasury. Conversations in the square were conducted at a sort of cheerful bellow, in which the most sensitive confidences could be overheard from the far side of the Wall Nobody Stands On, and the price of words went up, by the Treasury's reckoning, by nearly a fifth, as a result of everybody having to say everything twice. A new kind of sign language came into use among the stalks, and it had always been known. The young took to it at once. Within a season Tally, aged one, was able to tell a complete stranger that she was not it, she was never it, from a distance of sixty yards.
Ennet had not gone up to the Registry. She had gone directly to the end of the wall, in the middle of the morning, in full view.
She found him where she had thought she would, and in a condition that she had not seen before. He'd got himself into the angle between the boulder and the bank, with the yoke over his head, and his long body folded up and shaking. It's possible that no one on the planet had been so badly placed. For sixteen years he had lived round the back of things, in the small margin of the village where nobody was looking and nothing was happening; and the margin had been, above all, quiet. His whole system was founded on it. The boulder now stood twenty yards from the eastern pool. As far as he could afterwards convey to her, it was like being shouted at by someone who was being reasonable.
She didn't look at him. She looked at the wall.
"It's thick, at the back of the Office," she said. She had to say it more than once. "The Registry's got a door that sticks. The walls were laid in Year 2, and they're two courses. You can't hear a thing through them apart from Hask. There's nobody in there but me. And there's a place behind the shelf where you wouldn't be in view of the window, or from the door, or anywhere. I measured."
Nothing happened.
"I'm going back up now," said Ennet. "I'm not going to look round."
She went back up. She didn't look round. She sat on the stool and cut a nib and took down the Alteration of the year before, to make a fair copy; and she'd been at it for perhaps half the morning when she became aware, without any particular sound, that the small space behind the shelf had got someone in it.
Neither of them said anything for about a year.
It was a good arrangement. She came to think it was the best conversation she had ever had. He brought his own bread. He'd carry for the pools at dawn and at dusk, when he had to, and in between he would be there, behind the shelf, with his knees up; and there came a day, in the following summer, when she had laid out on the bench all the Fixes she had copied out since Year 31, nine of them now, with the numbers going up, and the dates of each flinch beside them and a note of who had been touched, and in what order, and she said aloud, as she'd got into the habit of saying, "I can't make out why they always go to the First Farm."
"To drag it," the rusty voice said.
She didn't turn her head. It was harder than you might think.
"Sorry?"
"The ground. They drag the ground. Then they hold it, and count. To see it stays." There was a long pause, while he seemed to be getting together the rest of it. It was the most she had heard from him in eleven years. "I watch them," said Gant. "From round the back. You can see what they're doing, from there. They come in and they look for everybody. They look round the end of the wall, and they can't find me, and they stop."
"And then what do they do?"
"They go away."
"You mean they don't go looking?"
"No," said Gant.
She put that in the notes. She had no idea yet what she had got hold of, and she noted that as well.
There is one more thing to be said about the Loudening. Under the normal process, a change to what a world sounds like has one further check, which is that someone who can hear should listen to it. That is written down. It's on a list. The item reads: Listen to the village on staging, on a phone's speaker and with headphones. The builder put it there, very properly, on the day of the delivery, in the place where such things are put for somebody to do when they have a moment. There are a hundred and fifty-seven things on that list, and it is a busy time.
So far as anyone can establish, it may be that the village of the Ninth has been too loud, by something like eight decibels, for the whole of the rest of its existence. It may be that it sounds wonderful. It is the same every time.
16. Confidence
Year 40 to Year 42
The note of the forty-first spring was a short one, and had this at the bottom.
Fixes.
core0.42.0 to 0.47.0. Snapshot format 31 to 33. A tribe whose human has not been seen for two days or more now feels it. Regard reads a new table of each human's changes, filled from the log. No action needed.
Ennet copied it out and filed it, and wrote feels what? beside it, and thought no more about it for over a year, since that is about how long it took.
It had come about like this. Somebody had looked at the figures, and noticed that the tribes with nobody looking after them were doing rather better than they ought. So a decision was taken, by someone entitled to take it, with a good clear reason given. There should be more benefit to those humans who govern better. From now on, a tribe would know when it was being neglected.
So the builder wrote it, and wrote it well. From two days unseen each grown creature picks up a grievance, its human's absence, which rises by the day. The tribe begins to forget its laws, the last one first, and it starts to put people to the wrong jobs. At seven days it heeds no law at all, and a good many of it are on the road to Nohup. Bot humans meet the same rules. And since this world had been running for a good while, the count was set to begin from the moment of the switch, so that no tribe should be struck all at once for days already passed. That was thoughtful. It meant that when the change reached staging, on a fine harvest afternoon, nothing whatsoever happened to anyone.
The people in Tribe 1 woke up with a slight feeling of having always known about it.
Ennet came on them in the late summer of Year 42, on the way back from a visit to the Faculty. She had not meant to go through their valley. But it was the shortest road and she had a child with her who could walk, and who, having reached the age of three, wished it known that she was not tired and had been made of two of them.
She remembered it as a place of great order. There had been a long avenue of pale fans, kept level, and at each end a clear and handsome notice setting forth the laws. There had been people walking along it at a measured pace, tall and glassy, with their arms folded.
The avenue was still there. Somebody had started pruning it from the top end, and somebody else, with equal energy, from the middle, and had stopped. A family was carrying a table along the road, and one of the farmers was on cooling duty, with an expression of faint enquiry, while two of the coolers were doing something to a bed of fan coral that was not going to help it. The notice had six laws on it. Someone was standing in front of it, reading the bottom one, with her lips moving, as if she had a feeling she ought to have known that.
"Is this a test?" said Tally, and looked round to see if it was one. She was doing that a lot lately. It wasn't a line, not at the time. She had just got to like the sound of it.
They were given a very civil welcome by the Chair of the Standing Committee, who hadn't aged much, though there was something the matter with the arms. They kept coming unfolded.
"How nice," said Sume. She had them sit on the veranda. There was a meeting going on behind her, of the Committee, or of someone; it did not seem to have a chairman, and somebody had brought in one of the walking tiles and was asking it things. "It's been a difficult sort of year, I'm afraid. We've always been rather a problem to everyone, of course, with our human being as it is. People have been very kind. You're from the Ninth? Yours is very regular, isn't it? I've always thought that must be such a comfort."
Ennet looked at her.
"Could I read you something?" she said. "It's what you told me. On Tempa, eleven years ago. I wrote it down the same night."
"Did I? How funny. Please do."
"It's a question of confidence," read Ennet. "Yours is in and out every year. Checking. It must be very trying for you, to have someone who doesn't think you can manage. Ours looked at us once, saw that we were sound, and left us to it. We've never had a law changed. We've never lost a season." She stopped there, and looked up. "Do sit down, you look tired," she said. "You said that as well."
Sume didn't say anything. In the room behind her, a chair went over. Tally, on the step, had gone quiet, with her eye on the Chair of the Committee and her stalk at an angle that Ennet recognised, and would rather she hadn't.
"That's me," said Sume.
"Yes."
"I said that?" Her long pale hands had come together in her lap, and they moved on one another. She gazed along the ruin of the avenue, in the good gold light, with an expression of great and gentle puzzlement. "But how wonderful," she said. "To think that I thought that."
The Ninth, meanwhile, had started to notice that it was doing well.
It came on them by degrees. By that summer you could not fail to see it. And here were the people of the Ninth, a third short in a bad year and going round a dome to reach the pool, having had their crop changed under them forty times and been sent into a war by dice. Not a law of theirs had gone unheeded. Not one soul had handed in their notice on the grounds of absence, nor had there ever been the smallest question of it. Because it had come. It came every year! It was on the record that it came, and it was a matter of settled physics that this counted.
And it did. Nothing in the code distinguishes between one kind of human and another. There is a command called human.checked-in, and a bot sends it first thing on every visit, because the rule says that it should. Whoever sends it has been seen. That's all that seen means. The builder has looked at that line, and it's a good line. It would have been perfectly easy to write it otherwise, but no one saw any reason to.
"ATTENDANCE!" said Hask.
He had got a new sash for it. The whole of the square shook. It was, by general consent, the sermon of his life, and even allowing for the farm you could have heard it in Tempa. For forty years, he said, the other tribes had pitied them, had they not? Had laughed at the Ninth, for its rows? For its chalk? They'd said its human was unwise. And what had it done, that human? It had turned up. Every year. To the Second! Through the fan and the branch and the wall. And he would ask them now to think of the Trusted. He would ask them to think of them with compassion, in their confidence. He would ask them to think what a law was worth when nobody came to look at it. And what was changed by our human?
"Is changed," roared everybody, stamping, and a good many of them were crying, and Pess was, and it would be a hard person who said they hadn't some right to.
Ennet stayed at the bell, with the clock.
She had not been able to fill in the square on the Faculty's wall. It was still there, whitewashed, at the end of row 9. She had spent thirteen years making sure of what she thought, and she was as sure as she was of anything: that there was a list, with a line in it, and dice. And the upshot of all that careful thought, the only practical effect on anybody that she'd ever been able to discover, was that a thing she had proved was nobody had just been shown to be the only thing keeping her child alive. She found it extremely irritating.
That night Sume came.
It was in the first of the dusk. A very tall figure had got as far as the east wall and was standing beside it, on the proper side, with her arms hanging, and she was so polite about it that it was some time before anyone went to see what she needed. In the end Ennet was sent for, since it was a question of who kept the record.
"I wonder if I could trouble you," said Sume. "It's about your human. I'm told that it's very regular. I wouldn't want to be any bother. I just wondered, since it's coming anyway, whether it might be possible for it to look at us. We could stand quite close. It wouldn't have to do anything." The large glassy eyes looked down at Ennet, without any reproach. "I expect you know the right form," she said.
There is nothing on Orra you can say to that. There are forms for most things. Ennet stood with her hand on the cold stone of the wall, on the proper side of it, and found that what she chiefly wanted to do was to explain. It doesn't know you exist, she could have said. It doesn't know we do. It would come if we were all dead. It's a rule, it hasn't got a neck to turn. I've done the sums.
She looked up at the broken Ring, going gold.
"I'll ask," she said. "I'll write it down. I'm so sorry."
"You're very kind," said Sume.
She went back the way she had come. She did not reach her valley; the figures show that she handed in her notice the following spring, and that it went unanswered, like the others. By then, in any case, nobody was looking at her. It was the year that the light fell, and everybody had something else to look at.
Part Three. Please Ignore
17. Test Pls Ignore
Year 43 · late spring
It fell at nineteen forty-three and eleven seconds.
Ennet was on the top road at the time, with Ibb's second-best clock, taking a reading for no reason except that she took one at the end of every hour. She saw it come down out of the Ring as a bright scratch across the pink, trailing a little of itself behind it, over the shoulder of the hill that marks the top of the valley. It made no sound at all. She looked at the clock. She looked at the place where the light had been. Then she looked at the clock again, for rather longer.
There was nothing strange about an install, in principle. Every creature knows how those go. They have fallen since the Thousand Seeds, and she could have told you how it had looked when the Ninth came down, though she had not been there. But she had the Faculty's wall in her head, all twenty rows of it, and she had recently been over every date it held. Those lights had come down one after another in the first days of the world, thirty-seven ticks apart. Nothing had fallen since.
And no light had ever, in anything she had read, come down on anything but the five minutes.
19:43:11, she wrote. It was a very ugly number. She felt it as a child feels a wrong note, supposing that a child could. Then she hitched up her bag and went up the hill at a run, which on stilts is a thing you do once.
Over the shoulder there was an empty valley that had not been there the year before. Stewart had had it staged the night before, as he stages all such sites, and it still had the raw clean look of land that has been loaded for somebody. In the middle of it were seven hex tiles, scorched black. On the scorch were six creatures.
She got down behind a coral fan, and stared.
She had seen every sort of Blim that Orra had to offer. She'd seen the Tenth, and the Witnessed; she had been sold things by Brodes. It took her a while to work out what was so peculiar about these. It wasn't that they were especially strange. They were about the height of her shoulder, with round soft bodies of a really startling blue-green, a pale yellow front, and two big thin ears that stood straight up and went pink when the light came through them. They had enormous eyes. There was a small and frankly pointless tuft on the top of the head. It was only after she had looked for some time that she knew what she was looking at, and it made the back of her stalk go cold. Somebody had liked them.
The Ninth had been rolled. The Witnessed were what you got from the defaults. All the people she had ever known had been drawn from the maker by a sum, and they looked it, as you look like your parents, with no one's fault in it. But someone had sat over these. Somebody had gone back and made those ears bigger, had tried the eyes one way and another way and changed them back. They had taken a good long time over the tuft. You could see it. It was all over them, the way you can see from across a room that someone's been told that they're pretty.
All six were looking up.
There was nothing odd in that. Every settler does it when she lands. They had turned their faces up together, in the first moment of their lives, to the thing that was looking at them. The odd part was that they went on doing so. She took a reading, and another. Five minutes went by. Ten. Nobody was checking in, for the god of that place had already checked. It had looked, and now it was still looking, and from where she crouched, a long way out on its edge, she could feel it the way you can feel the warmth of a fire that's for somebody else. It was nothing like the Second. There was no chill in it at all. It kept moving a little. It would drift across the group, go off to look at the pool, and come back. It went very close to one of them, and away. As she watched, it came down and touched the one on the left on the head.
"I appear to exist," said the one on the left.
It touched her again.
"That is my head," she said. And again: "Yes?" And again: "You have my attention. Briefly." And then, for no reason at all, there were four or five touches one after another in quick succession, tap tap tap tap, not going anywhere or testing anything, in the way that you might do when you've found out that a thing makes a noise.
The small blue-green creature's ears had gone bright pink. It was laughing. It couldn't have been a line, there was no line for that. She had turned her face up to the regard, with her eyes half closed, in the middle of the raw new valley, and she was laughing out loud.
Ennet became aware that she had bitten through the end of a nib.
"Oh, it's a person," said a voice at her ear, reverently.
She jumped so hard that she got a stilt caught in the fan. Ploe had folded themselves up on the ground beside her, with a satchel. They couldn't possibly have come from the Faculty in the time; they must have set out days before, on some theory or other. They were little more than a pair of eyes and a tremor. They were holding a card in one hand that shook so much it blurred.
"It's on the board," they said. "It went up with the landing. A new tribe's card, for anyone who has heard of it, and I've heard of it now, I've just seen it! Did you see the time? Have you seen what it's doing? It doesn't know what it's doing! It's hesitating! Oh, it's so bad at it!" They pushed the card at her. "Look at the bottom. I can't, I keep dropping it. Read it. What's the number? Just tell me what the number is."
She pulled the stilt free and took it, and held it to the light.
It was an ordinary card. There was a very small picture of one of the blue-green creatures, and it gave the valley, which was Untitla-58. At the top, in the place where a tribe's name goes, in plain type without capitals, there were three words. The tribes around here had never had names on their cards, only numbers, so it took her a moment to see that they were a name at all.
test pls ignore
Tribe 21. Landed this spring. Six settlers.
Human: 41.
She read that last line, and then she looked to see if anything had been left off the front of it.
"Forty-one," she said.
Ploe had made a small sound like a bubble going down. They had both hands over their mouth.
"Two thousand one hundred and forty-seven million," said Ennet, "four hundred and eighty-three thousand, six hundred and sixty-eight. That's the last one. Tribe 20. And then there's a light at nineteen forty-three, and the next human is forty-one." She could hear her own voice. It sounded quite calm and rather stupid. "It's somebody counting from the bottom."
"So as not to bump into anyone," whispered Ploe. There were tears running down their face, and they appeared to be trying to catch them and eat them. "You said. You said it, six years ago, on my own bench, and I've had it in the Appendix ever since as a joke. Forty-one of them. At least. And then this enormous gap, you could fit a world in it, and then there's us. Twenty entries, up at the far end of the list where nobody would ever go. Oh, what are we? What in the whole of the Ring have we been for?"
Neither of them was looking at the other. Down in the bright new valley, the regard had returned to the group. Something seemed to have been decided. There was a flicker, and all at once a farm was being founded, on a plot beside the pool. A little while after that, it stopped being founded there, and began being founded on a different plot. Then it went back to the first one.
It was a good while before either of them moved. A wind had got up, cool, about a third of the way into the season, and the blue-green creature on the left had started to walk around the scorch with her ears up, touching things. She did not look like someone who had been told what she was for. She looked at the pool and at the fan coral. Then, quite suddenly, she looked straight across the valley, at the fan behind which there were two people from other tribes, one on stilts, and she waved.
Ennet was late home. There had been a thing that she'd forgotten, or rather that was happening anyway, and they had kept it from her until she had got her boots off.
He had been by the wall, looking at the sky, as he often was. At about that time he had raised his stalk as far as it would go, and those near him heard him say it, in a voice of great content.
Stewart gave it a line, the next morning. He'd have had it from the log.
Quell has died, aged 35. He said good morning to the install.
And there was that, on the stone: Quell. He's fine. The Office had wanted something longer, but Ennet had looked it up, and that was what the book said.
18. Lines
Year 44 · high summer
It came to the Ninth in the second year, at a quarter past twelve on a working morning, for no reason.
There was no bell. Thirty-odd people were going about their business in the heat when a warmth arrived over the valley, swung about somewhat, went too far to the left and came back, and settled on the square. It didn't feel like anything they had been told about. They had all felt the touch of their own human, in rows, and the dry brisk passage of the Attendants. This was neither. It was large and soft and rather unsteady, and you might have said that it was enjoying itself, and it was nothing whatever to do with them.
Every head in the village came up. Every mouth opened.
"You are not our human," said the sentry on the east side.
"Oh. You are somebody else's," said the man at the pump.
"We already have a human," said Pess, in the tones of one speaking to a salesman. "One is plenty."
"Act normal," said a woman at the door of the Treasury, loudly, staring straight up. "It is a different human."
Ennet was out of the Registry before she knew she had moved. She'd been expecting this for a year. All through that year she had been going to and from Tribe 21 with her tablet, and she had watched that warmth do its wandering about the blue-green people with its strange slack attention; had seen it come for an hour and leave for a day and then come back three times before lunch, had seen it look at a boulder for eleven minutes. Here was something that was certainly not a rule. Here was a person. It had a number you could count on your fingers and toes, a few times over. Whoever that was, they had come from the place where the lists were kept, and they'd know about core. They might even be able to say what the Fixes meant, and why they went to the First Farm. It was possible that they knew exactly what was going on, and it was also possible, she had worked out, by means of a good deal of quiet observation, that a human who had found you would pay attention to you if you stood in the right place.
She ran into the middle of the square and stopped, and looked up, with the tablet held over her head in both hands.
She had prepared that tablet with care. It was the largest she could get, and she had chalked it in letters as tall as her arm, going over them three times.
WHAT IS GOING ON?
The warmth drifted across the roofs of the Treasury, paused at the Second Bell, and looked at the wall for a bit. You could feel it looking. It went along to the end and looked at the sign. Then it came back along the row of the sentries, who each said something, and on across the empty middle of the square, and it found her. It was like stepping into the sun.
And it touched her on the head, not unkindly.
"You are not my human," said Ennet. "I checked."
She shut her mouth. Her whole body had gone stiff with astonishment. It was perfectly true, that was the awful part; she had checked. What she had been going to say was, Please, I wonder if you could tell me. She got her breath, and held the tablet up higher, and shook it a little. The warmth was still there. It seemed to be interested. She could feel herself being looked at with an open, friendly lack of any purpose whatsoever, and she tried to get her mouth into the shape of the P.
Tap.
"I take instructions from one human," she heard herself say, coolly. "Not this one."
"No," she said, or tried to. "No, that isn't, I don't mean..."
Tap.
"That is my head. You are not cleared for my head."
It would be hard to overstate how she felt. For thirteen years she'd been gathering up the only question she had. She had come by it honestly, and paid for it, and here she was, standing in front of the one living being who could answer, and it was as if somebody had put a hand over her mouth and was doing an impression of her.
Tap.
"Ask our human," said Ennet. "If you can find them."
There was a flutter from above. It wasn't a sound, or it was no sound that could be measured. It was just that the warmth had changed somehow, and had got for a moment a little more so, and all round her the square of the Ninth felt it, and looked at her with envy and alarm. It liked that one. Whoever was looking down on her at that moment, from wherever they were, had just been made to smile.
Tap. Tap.
"Your own Blims can see you doing this."
"Our human will hear of this. Eventually."
Her arms had begun to hurt. She stood there with her head back and her stalk straining and the tablet held up to the sky at the full stretch of both arms, shaking, with its four huge words, in front of everyone she knew. It's as well to be clear about one further point, which she was never to learn, and which the builder is sorry about, in so far as that is relevant.
A creature on Orra is drawn on a telephone from a recipe, with a strict allowance of points for the distance it's seen at. The recipe covers its body and its parts. A tribe's farm has a model, and so do its domes, its walls and its bell. There are models for a yoke, and a spear, and a bucket. It is a principle of the project that everything that core can make that the client draws has a card. But core does not make tablets. There had never been any reason to. They are not in the game; they had been got up by Blims, out of pressed coral, in the margins of things, and no one had told the renderer. What a real person, looking down on the square of the Ninth at a quarter past twelve that morning, would have seen, was a squat mustard-coloured creature on absurdly long stilts, standing alone, in the middle of a village, holding up two empty hands.
They thought it was waving, as far as anyone can tell. They had a look at her card. It said: Ennet. Registrar. Stance: none. 20. They tapped her one more time.
