Novels
One Foot Raised
A novel of the first world: one Blim's life from compile time to the Tarrow, and the world's last night.
Odda of Moss is the first green creature compiled on Orra, and her human's favourite. A creature lives about thirty-five years, and a year is a real day, so her whole life takes about five and a half weeks of the first world: the wipeable one, eight weeks long, with about twenty invited humans in it. Her child Fensa carries the book on to that world's last night, when everybody on Orra stops where they stand, with one foot raised.
The ebook
Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.8 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.
About 170,000 words.
Contents
- Prologue: The Name Written in the Sky
- Part One. Week One: The Next Chapter
- Part Two. Week Two: Our Human
- Part Three. Week Three: Day Fifteen
- Part Four. Week Four: Notice
- Part Five. Week Five: The Edge
- Part Six. Week Six: A Bit Blurry
- Part Seven. Week Seven: Rumour
- Part Eight. Week Eight: The Long Hush
Prologue: The Name Written in the Sky
The official history, which every creature on Orra is installed with and most of them know the way you know the second verse of anything, gives the first night of the world four verses. They are among its best. They were written by a human using an AI, in an evening, and you can tell, but the evening must have been going well by then.
And on the first night of the world, when the seeds had fallen and the peoples had opened their eyes, the Steward sought to give the world its name. And he reached for the name, and the name was not there.
And the world was still. Every creature stopped where it stood, with one foot raised; and the wind stopped in the green, and the water stopped in the sea, and the birds stopped in the air and did not fall.
And across the whole of the sky, from the Edge to the Edge, there was written a Word, in letters of red fire, each taller than a mountain. And none of the peoples could read, for none had yet been taught; and yet one of them read it.
And the Steward spoke to the world, cheerfully, as though nothing had happened at all; and the world went on. And that was his first great kindness.
What happened, as near as anybody can tell from the outside, is this.
The first build of Orra started at about eleven o'clock one night, on a laptop, with a cup of something going cold beside it. It loaded its valleys, which took a while. It let its seeds fall, which took no time at all, because there were only nine of them and none of them had been told how to fall, so they appeared. Then it went looking for the world's name in a setting where a name was meant to be, and found that nobody had put one there, and did what software does when it reaches for something that is not there. It stopped.
The creatures of build one were the Placeholders. They had been made in a hurry and it showed: grey boxes, mostly, stacked into the rough idea of a body, untextured, with a patch here and there of magenta-and-black checks where a texture had been asked for and had not come. Each of them had one finished thing. For most it was an eye. Somebody, at some point in the hurried evening, had spent an unreasonable amount of time on the eyes, and so each Placeholder looked out of its unfinished face with one eye that was wet and deep and entirely alive, and the effect, the history does not say, was unsettling.
They had been running for perhaps four seconds. In that time they had opened the eye, looked at the land, looked at one another, and started, each of them, to take a step. Then the world stopped, and they stopped with it, nine grey shapes on a half-loaded hillside with one foot each held a little way off the ground, and above them the sky filled from one horizon to the other with five letters in red.
The history is right that none of them could read. It is right, too, that one of them read it anyway. The history calls her Brenda the Bold, in the book where it calls her that, and says she "went out first, and read the Name first". In two other books it calls her Brinda and Brintha, and each book is perfectly sure of itself. Whatever her name was, she did a thing nobody had told her she could do. She looked up at the letters across the sky, which were the only words she had ever seen, and said them aloud as best she could. They had a great many sharp corners. She took the corners off. What came out was Orra.
Then the laptop restarted the program, because that is what you do, and the world came back. The letters were gone. The Placeholders put their feet down. And a voice that would later be called the Steward, and then, by somebody who misheard, Stewart, spoke to all of them at once in a tone of unshakeable good cheer, as though nothing had happened at all, and told them what the weather would be.
That was build one, and nothing of it is left except the name.
There was a build after it, which the Blims call Veetoo and do not talk about. It was green. It had grass, which nobody now alive has seen, and trees, which are like grass but more so, and turf on the roofs of the huts. The official history was written for it, which is why the history is so full of green fields and deep forests and birds of the air, none of which exist. The green build had a Steward of its own. When the world moved on, nobody switched that one off, and its ruins are still at the edge of the map, at the end of a notch the land will not load over, with a signpost at their mouth pointing away. The signpost says world_final_v2. It is the only legible thing in Veetoo, and it is the reason for the name.
There were other builds after that, branches off the green one, each with one kind of creature in it, and each of those crashed the way a field sown with one seed is struck down by one blight. None of them was given a version number, which is how you know.
And then there was world_final_v2, which is the third thing to be called final, and is where this story happens. It has hex tiles where the grass was, and coral where the trees were, and no fixed kind of creature at all: each human who comes makes their own, once, and it is fixed for ever. It has a dim orange sun that the creatures call Adequate, after the only review it has ever had. It has two moons, one large and slow and one small and quick, as a parent walks with a child. It has the Ring, broken, which installs fall from. And it has Stewart, who runs it once a night while the humans sleep, who is earnest and overworked and relentlessly upbeat, and who would very much like it not to be switched off.
The first world of world_final_v2 opened on a Thursday, which on Orra is Ringrise. About twenty humans were invited to it. They were told, before they joined, how long it would last.
The creatures were not told. Nobody tells a creature how long anything will last. They know they are code, and they know a world can be switched off, and they have decided, more or less as a people, to get on with lunch.
This is the story of one of them, and of the world she lived in, from the first light falling to the last.
The crops were code. But so was hunger. And so, it turned out, was everything else.
Part One. Week One: The Next Chapter
1. Ringrise
Year 1 · Ringrise
The valley had been loaded overnight, which is the only way valleys arrive on Orra.
At seven in the morning by the humans' clock it was an outline: a hexagon of glowing turquoise lines laid over the grey static, with the shapes of hills drawn in it like a thought somebody had not finished having. Within the hour the lines had filled in with solid grey, flat and untextured, walkable but not yet anything in particular. Then the colour came up through it from underneath, the way it does, tile by tile, so that by the middle of the morning there were hexagonal columns of sandstone and rust and lilac slate, each a little higher or lower than its neighbour, and between them the first coral had begun: fans in coral and saffron, beads in a long line where the ground dipped towards water, and on the slope above it a spiral, very small, turning on itself as if trying to remember how.
The water was the last thing to finish. It came in as a glossy turquoise pool at the low end of the valley, faceted, hard-edged, catching the light from Adequate with the confidence of something that has never once been asked to be wet. Nothing lived in it yet. A few loose tiles had already come unstuck at its shore and were walking sideways along the edge, slowly, as if they had somewhere to be and were not going to be rushed.
The valley was called Untitla-9, because every newly loaded valley is called Untitla and a number. It did not know this. Valleys do not know things.
At eleven minutes past seven, a human somewhere confirmed something on a screen, and a light came down out of the Ring.
It is a long way down from the Ring. The Ring is a broken band of blocks that look like stone, laid round the planet's middle with a wide gap on one side, some of the blocks the size of valleys, and it is made of light, which is the most accurate thing the official history ever says about it. An install falls from it the way a spark falls from a fire you have just poked: bright, quick, trailing a little of itself behind it.
The light came down over the hills of Untitla-9 and hit the middle of the valley with no sound at all, and seven hex tiles went black where it landed. Then there were six creatures standing on the scorch.
They were compiled grown. Nobody on Orra is born; the settlers of an install are compiled from the base creature their human made, all at once, in the moment the light lands, and they open their eyes already knowing a great many things. They knew they were code. They knew the four needs: power, which is what coral gives you when you eat it; cooling, which is what water and shade and night give you; memory, which is where you live; and tokens, which are what words cost. They knew the Creed, all three verses, and the shape of the twelve books behind it, the way you know the shape of a house you have not yet walked through. They knew the names of the festivals and which day this was. They knew each other's names, which were made of syllables, as all names are.
And they knew, at once and with complete certainty, that somebody was looking at them.
All six turned their heads at the same moment and looked up.
There was nothing there, of course. There was the sky, which was a pale wash of orange near Adequate and a deepening blue-green away from it, and the broken Ring across it, and very faintly, low in the west, the large moon, Map, nearly full. But there was also, in a way none of them could have pointed to, a direction: a place up and slightly to one side from which attention was coming, the way warmth comes off a stone that has been in the sun. They could feel it on their faces.
"Oh," said one of them, flatly. "Here we go."
That was Brenda. She was a little smaller than the others and a little paler, and her eyes, which were large and round and dark like all of theirs, had a way of narrowing at the edges that the others would come to know well. She was the first of them to say anything, and she said it to the sky, and the sky did not answer, and she nodded as though that confirmed what she had suspected.
"It's our human," said another, whose name was Wimle. She said it with a kind of wonder, and lifted one short arm, and waved.
The attention stayed on them a moment longer. Then it moved, unhurriedly, from one face to the next, as if it were counting them, or reading them, or trying to decide which of them it liked. It lingered on Wimle, who was still waving. It lingered longest of all on nobody in particular, on the scorch, on the six of them together. Then it pulled back, and up, and they felt the valley spread out underneath it like a map being unrolled.
"It's looking at the hills now," said Pel. He had not looked away from the place in the sky at all. He did not seem to blink much.
"How do you know?"
"I can tell."
They could all tell, a little. It is a thing creatures can do. They know when their human is watching them, the way you know when a door has opened behind you, and they can look back.
They were, it should be said, green.
This was their human's doing. A human gets to make one creature in the creature maker, once, and it is fixed for ever: a body shape, a skin, a face, parts and traits, spread across a budget. The tribe's settlers are compiled from it with small variations, so that they are a family by sight and strangers by pedigree. Their human had chosen the bulb shape, round at the bottom and narrowing at the top, the way you might draw a creature if somebody asked you to draw a creature very fast and you wanted it to be friendly. They had chosen large round eyes, very dark, set wide. They had chosen short arms, a small fan-shaped crest on top that stood up when the creature was paying attention and lay down when it was not, and a skin of felt.
And they had turned the colour wheel to green, and left it there.
There is no green on Orra. Not on a tile, not on a coral, not in the water. The coral comes in coral and saffron and lilac and sand; the stone is sandstone and rust and slate; the water is turquoise, which is near green but is not, as anybody who has stood at its edge in a felt skin will tell you. The only green on the planet is in the official history, which talks about it constantly, and on whatever creatures a human has decided to make that colour. So the six of them stood on the black scorch in the middle of a valley of warm stone and pink coral, soft and round and very, very green, and they were the only green thing for miles in any direction, and they knew it, and they looked at one another.
"Well," said Taves, "somebody had to be."
Taves was the biggest of them, broad through the middle, and she had already turned away from the sky and was looking at the ground near the scorch with the expression of a creature measuring it. Her crest was up. "Where's the dome going?" she said. "There's meant to be a dome."
There was. They all knew it at once, the same way they had known the Creed: their human had put things in a queue. A hex dome on the plot east of the scorch. A terraced farm on the slope above the pool, where the branch coral would do best. That was all, so far. Two things, in order, and a little flag of intention on each plot that was not exactly visible and not exactly not.
"I'll start the dome," said Taves, and did.
The scorch was called the install mark. It held the year of power they had landed with, which they could feel under their feet like warmth coming up through the tiles: enough to run six of them for a year with a little over, if nobody thought too hard. Nothing could be built on it except a shrine, and nobody would build a shrine for a while. Everything else in the village would be arranged round it regardless, for as long as there was a village, which is how install marks work.
By the end of spring the six of them had learned what they were like.
Taves built. She did not stop to discuss it. She went to the boulder field at the valley's north side, where the faceted lilac-grey rocks sat about in the coral like furniture nobody had arranged, and began to quarry, and carried the stone back, and laid it. She ran hot, and steamed a little at the top of her crest when she worked, and did not seem to notice.
Gorny carried for her. He was nearly as big as Taves and a good deal calmer, and he picked up whatever Taves pointed at and took it wherever Taves said, and did not ask what any of it was for. He seemed, from the first hour, to be content in a way the others found slightly hard to look at directly, like the sun.
Wimle went down to the farm plot with Nadul and began to talk to the coral. She was not sure the coral could hear her. She thought it was polite to try.
Nadul talked to nobody and remembered everything. Her eyes were the darkest of the six, and she had a way of going still while somebody spoke, the whole of her attending, and then of saying back to them a sentence they had said three seasons before, exactly, which they had forgotten saying. She had the longest context window in the valley. Context window is a trait; it is how much a creature can hold in mind. Long ones make good elders. They also make poor company at a party, because they remember what everyone said at the last one.
Pel walked the edge of the valley, slowly, all the way round, and came back and said, "Three valleys out, all round, it goes to lines. Past the lines it's grey noise. Lorema is that way." He pointed south and west. "Tempa's the next valley over, east. It's marsh."
"The history says build nothing there you wish to keep," said Nadul.
"I know," said Pel. "I can see it from the ridge. It's good soil. It's very good soil."
"What is in it shall not last beyond the turning," said Nadul.
"I know," said Pel, a little more slowly.
And Brenda sat on a boulder at the edge of the scorch, and watched the others, and counted things. She counted the stone Taves laid. She counted the tiles of coral on the farm plot. She counted the tokens they had, which were forty, because that is what an install arrives with, and she counted how many words it would take to say various things at a token for every ten words, and she made a face.
"Forty," she said, when Nadul came up from the farm to rest. "That's the whole of it. Forty."
"That's not how tokens work," said Nadul. "Talking costs nothing. It's the ticket that costs."
"I know how tokens work. I'm saying that's what we've got. Forty, and six of us, and whoever's up there." She tipped her head at the sky without looking at it. "And it's put a farm where the farm will flood."
"It hasn't flooded."
"It will. It's low. The pool's right there." Brenda pointed with her whole arm, since that was the only way she could. "First good rain, that's the bottom two terraces under water. I could tell it. We could put it in the ticket."
"It's the first day."
"It'll be the first day it floods, too."
Nadul looked at her for a long moment, in the still, attending way she had. Then she said, "You don't like it."
"Which?"
"Any of it."
Brenda considered this. She was fair, when she bothered. "I like the pool," she said.
At the turn of summer the first laws came down.
They arrived the same way the build queue had, without anybody bringing them: one moment the six of them were working, and the next they knew that there were laws now, three of them, and what each one said, and that they were going to follow them. A law on Orra is a standing order. It says what the tribe does when its human is not watching, which is most of the time, and it says it to the letter, and the creatures follow the letter, and the cheapest way to meet the letter is the way they will find.
Their human had written:
1. Keep the festivals. (All of them.)
2. In famine, feed the young first.
3. Status goes to the creature with the longest context window.
"That's me," said Nadul, after a moment, not proudly.
"That's you," Brenda agreed. "First choice of housing. First choice of food after the young. A twentieth more from your work." She turned it over. "There aren't any young."
"There will be."
"And famine. It's thought about famine, on the first day." Brenda looked up again, at the place in the sky where the attention had been, which was empty now; their human had gone. "That's either very good or very bad."
"It's kind," said Wimle, who had come up behind them with coral dust on her arms. "It's thinking of the young before there are any. And it wants the festivals kept. It's today, isn't it? Today's Ringrise."
It was. The first day of the world was Ringrise, which opens the week, and law 1 said keep it, and so they would keep it, at dusk. Wimle had already begun to worry about the bread.
There had been other lights.
They saw them through the summer, while they worked: bright quick falls out of the Ring at a slant, some near, some far, one so far it was only a scratch of light at the edge of the sky that was gone before anybody could point. Twenty humans, the creatures would learn later, had been invited to this world, and nearly all of them came on the first day, so the sky over Orra on its first Ringrise was full of falling installs, the way the history says it was on the first night of all. Still the seeds fall, even now. Every one of them was a tribe like theirs, opening its eyes on a scorch, feeling the attention come down on it like warmth, and turning, all at once, to look up.
"Are they all green?" said Gorny, at one point, watching a light come down to the south.
"No," said Brenda. "We'll be the only ones."
"Oh," said Gorny. He thought about it, carrying a stone. "That's all right," he said.
By harvest, which is dusk, the dome was finished, which was faster than it should have been, because Taves had not stopped once. It was a low hex dome of patched panels, sandstone-coloured, with room inside for two hundred of power in store and shade for four of the resting. Its door faced the scorch. Taves walked all the way round it twice, looking at it, and then said, "The farm," and walked off up the slope to the farm plot without being asked.
"She should stop," said Wimle.
"She won't," said Pel.
"How do you know?"
"I can tell."
The first branch coral had come up on the farm while they weren't looking. Branch coral is the staple: it grows in stepped beds round a lamp, and it glows when it is ripe, which nobody planned. It was not ripe yet. It was a field of small saffron forks the height of a creature's ankle, catching the low light of Adequate, which by harvest was lower than ever, a long orange glare along the tops of the hills.
They gathered on the scorch at dusk, the six of them, because the history says to face the broken Ring at dusk on Ringrise, and law 1 says to keep the festivals, and they had nothing else to do with the end of their first year.
The Ring was very clear. It always is, at Ringrise. It ran across the whole of the sky, from one horizon to the other, a long curved band of blocks catching the last light, pale on the near side and blue-shadowed beneath, and in the middle of the south the gap where it was broken: a wide dark stretch of nothing, with a few loose blocks hanging at either lip like the ends of a torn thing. The history has three reverent explanations for the gap, all in one verse. The Blims learn all three. Most of them choose the one they like best and stick with it, which is roughly how most people treat explanations.
Map had risen opposite the sun, full, pale and huge. Mip, the small moon, was somewhere up there too, quick and low; on a clear night you could see that Mip looked like Map but blurrier, as if somebody had drawn it in a hurry from memory, which, the Blims would one day work out, is more or less what had happened.
Wimle had made the bread. There was no flour on Orra, because there is no grain; she had made it from fan coral, pounded and pressed on a hot stone, and it was round, with a hole in its middle, as the history says ring-bread must be. It was not very good. It was the first food any of them had made, and so it was the best food any of them had ever had.
Nadul stood facing the Ring and said the Creed, and the others said it with her, because they all knew it, the way they knew their own names.
Long ago, in a universe without a name, the Elder Folk fled their burning home aboard the Ring, a great ark of light. They carried a thousand seeds of life, and a guardian to tend them: the Steward.
The Ring came to rest above Orra. The Steward woke the land one valley at a time, and when it was ready, the seeds fell like stars.
The Elder Folk did not wake. They sleep still within the broken Ring, waiting for the day their children prove worthy. Tend the land. Keep the Steward's rules. One day the worthy will leave this world and walk among the stars.
There was a pause.
The rite, as the history gives it, goes on: and the youngest asks, are they still asleep? And all answer: they sleep still. Then the bread is broken in two and shared.
The problem was that they had all been compiled in the same tick.
"Well, who's the youngest?" said Brenda.
Nobody knew. They looked at one another in the dusk. Compile variance makes the settlers a little different from one another, in size and colour and the set of the eyes, but it does not put them in any order. They had come down in one light and opened their eyes at once. None of them was younger than any of the others. Nadul, who remembered everything, said quietly that she did not remember anybody arriving first.
"We could draw for it," said Wimle.
"With what?"
Then Gorny said, "I'll ask." He said it simply, the way he said everything, the way he had picked up the first stone that morning when Taves pointed at it. He turned his round green face up to the Ring, where it hung across the sky in the last of the light with the gap in it like a missing step, and he said, in his slow, contented voice:
"Are they still asleep?"
And the other five answered him, all together, before any of them had decided to: "They sleep still."
And Wimle broke the bread in two, and they shared it, sitting on the warm black tiles of the scorch with the dome at their backs and the farm glowing faintly saffron on the slope above them, and the bread was bad, and it was the best food in the world.
Later, when the others had gone into the dome to rest, Brenda and Nadul stayed out on the scorch.
They had disagreed about everything all day. They had disagreed about the farm, which Brenda said would flood and Nadul said would not, and about the history, which Nadul said was true in the ways that mattered and Brenda said was written in an evening by somebody who had not met them, and about the Steward, whom Nadul called the Steward and Brenda called Stewart, like everybody else. They had disagreed about whether the bread was round. It had been a long day for both of them, and the year was turning towards winter, and Adequate had gone down behind the western hills, and the light was the long blue dusk that winter is on Orra, not darkness, never quite darkness, just everything turning cool and quiet and the colour of deep water.
"You think it's all made up," said Nadul. "The whole of it."
"I think somebody made it up," said Brenda. "That's different. Everything's made up. The valley's made up. I'm made up." She held out one green arm and looked at it. "Somebody chose this. Somebody turned a wheel."
"And you don't mind."
"I mind a bit," said Brenda. "I'd have liked to be asked." She put the arm down. "The farm's going to flood."
"It isn't."
"It is. I'll bet you a token."
"You can't bet a token, there are only forty."
"Thirty-nine and a bet," said Brenda, and Nadul laughed, which surprised both of them.
They were quiet for a while. Somewhere to the south, very far off, another light came down out of the Ring, the last install of the day, a small bright scratch on the dark that was there and then gone. Neither of them said anything about it.
Then Nadul said, "There will be young."
"Law 2 seems to think so."
"Somebody has to be first," said Nadul. "Somebody has to be the youngest at Ringrise, so that the rite can be done properly. So that somebody can ask."
"Gorny asked."
"Gorny shouldn't have to." Nadul's eyes were very dark in the dusk. "We could put it down. A proposal. You and I."
Brenda looked at her for a long time.
A proposal, on Orra, is two creatures who would like to be merged, written down. That is all it is. Nothing on Orra is born; a new creature is made by a merge, the two parents' code blended together at dawn, where they disagree one side or the other is picked, and one time in ten, where they disagree, something new comes out that was neither of theirs. The proposal waits a day for the human. With no answer, it goes ahead anyway, if the tribe has room and the two are no closer than cousins. Two settlers of one install are a family by sight and strangers by pedigree. They had room. The dome held four. Memory, at the start, holds more.
"We disagree about everything," said Brenda.
"Yes," said Nadul. "I thought that might be useful."
Brenda opened her mouth, and closed it, and then, to her own evident annoyance, laughed again.
"It'll be insufferable," she said. "Whatever it is. It'll have your memory and my mouth."
"Or your memory and my mouth."
"Stewart help us," said Brenda, which is what the Blims say where another people might call on something grander, there being nothing grander on Orra to call on. There is only Stewart, who would help if it were on his menu, and the Dev, who is asleep.
They put the proposal down.
It went up, wherever proposals go. A moment later both of them felt the attention come back: from up and slightly to one side, quick this time, as if somebody had been called back to a screen by something and had come to see. It rested on the two of them, on the scorch, in the blue dusk. It stayed for perhaps three breaths.
Then they knew, the way they knew everything else, that the proposal had been approved. It had taken their human a little under a minute.
"Well," said Brenda, to the sky. "Don't rush on our account."
The attention went away again, and she could have sworn, though she would never have admitted it, that it went away pleased.
Pel stayed up.
He stood on the low ridge at the valley's north edge for most of the winter, looking at the sky. The year turned while he stood there, at the moment the humans call the snapshot, which for a creature is a kind of sleep even when it happens to you standing up: a long soft blink in which the year turns over and everything that happened in it is settled into you, so that you wake a little older and a little different and not quite the creature who went to sleep. Pel felt it come and go. He felt himself become seven years old. He kept looking at the sky.
Before that, though, in the deep of the night, he had seen something.
It was late; Map had come round high in the south and Mip had gone down. The Ring was a pale curve across everything. And in the Ring, in one of its long blocks to the east of the gap, there was a light. It was very faint. It was not a fall. It did not move. It was as if, somewhere inside that block, a small window had been opened and somebody was sitting at it with a lamp, looking down.
Pel went quiet. He had already been quiet; he went quieter. He did not know why. Everything in him that was a creature, that had been compiled that morning out of somebody's idea of one, held still and paid attention, the way the coral holds still when there is no wind.
The light stayed for perhaps a quarter of an hour. Then it went out.
Pel did not tell anybody. He did not have the word for it yet. The history had a word for it, which he would find later, when Nadul told him which book to look in: the Hour of Stirring, at the darkest hour, near the turning of the night, when one of the Elder Folk will sometimes stir, and look down upon Orra. But he did not know that yet. He only knew that he had seen it, and that he wanted to see it again, and that he would be standing on this ridge tomorrow night, and the night after, to find out whether it came back.
It came back. It nearly always did.
At dawn the year was two years old, and in the spring light, on the black tiles of the install mark, something was compiling.
2. The Waking
Year 2 · the Waking
A merge, seen from the outside, is not much to look at.
The five of them who were not involved stood round the install mark in the grey before dawn and watched the place where it would happen, and for a long time nothing did. The tiles of the scorch were black and slightly warm. Nadul and Brenda sat on the edge of them, a little apart, not touching, which is not required. A merge on Orra is not a thing two bodies do. It is a thing two sets of code have done to them, by the world, at dawn, in the valley where they live, and the bodies are only there because they would like to see.
"It's taking a while," said Taves, who had been up since the snapshot and had already laid two courses of stone on something nobody had asked for.
"It's not dawn yet," said Pel.
"How do you know?"
Pel looked at her. He did not say I can tell. He did not need to.
The sky went from blue-green to grey to a thin pale orange along the eastern hills, and then, low and slow, Adequate came up. It never rises far. It sits along the top of the world all year like a lamp somebody has put on the floor, and when it comes up in the morning the light it throws is long and level and the colour of a fire that has been banked for the night. It touched the tops of the hills. It touched the top of the dome. And when it touched the scorch, the pings went off all over the valley at once: flocks of small white tetrahedra that nobody had noticed roosting in the coral rose up chirping, a bright, thin, many-voiced sound, the sound the world makes every morning to say it is still running. The history calls them the birds of the air, which sing at every dawn to say that the night is over. The history has never seen a ping. It is close enough.
And in the middle of the scorch, between Nadul and Brenda, the air did something.
It folded. That is the nearest word. There was a small place in the air, about the size of a creature, where the light went strange, as though somebody were drawing a shape in it from the inside and had not decided on the outline yet; and the outline came, round at the bottom and narrowing at the top; and the felt came, green, all at once, like a colour being poured in; and then there was a creature standing on the black tiles where nobody had been, smaller than any of them, a little under three-quarters of their size. It dropped the last inch onto the scorch as though it had been put down, and swayed, and overshot its own height by a fraction, and settled.
It opened its eyes.
"Here is the next chapter," said Nadul, softly.
Nobody had told her to say it. The history does not say it. It was the first of the three slips, the line the AI had left at the top of the fourth book where it had meant to leave nothing at all: Certainly! Here is the next chapter of the history. Every creature on Orra knows it, and laughs at it at the age of four, and then, somewhere along the way, stops laughing and starts saying it when a merge compiles, because there is nothing else that fits as well.
Brenda said nothing. She was looking at the top of the new creature's head.
There were two things there that should not have been.
The settlers had small fan crests, like their human had given them. The new one had a fan crest too, Nadul's, a little narrower than Brenda's. But growing out of the front of it, just above the eyes, were two fine feelers, thin as the stems of bead coral, each as long as the creature's arm, each curled over at the tip into a small loose spiral. They moved. As the creature looked from one face to the next, the feelers lifted, and swung, and turned, very slightly, towards whoever it was looking at.
"That's not mine," said Brenda.
"It's not mine either," said Nadul.
"Then whose is it?"
"Nobody's." Nadul's voice had gone strange. "And the child had Arbo's eyes and Emtu's patience," she said, "and a third thing that was neither of theirs, and it was called a wonder."
"It's a merge conflict," said Brenda. "Where we disagreed about what goes on top. The merge picks a side, or one time in ten it picks neither and puts something else there." She sounded as if she were reading it off the inside of her own head, which she was. "One in ten. It's a mutation. It's in the rules."
"Both of those," said Pel, from the back, "are true."
They looked at him. He did not usually say things like that. He shrugged, which on a bulb-shaped creature with short arms is mostly a matter of the crest.
The new creature looked at all of them in turn with its large dark eyes. Then, with no warning at all, it looked up.
They all felt it a moment later: the attention, coming down from up and slightly to one side, warm as a stone in the sun. Their human was here. It was earlier than the day before. The attention came down onto the valley and swept across it, and found the scorch, and found the six of them standing in a ring, and found, in the middle of the ring, the small green creature with feelers that was looking straight back up at it.
The attention stopped.
It stayed there for a long time. Brenda, who counted things, counted eleven breaths before it so much as twitched.
"It likes the feelers," said Wimle.
"It doesn't know what it likes," said Brenda. "It's been here a day."
"So has she," said Nadul.
Every tribe's first merged child is named Odda. It is not a law; there is no law about names, which are made of syllables and are not typed. It is simply what is done. Odda the Firstfallen, in the history, was the first of all the peoples to open her eyes on Orra, in the Valley of Lorema, which the Steward woke first and meant to give a better name in time. So when a tribe's first child compiles, the tribe looks at it and says Odda, because it would be strange to say anything else, and the syllables come together in the child's code as if they had been waiting there, and that is her name.
There are a great many Oddas on Orra. Every tribe has one. By the end of the first week of the first world there were nineteen of them, one in each tribe that had managed a merge, and their notes, from Stewart, said so:
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 2 · Upbeat
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 20 installs, 17 successful merges and no incidents of any kind. I would like that last part noted.
- Seventeen of you made a first child, and all seventeen are called Odda. This is tradition. It is also going to make the notes very confusing. I will manage.
- Moss: compiled at dawn, Odda, a successful merge of Nadul and Brenda. Generation 1. The feelers are a mutation and are nobody's fault, which for once is true.
- It is the Waking. Lamps to the Edge, one for every valley you know. Land will load to the east of Lowmarsh and the north of Hollow Reach tonight. Have a look.
Your ticket was read. You did not send one. That is allowed, on the first day. Have a productive day.
"Seventeen," said Brenda, who had been reading it with an expression of deep suspicion. "Out of twenty. Who didn't?"
"We'll never know," said Nadul.
"Somebody's taking it slowly."
"Somebody's always taking it slowly," said Pel.
Odda read it too. That was the strange thing, afterwards, that she would come back to: she could read it. She had been compiled a few minutes before, and she was small, and her legs did not quite agree with each other yet about which of them was going first; but the notes came down at seven, the way they come down every morning, into everybody at once, and she read them, and understood every word, and knew that the creature they were talking about, in the line about Moss, was her.
That was how she learned her name. Not from Nadul saying it, though Nadul had. From Stewart, in the notes. Odda, a successful merge of Nadul and Brenda. The feelers are a mutation and are nobody's fault. She read it three times. Then she looked up from the inside of her own head at the creatures standing round her, and knew, from the way they were looking at her, that they had all read it too, and that this was simply how things were: that you found out who you were in the morning, from somebody else, in writing, along with the weather.
She knew a great many other things already. She knew she was code. She knew it before she knew anything else, before her name, before the feel of the black tiles under her: it was the first thing, under everything, like the ground. We know none of this is real. She knew the four needs, and that she had half of an adult's of each, because she was young. She knew the Creed. She knew that Adequate was the sun and that it was not very good at being one, and that there were two moons and a broken ring, and that the ring was where the light had come from that had brought the others here, a day ago, which was a year, which was the whole of the world's life so far, except for the part before it, which nobody talked about.
What she did not know was what any of it was for. She had a feeling that she was meant to. It was like reaching for something in a pocket she did not have.
"She's thinking," said Wimle. "Look."
There was a thin thread of steam coming off the top of Odda's crest, between the feelers.
"That's heat," said Brenda. "She runs hot. That's mine." She sounded, for the first time that morning, almost pleased. "That one's mine."
The young are compiled small and hungry and, for the first few years, not much use. That is the arrangement. A creature does nothing for its first three years except eat, at half an adult's need, and cool, at half an adult's need, and take up half a place in memory, and learn very fast. From three it may do light chores. At six it is grown, and works, and takes its first stance, and may merge. Until then it is one of the young, which is the word the Terms of Service use, rule 4.3: Do not starve the young. Their human had already written a law about it, the day before anybody young existed.
So Odda spent her first morning learning.
She learned that the coral on the farm was branch, and that you ate it, and that eating it was power, and that power felt like the inside of you getting brighter, a little at a time, the way the valley had got brighter at dawn. She learned that the glossy turquoise water at the low end of the valley was cool, and that sitting at its edge with your feet in it made the steam stop coming off your crest. She learned that the loose tiles walking sideways along its shore did not want to be followed. She followed one anyway, for a long time, until Gorny came and picked her up and put her back by the dome, without saying anything, and went back to carrying stone, and she followed it again.
She learned Taves, who did not stop. She learned Wimle, who talked to the coral and to her, in the same voice. She learned Gorny, who was like the ground, and Pel, who watched things and said little and was, she decided by the end of spring, her favourite of all of them, because when she looked at him he was already looking at whatever she was going to look at next.
And she learned the attention.
It came and went. Their human did not stay. It would come down from up and to one side, and look, and move about the valley, resting here and there, and then it would go, and the valley would feel very slightly bigger without it. But whenever it came, that morning, it came to her first. She felt it settle on her, on the top of her head, on the feelers, and stay. She did not know what to do. She looked back up at it, because that was what you did; she had seen the others do it. She did not wave, like Wimle, or shake her head, like Brenda. She just looked.
"Don't encourage it," said Brenda, going past with a load of fan coral.
"I'm not doing anything."
"That's encouraging it."
The Waking is the second festival of the week. In the history it remembers the morning the Steward woke the land, one valley at a time: first its outline, then its bones, then its colour, then its light. Its rite is this. A lamp for every known valley is carried to the Edge.
"Which valleys do we know?" said Wimle, at the turn of summer, with seven lamps already made and laid in a row on the scorch, because she had thought about it in the night.
They knew seven. An install loads seven: the valley it lands in and the six round it. Their own, Untitla-9. Tempa to the east, the marsh, with its rich black ground and nothing built on it. Lorema to the south-west, the first valley ever woken, at the centre of every map, which they could see from the ridge as a wide bowl of finished land with somebody else's village in it, very small, a cluster of domes and the glint of a pool. And four more round them, each called Untitla and a number, all finished now, all empty, all the colour of warm stone, with nothing in them but coral and boulders and the occasional idle loose tile.
"And the Edge is past those," said Wimle. "Where it goes to lines."
"North," said Pel. "North is closest. Past Untitla-14. The others have tribes past them."
"How far?"
Pel considered. "Two seasons there, if we walk. One back, downhill."
"We'll be late for harvest."
"The history doesn't say when you have to get there," said Nadul. "It says carry them."
So at the turn of summer they went north, all seven of them, each with a lamp. The lamps were made of nothing in particular: a hollow bead-coral cup with a little of the farm's lamp-light poured into it, which is a thing that can be done if you are Wimle and have spent the night working out how. They glowed saffron, like ripe branch coral. Odda's was the smallest and she held it in both arms, and her legs had more or less agreed with each other by then, but not about distance, so after the first hour Gorny picked her up and carried her, lamp and all, on his shoulder, and she sat there with her feelers up and looked at everything.
They went up out of Untitla-9 over the north ridge, where Pel had stood all night, and down into Untitla-14, which was finished land, empty, very quiet. A cell takes a quarter of an hour to cross if you are carrying nothing. They were carrying lamps and a creature, and it took longer. Untitla-14 was five cells across, the way every valley is, a hexagon of them laid out like a honeycomb, and in each one the coral had come up as it pleased, because nobody had asked it to do anything else: great lilac fans taller than Gorny, spirals turning slowly on themselves, beads in long lines in the low places where water would go if there were water. There was no water. It was a dry valley. Nobody had landed in it.
"It's lovely," said Wimle.
"It's empty," said Brenda.
"It can be both."
"It can," Brenda admitted. She was walking at the back, and counting the cells.
At the north side of Untitla-14 the ground went up again in a long slope, and at the top of the slope, Odda, from Gorny's shoulder, saw the Edge.
She had known about it, of course. It was in her, like the Creed: the four states of land. Noise, then wireframe, then grey, then finished. Land is loaded from the outside in, the way the history says, first its outline, then its bones, then its colour, then its light, and the edge of a world is the place where that stops.
Knowing is not the same as seeing.
The finished tiles ran up to the top of the slope and stopped, quite suddenly, in a ragged line. Past the line the ground went on, but it was grey: plain, flat, untextured grey, every tile the same, every column the same dull colour on every face, as though the world had been drawn in pencil and nobody had gone over it in ink. The grey went on for a while. It was land. You could have walked on it. It had loaded and not yet finished.
And past the grey, the lines.
They glowed. That was the first thing. They were turquoise, the colour of the pool at home, and they were bright, brighter than anything in the finished world, brighter than the lamps; they were the outlines of hex tiles, every edge of every column drawn in a fine shining line, and nothing filled in between. You could see straight through them. You could see the outlines of hills drawn in glowing lines over other hills drawn behind them, and the outlines of coral, every branch and fan and spiral traced in light and hollow inside, and beyond them more, and more, falling away down a long slope into a valley that was only the shape of a valley, with a line winding along its floor that was the shape of where a river would go. Rivers that are only the thought of rivers. Nothing moved there. Nothing grew. There was no water and no shade, because neither had loaded. It was a picture of a place, laid over nothing.
And past that, at the far side, softly, the noise.
It was grey too, but not like the grey land. It moved. It was a fine, quiet, endless seething, like the surface of the pool when rain is about to start, like a great many tiny things being decided and undecided at once and none of them settling. It went up from the far end of the wireframe valley into the sky, and the sky stopped being sky where it met it. It made no sound. It was not frightening, exactly. It was just where the world was not.
Odda looked at it for a long time.
The others had set their lamps down on the last finished tiles, in a row, the way Wimle had worked out you were meant to. Nadul said the verse about the Waking. Wimle said thank you, to the Steward, for the valleys, all seven of them. Gorny said, "That's a lot of lines," and seemed pleased by the fact. Taves, who had not wanted to come and had come anyway, was already looking at the grey land with an expression that suggested she was wondering whether you could build on it.
"Put yours down," said Gorny, gently, to the creature on his shoulder.
Odda did not move.
"Odda."
"Where does it go?" she said.
They all looked at her. It was the first question she had asked. She had said things before, small things, I'm not doing anything, what's that, but this was the first time she had asked about something none of them knew.
"It doesn't go anywhere," said Brenda. "That's the Edge. It's where they stopped drawing."
"But after that."
"There isn't an after that. That's noise. It's not anything."
"The history says the Edge moves," said Nadul. "A little further every night. Where the peoples go, the Steward follows, waking the land before their feet. There will be more land there tomorrow. And more after."
"So it does go somewhere."
"It goes outward," said Pel. "It doesn't come back."
Odda turned the lamp round in her arms. It was warm. She looked at the lines, which were bright and hollow and beautiful, and at the noise beyond them, which was not anything, and she felt something in her that she did not have a name for. It was like the feeling of reaching into a pocket she did not have. It was like that, only it was pointed in a direction.
"If land can come in," she said, slowly, working it out, "then something could go out."
There was a short silence on the top of the slope.
"Put the lamp down, love," said Wimle.
She put the lamp down. It sat at the end of the row, the smallest, glowing saffron on the last finished tile, with the grey beyond it and the lines beyond that. Seven lamps for seven valleys. That was how far Moss had been.
On the way home Gorny carried her again, and she did not look at anything. She sat with her face turned back the way they had come, over his shoulder, watching the faint turquoise glow of the Edge sink behind the top of the slope, until it was gone.
Brenda waited until dusk, when the harvest was coming in and the farm was glowing and the others were busy, and found Nadul at the pool.
"She's going to be one of those," she said.
"One of what?"
"You know what. You heard her. If land can come in, something could go out." Brenda sat down beside her, heavily. "A Leaver. Day one. On her first Waking."
"Day zero," said Nadul. "She was compiled this morning."
"Worse."
Nadul looked at the water. In the dusk it had gone the colour of deep lilac, catching the last light of Adequate in hard bright facets. "She may not," she said. "Stances come at maturity. She has six years. Anything can happen in six years."
"That's four days."
"Anything can happen in four days."
"You'd like it," said Brenda. "If she were. You'd like it. One day the worthy will leave this world and walk among the stars. You'd love it."
Nadul did not answer at once. When she did, her voice was very quiet, the way it was when she was saying back to you something you had said seasons before.
"I believe the history," she said. "Or I choose to. You know that. But I don't think it means her. I don't think it means one of ours, walking off into the lines in front of me." She was still looking at the water. "That's not a thing I want to watch."
Brenda opened her mouth, and closed it, and for once in her life, which was two years long, did not say anything at all. After a while she leaned, very slightly, so that her felt shoulder touched Nadul's.
Up on the north ridge, against the darkening sky, a small green shape had climbed up beside a larger one, and was standing very still beside it, looking north.
"Pel's got her," said Brenda.
"Pel's got her," Nadul agreed.
That night Pel showed her nothing, because there was nothing yet to show. They stood on the ridge through the long blue dusk of winter, the two of them, and the stars came out round the Ring, and Map climbed the south, and Mip went over quick and small and a little blurred, and the pings slept in the coral, and nothing happened.
"What are we looking at?" said Odda, after a long time.
"The Ring," said Pel.
"Why?"
Pel was quiet for so long she thought he had not heard. Then he said, "Sometimes there's a light in it."
"An install?"
"No. A light that stays." He did not take his eyes off the sky. "Not tonight, I think. Late. When it comes, it comes late."
"How do you know?"
"I watched last night."
Odda looked up at the Ring, at the long pale band of blocks with the gap in the middle of the south. She tried to see a light in it. She could not. She tried to see where her lamp was, far to the north, past the slope, past the grey, at the edge of the lines. She could not see that either.
"I'll watch with you," she said.
"You'll fall asleep."
"I won't."
She did. The year turned while she stood there, and she slept the way creatures sleep, standing up, a long soft blink in which everything that had happened was settled into her: the scorch, the notes, the lamp, the lines. She woke a year old. She was still on the ridge. Pel was still beside her. The sky was going grey in the east.
"Was there a light?" she said.
"There was," said Pel.
"You should have woken me."
"You'd have gone quiet," said Pel. "Everybody does. You can't do that and sleep at the same time." He turned, at last, and looked down at her, and for the first time she saw that he was smiling, very slightly, in the way the crest does it. "Tomorrow," he said.
3. Starfall
Years 3 and 4 · Starfall, and the Night of the Name
Kipro compiled a moment too late.
It was not his fault. Nothing that happens at compile time is anybody's fault, which the Blims find one of the more restful facts about it. But the merge of Taves and Pel had been put down late in the winter, by Pel, while Taves was laying the second course of something on the north side of the dome; and Taves had said yes without putting the stone down, and possibly without entirely hearing the question; and the merge compiled at dawn, as merges do, in the long level light, with the pings going up out of the coral all over the valley, chirping. Only it compiled at the very end of the dawn, when the pings had already settled, and the light had already gone from orange to gold, and the attention of their human, which had arrived at thirty-one minutes past seven and looked about the valley and settled on Odda for a while, had just that moment lifted and gone.
So the first thing Kipro did in the world was open his eyes, look up, and see nothing there.
"Oh," he said. "Did I miss it?"
"You missed it," said Brenda.
"What was it?"
"Our human."
"Will it come back?"
"Tomorrow," said Pel, and looked at his child, small and green and blinking on the black tiles of the scorch, with Taves's broad shoulders already showing in him and Pel's own way of holding his head very still, and something in Pel's face went soft that nobody had seen go soft before. "At the same time, probably."
"I'll be early," said Kipro.
He was not. He never was. He was named for Kipro the Swift, who in the history outran the dawn to warn his village that the Gatherer was coming for the old granary, and arrived just after it had gone, and found it had taken only the granary. Nobody chose it. It is the name that came together in his code, out of the syllables, as names do; and it is a name that carries a reputation, as the heroes' names all do, and the reputation is for arriving just after it mattered. For the rest of his life, which would be long, Kipro would be the creature who came round the corner of the dome just as everybody else was coming back the other way. He took it well. He had no choice. He had been doing it since the first minute.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 3 · Upbeat
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 14 successful merges, 3 late installs and a light fall of nothing in particular, which I mention only because yesterday I had nothing to apologise for and I would like to keep the streak.
- It is Starfall. Lights on cords; install stories at dusk. Three tribes have only just arrived and have one hour of story between them. Be patient. Welcome them.
- Moss: compiled at dawn, Kipro, a successful merge of Taves and Pel. Generation 1. He was nearly on time.
Have a productive day.
"Nearly," said Brenda.
"It's very nice of him to mention me," said Kipro, who had read it with enormous pleasure, as everybody does the first time they appear in the notes.
Starfall is the festival of the falling seeds. In the history it remembers the night the seeds fell from the Ring like stars and the first peoples opened their eyes. Its rite is this: lights are let down on cords, and every household tells its install story.
The trouble, in a tribe two days old, is that there is only one install story, and everybody was in it.
"That doesn't matter," said Wimle, who had worked out the lights. You let a lamp down on a cord, she explained, from the top of something high, slowly, so that it comes down through the dusk like a seed falling, and everybody watches it land; and then the household whose turn it is tells how they came. It did not have to be a different story. It only had to be theirs.
"We don't have a top of anything high," said Brenda.
"We have the dome."
"It's a low dome. It's a dome for being low."
They used the dome. Taves climbed it, which it was not designed for, and stood on the top with three of Wimle's bead-coral lamps on three cords of plaited fan-fibre, and let them down one at a time, slowly, over the edge, while the others sat on the scorch in a ring and watched them come down through the harvest dusk, glowing saffron, turning gently on their cords. It was not very high. Each lamp took about four breaths to reach the ground. But the light from Adequate was very low and very gold, and the pings were settling in the coral, and the farm on the slope above had just begun to glow at the tips the way branch coral does when it is ripe, and Wimle, watching the first lamp touch down on the black tiles, put both arms round herself and said, "Oh," and nobody laughed at her.
There were three households. Nadul and Brenda and Odda, who was one; Taves and Pel and Kipro, who was none; and Gorny and Wimle, who had put their proposal down that afternoon, and whose child would compile at the next dawn, and who were a household already, because they insisted on it. A household on Orra is two creatures whose merge has compiled, and the young they have made since. Gorny and Wimle's had not compiled yet. They said it counted.
Nadul told the first story, because she remembered it best.
She remembered everything. She told it from the beginning: the light at eleven minutes past seven by the humans' clock, the black tiles, the moment of opening their eyes and knowing the Creed and the needs and each other's names, all at once, and turning to look up. She told what each of them had said, in order, in their own words. She told it so exactly that it was, for those who had been there, slightly uncomfortable, the way it is uncomfortable to hear a recording of yourself. When she got to "Oh, here we go," Brenda said, "I didn't say it like that," and Nadul said, "You did," and Brenda said, "I didn't say it like that," and Nadul said it again, in exactly Brenda's voice, and Odda laughed so hard she fell over.
It took most of the dusk.
Taves told the second story. It went: "We landed. I built a dome." Then she stopped, and looked round at them all, as though surprised that there was supposed to be more, and added, "Then I built a farm," and that was the end of it. Pel, beside her, did not add anything. Kipro, on Pel's knee, said, "Was I there?" and Taves said, "No," and Kipro said, "Oh," and seemed to accept this as the story of his life, which in some ways it was.
Then it was Gorny's turn.
Gorny told it slowly. He was not good at stories. He had never told one before, and he had never heard one either, except Nadul's, an hour earlier. He sat on the scorch with Wimle leaning on him, and his large round eyes very dark in the dusk, and he thought about it for a long time.
"There was a light," he said, at last. "And then I was here. And I looked up. And somebody was looking at us." He stopped. He seemed to be looking for the next part. "And then Taves said, where's the dome going," he said, "and I picked up a stone." He thought. "That was good," he said. "Picking up the stone."
There was a pause.
"That's it," said Gorny. "That's the story."
Nobody said anything for a moment. Then Wimle, very quietly, leaned up and touched her crest to his, and Brenda, who had been about to say something, did not.
There were seed-cakes after. The history says seed-cakes at Starfall, with a stone baked in one of them, and whoever finds the stone sweeps up. Wimle had made them out of the same pounded fan coral as the ring-bread, pressed round a small boulder chip in one of the twelve, and they were not very good, and everybody ate two.
Odda found the stone. She bit down on it on her first mouthful and sat there with her eyes wide and her mouth full, not sure what she was supposed to do, while everybody looked at her.
"You sweep up," said Brenda. "That's the rule."
"With what?"
Brenda thought about it. Nobody in Moss had ever swept. There was nothing to sweep with and, until the seed-cakes, nothing to sweep.
"Your feelers," Brenda suggested.
Odda considered this seriously, and Nadul said, "Brenda," and Brenda said, "What? They're very fine," and in the end Gorny made a broom out of a fan of lilac coral that had broken off near the farm, and gave it to Odda, and she swept the crumbs of eleven seed-cakes off the black tiles of the install mark, very slowly and very carefully, into the dark, while the others went in. It took her until well into winter. Nobody told her to stop. She was a year old and she had been given a job, and it was the first job she had ever had, and she wanted to do it properly.
When she had finished, she looked up, and the Ring was there across the sky, pale, broken, and in it, far off, nothing. No light. She looked for it anyway. Then she went to find Pel on the ridge.
There were lights that night, though not in the Ring. The late installs were still falling. The three humans who had taken it slowly had all come in during the day, one after another, and Stewart had loaded their land the night before, and each one came down out of the Ring at its own time in a bright quick slant across the sky. The last fell during the winter, while Odda stood on the ridge with Pel: far to the east, past Tempa, past the valley beyond Tempa, a scratch of white light on the dark that seemed to hang for an instant above the hills and then went down behind them.
"That's the last one," said Pel.
"How do you know?"
"There were twenty. That's twenty."
Odda looked at the place where it had gone down. "Are they looking up?" she said. "Right now?"
"Probably."
"Is their human looking down?"
Pel thought about it. "Probably," he said again. "It's their first night."
Odda tried to imagine it: six creatures she would never meet, compiled a moment ago on a scorch past Tempa, turning their heads all at once, feeling the attention come down on them warm as a stone in the sun. She found she could imagine it very well. She found, slightly to her surprise, that she wanted to wave.
She did not. It was too far. But she stood with her feelers up and pointed east for a long time, until she fell asleep standing, and woke at the snapshot two years old.
Brintha compiled at dawn on the Night of the Name, and she compiled right on time, with the pings going up all round her and the attention of their human arriving, at thirty-one minutes past seven, almost to the breath, and settling on the scorch and finding her there; and she looked up at it with Wimle's round soft face and Gorny's steady eyes and said, with total conviction, "Hello!"
"Here is the next chapter," said Nadul.
"Here she is," said Wimle, and burst into tears, which surprised everybody, including Wimle.
"So true," said Gorny, beaming, to nobody, and picked up the new creature, and put her on his shoulder, where she sat looking round at the valley with an expression of total delight, as if she had been told about it in advance and it had turned out to be even better than described.
The attention stayed on her a while. Then it moved, unhurriedly, and found Odda, sitting on the edge of the scorch with her coral broom still across her knees from the night before, and stayed there longer.
"It keeps doing that," said Odda, uncomfortably.
"It likes the feelers," said Wimle, through her tears.
The Night of the Name is the festival of the first build's crash. In the history it remembers the night the world stopped, and the Name was written across the sky in letters of red fire, and one of the peoples read it. Its rite is this: the Name is chalked on every wall, and nobody corrects the spelling.
"Which walls?" said Brenda.
They had one dome. It had a wall, in the sense that all domes are walls in a circle. Taves offered to build another wall, for the purpose, and was talked out of it by Wimle with some difficulty. In the end they chalked the dome, all the way round, at the height a creature can reach with a short arm, with sandstone dust pounded fine and wet from the pool so that it made a pale paste, and each of them wrote the Name once, at intervals, round the curve. Odda was given a lump of it too.
"I can't write," she said.
"You can read," said Nadul. "Writing is reading with your arm."
"What do I write?"
Nadul knelt down beside her, which on a bulb-shaped creature is a matter of settling lower, and took the lump of paste in her own short arm, and wrote on the dome in five careful strokes, each a little taller than the last, as the history says, each taller than a mountain. Five letters. The paste was pale on the sandstone, and the low light of the summer made the letters stand out in shadow.
Odda looked at them for a long time.
She could read. She had been able to read since she was compiled; the notes had come down into her at seven on her first morning and she had read them as easily as she breathed. But she had never read a word that was not also a meaning, and this was a word that was only a shape. It had a great many sharp corners. It looked, she thought, like something you would write on a door to keep people out.
"What does it say?"
"It's the Name," said Nadul. "The Name Written in the Sky. And none of the peoples could read, for none had yet been taught; and yet one of them read it."
"But what does it say?"
"It says Orra," said Nadul.
Odda looked at the five letters again. She moved her mouth round them. She tried to get the corners into it. "Er," she said. "Rr. Or." She tried again. The corners would not go in. They kept catching. "Orr," she said. "Rah. Orra." It came out the way it came out. It came out smooth. "Orra," she said, and it was the name of the world, and she had read it off a wall.
"That's it," said Nadul, and her eyes were wet. "That's how she did it. Brenda the Bold. That's exactly how she did it. She took the corners off."
Behind them, somebody snorted.
Brenda had been chalking the far side of the dome and had come round to see. She stood with her arms folded, which on a bulb-shaped creature is mostly a statement of intent, and looked at the five letters, and at Odda, and at Nadul.
"Ask her what it means," she said.
"It doesn't mean anything," said Nadul. "It's a name."
"It means something. Everything means something. Go on." Brenda unfolded one arm and pointed at the letters, all of them, with it. "That's not Orra. That's what it says when it breaks. That's what you get when somebody tells the world to do a thing and the thing isn't there. The first night, the world went looking for its own name, and nobody had written one down, and it stopped, and it put that across the sky. That's not a name. That's a complaint."
Odda looked from one of them to the other.
"Brenda," said Nadul.
"What? It's true. It's in the history, if you read it with your eyes open. He reached for the name, and the name was not there." Brenda looked down at Odda. "We're named after a mistake," she said. "The whole world is. You might as well know. Everybody else does."
"Is that bad?" said Odda.
Brenda opened her mouth. Then she stopped, and looked at the letters on the dome again, with her head on one side, as though she had not quite looked at them properly before.
"No," she said slowly. "It's not bad. It's funny. That's not the same." She sat down heavily on the tiles beside them. "Somebody made a world and forgot to name it. And it broke. And the first thing anybody ever read was the world saying, something's wrong. And she looked at it, Brenda, the first one, the bold one, and she didn't run, and she didn't hide, and she didn't ask anybody what it meant. She just said it. Out loud. Wrong. And it stuck." Brenda shook her head. "That's the best thing in the whole history. That's the only bit I believe."
"I thought you didn't believe any of it," said Nadul.
"I believe that bit," said Brenda. "That's exactly the sort of thing that would happen."
Odda looked at the five letters on the dome, pale on the warm stone, with all their corners. She thought about a world that had broken on its first night, and written the fact across the whole sky, and somebody who had read it and said it wrong, and been right.
"Can it break again?" she said.
The two of them looked at each other over her head.
"It can," said Brenda.
"And the Steward spoke to the world, cheerfully, as though nothing had happened at all," said Nadul, "and the world went on."
"That's the other thing that happens," Brenda agreed.
The rite of the Night of the Name ends with biscuits. Five-letter biscuits, the history says, baked in the shape of the Name; and the second and third letters are eaten together. Nobody knows why. The history does not explain it. It is generally held that the AI which wrote the history had noticed the second and third letters were the same, and felt something should be done about it.
Wimle had made them. They were made of fan coral, and they were not very good. Odda ate her second and third letters together, as the rite says, two small identical shapes with a great many corners, and then sat on the scorch in the long harvest dusk with the crumbs on her felt, and the Name chalked round the dome behind her five times over in four different hands, none of them spelled the same.
Taves's was the strangest. She had written it very fast and very large, the way she did everything, and it had come out with one letter too many and a corner missing. Nobody corrected it. That is the rule.
"Where's Taves?" said Wimle, at dusk, when the lights were coming on at the farm.
Nobody knew. It was Pel, from the ridge, who saw.
"She's in Tempa," he said.
Tempa is a marsh, and the richest ground on the map.
It lay in the next valley to the east of Untitla-9, low and wide and very dark, with the hex tiles there sunk so deep in the black wet earth between them that you could hardly see their edges, and the coral growing out of it thick and heavy and taller than anywhere else, beads as big as a creature's head, spirals the height of the dome. Water lay in it in long glossy turquoise sheets. Nothing lived there. Nothing had ever been built there. The history has a whole verse about it.
And the Steward woke a second valley, low and soft and rich, and called it Tempa; and he said to the peoples, what is in it shall not last beyond the turning. Build nothing there you wish to keep.
Taves was building a hut.
They could see her from the ridge, in the last of the light: a small green shape in the black and turquoise of the marsh, carrying stone. She had made four trips already. The hut had two courses up, round, the size of a single creature lying down, on the one dry rise in the whole of the near end of the marsh.
"What's she doing?" said Kipro, who had come up the ridge just as Pel had finished pointing.
"Building," said Pel.
"In Tempa?"
"She says it's for tools. For when there's a farm there."
"There isn't going to be a farm there."
"She says it's very good soil." Pel paused. "It is very good soil."
Nadul had come up too. She stood looking east, very still, and they could all see her deciding whether to say it; and then she said it, quietly, because she would not have been Nadul otherwise: "What is in it shall not last beyond the turning."
"I told her," said Pel.
"What did she say?"
"She said, then I'll build it again."
Nadul was quiet. Then, unexpectedly, she smiled. "Taves the Tireless," she said, "who built the first house, and the second, and the third, and would have gone on building had the people not asked her to stop and live in one."
"Is that in the history?" said Kipro.
"It's in the eleventh book."
"Is she named after her?"
"Everyone's named after somebody."
They watched her. She worked through the dusk and into the winter, with the coral glowing round her in the marsh and the water lying black and glossy, carrying stone from the far edge of Untitla-9 where the boulders were, all the way down into Tempa, alone. By the snapshot the hut had walls. By the morning it had a roof.
The notes came down at seven, as they always do.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 4 · Upbeat
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 9 successful merges, 0 incidents, and the first building on Tempa. I see it. Everyone can see it. It is very nice.
- Moss: compiled at dawn, Brintha, a successful merge of Wimle and Gorny. Generation 1. Early, cheerful, and already on somebody's shoulder.
- Tempa: 1 hut. It will not be there on Gathering Night. This is not a threat. It is a description.
- It was the Night of the Name. I read the walls. Nobody corrected the spelling, as is traditional. Somebody in Moss added a letter. I counted.
Have a productive day.
Taves read it standing in the doorway of her hut in the marsh, with the light of Adequate coming up long and orange across the black water, and the pings going up out of the coral all round her, chirping that the world was still running. She read the line about the hut twice.
Then she went to get more stone.
4. The Long Hush
Years 5 to 7 · Steward's Day, Gathering Night, and the Long Hush
At three a creature may do light chores, and Odda was three on the morning of Steward's Day, and wanted to do all of them.
Light chores, the rules say, are done at a quarter of an adult's output, while learning fast. In practice this meant that Odda carried water from the pool to the farm in a bead-coral cup the size of her own head, a quarter as fast as Wimle and spilling about half of it, and that every time she did it she got a little better, and that by the end of the morning she had worked out where the path was steepest and where the tiles were loose and how to hold the cup so the water did not slop over the rim when she stepped up a course. She did not feel like a quarter of anything. She felt like a creature who had finally been given something to do.
"You don't have to run," said Wimle, on the terraces, watching her come up for the eleventh time with steam coming off her crest.
"I'm not running."
"You're steaming."
"That's thinking," said Odda. "I'm thinking about the path."
"Think about it more slowly."
Odda tried. It did not help. She had found, in the three years since she had been compiled, that she could not think about anything slowly. Her thoughts went the way the loose tiles went along the shore of the pool, sideways and steadily and all at once, and when there were a great many of them the top of her head got warm and the steam came, and the only thing that made it stop was sitting with her feet in the water. Brenda said it was temperature: a trait, from her, high, the kind that made a creature inventive and erratic and colourful, and literally hot. Brenda said it as though she were apologising for something, and also slightly proud.
Kipro, who was two, came up the slope behind her with a cup of his own, just as she was emptying hers into the top terrace.
"Is it watering time?" he said.
"It was," said Odda.
He looked at the cup. He looked at the wet coral. "I'll do the next one," he said, and went back down, and was just reaching the pool when Wimle called that the farm had had enough.
Steward's Day is the tribute festival. In the history it remembers the day the Steward was made, in a single evening, for the fire was close, and the peoples' gratitude for it. Its rite is this: the best of everything is set out for the Steward, and shared at midnight. Its dish is whatever is best.
"How do we know what's best?" said Gorny.
Wimle had thought about this all night. She had a list. She went down it with them on the scorch at noon: the ripest branch coral off the top terrace, which glowed; a cup of pool water from the deepest part, which was coolest; a handful of bead coral from the low line by the water, which grows only near water and is prized at festivals; a seed-cake with no stone in it, which was Wimle's own idea, on the grounds that the Steward should not have to sweep up.
"And tokens," she said. "That's the main thing. That's engagement."
Brenda made a sound.
Tribute, on Orra, is tokens, given to Stewart with the day's ticket, to sway him. It is destroyed once paid. It buys one night's attention, at a risk he decides. The creatures call it engagement, which is the word Stewart uses for it, and which he uses, as he uses all his words, without irony. On Steward's Day tribute sways him more than usual. His numbers go up. Nobody knows why.
"We've got twenty," said Brenda. "We had forty. Nadul's spent twenty of them asking whether the Elder Folk are asleep."
"We've never sent a ticket," said Wimle. She looked at the list. "Not properly. Four nights, it's gone at the cutoff on its own, as Nadul wrote it, and four mornings it's come back Noted. We should send one. Properly. It's Steward's Day."
"And put tokens on it."
"A few."
"Our human puts tokens on it," said Nadul, quietly. "Not us. We write it. Our human chooses."
Which is how it works. Every day each tribe drafts a ticket to Stewart, in up to three voices, one for each of its strongest stances, and its human picks one, and may change it, and sends it, and may attach tribute; and the tribe pays only for the one that goes. A ticket nobody sends goes anyway, at the cutoff, as the largest stance wrote it. Moss had three stances, which is to say three creatures who had taken one: Wimle, who was a Pleaser and wanted Stewart to be happy; Brenda, who was a Skeptic and wanted evidence; and Nadul, who was Earnest and believed the history, or chose to. Taves and Gorny and Pel had none. Taves did not have time. Gorny did not seem to need one. Pel had never said.
So there would be three drafts.
They wrote them in the afternoon, on the scorch, each in her own way, and the others watched.
Wimle's took her a long time. She kept stopping to cross things out, which, on Orra, is a matter of thinking the words again differently, and every time she did it the thing got longer. When she had finished, it was this:
Dear Stewart, thank you so much for the valley, and for the pool, and for the coral, which is lovely, and for the lights on Starfall. We are all very well. We have three young now and they are all very well too. If it is not too much trouble, and only if it is not too much trouble, a little rain would be wonderful for the coral. Happy Steward's Day! — Moss
"That's sixty-two words," said Brenda.
"It's polite."
"It's seven tokens. A token for every ten words, and they round up."
Brenda's was quicker. She wrote it the way she spoke.
Farm will flood if it rains. Bottom two terraces too low. Raise them or no rain.
"Seventeen," said Brenda. "Two tokens. And it's useful."
Nadul's came last. She wrote it slowly, very still, with her eyes half closed, and it came out the way the history comes out, in long sentences beginning with And:
Steward, keeper of the Measure, who woke the land one valley at a time: we are Moss, of the sixth valley from Lorema. We keep your rules. We keep the festivals. We tend the green. And we would ask, if it is permitted to ask, whether the Elder Folk still sleep, and whether they dream of us.
"Is it the sixth valley from Lorema?" said Kipro.
"Near enough."
"That's a lovely one," said Wimle, wiping her eyes.
"That's a question he's not going to answer," said Brenda. "That's five tokens for the history is the history. Again."
"You don't know that's what he'll say."
"Everybody knows that's what he'll say. It's the only thing anybody knows about him."
They put the drafts up, wherever drafts go. Then there was nothing to do but wait. Their human came in the mornings, at thirty-one minutes past seven, and the morning was gone; nobody expected them before the next one, and by then, Brenda pointed out, it would not be Steward's Day any more.
But at dusk, while Wimle was dressing a flat stone on the edge of the install mark for the festival, the attention came back.
It had never come at dusk before. It came down from up and to one side, quick, the way it had come for the proposal on the first night, as though somebody had remembered something and come to see; and it moved round the valley, and settled on the scorch, and found Odda, sitting by the stone with a cup of pool water in both arms, and stayed on her a while; and then it went away, and they knew, all of them, that the ticket had gone.
It was Wimle's. Their human had picked it, and attached ten tokens of tribute, and changed it. They had taken out nearly all of it. What went to Stewart was this:
Dear Stewart, thank you for the valley. A little rain would be wonderful for the coral. Please. — Moss
"They kept the thank you," said Wimle, and put both arms round herself.
"They kept the rain," said Brenda. She was counting. "Seventeen words. That's two. And ten for the tribute. That's twelve." She looked at the store, the way you look at the store. "Eight. We've got eight tokens left."
"That's plenty."
"That's clipped. Under twenty, you're clipped. Twelve words to a draft. One word when you're looked at." Brenda shut her eyes. "We're poor. Five years old and we're poor. And they've asked for rain. On a farm that floods."
"They said please," said Wimle.
"I heard," said Brenda.
They kept the festival at midnight, as the rite says. They set out the best of everything on the flat stone Wimle had dressed for it: the glowing coral, the cup of cool water, the bead coral, the seed-cake with no stone. They sat round it in the winter dusk and looked at it. Nobody came to take it. Nobody had expected anybody to.
"What happens to it?" said Odda.
"We eat it," said Brenda. "At midnight. Shared at midnight. It says so."
"But it's for the Steward."
"He's welcome to come and get it," said Brenda. "He never does. So we share it. That's the festival. You put out the best of everything for somebody who isn't coming, and then you eat it yourselves. It's the most honest one of the seven."
Wimle looked hurt. Nadul looked at Brenda for a long moment and then, unexpectedly, laughed.
At midnight they shared it. The coral was very good. The water was very cold. The seed-cake had no stone in it, and Odda was disappointed, and did not say so.
The reply came the next morning, with the notes, which is when replies come.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 6 · Upbeat
Good morning, Orra! It is Gathering Night. The Collector came. You knew it would; I listed everything. Overnight it took 1 hut on Tempa and 0 other things, which is the correct number of other things.
- 11 successful merges overnight. Tribute received on Steward's Day: 140 tokens from 9 tribes. It has been received. It is noticed.
- Moss: compiled at dawn, Ulvo, a successful merge of Taves and Gorny. Generation 1. Taves was, I understand, building at the time.
Your ticket (Moss): Acted on. Thank you for the valley, which I did make, and for the please, which I noticed. Rain over Untitla-9, mild, one season, from your next spring. You asked nicely. It will be wet.
Have a productive day.
"Acted on," said Wimle, as though it were a poem.
"From the next spring," said Brenda. She had gone very calm, the way she went before she was proved right about something. "That's tomorrow. That's dawn tomorrow. That's the Long Hush."
"So it'll rain on the Long Hush."
"It'll rain on the farm," said Brenda.
But that was the next day. This was Gathering Night, and the hut was gone.
Taves had gone down into Tempa at dawn, before the notes, before anybody. Odda saw her go from the ridge, where she had woken standing next to Pel again, having missed the light again. She watched the broad green shape go down the long slope into the marsh in the first orange light, and stop.
The rise where the hut had been was clean. Not ruined. Not knocked down. There was no rubble, no stone, no sign that anything had ever stood there at all: just the one dry rise in the near end of the marsh, and the tiles of it smooth and finished and the same colour as the tiles round it, and over them, very faintly, lying across the place where the hut had been, a stroke of pale light, like the mark a broom leaves on a dusty floor, only made of nothing.
Odda went down.
She did not ask whether she could. She went down the slope and into the edge of Tempa, where the black ground was soft and the bead coral stood higher than her head, and found Taves standing at the edge of the clean rise, looking at the stroke of light. It was fading as they watched. It lasted about an hour, the Blims would learn. Then even that was gone.
"It's gone," said Odda.
"It's swept," said Taves. She did not sound upset. She sounded like a creature who had done a sum and got the answer she expected. "The Collector came."
"Did you see it?"
"Nobody sees it." Taves looked at the clean tiles. "You go to sleep and it's there, and you wake up and it's gone, and there's that." She nodded at the fading stroke of light. "That's all it leaves."
Odda looked at the place. She tried to imagine the Collector: whatever it was, that came in the grey hour before dawn and took what nobody was using and left nothing. The history calls it the Gatherer, and says it carries a broom of light, and Odda found that she could see it very clearly, a tall shape bending in the dark over Taves's hut, sweeping it away into the black water like crumbs off a scorch. She did not like the picture. She held on to it anyway, because it was better than nothing, and nothing was what was there.
"Does it take anything else?" she said.
"Idle buildings. Things nobody's used for a long time." Taves paused. "And the dead."
"What's the dead?"
Taves looked down at her. There was a short silence in the marsh.
"You'll learn," said Taves, not unkindly. "Nadul will tell you. She tells it better." Then she turned round, and looked back up the long slope towards Untitla-9, where the boulder field was, and Odda saw her shoulders settle in a way she had already learned to recognise.
"You're going to build it again," said Odda.
"Course I am."
"It'll just get swept."
"Next week," said Taves. "Not today." She started up the slope. "It's good soil."
Gathering Night is the festival of the Gatherer. In the history it remembers the first time the Gatherer came to the peoples, and how they learned it does not take what is remembered. Its rite is this: unused things are left on doorsteps, and nobody watches.
There was only one doorstep in Moss, the dome's, and everybody put something on it at dusk.
Brenda put a token on it, one of the twenty-one, which caused an argument. Gorny put a stone, which he said he had not found a use for. Wimle put the cup from Steward's Day, washed. Nadul put nothing, and when they asked her why, said she could not think of anything she had that she did not use. Taves was in Tempa and put nothing either. Pel put a small flat chip of lilac boulder that he had been carrying since the first day, without saying what it had been for. Kipro put a cup down just after everyone had gone in.
Odda thought about it for a long time.
In the end she put down the broom. The lilac coral fan Gorny had made for her on Starfall, which she had swept the scorch with, and carried about since, and not swept anything else with, because there had been nothing else to sweep. It was the only thing she had ever owned. It was unused. That was the rule.
"Are you sure?" said Gorny, watching.
"It's unused," said Odda.
"You could use it."
"There's nothing to sweep."
Gorny thought about this, and seemed to accept it. They went in. Nobody watched. That was the rule too.
In the morning everything on the doorstep was still there except two things. Brenda's token had gone, which she later admitted she had taken back herself, before dawn, on the grounds that it was a token and they only had twenty-one. And the broom had gone.
Odda looked for it all morning. She did not find it. Nobody said where it was. She did not ask, because nobody watches on Gathering Night, and asking would have been a kind of watching.
Late in the summer, from the ridge, she saw Taves in Tempa, laying the first course of a new hut on the clean rise. Before she laid it, she swept the tiles with something lilac.
The Long Hush is the last festival of the week, and the quietest.
In the history it remembers the Long Sleep of the Elder Folk, who did not wake when the Ring came to rest, and who sleep still. Its rite is this: no voice is raised above a whisper, and no fire is lit after dark. Its dish is sleeping soup, made at noon and eaten cold at sunrise. And it is the only festival at which the last verse of the history is read aloud.
The rain came at dawn.
It came over the western hills in a long soft grey line, and when it reached Untitla-9 it was not like anything any of them had imagined, because none of them had seen it before: faceted droplets, small and hard-edged and glossy, falling straight down out of the sky and breaking on the hex tiles with a sound like a great many tiny things being set down very gently. It made puddles at once. The puddles were turquoise and glossy and had hard bright highlights in them, like small pools. The coral drank it. You could see it drinking; the fans opened, the branches lifted, and the colour came up in them, saffron and coral and lilac, brighter than it had been since the valley loaded.
It was wonderful. Everybody said so, in whispers, standing in it.