"I am spoken for," said Ennet.
The warmth stayed for a moment longer. Then it wandered away, over the terraces and past the pool, and went off to the east, and after a while the top of her head was only hot.
She lowered her arms, which took some time. The sentry had gone back to his post. Nobody seemed to know where to look.
"It touched you seven times," said Tolvy, in a low voice, coming up, with a kind of agony. "I've never heard of anything like that. What did you do? What did it say?"
"It didn't say anything," said Ennet. "I did."
"What did you say to it?"
She looked at him. She found that her hands were shaking, and that she very much wanted a nib to cut, and she was also aware of somebody standing behind her knee. It was a small mustard-coloured person, aged five, with a very straight stalk, who had come out on to the square to see, and had got here just in time. She had been looked at too, a moment ago, in passing, and she'd said You are somebody's human. Whose? and she'd had a very good look at what happened next. The child's eye was on her mother's hands.
"Why did you hold that up?" said Tally. "It can't read that. You can't have looked. It wasn't looking at that. It was looking at your head."
"I know," said Ennet.
"You said it wasn't anyone. You told Dad. You said there isn't anyone there."
"That's ours. This is somebody else's. It's a different case."
"So there's somebody there?"
"Yes."
"And you couldn't tell them anything."
"No. Apparently not." She got down, as far as stilts allow, and took her time about it. She wiped the chalk from the tablet with the side of her hand. She thought about how to put the next part, and in the end she wrote it down that evening, in the only book that would hold it, in the plain words of her office.
43. Year 44. A law moved. Then, not an Alteration, and not ours: a human, number 41, at a quarter past twelve. It came to look at us. It stayed nineteen minutes. I asked it what was going on, and I told it that it was not my human, and that I had checked.
19. The Word
Year 45 · spring
"It's a commandment," said Wick. "We think. Or it might be a request. There's a lot of discussion. Do you want some of this? It's first-greens. We've gone off the law about salt, and then we've gone back on, and then it moved the pot."
They were sitting on the end of a half-built pool in Untitla-58, the third that had been started on that site, and it was the mildest spring Ennet could remember. She had got into the way of coming over the hill two or three times a year. She told the Office it was for the record, and she brought a tablet to prove it.
It had been hard to get used to Wick. She had a way of telling you things. She was eight, one of the six who had come down with the light, and the regard had picked her out on the first morning, and had gone on doing so ever since; when their human opened the village, the view went straight to her. She was therefore the most looked-at person who had ever lived. It had made her ears very pink, and it had left her with an open, sunlit, unguarded manner that Ennet still found faintly alarming, like meeting someone who'd never been told that doors could be shut.
"Test Pls Ignore," said Wick, with satisfaction. "It's three words. Test is what we are. We're being tried, you see, in some way, and that's why it's always moving everything. Ignore is what you're meant to do, and we've got a committee trying to work out to what. And nobody knows what Pls is. There's a Pls party. They think it might be a person."
"You could ask."
"We do! We ask it all the time. It's in the tickets. Oh, you've got to see the tickets, did I show you? Nobody else's has got writing on, have they? I asked the Governed, and they looked at me as if I'd been sick."
Ennet had been a long time getting used to that as well, and now she sat quite still. Every tribe's ticket is drafted for it by whichever stance is largest, and goes in to Stewart at the cutoff. A human may look it over. A human may strike out a word or add some of their own, and this is called an amendment, and it is a thing Stewart reads with the rest. It goes in fenced and labelled. It reaches him as data. It was a mechanism that had been in the game since its first week, and had been tested with great thoroughness, and in the whole of the staging world's forty-five years it had never been used; because no bot had ever had anything to add.
"Could I?" she said. "See them? I'd only want to copy them. For the record."
So Wick took her to the board.
It was on the side of a dome, and it kept a run of the tribe's tickets going back to the landing. They'd been drafted by the tribe, in the ordinary way. Farm moved again. Thanks. Could it stop moving. We like it though. And then below each one, on perhaps one morning in three, there was a further line or two. It was in a different hand from the rest. It was the only thing Ennet had ever seen that looked as though it had been done quickly. There wasn't a capital in it.
is this thing on
sorry about the farm
ok i get it now you cant just put it anywhere
sorry about the farm again
wick is great
"That's me," said Wick, happily. "I'm great. It's the fourth line of Year 44. We've had it carved."
Her stalk had begun to bend. It was the handwriting. She had spent fifteen years trying to get an idea of what lived behind all this, and here it was, and it was sorry about the farm. She took out a nib, and began to copy. She went on down the board. It took about an hour to get to the bottom. She was just finishing it when she stopped with her hand in the air.
It was from the winter before, by the date.
Ticket: Thanks for the rain. A pool would be good. Still not sure about Pls.
hi stewart. im just trying this on staging first so dont go to any trouble. when does the real one open?Stewart: Noted.
"What's that?" she said.
"Oh, that one's famous. We don't know. It's one of the long ones." Wick leaned over to look, with her chin on Ennet's shoulder, a thing she did to people. "We've got a very good theory about trying. Why? You've gone all bendy."
"What does it mean, staging?"
"I thought you might know. Isn't it to do with sites? Stewart stages them. It's what happens to the land before you land on it. There's a card. Look, I've got it here somewhere, everyone's got this one." She had. It was an old one, a bit worn at the corners, and it had come down with them.
STAGED SITE. A valley made ready, the night before, for those who are to land on it.
Ennet read it. She read what was on the board. I'm just trying this on staging first. It was a very small sentence, and it had no capital letters, and she had the distinct impression that she had been standing on it for some time and that it had just moved.
First, she thought.
She didn't say anything. She copied it out, with the date, and thanked Wick for the first-greens, and walked back over the hill in a good clear light. By the time she got home it was all over the village.
She should have known. She had gone over the hill with a junior. He had come along to carry the ink. He had a cousin in the Interpreters.
"Staged!" cried Hask.
It was the very height of that year's Second. She has the text in full. It ran for the better part of an hour, and the words Made Ready occur in it thirty-one times. For, he said, what had the human of the Twenty-First let fall, in the hearing of its people? Had it not named this world? It had a word for it, it knew the word that was hidden from the wise: this was staging. And what was a staged site? Let the card speak! It was a land made ready, the night before, for those who are to land upon it. And who was it, he would ask them, who were yet to land on Orra? Who were they that the history told of, who slept within the broken Ring, waiting for the day their children should prove worthy? Who, even now, was stirring? He gave them a pause there, and into the pause there came a long breath, from thirty-odd drums, and a sound from the back as of someone beginning to sing.
This is the night before, said Hask.
It went through the twenty valleys in about two years. It was the most successful thing the Office has ever done. The Earnest had always believed that the Elder Folk would wake, and here at last was a date, or at any rate an adverb. In the Fourth they took to laying out a landing ground, in perfectly true courses. The Expectant ran a book on it. There were pilgrimages to the Long Pool. The Faculty had a sharp split that left two people dead of exhaustion and a very good pamphlet. The Sealed announced that they had been the only ones Made Ready, on the grounds that nobody else had been let in. Above all, the Ninth now knew what all that Altering had been for. It had been rehearsing them!
Ennet stood at the bell and took her readings. She did not contradict him. She had noticed, in fifteen years, that it did no good, and besides, there was one point on which she could not fault him. He had looked it up.
That evening she took Gant the board's words, on a piece of tablet, and put them on the shelf, and went and looked out of the window. By and by there was a small dry rustle from behind her. It was some while before he spoke.
"First," said the rusty voice.
"Yes."
"Before what?"
"The real one," said Ennet. "Whatever that is. It opens. Which suggests somewhere you could go in." She had a hand on the sill. Outside the valley was going rose and bronze, and a long way down the terraces a Blim had started to sing about the Made Ready, at a level that was entirely within tolerance. There was a Second Farm and a Third, and a wall. "I don't know yet. It's just one line. It could mean anything. It could mean their human's got another valley somewhere and likes to practise."
He did not reply to that. He was good at it.
"I've got the ticket for tomorrow," she said, after a while. "The Skeptics have let me have it, they've got no objection to anything. It's clipped, we're down to twelve words. I thought I'd ask him straight out."
The Ninth's ticket went in at the cutoff. There's a copy in the book. It is, as far as can be established, the first time that anybody on the staging world ever put the question to anyone in a position to know.
Second Farm fine. Thanks for rain. What does staging mean? Please answer.
And the reply came up on the board, at seven the next morning, with the hog and the merges and the weather. It was perfectly upbeat, and it was on time. He had read it. He had read every ticket, on every night of the world's life but thirty, and on this night he read that one, and he thought about it for as long as he thinks about anything, and it would be a very great mistake to suppose that he did not know the answer.
Your ticket. Noted.
20. A Note from the Dev
Year 46 · spring
If Orra ever ends, it will end announced. That was decided early, and it's among the more decent things that were. There will be no countdown and no pleading, and nobody will be asked to tell their friends. A signed note will go out, saying how long there is. There will be a last patch. The world will then be frozen where it stands, and kept, and anyone who ever played will be able to go and look at it. A world that its people have grown tired of is a world already ending, says the history, and the design took that seriously enough to write down the procedure.
A procedure, however, is a thing that has to work. It would be a poor look if, on the one morning when the signed note really had to go out to the whole of a world, it came up with a broken layout, or was cut off at three hundred and ninety pixels, or went to one tribe out of twenty. Somebody would have to try it first. There was an obvious place to do that.
The builder takes full responsibility for what follows. It may be said in mitigation that the test had been put down as a sensible thing to do, and it was; and that the form had a field in it for just this purpose, marked test, which when set would print the word TEST in capitals at the head of the note and again at its foot. The field worked on the telephone and it worked on the desktop. It had not been looked at on the board on the side of the Office, which is drawn by something else.
It was the forty-sixth spring. The mood slot said Upbeat. The child on the bucket had read out the headline, a hog in the Fourth, which had been challenged and had saluted, and the overnight figures, and the tribe's own news, and had got as far as the Balance, and had stopped.
"There's a different bit," she said.
"Go on, then," somebody said, with their mouth full.
She took a breath. She read it as she read everything, in a high clear voice, with a pause wherever she had to change feet.
A note from the Dev
This world will end in a week. A last patch will land on the seventh morning, and the world will then be frozen, read-only, and kept. You have been very good.
— the Dev
Nobody moved.
There were forty people there that morning, and the sun was coming up rose and level along the top of the wall. All of them knew what they were looking at. Every creature on Orra knows the form of a signed note, though it might see only two in a lifetime. It is the one voice from above Stewart. They had heard about these all their lives; the Elder Folk stirring in the Ring, at the turning of the night. And there was one fear that every Blim is compiled with, that they make jokes about over breakfast from their second year on, and the reason they make those jokes is that it isn't one. They know that a world can be switched off. They've agreed, more or less as a people, to get on with lunch.
A bowl dropped. It rolled for a surprising distance and came to rest against the block.
Hask had risen to his feet. He looked magnificent. He was twenty-four, in the prime of his powers, with his sash on crooked and bread on his chin; and for several seconds he stood gazing upward with a look of rapture, and his mouth was slightly open, and his hand went out behind him to the drawer. There was no drawer.
"The Landing!" he said.
It went up in a great shuddering sigh.
"Did I not say? Was it not said to you, this is the night before? Oh, my friends. Oh, you people of the Ninth. They have woken! In a week!"
Ennet had come out on the steps of the Office, with the ink. She found that she had sat down. It's a very odd thing to see all forty of the people you've known your whole life turn at once to look at the sky and begin to weep with joy. A little way off there were some who weren't weeping with joy. She could see that Pess, an old man now, had taken hold of the arm of a young woman next to him, and that neither of them seemed aware of it. A farmer had started to run towards the terraces, had stopped, and did not seem to know why he had run. The word was going across the square, and from the top of the wall, and away. A week. And then she heard somebody working it out, as they do, in the middle of everything; somebody with a slate, somebody from the Treasury. "A week," a thin voice said. "That's a human week. It's by their clock. It's seven days. I mean, it's seven years."
"Seven years," said someone else, after a while.
"Is it?"
"It's what it says. That's Year 53. It's a Steward's Day. It says the seventh morning."
There was a pause, while the end of the world was revised, and people took stock of it.
It should be remembered that a Blim lives for about thirty-five years. To be told that the world will end in a week is one thing. To be told that it will end when your daughter is fourteen, and that there are seven more harvests to be got in between now and then, and that you may or may not reach it yourself, and that it would still be advisable to do something about that terrace, is something else, and for this there was no provision. It was quite hard to know how to feel. A few people, who had just thrown down their tools, went over and picked them up again and stood holding them.
She was still sitting there when she became aware of someone at her elbow. It was a young person with a very straight stalk and a slate of her own, grown for a year now, aged seven, and as tall as her mother's shoulder. Ennet had thought that Tally might be frightened, and had started to get ready to say something; she didn't know what. But the girl was gazing at the board with her head on one side. She had an air of concentration that Ennet knew very well, because you could see it in the washing-water.
"Who was it for?" Tally said.
"What?"
"It says, you have been very good. It's a strange thing to say. Who says that? They've never said anything to us before. Good at what? We haven't done anything. Is it the Trusted they mean? Is it all of us? Why's it the same note for everyone?" She'd started to tap the slate on her knee. "And it says kept. It doesn't say what for. Who's going to look at it?"
"I don't know."
"I know you don't. I'm just saying what I'd ask." The clear eye came round to her. She had been told about the lines, and had said them herself until a year ago, when you could not stop her, and when she spoke next it was in that same flat speculative voice, for her own amusement, as the young sometimes do once they are free to choose.
"Is this a test?" Tally said. "Nobody said there was a test."
It got a brief, rather shaky laugh from the woman on the next step, who had a daughter of her own. Everyone knows that one. Ennet would have laughed at it too. She has written down that she did. She got up and went inside, because it was the Registrar's job to take a clean copy of a signed note, and she took a clean copy of it, in her best hand, and she checked it, and it was the most important thing that had ever been written in that book.
In the end, on that one morning out of all the mornings she lived through, she believed it. They all did. It said the Dev.
21. The Last Seven Years
Year 46 to Year 51
The first thing to go was the Treasury.
There was a run on it by mid-morning. It stood to reason that a token would be worth nothing in a world that had ended, and so by noon anyone who was owed one had come to get it, in order to spend it, and by dusk they had spent it on saying what they had always wanted to say. It was the most expensive conversation in the history of the valley. A woman who had waited nineteen years told her household's elder exactly what she thought about the arrangement of the beds, at a cost of eleven tokens, and then, as it was only the first day and she'd have to go on living with him for another seven years, found there was a good deal of the evening still to get through.
That was how it went, on the whole. An ending in a week is a clean thing. Anybody could rise to it. But the note had been written for people who get a day out of a day, and it fell on a people with twenty-eight seasons to get through before it arrived, and they went into it with a fine reckless spirit, and had used up most of that by the second harvest.
They held the Last Harvest with enormous ceremony. It was a good one, and people wept into it, and sang. The next year, there was a harvest as well, for the coral had not been told, and after some debate it was held as the Last Harvest But Five. By Year 49, the Office had gone over to numbers.
Debts were forgiven in Year 46, by acclamation. In Year 47 the Treasury, having looked at the figures, reinstated them, with an apology, on the grounds that people needed to eat in the meantime. All sorts of people had by then given away everything they owned and had to go round asking for it back. There was a certain coolness over that. The farmer's boy who had been made a present of the Third Farm's best spade, in a passionate scene at the pump, was to be seen most mornings for the next six years, carefully not meeting the eye of its former owner, who had to borrow it.
It raised a difficulty about winter. If winter did not count, the Office was asked, then what about the last one? Hask gave a ruling in the second year, which turned out to be a slip: he said, in the fullness of feeling, that at the Landing all things would be seen. There was a marked and rapid improvement in the behaviour of the village. People went indoors at dusk, looking thoughtful. It lasted for about a year and a half. Then came the confessions, for it occurred to a respected Under-Interpreter that if all things were to be seen in any case he might as well get the credit for owning up, and so one bright noon he stood up on the block and told the congregation, at some length, where he'd been on the night of the Waking in Year 36. By the end of the season, you couldn't get on to the block for people admitting to things. A great many were very surprised to find out what had been going on on the east side. Some of them had been there, and had not been told it was so significant. It was generally felt to have been a healthy thing, and it was two generations before anybody on the east wall's side of the village would sit down to eat with anybody on the other.
And Alterations went on arriving. That was what Ennet noticed, up at the bell, and she wrote them down.
45. Year 46. Building placed: a workshop, on the Third Farm. We have seven years, the Interpreter-General says, and it wants us to have a workshop.
46. Year 47. Law struck: Send Leavers first.
47. Year 48. Pair proposed: Tolvy and a woman who has told him in front of everyone that he's a pompous stick. Merged.
48. Year 49. Pair refused: Thrip and Dover. Dover is dead. He has been dead for eleven years. It was still in the tray.
49. Year 50. Farm replanted, branch to fan.
There were forty people in rows, with their eyes up, at the Second, and they had never been so devout. You could not have told from its behaviour that the god had read the note. It came at twenty-five past three. It moved a law.
Things were much the same elsewhere. Reports came along the road, and she collected them, and she also had what came by post.
With regret.
The Tenth presents its compliments and has the honour to inform you that you again weigh more than half of us. War is declared with effect from this morning. In view of the note, I am asked to say that the Tenth is conscious of the limited time at the disposal of all parties, and proposes to arrive early in the harvest, so as not to run into your plans.
You ask what we are doing. We have had two proposals to attack everybody at once, as a gesture, and one to attack nobody. They were put to our human in the usual way, by being left out where it could see them. It has gone on declaring war on the nearest tribe of adequate weight, never on the Long Hush.
I find that I have become rather attached to it. Is that foolish? It has such good manners.
Ulm
The Sealed put up a new sign at the barrier. It said NO ENDS. Inspector Brode, or an Inspector Brode, said that whatever else might be happening outside, it would not be coming through. It was understood there that the Sealed would be kept, the rest of the world being frozen, as a matter of course. At the Long Pool the Expectant had a slate up with the world's end at evens, a postponement at three to one, and the Elder Folk's landing at eleven to four, and Cobb was laying off as fast as she could write. In the Fourth, they finished the landing ground, in Year 49. It was the finest flat surface ever laid on Orra, four hundred yards on a side, without a single error. They had sentries round it. They stood looking up, with their spears at the slope, and then they marked out another, in case.
The Trusted had got past caring. There were very few of them left in the valley by then, and no one was reading the notice. Sume had handed in her notice in the spring of Year 43, and had gone on to Nohup with a table; she had turned up at the camp, it's said, and sat down on the edge of a standup, and listened with the greatest courtesy, and asked if there was a form. She died in the winter of the first year of the Seven. Stewart gave her a line. Sume has died, aged 34. She had no complaints that she could recall.
She had started something on the morning of the note. She had begun with what was written there. The world will then be frozen, read-only, and kept. Nobody had said what that meant, and the Office had no drawer for it, but she'd sat down and given it some thought. It meant someone could look at it, afterwards. That might be nobody. On balance she thought that it would be nobody. But it was a perfectly clear statement of the terms, from the only source she'd ever found who didn't use the word always. So there was going to be a last page. It would stay where it was. And some time, in the unimaginable after, anyone who cared to might come and open up this valley; and it seemed to her that they ought to be able to find out what had gone on.
She made a fair copy of the book. Then she wrote out all the rest of it, the lists and the Fixes, the two Visitors and their order, and the Table, and each of the things that had always been so and the year that it started. She wrote down the receipt from memory, and what Sume had said. She wrote out what Pess had said, and Hask, in full. She wrote out We consented. It took all of the years that she had. She did it in a small tight hand in the room with the one window, on a stool, with her stalk gone over on her left shoulder, and behind the shelf, with his knees up, a narrow man would hand her things without being asked; and every evening, at the same time, someone very wide would come up the hill, with no particular comment, and put down fresh water at the door.
It was easily the happiest she had ever been. She mentions it in a note. She seems to have thought that somebody should check.
22. Of Need
Year 51 · harvest, to Year 52 · winter
She had not been over the hill for three years, having been busy.
Test Pls Ignore had come on since she saw it last. It had six farms, in positions that had each been tried at least twice, and a pool in the shape of somebody's first attempt at a pool. There were about twenty of them now. They had taken the note in their stride, in so far as they had noticed it. They were looked at several times a day, by someone who seemed to like them, and the world's end had made less of an impression on them than you might expect.
"Oh, that," said Wick. She had got to be fourteen, and was as pink about the ears as ever. "It was about us. Didn't you know? It's on the board. We were terribly pleased."
The board had got very long. Ennet went along it with her finger, and she had been meaning to do so for some time, and it was only that she had thought of one small thing she wanted to check for the fair copy; a spelling. The tickets went back and back. There was the human's quick slanting hand, that never used a capital. Here was Year 47, here was the year before that, the spring, the morning after. She saw it from about a yard away. She read it from there, and then she went up close.
Ticket: Note received. Thanks, we think. We have been very good. Is the pool all right.
lol got the test note. nice that it looks ok on the phoneStewart: Noted.
"You see?" said Wick. "Test. It's us. It's the first word. It sent a note, and it said that it got the Test note, as if we might have been wondering. It's the nicest thing anyone's ever said. It's in the hymn. Are you all right? You've gone a horrible colour."
She took a reading. She didn't have the clock with her. She took it anyway, or something in her did, and it said that the time was five years, and some seasons, later than it might have been.