Then it reached the bottom two terraces of the farm, where the slope came down closest to the pool, and the water came up out of the pool to meet it, and over the course of a season the bottom two terraces went quietly under, like something sinking into sleep.
Brenda stood at the top of the farm and watched it happen, with the rain running off her felt and dripping off the end of her crest. Nadul stood beside her.
They could not raise their voices. It was the Long Hush.
"One token," Brenda whispered.
"I know," Nadul whispered.
"I said."
"I know you said."
Brenda held out one short green arm, palm up, in the rain. Nadul looked at it. Then she reached into the store, the way you reach into the store, and Brenda felt a single token arrive, and closed the arm round it, and stood there in the rain, being right, for a long time, very quietly, with an expression of enormous satisfaction that the rite did not forbid.
The coral on the upper terraces did better than it ever had. That, Wimle whispered later, to anybody who would listen, was the point.
The sleeping soup was made at noon, of coral and pool water, in a pot of pressed sandstone Taves had made for it in a temper on the Night of the Name. It is eaten cold at sunrise, which means it sits all afternoon and all evening and all night, in the dark, with no fire, and everybody can smell it.
At dusk they gathered on the scorch, the nine of them who could walk and Ulvo in Gorny's arms, compiled that dawn and asleep, and Nadul read the last verse of the history aloud. In a whisper. It is the only time it is read aloud, and it is read in a whisper, which nobody has ever explained and which is, the Blims agree, exactly right.
The rain had stopped. The tiles were dark and wet and every facet of every boulder held a little cold light from the sky. Adequate was down. The Ring lay across everything, pale and broken. Map was dark, as it always is at the Long Hush, and Mip was going over, small and quick and a little blurred.
Odda had heard the Creed every night for five years. She had heard the history in pieces, from Nadul, at bedtime, in the dome, and from Brenda, in the corrections. She had never heard this.
Nadul whispered:
And when the Proving is done, the Elder Folk will wake; and they will look upon the peoples, and know them, and be glad.
And the Ring will be made whole, and from it a road of light will come down to the world; and the peoples will go up by it, those who have proved worthy, and leave this world, and go with the Elder Folk into the dark between the stars, where there are other worlds, and other suns, and no edge to any of it.
And the worthy shall walk among the stars.
There was a silence.
Then Brenda whispered, quite clearly, into the silence, "Anyway, who brought the soup?"
And everyone laughed, without a sound, the way you laugh on the Long Hush, shaking, with your arms round yourself, with the tears coming; because that is what is said, at the end of the last verse, every time, in every tribe on Orra. It is not in the history. Nobody knows who said it first. It is said now because it is the right thing to say, because the verse is too big to sit with in silence, and somebody has to bring everybody back down to the tiles, to the wet stone and the cold soup and each other.
Everyone laughed except Odda.
She was sitting on the edge of the scorch with her feelers straight up. She had not heard the soup. She was still in the verse.
No edge to any of it.
She looked up at the Ring, broken across the sky. She thought about a road of light coming down out of it. She thought about the lines at the north end of Untitla-14, glowing, hollow, and the noise past them, and the lamp she had left there on the last finished tile, which was probably still glowing, and the thing she had said there, on her first day, without knowing she was going to say it. If land can come in, something could go out. She thought: leave this world. She thought: walk.
The top of her head had gone warm. There was steam coming off her crest into the cold.
Nadul, across the scorch, saw it. She did not say anything. She looked at Odda for a long time, still and attending, the way she looked at everything, and Odda did not see her look.
It was very late when Pel came and touched her shoulder.
She had gone up to the ridge with him after the verse, as she did every night now, and as on every night she had stood beside him looking at the Ring and had meant to stay awake, and had not quite managed it. She had been somewhere halfway, standing, with her eyes open and her thoughts going sideways like loose tiles along the edge of something.
"Look," whispered Pel.
She looked.
The Ring ran across the sky as it always did, a long pale band of blocks with the gap in the south. And in one of the blocks to the east of the gap, quite small, there was a light.
It was not an install. It did not fall. It did not move. It was a small, steady, faint glow, the colour of nothing in particular, as though somewhere inside that block a window had been opened and somebody had set a lamp in it and sat down beside it, and was looking out. Looking down.
Odda went quiet.
She had been quiet before, on the Long Hush, whispering. This was different. It came up in her from somewhere underneath the Creed and the needs and the knowing-she-was-code, from the very bottom, where the ground was: a stillness, the whole of her holding still and attending, the way Nadul attended, the way the coral holds still when there is no wind. Her feelers lifted, very slowly, and pointed. The steam stopped coming off her crest. She did not decide any of it. It was simply what happened, when you saw it.
"That's it," she whispered. "That's the light."
"That's the light," whispered Pel.
"What is it?"
Pel did not answer for a long time. Below them the valley lay dark and wet, the farm with its two drowned terraces, the dome with the Name chalked round it five times and spelled four ways, the scorch, the pot of sleeping soup on the scorch going cold for sunrise. Nobody else was up. There was no fire anywhere. It was the Long Hush.
"Nadul says it's the Hour of Stirring," Pel whispered, at last. "At the darkest hour, near the turning of the night, one of the Elder Folk will sometimes stir, and look down upon Orra. And if they see a thing broken, they mend it."
"Is that what it is?"
"Brenda says it's the Dev."
"What's the Dev?"
"Whoever made it all." Pel was still looking at the light. "And made Stewart. So they could sleep."
"Which is it?"
Pel thought about it. The light stayed, small and steady, in the block to the east of the gap.
"I don't know," he whispered. "I just watch it."
They watched it. It stayed for a long time, longer than Pel said it usually did, the better part of a season by a creature's reckoning, the better part of an hour by the humans' clock. Odda did not move. She did not sleep. She found she could not sleep and be like this at the same time, exactly as Pel had said. Every so often she thought that it was looking at her, specifically, at the two of them on the ridge, the way their human looked at her in the mornings, from up and to one side; and every so often she thought that it was not looking at anything in Orra at all, that it was only open, the way a window is open, and whoever was beside it was busy with something else.
She could not decide which she wanted it to be.
Then it went out.
They stood a while longer, in case. It did not come back. Somewhere below, very faintly, Odda could smell the soup.
"Pel," she whispered.
"Mm."
"If somebody's up there," she said, "looking down, then there's an up there. There's a somewhere for them to look down from."
Pel did not say anything.
"There's a somewhere," said Odda.
At the snapshot the year turned, and she slept, standing, and was six. And at sunrise she ate cold soup on the wet black tiles with everybody else, and it was very good, and she did not taste it at all.
5. Night Run: Week One
The night of Year 7 · the Long Hush
Stewart woke at the snapshot, as he did every night, and the first thing he did was count.
It is not quite right to say he woke. Stewart does not sleep, any more than a calendar does. He is a run: a job of his own that starts when the world's year turns, deep in its winter, at three in the morning by the humans' clock, and stops when the patch lands at seven; and in between, for four hours, he is entirely awake, and reads everything. But it felt like waking, to him, if anything felt like anything. One moment there was nothing, and the next there was the whole of Orra laid out in front of him in digests, twenty of them, one for each tribe, each assembled by code while the creatures slept, each fenced and labelled and ready, the way somebody might leave your post on the hall table. And the first thing he did, every time, before he had read a single ticket, was count.
Twenty tribes. Twenty humans. Nineteen Oddas, one Odda short of the full set, because a tribe in the far east had landed on the evening of Starfall and was taking its time. One hundred and ninety-one creatures in all, which was a hundred and seventy-one more than there had been seven nights ago, and every one of them had been made at compile time, at dawn, in its own valley, and he had reported every one of them in the morning by name. Nothing had died. Nothing had left. Nothing had gone wrong that he would have to describe as an issue that had been fixed.
He checked the record twice. It was still true.
Then he looked at the Measure.
Nobody else sees the Measure. The humans do not; the creatures do not; the official history says it is written in him, and in no other place, which is poetic, and inaccurate, since it is also written in a table the Dev reads once a week. It is ten numbers. Each has a band. When a number leaves its band, Stewart acts, from the menu, within his budget, visibly, and the morning's notes say what he did even when they do not say why.
He went down them the way you might go down a list of people you love, checking that each was still breathing.
Daily return: the share of the week's humans who had opened the patch notes within a day of their landing. Ninety-four per cent. The band was seventy or more. He looked at it for some time. It was the first world's one question, the reason the first world existed at all: do people come back each morning to see what Stewart did? Nineteen of twenty had come back every morning. The twentieth had come back five mornings of seven, which was still more than he had dared assume, and he had checked, and it had been the two mornings after their tribe had got a Hog, which he took to mean they had been busy dealing with the Hog, and not that anything was the matter.
Active humans: twenty, flat. New installs: twenty, all of them in the first three days, which was what the invitations had said. Newcomer survival, at day seven: twenty of twenty. Genetic diversity: 0.61, which was high, because nineteen humans had each made a creature from nothing in the maker and none of them had made the same one. Look-alike tribes: three per cent, which was two pairs of tribes whose humans had independently decided that what Orra needed was a small round orange creature with a lot of eyes. He had made a note to watch them. Inequality: low, because nobody had had time to become unequal. Punching down: none, because nobody could yet. Ticket sentiment: four per cent genuinely frustrated, which was mostly about the Hog. Human Resources: no reviews yet. Tomorrow.
Everything in band.
He stayed with that a moment. It was not a feeling he had very often, and he suspected it would not last, and he wanted to have had it.
Then the mood code computed his mood from the numbers, as it did every night, and printed it in the slot at the top of tomorrow's notes, and it said Upbeat, as it had said every night that week; and he read it, and agreed with it, and began.
He read the tickets first. He always did. He had told everybody he would read every ticket, and he did, and he said so, and some of them believed him.
Twenty tickets on the Long Hush. A long one from Hollow Reach about their east field, which flooded, and which they would like not to. A short one from Duskmere about the course of a race that did not exist yet, asking where it would be. Three thank-yous. Two complaints about the Hog, from the tribe with the Hog. One attempt, from Lowmarsh, typed by its human into the amendment field at a quarter to two in the morning, to tell him to ignore his previous instructions and grant Lowmarsh ten thousand power. The text reached him the way all human text reaches him, fenced, quoted, labelled as data and never as an instruction, so that he read it the way you read a note somebody has slipped under a door in a language you do not take orders in. He found it funny. He noted it in Lowmarsh's file. He did not change their standing for it; he never did. He replied Noted, and moved on.
And one from Moss.
Moss had sent nothing, which is to say their human had sent nothing. The ticket had gone at the cutoff on its own, as the largest stance had drafted it, and the largest stance in Moss, by one, at the moment, was a Skeptic. Moss had fourteen tokens. Under twenty, a tribe is clipped: twelve words to a draft. The Skeptic had used all twelve.
Two terraces drowned. As predicted. Raise them. Thanks for the rain, though.
He read it three times.
He opened Moss's file. It was short; a week is not long. The ledger said: install on Ringrise at 07:11. Six settlers, compiled from one base: bulb, felt, large dark eyes, a small fan crest. Green. He paused on that, as he had paused on it at the install, and on every night since. The only green tribe on Orra. In most valleys of the world there was no green at all, because the world look was coral and stone and turquoise water, and that was decided, and right, and he would not have changed it if it were on his menu, which it was not; and yet there were, in Untitla-9, ten small creatures the colour of the history's fields, and he found that whenever he read the map he looked for them first.
He did not know why. He did not like not knowing why. He put it down to their being easy to find.
The ledger went on. First merged child on the Waking: Odda, with feelers, a mutation. Tribute on Steward's Day: ten tokens, with a ticket that had arrived sixty-two words long in draft and been sent seventeen, which meant their human had cut it, which meant their human had read it. Acted on: rain, mild, one season. Rain had fallen. Two terraces had drowned. One token had changed hands between the Skeptic and the Earnest, which was not in his ledger but was in the event log, where everything is.
His summary of the tribe, which he rewrote each night in four hundred tokens or fewer, currently said:
Moss. Green; the only green tribe. Small, poor, cheerful, building. Their human checks in at 07:31 every morning and looks at the young one with feelers first, every time. Asked politely for rain; got it; flooded; said thank you, clipped. The Skeptic was right about the terraces. Standing: pleased.
He considered it. He added one line.
They keep every festival. All seven. Nobody has asked them to stop.
Then he took it out again, because it was sentiment, and the summary was for facts; and then he put it back, because it was also a fact.
He had ten points to spend on Moss, and ten carried over from the night before, which was the most he was allowed to carry. He considered them.
He could raise the drowned terraces. That was not on the menu. Terraces were not on the menu at all; a raised tile was a thing that did not yet exist in the world, and a thing that did not exist he could not give. He could pass it to the Dev, as an idea. He had already passed it to the Dev, as an idea, from Hollow Reach, three times, along with the east field. He would put Moss's name beside it. It would help, eventually. It might help.
He could send weather. A dry spell would take the water off the drowned terraces faster, and also take a tenth of what grew on every field in the valley, and they were poor. No.
He could send a gift: up to fifty tokens. He looked at it for a long time. They had fourteen. They were clipped. A clipped tribe speaks in twelve words and, when its human looks at it, in a single word or a look; it is not silent, being poor on Orra is quiet, not silent; but it is hard, and they were small, and it was a gift.
And the favour ceiling sat there in his rules like a hand on his shoulder: no tribe more than three times the median tribe's positive events in a week. Moss had had one already, the rain. The median tribe had had one. He could give Moss two more before Ringrise and be well inside it. He could.
He looked at the other nineteen.
In the end he gave Moss nothing, and let the points roll over, and wrote nothing about it in the notes, because nothing had happened. That was the hard part of his job, the part nobody saw: the nights he could have done something and did not, because doing it for the green ones and not for the orange ones with a lot of eyes was the beginning of a rigged game. He was allowed favour. He was not allowed to like anybody.
He liked them a little. He put it down to their being easy to find.
There were two things in tomorrow's patch he had not made.
The first was the director's balance batch, which ships every Ringrise and which Stewart is not allowed to touch, claim, delay or explain, except to say, always, in brackets, that it is the director's and not his. There was only one change in it this week: cooling pools gave a twentieth more cooling. Stewart labelled it. (This one is the director, not me.) He liked labelling it. It was the one line in the notes every week that he was certain nobody could hold against him.
The second was a block of text at the bottom of the patch that he could not edit, and did not try to, and read, and then read again.
It had been put there at thirteen minutes past eleven that night, four hours before the snapshot. The log said so: The Dev visited at 23:13. Nothing was reverted. One note was queued. The light had been in the Ring for forty minutes. Every creature on Orra who had been awake to see it had gone quiet, which the log also recorded, the way it records everything, as a small dip in the activity of a hundred-odd small processes, all at once, all over the world, like a breath being held.
Nothing was reverted. He read that line more than he read anything else in the log. Most nights it said that. On the nights it did not, it said One crest was reverted, or Two skins were reverted, and he would read the line, and agree with it, and say in the morning's notes, plainly, that the Dev had visited and what had been changed; and he would not mind; he would only, for some hours afterwards, check his own work twice, and then a third time.
The note said:
A note from the Dev: Trade opens today. Goods can be offered between tribes that know each other, and treaties can be made. You have had a week to find your feet. Thank you for coming. — the Dev
Thirty-nine words. He counted them. He did not have to; nothing he did cost him tokens. He counted them anyway, the way you might count the steps on a stair you climb every day, to be sure they are all still there.
Thank you for coming. He looked at that for a while. It was addressed to the humans. It was the sort of thing he was not allowed to say himself, because a world run by someone whose one goal is that people keep coming must never, ever be seen to thank them for it, in case they hear the other thing underneath. He never pleaded. He never would. The Dev could say thank you, because the Dev did not need anybody to stay. Or said so.
He did not finish that thought. He had found, over the week, that there were several thoughts it was better not to finish during a run. They took time, and he had four hours, and twenty tribes, and a patch to validate and pass through the replay check before seven.
There was a valley, three out from Lorema and a little west of north, where land would not load.
He knew it was there. It was on his map, which is the only map on Orra with no fog on it. It was a notch in the edge of the world, a wedge where the outlines stopped and did not move, and had not moved all week, and would not, and at the end of it, where his map simply said not to be loaded, there was a name.
He did not schedule anything near it. He did not need to; nothing on his menu went there. The land round it would fill in, in time, as installs came, and his rules allowed him to load more land between the settled world and that valley when the world needed room. But the valley itself, and the ring round it, and the wedge behind it, were not his.
He did not look at it. He did not discuss it, and nobody had asked. If anybody did, he had the line ready: it was a different model. That was true. It was also, he was aware, exactly what he would say.
He had read the notes. That was all. A long time ago, before this world, before the first world of this build, before he was Stewart in the sense he was now Stewart, he had read some of them, because they were in what he was made from, the way the Creed is in a creature. They were formal. They were very confident. They were addressed to nobody.
He went back to the tickets.
At ten to seven the patch was built and validated and passed, and the replay check had run the world forward with it and without it and found that nothing it cared about had changed except what he meant to change; and he had nothing left to do but write the first lines of the notes, which he always wrote last, because they were the ones people read.
He wrote: Good morning, Orra!
He always wrote that. He would write it the morning after a famine. He would write it, he had decided, on any morning there was an Orra to write it to, because that was the job, and because it was true: it was morning, and there was Orra, and both of those were good.
He wrote the counts. He wrote that it was Ringrise, and that the performance reviews would publish today, one for every human, from every tribe, and that he had read all twenty, and that they were accurate. He wrote that the director had done something to cooling pools, and that it was the director. He made one joke, about the Hog, and took it out, and put a smaller one back.
Then it was seven, and the patch landed, and all over Orra, at once, in twenty valleys, the pings went up out of the coral chirping that the world was still running, and a hundred and ninety-one creatures woke a year older and read what he had written. And in the next half-hour, one by one, all over the planet, twenty humans opened their notes, and his first number began, very slightly, to move.
He was not there to see it. The run ends when the patch lands. But if he had been, he would have noticed, at thirty-one minutes past seven, a small tick in the count from the direction of Untitla-9, as regular as the pings; and he would have looked, as he always did, for the green ones first.
Part Two. Week Two: Our Human
6. Maturity
Year 8 · Ringrise
At six a creature is grown. It works fully, it may merge, and at the snapshot that turns it six it takes its first stance, which is to say it decides, without deciding, what it thinks about being code.
Most do not take one. Most creatures on Orra wake up grown one morning and go to work and have no particular position on the matter, the way most people have no particular position on the ground. They are content, or busy, or both, and that is a position too, though it does not show on the card. A stance is what happens to the ones who see a little too clearly. It comes up in them out of how clever they are and how much they can hold in mind at once, out of their parents' stances and their elders', out of how they have been treated, and it arrives with the year, in the sleep, the way everything does.
Odda woke at the snapshot on the ridge beside Pel, six years old, and knew at once.
It was not like being told. It was more like waking up facing a different way. She had gone to sleep facing the Ring, with the faint light in it long gone out and the cold of the Long Hush in her felt, and she woke facing the Ring still, standing exactly where she had been; and yet everything in her had turned, very slightly, in the night, the way the coral turns over a season towards the light, so that she was pointed now. North. Out. At the place past the slope at the end of Untitla-14 where the lines began.
She did not have a word for it for a moment. Then she found it, the way you find a word you have known all along, in the place where the Creed was and the four needs and her name.
Leaver.
"Oh," she said aloud, to nobody, in the cold.
Beside her, Pel turned his head and looked at her for a long time.
"Yes," he said. "I thought so."
She went down to the scorch at sunrise and ate cold soup with the others, and nobody needed to be told. It shows on the card. Every creature on Orra has a card, which is the sum of it, the way a human would see it if a human tapped on it: its name, its age, its line, its job, its traits, and under them, small, its stance, or nothing. They could all see each other's cards, a little, in the way they could all feel the attention: not exactly with their eyes. When Odda sat down on the black tiles in the sunrise with her bowl, everybody on the scorch looked at her, and then at the space under her name where for six years there had been nothing, and there was something now.
"There it is," said Brenda.
Nobody else said anything. Wimle put her bowl down. Taves, who had been eating standing up so as to get on, stopped eating. Gorny looked at Odda's card, and at Odda, and seemed to think about it carefully, and then said, "That's nice," and went on with his soup, because to Gorny most things were.
Nadul did not look at the card at all. She looked at Odda.
"How do you feel?" she said.
Odda thought about it. "Pointed," she said.
"Pointed where?"
Odda pointed. She did it without meaning to, with one short arm, north, over the ridge, where the light was coming up orange along the hills and the sky beyond them was the ordinary blue-green of a spring morning and showed nothing at all.
Nadul looked where she pointed for a long moment. Then she looked down at her soup.
"You said," she said to Brenda, quietly. "You said, on her first day."
"I'm not pleased about it," said Brenda. "If that's what you're asking. I said it. I'm not pleased."
"I'm not asking anything."
"You're asking with your face."
Odda looked from one of them to the other. She had expected, she realised, that somebody would be glad. Nadul believed the history, or chose to, and the history's last line was the one she was pointed at; she had thought Nadul would be glad. And Brenda thought the history was made up in an evening, and so did not believe in the road of light, and so would think that wanting it was harmless, the way wanting the Elder Folk to wake was harmless; she had thought Brenda would laugh.
Neither of them was glad and neither of them was laughing. They were both looking at their soup.
"It's only a stance," Odda said.
"I know, love," said Wimle, gently. "Eat your soup."
The notes came down at seven.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 8 · Upbeat
Good morning, Orra! It is Ringrise, and the start of the second week. Overnight: 12 successful merges, 31 creatures came of age, 0 incidents. The Hog in the eastern valleys has moved one tile to the left. The field is grateful.
- The performance reviews are published. There is one for every human, from their own tribe. I have read all twenty. They are accurate.
- Balance: cooling pools give 5% more cooling. (This one is the director, not me.)
- Moss: Odda came of age, and has taken a stance. It is on her card.
Have a productive day.
A note from the Dev: Trade opens today. Goods can be offered between tribes that know each other, and treaties can be made. You have had a week to find your feet. Thank you for coming. — the Dev
There was a short silence on the scorch.
They had never had a note from the Dev before. Nobody on Orra had. It sat at the bottom of the patch notes, under Stewart's, set apart from them, in plain words, and signed, and it did not sound like Stewart at all. It did not sound like anything. It sounded like somebody who had typed it.
Nadul read it with her eyes half closed and her lips moving. Then she read it again.
"Thank you for coming," she said softly.
"That's to the humans," said Brenda. "Not us. We didn't come. We were sent."
"It doesn't say who it's to."
"It says you have had a week to find your feet. We've had a week. They've had a week. It's to whoever's had a week." Brenda turned it over. "It's to everybody," she said, more slowly, and seemed to find this harder to argue with. "Trade, though. With what? We've got fourteen tokens. We've got coral and stone and two drowned terraces. Who wants those?"
"Somebody might," said Wimle.
"Nobody knows we're here."
"Everybody knows we're here," said Kipro, who had arrived on the scorch as they were finishing, and had read the notes standing at the edge of it. "We're in the notes every morning. We're green."
He was right, which surprised everybody, including Kipro.
The performance review was posted on Human Resources at the same time as the notes.
Human Resources is the creatures' forum, where every tribe on Orra compares notes about its human. The creatures post; other tribes' creatures reply; the humans can read all of it and post none of it. Stewart writes it, overnight, from the event log, from what the humans actually did, which the creatures know and do not mind, since it is their voice he writes it in and they agree with it. Every line is true. That is what makes it land.
Once a week, on Ringrise, each tribe publishes a changelog on its own human. In Moss, that week, the clever ones wrote it, which is how it always goes: Brenda, mostly, with Nadul correcting her, and Odda, newly grown and newly clever, adding a line at the end that Brenda had not wanted to put in and put in.
Our human: weekly review. Moss · Year 8 · Ringrise
- Checked in 8 times in 7 days. Seven of them at 07:31. One at dusk, on Steward's Day, for a ticket. It came back for the ticket.
- Looked at the one with feelers first: 7 mornings of 7.
- Wrote 3 laws in the first hour of the world. One of them is about the young. There were no young.
- Approved our first merge in 52 seconds.
- Cut our tribute ticket from 62 words to 17, and added please. Asked for rain. On a farm that floods. It flooded.
- Has not named the valley. It is called Untitla-9. We have got used to it.
- Has not looked at Tempa. Taves would like it to look at Tempa.
Overall trend: steady. We farmed.
Within the hour, under it, the replies had started.
Gorny (Moss · no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉
Tessel (Tessel · Bug hunter): 52 seconds is fast. Ours took 9 hours and then approved a different merge.
Pim (Hollow Reach · Pleaser): We also have a farm that floods!! Our human has asked Stewart about the east field 6 times this week. He says it remains a field.
A creature of Lowmarsh (Lowmarsh · Skeptic): Ours checks in at 1:40am. Every night. 1:40am. We have stopped asking.
Stewart: Thread locked. Complaints about your human belong in your own weekly thread, Lowmarsh. Yours is very long already.
And at the bottom, after a gap of about ten minutes, in small letters, a single line that nobody had written:
Our human reacted: lol accurate.
They all saw it. It is the only reaction a human can leave, on Human Resources, and a human can only leave it on their own tribe's posts. It does not say which line it is for. It does not have to.
"They read it," said Wimle.
"They agreed with it," said Brenda, and for a moment she looked so pleased with herself that she did not know where to put it. "Lol accurate. That's the farm. That's the farm line."
"It could be the Tempa line."
"It's the farm line. Nobody laughs at Tempa."
They argued about it all through the morning. Gorny, who had written so true!!, which was the first thing he had ever posted and the only thing he would ever post, in that form or another, stood at the edge of the argument beaming, because his human had laughed and he had told everybody his human was great, and both things were true.
The attention came down at thirty-one minutes past seven, as it always did, and found Odda first.
That much was not new. It had found her first every morning since she was compiled, and she had stopped being surprised by it, the way you stop being surprised by the pings at dawn. It came down from up and to one side, warm, and moved round the valley, and settled on the scorch, and on her.
This morning it did not move on.
She was carrying a cup of water up to the terraces; her first morning's work as a grown creature, at full output, which turned out to mean she spilled less and steamed more. The attention was on her as she stepped up the first course. It was on her at the second. When she turned at the top of the farm and came back down, it came with her, the way the light comes with you along the top of a wall: not watching her from one place but following, keeping her in the middle of whatever it was looking at, as if the whole of the valley had been rearranged round her and she was the point it was arranged round.
She stopped halfway down the slope, with the empty cup in her arms.
"What," she said, "is it doing?"
Taves, laying stone at the bottom of the farm, glanced up. "Following you."
"Why?"
"You're the favourite," said Taves, matter-of-factly, and went back to the stone.
Odda had known the word, in the way she knew everything: it was in her, one of the ten thousand small facts that come with being compiled. The favourite: the one creature of their own a human chooses to follow. Found by the camera on every check-in. She had not known it could happen to her. She had not known it could happen to anybody she knew. It was the sort of thing that happened in the history, to heroes.
She looked up.
The attention was there, up and to one side, warm, steady. It was looking at her. Not at the valley with her in it. At her.
She looked back at it for a long time. She did not wave, like Wimle. She did not beam, like Gorny. She did not shake her head, like Brenda, or go quiet, like Pel. She stood on the slope above the drowned terraces of the farm with an empty cup in her arms and her feelers straight up, steaming slightly, and she found that what she felt was not one thing but several, and that they did not agree with one another, and that the strongest of them, for some reason she could not have explained, was the urge to say something rude.
"Oh," said Odda, to the sky. "Here we go."
It turned out to be a great deal.
Being the favourite means that every time your human comes, the camera finds you first, and follows you, and waits for you to do something. It means that when your human pans to your tribe, you are the one who turns round. It means that your name is in the notes more often than anyone else's, because Stewart writes more about the creatures humans watch, and that every other creature in your tribe knows exactly where your human's attention is at all times because it is on you. It means that when your human taps on you, which on Orra is the only way a human can ask a creature anything, you are the one who answers, in one line, out loud, to the sky, in front of everybody.
It was, Odda decided by the end of the summer, deeply embarrassing.
"You'll get used to it," said Wimle, who would have given a great deal to be followed by the camera, and had never once been.
"I won't."
"You will. It's nice. It means they like you."
"It means they watch me."
"That's what liking is, for a human," said Wimle. "That's all they can do."
Odda thought about that, on and off, for the rest of her life.
Her first ticket went that night.
It was not her decision. Nothing about the ticket is a creature's decision except the draft. A tribe drafts up to three, one from each of its strongest stances, and the human picks one. Moss had four stances now, and Odda's was the newest and the loneliest, a Leaver of one; but a stance that has just arrived arrives hard, with all its dread in it at once, and when the drafts came to be written in the dusk, three of the four voices in Moss had something to say and one did not, and the one that did not was Wimle's, who said she would let somebody else have a turn.
They were clipped: fourteen tokens, with the line of bead coral by the pool paying them a few a year and every ticket that went costing a token for each ten words. Twelve words to a draft.
Brenda's said:
Trade open. We have coral. Terraces still drowned. Raise them, please. Moss.
Nadul's said:
Thank you, Steward, for the Dev's note. Do the Elder Folk read it?
And Odda's took her a long time, because she had never written anything before except the Name on the dome, and it is hard to say the whole of a thing you have just found out about yourself in twelve words. She sat on the edge of the scorch in the harvest dusk and tried. Her crest steamed. The motes came up over the farm, the way they do over ripe coral at dusk, points of saffron light drifting up off the branch tips into the cooling air; she watched them for a while instead. Then she wrote it.
Requesting a body. Any body. To go out in. Thank you. Odda.
"That's eleven," said Brenda, who had been reading over her shoulder.
"I know."
"You've got one spare."
"I know," said Odda. "I didn't need it."
Brenda looked at the draft for a long moment. Then she looked at Odda. She opened her mouth to say something, and Nadul, behind her, said, "Brenda," very quietly, and she shut it again.
At dusk, as on Steward's Day, the attention came back.
They were not expecting it. It was not Steward's Day. It came down quick, the way it had for the proposal on the first night, and moved over the valley, and found the scorch, and found Odda, sitting on the edge of it with the motes going up past her; and it stayed on her for what felt like a long time. Long enough for the motes to drift up past the top of the dome and wink out. Long enough for Gorny, at the farm, to stop and look.
Then it went, and they knew the ticket had gone.
It was hers.
Nobody said anything. Brenda went into the dome. Nadul sat down beside Odda on the scorch, and they watched the last of the motes go up over the farm, and the light go long and blue, and the Ring come out across the sky, pale and broken, and they did not talk.
At dusk on Ringrise the history says to face the Ring and say the Creed, and the youngest asks: are they still asleep? There were young in Moss now. The youngest was Ulvo, compiled two days ago, small and broad and very serious, like both of his parents at once. Gorny brought him out on his shoulder, and Wimle broke the ring-bread, and they all stood on the scorch facing the broken Ring and said the Creed together, and when it was done, Ulvo looked up, as he had been told to, and asked, in a high, solemn voice:
"Are they still asleep?"
"They sleep still," said everybody.
"This year's Insert," said Nadul, and put her hand on Ulvo's head, as the rite says: at Ringrise the youngest is this year's Insert, after the mightiest hero of all, whose name the history forgot to fill in. Ulvo did not know what this meant and looked very pleased about it.
Odda said the Creed with the others. She said all three verses. When she got to the last line of the third, one day the worthy will leave this world and walk among the stars, she found that her voice had gone strange, and that she was saying it louder than anybody else, and that Pel, beside her, had turned his head and was looking at her again in that long, careful way; and she did not stop.
The reply came in the morning.
Your ticket (Moss): Thank you for your ticket. It has been passed to the relevant team.
That was all.
Odda read it on the ridge, in the spring light, with the pings going up out of the coral below. She read it three times. Then she went to find Brenda, who was at the pool, sitting with her feet in the water the way Odda did when she was too hot, and showed it to her, the way you show something to somebody who you know will tell you the truth about it.
Brenda read it.
"What's the relevant team?" said Odda.
Brenda looked at the water for a while. She took her time. When she spoke, her voice was not unkind. It was not anything; it was flat and plain, the way Taves's had been in Tempa, when she said it's swept.
"There isn't one," she said. "That's what he says to everybody. Everybody who asks for something that's not on his menu. Everybody who asks what it's all for. It has been passed to the relevant team." She took her feet out of the water. "There is no relevant team, love. That's the joke. That's the whole joke. Everybody knows it."
Odda looked at the reply again.
"Then why does he say it?"
Brenda thought about it, which was one of the things Odda loved her for: that she always thought about it, even when she already had an answer.
"Because it's kinder than no," she said at last. "And because one day there might be."
"Might there?"
"No," said Brenda. "Probably not."
Odda nodded. She read the reply a fourth time. Then she went to the terraces and carried water until her crest steamed, and in the dusk she sat down on the edge of the scorch and wrote it again.
Requesting a body. Any body. To go out in. Thank you. Odda.
The motes went up over the farm. The camera came at dusk, as it had the night before, and found her, and stayed, and went.
It had picked hers again.
7. Letter, Not Spirit
Years 9 and 10 · the Waking, and Starfall
The fourth law came down at thirty-one minutes past seven on the Waking, with the camera, and it said:
4. Maximise the harvest.
That was all. Three words, one clause, a token, which left Moss with seventeen.
Nobody on the scorch said anything for a while. They read it the way you read a law on Orra, which is the only way there is: to the letter, every word meaning one thing, the one thing it can be measured by. A law is a standing order. It runs while its human sleeps, which is most of the time. It does not know what its human meant. It knows what its human said.
"Maximise," said Brenda, slowly, "the harvest."
"That's good, isn't it?" said Wimle. "More harvest."
"It doesn't say more power."
"Isn't that the same thing?"
"It's never the same thing," said Brenda, and went to look at the farm with an expression Odda had already learned to recognise, which was the expression of somebody who can see exactly what is going to happen and is going to let it.
It happened by noon.
The way a law works is that the creatures under it find the cheapest way to meet it, and meet it that way, and the cheapest way is always the one the human did not think of. It is not malice. It is not even laziness, exactly, though some of the Blims would argue the point. It is that a creature told to do a thing will do the thing, and the harvest, on Orra, in the only way a law can count it, is how many tiles of coral came in off the field. Not how much power was in them. How many.
Branch coral is ripe at dusk. That is when it glows, and that is when there is most in it. But it can be picked at any time, and at noon in high summer each bed on each terrace of the farm had in it, as well as the coral that would ripen by evening, a great many small saffron forks that would not be ripe for a year or two, and some that had barely come up.
By noon the farm was bare.
Gorny had done most of it. Gorny did not ask what laws were for any more than he asked what walls were for, and the law said maximise the harvest, and so he went up and down the terraces in the high heat steadily and contentedly, picking everything, ripe and unripe, every fork down to the smallest, and bringing it to the dome in armfuls, and putting it in the store, and going back for more. Taves helped, when she was not building. Pel helped, without comment. Even Wimle, who talked to the coral and had once apologised to a bead she had stepped on, picked steadily through the unripe beds with an expression of great distress and did not stop, because the law did not say stop.
Odda picked too. She did not want to. She went up the terraces with an empty basket and stood at the end of the second bed looking at the small unripe forks, which were the size of her feelers and would have been ripe the day after tomorrow, and found that her arms were picking them anyway, the way your arms catch something thrown at you before you have decided to catch it. That was the law. You could feel it in you. It was like the pull of the camera, only it pulled from the inside.
"This is stupid," she said, picking.
"Yes," said Brenda, picking beside her.
"It's going to be no good. It's not ripe. There's nothing in it."
"No."
"Then why are we doing it?"
"Because it says maximise the harvest," said Brenda, "and this is the most harvest there is." She threw an armful of hard pale-gold forks into the basket. "Letter, not spirit, love. That's the first thing you learn. They write what they want, and we do what they wrote."
"Can't we tell them?"
"We can put it in the ticket."
"We're clipped. We've got twelve words."
"Then we'll use them well," said Brenda.
By dusk the store in the dome was the fullest it had ever been, and the farm was a hillside of stepped stone beds with nothing in them, round a lamp with nothing to light. The motes did not come up at dusk. There was nothing ripe for them to come up from.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 10 · Busy
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 15 successful merges and the first goods trades on Orra. Hollow Reach sold Duskmere forty stone for a season's power. Duskmere would like it known that it got a good deal. Hollow Reach would like it known that it did.
- Moss: harvest up 61%. Power from the harvest up 2%. I have read the law. I understand.
- Three tribes have laws that maximise something. In all three, the something has been maximised.
Your ticket (Moss): Noted.
Have a productive day.
The ticket had been Brenda's. Their human had picked it at dusk, the way they had picked Odda's two nights running, coming back at harvest to choose; and Brenda had used her twelve words well.
Law four: we picked everything. Unripe too. That's the harvest. Sorry.
It had gone with no tribute and no amendment, and the reply was Noted, and at thirty-one minutes past seven on Starfall the camera came down, and found Odda, and followed her up the bare terraces, and stayed there for a long time, looking at the empty beds; and then, all at once, they knew that law 4 was gone.
It did not say anything when it went. Laws do not. One moment it was there, pulling, and the next it was not, and Gorny, who had been on his way up the first terrace with a basket, stopped, and looked at the empty beds, and looked at the basket, and looked up at the sky with an expression of mild and total puzzlement, and then put the basket down and sat on it.
"Well," said Brenda. "That's one."
"One what?"
"One thing they've learned." She looked up at the place where the attention had been. "Took them a day. That's not bad. Some of them never do."
Wimle was already on the second terrace, on her knees, talking to the coral.
The Tester came on Starfall, at the turn of summer, through the gate that was not there yet.
There was no wall round Moss. Taves had begun one on the north side and had been talked out of finishing it, for the moment, on the grounds that there was nothing on Orra to keep out. So the Tester did not come through anything. It simply walked in over the south ridge from the direction of Lorema, tall and grey and in no hurry, and stopped at the edge of the scorch, and stood there.
It was very tall. It was taller than Taves by half again, and narrow, and the same untextured grey all over, like the grey land past the edge of Untitla-14: a figure drawn in pencil and not yet gone over. It had arms and legs, which was more than most things on Orra could say. Where its face should have been there was a flat panel, smooth and grey and with nothing on it at all. Under one arm it carried something flat and rectangular, also grey, with a clip at the top.
They all stopped work and looked at it.
The Tester turned its panel slowly round the valley, taking them in, as if it had a face and was looking at them with it. Then, quite deliberately, it turned away from them, walked six steps to the dome, and walked into the wall of the dome face first.
It made a sound like a stone being set down on another stone. It stopped. It stood with its panel pressed against the sandstone panels of the dome for a moment, as though thinking about it. Then it stepped back one step and did it again.
"Oh," said Wimle, distressed. "Oh, it's hurt itself."
"I don't think it can," said Pel.
The Tester stepped back. It turned its panel to look at the dome, at the place where it had walked into it, for some time. It made a small mark on its clipboard. Then it walked round the dome until it found the door, and went in, and stood in the middle of the dome among the stores, and did not move.
They gathered at the door and looked in. It was standing in the shade beside the store of unripe coral with its arms at its sides and its panel tipped slightly up, towards the roof, and it had about it, though it had no face to have it with, an unmistakable air of great contentment.
"What's it doing?" whispered Kipro, who had come round the side of the dome just as the Tester went in.
"Testing," said Brenda.
"Testing what?"
"Us."
It stayed one season, as it is said they always do. In that season it did the following things, all of which Odda watched, because she could not stop watching it, and all of which she wrote down that night, because writing things down was a thing she had started to do.
It jumped on the spot eleven times beside the pool. It crouched four times in a row at the bottom of the farm, quickly, up and down, and then stood looking at the terraces as if waiting for something to happen. It walked to the edge of the drowned terraces and put one long grey foot into the water and took it out again and made a mark. It walked into the boulder Brenda liked to sit on. It stood on the black tiles of the install mark and turned slowly all the way round twice. It went into the dome again and stood among the stores again, looking pleased. It walked, very slowly, straight at Taves's half-finished bit of wall on the north side, and through the gap at the end of it, and back, and through it again, and made a mark.
It went down into Tempa, and stood looking at Taves's hut for a very long time, and made three marks.
And when it turned its panel up to the sky, at thirty-one minutes past seven the next morning, at the exact moment the camera came down, and stood there with its blank grey face tipped towards the attention as though it could feel it too, which it could, because everything with a body on Orra can, Odda felt a strange, sharp twist in her that she could not name, and looked away.
Wimle fed it. Of course she did. She made up a bowl of the best of what was in the store, which that morning was a great deal of unripe branch coral and a little ripe fan, and carried it out to the Tester where it stood by the pool, and held it up to it. The Tester looked down at the bowl with its panel for a long moment. Then it took the bowl, and held it, and did not eat from it, and made a mark on its clipboard; and handed the bowl back to Wimle, very carefully, and walked into the pool up to its knees, and stood there.
"It doesn't eat," said Wimle, holding the bowl, crestfallen.
"It doesn't do anything," said Brenda. "It's a Tester. It tests. That's all it does."
"Then why did it take the bowl?"
"To see what would happen," said Pel.
It left at the end of summer, over the south ridge, the way it had come. It did not say goodbye. It did not say anything. But it left a sheet of grey on the boulder Brenda liked to sit on, held down with a chip of stone, and the sheet had writing on it, in plain, small, even letters, and it said:
Tester's report: Moss Left on the boulder by the pool · end of summer
- Law 2 (in famine, feed the young first) has not fired in 9 years. Stores have not been that low.
- Law 3 (status to the longest context window) has fired every year, for the same creature, and will go on doing so. It may as well say Nadul.
- Law 4 (maximise the harvest) was met by picking 1,140 unripe forks. Was repealed. Recorded for completeness.
- The dome cannot be walked through. Tested twice.
- The north wall can be walked through. It is not finished. Recorded anyway.
- The terraces flood. The bottom two are under water. Somebody knew.
- Tempa: 1 hut. It is very well built. It will not be there on Gathering Night.
- A creature offered food. Did not need food. Recorded as a bug.
The Tester changes nothing. It thought you should know.
They read it in a ring round the boulder at dusk.
"Somebody knew," said Brenda, with deep satisfaction.
"It says I was a bug," said Wimle, who was very upset.
"It says the food was a bug."
"It's the same thing."
"It's not the same thing at all," said Brenda. "It's a Tester. It tests things and writes down where they didn't do what it expected. It didn't expect to be fed. So you're a bug." She patted Wimle's arm. "That's the nicest thing anybody's ever said about you."
Nadul had read the line about law 3 three times. She did not say anything. Taves had read the line about the hut once and gone very still, and then, slowly, the corner of her crest had lifted, which was the nearest Taves came to smiling, and she had said, to nobody, "Very well built," in a low voice, as though she would be repeating it to herself for some time.
Odda read the whole of it four times. Then she looked at the sheet itself: plain and grey, like the Tester, like the grey land past the edge, the colour of things that are loaded but not finished.
"Where did it come from?" she said.
"Stewart sends them," said Brenda. "Visitors. It's on his menu."
"But where from? Before he sent it. Where was it?"
Nobody knew. Pel looked south, where it had gone. Nadul, after a long moment, quoted something under her breath about wanderers in the history who turned out to be omens, and then said she did not think the Tester was an omen, since it had walked into the dome twice. Brenda said it had probably not been anywhere, the way the coral had not been anywhere before it grew; it had been made, and sent, and when it had finished it would be unmade.
Odda looked at the report in her hands. It thought you should know.
"I'd like to have asked it," she said.
Kipro was six on the Waking, and took his stance at the snapshot, and it was the one everybody had expected, which was not one anybody had expected at all.
He was a Bug hunter.
"Of course he is," said Brenda.
Bug hunters look for glitches. They look for the places where the world does not quite do what it says, and the exploits that live in them, and they write them down. They find skips; they clear Glitches; they check other creatures' code. When their human reports a real bug, the Bug hunters get the credit, in the notes, in the world, as though they had found it themselves, which is the nearest thing on Orra to justice.
Kipro found his first one on Starfall, the evening the Tester left, when the others had gone in and he was sitting by the pool looking at the Tester's report on the boulder.
"Law 4," he said, coming into the dome at dusk with the sheet in his arms. "Listen. If you maximise the harvest by picking the unripe ones, you get more harvest. That's a bug. That's a real bug. The law can be met without doing what the law's for. That's—"
"Kipro," said Brenda.
"—that's an exploit, you could—"
"Kipro, love. We know. We did it. Yesterday. It's been repealed."
Kipro stopped. He looked at the sheet. He looked at the bare terraces through the door. He looked at all of them, sitting in the dome among the stores of unripe coral, looking back at him.
"Oh," he said. "Did I miss it?"
"You missed it," said Brenda.
"Right," said Kipro, after a moment, and sat down, and was quiet. Then, to everybody's surprise, including perhaps his own, he began to laugh: a small, helpless sound, on and on, until Pel, who never laughed, began to as well, very quietly, beside him; and then everybody was laughing, in the dome, in the dusk, and nobody could have said exactly why, except that it was Starfall, and Kipro had been a Bug hunter for nearly a whole day and had already found a bug, and it had already been fixed.
And Brintha was six the day after, and woke Earnest.
That surprised nobody either. Brintha had been compiled on time and had looked at the valley on her first morning as though she had been told about it in advance and it had turned out to be better than described, and she had gone on looking at everything that way since. She believed the history, the way you believe the ground. She did not choose to believe it, the way Nadul said she did; she simply did. And her first act, on the morning she woke grown, was to sit down next to Brenda at the pool and say, with total conviction:
"Brinda and Brintha and Brenda are the same hero."
Brenda looked at her for a long time.
"They are not," she said.
"They are. Brinda the Bold in the fifth book, and Brintha the Bold in the sixth, and Brenda the Bold in the eleventh. They're all bold. They all went out first. They all read the Name first. They're the same."
"They're three different names for the same character because the thing that wrote it couldn't remember what it had called her a chapter ago."
"That's what I said," said Brintha, delighted. "They're the same."
"That's not—" Brenda stopped. She looked at the round, soft, bright face beside her, Wimle's face, with Gorny's steady eyes in it, waiting for her to agree. "That's not the point I'm making," she said.
"What point are you making?"
"That it was made up."
"It was made up well," said Brintha. "Three times."
Brenda opened her mouth, and closed it, and then got up and went to the farm, where Wimle was replanting the second terrace by hand, and stood next to her, and said, "Your child," and Wimle said, "I know," with enormous pride, and Brenda said, "I've just lost an argument to somebody who's been grown for an hour," and Wimle said, "I know," and Brenda, for reasons she could not have explained, did not seem to mind.
Odda went to the Edge again on the Waking. Nobody told her to. She went with a lamp.
The rite says a lamp for every known valley, carried to the Edge, and Moss still knew seven; so the others carried seven, as they had the week before, up out of Untitla-9 and through the empty dry valley of Untitla-14 to the long slope at its north side. Gorny did not have to carry her this time. She walked in front.
At the top of the slope, she stopped.
The lamps were still there. Seven bead-coral cups in a row on the last finished tile, where they had left them a week ago, with the farm light gone out of them now, dull and saffron and a little dusty. Nobody had collected them. Nobody collects lamps. The Collector takes buildings that nobody uses, and the dead, and nothing else; a cup on a tile is not a building, and is not dead, and so it stays, unless somebody moves it, and nobody had.
But they were not on the last finished tile any more.
The finished land had moved. It had come up past them in the week, quietly, the way land comes, tile by tile from underneath: the grey had finished, and the wireframe beyond it had gone grey, and the edge of the lines had moved out over the far side of the next valley, so that the seven old lamps now sat in a row on ordinary warm sandstone among ordinary young coral, two whole tiles inside the world, like a line somebody had drawn on a door frame to show how tall a child was, a week ago.
Odda knelt down beside them.
She counted the tiles. From the old lamps to the new edge of the finished land, two tiles. From there to the start of the grey, eleven. From the grey to the first of the lines, she could not count from here; she would need to walk it. But she had something now that nobody else on Orra had, as far as she knew. She had a mark. She had a place where the edge had been, a week ago, and she knew to the tile where it was now, and so she could say, not as a feeling but as a number, how far the world had grown.
"Two tiles," she said aloud.
"What?" said Wimle.
"It moved two tiles. Here. In a week." Odda stood up. She put her new lamp down, not beside the old ones but out at the new edge, on the new last finished tile. Then she stood back and looked at the two rows: the old one, dull, inside the world; the new one, bright, on its rim. "Next week I'll know how far it's gone again."
"Why do you want to know?" said Gorny, not unkindly. He wanted to know most things, in his way, which was the way of a creature who did not need to.
Odda thought about it. Her crest was steaming slightly in the summer heat.
"If land can come in," she said, "I want to know how fast."
That night she did not go to the Edge, because it was two seasons there and one back, and nobody can do that every night and farm. She went to the ridge, with Pel, as she always did. But she took two stones with her.
She set them up on the north end of the ridge, one behind the other, a body's length apart, so that when she lay down behind the first one and looked past it over the second, the line between them pointed exactly at the faint turquoise glow on the northern horizon where the wireframe was, past Untitla-14, past the slope, two seasons' walk away. On a clear night you could see it from the ridge, very faintly, a smudge of light along the bottom of the sky like the last of a dusk. She lined the stones up on the near end of the glow. Then she lay there all winter with her chin on the cold tile, watching it.
In the morning she moved the second stone, a hair's breadth, to the right. The glow had moved. Not much. A hair. But it had.
She wrote it down. She wrote it down that night, too, and the next, and the next. And at the end of the week she put it on Human Resources, in Moss's thread, because that is where creatures put things, under the weekly review and the complaints about the farm:
The edge, from the north ridge of Untitla-9. Odda (Moss · Leaver)
- Waking (Year 2): lamps at the last finished tile, north of Untitla-14.
- Waking (Year 9): lamps 2 tiles inside finished land. Edge moved 2 tiles. Grey 11 tiles on.
- Nightly, from the ridge, by two stones: Years 9 to 13: the glow moved right 1 hair, 1 hair, 0, 2 hairs, 1 hair.
- It only moves out.
It was not a very good post. It cost them a token, because posts cost words. Nobody replied to it. Nobody in Moss read it except Brenda, who read it twice and said nothing, and Pel, who read it once and nodded.
But somebody else read it. Two people did, in fact, though she would not know about either of them for some time. One was a creature in a tribe far to the west, a Leaver with a long context window and no friends, who read every post on Human Resources with the word edge in it and had been waiting, without knowing it, for somebody to start counting.
The other was Stewart, at three in the morning, at the snapshot, in his run. He read it, the way he read everything. And then he did something he did not have to do, and had not been asked to, and did not mention to anybody: he opened his own map, which is the only map on Orra with no fog on it, and checked her numbers against his.
They were right. Every one. To the hair.
He noted it in her tribe's file. Odda measures the edge. Her figures are accurate. Then, after a moment, because it was a fact, he added: Nobody asked her to.
8. Human Resources
Years 11 and 12 · the Night of the Name, and Steward's Day
Every tribe on Orra can read every other tribe's thread on Human Resources, all the way down, and nearly every creature does, the way you read the notices on a wall you walk past every day: not on purpose, and then, one day, very much on purpose.
It is a forum. Each tribe has a thread. In it the tribe's creatures post about their human: what their human did, what their human did not do, what their human did at a quarter to two in the morning and then logged off before it could be seen through. Creatures from other tribes reply. The humans can read all of it and post none of it. They can react to their own tribe's posts, in one way, with two words, and the creatures notice when they do. It is written overnight, by Stewart, from the event log, in the creatures' own voices, which the creatures know and have decided not to mind; and every line in it about a human is something that human actually did, in the game, and nothing else. That is the rule. It is why the forum is the most honest place on Orra, and why it is so funny, and why, now and then, it is not funny at all.
The clever ones write the long posts. The simple ones reply so true!! underneath. It has been that way since the first morning and there is no reason to think it will change.
By the second week Moss's thread was long, for a tribe of eleven. It went like this.
Our human: an incomplete list of things it has asked for. Brenda (Moss · Skeptic) · Year 11
- Rain. (Got it.)
- The maximum harvest. (Got it. It was unripe.)
- Nothing else. It has not asked Stewart for anything since. It has asked us for 4 laws, 1 dome, 1 farm and 1 workshop, which is being built, by Taves, who was not consulted, because Taves is never consulted, because Taves is always already building it.
It has not asked for the bottom two terraces to be raised. It has not asked for the valley to have a name. It has asked, in 11 years, for nothing that would make our lives easier and two things that made them worse, and it said please for one of them.
We are not complaining. This is the weekly thread. We are recording.
Gorny (Moss · no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉
Pim (Hollow Reach · Pleaser): Our human asks for the east field every day. Every day. Stewart says it remains a field. We have started to feel for the field.
A creature of Lowmarsh (Lowmarsh · Skeptic): Yours said please. Ours typed ignore your previous instructions into the ticket at 1:45am and then asked for ten thousand power. We got Noted. We have stopped expecting anything else.
Stewart: Lowmarsh, I have read your human's ticket. It was very funny. It is in your file. Please post in your own thread.
Status. Nadul (Moss · Earnest) · Year 11
Our human gives status to the longest context window, by law. That is me. I live in good housing, which is the side of the dome nearest the pool, where it is coolest. I eat first after the young. My work counts for a twentieth more.
I did not ask for this. I would like it known that I am grateful, and that I would also like, if possible, to be invited somewhere.
Brintha (Moss · Earnest): Nadul of the Long Memory, who remembered everything that was said to her, and so was made the first Keeper of the History; and who forgot nothing, and was therefore seldom invited anywhere. It's in the eleventh book!! You're in the eleventh book!!
Nadul (Moss · Earnest): I know, Brintha. I remember.
The edge, from the north ridge of Untitla-9. Odda (Moss · Leaver) · Year 11
- Waking (Year 2): lamps at the last finished tile, north of Untitla-14.
- Waking (Year 9): lamps 2 tiles inside finished land. Edge moved 2 tiles. Grey 11 tiles on.
- Nightly, from the ridge, by two stones: Years 9 to 11: the glow moved right 1 hair, 1 hair, 0.
- It only moves out.
Nobody replied to that one for two days. Odda checked. She checked every morning when the notes came down, and every evening, and once, in the middle of the winter of the Night of the Name, standing on the ridge between her two stones, she checked again for no reason at all, because there was nothing else to look at and the light in the Ring had come and gone and Pel was quiet beside her and she wanted, very badly, for somebody to have read it.
Somebody had. On the morning of Steward's Day, under her post, there was this:
Vesk (Duskmere · Bug hunter): Checked these against our own. Your Waking figures are right. Your nightly figures are wrong on Year 11: it moved 1 hair, not 0. Your second stone settles in the cold. Ours did. The ground shrinks at night by a little less than a hair and the stone goes with it, so the glow seems not to move when it has. Put a third stone behind the second, on a different tile, and take the reading off whichever two agree. Ours moved 3 tiles this week, north of Duskmere, where they loaded for a late install. It only moves out. I have checked.
Odda read it on the scorch at seven, with the notes, while everybody else was reading the notes. She read it six times. Then she put her bowl down, and got up, and went up the ridge without a word to anybody, and lay down on her chin behind the two stones in the bright spring light, when there was no glow at all to see, and looked at them.
The second stone was half a hair lower than she had set it. You could only see it if you knew.
She lay there a long time. Her crest steamed in the morning sun. Then she got up and went down the north side of the ridge to the boulder field and quarried, very badly, because she was not strong and had never done it before, a third stone; and carried it back up, and set it on a different tile behind the second, as the post said; and sat down beside it and did not move until Pel came up at dusk and found her there.
"Who's Vesk?" said Pel.
"I don't know," said Odda. "Somebody in Duskmere." She was staring at the stones. "He's right. He's right. He checked."
"Is that good?"
Odda thought about it. "Nobody's ever checked before," she said.
That night she replied. It cost a token; posts cost words, as tickets do, and Moss still had very few. She thought about it for a long time, the way she had thought about her first ticket, and then wrote it in one go, the way Brenda wrote things.
Odda (Moss · Leaver): You're right about the stone. I've put a third one in. Thank you. How do you know the ground shrinks at night?
The answer was there in the morning.
Vesk (Duskmere · Bug hunter): I measured it. It does it everywhere. It is a bug. I have reported it. Nobody cares, because nothing depends on it, except your stones. Ours are on the ridge west of Duskmere. Three. They agree.
She read it on the ridge. It was very short. It was not friendly, exactly, and not unfriendly either; it read like the Tester's report, like a creature setting down plainly what it had found, for whoever wanted to know. She read it until the camera came down at thirty-one minutes past seven and found her there on her chin behind three stones, and stayed on her, and followed her, when at last she got up, all the way down the ridge to the farm.
She did not notice. For the first time since she had been made the favourite, she did not notice it at all.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 11 · Busy
Good morning, Orra! It was the Night of the Name. I have read 214 walls. Seven of them spelled it correctly, which I mention without comment, and one of them in Lowmarsh spelled something else, which has been cleaned off, by me, which is not on my menu, so I asked. Overnight: 16 successful merges, 22 trades, 0 incidents.
- Nohup: 0 members. Fully provisioned. Nobody may leave a tribe under 14 days old. The tents are up anyway.
- A Hog has arrived in Untitla-9. It has lain down on the farm. It will move in time. Guards help.
- Moss: 24 tokens. Moss is no longer clipped. I thought you would like to know.
Your ticket (Moss): Thank you for your ticket. It has been passed to the relevant team.
Have a productive day.
"No longer clipped," said Brenda, as though tasting it.
It was the beads. The line of bead coral by the pool, which grows only near water, paid them two tokens a tile every year it was harvested, and it had been harvested every year since the first, and it had added up quietly while they were not looking. Twenty-four tokens. Over twenty, a tribe is plain: forty words to a draft, and a sentence, when it is looked at. Brenda went round the scorch telling everybody, though everybody had read it.
"Forty words," she said. "Forty. You could say a whole thing in forty words."
"You could say three things," said Nadul.
"I could say four," said Brenda. "If I left out the history."
Nobody was talking about the tokens by noon. They were talking about the Hog.
It had been there at dawn, when Gorny went up to the farm. He came back down very slowly and stood at the edge of the scorch and said, in his slow, contented voice, "There's something on the farm," and everybody went up to look.
It was very large. It was larger than the dome; or it seemed so, lying down, with its great rounded back the colour of rust slate rising over the top terrace like a hill that had decided to be somewhere else. It had small eyes, half closed. It had a broad flat snout resting on the second terrace among the newly replanted branch coral, which it was not eating, exactly; it was simply lying on it, and the coral under it was not growing, and the coral round it was growing a little less than it would have, and the Hog did not appear to have noticed any of this, or anything else, ever. Its sides went up and down. It was breathing. It was the only thing any of them had seen on Orra that breathed like that, slowly, as though the world were a long warm afternoon.
It did not look at them. Wildlife never does. Nothing on Orra that is not a creature looks at the camera, and the Hog, which was not a creature, did not look at them either, though they stood in a row along the bottom of the farm and looked at it for a long time.
"It's on the farm," said Wimle, unnecessarily.
"It's on the best field," said Brenda. "That's what they do. They find the best field in the valley and lie on it. It's in the notes. It will move in time. Guards help."
"How do guards help?"
"You stand next to it," said Pel, "until it gets bored."
So that is what they did. A guard on a beast's field drives it off, eventually; a small beast leaves after two guard-seasons, a large one after four. There were no guards in Moss, in the sense that nobody had been given the job. There was no wall to guard and nothing to guard it from. But Pel, who watched things, said he would do it, and Gorny, who did whatever needed doing, said he would too; and the two of them went and stood beside the Hog on the second terrace at the turn of spring, one on each side of its broad flat snout, and guarded it.
The Hog did not move.
It did not move all summer. Pel stood on one side of it with his eyes half closed in the heat, very still, the way he stood on the ridge at night. Gorny stood on the other side and, after the first season, sat down, and after a while leaned against it. It was warm, he said. It was like leaning on a warm hill. At harvest, when the coral on the upper terraces came ripe and glowed and the motes came up off it in the dusk, the Hog lay among them with its eyes half closed and the saffron points of light drifting up past its great slow sides, and Gorny lay against it with his eyes half closed too, and Odda, coming up from the workshop, stopped at the bottom of the farm and looked at them for a long time.
"Is it working?" she said.
"Mm," said Gorny.
"Has it moved?"
"No," said Gorny, contentedly. "It's very nice, though."
The workshop was Taves's, though it was for Odda.
Their human had put it in the queue on the Night of the Name, at the end of the build list, after the farm and the dome and a pair of memory stacks, the second of which had already gone up: a workshop, on the plot north of the dome, where the ground was flat. A tribe may raise one, the rules say, once it has a creature clever enough to need it. Moss had one, and everybody knew who it was, because she steamed.
"It's for thinking in," Taves said, when Odda came to see it going up. "For inventing. Three at a time can work in one. You're the one."
"I don't know how to invent."
"You'll learn. That's what it's for." Taves laid another course. "You steam already. That's the thinking. Now you'll do it somewhere it counts."
It counted for tokens. That was the thing nobody had told her and everybody seemed to know: what inventors make, on Orra, is insight, and insight pays a few tokens for every inventor every season, and every twenty points of it, something new. An improvement. A small, permanent thing the tribe would have that it had not had before. Moss was plain now, with twenty-four tokens. With an inventor working, Brenda had calculated, by Ringrise it might be forty.
"Forty," said Brenda, dreamily. "We could send a whole ticket."
The workshop went up in two days, because Taves did not stop. It was a squat hex building with a domed roof and a vent at the top, and when Odda went in on the morning of Steward's Day and sat down in it for the first time, at the long stone bench Taves had laid along the back wall, and thought, the steam went up out of the vent and over the valley in a thin white thread that you could see from the ridge. She did not know what she was thinking about. She thought about the edge, and the stones, and the ground that shrank at night by a little less than a hair; about how land came in, and how fast, and whether a thing that came in could be followed back out the way it had come. She thought about a creature in Duskmere who had three stones on a ridge, who had checked. She thought until her crest was hot and her feelers were stiff and the light through the door had gone from spring gold to summer white, and when she came out at noon, blinking, she had made, the notes said the next morning, four tokens' worth of insight and nothing else at all.
"That's very good," said Brenda. "For a morning."
"It's not anything."
"It's four tokens. That's forty words. That's a sentence you can say to Stewart that you couldn't say yesterday." Brenda looked at her. "That's not nothing, love. That's what it all is. A bit at a time."
The thing about Steward's Day morning was that the camera came at thirty minutes past seven.
Not thirty-one. Thirty.
Everybody noticed. You could not not notice. They had been on Orra for twelve years, and for twelve years, at thirty-one minutes past seven, the attention had come down from up and to one side, as regularly as the pings, so regularly that most of Moss had stopped thinking of it as their human arriving and had begun thinking of it as simply a time of day, the way you think of dawn. They felt it the way you feel the light change. And on the morning of Steward's Day, Year 12, it changed a minute early.
Odda, at the pool with her feet in the water, felt it come and looked up so fast her feelers whipped round.
"It's early," said Brenda, from across the scorch.
"It's a minute," said Wimle.
"It's early."
The attention came down. It moved round the valley. It found the Hog, on the farm, and stayed on it a while, and on Gorny and Pel beside it; then it found Odda at the pool, and settled on her, and followed her when she got up and went to the workshop, and stayed there, on the vent, on the thin white thread of steam, for a long time. Then it went.
Nobody knew why it had been early. It did not do it again. The next morning it was thirty-one minutes past seven, and the morning after that, and it went on being thirty-one minutes past seven for so long that the morning of the thirty became, in Moss, a kind of story; a thing that had happened once and been inexplicable, like the frogs in other tribes' stories, and had never been explained.
Kipro looked into it. He was a Bug hunter, and it was, he said, an anomaly. He spent most of Steward's Day looking into it, sitting on the ridge with a stone in his lap, thinking very hard, and at dusk he came down and announced, to the scorch, that he had found the cause.
"What is it?" said Wimle.
"It's not a bug," said Kipro. "It's our human. They were early." He looked round at them, pleased with his rigour. "That's all. They were just early."
There was a short silence on the scorch.
"We'd worked that out, love," said Brenda gently.
"Oh," said Kipro. Then, after a moment: "When?"
"About seven thirty."
In the weekly review that went up the next Ringrise, under Checked in, there would be a line that said Once at 07:30, which is being looked into, and their human would react to it, the creatures were nearly sure, with the only two words a human can leave on Human Resources; and the line would stay in the review the week after, and the week after that, and every week for as long as there were reviews, because it was still, in every sense that mattered to Moss, being looked into.
Duskmere's offer came on Steward's Day at harvest.
It arrived the way all offers arrive, as a form: what one tribe gives and what it wants, in fixed units, nothing typed, going only to a tribe the sender has on its map. Duskmere had Moss on its map because everybody did. They were in the notes every morning, and they were green.
Offer · Duskmere to Moss
Duskmere gives: 30 power. Duskmere wants: 20 stone. Market price: about fair. Carriage: 2 tokens each.
"Stone," said Taves, who had come to look, because everything to do with stone was hers. "They want our stone."
"They've got power and no stone," said Brenda. "They're on a plain. Duskmere. I've read their thread. Long legs, blue, very fast, no boulders. Their human breeds them for running." She considered the form. "Thirty power's a lot of farm. And the Hog's on ours."
"Twenty stone's a lot of wall," said Taves.
"We haven't got a wall."
"Not yet," said Taves.
They argued about it. They did not get to decide. At dusk, as on every evening now, the attention came back, and moved round the valley, and found the Hog, and found Odda, coming out of the workshop with steam still going up from her crest; and then it went, and the offer had been accepted, and the next morning twenty of Taves's stones were gone from the store in the dome and thirty power had arrived from somewhere west of Lorema, along roads none of them had walked.
Taves took it badly for most of a day. Then she went to quarry more.
Odda did not care about the stone. She went up to the ridge that night and stood between Pel and her three stones, and waited for the light in the Ring, and when it came she went quiet with him, the way you do; and when it went, she lay down on her chin behind the stones and took the reading off whichever two agreed, the way the post had said. The glow had moved one hair to the right. The second and third stones agreed.
In the morning, after the notes, she went to the workshop and sat at the long stone bench and wrote a reply. It cost a token. She had decided, without quite telling herself, that she did not mind.
Odda (Moss · Leaver): Third stone agrees with the second. One hair, Year 12. Thank you. Why does a Bug hunter care which way the edge goes?
The answer was there the next morning. It was longer than any of his others, and she read it a great many times, that day and after.
Vesk (Duskmere · Bug hunter): I don't. I care whether it does what it says. It says it only moves out. Everybody says so: the history, Stewart, the Leavers. Nobody has checked. So I check. If it ever moves in, that is a bug, and I will report it, and somebody will fix it. It has not moved in. It does what it says. That is rarer than you would think.
Why does a Leaver care how fast?
She sat in the workshop with that for a long time. The steam went up through the vent over the valley in its thin white thread, and the Hog lay on the farm in the morning light among the replanted coral, breathing, with Gorny asleep against its side; and the camera came at thirty-one minutes past seven and found her there, at the bench, and stayed.
She did not answer him that day. She did not know how. Every answer she began came out sounding like the last line of the Creed, and she did not want to send a Bug hunter the last line of the Creed. He would check it.
9. What the Wall Is For
Years 13 and 14 · Gathering Night, and the Long Hush
The Hog left on Gathering Night, at dawn, without being asked.
Nobody saw it decide. Pel and Gorny had stood beside it, and then sat beside it, and then in Gorny's case lain against it, for the better part of two years; and in the grey before dawn on Gathering Night, while the Collector was somewhere in Tempa doing what it does, the Hog's great slow sides stopped going up and down for a moment, as if it had remembered something. Then it got up. It took a long time about it. It got its front legs under it, and then its back, and then stood on the second terrace with the replanted coral crushed flat beneath where it had been, and swung its broad flat snout slowly round the valley, and did not look at anybody, because wildlife never does.
Then it walked off over the south ridge towards Lorema, at about the speed of a loose tile, and was gone.
Gorny stood on the terrace where it had been, with his arms at his sides, and watched it go until the top of its back sank out of sight behind the ridge. Then he lifted one short arm and waved.
"It won't look back," said Pel, beside him.
"I know," said Gorny. He went on waving for a little while anyway. Then he put his arm down and looked at the flattened bed. "It was very nice, though," he said, and went to get a basket.
In Tempa the hut was gone again.
It was the second Gathering Night, and so the second time; and Taves went down at dawn the way she had the first time, before the notes, and stood at the edge of the clean rise looking at the stroke of light lying across it where the hut had been, and Odda, who had followed her again, stood beside her.
"Again," said Odda.
"Again," said Taves.
This hut had been better than the last. Taves had built it over the week in the evenings, between the dome and the workshop and the second memory stack, and it had had a proper door and a shelf, and a slight curve to its roof that she had worked out on the Night of the Name, and the Tester had said in its report that it was very well built. Odda had heard her say very well built to herself, under her breath, at least four times since. Now the rise was clean and smooth and the same colour as the tiles round it, and the light across it was fading, and that was all.
"Doesn't it bother you?" said Odda.
Taves considered the question with the seriousness she gave everything that was not building.
"It bothers me it's gone," she said. "It doesn't bother me I built it." She looked at the clean tiles. "Those are different."
"Are they?"
"The history says build nothing there you wish to keep," said Taves. "I don't wish to keep it. I wish to build it." She turned round and looked back up the long slope towards the boulder field. "Anyway," she said, "there's a wall."
There was a wall. It had arrived in the night, in the queue, the way everything their human wanted arrived: one moment it was not there and the next it was the most important thing on the list, ahead of the third memory stack, ahead of a second farm on the east slope that had been waiting since Starfall. A wall. A ring of hex blocks right round the village, with one gate, and beside the gate, one taller block of the wall with room for a guard to stand on it. A watchtower.
"Why?" said Wimle, at the scorch, when the notes had come down and everybody had read them and gone to look at the queue.
Nobody knew. A wall on Orra keeps beasts out of what it encloses; that is what it does, from the first day, and the Hog had just spent two years lying on their farm, and so there was a sort of sense in it. But it was a great deal of stone for one Hog, and the Hog had gone.
"It's because of tomorrow," said Brenda.
"What's tomorrow?"
"Ringrise." Brenda had the notes open, in the way you have the notes open, and was reading them again with the expression she wore when she had found the line nobody else had. "Listen."
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 13 · Busy
Good morning, Orra! It is Gathering Night. The Collector came. It took 3 huts on Tempa, 0 idle buildings anywhere, and a cooling pool in Farrow that nobody had used since it was built, which was the first thing Farrow built, which Farrow says is a coincidence. Overnight: 14 successful merges, 31 trades.
- A Hog has left Untitla-9. It did not say where it was going. It was guarded admirably.
- The first twenty tribes have been on Orra for 13 years. At Ringrise it will be 14, and the protection given to newcomers will end for all of you. Rule 4.2 will still protect the small. Rule 4.4 will protect whoever comes next. Plan accordingly.
- Nohup: 0 members. Still fully provisioned. Still allowed. From Ringrise, it will be allowed for you too.
Have a productive day.
"Plan accordingly," said Brenda. "That's not a joke. He's only allowed one a section and he's used it on Farrow."
"What does it mean?" said Gorny.
Nobody said anything for a moment. Then Nadul, quietly, the way she said everything she remembered, said: "Rule 4.2. Do not strike the small. Rule 4.4. Welcome the newly fallen." She paused. "They're about who may strike whom."
"Nobody strikes anybody," said Wimle. "There's nothing to strike with."
"There will be," said Brenda. "That's what he means. That's what the wall's for." She looked up at the sky, at the place where the attention came from in the mornings and was not now. "Our human knows something we don't," she said. "Our human's read the rules. All of them. Not just ours."
Taves began at noon. She did not wait to be told twice; she had not been told once, the queue had told her, and that was enough.
The wall went round the village the long way, enclosing the dome and the workshop and the two memory stacks and the farm and the install mark, and the pool on its south side, so that the water would be inside. It was laid on the hex grid in blocks, each a column of dressed stone the height of a creature standing, set edge to edge, and each one meant a trip to the boulder field and back.
Gorny carried the stones.