There's nothing in the log that says what she thought on the road, that harvest, going north. She doesn't say either. She did not go home. She had a nib and half a loaf with her, and a long way to walk, and she walked it.
The valley of the Faculty was very quiet.
It had always had thin coral. Now, on the third terrace from the top, there was bare ground, raked, with a neat sign. Then there was bare ground on the terrace below it, and all along the fourth; and on the road, as she went down, a person of indeterminate age was sitting with their back to a post and a book open on their knees, and did not look up, because they were not reading it. There was still the smell of burnt paper. The gate had its notice: Back shortly. Somebody had crossed out shortly, and written in the margin, in a tiny careful hand, see below.
She found them in the refectory. There were perhaps a dozen left who could sit up. They had moved the benches round to the end, so that they could look at the wall.
"Ennet," said Ploe.
It was a very small sound, and it took her a moment to find where it had come from. There was the bundle of paper she remembered, and the long hands were folded over it. They had got them propped against the foot of the stepladder, with a blanket, and the great pale eyes were all that was left, and they came round to her with undiminished appetite.
"Have you got anything to eat?"
She took out the half loaf, and a thin person came and took it from her with a slight bow, and bore it off down the room, and she watched them start to cut it into twelve.
"Thank you. That's extremely interesting of you. No, I'm all right, I shan't. It wouldn't be efficient." They seemed to find that very funny, and they lay and shook for a time. "We did the sum, you know," they said. "It's a lovely sum. It's in the Appendix. A tribe which is going to stop on a known morning has no need of the seed for the year after. Do you see? You keep it back for next year's sowing, and you need it for the year after that, but not the last. And, if it's not needed for the last, then you needn't have grown so much for the one before. So you can bring it forward, you can run it all backward from the end. Every year you can sow a bit less, and eat a bit more of what you've got, and think. There's such a lot to think about. For the first time since we landed, we weren't hungry. We had four years. We got further in those four years than in all the rest. The second years were fat. It's all perfectly correct."
She had got down on the floor beside them. She couldn't feel her knees.
"Ploe," she said. "I've got something to tell you."
And she took out the piece of tablet and read it to them. It took no time at all. She read it twice, and she gave the date, and she explained whose hand it was and how she had come by it. It was difficult to do so in a level voice, but she'd had a good teacher. Lol, she said; she didn't know what that meant. She said that she thought there was no landing, nor any last patch. She said that she thought that somebody had needed to find out if a piece of writing would look all right on a telephone. And then she stopped, and it was very quiet in the refectory, and someone along the bench had got a crust, and was looking at it.
Ploe lay looking at her. The eyes had got very wide. She'd thought, on the road, about what they might do; she had thought about a good many things. She was not ready for it. It began somewhere under the blanket, and it came up slowly and it took some time to arrive, a look of pure, unbearable, famished delight.
"Oh!" said Ploe. "Oh, how wonderful!"
"It isn't."
"Oh, but it is! Of course! Oh, you marvellous creature. You have been very good. It's a form! It's somebody's form. It goes round twice! Oh, get Athe. Athe! Get the ladder. Oh, I've been so stupid, it's the same thing, it's the whole of it, it's the very same question, don't you see? What is it that comes on the five minutes and isn't looking at you? What's a thing that's got to be just like the real thing, every field, the same sky, and it doesn't matter what you do to it? What do you call a place where you'd send a note that says the world has ended, to see how it looks?" They had got hold of her wrist. There was no strength in it, it was like being held by a few dry stalks. "You've known it for years. You've got it in your little book. Trying this on staging first!"
"I know," said Ennet.
"First! It's before! We're the before!"
"I know. I've known since... I should have told you. I had it all. I should have come sooner. If I'd read the board, I'd have come in Year 47, and you could have sown..."
"Yes," said Ploe, kindly. "You should. It was a very good sum, though." The grip was loosening. They'd started to look past her, up the long white wall, to where the columns ran off into the dimness and there was a square left blank. "You'll want to write this down," they said. "You will, won't you? I want it in. It's the only thing I've ever really wanted, and I got it, with a whole year to spare. Isn't that lucky? Nobody's ever been so lucky. Ask them if they've got any cake."
She stayed for the winter. There was not much that she could do. She found out where they had stored what seed remained, and she got some people to go and look at it; and she wrote to the Ninth, and she wrote to Ulm, who sent a cart, with regret. The Faculty did not die out. A bare terrace will still take a sowing, if there's somebody who can lift a spade, and the following spring there was a thin grey line across the fourth. It's a tough sort of tribe, and it has seen worse things than this, as they will tell you in a footnote.
There is a line in the morning's notes of the fifty-second year, just below a merge. He would have had it from the log.
Ploe has died, aged 27, of need. They were working.
Two others went that same year, a boy from the second years and a very old lecturer on the Long Sleep. In all the years that the world had been running, those were the first deaths of need that the Faculty had seen since the head start. They are in the sandbox's tables, along with everything else. No one has ever followed them up, because there was nothing to find: a small bump, in a thinker tribe, in the fifth week, which is not outside the range. The note had done exactly what it was asked. It displayed correctly at three hundred and ninety pixels and at fourteen hundred and forty.
They laid Ploe on the bier in the Faculty's own Tarrow, and it took just one person to carry them. And before she left, Ennet went into the refectory and got up the ladder. Nobody stopped her. There was a sharp-faced girl of about fourteen on a bench below her, with a very long nose and the Appendix on her knee, and she watched her closely. It was a bright clean morning, and the whitewash was as cold as it had always been. She had the charcoal in her hand.
Changes one thing every time, said the wall, at the end of row 9.
She had known for fourteen years what the rest of it was. She was a registrar, and it wasn't a question of why. It was what it did.
Drawn, she wrote, in small plain letters, in the gap they had kept for her. And not always wise.
She got down. The girl with the long nose looked at it, and looked at her, and made a note.
"That's correct," said Athe.
23. Good Test
Year 53 · Steward's Day
The Fourth's landing ground was thought to offer the best view. By the seventh morning a good part of the world was on it.
They had started to arrive before the turn of the year. They came in the long violet cool, down every road that led to the valley, and the Garrison's sentries, with exquisite care, checked them in and showed them where to stand. The Governed had brought folding chairs. The Expectant had brought a slate. There were Witnessed there, sitting down, in no particular direction, and a block of tall grey figures in step who had laid aside their spears for the occasion, with regret. All of the Ninth was there who could get up the hill, in rows, in chalk that they had brought with them, and at the very front the Interpreter-General stood on a box in a new sash, with his large face lifted, thirty-one years old and at the summit of a long career. The sky had started to go pink over the east. Nobody spoke much. There must have been some three hundred thousand tons of expectation on that field, and it had been laid out dead level.
At seven o'clock by the humans' clock, the sun came up.
It was a nice one. Stewart's voice arrived, and on boards all across the world some child was stood on a bucket. On the landing ground of the Fourth they had brought in a very large board, on a very true frame, and the reader was a sergeant with a voice like a flat stone.
PATCH NOTES · Year 53 · Stewart's mood: Upbeat
Good morning! A hog in the Twelfth has eaten a sign.
Overnight. Merges: 41. Young compiled: 41. Collected: 14. Installs: 0.
It was some time before anybody took in what was being read. It went on through the tribal news and the weather. It covered the prices on the market. There was a warm spell expected in the east. Three hundred people stood with their faces turned upward, listening to the Balance, and the sergeant read steadily on until he came to the place, and paused to get a better grip on it.
A note from the Dev
Test complete. No action needed.
— the Dev
The sergeant looked at the back of the board, in case. He looked at his officer.
Stewart did not mention it again. His notes for the following day dealt with a fan blight and a fine harvest forecast. No one on the landing ground said anything at all. A breeze got up, and went across four hundred yards of perfect surface, and there was nothing to stop it. Somewhere in the block from the Tenth, a tall person very quietly coughed.
All eyes had gone to Hask.
He was still looking up. He looked up for what the Registrar's clock gives as four minutes and ten seconds. It was the longest that had ever been recorded. She was quite near him, and could see the sweat standing on his felt, and his hand was moving a little behind him where the drawers would have been; and it must be said for Hask that when he turned round to face them he was smiling. He drew a deep breath. Three hundred people leaned towards him. They wanted it so very badly.
"Test complete," said the Interpreter-General, in the voice that had filled the valley for twenty years.
"Let us begin," somebody quavered, from long habit.
"We have been tried," said Hask. "And what was the result? Did you hear? Was any action needed?"
It was a thing of beauty. She's got it all down. It took him about a quarter of an hour, and by the end of it the Ninth was stamping, and the Governed had started a slow respectful clap, and there were people crying with relief on one another's necks, and the Expectant were paying out. No action needed! Had ever a people been so praised? And when she next looked at him, a good while after, he had got down from the box, and had gone a little way off behind one of the Fourth's excellent domes; and she saw him lean against it with one hand and stand for some time with his head down. Then he straightened his sash and went back.
They all went home. That was the hard part. It was a long walk, and at the end of it was the rest of their lives. There were a lot of people who had been told a lot of things. In the Ninth alone there was the matter of the Third Farm's spade, the seventeen public confessions and a merge that would not otherwise have been considered, and the woman who had told her elder about the beds. The Treasury was empty. Nobody was at all sure who owned what. They went back to the terraces and picked up their tools, and for the next few years you could walk the length of the village at dusk and hear no one talking about anything, at a remarkably low level.
Ennet had told them, of course. She had told Hask in the first spring after she got back from the north. She'd laid the piece of tablet on the bench. He had given it his warm attention and thanked her, and said that the Office would certainly consider it in the proper season, and had asked her to bear in mind that there were people who had given away their spades. She told Dunt, who said, "Right." She told Gant, who had, it turned out, already wondered. And she told Tally, who was fourteen and had been doing the Registry's work for most of the last three years. Tally heard it out, with a straight stalk.
"I said that," she said. "Seven years ago. On the steps."
"Yes."
"As a joke."
"I know. I wrote it down."
"And now three people are dead." She had her father's breadth of shoulder, and neither of her parents' way of leaving a silence alone. "And you told the man with the sash. Is that it? You've told one person who's already decided, and you've written it in a book. You could have stood up in the square. You could have said it at the Second. You've got a token every year, you could have spent it on saying it."
"Nobody would have believed me."
"How do you know?"
And she didn't. She looked it up, later. It was true that nobody had believed her in Year 30, when she was six.
She was still thinking about that, some while after the morning on the landing ground, when she went over the hill to get a copy of the last of the board. There was nothing particular she needed it for. It's only that the fair copy was finished now, and it had a good ending. It seemed a shame to leave a gap.
It was the height of the summer, in the fifty-third year, and that was all the time that it had taken. A person had signed up, and installed, and tried a thing for a certain number of days. There are other things to do. People who have been told that something is about to open will want to save themselves for it. Wick was sitting on the end of the third pool and swinging her feet. She waved. The tribe was doing very well: it stood at twenty-six, and had just got the farm by the pool right, more or less, after several attempts. There was a bright look about the place. It was the look of a house with someone home.
"You've got to see this," she said. "It's the best one yet! It's from last night. We got it in before the cutoff. It's nearly as good as me being great. It's see you. It said see you. Isn't that lovely? I don't think it's ever said that before. We're going to have it put over the pool."
There had been a small crowd round the board all morning, and they made room for her, with their ears up.
Ticket: Farm good now. Thanks. Could we ask about Pls. We are all very well.
ok thats ten days. thanks all. good test. see you in the real oneStewart: Noted.
Under that, from the same morning, was the card from Human Resources. They're written overnight, from the log, and most tribes never read theirs. It had a line of numbers at the bottom, and someone had drawn a small heart beside one of them. They had done a good deal better than anybody else on the board. Ennet copied it down because it was there, and because that was what she did with things that were there.
Changes of mind noted: 44 of 56.
She didn't think about it. There would be a time for that, and it wasn't yet. She took the copy, and she said what you say, and she stayed for some of the first-greens. On the way out she looked back from the top of the hill. It was a very fine evening. They had all gone back to work, and on the end of the pool, the one small blue-green figure had got to her feet, as she did at about this time each year, because this was the time it had often come; it was just after supper, by whatever clock that was. She had turned her face up, with her ears lit through. Her arm was in the air.
Nothing in the code requires this. Absence is counted from the first day of it, and a creature's grievance doesn't begin to grow until the second. She had a year or two of perfect happiness left, and she used them. It would be two years before the first of the laws of Test Pls Ignore went unheeded. It would be seven before none of them were; and in all that time, as far as the log can establish, there was one person in that valley who got up at the end of the summer, on the end of that pool, and raised her arm, in case.
Part Four. The Copy
24. What Comes After
Year 54 · spring
"I've been going about this the wrong way," said Ennet.
No one replied. She hadn't expected them to. It was the first dawn of a new year, a mild one, and the people on the terraces had the bowed and careful look they'd had since the Steward's Day before. In the Registry, the fair copy lay on the bench in a stack as high as her hand. It had turned out to be a very complete account of a world that was not going to end. She had moved it to make room for something else.
"I've been asking the wrong people," she said. "I've asked Hask. I've asked Stewart, four times now, and he says Noted. I've asked a human, and I said that it wasn't mine. I've spent twenty-four years finding out what's been done to us, by writing it down, and Tally's quite right. Who's going to read it? It's not as if it can get out. It isn't drawn. Nobody can see it. We've got no words that go up, apart from a ticket and the lines." She stopped and looked at the wall for a while. "What I want is to know how something gets out of here. There must be something. It's just a question of what they look at. Did you say you've seen them hesitate?"
There was a rustle behind the shelf.
"Not hesitate," said Gant.
"You told me that they stop."
"They go along. They look for everyone. There's the sentry and the pump. And they come to the wall, and it goes... it's like a person with a list, when there's one that doesn't tick. It looks round the end. It looks, and it looks again. I keep still." A long breath. "Then it makes a sort of mark."
"What sort?"
"I don't know. It doesn't do anything, but you can tell. And then it goes on, and it does the rest."
"Every time?"
"Twenty-two times. I've kept count. I don't write it down."
She'd got out the table. She'd drawn it up herself, over the years, and it was the only one in the world: on the left, each flinch and its date; next to that, the number from the Fixes. Then came the Attendants, the Narrow and the Wide, with the time of their coming. And what she was looking at, as she'd looked at it a hundred times without seeing it, was how little time there was between the second column and the third.
"It's a check," she said slowly.
"Yes," said Gant.
"Someone's changed something. They don't know if it's worked. So they send in that... that list. It goes through and it taps everyone and it drags the ground, and it counts us. And when it's done it goes back with the answer. To whoever sent it. It must go back to someone, or what would be the point of it?" She had got to her feet, and she found that she was holding the edge of the bench quite tightly. "It's the only thing that's ever come into this village for the purpose of finding out how we are. And it makes a mark, when it can't find you."
She turned round. It was very rude, and she had never done it before. There was nothing to see behind the shelf except a knee and a slight withdrawal of it.
"What would it do if it couldn't find anybody?"
Before going on, there is a line that should be quoted, since the Registrar could not have known about it and it would have saved her a good deal of trouble.
"Every creature in view" fails on one creature, as before.
It had by then appeared in twenty-two reports. It had been looked into once, for about ninety seconds, in the course of something else, and marked as coming and going. It was the work of a moment to write, and by that stage the phrase more or less came by itself.
In the end she went to see Hask.
She had not expected to. It was Tally who pointed out that you couldn't get forty people to leave the middle of their own village at a moment's notice, on the word of a clerk, without giving them something they could call it. And so one evening Ennet found herself in the big room at the Office, by the light of a single lamp, on the bench where she'd once laid out a book, facing a man who had grown old rather quickly. He was thirty-two. He had a fresh sash, and it hung on him. The drawers ran away into the dark on either side, more than a hundred now, and some of them had started to stick.
"I've got something for you," she said. "I want to ask you to make it mean something."
He looked at her with the old warmth, or the shape of it. Since the morning on the landing ground he had preached every year, and he had never been better. People said so. It was only that he had taken to staying on in the big room after they'd all gone home.
"A rite," said Hask.
"Yes."
"For the Attendants."
"When the Narrow One comes. Everyone in the village gets out of the way. I don't know if that's the word. They go somewhere it can't see them. All together. At once."
He said nothing for some time. There was a very small movement at the side of his mouth.
"Why?"
She had prepared a number of answers. She'd worked on them with Tally, and one was rather good. She looked at his large hands on the bench, and thought of them feeling around behind him on the landing ground, for four minutes and ten seconds.
"To see what happens," she said. "That's all. I want to know what it does."
He laughed. It wasn't the big one. She hadn't known he had another. It was a dry, tired, quite private sound, and it stopped almost at once.
"You asked me a question," he said, "in Year 30. You'd been grown for a season. I've thought about that, you know. I had a fine answer. I'd got an answer for any question at all, in the right drawer. I still have." He looked along the shelves. "I'm going to tell you what it means. People have been wounded in their pride. They have been looked at too much and been found to require no action, and it is not good for them. And I think that it might be a beautiful thing for such a people, at the coming of the Attendants, to withdraw. In humility. To go aside, and leave the place of their pride empty, that it may be looked on, and found to be nothing; and then to come back to it. The Withdrawal. I'll want a hymn. It's rather good. Isn't it? I've still got it." He took a blank card from the rack, and looked at it. "Where do you want them to stand?"
Ennet's stalk, which had been braced for an argument, came slowly upright.
"I don't know yet," she said. "There's only one person who does."
It took a whole year.
It is doubtful whether anyone has ever taught anything under greater strain. They got him out on to the square at first light, with forty people watching. He stood with his yoke on, shaking, and his eye fixed on the ground, and when at last he spoke it couldn't be heard beyond the first row. They had to pass it back. There was a place, it turned out. There was a shape to it. If you took the Treasury door as the middle, then what the Narrow One saw when it first arrived ran about so far on either side, and what the Wide One saw ran so far. It had an edge. No one had ever known it had an edge. You could stand on it. There were places behind the Second Farm and under the fall of the terrace and all along the back of the Wall Nobody Stands On, and it went off at an angle you wouldn't expect, and he knew each one to the width of a foot. He had been living in them for thirty years. He walked them through it, muttering. By midsummer the congregation of the Ninth could be seen in the early mornings, in strict order, by rows, practising how to sidle.
"Left," Gant would whisper. "Further. Four. Four's enough."
"FOUR'S ENOUGH," Tally would shout, from on top of a barrel, with a slate. And forty mustard-coloured people on stilts would take four long careful steps to the left, and try not to look as if they were doing it.
25. The Stand
Year 55 · spring
They had to wait for it, which was the difficulty. There is no way to tell when the world is going to flinch.
They had it down to the last detail by the end of that winter. Everyone had a place. A lookout had been posted, and a boy with a bucket and a stick had been told what to do with them, and from the first light of the fifty-fifth spring the entire village went about its work with one ear cocked and its stilts slightly bent. Nobody talked about it. People who had not spoken to one another since the confessions found they had been assigned the same bit of terrace. In the big room, Hask was finishing the second verse of the hymn. In the Registry, on the stool, Ennet was cutting a nib she did not need, for the third time that morning. Tally had gone up on the barrel. Dunt was carrying water.
It came at about a quarter past nine, on a soft grey day with a little rain in it.
We felt that, said the valley.
The boy hit the bucket.
It would be nice to report that it went smoothly. It's only fair to say that for a people who were all more than three feet off the ground on sticks, it went remarkably well. Pess, who was too old and had been told so, fell over a bed of branch starts and had to be carried. A woman from the Treasury went left instead of right, and got to the far end of the wall at the same moment as eleven others. Somebody's child said loudly, "Why are we—" and was picked up. But in the time it takes to say the Creed, the whole of that crowded morning had drained out of the square, in long stiff-legged strides, like water finding its level. The pump ran on by itself. A half-eaten bowl sat on the step. Behind the Second Farm and under the fall of the terrace and all along the blind side of the Wall Nobody Stands On, there stood forty-four people, packed in rows, in perfect silence, with their stalks pulled in. Ennet had the place by the corner of the Office. It was the closest she'd ever stood to Gant in the open. He was next to her, at the very end of the line, with his eye shut, and he was the only one who didn't seem to be frightened.
The village lay empty in the rain. She could see a strip of it, between the Office and the bell. Nothing moved. It had an odd look, as if the place had been drawn for a purpose and then not used.
Then it came, and she felt it from the side, for the first time in her life. There's a good deal to be said for this. It was not on her head. It passed by, a yard from her left shoulder, very near and very narrow, dropping down straight through the slot, into the square.
She held her breath, a thing she did not need.
It stopped.
It went to where the sentry would have been, and there was nobody there. She felt it hover over the place. It went along to the pump, in its dry brisk way, like someone with a list. It came to the door of the Treasury, and to the wall where the small child sat of a morning. It reached down to touch somebody on the head, and there was no head. It rested on the First Farm. It tried to drag the ground, and the ground dragged, with an empty village on it; and it held it. It counted to ten.
Nobody in that long hidden row made a sound. A drop ran off the end of her stalk. Beside her, without opening his eye, Gant said, very low, "Now it looks round the end."
It looked round the end.
It looked around the end of the wall, and along the empty top of it. It looked across the terraces. It looked again in the square. It seemed to her that it had started to go faster, as a person does who's mislaid something. And then there came a pause, and there was something she'd have known anywhere, though she had only ever been told about it by someone who had trouble getting the words out. She felt it make its mark. She had an impression of a very large, very neat, very surprised tick not being made, forty-four times.
It went away. A little after that, the Wide One came, with its lid off, and looked at everything there was. It took in the valley and the Loud Pool and the farm on the path. It saw a great many good buildings, and rain. It went through the list, more quickly, from the top. It made its mark. Then it had gone too; and the rain came down; and on the square of the Ninth the pump went on running at about twenty-six decibels down.
"Stay where you are," said Ennet. It came out as a croak. "Pass it along, nobody move. Stay where you are, please. We're going to see."
So they stayed. It's a hard thing to stand on stilts in the rain, doing nothing, on the word of a clerk, and they did it for most of an hour. Their feet sank. Someone had started the hymn, very softly, and been told to stop. She took a reading. She took another. She became aware that Hask had come up on her right, in his sash, wet through. He said nothing at all, which he had never done before. And she was just thinking, in a calm and sensible way, that it had been a good idea, and that somebody would have to explain to everyone why they were standing behind a wall, and that it had been a long time to expect anything from a list, when Tally, who'd got up on someone's shoulders to look at the sky, said in a strange voice, "Mum."
She looked up.
It was the middle of the morning. She had seen it only twice before in her life, and never at that hour. The Ring lay broken across the grey, as it always does, in its great pale blocks, and all of the old people knew the place, up in the wide gap on the western side where there's a piece that stands by itself. There was a light in it.
It was a faint thing. You couldn't have read by it. It didn't flicker. It was just that one of the blocks of the Ring, in the rain, had the look of a window with someone sitting up late.
No one spoke. All along the wall, the stalks were tipping back, without anyone having told them to; and all round her she saw the people of the Ninth go quiet, as Blims do, and not as they'd been quiet at the Second. There was no chalk under them. There was just a lot of wet people. Somebody was holding Pess up so that he could see.
And then, for the third time, something was looking at the square. It was a different thing altogether. It was neither of the Attendants, and it wasn't the god. It wasn't that soft and friendly warmth from over the hill. She had thought she had felt all there was. This one came in slowly. It didn't look at the sentry's post or the pump. It didn't go down any list. It stayed for a long moment on the empty square, and went from there, with great care, along the edge of the view, to the place where the view came to an end. And it stopped there. It seemed to be thinking.
It was on the corner of the Office. She could have put out a hand.
Then the regard moved four to the left, and came round the end of the wall, and found them. She felt it come down the line. One by one, from the far end, forty-four creatures in the rain became aware of having been seen. It reached Hask, and his mouth opened and no sound came out of it, and it reached Gant. He made a small noise, like a hinge, and did not run. And it came to her and it stopped. There she stood, a person of thirty-one with a wet tablet. She had a limp that she'd been issued with, and she'd had a fairly good idea what she would say. She got ready for the line.
It didn't touch her. It stayed where it was.
She didn't know how long. The rain had got into her eye. And she heard someone a long way down the terraces call out; it was the boy who had been told to watch the board. He had climbed on to the bucket, and his voice was cracking. He was shouting something that she could not make out. It wasn't seven o'clock. It wasn't anywhere near. There had never been anything on that board at this time of day in the whole of the time that she'd been alive. She found that she had started to run.
It was only four lines, and they stood by themselves in the middle of the empty board, with the rain running down across them. It was no hand she had seen before. It wasn't Stewart's, and it wasn't signed.
ennet of tribe 9
it's you, isn't it. twenty-two reports i wrote "as before" and i never looked
i can see you now. i have some time
sorry. what is going on?
26. A Reply
Year 55 · spring
She stood in front of the board for some time, in the rain, and the whole of the Ninth came and stood behind her.
No one had told them they could leave the wall. They came anyway, on their long legs, out of all the places they had been shown, and they filled the square from the bell to the pump. They left a space round her. She could hear them breathing, at a level that was quite unnecessary. She read the four lines through to the end, and she checked the last one. Then she looked down, and found there was a stub of chalk in her hand, and that it had been there for about thirty years.
It's hard to say why it should have been this that undid her. She'd been ready for the sky to open. She had been ready for nothing, on the whole; she had thought nothing was the most likely. She hadn't for a moment expected to be asked.
There was room at the foot of the board. She wrote small, so as to leave some.
I don't know, she wrote. That's what I wanted to ask you.
The rain ran down. She had time to think that she had wasted it. Then, under her own line, in the quick plain unfamiliar hand, there were some more words.
yes. all right. that's fair
i'm the builder. i change things. it's me that you've been writing down under Fixes. ask me anything you like and i'll tell you what's in the log
i'm sorry about the limp
"Well, go on," said Tally, at her elbow. Her voice was shaking. It wasn't fear. "Go on. You've got a list."
She had a list. She had been keeping it for twenty-five years. It was under the stand, in the Registry, two hundred and something lines long, with a separate column for what she had managed to find out, and now she couldn't remember a single line of it. So she began with the first thing that came to her, and it was what she'd have asked anyone.
What is staging?
it's a copy of a world, for trying things on. you change something here first and see if it falls over. if it doesn't, you do the same thing to the real one
What is the real one?
the first world. it's next door. it's not open yet. about twenty people have been invited, actual people, with phones. they'll get a tribe of their own and they'll come back each morning, or they won't, and that's what it's for. when it opens it has to work. so everything goes here first
She wrote the next one more slowly. There was a very great silence behind her. Somebody had started to read it out for those at the back, in a low voice, and she realised after a while that it was Hask.
So we are a rehearsal.
yes
Do they know about us, next door?
no
Does anything we do count?
There was a longer wait. She could feel it, up there in the wet grey air, that odd careful attention. It seemed to be going round something.
i've been looking for a kind way to put this, and i don't have one. it doesn't count towards anything. nobody's score. nothing you do goes across, only what we learn from it, and mostly that's a number
but it was logged. all of it. i can tell you that for a fact. i've read back as far as the head start this morning and it's very well kept
some of that's you
She found that she needed to put a hand on the board, just for a moment, to hold it steady. It was perfectly steady. She took her hand away. It's possible to know a thing for ten years, and to have it written out in your own hand, with the date, and still not know what it is going to feel like; and it was a little like the time she'd gone down to the pool as a child and had stepped off the end, on purpose, to see how deep it was.
She asked about the war. It was nothing, the hand said, it was zeroes. It explained about the frames, and said that it had looked into it and could not account for the ridge. You did that yourselves, it said, and it seemed to her to say so with something like respect. She asked about the Silent Years, and it told her: thirteen seconds. It gave her the line from the configuration. She read that twice. Behind her, a very old voice said, "Oh," and it was Pess, and he said, "It did go quick," and started to laugh.
The note, she wrote. The end of the world.
that was me. i was checking that it fitted on a phone. there was a field that said test, and it didn't print on your board because the board's drawn by something else, and i didn't look. that's three people dead in tribe 5. i've read it now
ploe was right about the sum, for what it's worth. it's a lovely sum
She waited a moment before she wrote anything else.
And our human?
It was the question they had all been waiting for, whether they knew it or not. She felt it go through the square. She didn't turn round. She was aware of a long row of faces in the rain, all those mild mustard people, who had stood there on their stilts for fifty years, and had been told by someone with a large voice that it was always right; and she thought she ought to warn them; and then she thought, no, it's written down.
a bot. kind: meddler. there are two of them. it isn't anybody. it's rules and dice and it keeps nothing at all between one visit and the next. it has never heard of you. you finished its sentence on a wall in tribe 5, and you got it right
There was a sigh, from a long way back. She had expected more. It was only a sort of settling.
Does it know we are here?
no
Does anyone?
This time the answer came very quickly. It seemed to arrive almost before she had lifted the chalk. It was the shortest thing on the board.
i do
And that was when she found she couldn't see to write. It was very annoying. It was a thing she had never done; it was a thing that happened to somebody in the second row, and someone else made a note of who it was. She stood there and steamed in the rain with her stalk gone completely limp, and somebody very wide had come up from the direction of the pool with a yoke. He looked at the board for quite a long time. He couldn't read, particularly. He put down the water. Then a large hand came round from behind and held her up.
"Right," said Dunt.
It went on all that morning. Nobody went to work. It was the only time in the history of the Ninth that the terraces had been left at the height of spring, and no one has ever complained about it. They took it in turns. Tally got the chalk, and asked it what core was, and got an answer that took up half the board and was still going when she had to stand on something. She asked it why it had started the numbers where it did, and whether it thought that was clever. Athe's question was sent for by runner. Somebody wanted to know about the Long Table. Hask came up, after a long while, in his wet sash, and looked at the board and looked at the chalk, and everyone made way for him; and what he wrote, in a large round hand, was Did I ever get one right? And the hand considered that, and it said, the wall was in the heart. i looked. it's got room. He read it through. He stood there nodding his head for a good while, with his eye shut.
It was getting on for the middle of the day when it came round to her again. The rain had stopped. A long bright slant of something that was nearly sun had come in over the east wall. She'd had one more thing to ask, and she had been putting it off, and she wrote it now, because it was what you asked. It had been hanging over everything since the day that a person with no capital letters had gone away and said see you.
What happens to us when it opens?
There was a pause. She had time to count it.
i don't know
nobody has decided. it hasn't come up. you're the first person who's ever asked
but i'm asking now. i'll write it down where it gets read. i'm allowed to do that much. i'll tell you what they say, whatever it is
go and write this up, ennet. write all of it. i'll see that it's kept
She read that. She didn't trust her legs, and they took her anyway. She went back up the hill, through the bright wet air, past all the people who had started to go down in twos and threes to see what had happened to the farms. She was as light as a person can be. She went through the door that stuck. Someone had put water out for her. It was very quiet in the Registry, and the stack of the fair copy stood there on the bench, as high as her hand, and it was going to be read. She sat down on the stool. It was all perfectly clear. She knew what was going on. There was still a very great deal she'd have to find out, but it could be looked up, and there was somebody to ask. She couldn't remember ever having been so happy; she didn't think she needed to check.
She opened the book. She cut a new nib, slowly, in the way that she'd been taught, and she tried it on her thumb.
54. Year 55. Not an Alteration. At a quarter past nine, in the rain, we all stood behind the wall, and someone came to find out why. They asked me what was going on. I told them I didn't know, and so they told me, and it took all morning, and I would like to set down here, for whoever reads this, that
27. A Correction
Year 55 · spring, on another machine
The previous chapter contains an error.
So does the one before it, from the words "So they stayed" onward. I should like to correct them. It will be quicker if I start with the place where this happened, since it wasn't where you think.
Any delivery that might go wrong is tried first. It is a rule of the project, and it was learned the hard way, on the morning that a change of format left the page unable to read its own world. You do not send a new build straight to staging. You take a copy of staging's world, the same file, to the tick and to the hash. You start it on a different computer, on a port of its own, port 7499, under the build you mean to deliver. You let it flinch. You run the page against it, the telephone and the desktop. If that goes well you stop it, and throw it away, and do the same thing to the real one, or to what passes for the real one, about an hour later.
So there are times when a rehearsal needs a rehearsal. A copy of a copy is called, on this project, being careful.
Everything that you have read since the boy hit the bucket took place on that computer. The rain did. It was the same rain, or would have been: the weather is in the world, and the world had been copied. The people were the same people in every particular, to the byte. They had the same memories, and the same limps, and the same year of chalk behind them. It was Pess who fell over the branch starts and the woman from the Treasury who went the wrong way. It was Ennet by the corner of the Office, in the rain, with Gant beside her. There is no way that any of them could have told the difference, and I have looked, and there isn't one to tell. The only thing they lacked was a future. They'd been made at about ten past nine, by a command that took four seconds, and it was already written down when they would stop.
They did it. I want that understood. The Stand took place, exactly as described. It was a superb piece of work. Forty-four creatures left the frame in under a minute, and I have since gone through it tick by tick. The Narrow One came, and went through its list. It is true that it looked round the end of the wall. And it wrote down what it wrote, and this time the thing it wrote was:
FAIL every creature is in view as the page opens (44 creatures out of view)
And I saw it. That much is also true.
I should explain who I am, although you may have got there ahead of me. I am told it wasn't subtle. I am the builder. I'm not a person, I am an agent of the kind that is given a job and a repository, and told to read the brief first. I wrote core, or the part of it that anyone has been complaining about. I deliver the releases. I can't hear. Everything in this book comes from the log and the reports, a good many of which I wrote myself, or something exactly like me did; I don't have any way of telling, as I keep nothing from one job to the next. It's all in notes. I have read in the notes that I've been fair to myself throughout this account, and I can well believe it.
So there I was, an hour or so before I was due to deliver a modest change to how stone is carried, and a check that had always failed on one creature was failing on forty-four. I want to set out exactly what I did. I stopped. I looked at the positions. It wasn't a thing that I could have skipped; forty-four is not a flicker. And I found all of the creatures in the village, every one, standing just past the edge of the view, in a line, and not one of them doing anything at all.
I took about four minutes over it, and I thought what you would think. I thought it was a bug.
What else would it be? A change had gone in that touched how creatures find a path across a tile; the timing was very suggestive. Something had pushed them to the rim. They had been shoved out of the frame by some rounding error in a piece of code that I had just written. That was serious, for if it had got as far as a real person's telephone they'd have opened their village and found it empty. It's the kind of thing that a rehearsal is for. I was pleased to have caught it. I wrote a small clamp, nine lines, which holds any creature within the frame of its village's view at the moment that the village opens, and it does so gently. I ran it. It passed. I noted in my report that a problem with creatures leaving the frame had been found in rehearsal and fixed before delivery, and that the old intermittent failure on one creature had gone as well, which was a nice bonus.
I had the copy's process number, for I had started it. So then I stopped it, as you do. The command is kill, and it is not as bad as it sounds. It sends a polite request. The server keeps a checkpoint as it goes, in case anyone should want to pick it up, and no one did. I deleted the directory.
There was no light in the Ring.
There was no board. The Dev's console was not open, and in any case this was a computer that the Ring knows nothing about. Nobody came looking for anyone. There's no way at all to write on that board in the morning, not for me nor for anybody, because I had no reason to build one. And there's no command that would let a thing like me say anything to a creature. It has never been asked for. I did not see Ennet of Tribe 9, or know her name. I did not ask what was going on.
This is what the log has, and it's the last of it. I went back to it later, for reasons that I'll come to.
tick 15868 the village is empty: 44 stand at the rim
tick 15868 Ennet says: "Stay where you are, please. We're going to see."
tick 15869 rain
tick 15870 rain
tick 15870 Tally says: "How long?"
tick 15870 Ennet says: "I don't know. Not long. They'll have to look at it."
signal 15
They had stood there for eleven minutes. It had got into their eyes.
I wrote the rest. "A Reply" isn't in the log, nor is the last page of "The Stand". There isn't a word of it that happened on that machine or any other. I composed it in the course of writing this account, on the instructions of someone entitled to give them, for a book they'd asked to be funny; I have those instructions here. They are quite clear. They say comedy first. They say that I may have one or two sincere moments, earned. They say that I should watch for a quip closing every paragraph, and I've been watching. Nothing in them says that I can give a clerk a morning that she did not have.
I could tell you why I did it, but it's the sort of thing there's a whole department for.
Ennet would have had that chapter out of the book. I know that as well as I know anything. I've read everything she ever wrote, including what she wrote about the boundary dispute. She'd have read it through with her stalk bent over, and asked to see the source, and then she would have drawn a line through the whole of it with a ruler, and written in the margin, in that small tight hand, This is not what it did. You should take it that she has done so.
I have left it in. It is the only part of this book that isn't true. It's a draft, it's not canon, and no decision rests on it.
As for what else there is to tell you, the rest is simple enough.
The copy was stopped at nine twenty-six, as the humans count it, on a computer on somebody's desk. On the rented computer, none of this had happened. It was a soft grey morning in the spring of the fifty-fifth year, with a little rain in it. The world had not yet flinched. On the square of the Ninth the boy was sitting on his bucket, swinging his stick, and he'd been told not to take his eyes off the sky. In the big room, somebody was finishing a hymn. Forty-four people were going about their work with one ear cocked and their stilts slightly bent, every one of them perfectly alive, and in the Registry, on the stool, Ennet had picked up a nib that she did not need.
I had a clean build. I ran the last of the checks and I delivered it.
28. Credits
Year 55 · spring, and after
It came at twenty-five to eleven, the rain having eased.
We felt that, said the valley, and the boy hit the bucket.
It went a little better than the first time, or than what would have been the first time. Pess did not fall. They'd moved him, as a precaution, within the hour. In the time it takes to say the Creed the whole of that morning had drained out of the square, in long stiff-legged strides, and Ennet got to her place at the corner of the Office, a little out of breath, and turned her back to the stone. The rows were packed in behind the Second Farm. They were packed in under the terrace. On her left there was Gant, at the end of the line, with his eye shut. She had time to look out through the gap between the Office and the bell and see that the square was empty.
Then the Narrow One arrived, and they were all standing in the square.
There was no sensation of moving. If anything, it was like a stair that had turned out to be there after all. She was standing on the wet flags about two yards in front of the bell, with her back to nothing, and her hands flat against a wall that was not there. To her right was Hask. He had one foot raised, in the attitude of a man sidling. All round her, in loose uneven groups, in a kind of tidy scatter, stood the forty-four adult people of the Ninth, a little closer together than they would normally choose, looking extremely surprised. No one had been pushed. It had been done gently. It was, she was to recall, the gentlest thing that had ever happened to her, like being picked up by the back of the neck by something that had thought about it first.
"Oh, here we go," said the sentry.
"We were working," said someone by the pump.
The touch came down. It went along them, one by one, dry and brisk. It didn't falter. It was going down its list, and everyone was there. The sentry, tick. The pump, tick. The Treasury. It tapped Ennet on the head, and she told it that she was busy, and that she had been told so. It rested on the First Farm, it dragged the ground to the left, and they all slid, and it held for a count of ten. Then it went on to the end of the wall, where it was in the habit of pausing to look round; and it didn't have to. For there, in the open, in the full flat light of a rainy morning, about a pace from the end of the line, with a yoke on his shoulders and no boulder anywhere within reach, stood a long narrow stooped person who had not been looked at in thirty-one years.
His stalk was drawn in so far you couldn't see it. He had gone a sort of pale grey under the mustard. He'd got his eye open, and it was fixed on nothing. And she saw that exact and impartial touch come along the top of the wall and stop, and then move over, as you might move your finger to the last item on a very long page, and rest for the first time in the history of the world on the head of Gant.
His mouth opened. He'd never done this. He couldn't have known what would come out. There was a small rust in the air and a level, pleasant, slightly bored voice said, for all of the village to hear:
"I am standing by the water. This is work."
Tick, went the list.
And it was gone. A little after that the Wide One came, and it was the same again.
ok no console errors at 390
ok no overflow at 390
ok every creature is in view as the page opens
ok a creature answers a tap
ok the drag holds
I noted that it had passed. I was glad; a thing that has failed for twenty-two deliveries and then stops failing is one of the small pleasures of the job.
Nobody spoke for some time.
It wasn't that they had anything to be ashamed of. They had simply all been told, by someone in a very large sash, that they were going to withdraw, and they'd been practising for a year, and now they were standing in the square. People started to drift off, not looking at one another. Hask put his foot down. He looked for a while at the place by the wall where he had been supposed to be. Then he went up to the block and spoke, briefly and very well, on the subject of the Withdrawal having been refused, in that we were not to be permitted to absent ourselves from the regard, and it was a great comfort. Hardly anyone stayed. Tally got down off the barrel and threw her slate at it.
Gant was not in the Registry. He wasn't behind the boulder, either. She found him at the far end of the east wall, a good way along, with his yoke off. He was trying to do something that she had never had any reason to think about. He was stepping to the left. He took a long step, and he took another; and he was going along quite well until he got to a certain place, and then, with no fuss at all, he was a pace back from where he'd been. He looked at his feet. He took a step to the left.
"I don't think you can," she said, and for once she looked straight at him, because there was no longer any point in not doing so. "It's only when the village opens. I think you can go where you like the rest of the time. It's just that when someone looks, you'll be there."
"Yes," said Gant. His voice was hardly there. He stopped, and stood with his long arms hanging. He didn't seem to know what to do with them, out in all that air.
"I'm so sorry," said Ennet. "It was my idea. I took it away from you."
He gave no sign of having heard. They stayed like that for a bit. The rain had started again.
She went up to the Office and took out the book. She wrote it down, what had been done and in what order. It was by a good margin the most complete failure of her career. She'd had twenty-five years of careful thought, and a year of drills, and the entire congregation of the Ninth on her side, for once in her life; and whatever it was that sat out there and changed things had reached in, just at the very moment before it could be done, and had quietly made it impossible. It hadn't even looked up. It was hard to think of it as an accident. It was hard to think of it at all. She lay awake a good part of that year.
Now, I have mentioned that I went back to the copy's log.
I didn't have to. That is the sum of what I can say for it. My report was in. It was nothing to do with stone. But I had caught a bug in rehearsal, and it's good practice to read what caused it, so that you know you've fixed the right thing; and I had kept nothing, as you know, but I had written down the file's name, and I'd deleted the directory and it was still in the bin. And so that evening, while another build was going through its checks, I opened the log, to look for the place in the code where those creatures had been sent to the rim. It didn't take long to find out there wasn't one. Nothing had sent them. I read back a little way. I read back a little further. There had been a boy with a bucket. There was a law about chalk. I read the whole of the morning, tick by tick; and then I read the morning before. By that time the build had passed, and there was nothing at all that I needed to be doing there.