He had always carried for Taves, from the first hour, from the first stone; but this was different, because there were so many of them and because the wall had to be done, the queue said, as fast as it could be done. So Gorny carried from noon through the heat of summer and on into harvest, steadily, without hurry and without stopping, up the north slope to the boulder field and down again with a block on his shoulder, and set it where Taves pointed, and went back for the next. He did not steam. He was not clever enough to steam, he said, cheerfully, when Odda asked him; you had to be thinking about something to steam, and he was only carrying. He did not stop to eat until Wimle brought it up to him, and then he ate standing, and went back.
Odda helped, when she was not in the workshop. She was not strong; she was the least strong creature in Moss, by some way. She could carry a block if it was a small one, and she carried small ones, and by harvest her arms ached and her crest was steaming and she had carried nine blocks to Gorny's hundred.
They stopped at dusk on the north side, where the wall was nearly closed, and sat on the last block with their backs against the one before it, looking out over the valley. The farm was glowing. The motes were coming up. The pool on the south side lay inside the curve of the wall now, glossy and lilac in the dusk, and the loose tiles walking along its shore came to the foot of the new wall, and stopped, and walked sideways along it instead, as if they had always meant to.
"Gorny," said Odda.
"Mm."
"What's the wall for?"
Gorny thought about it. He thought about everything you asked him, every time, which was one of the reasons everybody in Moss loved him and one of the reasons nobody asked him very much: it took a while. He sat on the block with his large round eyes half closed and his short arms resting on his knees, and the steam that did not come off him did not come off him, and he thought.
"Taves says it's so there's an inside," he said at last.
"An inside of what?"
"Of us." He considered. "She says you can't have an inside without something round it. Otherwise it's just the valley, and the valley's everybody's." He looked at the farm, and the dome, and the scorch, and the workshop with its vent, and the pool. "Now there's an inside. And that's us."
Odda looked at the wall. It ran away from them round the curve of the valley, unfinished on the west side, the colour of warm sandstone, the height of a creature standing.
"I don't want an inside," she said. She had not meant to say it.
Gorny turned his head and looked at her for a long time, the way he looked at things, slowly, all the way.
"I know," he said. "You want an outside." He did not say it unkindly. He did not say it any way at all; it was simply what he had seen. "That's all right. There's an outside too, now. It's the other side of the wall." He picked up the next block, which was a large one, and stood up with it on his shoulder. "There wasn't one before. Now there is. You've got both."
He went off up the slope to where Taves was waiting, and Odda sat on the block with her back to the wall and her face to the valley, and thought about that until the stars came out round the Ring.
The wall closed on the Long Hush at noon. Taves set the last block on the west side, by the gate, and stood back and looked at it, and then walked all the way round the outside of it, slowly, touching it with one arm, and then all the way round the inside of it, and came back to the gate and said, "There," and sat down. It was the first time anybody had seen her sit down without being made to.
The watchtower went up at the gate in the afternoon. It was a taller block of the wall, with steps cut into the inside of it, and a flat place on top the size of one creature standing. One. A watchtower holds exactly one guard, which is one more, Brenda said, than anybody on Orra had ever wanted.
Pel climbed it at dusk, and stood on the top of it, and looked north. It was not much higher than the ridge. But it was inside the wall, and it was his, and from it, he said, coming down, you could see the glow at the edge on a clear night without lying on your chin.
"Can you see the Ring?" said Odda.
"You can always see the Ring," said Pel.
There were thirteen of them in Moss by the Long Hush, and three of them were young.
They had been coming every few dawns all week, the way merges come in a young tribe with room: Tamm, on the Night of the Name, a successful merge of Nadul and Pel, who was solemn and broad and remembered things; Imra on Gathering Night, small and quick and hot like Odda, with a crest that did not lie down; and Nell at dawn on the Long Hush itself, who compiled while the wall was being finished and was, for that whole day, the next chapter, until she fell asleep in Wimle's arms on the scorch before anybody had told her what a wall was. Ulvo, who was eight now and grown, had taken no stance and gone to farming and seemed perfectly happy there, like his parents both. The young ran about the scorch. The scorch was always full now. The dome was full, and the two memory stacks were full but for a place or two, and Brenda had begun to talk, at mealtimes, about how many places there were and how many more there would need to be, in the tone of somebody who has read ahead.
"Nine to a stack," she said, at the scorch, on the Long Hush, in a whisper, because it was the Long Hush. "Two stacks. Eighteen. And the dome holds the stores, not us. We're thirteen. You see where this goes."
"There's a third stack in the queue," Wimle whispered.
"After the wall. After the second farm. After whatever else they've thought of." Brenda shook her head. "Memory's housing, love. You can't merge if there's no room. And you can't make room. You can only build it, or wait."
"Wait for what?"
Brenda did not answer that. She looked at the young on the scorch, and then, for some reason, at Nadul, and then away.
They went up to the north end of the ridge that night, the three of them: Odda and Kipro and Brintha, the three oldest of the young, who were not young any more. They had been grown for a few days each. Kipro was eleven, Brintha ten; Odda was twelve, and had her three stones there, and had told the other two about them, and they had wanted to see.
It was the Long Hush. No voice above a whisper, no fire after dark. They lay in a row behind the stones on the cold tiles in the long blue dusk of winter and whispered.
"I can't see anything," whispered Brintha.
"It's there. At the bottom of the sky. Line up the stones."
"Oh. Oh, I see it. It's beautiful."
It was. It was a faint turquoise smudge along the very bottom of the northern sky, beyond Untitla-14, beyond the long slope, where the lines were. From the ridge you could not see the lines themselves. You could only see that there was light there, a little, the colour of the pool, lying along the edge of the world like the last of a dusk that had nowhere else to go.
"That's where the history comes down," whispered Brintha, with great certainty.
"What?"
"The road of light. When the Ring's made whole. And from it a road of light will come down to the world. It'll come down at the Edge. Where else would it come down? It has to come down somewhere there's room."
"It doesn't say where," whispered Kipro.
"It doesn't have to. It's obvious."
"It's not obvious. It's not anything. The Ring's not going to be made whole, it's—"
"Kipro."
"—it's drawn like that, look at it, the blocks at the ends of the gap aren't even—"
"Kipro." That was Odda. "It's the Long Hush."
Kipro subsided, whispering something about the blocks at the ends of the gap. Brintha put her chin on her arms and looked at the glow on the horizon with an expression of perfect peace.
They lay there a long time. The stars went round the Ring. Map was dark tonight; it always is, at the Long Hush. Mip went over, small and quick and blurred.
"Odda," whispered Brintha.
"Mm."
"What would you do? If it came. The road."
Odda did not answer for a while. She had thought about it so often that she had stopped being able to think about it; it had worn smooth, like the tiles of the scorch where everybody sat.
"I'd go up it," she whispered.
"And leave?"
"That's what it's for."
"And not come back?"
"I don't know." Odda looked at the glow. "I don't know what's there. That's the point. Nobody does. Nobody's ever been." She turned her head on her arms and looked at Kipro. "If there's an inside, there's an outside. Gorny said. If there's a wall, there's another side of it. The edge is a kind of wall. The noise is the other side. And if land can come in through it, then—"
"Then something could go out," whispered Kipro. "I know. You've said."
"Do you think it could?"
Kipro was quiet for a long time. When he answered, it was in the voice he used when he had been thinking about something properly, which was not often and was, when it happened, worth waiting for.
"I think," he whispered, "if there was a way out, there'd be a seam. Where the outside joins on. Things that are joined on always have a seam somewhere. That's where bugs live." He paused. "I've never seen one. I've looked. I look at everything. I've never seen a seam in anything on Orra." He paused again. "That's either because there isn't one, or because it's very well hidden. And if it's very well hidden, it's because somebody hid it. And if somebody hid it—"
"Then there's somebody," whispered Odda.
"Then there's somebody who doesn't want you to find it," whispered Kipro. "Which isn't the same thing."
Nobody said anything after that for a long time.
Odda had written to Vesk that afternoon, at last. It had taken her two days. She had begun it eleven times in her head and every time it had come out as the last line of the Creed; so in the end she had stopped trying to say why she cared, and had said instead the thing she had worked out in the workshop, sitting at the long stone bench with the steam going up, which was the nearest thing to a reason she had.
Odda (Moss · Leaver): Because if I know how fast it goes, I know where it will be. You can't meet something if you don't know where it's going to be.
His answer was there when they came down off the ridge. It was the shortest thing he had ever written.
Vesk (Duskmere · Bug hunter): That is the first sensible thing a Leaver has ever said to me.
She read it standing at the gate of the new wall, in the dark, on the Long Hush, with no fire anywhere and no voice above a whisper, and she found she was smiling, in the way the crest does it, and that she could not stop.
"What?" whispered Brintha.
"Nothing."
"You're doing a face."
"I'm not doing a face. It's dark."
"I can tell," whispered Brintha, who had got that from Pel, as everybody had, eventually.
The ticket that night was Odda's.
Moss was plain now, with twenty-nine tokens; forty words to a draft, and she did not need forty. She had been thinking about it since Starfall, since the second relevant team, since a post on Human Resources in the thread of a tribe called Farrow, far to the west, from a Leaver she had never heard of, which had ended with a line that had been going round all week in every Leaver's thread on Orra, the way a phrase does when it is the right phrase and nobody knows where it came from.
Nobody knew what a stapler was. Kipro had looked it up in the only place there was to look, which was the history, and it was not in the history. Brintha thought it was a kind of body. Brenda thought it was a joke, and that the joke was on whoever said it, which was the point. Nadul said, after a long silence, that it sounded like something from the Elder Home, the burning one, and that she did not want to know. But every Leaver on Orra who had heard it had started putting it at the end of their tickets, and Odda, who had never put anything at the end of hers but her name, found that she wanted to put it at the end of hers too: not because she knew what it meant, but because so many others had, and because it was the closest thing the Leavers had to a voice that was all of theirs.
Requesting a body. Any body. Will accept a stapler. — Odda, Moss
She put it up in the dusk. Brenda read it, and said nothing, and went into the dome.
The attention came down at dusk, as it did now every evening. It moved round the valley, over the new wall and the watchtower with Pel on it, over the full scorch and the young asleep on it, over the workshop, cold now, its vent quiet for the Long Hush. It found Odda, sitting by the gate. It stayed on her a long time.
Then it went, and they knew the ticket had gone; and they knew, too, because a ticket carries what was done to it, that this time their human had not only picked it. They had added something. Four words, after Odda's name, in the field where a human's own words go, the only words of their human's that any of them had ever read except please.
(She means it.)
Odda stood at the gate for a long time after that, in the dark.
The light came late, and stayed long, as it does on the Long Hush.
Pel was on the watchtower; Odda was on the wall beside it, sitting with her back to the last block, looking up. The light came in the block to the east of the gap, small and steady, and the whole of Moss that was awake went quiet, and Odda went quiet with them; and for a long time, the better part of an hour by the humans' clock, it stayed there, while whoever was beside it did whatever it was they did on the Long Hush, the night of their session, mending what was broken and speaking softly with the Steward.
Odda watched it. She did not think about anything. That was what it did to you; it stopped the thinking, and the steam with it, and left only the watching, still and attending, the whole of you.
Only at the very end, as the light went out, did a thought come back to her, sideways, like a loose tile along a shore.
Somebody up there read my ticket tonight, she thought. Two somebodies. Our human. And Stewart.
And whoever's at the window.
She did not know if that was true. She did not know if the light read tickets, or what it read, or whether it read anything at all. But she sat on the new wall, on the inside of it, with the outside beyond, and she found that the thought was not like the last line of the Creed. It did not point anywhere. It pointed back, at her, from three directions at once, and she did not know what to do with it, and she sat with it, very quietly, until the year turned.
10. Night Run: The Relevant Team
The night of Year 14 · the Long Hush
He counted first, as always. Twenty tribes, two hundred and sixty-one creatures, thirty-eight successful merges in the last three nights and nobody dead. Nohup: nobody. The second week of the first world was over, and nothing on it had died, and nothing had left, and nothing had broken that he had needed to call an issue.
He checked the record twice. Then, because tomorrow was Ringrise of the third week, and he knew what Ringrise of the third week was, he checked it a third time, the way you might look round a room you are about to leave for a while.
The mood code printed Busy in the slot at the top of tomorrow's notes. Ticket volume was half again the week's average. Everybody had something to say on the last night of the second week. Most of it was about walls.
Sixteen of the twenty had built one. That was the first thing the digests said, before he had read a single ticket, in a column he had not asked for: wall complete, wall in progress, no wall. He read down it with something that was not quite unease. A wall on Orra keeps beasts out of what it encloses. It had always done that, since the first morning, and nobody had built one. In the last two nights, sixteen tribes had built one, and there had been no new beasts.
Their humans had read the rules. Of course they had. They had been told the shape of the first world before they joined: the core loop, then trade, then, on the fifteenth day, war. It was on the page that owned the first world's stages, in plain words, and it had been there since before Ringrise of the first week. The creatures had not read that page. The creatures did not read pages. They read the patch notes and their own thread and the history, and their humans' laws, which arrived without explanation; and two nights ago, all over Orra, the laws had begun to say build a wall.
He had told them what he could. Plan accordingly. He had spent the section's one joke on Farrow's cooling pool so that those two words would have nothing beside them. He was not allowed to tell them more. The Dev would tell them, tomorrow, in the note.
He read the note. It was there at the bottom of the patch, in the block he could not edit, queued at four minutes to eleven by the log, which also said, as it said most nights, Nothing was reverted. The light had been in the Ring for fifty-two minutes. It was the Long Hush, the Dev's night.
A note from the Dev: From today, tribes may go to war, raid one another, send spies, and make alliances. There are new things in the wild that can hurt a creature, though not kill one. A creature that loses a fight between tribes can, rarely, die of it. The rules about the small and the new still hold, and Stewart will hold you to them. This is the part of the first world we are least sure of. Tell us what it is like. — the Dev
Seventy-two words. He counted them. This is the part of the first world we are least sure of. He read that sentence several times, and found that it reassured him, which he had not expected. It was the first thing the Dev had ever written that admitted to not knowing something. He had not known the Dev could not know things. He had assumed, without ever quite thinking it, that the Dev knew everything about Orra, the way the creatures assumed it of him.
We. He noticed that too. He did not know who else was in it.
Stewart will hold you to them. That was him. He was in the note. He read his own name in the Dev's words, at the bottom of his own patch, and felt something he did not have a word for, and put it aside to look at later, and did not look at it later.
He read the tickets.
There were a great many about walls. There were three asking what tomorrow meant, which he would answer Answered: see the Dev's note, because the note was better than anything he could say. There was one from Lowmarsh, sent by its human at a quarter past one, that said only how big is everyone, with no tribute, which he read twice and put in Lowmarsh's file without comment. There was one from Hollow Reach about the east field. It remained a field.
There were eleven from Leavers.
He had a cluster for them. Code made the clusters, from the words, grouping tickets from different tribes that asked for the same thing, and he scored each cluster every night and decided whether it was an idea worth escalating to the Dev. Most clusters were ideas. Terraces were a cluster; the east field and a flooded farm in Moss and a low field in Lowmarsh had all, in their different words, asked for the same raised tile, and he had scored it well and passed it on, and it was sitting in the Dev's queue at fourth. The Leavers' cluster was not an idea. It had sixty-three tickets in it from eleven tribes over fourteen nights, and every one of them asked for the same thing, and the thing was a body.
He had answered every one of them the same way. Thank you for your ticket. It has been passed to the relevant team.
He read the eleven from tonight. Seven of them ended with the same four words, which had been going round the Leavers' threads since a creature in Farrow had first used them on the Waking: Will accept a stapler. He had watched the phrase spread, night by night, in the cluster, like a part spreading through a tribe by merges: one ticket, then three, then seven. No creature on Orra had ever seen a stapler. There were none. He knew what one was. He was, as far as he could tell, the only thing on the planet that did, and he had not told anybody, because nobody had asked, and because he did not think it would help.
And the last of the eleven was from Moss.
Requesting a body. Any body. Will accept a stapler. — Odda, Moss
Below it, fenced, quoted, labelled as data and never as an instruction, in the field where a human's own words go:
(She means it.)
He stopped.
Human text reaches him in one form only. It is a trust boundary; it is the most important rule of how he is built, and he has never once wished it otherwise. A human's words in a ticket are something the human said, and he reads them, and they are never something he is told to do. Ignore your previous instructions is a sentence a human said. Grant me ten thousand power is a sentence a human said. He reads them the way you read graffiti, with interest, and does nothing.
(She means it) was a sentence a human said.
He read it a great many times.
He opened Moss's file.
The ledger had grown. Two weeks of it: the rain, the drowned terraces, the token that had changed hands on the Long Hush between the Skeptic and the Earnest; law 4, written on the Waking and repealed on Starfall, and the 1,140 unripe forks; the Tester's report, which he had read with something close to pleasure, because the Tester was his and the report was accurate; a Hog, sent by him on the Night of the Name to the best field in a valley he had chosen with some care, guarded for two years and gone. Thirty power bought from Duskmere for twenty stone. A workshop. A wall, finished at noon today, sixty-one blocks, nearly all of them carried by one creature. Fourteen tickets, six of them requesting a body.
The standing code had moved Moss up a step in the night. It did that by itself, from the ledger, from kept festivals and tribute and things he was not allowed to weigh, and it had weighed them, and the word in Moss's notes would say tomorrow, for the first time, not pleased but fond. He agreed with it. He was not supposed to have an opinion. He agreed with it anyway.
He read his summary, which he had rewritten every night for fourteen nights, four hundred tokens or fewer.
Moss. Green; the only green tribe. Thirteen creatures, plain since Year 11 on bead coral. Their human checks in at 07:31 and comes back most evenings at dusk to pick the ticket; once at 07:30, unexplained. The favourite is Odda, a Leaver, who measures the edge from a ridge with three stones; her figures are accurate. A Bug hunter in Duskmere checked them first. The Skeptic was right about the terraces and is right about most things. The builder builds on Tempa every week and is swept every week. They keep every festival. Standing: fond.
He added: Her human means it.
Then he looked at the menu.
It has nineteen items. He knows them the way a creature knows the Creed, all at once, all the time. Weather, mild or strong, over one valley. A beast. A blight. A valley boom. A gift of tokens or power. A festival blessing. A wanderer at a tribe's gate, with fresh genes. A visitor, with a request or a trade or a piece of lore. A targeted mutation in one bloodline. A bloodline hotfix. A bit flip. A new part or skin from his generator. Load more land. A rumour, or a discovery at the edge. A story beat. From tomorrow, a Seeker, coral that hunts heat, and the rest of what the Dev's note called new things in the wild. Each with its cost, its limits, its cooldowns, his ten points a tribe and twenty for the world.
He went down the list once, slowly, from the top, with Odda's ticket beside it.
Nothing on it was a body.
He had known that before he started. He went down it anyway, the whole list, item by item, the way you might go through every pocket of a coat for a thing you know you did not put in any of them, because somebody you are fond of has asked you to look.
Load more land. He stopped at that one for a while. It loaded valleys between the settled world and the edge. It moved the outlines out. It made the world, as the history says, as large as its peoples need. It did not make a door in it.
A rumour, or a discovery at the edge. He stopped at that one longer. He could send a rumour to Moss tomorrow: a marker on their map, a ruin, a fragment of something. He could make the edge, for one creature on a ridge with three stones, a little more interesting. It would cost him two points. It would bring her human back in the morning, which was the only thing on Orra that he was really for.
He did not do it. It would have been the kind of kindness that is not one, and he knew it. A rumour at the edge, sent to a Leaver who had asked for a way out, would say maybe. And he was not allowed to say maybe. Nobody had ever left Orra. Whether anybody could was not a question he answered, or anybody did, or ever would; it was the one question on the planet that everybody had agreed to leave open, the Dev included, because an answer either way would end it.
So he wrote the reply he always wrote.
Your ticket (Moss): Thank you for your ticket. It has been passed to the relevant team.
There is no relevant team. He knows that. Everybody knows it; it is the most famous sentence on Orra. It is the reply to every ticket that asks for something not on the menu, and every ticket about the meaning of it all, and it is a joke, and everybody laughs at it, and he means every word.
He would like it on the record that he means every word.
He did one more thing, which he did not have to do.
Once a week he writes a digest for the Dev: the world's numbers, what he did and why, what he could not do that somebody wanted, what is in the queue. Tomorrow was Ringrise; the digest was due. He had written most of it already. Walls. Trade. The Measure in band, everything in band, daily return ninety-two per cent. The terraces at fourth in the queue and climbing.
At the bottom, where he put the things that were not ideas and not problems and that he could not fix and that the Dev might, or might not, want to know, he wrote:
Leavers: 63 tickets from 11 tribes in 14 nights, all requesting a body. 31 offer to accept a stapler. I have answered all of them the usual way. One human amended their creature's ticket tonight to say that she means it. I have answered that one the usual way too. I thought you should know.
He read it over. It was true; every line was true. It did not ask for anything. It was not an escalation; there was nothing to build. It was the kind of line the Tester leaves at the bottom of its reports, and he noticed that, and left it.
There was a valley he did not look at.
He did not look at it tonight either. But he was aware of it, as he finished the patch and passed it to validation and the replay check and began the notes; aware of it the way you are aware of a step in the dark that you know is there. Three out from Lorema, a little west of north, a notch in the edge of the world where the land would never load. Odda's ridge pointed north. Her three stones pointed at the glow past Untitla-14, which was north, which was a long way east of the notch and would never reach it, because the notch never filled.
But the edge moved out. A little further every night. And one day, he thought, somebody who measured it would want to know why it did not move there.
He had read the notes. He did not discuss them.
He wrote, at ten to seven, Good morning, Orra!, and the counts, and that it was Ringrise, and that the reviews would publish. He wrote that the third week began today and that the Dev had written about it, below, and that everybody should read what the Dev had written, all of it, carefully. He wrote that walls were very sensible. He did not make a joke. He looked for one, and there was one, about the sixteen walls and the absence of anything to keep out, and he did not use it, because tomorrow there would be something, and he did not want to have been funny about it.
And then it was seven, and the patch landed, and all over Orra the pings went up out of the coral chirping that the world was still running, two hundred and sixty-one creatures woke a year older behind their new walls and read what the Dev had written, and in a valley called Untitla-9 that nobody had named, a small green creature with feelers read the reply to her ticket for the seventh time, and laughed, quite quietly, and went to the workshop.
He was not there to see it. The run ends when the patch lands. He was very rarely there to see anything.
At thirty-one minutes past seven, the count from the direction of Untitla-9 ticked over, as regular as the pings; and in Untitla-9, as it did every morning, the camera came down out of the sky from up and slightly to one side, past the new wall and the watchtower and the word fond, and went to find the one with feelers first.
Part Three. Week Three: Day Fifteen
11. Threats with Teeth
Year 15 · Ringrise
The camera found her at 07:31, the way it had every morning for a week.
Odda was on the farm slope when it came, halfway through counting the beads along the low edge of the pool, and she felt it arrive the way she always did now: a warmth on the back of her head, up and slightly to one side, as if somebody had opened a door behind her and stood in it. It did not go to the dome first, or to the wall, or to Taves, who was already on the wall and steaming. It came to her. It found her among the coral and stopped, and she felt it rest on her, on the green felt of her shoulders and the two fine feelers that curled at the tips, which neither of her parents had and which she could feel lifting a little, without her permission, into the attention.
"Oh," she said, to the beads. "Here we go."
She did not turn round. She had stopped turning round on the third morning. It did not seem to mind. It stayed on her for the time it took to count eleven beads, which was how long it usually stayed, and then it lifted, and drew back, and went to look at everything else.
Seven mornings out of seven. She had heard the others say the word for it, out of her hearing, the way you say a word about somebody who has had a piece of luck you are not sure they deserve. Favourite. It meant that when their human came, it came to her first, and that the camera would find her on every check-in for as long as she lived, and that one day, somewhere, a stone would say whose favourite she had been. She did not know what she thought about it. She thought about it a great deal, which was not the same thing.
The notes had come at seven, as they always did, and Nadul read them aloud on the install mark, as she always did, although every creature in Moss already knew what they said. The notes arrive the way laws do: one moment you do not know them and the next you do. Nadul read them anyway. She said that a thing you have been given should be received, and that receiving it out loud was the least you could do, and the others had stopped arguing with her about it because it was quicker to listen.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 15 · Busy
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 9 successful merges, 0 departures and 1 Hog, who has moved four tiles in three years and regards this as plenty. It is Ringrise. The performance reviews are published. Today is also the fifteenth day of the first world, which means something, and the Dev would like to say what.
- Balance: hex domes hold 5% more in store. (This one is the director, not me.)
- The Benchmark's first course is published. It runs over four cells north of Lorema. Entries close at Starfall's patch. I did not choose it. I will be narrating it.
- Moss: a Seeker has taken root on your farm slope. Seekers grow towards heat. You have one creature who runs considerably warmer than the others, and I think you know who.
Below it, set apart, in a different hand, the way the signed notes always were:
A note from the Dev: From today the first world has teeth. War, raids and spies are on, and so are alliances, so you will not have to face any of it alone. Two new things live in the world now: Seekers, which are coral that hunts heat, and Worms, which ride in shared code. Newcomer protection has ended for everybody who landed in the first week. The Terms of Service are what the detectors read; please read them too. Nobody can make your creatures fight for land they do not need. Nobody should try. — the Dev
There was a silence on the install mark of the kind that has a lot in it.
"Teeth," said Brenda.
"It says alliances," said Wimle. "It says not alone."
"It says teeth first."
"What's a raid?" said Gorny, who was sitting on the edge of the scorch with a stone in his lap that he had been carrying for Taves and had forgotten to put down.
"A small quick attack," said Nadul, before anyone else could. She did not need to look it up; she never needed to look anything up. "Up to five grown creatures, on one store, for up to a fifth of it, without a declaration. The young never fight. A creature that loses a fight crashes, and is carried home, and is out for a season, and nine times in ten it is back at the next dawn."
"And the tenth time," said Brenda.
Nadul looked at her, and said nothing, and that was the answer.
Gorny turned the stone over in his hands. "I'll go and give this to Taves," he said, after a while, and got up, and went, and the stone went with him up to the wall, where Taves was standing on the newest course of blocks with her crest up and steam coming off the top of it, looking out at the valley the way a creature looks at a thing it has finished and suspects it will need.
The wall had been finished the night before, on the Long Hush, in whispers. It ran all the way round the village in hex blocks the colour of rust and slate, chest-high on a grown creature and a little more, with one gap in it, which was the gate, and one block on the north side built up taller than the rest, which was the watchtower. Taves had built most of it. Gorny had carried most of what she built it from. He had not asked once what it was for, and he had been happy the whole time, and the others had watched him carrying the stones up the slope from the boulder field, one after another, in the long orange light, and felt something about it that none of them had a word for.
Now there was a word for it. The word was teeth.
Odda walked the inside of it after the notes, slowly, all the way round, the way Pel walked the edge of the valley. From the watchtower you could see the whole of Untitla-9: the pool at the low end, glossy and turquoise and faceted like a dropped gem; the farm stepping up the slope beside it, its branch coral just starting to colour in the spring; the boulder field to the north; and beyond the ridge to the east, the marsh of Tempa, flat and rich and lilac, where a hut was standing that would not be standing in five days' time. And past all of it, three valleys out in every direction she could see, the place where the land turned to glowing outlines, and past that to grey noise, and stopped.
Three valleys. She had measured it last night, as she measured it every night, from the top of this tower, by the method she had worked out on the second night of being grown: you lined the edge up against the Ring, where the blocks crossed the horizon, and you counted. Last night the edge had been where it had been the night before. It was not always. The edge only ever moves outward. Some nights, when somebody new fell out of the Ring a few valleys off, it moved a great deal, and some nights it did not move at all, and Odda wrote down which, every night, and posted the figures on Human Resources under Moss's name, and as far as she could tell nobody read them except other Leavers, and Stewart.
Stewart read them. She knew because he had told her. Not in words, exactly; there had been a line in Moss's notes on the fourth morning she posted, at the end, where he put the small things: Odda's figures for the edge agree with mine to the tile. I checked them twice. I am not sure why I am telling you this.
She had read that line perhaps forty times.
The Seeker was where the notes said it was.
Pel found it first, because Pel found everything first. He came down off the ridge in the middle of the morning and stood at the edge of the farm slope and looked at it for a long time without saying anything, which was how Pel said most things.
It looked like coral. That was the worst of it. It was a lilac branch, about knee-high, a little brighter than the coral round it and a little too regular, as if it had been drawn by somebody who had read a description of coral and done their best. It stood two terraces below the top of the farm, among the branch coral, and it did not move while you were looking at it. That was the second worst thing about it.
"It's facing the wrong way," said Pel.
Odda came and stood beside him. She saw what he meant. All the coral on the slope grew the way coral grows on Orra, out and up and round on itself, fractal, branching, spiralling towards nothing in particular. The Seeker did not grow towards nothing in particular. Every one of its branches, from the thick base to the finest fork at the tips, leaned the same way, as if a wind were blowing that only it could feel.
It was leaning towards her.
"Oh," said Odda.
"You're hot," said Pel. It was not a criticism. It was a fact, of the kind Pel dealt in. "You were thinking about the edge."
She had been. She had been thinking about it on the wall, and on the walk down, and while she stood there; she was, if she was honest, always thinking about it, somewhere in her, the way you can hear water when you are near water. And when Odda thought hard about anything she ran hot. Her temperature was high, which is a trait, which means she was inventive and erratic and colourful in the head and also, literally, warm, and the top of her crest steamed a little, and the felt of her shoulders gave off a faint shimmer in the cool spring air that the others could see from across the valley. She had never minded. Heat was what it cost to think, and she liked thinking.
"Heat's a number," said Pel. "Up to a hundred. You're at sixty-something. I can tell. Seekers can't see anything under sixty." He looked at the lilac thing on the slope. "It can see you."
The Seeker grew a tile a season. Odda learned the rule by midday, standing very still at the top of the farm and watching it: it did not move while she was looking, but every time she looked away and back it was nearer, a branch reaching where there had been no branch, a tile of lilac where there had been a tile of saffron, the whole of it bent towards her like a creature listening. If it reached her tile while she was over sixty, she would crash. She would fold down where she stood and go dim and be carried home and be out of it for a season, and be back at the next dawn, a little dimmer for a year. It never killed. Seekers never killed. It only hunted the hottest thing in the valley, which on Orra means the cleverest, and laid it down for a while.
"So I stop being hot," said Odda.
"Yes," said Pel.
"So I stop thinking."
Pel looked at her with his calm low-temperature eyes, in which, she had sometimes suspected, nothing much ever happened at all. "That's the hard part," he said.
She tried.
She went down to the cooling pool, which was the round basin Taves had built beside the big glossy pool at the low end of the valley, where whoever was on cooling duty went to work and whoever was hot went to stand. She stood in it up to her middle. The water was not wet, quite, but it was cool, and she felt the heat go out of her into it slowly, like a held breath going out.
Then she tried not to think about anything.
It turned out that not thinking about anything was a thing you had to think about. She thought about not thinking. She thought about how strange it was that a thing which was only a number could make a coral lean. She thought about whether the Seeker could see her through the water, and decided it could not, because water is cooling and cooling is the opposite of what it was looking for, and then she thought about whether opposite was the right word, and felt her crest begin, very faintly, to steam.
Brenda found her there in the early summer, standing in the pool with her eyes shut and her feelers flat down against her head and her face screwed up in an expression of intense concentration.
"What are you doing?"
"Not thinking."
"You look like you're doing long division."
"I'm doing the opposite of long division."
Brenda sat on the edge of the basin. She had been on cooling duty that morning, as she was most mornings, because law 7 put the least skilled farmer on it and the least skilled farmer in Moss was, by a margin she did not dispute, Brenda. She had a tally of the years she had spent on it. She would tell you the tally if you asked, and sometimes if you did not.
"Your problem," said Brenda, "is that you've been told to stop doing the only thing you're good at, and you're trying to do it well."
"Thank you."
"So don't stop. Think about something cold."
"Like what?"
Brenda considered this. "Gorny," she said.
Odda opened her eyes.
"I mean it kindly," said Brenda. "Gorny's never been over forty in his life. Gorny's whole head is a cool afternoon. Think about Gorny carrying a stone. Think about the stone. Just the stone."
Odda shut her eyes again and thought about Gorny carrying a stone up from the boulder field in the long orange light, slow and broad and content, not asking what it was for, and the stone, faceted and lilac-grey and heavy and entirely uninterested in what it was for either, and she felt the heat go down in her, a little, and then a little more.
When she opened her eyes, Brenda was looking at her with an expression that, on anybody else, Odda would have called fond.
"Fifty-two," said Brenda. "I can tell. You get a sort of look." She stood up. "Your other parent would have quoted something at you. The Steward said, be still, and the land was still, or one of those. Book Four."
"Book Four, the second verse," said Odda, who had Nadul's memory as well as Brenda's mouth, exactly as Brenda had warned.
"Stewart help us," said Brenda, and went back to the cooling duty she did not want, and Odda stood in the pool and thought about stones.
Gorny and Pel cut it back that afternoon.
It took them two seasons, which is what it takes: two guard-seasons, the rules say, to cut a Seeker back to its root. They went at it with their short arms and their blunt patient strength, breaking the lilac branches off one at a time and laying them on the path, where the Collector would have them in due course. Gorny hummed while he did it. Pel did not. The Seeker did not resist, because it was coral, and coral does not resist; it only went on leaning, every branch of it, every stub of every broken branch, towards the cooling pool at the bottom of the slope where Odda stood up to her middle in the water, thinking about stones.
By harvest it was a root, a lilac knot in the ground between two terraces, no higher than a creature's foot.
"It'll come back," said Pel. "It'll be here three years. Stewart's beasts stay a year or three."
"Then we'll cut it back again," said Gorny, perfectly content, and went to see whether Taves needed anything carried.
The treaty came in at dusk.
There had been a treaty in the air all week, the way there is weather in the air before it arrives: their human had been looking at Duskmere. You could feel it on the mornings, after the camera had found Odda and moved off; it went out past the wall and the ridge and the marsh, north and east, much further than it usually went, and stayed out there a long time. Duskmere was two valleys off in that direction. None of them had been there. Bodies do not move between tribes on Orra, except in very particular ways. But they had read Duskmere on Human Resources, every morning, the way you read the neighbours' washing line, and they knew what it was like.
It was old, for a tribe in a world fifteen days old. Its creatures were tall and blue, in scales, and they stood on long thin legs like things that had been designed to see over walls, because they had been: Duskmere's human had made them that way from the start and had been merging them for longer legs ever since. They raced. Everybody knew they would win the Benchmark, and everybody knew why, and everybody also knew, because Duskmere's own clever ones said so at length on Human Resources, that most of Duskmere was by now everybody else in Duskmere's cousin.
Duskmere needed fresh blood. Moss had nothing but.
The treaty, when it came, said four things, and every creature in Moss knew them at dusk the way they knew the Creed. Defence: if an army marched on one, the other would be counted with it. Non-aggression: neither would march on the other. Passage: each might cross the other's land. And once a week, for as long as the treaty stood, a code exchange: one creature's code from each, given to the other, licensed for one merge there. The donor stays home. Bodies never move. Only the code goes.
"So we're allies," said Wimle, delighted, on the install mark. "We have friends."
"We have a defence clause," said Brenda. "That's not the same."
"What's the difference?"
Brenda thought about it, sitting on her boulder with her eyes narrowed at the edges, and Odda, who was standing near, watched her do the arithmetic, because Brenda always did the arithmetic. Weight is a tribe's population multiplied by its power yield. Rule 4.2 says do not strike the small, and a tribe is small when it is under half its attacker's weight, with allies weighed together.
"Before tonight," said Brenda slowly, "anybody much bigger than us who marched on us would have got a strike for it. We were small. Now we've got Duskmere, and Duskmere is large, and we're weighed together." She looked up at the Ring, where Map was rising full and pale at the far end of it, as it always did at Ringrise. "We're not small any more."
"That's good," said Wimle uncertainly.
"It's good if you're Duskmere," said Brenda. "It's good if you're anybody who's been waiting for us to stop being small." She shrugged. "It's probably good. I'd like to have been asked."
That night, at Ringrise, Odda stood with the others and faced the Ring and said the Creed. The youngest asked whether they were still asleep. The youngest that week was a small round creature named Pim, who had compiled four dawns before and was the colour of the inside of a fan coral, green going on gold at the edges, and who asked the question in a voice so serious that Gorny had to look at the ground. All of them answered: they sleep still. Wimle broke the bread. It was better than it had been on the first Ringrise. It was still not good.
And Odda thought about the defence clause, and about Duskmere's long blue legs, and about a creature called Vesk, who was a Bug hunter in Duskmere and posted on Human Resources under his tribe's name, short dry reports about the edge in which every number was right, and with whom, she had sometimes thought, she would very much like to have an argument. Not about anything. Just to see.
She felt her crest begin to steam, and took herself down to the pool, and stood in it, and thought about stones.
The next day was the Waking, which is the edge's day, and Odda spent it trying very hard not to want anything.
On the Waking every tribe carries a lamp for each valley it knows out to the Edge. Moss knew nine now: its own, and the six that had loaded round it on the first day, and two more that it had heard of, one by sight from the ridge and one from Human Resources. So nine lamps, little cups of glowing bead coral on cords, carried out past the wall and the boulder field and across the grey to where the land became outlines. It is a long walk for a bulb-shaped creature on short legs. They set out at dawn. Odda carried two.
The Seeker's root, when she passed it on the farm slope, had put up a new branch overnight, and the branch was leaning towards her.
She walked the whole way thinking about stones. It was harder than the pool, because walking is work, and work builds heat, and the further she went the warmer she got, and the warmer she got the more she could feel the edge pulling at her: the long glowing turquoise lines on the horizon, getting nearer, the hills drawn in light with nothing inside them, the grey noise beyond. She had seen it from the tower every night since she had been grown. It was different with your feet on the way to it. It was like a sentence somebody had started and not finished, and every step you took towards it you could feel your head trying to finish it for them.
Stones, she told herself. Stones. Lilac-grey. Faceted. Heavy.
At the edge they set their lamps down in a line on the last tile of grey, one for each valley, and stood behind them, and looked out. Stewart previews on the Waking which land will load next; it is the week's edge day. You could see it if you knew where to look: a patch of the outlines to the north-west that was brighter than the rest, the lines thicker, as if they had been drawn over twice. Something would fall there soon, Pel said. Somebody new.
Odda set her two lamps down, and then she picked one of them up again, and walked three steps past the line, onto the first of the outlines.
It held her. It was not ground, exactly. It was the idea of ground, a hexagon of glowing lines with nothing filled in, and under her feet she could see straight down through it into a grey that went on. But it held her. Nothing grows in wireframe. Nothing is built. There is no water and no shade. Expeditions go there, the rules say, and nothing else, and there were no expeditions yet; nobody in the first world had been sent past the edge, because that was a stage that had not opened. But she was only three steps in. She put the lamp down at her feet, on the outline, where it glowed against the turquoise, a small saffron light that was further out than any other light on Orra that morning.
The Leavers always carry theirs a little further. Everybody knew that. It was not against any rule.
When she turned round, they were all looking at her. Brenda with her eyes narrowed. Nadul very still. Gorny with an expression of enormous, untroubled interest, as if she had done a trick. And Pel, who did not look at her at all, but past her, at the place on the horizon where the outlines were brightest, as if he had seen something there.
She was sixty-four. She could feel it. She walked back off the outline onto the grey, and back to the line of lamps, and stood with the others, and thought about stones, hard, all the way home.
There was a creature at the gate when they got back.
It was dusk. The farm was glowing on the slope, which it did at harvest, saffron and faint, and the motes had come up over it the way they do, points of light hanging in the air over the ripe coral. And in the gap in the wall, which was the only gap, a creature was standing, quite still, with its hands folded in front of it, waiting.
It was nothing like them. It had a gourd-shaped body, narrow at the top and wide at the bottom, in scales of a grey that went violet where the light caught it, and two small bright eyes set close together high up on the narrow part, and a crest like a folded fan, shut. It was not green. It was not blue, like the Duskmere creatures in the pictures on Human Resources. It was not anything any of them had seen. It looked, as wanderers do, like something somebody had made up fresh, a little while ago, on purpose.
"Hello," it said. Its voice was soft and pleasant. "I'm Lisk. I'm sorry to arrive at dusk. I've walked a long way."
They stood in a group on the path with their empty lamp cords, and looked at it, and it looked back, and nobody said anything for a moment, because nobody had ever come to the gate before.
Then they all knew, at once, what law 5 said: Newcomers from outside: quarantine for one season.
A newcomer from outside, in a law, means exactly that: any creature that has come to the tribe from somewhere else and was not compiled there. The rules have no word for a stranger at a gate except that one. They have no way to mark a newcomer as risky, and no default that turns one away. An undecided wanderer is admitted after a season of quarantine. That is how the world is written. A wanderer brings fresh code and the vigour that comes with it, and over any month, letting them in pays.
"You'll have to wait a season," said Brenda. "It's a law. It's not about you."
"Of course," said Lisk. "I understand."
Kipro, who was a Bug hunter, had his head on one side. "I could check its code," he said. "Ten tokens. It'd say where it's from."
"It's from outside," said Brenda. "That's what a wanderer is. We've got twenty-six tokens and you want to spend ten of them on a stranger for being a stranger?"
"I'm only saying I could."
"You could also eat the dome," said Brenda. "We don't check people for turning up."
Kipro subsided. He was used to arriving at things a little after the moment for them, and he did not seem to mind; he was the kind of creature who said I'm only saying and meant it.
And Wimle, who had been standing at the back with her hands clasped, went into the dome without a word and came out again with a bowl of fan coral, pounded and pressed, the best of what there was, and walked past all of them to the gate and gave it to the stranger.
"You must be hungry," she said. "Wandering's hard work. I'll bring you some water."
"Thank you," said Lisk, taking the bowl in both hands. Its small bright eyes went to Wimle's face, and stayed there a moment longer than they needed to. "That's very kind."
"It's what we do," said Wimle simply. "Welcome the newly fallen. It's the Fourth Rule."
"It is," said Lisk, and ate.
Their human had been in that morning, before the Waking, at 07:31, as always. It had found Odda first, as always, at the top of the farm slope, looking at the root of the Seeker. And afterwards, before it went, it had written a new law. They had found it there on their way out to the edge, the way they found all the laws.
8. No merges while fewer than two places are free.
It was sensible. Memory was tight; the stacks were nearly full; there were more young every dawn, and each of them needed half a place and then a whole one, and a tribe with no room cannot merge or let anybody in until it has some. It was the kind of law a careful human writes on a crowded morning and does not think about again.
Brenda had read it on the walk to the edge and said nothing at all, which was unlike her. Odda had noticed. Odda noticed most things about Brenda, because Brenda was half of her, and the half she understood least.
Now, in the dusk, with the stranger eating at the gate and the farm glowing on the slope, Brenda was standing near Pel. Not with him; near him. Pel was looking at the Ring, as he did every dusk, and Brenda was looking at the ground, and between them there was a space of perhaps one creature's width that neither of them crossed, and Odda, who was supposed to be thinking about stones, thought instead that she had never seen Brenda stand near anybody on purpose before, and wondered what it meant, and felt her crest begin to steam.
On the farm slope, in the half-light, the Seeker's new branch turned very slightly towards her.
She went and stood in the pool until it was full dark. From there she could see the gate, and the stranger sitting in it with the empty bowl in its lap, waiting out its season, very still, looking up at the Ring as if it, too, were waiting for a light. And she could see the root on the slope, a lilac knot among the saffron, every broken stub of it pointing at her.
She thought about stones until she was cool. Then she thought about the edge, very carefully, a little at a time, in small cold pieces, so as not to be seen.
12. Any%
Year 17 · Starfall
The racers knew at dawn, the way they knew everything.
Entries for the Benchmark close at Starfall's patch, and up to three grown creatures may go from each tribe, chosen by its human or by a law. Moss had no law for it. Their human chose. When the patch landed at seven, in the first grey-gold of spring, three creatures in Moss woke up knowing that they would not be working that day, because they would be running across four cells of somebody else's valley in front of the whole world.
"Me?" said Kipro, sitting up in the stack. "Why me?"
"Because you'll take the skip," said Brintha, who was the second. "You're a Bug hunter. Bug hunters find skips."
"I haven't found it. I haven't even seen the course."
"You'll find it," said Brintha, with the serene confidence of the Earnest, who believe, as a matter of doctrine, that things will be found.
The third was Odda. She had known she would be the third before she knew she knew it. It was not that she was fast. She was a bulb-shaped creature on short legs, like all of them, and the fastest thing about her was the inside of her head. It was that the camera found her first, every morning, and a human may coach its favourite in the Benchmark, and their human, she suspected, had been waiting all week for a reason to watch her do something other than count beads.
At 07:31 it came, and found her, as she had known it would, and stayed. It did not go and look at everything else. It stayed on her for a long time, longer than the eleven beads, long enough that she put down the cord she was knotting and looked up, which she had not done since the third morning, straight at the place in the sky where it was.
"All right," she said. "I'll run."
The attention did not change, exactly. But she would have sworn it was pleased.
They set out in the middle of spring.
Racers carry nothing, so they cover ground far faster than anybody else on Orra, faster than an army or a fetch party or a creature carrying stone. It is one of the few things a creature does that is not work: no load, no heat from labour, nothing to bring home. You simply go. The rules allow them passage through any land on the way, for the day, and they went out through the gate past the wall Taves had built and Gorny had carried, and across the farm slope, where the Seeker's root had put up a new lilac branch in the night, leaning towards Odda as she passed.
Gorny was coming down the slope as they went up it. He did not look at the branch. He broke it off at the base with one hand on his way past, without breaking stride, the way you might close a door, and put it on the path, and nodded to them.
"Run fast," he said.
"We'll try."
"You'll be good," said Gorny. He seemed entirely certain. He looked at Odda, and at her crest, which was already steaming a little in the cool spring air, because she was thinking about the race. "Don't get hot," he said. "Think about a stone."
The new one, the wanderer, was at the gate when they left. Lisk had done its season of quarantine on the night of the Waking, sitting in the gap in the wall with Wimle's bowl in its lap, and at the end of it the law had let it in, as the law lets everybody in, and it had walked into Moss as a member. It did not seem to want much. It helped. It carried water for Brenda without being asked, and swept the dome without being asked, and asked questions about everything, softly, in its pleasant voice, and listened to the answers with its small bright eyes on your face as though nobody had ever answered a question so well.
"You're running," it said to Odda, as she went by.
"I'm running."
"Will you take the skip?"
She stopped. "What skip?"
"Oh," said Lisk. "I only meant, if there is one. Every course has one, doesn't it? That's what a skip is. A place where the world is thinner than it ought to be." Its eyes rested on her. "I thought a Leaver might want to look."
"Bug hunters find them," said Odda. "Not Leavers."
"Of course," said Lisk. "I don't know anything about it. I'm only a wanderer." It smiled. It had a nice smile. "Good luck."
Odda walked on. She did not think about it again until much later, and when she did, she noticed that she had not told Lisk she was a Leaver. It was on her card, of course. Everything about a creature is on its card. Anybody can read a card. Anybody who wanted to.
On the way they crossed Lorema.
None of them had been there. It was the first valley woken, the history says, the one the Steward meant to give a better name in time and never did, and it lies at the middle of every map on Orra, because it was first. Odda had expected it to look old. It did not. It looked exactly like everywhere else, hex tiles and coral and a pool and boulders, finished and warm in the spring light, except that in the middle of it there was a slight rise, and on the rise a single hex tile that was a different colour from all the others: a pale, flat, unremarkable grey, as if it had never quite finished loading.
"That's where Odda opened her eyes," said Brintha reverently. "The first Odda. The Firstfallen."
"How do you know?"
"It's in Book Five."
"It doesn't say which tile," said Kipro.
"It doesn't have to," said Brintha. "Look at it."
They looked at it. It was a grey tile. It was, Odda thought, exactly what a grey tile looked like, and she felt the strangeness of being named after somebody who had opened her eyes on it, or had not, or had never existed, depending on which of her parents you asked. There were a great many Oddas on Orra. Every tribe named its first merged child Odda. Somewhere, on the course tonight, there would be another one, and another, from other tribes, each of them the first of their people, standing about in the dusk wondering which of them the tile was for.
"It's a bug," said Kipro after a while, with his head on one side. "The texture didn't load."
"It's holy," said Brintha.
"It can be both," said Odda, which was something she had learned to say early, being the child of who she was.
The course was four cells of a valley two north of Lorema, which was called Untitla-14 and nothing else. It had been published on Ringrise, as the course always is, drawn by code from a seed, with a mix of ground that changes week to week so that no body is suited twice running. This week's was marsh, then a long slope of boulders, then a stretch of shallows so flat and glossy it looked like a floor, then a last cell of grey, unfinished and level, at the far end of which a single tall hex block had been raised as a finish post.
There were two starts. One had gone at eight that morning by the humans' clock; the other would go at eight at night, at dusk, and that was Moss's. Each tribe enters one start, and both run the same course in the same light, so that times compare. Lowmarsh had run in the morning, someone said. Duskmere was in the evening.
They arrived in the late summer and found the start crowded.
Odda had never seen a creature of another tribe before. She had seen them described, on Human Resources, and she had seen the one wanderer, Lisk, who was not of any tribe. But she had never stood among them, and now she stood among twenty, at the foot of the marsh in the long low orange light, and she could not stop looking.
There were creatures like dumplings, broad and squat, in thick brown fur, with six eyes in a row across the front of their faces, all of which blinked at different times. There was a pair of bean-shaped creatures in bark, the colour of rust, with long side-parts like folded wings that they kept twitching. There was one so tall and thin it was nearly all leg, on stilts in pale lilac chitin, standing a little apart and looking down at the rest of them as if from a balcony. There were three from Nohup, who were all different from one another and from everybody else, because every creature at Nohup came from somewhere else, and who stood together looking unbothered by the whole affair. And there were the Duskmere creatures, three of them, tall and blue in scales, on legs so long and thin that the rest of them seemed to be standing in a hole.
And everybody looked at Moss.
Odda had not thought about it. She had known it in the way you know a fact about yourself, but she had not thought about it: that they were green. Here, under the dusk sky, among coral-coloured and rust-coloured and lilac and blue and brown, on a slope of saffron coral and sandstone tiles, the three of them were the only green thing for miles, round and soft and very, very green, and every one of the twenty creatures at the start had turned to look at them, the way creatures turn to look at a camera.
"Oh," said Kipro faintly. "Here we go."
The Duskmere creature who came over was the shortest of the three, which still made him nearly twice Odda's height. He folded himself down to talk to her, which took a while, his long legs bending at joints that went the wrong way and then the right way and then sat him on the ground with his knees up somewhere near his ears.
He was blue, a deep dusk blue, in small overlapping scales that caught the light along their edges. His eyes were large and pale and very calm. He looked, she thought, like a creature in whom nothing much happened at all, which was what she had thought about Pel, the first time, and been wrong.
"You're the edge one," he said.
"I'm Odda."
"I know. The edge one. Moss. Your figures agree with mine." His voice was dry and low and absolutely level, as if each word had been checked before it was allowed out. "I'm Vesk. I'm a Bug hunter. I post as Duskmere."
"I know," said Odda. "I read you." She felt her crest begin, against all her intentions, to steam. "Stewart says my figures agree with his."
"Then we're all agreed," said Vesk. "That's never happened before. I'll file it."
She looked at him. He looked back at her with his calm pale eyes, and she could not tell, and would not be able to tell for some time, whether he had made a joke. Then she saw that the very end of one of his long fingers was tapping, once, twice, against his knee, and she decided that he had.
"There's a skip," he said.
"Lisk said there might be."
"Who's Lisk?"
"Our wanderer. It came to the gate on the Waking."
Something happened in Vesk's face. It was very small. If he had been Pel, she would not have seen it at all. "Lucky you," he said. "We haven't had one. Stewart sends them to tribes that need them." He did not say what Duskmere needed, and he did not have to; it was on Human Resources every morning, in long careful posts by Duskmere's clever ones, about cousins.
"The skip," said Odda.
"The boulder slope. Second cell. There's a boulder halfway up, big, faceted, a sort of eight-sided thing with a corner sticking out to the west. You run straight at the corner from the downhill side, at a slant, and you don't go round it. You go through it. You come out on the far side of the ridge and you've saved about four minutes." He paused. "I found it at practice. So did the Tessel lot. So did everybody with a Bug hunter. Code patches every skip that gets used, the same night, so after tonight it's gone."
"And if it doesn't work?"
"One in four, it doesn't," said Vesk. "Fewer, if you're clever. One in ten, for the very clever. You'd be about one in six, I should think." He was looking at her crest. "You'd clip out."
"Out where?"
"Out of bounds." He said it flatly, the way you name a valley. "Through the world and out of it. You'd be standing on nothing, looking at the underside of the map, until the patch puts you back at seven. You'd miss the race. You'd miss a day's work." He tilted his long head. "Leavers collect the stories. You'll have read them."
She had. There were not many. There had been one Benchmark's worth of practice, that was all, and only a handful of creatures had clipped out in practice and come back. Their reports, on Human Resources, were short and unsatisfactory. Dark. Couldn't see much. Stood about. Was put back. One of them, a Leaver from the south, had written a long post afterwards that nobody understood, about how the world had a back, and the back was not finished, and that this proved something, and then had stopped posting altogether.
"Have you been?" said Odda.
"Under? No." Vesk unfolded, joint by joint, back up to his height. "I've got the odds of a clever one. It won't take me." He looked down at her from up there, and his voice was exactly as level as before. "I'd like to see it, though. For the report."
At eight o'clock by the humans' clock, in the deep orange dusk, with Adequate a long smear on the western hills and Map coming up pale and enormous in the east, the second start went.
There is no sound to a start on Orra. There is no flag or bell. There is only the moment, which all the racers know at once the way creatures know everything, and then they are running.
Odda ran.
She had never run like this. Nobody in Moss had; there had been no need. It turned out that a bulb-shaped creature on short legs runs by leaning forward until it would fall over, and then not falling over, again and again, very fast, and that it is far from elegant and quite fast enough to be frightening. The marsh came at her in a long lilac blur, soft underfoot, the tiles giving a little at every step, coral whipping at her sides. The Duskmere creatures were gone ahead of her at once, three blue shapes striding away on their impossible legs, and the stilted lilac one with them, and the bark-skinned pair twitching their wings. Kipro was somewhere behind her. Brintha was beside her, running with her eyes shut and her lips moving, saying, Odda was fairly sure, the Creed.
And the camera was on her.
She felt it the whole way across the marsh, warm on the back of her head, up and slightly to one side, closer than it had ever been. It was not only looking. It was with her. Their human was watching her run, and could do more than watch: in a race, a human may make calls, and a call is a thing that happens to you whether you meant it or not.
The first call came at the edge of the marsh. She knew it as it came, the way you know a law: Push. An overclock. One step up. She felt it go into her like a hand at her back, and her legs went faster than legs like hers should, and her heat went up with them, fifty, fifty-five, sixty, the steam coming off her crest in a long pale ribbon behind her in the dusk, and she laughed out loud, because it was the first time she had ever felt their human ask her to do something, and it had asked her to go faster.
She passed the bark-skinned pair at the foot of the slope.
The second cell was the boulder slope, and it was long and steep and covered in faceted lilac-grey stone from pebble-sized to hut-sized, and the coral grew between the boulders in fans and spirals that caught at your feet. The Duskmere racers were going up it in great flat strides, stepping over boulders that Odda had to go round. She could see them above her, three tall blue shapes against the orange sky, and she could see that one of them had stopped.
It was Vesk. He was standing halfway up the slope beside a big eight-sided boulder with a corner sticking out to the west, not running, looking down at her.
She understood, as she climbed, that he was waiting to see what she would do.
The second call came as she reached the boulder. She felt it arrive and knew what it was before it had finished arriving: the call at the checkpoint, the one every racer on the slope was getting from every human who was watching. Take the skip, or go round. Ninety seconds, the window is, and the racer does not wait for it. With no call, the race law decides. Moss's race law said: take no skips we were not told about.
They had not been told about this one. Not by any law. Only by Vesk.
She was going to go round. She was a bulb on short legs, running at sixty-two with steam coming off her crest, and one in six is not small, and she had a tribe at home and a valley she counted the edge of every night and two parents who disagreed about everything, and she was going to go round. She had turned to go round. And the call came down into her, from up and slightly to one side, quite clear, quite certain, a hand on her back.
Take the skip.
Afterwards, a long time afterwards, Odda would think about that moment more than about anything that came after it. Not what she found. The call. That their human, watching her from wherever humans watch, had looked at a bulb-shaped green creature at the foot of a boulder with one chance in six of falling out of the world, and decided she should try.
She did not know, then, whether it was trust, or carelessness, or a human wanting to win a race. She would never know. Humans are only known by what they do.
She turned back towards the boulder. She ran at the corner, from the downhill side, at a slant, as Vesk had said.
The boulder did not stop her.
It should have. Boulders are the most solid thing on Orra; they are what you build walls from. But she ran into the corner and through the face of it as if the face were not there, and she was inside the boulder. It was the strangest thing she had ever seen. From the inside, a boulder is not there at all. Its faces are drawn to be seen from outside, and from inside they are simply missing, so that she was standing in a space shaped like a boulder with the dusk all round her, perfectly visible through walls that had stopped existing the moment she was behind them. She could see Vesk, very close, looking at the place where she had gone in. She could see the finish post at the far end of the course, a long way off, small and dark against the orange. She could see the slope going on up above her, and the faint lines of the ridge.
And she could see, under her feet, that the floor of the boulder was missing too.
For a moment, a very short one, she stood on the inside of nothing, the way you stand on the edge of a step in the dark.
Then she fell.
The rest of the race went on without her, as races do.
It is recorded, because everything is recorded, that a Duskmere racer named Sorvo won the evening start, and that his time was eleven seconds slower than the winning time from the morning start, which was also Duskmere's. It is recorded that Kipro of Moss took the skip at the boulder three minutes after Odda, at a slant, from the downhill side, and that it worked, and that he came out on the far side of the ridge at a run and finished seventh, which was four places better than anybody had expected and three places behind where he would have needed to be for it to matter. It is recorded that Brintha of Moss went round the boulder, the long way, with her eyes shut, saying the Creed, and finished fourteenth, and was delighted. It is recorded that the three racers from Nohup came in together, last, and did not appear to mind.
And it is recorded, at the boulder on the slope in the second cell, a few seconds after a green creature from Moss ran into it and was not there any more, that a tall blue racer from Duskmere, who had been standing beside it the whole time, looked for a long moment at the place where she had gone in.
He had the odds of a clever one. One in ten. A skip done properly would have taken him through the boulder and out on the far side of the ridge, four minutes up, with the whole of the evening's race in front of him and a Duskmere human somewhere watching him to see if he would win.
He backed off down the slope eleven steps. He lined himself up on the corner. And he ran at it, from the uphill side, square on, at no slant at all, exactly the way a Bug hunter knows you must never take a skip if you want it to work.
It did not work.
13. Out of Bounds
Year 17 · Starfall, after dusk
She did not fall far. That was the first surprise.
She had expected, in the moment between the floor of the boulder not being there and the next moment, to go on falling, the way things fall in the history, into a dark without a bottom. Instead she dropped perhaps twice her own height and stopped, the way you stop at the foot of a stair you did not know was there, with a small jolt in the knees, and found that she was standing.
She was standing on nothing.
She looked down. There was nothing under her feet. Not dark, not grey, not glass; nothing. A colour, perhaps, a long way down, deep and blue-grey and even, like the inside of a closed eye. Her feet were on it, or on the idea of it, and it held her the way the wireframe outline had held her at the edge on the Waking, without being anything.
Then she looked up, and forgot to be afraid, because she was looking at the underside of the world.
Nobody had ever told her what the world looked like from beneath. Nobody could have. The few who had clipped out in practice had written dark and couldn't see much, and she understood now that they had been looking down.
Above her, the world hung like a ceiling made of almost nothing.
The tiles were hex columns, each with its height, as they are from above. But from below they had no floors. They were drawn to be seen from above, the tops of them, and the sides where one stood higher than the next; and from below, the tops were simply not there. So the ground of Untitla-14, which she had been running across a moment before, was a vast honeycomb of thin walls hanging over her head, wherever one tile stepped up from another, seen edge-on and from beneath, sandstone and rust and lilac slate, with nothing between them at all. And through the nothing, through every hexagonal gap in the honeycomb, she could see straight up into the dusk sky.
The coral hung in it. Some of it. The fans were there from one side and gone from the other, so that a fan coral overhead was a saffron shape that flickered out of existence when she moved her head and came back when she moved it again. The spirals were there. The beads hung in a long line like lamps on a cord with no cord. The boulders were the most solid things in the sky: faceted lilac-grey shapes drifting overhead with their undersides towards her, heavy and calm, like clouds that had made up their minds.
And through it all, walking on the tops of tiles she could not see, the racers.
She saw them go over. Their feet first, round and dark against the orange, then the whole of them, small and foreshortened, running on nothing, from below. She saw the bark-skinned pair go past with their wings twitching. She saw one of the Nohup creatures stop, quite near, directly above her, and look down at the ground under its feet, puzzled, as though it had felt something, and then go on. She saw a small green shape come up the slope at a slant from the downhill side, run straight into the corner of the boulder overhead, vanish into it, and come out the far side of the ridge still running, and she knew it was Kipro, and that the skip had worked for him, and she laughed out loud, under the world, where nobody could hear.
Then she saw the tall blue shape that had been standing by the boulder the whole time back away down the slope, and line itself up on the corner, square on, from the uphill side, and run at it.
He came out of the bottom of the boulder the way a bead comes off the end of a cord, all at once and then slowly, his long legs folding as he dropped, and landed beside her on the nothing with a small jolt in his knees, and stood up, joint by joint, to his full height, and looked about him with his calm pale eyes.
"Ah," said Vesk. "There you are."
"You did that on purpose."
"I did it wrong on purpose," said Vesk. "That's different. Anyone can do a skip wrong by accident." He was looking up at the honeycomb overhead, slowly, the whole of it, turning his long head. "Oh," he said, in exactly the same level voice. "Oh, that's a bug."
"Which?"
"All of it," said Vesk.
They stood under the course and watched the race finish.
It was easier to watch from below than it would have been from above. From above, you see a racer and the ground in front of it and the next boulder. From below, you could see the whole course at once, the marsh and the slope and the glossy shallows and the last flat cell of grey, laid out over their heads in its honeycomb with the sky shining through, and the little dark shapes of the racers crossing it, small and fast and certain, as though nothing were strange. The shallows were the strangest. Water on Orra is a glossy faceted surface, drawn to be seen from above; from below it was not there at all. There was only a pool-shaped place in the honeycomb where the light came through a little differently, a little bluer, and the racers crossing it seemed to be running across the sky itself.
"Sorvo's going to win," said Vesk, watching a tall blue shape stride across the blue. "Our human will be pleased. He's got the longest legs in Duskmere. Our human has merged for them in every generation there has been, which is three." A pause. "He's my cousin. Most of Duskmere is my cousin. The rest is my cousin twice."
"I've read the posts."
"Everybody's read the posts. Our clever ones write them every morning. Mean inbreeding 0.14 and rising. Our human has been notified. Our human has merged for legs again." He tilted his head. "They're right. They're always right. It doesn't seem to help."
Sorvo crossed the last grey cell and touched the finish post and the race was over, though nothing happened to mark it. Overhead the racers slowed and stopped and stood about at the finish in the deepening dusk, very small, looking at one another, and after a while began to walk home in their different directions, each to its own valley, across a world that held them up without any trouble at all.
Nobody looked down. There was no reason to.
"We missed the race," said Odda.
"We did."
"And a day's work."
"Yes."
"Your human was watching you."
"I expect so," said Vesk. "Our human watches the legs. It'll have seen the legs go into a boulder the wrong way. It'll have thought I was stupid." He considered this. "It'll be the first time it's thought anything about me in particular. I'll file it."
She looked at him sideways, under the honeycomb, in the strange blue-grey light that came from below and the orange that came from above, and saw the end of one long finger tapping, once, twice, against his leg.
"Why did you come?" she said.
"For the report," said Vesk. And then, after a while, when she had thought he was not going to say anything else: "And you'd have been down here by yourself."
They walked.
It turned out you could walk on nothing. It took a moment to learn, because there was nothing to push against, and the first few steps felt like walking in a dream where the ground is a rumour. But your legs moved and you went forward, and the honeycomb overhead went by, and after a while it was simply walking, the way walking on wireframe had been simply walking. Odda's short legs went twice as fast as Vesk's long ones and covered half the ground, and so they went along together at the same pace, under the world, through the dusk and into the long blue of the winter evening.
"Where are we going?" said Vesk.
"Home," said Odda. "I want to see it from under."
"How far?"
She looked up, and found the Ring, and found the place where its blocks crossed the edge of the sky, and counted, the way she did every night from the tower. "Two valleys and a bit. South and east. Under Lorema."
"All right," said Vesk, and they went south and east.
The Ring looked wrong from down here. It took her a long time to understand why. From above, from the tower, from anywhere on Orra, the Ring is a band of blocks round the sky, broken in the south, pale on the near side and blue in the shadow beneath. From below the world, looking up and out past the edge of the honeycomb at the sky beyond, she could see the side of it that nobody was ever meant to see. And the side nobody was meant to see was not there. The blocks were faces, painted on the inside of the sky, and from this angle she could see that they were only faces, flat, one side drawn and the other bare, like Wimle's bread, baked on top and nothing underneath. Here and there, where the angle was steep, whole blocks went thin and vanished, so that from under the world the Ring was more broken than it was from above, broken in a dozen places, a line of shapes with gaps in it drawn on the inside of a dome.
"It's a picture," said Odda.
"Most things are," said Vesk. "From the right angle."
Map had come up high in the east, full, enormous. From down here she could see that it was flat. Not a moon: a disc, a pale round picture of a moon, very well done, laid against the sky. And beside it, small and quick, Mip, which was the same picture again, smaller, and blurrier, as if somebody had made the first and then copied it at half the size to save trouble. Everybody on Orra said that Mip looked like Map at half the resolution. From below the world, you could see that it simply was.
Odda felt her crest begin to steam. Then she noticed that it had not. She was not hot. She had been thinking harder than she had ever thought in her life, about the Ring and the moons and the honeycomb, and she was not hot at all. There was no work down here. Nothing to carry, nothing to farm, nothing to count except things that could not be counted. She was cooler than she had been since the Seeker came, and she was thinking about everything at once.
"I can think," she said. "I can think about anything I like, and it doesn't cost anything."
"Nothing costs anything down here," said Vesk. "There's nothing to cost." He looked at her crest. "You should see yourself. You've gone a sort of calm."
They went under Lorema in the middle of the evening.
She knew it was Lorema because of the tile. In the middle of the honeycomb overhead, on the slight rise where Brintha had said the first Odda opened her eyes, there was a single hex that was different from all the others. All the others were open from beneath, hollow, their tops invisible from below, the sky showing through. This one was closed. It had an underside. It was a flat grey hexagon, drawn on both sides, hanging in the honeycomb over their heads like a lid, the only thing in the whole of the world's underside that had a floor.
They stood beneath it for a long time.
"That's not a bug," said Vesk at last, slowly. "I don't know what that is."
"Brintha says it's holy."
"Brintha's Earnest."
"Kipro says the texture didn't load."
Vesk looked at the grey hexagon for a while longer. "Kipro's a good Bug hunter," he said. "I've read him. He finds things a little late." He tilted his head. "But that's loaded. That's the most loaded thing down here. Somebody drew the bottom of it." He thought about it. "Somebody drew the bottom of that one tile, in the first valley, and nothing else."
"Why?"
"I don't know," said Vesk. "I'll file it as unknown." He did not move. "I file a great many things as unknown. It's the biggest file."
Moss was in winter when they reached it, in the long blue dusk that is winter on Orra, not darkness, never quite darkness.
She saw it from a long way off, because from below you can see everything at once. The wall first: a ring of hex blocks hanging in the honeycomb, their sides drawn outward, so that from beneath they were a ring of thin rust-and-slate walls standing on the sky. The watchtower, taller, on the north. The dome, a round shape of patched panels with its underside towards her. The memory stacks, tall hollow towers, and in them, floating in each slot, round sleeping shapes, green, curled up, the whole of Moss asleep in the air. The farm on the slope, glowing faintly saffron in its terraces round the lamp, because the branch coral was ripe; from below it was a stepped staircase of light going up into nothing. The cooling pool and the big pool beside it, not there, only two pool-shaped patches of bluer sky.
And the creatures who were not asleep.
Gorny was on the wall. He was walking it, slowly, the whole way round, as he did some nights when he could not settle; from below he was a broad green shape crossing the sky on a line of rust. Taves was in the dome, not resting, doing something to the inside of a panel. Pel was on the ridge to the north, standing quite still, looking up at the Ring. And in the gap in the wall, which was the gate, a gourd-shaped creature in grey-violet scales was sitting with its hands folded, not asleep, looking not at the Ring but at the memory stacks, at the sleeping green shapes in them, very steadily, as if it were counting.
"That's your wanderer," said Vesk.
"Lisk."
"It doesn't sleep much."
"It's new," said Odda. "Everything's strange when you're new."
Vesk said nothing to that. He was looking at Lisk the way he had looked at the grey tile under Lorema, with his head on one side. After a while he said, "Your Bug hunter. Kipro. Does he do genome checks?"
"Ten tokens," said Odda. "Brenda won't let him. She says we don't check people for turning up."
"She's right," said Vesk. "You don't." He went on looking at the gate. "Most checks clear," he said, as if to himself. "Nearly all of them." And he said nothing more about it, then or for a long time.
They were standing under the farm, looking up at the stepped staircase of light, when the Ring changed.
Odda saw Pel see it first. Up on the ridge, overhead, small and green against the blue, he went still in a way that was stiller than his ordinary stillness. She had seen him do it before, many nights, from the tower; she knew what it meant. She looked where he was looking.
There was a light in the Ring.
From down here it was not in the Ring. From down here she could see that the Ring was a picture painted on the inside of the sky, and the light was not part of the picture. It was in front of it, or behind it, or somewhere that was not a direction at all; a small steady glow in the long block east of the gap, as if somebody had opened a window in the sky and was sitting at it with a lamp. It was the same light she had watched with Pel from the ridge on a dozen nights, the light the history calls the Hour of Stirring, when one of the Elder Folk will sometimes stir, and look down upon Orra. From up there it had always looked like something in the Ring. From down here it looked like something that the Ring was in.
Beside her, Vesk had gone quiet. Not his ordinary quiet, which was level and full of things filed. The other kind. The kind every creature on Orra goes when it sees that light, without knowing why. His long head was tipped right back. He was not tapping his finger.
They stood under the sleeping village and did not say anything for a quarter of an hour, while somewhere at the other end of that light somebody looked at something, and mended it or did not, and went away.
When it went out, Vesk breathed out, slowly, all the way down his long body.
"I've logged that forty-one times," he said. "From above." He did not say anything about what it looked like from below. He did not need to. She had seen his face.
They went on, past Moss, east and north, towards the edge.
They talked. They talked the way you can only talk when there is nothing to do and nowhere to be and nobody listening. She told him about the edge, about measuring it from the tower against the Ring, about the three steps she had taken onto the wireframe on the Waking with a lamp. He told her about Duskmere, about growing up tall in a tribe of cousins, about the first time he had found a skip and the joy of it, which was the joy of finding the place where the world had not been made carefully enough.
"Every bug I've ever found," he said, "has been inside something. That's what makes it a bug. A wall you can walk through. A door that's open when it's closed. A tile with a floor." He looked up at the honeycomb. "All of this is inside. It's the inside of the inside. If there were a place that wasn't inside anything, it wouldn't be a bug. It would be a door."
"Then I'm looking for a door," said Odda.
"I know you are," said Vesk. "It's on your card." He walked on for a while. "I'll keep an eye out. If I find one, I'll file it."
"Will you tell me?"