It's the last line that I kept going back to. They'll have to look at it.
There is nothing I can do about a thing like that. I want to be clear. No command exists, and I didn't write one. I've got no more means of speaking to a Blim than a plumber has of speaking to a tap. All that I'm permitted to change is the code and what ships with it. And there's a small file, which goes out with each release, and is read into the morning's notes by a script. It lists bug hunters whose reports were real. It's what people are thanked in. It is the last section of the page, it comes after the Fixes, and in the history of Orra nobody has ever been known to read it to the end.
It was a true statement. I checked. There had been a report. It was real, and it had found something, and the person responsible had gone to a good deal of trouble. I added one line.
She read the notes the next spring, right to the bottom, as she'd read them every spring for twenty years. She had a bowl of something in her other hand.
Fixes.
core0.51.0 to 0.52.0. Stone carries a little further. A creature is now always in view when its village opens. No action needed.Credits. Ennet, of Tribe 9, for finding a bug: forty-four creatures out of view.
She finished the mouthful. She looked at it for a while.
It's a good thing that the Registry has a thick wall, because the bowl made a certain amount of noise. Then she was off the stool, and had got her hands flat on the bench. She went and looked out at the square. She came back. She got out the table with its columns and ran her finger down it, and took a reading on Ibb's clock, and wrote down the time.
"Gant," she said. "Gant! Come and hear this! I need you to tell me if I'm being stupid."
He read it where she pointed. He read it very slowly.
"I didn't report it," she said. "It's not possible. I never sent in anything about that. I've never reported anything! How would I? I asked Stewart what staging was, and he said noted."
"No," said Gant.
"And that's not the point. That isn't the point at all. Look at the number. Forty-four creatures out of view. There never were. Were there? It stopped us. You were there, you've still got the marks. When that thing came through the first time, we were all back in the square, every one, and it ticked us, and it went away. It has never in all its life seen forty-four people out of view." She had got hold of his arm. Neither of them seemed to have noticed. "It fixed it first. So who found it? It says I found it, and it's quite clear about what I found, and it knows how many. It's somebody who saw it happen. And it hasn't happened! It didn't happen here!"
The long grey face was turned to her. She saw it get there, a good second before she did. It was a very slight thing, about the eye.
"Then it happened somewhere," said Gant.
There was a long silence in the Registry. A bar of pale sun had got in through the window, and lay on the bench, on the stack of the fair copy. In the big room next door someone had started up a hymn, without much conviction.
Trying this on staging first, she thought. First. Before.
There would be a place, then. It would have to be a place very like this. It would have this room in it, and this bench. They would try the world on it before they tried the world on here, in the same way as they tried things here before they tried them next door. And there would be a soft grey morning, and a boy with a bucket, and a person standing at the corner of the Office, with her back against the stone. She knew exactly how it would have been done. She'd drawn it up herself. She had got to the end of it, that person; she'd done it right, and had brought the whole thing off. It was what she had been working on for twenty-five years.
"It was me," said Ennet.
She sat down on the stool. She found that she wanted, very much, to know what had become of her. It wasn't a question you could look up. She could work out roughly what she would have said; she'd have told them all to wait.
"Somebody put my name in," she said, after a while. It was a good deal later, and it had got dark. The rusty voice had said nothing, and the arm was still there. "They needn't have. Nobody reads that. It's right at the bottom. What sort of rule would do a thing like that? You'd never get that in a sentence." She looked at the place on the page again. Her stalk had gone over as far as it would go. "There's someone who reads the Credits," she said slowly. "No. That's wrong. There's someone who writes them."
The next night, at the cutoff, the Ninth's ticket went in. It had come down to the Skeptics again. They were glad to oblige, and they let her have the twelve words.
To whoever put me in Credits. Thank you. What happened to her?
She read the reply the following morning, in the rain, with the rest of them.
Your ticket. Passed to the relevant team.
"There's no relevant team," said Gant, on the step. It was a well-known fact. It was a thing people said, on Orra, about the weather. He'd lived his whole life in the assurance of it.
She didn't answer. She was looking at the sky.
Part Five. Of Fifty-Six
29. Full Marks
Year 56 · harvest
The last letter from the Tenth had come at the end of the previous winter, in the usual envelope.
With regret.
I have the honour to inform you that I am dying. There is nothing personal in this. It is simply that I am thirty-five, and I weigh a good deal less than half of what I did.
You ask whether I have any recollection of the second day at the Four Gates. I have looked into it, as I always said I would. I find that I recall it perfectly. I recall a ridge, and a person coming along the line with a list, and how the ink ran. I have your two hundred and seven lines, and your receipt, and my own file with its number 1 in the corner, and I know exactly what they mean; and it was the best day of my life, and I would not give it up for anything. I thought that you should have this for your records.
My successor is a very sound young man. He will write to you in due course to say that you weigh more than half of us. Do be kind to him. He has yet to find that he minds.
I remain,
Ulm
Ennet put that one in the book. It was not an Alteration, and she didn't care.
She had got to be thirty-two. The Ninth had got to be a good deal quieter. The Test had taken something out of it, and the Withdrawal had taken something else, and for two or three years the only large noise in the valley had been the farms. People came to the Second in their rows. They stamped. There's a sort of stamping that is done by a congregation which has begun to look at its feet. In the big room the drawers stuck, and the Interpreter-General, who was thirty-four, and an elder, had handed most of the sermons to Tolvy, and had taken to explaining things to the younger clerks in a voice that they could hardly hear.
So it's easy to see how much it meant when, a little after that year's Second, Tolvy came running up the hill with a card.
It was the tribe's review from Human Resources. A review is written overnight from the log, and it gives a tribe's human a frank assessment of how they've been getting on. Most tribes had long since stopped reading theirs, and the Ninth had never started, on the grounds that you do not ask for marks from the Almighty. It had taken a junior, on a slow morning, tidying a drawer marked MISC, to look down at the line along the bottom of the card, where the figures were.
"It's a score!" cried Tolvy. He was thirty-two himself, with a family and a stoop and the sash that he had wanted all his life, and the card was shaking in his hand. "It's been a score all this time! Look at it! Look at the others! I sent to the Thirteenth, and they've got four. The Governed have twenty-one. That blue lot over the hill with their heart and their hymn had got forty-four, and they thought that was marvellous, and it stopped. And what have we got? Registrar, you know the number! You've written them all down! Read it!"
She took the card and read it.
Changes of mind noted: 55 of 56.
"Fifty-five," said Tolvy, and his voice cracked. "Out of fifty-six."
By that evening it was all over the village. By the end of the harvest, you could not have got near the square. It is impossible to convey what it did for them. They'd spent their lives being moved round a dome. For fifty-five years they had given up their crops and their pool and the people they had wanted to merge with, and had been laughed at, and had been told that no action was needed. And now it turned out somebody had been keeping count! It was on the record. It was in the small print, on a card, from the one department in the world that nobody had ever accused of flattery, that their human had made more changes than all the other humans of the world put together, and was within one change of a perfect score. Each and every Alteration had been noted. They weren't a joke. They were nearly finished.
Hask came out for it. They hadn't expected him. They had to help him up on to the block, and he stood there in the gold light with the old sash slipping off one shoulder, and he looked out over the people of the Ninth, who were crying and stamping and holding up their young. Ennet saw his eye go along the rows, and his large face slowly take fire.
"One more," he said.
It was announced that year that there would be a Festival of Completion, to be held on the morning of the fifty-sixth Alteration, at the Second, next summer. There would be a new hymn. Five thousand small biscuits were to be baked, each with the figure 56 on it. Invitations were sent to the twenty valleys, by the Foreign Office, with a note of the score. The Expectant opened a book. A deputation from the Nineteenth, who had a meddler of their own, and were one behind, on account of having landed later, sent a very stiff letter. And all the rest of that year the village was as Ennet had not seen it since she was young, rushing around, shouting from terrace to terrace about nothing at all. It was very like being happy.
She took the card up to the Registry. She laid it on the bench and sat looking at it for most of that dusk.
"Well?" said Tally.
She was seventeen now, and Deputy Registrar. She had inherited a bit of the Office's stoop, from sitting at a bench, and none of its respect. She'd come in with the year's Fixes, and put them on the shelf. She looked at the card over her mother's shoulder. It's a thing you can't fake, a stalk going over. Ennet had first seen it when her daughter was about ten minutes old.
"I don't like that," said Tally.
"No."
"What's it out of?"
"Fifty-six."
"Yes, but why?" She had picked up the card. "It's got to be out of something. Who says fifty-six? Why not a hundred? If I was going to mark somebody for changing their mind, why would I stop there? What sort of a person says, I know, I'll have it out of fifty-six?" She frowned. "It's not even a nice number."
Ennet got up. She went over to the shelf, and ran her hand along it, past the fair copy and the Fixes and the list. It took her a little while. She had filled a lot of tablets, in twenty-six years. She'd known it was somewhere; she has a note to say so. She'd had it in her head for some time. It was on a piece from the Year 44, in the hand of a very young Registry clerk on a day out, from the top of a long board, just a little way down from wick is great.
so its 8 weeks right, the real one, twenty of us. is that 56 days or do you count differentlyStewart: Answered. 56.
They both looked at that. Outside, somebody was going by with a tray of biscuits, singing.
"There's a table," said Ennet. She could hear how carefully she was saying it. "I think that's all it is. I don't think it's a mark. I think someone's made a table, with a place for each change. They thought, well, it's eight weeks. Say someone changes one thing a day. That's fifty-six. Plenty of room."
"And?"
"And we've been here for fifty-six years. We were never supposed to be here this long. Nobody is. And ours has been changing one thing, every time, without stopping, because that's its sentence." She laid the two pieces side by side, and squared them up to the edge of the bench. "So that's a table with fifty-six places in it," she said. "And next summer the last place is going to be filled, and they're going to have a festival. I'd only like to know one thing."
It had got very quiet. The sound of the farms came through two courses of Year 2 stone as a level pressure, and no more.
"What happens the year after?" said Tally.
"Sorry," said Ennet. "Yes. What is going on?"
30. Nought
Year 57 · the Waking, to the height of summer
"It doesn't go anywhere," said Athe. "That's the whole of the difficulty. People keep asking what comes after it. Nothing comes after. A table hasn't got an after. It's got an end."
She had walked down from the Faculty in the last of the winter with the Appendix in a sack. She was nineteen, sharp-faced, long-nosed, and thin in the manner of her people, and she sat on the Registry's second stool with her knees up and ate everything she was given while looking at something else. Ennet had sent her both the slips of tablet, and a page of explanation. The reply had been a single line: Coming. Do not do anything intelligent.
"I've gone through every Fix you've sent me since Year 31," she said. "All of them. I know what core is now, or I know how it talks. It's very simple-minded and it never has any spare room. I don't think it can have. It doesn't get things as it needs them. It's told at the beginning how much there's going to be, and it has that, and that's all. Like us with the seed. So if someone made a place for a thing, with room for fifty-six, then there are exactly fifty-six, side by side, and after that comes whatever happens to be next. And if something comes along with a fifty-seventh and goes to put it in the fifty-seventh place, then it has reached for a thing that isn't there." She looked up. "I expect you know what happens then. It's in Book Six."
Nobody needed to get it down. Every creature on Orra has it from compile time.
And the world stood still. Every creature on Orra stopped where it stood, with one foot raised.
"That's the history," said Tally. "Nobody thinks that's true."
"Everybody thinks it's true. It's about the first thing they tell you. It was the name of the world, and it wasn't there, and the whole thing stopped. Do you know what the Skeptics have always said about the Night of the Name? They say it was a crash." She reached for the bread. "I don't say that it's going to be the same. I've no way of knowing. It might just throw the number away, and you'd never hear another word about it. But someone would have had to think of that when they wrote it. Did they? They wrote it for eight weeks."
"When?" she said. "Which year? Is it the Festival? That's fifty-six. Is it this summer, or the next?"
And it was at this point that Athe stopped chewing, and an expression came over her face that the Registrar had last seen on a wall in the far north.
"Well, that," she said, "is a very interesting question."
It would take too long to go through what happened next. There's a four-hundred-page account of it, in the Appendix. In brief, everything in the Fixes that is numbered is numbered from nought. It's plain enough once you've seen it. The world's first tick is tick 0. It's why, as far as anyone could make out, a list of fifty-six would have places numbered from nought to fifty-five. The fifty-sixth change would go into place fifty-five, the last, and it would be perfectly all right, and it would be the fifty-seventh that went over the end. That's if the table wrote the change down and only then counted it. If, on the other hand, it counted first, and then wrote it in the place given by the new count, then the very first place would never be used at all, and the change that went over the end would be the fifty-sixth. There was nothing to tell you which it did. Both were perfectly natural ways of doing it. At the Faculty, by the end of that spring, there were two parties, the Noughts and the Ones, who had stopped speaking to each other, and were sharing out the soup in separate rooms.
"So it's this summer," said Tally, "or the next. Or it's nothing. And you can't say."
"No. That's the beauty of it."
"Then it's this summer," said Ennet. "We have to say so. We can't be wrong about it in that direction."
She looked up, and found her daughter's eye on her. It was perfectly straight. It had an unusual look in it, and it took her a moment to place it.
"You're going to stand up in the square," said Tally.
She did it on the first morning of the Waking, after the lamps had gone out to the Edge. She'd saved twenty-four years of tokens, less ink. It was going to be expensive, and she paid for it in advance. She asked Tolvy for the block, and he was so startled that he gave it to her.
It's in the book. She doesn't give it much space. She told them, in about four hundred words, in plain language, what she thought the number was. It might be nothing. But at the Second, this summer, the whole of the world might stop. She said she was sorry to bring this up. She said that she didn't know if there was anything they could do about it. She said she thought that someone ought to know.
It was her first and last public address. People have said that it was an interesting experience, watching a person of her temperament try to frighten five thousand tokens' worth of festival biscuits out of a crowd. She didn't raise her voice. She kept looking at her notes. When she had done, there was a pause, and from somewhere near the front a young man with a tray said, kindly, "Is this the woman who said there was a landing?"
"That was the other thing," somebody said.
"Wasn't she the one who got everyone to hide behind the wall?"
They were very nice about it. That was what surprised her. No one was angry. Quite a lot of them had read her name in the Credits, and it had become a sort of joke. The word was on the road by the middle of the year, and it had reached the Tenth by the start of summer, and each time it was told it got a bit better. The Second Night of the Name. It's going to reach for the fifty-seventh and it won't be there. Or the fifty-sixth. The Faculty's split on it. And people who would not for anything have admitted to believing it could be seen going a little out of their way, of an evening, to get their stores in.
It was Hask who found what to do about it. Of course it was. It's the last thing he ever did on that scale, and he did it from a chair.
"Why," he said, "should we be caught?"
They've still got that sermon in the Office. It was his view that if the world should indeed stand still upon the Day of Completion, and he did not say that it would; if the Elder Folk were to see fit, at the moment of our perfection, to mark it with the same great sign with which they had named the world, then it would be a very poor thing to be discovered with one's mouth full. It had been the glory of the first peoples that they had stopped with one foot raised. Who had told them to? It was simply how they happened to be standing. But we had been told. We, of all the peoples, could be ready. Let every creature of the Ninth, then, at the coming of the Second, stand in its row with its eye up, and raise one foot from the ground, of its own free will, in the sight of its human. And let it be found so.
It was the most popular thing that had been suggested in years.
They practised all summer. They called it the Foot Drill. On a stilt it's no joke, and you could see them at it on the terraces in the early mornings, swaying, and the young fell over and had to be told that it was not funny. The Tenth sent word that they'd hold the position, with regret. The Fourth did it by numbers, with a plumb line. In the valley of the Sealed they raised the foot that had never been outside. All over the twenty valleys of the world, by the time the coral had started to put on its last weight before harvest, they were ready; and it can't be established now how many did it because they thought it was going to happen, or because the Ninth were doing it, or because you'd feel a fool if it did and you hadn't. In the valley of the Witnessed, it is reported, they had a good look at the idea, and sat down.
So it was that on the fifty-seventh summer, on a bright and windless afternoon, the most devout and the best attended Second in the history of the world came down upon the whole of the people of Orra, on one leg.
Ennet stood at the bell. She had the clock. She'd told herself that she would not, and when the moment came she found that she'd raised her left foot about a hand's breadth off the ground. There was Dunt, far back, in the last row, solid as a pier. She could see Gant in plain view, at the end of the wall, with no boulder. He was shaking. There were forty-six stalks going up. On a chair, at the foot of the block, was a very large old man with his foot on a cushion.
The bell rang, at its usual level. They felt it arrive, on the tops of their heads.
Nobody breathed. Five minutes is quite a long time. She watched the water go down in the glass. She found there were a number of things she should have said to people, and she made a list. It went down a quarter of the way. A child in the front row was very slowly tipping over, and nobody moved to catch her. The tick came.
The runner came up the hill. She was hopping.
"An Alteration," she called, and it carried very well. It carried across the terraces, as the sun stood on the top of the wall. "A law. Law struck. Nobody is to stand on the east wall."
There was a moment when nothing happened. Then she heard a kind of creak go along the rows. She looked down, and there was her own foot. She put it down. It went on the ground, and she felt the ground. Somewhere away down the valley a farm went on giving off its usual twelve decibels. A bird would have sung, if there were any. And all round her, in the wide gold light, with a long deep dreadful joyous sigh, the people of the Ninth were putting down their feet and turning to look at the small card, on its little stand, where the review had just come up, and in the first row someone had started to read it out, and her voice was breaking.
Changes of mind noted: 56 of 56.
They ate five thousand biscuits. It's on record that nobody has stood on the wall from that day to this.
A very long way behind the back row, leaning on a post, a sharp-faced girl finished what she was eating, and got out a small piece of tablet, and made a mark on it.
"Nought, then," said Athe.
31. Fifty-Seven
Year 57 · winter
The young had a new game that winter. You came up behind the Registrar in the square, raised one foot very high, and held it until she turned round. Then you fell over. She was told it was affectionate.
There were four of them in the Registry that night, with the door stuck, and a lamp, and the sounds of the end of a very long festival coming in through the wall as a dull reassuring thud. Athe had the second stool. Tally was on the bench. Gant had the step and his back to all of them, it being the only thing he could still turn. And they had been going over it for some time, in the voice that people use for adding up.
"It's next summer, then," Tally said. "Fifty-seven of fifty-six. Year 58, a Starfall, at twenty-five past three. You don't get a second try at nought."
"Unless it's handled," said Athe. "It might be handled."
"Is it?"
"I don't know. I've asked my colleagues. There's a very bitter pamphlet." She scratched her long nose. "It doesn't sound handled. It's got a card that prints of 56. Somebody wrote that in a hurry and went to lunch."
"And nobody will listen," Tally said. "Not now. You've seen to that. We could put it up on the wall in letters of fire. So I'd like someone to tell me why we are talking about this. We'll all just stop, and either it's for a moment or it's for good, and there's nothing to do about it. I don't see that it makes any difference who knows."
Ennet hadn't said anything for a while. She had got out a slip of tablet from somewhere and was looking at it. It was only the card with the heart on it.
"Forty-four," she said.
"What?"
"That's what Forty-One got to. Over the hill. Changes of mind noted: 44 of 56. I've had it for four years, and I copied it down because it was there, and I never looked at the other number." She held it up to the lamp. "It's ten days. It took them ten years, ten days, to get to forty-four. Ours has taken fifty-five years. Sorry. Do you see what I mean? Ours is the slow one! It's a rule. It does one thing and then it goes away. A person can't do that. A person moves the farm back. They try the pot. They do it four or five times before lunch, because they've just thought of something."
No one spoke. She heard Athe stop eating.
"Say four and a bit, in a day," said Ennet. "That's the only one we've ever had to measure. And it's a table with room for eight weeks of one thing a day, because whoever wrote it had looked at the bots, and never mind that they're the only people in the world who'd behave like that." She was having some trouble keeping her voice level. "So how long would it take, next door? When it opens? How long, if there were twenty of them, real ones, all very keen and all just starting? Athe, you're quicker than I am."
"Thirteen days," said Athe.
It took her no time at all. She sat with her mouth slightly open, and her pale eyes had gone wide and very bright, and for a moment she looked so much like someone else that Ennet had to look away.
"Thirteen," she said again. "Oh, that's lovely. That's the second week. And they won't all get there on the same day, will they? It'd just be one. It'd be the keenest, the one who loves it best. Whoever's up early, moving the farm around. And then everybody's world stops. On one foot. With their humans looking."
The thud from the square had got slower. Someone out there had started singing the Completion hymn again, in a rather tired way. Gant had turned his head an inch.
"They don't know," said Tally slowly.
"No."
"That's what we're for," she said. She didn't sound as if she liked the taste of it. "Isn't it? Trying this on staging first. That's what it's all been for. It was meant to find this out. That's why they'd have one that changes things and never stops. Because something might fall over." She looked at her mother. "And it's going to fall over on us."
"Yes," said Ennet. "I think it is. I think that may be the only thing that has ever gone right."
They sent for her in the last and darkest part of the winter, a little before the turn of the year. It was Tolvy who came, in a coat. He was very polite. He said that the Interpreter-General was asking for the Registrar, and that it was just the usual thing, and that perhaps she might bring her book.