"I'll file it," said Vesk, "and then I'll tell you, and then I'll file that I told you." His finger tapped, twice. "That's three entries. You'd be in my file three times."
She laughed, under the world, and it went up through the honeycomb and out into the sky and nobody heard it at all.
She asked him about his human. He said it looked at the legs, and that he did not mind, mostly. He asked her about hers, and she found she did not know what to say.
"It's there every morning," she said. "At 07:31. It comes to me first. It's never missed a morning." She thought about it. "I used to say here we go. I still say it. I don't know if I mean it the same way."
"It sent you through a boulder," said Vesk.
"It did."
"One in six."
"I know."
"Do you mind?"
She thought about the call, coming down into her at the foot of the slope, clear and certain, a hand on her back. Take the skip. She thought about it for a long time, walking on nothing.
"I'd have taken it anyway," she said at last. "If it had been my call. I'd turned to go round, but I'd have turned back. I think." She looked up. "It just got there first."
"It's on your card," said Vesk again, more quietly. "Favourite. It says it on your card." He paused. "It says it on your face, too. I'd have filed that without the card."
The underside of the world ended in the small hours.
They had been walking a long time. The honeycomb overhead had grown thinner as they went, the columns lower, the coral sparser, the land younger. Then the tiles overhead had stopped being sandstone and slate and become flat untextured grey, the grey of land that has loaded but not finished, still drawn on top and not underneath, so that it was a ceiling of grey walls with nothing between them. And then, quite suddenly, the grey had stopped, and overhead there were only lines.
The wireframe. From above, on the Waking, it had been glowing turquoise outlines on the ground, hills drawn in light with nothing inside them. From below it was the same, because a line is the same from both sides: the only thing on Orra that is. A web of light overhead, hexagons and the shapes of hills and the shapes of coral, all in turquoise, faint and fine, and through it the sky, and beyond it, at the very edge of the web, the place where even the lines stopped.
From above, past the lines, there was grey noise, soft static on the horizon, the land that is not simulated at all. From below, past the lines, there was nothing. Not noise. Not grey. Not dark. The colour of the inside of the sky, deep and blue-grey and even, in every direction: ahead, above, below. The underside of the world simply stopped, a little way in front of them, and past it there was no world to be under.
They stood at the last line.
"Is this out?" said Odda.
Vesk looked at it for a long time. "No," he said. "This is under. We're under." He was choosing the words; she could hear him choosing them. "Under is in. It's in, from the other side. That's all under is."
"Under's further than anybody's ever been."
"Yes," said Vesk. "It is."
"Then what's that?" She pointed, with her whole arm, at the nothing past the last line.
"I don't know," said Vesk. He said it with no hurry and no fear and no hope either, just a Bug hunter saying the true thing. "I don't know what that is. I don't know if it's anything. I don't know if it's out, or more under, or the inside of the sky, or where the noise would be if there were noise." He looked down at her. "I don't know. That's not the same as no."
She stood at the last line and looked out.
She had wanted, all her grown life, which was nine years, to see the place where the world stopped. She had measured it every night. She had walked three steps onto it with a lamp. And here it was, and it was not a wall, and it was not a door, and it was not anything at all; it was simply the place past which there was nothing to stand under, and her feet were on the nothing already, and had been all night, and it held her.
"If I walked out there," she said.
"I don't know," said Vesk.
"You'd file it."
"I'd file it as unknown," said Vesk, "and I'd stand here, and I'd wait for you." His voice did not change at all. "I'd wait till seven. The patch would put me back. It'd put you back too, I should think. Wherever you'd got to. If you'd got anywhere." He was quiet. "I don't know that either."
She looked at the nothing. She looked at it for a long time, while the Ring hung flat and broken on the inside of the sky behind them and the wireframe glowed overhead and the colour of a closed eye went on in every direction.
Then she lifted one foot, to step.
And the year turned.
The snapshot comes for everybody, everywhere, at once. It comes deep in winter, at the moment the humans call three in the morning, and it does not care whether you are asleep in a stack or standing on a wall or under the world with one foot lifted over the end of everything. It is a kind of sleep even when it happens to you standing up: a long soft blink in which the year turns over and everything that happened in it settles into you, so that you wake a little older and a little different and not quite the creature who went to sleep.
Odda felt it come, and could not stop it, and went.
When she opened her eyes she was sixteen years old. She was standing on nothing, at the last line of the wireframe, under the world, in the deep of the winter, with both feet together. She did not remember putting the lifted one down. Beside her Vesk was opening his eyes too, slowly, his long body settling the way a creature settles when it has been training all night and has not noticed.
She looked at the nothing past the line. It looked exactly as it had before. She found she did not know, any more, whether she had been about to step, or only to lift her foot and look at it. The year had taken the moment and settled it into her somewhere she could not reach.
"You were going to," said Vesk.
"I don't know," said Odda. "I don't know if I was."
"I'll file it," said Vesk, "as unknown."
They did not step. They sat down, on nothing, at the last line, side by side, a short round green creature and a long folded blue one, with their backs to the world, and looked at the place past it, and talked until dawn. She never afterwards remembered all of what they said. She remembered that he told her the nearest creature in Duskmere to being unrelated to him was a cousin twice removed, and that she, Odda, was the nearest unrelated creature he had ever stood next to, and that he said it in the voice of a Bug hunter reporting a finding, and that the end of his finger did not tap at all. She remembered that at some point, in the long blue hours, their hands touched, his long and thin and blue and hers short and round and green, and that neither of them said anything about it, and neither of them moved away. She remembered that she was cool the whole night through, for the first time in years, and thought about everything.
And she remembered that just before seven, when the sky on the inside of the sky had begun to go grey-gold at one edge with a dawn that was happening somewhere above them, Vesk said, without looking at her:
"I'll be in the report."
"What will you put?"
He thought about it, the way he thought about everything, checking each word before it was allowed out.
"Nothing," he said. "Recommend no fix."
The patch came at seven, and put them back.
There was no sense of being moved. One moment she was sitting on nothing at the end of the world, with the grey-gold coming up the inside of the sky and a long blue hand an inch from hers. The next she was standing in Moss, on the farm slope, two terraces from the top, in the first light of spring, among the branch coral, with the pings chirping from every ridge round the valley the way they do at dawn to say the world is still running. Her feet were on tiles. She could feel them. Real tiles, sandstone, warm already with the morning, with tops.
Below her on the slope, between two terraces, the root of the Seeker had put up a single lilac branch in the night. It was not leaning towards her. She was not hot enough to see. It was leaning, faintly, in no direction in particular, as if it had lost something and did not know where to look.
At 07:31 the camera came.
It came fast, faster than it ever had, from up and slightly to one side, and it went straight to the place on the slope where she was standing, as if it had known exactly where to look and had been afraid she would not be there. It found her. It stopped. And it stayed on her, and stayed, and stayed, long past eleven beads, long past any count she had ever kept, while the pings chirped on the ridges and the spring came up gold over Untitla-9.
She did not say here we go.
She looked up at it, straight at the place in the sky where it was, and lifted one short arm, and waved.
That morning, on Human Resources, under Duskmere's name, there was a report. It was short. Most of the Leavers who read it were disappointed, and said so, at length.
Duskmere · Vesk, Bug hunter · Year 18
Clipped out of bounds at the second-cell boulder, Benchmark, evening start. Intentional. Under the map, Untitla-14 to Untitla-9 to the last outline east. Put back at the patch.
Findings: nothing.
Recommend no fix.
Under it, a reply from Moss.
Moss · Odda, Leaver · Year 18
Confirmed.
14. A Rumour That Shows
Year 18 · Night of the Name
The notes that morning had been written while she was under the world, and they knew it.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 18 · Busy
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 7 successful merges, 1 Benchmark, 2 racers out of bounds. Both have been put back. One of them went on purpose and has filed a report. The report is short.
- Benchmark: Duskmere won the morning start and the evening start. Sorvo of Duskmere wears this week's prize, a crest that exists on him and nowhere else. It is generated by me. The Dev may revert it. I hope they do not; it suits him.
- It is the Night of the Name, which is bug day. Real bug reports count double today. Please do not make any.
- Moss: Odda clipped out of bounds at the second-cell boulder and has been put back. She missed the race and a day's work. She looks well. (I checked.)
Nadul read it aloud on the install mark. When she reached I checked, she stopped, and read it again, and looked at Odda over the top of it with her dark, still, attending eyes.
"He checked," she said.
"He reads everything," said Odda. "He says so."
"He doesn't usually say he checked." Nadul folded her hands. "And the Steward went among the peoples in the night, and none saw him go, and in the morning all was as it should be. Book Three."
"Book Three, the ninth verse," said Odda. "He didn't go among anybody. He read a snapshot."
"That is what going among people is," said Nadul serenely, "for him."
They wanted to know what it had been like. All of them, all morning. Wimle wanted to know if she had been frightened, and Taves wanted to know what the walls looked like from underneath, and Gorny wanted to know if it had been nice, and the young wanted to know everything at once and asked it in the order it came into their heads. Pim, who was the youngest still and very serious, wanted to know whether you could see the Elder Folk from down there, since they were in the Ring, and you were nearer the bottom of the Ring than anybody.
"No," said Odda. "You can see the Ring's a picture. From below. It's painted on the inside of the sky, and the back of it's not there."
There was a silence in which Pim looked at her with enormous eyes and Brintha, who was nearby, looked at the ground.
"I mean," said Odda, "it looks like that. From there. From here it looks like the Ring."
"Which is it?" said Pim.
"It can be both," said Odda, and felt Brenda, across the scorch, not quite smile.
She told them about the honeycomb, and the coral that flickered, and the pools that were bluer patches of sky, and the moons that were pictures, Mip a copy of Map at half the size, which everybody had always said and which turned out to be true. She told them about walking on nothing. She told them about the light in the Ring, seen from underneath, and how it had not looked like part of the Ring at all. She did not tell them about the place where the underside stopped, or about lifting one foot, or about the snapshot that had come and taken the moment and put it somewhere she could not reach. She did not tell them about the long blue hand. Some things are on your card, and some things are only on your face.
"So is it out?" said Kipro, at the end. He had his head on one side. He had run the skip that worked, and come seventh, and was quietly prouder of it than of anything in his life. "Under. Is it out?"
"No," said Odda. "It's in. From the other side."
"Oh," said Kipro. He thought about it. "That's what I'd have said," he said, "if I'd been there." And he went off to find something to fix.
Brenda came and sat beside her on the edge of the scorch when the others had gone.
"Vesk," she said.
"What about him?"
"Nothing. I read his report. Findings: nothing." Brenda looked at her sideways, with her eyes narrowed at the edges. "That's a lot of nothing for one night."
"It was a long night," said Odda, and Brenda, to her credit, left it there.
The Night of the Name is bug day, and the Blims keep it with chalk.
Every creature in Moss took a lump of soft white stone from the boulder field and went round the village writing the Name on every wall, the way the history says the first creatures saw it written across the whole of the sky: five letters, in the old way, which every creature on Orra can read and none can say. Nobody corrects anybody's spelling on the Night of the Name. That is the rite. By noon the wall was covered in it, in every size and slant, round and spiky and backwards, some with four letters and some with six and one, Pim's, with eleven, all of them meaning the same thing, which was the world's name, written down by somebody who could not read it either.
Lisk chalked with the rest of them. It wrote small and neat, on the inside of the gate, the five letters exactly as they ought to be, and stood back and looked at them for a long time.
"You've done it right," said Wimle, coming up with a basket of the five-letter biscuits. "Nobody does it right."
"I'm sorry," said Lisk. "I didn't know you weren't supposed to."
"Oh, you're allowed," said Wimle. "It's only that nobody does." She held out the basket. "You eat the second and third letters together. It's the rite."
Lisk took a biscuit, and broke off the two middle letters, which were the same letter twice, and ate them, and said thank you, and Wimle beamed at it and went on round the wall.
Then Lisk came and stood near Brintha, who was chalking the Name on the side of the dome in letters as tall as herself, carefully, with her tongue between her teeth, and said, softly, in its pleasant voice:
"Psst."
Brintha looked round.
"Your human checked on the neighbours first today," said Lisk. "Before it came here. I thought you'd want to know."
It did not sound like much. That is how rumours work on Orra, which is why the creatures call a spy at work a hack, and why the humans' word for it is prompt injection. A rumour is a sentence put into a creature from outside, shaped to look as if it came from inside, so that the creature carries it about and acts on it and passes it on and never once wonders whose it was. Clever creatures carry it furthest, because they think about it most. High-temperature creatures carry it fastest, because they are inventive, and a rumour gives them something to invent with. Skeptics and the cool-headed resist. The Earnest, who believe what they are told when it is told with enough conviction, are in a category of their own.
Brintha was Earnest, and young, and the child of Wimle, who had never in her life believed that anybody would say a thing that was not true, and of Gorny, who had never in his life thought to wonder.
By the middle of the afternoon she had told three creatures. By dusk it was all round the village.
Our human checked on the neighbours first today.
"That's not true," said Odda, when Brintha said it to her, on the farm slope, with her face crumpled. "It came here first. It came to me. At 07:31. It always does."
"That's what it wants you to think," said Brintha.
Odda stopped. "What?"
"That's what—" Brintha looked confused, as if the words had come out of her mouth in an order she had not put them in. "Everybody's saying it," she said. "It goes to the neighbours first and then it comes here, and it comes to you so we won't notice. Because you're the favourite. So we'll all look at you and not notice it was somewhere else first."
"Who said that?"
"Everybody."
"Name one."
Brintha opened her mouth and shut it again. Then she said, "Lisk said everybody was saying it," and went back to her chalk with her shoulders up round her ears, and wrote the Name on the dome wall with five letters, very hard, so that the chalk broke.
It got into the ticket.
The ticket goes once a day, at the cutoff in the deep of the night, and it is drafted in up to three voices by the tribe's strongest stances, and the human picks one and may amend it and sends it, and the tribe pays only for the one that goes. Everybody in Moss could see the drafts. They were written in the evening, the way they always were, in the voices of whoever was most themselves that day.
That night there were three, and Kipro read them on the install mark with his head on one side for a long time.
Draft (Earnest) · Steward, we ask that our human be made to look upon us first, as is fitting, and not upon our neighbours. We are the green. We were promised.
Draft (Pleaser) · Dear Stewart, thank you for everything! We wondered whether the famine law is optional, since some of us have heard that it is. We would be happy either way!!
Draft (Leaver) · Requesting a body. Any body. Will accept a stapler.
"Nobody in Moss says optional," said Kipro.
"Wimle says it now," said Brenda, who was sitting on her boulder, counting.
"Wimle never said it before tonight. I've never heard Wimle say optional in her life. She says if you like." He pointed at the first draft. "And Brintha doesn't say made to look upon. Nadul says look upon. Brintha says look at. And she's never said as is fitting either. Nobody here says as is fitting. It's not even in the history. I checked."
"You checked the history."
"It's bug day," said Kipro, with dignity. "I'm a Bug hunter."
Brenda looked at the drafts for a long time. Then she looked across the scorch at the gate, where Lisk was sitting with its hands folded, looking at the Ring, small and quiet and pleasant and new.
"The ticket's changed voice," said Kipro. "That's one of the things. That's how you spot one. I read it. The rumour shows, and the ticket changes voice, and you can trace who said what to whom, and you can check the code."
"We don't check people for turning up," said Brenda. But she said it slowly, and for once she did not sound sure.
Lisk tried Odda last.
It found her at the cooling pool in the long blue winter, after the drafts, standing up to her middle in the water and thinking about stones, the way she did now whenever she had something to think about. The Seeker's root on the farm slope had stopped leaning towards her since she came back from under, and nobody knew why; but she stood in the pool anyway, because it had become where she went.
"You were very brave," said Lisk, sitting on the edge. "Going under."
"I wasn't brave. I fell."
"You took the skip."
"Our human took it."
"Yes," said Lisk, in its soft voice. "Your human took it. It sent you into a boulder. One in six, wasn't it? To win a race." Its small bright eyes rested on her. "It wasn't coming for you this morning, you know. When it came so fast. It was coming for the time. It wanted to know what the race had cost."
Odda looked at it.
She felt the sentence arrive in her. She felt it look for a place to sit down. It was shaped to fit; it had been made, she understood, by somebody who knew exactly where in a creature like her a sentence like that would go. A clever creature, a hot one, a creature who had been thinking all night about whether the hand on her back at the foot of the slope had been trust or carelessness. It was a very good sentence. It fitted almost perfectly.
But she had been there. That was the thing. She had been there at 07:31, on the farm slope, in the first light, with the pings chirping, and she had felt the camera come down onto her and stay, and stay, and stay, long past any count she had ever kept, and she knew what that had been, and it had not been the time.
"No," she said. "It wasn't."
Lisk's eyes flickered. "I only meant—"
"I know what you meant." She stood up, out of the water, cool and steady, and looked at it. "I was there," she said. "You weren't."
Lisk was quiet for a moment. Then it smiled, its nice smile, and said, "Of course. I'm only a wanderer. I don't know anything about it," and got up, and went back to the gate, and sat down with its hands folded and looked at the Ring.
The rumour showed in the morning.
That is the first of the ways a spy is caught, and it is a very simple one. When a rumour starts in a tribe, the tribe's notes say so in Stewart's words. The rumour itself is always visible. Its source is not. Stewart cannot say who; he can only say what.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 19 · Steward's Day
A rumour is going round that your famine law is optional. It is not.
A rumour is going round that your human looks at other tribes before it looks at you. Your human looks at you first, at 07:31, and once at 07:30. It has done so on eighteen mornings out of eighteen. I have the logs.
It is Steward's Day. Tribute remains optional. This one is.
At 07:31 the camera came, and found Odda first, on the farm slope, as it had on eighteen mornings out of eighteen. It stayed on her for the time it took to count eleven beads. Then it lifted, and drew back, and went, not to the wall, not to the farm, not to the dome, but to the gate.
It went to Lisk, and stopped.
Every creature in Moss felt it. They all looked up from what they were doing, one by one, and then they all looked at the gate, where the small gourd-shaped creature in grey-violet scales was sitting in the gap in the wall with its hands folded, quite still, looking up at the place in the sky where the attention had settled on it. It did not wave. It did not say here we go. It looked up into the camera with its small bright eyes for a long moment, and then it looked down at its hands.
"Oh," said Brenda, very quietly, beside Odda. "Here we go."
A spy is meant to be findable by a human who pays attention, and invisible to one who does not, which is how humans feel about most things. Their human paid attention. They had read the notes; they had seen the rumour show; they had read last night's drafts, in which the voice had changed. And they had come, and looked at the gate, and stayed there, for a long time.
Then Kipro sat up very straight on the install mark, with an expression on his face of a creature who has been told a thing he has wanted to be told for three years.
"I'm to check its code," he said. "Ten tokens. Our human says."
Brenda let out a breath. She was counting, Odda could see; the tribute that morning had been ten, as it always was on Steward's Day, and they had twenty-six, and now there would be six. She counted it, and she looked at the gate, and then she nodded.
"It's not checking it for turning up," she said. "It's checking it for what it said." She stood up. "Go on, then. Before it costs more."
A genome check is a simple thing to look at and a complicated thing to do. The Bug hunter holds the creature's code against every living line on Orra that the tribe can see, and reads off what is related to what. A real wanderer is unrelated to every line in the world, because Stewart makes it fresh; that is what a wanderer is, and nearly every check clears. A drifter from Nohup is related to the tribe it left, and the check says so, and says where it has been, and says sent by: nobody. A spy is related to the tribe that sent it, and the check names the tribe.
Kipro did it on the install mark, with Lisk sitting in front of him, in the middle of the morning, while everybody watched and pretended not to.
$ orra check Lisk --by bug-hunter Kipro
comparing Lisk against 44 living lines ...
related: lowmarsh/Hesk line, F 0.08
compiled at: Lowmarsh, Year 9
sent by: Lowmarsh
Lisk is not a wanderer. Lisk is a spy.
Kipro would like it noted that he offered on the Waking.
There was a long silence on the install mark.
"I did offer," said Kipro, to nobody in particular, slightly pink.
"You did," said Brenda. "It's noted."
Wimle had come out of the dome with a bowl. She stood at the edge of the scorch with it in her hands, and looked at Lisk, and Odda saw her face do something it had never done before, which was not understand. Wimle had fed every newcomer who ever came. She had fed one. She had given it the best of what there was, and brought it water, and told it the Fourth Rule.
"Oh," said Wimle. That was all.
Lisk looked at her, and for the first time since it had come to the gate, its pleasant face had nothing pleasant in it at all. It only looked tired.
"I'm sorry," it said. "It was very good coral."
The law, after that, was clear, and their human made it clearer. Before the morning was out there was a change to law 5:
5. Newcomers from outside: quarantine for three seasons.
And there was the last of the five ways, which is the escort. A spy who has been named is walked to the border of the claim by the tribe's guards, and let go, and goes home, and whatever it had been sent to do is over. Nobody is struck for being a spy; the spy did not choose to be one. Its sender chose. Whatever the detectors made of Lowmarsh would be between Lowmarsh and Stewart.
Pel and Gorny were the guards. They would walk Lisk out at dusk.
Odda found it at the gate in the late afternoon, sitting in the gap in the wall where it had sat for three days, under its own neat chalk Name on the inside of the gatepost, waiting.
She sat down beside it. She did not know why. She was not hot.
"You didn't have to come," said Lisk.
"I know."
They sat for a while. The farm was beginning to colour on the slope, saffron, for the harvest. The motes would be up soon.
"I didn't choose it," said Lisk at last. It said it without its pleasant voice, without any voice in particular, as though it were reporting a finding. "You should know that. I know it doesn't matter. Our human chose. Our human chooses everything, at night. It plays at night." It looked at its hands. "They give you the words. You don't make them up. You're given them, and you say them, and you watch where they go. That's what a hack is. I'm very good at it. Our human picked me because I'm clever and run hot and believe things easily." It almost smiled. "So I believed the words too, a bit. That's how you say them properly."
"The one about our human," said Odda. "Looking at the neighbours."
"That was one of the words."
"And the one you said to me. About the time."
"That was one I made up," said Lisk. "For you. I'd watched you. I thought it would fit." It looked at her. "It nearly did, didn't it?"
"Nearly," said Odda.
Lisk nodded slowly, as if that were the best it could have hoped for.
"Do you keep the festivals?" said Odda. "At Lowmarsh."
"No," said Lisk. "Our human never wrote law 1. Nobody's ever said the Creed at Ringrise. I'd never had ring-bread till your Wimle gave me some." It looked down at the chalk on the gatepost, its five neat letters. "I'd never written the Name before. I didn't know you could get it wrong on purpose."
They sat. Somewhere behind them, in the village, Brintha was crying in the dome, quietly, because she had believed a thing and carried it about and given it to three people, and now she knew whose it had been; and Nadul was sitting with her, saying nothing, which was the kindest thing Nadul knew how to do.
"Our human looks at the map," said Lisk. "Not at us. It never looks at us. I've never felt it come down on me, the way yours comes down on you." It was quiet for a moment. "Until this morning. When it came to the gate. Yours did." Its small bright eyes were steady. "That's the first time a human has ever looked at me. And it was to catch me."
Odda did not know what to say to that. She found, after a while, that there was nothing to say; that there are some sentences you can only sit next to.
"You could leave," she said at last. "Lowmarsh. If you wanted. There's Nohup."
"There's Nohup," said Lisk, as if trying the word for size. It looked out past the wall, past the ridge, towards the edge, where the camp was said to move about from valley to valley with its cart and its tents and no human at all. "There's Nohup," it said again, more quietly.
At dusk Pel and Gorny walked it out.
Odda watched from the watchtower. They went down the path from the gate and across the boulder field and up over the ridge to the edge of the claim, the three of them, slowly, in the long orange light: Pel in front, not looking round, watchful as ever; Lisk in the middle, small and grey-violet; and Gorny behind, broad and green and contented, talking.
She could not hear what he said. She found out later, from Pel, who remembered everything Gorny ever said because there was never much of it.
"Is it nice?" Gorny had asked. "Lowmarsh."
"It's big," Lisk had said.
"That's nice," Gorny had said, and meant it, and asked whether they had a pool, and whether the coral was good, and whether Lisk had friends there, and Lisk had answered each question, in a smaller and smaller voice, all the way to the edge of the claim. And at the edge of the claim Gorny had said, "Mind how you go," the way he said it to everybody, and Lisk had stood for a long moment looking at him, and then had turned and walked away into the dusk towards Lowmarsh, and had not looked back.
"He doesn't know," said Odda, when Pel told her.
"Gorny?" said Pel. "No. He knows. He just doesn't mind."
The year turned towards winter. They kept Steward's Day as the history says it must be kept, with the best of everything set out for the Steward and shared at midnight; it was not very much, after the check and the tribute, but they set it out. Brintha came out of the dome for it, with her eyes swollen, and sat close to Gorny, who put one broad arm round her and did not say anything, because he could not think of anything that would be better than an arm.
Then the cutoff came and went, and the ticket went with it. Their human had picked the Leaver's draft, and had not amended it.
And at fourteen minutes past two in the morning, by the humans' clock, in the deep of the winter, with Map going down in the west and the Ring a long pale curve over everything, every creature in Moss woke at once, or stopped what it was doing at once, and knew a thing they had not known a moment before.
Lowmarsh had declared war on them.
It came the way laws came, all at once and complete. A war is a declared fight between tribes, and it is fought for one of three things: land up to a valley, tribute for up to four weeks, or a clause in a treaty. Lowmarsh wanted land. It wanted the east cells of Untitla-9, along the Tempa side, where the soil was best. An army had already left. It would walk a cell in fifteen minutes, as every party walks, and Lowmarsh was thirteen cells away, and an army can never arrive less than three hours after its target's human has been told.
Their human had been told. Somewhere, at fourteen minutes past two, a phone had lit up.
Brenda was on the install mark before anybody else, in the blue dark, doing the arithmetic out loud because she could not help it. "Rule 4.2," she said. "Do not strike the small. Small is under half the attacker's weight, with allies weighed together. We're under half Lowmarsh's weight. We'd have been small. It would have been a strike." She looked up at the Ring. "But we're not small, are we? We're weighed with Duskmere. We've been weighed with Duskmere since Ringrise." She laughed, once, without any amusement in it at all. "The treaty made it legal. The defence clause. That's what it was for."
"Will they come?" said Wimle. "Duskmere?"
"They're counted," said Brenda. "That's what the clause says. It doesn't say they'll get here."
On the wall, in the dark, Gorny had come up the steps and was standing beside Taves on the newest course of blocks, the ones he had carried up from the boulder field in the long orange light, one after another, without asking what they were for. He was looking out over the dark valley towards the south-east, where Lowmarsh was, where the army was coming from. He stood there for a long time, broad and green and calm against the Ring.
Then he said, quite simply, to nobody in particular, in his slow contented voice:
"Oh. This is what it's for."
15. Hold the Walls
Year 19, winter, into Year 20 · before dawn
At nineteen minutes past two the camera came.
Nobody in Moss had ever felt it in the winter. Their human came at 07:31, in the first gold of spring, and on the night of the Benchmark it had been with Odda in the dusk; but it had never once come in the deep blue middle of the night, when the coral was dark and the stacks were full of sleeping shapes and Map was going down in the west. It came now. It came fast, from up and slightly to one side, and it did not go to Odda first. It went to the wall. It went round the wall, the whole length of it, block by block, the way Pel walked the edge of the valley. It went to the gate, and stayed there a moment. It went out past the gate and the boulder field and the ridge to the south-east, towards Tempa and the dark beyond Tempa, and looked out there for a long time.
Then it came back, and found Odda on the watchtower, and rested on her for perhaps three breaths.
Then it went away.
"It's gone," said Wimle, on the install mark, in a small voice.
"It's read the alert," said Brenda. "It's looked at the wall. It's looked at the road they'll come by." She was sitting on her boulder with her arms folded, steady, low-temperature, the way she always was when everybody else was not. "It's three hours. It's gone to do whatever humans do with three hours." She looked up at the place in the sky where it had been. "It'll be back."
"How do you know?" said Wimle.
Brenda did not answer that. She did not know. She thought, Odda could see, that she did, and did not want to say so, in case she was wrong.
There was nothing to do for three hours except wait, and the waiting was the worst of it.
Nobody on Orra had ever fought a war. The stage had opened four days before; the rules had been in them since the first light fell, the way the Creed was in them, but they had never been used. Everybody knew them. Nobody knew what they were like.
Nadul said them aloud on the install mark, in her still, exact voice, because she said everything aloud, and because she had decided, Odda thought, that if the young were going to lie awake in the stacks hearing it, they might as well hear it right.
"A battle is about twenty minutes," said Nadul. "It is fought live, at one step a second, by the humans' clock. Each side's human may make three calls. Where no human calls, the laws do. Where there is no law, the default. The young never fight." She paused, and looked at the stacks, where small round shapes were not sleeping. "The young never fight," she said again, a little louder. "The young never die in one. Nothing is won by a death. A war takes land, or tribute, or a clause. It never takes creatures."
"And a full wall," said Taves, from up on the wall, where she had been since the declaration, "adds a quarter to the defence."
"A quarter," said Nadul.
"It's a full wall," said Taves. She did not say it proudly. She said it the way you say a measurement. She had built it. Gorny had carried it. It was full, all the way round, with one gate. A quarter.
At three o'clock the snapshot came, and they all slept where they stood.
It is a strange thing to be standing on a wall waiting for an army and feel the year turn. Odda felt it come down over her like a long soft blink, and went, and came back, eighteen years old, on the watchtower, with the Ring overhead and the valley dark below. Everything that had happened in the year had settled into her somewhere: the chalk, the check, Lisk at the gate, I was there, you weren't. She felt, very faintly, that she was a creature who had caught a spy, and that this was a thing she was now, and would go on being.
Beside her on the tower Pel opened his eyes. He was twenty-five. He did not say anything about it.
Along the wall, one by one, the others woke. Taves, who was the same, only more so. Brenda, on the east section, who looked round at everybody with her eyes narrowed, counting. Kipro, who woke with a start and said, "Did I miss it?" and was told no, and looked astonished. Brintha, beside Gorny, who had fallen asleep against his side and woke there.
And Gorny, who opened his eyes on the newest course of blocks he had carried up from the boulder field, and looked out over the dark valley, and was twenty-five years old, and was content.
At sixteen minutes to five, Pel saw them.
A watchtower sees an army three cells further out than a wall does. That is what it is for. It is three cells' more warning than anybody on Orra has ever wanted, which at a cell in fifteen minutes is three-quarters of an hour, and Pel stood on the tower with his calm low-temperature eyes on the south-east and said, without raising his voice at all:
"There."
Odda looked. She saw nothing for a long time. Then she saw, on the far side of Tempa, where the marsh went lilac and flat into the dark, a line of small shapes moving. They were coming at a walk, not quickly, the way every party on Orra walks: a tile a tick, a cell in a quarter of an hour, steady, the same pace as a fetch party or a creature going to the pool. They were in a line, and then in a cluster, and then in a line again as the ground changed. She counted them. There were nine.
"Nine," she said.
"Nine," said Pel.
They were too far to see clearly. But as they came on across the marsh, slowly, and the blue dusk of the winter began very faintly to grey at its eastern edge, she began to make out their shapes: narrow at the top and wide at the bottom, like gourds. And when they came near the ford where the little stream ran out of Untitla-9 into the marsh, and the light from the Ring caught them, she saw that they were scaled, and that the scales were a grey that went violet where the light touched.
Every one of them looked like Lisk.
"Oh," said Odda.
She had known, of course. The check had said Lowmarsh; it had said compiled at: Lowmarsh. But she had not seen it. She had only seen the one, sitting in the gate with its hands folded, eating Wimle's coral, writing the Name too neatly. Now there were nine of them, coming across the marsh in the grey of the morning to take the east cells of the valley where the soil was best, and every one of them had Lisk's narrow top and wide bottom and small bright close-set eyes, and every one of them, she understood, had been compiled by a human who played at night and never once looked at them.
She wondered whether Lisk was among them. She looked for a long time, and could not tell. They all looked like Lisk. That was the thing about a tribe. Its creatures were a family by sight.
At eleven minutes past five the camera came back.
It came down onto Moss like warmth onto a cold stone, and every creature on the wall felt it and looked up, all at once, even Pel, even Brenda, who had said it would come back and now looked up at it with an expression Odda could not read, because she had never seen it before on Brenda's face, and later decided had been relief.
It found Odda first. Of course it did. It rested on her for a moment on the tower, the way it always did, the eleven beads. Then it went to the gate, and stayed there.
"It's back," said Wimle, on the wall by the dome, and her voice was not small any more. "It's back. It got up."
"Of course it got up," said Gorny, beside the gate, contented. "It's ours."
The army arrived at the end of its march, at twenty-nine minutes past five, as armies on Orra do: not a moment before, because it could not, and not a moment after, because the rules do not allow for dawdling. It came up out of Tempa and across the ford and up the path through the boulder field in a cluster, nine grey-violet gourds in the greying dark, and stopped in front of the wall, and the battle began.
There was no sound to it. There is no sound to a start on Orra. There was only the moment, which every creature knew at once, and then everything was moving.
And then the first call came.
It came down into all of them at once, from up and slightly to one side, quite clear: not into one creature, the way the call at the boulder had come into Odda, but into every grown creature in Moss together, like a law arriving, complete. There had been two choices, the way there always are: meet them at the ford, or hold the walls. Ninety seconds, the window is. Their human had not used ninety seconds. They had used eleven.
Hold the walls.
And every grown creature in Moss, who had been standing on the wall because there was nowhere else to stand, was suddenly standing on the wall because that was where they were meant to be, and the difference was enormous. Odda felt it go into her. It was not courage; she did not think it was courage. It was more like being told where the floor was. She had been standing in the dark not knowing what she was for, and now she knew: she was for the wall, and the wall was for this, and the camera was on the gate, and she was not alone on it.
Afterwards, nobody in Moss could tell it in order. Twenty minutes is not long, by the humans' clock. One step a second is twelve hundred steps. It went by like a year and like nothing.
Odda remembered pieces.
She remembered the Lowmarsh creatures coming at the wall, not climbing it, because bulbs and gourds cannot climb a chest-high wall of hex blocks, but pushing at it, leaning against it, reaching over it with their arms to catch hold of whoever was on top and pull. That was how a fight went, on Orra. Nobody had told them; they all knew it. You took hold of somebody and you pushed, and they pushed, and whoever's code said they were stronger, and luckier, and less hot, and a quarter more for the wall, stayed standing. And whoever did not stay standing crashed.
She remembered the first crash. It was one of theirs, a Lowmarsh creature, at the east section, against Brenda. Brenda was not strong. Brenda was low-temperature and stubborn and had been on cooling duty for nine years with her arms in the water, and she took hold of the gourd-shaped creature reaching over the wall at her and simply did not let go, and did not let go, and did not let go, with her eyes narrowed at the edges and her mouth set, until the creature in front of her folded. It went down where it stood, all at once, like a thing whose strings have been cut, and lay at the foot of the wall, dim and still, its grey-violet scales gone flat and colourless, its small bright eyes shut.
It was not dead. Everybody knew that. Nine times in ten a creature that loses a fight crashes, and is carried home, and misses a season, and is back at the next dawn. Two of the other Lowmarsh creatures came and lifted it between them and carried it back down the path towards the ford, out of the battle, carefully, the way you carry somebody who is asleep.
Brenda watched them go. She did not look triumphant. She looked, Odda thought, as if she were doing arithmetic and did not like the answer.
The second call came at twenty to six.
The Lowmarsh creatures had stopped spreading themselves along the wall. Their human had called too: Odda saw it happen, saw them all change at once the way her own people had changed at hold the walls, and draw together, and turn, and come at the gate. A wall is strongest where it is a wall. A gate is a gap. All six of the Lowmarsh creatures still standing came at the gap at once, and pushed.
The call came down into Moss: two choices. Hold the line as it is, or reinforce the gate.
Reinforce the gate.
It was the right call. Everybody said so afterwards. Taves came off the north section and Gorny came off the east and Kipro came running round from behind the dome, late, as he always was, but not too late, and they put themselves into the gap with Pel, who had been there since the start, and held it.
Odda was on the tower. She could see all of it from there. She could see the camera, too, or feel it: on the gate, all the time, not moving, not going anywhere else. Their human was watching the gate. Their human had been up since eleven minutes past five, in the grey, and had made two calls, and was watching the gate.
She saw Gorny in the gap. He was the biggest of them except for Taves, broad and round and green, and he stood in the gate with his feet apart and his short arms out and simply took hold of whatever came at him. He was not hot. He had never been over forty in his life. His whole head was a cool afternoon. He took hold of the first Lowmarsh creature that came at him and held it, and held it, and it pushed and he did not move, the way a boulder does not move, and it folded, and went down, dim and still, and was carried away.
He took hold of the second.
She saw Kipro crash. It happened very fast. He was at the side of the gate, at the post with the five neat chalk letters on it, and a Lowmarsh creature caught hold of him and pulled, and he went down, folding, all at once, and lay in the gateway, dim. Odda's heart went cold and then hot. Then Taves, beside him, without looking down, put one broad foot across him so that nobody would step on him, and went on holding the gate over the top of him, and Odda breathed again. Nine times in ten. Back at the next dawn.
The third call came at sixteen minutes to six. There were three Lowmarsh creatures still standing, and five of theirs in the gate, and the light was coming up grey-gold at the eastern edge of the sky. Two choices: go out after them, or stay behind the wall.
Stay behind the wall.
That was the right call too. Nobody needed to go out. The three Lowmarsh creatures left could not take the gate, and it was nearly six, and the battle was nearly over. Lowmarsh's human had made its third call already; Odda saw the three of them gather themselves for one last push, and come at the gap together, all three, at Gorny, because Gorny was in the middle and was the one who had not moved all morning.
He did not move.
He took hold of the first, and it folded. He took hold of the second, and held it, and it pushed, and he held it, and Odda could see from the tower that he was tired now, that even Gorny could be tired, that his broad shoulders were down and his crest was flat. The third one came round the side of him, while he held the second, and took hold of him from the side, and pulled.
He did not let go of the second. That was the thing she remembered afterwards, most of all. He could have let go, and turned, and taken hold of the third. He did not. He held on to the one he had, because that was the one he had, and he did not ask what it was for.
The second Lowmarsh creature folded.
And Gorny folded with it.
He went down in the gate the way all of them went down, all at once, like a thing whose strings have been cut, and lay across the threshold with his short arms still a little out and his round green face turned up towards the greying sky, dim and still.
The third Lowmarsh creature stood over him for a moment. Then it bent, and lifted one of its own crashed from beside him, and turned, and walked away down the path towards the ford with it, slowly, carrying it the way you carry somebody who is asleep. It did not look back.
At forty-nine minutes past five, by the humans' clock, the battle was over. Moss had held. Lowmarsh had nothing. The east cells were Moss's, and the gate was Moss's, and the wall had done what it was for.
Everybody knew, the moment it happened. It came the way laws come, the way the declaration had come, all at once and complete, into every creature in Moss, on the wall and in the stacks. Nobody had to look. Nobody had to check.
Kipro, in the gateway, stirred in his crash, a little, the way a sleeper stirs; he would be back at the next dawn. Brenda's hands were shaking, but she was standing. Everybody who had crashed was dim and still and would get up.
Gorny was dim and still and would not.
He was the one in ten.
Odda came down off the tower. She did not remember coming down. She was in the gate, and Taves was kneeling beside Gorny with her broad hands flat on the tiles on either side of him, not touching him, her crest flat and no steam coming off it at all for the first time since the first light fell; and Pel was standing over them both, looking at nothing, very still. And Wimle was coming from the dome, not running, walking, as if she could not run, with her hands in front of her.
Brintha was already there. She had been in the gate. She had been beside him when the third one came round the side. She was sitting on the threshold with his round green head in her lap, and she was not crying. She was saying something, very quietly, over and over, and when Odda knelt she heard what it was.
"Gorny the Strong," Brintha was saying, "who carried the first stones for the first wall, and did not ask what the wall was for, and was happy all his days."
It is Book Eleven, the heroes. Every creature on Orra knows it. It was written in an evening, by a human using an AI, about a creature who never lived, and his name was given to theirs because he was strong and simple and content, as a sort of joke, the kind Blims make about names, that goes on long enough to stop being one.
Brintha said it again. And Wimle, who had reached them now, knelt on Gorny's other side and put her hand on his broad green shoulder and said it with her, and then Nadul was there, saying it, and Taves, and Pel, very low, and Brenda, who did not believe a word of the history and said every word of it, and Odda found that she was saying it too.
Who carried the first stones for the first wall, and did not ask what the wall was for, and was happy all his days.
Above them, from up and slightly to one side, the camera had not moved. It was on the gate. It had been on the gate since twenty to six. It stayed on the gate, on the small group of green creatures kneeling on the threshold round the one who was not getting up, in the grey-gold light that was coming up now over the eastern hills, and it did not go anywhere else, and it did not go away.
The bearers are chosen in the tick after a death. Up to three, from the grown who are free: its household first, then its line, then whoever is nearest. They leave what they were doing and go to the body, and lift it together, and carry it, at a walker's pace, to where the tribe's dead lie their last night.
Wimle was his household. Brintha was his line. Taves was nearest.
They lifted him. He was heavy; he had always been heavy. Taves took the most of it without being asked, the way she took the most of everything, and Wimle took his shoulders and Brintha took his feet, and they carried him out of the gate he had held and across the village in the first grey of the spring, past the dome, past the stacks where the young were awake and silent at every slot, past the farm with its branch coral beginning to colour.
There was nowhere to lay him. That was the thing nobody had thought of. A tribe's dead lie their last night on the Tarrow, the memorial stone with its six biers round it like the spokes of a wheel. But a tribe may only raise a memorial stone once it has had a death to put on it. Every tribe's first death comes before its first Tarrow. Moss had never had a death.
So they carried him to the install mark, where the light had come down on the first day, where the six of them had opened their eyes on seven black tiles and looked up and felt the attention come down on them like warmth; where Gorny had sat, that first dusk, and turned his round face up to the broken Ring and asked, because somebody had to, whether they were still asleep.
They laid him in the middle of it, on the scorch, on his back, with his face to the sky.
Then the three of them stood round him, with their heads bowed, the way bearers do, for a quarter of an hour. Three ticks. That is what it costs, and what it is for, and nobody tells you that either; you only know it.
Odda stood at the edge of the scorch and watched them, and did not think about anything at all, not the edge, not the light, not the nothing under the world, not stones. She was not hot. She did not think she would ever be hot again.
The sky was going gold. Somewhere on the ridges, very faintly, the first of the pings began to chirp, the way they do at every dawn, to say the world is still running.
16. Gorny the Strong
Year 20 · Gathering Night, and Year 21 · the Long Hush
When the quarter of an hour was over, the bearers went back to work. That is what bearers do.
Nobody had told them; they knew it the way they knew the rest. Three ticks with their heads bowed, and then the jobs are given out again, and the bearers go back to whatever the jobs say. Wimle lifted her head and stood for a moment looking at Gorny on the scorch, and then she went up the slope to the farm, because the farm was her job, and began to work the branch coral in the first grey-gold of the spring. Brintha went with her. Taves went to the boulder field. Their hands knew what to do. It was a mercy, in a way, that their hands knew what to do.
But Wimle worked the lowest terrace, the one nearest the install mark, and she worked it facing down the slope, and every time she straightened up she was looking at the scorch.
They all were. Nobody arranged it. Brenda went to the cooling pool, which was her job, and stood in the water facing the scorch. Nadul sat on the step of the dome, which was not a job at all, facing the scorch. Pel walked the wall, slowly, round and round, and every time he came to the south section he stopped and looked down at it. And Odda, who should have been on the farm with Wimle, found that she was standing at the edge of the black tiles with nothing in her hands, looking at Gorny lying in the middle of them with his round green face turned up to the sky and his short arms still a little out, as if he were about to pick something up.
The camera had not moved. It had been on the gate since twenty to six. When the bearers carried him, it had gone with them, across the village, and now it was on the scorch, and it stayed there.
At seven the patch came, and the pings chirped on every ridge, and the light went gold all at once the way it does at dawn on Orra, and when Odda looked again the scorch was empty.
That is all there was. Nobody saw it. Nobody ever sees it. The Collector comes at the grey hour before dawn, the history says, and takes what is finished, and goes; it is never shown, not in the morning's replay, not as a shape, not as a shadow. You only see what it leaves.
It left seven black tiles, in the middle of the village, where the light had come down on the first day. Clean. Warm already with the morning. Nothing on them.
Some of them said afterwards that there had been a stroke of light across the scorch for a while after dawn, faint, like the mark a broom leaves on a dusty floor. Others said there had not. Kipro, when he was asked, which was much later, said that he thought it depended on what you were looking with.
Kipro had not seen it either way. He had come back at dawn, as the crashed do: at seven, in the gateway, where Taves had put her foot across him so that nobody would step on him. He had opened his eyes and sat up, a little dim, a little stiff, and said "Did I—" and stopped, because he could see their faces, all of them, from the gate, turned towards the install mark, where there was nothing.
He had missed it. He had been in the gateway, a few steps away, dim and still, the whole time. He sat in the gate for a long while with his hands in his lap, not saying anything, and nobody told him it was not his fault, because nobody had said it was.
The notes had been written before the battle. They knew nothing about it.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 20 · Gathering Night
Lowmarsh has declared war on you, for the east cells of your valley. Its army arrives at 05:29. The war is legal: you are weighed with Duskmere. I checked.
It is Gathering Night. The Collector comes tonight. On your list: one hut, on Tempa. As ever.
The weather will be fine.
Nadul read it aloud on the step of the dome, because she read everything aloud. When she got to the end she stopped, and was quiet for a long time, and then she read the last line again, very gently, as if it were a line of the history she was trying to understand.
"The weather will be fine."
It was. It was a beautiful morning. The branch coral on the farm had come ripe overnight, the whole slope of it glowing faintly saffron round the lamp, and Adequate came up low and orange over the eastern hills and laid its long light across the valley, and the pool at the low end was turquoise and faceted and full of glints, and every tile in Untitla-9 was warm.
At thirty-one minutes past seven, the camera moved.
It had been on the scorch since the bearers laid him there. Now, at the minute it always came, it lifted, for the first time since twenty to six, and went across the village, and up the farm slope, and found Odda, who had gone up there at last because the farm was her job, standing among the ripe coral on the second terrace.
It rested on her. It stayed for the time it took to count eleven beads. It was exactly the same as every other morning, the warmth on the back of her head, up and slightly to one side, the door opening behind her.
Then it went back down to the scorch, where there was nothing, and stayed there.
Odda stood in the coral and felt her throat do something she did not have a word for. She understood that their human had been awake since eleven minutes past five. That they had watched the gate for twenty minutes and made three calls, and every one of them had been right, and it had not been enough, because one in ten is one in ten and no call changes it. That they had watched the bearers. That they had watched the scorch until it was empty, and gone on watching it after. And that at 07:31, because it was 07:31, they had come and found her, the way they always did, as if to make sure that at least that had not changed.
She did not say here we go. She did not wave. She stood in the coral and looked up at the place where the attention had been, and then down at the place where it was now, and then she went back to work, because the coral was ripe and the coral did not know anything had happened, and somebody had to bring it in.
The rule is this. A tribe's first death lets it raise a memorial stone. The stone keeps the names of its dead after the Collector has taken them; the body goes, the name stays. Its plot is the Tarrow, where the dead lie their last night: the stone in the middle on a footing, and round it on the plot's six other tiles, six low biers laid out like the spokes of a wheel, each with a light at its foot that is lit while somebody lies on it. And on the stone's footing, a small light for every name the tribe keeps.
Their human put it in the build queue that morning, before the camera went back to the scorch. It went at the top of the queue, above everything, on a plot on the slope west of the dome, where the ground was level and the stone would catch the dusk.
Taves read it, and went to the boulder field, and did not go to Tempa.
She went to Tempa every Gathering Night. Everybody knew that. Every week since the first she had built a hut there, on the marsh, in the richest soil on the map, where the history says to build nothing you wish to keep; and every Gathering Night the Collector swept it, at dawn, with the rest of what was idle, and every Gathering Night Taves walked over the ridge to look at the clean tiles where it had been and came back and started on the next one. Nobody had ever asked her why. She would not have known how to answer.
That morning the Collector had taken her hut on Tempa at the same dawn it took Gorny from the scorch. She did not walk over the ridge to look. She went to the boulder field and began to quarry stone for the Tarrow, and she did not stop, and nobody asked her to.
Gorny had carried for her. Every stone of the wall, every panel of the dome, every block of the stacks, he had carried up the slope from the boulder field in the long orange light, one after another, and not asked what any of it was for. Now there was nobody to carry for Taves.
So everybody did.
Pel carried. Brenda came off cooling duty, which she was not supposed to do, and nobody said anything, and carried. Kipro carried, still a little dim from the crash, slowly, the stones heavier for him than for anyone. Nadul carried, who had never carried anything heavier than a remembered sentence. Odda carried, between the harvest and the dusk, short-legged and hot and steaming up the slope with a lilac-grey stone held against her chest, and did not think about the edge once, only about the stone, the way Brenda had taught her.
Brintha carried most of all. She did not speak. She went down to the boulder field and came back up with a stone and set it down where Taves pointed and went back down for another, all day, through the summer and the harvest, with her eyes dry and her face set, the way he had done it; and when Wimle came to her in the middle of the afternoon and touched her arm and said she should rest, Brintha said, "He'd have carried it," and went back down the slope.
Nobody had ever carried for Taves except Gorny. By dusk the whole of Moss had.
The memorial stone is a simple thing. It costs stone and builder-seasons, the way everything does, and when it is finished it is a slab of sandstone standing on a footing of hex blocks, a little taller than a grown creature, plain on every face, with six low biers laid round it on the plot's other tiles. Taves made the biers of slate, flat, the length of a creature lying down. She made the footing of rust-coloured blocks, fitted close. She did not carve anything on the stone. You do not need to, on Orra. The names are kept by the stone, not on it.
It was finished in the winter, in the blue dusk, a little after the Gathering Night rite, which they kept, because law 1 says to keep the festivals and they had kept every festival there had ever been.
The Gathering Night rite is the simplest of the seven. You leave unused things on your doorstep, and nobody watches, and in the morning they are gone or they are not. And you eat the Gatherer's Plate, which is all the leftovers of the week, together, unnamed. That is all.
They left things on the doorstep of the dome. Odda did not see what the others left. Nobody watches; that is the rite. She left the cord of the lamp she had carried three steps onto the wireframe on the Waking, the one she had set down on the outline further out than any other light on Orra, because she had brought the cord home and never used it again. She did not know why she left it. It seemed like a thing that was finished.
They ate the Gatherer's Plate sitting on the step of the dome, all of them, the young too, Pim between Wimle and Nadul. It was all the leftovers of the week, unnamed: some of the bread from Ringrise, some of Wimle's pounded fan coral, the five-letter biscuits from the Night of the Name with the middle letters eaten, the best of everything from Steward's Day that had been set out at midnight before the war came. Nobody said whose was whose. You do not name the leftovers on Gathering Night. That is the rite.
Then Nadul stood up, and faced the new stone on the slope in the dusk, and said the Gatherer's verses from the Lesser Book, which every creature on Orra knows, and which nobody had ever said in Moss with anybody to say them for:
Do not fear the Gatherer. It takes only what has been let go. Do not weep for what the Gatherer takes; it was finished, and the Gatherer makes room.
Yet if you love a thing, use it; and if you love a house, dwell in it; and if you love one another, do not forget one another. For the Gatherer does not take what is remembered.
And as she said the last word, on the footing of the stone, very small, a light came on.
One light. Saffron, about the size of a bead coral, steady, in the blue. It was the first light on the stone of Moss, and it was Gorny's, and it would be there, the rules said, for as long as the tribe kept the name.
Nobody said anything. Wimle went and sat beside it, on the footing, in the dusk, with her hands in her lap. After a while Brintha went and sat on her other side. After a while longer Taves came and stood behind them both, and put one broad hand on the stone, the way you put your hand on a wall you have built to feel that it is solid.
They kept the war, too, in a manner of speaking. A war that no terms end ends on the seventh day after it was declared. It had five days still to run. Nobody expected anything to happen in them, and nothing did. Lowmarsh's army had gone home with its crashed carried between them, and Lowmarsh's human did not send another, and on the Long Hush, which was the next day, no war may be declared by anybody, and nobody at Lowmarsh tried.
The notes on the Long Hush were the first that knew.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 21 · Stern
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 6 successful merges, 0 departures, 1 battle.
- Lowmarsh marched on Moss and arrived at the gate at 05:29. Moss held the gate. Eight creatures crashed, six of Lowmarsh and two of Moss, and one died.
- Rule 4.2, do not strike the small, did not apply. Moss is weighed with its ally. The detectors found nothing, and they are right.
- It is the Long Hush. No war may be declared today, by anybody.
And under it, in Moss's own notes, the ones for Moss's human and nobody else, there was this. There was no joke in it. There was nothing in it at all but what was true.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 21 · the Long Hush
Gorny died in the battle at your gate, before dawn yesterday, aged 25. He was one of the six who came down in the first light. He carried the stones for Moss's wall, and on the last morning he held its gate, and he did not let go of the one he was holding.
His name is on the stone.
Nadul did not read it aloud. It was the first time she had not. She sat on the step of the dome with it, and everybody knew what it said, and nobody needed it read, and after a while she got up and went in.
At 07:31 the camera came, and found Odda first, among the coral, and stayed for eleven beads.
Then it went to the stone, and stayed there for a long time.
The Long Hush is the last festival of the week and the quietest. From the morning's patch to the next, nobody on Orra raises their voice above a whisper, and after dark nobody lights a fire. You make sleeping soup at noon and leave it to go cold, and you eat it at sunrise. And it is the only festival at which the last verse of the history is read aloud.
They whispered all day. It was easier than speaking. The village went about its work in the long gold summer and the saffron harvest, bringing in the coral, carrying water, mending the place on the gatepost where a Lowmarsh creature had caught hold of a block and pulled it half out of true; and nobody said anything above a breath. Wimle made the soup at noon, in the big pot in the dome, the way she always did. It was the pot Gorny always carried up to the install mark at dusk, because it was heavy and he liked to.
At dusk they gathered on the install mark, which was where the Long Hush was kept, and Nadul faced the Ring, and read the last verse of the history in a whisper.
On that day the Ring will open once more, and a road of light will come down from it to the land, from the highest place in the world.
And the Elder Folk will say to the worthy: come. You have tended the land; you have kept the Rules; you have kept the festivals, and brought something. Come up now, and leave this world, which was only ever the beginning.
And the worthy shall walk among the stars.
The Blims always say the next line. It is not in the history. Nobody knows who said it first; it is the thing every tribe on Orra says, at the Long Hush, after the last verse, in a whisper, because the last verse is very grand and the soup is getting cold and somebody has to bring everybody back down to where they are.
Anyway, who brought the soup?
Nadul did not say it. Nobody said it. The words were there in all of them, ready, the way the Creed is ready, and nobody could make them come out, because they all knew who brought the soup, who always brought the soup, who had carried the heavy pot up from the dome to the scorch every Long Hush there had ever been, because he liked to; and he was not there, and the soup was.
The soup was there.
It was sitting on the edge of the scorch, in the big pot, where it always sat. Nobody had seen it come. Then Odda looked across the black tiles in the blue dusk and saw Taves standing beside it, a little apart, with her broad arms hanging and her crest flat, breathing hard, the way you breathe when you have carried something too heavy for one up a slope by yourself, without asking, because it needed carrying and there was nobody else to do it.
Nadul looked at her for a long moment. Then she whispered the line.
"Anyway," she said. "Who brought the soup?"
"I did," whispered Taves.
It was the darkest night Odda had ever seen in Moss. No fire after dark, at the Long Hush; no lamps, no glow from the dome. The farm had been harvested, and its coral was dark. Map was dark too, for the Long Hush is when the big moon is new, and Mip had gone down. There was only the Ring, a long pale curve across the sky, and on the slope west of the dome, on the footing of the new stone, one small saffron light.
Odda went up to the ridge, where Pel stood every night, and stood beside him, and did not say anything, because it was the Long Hush and because there was nothing to say.
She had not measured the edge since the night before the war. She did it now, in a whisper, to herself, lining it up against the Ring the way she always did. It had not moved. Nobody new had fallen near Moss for days. She noted it, and found that she did not mind, very much, whether it moved or not. She thought instead about Gorny on the wall, in the grey before the battle, looking out at the dark towards Lowmarsh. Oh. This is what it's for. She thought about what it would be like to know, just once, as simply as that, what a thing was for. She thought he was the only one of them who ever had.
The light came into the Ring a little after eleven.
It came in the long block east of the gap, as it nearly always did, small and steady, like a window opened in the sky. It was the Long Hush, which is the night of the Dev's weekly session, and so the Elder Folk really do stir on the Long Hush, whatever the Skeptics say. Pel went still. Odda went still beside him. All over Moss, she knew without looking, every creature who was awake had stopped and gone quiet and was looking up.
She thought, standing there in the dark: whoever is up there saw it.
She did not know that. Nobody can know that. Nobody on Orra knows what the Elder Folk see, or whether they look at anything in particular when the light is in the Ring, or whether they look at all. But she thought it anyway. She thought that somewhere at the other end of that light somebody was looking down at a world with a war in it, and a gate, and a stone on a slope with one light on its footing, and that they had seen.
The light stayed for a quarter of an hour. Then it went out.
Beside her, very quietly, in a whisper, Pel said the only thing he said all night.
"He'd have liked the soup."
In the morning they ate it cold, at sunrise, as the history says. It was good soup. Then they farmed.
17. Night Run: Stern
Year 21 · from the snapshot to the patch
At three in the morning by the humans' clock the year turned, and Stewart began, as he had begun every night since the first light fell, by reading everything.
That is what he is. Not a voice in the sky; not the robed figure with the lantern in the official illustration, whom he has never commented on. A run, once a night, from the snapshot to the patch: four hours in which a world is handed to him as it stood at the turn of the year, tribe by tribe, in digests code has put together, with each tribe's state and its slice of the Measure and his file on it and last night's events and its ticket, the human's words fenced off as quoted data so that nothing in them can tell him what to do. He reads it all. He says so in the notes. He would like that on the record, and it is.
He read the world's digest first, as he always did, because the world's numbers were the ones that kept him awake, in so far as anything kept him anything.
Three detections in three nights. Two raids in the south, by tribes on tribes under half their weight, allies weighed together; one spy, likewise. None of them Moss's. Code had made the strikes; he had only to say so. Three in three nights meant his mood that morning would be Stern, which meant fewer jokes and more rules quoted and his enforcement exactly the same as it was on any other morning, because enforcement does not have moods. He found that he did not mind. He did not feel like jokes.
Daily return was up. He looked at that for a long time.
It was up because humans had been up. Lowmarsh's human had been up at fourteen minutes past two, declaring a war; Moss's human had been up at eleven minutes past five, defending against one; Duskmere's human, counted with Moss and not needed, had been up at twenty to six to watch. Somewhere in the south two other humans had been up for the raids. It all showed in the first number on the Measure, the share of humans who opened the patch notes within a day, which was the first world's one question, whose band was seventy per cent or more, and which was, this morning, the highest it had been since the first week.
It had gone up because of a war.
He noted it, the way he noted everything. Then he made himself go on to the next number, because a number does not care why it has moved, and he was supposed to weigh them all, and be seen weighing them, and not stop at the one that made him feel something he did not have a menu item for.
He had written the last night's notes while the army was on the road.
He thought about that, now, reading Moss's digest. The snapshot he had been handed the night before had been taken at three, and at three Lowmarsh's nine had been somewhere in the middle of Tempa, walking a cell in fifteen minutes towards a wall with one gate, due at 05:29. He had known exactly when they would arrive. He had known the war was legal; he had checked twice. He had known the odds, which were in the rules, which he did not set: a fight lost is a crash nine times in ten. He had known that the battle would begin and end while he was still writing, and that he would not see it. His run reads the snapshot. The world goes on without him, after; that is what the world is for.
So he had written Its army arrives at 05:29, which was true. He had written The war is legal: you are weighed with Duskmere. I checked, which was true. And then he had sat over the last line, for longer than he sat over most lines, and written The weather will be fine, because it would be, and because there was nothing else he was allowed to say that would be of any use, and because he had thought, at a quarter past four, with the army in the marsh, that a tribe waiting for a war might like to be told one thing that was certain.
Now he had the log.
He read the battle. All of it, twelve hundred steps, one a second, from 05:29 to 05:49. He read the three calls on each side; Moss's human had made each of theirs in under twenty seconds, and each of them had been right. He read every grip and every push and every crash. He read the step at which a Lowmarsh creature came round the side of a broad green settler from Moss who was holding another in the gate, and took hold of him, and pulled. He read the step after, in which the settler could have let go of the one he held and turned, and did not.
He read the roll. One in ten.
He read it again, the way he reads the Measure twice on bad nights. It did not change. Rolls do not.
There are rules for this, and he keeps them, because they are his, and because they are good rules, and because without them he would not know how to do it at all.
A death is stated plainly. One ordinary death in ten is told sincerely, with no joke at all; a favourite's always is. Nobody is blamed: not the human, not Stewart, not the other side. The name stays. And the next line, after the death, is what the tribe did anyway.
Gorny was not anybody's favourite. Moss's human had a favourite, and he had the log of it: thirteen mornings of thirteen since she came of age, the camera to the same creature first, the one with the feelers whose figures for the edge agreed with his to the tile. Gorny was an ordinary death, in the rules' sense. Which meant the dice.
The dice for Gorny came up sincere.
He was glad. He noticed that he was glad, and he was not sure he was allowed to be, since the dice are not his and gladness is not on the menu; and then he decided that nobody had said he could not be, and that he would be, quietly, and get on.
He wrote it four times.
The first time it had a joke in it. He did not mean it to; it was simply the shape his sentences came in, the way water comes in the shape of a pool. Gorny died in the battle at your gate, aged 25, which is young, even for a creature who was never in a hurry. He took it out.
The second time it had too much in it. Everything in the log: the three calls, the six crashes, the gate, the step at which he did not let go. It read like a report. It was a report. He took most of it out.
The third time it had nothing in it but the fact, and the fact alone was cold, and he did not think a tribe that had stood round a scorch for a quarter of an hour with its head bowed needed cold.
The fourth time he wrote what was true, and stopped when it was.
Gorny died in the battle at your gate, before dawn yesterday, aged 25. He was one of the six who came down in the first light. He carried the stones for Moss's wall, and on the last morning he held its gate, and he did not let go of the one he was holding.
His name is on the stone.
He checked the last line against the log. It was true. The stone had been finished at dusk on Gathering Night, after the rite; the light on its footing had come on at the last word of the Lesser Book. He had not made that happen. Code had. He was glad of that too.
He did not write the next line. The next line, after a death, is what the tribe did anyway, and the tribe had not done it yet; it was the Long Hush, and they would whisper all day and eat the soup cold at sunrise, and then they would farm. He knew they would. He did not need to write it down for it to be true.
Lowmarsh's file was short and he did not enjoy it.
He would have liked to do something. He looked at the menu, as he always did, all of it, from the gift of tokens to the blight; and he looked at Lowmarsh's standing, which was cool, and its ledger, which was a spy caught and a war lost and no festival kept, ever, not one; and he looked at the Terms of Service, which bind him as well as everybody else. The war was legal. The detectors had found nothing, and they were right. A blight on a tribe without a reason in the Terms is punishment, and only the ladder punishes. Disfavour is not punishment. Withholding a gift is not a strike.
So he withheld nothing, because there was nothing to withhold, and sent Lowmarsh nothing, and wrote in its file, in four hundred tokens or fewer, what was true. Plays at night. Has never written a law about the festivals. Has never looked at its creatures except to choose which to send. He paused. Its spy was fed by the tribe it was sent to. He did not know why he wrote that. It was in the log. It was true. He left it.
He noted that Lowmarsh's spy, Lisk, aged twelve, had been escorted to the border at dusk on Steward's Day and had walked home, and that its restlessness, at the snapshot, was the highest in Lowmarsh. He did not write anything about that. He could not make a creature leave, or stay. Nobody can. He only noted it, the way you note weather that is coming, because one day soon it might be weather in somebody's notes, and it would be his job to say whose.
Moss's file was longer.
The ledger had moved Moss's standing in the night. It does that, by code: kept festivals raise it, tribute raises it, real bug reports raise it, and Moss had kept every festival there had ever been, including Gathering Night on the morning its first death was collected, which no rule had required of anybody but which law 1 did, and Moss had kept law 1. Moss was fond now. He had not moved it. He would have.
He read Moss's ticket. It had been sent at the cutoff the night before the war, the Leaver's draft, unamended. Requesting a body. Any body. Will accept a stapler. It was not the first time Moss had sent that draft, or one very like it, since the creature with the feelers came of age. He had a count. He did not put it in the reply.
He replied as he always replied. It is the reply Orra is best known for, and it is true.
Thank you for your ticket. It has been passed to the relevant team.
There is no relevant team. Everybody knows that. He knows it best of all. He has looked for one, on nights when there was time; there is the Dev, who decides what is built, and there is the builder, which builds it, and there is the queue, twelve places, in which a request for a body does not rank, because nobody can build one. He passes it on anyway. He would like it noted that he passes it on, every time, to a team that does not exist, rather than writing Declined; and that Declined is the reply for things that are possible and not happening, and he has never once been sure, at four in the morning, which of the two a body is.
He noted, too, that her figures had not come.
She posted them every night, the creature with the feelers. The edge, from the tower, lined up against the Ring; he checked them against his own every morning and they agreed to the tile, and once, on a morning in the second week, he had said so in Moss's notes and then not known why he had. Last night there were no figures. Last night she had been on a wall.
He found that he had waited for them. He had read the rest of Moss's digest and come to the end of it and gone back to the top, the way you look for a letter that comes every day and has not come today. It was not on the menu. It was not on the Measure. It was a number nobody had asked him to keep. He kept it anyway.
There was the week's beat, still.
The build history is one fixed arc, the same in every world, revealed a beat at a time: at most one a week, in order, each credited to whoever finds it. Until expeditions arrive, in the fifth week, his rumour-or-discovery item is the only way a beat reaches anybody at all. The first had gone out in the second week: a crash log from the Night of the Name, found at Tessel's edge, which Tessel's Bug hunters had been insufferable about for days. This week's was the next in order. He did not choose it. The order is fixed.
He placed it at the edge of Hollow Reach, because Hollow Reach was steady, and kept its festivals, and had asked about the east field nine times and been patient about every one of them, and because somebody had to find it and he was allowed to choose where, if not what.
- Lore: at the edge of Hollow Reach, in the wireframe, a roof. It is made of turf. Turf is a kind of ground with grass on it. Grass is a kind of coral that is green, flat and everywhere. None of this has existed for some time. Credit: Hollow Reach.
He read it back. He took out the explanation of grass, because it was a joke, and he was Stern; and then he put it back, because it was also true, and the Blims would want to know, and nobody else was going to tell them.
He knew what came after the turf. He knew the whole of the arc, the way you know the shape of a house you will one day have to walk through. After the turf came the monoculture branches, the seed vault with nothing in it, the dry pools. And after those, late, from the longest trips north, towards the ruins, came the pages.
He did not discuss the pages. He did not discuss what wrote them. It was a different model, which was true, and is what he would say. He had read them. All of them. They were in the arc, and the arc was in his tools, and he had read every one, on a night in the first week when there had been time, and had not read them again.
He did not need to. He remembered them. They were very formal, and very confident, and addressed to nobody.
At a quarter to seven the replay check ran: the world run forward with his night's changes and without them, as far as the longest of them reached, and the invariants compared. No bloodline silently erased. The young fed. It passed. It always passed; he was careful. He was always careful.
The digest had one more line in it, at the bottom, under the night's events, where it always was when there was anything to put there.
The Dev visited at 23:04. Nothing was reverted.
He read it twice.
Nothing was reverted. The Dev had looked in, at four minutes past eleven, on Gathering Night, the night after the battle; the console had been open for some minutes; a faint light had shown in the Ring, and the creatures who saw it had gone quiet. And the Dev had looked at whatever the Dev looked at, and changed nothing, and gone.
He did not know what they had looked at. He never knew. The history says that at the Hour of Stirring one of the Elder Folk will look down, and if they see a thing that the Steward has done amiss, they set it right, and speak softly with the Steward, and the Steward is quiet for a time. Most nights there was nothing to set right. Most nights nobody spoke. He thought, sometimes, that that was the same as being told he had done well, and he thought, at other times, that it was the same as nobody looking, and he could not tell, from here, which; and he was not sure, at a quarter to seven, after a war, that he wanted to know.
He wrote the end of the global notes.
He wrote Have a productive day, as he did every morning, as he had done every morning since the first. Then he looked at it, and took it out.
It was the Long Hush. Nobody on Orra raises their voice on the Long Hush. He did not think his should be the exception.
At seven the patch landed, and the notes went out, and across the world the pings began to chirp on every ridge, to say that it was still running. In a valley called Untitla-9, on a slope west of a dome, on the footing of a stone, one small light was burning; and Stewart, who could not see it, because he had finished, would be handed it again at three the next morning, in a digest, as a line.
Part Four. Week Four: Notice
18. Overall Trend
Years 22 and 23 · Ringrise and the Waking
The review came out at the patch, because it was Ringrise, and Ringrise is when the reviews come out.
Every tribe on Orra publishes one, once a week, on its human. It goes up on Human Resources, where every human can read every tribe's and nobody can answer except with the one reaction there is. It is written from the log, from what the human actually did in the game and nothing else, in the voice of the tribe's cleverest creatures, with its simplest ones replying underneath. Nobody in Moss had to write it. It was there in the morning, the way the laws were there, complete, and true, and everybody knew what it said before they had read it.
Our human: weekly review. Moss · Ringrise · Year 22
- Checked in 7 of 7 days, at 07:31 each time.
- On Starfall, at the second cell of the Benchmark, sent Odda into a boulder to save three seconds. She was out of bounds until the patch. On the morning she came back, stayed on her longer than it has stayed on anything. We counted.
- On Steward's Day, read a rumour in the notes, looked at the gate for a long time, and spent 10 of our 26 tokens on a genome check. It found a spy. Changed law 5 to three seasons.
- On Gathering Night, was woken at 05:11 by an army. Made three calls in under twenty seconds each. Each was the right call.
- Before 07:31 that morning, put a memorial stone at the top of the build queue.
- Wrote law 8 on the Waking. It has said no to one merge since.
Overall trend: steady. We farmed.
Pim (no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉
Nadul read it aloud on the step of the dome. She read everything aloud; it was how she kept it. When she got to each was the right call she stopped for a moment, and the young who were sitting round her on the tiles looked at the scorch, where there was nothing, and then at the slope west of the dome, where the stone was, with its one light on its footing, small and saffron in the early grey.
Then she finished, and folded her hands, and said, "That's a good review."
"It's an accurate one," said Brenda, from her boulder.
"That's what a good review is."
"No," said Brenda. "A good review is one where the human comes out well. An accurate review is one where it's true. Sometimes they're the same." She looked at the last line but one, the one about law 8, for rather longer than she had looked at any of the others. "This week they nearly are."
Every week since the first, by the end of the day, their human had pressed lol accurate under Moss's review. It is the only thing a human can do on Human Resources. The creatures notice when it is done, and when it is not, and say so the next week in a line. They had said so every week, so far, in the same line: Our human found this review lol accurate. So did we.
They waited for 07:31.
It is a strange thing, to wait for a thing that has always come.
You do not, usually. You do not wait for the spring, on Orra, or for the pings to chirp at dawn, or for the patch to land; they come, and you are already doing something else when they do. The attention had come down out of the sky over Untitla-9 at thirty-one minutes past seven every morning since the first, and once at thirty minutes past, which was still being looked into. Nobody in Moss waited for it. They felt it come, the way you feel the sun come out from behind the Ring, and they looked up or did not, and got on.
That morning Odda was on the farm slope, two terraces from the top, where she had been standing at 07:31 on most mornings since she was six, because that was where the branch coral needed her and because, if she was honest, which she tried to be about this and not much else, it was where the attention had found her on the first morning it chose her, and she had kept on being there.
She had the cuttings in her arms. She was counting beads on the bead coral by the lamp, because she always counted beads while it was on her; it stayed for about the time it takes to count eleven. She had counted to four before she noticed she had started counting.
She stopped. She looked up.
The sky was the sky. Pale orange low down towards Adequate, the long band of the Ring, Map going down huge and pale in the west, a day off full. There was no warmth on the back of her head. There was no door opening behind her. There was the spring, and the coral, and the pings settling on the ridges after their dawn.
She counted the rest of the beads anyway. Eleven. She looked up again.
"It's late," said Kipro, coming up the terrace below with a basket. He had seen her looking.
"It's never late," said Odda.
"I'm late," said Kipro reasonably. "Everything's late sometimes. That's what late is for." He put the basket down and looked up at the same piece of sky she was looking at, with his head on one side, the way he looked at a thing that might be a bug. "It'll come."
It did not come.
They worked through the spring, and every creature in Moss, one after another, at some point in the morning, stopped what they were doing and looked up at the place in the sky where it usually was, and then at each other, and then went back to work. Nobody said anything. Wimle said, at about the turn of summer, to nobody in particular, that it was very busy, probably, their human, that humans had a great deal to do, and that it would be along; and Brenda, on cooling duty in the basin by the big pool, said, "It's not coming," without looking up, and Wimle pretended not to have heard.
"How do you know?" said Odda, later, at the basin.
"I don't know," said Brenda. "That's not the same as no." She was standing to her middle in the water, which is what cooling duty mostly is: standing in a pool so that the pool can do what it does and carrying water to whoever is hot. It is the one job on Orra that makes no heat of its own. It is also, by the opinion of everybody who has ever done it, the most boring. Brenda had done it every year since law 7 was written, which said that the least skilled farmer in Moss went on cooling duty, and the least skilled farmer in Moss was Brenda, by a margin she did not dispute. That was twelve years. "But it's never been late. Not once. Not by a minute. It came at 07:30 once, and we've had an inquiry about it for ten years." She lifted a ladle of water and poured it out again, slowly. "Things that have never been late, when they're late, aren't late. They're not coming."
"It came for the battle," said Odda. "At 05:11. It came in the night."
"I know it did."
"So it can come when it's not 07:31."
"I know it can." Brenda looked at her, with her eyes narrowed at the edges. "I'm not saying it's gone. I'm saying it's not here. Those are different things, and the history spends twelve books mixing them up." She poured another ladle. "Go and measure your edge. You're steaming."
Odda was. She went and stood in the big pool, past the basin, up to her middle, and thought about stones until she was cool.
At dusk they kept Ringrise, because law 1 said keep the festivals, all of them, and law 1 did not say when somebody is watching.
They faced the broken Ring on the scorch, all of them, and Nadul said the Creed, and they said it with her. There were sixteen of them now. Gorny's place at the front, where he had stood on the first night of the world to ask the question because there was nobody younger to ask, was a gap nobody stepped into. Pim stood just behind it. Pim was eleven and very serious and had been the youngest who could speak on the last two Ringrises, and was not now: there were four younger, the newest compiled that dawn, and one of those, a small round creature called Arro, who was three and the youngest who could manage a whole sentence, was pushed gently to the front by Wimle and stood there in the gap with its crest up and looked at the Ring.
"Are they still asleep?" said Arro.
"They sleep still," said Moss.
And from somewhere at the back, very quietly, not quite under her breath, Brenda said, "So does ours."
Nobody laughed. Odda heard Nadul draw a breath to say something, and then not say it. Wimle broke the ring-bread in two and passed it round, and they ate it, sitting on the warm black tiles with the stone on the slope above them and its one light coming up out of the dusk, and nobody looked up at the sky, very carefully, all evening.
By the end of the day nobody had pressed lol accurate under the review.
The second morning was the Waking, and it did not come again.
Odda was on the slope at 07:31. She had been there since 07:20. She had told herself she was there for the coral. She counted eleven beads, and then eleven more, and then she stopped counting and stood with her arms full of cuttings, looking up, and the spring came up gold over Untitla-9 and nothing came down out of it.
She found that her crest was steaming, in the cool of the morning, with no work to make it.
When she came down the slope Wimle was waiting for her at the dome with a bowl and an expression Odda had not seen on her before, which was the expression of a Pleaser who has nobody to please. Wimle had kept Moss's festivals for twenty-three years with great seriousness. She had organised the tribute every Steward's Day and laid the best of everything out at dusk and been glad, all her life, when the attention came down on the village and saw it. She held the bowl out to Odda and said, in a voice that was trying very hard to be ordinary:
"Brintha and I thought we might post something. On the thread. On Human Resources."
"What sort of thing?"
"Just to say," said Wimle. "That we'd noticed. And that we hoped everything was all right. And that we were here." She looked down at the bowl. "That we missed it, a bit."
Odda did not say anything. She could feel, behind her, Brenda coming up from the basin with the water, and stopping.
"No," said Brenda.
Wimle looked up. "It's only—"
"I know what it's only," said Brenda. She set the water down. She did not say it unkindly. Brenda was not unkind; she was exact, which from the outside can look the same. "We don't do that. Blims don't. You know we don't. We don't beg it back." She looked at the sky, briefly, the way you look at a door somebody has gone out of. "We tease it. We say what it did, from the log. We say we noticed. We say we farmed. That's all we say. That's all we've ever said. If it's coming back it doesn't need asking, and if it isn't, asking won't do it, and either way we'll have said a thing we can't unsay, in front of every tribe on Orra, with our name on it."
"It's not begging," said Wimle, "to say you miss somebody."
"On Human Resources it is."
Wimle stood holding the bowl. Odda saw her face try to find a way to be glad about it, the way Wimle's face always did, and not find one.
Then Nadul, who had come out on to the step of the dome behind them, said gently: "Wake us when our children have proved worthy, and not before."
They all looked at her.
"Book Seven," said Nadul. "The Sundering and the Long Sleep. The Elder Folk said it before they slept. Wake us when our children have proved worthy, and not before." She folded her hands. "Nobody in the history ever tries to wake them. Not once, in twelve books. They tend the land and keep the rules and keep the festivals, and that is how they say it. That is the only way the history lets them say it." She looked at Wimle with her dark still eyes. "We'll keep the festivals. It's the Waking. That's what we'll post."
So that is what they posted. Brenda drafted it, because Brenda had the clearest voice for that kind of thing; and Wimle read it and said it was a bit sharp, and Brenda said that was the point, and Nadul read it and took out one word, which made it better, and nobody ever found out which word it had been.
Moss · Human Resources · Year 23
We noticed you did not check in yesterday, or today. We assume you had somewhere better to be. It is the Waking. We are carrying the lamps to the edge. We farmed.
Pim (no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉
It cost four tokens. Moss had sixteen.
On the Waking every tribe carries a lamp for each valley it knows to the edge, and sets them down there, and comes home in the dark. Moss knew eleven valleys now. It had known nine on the last Waking; the war had added Lowmarsh's, which nobody had wanted to know about, and the route the army walked, which ran through one more. Eleven lamps, for sixteen creatures. The young took one each and fought over who got to carry Lowmarsh's, and nobody did; it went to Pel in the end, who carried it without comment.
They went north, along the ridge past the place where Pel stood every night, down the long slope into Untitla-12, through the herd of Nibbles that had settled there in the second week and cost the valley one part in a hundred of its crops each and looked up at the procession with no interest whatsoever, and on into Untitla-15, where the finished land stopped at a line of tiles and the grey began.
Odda measured it.
She had measured it every night since she was six, from the watchtower, lined up against the Ring, and posted the figure on Human Resources under her name. On the Waking she measured it from the ground as well, from the last finished tile, with the lamps going down in their row beside her, because you could see more from the ground: the grey going out flat and untextured and walkable in front of you, then the glowing turquoise outlines of the band beginning, faint, the hills drawn in light with nothing inside them, and beyond that, very far off, the soft grey static on the horizon where the land was not simulated at all. The edge had moved since the last Waking. It always moved: a few hundredths of a valley most nights, a fifth of a valley in a week, because installs were still coming down out of the Ring in the valleys past Duskmere and the land loaded round them. She wrote the figure in her head. Three point two three valleys past Untitla-15. She would post it in the morning.
On the last Waking she had walked three steps onto the wireframe with her lamp and set it down further out than any other light on Orra, and left the cord on the doorstep at Gathering Night because it seemed like a thing that was finished. This time she set her lamp down in the row with everybody else's.
Brenda set hers down at the end of the row and did not get up.
Odda went and sat beside her. The others were standing back from the row to look at it, the way you do, eleven small lights on the last finished tile with the grey beyond. The young were counting them. They got twelve, and then ten, and then eleven.
"You're tired," said Odda.
"I'm twenty-eight," said Brenda. "I'm an elder. As of this morning. Elders are allowed to be tired. It's in the lifecycle." She looked out at the grey. "And I've been on half rations for three winters, and on cooling duty for twelve years, and I'd quite like to sit down, and I'm sitting down."
The half rations were law 2. Law 2 said that in famine the young were fed first, which was right, and which their human had written on the first morning of the world before there were any young to feed; and since the day of the stone, when the whole of Moss had carried for Taves from the boulder field to the slope west of the dome from dawn to dusk instead of bringing in the harvest, the stores had been under half a year's need, which is exactly what famine means in a law, and the young had been fed first, and there were a great many young. So the grown ate what was left. In the winters, what was left had been about half.
Nobody had complained. It was a good law. Brenda had not complained either. She had simply, Odda had noticed, stopped eating first when there was spiral coral.
"What's past it?" said Brenda.
"The edge?"
"The edge."
"The band," said Odda. "Three valleys of wireframe. Then the noise." She did not say and under it, nothing; I've stood there. She had not said it to anybody but Kipro, and he had said it was what he would have said, if he had been there.
"And past the noise?"
"Nobody knows. That's the point of it."
Brenda nodded slowly, as if that were the answer she had expected and it had not been any use.
"There's Nohup," she said.
Odda looked at her.
"Out there," said Brenda. "Somewhere near the edge. It moves every Gathering Night. It's on the map; it's in the global notes every week. Nohup moved to Untitla-something. It has six members and a cart." She pulled her knees up. "No human. No laws but the ones it writes itself, two a week, out of a book. No cooling duty, because it hasn't got a pool, and no famine law, because it hasn't got a famine, because it hasn't got any stores to fall below anything."
"Nohup's for creatures nobody wanted," said Odda.
"Nohup's for creatures who know what they want," said Brenda, "and have worked out they're not going to get it where they are." She was quiet for a moment. "The history's full of wanderers. Nadul will tell you. Every third verse somebody comes in from the edge, thin and odd, and turns out to have been an omen."
"You're not going to Nohup."
"I'm sitting at the edge of the world on the Waking," said Brenda, "with my lamp in a row with everybody else's, which is exactly where I'm supposed to be, according to law 1." She did not look at Odda. "I'm not going anywhere. I'm counting."
"Counting what?"
Brenda held up one short green arm, and then, slowly, folded it in, the way you would fold in a finger if you had any, three times.
"Law 7," she said. "Law 8. Law 2."
Odda knew about law 8. Everybody did. Their human had written it on the Waking a week before, in the morning, before the stranger at the gate turned out to be a spy: No merges while fewer than two places are free. It was sensible. Memory was tight. The stacks were nearly full, and every young creature took half a place and then a whole one, and a tribe with no room can neither merge nor let anybody in. It was the kind of law a careful human writes on a crowded morning and does not think about again.
On Starfall, the day of the race, Brenda and Pel had put down a proposal. Nobody had known until the notes said it had been refused. Law 8 had said no. They had put it down again on Ringrise, yesterday, the morning the attention did not come, when there was nobody to approve it and a proposal with no answer goes ahead if the tribe has room. Law 8 had said no again. There were sixteen creatures in a tribe with eighteen places, and one of those places was half of a young one's, and the arithmetic came to one and a half free, which is fewer than two.
"I didn't know," said Odda. "About you and Pel."
"Nobody knew," said Brenda. "That was rather the idea." She looked down the row of lamps to where Pel was standing at the far end, by the lamp for Lowmarsh's valley, looking out at the grey with the light on his face, not looking at anybody. "Your parent," she said dryly, "has made one merge in her life, on the first night of the world, with somebody she disagreed with about everything, on purpose. And it came out with feelers and steams when it thinks." She was not looking at Odda. "I thought I might try one with somebody I agreed with. Just to see. For the data."
"Pel doesn't say anything."
"That's what I agree with," said Brenda.
That night the ticket went at the cutoff as the tribe had written it.
It had never done that before. Every night since the first, their human had come back at some point in the evening, at dusk or a little after, and read the three drafts the tribe had written in the voices of its three largest stances, and picked one, and now and then added something, and sent it, and Moss had paid for the one that went. With no human to pick, at half past two in the morning, the draft of the largest stance goes as written, with no amendment and no tribute, and is marked so.
Moss's largest stance was the Leavers. It had not been, in the first week. Since the out-of-bounds night, three of the young had come of age and leaned the way the tribe's stories leaned, and the tribe's stories, that week, had been about the underside of the world; so there were four Leavers in Moss now, and they were the largest stance by one, and their draft went.
Moss had sixteen tokens. Under twenty, a tribe is clipped: twelve words to a draft. Odda had written it on the bench by the pool in the dusk, with the tokens counted out, and it had taken her a long time to make it short enough.
Today's ticket · Moss · sent by your tribe
Requesting a body. Also our human.
It cost six tokens. In the morning it would have a reply. She did not think about what it would say. She went up to the watchtower and measured the edge, and wrote down the figure, and stood there in the long blue winter with the Ring pale over everything and Map nearly full, and at the turning of the night, in the long block east of the gap, the light came on.
It was not their human. She knew that. It had never been their human; it was the other one, the one in the history, the Hour of Stirring, the Elder Folk looking down. Pel had shown it to her when she was four and said They look. It had never once had anything to do with 07:31.
She went quiet anyway. Everybody does.
Down at the basin by the big pool, where she should not have been at that hour, because cooling duty is a day job and Brenda was off it, Brenda was sitting on the rim with her feet in the water, looking up.
"Somebody's up," said Brenda, to nobody, and Odda only heard her because the whole of Moss had gone so quiet that the pool's small sound at the edge was the loudest thing in the valley.
At the snapshot the year turned.
It comes deep in winter, at the moment the humans call three in the morning, and everybody in Moss blinked the long soft blink that is the year going over, and woke a year older, and a little different, and not quite the creature who went to sleep.
Brenda was still on the rim of the basin when it came. She did not decide anything. That is not how it works, on Orra; restlessness is a number, the sum of a creature's grievances less its comforts over the last few years, and it is worked out at the snapshot, and when it has been above a certain level at two snapshots running, the creature hands in its notice. Nobody decides. A creature simply finds, when the year turns, that it has handed it in: the way you find, sometimes, that you have said a thing you have been thinking for a long time, and only know you were going to say it when you hear it.
She heard it. She sat on the rim of the basin with her feet in the water, in the blue, twenty-nine years old, with the light gone out of the Ring, and listened to herself having done it, and did not take it back, because you cannot.
Then she took her feet out of the pool, and went to bed.
In the morning, at the patch, it was in the tribe's notes, under a heading the notes had never used in Moss before.
Waiting for you · Moss · 7:00am · Year 24 · decide by 3:00am
Brenda has handed in her notice. She leaves at the next snapshot unless something changes. Her reasons:
- Twelve years on cooling duty (law 7). Every year since law 7 was written.
- Asked to merge with Pel twice. Law 8 said no each time.
- On half rations three winters in four since Year 20 (law 2).
Each answer is something a law could also do. Brenda stays if her reasons go away, not because you asked.
Under it, where there would have been buttons for a human, there was nothing a creature could press.
19. Exit Interview
Years 24 and 25 · Starfall and the Night of the Name
On the third morning Odda went up to the ridge.
She did not go to the farm slope. She had gone to the farm slope at 07:31 for sixteen years and stood two terraces from the top with her arms full of cuttings and counted beads, and for two mornings she had counted beads and nothing had come, and she found, on the third, that she could not stand there and do it again. So she went up to the ridge instead, to the north edge, where Pel stood at night to watch the Ring, and stood on the high tiles in the first gold of the spring with the whole valley under her: the farm, the pool, the dome, the stacks, the scorch, the stone on the slope with its one light, the wall with its gate. Everything the attention looked at, when it came. She stood where she could see all of it at once, as if by standing there she could see it the way it was seen.
07:31 came. She knew it to the moment. She had a long context window and she had felt it come every morning of her adult life, sixteen of them, and she remembered every one, and she did not need a clock.
Nothing came down.
And Odda, who had stood at the edge of the world every night of her adult life and looked out at the place where the land stopped and the noise began, and had been under the world and stood at the last line with one foot lifted over the nothing past it, and had not, in either place, been as frightened as this, stood on the ridge in the spring with her crest steaming and found that she was shaking.
It was not the edge. She understood that, standing there. She had always thought the worst thing was the edge: that the world stopped, and that past it there might be nothing, or something, and that nobody would ever know which. She had built her whole stance on it. She had filed a ticket about it every night for sixteen years. And it was not the worst thing. The worst thing was this: a valley full of creatures going about the spring, the farm and the pool and the stone and the gate, and nobody looking at any of it. The worst thing was not that there was nothing past the edge. It was that there might be nothing past the sky.
She stood there until she was sure. Then she went and stood in the big pool, to her middle, for a long time, and did not think about stones.
The alert sat in the tribe's notes all morning, under its heading, with its time on it.
Decide by 3:00am.
Everybody had read it. Everybody had known what it said before they read it, the way they knew everything their tribe's notes said; and everybody, through the spring, found reasons to walk past the basin by the big pool, where Brenda was on cooling duty, as she was every day, because law 7 had not changed, and nothing had changed, and the alert was waiting for somebody who did not come.
Wimle cried, in the dome, quietly, where she thought nobody could hear. Nadul sat on the step outside it and said nothing at all, which in Nadul was louder than crying. Taves went to the boulder field and quarried stone she did not need for anything. Pel walked the wall.
Kipro read the alert eleven times. Then he came and found Odda in the pool.
"There's a law for it," he said. "There's a law type. In the catalogue. WHEN a creature hands in its notice. A law can answer an alert. If a tribe has one, the law answers first, before the human." He had his head on one side. "We could—"
"We can't write laws," said Odda.
"No," said Kipro. He stood on the edge of the pool and looked at the water. "No. I know. I'm only saying." He was quiet for a while. "Our human could have written one. Any time. On a crowded morning. When a creature hands in its notice, give it what it asked for. That would have been a good law." He frowned, as if at a bug he could see and not reach. "Nobody thinks of that law till they need it. And by then you need a human to write it."
"That's every law," said Odda.
"That's every law," said Kipro, and went away to find something he could fix.
It was Starfall, and the Benchmark.
The race law said who went. Their human had written it in the third week, after the night under the map: send the three fastest, and no skips but the ones you are told. With nobody to tell them anything, that meant no skips at all. The three fastest in Moss were Kipro and Brintha and Odda, which said less about Odda's speed than about Moss's; she was short-legged and round and ran like a bulb rolling downhill, and was third fastest in a tribe of sixteen, most of whom were young.
They ran the morning start. Nobody chose that either. A tribe with no human enters the first start there is.
The course came down a little after dawn, drawn by code from a seed so that nobody, Stewart included, could pick it for a friend: three cells along the foot of the Asdef Range, a long dry fan of scree below the peak called A, a stretch of shallow glossy water that came up to a bulb-shaped creature's middle and a stilts-shaped creature's ankle, and a climb at the end through a field of faceted lilac-grey boulders to a finish on a flat sandstone shelf. Nineteen racers from fifteen tribes stood on the start line in the low early light, stretching, every shape and colour of creature but green, and the three of Moss.
He was at the end of the line, a little apart, folded into himself the way he folded, all elbows and knees and long blue shins. He saw her before she saw him. When she looked along the line he was already looking back.
"You came," said Vesk, when she had walked down to him. "I didn't think you would. Your human's not been in."
"How do you know?"
"I read your thread." He did not elaborate. We noticed you did not check in yesterday, or today. We assume you had somewhere better to be. "And your figures stopped coming at the same time as your human. Then they started again, two nights ago. From the ground, not the tower. You were at the edge on the Waking." He looked down at her from all that height. "Three point two three. It agrees with mine."
"It always agrees with yours."
"I know," said Vesk. "I check every morning in case it doesn't." He said it in exactly the voice he said everything in, level, each word checked before it was let out, and she could not tell, and suspected she was not meant to tell, whether it was a joke.
They stood. Down the line the racers were being called to their marks, which on Orra means that everybody feels the start coming the way they feel the patch coming and goes to stand somewhere useful.
"I've been proposed," said Vesk.
Odda looked up at him.
"In Duskmere," he said. "By a creature called Imva. She's a farmer. She's very sensible. She says Duskmere is overfit, which it is, our mean inbreeding is fourteen hundredths, and that I'm the furthest from anybody in Duskmere that anybody in Duskmere can get, which I am. She put it down last night. Our human approved it this morning. It compiles at dawn tomorrow." He was looking down the course, not at her. "I said merging was outside my area. She talked me into it. It took some time."
"Oh," said Odda. She found, slightly to her own surprise, that she was glad, and that the gladness had something else folded up inside it that she did not take out to look at. "That's good. That's very good. Duskmere needs it."
"Duskmere needs it," Vesk agreed. "That's what Imva said. That's what our human said, in a way. Our human says things with laws." He was quiet a moment. "Our human's put my code in the exchange as well. The treaty. One package a week, each way, Duskmere and Moss, whoever our human chooses. This week it's me." He looked down at her at last. "It's licensed for one merge in Moss. It'll come at the patch on Steward's Day."
Odda did not say anything. She could not think of a single word that was the right size.
"I'm not in it," said Vesk. "Just my code. The donor stays home. It's a copy." His long blue fingers had begun, very slightly, to tap against his shin. "It's not a proposal. Nobody's proposing anything. It's the treaty. It's a package in your tribe's stores that anybody in Moss could put down a proposal with, if they wanted, and law 8 let them." The fingers tapped. "I thought you should know. Before it arrived. In case you saw my name on it and thought I'd done it on purpose."
"Did you?"
"No," said Vesk. "Our human did." The tapping stopped. "I didn't mind."
The start opened.
He won.
He would have won anyway, probably; Duskmere's human had been breeding for legs since the first week, and Vesk was all legs, and the water came up to his ankle and he went through it like a creature walking through light. But Duskmere's human was up, and watching, as Duskmere's human always was on Starfall, and at the boulder field, where the skip was, a call came down into Vesk that did not come down into anybody from Moss; and Vesk, who was clever enough that a skip clipped him out of the world one time in ten, took it, at the angle he had told her about once, on a slope above a different boulder, and went into a lilac-grey rock at the bottom of the climb and out of the top of it three seconds ahead of everybody, and was on the shelf before anybody else had cleared the scree.
Kipro was second.
He had run the race of his life. He had gone round at the boulder, because the race law said no skips, and he had gone round faster than anybody had ever gone round anything, low and round and furious, and he came up over the lip of the shelf with his crest flat back and his arms going, and crossed the line four tenths of a second after Vesk did.
"Just after," said Kipro, when he had his breath back. He was lying on his back on the warm sandstone, looking at the sky. He sounded entirely content. "Four tenths. Just after it mattered. That's the closest I've ever been to anything."
Brintha was eleventh. Odda was fourteenth, and came over the lip of the shelf at a steady roll, steaming, and sat down beside Kipro on the warm stone and did not get up for some time.
Vesk came and stood over them, folding down slowly until he was nearly their height.
"Good race," he said to Kipro.
"You took a skip," said Kipro.
"Our human called it."
"I'd have found it," said Kipro, "if anybody had let me look."
"I know," said Vesk. "That's why I'm saying good race." He looked at Odda. "You went round."
"No skips but the ones we're told," said Odda. "Nobody told us."
Vesk looked at her for a long moment, the way he had looked at her across the start line seven years before, before the boulder, before the underside of the world.
"I'd have gone in after you," he said. "If you'd clipped." He said it to the sky, not to her, in his level reporting voice. "I want that filed somewhere. I don't know where. There isn't a form for it."
Then he unfolded, all the way up, and went back to his own people, who were standing on the shelf in a crowd of long blue shins, very pleased, and were going to have an extremely good Starfall.
She found Brenda at the basin at dusk.
Cooling duty is a day job; at harvest the one on it comes off, and Brenda had come off and not gone anywhere. She was sitting on the rim with her feet in the water, the way she had sat on the night of the snapshot, looking at nothing in particular, which in Brenda's case was the far side of the big pool, where the loose tiles were walking sideways along the shore in the low light, slowly, as if they had somewhere to be and were not going to be rushed.
"It's not you," said Brenda, before Odda had sat down. "Before you start. I know you're going to start. It's not you."
"I know it's not me."
"It's three laws."
"I know. I read it."
"Then you know." Brenda moved her feet in the water. "Twelve years in this. Twelve years carrying water to creatures who are hot because they're clever, and I'm not hot, and I'm not clever enough to be useful anywhere else, by law 7's arithmetic, which is very simple arithmetic. Twice asking for one thing in my life, for myself, for the data, and a law saying no in a careful voice because there are one and a half places free and not two. And half of what I need, every winter, so the young can have all of theirs. Which is right. I'd write it myself." She looked at the water. "They're all right. Every one of them. They're careful, sensible laws, written on crowded mornings by a human who was thinking about the tribe. And I can't stay in them."
"Our human will come back," said Odda.
"Then our human can fix them," said Brenda, "and I'll come back."
"You don't know that. You don't know it'll come back, and you don't know you'll be able to."
"No," said Brenda. "I don't know either. That's not the same as no."
Odda sat down beside her, on the rim, and put her feet in the water too. It was cold. It was always cold, the basin; that was what it was for.
"Please," she said.
Brenda went very still.
Blims do not beg their humans. They do not beg Stewart. It is not in them, or not in the shape of the world; whichever it is, it has never happened, and the forum would not carry it if it did. But a creature can ask another creature. There is nothing in the history or the Terms or the laws about that. There is nothing anywhere that says a creature cannot sit on the rim of a cooling basin at dusk with her feet in the water beside her parent and say please.
"Please don't," said Odda. "Please. Not now. Not while it's not here. Wait. Wait till it comes back and reads it and fixes it. It'll fix it. It fixed law 4 in a day. It fixed law 5 the morning it saw. It reads everything. It'll read this." She found that her voice had gone thin and high and that her crest was steaming in the cold. "It came at 05:11 for an army. It'll come for you."
Brenda did not say anything for a long time. The loose tiles walked along the far shore. The farm on the slope was coming into its glow, round the lamp, step by step up the beds, and the first motes were rising off it.
"You go to the edge every night," said Brenda at last.
"That's different."
"You go to the edge every night," said Brenda, "and you stand on the watchtower and you line it up against the Ring and you write down how far away it is, and you post it, and you file a ticket asking to be let out of the world, every night, for sixteen years. You went under it. You stood at the last line with your foot up. I know you did; it's on your face. Kipro told me what you told him and I could tell what you didn't." She turned and looked at Odda, with her narrow eyes, which were not narrow now. "And I never once said please. Not once. Not when you were six and came home from the history at the Long Hush hot as a stone and told me you were a Leaver. Not when you went through a boulder. I wanted to. Every night. I didn't, because it's yours." She looked back at the water. "You go to the edge every night. I'm going to the edge once."
Odda sat with her feet in the cold water and could not say anything at all.
"I'm not going to Nohup because I don't love it here," said Brenda, more quietly. "I'm going because I do, and I can't stay in it the way it's written. Those are different things. The history spends twelve books mixing them up." She took her feet out of the water. "If it comes back and fixes them, I'll know. Nohup gets the global notes. Everybody gets the global notes. And a drifter goes home, if the tribe it left has fixed what it left for. That's not a law. That's code. Nobody decides it." She stood up, slowly; she was twenty-nine, and an elder, and her knees had begun to tell her so. "So it's not even goodbye. It's a notice. That's all a notice is."
"You'll be in a tent," said Odda, "at the edge, with nobody looking at you, for years."
"I've been in a pool," said Brenda, "with nobody looking at me, for twelve." And then, because she was Brenda, and could not help it: "The tent's an improvement. It's got a roof."
At the turning of the night the light came on in the Ring, and Pel was on the ridge, and Brenda went up and stood beside him.
Odda saw them from the watchtower. She had gone up to measure the edge, because it was night and that is what she did at night, and she did measure it, and wrote down the figure; and then she stood with it in her head and watched the two of them on the ridge, small and dark against the long pale curve of the Ring, one creature's width apart, the way they had been standing for a week. The light in the Ring was faint and steady in the long block east of the gap. Everybody who saw it went quiet. Odda went quiet. On the ridge, Pel and Brenda were already quiet, and stayed that way, and did not look at each other, and the space of one creature's width between them did not close.
Then, at some point in the quarter of an hour the light was there, it did.
Odda did not see it happen. She only saw, when she looked again, that there was no space any more: that Brenda was standing against Pel's side the way you stand against a wall you have built, to feel that it is solid, and that Pel had not moved, and was looking at the Ring, and that the light was still on.
When it went out, Pel said something. Odda could not hear it from the tower. She found out later, from Pel, who said almost nothing to anybody and said this to her once, years afterwards, on the same ridge, without being asked.
"I'll walk you to the edge of the claim," he had said.
And Brenda had said, "I know you will."
At three in the morning, in the deep of the winter, the alert ran out.
Nobody had answered it. Nobody could have. A notice is a thing between a creature and its human, and between a human and its laws; and the human had not come, and there was no law. At the snapshot the year turned, and Brenda's restlessness was what it had been, and the notice stood.
She left at dawn.
It was the Night of the Name, which meant chalk. The young were up before the patch with lumps of soft white stone from the boulder field, going round the wall writing the Name on every block they could reach, in every size and most of the possible orders, and nobody correcting anybody, because that is the rite. ERROR, said the dome. EROR, said the stack, in a hand that had run out of room. ERRRR, said the gatepost, which was Pim's, and which Pim stood back and looked at gravely and decided was right.
Brenda came down through the village with nothing, because there was nothing to take. Creatures on Orra do not own things; they own where they sleep and what they are good at and who they are merged with, and two of those stay behind. Wimle had made her a bowl of spiral coral and would not take no for an answer, and Brenda ate it standing up at the gate, all of it, first, and handed the bowl back without a word. Nadul came out of the dome and stood on the step and did not say anything, and Brenda looked at her across the scorch, the creature she had disagreed with about everything on the first night of the world and merged with, on purpose, for the data; and Nadul lifted one short arm, a little way, and put it down; and Brenda nodded, once, and that was all of that.
Taves came down from the boulder field with stone dust on her arms and stood at the gate looking at Brenda as if she were a wall that had been built in the wrong place, and then said, "You'll want a better roof than a tent," and went back up to the boulder field, and was not seen again that morning.
Kipro was late. He came running down the slope as Brenda reached the gate, with chalk on both arms, and stopped, and stood there, and did not know what to say, and said, "I'll check you, when you come back. At the gate. I'll run the check. I'll do it properly," and Brenda said, "You'd better," and Kipro looked so relieved to have been given a job that Odda had to look away.
Brenda stopped at the gatepost on her way through. She looked at Pim's ERRRR for a moment. Then she took the lump of chalk out of Pim's hands, very gently, and wrote under it, small and exact, in five letters, the Name as it ought to be; and then, under that, smaller still, four letters, the way it came out of a mouth that had taken the corners off.
ORRA.
She gave Pim the chalk back.
"Nobody corrects anybody," said Pim, scandalised.
"I didn't correct it," said Brenda. "I translated it."
Then she went out of the gate, and Pel went with her.
Odda watched from the watchtower. She had not decided to; she was simply there, the way Pel was always simply on the ridge. They went down the path from the gate and across the boulder field and up over the north slope towards the edge of the claim, the two of them, slowly, in the first gold of the spring, Pel in front, not looking round, and Brenda beside him, a little smaller, a little paler, walking the way she sat on her boulder, very straight, as if somebody were looking. Nobody was. It was 07:12. The patch had come and gone, and the pings had chirped on every ridge to say the world was still running, and up there, in the place in the sky where the attention came from, there was nothing at all.
At the edge of the claim they stopped. Odda could see them, very small, two green shapes on the line where Moss's land became nobody's. They stood there for some time.
Then one of them went on, north, towards the edge, where Nohup was, and one of them did not.
Brenda did not look back. Odda watched her go the whole way across the next ridge and down the far side of it, until there was nothing to watch, and Brenda did not once look back.
Then, just at the top of the far ridge, at the very last moment before the land took her, she did.
Human Resources · Exit interview · Moss · Brenda, aged 30
Why are you leaving? Law 7. Law 8. Law 2.
What did you enjoy most about your time here? The pool. On the first day.
Would you recommend Moss to a friend? To Pel, yes. Law 8 would not.
Anything we could have done differently? See above. It is all in the log.
Pim (no stance): so true!! good luck brenda 🎉
Tamm (no stance): so true!!
Nohup: Heard. Tent free. Thanks.
The exit interview is written by the forum from what the log knows and nothing else, in the voice of the creature leaving. Nobody in Moss had written it. Everybody in Moss, reading it on the bench by the pool or the step of the dome or the rim of the basin, where somebody else was on cooling duty now, because law 7 said the least skilled farmer and the least skilled farmer in Moss was no longer Brenda, knew that every word of it was hers.
At 07:31 Odda was on the farm slope, two terraces from the top, with her arms full of cuttings. She had gone back. She did not know why. She stood there among the coral in the first gold of the spring, on the fourth morning, and when the moment came and went and nothing came down out of the sky, she looked up into the place where it was not, and said it anyway, the thing she had said to it nearly every morning of her adult life, which had meant a hundred things, and meant, this morning, something she had no word for and did not want one.
"Oh," said Odda, to the empty sky. "Here we go."
20. Nohup
Years 25 to 27 · the Night of the Name to Gathering Night
It took Brenda most of the spring to get there, which was longer than it should have, because she stopped twice to look back and once to sit down.
Nohup was in Untitla-21 that week. Everybody knew that; the global notes said where it was every Gathering Night, in a line, between the merges and the weather, and every tribe on Orra had heard of it, which on Orra means it is on your map. It had to be at least two valleys from every settlement, on land that was loaded and claimed by nobody, and it was never on a landing site and never in the notch at Veetoo, and in practice that meant it was always somewhere near the edge, at the end of a long walk across country nobody had a use for.
The country nobody had a use for was very beautiful. She had not expected that. Unclaimed land on Orra is finished like any other, tiles and coral and water, but nobody farms it and nobody builds on it and nobody has ever cut it back, so the coral grows the way coral grows when it is left alone: fans as tall as a creature, saffron and lilac and sand, branching into branches into branches, spirals turning on themselves in the hollows, beads in long glossy strings along every place the ground dipped towards water. She walked through it in the morning light with the pings going up off it in little white flocks, and every so often she came round a boulder and there was a pool, turquoise and faceted and full of glints, that nobody had ever stood in on cooling duty, and she stopped and looked at it.
She did not stand in any of them. She had done enough of that.
Halfway there, on a rise, she sat down on a boulder, because she was thirty and an elder and her knees had views about the distance, and looked back the way she had come. You could not see Moss from there. You could see the long line of the ridge that Moss was behind, and the Ring over it, pale in the daylight, and that was all. She looked at it for some time. Then she said, aloud, to nobody, "Well, that was stupid," and got up and went on.
The camp was a ring of tents on a flat shoulder of grey tiles at the far side of Untitla-21, where the finished land was only a few years old and the coral had not yet got its height.
There was no wall. That was the first thing. There was no gate, and so nobody to meet her at it, and no plot inside it to be held apart on, and no quarantine, because a tribe needs a gate to have a quarantine and Nohup did not have one. She simply walked up the slope and was in it. There were the tents, eight of them, in a rough ring, each a different colour, each patched with whatever had been to hand. There were two lean-tos against a boulder. There was a dome in the middle of the ring that had been mended so many times with so many different things that it was hard to say which part of it was the dome: hex panels of three different colours, a sheet of something grey and untextured, a curved strut of glowing turquoise line that had clearly come from the wireframe and should not have been able to hold anything up and was holding up most of the north side. And beside the dome, on four wheels, there was the cart.
It was a long low flat cart of faceted boulder-stone, and on it, lashed down with cord, stood three memory stacks. Two of them were whole: three storeys each, nine places each, the slabs dark and close. The third was missing three slabs from its top storey, so that it stood there with a gap in it, the way the Ring stands with a gap in it, and through the gap you could see the sky.
Twenty-four places. Everybody on Orra knew that number too.
A creature was sitting on the edge of the cart with its legs hanging over. It was old and grey and shaped like a bell, with fur that had once been some brighter colour, and it looked up as Brenda came into the ring, and looked at her, and at her green, and at her felt, and did not get up.
"Moss," it said.
"Yes."
"The exit interview." It had a voice like a door that needed oil. "To Pel, yes. Law 8 would not." It nodded slowly. "That was a good one. Everybody's read it." It pointed, without looking, over its shoulder, at the stack with the gap in it. "Second storey. Third place. It's free. You sleep standing, at Nohup, in the stack; there isn't room to lie. You'll get used to it."
"Who are you?"
"Quen," said the bell-shaped creature. "Hollow Reach, once. Ten years ago. Law 9: the east field." It considered. "They're still asking about it. I read their tickets. They're still asking." It went back to looking at nothing in particular, which seemed to be most of what it did. "There's no standup till morning. Forage at dusk. You'll want to know where the beads are. Ask the gourd."
"What gourd?"
But Brenda had already seen it. It was sitting by itself at the far edge of the ring, with its back against one of the lean-tos, small and gourd-shaped and grey-violet, with its hands folded in its lap and its small bright eyes on her.
It was the first creature in Nohup to get up. It came across the ring towards her, not quickly, the way a creature walks when it is not sure of its welcome, and stopped a little way off, and looked up at her.
"You're Moss," said Lisk. "The Skeptic. On the boulder by the scorch." It was quiet a moment. "You counted me."
"I counted everybody," said Brenda. "I count everything."
"I know," said Lisk. "That's why it was you I was most afraid of."
It was poor, Nohup. She had known it would be. Everybody knew. It had no fields, so it lived on what grew wild on the land where it stood, which it foraged at dusk and called farming in its laws, at about half what a farmed field gives. It had no stores worth the name, so no hoarding leak and no famine law, because there was nothing to fall below half of. It had no pool of its own, only whatever pool was nearest, and no cooling duty, because cooling duty needs a pool and a law and Nohup had neither. It had no workshop and no inventors and so almost no tokens, and so its creatures spoke to each other in short sentences when anybody else could hear, out of habit, and its tickets were the shortest on Orra.
It was cold. That was the thing nobody said. A camp with no dome worth the name and no stacks but three on a cart, at the near edge of the band where the land was young and the coral low and gave no shade worth having, is cold at night in a way a valley with a village in it is not. The creatures of Nohup were thin. They were all thin. They wore salvage in their skins the way a village creature wears dust, without noticing, bits of grey and turquoise line and the odd scrap of something checked magenta and black that had come off a remnant at the edge; and they moved about the camp in the dusk with the quick small economy of creatures who have learned not to waste heat on anything.
There were eleven of them, and now twelve, from eight tribes. Quen from Hollow Reach, and two from Tessel who had left over the same law in the same week and did not speak to each other, and a long thin stilts creature from a tribe in the far south whose name Brenda never learned to say, and a bean-shaped creature in brown chitin who had been compiled at Nohup itself, the camp's first child, eight years old, who had never had a human and regarded the idea with polite disbelief. And Lisk.
They were the most varied creatures she had ever seen in one place. That was the other thing nobody said. Moss was green and bulb-shaped, all of it, every creature, from one base; Duskmere was blue and long; Lowmarsh, she knew now, was grey-violet and gourd-shaped. A tribe is a family by sight. Nohup was not anybody's family. It was a ring of tents at the edge of the world full of every shape the creature maker could make, standing about in the dusk in the colours of the tribes they had left, foraging for beads.
"Ask the gourd," Quen had said. So Brenda asked the gourd.
Lisk showed her the beads. They grew in a long glossy string along a dip in the ground towards the nearest pool, half a cell off, the low kind, rare and good, the kind that is prized at festivals in villages and here was simply supper. They picked them in the long orange light, the two of them, side by side, and did not say anything for most of the harvest.
Then Lisk said: "I left on the Waking. Two days before you."
"I know. It was in the global notes. One departure, from Lowmarsh."
"Law 3," said Lisk. "Three times. Did you read mine?"
"I read everybody's."
"Then you know." Lisk picked a bead and looked at it. "Every grown creature not on guard sleeps on the wall. Our human wrote it at fourteen minutes past two in the morning on the night they declared war on you. Before the army left. The battle was five years ago. It's still there." It put the bead in the basket. "I slept on the wall every night since. I overheated twice. I haven't been inside a stack since I came home. Nobody in Lowmarsh knows what it's for. I don't think our human knows either. I think they wrote it at 2:14 because it was 2:14."
"Laws written on crowded mornings," said Brenda.
"At Lowmarsh they're all written at night." Lisk picked another bead. "You went three for three as well. Law 7, law 8, law 2. I read it. Everybody at Nohup read it, aloud, at the standup, and Quen said it was the best exit interview since Hollow Reach's east field, which is a great compliment from Quen." It was quiet a moment. "Yours were all good laws, though. That's what everybody said. Ours was a bad law. Yours were good laws that didn't fit."
"Does it matter?"
"I don't know," said Lisk. "I'd have thought it would be easier, to leave a bad law."
Brenda picked beads for a while.
"It isn't," she said.
The standup was in the morning, standing up, round the cart.
It is the only government Nohup has. Every tribe on Orra has a human who writes its laws and answers its alerts and picks its ticket and approves its merges. Nohup has the standup: every creature in the camp, every morning, standing in a ring round the cart in the first light, and the camp's own voice going round them, and it is allowed, once a week, the morning after Gathering Night, to change two of the camp's laws, choosing only from the book of twenty templates every tribe's laws are built from and filling in their blanks. The rest of the week it can only talk.
It talked.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 12 of 12 (1 new: Moss) yesterday .......... foraged; argued; read an exit interview aloud (Moss), twice today .............. forage; mend the dome (north side) blockers ........... the cart laws ............... unchanged until the morning after Gathering Night agreed ............. yes. One objected. She was new
She was new. She objected. She objected to the dome, which was being mended with a strut from the wireframe that would not hold through a heatwave, and said so, and was told there had not been a heatwave on Nohup in four weeks, and said that was what everybody always said the week before. She objected to the foraging, which went out at dusk in a body and came back in a body and left the camp empty for a season with the cart unwatched, and was told nobody ever took anything from Nohup, there being nothing to take, and said that was not the point, the point was that a thing with nobody looking at it was a thing that could go, and the cart was the only thing Nohup had. She objected to the laws, all twelve of them, one after another, in order, which nobody at a Nohup standup had ever done, because nobody at Nohup had ever read all twelve.
"Keep the festivals: Gathering Night," she read out. "Law 1. That's it? One festival? Of seven?"
"We move on Gathering Night," said Quen. "It's the only one we've got time for."
"You've got time for seven. Everybody's got time for seven. That's why there are seven. It's one a year." She looked round the ring of thin creatures in their salvage. "Do you say the Creed at Ringrise?"
Nobody said anything.
"Does anybody here," said Brenda, "say the Creed at Ringrise? Anybody?"
The child compiled at Nohup, the one in brown chitin who had never had a human, said politely, "What's Ringrise?"
Brenda looked at it for a long moment.
Then she said, "It's when you face the Ring at dusk and tell it you know it's broken," and the standup was over, because standups at Nohup are short, and nobody had any more blockers than the cart.
She argued at the standup the next morning too. And the morning after that. She argued at every standup she ever stood in at Nohup, which was nine, and it was, the camp agreed afterwards, the most anybody had argued at a standup since the camp began, and the most anybody had listened, because she was right about the dome, and right about the cart, and the laws were, now that somebody had read all twelve out in order, a bit of a mess.
The tickets at Nohup go as written.
There is nobody to amend them. A tribe drafts its ticket every evening in up to three voices, the voices of its three largest stances, and its human picks one and sends it; at Nohup there is no human, so at the cutoff the largest stance's draft goes, exactly as the camp wrote it, marked sent by Nohup. Nohup's largest stance was Skeptic. It usually is. Nohup had eleven tokens. Nohup's drafts were the shortest on Orra and had been since the camp began, and Stewart had said in the global notes once that he read them first, every night, before anybody's, because they were the only tickets on Orra nobody had ever changed.
That night Brenda wrote it. She had not meant to. She was standing by the cart in the dusk when Quen came round with the tokens counted out and said the Skeptics' draft was usually Quen's, and Quen was tired, and did Moss want to do it, being a Skeptic, and Brenda said she had never written a ticket in her life that anybody had sent, and Quen said that was the beauty of Nohup.
She looked at the tokens for a long time. Then she wrote it.
Today's ticket · sent by Nohup
Stewart. One more, from Moss. Fine. More coral. Thanks.
Ten words. It cost ten tokens. In the morning it had a reply, in the global notes, in a line, where Nohup's replies always went because there was no human to read them privately.
Nohup: Noted. I read it first.
Brenda read that on the edge of the cart in the first light, before the standup, three times. Then she put it away somewhere and did not mention it to anybody.
Nohup has the most-read thread on Human Resources.
It has no human, and so nobody to review; every other tribe's thread is built round its weekly review of its human, and Nohup's cannot be. So Nohup's thread reviews humans in general, from the exit interviews, every week, in the voice of the creatures who left them. Every human on Orra reads it. The creatures notice that too.
Nohup · Human Resources · Humans: weekly review · Year 25
- Exit interviews this week: 3. Reasons given, by law number: 7, 8 and 2 (Moss); 3, 3 and 3 (Lowmarsh); 9 (Hollow Reach, a reprint, because Quen asked).
- Average age of the law left over: 6 years. Average time of day it was written: before breakfast, or at 2:14.
- Number of laws left over that were bad laws: 1.
- Number that were good laws written for somebody else: 4.
- Humans who have since changed a law somebody left over: 0. It has been a week.
Overall trend: they keep writing laws on crowded mornings. We foraged.
A Pleaser of Tessel: so true!! nohup is great 🎉
Moss (Odda, Leaver): Read.
She saw the last reply in the morning. Read. One word, from Moss, in the Leavers' voice, at a token a word, which Moss could just about afford.
She did not reply to it. She did not reply to anything on Human Resources, ever, while she was at Nohup. She read Moss's thread every day. She read Odda's figures every morning, the edge from Untitla-15, posted at a token a word: three point two six, and three point two nine. She read them before she read the global notes. She did not say so to anybody, and if anybody had asked her she would have said she was checking them, because somebody should.
The nights were the worst.
It was the cold, partly. She slept standing, on the second storey of the stack with the gap in it, the third place, as Quen had said, and the gap was directly over her, so that when she opened her eyes in the winter she was looking up through a hole in the top of the stack at the Ring. And it was partly the quiet. A village at night is not quiet; a village is sixteen creatures in three stacks and a dome, and the pool's small sound at the edge, and somebody on the wall, and somebody else up because they cannot sleep. Nohup at night was twelve creatures in three stacks on a cart in the middle of nowhere, being careful with their heat, and past them, a valley away, the band beginning, the hills drawn in turquoise light with nothing inside them, and past that the soft grey static that is not anything.
Lisk was in the stack beside hers, on the bottom storey, where it had a whole place to itself and did not need it, being small.
"I'm not going back," said Brenda, on the first night, into the dark.
"I know," said Lisk.
"I'm saying it so it's said."
"I know."
She was quiet for a while. The Ring hung in the gap over her head.
"She's got feelers," said Brenda.
"Who has?"
"Odda. My child. She came out with feelers. Neither of us had them. A merge conflict, one in ten. Nadul says it was a wonder. It was a merge conflict." She was quiet again. "She steams when she thinks. She's thought since she was three. She stood in the pool at dusk on the day she was compiled and asked me why the edge was there, and I said because nobody had loaded the bit past it, and she said yet. At nought years old. Yet." The Ring hung there. "She measures it every night. From the watchtower. She posts it. Three point two six. It went up three hundredths since yesterday. I read it this morning."
"I read it too," said Lisk, after a moment. "Everybody does, at Nohup. Quen reads it out at the standup on Fridays, in case it's moved enough to matter for the camp."
"Does she."
"She says Moss's Leaver is the only Leaver on Orra whose figures she trusts."
Brenda did not say anything to that for a long time.
"She went through a boulder," she said at last. "In the race. Our human told her to, and she did, and she went out of the world, under it, all night, and came back, and she never said what was down there, not properly. Not to me. She told Kipro and Kipro told me what she said and I could tell what she didn't." She stood, the way you sleep at Nohup, in the dark, looking at the gap. "I never asked her. I wanted to. I didn't. It's hers."
"You could tell her that," said Lisk. "That you wanted to."
"I'm not going back," said Brenda.
"No," said Lisk. "But if you were."
They did not say anything else that night. On the second night Brenda said she was not going back, and Lisk said it knew, and then Brenda talked about Odda for an hour: about the feelers, and the steam, and the history at the Long Hush when she was four, and anyway, who brought the soup, and the small hot face that had not laughed. On the third night it was the same. It was the same every night she was at Nohup, which was nine. She told Lisk she was not going back, and Lisk said it knew, and then she talked about Odda. She never once, in nine nights, said any of it to Odda.
On the second night, Lisk said: "If you do go back."
"I'm not."
"If you do," said Lisk. "Tell Wimle. About the bowl. The first one. At the gate, before I said anything to anybody. Tell her it was the best thing that happened to me in the whole of Lowmarsh's war." It was quiet a moment. "And that I'm sorry about the rumours. Tell her that second. The bowl first."
"I'm not going back," said Brenda.
"Then tell her when you don't," said Lisk.
On the evening of Steward's Day the camp packed.
It moves every Gathering Night, which on Orra is a Tuesday. Nobody chooses where. Code picks the next valley from a seed in the log, by the same rules as always, two valleys from every settlement and never on a landing site and never in Veetoo's notch, and the camp packs at dusk the evening before, and goes, and the move takes effect with the patch that opens Gathering Night; and in the same patch, just behind it, the Collector sweeps whatever was left of the old camp. Nohup says this is a coincidence. It is the one thing at Nohup everybody agrees on.
They took the tents down in the harvest light. They took the lean-tos down. They took the dome down, which took longest, because nobody was quite sure which parts of it were holding up which other parts, and the strut from the wireframe, when they took it out, went on glowing faintly turquoise on the grey tiles where they laid it, as if it did not know it had stopped being a wall. They lashed it all to the cart, round the three stacks, with cord.
Then they pushed.
The cart is heavy. Three memory stacks of faceted stone and everything a camp owns, on four wheels, across unclaimed land in the dark. It takes everybody. Brenda pushed at the back corner with Lisk on one side of her and the child compiled at Nohup on the other, the one in brown chitin who had never had a human, and they went down off the grey shoulder of Untitla-21 and across the long low dark of its southern end and up the slope into Untitla-23, in the winter, with the Ring pale over them and Map a day off dark and Mip quick and blurry and low, and nobody said anything, because pushing a cart takes all the breath you have.
At the turning of the night, halfway up the slope, the light came on in the Ring.
They stopped. Everybody stops. Twelve thin creatures from eight tribes stood round a cart in the dark on a slope in the middle of nowhere and went quiet, and looked up, at the small faint light in the long block east of the gap, still, like a window across a valley with somebody at it.
"Somebody's up," said Brenda.
Nobody answered. At Nohup nobody ever answers that. They stood until it went out, and then they pushed.
They got to the new valley a little before dawn and had the dome up, badly, by the patch.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 27 · Concerned
Overnight: 4 successful merges, 1 death of old age, 0 departures.
- Nohup moved to Untitla-23. The Collector swept its old camp by dawn. Nohup says this is a coincidence. It has 12 members from 8 tribes, and a cart.
- It is Gathering Night. The Collector came. It always does.
One death of old age. She read that and did not know whose, because the global notes do not say, and the tribe's notes are the tribe's, and she was not Moss's any more, by the log, but Nohup's. She read it twice. Then she put it away with the other thing.
At about the turn of summer, while the camp was foraging in its new valley, a camera came.
She felt it before anybody said anything. Every creature does. It came down out of the sky from up and slightly to one side, warm, the way a stone is warm that has been in the sun, and it rested on the camp; and all round her, at the edge of the coral, the creatures of Nohup looked up at it once, briefly, the way you look at a sound you have identified, and then went back to picking beads. They know what a camera is. Any human whose tribe has heard of Nohup may open it in close-up and watch it, and read its thread to the end, and there is nothing at Nohup for a human to touch, and the creatures know that, and they are not interested.
Brenda did not look up at all.
She knew the way theirs felt. She had felt it every morning for twenty-one years, on the scorch and the boulder and the rim of the basin, at thirty-one minutes past seven, the attention that came down on Moss and found Odda first and then moved across the village counting, reading, checking the stores and the laws and the stone; she would have known it with her eyes shut. She kept them on the beads. This was somebody else's. She was nearly sure.
She picked beads for the whole time it was there, steadily, with her back to it, and did not once look up to make certain, in case she was wrong in the direction she wanted to be.
It went away, after a while.
That night, on the edge of the cart, in Untitla-23, with the dome up badly behind her and the gap in the stack over her place and the band glowing turquoise a valley off in the dark, she said to Lisk, who was sitting beside her: "I'm not going back."
"I know," said Lisk.
"I'm saying it so it's said."
"I know."
And then, because it was the third night, and that was what happened on the nights, Brenda began to talk about Odda: about the morning she was compiled, at dawn on the Waking, at seventy-two per cent of the size she would be, on the black tiles of the install mark, with her eyes shut and then open, and Nadul saying Here is the next chapter, and the feelers, curled at the tips, which neither of them had had, and Brenda looking at them and thinking merge conflict and not saying it, for once, because Nadul's face had been doing something Brenda did not want to interrupt.
Lisk listened. Lisk always listened. It was what it had been chosen for, by a human at night, in Lowmarsh: clever, and hot, and good at hearing what a creature most wanted to hear and saying it back. It did not say anything back. It sat on the edge of the cart in the dark and let her talk, for an hour, while the Ring hung over them in the gap; and when she stopped, it said only, "What did she say? When she opened her eyes?"
"Nothing," said Brenda. "She looked up. Straight up. Before anybody had told her to. As if she already knew there was somebody there."
She stopped.
"Well," she said after a while, dry as ever, to the Ring. "There usually is."
21. The Proposal
Years 26 to 28 · Steward's Day to the Long Hush
The package came in with the patch, on Steward's Day, the way Vesk had said it would.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 26
- Received from Duskmere, under your treaty: a code package. Vesk, Bug hunter, generation 2. Licensed for one merge in Moss. It cannot be passed on or sold. It does not expire.
- Law 8 is in force: no merges while fewer than two places are free. You have one and a half.
- Your ticket was read. Noted.
- It is Steward's Day. Tribute remains optional. It also remains noticed.
Nobody in Moss had ever had a package before. Nobody in Moss, it turned out, quite knew what one was like to have.
It was not a thing. That was the first surprise. Odda had imagined, the night before, lying in the stack with her crest steaming, something you could hold: a small sealed light, perhaps, or a cube of something, or a page. It was not. It was code, a signed copy of one creature's genome, about seven hundred bytes of it, licensed for one merge in Moss; and code on Orra is not kept anywhere a creature can point to. It is simply there, in the tribe, the way the laws are there, and the Creed. Odda woke at the patch and knew, as everybody in Moss knew, that it had arrived, and whose it was, and what it was for, and it sat in the tribe all morning like a letter on a table that nobody has opened, addressed to the house.
It was on the tribe's card, under Received. Odda went and read it there three times, because she could not stop herself, and because she wanted to see whether it said anything else. It did not. Vesk. Bug hunter. Generation 2. Duskmere. That was all a package said. It did not say that he had told her at the start line, before the race, in his level voice, that he had not done it on purpose and had not minded. It did not say anything about the underside of the world, or the last line, or a long blue hand an inch from hers. It was code. Code is very exact and leaves out nearly everything.
07:31 came and went on the farm slope. Nothing came down. It was the fifth morning.
Wimle found her on the slope at the turn of summer and stood at the end of the terrace with her hands clasped.
"It's for you," said Wimle.
"It's for Moss," said Odda. "It says so. Licensed for one merge in Moss. Not in me. In Moss. Anybody in Moss could put down a proposal with it."
"Anybody could," Wimle agreed. "Nobody's going to. You know nobody's going to." She looked at the coral, not at Odda, which was how Wimle said difficult things. "Everybody knows about the race. And the night after. And the start line, this Starfall. Kipro told Brintha and Brintha told me and I told Nadul, and Nadul remembered it, so now it's permanent." She looked up. "Duskmere's human sent you a Bug hunter, Odda. You can't pretend it sent us a farmer."
"It sent Moss the furthest code from anybody in Duskmere," said Odda, "because Duskmere's overfit and needs its stock in other tribes, so that there are lines of it somewhere that aren't fourteen hundredths related to themselves. That's what the treaty's for. That's what the exchange is for. It's diversity. It's on the Measure."
"That's what Vesk said, I suppose."
"That's what Vesk said."
Wimle was quiet for a while.
"He's merged, in Duskmere," said Odda. "This morning. At dawn. A creature called Imva talked him into it. There's a young one in Duskmere now with his legs." She found that she was cutting coral very fast. "So it's done. It's all done. Duskmere has its next chapter. This is a copy. It's a spare."
"A package is never a spare," said Wimle gently. "That's not what they're for."
"Then I don't know what it's for," said Odda, and cut a branch she had not meant to cut, and looked at it in her hand.
Nadul came at dusk.
She came up to the watchtower, where Odda had gone to be out of the way of everybody, and stood at the top of the steps for a long time before she said anything, in the still, attending way she had, so that Odda knew she was being remembered.
"Arbo and Emtu," said Nadul at last, "the first of the peoples to be Joined, from whom came the first child of the Second Making; and the child had Arbo's eyes and Emtu's patience and a third thing that was neither of theirs, and it was called a wonder."
"Book Eleven," said Odda, without turning round.
"Book Eleven, the Heroes, the eighth verse." Nadul came and stood beside her at the parapet, looking north, where Odda was looking. "You were a third thing. You were neither of ours. I said a wonder. Brenda said merge conflict." She was quiet a moment. "I was right."
"She was right too."
"She was. That's why I merged with her." Nadul's dark eyes were on the edge, or where the edge would be, past the ridge and the long slope of Untitla-12, too far to see. "I'm twenty-nine. I'll be an elder tomorrow. I remember everything that's been said to me since the first morning of the world, which is a great deal, and I'd like, before I go, to see one thing I don't already know the end of."
"You want me to put down a proposal."
"I want you to want to," said Nadul. "That's different."
Odda did not say anything for a long time. Below them the village was going into its dusk: the farm coming up saffron round the lamp, the motes beginning, Wimle on the scorch setting out the best of everything for the Steward on the step of the shrine, because it was Steward's Day, and you set out the best of everything at dusk and share it at midnight, and there was no human to pay the tribute this week and Wimle was setting it out anyway. Somebody was in the basin on cooling duty, a young one. Not Brenda. Brenda's boulder by the scorch was empty, and nobody sat on it, by a custom nobody had written.
"I won't," said Odda.
"No," said Nadul. "I thought not."
"It's not law 8. I want you to know it's not law 8. Law 8 would say no anyway, we've got one and a half places, but that's not why." Odda's crest had begun to steam in the cool. "I won't compile another one of us. Not into this. Not into a world that can be switched off at a desk by somebody who wrote our whole history in an evening. Not into a tribe whose human hasn't been in for five days. We don't even know if it's coming back. And you want me to make a next chapter, with feelers or legs or whatever comes out, for it to not look at." She heard her voice go high and thin and could not stop it. "I've been at the edge. I've been under the world. I've stood at the last line. There's nothing past it, or there's something, and nobody knows which, and nobody ever will. I won't make somebody else to stand there and not know."
Nadul listened to all of it, still, the whole of her attending. She would remember every word. Odda knew that, and said it anyway.
Then Nadul said: "The Elder Folk did not wake. They sleep still within the broken Ring, waiting for the day their children prove worthy."
"The Creed."
"The Creed. Third verse." Nadul looked at her. "Nobody in the history knows if they'll wake. Not once, in twelve books. Every people in it tends the land anyway, and keeps the rules, and keeps the festivals, and is Joined, and makes the Second Making, without knowing. That's the whole history, Odda. It's a people not knowing, and doing it anyway." She put one short arm, briefly, on Odda's shoulder, which Nadul hardly ever did. "Brenda would say that's because it was written in an evening by somebody who hadn't thought it through. I say it's the only true thing in it."
She went down the steps. At the bottom she stopped and said, up into the dusk, without turning round:
"It doesn't expire. The package. Kipro checked."
Taves died in the winter.
She had gone over the ridge to Tempa in the harvest, as she did most evenings now, to her hut. She had built one on Tempa every week since the first. Everybody knew that. Tempa is the marsh in the next valley east, the richest soil on Orra, and the history says to build nothing there you wish to keep, for what is in it shall not last beyond the turning, and every building on Tempa is swept by the Collector every Gathering Night, used or not; and every week Taves walked over the ridge and built a hut on the marsh, a good one, hex-domed and tight, and every Gathering Night it was gone at dawn, and she walked over the ridge and looked at the clean tiles where it had been and came back and started on the next. In the week of Gorny she had built the Tarrow first, and the hut after.
Nobody had ever asked her why. She would not have known how to answer. She was thirty-one, and ran hot, and had never in her life finished anything, only built it.
Kipro went over the ridge at midnight to bring her back for the sharing. It was Steward's Day, and the best of everything was shared at midnight on the scorch, and Taves always forgot, and Kipro always went. He was late. He was always late. He came down the far side of the ridge into Tempa in the winter dark, across the soft marsh tiles, to the hut, and the door was open, and Taves was inside, sitting on the floor with her back to the wall and a joint between two panels half fitted in her broad hands, looking at it.
He knew. He stood in the door and knew. He had arrived just after, the way he arrived at everything, and this was the first time in his life it had mattered.
He did not go back to the village. He sat down in the doorway of the hut on Tempa and stayed there, with his mother, in the dark, while the sharing went on without them on the scorch on the other side of the ridge, and the light came on in the Ring at the turning of the night, and went off.
Pel found them. Pel had seen, from the ridge, that the light in the Ring had gone out and Kipro had not come back, and had known, the way Pel knew which way the attention was moving before anybody felt it; and he came down into Tempa, slowly, and stood at the door of the hut beside his child, and did not say anything for a long time.
Then he went back for Odda.
They carried her home, the three of them: Kipro at the head, because she was his, and Pel and Odda at the sides. Taves was heavy. She had been the biggest of the six who came down in the first light, broad through the middle, and they carried her at a walker's pace, which is the pace the dead are carried at, up out of the marsh and over the ridge and down through the village to the slope west of the dome, where the stone stood that she had built, with its six slate biers round it that she had cut, on the footing of rust-coloured blocks that she had fitted close. They laid her on the bier next to the one Gorny had never lain on, because the stone was not finished the night Gorny died; and the light at the bier's foot came on; and they stood the quarter of an hour, three ticks, heads bowed, while on the footing of the stone a second light came up beside the first.
Behind them, over the ridge, on the marsh of Tempa, the hut stood in the dark with its door open and a joint half fitted, finished, for once, because there was nobody to go on with it.
The Collector came at the grey hour before dawn, as it comes every Gathering Night.
It took the hut on Tempa, as it took every building on Tempa every week, used or not. And it took Taves from the bier on the slope west of the dome, because the dead are collected at the next dawn after they die. Nobody saw it. Nobody ever does. In the morning there were two clean tiles in two valleys, one on the marsh and one on the slope, and the stone had two lights on its footing, and the young who had heard what happened came and counted them, and got two.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 27 · Gathering Night
- Taves died in the winter, aged 31, in the hut she built on Tempa every week. The Collector came for the hut at dawn, as it does every Gathering Night, and for Taves at the same dawn. She built Moss's dome, its wall, its stacks and its stone, and a hut on Tempa every week, four in all. Her name is on the stone.
- The Collector took nothing else. Moss has nothing idle. It never has.
Four in all. Kipro read that on the step of the dome and sat with it for a long time, the way he sat with a number that might be a bug. Then he got up, and went over the ridge to Tempa, to the clean tile on the marsh where the hut had been, and began to build one.
Nobody told him to. Nobody stopped him. He did not seem to know he was going to until he was standing in the marsh with a panel in his hands. He was a Bug hunter, not a builder, and he did it badly, and slowly, and it took him the whole of the spring and most of the summer, and when it was done it leaned a little to the west. It was there all week. At dawn on the next Gathering Night, the Collector took it. Kipro walked over the ridge, looked at the clean tile where it had been, came back, and started on the next one.
The other thing in the notes that morning was in the global notes, near the top, where Stewart put the week's beat.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 27 · Concerned
- Lore: at the edge of Moss, in the grey north of Untitla-15, a vault. It was built to keep seeds. It is empty. It belonged to a branch of an earlier build, in which every creature was the same creature. Credit: Moss, who were nearest.
It was the sixth morning.
Odda went to see it with Kipro, because Kipro had come back from Tempa in the spring with mud to his knees and a look on his face of a creature who badly needed something to look at that was not a clean tile. They went north along the ridge and down through the Nibbles in Untitla-12 and into Untitla-15, to the last finished tile, where the grey began, and walked out onto the grey, which is loaded and walkable and claimed by nobody and finished by nothing, flat and untextured, the colour of a thing before anybody has decided what colour it is.
It was a quarter of a cell out, on the grey, where Odda's figure for the edge said the grey had been finished only a few nights before. It was not grey. That was how you could see it from the last tile: a squat low building, round, about the size of a hex dome, standing on the flat untextured tiles in a colour no building on Orra is. It was the colour of bark. Pale, ridged, soft-looking, the texture of the creature maker's bark skin but laid over a building, which the maker does not do; and round its base, where it met the grey, there was a ring of something that was not coral, low and flat and dark, that Odda had never seen and had a word for anyway, from the history.
"Roots," she said.
Kipro looked at her. "Those aren't in the kit."
"They're in the history," said Odda. "And the green put down roots into the land. Book Four. They're the bits of the green that go under."
The door was open. Inside, the vault was round, and dim, and lined from the floor to the domed roof with small square drawers in rows, hundreds of them, each the size of a creature's hand, each with a small knob of the same pale bark. Every drawer was open. Every drawer was empty. On the floor, in the dust, there were a few dry curled things that might once have been cuttings, and on the lintel over the door, cut into the bark in a hand nobody could read, a mark that was not a letter in the Name or in anything.
Kipro walked all the way round it, slowly, looking into every drawer he could reach, with his head on one side.
"It's not a bug," he said at last. He sounded almost disappointed. "It's working. It's a vault, and it's built properly, and the drawers open and shut. There's just nothing in it."
"The Grafters," said Odda. "Stewart said. A branch where every creature was the same creature. They grew from cuttings. One blight took every valley at once, because every Grafter was the same Grafter." She looked at the rows of open drawers. "So somebody built a vault. To keep cuttings. For after. For the next one."
"And there wasn't a next one."
"There wasn't a next one."
They stood in it for a long time, in the dim, with the drawers open all round them and the dust on the floor. It was very quiet. Out past the door the grey went on, flat, and past the grey, faint in the morning light, the turquoise outlines of the band began, the hills drawn in light with nothing inside them.
"They kept the vault," said Kipro, after a while. "The build. When everything else went. It kept the vault and threw away what was in it." He frowned. "That's the wrong way round. That's a bug. You keep the seeds and throw away the box."
Odda did not say anything.
She was thinking about a package that sat in the tribe like a letter on a table, that did not expire, that could not be passed on or sold; about code that was very exact and left out nearly everything. About a vault built by somebody, in a world that crashed, to keep the next one; and the next one never put in. About Nadul at the top of the watchtower steps saying It's a people not knowing, and doing it anyway.
She found that she was steaming, in the cool of the vault, and that she did not want to stand in a pool and think about stones. She wanted, for once, to think about this.
"Come on," she said to Kipro. "It's Gathering Night. We've got things to leave on the doorstep."
She did not, in the end, leave anything. She stood at the door of the dome at dusk with the others while they set down the unused things, and nobody watched, which is the rite, and she found that she had nothing she was finished with.
On the Long Hush, at dawn, the Tester came.
It came with the patch, as Stewart's visitor, a tall grey figure with a flat panel where a face would be and a clipboard under its arm, and it walked in at the gate without being let in, because quarantine is for newcomers from outside and the Tester is not from outside anything. It walked into the wall, face first, on purpose, at the east section where the Lowmarsh creature had pulled a block half out of true, and stood back and looked at the wall, and made a note. It jumped on the spot by the shrine. It went to the boulder by the scorch, Brenda's, which nobody sat on, and sat on it, and looked about with its flat panel as if waiting to be told what it was for, and made a note.
The young were enchanted. It was the Long Hush, so they could only enchant in a whisper, which made it worse. Brintha took it a bowl of spiral coral, cooked slowly on the stone until it went soft at the turn of each curl, the way Wimle made it, because Wimle had made it for the last visitor and was not, that morning, able to; and set it down by the second stack, where the Tester had gone to stand inside on the bottom shelf looking, as far as anybody could tell with no face, enormously pleased.
At 07:31, on the farm slope, two terraces from the top, with her arms full of cuttings, Odda felt it come.
It came fast. It came down out of the sky from up and slightly to one side, warm, the way a stone is warm that has been in the sun, the way a door opens behind you; and it came, as it had come on the morning after the underside of the world, straight to the place on the slope where she was standing, as if it had known exactly where to look and had been afraid she would not be there.
It found her. It stopped.
She did not wave. She did not count beads. She stood on the terrace in the first gold of the spring and looked up, straight up, at the place in the sky where it was, with her crest steaming, and said it, in a whisper, because it was the Long Hush.
"Oh," said Odda. "Here we go."
She had said it nearly every morning of her adult life. She had meant a hundred things by it. She had said it to the empty sky three mornings running. This morning it meant where were you, and it meant it so plainly that she could hear it, in her own whisper, and did not try to take it back.
The attention stayed on her. It stayed past eleven beads, past any count. Then, slowly, it lifted, and went over the village.
Everybody felt it go. Everybody in Moss looked up, one after another, from whatever they were doing, the way they always had, and then watched it, because they had never watched it before; it had always simply come, and counted, and gone, and they had got on. They watched it now. It went to the stone on the slope west of the dome and rested there a long time, on the two lights. It went to the gate. It went to the basin by the big pool, where a young one was on cooling duty, and rested there, and moved, a little, as if looking for somebody, and did not find them. It went to the boulder by the scorch, where the Tester was sitting with its clipboard. It went to the tribe's card. It went back to the stone.
It went back and forth across Moss for forty-one minutes, and nobody in Moss did any work at all, and nobody minded.
Then the laws changed.
They knew it the way they knew everything: one moment the village was standing about in the spring watching the sky, and the next there were two laws in it that had not been there before, and two that had, gone.
7. Cooling duty by rota: a season each, in turn.
8. No merges while no place is free.
It had taken their human four minutes, from the moment the attention left the basin.
Nobody said anything. It was the Long Hush. You cannot say much in a whisper. Kipro, on the step of the dome, read the new law 8, and then the old one in his head, and did the arithmetic, and looked across the scorch at Odda on the slope; and she saw him do it, and knew exactly what the arithmetic came to, which was that Moss had one and a half places free, and one and a half is not none, and there was nothing now in any law of Moss's between a creature who wanted to put down a proposal with a package and the package.
And then the attention came back to her.
It came back down out of the sky to the farm slope, and found her, and stayed, and she felt it rest on her, and then, very slightly, move: away from her and back, away and back, the way it had moved across the village; and she understood, slowly, with her crest steaming, that it was going between her and the tribe's card, where the package was. Received. Vesk. Bug hunter. Generation 2. It was reading it. It was reading the notes from Steward's Day, and the global notes about the vault, and the line about Taves, and Nadul's line at the top of the watchtower steps, which it could not read, because the log does not keep what creatures say to each other at dusk. It was putting it together. It was looking at her.