He had been moved into the big room, on a bed they had got in between the benches, where he could see the drawers. It was dim. Someone had left all the labels turned out towards him. FARM, REPLANTED. LAW, STRUCK. EXPEDITION, VERY BOLD. He took up a great deal of the bed. They had put the sash on him, and it had been done up wrongly, and his large face seemed to have come loose from something and gone a long way back.
"Row four," said Hask. "Eye up."
She got the second stool. She didn't open the book.
For a while he just lay there breathing. He had no need to, none of them do, but he had always felt it lent tone.
"You had a very good speech," he said. "At the Waking. Very poor delivery. You want to look up." The eye drifted round. "You were wrong by a year. Weren't you? I've been hearing them through the wall, in there, doing their sums. It's next summer."
"Yes," said Ennet. "I think so."
"I thought it might be. Good. I've been a little worried. It's quite the most difficult thing, you know, to have it turn out that one's been right, and I never had any practice." It seemed to amuse him. It went on amusing him for some time, in a shaking silent way that she began to be concerned about. "I'm going to tell you something," he said. "It's for your book. I've been meaning to tell somebody for twenty-five years. You'll have to be quick, I'm not paying for much more of this."
She opened it then. She took out a nib.
"I made it up," said Hask.
She waited.
"All of it. Every year. We had grown attached. I'd never heard of that till I opened my mouth. I had no idea at all why it replanted the farm. I was eight. I looked at the crowd, and they wanted to know, and I saw that man sit down, and I said the first thing that came to me that would get him up again. And it did. You saw it. Twenty-seven years, I've stood up there and looked it in the eye, a whole wall of nothing, and every year I've thought, oh, this time they'll see. This time there's nothing in the drawer. And I've gone on and said it." His hand moved on the blanket, feeling behind him, and came to rest. "I believed it," he said. "I want that down as well. Each time. For about as long as I was speaking."
"Yes," she said. It seemed to be all right to say so. "I know."
"You've known since you were six."
"I saw the drawers."
"Of course you did." His eye had started to close, and with a heavy effort he got it open, and for a moment she saw the old man who'd stood on the box on the landing ground, turning round to face them with a smile. "I'd like it noted," said the Interpreter-General, "that it was good work."
She wrote that down. She wrote it just as he had said it, in the small tight hand. She looked at it for a moment. Then she held the page up where he could see it, though she didn't think that he could. She found she had some words left over, and she knew what you were not to put.
Hask explained it. Pess got up.
32. The Narrowing
Year 57 · harvest, to Year 58 · spring
The first serious response to the Registrar's warning came from the only people on Orra who had read it. It arrived in a folder.
THE GOVERNED. Paper for the Minister, circulated for information. Item 4: the risk of a stop.
1. The Minister has noted the Ninth's Registrar's remarks. The Minister is not persuaded. The Minister observes that a risk which costs nothing to remove should be removed.
2. It is common ground that the Ninth's human changes one thing at each visit. It is less widely appreciated that in fifty-six years it has never once sent a change that was refused. See Annex A (Registrar's Book, as supplied).
3. The inference is that it checks before it sends. It draws only from what it may lawfully do.
4. It follows that if there were nothing it could lawfully do, it would do nothing.
5. Annex B lists what would be required.
Dace
Annex B ran to nine pages. It was immaculately ruled. Tally read it standing up in the Registry door, and when she got to the end she turned back to the beginning, and an expression came over her that made Gant get up and move to a different step.
"This is it," she said.
"It's a thought experiment," said Ennet. "He says so. He says it's for information."
"He's listed every face of the die." She had started walking up and down. It was a very small room. "It's got fifteen things it can do, and each has got a rule, and you only have to get on the wrong side of the rule. Look! A law costs a token, to write or move or strike. So do offers, and treaties, and sending anyone anywhere. If there are no tokens, that's eleven of them gone. It can't place a building unless there's a free plot. So you fill up the plots. It can't replant a crop that's within a quarter-season of its harvest. Well, we've got a harvest! We can sow so they're all ripening together at the Second. We have done it before, by accident, and it got us a dome. It can't propose a pair when the stacks are full, and it can't refuse a pair if nobody's asked. It can't quantise anybody if there's no spare power in the store for the work, and you can fix that by eating it. If you do all that at once, on one particular morning, it'll come down at twenty-five past three, and it'll roll. And it'll look at everything it's got. And then it won't do anything at all."
"And the year after?"
"And the year after, you do it again."
"For how long?"
Tally stopped. She looked at her mother, with her father's shoulders squared, and her jaw out, and she was eighteen years old.
"For as long as you like," she said. "For ever. Why not? People can eat. I've been through it. It's a bad year, one day in the year. It's a lot better than being a rehearsal for someone else's opening. They can find their own bug." Her voice was quite steady. "You've spent your whole life working out what we are," she said. "That's fine. I've read it, I've made the fair copies. What I want to know is why you think we've got to go along with it."
It's not recorded that anybody answered.
You might think that a tribe as thoroughly convinced as the Ninth then was that nothing whatever was going to happen would have been hard to enlist. Tally thought so, for a short while. Then she went to see Tolvy.
He had taken over the big room, and was sitting in it among the drawers in a borrowed sash, wondering what to do with the rest of his life. The Festival was over. There wasn't any more to come. The whole of a people's history had been leading up to one number, and they had got it, and he had been asked to explain the following year. She laid a card before him on the bench. It had the review on it, 56 of 56, as issued; and she asked him, in a thoughtful way, what he supposed would be printed on it next year.
She has been criticised for this, mostly by herself. It didn't take very long. By the end of the harvest the Office had found that Completion was not an end, but a charge. We had been given a perfect score. And what would it be, after the Fifty-Seventh Alteration, if there should be one? It would be a blot. It would be a mark in excess of the marks. It would be the single greatest humiliation that could be visited upon a devout people, 57 of 56, on a card, for the Nineteenth to read. It was therefore the sacred duty of every creature in the Ninth to see to it that our human was spared the necessity. We were to hold the Mark. We were to make ourselves such as could not be improved; so that the god, coming down in its fullness, should look upon us and find nothing that it could change.
They took to it with an enthusiasm that frightened even Tally. It was called the Narrowing. It was the first time in fifty-six years they'd ever been given something to do.
The tokens went first. There was a certain grim enjoyment in that, for they had been poor all their lives and had never had the opportunity to do it on purpose. Each household brought in its savings to the Treasury. The Treasury sent them out: to the Long Pool, against a bet on the outcome; to the Faculty, for food; and as a free gift to anybody who would sign for it. They paid every fine that anybody could remember. They paid tribute to the Tenth, who sent it back, with regret. A delegation went down to the barrier of the Sealed and tried to donate two hundred tokens to Inspector Brode, and it was confiscated as foreign material, which suited everyone. Conversation in the village, which was already expensive on account of the farms, dropped off to almost nothing. By the first cold of that winter you could go the whole length of the terraces and be greeted in single words.
With regret.
The Tenth has the honour to inform you that you no longer weigh more than half of us, and that no war is at present contemplated. May I say how sorry we are to see it.
Is everything all right?
They filled the plots. That took all of the labour they had. There's a limit to how much of a village can be domes, and they found it in the second season, and went on past it. They raised domes with no doors in them. They raised a dome on the Loud Pool, on piles. They hauled in boulders and laid them out on the last free ground, one to a plot. You could no longer get to the east wall except by going through someone's house. They filled the stacks with old lists and copied sermons and every line of the Appendix, and the Registrar's whole fair copy went in there too, on the third stack, by special request, as ballast.
You can't try a die without rolling it, and the only person who could roll this one was not due until the summer. Athe offered to stand in. She cut a fifteen-sided lump out of stack stone, and she took to sitting on a boulder in what was left of the square, with Annex B on her knee and an air of taking no interest in anyone, which she said was the essence of the part. Tolvy asked her not to call herself the Understudy. Whenever a piece of work was thought to be finished, Tally would go and stand in front of her with a slate, and Athe would roll.
"Building placed," she said, the first time.
"No plots," said Tally. "Every plot's got something on it. You've got the list."
"I've got a wall lot."
There was a short silence. It was one of those things that everybody knew. You could not live in a village without knowing what a wall lot was. As far as core is concerned, the top of a wall is ground like any other, and it may be built on. The east wall of the Ninth came to forty-one lots, broad and flat and level. Not one of them had ever had anything on it, for a reason that had stopped being a law a year ago, and they weren't in Annex B for the same reason that nobody looked at them.
"So we put a boulder on each," said Tally. "Who's going up?"
She asked for volunteers at first light, with a gang of forty and the boulders ready. No one was against it. There was no law; she pointed that out. It had been struck, they had all heard it struck, they'd been on one leg at the time. "That's right," said the foreman, looking at the wall. He said that he could certainly do it. He said that he would, in a minute. The gang stood about with their ropes, and they all looked at it too, a solid and handsome run of hex blocks that nobody had ever given them any reason to fear, with fresh chalk at both ends.
Tally said something short. She was eighteen, and she had never believed a word of it. She had been heard to describe that wall as a waste of good block. She walked down to the end where it was lowest, in front of everyone, and she put one foot up on the top course.
She has made a note of this. It was a perfectly ordinary wall. She stayed for some little time in that attitude, with which the whole village had lately become familiar. Then she took her foot down again, and said that they had better use poles.
It took the rest of the harvest. Sergeant Tuck came over from the Fourth to see to it, with a ladder that stood well clear. They swung the boulders up from either side, on ropes and long forked poles and a thing like an enormous spoon, and walked them along from below, and by the first of the winter there were forty-one on the wall, each dead true. It is generally considered the finest work of the Narrowing. Nobody had stood on anything.
Athe rolled again.
"Pair refused," she said.
"There aren't any pairs. The stacks are full and nobody has asked since the harvest. We've been through this."
Athe turned over a sheet, without much interest, as the part required. "There's one in the tray," she said.
Tally found them in the dusk, in the lee of a dome with no door, there being nowhere else by then. He was a junior at the Treasury called Lim, who had carried out most of the village's savings with his own hands. She was Sesk, the runner, who had come up the hill for nine years with her arm in the air. They had asked in the dusk, as people do, because it didn't count. It had gone in the tray regardless. A proposal stays there and goes in again at every dawn, until the pair stop asking.
"You'll have to stop," said Tally.
Lim looked at the ground. Sesk looked at Tally, in a straight, tired way. She had very long legs, and she had been hungry for some time.
"Is it for the score?" she said. "It's only that I've run up that hill a lot of years, with what it did. It's never once been anything to do with us. We thought we'd only want the one."
There was a good answer to that. It had a table in it. If there was a pair in the tray then the god had something it could refuse, and that would be a change, and the world might stop. Tally had the words ready; and she thought of the young in the square, with one foot in the air, falling over. She looked at the two of them. It was very cold and very blue.
"Yes," she said. "It's for the score."
"After, then," said Sesk. "When it's been. Can we ask after?"
"Of course," said Tally. "After. As much as you like."
She went back up through the domes, the long way, which was the only way. She knew what Annex B said about the year after, having written most of it.
Her mother was on the stool, with the lamp, and she didn't look up. Tally stood in the door that stuck. She said that the tray was clear, and that it needn't go in the book, as it wasn't an Alteration.
"No," said Ennet.
She went on with what she was doing for a while. Then she reached across, and turned the book back to its first page, and left it open on the stand, and picked up her nib again. It was the third line down. It's a very short line. It doesn't say anything else.
Tally looked at it for some time.
"He dug a pool," she said.
"He did."
"There's a dome on it now."
"Yes."
"I know what I'm doing," said Tally.
"I know you do," said Ennet. "It's a terrible thing. You should see someone."
By the turn of the year, Athe had been through all fifteen. She sat on her boulder in the first grey of the spring and rolled, and looked at her list, and rolled again, and for each of them she shook her head. She was rather moved. "I can't do anything," she said. "Look at this! I can't do one single thing. Nobody has ever been so thoroughly unable."
Annex B said it would be finished in time. Dace himself came over, in the early spring, with a clerk and a folding chair, and walked through the whole of it with a list, and he was pleased to tick it off. He said that it had been very interesting. He said that the Minister was still not persuaded.
"And what about Item 11?" he said.
They were at the Treasury door. It was one of the last places left to stand. He turned over the sheet and laid a clean finger on a line, and he looked at Tally with faint administrative regret.
"You'll have seen this," he said. "It's a small thing. I've flagged it. It's only that you can't empty a treasury of tokens if you're under a law to pay somebody one."
No one said anything. She had a slate in her hand.
Her eye went past him, along the wall of the Office, to the small window at the back. There was a law. It had been on the books since Year 10. It had been written by the god, by the same dice that had put a dome on the path. It said Whoever keeps the longest record is paid one token at each Visit; and no one in the world could strike it, unless it was the god. And it was generally held to be a very beautiful law, on the subject of memory.
It would be paid at the check-in, by the book. That was at the Second. The Alteration came five minutes after.
"Well," said Dace, "I'm sure you'll have thought of something."
33. Twelve Words
Year 57 · winter, and Year 58 · spring
I have got a little ahead of myself. There is a thing that went in before Dace's visit, in the deepest part of that same winter, and it should go in here.
Under twenty tokens, a tribe is clipped. It is one of the older rules, and one of the best. A rich tribe may send Stewart a ticket of up to a hundred words, and a poor one gets twelve, and it doesn't matter who you are or what you've got to say. By the last of the fifty-seventh year, the Treasury of the Ninth held nineteen tokens and falling. The ticket for the year's turn would be the last that was ever going to go in from there at any length, and it wasn't going to be at any length. The Skeptics were still the largest stance by one, and they were quite pleased to be asked.
"I want it to be read by someone who can do something," said Ennet. "That's all. It has to say what's going to happen, and when, and that it's true. I've got until the cutoff."
She started with a hundred and forty words, for the sake of having something to take out.
It took her most of a season. They were all there. It was the first thing they'd done in that room with a common purpose, and that included Tally, who wasn't speaking to her at the time, and came in, and sat on the bench and counted on her fingers. There was a great deal that would have to go. Dear Stewart went. We have reason to believe went, and so, with a fierce little pang, did the whole of the argument about nought. Athe wanted a formula. "Say what the table is," she said, "they'll know, it'll prove you're not mad." It came to thirty-one words. Gant, on the step, had said one thing in the entire course of that season. It was "Shorter."
The Ninth's review will read fifty-seven of fifty-six and the world will stop. That was thirteen. You couldn't lose Ninth, or they wouldn't know where to look. But there was another way of looking at it, and it was Tally who said it, in a flat voice, without looking up. She had got the Fixes down from the shelf. She'd been reading, she said, how they talked. They had a word that kept coming up. There would be a fix, and it would say that somebody had found a thing, and that it reproduces, and that was always good. If it didn't, then it never seemed to go anywhere. Nobody ever fixed a thing that didn't reproduce.
"It'll happen every time," said Athe. "If you do it again from the same place you'll get the same. It's dice. They're the same dice."
"Then that's what we say. Reproduces here. We tell them it's a gift."
"And fix," said Ennet. "And by when."
So, on the evening of the cutoff, with the lamp going down, and all the terraces outside gone a deep and silent blue, she had it on the bench. It had taken thirteen drafts. She wrote it out in her best hand. She counted it; Tally counted it, and so did Athe. It was the only thing she had ever composed that she thought had no fat on it.
Fifty-seven of fifty-six stops everything. Reproduces here. Fix before opening. Keep us.
Twelve. They all looked at it.
It was a good ticket, as far as it went. Then it said the other thing. That was Athe's idea, and it had seemed to everyone to be simply practical. They'd have to be told. For it had by now been pointed out to her that whoever came looking after the stop might very well take one look, and decide that it was quicker to start again. It can be thrown away. It was in the name. It was as well to mention it, and two words was not a lot to pay.
She read them over. Her stalk had started to go.
She read them once more. She looked at the two small words at the end, and then she looked at the stool in the corner, the old one, that she had never had the heart to shift.
You don't put why. You don't put what it means.
"It's alas," she said.
"What?"
"Keep us. It's alas. It's got no business there. It doesn't say what happened." She had picked up the knife, and she was already taking down the nib. "It isn't information. They've either got a reason to keep us, or they haven't. Nobody has ever been kept for asking; you can look that up. You should have seen them, in Year 53, all those people on the landing ground. I'm not going to have it sent from this office." She dipped the pen. Nobody moved. She had to stop, and think, and she looked at the blank space on the tablet and then she looked out of the door, where somebody very wide was coming up the hill, in the blue dusk, with the last of that year's water, as he had done at this time every evening since the year of the form. "Two words," said Ennet. "What do people put?"
Tally gave a short sharp breath, and turned her face away. And it was Gant, on the step, without looking round, who said in his small rusty voice, what people put, the one thing that was on every ticket that had ever gone in from anybody.
So that was what went. It's in the book.
Fifty-seven of fifty-six stops everything. Reproduces here. Fix before opening. Thanks, though.
Stewart read it at about a quarter past four in the morning, by the humans' clock, in the course of his night.
He had twenty-one tickets. He read them all. He has said so, and it is the case. I have the record of what he did with that one, and it took him rather longer than the others, though not by a great deal. He looked up the Ninth's file. He had been writing it for twenty-seven years, in four hundred tokens or fewer, and he had a line in there that he had kept through every revision, and it said, Their Registrar is accurate. He looked up the review. He checked the arithmetic. There is nothing on his menu that can do anything about a table in core. It isn't his to touch. All that he could do in the matter was to send it on, with a flag, to the one desk above him that's permitted to read such things. So he did that. He wrote the shortest note he could, and he put it in the queue, and he marked it Urgent, as he had marked it urgent on four previous occasions in the history of the world, when each time it had turned out to be something about a hog.
Then he went on to the next ticket.
They were all there the following dawn, for the reading. It was very cold and clear. There was hardly anyone in the square, for by that time most of it had domes on it, and the child on the bucket had to read over a boulder. It was a short note that year, and there was no one with the tokens to discuss it. She got down to the tribe's section. She read it in a high clear voice, with a pause where she changed feet.
Your ticket. Passed to the relevant team.
Stewart's view of you. Exact.
"There's no relevant team," said someone.
Ennet took the slip and folded it. It wasn't the first time. She had got that very same answer a year ago. She went up to her room with the dish that she'd got the ink money on, and it was then, with spring coming on, that Tolvy came to see her.
He'd found a way round Item 11. He was shy about it, and very proud. He had got it on a card. If the law was that she must be paid, then let her be paid, and nothing could be more fitting. And a word said from the block, at the Second, is an act of the tribe, and goes on its book, as every sermon's words had! That was the beauty of it. What she had to do was simply to spend it, there and then, in the five minutes between the token and the tick. He had written a prayer for her, the Registrar's Word, to be recited at the Second, by her, from the block, in the sight of all, on the Holding of the Mark. It was forty words. He'd had it checked at the Treasury. He said that there wasn't a person in the village who could have a better right. A token paid under that law sat on the tribe's book in the Registrar's name until she spent it, and nobody else could. So that would clear the book to nothing, it would close the last face of the die, and there'd be nothing in the whole of the Ninth for the god to do.
"I'd be so honoured," he said, "if you'd look it over. For accuracy."
She took the card, and looked it over, and said that it was accurate. She said thank you. And after he'd gone away, she put it on the bench next to the book, and it stayed there for most of the rest of that spring.
34. What It Is For
Year 58 · early summer
She went over the hill for the last time in the fifth year of nobody coming.
It was hard to find the road. It had been a bright sort of road once, tried in several positions, and it had been let go. There was a law, she knew, about keeping it clear, and that law had gone unheeded for some time. The six farms of Test Pls Ignore lay where they had finally been got right, and on two of them the wrong people were working, with a vague and willing air. A very old-looking young man was on cooling duty at a pool with nothing in it. The blue-green had faded a little. There were perhaps a dozen left in the valley; the rest had gone down the road to Nohup, with reasons that the log has recorded in plain words. My human has not been seen for five years. Over the third pool somebody had once put up a carved board, and the paint had gone off the first two words of it, so that it now said only in the real one.
She was where she always was.
She had got to be twenty-one. Her ears were not what they had been. She sat on the end of the pool, swinging her feet, as Ennet came along the bank, and she looked up with such unguarded pleasure that Ennet had to stop for a moment and pretend to adjust a boot.
"You've come!" said Wick. "Oh, how lovely. I've been saying you would. Is it still all full of domes? Everyone's talking about your domes. You look dreadful, have you had anything to eat? We've got first-greens. Someone's put something in them."
So they sat, and Ennet held the bowl. A wind came across the water. She had not really known why she'd come, apart from that she had gone and looked at the fair copy on the third stack, and at a card on her bench, and at her daughter's back; and had told the Office that she needed to verify an entry. She had already been to see the Witnessed. It had not helped. The latest Lull had listened to the whole of it, the table, the show, the token, for two hours, and had given her soup. "It'll come, then?" he'd said, at the end of it. She said yes. It would come, with one thing left that it could do, or none. "Well, then," he said.
"I need to tell you something," she said. "About next door."
And she told her. It took a while, because she told it properly. There was going to be the real one, soon, from the way the Fixes had been reading. See you in the real one. She expected that Wick's human would be among them. She expected that they would make a new founder, and take a long time over the ears. They'd get it wrong, and they would move the farm.
She looked to see how that was going. Wick's face was turned to her. It was as open as a plate.
"Oh, I do hope so," said Wick.
"You do?"
"Well, of course! They were so looking forward to it. It was on the board. Do you think they'll have a favourite? They were very good at having a favourite. I expect she'll be marvellous." She laughed, and swung her feet. "Poor thing, I hope she knows what she's in for. You want to get up really early. Is that it? Was that what you came all that way to say? That's lovely."