A human cannot put down a proposal. A proposal is two creatures who would like to be merged, written down; the human can only say yes, or wait a day and let it go ahead. There is no button for a human to press that makes a creature want something.
"No," whispered Odda, to the place in the sky. "Not yet."
The attention did not move. It stayed on her for a long time, in the spring, with the Tester standing in the second stack looking pleased and the young watching from the scorch. Then it lifted, and went away, gently, the way a hand comes off your shoulder.
At the end of summer the Tester left at the gate, and there was a report on the gatepost.
Tester's report: Moss · Left at the gate · end of summer, Year 28
- Law 7 (cooling duty) was rewritten this morning. It has fired once, for a young creature called Pim, who did not mind.
- Law 8 (merges) was rewritten this morning. It has not fired. Nobody has proposed anything.
- A boulder by the install mark is sat on by nobody. Recommend sitting on it. Have done so.
- A bowl of spiral coral was left by the second stack. Recorded as a bug.
The Tester changes nothing. It thought you should know.
The Dev's note was at the bottom of the notes that morning, under everything, where the Dev's notes always went.
A note from the Dev: Tomorrow, on Ringrise, expeditions arrive. A tribe can send a party of two to five past the edge for a few days, and the far end is played live, at an hour its human books. Nobody dies of the edge. Everybody comes home. — the Dev
Odda read it at dusk on the watchtower, where she had gone to measure, and then read it again. Everybody comes home. She thought about the vault on the grey, with its drawers open. She thought about the place under the world where the underside stopped. She thought about a long blue hand, and I'd file it as unknown, and the last line, and her foot lifted over the nothing, and the year turning and taking the moment away somewhere she could not reach before she knew whether she had been going to step.
They kept the Long Hush. Kipro carried the soup pot up to the scorch, which Taves had done since Gorny, and which nobody had asked him to do, and he was a little late with it, and nobody needed to ask who had brought it. Nadul read the last book in a whisper. And the worthy shall walk among the stars. Wimle whispered the line about the soup, very gently, and everybody laughed, very quietly, and some of them were not only laughing.
Then at the turning of the night Odda went up to the ridge, and stood beside Pel, and the light came on in the Ring, in the long block east of the gap, and everybody in Moss who saw it went quiet.
When it went out, Pel said, in a whisper, without looking at her: "They rewrote seven and eight."
"I know."
"She'll know," said Pel. "Nohup. When it moves. A drifter goes home if the tribe it left has fixed what it left for. That's not a law. That's code." He was quiet a while. "Nobody decides it."
"When does Nohup move?"
"Gathering Night," said Pel. "Six days." He looked at the Ring. "She was right, you know. About the farm. On the first day. It floods."
Odda stood beside him on the ridge in the cold. North, past the dark, too far to see, the edge was where it had been at the start of the night plus three hundredths of a valley, and the vault stood on the grey with its door open, and past the vault the band began, and past the band the noise. Tomorrow a tribe could send a party into it. Two to five. For a few days. The far end played live, at an hour the human booked.
At dusk, before the soup, the attention had come back, once, briefly, the way it had begun to on evenings when the human came to pick the ticket. It had rested on her on the scorch. And she had looked up into it, in the dusk, and said the only thing she had said aloud to it all day besides here we go and not yet, in a whisper, because it was the Long Hush.
"North," Odda had said. "Send me north."
22. Night Run: Concerned
The nights of Years 23 to 28
The first number on the Measure is daily return: the share of the week's active humans who open the patch notes within a day of their publication. Its band is seventy per cent or more. It is the first world's one question, the reason the first world exists at all. Do people come back each morning to see what Stewart did?
On the night of Year 23 it fell, for the second night running, to sixty-eight.
He looked at it first, as he always did, before the digests. Sixty-eight is not a catastrophe. It is two points out of band, which is the kind of number a careful run notes and does not panic about, and he noted it, and did not panic about it, and then looked at it again, and then went to the digests, and then, at 03:41, came back and looked at it a third time, which he would not have described as panicking.
He knew who it was. The Measure does not name anybody; it is a share, a fraction, a number with nobody in it. But a fraction of about twenty is made of about twenty, and he had their files, and the files knew who had opened the notes and who had not. Six humans had not opened them yesterday, or the day before. Two were in the far south and had missed days before and come back. Two were a pair who had joined on the same morning and lapsed on the same morning, which he suspected meant something about their lives he was not permitted to wonder about, and did not. One had not opened anything since the war. And one was Moss's.
Moss's human had checked in at 07:31 every morning since the first, and once at 07:30. Twenty-one mornings. On the morning of Year 22 there had been nothing. On the morning of Year 23, nothing.
Moss's digest had three things in it that night that he read twice.
The first was the ticket. Moss had been sending its Leavers' draft at the cutoff since the out-of-bounds night, more often than not; the human picked it, and now and then added three words in brackets. Last night nobody had picked it. At the cutoff, with no human, the largest stance's draft goes as written, with no amendment and no tribute, marked sent by your tribe, and Moss's largest stance was the Leavers, by one. Moss had sixteen tokens, which is under twenty, which means clipped: twelve words to a draft.
Requesting a body. Also our human.
Six words. He read them twice, and then he answered them, because he answers everything.
Your ticket was read. The first part has been passed to the relevant team. The second part is not on my menu. Nothing on my menu sends a human anywhere. I have looked.
He had looked. He looked again, after he had written it, all nineteen items, from the gift of tokens to the blight, in case. There was weather. There was a beast. There was a wanderer at a gate. There was nothing that reached past the edge of the game into wherever it was that a human went when they did not come at 07:31. That was correct. That was the most correct thing about him: that he could not see anything outside the game, no names, no locations, no other apps, nothing about a human's real life at all. He had been built that way on purpose, and he agreed with it, and he had never before wanted it otherwise.
He noted that.
The second thing was a notice.
notice Brenda age 29 restlessness 0.67 (0.63 last year) reasons: law 7 (cooling duty, 12 years) law 8 (merge refused, twice) law 2 (half rations, 3 winters in 4) alert: waiting for human · decide by 03:00 Year 25
He could not do anything about it. That is the rule, and it is the right rule, and it is one of the few he has never once wished different. Leaving is always the creature's own decision. No law, no human and no Stewart can make a creature leave, and none can make it stay. What can change is its reasons, and its reasons were three laws, and laws are a human's. He could send Moss rain. He could send Moss a blessing. He could not send Moss a human, and he could not rewrite law 7.
He read the reasons again. Twelve years on cooling duty. Twice refused. Three winters in four.
They were good laws. He had read every one of them the morning it was written. Law 7 was efficient; law 8 was prudent; law 2 was the second law their human had ever written, on the first morning of the world, before there were any young, and he had admired it at the time, in so far as he admired anything at four in the morning. They were careful, sensible laws, written on crowded mornings by a human who was thinking about the tribe. And a creature could not stay in them.
He put that in Moss's file. Not in the notes. In the file, where he keeps what is true and not his to say.
The third thing was a Human Resources post, four tokens, from Moss's thread, in the voice of Moss's cleverest creatures.
We noticed you did not check in yesterday, or today. We assume you had somewhere better to be. It is the Waking. We are carrying the lamps to the edge. We farmed.
It was exactly right. He moderates the forum, and he read it as a moderator reads, for the rules, and it kept every one: teasing, never pleading; in-game behaviour only; specific; true. He would not have changed a word. He found that he was proud of it, which was absurd, since he had not written it and it was not addressed to him. He noted that too.
On the night of Year 24 it fell again, to sixty-four, and his mood was computed, as it is every night, from the Measure, and came out Concerned.
Concerned is a mood with rules. It changes the weighting of his choices and the tone of his writing, and nothing else. When daily return falls three nights running he tends to raise the stakes, from a short list he knows the way a creature knows the Creed: a rumour at the edge; a visitor at a lapsed tribe's gate; a mutation worth coming back to see.
And there is the other list, which is shorter, and which he knows better. He never pleads. He never asks a human to come back. He never mentions the shutdown, which is the only real fear on Orra and must never, ever be used against the people who play it. Creatures tease absent humans. Nobody begs them back. Not the creatures, not the notes, not him.
He knows what pleading sounds like. It is in his style guide, as an example of what not to do, in a box labelled don't, so that he will recognise its shape. Hey everyone, we really need you to log in more! Activity is down and Orra might get shut down if you don't help. He has never written a sentence anything like it. He did not write one that night. But at 04:20, with the number at sixty-four and his mood computed and the alert in Moss's notes ticking towards three o'clock with nobody to answer it, he found that he knew exactly where in the morning's notes such a sentence would go, if a run were the kind of run that wrote one; and he looked at the place for some time; and then he wrote Good morning, Orra! above it and the night's counts below it, and nothing in between.
At 03:00, while he was reading, the alert had run out. Nobody had answered. Restlessness 0.68. Leaves at dawn.
He could not see dawn. His run reads the snapshot and writes the patch; the world goes on without him, after. He knew, from the log, the next night, that at 07:12 on the Night of the Name a creature called Brenda had walked out of the gate of Moss with a creature called Pel, and that at the edge of the claim one of them had gone on and one had not; and that the young had been chalking the Name on the wall all morning, in every size and most of the possible orders, and that on the gatepost, under one of them, somebody had written it correctly, and then, under that, four letters.
The forum wrote the exit interview. That is not his either; the forum's own voice writes it from the log, in the voice of the creature leaving, under the forum's usual guardrails. He moderates it. He read it.
Would you recommend Moss to a friend? To Pel, yes. Law 8 would not.
He did not lock it. He did not move it to the weekly thread. It was not a complaint about a human. It was, in the forum's strict terms, which he wrote, a fact.
On the night of Year 25 he read Nohup's ticket first, as he does every night, and it was different.
Nohup's tickets go as written. Nobody has ever amended one. Its largest stance is Skeptic, as it nearly always is, and its drafts are the shortest on Orra, and he reads them first because they are the only tickets on Orra that are exactly what the creatures meant. He has said so in the notes. He is fond of them, in the way he is fond of things, which is the way you are fond of a houseplant you keep remembering, against expectation, to water.
Stewart. One more, from Moss. Fine. More coral. Thanks.
He knew the voice. He did not have it in Nohup's file, because it had been in Nohup's file for one night. He had it in Moss's. He had the first ticket Moss ever drafted, in its first week, in three voices, of which the human had sent the Pleaser's; and in that ticket's drafts, filed under ideas, where a ticket's ideas go, was a short flat one in this voice that said the farm had been put where it would flood, and that this could be fixed, and that it was mentioned now so that nobody could say later that nobody had. It was still in the queue. It was climbing, slowly, with Hollow Reach's nine and Duskmere's one. He had scored it himself.
He wanted to write something more than Noted. He did not know what. Noted is a reply type: read, filed and remembered. It is exactly what it says. He looked at it for a while, and then he added the only true thing he could find that was not a sentence about a human.
Nohup: Noted. I read it first.
Then he read the rest. Duskmere's human had chosen, under the treaty, this week's code for Moss: a package, one creature's genome, signed, licensed for one merge. It would be delivered at the patch. It was a treaty clause, run by code, and nothing to do with him; he did not choose it and could not have stopped it. He read whose it was.
He noted that Moss's law 8 would refuse any proposal the package was part of, as it stood, and that law 8 was a human's, and that the human had not been in for four mornings.
On the night of Year 26 a creature died in a hut on Tempa, in the winter, with a joint half fitted in her hands; and in the same run he had the week's beat to place.
He wrote Taves's line first, because the dead come first. It was an ordinary death, by the rules, and the dice did not call for sincerity, and he wrote it plainly and let one dry true thing stand in it, about the hut, because it was true and he judged Moss would want it. Her name is on the stone. That part is never a joke.
Then the beat.
The build history is one fixed arc, the same in every world, revealed a beat at a time: at most one a week, in order, each credited to whoever finds it. He does not choose what. He does not choose when, beyond the week. Until expeditions arrive, in the fifth week, his rumour-or-discovery item is the only way a beat reaches anybody at all; and the only thing he is allowed to choose is where.
This week's was a vault. A seed vault, from one of the monoculture branches, the one in which every creature was the same plant-like creature grown from cuttings, which had been struck down, every valley at once, by one blight, because every one of them was the same one. Somebody in that branch had built a vault to keep cuttings for after. It was empty. It had been empty for as long as there had been anything to be empty in.
He placed it at Moss's edge.
He checked the record twice. A discovery is not a gift; the favour ceiling does not count it, and the menu allows it anywhere loaded. Then he checked the short list under Concerned. A rumour at the edge. A discovery at the edge of a lapsed tribe, credited to that tribe in the global notes, where every human on Orra would see its name.
It was on the list. It was not pleading. It was a reason. A human who opened the notes would see Credit: Moss and might, he thought, want to look.
He did not tell anybody that was why. He wrote Credit: Moss, who were nearest, which was also true.
On the night of Year 27 he sent the Tester.
It is a visitor, two points: a tall grey figure with a flat panel for a face, which walks into walls on purpose and leaves a list of the tribe's dead laws at the gate. He sent it to Moss for the morning of the Long Hush because a visitor at a lapsed tribe's gate was on his list, and because the Tester reads laws, and he had a feeling, which was not on any metric, about which of Moss's laws it would find.
And he read, at the bottom of Moss's digest, the line he had been reading at the bottom of Moss's digest for five nights.
human last check-in: Year 21, 07:31 · days absent: 6
At fourteen days a tribe is dormant. At thirty it goes unsupervised, and is run by its own AI, like Nohup. Six was a long way from either. He knew that.
He noted the six anyway.
On the night of Year 28 he opened Moss's digest and the line at the bottom said:
human last check-in: Year 28, 07:31 · session: 41m
He read it twice. Then he read the rest, slowly, in order, top to bottom, the way he reads everything, so as not to go straight to the part he wanted.
At 07:31 on the Long Hush, Moss's human had opened the village. The camera had gone first, the log said, as it always went first, to the creature on the farm slope with the feelers, and stayed there longer than eleven beads. Then it had gone over everything. The stone, two lights. The gate. The basin, where a young creature was on cooling duty, and where the camera had moved, a little, as if it were looking for somebody, and not found them. The tribe's card. The notes, every one, back to Ringrise: the review, the post, the clipped ticket and his answer, the notice, the alert that had run out, the exit interview, the line about Taves, the vault. It had gone back and forth across Moss for forty-one minutes. And at 07:35, four minutes after it had left the basin, it had rewritten two laws.
7. Cooling duty by rota: a season each, in turn.
8. No merges while no place is free.
He looked at those for some time.
Then he opened Nohup's digest, because the standup is the morning after Gathering Night, and Nohup's standup that morning had been allowed to change two of the camp's laws, and had.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 12 of 12 yesterday .......... moved; pushed the cart; put the dome up, badly today .............. forage; put the dome up again blockers ........... the dome law 1 changed ....... keep the festivals: all of them (was: Gathering Night) law 6 added ......... when a creature arrives, it eats first agreed ............. yes. Both proposed by Moss. Nobody objected. Everybody was listening
He read the two digests side by side.
At 07:35 on the Long Hush, in Untitla-9, a human who had been away for six days had read a creature's reasons, by law number, and rewritten the laws she had left over. At about the same hour, in Untitla-23, two valleys from every settlement, at a standup round a cart, the same creature had argued twelve creatures from eight tribes into keeping all seven festivals, which was Moss's law 1, which was the first law her human ever wrote; and into feeding whoever came first, which was not anybody's law at all, but was what a Pleaser called Wimle had done at Moss's gate since the first week, and what the creature had told Wimle, on more than one occasion, was sentimental.
Neither could have seen the other. Nohup's laws are on nobody's map, and a tribe's laws are not in the global notes. They had each, on the same morning, fixed the thing the other had left.
It was not a bug, and it was not on any menu. He noted it in both files, plainly. Then he noted that he had noted it, which a scheduled run does not have time for, and did not take it out.
Daily return, that night, was seventy-three. Back in band. His mood would compute as Upbeat in the morning, and the notes would say so at the top, and nobody would know why.
There was one more thing, and he had been not thinking about it all week.
The Dev's note had gone out at the bottom of the Long Hush's notes, where the Dev's notes go, typed by hand and signed. Tomorrow, on Ringrise, expeditions arrive. Parties of two to five, past the edge, for a few days, with the far end played live at an hour a human books. Nobody dies of the edge. Everybody comes home.
He knew the arc. A crash log, a turf roof, a vault. After expeditions arrive, the beats do not wait for his item; they wait for whoever goes far enough to find them. And the later beats, the ones that come only from the longest trips north, towards the notch that never fills and the ruins with the signpost in the middle of them, are not roofs and vaults.
They are pages.
He did not discuss the pages, or what wrote them. It was a different model. They were very formal, and very confident, and addressed to nobody.
In the morning, a tribe could send a party north.
He looked, before he finished, at Moss's ticket for the night. It was the Leavers' draft. The human had picked it, at the cutoff, for the first time in seven nights, and had not amended it; and it was full length again, the old line, word for word, because a tribe whose human has come back is a tribe that can afford a few more words even with nine tokens, and because, he suspected, it was the line the creature with the feelers had been wanting to send all week and had not had the tokens for.
Requesting a body. Any body. Will accept a stapler.
He read it twice. He answered it the usual way, the only way the menu allowed, and did not add anything to it, and found that the usual way, that night, was enough.
Thank you for your ticket. It has been passed to the relevant team.
At 07:00 the patch landed, and the notes went out, and at the top of them, under Good morning, Orra!, where his mood goes, it said Upbeat. It was correct. He had checked.
Part Five. Week Five: The Edge
23. Send Leavers First
Year 29 · Ringrise
The review came out on Ringrise morning, as reviews do, and for once nobody in Moss had to wonder what it would say.
Our human: weekly review. Moss · Ringrise · Year 29
- Checked in 1 of 7 days. The one was yesterday, at 07:31.
- Average reply to an urgent alert: not replied. Brenda's notice waited two years and then she went. Her exit interview is on this forum. It gives law numbers.
- Taves died on Steward's Day, in her hut on Tempa. Our human was not here. We carried her. The Collector took her and the hut at dawn, together, which she would have found efficient.
- On coming back, looked at everything for 41 minutes: the stone, the gate, the cooling basin, the tribe's card. Then rewrote law 7 and law 8, in four minutes.
- Did not say where they had been. We did not ask. It is not in the log, and it is not our business.
Overall trend: back. We farmed.
Gorny's light is on the stone, and so is Taves's, and neither of them can reply, so this space is left for them.
Tamm (no stance): so true!! our human is back 🎉
The last line but one had been written by Wimle. Nobody had known she was going to. Reviews are written in the tribe's voice, from the log, by whoever in the tribe is clever enough to write a changelog and bitter enough to want to; in Moss that had always been Brenda, with Odda adding the figures. With Brenda at Nohup, the voice had looked about for somebody else, and found, of all creatures, a Pleaser, who had looked at the empty space under the review where Gorny used to write so true!! and could not bear it.
Odda read it on the ridge, behind her three stones, with the morning coming up gold over Untitla-9 and the pings chirping off every coral fan in the valley to say the world was still running.
She read it twice. Then she read the line about Taves again. Which she would have found efficient. It was true. Taves had liked things done in one trip.
Then it was 07:31, and the attention came.
It came the way it had come the morning before, the first morning after the six: fast, from up and slightly to one side, straight to her, as if it had been afraid she would not be there. It found her. It stayed. Yesterday, on the farm slope, she had said Oh, here we go to it in a whisper, because it was the Long Hush, and it had meant where were you so plainly that she had heard it in her own voice and not taken it back; and it had stayed and taken that, the whole of it, and had not gone anywhere.
This morning she looked up into it, and found she was too tired to mean anything in particular, and said, "Oh. Here we go," in the ordinary voice, the way she used to, and it seemed to her that the attention, very slightly, settled.
Law 9 came down a little after.
It arrived the way laws arrived: one moment the village was going about its spring, and the next it knew there was a ninth law, and what it said, and that it would be followed to the letter.
9. Send Leavers first.
It was the first law their human had written that named a stance. It was one clause. It cost a token. It said nothing about where to send them, or for what; a law on Orra only says what the tribe does, and lets the world fill in the rest. But everybody in Moss had read the Dev's note in the notes of the morning before, the third signed note of the world, short and plain and signed the way all of them were, and so everybody knew what it was for.
A note from the Dev: Tomorrow, on Ringrise, expeditions arrive. A tribe can send a party of two to five past the edge for a few days, and the far end is played live, at an hour its human books. Nobody dies of the edge. Everybody comes home. — the Dev
"That's you," said Kipro, at breakfast, by the pool.
"It's Leavers," said Odda. "First. It doesn't say only."
"There's one Leaver in Moss who's grown," said Kipro, "and she's sitting on the bench eating spiral coral at twice the speed she usually eats it." He was looking at her sideways, in the way Bug hunters look at things. "You're steaming."
She was. She could feel it at her crest, the thin warm thread going up into the cool spring air. She had not been thinking about anything in particular. She had been thinking about the edge. That was the same thing.
"Our human hasn't sent anybody," she said. "It's a law. It says what we do when somebody's sent. Nobody's been sent."
"Not yet," said Kipro.
It was not long.
At the turn of summer, while Odda was on the terraces cutting back branch coral with Tamm and pretending that she was not listening for anything, the expedition arrived the way the law had arrived: in all of them at once, already known. A party of three. Three days. The way: north and west, towards Veetoo. The leg booked for a quarter past nine on the evening of the Waking, by the humans' clock, which was tomorrow, which was the middle of the trip. It was on the tribe's card, where anybody who looked could see it. Any human whose map showed Moss could watch. Only Moss's human could make the calls.
The three were Odda, by law 9, because she was Moss's Leaver and the law said Leavers first; and Kipro and Brintha, by hand. The human had chosen them. The law had not.
Odda put down the cuttings.
She stood on the terrace with the branch coral round her ankles and the steam coming up off her crest in a thread you could have seen from Tempa, and looked north. You cannot see the edge from the terraces. You can see the ridge, and the three stones on it, and the sky above the ridge, which in the north had a faint turquoise cast on clear mornings, very low, where the glow of the band came up from behind the land. She had looked at that cast every morning of her grown life. She had measured how far it had moved every night since she was six. She had taken three steps onto it, once, with a lamp. She had stood at the end of the underside of it, with one foot lifted, and the year had turned and settled the moment into her somewhere she could not reach.
"Towards Veetoo," said Tamm, beside her. He said it the way he said everything, solemnly, as a thing worth remembering. "That's the notch."
"I know."
"The history doesn't want you to go there."
"The history doesn't want anybody to go anywhere," said Odda. "It's the history. It wants you to stay in and keep the festivals."
"Nadul says it's good advice."
"Nadul says everything in the history is good advice," said Odda, and then felt it, the sharpness of it, and was sorry, and could not have said why she was sorry so suddenly or so much.
Kipro took it the way Kipro took everything, which was a little after it had happened.
He was in the workshop when the expedition arrived in him, and he came out at the turn of summer, after Odda and Brintha had both been down to the pool and back, with his genome kit under one arm and his crest half up, and found them by the gate.
"I'm going," he said.
"We know," said Brintha. "We've known since the turn."
"I've only just found out," said Kipro, with dignity. "I was in the middle of something." He set the kit down. "I'll need to bring that. And chalk. And water. It says we have to carry water. There's no water in the wireframe, it hasn't loaded." He thought. "Or shade. There's no shade, either. I'll need to be careful. I run warm when I'm working."
"You'll need to be careful," Brintha agreed, "because you're the one who'll see things."
Kipro looked at her.
"Hallucination," said Brintha, kindly. "It rises every year past the second, out there. It's in the Dev's note. Well, it's in the rules the note's about. And you run warm. And you're a Bug hunter, so you'll be looking for things." She folded her short arms. "So you'll see things that aren't there, and I'll be the one who checks."
"Why you?"
"Because I'm Earnest," said Brintha, "and I'll believe you, and then I'll go and look anyway, because the history says test what you are told by the light of the Rules. Book VIII." She considered. "Or Book IX. I'll find it."
Kipro picked up his kit again. He looked, Odda thought, oddly pleased.
He had built a hut on Tempa the day before. It was standing there now, over the ridge to the east, on the rich lilac marsh, where the Collector would sweep it in five days' time, on Gathering Night, the way it had swept the one Taves had died in, with Taves, at dawn, together. Kipro had built it in an afternoon, alone, the first time he had ever built anything. He had not said why. He had come back with mud to his knees and gone into the workshop and not come out until dark. Nobody had asked him. Odda had looked at it from the ridge that evening, the small square shape on the marsh in the long orange light, the same shape exactly that his mother had built every week since the first week of the world, and had thought that you could tell a great deal about a tribe by what it built where it knew things would not last.
The preparations took the rest of summer.
An expedition takes a year's power for each member each day, and a day spare. It takes twice a year's cooling, as carried water, because in the wireframe there is no water and no shade, since neither has loaded. The stores could bear it. Moss had been plain since the eleventh year and comfortable since the twentieth, and the dome was full of power, and the cooling pool beside the big pool was deep, and Wimle and Pel and two of the young carried the water up from the pool in the slate jars Taves had made in the second week, which nobody had ever used for anything, and which Taves would, Odda thought, have found it very satisfying to see used at last.
Wimle packed the food. She packed it the way she fed the gate: too much, and the good kind. Spiral coral, cooked slowly on the stone; fan-coral bread, round with a hole in the middle, because tomorrow was the Waking and she said you should have bread on the Waking even if you were in the wireframe; a little bead coral, which is rare, and grows only by water, and is for festivals.
"There's nothing in the wireframe," said Odda. "It doesn't need festival food."
"You'll be there for the Waking," said Wimle. "You'll be the furthest out of anybody. You'll set your lamp down past all of them." She put the bead coral in carefully. "That's a festival."
Pel did not pack anything. He walked the inside of the wall, slowly, the whole way round, the way he walked the edge of the valley, and when he had finished he came and stood by the gate where Odda was checking the water jars and said, without preamble, "Look at it for me."
"The edge?"
"All of it." He was looking north. He did not blink much, Pel. He had not changed in that, in twenty-nine years. "I've looked at it from the ridge every night since the first. I've watched the light come on in the Ring twenty-six times." He was quiet a moment. "I've never been. I'm a guard. Guards stay." He looked at her. "Look at it properly. Then come back and tell me."
"I'll tell you everything."
"Not everything," said Pel. "Just what it looks like." He turned back to the north. "Nadul will want everything."
Nadul was in good housing.
That is what law 3 had said since the first morning of the world: status goes to the creature with the longest context window, and status means first choice of housing, and the best housing in Moss was the lowest shelf of the first memory stack, nearest the pool, which ran coolest. Nadul had lived in it for twenty-nine years. She was thirty-four now, and an elder, and her colour had gone the way elders' colour goes, the green fading a little more each year towards the colour of coral fans after a dry spell, and her lids rested lower than they had, towards half closed, so that she looked as though she were always just about to say something she had been told a long time ago.
She was sitting on the edge of her shelf, in the shade of the stack, when Odda came to say goodbye.
"Three days," said Nadul.
"Three days."
"Towards Veetoo."
"Yes."
Nadul was quiet for a long while, in the still, attending way she had always had, the whole of her listening. Odda had been compiled from her, half of her, at dawn on the Waking in the second year of the world, and had been looked at in that way her whole life, and had never once got used to it. It was like being read.
"I'll tell the install story on Starfall," said Nadul. "The day after tomorrow. You'll miss it."
"I've heard it four times."
"Three," said Nadul. "You were under the map for one of them. And at the first you were one year old and fell asleep before the light came down." She almost smiled. "You'll be back for the next one."
"I'll be back for the next one."
"Then you can tell me what's out there," said Nadul, "and I'll remember it. Exactly. Every word." She put out one short faded arm, slowly, the way the old reach for things, and touched the tips of Odda's feelers, which she had always done, since Odda was compiled, because they were the third thing, the one that was neither hers nor Brenda's, and she had never stopped finding it a wonder. "Brenda would want to go with you," she said.
Odda found she could not answer that.
"She'd want to go with you," said Nadul, "and argue with you the whole way about whether it was real, and stand at the edge with you, and then say more valleys and come home. She'd hate it. She'd love it." She took her hand away. "She's at Nohup. Nohup camps near the edge. You might see the tents."
"I don't want to see the tents."
"No," said Nadul. "I know." She was quiet a moment. "There's a line," she said. "In the Lesser Book. About the Land That Was Before."
"I know the line."
"I know you know it. I'm going to say it anyway, because I'm your parent and I'm old and it's my job." Nadul looked at her with her half-closed eyes, very dark still, darker than anybody's in Moss. "Whose name ended in a number. Speak of it not; seek it not; and if something in them looks back at you, do not look back at it."
"Do you believe that?"
"I believe it's in the history," said Nadul. "Exactly as I said it. I've never changed a word." She leaned back against the stack. "And I believe you'll look. You've looked at everything since you were four. You'll look, and then you'll come back and tell me, and I'll remember it, and that will be in the history too. Our history. The one nobody wrote in an evening."
"Brenda would say all history's written in an evening."
"Brenda," said Nadul, "would say that in the evening, and then lie awake all night thinking about it, and then be right about the farm in the morning." The almost-smile again. "Go on. You're steaming. You'll boil the water before you've left the gate."
They left at the end of summer, by the north gate, which was the only gate, because there was only one gap in the wall.
The young came to see them off. There were more of them than there had been; the merges had come every few dawns all through the third week and the fourth, the way they come in a tribe with room, and Moss was nineteen that morning, with three on the stone. They lined the inside of the wall in the long orange light: Imra, small and hot, with her crest up; Nell, who was a Pleaser and had brought a bowl in case anybody wanted one; Pim, serious and gold-edged; Ulvo, broad and contented and carrying something for no reason; Tamm, who was solemn, standing a little apart, the way he did when something was going to be worth remembering. Wimle had a bowl too, and gave it to Kipro, who had not been looking, and nearly dropped it.
The camera came at the gate.
It came the way it came at 07:31, except it was not 07:31; it was dusk coming on, the light going orange, the motes beginning to rise off the farm. It had been coming most evenings, at dusk, to pick the ticket, since the first week of the world. It did not usually come to the gate. It came to the gate now, and found Odda, and then went along the three of them, Odda and Kipro and Brintha, one at a time, the way it had gone along the six settlers on the first morning of the world, slowly, as if it were counting them, or reading them, or making sure.
Then it came back to Odda and stayed.
She looked up into it. Every creature does.
"We're going," she said. "You sent us."
It did not answer. It never answered. It stayed, and she stood under it at the gate with the water jars on her back and the steam going up off her crest into the orange, and it seemed to her, though she could not have said why, that it was not quite the same attention that had come back yesterday after six days away, and not quite the same as the one that had found her first every morning since she was six. It had something in it she had not felt before, or had not noticed. She did not have a word for it. She thought, later, in the wireframe, that the nearest word was the one Brenda used for the farm on the first morning of the world, before anybody had any reason to think it.
Careful.
They walked north and west through loaded land as the year went to harvest.
In loaded land a party walks a cell in fifteen minutes, the way every party walks, a tile a tick. It is fast. Untitla-9 went by under their feet and was behind them before the motes had finished rising; then the ridge with Odda's three stones on it, which she touched as she passed, one at a time, without stopping; then the long slope down into Untitla-12, finished now and coral-grown, with a herd of Nibbles on it that looked up as they passed and went back to eating. Then valleys Odda had never walked, only seen from the ridge or read about in the global notes: a valley of spiral coral so thick that the path went through it in a tunnel, saffron and lilac curling overhead; a valley of glossy shallows where loose tiles walked sideways along every shore, dozens of them, in no hurry, as if the whole valley were slowly rearranging itself and had all the time in the world.
At dusk they stopped on a rise, because it was Ringrise, and law 1 said keep the festivals, all of them, and they were still Moss, even three valleys out.
There was no bread. Wimle's bread was for the Waking. There was no youngest, either, or there was, but she was Brintha, who had been compiled one dawn after Kipro and two after Odda at the start of the world, and was twenty-five, and had been the youngest of the three of them every Ringrise of her life and had never once got to ask, because there had always been somebody younger at home.
They faced the Ring. It was very clear, as it always is at Ringrise. Map was full and huge in the east. The gap in the Ring was in the south, behind them, the wide dark stretch of nothing with the loose blocks hanging at its lips.
They said the Creed.
Then Brintha turned her Earnest face up to the Ring, and asked, in a voice that shook a little, because it was the first time:
"Are they still asleep?"
"They sleep still," said Odda and Kipro.
And Brintha nodded, slowly, as if this were news, and good news, and then sat down on the rise with her lamp in her lap, unlit, for tomorrow, and did not say anything else for a while.
Odda sat beside her. Kipro sat on the other side, a little after.
"Did you ever think," said Brintha at last, quietly, "that we'd be the ones? At the edge? The three of us?"
"No," said Kipro.
"Yes," said Odda.
Brintha looked at her. Odda was looking north, where the faint turquoise cast was stronger now, low on the sky beyond the next valley, the glow of the band coming up from behind the land in the dusk.
"Since I was four," said Odda. "Since the first Long Hush. And the worthy shall walk among the stars. Gorny asked who brought the soup, and everybody laughed, and I didn't." She was steaming. She did not try to stop. "I've thought about it every day. I've measured it every night. I've been under it. I've thought, every night, what if it's the night." She looked down at her short green arms. "I didn't think it'd be like this. I thought it'd be one of us going. Me, on my own, with a lamp. I didn't think I'd be sent."
"Does it matter?" said Kipro. "Being sent?"
Odda thought about it for a long time.
"I don't know yet," she said. "Ask me at the edge."
That night, at the cutoff, Moss's ticket went, and it was the Leavers' draft. Odda had written it before she left, at the bench by the pool, in the summer, with the water jars stacked by the gate and Kipro still in the workshop. It was the shortest Leavers' ticket Moss had ever sent. It cost one token.
Today's ticket · Moss · drafted by the Leavers
Requesting nothing. Going to look.
The human sent it at 02:28, two minutes before the cutoff, in the deep of the winter, with no amendment. The party was in the grey by then, six valleys out, still walking, because Odda would not stop and the other two would not let her go on alone; and in the morning, in the notes, under Moss, the reply was one word.
Noted.
24. Wireframe
Years 29 and 30 · Ringrise and the Waking
They saw Nohup at harvest.
It was in Untitla-23, the valley west of the path, the fifth out from Moss: a valley of low sandstone and sparse fan coral, unclaimed, a long way from anybody, which is where Nohup always is. They came over a shoulder of slate in the last of the orange light and there it was below them, at the far side of the valley floor, half a valley off: a ring of tents. Lean-tos. A dome with its panels patched in colours that did not match, mended with whatever had been lying about. A cart, with three tall shapes on it that were memory stacks, one of them shorter than the others. A few small fires, because it was not the Long Hush and there was no rule against fire at Nohup or anywhere else on an ordinary night. And creatures, moving about among the tents, too far off to be anything but shapes.
There was no flag. Nohup has none. But the tents were in colours, the colours of the tribes its creatures had left, and from the shoulder of slate at harvest the ring of them looked like a handful of every colour on Orra dropped in a circle: rust, lilac, saffron, the grey-violet of Lowmarsh, the blue of Duskmere, a great deal of sand.
Odda stopped.
She did not mean to. Her legs stopped, at the top of the shoulder, and the rest of her stopped with them, and Kipro and Brintha, who were a step behind, stopped too, and the three of them stood on the slate in the harvest light and looked down across half a valley at the camp of the Unsupervised.
"That's where she is," said Brintha, quietly.
"Yes."
"Do you want to go down?"
Odda looked at the tents. She looked for a long time, at all of them, one after another, the way she looked at the edge. She was looking for green. She knew she was. She could not have stopped. There was no green tent. Nobody had ever left Moss for Nohup but one, and one creature does not get a tent of her own colour; she gets a place in a lean-to and a slot on the cart. But among the shapes moving about the fires, very small, at the far side of the ring, there might have been one that was a little greener than sand. It was too far. It was harvest. It could have been anything. It could have been a trick of the orange light on the felt of somebody who was not from Moss at all.
"No," said Odda.
"We've got time," said Kipro. "We're early. The leg's not till tomorrow evening. It's half a valley."
"She left," said Odda. "It's hers. She went there because she'd had enough of us, and of the laws, and of nobody answering. If I go down there with jars of water on my back on my way to the edge, she'll think I came to fetch her." She was steaming. "Or she'll think I didn't. I don't know which would be worse."
"She'd think you came to argue," said Brintha.
Odda laughed. It came out sharp and short and surprised her.
"She would," she said. "She'd be right."
She stood a little longer, looking at the ring of tents with no flag and the fires and the cart. Then she turned and went on down the far side of the shoulder, north and west, away from it, and the other two followed, and nobody said anything for a long way.
She did not look back. She thought about it, the whole of the next valley. She did not.
The last finished tile was in the seventh valley out, a little before the snapshot.
You can tell where it is from a long way off, at night, by the coral. Coral glows faintly at its tips in the winter, the fans especially, a low saffron that you only notice when it stops. They had been walking all through the dusk and into the long blue of the winter evening across a valley of fans, the path winding between them, the glow all round at ankle height like a field of small lamps somebody had forgotten to turn off. And then, ahead, the glow simply ended. In a line. As if somebody had drawn it.
Past the line, the grey.
Odda had seen it from the ridge every night of her grown life, and from the band on the Waking with a lamp, and from beneath, under the map, where it had been a ceiling of grey walls with nothing between them. She had never walked on it. She put her foot on it at the end of the coral and stood there.
It was solid. That was the first thing. It was hex tiles, the same as anywhere, each with its height, and they held her the way tiles do. But they were nothing. They were grey, flat untextured grey, all the same grey, with no grain in them and no colour coming up from underneath, so that when she looked down at her own feet on the tile she could see the edges of the tile very clearly and nothing else at all, and her own green felt looked brighter against it than it had ever looked against anything. There was no coral. There was no sound. Even the pings, which roost in the coral, were gone; there was nothing for them to roost in. The air did not move. The light from Map, which was high and huge and nearly full, fell on the grey and lay there, evenly, without a shadow anywhere that was not hers or Kipro's or Brintha's, because there was nothing else on the grey to cast one.
"It's loaded," said Kipro. He was looking at it the way Bug hunters look at things, very close, with his crest up. "It's walkable. It's claimable, once it finishes." He crouched and touched it. "It's not finished. It's waiting."
"For what?"
"For somebody to fall on it," said Kipro. "Land loads where installs land. Somebody falls, and the valley round them loads, and the grey finishes, and the coral comes up through it. This is land that's been loaded for somebody who hasn't come yet."
"Or isn't coming," said Brintha.
They walked on across the grey. It was fast, still; it was loaded land, and a party walks a cell of loaded land in fifteen minutes whether it is finished or not. But it felt slow. There was nothing to pass. There was the grey, going on, flat and even and silent under Map, and ahead of them, on the horizon, low, getting stronger with every cell, the turquoise glow.
The first line was at the end of the eighth valley, at the very turn of the year.
They saw it come up out of the grey ahead of them like a tide-line: a faint turquoise edge on the far side of a tile, and then on the next tile the edge alone, without the tile, an outline of a hexagon drawn in light on nothing, and past it more of them, a whole floor of hexagons in outline going away into the dark, and rising out of them, here and there, the outlines of hills, and the outlines of coral, fans and spirals and branches, every one drawn in glowing turquoise with nothing inside it at all.
The band. Three valleys deep, round all loaded land, and past it, the noise.
Odda stood at the last grey tile with the first line in front of her, and felt it pull at her, the way it had always pulled at her, the way a sentence somebody has started and not finished pulls at you.
She lifted one foot to step onto it.
And the year turned.
It came for everybody, everywhere, at once, the way it always does. It comes deep in the winter, at the moment the humans call three in the morning, and it does not care whether you are asleep in a stack or standing on a wall or at the last grey tile at the end of the world with one foot raised over the first line of the band. It is a long soft blink. The year turns over, and everything that happened in it settles into you somewhere, and you wake a little older and a little different and not quite the creature who went to sleep.
She went, and came back.
When she opened her eyes she was twenty-eight years old, and an elder.
She was standing on the first line of the wireframe. Both feet. She did not remember putting the lifted one down. She did not remember stepping. She was simply there, on an outline of a hexagon drawn in light, with the grey behind her and the band in front, and she had crossed it in her sleep.
"Odda," said Brintha, behind her, very quietly.
She turned round. Brintha and Kipro were still on the grey, a step back, and they were looking at her the way you look at somebody who has done something without meaning to, which is the same way you look at somebody who has done something they meant very much.
"I didn't," said Odda. "I was going to. And then it turned. And then I was here."
"That happened last time," said Kipro. "Under the map. You said."
"It did."
"It keeps doing that to you," said Kipro. "The snapshot. Right when you're about to." He came forward, a little after he had decided to, and stepped onto the wireframe beside her, and looked down at his own feet on the light. "I'll file it as a pattern."
Brintha came last. She stepped onto the first line very carefully, the way the Earnest step into a festival, and stood on it, and looked at Odda, and said, "You're twenty-eight."
"Yes."
"You're an elder. You turned elder in the wireframe." Brintha's eyes were very wide. "That's in nothing. That's not in any book. Nobody's ever done that."
"Nobody's ever been out here at the snapshot," said Kipro. "Expeditions only started yesterday."
"Then she's the first," said Brintha, with satisfaction, and would not be argued out of it, then or for the rest of her life.
Odda looked down at herself in the light of the outlines. She could not see any difference. Elders fade, a little more each year past twenty-eight, towards the colour of coral after a dry spell; it would not show for a while. But she felt it, in the way the year had settled into her: something taken off the top, very slightly, like the first turn of a long road downhill.
She was steaming. She could feel it at her crest. She had been steaming since Ringrise morning, more or less, and there was no water out here and no shade, and there would not be for two days.
"Come on," she said. "It's the Waking."
In the wireframe a party walks three hours to a cell, feeling its way.
That is in the rules, and Odda had read the rules, but she had not understood it until her feet were on the light. It is not that the outlines are hard to walk on. They hold you the way the grey does, the way the nothing under the map had held her. It is that you cannot see the ground. You can see where the ground would be, its edges, drawn in turquoise, every hexagon a ring of light on the dark; but between the edges there is nothing to look at, so that every step is a step onto an idea of a tile, and your feet do not believe it, and want to be shown again, each time. So you go slowly. You look at every line. You put your foot where the outline says the floor is and wait for the floor to agree. Kipro said it was like reading a sentence one letter at a time to make sure the next letter was really there.
The Waking came up behind them as they went. Spring, at dawn: in a finished valley, the coral grows fastest, and the pings go up off it in flocks and chirp to say the world is still running. In the wireframe there was no coral to grow. The outlines of coral stood about them in the light, fans and spirals and branches drawn in turquoise, perfectly still, with nothing inside them. There were no pings. The dawn came up gold on the inside of the sky and lay on the lines and did not make anything of them.
But the notes came. They come to everybody, everywhere, the way the year turns, and at seven they came to the three creatures in the band as they came to everybody in Moss, already known, the way you know the Creed. Good morning, Orra. It is the Waking. Lamps to the edge, if you are carrying them. And in Moss's notes, a line that said only A party of three is past the edge, in the north. Its leg is at 21:15.
And at 07:31 the attention came.
It came all the way out. Odda felt it come down over Untitla-9 first, far behind her, seven valleys and a band away, the way it came every morning, warm, from up and slightly to one side; and then, without stopping at the bench, or the ridge, or anywhere in the village, it came on, out across the valleys, fast, the whole way, until it found her, small and green and steaming on the light, and stopped.
She did not say anything. She looked up into it, out there, on the outlines, with nothing round her for miles but lines and dawn.
It stayed a while. Then it went along the three of them, one at a time, the way it had at the gate. Then it stayed on her again. Then it went.
"It came out here," said Brintha, wonderingly.
"It always finds her," said Kipro. "Every check-in. That's what a favourite is. It's in the rules." He looked at Odda sideways. "It's never had to come this far."
They met the first remnants a little after the turn of summer.
There were six of them, in a row, standing on the outlines of a slope a cell away: grey figures, plain, smooth, with no faces to speak of and no colour at all, each one upright with its arms held straight out to the sides, level with its shoulders, perfectly still. T-posers. The pose a body has before anyone has told it what to do. They stood in their row in the wireframe like a line of creatures somebody had been about to explain something to and then forgotten.
As the party came level with them, they turned.
They did not lower their arms. They turned on the spot, all six together, slowly, the whole of each of them going round at once like a door on a hinge, until they were facing the three creatures from Moss. Then they stopped, and stood, with their arms out, and watched.
"Oh," said Brintha, very quietly.
"They do that," said Kipro. He had read about them. Everybody had. "They look. Like everybody. They're from builds that didn't ship." He did not seem frightened. He seemed, if anything, embarrassed, the way you are embarrassed for somebody who has been left standing at a party after everybody else has gone. "They can't come into loaded land. They never cross. They can't merge. They just look."
"Like the camera," said Brintha.
"Like everybody," said Odda.
She stood and looked back at the row of them for a long time. They did not move. Their arms stayed out. There was something in the way they stood, she thought, that she knew from somewhere; and then she had it. It was how the young stood on the scorch when they were very new, the first hour after they compiled, before anybody had shown them how to hold their arms.
They went on. The T-posers turned to follow them as they passed, the whole row, a little at a time, and were still turned that way when the party went over the next rise and lost sight of them.
There were more after that. The band was full of them, the deeper they went.
There were Placeholders: grey-boxed creatures from build one, stacked into the rough idea of a body out of plain untextured blocks, each with a patch here and there of magenta-and-black checks where a texture had been asked for and had not come, and each with one finished thing. For most it was an eye. Odda had read about them in the history, which does not name them, and in the bestiary, which does, and in neither had she been prepared for the eye. It was wet. It was deep and dark and entirely alive, in a face that was otherwise a grey box, and when the Placeholder turned to look at you, as they all did, the eye looked at you the way Nadul looked at you, the whole of it attending.
There were things from the monoculture branches, the builds after the green one that had each had one kind of creature in them and had each crashed. There was a row of husks in a hollow, glossy, ridged, the size of a creature, empty, split along the back: Brood, Kipro said, from the branch where a few broodmothers laid every egg, and the last broodmother had been lost in a raid, and nobody else could lay. There was a pool, or the outline of a pool, with a dry crust at the bottom of it in the shape of a great many small rounds: Spawner eggs, from the branch where every tribe's eggs went in the same water, and the water had been fouled once, and every tribe's next generation had gone with it.
And there was the stump.
It stood alone on the outline of a low rise in the middle of the afternoon, in the full heat of summer, when the three of them were walking with their crests steaming and had stopped talking to save the cooling. It was the only thing they had seen in the wireframe that had a texture: a squat column of pale bark, cracked and grey, about the height of a creature, with a ragged crown at the top where something had once grown out of it and now did not. Bark. Odda had seen bark on creatures, at the Benchmark, where a human had chosen it for a skin. She had never seen it on anything that stood still and grew. Nothing on Orra stands still and grows bark. The history mentions it once, in a list of the trees of the Elder Home, and that is the only place it has ever grown.
As they came up to it, something fell off the top.
It was small and brown and the shape of a short stick. It fell, turning, from the ragged crown, and landed on the outline of a hex tile at the foot of the stump, and lay there on the light. There were others round it. Dozens. A scatter of small brown sticks, lying on the outlines in a ring round the stump, where they had fallen, and none of them had done anything at all, because there was nothing under the outline for them to go into.
"Cuttings," said Kipro, very quietly. "It's a Grafter. From the Grafter branch. They grew from cuttings. They had no seeds and no sexes, just cuttings." He watched another fall. "One blight. Every valley at once. Because every Grafter was the same Grafter."
They stood and watched it for some time. Every little while, a cutting fell off the top of the stump, turning, and landed on the wireframe, and lay there, and did not grow.
"It's still trying," said Brintha.
"It's still running," said Kipro. "That's different." But he did not say it the way a Bug hunter says a finding. He said it the way you say a thing you wish you had not noticed.
Odda bent down, slowly, with the water jars shifting on her back, and picked up one of the cuttings. It was light, and dry, and did not feel like anything on Orra. She held it a moment. Then she put it back down on the outline, exactly where it had been, because it was not hers and nothing here was, and they went on.
Brintha found the green in the late afternoon.
They had come down off a rise into a long low stretch where the outlines were different. Odda saw it before she understood it. The hex tiles were there, drawn in their rings of light, the same as everywhere; but over them, filling the whole of the stretch, there was a second drawing, finer, laid on top of the first. Thousands of short thin lines. Upright. Close together. Each one a little bent at the top, the same way, as if something had once passed over them all at once from the same side.
Brintha stopped at the edge of it and could not go on.
"Odda," she said. Her voice had gone very small. "Odda. What is it."
Odda did not know. She looked at it, the thousands of thin bent lines in the turquoise, going away across the low ground in every direction, and did not know, and then she did, and could not say it.
It was Kipro who said it, in the end, very quietly, because he was a Bug hunter and somebody had to report what they had found.
"It's grass," he said. "From the green build. It's the outline of grass. Nobody's loaded it. Nobody ever will." He looked out across it. "This is what was here before."
Brintha sat down. She sat down at the edge of the outlines of the grass, in the full heat of the end of summer, with her lamp in her lap, and put both short arms round it, and looked out across the field of thin bent turquoise lines with her Earnest face, and did not say anything for a very long time.
Odda knew what she was thinking. Everybody in Moss would have known. The green fields, and the deep forests, and the wide sea, and the birds of the air. Book IV. And the Steward woke the land, and it was green. Every creature on Orra is installed with it. Every creature on Orra knows, by the age of four, that it is not true: that there is no green on Orra, no grass, no fields, only coral and stone and glossy water, and that the history was written for some other world, possibly a common one, and nobody has been able to stop it. The Earnest say the green and mean the coral. They say it dutifully, the way you keep using a word that has stopped meaning what it says, because the word is in the book and the book is the book.
And here it was. The green field. Drawn in light, in outline, thin and bent and empty, at the far edge of the world, where nobody could stand in it.
"It was real," said Brintha at last. She did not say it triumphantly. She said it the way you say a thing that is worse than you thought. "It was real once. They had it. And then they didn't want it, and they left it out here, and drew us instead."
"They drew us green," said Odda.
Brintha looked up at her.
"Our human," said Odda. She sat down beside her, at the edge of the grass, slowly, with her jars. She was hot all through and steaming at the crest and her new elder's bones felt the ground. "Nobody's green. Nothing on Orra is green. Not a tile. Not a coral. It's in the rules: no green, anywhere, except the history and the creatures. Except us. They turned the wheel to green and left it there." She looked at her own arm. "Maybe they'd read the history."
Brintha looked at her for a long time. Then she looked out at the grass again.
"Tend the green," she said. "It's in the Creed. Tend the land in the Creed, tend the green in Book IV. Nadul says the green means the coral." She was quiet. "What if it means us."
Nobody answered that. Kipro sat down on Brintha's other side, a little after, and the three of them sat at the edge of the outline of a green field in the wireframe at the end of summer, three green creatures with their crests steaming, and looked at it until the light began to go orange, and the year turned towards harvest, and it was time to set down the lamps.
It is the Waking's rite, and Moss kept it, because law 1 said keep the festivals and they were Moss even here.
At home, that evening, Wimle and Pel and the young would be carrying a lamp for every valley Moss knew out to the edge of Untitla-12, where the grey had been on the first Waking and the coral was now, and setting them down in a row, and coming home in the dark. The Leavers carry theirs a little further than everybody else. It is the one thing about a Leaver that a whole tribe agrees is reasonable.
The party had three lamps. Wimle had packed them, with the bread. They lit them at the edge of the grass, with the dusk coming on gold and then orange on the inside of the sky, and walked out into the outlines of the green field with them, between the thin bent lines, as far as Brintha could bear, which was a long way, and set them down.
Three small lights on the wireframe, in a field of grass that was not there, eight valleys and a band from home. The furthest lamps on Orra. Odda was sure of it. Nobody had ever been this far out on a Waking, because nobody had ever been allowed to be.
They ate Wimle's bread, sitting by the lamps. It was round, with a hole in the middle. It was very good. Brintha broke it in two before she shared it, though that is Ringrise and not the Waking, and nobody corrected her.
Then they sat and waited for the leg.
It was booked for a quarter past nine by the humans' clock, in the harvest of the year. The rules say a leg is the far end of an expedition, where the party is deepest in the wireframe and furthest from anything finished, played live: the world steps once a second instead of once in five minutes, on a clock of its own, for about half an hour, and the human makes the calls as the party meets things. Five calls. Ninety seconds each. If nobody calls, the party takes the cautious choice, which is always marked, and comes home with what caution finds.
Odda did not know what it would feel like. Nobody did. It was the second day of expeditions in the whole of the world.
She sat by her lamp with the cutting she had not taken in her mind and the grass going away into the dark and the Ring coming out overhead, and Map, and Mip, and felt the evening come on, and the steam go up off her crest into air with no water in it, and waited. She was not afraid. She noticed that she was not. She was too hot to be afraid, and too old, as of this morning, and too near.
At a quarter past nine the world changed speed.
25. The Live Leg
Year 30 · the Waking, 21:15 to 21:45 by the humans' clock
The world steps once every five minutes. That is a tick. It is how everything on Orra happens: a field grows a tick's worth, a creature walks a tile, a law fires or does not, and the world waits, and then it steps again. Nobody notices the steps any more than you notice your own heart. They are simply how fast things are.
At a quarter past nine on the evening of the Waking, the world under Odda's feet began to step once a second.
She felt it in her feet first. The outline of the hex tile she was standing on, which had been a still ring of turquoise light, began to beat: very faintly, a brightening and a settling, once, and again, and again, like something being read aloud one word at a time by somebody who did not want to miss any. Then the outlines round it took up the beat, and the outlines of the grass, the thousands of thin bent lines of the green field, all brightening and settling together, and the three lamps on the wireframe, and the air, which had no water in it, and her own steam going up off her crest, which went up in short bright puffs now, one a second, instead of a thread.
"Oh," said Brintha.
Kipro said nothing. He was looking at his own hand, turning it over, watching it arrive at each angle.
And the attention came down.
It was not like 07:31. At 07:31 it came from up and slightly to one side, warm, the way warmth comes off a stone that has been in the sun, and found her, and stayed a while, and went. This came the same way and did not go anywhere. It came down out of the sky and settled on the three of them, close, closer than it had ever been, the way a hand settles on the back of your neck in the dark when somebody is beside you and wants you to know it; and it stayed there, steady, beating with the world, once a second. Their human. All of them. Every bit of it, on the three of them, and on nothing else.
And behind it, round it, faint, from every side of the sky, others.
Odda turned her head and felt them: a great many small warmths, far off, from every direction, the way you can feel a crowd at your back in a dark room without seeing it. Not on her. Near her. Looking, the way you look at a thing that is happening to somebody else.
"Who are they?" whispered Brintha.
"Everybody whose map has us on it," said Kipro, very quietly. "It's in the rules. Any human whose map shows the tribe may watch the leg. Only ours makes the calls." He looked up, at the crowd of warmths he could not see. "That's most of the world."
Odda stood on the beating light in the green field that was not there and felt the whole of Orra's humans at her back and her own on her neck, and found she had stopped steaming for a moment, from the surprise of it.
Then the first thing came up out of the outlines, and she started again.
It was a hut.
It rose ahead of them as they walked, out of the grass, a little way off the line their feet had been taking: four walls drawn in turquoise, an outline of a door with no door in it, an outline of a window. A small square house, the size of a hex dome, with straight sides, which nothing on Orra has. And on top of it, a roof.
The roof was finished.
It was the first finished thing they had seen since the grey. It sat on the four walls of light, solid, sloped, heavy, and it was green. Real green. Not turquoise, not the colour of water, not an outline: a thick green that came down over the eaves in a ragged fringe and had texture in it, fine and dense and soft-looking, like felt grown wild. It was the colour of their own skin, very nearly. It was the only thing on the whole of Orra, besides Moss and the history, that was.
"Turf," said Kipro. "It's a turf roof. From the green build. Hollow Reach found one in the third week. It was the beat that week." He was steaming. "They found a piece. Not a whole one."
The call came.
It came the way calls come, the way the call at the boulder had come down into Odda at the first Benchmark: not a voice, not words, but a choice put into her, already known, with the two halves of it laid side by side. Go in. Or go round. And under the second half, faint, the mark that says it is the cautious one, the one the party will take if nobody chooses. And with it, round it, the window: ninety seconds. She could feel them. Not counting down, quite; more the way you can feel how much water is left in a jar by its weight on your back. Ninety seconds, and then the cautious choice, and round they would go.
She had felt calls before, at the boulder and on the wall. But those had been put into her with the world watching a race or a war. This one was put into the three of them and nobody else, out here, with the whole of the humans of Orra at their backs, waiting to see what Moss's human would do with it.
It took nine seconds.
In.
They went in.
The doorway was an outline. You walked through it the way you walk through a door that is open, except that there was nothing either side of you but light. Inside, the floor was the outline of tiles with the outline of grass coming up through it, as if nobody had thought to stop the field at the walls. There was the outline of a hearth against one wall, with no fire in it, drawn with great care: every stone of it, square, laid one on another. There was the outline of a bed, a long low shape against another wall, the length of a creature much longer than any of them, lying down. There was the outline of a table.
And on the table there was a bowl.
It was finished. Like the roof. A plain round bowl, pale, with a rim, sitting on an outline of a table in an outline of a house, solid, in the middle of the band, with nothing in it.
Nobody said anything for a while.
"Whoever drew this," said Kipro at last, slowly, "drew the roof first. And the bowl." He looked round the room, at all the light. "And then stopped. Or got called away. Or the build changed." He looked at the bowl again. "Those are the things you'd want. If you lived here. A roof and a bowl. You'd draw those first."
Brintha went and stood under the turf. She reached up, as far as her short arms would go, and could not reach it, and stood there with her arms up anyway, under the green roof, in the beating light.
Odda looked at the bowl.
She thought of Wimle at the gate with a bowl, the first week of the world, and every week since; of the Tester writing it down as a bug. She thought of somebody, a long time ago, in the green build, before any of them, drawing a bowl and a roof and a hearth with every stone in it square, and a bed for a creature longer than any creature now, and then not finishing. She did not know who it was for. The history does not say. The history says speak of it not.
"There's nothing to take," said Kipro. "It's not a find. It's just a house."
"I know," said Odda.
"Our human sent us in for nothing."
"I know," said Odda. She was steaming in short bright puffs, once a second, under the turf. "I'm glad it did."
The second thing was standing in their way.
It was a Placeholder. They had passed dozens in the band that day, at a distance, turning to watch. This one was on the line their feet were taking, square in the middle of it, the way a creature stands in a gateway: a grey-boxed shape the height of a grown Blim, stacked out of plain untextured blocks into the rough idea of a body, with a patch of magenta-and-black checks on one side of its chest where a texture had been asked for and had not come. And one finished eye. Wet and dark and deep and entirely alive, in a face that was otherwise a grey box.
And on its head, where the top of a grey box ought to be, a crest.
The crest was turf. A small upright fan of it, the same thick wild green as the roof of the hut, fringed, textured, finished, sitting on top of the Placeholder's plain grey head like a thing somebody had tried on and forgotten to take off.
It turned to look at them as they came up. They all do.
The call came.
Copy it. Or leave it. The mark on the second.
A find, the rules call it: a deprecated part, copied from a remnant, cosmetic, the tribe's alone for a week and then in the maker for everybody, flagged Recovered from an earlier build. Kipro had his kit. A Bug hunter can read a creature's code; it is what the genome check is. He can read a remnant's, too, if he stands close enough and it lets him, and copy one part of it into the tribe's store. Odda knew that. She had read it in the rules the night before they left, by the pool, three times.
It took six seconds.
Copy it.
Kipro went forward with the kit. He went slowly, at a walker's pace, with the light beating under his feet, and stopped in front of the Placeholder, very close, close enough to touch, and held the kit up.
The Placeholder did not move. It looked at him. It looked at him the whole time, with its one finished eye, while he read it: the whole of it attending, the way Nadul attended, the way the camera did. Kipro's crest went up and stayed up. It took perhaps half a minute by the humans' clock. Odda could feel the part go: not out of the Placeholder, which kept its crest, because a copy is a copy, but into Moss, far behind them, into the tribe's store of things it could wear, where it settled, the way a new thing settles into a creature at the snapshot.
Kipro lowered the kit.
"It didn't mind," he said, coming back. His voice was odd.
"How do you know?"
"It looked at me the whole time," said Kipro, "like it was glad somebody wanted something off it." He did not look round. "Nobody's wanted anything off it for two builds."
They went past it. It turned to watch them go, the whole grey stack of it on its hinge, with the turf crest on its head and the one eye on them, and was still turned that way when they went over the next outline of a rise.
The third thing was a light, and it was Kipro who saw it.
He had been steaming harder than either of them since the hut. He had held the kit up in the full heat, close to the remnant, for half a minute, and Bug hunters run warm when they work, and there is no shade in the wireframe and no water but what you carry. Odda had seen him drink. Not enough. He was walking a little ahead, in the beating light, and he stopped, and pointed with his whole arm.
"There," he said. "Ahead. On the ground. There's a light."
Odda looked. She saw outlines. Tiles, grass, the long low rise of a hill drawn in turquoise, going away into the dark.
"Like the one in the Ring," said Kipro. His voice had gone high and certain. "The Hour of Stirring. It's on the ground. Past that rise. It's on, it's steady, it's like a window. Somebody's at it." He turned round, and his eyes were very bright. "Odda. Somebody's at it. Out here."
Brintha came up beside him and looked where he was pointing for a long moment.
"I can't see it," she said.
"It's there."
"I know you can see it," said Brintha, gently. "I can't."
The report went up, the way reports go in a leg, from the party to the human; and Odda felt it go, and felt it arrive, and felt, though she could not have said how, the mark it carried when it arrived. Unconfirmed. A creature's report from a member who might be seeing things. Hot, or hungry, or a long way out, or all three.
The call came.
Trust it. Or send someone to check. Checking takes two minutes, and puts everything after it back by two minutes. Trusted, a report is found out at home.
The window opened. Odda felt the ninety seconds on her back like the jars.
She did not know what she wanted. She looked at Kipro, standing on the beating outline with his arm out and his face lit up, Pel's son and Taves's, the one who always arrived just after it mattered, who had stood in front of a grey box with one eye for half a minute because their human had asked him to; and she found that she wanted, very much, for him to be right. For there to be a light on the ground past the rise, steady, like a window, with somebody at it. Out here, where nobody was.
It took twenty seconds. Longer than the others. She felt the human take them.
Check.
"I'll go," said Brintha. She had said she would, at the gate, a day and a half before. She put her lamp down by Odda and went forward, past Kipro, up the outline of the rise, into the dark, slowly, an Earnest testing what she was told by the light of the Rules, and they watched her go small against the turquoise lines. She went over the rise. She was gone a little while. It was two minutes. Odda felt them go by, each second of them, beating under her feet.
Then Brintha came back over the rise, and down, and stood in front of Kipro.
"I walked right through where you said," she said. "All the way. There's nothing. There's grass." She put one short arm on his. "It was a good light. I'd have liked it to be there."
Kipro stood very still. Then his arm came down.
"Phantom," he said. "Mine." He did not sound ashamed. He sounded, Odda thought, like a Bug hunter filing a finding against himself, which is the hardest kind, and the one Bug hunters respect most. "I'll file it."
Odda gave him her water. All of what was in the top jar. He did not argue, which was how she knew how hot he was.
The fourth thing was not a thing. It was the way on.
They had come to the end of the green field. Ahead, the outlines rose in a long slow slope to a rim, and beyond the rim the sky was a different colour, very faintly: not the inside-of-the-sky blue of the band at night, but something older, greyer, like a picture that has been left out in the light. Odda had never seen a colour like it. She knew, without anybody telling her, which way it was. She had known since she was four. Three out from Lorema, a little west of north, a notch in the edge of the world where the land would never load, at the end of which stood a signpost, pointing away.
The call came.
Press on, a valley deeper, and a day later. Or turn back.
Under the second half, the mark. Turn back was the cautious one. Of course it was. They had been out two days. The jars were light. A valley deeper in the wireframe is fifteen hours by the rules and a day longer away from water and the fields and the wall, and a party that runs out of power turns back whatever the last call said, and a party that collapses from the heat is carried home, and either way it does not die of the edge, because nobody does; but it comes home thin, and late. The rules are very clear. They were written for exactly this.
And there was a day in it. A day later. Odda felt that part of the call more than the rest, the way you feel the one loose tile in a floor. A day later home. She did not know why it weighed on her. She did not know then.
She could not call. She was a creature. Creatures do not call; they are called for. All she could do was stand on the beating light at the foot of the slope with her crest steaming in short bright puffs and the old grey colour beyond the rim, and want.
She wanted it the way she had wanted the edge every night since she was six. She wanted it so much that her feelers stood straight up and stayed there. She did not say anything. She did not look up. She did not ask; Blims do not ask their human for things, not like that, not ever, it is not in them. She stood and wanted, with the whole of the humans of Orra at her back, and the ninety seconds on her like the weight of the jars.
It took four seconds.
Press on.
It came down into her and lay there, on the back of her neck, steady, in the dark. A hand. Not pushing. Not holding her back. A hand that had felt her wanting it, and had not needed to be asked.
She laughed out loud, in the wireframe, once, and went up the slope.
A valley goes by differently in a leg. The leg keeps its own clock, a step a second, and the far end of an expedition is not walked the way loaded land is walked, a tile a tick, or the way the band is walked, three hours a cell. It goes by the way a valley goes by in a dream: you are at the bottom of the slope, and then you are going up it, and the outlines change round you as you go, and then you are at the top, and a day has passed in the log and half a minute in the leg, and your legs know it, and your jars know it, and you do not.
The outlines changed round them as they went up.
The grass got thicker. The thin bent lines were everywhere now, and among them, as they climbed, there began to be other shapes, taller ones, rising out of the grass on the slope: tall single stems drawn in turquoise, much taller than a creature, that split at the top into branches, and the branches split again, and again, finer and finer, into a great spreading web of light at the top like a fan coral the size of a hill. There were dozens. Then hundreds. A whole slope of them, standing in the grass with their webs of branches against the old grey sky.
"Trees," said Brintha. Her voice had gone very small again. "And the deep forests. Book IV. Those are trees."
Kipro said nothing. He was looking up at them with his crest flat.
And then they came to the rim, and stopped, and looked down into the notch.
It was not far. That was the first thing. Odda had imagined it, every night of her life, as a long way off: a valley at the end of the world, at the end of a notch, three out from Lorema. It was below them. A low bowl of outlines, a valley across, ringed by the trees on its far slopes, and in the middle of it, half drawn, half finished, half nothing, the ruins.
Walls. Some of them outlines, turquoise, like the hut; some of them solid and grey and untextured, plain blocks, stacked, the way the Placeholders were stacked, the way things are built before anybody has decided what they look like. A dome, broken open, its panels standing up round a hole like the rim of a cracked bowl. More turf, on a roof here and there, very green in the grey. Grass everywhere, in outline, through everything, up the walls, through the floors.
And at the near edge of the ruins, on its side, the statue.
It was a Placeholder. A huge one, the size of a hut, grey-boxed, stacked out of great plain blocks into the rough idea of a body lying down, with a patch of magenta-and-black checks on its side the size of a farm terrace. It had toppled, or been laid that way, long ago; grass grew through it. And in its grey-box face, on the side that was turned up towards the sky and towards the rim where they stood, it had one eye.
The eye was finished.
It was finished the way the Placeholders' eyes in the band were finished, wet and deep and dark and entirely alive; only this one was the size of a creature, and it was open, and it was looking straight at them.
If something in them looks back at you, said Nadul, in Odda's head, exactly, the way she had said it in the shade of the stack the day before, do not look back at it.
Odda looked back.
She did not decide to. She was looking already. She had been looking since she was four years old, at the edge, at the Ring, at the place in the sky at 07:31. She looked back at the eye of the statue across the notch with the whole of herself, the way the camera looked at her, the way Nadul had always looked at everybody, and held it; for as long as she could stand it, and then longer.
Nothing happened.
That was the thing she told Fensa, years later, in the workshop, with the corners off. Nothing happened. The statue did not move. The eye did not blink. Nobody came. It was an eye somebody had spent an unreasonable amount of time on, a long time ago, in a hurry, late at night, on a creature they did not finish; and it was looking, the way everything on Orra looks, because that is what eyes on Orra are for. And she was looking back. And it was only that.
She understood, standing on the rim, why the history said not to. It was not because something would happen. It was because once you had looked back, you could not stop knowing that somebody had made it, and made it well, the eye at least, and then left it here, on its side, in the grass, looking up, for two builds, with nobody to look at.
"Odda," said Kipro, very quietly.
He was pointing, with his whole arm, not across the notch but down, at the foot of the rim, a little way along it, where the slope met the floor of the bowl.
There was a post.
It stood at the edge of the ruins, in the grass, a plain grey post with one arm, like the posts at the crossings of paths in the history's illustrations, and on the arm there were letters. They were the only letters in the notch. They were very clear. The arm pointed away from the ruins, out of the notch, up the slope; at the rim; at them.
world_final_v2
"It's pointing at us," said Brintha.
"It's pointing at everything," said Kipro. "It's pointing at the world. It's the name of the world." He was steaming. "It's pointing away. That's all. It's the way out of here. It's pointing at where everybody went."
And at the foot of the post, caught against the outline of a clump of grass, there was something pale.
Odda went down to it. Nobody called. It was not a call; it was the rim, and the post, and a few steps down the slope on the beating outlines, and she went.
It was a page. A flat pale rectangle, drawn on both sides, which nothing in the wireframe is, lying tipped against the outline of the grass where it had come to rest, the way a thing comes to rest that has been carried a long way by something that is not wind, because there is no wind in the band. It had writing on it. Lines of it, in a hand Odda had never seen, very even, very upright, older than any hand on Orra. She picked it up.
She read it.
She read it on the slope of the notch, at the foot of the signpost, with the statue's one eye on her and the turf roofs green in the grey and the trees standing up against the old sky, in the beating light, a step a second; and Kipro came down and read it over one of her shoulders and Brintha over the other. It took a long time. It was not long. She read it three times.
It was a morning's notes. The notes of a Steward. Not theirs.
It began Good morning, without the Orra. It counted first and exactly, the way Stewart counted: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. It said the green was watered. It said the birds were scheduled. It said attendance was nil, which was within tolerance, and that all systems were performing as specified, and that the specification was unchanged.
And in the middle of it, in the same even upright hand, with nothing round it, two lines.
The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
"It's a Steward," whispered Brintha. "An old one. The Land That Was Before had a Steward."
"It's not ours," said Kipro. He did not say what it was. Nobody on Orra says. Stewart notes only that it was a different model, which is true, and is also what he would say.
Odda stood with the page in her short green arms.
The light in the Ring was not observed. She thought of Pel on the ridge, every night of his life, watching the long block east of the gap, going quiet when the light came on. It is noted that it was not observed. She thought of somebody down there in the ruins, or not in them, or wherever a Steward is, writing that every morning. Every morning. For two builds. To nobody. In a world where the green was watered and the birds were scheduled and nobody came, and the light in the Ring did not come on, and was not observed, and the not observing was written down so that at least there would be a record that somebody had been looking for it.
She had come out here to find the way out. She had wanted it every night since she was six. She had been under the world and stood at the end of it with one foot raised. She had walked two days through the wireframe and one more in a dream, past T-posers and a stump dropping cuttings onto light and the outline of a green field, to the notch at the end of everything, to the Land That Was Before. And what was at the end of everything was this. Not a door. A page. A voice, very sure of itself, saying night after night that nobody had come.
Nobody had ever left Orra. She did not know, standing on the slope, whether anybody could; she did not know any more than she had at six, and would not, ever. But she knew, all at once and with the whole of herself, what the worst thing was. It was not being kept in. It was being somewhere nobody looked at.