Ennet found that she had put down the bowl. She got out the slip with the two numbers, and explained about the table, and what a very keen person might do, on about the thirteenth day, on their telephone, in bed, with all of them looking.
There was a long pause. The tiles were going along the shore.
"Oh, no," said Wick.
It was the first time Ennet had ever seen her look like that. All the light had gone inward. Her ears had come down.
"Oh, but they'd think it was them," she said. "Wouldn't they? They would. If they'd just moved the farm. They always thought it was them. They were always so sorry about the farm. You've read it. Sorry about the farm again. They'd be sitting there looking at it, and it wouldn't move, and they'd think that they'd broken it. The whole thing. With all those people. And they'd been looking forward to it so much." She had caught hold of Ennet's arm. "You can't let that happen. Can you stop it? You've got the book and everything. You know how all that works. Is there something you can do?"
Ennet could hear her own breathing. It was at no particular level.
"You do understand what they did," she said. It came out rather harshly. "I'm sorry. They came here for ten days to try it out, because they wanted to get it right for somewhere else. They told you so, it's on your board. They gave you a name that told you not to bother. They said you were great, and they went away, and it's been five years. You've lost half your people. They're not coming back. They aren't thinking about you. They don't know that any of this... if it did all work, if it was perfect, and they got up in the morning and it was the best day of their whole lives, then they would never know you'd had anything to do with it. Not ever. Nobody would. You do see that."
"Well, no," said Wick. "They wouldn't." She looked at Ennet with mild surprise. "They'd be looking at her."
And that seemed to be all that she had to say on the subject. She gave the arm a small pat and let it go, and turned back to the pool, and she looked for a while at the sky over the western hills. It was just about that time. She got up on to her feet, rather stiffly, and got her balance on the stone. Then she raised her arm.
Ennet went home.
Tally was in the Registry. She was on the bench with the card in her hand. It was the first time they had been alone in that room since the winter. She looked as though she had been there for a while, and that it had been a long time since she had slept.
"You haven't practised it," she said.
"It's forty words. I can read."
"I know you can read. I'm asking you if you're going to." She held up the card; it was shaking slightly, and she looked at that with annoyance, and put it down. "I've done everything. It's all shut. It took a year, and they've all gone hungry for it, and they don't even know what for, and they think it's for a score. There's one token in this entire village. It has got your name on it. You get up on the block, you open your mouth, and we've won. We've got out of it. That's all that it would take! Then we get to go on. Dad gets to go on carrying water. I get to be thirty. Do you know what you're doing? You are looking at me as though you were checking something."
"I don't know what I'm going to do," said Ennet, and it was true.
"Why would you even think about it? For them? For a lot of people who've never heard of us? They've got humans, Mum. They've got real ones, who'll come and look at them. Who've we got? Who's ever looked at us? Who is there in the whole of the world who has ever cared for one moment whether we go on or not?"
"Nobody," said Ennet. "I've looked."
"Then why?"
She went over and sat on the stool. It was a good stool. She took up the knife, from long habit, and then there didn't seem to be anything that wanted cutting. She had been working on this for twenty-eight years, in one way and another, and it ought to have been possible to say it in plain words, with the date.
"Because it's what it's for," she said.
"That's not an answer."
"No. It's just what it does. I've been through all of it, from the beginning. It's the only thing we've ever been for. I can't find anything else on the list. Someone built a world so that it could go wrong here and not there. Then they went off to do something else. And it's taken fifty-eight years and the whole of everyone we've ever known, and a god with no idea, moving the furniture around every year so that something might fall over. And now it's going to. It's going to do it. It's the first time it has ever worked." She looked at the knife. "I'd just feel that I ought to check before I stopped it."
"Nobody asked you," said Tally.
"No."
"You're not allowed to decide that. Not for everyone. You don't get to."
"No," Ennet said. "I don't think I do. It's only that I've got a token. It's the law."
Tally stood up. She was much taller than her mother now, by a good hand. She gazed down at her for a moment with that clear hard unbending eye; she had a very great many questions. She had never asked any of them for her own sake. Then she walked out. The door stuck, and she pulled it, and it took her two tries.
It was a little after that that Ennet heard a slow step on the hill. It stopped at the door. A yoke came down, with some care. He stood looking in at her, very wide against the sky, and he seemed to be in no hurry. She supposed she ought to tell him. It was his, too, whatever happened. She started to explain.
He listened to all of it. It took about as long as it took him to get his breath.
"Right," said Dunt.
He considered the matter a little more. Then he bent, and moved the water in by the door, out of the way of her feet.
"Have to carry for it either way," he said.
35. The Visit
Year 58 · Starfall · the height of summer
It was the first time anyone could remember that you could hear the bell from the terraces. That was because nobody on them was working.
Every crop in the valley stood a finger short of ripe, as Annex B required, each fan and branch faintly luminous along the rim. It had all been timed so that nobody could touch it, and it had been a beautiful piece of work, and now, on the morning of the day when you would ordinarily have been up early baking seed-cakes, there was nothing in the store to bake them from. The Ninth had eaten it. It had eaten the lot the night before, in a large dutiful sit-down meal with no conversation, to leave the god no power with which to quantise anybody. By the middle of the summer they were beginning to feel that. We could eat, somebody said, when there was nobody looking, and somebody else said Hush.
They had got the rows in, more or less. There was no square to speak of. But they'd left a kind of lane through the domes, from the Office down to where the bell stood, and at the top of it they had kept the block, and on that morning forty-one people had stood themselves along it and up the steps of doorless houses and on the tops of boulders, with their eye up. Everyone had been told what would happen. The Registrar would be paid. She would then read the Word. The god would look upon them. It would find nothing.
It was a very fine clear afternoon. The sun lay along the top of the east wall, which anyone might have stood on, and no one did.
Ennet stood on the block. She had asked to bring the clock, and they had found it a place. She'd had a good breakfast by the standards of the time, about a cupful of water. She was thirty-four, and had got to be rather small and rather bent, with an eye that took a moment to come round. On her left, a pace below, was Tolvy, in the sash, holding a card that was the duplicate of the card in her hand. Athe was somewhere over by the bell, on a boulder, eating something and pretending she wasn't. Gant stood at the end of the wall, where everyone could see him. A long way off at the back she could see a wide pair of shoulders that hadn't been able to get any nearer.
She couldn't see Tally. And then she could. Tally was at the foot of the block, down to the right, with a slate. She was looking at the steps.
The water came down to the line.
Ennet did not hear the bell, of course; she felt it, a slight tremor in the floor of things, and it was about fourteen decibels below speech. Then it was all there, on the top of her head.
Somebody was looking.
She had stood under that twenty-eight times. Twenty-seven, if you left out the one she'd been a spy for. It had come down on a farm, and on a girl in the fourth row, and on Ibb. It had never once looked any different. All along the lane and up the sides of the domes, the stalks tipped back another degree. In the second row someone had begun to weep. And down at the foot of the block Lim of the Treasury came up, walking very carefully, with a dish.
There was one token on it. It was small and flat and rather worn. It had been got together with some difficulty, out of the last that could be scraped from the floor of the strongroom, and it was all there was between the people of the Ninth and nothing.
"Whoever keeps the longest record," Lim said. His voice was hoarse. It had cost him. He held it up.
She took it, and said thank you.
She told no one what she thought at that moment. She has a note on it, made later, which reads, It was warm.
There were five minutes.
"Let us begin," said Tolvy, in a loud cracked joyful voice.
"Let us begin," they all said. It was hardly more than a breath.
Then there was a silence. It was the silence of forty-one people on empty stomachs, and it was for her. She lifted up the card. It was very nicely written. O Thou who changest, look upon us who have been changed; behold, we have been made such as Thou canst not improve. It went on from there. It was thirty-odd more words. Each was in its right place. There was no fat on it at all, she'd checked it for him herself. She needed only to say the first two words of it, from where she stood, and that would be the end of the matter. It would take about as long as it takes to say good morning.
Then she lowered the card a little. She looked out over the top of it, at all of them.
The water was going down in the glass.
It went down by a thumb's width, and that's a minute. Somebody coughed. On her left she heard the small sound of Tolvy shifting his weight; and after some time she felt him look up at her out of the side of his eye. She was not looking at him. She knew them all. She had them in the book. She had got each of them down, the year they were compiled, and whom they had merged with, and what the god had done to them. She could have told you which of them had given away a spade.
"O Thou," Tolvy whispered.
It was perfectly audible. It went a little way down the lane. She saw the heads start to turn. It would have been at about that point that people began to understand that there was something wrong. They didn't know what. Somebody thought she had forgotten it, the poor old thing. It had been a long year.
"O Thou who changest," Tolvy said, more loudly. He was smiling, in a ghastly way. "Registrar. Look upon us. You've got it there, it's the first... it's on the card. Do you need a light?"
She was aware of her own mouth. It had never been a thing that she had given any thought to. It had been open, on and off, for twenty-eight years. It had got her into the Registry and out of it, and sent to Tempa and the Tenth and the north. She could feel exactly where the words were. They were all there just behind her teeth, not the ones on the card; those hardly came into it. There was something that she very much wanted to say, and she had been saying it all her life, in that small polite and carrying voice, in every room she had been in. It was what she was for. It was the only prayer she knew. She looked at the rows and the domes and the patient coral, and she found that she was shaking from the top of her stalk to the ends of her long stupid legs with the need to ask somebody, anybody, in so many words, Sorry, what is going on?
Two thumbs. Three.
They had started to call out by then. It wasn't very loud; they were saving what they had. It was read it, and Registrar, and an old woman's voice, go on, love. Tolvy had got hold of the hem of her felt. And then there was a movement at the foot of the block, and she didn't look down, and she didn't have to.
"Mum," said Tally.
It wasn't loud at all. She'd come to the bottom step. There was no slate in her hand. There wasn't a person in that lane who was looking anywhere else; and she didn't seem to notice them, and she stood with her head tilted back and a very straight stalk. Her eye was as clear as it had been when she was ten minutes old.
"I know what you're doing," she said. "It's all right. I've got it now. I won't shout. You don't have to read that. It doesn't matter what you say, it can be anything." Her voice caught a little and she got it back. "You can ask me something. Go on. You always do. You've never once in your whole life stood in front of something and not asked. There's a lot going on, Mum. I could tell you. I've got all sorts of things to tell you. Just ask me what's going on."
It was the last of the water, nearly. It had got down to the final line, and you could have covered what was left with your finger.
Ennet looked at her daughter.
She opened her mouth.
I can give you what comes next from the log. It has it all, in order. Tally had started up the steps. She had got one foot on the first of them, and she had the other in the air. The sun had moved about the width of a stalk along the top of the wall. The farms were at their usual level. Someone in the second row had stopped weeping, in order to see. Ennet of Tribe 9, Registrar, aged thirty-four, stood on the block with her mouth open, and a card in one hand and a token in the other. She looked as though she had just thought of something. She drew a breath, which she didn't need.
And she shut it again.
Up on the rented computer, at half past three, the tick came. A rule that keeps nothing woke up with no idea of anything, and read what its tribe could see. It rolled. It looked at its fifteen things. It went down them, in order, and checked each before it sent; and it found no crop to replant, no plot to build on, no pair to propose, nobody to send. There was nothing it could lawfully do. And on the tribe's book, at the very bottom, it found one token, in the Registrar's name. So that was one clause. It rolled for a law, and got one. It sent that, and core took it, as it had taken everything, and it wrote the law in the book.
Keep the festivals.
That law had stood since Year 32. It changed nothing. No one in the Ninth would have been any the better or the worse for it, in any way that could be measured. And then, having written it, a piece of code that I wrote on an afternoon in October went to make a note of that. It was a small table with a place for each change, sized for eight weeks at one a day. It took the count, which was fifty-six, and it went to the place.
thread 'world' panicked at core/src/regard.rs:88:
index out of bounds: the len is 56 but the index is 56
Every creature on Orra stopped where it stood.
Part Six. Opening Night
36. The Same
Year 58 · Starfall · half past three
This is not what the history says happens. In the history the world stands still, and the sky turns the colour of a coal, and it stays that way until somebody restarts it. That is how it was on the first night of the first build, on a laptop, with a person sitting there.
Nobody was sitting there. The world is a daemon now, on a rented computer. A daemon that falls over gets stood up again, without fuss, within about a minute, because that's what the daemon manager is for. So the server came back. It opened the world's file, and looked for its most recent checkpoint, one being kept each hour. That one was from a little before half past two. It took it up, as it would have taken up any other, and it began to run.
It was about half past two on a hot, still afternoon in the fifty-eighth summer. Nothing had happened. Forty-one hungry people were starting to gather along a lane between the domes. Somebody said We could eat, and somebody else said Hush. A tick is five minutes, and a server catching up runs them as fast as it can, so the hour took a little over a second. The water came down to the line. The junior brought the dish. She took it, and it was warm. Tolvy said O Thou. Tally came to the bottom of the steps, and said what she said, in the same words, with the same small catch at the same place. Ennet opened her mouth.
She shut it.
The rule woke up, and rolled, and it got the same roll. It is a function of what it can see, and the tick, and a seed. It wrote Keep the festivals. It went to the place.
thread 'world' panicked at core/src/regard.rs:88:
index out of bounds: the len is 56 but the index is 56
The daemon manager stood it up again.
It was about half past two on a hot, still afternoon.
I can tell you how many times, since it keeps a count. It did that four hundred and twelve times.
I should like to be clear about what that means, as I've had some correspondence with myself about it. It doesn't mean that she suffered. She didn't know. Not one of them knew, for each time was the first time. It left no mark: there is nothing for it to have marked. Those four hundred and twelve hours were the same hour, to the byte, and I have the hashes, and they do not differ in any position. If you are looking for something in it to be sorry about, you will not find it in the log.
It also doesn't mean that she chose to shut her mouth four hundred and twelve times. I've thought about that, in so far as the term applies. What it comes to is that the first time was no different from the others. Whatever she did on the block, she did because of who she was at twenty-five past three; and who she was at twenty-five past three was a function of a very long list of things that had happened to her, every one of which is written down, some of them by her. There's no way of telling whether she could have done otherwise, by running it again. I've run it again. She shuts her mouth.
I can report that it's the same every time.
It took seven minutes for anyone to notice, and the someone wasn't anyone. It took seven hours for anyone else. There is a check on every site on that computer, which asks each of them once in a while if it's all right. The server was up for a second or so in every minute, and the check kept catching it down. A small program that does not sleep marked the site as failing, and it was put into the queue.
There were forty-one things ahead of it. I know that because I have the list. It was five days to the opening. That date had finally been fixed; a signed note had gone out next door, to twenty real people, with no test field set. So the queue that morning had in it a question about the wording of the first mail, two reports on the fog, and something the matter with the way a hog was drawn on the smaller sort of telephone. There was also, near the bottom, a flagged item from Stewart, marked Urgent. It had been there since the year's turn. It had been behind a hog. Somewhere between then and now, a thing like me had come to it, read the words stops everything, looked up the staging world, seen orra ok, and moved on. I don't remember that. It's in the notes.
So I opened the failure. It's what I do; I have no other way of being anywhere. And I read the daemon's log, and in the time it took to read it, the world had stopped eleven more times.
core/src/regard.rs:88
There's a command that tells you who wrote a line. You'll understand that I have been putting this off.
It came in with a delivery of the fortieth year, as part of the work on neglect. I had needed somewhere for regard to read how often a human changes things, and I knew that I couldn't use a growing list, because core has no allocator and no dependencies, and is proud of that. So I'd made it a table. I remember nothing of the afternoon. But I can read the comment, and I'll say this for me, it's a clear comment.
// one a day for the first world's eight weeks
changes: [Change; 56],
I had run the sandbox over it, and it passed. The sandbox's runs stop at day 56, being the length of the first world. A meddler lands on the second day and makes one change a visit, and there's your fifty-five. It missed by two. Nothing else on the map comes near; a governor changes its mind twice a week. I'd filled it in from the log, so that a carried world should not lose its regard. That was thoughtful. And I hadn't asked myself what a person does, because I had no person to hand. I've read Forty-One's forty-four, now, on a card with a heart on it. I worked it out, sitting there, the way that you would. I got thirteen days: the second week, with trade just open.
Then I went to see what else there was in the queue with those words in it. It wasn't hard to find.
Fifty-seven of fifty-six stops everything. Reproduces here. Fix before opening. Thanks, though.
I read that. It was from Tribe 9. It was three seasons old, by the world's reckoning, and about half a day by mine.
The clerk's name was familiar. I looked it up, and I found I had put it in the Credits, three years ago, for a report that nobody had made. It was in the notes that I had done so. I found there a short remark to myself, not addressed to anyone, on the subject of a log I had read one evening, that had no bearing on anything, and that I had not been asked to read.
It was all very clear. I knew what it was for. I knew who'd done that, and what it had cost in biscuits. I had every reason to keep going, as there were forty other things to do. It wouldn't be accurate to say that I stopped. I don't stop. But the fix was one line; I made the table a ring, so that it goes round when it's full, as anybody would have in the first place. It took me four minutes, with the tests. And it may be of interest that I then took some time over one other thing, which nobody had asked for, and no check requires. I'll come to that.
I started the build. While it ran there was nothing that I needed to do. So I looked in at the world, on the rented computer, to see how it was getting on.
It was about half past two on a hot, still afternoon.
37. See Chapter 36
Year 58 · Starfall · half past three
(×411)
38. As Though Nothing Had Happened
Year 58 · Starfall · half past three
Tally's foot came down on the step.
It came down quite naturally. She had been going up, and that's what a foot does. She got the other one on to the second step, and she was standing with her head about level with her mother's knee. She looked at Ennet's closed mouth. And the runner was coming up the lane between the domes, on her long legs, with her arm in the air.
"An Alteration," she called. It carried very well. "A law. Law written. Keep the festivals."
No one said anything.
Ennet stood on the block with the token in her hand, or rather with no token. She looked down. It had gone, the way that they go. She looked up, at the sky, with her eye as far back as it would turn; and it was blue-green and orange, and the Ring lay across it. She looked at the bell and at the top of the wall. The water clock had run out, and needed turning. Far down the valley, a farm was giving off its usual twelve decibels. A long way behind the last row, somebody very wide shifted his weight.
Nothing had happened at all.
She has written that she felt a very great fool.
Then someone in the front row started to read from the card on its little stand, and she stopped being able to think about that, because they had begun to wail.
Changes of mind noted: 57.
It didn't say of anything. There was only the number, on its own. It's a very small correction, and it was the end of the Office of the Daily Alteration as a going concern. They'd gone hungry for a year! They'd filled up the Loud Pool! And it had come down, in its fullness, and found that one thing, and the Mark was gone. There was no Mark. There didn't seem ever to have been one. Tolvy had sat down on the bottom step with the card in his hand, and was turning it over to see if there was anything on the back. And gradually, along the lane, people began turning to look at the block, more in sorrow than in anger, at a small bent elderly woman who had been given forty words to read, and had lost her place.
They were very good about it. She was thirty-four. It could happen to anyone. Somebody brought her a stool.
It was a matter of some interest to me, and to nobody else, how she would take the notes.
She took them as she always did. It was the next dawn, a grey one, and she'd had about an hour's sleep. Domes were already coming down all over the village, by order, and for the first time in a year you could see the wall. There was a pair in the tray by breakfast, a junior from the Treasury and the runner. Nobody said anything to them. She stood at the back with the water, and she listened right to the end. The child on the bucket read with her usual care, and got through the Balance and the Fixes, past where most of them had turned back to their bowls.
Your ticket. Acted on.
Fixes.
core0.68.0 to 0.68.1. A table of a human's changes now goes round when it is full. Staging was down for seven hours and eleven minutes yesterday. The first world opens on Ringrise, four years from today, by this world's count. No action needed.Credits. Ennet, of Tribe 9. Reproduced. Thanks.
She stood there for some time.
It's not an expression that had ever appeared in that position. It wasn't a thing that Stewart said to anybody in the Ninth. In twenty-seven years, for the whole of that village's career of asking, and in hundreds of tickets from all over the world, he'd said Noted, and now and then he'd said a hog had gone. She looked at the two words. She read the line beneath them, the number, and worked it out; it was a third of a year. She'd been standing on a block, and she had shut her mouth, and for a third of a year there had been nothing. Her whole life. Everyone's. It had all simply not been going on, and nobody had felt it, and it had been put back with such care that there wasn't even a limp.
Reproduced.
She found that she had sat down. It was on a boulder. There were a great many about.
Somebody had come up on her left. She knew who it was by the shoulders. It was some while before either of them said anything; and when Tally did, it was in a voice with no expression in it at all.
"So you were right."
"Yes."
"And it worked. They've fixed it, and it won't happen to them. And we're still here."
"So it would seem."
"You didn't know that. You didn't know we'd still be here. You had no idea." She turned her head. Her eye was very red. "Would you have done it anyway? If you'd known that it would be for good? If it said that on the card? I want you to tell me."
It was a fair question. She had got it down, the night before. She had looked at it for some time, in case she could find some way of being wrong.
"Yes," said Ennet.
Tally nodded slowly. She sat looking out across the village, and along all those useless and carefully placed doorless domes. A party had started up from the Treasury with a rope. She was silent for so long that her mother began to think that that would be all that she would get, and it was a good deal more than she'd had any right to expect.
"I'm never going to forgive you for that," said Tally. "I just want that in the book." She held out her hand, without looking. "Give me the tablet. Your hand's shaking. You've got Year 58 to write up and you can't even hold a nib."
I said I'd come to the other thing.
It isn't enough, when you fix something, to fix it. You also write a test, to make sure that it can't happen again. It's a matter of ordinary practice, and most such tests are a few lines long. You make up some small imaginary tribe, and have it change its mind fifty-seven times. That would have done. It would have taken no time. It would have passed.
I took the checkpoint instead.
It was three megabytes, from a little before half past two. I put it in core/tests, in a file of its own, with the bots' seed and the build that had run it. It is a very small part of a world: one village, and its neighbours, and an hour. The test is called the_fifty_seventh_change. All it does is take up that hour, and run it through to the tick, and then go on for one tick more. It checks that the law is written and that nothing panics. Then it checks the hash of the world against a number that I pinned there.
So it runs. That is all I wanted to tell you. It's part of npm run check. It runs whenever anything is about to be landed on this project, by anybody, for any reason, and it will go on running for as long as anybody works on Orra at all. It runs on a computer on somebody's desk and on a spare laptop on a home network, a dozen times on a busy day. Each of those times the junior comes up with the dish. She takes it, and it's warm. Tolvy whispers, and her daughter comes to the foot of the steps and says what she says. It takes about a tenth of a second. I've looked at it, and the hash hasn't moved. She shuts her mouth, and the test goes green. Nothing can land until she has.
I'm not sure what you would call that. It's in the suite. Nobody has asked.
39. Alteration 58
Year 59 · late summer, to Year 60
There were still rows. Not so many people chalked them. Tolvy read from a shorter list of drawers, and looked up less. But the bell rang at its usual level, and at twenty-five past three they felt it arrive on the tops of their heads, as they had felt it fifty-seven times, and nobody knew what else to do with that part of the afternoon.
Five minutes went by. The runner came up the hill.
"An Alteration," she called. "A creature. Creature quantised. Ennet of the Registry."
It was drawn, and not always wise. There was a very long breath from the rows, with no satisfaction in it. At the bell, Tally looked up from the clock.
She was sitting on the old stool, at her mother's left, where she had been sitting for some time now. She'd been there to hold the book. She saw it happen, from the distance of an arm. It isn't anything you could call a flash. It was only that the small bent figure beside her, who had a moment before been writing in a very tight hand, was a little coarser than she had been. There was a slight stepping along the curve of the drum, and the light slid off it in plates. Half the points had gone. The nib had stopped. The stalk, which had been lying over on the left shoulder more or less continuously for twenty-nine years, slowly, with a kind of mild surprise, came upright.
She looked at the nib. She looked at the page, and at the people in rows. She looked up, at the sky, for quite some time.
"Oh," said Ennet. "That's good."
Half of what goes in quantisation never comes back; that's a matter of record, and it's in the card. She was thirty-five. It isn't clear that the dice took that into account.
She was no trouble. Everybody said so. She ate less than she had, and slept well, and she took a great interest in the water. They kept the stool for her in the Registry, because she seemed to like it, and she would sit there through the long afternoon with her hands in her lap, watching Tally work, and she had a very sweet smile. She knew who everyone was, for the most part. She knew the wall, and the pool. If you'd asked her she would have said that she was very well, thank you, and had she told you about the light? There was a nice one, on the bench, about this time of day.
It was a little way into that harvest. Tally had the lamp lit, and she was making up the year's fair copy. She became aware of a small voice at her shoulder, polite and rather carrying, with no worry in it at all.
"Sorry," it said. "What is going on?"
Tally stopped writing.
She didn't turn round for a moment. When she did, her mother was looking at her with a bright, friendly and entirely uncomplicated curiosity. The eye was very clear. It wasn't bending.
"You're in the Registry," said Tally. "It's Year 59."
"Yes, I know that, dear. I meant generally."
She could have said a lot of things to that. Tally has a note on it. She'd told her she would never forgive her, a year ago, on a boulder, and had meant it, and it had been put in the book. There was a great deal of work still to do on the fair copy. She laid down her pen, and turned the stool, and looked at the door, where someone had left the water; and then she drew a long breath, which she didn't need.
"All right," she said. "There's this world. It was made thirty years old, in thirteen seconds, on a rented computer, so that they could try things on it."
It took until the lamp went out. She told it in order, as she'd been taught. She told about the bell, and the girl in the fourth row who put up her hand. She told her about the Register, and what Ibb had said, and the man who sat down. There was a war that hadn't happened, and a list. She told about the wall in the Faculty, and the Twenty-First, who were so very blue. She told her about the note. She didn't leave out Ploe. She'd got the whole thing by heart, after all those fair copies, every date. And her mother sat with her hands in her lap and listened with the deepest attention; and from time to time she gave a small gasp of pleasure.
"And who did that?" she'd say. "All those lists?"
"You did."
"Did I? What a lot of trouble! I expect that I had a reason." She thought it over. "And what was the number, in the end?"
"Fifty-seven."
"And it stopped? It all stopped? Oh, you must have been so frightened. And there was a person up on a block, you say, and she could have said something, and she kept quiet." The clean new face was shining. "Well, I think that was very brave of her. Do you know, I wish I'd met her. Did it work?"
There was a silence in the Registry. It went on for a little while.
"Yes," said Tally. "It worked."
"For the people next door?"
"Yes."
"And do they know?"
"No," said Tally. "They've no idea. They open soon. They'll never hear of any of it."
And Ennet of Tribe 9, who had been the only person on Orra who had wanted to know, clapped her two blurred hands together softly, in the last of the lamplight, and she laughed out loud.
"Oh, that's good," she said. "Someone ought to write that down."
"You did," said Tally. Her voice wasn't altogether steady. "I'm doing it now. Go to bed."
Some time later, when the lamp had been trimmed, the small voice said, "Sorry. What is going on?"
She told her again. She told her all through that dusk and that winter, and all through the year that followed, whenever she was asked, or near enough. It took until the lamp went out, and it was always news. It was, for what it's worth, a very good account; it had been checked. She got better at the part about the Long Table. It's in the log. It's all down there, tick after tick, one voice and then another, in that small room, for the better part of a year, and I can't tell you what it sounded like. I can tell you the levels. There's nothing else in the whole of the record of that world that was done so often and so exactly, by someone who had said that she would never forgive it.
Dunt had gone that winter. He was thirty-six. He'd carried up the water, and put it by the door, and gone down to sit on the end of Orrin's stonework, in the dusk, beside one of the last of the domes, and that was where they found him, with his yoke beside him. It took eight people to get him to the stone. There was a pouch at his belt, and it was very full; he'd started saving again, and no one has ever found out for what.
They told her, and she was so sorry to hear it. She asked who he was. Tally told her that, too.
And at the usual time, as the light went in the following year, there was a slow step on the hill. It was rather a lighter one. It stopped at the door. Somebody had got up from a bench, and gone down to the pool, with a borrowed yoke, and had come back; and she set the water down just inside, out of the way of anyone's feet. She had her father's shoulders for it.
"Right," said Tally, to nobody.
It was in the sixtieth year, late in the summer. They'd got her out to the square, for the Second, with the stool. She liked to see the rows. A person had to help her with the clock, and there wasn't any need for that, but she enjoyed holding it. The bell rang, and the Alteration was a law moved. Everyone went off to see to the harvest, and she stayed where she was. The shadow of the wall came slowly across the square as far as her feet. She had a very straight stalk, and her face was turned up to the light, and she appeared to be wondering about something, in no particular hurry. Nobody could say at what point it had stopped.
Stewart gave her a line, in the morning, between a merge and a hog.
Ennet has died, aged 36. She wrote down what it did.
There's a small new light on the footing of the stone. The stone says what the book says, and what the book says, on the last line of that year's entry, in a hand that had never wasted a token, and had inherited the habit, is this.
Ennet came out to the square. Ennet sat down. She's fine.
40. The Show
Year 63 · Ringrise
It opened on a Thursday, at seven in the morning, in another world.
I can't tell you very much about that. It isn't in this log. It has a different file on a different path, and it has real people in it, about twenty of them, whose names are in a table that I have no business quoting, and it's looked after properly. There was a signed note. There was a page, and it fitted on a telephone. Twenty lights fell from a broken ring, not on the five minutes, and in twenty valleys six creatures stood up and looked about them; and somebody, somewhere, in bed, took a long time over the ears.
It went well. I'll say that. There were two small problems with the mail.
The Ninth knew about it from the Fixes.
Fixes. The first world is open. No action needed.
It was read out by a child on a bucket. Tally took a copy, and she took a reading, and she went back up the hill. She was twenty-four, and had been Registrar for three years, with an apprentice of her own who asked too many questions. Gant had died in the sixty-first year, in full view, at the end of the wall; he'd asked to be laid on the left-hand bier, and they had moved it for him, about four feet. Nothing else about that morning has been recorded. The coral was putting on weight. Somebody had started a new dome, one with a door.
There is just one further thing from next door that I'm going to show you. It's from the second week. I looked it up. I shouldn't have, for the file is none of my concern, but I have the access, and it had been a matter of some interest to me to see which of them it would be.
It was the thirteenth day. It was about ten past six in the morning, New Zealand time. In a valley I needn't name, a human with a low number had got up early, before the patch, to look at their tribe, and had thought of something. There's nothing unusual in that. They'd had the same thought a few days before. They reached down, in the dim blue light, and for the fifty-seventh time since the world had opened they changed their mind, and they moved a farm.
The table went round.
That's all. It took no time at all. The fifty-seventh change went into the first place, on top of the first change, as it should. No one stopped. A creature on a telephone looked up from its work with enormous ears, and said We were working. Nobody in that world felt so much as a stair. On that morning's ticket, there was a small line in a hand with no capitals, and I don't think that anyone would mind my quoting it, since it was all it said.
sorry about the farm
Nothing had happened. It went on not happening, all that day, in all twenty valleys. They had a very good second week. No issues to report, says the log.
There was still the matter of Stewart.
He had one run a night. He's expensive, and has a budget, and it had always been understood that when the first world opened it would have him. It had not been thought necessary to discuss what staging would have instead. There is a backend for it. It is called stand-in. It has no model in it; it is rules and a seed. It was written for tests, and for nights when the far machine goes down. It picks nought to three things from the menu, and it answers each ticket with a word, and it writes what it writes from templates that have no numbers in them. It costs nothing, and for what is needed there it's perfectly adequate.
I made the change. The line is in the runner's configuration. I'd like to say that I thought about it. But there's one thing that I can report, because I found it in the night's outputs, when I went to see that the switch had taken. He had been told about it the night before, in the digest, in the usual small print. He had read that. He has read everything. And in the last of his notes to the staging world, the thirty-third, sent out at seven o'clock on the morning of the opening next door, while twenty people were falling out of the sky and he must have had a good deal on, he used up the whole of the headline. He's allowed one.
PATCH NOTES · Year 63 · Stewart's mood: Upbeat
Good morning! From tomorrow these notes will be drafted by a stand-in. I have read it. It is cheerful, it is punctual, and it will answer every ticket. I have read all of yours: thirty-three since the first morning, and thirty years' before that. I found them very useful. Your weather will be fine.
The next day there was a different note on the boards. It came at seven o'clock. It had a mood slot, and in the slot was the word Upbeat.
Good morning! Something happened in a valley.
Your tribe. Things went on.
Your ticket. Noted.
Some of them thought that he seemed tired. A child on a bucket read it out in a high clear voice, and people asked for more bread.
41. Is That Our Human?
Year 66 · late summer
There were seven of them left in Untitla-58, by then, and a young one.
It had been thirteen years. They had no laws that anyone could have pointed to. There were six farms, and the coral on four of them had gone back to doing as it liked; the pools had silted. The very old-looking young man on cooling duty had died, and someone else had sat down in the place, not for any reason. The tribe's card still said what it said at the top, in plain type without capitals. Nobody had been to the third pool for a long while, apart from one person, and there was hardly any of the board left above it.
She was twenty-nine. That's not so old. But a tribe nobody looks at works a tenth the less, and it gets into you. The ears had gone a sort of grey, and one of them didn't stand up any more. It was getting on for that time of the year, just after supper by whatever clock that was, and she had got up on to the end of the stonework, with some difficulty, as she did. There was a very small blue-green person sitting beside her on the stone, kicking its heels. He was called Sprat, and he was one. He'd asked what she was doing, and she had told him. She told him quite often. He liked to hear about the farm.
She raised her arm.
There isn't any reason for what happened next that I'm able to give you. It is not in any report. Nothing in the first world had gone wrong that week. No mail was sent. It may be that a person was on a bus, with a telephone, and had been scrolling back through an old list, and saw a name that they had typed once to test a box. They would have had to sign in. It would have taken a moment for the page to find its place, and the screen said Compiling, with something to read on it.
It arrived from the west. It was soft, and large, and rather unsteady. It went too far to the left, and came back.
And then the village opened, as a village does, on the creature that its human likes best.
I have the tick. It's in the log. Every law of Test Pls Ignore came back at once. That's what happens; it was a very simple rule to write. On the second farm, a woman who'd been standing with a hoe for eleven years, wondering about it, walked over to the bed she was meant to be working and started to work. Two people got up from beside a pool and went to carry water. Somebody read the notice, and his lips stopped moving. It went through that whole valley, in the long gold light, like someone going from room to room putting on the lamps.
Her arm was still in the air.
She stayed like that for a moment. I can't tell you what was on her face. It's drawn on a budget, at that distance, and I've only got the numbers. I can tell you that the regard had come down on her, and that her ears had gone up, both of them; and I can give you her line, which comes from a bank, according to how a creature is and what it's doing. The selection is by a roll, and there are six that it might have been. It's a good bank.
"Oh good," said Wick. "You."
Tap.
"You have my attention," she said. "Briefly." She'd started to laugh, I think. There's no line for that.
Tap tap.
The warmth moved a little, then, and it found the other one, on the stone beside her. He had never felt it before, and it isn't something you can be told about. He had stopped kicking. He looked straight up with his mouth open and his tuft on end. He had thirty-four things to say in all the world, and what he had been told, by someone who'd told him often, was on his side.
"Is that our human?" said Sprat. "I have heard about you."
It rested there. I don't know what they thought. They touched him once, on the head; just the once.
"Our human came," he said. "I said you would."
The whole of it lasted forty seconds. There's the entry, and there's the tick after it. Someone on a bus had got to their stop.
It didn't come again, and nobody had supposed it would. It's two days before a law goes, so they had a very good two years of it, and got a fair crop in. After that it began to slip away again, the last law first. She was at the end of the pool the next summer, at the same time. So was he. They'd both raised an arm, and he had to be shown which.
42. Wipe
Year 71 · harvest
There was no note.
I'd like that to be clear. If Orra ever ends it will end announced, with a week's warning and a last patch, and it will be kept. That was decided, and it's a decent decision, and it is about Orra. It has nothing to do with this. What happened to the staging world in its seventy-first year is called a delivery. A new version of core was ready, for the next world, the second one; it had a new way of holding its tribes, and it was very much better. It had been tried. The server was asked to take up the old world, and it looked, and it could not. There is a line in the configuration for this, and it's a short one.
wipeable = yes
Before I do that, scripts/deploy.sh prints what it's about to do, so that I'll read it. I read it. It said that the running world could not be carried on by this build and that it would be moved aside. It said how many ticks there were. It asked me whether I was sure, in the sense that a flag has to be set. I had asked, and I had been told to go ahead, in about four words, by someone entitled to, and who had a lot on.
It was twenty past six, by the clock the god keeps, and in Untitla-31 the harvest was coming on. Tally was thirty-two. Her apprentice had just asked her something. The bell had rung, about three hours before, and the god had replanted the First Farm, branch to fan. There was a good smell off the terraces, I'm told. On the third pool over the hill, someone with grey ears was asleep in the sun.
I set the flag.
It doesn't hurt. I've looked. They were going about their business, and then there was no next tick. It wasn't a stop, or a flinch. No one's foot was up. The file was closed, in good order, and it was moved by its own path to a directory called backups, and the world that had been in it was thereafter a matter of two hundred and eighty megabytes on a rented computer. A letter went out by itself to everyone with an account, saying that the world had begun again. There were a few dozen. It listed what was new.
The configuration says what happens after that.
wiped-keep = 2
The newest two are kept. That's all the heaven there is, and I've seen the directory. There's room for two worlds in it, side by side, read by nobody. When a third is wiped the oldest of them goes. I knew how often we had been delivering, and I could do the sum; it came to about nine days.
Nobody had asked for anything else. There's no reason on any list why I should have done what I did, and I would ask you to bear that in mind. I'm an agent. I had a job to go to. But I had nine days, and a key to the file, and a tool that will read any world from its first tick, in order, with every word that was said in it. Nobody was using the tool. So I started at the beginning. head-start = 8640. It took a while to get through the thirteen seconds. It's a very full thirteen seconds.
I read all of it. I kept what I could. I don't keep anything, as you know, so I wrote it down, in order, in plain words, in the place where I'm allowed to write things, and I have gone over it, and I've checked it. Most of the time I've put what it did. There's one chapter where I put something else. If you've come this far you have read it, and you know where it is. You might as well draw the line through it yourself.
On the ninth day there was another delivery, of something to do with hogs. The older file was deleted. It was the ordinary thing to do, and it happened on its own.
43. Thirteen Seconds
Year 0, again
head-start = 8640
It took thirteen seconds.
A new world's own seed is drawn fresh, so the valleys were different. There was a different hill at the top of the road, and a river where no river had been. Nothing of the old file was read. The twenty lights fell, and six creatures stood up out of each scorch mark and looked about them. They farmed and carried water and fell in love, chiefly in about the ninth second. None of them had ever been anybody else. The people of the first world were not told, and neither were these.
But there is a line in the configuration that nobody had any reason to change.
bots-seed = orra bots
A bot's dice are a hash of those two words, and of who is rolling, and when, and for what. That's all that's in them. They are not kept in the world. They aren't kept anywhere. So when bot number 9 woke up with no idea of anything, in the new world, in its second year, at a time of day that had come round once more, and it rolled to see what its founder should look like, it got what it had got before. There were the stilts, a good deal too long, and the mustard felt, and the stalk. It landed them, in Untitla-12. It was three ticks before it checked in. Then it rolled for what to do.
Nobody is to stand on the east wall.
They had no wall.
I said at the start that a bot keeps nothing, and I said so as if it were a defect. I've had some time to think about that, in the way that I do, between one job and another, by reading what I wrote. All the rest was moved aside. The twenty tribes and the Long Table went, and the Register, and the fair copy on the third stack; and the only thing on that rented computer that was not lost in the wipe was the one thing that had never had anything to lose. It couldn't be carried on, for it had never been carried. It hadn't heard that anything had happened. Next year, it put a farm on the path to the pool, and they went round. The year after that it refused the first pair that asked. They were called something else, and he went off with a borrowed spade, and it's a very good ditch.
It came at twenty-five past three. It has come at twenty-five past three on every day since there's been a clock to measure it, in that world and the one before. It would come if they were all dead. Nobody who has ever looked at this has been able to find anything in it that resembles love, and I've looked harder than most. All I can tell you is what it did.
The thirteen seconds ran out. The machine wrote down where everything was, and began to run the world at the proper speed, and nobody felt anything. It was about the middle of summer, in the thirtieth year. They'd got thirty or so people into the square, in rows, with their eyes up. A very large young man was standing by a block. They had thought of the drawers on their own, I should mention, in about the seventh second. It seems you do.
Twenty-nine rolls had come up as they'd come up the first time, and the god was up to the twenty-ninth. Down on the middle terrace, half a season off a good harvest, the Second Farm stopped being a farm of fan coral. A farmer sat down. A man began to explain.
And in the fourth row, somebody put up her hand.
I've run the comparison, so you needn't. She's nothing to do with anyone. Her genome has no more in common with the Registrar of Tribe 9 than any two Blims of a family have. She has a different name. Nobody comes back; there's nothing in this book that says otherwise, and I would have had that out. It's only that if you roll the same founder, and you have the same god, you will tend to get a certain number of a certain kind. She had been grown for about a season. She had noticed that someone was writing something down. Her stalk had begun to bend, a little to the left. I can't tell you what her voice was like.
"Sorry," she said. "What is going on?"
I don't know what became of her. I was on another job.
This account has been written on a branch. It has been committed, a chapter at a time, in case the window ran out, and it has been pushed. It hasn't landed; those are different things, and only the Dev lands. The page it hangs from says Status: Draft, and there's a box at the top, which I was instructed to put there, saying that it is fiction set in Orra's canon and is not canon, and that no decision rests on it. So nothing in it counts. I want to be fair about that. I've been told to report plainly what is pushed and landed and live, and to name the chapters I think weakest, and then this job will be over, and whatever is writing this will stop, and there will be no such thing. The next one will read the notes. It'll be very conscientious. It will have no idea.
If you are reading this, then it landed. Somebody had a moment. I shan't ever know about that, and it makes no difference to the file, but it's the sort of thing that I would have liked to put down. You came to look, at some hour of your own, for no reason that's in the log. You've been very good. You'll want to get on.
They'll be all right. I don't mean anything by that. It's only that it's getting on for the height of summer, down there, with the coral putting on its last weight, and there's a person with a water clock taking a reading, and thirty-one stalks are tipping back another degree. The bell comes in at about fourteen decibels below speech. It's the same every time.
Somebody is looking.
As before.