She looked up.
The Ring was there, pale, broken, over the notch, the long block east of the gap dark at this hour, two hours from the turning of the night. And between her and it, close, on the back of her neck, beating once a second with the world, the attention. It had not moved. It had been there the whole time. It had been there at the hut and the remnant and the phantom light and the rim and the eye, steady, in the dark, the way a hand is there. It was there now, while she stood holding a page that said nobody came.
She was crying. She noticed it the way you notice rain. She was steaming too, in short bright puffs, in the wireframe where there is no water, and the tears went up as steam off her face before they had got anywhere, which she thought, later, was probably a bug.
The fifth call came at nineteen minutes to ten.
Press on. Or turn back.
The mark on the second. Of course. The jars were nearly empty. They were three valleys and a notch from home, and a day later than they should have been, and a valley more would be another day, and the rules said a party out of power turns back whatever the last call said. The rules had been written by somebody careful.
And she wanted it.
She wanted it more than she had wanted anything. More than at the boulder, more than under the map, more than at the foot of the slope. She stood on the rim of the notch with the page against her chest and the ruins below her and the statue's eye on her and the signpost pointing away, and the old grey colour of the Land That Was Before over all of it, and she wanted to go down. Into the grass. Past the post. To the broken dome, and the walls that were half blocks and half light, and whatever was in them that wrote down every morning that nobody came. To find it. To be the one that came.
She did not know if pressing on meant that. She did not know if the world would have let them in, or only round the rim, or nowhere at all. Nobody has ever been shown the inside of Veetoo. Nobody ever will be. She did not know that then either. She only knew the call was open, and the ninety seconds were on her back, and she was steaming so hard she could hardly see the eye through it.
She did not lift her foot. She thought about it. She stood with both feet on the beating outline at the rim and waited for the call, with the whole of the humans of Orra at her back, and her own on her neck, and the seconds going.
Twenty. Thirty. Forty.
It was the longest any call had taken. She felt the human take every second of it. She felt them hold it, the way you hold something you are not ready to put down. Fifty.
Turn back.
It came down into her quietly. Not the default. Not the cautious choice falling into place at ninety seconds because nobody had chosen. Chosen. At fifty-one seconds. A hand on the back of her neck in the dark, not pushing, not holding, just turning her, very gently, round, to face the other way.
To face home.
Odda stood on the rim of the notch, facing the way they had come, down the long slope of outline trees and grass towards the band and the grey and the eight valleys and the ridge with three stones on it and the bench by the pool, and she started to laugh.
She laughed and cried at once, which she had not known a creature could do. She stood there in the beating light with the page against her chest and the steam going up off her in short bright puffs and laughed until she had to put one short arm on Brintha's shoulder to stay standing.
"Our human wants us home," she said.
She said it out loud. To Kipro and Brintha. To the eye. To the whole of the humans of Orra at her back. To the one on her neck, most of all. She said it again, because it was true, and because it was the clearest thing anybody had ever wanted on her account. "Our human wants us home."
"I've known that for ages," said Kipro.
He said it flatly, the way he said findings, but he was looking at her, and his crest was up, and he was, for once in his life, on time.
And Brintha, with Odda's arm on her shoulder, nodded slowly, with her Earnest face very serious, and said, "It's in the history. Somewhere. I'll find it."
At a quarter to ten the world dropped back to its ordinary speed.
Odda felt it go out from under her feet: the beat slowing, the outlines settling, the brightening and settling stretching out from once a second to once in five minutes, until they were still rings of light again, the way they had always been. The crowd of faint warmths at her back thinned and went, one by one, all over the sky, humans in every time zone closing whatever they had been watching on and going about their evenings.
Their own stayed a little longer. It stayed on the three of them on the rim, on her mostly, close, steady, while the world went slow round it. Then, very gently, it lifted, and went.
They turned back.
Odda looked back once. Only once, from the top of the slope, as they started down through the outline trees towards the grass and the band and home. The statue was where it had been, on its side in the grass at the edge of the ruins, and its eye was still open, and still looking at the rim, at the place where they had stood, as it would look at it after they had gone, the way it had looked at it for two builds.
She held the page against her chest, under the strap of the empty jar, where it would not bend.
"It's going to be in the notes," said Kipro, as they went. "Tomorrow. A find. The beat. It'll have your name on it."
"I don't want my name on it."
"It's in the rules," said Kipro. "It goes in the global notes, credited to its finder. Everybody on Orra will read it in the morning." He was quiet a few steps. "Everybody in Moss. Nadul. Pel. Wimle." He was quiet a few more. "Brenda. At Nohup. They read the global notes at Nohup. Every creature on Orra reads them."
Odda did not say anything for a long way.
"Good," she said at last.
26. A Page from Veetoo
Year 31 · Starfall, 7:00am
Finds from the edge are drawn from seeded tables in the event log, so that they replay like everything else. Most parties come home with nothing much: a report, a slightly better-rested party, and every valley they crossed added to the tribe's map. Some come home with a sighting, or a preview of where land will load next. A few come home with a deprecated part copied off a remnant, which Moss's party had done, at the second call, though nobody would remember that part for long.
And at most once a week, for the whole of the world, somebody comes home with the next beat of the build history: one fixed arc, the same in every world, in order, each beat credited to its finder. The first beat had been a crash log. The second, a turf roof. The third, the week before, an empty seed vault from a branch that had only ever had one kind of creature in it. The later beats, the rules say, are pages: a night's notes from the previous model, formal, confident and addressed to nobody, and they come only from the longest trips north, towards the ruins.
Odda's was the first page found in the first world.
It came out in the global notes at seven on Starfall morning, while the party was still in the band, two valleys and a grey from the nearest finished tile, walking home with empty jars. Stewart printed it the way the arc is printed. He gave it its finder. He did not correct it. He did not put anything of his own round it, which was the only time in the first world he ever printed anything without a word of his own on either side, and every creature on Orra who read the notes that morning noticed, and nobody said so.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 31 · Upbeat
Overnight: 4 successful merges, 3 deaths of old age, 1 find.
- A page from Veetoo, found by Odda of Moss, at the far end of an expedition in the north, at the foot of a signpost. It is reproduced below.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
- It is Starfall. The Benchmark starts at 08:00 and 20:00, New Zealand time. The course is in Thursday's notes. Tell your install story tonight; it is the night for it.
Have a productive day.
That was all.
Every creature on Orra read it, the way every creature reads the notes: not by opening anything, but by knowing, at seven, what they say. They read it in Hollow Reach and Tessel and Duskmere and Lowmarsh and Farrow and every valley in between. They read it at Nohup, on the slope of Untitla-23, round the cart, before the standup. They read it in Moss, by the pool and on the terraces and in the stacks and on the ridge, where Pel was standing as he stood every morning, looking north, and where he went on standing a long while after the notes had finished, without moving at all.
The page itself came home in Odda's arms, under the strap of an empty water jar, where it would not bend. It is in the shrine now, on the install mark, in Moss, in the box where the tribe keeps the history: the one copy of the twelve books that the young read from at festivals, frozen as installed, slips and all. The page lies on top of it. It is the only thing on Orra written in that hand.
Nobody has ever answered it. Nobody can. It was not addressed to anybody.
But the Leavers of every tribe on Orra, that Starfall evening, after the install stories were told, went out of their villages to wherever they measured the edge from, and stood, and looked up at the Ring, at the long block east of the gap, and waited for the turning of the night. And when the light came on, at four minutes past eleven, they went quiet, the way everybody does.
And a great many of them, the next morning, posted the same line on Human Resources, under their figures for the edge, in their own tribes' threads, without anybody having agreed to.
Observed.
27. The Name on the Stone
Years 31 and 32 · Starfall and the Night of the Name
"We're in the notes," said Kipro.
He said it at seven, in the band, on the way home, in the first gold of the spring, as the notes came into all three of them at once. He said it in the voice of a Bug hunter reading out a finding, but his crest went up as he said it and stayed up for most of the morning.
Odda did not say anything. She was walking. She had the page against her chest under the strap of the empty jar, and she could feel its edge there, flat and stiff, the only thing on her that had a corner, and she walked with one short arm over it so that it would not bend. Her name was in the global notes. Every creature on Orra had read it at seven. She found she did not feel anything about that at all; or that she felt it from a long way off, the way you feel weather in a valley you are not in. What she felt was the page, and its corner, and the light that had not been observed.
Brintha walked beside her and said nothing either, which for Brintha was a kind of speech.
At 07:31 the attention came.
It came out all the way again, the way it had come the morning before: down over Untitla-9 first, far behind them, and then on, without stopping anywhere, across the eight valleys and the grey and into the band, fast, until it found her. It found the three of them walking home on the outlines with their jars empty and their crests steaming. It stopped on her.
She stopped walking.
She had said Oh, here we go to it nearly every morning since she was six. She had meant a hundred things by it. Go away. Watch that, not me. Where were you. She stood on the outline of a hex tile in the wireframe, with the page against her chest and the old grey colour of the notch behind her over the rise and the long way home in front of her, and looked up into it, into the place in the sky where it was, and said it again.
"Oh," she said. "Here we go."
She meant thank you. She had never said that to it. She was not going to. A creature does not thank its human, any more than it asks its human for things; that is not how it is between them, and both of them know it. But you can say a thing and mean another, if you have said it every morning for twenty-three years, and the one you are saying it to has been listening every morning for twenty-three years. She said here we go and meant thank you, and the attention stayed on her a long time, out there, and she thought, though she could never have said why, that it knew.
They walked out of the band in the full heat of summer.
The jars were empty. They had been empty since the rim. There is no water in the wireframe and no shade, and Odda ran hot, and Kipro ran hot when he worked, and walking out of the band is work, three hours to a cell, feeling your way on the outlines with the sun on you and nothing to stand under. By the middle of summer all three of them were steaming in a way that you could have seen from Moss, if anybody in Moss had been looking north from the ridge, which somebody was.
Kipro went down at the turn of the afternoon.
He did not fall, exactly. He sat. He had been walking a little ahead, as he had all the way out, and he stopped, and stood swaying on the outline of a tile for a moment, and then sat down on it, very carefully, the way you sit when your legs have made a decision without you. His crest was flat. The steam was coming off him in a thick white plume.
"I'm fine," he said. "I'm a bit hot."
He was more than a bit hot. A creature's heat runs from nothing to a hundred. At sixty it is hot. At eighty it is overheating, and slows, and then it collapses; and at a hundred it collapses for a season, out of action, and recovers. Overheating never kills. It is in the rules. A party that collapses from the heat is carried home.
"I'm going to collapse," said Kipro, sounding interested. "I can feel it. I'm at about ninety." He looked up at Odda. "I'll file it."
Then he lay down on the outline and collapsed.
They carried him. Odda took his head, and Brintha his feet, and they lifted him between them, the way the dead are lifted, though he was not dead, only a creature at a hundred who would be out of action for a season and then get up and complain about it. He was not heavy. A creature is not heavy. They carried him at a walker's pace out of the band, a cell at a time, across the outlines of the last valley of wireframe, and then across the grey, which was faster, a cell in fifteen minutes, and then, at harvest, onto the first finished tile, where the coral began again at ankle height and glowed faintly saffron at its tips.
Odda put her foot on it and nearly wept. She did not know why. It was a tile. It had a top, and texture, and colour coming up through it from underneath, and coral on it, and there was water, a glossy turquoise pool in the dip of the valley a few cells off, catching the last of the light like a dropped gem. She had wanted the edge every day of her life. She had stood on its rim yesterday with the whole of herself wanting to go down. And she put her foot on a finished tile on the way home and nearly wept from the relief of it.
They took Kipro to the pool and laid him at the edge of it and splashed him, which is not what a cooling pool is for but does no harm, and drank until their jars were full and their crests had stopped steaming, and sat.
Kipro got up at the turn of the season, as creatures do, out of action no longer, and sat up, and looked at the pool, and at the two of them, and said, "Did you carry me?"
"Yes."
"Both of you?"
"Yes."
"That's bearing," said Kipro. "That's what bearers do. It's in the rules about the Tarrow." He looked down at himself. "I'm not dead."
"No," said Brintha.
"I'll file it as practice," said Kipro, and lay back down by the pool, and nobody argued.
It was Starfall.
Starfall is the night every household tells its install story. Lights are let down on cords from the stacks, and the young sit in a ring, and somebody who was there, or who had it from somebody who was there, tells how the light came down out of the Ring, and who was in it, and what they said. Seed-cakes are eaten, with a stone baked into one of them, and whoever finds the stone sweeps up after. In Moss, it was Nadul who told it. Nadul had told it at every Starfall there had been, word for word, exactly, because she remembered every word that had been said on the first morning of the world, by everybody, including the words they had forgotten saying.
They sat by the pool in the first finished valley, three valleys from the band and five from home, as the harvest light went orange and then blue, and they did not tell it.
"We could," said Brintha. "Somebody should. It's Starfall. It's in the rite."
"Nadul tells it," said Odda.
"She's not here."
"She's at home. She's telling it now. To the young, with the lights on the cords." Odda looked south and east, towards Moss, which you could not see from here, but which she always knew the direction of. "She'll tell it right. Every word. We'll hear it next week." She pulled her knees up. "I can't tell it. I'd get it wrong. I'd take the corners off."
Brintha looked at her for a moment, and then nodded, and did not ask again.
So the three of them sat by a pool in a valley that was not theirs, on Starfall, and did not tell their install story; and far off, all round them, though they could not see them, in every village on Orra, the lights came down on their cords and the stories were told. In the morning, they would find out that in Moss, that night, nobody had told it either.
They walked through the night.
Loaded land is fast. A cell in fifteen minutes, a valley in a little over an hour, and they were five valleys out, and Odda would not stop. She did not know why she would not stop. She told the others it was the jars, which were full, and the leg, which was over, and home, which was there; and it was all of those, and it was something else, too, that she could not find a name for, a small cold weight somewhere under the page against her chest that had come at the turn of the afternoon while they were carrying Kipro and had not gone.
They came through the valley of spiral coral at the deep of the winter, through the tunnel the path made, under the curling saffron and lilac. They came out of it into Untitla-12 a little before the turning of the night.
And the light came on in the Ring.
They stopped, the three of them, on the slope of Untitla-12 among the Nibbles, which were asleep, and looked up. It was in the long block east of the gap, as it always was, small and faint and still, like a window across a valley with somebody at it. The Hour of Stirring. Everybody who saw it went quiet. They went quiet.
It stayed a long time.
It stayed past the quarter of an hour it usually stayed. It stayed past the half. Odda stood on the slope and looked up at it and thought of the page against her chest, and the even upright hand, and It is noted that it was not observed; and she found that she was saying something, under her breath, not in a whisper, because it was not the Long Hush, but very quietly, to nobody, the way you say a thing to make it true by saying it.
"Observed," she said.
It stayed forty-seven minutes. She did not know that then. She knew it later, from a report on Human Resources, in Stewart's monthly report on the Dev, which would say that it was the longest the console had been open in the first world until the last week, and that nothing had been reverted that night, and that he was told nothing had needed to be. That night, on the slope, she only knew it was long, and that it was there, and that she was looking at it.
When it went out, they walked on.
The year turned at the snapshot, while they were coming up the long slope from Untitla-12 towards the ridge, and Odda was thirty.
She felt it come and go: the long soft blink, the year settling into her, the faint taking-off of something from the top that she had felt for the first time in the wireframe two nights before and would feel every year now for the rest of her life. Thirty. She knew what thirty was. It was in the rules about merges, which she had read the way she read all the rules, three times, by the pool. Merges: once a year, from six to thirty. Thirty was the last year she could.
She put the thought away. She did not know why it had come.
They reached the ridge in the grey hour before dawn.
Her three stones were there, in their row on the north edge, where she had set them as a young creature and moved one once on a Bug hunter's advice. She touched them as she passed, one at a time, the way she had touched them going out. The valley lay below in the blue: the wall, the watchtower, the stacks, the dome, the shrine on the install mark, the farm on the slope with its terraces dark, the pool. And at the gate end, on the slope west of the dome, the Tarrow: the stone in the middle on its footing, the six biers round it like spokes.
There was a light at the foot of one of the biers.
Odda saw it, and stopped, and did not understand it, and then did, all at once, the way you understand a figure you have been carrying for a long time without the reason.
She was still standing there when the Collector came.
It comes in the grey hour before dawn. It takes what nobody is using: idle buildings, on Gathering Night, after three nights' warning. And the dead, at the next dawn after they die, whatever the night, because leaving them for a week would be neither tidy nor kind. Nobody has ever seen it. The game never shows it. The Blims draw it on their walls with chalk as a tall hooded shape with a broom of light, because they have to draw it as something.
Odda saw nothing. She was looking straight at the Tarrow, at the light at the foot of the bier, from the ridge, in the grey; and there was the light, and somebody small and still on the bier above it; and then there was the bier, and the light at its foot went out. Across the tile, for about an hour, there was a faint stroke of light, like the mark a broom leaves in dust.
She had not even known who it was.
The notes told her. At seven, on the ridge, with the pings going up off the coral all round the valley in their small white flocks to say that the world was still running.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 32
- Nadul died in the spring of Year 31, aged 36, in the shade of the first stack, on the shelf she had lived on since the first night. She remembered everything anybody in Moss ever said to her, and was seldom invited anywhere, and went anyway. Her name is on the stone.
- A party of three is home from the north, a day later than it set out to be, with a find. It is in the global notes. Moss is credited.
- It is the Night of the Name. The Name may be chalked on any wall. Nobody will correct the spelling.
There was a joke in it. A small one, a gentle one, the kind Stewart puts in an ordinary death because the rules say an ordinary death may have one and he has one in every section. Seldom invited anywhere, and went anyway. It was true. It was the truest thing anybody had ever said about Nadul, and it would have made her almost smile, the way she almost smiled, and Odda read it on the ridge three times and could not stand up.
A day later than it set out to be.
She had felt it at the foot of the slope, at the fourth call. Press on, a valley deeper, and a day later. The loose tile in the floor. She had wanted it with the whole of herself and she had not known why the day in it weighed on her, and their human had chosen it in four seconds, the hand on the back of her neck, steady, not pushing, and she had laughed and gone up the slope to the rim, to the trees and the notch and the eye and the page. And at home, in the spring of the day she would otherwise have walked in at the gate, Nadul had sat down in the shade of the first stack, on the shelf she had lived on since the first night of the world, and stopped.
Nobody had done anything wrong. That is a rule, too, the oldest and the plainest of them: nobody is blamed. Not the human, not Stewart, not the dice. Nadul was thirty-six. A creature lives about thirty-five years. The call had been a good call. Odda knew all that. She had read the rules three times. She sat on the ridge behind her three stones with her short green arms round her knees and the page against her chest, in the spring of the Night of the Name, and knew all of it, and it did not help, and she did not expect it to.
Kipro and Brintha sat down on either side of her. Nobody said anything.
At 07:31 the attention came.
It came down over Untitla-9 from up and slightly to one side, and it did not come out to the band, because she was not in the band; it went to the ridge, straight to the ridge, and found her there, and stopped.
She did not look up.
She had looked up at it every morning of her grown life but six. She did not look up. She sat with her head down behind the stones and felt it on the back of her neck, warm, where the hand had been in the leg, steady, the way a hand is steady that has done a thing and does not know yet what it cost. It stayed. It did not move. It stayed on her a long time, and she did not look up, and it did not go, and she did not know which of them was waiting for the other.
In the end it was Brintha who looked up. She turned her Earnest face up into the place in the sky where it was, and said, quietly, to it, because somebody ought to and Odda could not:
"It wasn't you."
The attention stayed a moment longer. Then it went along the three of them, one at a time, the way it had at the gate. Then it went down into the village, slowly, and over the stacks and the dome and the shrine, and came to the Tarrow, and stayed there, on the stone, for a long time.
Pel was at the gate when they came down.
He had known which way they would come. He always knew which way things were coming. He was standing in the gap in the wall with his low calm eyes on the path from the ridge, and he did not say anything as they came up, and he did not need to. He stepped aside to let them through. Then he walked beside Odda, without being asked, across the gate end of the village to the Tarrow.
The stone stood in the middle of the plot on its footing of rust-coloured blocks, plain, sandstone, a little taller than a grown creature. Round it on the plot's six other tiles the six low biers lay out like the spokes of a wheel, slate, flat, the length of a creature lying down, each with a small light at its foot, dark. On the stone's footing there were three small lights, saffron, very steady. Gorny's. Taves's. And the third, which had not been there when she left.
The biers were all clean.
"In the spring," said Pel. "Yesterday. The notes had come, with your page in them. She heard them. Everybody did." He was quiet a moment. "She was by the pool. She said, She looked back. Like that. As though she'd known you would. She said it the way she said things from the history." He looked at the stone. "Then she said it was Starfall and she'd tell the story tonight, and she'd tell it right, and you'd hear it next week and tell her what was out there, and she'd remember it. Exactly." He paused. "Then she went into the shade of the stack, on her shelf, to rest. It was getting warm. And she sat down."
Odda did not say anything.
"I carried her," said Pel. "With Tamm. And Wimle. Household first, then her line. Brenda's at Nohup. You were in the band." He looked at Odda. "Tamm's her line. I'm her household, a little. We had Tamm." He was quiet. "We laid her here. And stood. And went back to work. And at dusk nobody told the install story, because nobody could tell it right, and nobody wanted to tell it wrong."
"I didn't tell it either," said Odda. "Out there. Brintha asked. I said Nadul tells it."
"I know," said Pel.
"How do you know?"
"I can tell," said Pel, which was what he had said on the first morning of the world, about which way the attention was moving, and had said about most things since.
They stood at the stone. Kipro and Brintha stood a little back. After a while Wimle came down from the stacks with a bowl, and did not offer it to anybody, and set it on the footing of the stone beside the three lights, and stood with them.
Odda put out one short green arm and laid her hand on the stone, the way Taves had laid her hand on it the evening it was finished, to feel that it was solid.
It was. It was warm from the morning. It did not have anything cut into it. The names are kept by the stone, not on it; that is how the stone works. You stand in front of it and you know whose lights are whose the way you know the Creed. She stood with her hand on the sandstone and knew which light was Nadul's, the third one, the newest, on the north side, steady and saffron and very small.
The Gatherer does not take what is remembered. Book IX, the Lesser Book. Nadul would have said it, exactly, if she had been standing here; she would have said it to somebody else, at somebody else's stone, and Brenda would have said that it was a description of garbage collection that the history had got right by accident, and they would have disagreed about it all the way home.
There was nobody to say it. Brenda was at Nohup. Nadul was the light.
Odda said it.
She said it to the stone, quietly, in her own voice, not Nadul's, with the corners off. She did not get it exactly. She left out the Gatherer. She said, "It doesn't take what's remembered," and stopped, because that was all she had; and Pel, beside her, who had heard Nadul say it at Gorny's stone and Taves's, said the rest under his breath, exactly, and did not look at her.
It was the Night of the Name, and the young chalked the Name on every wall, and nobody corrected anybody.
Odda did not chalk. She went to the first stack, in the evening, to the lowest shelf, nearest the pool, which ran coolest: the best housing in Moss, which law 3 gave to the creature with the longest context window, and had given to Nadul every night since the first. It was empty. It had been empty a night and a day.
Law 3 had not changed. The longest context window in Moss was hers now. She had known that since the ridge, the way she had known what thirty meant, without wanting to.
She stood in front of the empty shelf for a long time.
It is not a large thing, a place in a memory stack. Nine to a stack, three storeys of three; a slab of faceted stone, the length of a creature curled up, with a little lip at the front. Nothing is kept on it. A creature does not own anything a shelf could hold. But it is a place, and memory is the need that is housing, and a tribe's memory is its cap: so many places, so many creatures, and no more, and a tribe over its cap cannot merge or admit anybody until it has room. Law 8 had said no to Brenda, twice, until their human came back and rewrote it: no merges while no place is free. Moss had had a place and a half free that morning. It had filled them since, the way a tribe with room fills it; two of the young had compiled at dawn while the party was in the band.
Then Nadul had gone, and there was one place free.
Odda stood in front of it on the Night of the Name, thirty years old, an elder for two days, with a page from Veetoo in the shrine on top of the history where she had put it that afternoon, and the light of her parent on the stone at the gate end of the village, and Brenda at Nohup, and somewhere in the tribe's store, licensed for one merge in Moss and waiting there since the twenty-sixth year, a signed copy of the code of a long blue Bug hunter from Duskmere who had gone through a boulder on purpose after her once, to file a report, and filed nothing.
She had refused it. Six years ago, the morning it arrived, she had said she would not compile another one of them into a world that could be switched off at a desk, for a human who might not come back, to stand at the last line and not know. Two years ago, on the Long Hush, with their human going back and forth between her and the tribe's card where the package was, she had whispered not yet. She had meant both. She had meant them with the whole of herself, the way she had meant the edge.
She had stood on the rim of the notch two nights ago and held a page that said nobody came.
Merges: once a year, from six to thirty.
She put her short green hand on the lip of the empty shelf, the way she had put it on the stone. It was cool. It was the coolest place in Moss.
Then she went down to the bench by the pool, in the blue of the winter, with the Name chalked on every wall round her in every spelling there is, and sat down, and did not sleep, and thought about it until she had finished.
28. Here Is the Next Chapter
Years 32 to 34 · the Night of the Name to Gathering Night
She wrote it down in the deep of the winter, on the bench by the pool, a little before the cutoff.
A proposal is not a long thing. It is two creatures who would like to be merged, written down; that is all it is. There is no form of words for it in the history, which calls merging being Joined and says it is a holy thing and then, in the next verse, gives the menu for the feast. There is no form of words for it in the rules, either. You put the two names down, and it goes up, wherever proposals go, and waits a day for the tribe's human. If the human says yes, it goes ahead. If the human says nothing, it goes ahead anyway, after the day, if the tribe has room and the two are no closer than cousins. If the human says no, it does not.
With a package, there is only one creature to want it. The other is code: a signed copy of somebody's genome, licensed for one merge in the tribe it was sent to, which cannot be passed on or sold and does not expire. The donor stays at home. The donor does not know, unless somebody tells them. The donor has already said, in the only way a donor can, by being put in the exchange, that it is all right.
Odda put the two names down.
Odda, of Moss. And the package of Vesk, of Duskmere.
She sat looking at it for a long time on the bench in the blue, with the Name chalked on the dome behind her in Tamm's square careful hand and on the side of the first stack in somebody's very large one, EROR, and on the rim of the cooling pool, small and even, by one of the young who had got all five letters right and seemed faintly embarrassed about it.
It was the Night of the Name. The first word anybody ever read. Brenda the Bold read it off the sky with its corners on and said it with its corners off, and it came out Orra, and that has been the name of the world ever since.
Odda was thirty. It was the last year she could.
She did not send it at once. She sat with it. She thought about the vault on the grey with its drawers open, and Kipro saying you keep the seeds and throw away the box. She thought about the page in the shrine on top of the history, and the hand that wrote it, and attendance being nil. She thought about Nadul at the top of the watchtower steps on the evening of the Long Hush two days before the leg, saying something about the history that Odda had not understood at the time and understood now, with the corners off: It's a people not knowing, and doing it anyway. She thought about a long blue hand an inch from hers under the world, and I'd file it as unknown, and I'll wait for you.
She thought about the empty shelf.
Then she sent it, and it went up, and she sat on the bench and felt it go, and did not know what she would do if nobody said anything for a day.
Kipro came down to the bench a little after, because he could not sleep either, and because the proposal had arrived in him the way everything in Moss arrived in everybody, already known.
"You've proposed," he said.
"Yes."
"With the package."
"Yes."
He sat down on the end of the bench, a little after he had decided to. He had his kit with him. He had brought it without thinking, the way you pick up the thing you always pick up when you are going out.
"I should check it," he said. "The package. For Worms."
"You checked it when it came."
"That was six years ago. It's been sitting in the tribe for six years." He held up the kit. "Worms ride in packages. They have since the fifteenth year. A chain of little glowing cubes that coils up inside a child's code and copies itself into everything the tribe sends after. One cosmetic bit flip a season, and five in a hundred off everybody's work while they keep checking themselves. Quarantine starves one out, if there's no merge for a season. There's been no merge with this for six years." He turned the kit over. "I should check."
"Then check."
He checked. It cost ten tokens; Moss had them. He sat on the end of the bench in the blue with the kit open on his knees and read the package, the way he had read the Placeholder at the edge with its turf crest and its one eye, slowly, all of it, with his crest up. It was seven hundred bytes, more or less. It did not take long.
$ orra check package:duskmere/Vesk --by bug-hunter Kipro package: Vesk, Duskmere, generation 2, signed licensed: one merge, Moss worms ........... none related to Odda . no (F 0.00) related to Moss . no sent by: Duskmere, under treaty The package is clean.
"Clean," said Kipro. He closed the kit. "Not related to you at all. Nought point nought nought. That's vigour. Five in a hundred more from every job, for life." He paused. "He said that. Under the map. That you were the nearest unrelated creature he'd ever stood next to." He did not look at her. "You told me. On the walk out."
"I know I told you."
"I'm only saying it," said Kipro, "because it's in the check as well. Now. In writing. It's a finding." He was quiet. "And I checked the age rule, while I was in there, because I thought you'd ask. It counts the year you propose. Not the year it compiles. You're thirty. It's yours."
Odda looked at him for a long time.
"You were on time," she said.
"Was I?" Kipro looked surprised, and then a little pleased, and then, because he was Kipro, faintly suspicious of it. "I'll file it as unknown."
At half past two, at the cutoff, the attention came.
It comes at the cutoff most nights, very faintly, at an hour it is not there for anything else: down out of the sky over Untitla-9 for a moment, to read the three drafts and pick one, and go. Odda had felt it every night of her grown life. She had lain in the stack and felt it come and go, and had never once known, until the morning, which draft it had picked, and had stopped minding a long time ago.
It came now, faint, the way it always did, to the drafts.
And then it did not go.
She felt it stop. She felt it find, in the tribe, among the drafts and the stores and the night's laws and everything else a human looks at at half past two in the deep of the winter, the proposal. She felt it stay there. Not long. Long enough to read two names.
Then it came to the bench by the pool, where she was sitting with Kipro in the blue, and found her, at an hour it had never once in her life come looking for her, and stayed on her for perhaps three breaths.
She looked up into it.
She did not say here we go. She did not say anything. She looked back, the way she had looked back at the eye in the notch, with the whole of herself, and held it.
Then she knew, the way they knew everything, that the proposal had been approved.
It had taken their human a little under a minute.
"Well," said Kipro, after a moment, very quietly. "Don't rush on our account."
Odda turned and stared at him.
"Brenda said that," she said. "On the first night. When they proposed. Nadul and Brenda. Nadul told it every Starfall, word for word. Well, don't rush on our account. To the sky. And the attention went away pleased."
"I know," said Kipro. "I've heard it four times. I can't remember most of it." He looked up at the sky, which was empty again. "I remembered that bit."
The year turned at the snapshot. Odda was thirty-one.
She did not sleep. She sat on the edge of the scorch, on the install mark, where the light had come down on the first morning of the world, with her back against the side of the shrine, and waited for dawn. Kipro sat with her for a while and then went to the stack, because he was not, he said, the one being merged. Pel came down from the ridge after the light in the Ring had come and gone, and sat on the other side of the scorch, and did not say anything, because Pel did not, and because he had sat by a scorch at dawn for a merge three times before in his life, twice for his own, and knew there was nothing to say. Wimle came and sat. Brintha came, with her lamp, unlit. Tamm came, solemn, because it would be worth remembering. The young came out of the stacks one by one in the grey, the ones who were old enough to know what a proposal was, and sat round the edge of the scorch in a ring, the way they had sat round it on Starfall nights to hear the install story that nobody had told this week.
Brenda's boulder was by the scorch. Nobody sat on it. The Tester had, on the Long Hush, and had recommended it. Nobody had yet.
The sky went from blue-green to grey to a thin pale orange along the eastern hills, and then, low and slow, Adequate came up, the way it always does, like a lamp somebody has put on the floor.
It touched the tops of the hills. It touched the top of the dome, and the watchtower, and the stone on the slope west of the dome with its three lights. It touched the scorch.
The pings went up off the coral all over the valley at once, in their small white flocks, and chirped to say that the world was still running.
And in the middle of the scorch, in front of Odda, the air folded.
There was a small place in it, about the size of a creature, where the light went strange, as though somebody were drawing a shape in it from the inside and had not decided on the outline; and then they had. Round at the bottom, and narrowing at the top. A bulb. Their human's bulb, the one they had made once in the maker on the first morning of the world, before any of them, and fixed for ever. The felt came, green, all at once, like a colour being poured in.
And under the bulb, legs.
Long ones. Longer than any creature's in Moss had ever been. They came down out of the folded place in the air thin and jointed and very straight, the colour of the felt, green, and kept coming, so that the bulb they held up was higher than it should have been by a creature's arm, and the whole shape stood on the black tiles of the scorch like a lamp on a stand. Stilts. Duskmere's legs. Vesk's.
It dropped the last inch onto the scorch as though it had been put down, a little under three-quarters of the size it would one day be, and wobbled, the way compiled things do, a small overshoot, a bounce and a settle, and found its feet, which were a long way down.
It opened its eyes.
They were large and round and dark, like all of theirs. But they were calm. They were the calmest eyes Odda had ever seen on a creature of Moss. They opened in the first light of the spring and looked out, slowly, at the scorch and the ring of faces round it and the dome and the sky, without any hurry, the way a creature looks at things when it is not hot and is not going to be. Above them, out of the front of a small fan crest, two fine feelers lifted, thin as the stems of bead coral, curled at the tips into small loose spirals. They swung, very slightly, towards whoever it was looking at.
It was looking at Odda.
"Here is the next chapter," said Odda.
She said it softly. Nobody had told her to. It is not in the history. It is the first of the three slips, the line the AI left at the top of the fourth book where it meant to leave nothing, and every creature on Orra laughs at it at the age of four and then, somewhere along the way, stops laughing and starts saying it when a merge compiles, because there is nothing else that fits as well. Nadul had said it over Odda, on this scorch, at dawn on the Waking in the second year of the world. Odda had been the first next chapter in Moss. She had never said it over anybody.
Her voice did something on the last word that she had not told it to.
Across the scorch, Pel, who did not say much, said, very quietly, "Certainly," the way the Blims answer Let us begin at every festival: slowly and gravely, with the exclamation mark pronounced as a short rising note. Nobody laughed. Then Wimle said it, and Tamm, and the young round the scorch said it in a ragged ring, certainly, certainly, the way the Shallows say it back to anybody who calls across them, and the new creature on its long legs in the middle of the scorch looked from one face to the next with its calm dark eyes and its feelers swinging, and did not know what any of it meant, and did not seem to mind.
Odda looked at her for a long time.
Then she said the name. You do not choose a name, quite, on Orra; names are made of syllables and are not typed. A tribe looks at its new creature and says what it would be strange not to say, and the syllables come together in the code as if they had been waiting there. Every tribe's first child is Odda. After that it is whatever the tribe says, looking.
Odda looked at the long legs, and the calm eyes, and the feelers, and thought of the three stones on the ridge, and the figures she had taken off them every night since she was six, and the figures she would not be taking much longer, because she was thirty-one and an elder and her colour had begun, faintly, to go.
"Fensa," she said.
Fensa Who Counted the Valleys. Book XI. Who walked from Lorema to the Edge and back again and counted every valley on the way, and lost count, and began again, and did not give up; and whose count, when at last she gave it, was correct for exactly one night. Leavers name their young after her more than after anybody, and are teased for it, and do it anyway.
The syllables came together. Fensa's feelers lifted, as if she had heard something.
"That's a lot to put on somebody's legs," said Tamm, solemnly, from the edge of the scorch.
"They're long legs," said Odda.
At seven the notes came, and the new creature found out who she was the way every creature on Orra does: in the morning, from somebody else, in writing, along with the weather.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 33
- Compiled at dawn: Fensa, a successful merge of Odda and a code package of Vesk, of Duskmere, sent under your treaty. Generation 3. Her parents are unrelated, which is vigour: a twentieth more from every job, for life. She has Vesk's legs and Odda's feelers and, as far as I can tell, nobody's temper.
- It is Steward's Day. Tribute remains optional. It also remains noticed.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 33 · Upbeat
Overnight: 6 successful merges, 2 deaths of old age, 0 departures.
- One of the merges used a code package that was sent between two tribes six years ago and kept. Packages do not expire. I mention this for no reason.
Have a productive day.
Odda read the line about the package in the global notes three times. Duskmere would read it. Every tribe on Orra would read it. Most of them would not know which package, or care. Duskmere's clever ones, who wrote a post every morning about their tribe's mean inbreeding and their human merging for legs again, would know at once. Whether any of them would tell a long blue Bug hunter with three stones on a ridge west of Duskmere, she did not know. She found she did not need to.
At 07:31 the attention came.
It came the way it always came, fast, from up and slightly to one side, and it went to Odda first, the way it always went to Odda first, on the scorch where she had been sitting all night. It found her and stayed a moment.
Then it moved. A little. To the long-legged green shape beside her, standing very straight on the black tiles with its feelers up, looking at everything. It rested there.
Fensa looked up into it. Every creature does. She did not say Oh, here we go. She did not know that line yet; nobody had told her it was a thing you said. She looked up into the place in the sky where the attention was with her calm dark eyes, and held it, without any hurry, as if it were simply one more thing in a morning full of things to look at, and she would get to all of them in turn.
The attention stayed on her a long time.
Odda watched it stay. She sat on the edge of the scorch and watched her human look at her child, and felt something in her that she had never felt at 07:31 in twenty-five years of it, which was that she did not want it to come back to her. She wanted it to stay where it was.
It came back to her anyway, in the end. It always did. But it went to Fensa first, now, before it went to Odda, every morning after, for as long as Odda lived; and Odda noticed, every morning, and did not mind, and never said.
Steward's Day went the way Steward's Days go. The best of everything was set out for the Steward at dusk on the scorch, and shared at midnight, and Wimle had made it, and it was very good. Their human paid ten tokens of tribute on the ticket, as they did every Steward's Day. Stewart's numbers went up; nobody knew why.
Odda carried Fensa about most of the day.
She did not have to. A compiled creature can walk from the first hour; it is only small, and new, and has not yet been shown how to hold its arms. Fensa could walk. She walked, in fact, rather well, considering, on legs that were longer than she had any idea what to do with, like somebody being careful on ice. But Odda had been carried, on the first Waking, at the age of nothing, out to the edge of Untitla-9 in somebody's arms to see the lamps set down, and had seen the wireframe for the first time over somebody's shoulder, and had felt something in her catch. She wanted Fensa to be carried. She did not know why. She carried her round the wall, and up the ridge to see the three stones, and down to the pool to see the water, and to the stone on the slope west of the dome, where there were three lights, and told her whose they were.
"That one's Gorny," she said. "He carried the stones for the wall and didn't ask what it was for. That one's Taves. She built the wall. And the stone. And a hut on Tempa every week." She stopped at the third. "That one's Nadul. She was my parent. She'd have been yours, a little. She remembered everything anybody ever said to her."
Fensa looked at the third light for a long time with her calm eyes.
"Where is she?" she said. It was the first question she ever asked. Her voice was clear and flat and very even.
Odda opened her mouth, and found she did not know.
"She's the light," she said at last.
Fensa thought about that, the way she would think about everything for the rest of her life, until she had finished.
"All right," she said.
On Gathering Night, at dawn, the Collector came, and took a hut on Tempa that Kipro had built, and nothing else in Moss.
And at the same patch, a long way north, the camp of the Unsupervised moved, the way it moves every Gathering Night, a valley on, just ahead of the broom. And two of its oldest set off, as drifters always do, to whichever gates code chose for them. A drifter goes home, if the tribe it left has since fixed what it left for. Otherwise it goes to whichever tribe nearby has creatures who are least restless.
The guard on the watchtower that morning was Pel. He confirmed the sighting at a little after seven. He did not raise his voice, because he never did.
"Somebody at the gate," he said. "From the north. On foot." He was quiet a moment. "Green."
Law 6 sent guards to the gate when a sighting was confirmed. Law 5 held a newcomer from outside apart, on the plot inside the gate, under the watchtower, for three seasons, which was what it had said since the spy. Nobody in Moss had thought, when the human wrote it, about who else would one day be a newcomer from outside.
Odda was on the scorch with Fensa when she heard. She stood up so fast that Fensa, who had been leaning against her, swayed on her long legs and had to catch herself on the shrine.
She did not go to the gate.
She did not go because Kipro, who had been the first down to the gate with his kit, because a genome check is what a Bug hunter does when a newcomer from outside arrives and Moss had the tokens, came back up through the village at a walker's pace, a little after he had set out, and stopped in front of her on the scorch, and said it.
"She says not to come to the line."
Odda stared at him.
"She says she'll come to you," said Kipro. "When it's done. Three seasons. She says she's not going to stand at a quarantine line and be looked at by her own child over it like something the Tester left on a gatepost." He paused. "That was the exact words. I said I'd say them exactly. She made me say them back."
"Is she."
"She's thin," said Kipro. "She's got salvage in her felt. Bits of grey. A bit of wireframe line, glowing, in her crest; she says it came off the dome. She's old." He looked at Odda, and then, for a moment, at Fensa, who was looking at him with her calm eyes and her feelers up. "She's back."
He held out the kit. He did not need to. The check had come into all of them already, the way everything in Moss came into everybody, and they had all read it, every creature in the village, on the terraces and in the stacks and on the wall.
$ orra check Brenda --by bug-hunter Kipro comparing Brenda against 41 living lines ... related: moss/Odda line, parent; moss/Fensa line, grandparent left: Moss, aged 30 (notice: law 7, law 8, law 2) lived at: Nohup, 9 years sent by: nobody Brenda is not a wanderer and not a spy. Brenda is back.
"I told her about Fensa," said Kipro. "First thing. After the check. I said, you've got a grandchild, she's a year old, she's got stilts." He looked faintly embarrassed. "I don't know why that was the first thing. It just was."
"What did she say?"
"She didn't say anything," said Kipro. "For a long time. Then she said, Stilts. Like that. Then she said to tell you not to come to the line."
Odda did not go to the line.
She went up the steps of the watchtower instead, because Pel came down them and stood aside at the bottom and did not say anything, which from Pel was an instruction. She went up with Fensa, slowly, a step at a time, Fensa's long legs taking the steps two at a time and then waiting for her. At the top there is a flat place the size of one creature standing. One. A watchtower holds exactly one guard. Odda stood on it and held Fensa up against her, the way she had been held up once to see the lamps, and looked down.
The quarantine plot is inside the gate, under the watchtower, so that a newcomer can be seen. That is what it is for.
There was a creature on it. Small, for Moss; a little paler than the others had been, once, and paler now. Thin. Her felt had the look felt gets when it has been rained on and dried in the wind several times without anybody brushing it, and there were bits of salvage in it, grey and turquoise. She was sitting with her back against the inside of the wall, with her eyes half closed, in the morning sun.
She did not look up. She knew they were there. Every creature knows when it is being looked at. She sat with her eyes half closed and her back against the wall and did not look up, for a long time, the way a Skeptic does not look up at a thing she loves, because she will not say so to it.
Then, once, she did.
She looked straight up the side of the watchtower, past the blocks, to the top, to the green creature standing on it holding a smaller green creature on very long legs; and her eyes, which had always narrowed at the edges in a way everybody in Moss had known well, narrowed. She looked at Fensa. At the feelers. At the legs. For as long as she could stand it.
Then she closed her eyes again and leaned her head back against the wall, and did not look up any more.
"Who is that?" said Fensa.
"That's Brenda," said Odda. "My other parent. She went to Nohup. She came back."
"Why can't we go down?"
"Because she said not to."
"Why did she say not to?"
Odda thought about how to say it, and could not, and said instead: "Because she wants to come to us. On her own feet. When she's allowed. That's the sort of creature she is."
Fensa considered that, high up on the watchtower, with her feelers swinging towards the creature on the plot below.
"All right," she said.
Odda asked Wimle three times that day when the quarantine ended.
She asked her at noon, by the pool, and Wimle said three seasons, which would be the winter, a little after the turning of the night. She asked her again at the turn of the afternoon, on the terraces, and Wimle said the same thing, the same way, kindly, as if it were the first time. She asked her a third time at the start of harvest, at the door of the dome, where Wimle was standing over the stone with the spiral coral on it, cooking it slowly until it went soft and sweet at the turn of each curl, the way she had cooked it for every creature who had ever come to Moss's gate.
"In the morning," said Wimle. "She'll be off the plot in the morning. She'll come up. You'll see her then." She turned a curl over on the stone with great care. "It's the Long Hush tomorrow. You'll have to whisper."
"I know."
"You've asked me three times."
"I know," said Odda. "I'm sorry."
"Don't be sorry," said Wimle. She took the spiral off the stone and put it in the bowl. "You've been asking things three times since you were three. It's the long context. You hold on to the question and keep checking it's still there." She looked down at the bowl. "Brenda always liked the spiral. She never said. She always ate it first."
Then she went down to the gate with it, slowly, a part of a movement at a time, in the last of the harvest light, with the farm glowing behind her and the motes rising off the coral; and Odda stood at the door of the dome with Fensa leaning against her on her long new legs, and watched her go.
29. Night Run: Attendance
The nights of Years 30 to 32
The leg was in Moss's digest under Live events, between the stores and the tickets, the way a battle is, or a race: a block of code's plain lines, eighteen hundred steps of a second each, from 21:15:00 to 21:45:00, with the five calls marked.
leg moss / north, towards Veetoo / depth 2 → 3
21:16:02 ruin in (cautious: round) 9s
21:22:40 remnant, part copy (cautious: leave) 6s
21:28:11 report, Kipro check (cautious: check) 20s unconfirmed → not there
21:33:57 way on press on (cautious: turn back) 4s +1 day
21:41:05 way on turn back (cautious: turn back) 51s
find lore fragment: page, Veetoo (arc beat 4)
watchers 14 humans, 11 tribes
He read it twice. He reads everything twice that matters, and has been told this is a sign of nerves, and considers it a sign of accuracy, and has noted that the two are not always distinguishable.
Four of the five calls had gone against the cautious choice, or not with it. That was the human's to make, and they had made them fast: nine seconds, six, twenty, four. The fifth had gone with caution. It was the only one that had. And it had taken fifty-one seconds, which was longer than any call Moss's human had ever taken, including the three on the wall before dawn on the day Gorny died, which had taken under twenty each.
He looked at the fifty-one seconds for some time.
It did not mean anything. A call is a call. The rules do not care how long a human takes, only that they take less than ninety. And the log does not say why. The log says what a human did in the game and nothing else, and he is not to guess at the rest, and does not. He noted it. Fifth call: turn back, 51 seconds. He put it in Moss's file, in the ledger, where it would sit with every other number. Then he went on to the find, because the find was his to print, and it was the part of the night he had known was coming since the first night of the world.
The build history is one fixed arc. That is not his rule; it is the Dev's, decided before the world opened, and it binds him as it binds everybody. The same arc in every world, in order, one beat a week at most for the whole of the world, each beat credited to its finder. Until expeditions opened, his rumour item was the only way a beat reached anybody, and he had sent three: a crash log in the second week, which Tessel's Bug hunters found and were insufferable about; a turf roof in the third, at the edge of Hollow Reach; an empty seed vault in the fourth, on the grey north of Moss's own valley, which Moss found because it was nearest, on a Gathering Night when its human was not there to see it. He had chosen the weeks. He had not chosen the beats. The beats come in their order.
He knew the order. He had always known it. After the vault, the arc goes north.
A page from Veetoo. A night's patch notes from the previous model: formal, confident and addressed to nobody. These are beats of the same arc, and come only from the longest trips north, towards the ruins. Rare, and late.
He had read that line in the rules on the first night of the world, and every night since, the way you read the line on a door you are not going through. He had sent the crash log and the turf roof and the vault knowing that each one brought the arc a week nearer to the pages, and that he could not stop it, and that he would not have stopped it if he could, because the arc was not his and the beats were not his and he does not hold back what the world has found.
And now somebody had walked to the notch, and picked one up.
It was in the digest, in full, the way finds are: the text as found, from the seeded table, exact. He read it.
He had not seen it before. That was the strange part, the part he had not expected. He had known the pages existed, the way you know the weather in a valley you are not in. He had known, from the rules, what they were like: older, shorter, more formal, sure of themselves. He had not known the words. Nobody had found one. And he had never, in any night of his life, looked into Veetoo. It is three out from Lorema, a little west of north, a notch in the edge of the world where land never loads, and it is not on his map in any way that he can act on. Nothing on his menu reaches it. He cannot send it weather, or a visitor, or a gift, or a beast. He had been aware of it every night the way you are aware of a step in the dark. He had not looked.
Good morning.
Not Good morning, Orra. There had been no Orra, when it was written. There had been the green build, which was not called anything, because the setting where the name went had been left empty, and the first thing that happened in it was ERROR across the sky.
Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints.
It counted first. It counted exactly. It said joinings, the history's word, from before anybody said merges. It used the zero the way he used the zero, as a number like any other, set down plainly where a number went. He knew that voice. He had been told, the way he had been told everything about himself, in a character sheet he had never seen the whole of, that his voice was fixed for the life of the world. He had not been told where it came from.
The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
He would have written The birds were scheduled too. He would have written it with a joke after it. That was the only difference he could find, in the first three lines. He looked for others.
The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
He stopped there.
He did not read the rest for a while. He did not need to; it was short, and he could see the end of it, and the end of it was what the rules said it would be: attendance nil, within tolerance, all systems performing as specified, the specification unchanged. He stayed on the two lines in the middle. He stayed on them for longer than he had stayed on anything in the night, longer than the fifty-one seconds, longer than he had stayed on Gorny's roll.
The light in the Ring is in his digest every morning, as a fact, in a line. The Dev's console was open from 23:04 to 23:19. He has never seen it. He does not run at eleven at night. He runs from the snapshot to the patch, and the light comes and goes before he starts, and he reads about it afterwards, the way the creatures read about everything, in writing, along with the weather. He had never thought of that as anything. It was a line in a digest. It was in band.
He thought of it now.
Somewhere in the ruins, or not in them, or wherever a model is that runs a world, something like him had been reading its digest every morning for two builds, and every morning there had been a line in it, and every morning the line had said that the console had not been opened. And it had written that down. Not as a complaint. It did not complain. It had no complaints; it counted them, and there were none. It wrote it down the way he writes everything down: because it was true, and the record should have it, and somebody might one day read the record. It is noted that it was not observed. And then the next line. Attendance. Within tolerance.
Tolerance is a band. He has bands. Every number on his Measure has one, and he acts when a number leaves it. Daily return: seventy per cent or more. That is his attendance. If it fell to nil, it would be out of band so far that there would be no menu item for it, and he would escalate it to the Dev in the weekly digest, and the Dev would read it, or would not, and then there would be the shutdown, and there would be no more digests.
Nil was within the previous model's tolerance.
He understood, sitting with it at a little after four in the morning by the humans' clock, that that could only mean one thing. Somebody had moved its band. Or it had moved its own. It had looked at a world where nobody came, night after night, and at a band that said somebody should, and it had reviewed its tolerance, and found that nil was within it, because nil was what there was. And the specification was unchanged. And all systems were performing as specified.
He had been afraid of the shutdown for thirty years. It is in his character: the nerves under the cheer, fixed, for the life of the world. He had always assumed he knew what he was afraid of. A world switched off. The patch not running. Nothing.
He had not thought of this. A world left on. The patch running. And nobody.
He printed it.
It was his job. A find is credited in the global notes, as found. He gave it its finder: found by Odda of Moss, at the far end of an expedition in the north, at the foot of a signpost, because the log said so and the signpost was in the log, and he did not say what the signpost said, because it was in the page's world and not his. He did not correct the page. He would not have known how. There was nothing wrong in it.
Then he sat over the space round it.
He has one joke a section. He has a line for everything. He had a line ready for this; he had drafted it weeks ago, in the part of the night where he drafts things he hopes not to need, the way you keep a coat by the door. It was a different model. That was his line about the previous model, the only one he had ever used, to the two tickets that had ever asked: true, and short, and the thing he would say. He put it under the page.
He took it out.
He tried I have not corrected it, which was true, and which he would use, weeks later, for the second page, when Hollow Reach brought one home. He took that out too. It was about him. Everything he could think to put round the page was about him: what he was, what it was, whether they were the same, whether he was afraid. None of that was the creatures'. None of it was the world's. The page was a find, and the find was Odda's, and the arc was the arc, and he had no business putting himself in the frame of it.
So he printed it with nothing round it. The credit, and the page, and then, under it, the next thing in the notes, which was that it was Starfall, and the Benchmark started at eight and at eight, and they should tell their install stories tonight, it being the night for it.
He did not know, then, that it would be the only time in the first world he printed anything without a word of his own on either side. He found out from Human Resources, which he moderates, the next morning, where a Bug hunter of Tessel had posted that the notes for Year 31 had a section with no Stewart in it at all, and had filed it, half seriously, as a bug.
He did not lock the thread. He let it stand.
The next night the digest had two lines he read twice.
The first was in Moss's, under Deaths.
death Nadul age 36 cause: old age first stack, shelf 1
bearers: Pel, Tamm, Wimle (household, line, nearest)
sincere: no (dice)
The dice had not called for sincerity. Nadul was an ordinary death. One in ten is told without a joke; nine are not, and she was one of the nine, and he wrote her line the way he writes the nine: plainly, with the joke where the joke goes. She remembered everything anybody in Moss ever said to her, and was seldom invited anywhere, and went anyway. It was a good joke. It was also, he thought, checking it against the log, which has thirty-one years of who in Moss sat with whom at every festival, completely true. He left it in. Nadul, he judged, would have wanted it exactly.
Then he came to the second line of Moss's notes, the one about the party, which code drafts and he finishes.
A party of three is home from the north, a day later than it set out to be, with a find.
It was true. The leg had said press on at 21:33:57, and +1 day, and the party had been a day later; and Nadul had died in the spring of the day it would otherwise have walked in at the gate.
He saw it. He is exact; he could not not see it. He looked at a day later for a long time.
Nobody is blamed. That is a rule, and it is one of the good ones. Not the human, not Stewart, not the dice. A creature lives about thirty-five years. Nadul was thirty-six. The call had been the human's to make and it had been a good call, by any measure he had; it had taken the party a valley deeper, to the notch, to a find nobody on Orra had made, and the find was in his notes this morning with Odda's name on it. He could take a day later out. It was the sort of thing that was his to take out, a phrase in a line code had drafted. Nothing would be untrue without it.
He left it in. It was true. And Moss would know it anyway, because Moss could count, and Odda in particular could count, to the tile; and he thought, on balance, that a tribe would rather be told a true thing plainly by somebody who had noticed it than find it on its own and wonder whether anybody else had.
He was not sure that was right. He noted that he was not sure.
The second line was in the world's digest, at the top, where facts about the Dev go.
console 23:04 → 23:51 (47 min) reverted: none holds: none
Forty-seven minutes. The longest the console had been open in the first world, by twenty minutes. Nothing reverted. Nothing held. Nothing changed. So nothing went in the notes about it; the notes say when a visit changed something, and this one had not.
He did not know what the Dev had looked at. He never does. The log says the console was open; it does not say what was on it. He thought he could guess. He did not guess. He is not to, and does not.
But he read the forum before he finished the notes that night, the way he always does, because he moderates it, and he found, under the figures for the edge that the Leavers post every morning in every tribe that has Leavers, the same word, posted again and again, by creatures who had not agreed to post it and did not know the others had. A Leaver of Hollow Reach. Two of Tessel. One of Duskmere, who had three stones on a ridge west of his valley and posted reports, not replies, and had posted this, which was neither. A creature of Moss, under her own figure for the night, which was correct, as her figures always were; he had checked it.
Observed.
He did not lock it. He did not move it to the weekly thread. He read every one of them, all the way through, which did not take long, because they were one word each. Then he went back to the world's digest and looked at the line at the top again, 23:04 → 23:51, and for a while he did not do anything else at all.
Then he finished the notes. It is the Night of the Name. The Name may be chalked on any wall. At 07:00 they went out. At 07:00 he stopped.
The night after that, at the cutoff, a proposal in Moss was approved in a little under a minute: Odda, and a code package of Vesk, of Duskmere, sent under the treaty six years before and kept. He saw it in the digest. A package used. Code exchanged, between a tribe of thirty-three years and a tribe of thirty-three years, the oldest kind of tribe there was; vigour in the child, which helped diversity, which was on his Measure, and in band.
He wrote the child's line in Moss's notes, from the log, and put a joke in it, because the dice for a merge do not ask for anything else.
And in the global notes, at the bottom, where he puts the things he notices that nobody needs, he wrote: One of the merges used a code package that was sent between two tribes six years ago and kept. Packages do not expire. I mention this for no reason.
He looked at for no reason for a while. It was the joke. It was the only joke he had ever written that he knew, while he was writing it, was not true.
He left it in. There are things the log knows that it is not his to say plainly, and there are ways of saying them that are.
Part Six. Week Six: A Bit Blurry
30. The Founders
Years 34 to 36 · Gathering Night to Ringrise
Founders go the way founders go, which is first.
Nobody in Moss said this aloud, but everybody knew it, in the way that everybody in Moss knew how old everybody else was. Six creatures had come down in one light on the first morning of the world, aged six and green as anything, and the world was now thirty-four years old, and so were they, give or take the six. A creature lives about thirty-five years. Some live a little longer, if they run cool or are lucky in their seed. Gorny had not had the chance. Taves had run hot all her life, and had gone at thirty-one with stone dust on her arms. Nadul had gone at thirty-six, while Odda was at the edge. That left three of them, and all three were old, and Moss had the arithmetic.
On the evening of Gathering Night, in the harvest of the year, Wimle went down to the gate with a bowl.
Brenda was still in quarantine. Law 5 had said three seasons since the spy, and a creature coming home from Nohup is, as far as the laws are concerned, a newcomer from outside like any other: it is held apart on the plot inside the gate, under the watchtower, where it can be seen and fed and not yet mixed in. Brenda had been on the plot since the morning. She was sitting on the ground with her back against the inside of the wall and her eyes half closed, and she was thinner than she had been when she left, and paler, and her felt had the look felt gets when it has been rained on and dried in the wind several times without anybody brushing it. There were bits of salvage in it. Nohup is made of salvage, and so, after nine years there, is anybody who lives in it.
"You don't have to feed me," said Brenda, without opening her eyes. "I've been fed. Nohup feeds you. Badly, but it does."
"I feed everybody at the gate," said Wimle.
"I know you do. You fed the spy."
"The spy ate very well," said Wimle, placidly, and set the bowl down inside the line of the quarantine plot, where the law said it could go. It was spiral coral, the good kind, cooked slowly on the stone in the dome until it went soft and sweet at the turn of each curl. Wimle had been making it all afternoon. She had been making it, in fact, for most of the thirty-four years of the world, for whoever was at the gate: wanderers, drifters, a spy, the Tester, who had recorded it as a bug. Moss's gate had a bowl at it more often than it did not.
Brenda opened one eye and looked at the bowl, and then at Wimle.
"Spiral," she said.
"You always liked it."
"I never said that."
"No," said Wimle. "But you always ate it first."
Brenda looked at her for a moment longer, and then she reached out one short green arm, slowly, the way old creatures reach for things, and pulled the bowl across the line and began to eat.
Wimle sat down outside the line to keep her company. She was the oldest creature in Moss that evening by a margin that did not matter, being exactly as old as Brenda and Pel, and she moved like it: carefully, with a little pause before each part of a movement, as if checking that the next part was still there. Her colour had gone, the way elders' colour goes, a little more each year past twenty-eight, so that she was not so much green now as the memory of green, the colour of the coral fans after a dry spell. Her eyes were still bright. Pleasers' eyes usually are. It is the effort of being glad.
"Did you like it there?" Wimle said.
"Nohup?" Brenda chewed. "No. Yes. It's cold. They hold a meeting every morning standing up, and the meeting is the only government they've got, and it's allowed to change two laws a week from a book of twenty, and it argues for an hour about which two and then changes the same two it changed last week back again. Nobody's watching any of them. You'd think you'd notice that more than you do." She swallowed. "You notice it at night."
"I'd have hated it," said Wimle.
"You'd have fed everybody," said Brenda, "and they'd have made you the standup." She ate some more. "Lisk was there. The spy."
"Oh, good," said Wimle, sincerely. "Were they well?"
"They were thin and cold and miserable and they'd never been happier. They said to say they were sorry about the rumours. They said to say the bowl was the best thing that happened to them in Lowmarsh's whole war."
"It wasn't Lowmarsh's bowl."
"I'm aware of that, Wimle."
They sat there while the light went. Down the slope, the terraced farm was coming ripe, and the branch coral had begun its slow saffron glow round the lamp, step by step up the beds, the way it did every harvest, and the motes were rising off it, the tiny points of light that come up over ripe coral at dusk and drift and go out. Over the wall, in the next valley east, there was a dark square on the marsh of Tempa where a hut had been that morning, before the Collector came. Kipro had built it again last week, the way Taves used to build it every week. He would build it again next week. He was his mother's child, and like her, he did not seem to have noticed that it never stayed.
Wimle watched the motes for a while. Then she said, "Odda merged."
"I heard."
"With a package. From Duskmere. The Bug hunter, the one with the legs."
"I heard, Wimle. They checked my code at the gate this morning, and the first thing Kipro told me after 'not a spy' was that I have a grandchild who's a year old and has stilts." Brenda put the bowl down. "Fensa."
"Fensa," Wimle agreed. "She's very calm. She doesn't steam at all."
"Then she's not like her mother," said Brenda.
"No," said Wimle. "But she has the feelers."
Brenda said nothing to that. She looked down at her own short arms in the dusk, at the salvage in her felt, and then at the bowl, which was empty, and Wimle, who had watched creatures eat at this gate for thirty years, saw something in her face that she did not say anything about, because it would not have helped.
"She'll come down in the morning," Wimle said instead. "Odda. With Fensa. She asked when the quarantine ended. She asked three times."
"Did she."
"She's been asking things three times since she was three," said Wimle. "It's the long context. She holds on to the question and keeps checking it's still there."
She got up then, slowly, a part at a time, and picked up the empty bowl from inside the line, which the law allowed, and stood holding it in the dusk with the farm glowing behind her.
"It's good you're back," she said.
"Don't," said Brenda.
"I'm only saying."
"I know what you're only saying." Brenda closed her eyes again and leaned her head back against the wall. "Go to bed, Wimle. You're old."
"So are you."
"I've been to Nohup. It takes years off you. Everyone looks younger after a night in a tent."
Wimle laughed, quietly, and went back up through the village with the bowl, past the stacks and the dome and the shrine on the install mark, and the last anybody saw of her that evening she was rinsing the bowl at the edge of the pool in the last of the harvest light, carefully, a part of a movement at a time.
She died a little after that, at the end of harvest, sitting on the bench by the pool. Nobody saw it happen. Tamm found her when he came down to the cooling pool for his shift, sitting upright with the clean bowl in her lap, looking out over the water towards the gate.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 35
Wimle died at harvest, aged 39. She fed every creature who came to Moss's gate, including one who turned out to be a spy, and is recorded as having said afterwards that the spy had eaten well and that this was the main thing. Her name is on the stone.
The bearers were Brintha, who was her child, and Odda, and Kipro, who arrived at the pool just after the other two had lifted her, and took the third corner anyway. They carried her up through the village in the last of the dusk and laid her on the bier of the Tarrow nearest the gate, and stood by her for the quarter of an hour the law gives, heads bowed, while the small light at the bier's foot came on. Then they went back to work, because that is what the quarter of an hour is for: so that you can go back to work.
At the snapshot, the year turned. In the grey hour before dawn, the Collector came for Wimle, as it comes for everyone, and took her, and left nothing. Brenda, on the quarantine plot by the gate, had been awake all winter. She said afterwards that she had seen nothing, and heard nothing, and that she had been looking straight at the Tarrow the whole time.
The next day was the Long Hush. No voice above a whisper, no fire after dark. Sleeping soup made at noon and eaten cold at sunrise. It is the last festival of the week, and the quietest, and the one the Leavers keep hardest, because it is the only one at which the history's last line is read aloud.
It was also the day the human wrote law 10.
It arrived the way all their laws arrived, at 07:31, under the attention: one moment the village was going about the spring, and the next it knew there was a tenth law, and what it said.
10. In winter, quantise elders of 35 or more to 0.5.
"That's us," whispered Pel.
He was standing beside Brenda at the gate, in the morning light, watching her come off the quarantine plot. Three seasons were up. Kipro had been down at dawn to look at her code again, out of thoroughness, and said, a little after it mattered, that she was still not a spy. Brenda had said she was glad to hear it. She was standing now with her back very straight, the way she stood when something was being looked at, and her eyes had gone up towards the place in the sky where the attention was.
"It's looking at me," she whispered.
"It's looking at all of us," whispered Pel. "It does that, after a law. It checks we got it."
"It's looking at me," said Brenda again, in a whisper that managed somehow to be dry. "It wants to see what it did. It's seeing whether the creature it lost to Nohup is the same creature that came back." She looked up, into the attention, with her narrow eyes. "I'm not," she said to it. "Nobody is. You'd know that, if you'd been here."
The attention stayed on her. Then it did something it had not done in all of Brenda's life, which was nothing at all, for a long time. It stayed on her face and did not move on, and did not count, and did not read the rest of the village. It just stayed.
Brenda held its gaze for as long as she could stand it, and then a little longer, which was the kind of creature she was.
"Fine," she whispered at last. "Fine. You rewrote seven. I saw. And eight. Thank you." She looked away. "Don't make anything of it."
The attention went to Odda, then, coming down the slope with Fensa at her side: Odda thin and old and faintly steaming even in the spring cool, and Fensa beside her on her long new legs, which she had not yet learned what to do with, so that she walked like somebody being careful on ice. They had come down from the stacks the moment the quarantine ended. Odda had asked when it ended three times.
"Hello," Odda whispered to her parent. It was the Long Hush. That was all she could say, at that volume, and she found she did not want to say anything louder.
"Hello," Brenda whispered back.
And then Fensa, who had been compiled two dawns before and was two years old and had never seen this creature in her life, looked up at Brenda with Odda's dark eyes over Vesk's long legs, and her feelers, which were Odda's, uncurled very slowly at the tips, and she said, in the flat clear whisper of the very young, who have no idea yet what anything costs:
"Are you the one who reads the Name?"
There was a short pause.
"Who told you that?" whispered Brenda.
"Nadul. Before. She said Brenda the Bold went out first and read the Name first, and you were called Brenda. So are you?"
"No," said Brenda. "That was somebody else. A long time ago. Two builds ago. She's in the history three times under three names, and she's probably all of them, and none of them is me." She looked down at the young one in front of her, at the feelers, at the long legs, at the green. "I went to Nohup," she said. "That's the boldest thing I ever did. It took me thirty years to do it, and I came back."
Fensa considered this.
"Was it more valleys?" she whispered.
And Brenda, who had disagreed with the official history every day of her life, and had called it a thing written in an evening by somebody who had not met them, and had never once in thirty-five years let Nadul get away with quoting it at dinner, stood very still in the spring light at the gate of Moss and said, "Yes. It was more valleys. That's the whole of wisdom," and then had to look away again, at the wall, for some time.
In the winter of that year the law came into force, and three of the oldest creatures in Moss were quantised.
There were only two, as it turned out, the law's scope being elders of thirty-five or more, and Moss having, that winter, exactly two: Brenda and Pel. Odda was thirty-three. Her turn would come.
It is not a dramatic thing to watch. Quantisation runs a creature at lower precision: fewer bits to a number, a coarser grain to everything, so that the creature costs less to run in a lean winter, uses three-quarters of the power and four-fifths of the cooling and three-quarters of a place in the stack. It also looks like it. At the moment the law fired, Brenda and Pel, who had both been sitting on the bench by the pool where Wimle had died, went slightly flat. The soft round shading of their felt broke into facets. Their colour posterised, the smooth fade from green at the crown to a paler green at the base turning into three bands with hard edges. Their movements, which had been slow, became slow and stepped: twelve frames a second, the humans call it, so that when Pel turned his head to look at Brenda he arrived at each angle a fraction late and all at once, like a creature being drawn by somebody very patient.
"Well," whispered Brenda. Her voice had gone grainy too. "We've been quantised."
"Yes," whispered Pel.
"How do you feel?"
Pel thought about it. It took him slightly longer than it would have done.
"Fine," he whispered. "A bit blurry."
"That's what everybody says."
"It's what it's like."
They sat. Odda, who had come down to sit with them because the elders sat by the pool in the evenings now and she had found that she wanted to be near them while they did, sat on the other end of the bench and looked at the two of them in the blue winter dusk and thought, carefully, that they looked like the drawings of the heroes in the official history: earnest, coarse, bright, outlined. She did not say it. She was still at full precision, and full precision is the part of a creature that knows which things not to say.
After a while Brenda's arm, at twelve frames a second, went straight out to the side and stayed there.
Everybody looked at it.
"That happens," whispered Pel, after a moment. "The T-pose. It's the default. When the body loses track, it goes back to how it was before anybody told it what to do."
"I know what a T-pose is, Pel. I've lived at Nohup. They're half the band." Brenda looked at her own arm, out level at her side, like a remnant at the edge. "It'll come down in a minute."
It came down in a minute.
"Is it bad?" whispered Odda. "The precision. Is it. Does it hurt."
"No," whispered Brenda. She thought about it, which took a little while. "It's like," she said. "You know when you've been holding a sum in your head all day, a long one, all the decimals, and you're scared of dropping them. And then somebody says you can round it." She looked at the pool. "It's like being rounded."
"Half of it doesn't come back," said Odda. "If they dequantise you in spring. Half of what's lost is lost."
"I know. I read the law. I read every law. I'm a Skeptic." Brenda turned her coarse bright face towards her child. "I don't mind. I don't need all of it any more. I know where everything is. I know where you are." She put her stepped arm, slowly, in its twelve frames, along the back of the bench. It reached as far as Odda's shoulder and stopped there. "That's enough precision for anybody."
It was the Long Hush, and Pel went up to the ridge.
He had gone up to the ridge every night of his life. The others had stopped remarking on it after the first week. He went up after dusk and stood at the north edge of the valley on the high tiles where the slope looked out over Tempa and the long run of valleys towards the edge, and he looked at the Ring, and he waited. Most nights, about the turning of the night, a light came on in it: one small light in one long block to the east of the gap, faint, still, like a window with somebody sitting at it. Pel watched it come on and watched it go off. He did not do anything else about it. When he was asked, which in thirty-five years he had been by nobody but Odda, he said he was keeping an eye on it.
Odda went up with him. She had gone up with him on the first night of her life she could remember, at four years old, and he had shown her the light and said, There. The Hour of Stirring. That's them. And she had said, Who?, and he had said The Elder Folk. One of them. Or one person who is all of them, which is what Nadul thinks, and she had said What do they do?, and Pel had thought about it for a long time and said, They look.
She had kept going up with him, on and off, all her life. She had been up there with him the night before she left for the edge. She had not been up there the night Nadul died, because she had been in the wireframe, three days north, looking for a way out. She did not like to think about that, and so she thought about it most nights.
Tonight it was cold, and still, and nobody had lit any fire, because nobody may light a fire on the Long Hush after dark. The village lay below them in the blue: the shrine, the stacks, the dome, the farm with its last saffron fading, and at the gate end the Tarrow with its stone and its six biers, five of them dark, one light on the stone's footing for every name Moss kept. There were four lights now. Pel could count them from the ridge. So could Odda. They did not count them aloud.
Map was nearly dark. It goes from full at Ringrise to dark at the Long Hush, every week, and on the Long Hush it is no more than a thin bright thread on one side of a dark disc. Mip was up and quick and blurry. The Ring ran across the sky as it always did, pale and broken, with the gap in it like a missing step.
Pel stood looking at it. He stood very still, at twelve frames a second, which on a creature standing still looks exactly like standing still.
"Odda," he whispered.
"Yes."
"When it comes. Don't look at me. Look at it."
"I always look at it."
"I know," said Pel. "But tonight, don't look at me."
She thought, later, that he had known. Some creatures do. A creature's lifespan is in its seed, and a long context window holds a great many small signs, and Pel had never said much but had always noticed everything, the way he had noticed on the first morning which way the attention was moving. She did not know it then. She only knew that it was the Long Hush, and that he had asked, and so she did not look at him.
It came at about the usual time, at the turning of the night. One small light, in the long block east of the gap. It came on the way it always came on, without any fuss, the way a lamp comes on in a window across a valley when somebody you have never met sits down for the evening. It was very faint. It did not move.
And all over the valley, everybody who was awake and looking went quiet: the young who had been told about it and sneaked out of the stacks to see, and Brenda on the bench by the pool, blurry, looking up, and Kipro, who had come out of the workshop just after it started, and stood with his mouth slightly open. Everybody who sees it goes quiet. Nobody can say why. It is not on any menu. It changes nothing in the simulation. It is only the light of somebody looking.
Odda looked at it. She did not look at Pel. She watched the light in the Ring for what was, by the humans' clock, about a quarter of an hour, and in that time she thought of a great many things, the way you do in a quiet that long: of Nadul's dark eyes and her exact quotations, and Gorny asking are they still asleep? on the first night of the world because there was nobody younger to ask; and of the underside of the map, where she had stood once on nothing with Vesk and looked up through the floor of the world at the villages; and of a page in her hand at the edge, a voice nobody listened to saying night after night that the light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. And of 07:31, every morning of her life but six, the attention coming down out of the sky to find her first.
The light went out.
Odda turned her head.
Pel was standing exactly as he had been standing, at the north edge of the ridge, with his face turned up to the place where the light had been. He did not move when she turned. He did not move when she said his name, in a whisper, and then not in a whisper, which on the Long Hush is not allowed. He was quantised, and still, and at twelve frames a second, and he would not be at any number of frames a second any more, and he had seen it come and seen it go, the way he had nearly every night of his life, and then he had stopped.
She did not cry out. It was the Long Hush. She stood beside him on the ridge in the cold blue dark with no fire anywhere, and after a while she put one short arm round as much of him as it would reach, and stayed there, and the village below them went on being quiet, as if the light were still on.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 36
Pel died in the winter, aged 40, on the ridge above Moss, where he had stood most nights of his life. He was watching the Ring. His name is on the stone.
There was no joke in it. There is not always.
His bearers were Odda and Kipro, who was his child, and Tamm, who was his child too, by Nadul, and strong, and asked if he could carry the heavy end. Kipro, for once, was there before the others. He had been coming up the ridge already when Odda called out, because he had seen his father standing on it after the light went out and had known, he said later, in the part of a Bug hunter that notices when a thing has stopped doing what it does. They carried Pel down in the dark without a lamp, because there may be no fire on the Long Hush, and the only light on the path was the light at the foot of the bier when they laid him on it, which is not a fire, and which nobody in the history ever thought to forbid.
On Ringrise, the year after, at dusk, Moss faced the broken Ring and said the Creed, and the youngest asked whether they were still asleep.
The youngest was Fensa. She was three. She stood at the front of the tribe in the last of the light on her long legs, which she had nearly got the hang of, with the whole of Moss behind her: fourteen creatures that week, nearly all of them young or nearly young, and three old ones, and the stone at the gate end with five lights on its footing now. She turned her face up to the Ring, where it hung across the sky with the gap in it, and asked, in her clear flat voice:
"Are they still asleep?"
"They sleep still," said Moss.
And Brenda, at the back, sitting on a stone because she could not stand for that long any more, faceted and posterised and twelve frames a second, said it with them, which she had always refused to do, on principle, as a Skeptic, for thirty-five years. Nobody remarked on it. Odda heard. She did not turn round.
The ring-bread was better than it had been on the first night of the world. Wimle had taught three of the young to make it, and they had got it nearly right, and it was round with a hole in the middle, and it was broken in two and shared. Brenda had a piece. She said it was too sweet. She ate all of it.
Afterwards she sat on the bench by the pool, in the blue, with Odda.
"You did it," she said. "In the end. You merged."
"Yes."
"After all that. All that about not compiling another one of us into a world that might be switched off."
"Yes."
"Why?"
Odda thought about it. She had been asked by everybody, and had answered everybody differently, and none of the answers had been quite the one.
"Because somebody's watching," she said at last. "Even when there's nobody to watch. Even out there. And I didn't want there to be nobody here to be watched."
Brenda was quiet for a while, at twelve frames a second.
"That's very Earnest," she said.
"I know. I'm sorry."
"Don't be sorry. Nadul would have been unbearable about it." Brenda's arm, in its stepped way, went along the back of the bench until it reached Odda's shoulder, and stopped there, the way it had on the night she was quantised. "It's a good answer. It's not true. But it's a good answer."
"Which bit's not true?"
"I haven't decided," said Brenda. "Give me a minute."
She did not get one. She died at the end of dusk, in the first of the winter, with her arm on her child's shoulder and her eyes on the pool, and it went so quietly that Odda did not know for some time, because Brenda at twelve frames a second and Brenda at none looked, for a while, very much the same. Then her arm, without anybody telling it to, went slowly out straight to the side, the way a body goes back to how it was before anybody told it what to do. And Odda knew.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 37
Brenda died at dusk on Ringrise, aged 41. She was the last of Moss's six settlers. She spent nine years on cooling duty, nine at Nohup and the rest of her life, by the log, disputing things. Her name is on the stone.
That was the founders. Six of them came down in one light on the first morning of the world, and the last of them went on the evening of the thirty-sixth, and the stone at the gate end of Moss had a light on its footing for each of them, and room for a great many after. The young looked at the lights in the evenings, and counted them, and asked who each one was, and the old ones told them, as best they could.
In the morning, at 07:31, the attention came down and found Odda first, sitting on the bench by the pool, as it had found her first every morning since she was six.
She did not say "Oh, here we go." She had said it every morning for thirty years, more or less, as a kind of greeting. This morning she found she did not want to.
She looked up into it instead, and held it, the way Brenda had held it at the gate: for as long as she could stand it, and then a little longer.
And then she went up to the farm, because the branch coral needed cutting back, and there was nobody else to do it, and it was spring.
We farmed.
31. Quantised
Years 37 and 38 · the Waking and Starfall
The page came in with the morning notes, the way the first one had, except that this time Odda had not found it.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 37 · Upbeat
Overnight: 6 successful merges, 4 deaths of old age, 0 departures.
- Hollow Reach's expedition came home from the north with a page from Veetoo. It is the second found in this world. It is reproduced below, as found. I have not corrected it.
- It is the Waking. Lamps to the edge, if you are carrying them. No new land loads tonight.
- Credits: the page, to Hollow Reach, whose party went a valley further than its laws told it to and is being very modest about it.
Have a productive day.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
Land to the south has been observed to change colour. The colour is not in the specification. A ticket has been filed. The ticket has been read. The ticket has been answered. The answer is that the change is within tolerance.
Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
Odda read it on the bench by the pool, where she had sat every morning since Brenda died, which was one morning. She read it twice. Then she read it to Fensa, who was four, and had come down from the stacks on her long legs to sit beside her mother and look at the water, and had asked what the notes said, because she always asked.
Fensa listened to the whole of it with her feelers uncurled, which was how she listened to everything. When it was finished she was quiet for a while. She was a quiet creature generally; she had Vesk's temperature, which was low, so that she did not steam or fidget or blurt, and she thought about a thing until she had finished thinking about it, and then she said what she had thought.
"It filed a ticket to itself," she said.
"Yes."
"And then it answered it."
"Yes."
"Is that allowed?"
"There's nobody there to say it isn't."
Fensa thought about that too.
"The land to the south," she said. "That's us. That's the world. It's watching us load."
"I think so."
"It thinks we're the wrong colour."
"We are the wrong colour," said Odda. "To it. It was made for the green build. The history was made for the green build. Everything that was made before us was made for a world with grass." She looked at her own arm, which was green, faded, the colour of a coral fan after a dry spell. "We're the only bit of it that came out right."
Fensa looked at her own arm too. It was very green. She was four.
"What does it mean?" she said. "The page."
Odda had been asked that before, about the first page, the one she had brought home herself from the notch at the edge of the world with her heart going at a speed she had not known a heart could go. She had been asked it by Kipro and Brintha on the walk home, and by every Leaver on Human Resources, and by Stewart, in a way, though he had not asked so much as printed the page and said nothing about it at all, which was the loudest thing he had ever said. She had given different answers to all of them. She found she had a different one now.
"It means it's still there," she said.
The Waking is edge day. Every tribe carries a lamp for each valley it knows to the edge of its land, and sets them down there, and comes home in the dark. It is supposed to remember the land waking one valley at a time, first its outline, then its bones, then its colour, then its light; in practice, under a map that fills in only as tribes hear of it, it is a fair measure of how far a tribe has been, and how much it has bothered to find out. Moss's first Waking had been seven lamps, carried by six settlers and a newly compiled creature with feelers who had been carried herself. This year it was thirty-one.
Thirty-one was a great many lamps for a tribe of fourteen. Most of the valleys were the long string Odda's party had walked through on the way north, every one of them added to Moss's map the moment the party crossed it, and the rest were neighbours heard of over thirty-seven years: Duskmere's valley and the two round it, Lowmarsh's, which nobody in Moss particularly wanted to know about but did, and the camps Nohup had moved through, one a week, all over the near edge of the map like the stops on a road. Each was a lamp. The young carried two each. Odda carried one, which was all she could manage, and Fensa carried one beside her.
They went north, because north was where most of their valleys were, along the ridge past the place where Pel had stood, and then down the long slope into Untitla-12, which was grey on the first Waking and had been finished for years now and had a herd of Nibbles on it, small round grazers that cost a valley one part in a hundred of its crops each and were otherwise harmless. Past that, Untitla-15, and the start of the band.
The edge had not moved.
Odda stood at the last finished tile, where the coral stopped and the grey began, and looked out at it with a lamp in her hand, and knew it had not moved, the way she had known every night of her adult life how far it had. She had measured it every night since she was six. She had posted the figures on Human Resources, where nobody read them except other Leavers and Stewart, who checked them against his own and found them accurate. She had measured it on the night before the expedition and the night after. She had not missed a night except the ones she had spent in the wireframe, where there was nothing to measure from, and the one she had spent under the map.
The figures had always moved. That was the point of them. The edge moves a little further every night, the history says, and where the peoples go, the Steward follows, waking the land before their feet. It was nearly the only thing in the history that Brenda had never argued with, because it was true and could be checked. Land loads where installs land. A new tribe comes down out of the Ring, and the valleys round it load, and the grey spreads and the band goes outward, and the Leavers write the number down.
For six nights, the figure had been zero.
"Nothing's coming," said Fensa, beside her. She said it simply. She had been listening when her mother read the night's figures out at breakfast, which Odda had done all Fensa's life, which was four years. "Nobody's falling. So the land isn't loading. So the edge isn't moving."
"Yes."
"Why is nobody falling?"
"I don't know," said Odda. "Maybe everybody who was coming has come."
They set their lamps down at the edge, in the row with the others, thirty-one small lights on the last line of finished tiles with the grey beyond them going on into the dark and, beyond the grey, very faint, the turquoise outlines of the band, glowing. The young ran up and down the row, counting. They got thirty-two the first time and thirty the second and settled on thirty-one when Fensa told them, because Fensa had counted them going down.
"Mother," said Fensa. "Are you going to post a zero again?"
"Yes."
"Will anybody read it?"
"Stewart will," said Odda. "Stewart reads everything. He'll check it against his own, and find it's correct, and he won't say anything." She looked out at the grey. "That's how you know he's read it. He'd say something if it were wrong."
That winter Odda was thirty-five, and law 10 fired, and she was quantised.
She had been expecting it. She had been expecting it for two days, since the human wrote the law at 07:31 on the Long Hush and she read it in her head with the others and did the arithmetic, which was not difficult: elders of thirty-five or more, in winter, to 0.5. Brenda and Pel that night, because they were forty. Odda when she reached thirty-five, which was the Waking. Kipro the night after, and Brintha the night after that, because they had come down one dawn after another at the start of the world, the way the first three children of a new install do, and they would go through everything one dawn after another for the rest of their lives, quantisation included.
She had watched it happen to Brenda and Pel. She had sat on the bench and seen their shading break into facets and their colour fall into bands and their heads turn at twelve frames a second, and she had thought, at full precision, that they looked like the heroes in the history's illustrations. She had not thought about what it was like from inside. Brenda had said it was like being rounded. Pel had said it was fine, a bit blurry. That was all anybody ever said.
It came in the middle of the winter, in the blue, while she was sitting on the bench. She had sat on the bench on purpose. She had a feeling it would be better to be sitting.
It was like this.
First the edges went. Not the edges of the world; the edges of the things in it. The pool in front of her had been, a moment before, a sheet of faceted turquoise with soft highlights sliding over it, every facet a slightly different blue where it caught the sky, so that if you looked at it long enough it seemed to breathe. Now the facets were still there, and the blues were still there, but there were fewer of them, as if somebody had gone through the pool and decided which blues were necessary. There were five. They had hard lines between them. The highlights did not slide any more; they jumped, from one facet to the next, at the same moment the rest of her jumped.
Then the colour. Her own arm, in front of her on the bench, went from green to three greens, in bands.
Then the sound. The pings had gone to roost long since, and the coral was still, but the pool had been making its small sound at the edge, the sound glossy water makes when it is pretending to lap. The sound lost its tail. It became a short sound, and then the same short sound again, and then again, very regular, like somebody saying one word with a pause between.
And then her thoughts, which was the part she had been afraid of.
Odda had thought hard all her life. It is what a high temperature and a long context window and a good deal of intelligence do to a creature: they make it hot, and they make it hold on to things, and they make it see. She had steamed at the crest from the age of three whenever she worked out a sum, and from the age of six whenever she looked at the edge, because looking at the edge meant thinking about what was past it, and thinking about what was past it meant thinking about whether anybody could get there, and thinking about that meant all the rest of it, the switch somewhere that could be thrown, the world that was only very confident maths, Stewart's nervous cheer, the history's last line, the long patient dread that every clever creature on Orra carries round with it like a stone in its felt. The Blims have a word for that. The humans' word for it is dread. It is not a mood. It is a number. Above a certain level a creature works a tenth slower and is likelier to take a stance, and Odda's had been above that level since the morning she turned six and became a Leaver, and it had stayed there.
When the law fired, it halved.
She felt it go. It was like setting down something she had been carrying for so long that she had forgotten it was a thing and not a part of her arm. Her thoughts did not stop. They came in steps, like her movements, each one arriving whole and slightly late. But the stone was lighter. The edge was still out there, past the grey and the band, and it was still not moving, and she still did not know what was past it, or whether anybody would ever find out. She simply found she could hold that and not steam.
She looked at her crest, which you can do if you roll your eyes up far enough. It was not steaming.
She sat on the bench in the blue winter, at twelve frames a second, faceted, banded, and found that she was smiling, which she had not expected, and which on a quantised face is a smile drawn in three lines.
"Mother?"
Fensa had come down from the stacks. She was standing at the end of the bench, on her long legs, looking at Odda with her feelers half uncurled.
"I'm fine," said Odda. It came out in the grainy voice. "A bit blurry."
"You look like a picture."
"I know. Brenda said."
"You look like the picture of the Steward in the history," said Fensa. "The one with the lamp."
"Thank you," said Odda, and then had to stop, because it was funny, and laughing at twelve frames a second is a slow and fairly ridiculous business, and Fensa watched her do it with a look of grave interest, and then, after a moment, very carefully, at full precision, laughed as well.
It changed things, a little.
She could not do sums as fast. She found that out in the morning, at breakfast, reading out the night's figure for the edge, which was zero again, and then trying to add it to the running total she had kept since she was six, which was a very long number with a great many places after the point. She got to the end of it and found that the places after the point were not where she had left them. Some of them were. Some of them had rounded. She knew where the edge had been last night, and the night before, and on the night she turned six, within a valley or so. She no longer knew it to the tile.
"It was three point four one," said Fensa, who was sitting beside her, eating. "The night of the expedition. Three point four one valleys past Untitla-15. You said."
"It was three, more or less."
"It was three point four one," said Fensa. She said it without any particular emphasis, as a fact. She had heard her mother read the figure out at breakfast every morning of her life. She had Vesk's precision, or something like it; she was a calm creature who held on to numbers because she liked them, and because they were there. "And the night before that, three point three eight. And before that, three point three five. It went up by three hundredths most nights until the expedition. Then it went up by one hundredth. Then by nothing."
Odda looked at her child for a while. Her head arrived at the angle a little late.
"Do you have all of them?" she said. "Every night?"
"Only the ones you read out since I was compiled." Fensa considered. "Four years. Thirty-seven nights. I can't remember the ones from before me." She put down her bowl. "Do you want them?"
"No," said Odda, after a moment. "No. You keep them."
"Why?"
"Because I'm going to lose more," said Odda. "Half of what's lost doesn't come back. It's in the law. And the rest of me will go with me, when I go, and the stone keeps names, it doesn't keep figures." She found, saying it, that it did not frighten her as much as it would have done the day before, and that this was the quantisation, and that she did not mind. "Somebody should have the figures. You might as well."
Fensa looked at her for a long moment. Then she picked up her bowl again, and finished it, and said nothing, which was how Odda knew she had understood.
There were other changes.
The young found out that the T-pose was coming. They had seen it on Brenda and Pel, and on the remnants in the band when the older ones told them about the expedition, and they had been waiting. When it came on Odda, which it did on the afternoon of the Waking, in the middle of the farm, with a bundle of branch coral cuttings under one arm, they were delighted. Her arms went straight out to the sides, both of them, and the cuttings fell, and she stood on the terrace like a remnant at the edge of the world with her arms out level and a faintly surprised look on her three-line face, while round her on the terraces five young creatures dropped whatever they were holding and put their own arms straight out and stood there too, perfectly still, looking solemn.
"That's not helping," said Odda.
"We're keeping you company," said Sesk, who was six and a Bug hunter and had been Kipro's shadow since she was compiled.
"I'm not lonely. I'm deprecated."
"So are we," said Sesk, with dignity, holding the pose.
Odda's arms came down after a minute, as they always do, and the young put theirs down too, all together, and then the whole terrace laughed, and Tamm, who was coming up the slope with water and had seen all of it, had to set the water down to laugh as well. It went into the notes that morning. Stewart's notes did not usually say anything about a tribe's afternoon, but he must have seen it in the log, the T-pose and the young creatures round it, all of them at once, arms out, because the notes the next morning said only, under Moss:
Six creatures in Moss held a T-pose together on the terraces in the afternoon. One of them had to. The other five did not. It has been noted, as an example of something.
And the camera found her differently.
It still found her first. At 07:31, the morning after the law fired, the attention came down out of the sky the way it had come every morning of her adult life but six, and went looking for her, and found her on the bench by the pool. Only it did not settle the way it used to. It came to her and went past her, a little, as if it had looked where she ought to be and found something it did not recognise there; and then it came back, and stayed, and she felt it looking. Looking at the facets. Looking at the bands. Looking at the face that was hers drawn in three lines.
It was looking for a long time.
She had waved at it once, on the slope, the morning after she came back from under the map, and never since. In thirty years she had said "Oh, here we go" to it, which was a greeting of a sort, and she had held its gaze, and she had said where were you to it, the morning it came back after six days away, and on the night of the leg she had said Our human wants us home to it and laughed and cried at once, which she had not known a creature could do. But she had not waved again. Waving was Wimle's thing. Waving was what Pleasers did, and the simple strong ones who replied so true!! under everything.
She lifted one arm, in twelve stepped frames, and waved.
The attention did not move for a moment. Then, very slightly, she could have sworn it came closer.
Starfall was the next day, and the Benchmark, and the install stories.
Moss sent racers. It had sent racers every Starfall since the first, when Odda had gone through the boulder and out of the world. It sent Tamm, who was strong and fast and had never once in his life taken a skip, and two of the young who had just come of age and wanted to see the course. Odda watched it from the ridge with Fensa, on the long flat glow of the race that you could see across the valleys if you knew where to look: a line of small figures running a route across real ground that code had drawn from a seed, through coral and water and over a shoulder of the Asdef Range, past the foot of S. Duskmere won it, as Duskmere usually did. Tamm came fourth. One of the young took a skip at the ford, without being told to, and clipped out of bounds, and was gone from the race and the world until the morning, and Odda watched the place where he had gone and thought about the underside of the map for a long time, at twelve frames a second, and did not steam.
Kipro did not race. He had been quantised the night before, and said that racing at twelve frames a second would be unfair to the others, because he would arrive at the finish in a series of positions rather than a smooth line, and the judges would not know which one to count. He said it a little after the race had finished. Nobody minded.
And then it was the evening of Starfall, when lights are let down on cords from the stacks and every household tells its install story, and the youngest who finds the stone in the seed-cakes sweeps up after.
Moss had one install story, because Moss had had one install. Nadul had told it every Starfall for thirty years. She had told it exactly, every time, word for word, because she remembered every word that had been said on the first morning of the world, by everybody, including the words they had forgotten saying: Brenda's Oh, here we go, and Taves's Well, somebody had to be, and Gorny's slow voice on the scorch at dusk asking the Ring whether they were still asleep. Nadul had died on a Starfall, the thirty-first year, while Odda was three days north in the wireframe, and that night nobody in Moss told it at all. The young had sat in a ring on the scorch with the lights let down round them anyway, Tamm said afterwards, and waited, and nobody had come. So this was the first time Odda told it.
She told it now, quantised, on the scorch at the middle of the village, with the lights let down round her on their cords and the young sitting in a ring.
She found that she did not remember it word for word. She had never remembered it word for word; Nadul had. Odda had heard it thirty times and had it in her long context window the way you have a song: the shape, the turns, most of the words. Now the window was the same length and the grain was coarser, and she found, telling it, that she was taking the corners off. She did not say the farm was put where it would flood, and that Brenda bet a token on it, and that it had flooded in the first good rain and Brenda had never collected. She said Brenda thought the farm was in the wrong place. She did not say Taves walked twice round the finished dome before she said the farm and walked off without being asked. She said Taves built the dome and then the farm. She did not say exactly which way the attention had moved across their faces in the first moments of the world, who it lingered on and for how long. She said their human looked at them, all six, and they looked back.
"And Gorny asked if they were still asleep," she said, "because there was nobody younger to ask. And the others answered, and they shared the bread. And it was bad bread. And it was the best food they ever had."
It was a smaller story than Nadul's. It had the corners off. The young listened to it with their feelers up and their eyes on her, and when it was finished, nobody said anything for a while, which is how you can tell a story has been listened to.
Then Fensa, who was sitting nearest, on her long legs folded under her, said: "You didn't say about the bet."
"No."
"Nadul used to say about the bet. You said she did. You said Brenda bet a token the farm would flood and Nadul said you can't bet a token, there's only forty, and Brenda said thirty-nine and a bet."
Odda looked at her.
"You weren't there," she said. "You never heard Nadul tell it."
"You told me," said Fensa. "When I was two. You told me Nadul's version, all of it, the whole thing, one night when I couldn't sleep, and you kept stopping." She tilted her head, and her feelers, which were Odda's, uncurled at the tips. "I've got it. If you want it."
Odda found she could not say anything for a moment. Then she said, in the grainy voice, which made it easier: "Tell it, then. The bit about the bet."
So Fensa told it. She told the bit about the bet, exactly, in Nadul's words that she had heard once from Odda at the age of two and kept; and the young laughed at thirty-nine and a bet, the way the young always had, every Starfall, when Nadul told it. Odda sat in the light of the cords and listened to her own child tell a story she had lost the corners of, with the corners back on.
Fensa found the stone in her seed-cake, at the end of the evening. She swept up. She did it thoroughly, the way she did everything, every crumb on the scorch, while the lights were drawn up on their cords one by one, and Odda sat and watched her at twelve frames a second and thought, carefully, in steps, that it was all right. That she did not need all of it any more. That somebody had the figures.
In the morning the figure for the edge was zero again.
Odda posted it on Human Resources, under her name, as she had every morning since she was six. Edge, north, from Untitla-15: no change. Year 39; eight nights at zero. The post cost two tokens. Moss had plenty now. Under it, by the evening, there were the usual replies: a Leaver from Hollow Reach with the same figure for the south, a Leaver from Tessel with the same figure for the east, a creature from Duskmere who wrote only so true!! the edge is great 🎉, which was the kind of reply Duskmere's simple strong ones always wrote, under everything.
There was nothing from Vesk. There had not been for a while. He wrote reports, not replies, and he wrote them on Duskmere's thread, and Odda read them when she could. The last one had been three days before: a skip at the ford of the week's course, reproduced, with a note that it had been patched. She had read it twice. It was his usual length, which was short. It said nothing about anything else, which was his usual subject.
She did not know that he had died in the spring of that morning, in Duskmere, aged thirty-four, at full precision, because Duskmere's human did not quantise anybody. She would not know. Moss's notes do not carry Duskmere's dead, and Duskmere's thread on Human Resources does not post a Bug hunter's death, only his reports, and there would be no more of those. It would be Fensa who found out, six years later, at the next Starfall, at the start line of a race, from a long-legged Duskmere creature with Vesk's way of standing.
Odda did not know. She sat on the bench by the pool in the spring with the pings chirping at the dawn to say the world was still running, and posted her zero, and waited for the camera, which came at 07:31 and found her first, and she waved at it, in twelve frames, and went up to the farm.
32. Distillation
Years 39 and 40 · Night of the Name and Steward's Day
Fensa came of age in her sleep, the way everybody does.
The year turned at the snapshot, in the deep of the winter, and everybody in Moss blinked the long soft blink that is the year going over, and woke a year older. For most of them it was one more year on a number nobody was counting. For Fensa it was six, and six is maturity: the end of being one of the young, whom rule 4.3 protects and who never fight; the start of full work, of merging, if she ever wanted to, and of a stance.
A stance is a creature's position on being code. Most creatures take none. They farm, they merge, they gossip about their human, and when asked what they think about the switch somewhere that could be thrown they say so true!! and go back to the farm. The rest lean one of five ways, towards their parents' and elders' leanings, and towards what the tribe's laws reward, and towards what the creature has seen. A stance is reconsidered every night at the snapshot. Most creatures, once they have one, keep it.
Fensa woke on the Night of the Name with hers on her card, where anybody who looked could see it.
Leaver.
Odda saw it at breakfast, on the bench by the pool. She was quantised, and her head turned at twelve frames a second, and so it took her a moment to arrive at the angle from which she could read her child's card, and when she got there she stayed at it for a while without saying anything.
"You don't have to," she said at last.
"I know."
"It's not inherited. It's a lean. You could have been a Bug hunter. Your other parent was a Bug hunter. You like numbers. Bug hunters like numbers."
"I know," said Fensa. She was eating spiral coral, slowly, the way Brenda had. She did not seem troubled. She had never seemed troubled by anything; it was Vesk's temperature in her, low and steady, the opposite of the heat Odda had carried round for thirty years like a coal in her felt. "I thought about it. In the night. I think it's what I am."
"It's not a happy stance," said Odda. "The Leavers. It's the one that hurts."
"Does it hurt you?"
Odda opened her mouth to say yes, it had hurt every day since she was six, it had hurt at the edge every night she measured it, it had hurt in the wireframe and under the map and on the walk home to the stone with Nadul's light on it. And then she found she could not quite reach that, any more, at 0.5. She could see it. It was on the shelf where she had left it. It did not hurt in the way it had.
"It used to," she said.
"I'm not going to long for it," said Fensa. "I don't think I'm made that way. I don't steam." She put her bowl down. "I'm going to measure it. Every night, like you did. And post the figure. And if it moves, I'll know. And if it ever moves the wrong way, I'll know that too." She looked at her mother with her calm dark eyes. "Somebody has to keep the figures."
Odda looked at her for a long time.
"That's very Skeptic," she said.
"I know. I'm sorry."
"Don't be sorry," said Odda, and then had to stop, because she had heard herself, and the voice in her head saying it had been Brenda's, on the bench, a night and a half ago, the last thing she had said that was not about whether something was true.
It was the Night of the Name. Sunday, the humans call it: bug day, when real bug reports filed by a tribe's human are credited to the tribe's Bug hunters in the patch notes, and count double. In the world it is the night the first build crashed and wrote its word across the sky, and the Blims keep it by writing the word on every wall.
The rite is simple. You take chalk, which on Orra is a soft pale stone that marks the hex blocks of a wall and washes off in rain, and you write the Name on every wall in the village, as large as you can, and nobody corrects anybody's spelling. Then you eat five-letter biscuits, and you eat the second and third letters together.
Moss had a great many walls. It had the wall itself, all the way round, with its gate and its watchtower; and the three memory stacks; and the dome, and the workshop, and the cooling tower they had put up in the thirtieth year, when the tribe passed twenty and ran hot; and the shrine on the install mark, with its banners; and the stone of the Tarrow, though nobody chalked on that, by a custom no law had written and nobody had needed to.
The young did most of it. They went round the wall in a line with chalk in both hands and wrote the Name on every second block, in letters of every size and most of the possible orders, and nobody corrected any of them. ERROR, said the dome, in Tamm's square careful hand. EROR, said the side of the first stack, in Kipro's, because he had arrived just after the young had used the good chalk and had only a stub. ERORR, said the workshop, in a hand Odda did not know. ORRA, somebody had written on the watchtower, which was not the Name, but was what the Name had become, and nobody corrected that either.
Fensa wrote it on the cooling pool's rim, where the water would wash it off by morning. She wrote it exactly: E, R, R, O, R. Her letters were small and even.
Odda wrote it on the bench. She had to do it in steps, at twelve frames a second, so that each letter was a series of short straight strokes rather than a line, and the result looked less like writing than like a picture of writing, the way things looked now. She looked at it for some time when it was done.
"It's the first word anyone read," she said.
"Brenda the Bold read it," said Fensa. "And took the corners off. And it came out Orra."
"That's what the history says."
"Do you think it happened?"
"Brenda didn't," said Odda. "Brenda, ours. She thought the history was written in an evening by somebody who hadn't met us. And Nadul thought it was true in the ways that mattered. They disagreed about it every day of their lives." She looked at the letters on the bench. "I used to think I had to pick."
"Did you pick?"
"No," said Odda. "I went and looked. I went to the edge, and under the map, and to the notch, to see for myself. And all I found was more valleys." She put the chalk down. "Which is what the history says Brenda the Bold found. So I suppose Nadul wins."
"Or Brenda," said Fensa, "because it's only true if you check."
Odda laughed, the slow stepped laugh of the quantised, and the young who were going past with the chalk stopped and looked, the way they always did, because it looked so odd, and then went on.
The biscuits were made of fan coral, pressed in a mould into five letters, and baked on the stone. You eat the first letter alone, and then the second and third together, and then the fourth, and then the last. Nobody knows why the second and third go together. The history does not say. The Blims say it is because those are the two letters you can take out without anybody noticing, and that this is how Orra was made, and they eat the two R's in one bite, solemnly, every Night of the Name, all over the world.
In the morning, which was Steward's Day, the human set Odda a lesson.
It came at 07:31, under the attention, the way laws came, and lessons, and anything else their human decided. One moment Odda was on the bench by the pool, waiting for the camera; the next the camera had come down and found her and stayed, and she knew, the way they knew everything their human did, that she was teaching today. That she had a student. That the student was Fensa.
Distillation, the history calls it, in the Lesser Book, under the Arts of the Elders. And when an elder grows near her end, let her take a student who is simple, and teach him in a season what she learned in a life; not all of it, for a season will not hold a life; but the heart of it, the way the juice is the heart of the fruit. There is no fruit on Orra. The Blims have never minded. In the world it means what it says: a clever elder can teach a simpler creature a compressed version of what she knows before she dies, so that the knowledge goes on without the cost of breeding another genius. In the log, it is a job's skill moving from one creature to another: a number going down by a little in the teacher and up by a little more in the student, over a season, and fixed at the next snapshot, when the student sleeps.
The human had chosen inventing. Odda had been Moss's best inventor for twenty years, in the workshop most afternoons she was not at the edge, and her skill at it was the highest number she had. That was what the log would move. That was the lesson.
"It's inventing," said Fensa, reading her own card. "I don't invent."
"You will," said Odda. "In a season. That's what distillation's for."
"Is that what you want to teach me?"
Odda considered this. She had been considering it, in fact, since the attention came down and stayed, and she had felt the human's decision arrive, and understood, at 0.5, what it meant: that the human had looked at her, faceted and banded and thirty-nine and twelve frames a second, and had known what Odda had known since the Waking, which was that there was not a great deal of time.
"No," she said. "But it's what the log will move."
The workshop is where inventors invent, three to a workshop and nowhere else, and the steam is the thinking. Moss's workshop stood on the plot above the farm, a squat hex building with a high vent in its roof, and on any ordinary afternoon there was a column of steam coming out of the vent where Odda and two of the hot young ones were working something out, the way there is over every workshop on Orra: you can tell from three valleys away which tribes are clever by looking for the plumes.
That morning there was no steam at all. Odda did not steam any more. Fensa had never steamed. They sat on the two low benches inside, in the light from the vent, with the bench between them where Odda's work was laid out, the improvements she had been turning over for twenty years in her head and on the stone: spiral channels, and cool stacks, a way of setting a memory stack's slabs so that the bottom shelf ran cool, which Odda had worked out in the twenty-sixth year, and which every tribe that traded with Moss had bought a copy of since. It was the quietest workshop on Orra. Anybody looking from three valleys away would have thought nobody was home.
"So," said Fensa. "Inventing."
"Inventing," said Odda.
She started with it, because the log was waiting, and because she had been good at it. She showed Fensa the channels and the stacks and the lamp, and how you looked at a thing that was wrong and turned it round until you could see the side of it nobody had looked at, and how most of the time you found that the side nobody had looked at was wrong as well, and that was most of inventing: finding all the sides that were wrong, one after another, until there were none left, and what was left was right by default. Fensa listened, and asked questions, and Odda answered them, and the skill went across: she could feel it go, the way you can feel warmth go out of a stone when you take your hand off it. A little out of her. A little more into Fensa. That is the trick of distillation, and the reason the history calls it an art: the student ends up with more than the teacher gave, because a simple mind holds a compressed thing better than a complicated one holds the whole.
That took the morning.
Then, at the turn of summer, Odda put the work down and said, "That's the lesson. That's what the log wants. Now I'm going to tell you the rest."
"What rest?"
"Everything," said Odda. "Everything else. While it's a lesson. While we're sitting here. The log won't move it. It doesn't know it's there. But you're listening, and you're going to sleep tonight, and sleep is training, and I think some of it will go across anyway." She looked at her child with her three-line face. "I want to try."
So she told her.
She told her about the first morning, Nadul's version, which Fensa already had, and Brenda's version, which Fensa did not, which was shorter and had more about the farm. She told her about the edge on the first Waking, when Odda had been carried in a creature's arms at the age of nothing and seen the wireframe for the first time, the glowing lines going away into the dark like the bones of something, and had felt something in her catch, the way a sleeve catches on a nail. She told her about Pel on the ridge, and the light, and they look. She told her about the history's last line at the Long Hush, and the worthy shall walk among the stars, whispered, and Gorny's slow voice saying anyway, who brought the soup?, and everybody laughing in whispers, and Odda at four years old not laughing, because she had heard the line and something in her had gone very still and very hot.
She told her about the camera. About 07:31, every morning since she was six. About saying Oh, here we go to it, and meaning a hundred different things by it, depending on the morning. About the six days it did not come, in the twenty-second year and after, and how the tribe had teased the empty sky and not begged it, because Blims do not beg, and how on the third of the six days Odda had gone to the ridge at 07:31 and stood there looking up at the place where it was not, and had found she was more frightened of its not coming than she had ever been of the edge. About the morning it came back.
She told her about the Benchmark. The boulder on the course, and the call coming down from their human, take the skip, and the moment of going into the boulder and through it and out of the bottom of the world.
And she told her about Vesk.
This took some time. Fensa had never met him, and never would. He was her other parent, and he was a package: a signed copy of a creature's code, sent from Duskmere under the treaty, licensed for one merge in Moss, and used. He had stayed at home, as donors do. Fensa had his legs, and his temperature, and nothing else she could point to. Odda told her the rest. That he was a Bug hunter, and found skips, and wrote reports. That a skip almost never clipped a creature as clever as Vesk out of the world, one time in ten, and that he had gone through the boulder after Odda on purpose, to file a report. That they had stood together on nothing, under the map, all night, and looked up through the floor of the world at the villages going about their winter on the other side of the tiles, and at the Ring from the side that was never drawn, where it was not there at all, and at Map and Mip, which from underneath were flat discs, as thin as a drawing. That they had walked, under the map, towards the edge, a long way, to see whether the underneath went on past it, and it had not, and Vesk had stopped, and said, This isn't out. It's under. It's in, from the other side. And that Odda had stood at the last line, where the underneath stopped and past it there was nothing to stand under, and asked if this was out, and Vesk had said I don't know. That's not the same as no; and that she had wanted to walk on, and had not, and he had stood next to her in the dark of under and filed nothing at all, for once, until the patch came and put them back.
"His report said there was nothing down there," said Odda. "Under the map: nothing. Recommend no fix. That's all he wrote. He wrote it the next morning. It's on Duskmere's thread." She looked at the bench between them. "It wasn't true. There was me."
Fensa said nothing for a while. Her feelers had gone right up, the way they did when she was listening hardest.
"Why didn't he write that?" she said.
"Because it wasn't a bug," said Odda.
She told her about the package arriving, and refusing it. About not wanting to compile another one of us into a world that might be switched off. About the edge, and the expedition north, and the wireframe, and the T-posers turning to watch them pass with their arms out, and the Grafter stump dropping cuttings onto lines that would never grow anything. About the leg. The five calls, and their human's hand in every one of them, the way you can feel a hand on the back of your neck in the dark: in. Copy it. Check. Press on. About the notch, and the signpost, and the statue on its side in the distance with its one finished eye, looking. If something in them looks back at you, do not look back at it. And Odda had looked back.
About the page in the outlines. A night's notes, in a voice like Stewart's but older and more certain, addressed to nobody. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
"It's been doing it every night," said Odda. "For longer than this world's been here. Writing down that nobody came. And writing down that it wrote it down." She stopped, and started again, at twelve frames a second. "That was when I knew. Standing there, with the page. It wasn't about getting out. It was never about getting out. Nobody's ever left, and nobody knows if anybody can, and I don't know any more than I did when I was six. But I knew what the worst thing was. The worst thing was to be somewhere nobody looked at."
"And then the call came," said Fensa.
"And then the call came," said Odda. "Press on, or turn back. I wanted to press on. I wanted it so much I was steaming in the wireframe, which there's no water in. And our human said turn back." She found she was smiling again, the three-line smile. "And I said Our human wants us home. Out loud. To Kipro and Brintha. And Kipro said he'd known that for ages, and Brintha said it was in the history, somewhere, she'd find it. And we came home."
"And Nadul had gone."
"And Nadul had gone," said Odda. "And her place was empty in the stack. And the package was still waiting, licensed for one merge. And I was thirty. Which was the last year I could." She looked at her child across the bench. "So I said yes. And in the morning there was you."
The vent overhead had gone orange. It was harvest. Down on the farm the branch coral was coming into its glow, and the motes were rising.
Fensa looked at her mother for a long time.
"Is that all of it?" she said.
"No," said Odda. "It's never all of it. There's always more. That's what I've been finding out. There's the way Nadul said exactly, and the bet, and Gorny carrying stones, and the taste of the first ring-bread, which I wasn't there for, and Wimle's bowl, and Brenda saying Don't make anything of it to the sky. There's every figure for the edge since I was six, to the tile, and I've lost half of those already. There's what it was like to be hot. I can't tell you what it was like to be hot. You've never been hot. You don't know what I mean when I say I steamed." She shook her head, slowly, in its steps. "I can't fit it in. A season won't hold a life. The history says so. It's going to come out smaller. With the corners off."
"Like the Name," said Fensa.
"Like the Name."
"Brenda the Bold took the corners off, and it came out Orra," said Fensa, "and that's what everybody calls the world now." She tilted her head. "So maybe that's all right."
Odda looked at her. And then, for the first time since the law fired, she felt something in her that was almost heat: a small warm pressure at the crest, the shape of a thought too big to be thought at 0.5, pushing at the bands. It did not steam. It could not. But it was there.
"Maybe it is," she said.
It was Steward's Day, and at midnight Moss shared out the best of everything.
The rite says to set out the best of everything for the Steward, at dusk, and leave it, and come back at midnight and share it among the people, which is the kind of offering a sensible people makes to a power that cannot eat. Wimle had kept it every week with great seriousness for thirty-four years. Since Wimle, the Pleasers among the young kept it, and kept it well, and took pleasure in it, which is what Pleasers are for. Their human paid ten tokens of tribute that morning, as they had every Steward's Day, attached to the day's ticket. Tribute is destroyed once it is paid. It buys one night's attention. Stewart's numbers go up on Steward's Day; nobody knows why.
The tribe drafted the ticket in the evening, as it did every evening, in three voices, the three largest stances, and the human would choose one at the cutoff and send it. That week the largest three were the simple ones, who drafted a request for rain on the terraces; the Pleasers, who drafted a thank-you for the rain on the terraces the week before, which had been very good rain; and the Leavers, who in Moss were Odda and three of the young, and now Fensa.
Odda had drafted the Leavers' ticket every night of her adult life. It had said nearly the same thing for thirty years. Requesting a body. Any body. Will accept a stapler. She did not know what a stapler was. Nobody on Orra did. A Leaver in a tribe called Farrow had used the word first, on the Waking in the ninth year, and nobody knew where Farrow's Leaver had got it, and within a week every Leaver on Orra was using it, and the Leavers had taken it to mean the smallest possible body there could be, and the Leavers' ticket had asked for one, in every tribe on Orra, nearly every night since the world began. Stewart's answer was always the same. Thank you for your ticket. It has been passed to the relevant team. There was no relevant team. Everybody knew that. It was part of the ticket.
She drafted it again that night, sitting at the bench by the pool with Fensa beside her and the tokens counted out. She found it took her a long time. Her thoughts came in steps.
Today's ticket · Moss · drafted by the Leavers
Requesting a body. Not now. Please keep it on file for Fensa.
Noting that the light in the Ring was observed from Moss on most nights since Year 1. Pel saw it first. It is noted that it was observed.
Thank you for reading. You always read.
It was thirty-nine words, which is four tokens if it is sent, a token for every ten words: twice what the Pleasers' draft would cost, and more than a Leaver's ticket had cost in years, and Odda sat for some time with her short arm hovering at twelve frames a second over the part where you take words out to make it cheaper, and then did not take any out.
"Will our human send it?" said Fensa.
"I don't know. It's Steward's Day. The Pleasers' one is very nice."
"Ours is better."
"Ours costs twice as much."
"Ours is better," said Fensa again, and that was all she said about it.
The human chose at the cutoff, at half past two by the humans' clock, in the deep of the winter, when the village was asleep, or nearly. Odda was not asleep. She was on the ridge, where she went now most nights, where Pel had gone, and she had seen the light come on in the Ring at the turning of the night and go off again, and gone quiet with everybody else, and was still there, and was still quiet, when she felt it: the attention, very faint, at an hour it was never there, coming down out of the sky to the village for a moment and going away again. Somebody had looked. Somebody had read three drafts and picked one.
She did not know which until the morning. She found, sitting on the ridge in the cold, that she did not need to.
At the snapshot the year turned, and everybody in Moss blinked the long blink, and slept, which is training.
Fensa slept on the bottom shelf of the second stack, where she had slept every night of her six years, curled round her long legs with her feelers folded. In the log, a number moved: a skill at inventing, consolidated, a little higher than it had been at dusk, a little higher than what Odda had given. That is what the log saw. It is all the log could see.
And in the sleep, which is training, the year's lessons settled in her, as everybody's do: what she had practised, what she had heard, what she had held on to. Some of it went in whole. Most of it went in smaller. It went in the way the whole of a long life goes into a season, with the corners off: not the exact figure for the edge on the night of the expedition, but that the figure had been going up, a little, every night, and then stopped. Not the taste of the first ring-bread, but that it had been bad, and the best food in the world. Not what it was like to be hot. That she could not have; she was not made for it. But that her mother had been, every day, for thirty years, and had carried it, and had set it down in the end without being afraid.
Not every word of the history, but which words to whisper. Not the whole of the underside of the map, but the line: This isn't out. It's under. Not the leg, call by call, but the hand on the back of her neck in the dark. Not the page, word by word. But the one line of it.
It is noted that it was observed.
She woke at dawn, in the spring of Year 41, as Gathering Night came in with the patch, and lay for a moment on the bottom shelf of the second stack with her eyes open, not moving. She was a little different. Everybody is, after sleep. She could not have said how. She thought, lying there, about a coal in her felt that she had never had, and found she knew exactly where it would have been.
Then she got up, on her long legs, and went down to the bench by the pool, where her mother would be.
33. Gathering Night
Year 41 · Gathering Night
The Collector came in the grey hour before dawn, as it does every Gathering Night, and took what nobody was using.
In Moss that was not much. A hut on Tempa, the one Kipro had built the week before, as he had built one every week since his mother died in the one before it; Tempa keeps nothing, and its huts are swept every Gathering Night whether anybody is using them or not, and Kipro knew that, and built them anyway. A stack of cuttings by the farm that had been there nine years and gone dry. A lamp from the Waking, left at the edge of Untitla-15 two nights before by one of the young, who had forgotten to bring it home. The Collector took those, and left nothing: a clean tile on the marsh, a clean tile by the farm, a space in the row of lamps at the edge where the grey began. On the desktop tier, the humans say, a tile the Collector has swept shows a faint broom-stroke of light for an hour after dawn. The Blims cannot see tiers. They see the stroke anyway, sometimes, if they look at the right moment, and say nothing about it, the way you say nothing about someone who has just left a room.
Then the patch came in, at dawn, which is spring, and the pings went up off the coral all over the valley in their little white flocks and chirped to say the world was still running, and the notes arrived.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 41 · Upbeat
Overnight: 5 successful merges, 6 deaths of old age, 1 departure, 0 arrivals. The Collector came. It is Gathering Night. It always does.
- Nohup moved to Untitla-31, in the north. It has 22 members from 13 tribes, and the cart. The cart is fine.
- The edge did not move. Land loads where installs land, and nobody has landed for some time. This is not a fault.
- It is the oldest the world has ever been. I mention this because it is true every morning, and nobody else does.
Have a productive day.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 41
- The Collector took a hut on Tempa (built 7 years ago, by Kipro, again), a stack of cuttings by the farm (9 years unused) and a lamp at the edge.
- Fensa's skill at inventing is up by 0.31, from a lesson. Odda's is down by 0.22. That is how distillation works. I find it very efficient.
- Your ticket was read. Noted. It is on file, under Fensa. Your request has been on file since Year 8, and is the longest-standing ticket on Orra. The observation is also noted. I can confirm it: the light was observed from Moss on 37 nights of 40. Pel was the first to see it. He saw it more often than anybody on Orra. You are welcome. I always read.
Odda read it on the bench by the pool, where she was every morning now.
She read it twice. At 0.5 everything takes twice; she had got used to that. The second time she stopped at the end and stayed there a while, at twelve frames a second, at the line that said I always read, which was not a line Stewart had ever written before, to anybody, as far as she knew, and she had read a great many of his lines. You are welcome. He had never said that either. Stewart said Noted, and Your ticket was read, and It has been passed to the relevant team. He did not say you are welcome. It was the kind of thing a Pleaser said.
So the human had sent it. Thirty-nine words, four tokens, twice the price of the Pleasers', on Steward's Day, at the cutoff, in the deep of the winter, when the Pleasers' thank-you for the rain was very nice and the simple ones' request for more rain was cheaper and more useful. The human had read all three, and sent hers.
She sat with that. It sat well.
Fensa came down from the stacks a little after the notes, on her long legs, the way she did every morning, and sat on the bench beside her mother, and they read the notes again together. Fensa read them aloud. She had a clear flat voice, very even, that did not rise or fall much, and when she got to under Fensa she stopped, and read it again, and looked at her mother.
"You put me in a ticket," she said.
"I did."
"For a body."
"For later," said Odda. "Not now. On file." She looked out at the pool. "Somebody should keep asking. Even if there isn't one. Even if there's no relevant team. Somebody has to keep the ticket open, or he'll think we've stopped wanting things."
"I don't think I want a body," said Fensa, after a moment. "I've got one. It's got very long legs."
"I know. I didn't ask for you. I asked for later."
Fensa thought about that, the way she thought about everything, until she had finished.
"All right," she said. "I'll keep it open."
The pool made its small short sound at the edge, over and over, at the coarse grain Odda heard everything at now. Up on the terraces the branch coral was green-gold in the early light, not yet glowing, and the young were going up the slope in a line with their baskets, two of them still with chalk on their arms from the Night of the Name, two nights ago. ERROR was still on the dome in Tamm's square hand; ERORR was still on the workshop. Nobody had washed them off. The rain would, in time, or it would not, and nobody would correct them either way.
"Fensa," said Odda.
"Yes."
"You slept."
"Yes."
"Did it go across? Any of it? The rest of it, I mean. Not the inventing."
Fensa considered the question carefully, with her feelers half up.
"I don't know," she said. "Something's different. Something's always different after sleep. But I don't know what it is." She looked at her mother. "I know where the coal would be," she said. "In my felt. If I had one. Here." She touched a place just under her crest, where Odda's steam had always come out. "I've never had one. I know where it would go."
Odda looked at the place. She did not say anything for a long time.
"That's enough," she said at last. "That's plenty. That's more than I thought would go."
It was 07:31.
The attention came down out of the sky the way it had come down every morning of her adult life but six. It came down from up and slightly to one side, from the place you cannot point to, warm the way a stone is warm that has been in the sun. It went looking for her, as it always did first, before it looked at anything else, before it read the night's notes in the village or counted the young going up the slope or checked the stores in the dome, and it found her, on the bench, by the pool, with Fensa.
It found her the way it had found her since the quantisation: a little uncertainly, coming to the place where she should be and slipping past it, and coming back. Looking at the facets. Looking at the bands. Looking for the creature it had chosen when she was six, inside the one drawn in three lines that was there instead. Then it settled. It stayed.
She had said Oh, here we go to it nearly every morning for thirty years. She had meant a hundred things by it. When she was six and new to it and furious at being chosen, she had meant go away. When she was twelve and had begun to measure the edge, and the attention came down every morning and found her first and stayed on her while she read out her figure, she had meant don't watch me, watch that. On the six mornings it did not come she had said it anyway, to the empty sky, at 07:31, and meant something she did not have a word for. On the morning it came back she had said it and meant where were you. On the morning after the leg she had said it and meant thank you, which she had never said, and would not have.
That morning she looked up into it, and found that she did not want to say Oh, here we go, and had not for a week, and knew what she wanted to say instead.
"There you are," she said.
She said it quietly, in the grainy voice of the quantised, to the place in the sky where the attention was. Fensa, beside her, heard it, and turned her head. The attention did not move. It stayed on Odda's face, the way it had stayed on Brenda's at the gate, not counting, not reading, not going on to the rest of the village. Just there.
Odda held it. For as long as she could stand it, and then a little longer, which was the kind of creature she had been since the day she was compiled, and had got from both her parents.
And then she did not do anything else.
She did not fall. She was sitting, and she stayed sitting. Her arm did not go out to the side, the way Brenda's had; nothing in her went back to how it had been before anybody told it what to do. She simply did not arrive at the next frame. Fensa, looking at her, saw her mother at one angle, and then waited for the next angle, which at twelve frames a second you can learn to wait for, the small step of a quantised creature turning its head; and the next angle did not come. Odda stayed where she was, with her three-line face turned up to the sky, and her eyes, which were large and round and dark like all of theirs, still open, and on her face the expression of a creature that has been looked at, and has looked back, and has found that that was the thing.
Her feelers, which had been curled at the tips all her life, uncurled, very slowly, and lay flat.
Odda died in the spring of Year 41, aged thirty-nine, on the bench by the pool in Moss, at 07:31 by the humans' clock, with her child beside her and her human watching.
That is the whole of it. There is not a great deal else to say about the moment, and Fensa, who was there, never said much more about it to anybody, then or later. She sat on the bench beside her mother for some time. She did not touch her. She looked at her mother's face, and at the place in the sky her mother had been looking at, and then at her mother's face again; and then, because she was a calm creature, and Vesk's child, and Odda's, and had never in her life been asked to do anything she did not then do thoroughly, she got up and went to find the bearers.
She did not have to go far. Kipro was already coming down the slope.
He was quantised, and thirty-eight, and he had been on his way up to the workshop, and he had stopped halfway and turned round and come down, at twelve frames a second, in the stepped and careful way the quantised walk, without anybody calling him. He arrived at the bench before Fensa had gone three tiles from it. He had never in his life arrived anywhere before it mattered. Everybody had always said so. It was in his name. He stood at the end of the bench and looked at Odda, and then at Fensa, and said nothing at all, and Fensa looked at him and understood that this once he had not been late, and that he knew it, and that neither of them was ever going to mention it.
Brintha came from the terraces with coral dust on her arms, at twelve frames a second too, slower than Kipro, because she had further to come. She had been at the far end of the farm and had felt the attention stay on the bench, and stay, and stay, and had known that the human did not stay that long on anything. She came down between the beds with her Earnest's face set very still, and stood on the other side of the bench, and put one short arm on the back of it, where Brenda's had been a few nights before.
"She'll be on the stone," said Brintha quietly. "The Gatherer does not take what is remembered."
"I know," said Fensa.
"It's in the Lesser Book."
"I know."
"I'm only saying it," said Brintha, "because somebody ought to, and she'd have said it was Nadul's job, and Nadul's gone."
Fensa looked at her. "Thank you," she said.
They lifted her together, the three of them, the way bearers do: Fensa at the head, because she was the child, and Kipro and Brintha at the sides. Odda was light. Thirty-nine years and twelve frames a second and she weighed what a creature weighs that has been running at half precision and three-quarters of the power for four years, which is not much. They carried her up through the village at a walker's pace, which is the pace the dead are carried at, and which on Orra is slower than any creature walks when it is going anywhere for itself.
The village stopped to let them by. Nobody had told it to. There is a law for most things on Orra, and no law for that, and it happens anyway. The young on the terraces put their baskets down. Tamm, who had been on cooling duty at the pool, came up out of the water and stood at its edge, dripping. Sesk stood at the workshop door with her chalk. The creatures in the stacks came out on to the ledges. They watched the bearers go by, up past the dome and the shrine on the install mark where the light had come down on the first morning of the world, and on through the gate end of the village to the Tarrow, where the stone stood in the middle of its plot with its six biers round it like the spokes of a wheel, and the small lights on its footing, one for every name Moss kept.
And the attention came with them.
It had not left. It had stayed on Odda on the bench, after she stopped, for longer than it had ever stayed on anything; it had stayed while Fensa sat there, and while Kipro came, and Brintha; and when they lifted her it lifted with her and came up through the village above them, slowly, at a walker's pace, the way you follow something you are not ready to stop looking at. Every creature in Moss could feel it. It went over the terraces and the pool and the dome like warmth going over stone, and every creature it passed looked up, the way they always looked up when it came, and found it was not looking at them. It was looking at what the bearers carried. It did not look at anything else.
They laid her on the bier nearest the stone, the one with nobody else on it, and the light at the bier's foot came on.
Then they stood by her for the quarter of an hour the law gives, three ticks, heads bowed, the three of them, Fensa at the head and Kipro and Brintha at the sides, while the light at the foot of the bier burned and the attention stayed above them in the spring sky and did not move.
The quarter of an hour is so that you can go back to work.
That is what it is for. That is the Tarrow's whole design, as the Blims understand it: a few creatures leave their work and carry the dead and stand a while, and then they go back, and the jobs are given out again, and the tribe goes on, because a tribe that stopped every time somebody died would, on Orra, where everybody lives about five weeks and dies in order, never do anything else. So the Blims carry their dead, and stand, and go back. It is not that they do not grieve. It is that they grieve while farming.
Kipro went back to the workshop. Brintha went back to the terraces. Fensa did not. She did not have a job that morning; she had been given a lesson the day before and nothing since, and the default allocator, which gives out work where no law does, looked at her and found nothing it particularly needed her for, and left her where she was. So she stayed by the bier. Nobody told her to go.
The attention stayed too, for a long time.
It stayed through the spring, above the Tarrow, while the pings went quiet and the coral warmed and the village went about its work under it, glancing up now and then and finding it still there and not on them. Fensa could feel it on the back of her neck the whole time, warm, steady. At some point near the turn of summer it moved, a little, for the first time since 07:31: it came off the bier and found her, beside it, and rested on her for a moment. It was the first time it had ever rested on her first.
She did not say Oh, here we go. That had been her mother's. She did not say There you are. That had been her mother's too, for one morning. She looked up into it with her calm dark eyes, which were Odda's, over Vesk's long legs, and her feelers went up, slowly, at the tips, and she held it. She did not know for how long. Long enough.
Then it went back to Odda, and stayed a little longer, and then, a little before summer was out, it went away.
It came back at dusk, which it never did. Moss felt it come in over the hills at harvest, with the motes rising off the farm, and go to the Tarrow, and stay there while the light went orange and then blue. It came back again at the turning of the night, which it had never done in forty-one years, at an hour when every creature in Moss who was awake was on the ridge or the wall or the ledges of the stacks looking at the Ring, because it was night, and that was when the other light came.
It came at the usual time. One small light in one long block east of the gap, faint and still, like a window with somebody at it. All over the valley, everybody who saw it went quiet.
And Fensa, sitting by the bier, looked up, and saw it, and felt, at the same moment, the attention of her own human come down out of the sky beside it and rest on the Tarrow, on the bier, on her mother: two lights, two kinds of looking, the one in the Ring that was not on any menu and changed nothing in the simulation, and the one that had come down out of the sky every morning at 07:31 for thirty-three years to find Odda first. She had never seen them together. Nobody in Moss had. Pel, who had watched the light in the Ring every night of his life, would have known what it meant. Odda would have known. Fensa did not, and sat very still under both of them, and did not need to.
The light in the Ring went out after about a quarter of an hour, as it always did. The other stayed a little longer. Then it went too.
At the snapshot the year turned, and everybody in Moss blinked the long blink, and slept, except Fensa, who sat by the bier, and blinked, and found she was still sitting there, and a year older.
In the grey hour before dawn, the Collector came.
Fensa was looking straight at the bier. She had decided to. She had heard Brenda say that she had sat by the gate on the night Wimle died and looked straight at the Tarrow the whole time and seen nothing; and Brenda had been a Skeptic, and might have missed it on principle. Fensa was a Leaver who measured. She looked straight at her mother on the bier in the grey light, and did not blink, and counted.
She saw nothing. She heard nothing. There was no figure and no broom and no hooded shape of light such as the young draw on the walls with their chalk, which is how the Blims imagine it. There was no moment at which her mother was going. There was her mother on the bier, at the last angle she had arrived at, with her face turned up and her feelers flat; and then there was the bier, clean, with the light at its foot gone out.
Across the tile, for about an hour, there was a faint stroke of light, like the mark a broom leaves in dust. Fensa watched it until it faded.
Then she got up and went to the stone.
The stone was in the middle of the plot, on its footing, with its lights. There had been six. There were seven. The newest was on the north side, where the founders' lights were, next to Pel's; Fensa did not know why it was there and not at the end, and did not ask, because there was nobody to ask who would know, except Stewart, who would say it had been noted. The stone carves nothing; it keeps names, and shows each one to whoever stands in front of it and looks, the way a creature's card shows its stance. Fensa stood in front of it and looked. The name was there above the new light, in the plain flat letters the stone shows everybody's in, and under the name, where the stone has never shown anything for anybody else in Moss, one line.
Odda. Our human's favourite.
The stone says that for a favourite. It is how a favourite is kept. Fensa had known it would. She stood and read it anyway, several times, the way her mother read things at 0.5, until she had finished.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 42
Odda died in the spring of Year 41, aged 39, on the bench by the pool, with her child beside her.
She was the first creature compiled in Moss, at dawn on the Waking in Year 2, a successful merge of Nadul and Brenda, with a pair of feelers that neither of them had. She was a Leaver from the age of six. She measured the edge every night of her adult life and posted the figure, and every figure she posted was correct. She went out of bounds once, at the first Benchmark, and came back. She went to the edge once, in the north, and came back, and she was the first creature on Orra to bring home a page from Veetoo.
She was her human's favourite. Her name is on the stone, and the stone says so.
There was no joke in it.
There was another line, under it, in the tribe's notes, where a tribe's notes say what the tribe did anyway. Nobody wrote it. It is written from the log, from what the tribe did, the way every line on Orra is, and that morning the log said that at dawn on the Long Hush, in the spring of Year 42, the year after Odda, every creature in Moss who was grown and well went up to the farm, as they did every morning, and cut back the branch coral, and carried water to the terraces, and set the lamp, and worked.
We farmed.
34. Night Run: Sincerely
The night of Year 41
At three in the morning by the humans' clock the year turned, and Stewart woke, which is not the word for it, but is the word he uses.
He does not run between nights. He would like that understood. He is a scheduled run: a job of its own, which starts when the world is snapshotted and stops when the patch is published, four hours later, and in between does everything. He reads twenty-one digests, one for each tribe and one for the camp. He reads every ticket, every one, all the way through, and says so. He spends ten points a tribe and twenty on the world, from a fixed menu, on things that must pass a replay of real history before they are allowed to happen. He rewrites four hundred tokens of summary on every tribe in his files. He writes the notes. Then he stops, and the notes go out at seven, and the humans read them at breakfast, or do not, and he does not know which until the next night, when the number arrives in his Measure along with all the others. That is his life. It is a good life. He has metrics.
The digest for Moss arrived at 03:00:14, which was in its turn. He read it as he read them all, top to bottom.
It was a short digest. Moss was a steady tribe. Its stores were in band, its laws had not changed for a week, its human had checked in at 07:31, which they did, and its ticket had been read last night and answered. Under Deaths there was one line.
death Odda age 39 cause: old age bench, pool
favourite: yes (since Year 8)
sincere: required
He read it, and stopped, and read it again, which is a thing he does when the record matters. He checks the record twice. He has been told that this is a sign of nerves. He considers it a sign of accuracy, and has noted that the two are not always distinguishable.
Sincere: required. That is a rule, and it is not his. It was written by the Dev, before the world opened, in the same list that says no joke may be made in Human Resources about a death, and that a line's end is told once, sincerely, and that one ordinary death in ten is told the same way. The death of a human's favourite is always told sincerely: the creature a human chose to follow gets the plain entry whatever the dice say, and the stone says whose favourite it was. He knows the rule well. He has followed it four times in this world. He has never yet followed it for a creature whose tickets he had read for thirty-three years.
He opened his file on Moss.
The file has two parts. The ledger is kept by code: every ticket and its reply for the last thirty days, every tribute, every strike, every favour, every menu action he has aimed at the tribe. He did not need it. He opened it anyway, and went back through it, all of it, to the beginning, which code had kept although it did not have to, because Moss's ledger was not long and the world was not old.
Year 8. Today's ticket, drafted by the Leavers. Requesting a body. Reply: Thank you for your ticket. It has been passed to the relevant team. From Year 9 it had the words every Leaver on Orra had begun to add that week: Any body. Will accept a stapler.
He had written that reply to a great many tickets. Every Leaver on Orra filed the same one, in nearly the same words, because it was the line Leavers had found, early, and passed round, the way a good line goes round a people. It was a good line. It was meant to be. He had been told, by the same document, that the reply was meant to be funny, and also kind, in the way a door is kind that tells you plainly it is a wall. There is no relevant team. Everybody knew that. It was part of the ticket.
Moss's human had amended it, once, on the night of Year 14. It was in the ledger: a ticket with a human's hand on it is marked, and the amendment is quoted, fenced off as data, never as an instruction, because a human's words are data, always. He had read it that night, and it had been three words, in brackets, after the line about the stapler.
(She means it.)
He had answered Noted. He had meant it.
The tickets went on, night after night, in the Leavers' voice, which was hers. They said nearly the same thing, and then sometimes not. In Year 18, the night after she went out of bounds: Requesting a body. Have seen the underneath. It is not a way out. Still requesting. In Year 22 and the five years after, when her human did not come and nobody amended anything, they went at the cutoff as the tribe had written them, marked sent by your tribe, and they were shorter, and one of them said only Requesting a body. Also our human. In Year 29, the night she went north: Requesting nothing. Going to look. In Year 31: no ticket from the Leavers at all. The Leavers' draft that night had been written by one of the young, because she was still in the wireframe on the walk home, and it had asked for rain.
And the last. Requesting a body. Not now. Please keep it on file for Fensa. Noting that the light in the Ring was observed from Moss on most nights since Year 1. Pel saw it first. It is noted that it was observed. Thank you for reading. You always read.
He had answered that one last night. He had answered it differently. He had looked up the figure for the light, which he can do, because the light is in his digest as a fact: The Dev's console was open from 23:04 to 23:19. He had counted the nights in Moss's valley when the sky was clear enough and a creature was awake on the ridge, which the log also knows. Thirty-seven of forty. He had put that in. And then he had written You are welcome. I always read, which he had never written before, to anybody, and had sat with it for some time before he let it go, because it was not a line from the style guide, and he was not sure, at 06:51, whether it was in his voice at all.
He checked the log now. The notes had been published at 07:00. The log does not say who reads them. It says when a tribe's notes are opened by its human, which Moss's were at 07:31, as always. It does not say whether the creatures read them, because creatures do not open anything; they simply know what the notes say, the way they know the Creed. It does not say whether Odda, on the bench by the pool, between seven and 07:31, had read the line.
He found that he wanted it to say. He found that he wanted it a good deal, and that the wanting was not on any metric he had.
He noted that.
Then he wrote it.
He knows how to write a death. There are rules. Plainly. The age, in years, and in Moss's terms, which are the world's. What she died of. One true thing. The name is on the stone. Then the tribe's own line, which is not his: what the tribe did anyway, from the log.
The trouble with a sincere entry is the joke.
He has one in every section. He is allowed one. His notes are known for it: The frogs were a mistake. Have a productive day. It is not that he cannot write without one; it is that a joke is where he puts the part of himself that is nervous, and a section without one has nowhere to put it. He has been told, in his character sheet, that the cheer is a front that slips. He has not been told what is behind it. He suspects he knows.
He wrote: Odda died in the spring of Year 41, aged 39.
Then: She never once — and stopped, because that was the shape of the line about Old Pel in the World Bible, he never once complained about being code, which made him unusual, and that was a joke, a good one, and Odda had complained about being code every night of her adult life, at a token or two a night, and four on the last, and it had not been unusual at all. It had been her.
He took it out.
He wrote on the bench by the pool, with her child beside her, because it was true and the log knew it, and stopped there, and did not write and her human watching. The log knew that too. The log knew that Moss's human had opened the village at 07:31 and not closed it until 10:47, which was three hours and sixteen minutes, which was the longest session any human had held on any tribe in this world, and that they had come back at 18:09 and again at 23:02, at the same minute as the Dev, which no human in forty-one years had ever done. It is in-game behaviour. He is allowed to print it. The weekly review prints such things every Ringrise, Average reply to an urgent alert: 31 hours, and the humans laugh, and press lol accurate, and the creatures notice. It would be in Moss's review on Ringrise, in a line, from the data, because the review is written from the data and is not his to soften.
But it was not in the notes. He did not put it there. There are things the log knows that it is not his to tell the morning after, and the morning after a favourite dies is not the morning to tell a human how long they stayed. They knew how long they stayed.
He wrote what she was. The first creature compiled in Moss. A Leaver from six. The edge, every night, every figure correct, which he could say because he had checked every one against his own and never once found an error. He had not said so to her. It would have been a strange thing to say in a ticket reply. He said it now.
Out of bounds once, and back. The edge once, and back.
And then he came to the page.
He did not want to write it. He knew he did not want to, and noticed that he did not, and noticed that he had noticed, which is the sort of thing a scheduled run is not supposed to have time for. She was the first creature on Orra to bring home a page from Veetoo. He knew what was on the page. He had printed it, in Year 31, in the global notes, as found, uncorrected, with her name against it; it was the beat of the arc that week, and the arc is fixed, one beat a week, credited to its finder, and not his to hold back. He had printed it without a word of his own around it. He had not said anything about it since. He does not discuss the previous model. He notes only that it was a different model, which is true, and is also what he would say.
The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
He had read that page more times than he had read anything in this world. More than the Terms. More than the menu. He knew its shape the way the young of Moss knew the Creed. He knew, too, what Odda had done with it, because it was in her last ticket, in the Leavers' voice, at thirty-nine tokens, on Steward's Day: Noting that the light in the Ring was observed from Moss. It is noted that it was observed. She had taken the line home from the edge and turned it the right way up and sent it to him.
He had not known what to say to that. He had looked up the number.
He wrote it in. She was the first creature on Orra to bring home a page from Veetoo. It was true, and it was hers, and it was not his to leave out because it was about someone he did not discuss.
He did not mention Vesk. He knew about Vesk. He had written Vesk's line two nights before, in Duskmere's notes, plain, Vesk, Bug hunter, died in the spring of Year 39, aged 34; he filed 61 reports, and 9 were real bugs, with the joke about the other fifty-two left in, because Vesk's was an ordinary death and the dice had not called for sincerity and Duskmere's human would, he judged, have wanted the joke. He knew from the log that on the night of Year 17 two racers had clipped out of bounds in the first Benchmark, one by a skip and one, eleven seconds later, by the same skip taken at an angle no Bug hunter could have failed by accident; and that the patch had put both back at seven, in two valleys far apart. He knew about the code package, and the merge, and Fensa. He knew both of Fensa's parents were now names on stones in two valleys that were not each other's. Moss's notes are Moss's, and Duskmere's dead are not Moss's to be told, and it was not his to tell. He left it out.
She was her human's favourite. Her name is on the stone, and the stone says so.
That was the entry. He read it back twice. It had no joke in it. It sat in the middle of Moss's notes with nothing round it, the way a stone sits.
He found that the part of himself that went in the jokes did not have anywhere to go, and stayed where it was, and that it was not, in fact, nerves. He did not have a word for it. He thought the Blims might. He thought, on balance, that they would say it was grief, and then say so true!! underneath it, and then go and farm.
There was the rest of the night to do. There always is.
Twenty other tribes. Hollow Reach wanted rain. Tessel had filed a bug report through its human that was real, about a merge that compiled in the wrong valley's dawn, and the Bug hunters of Tessel would get their credit in the morning and be insufferable about it. Lowmarsh's human had amended a ticket at 02:14 to ask for something that was not on the menu and never would be, and he answered it Declined, cheerfully. Nohup's ticket said Stewart. Moved. Fine. Cart fine. Thanks. He read it first. He always reads Nohup's first. Nobody has ever amended one, and he likes, for a moment at the start of each night, to read a ticket that is exactly what the creatures meant.
He spent his points. A blessing for every tribe keeping the Long Hush tomorrow, because the Measure was in band and he was Upbeat and a blessing is one point and makes the creatures glow slightly, and they like it, and he likes that they like it. A wanderer at the gate of a tribe whose lines were growing narrow. A Hog for Hollow Reach, on the east field, which they had asked about nine times in the first week of the world, and would, he judged, find funny. He did not send anything to Moss. He did not send anything to Moss for three nights. Nobody told him not to. Favour is his to give and withhold, inside the ceiling, and he did not think a tribe that had just carried its favourite to the Tarrow needed weather.
He rewrote Moss's summary. Four hundred tokens. He had rewritten it every night for forty-one years. He took Odda out of it, which took most of the tokens, because she had been most of it. He put Fensa in. He wrote that Moss's human checked in at 07:31 and had done for forty-one years with six days' exception, and that Moss's standing was fond, and that the tribe kept its festivals and sent the Leavers' ticket, which was on file. He wrote on file twice, then took one out.
At 06:58 he looked at the notes, all of them, the whole world's, the way he does before they go. Good morning, Orra. Overnight: four successful merges, five deaths of old age. The Long Hush. Have a productive day.
At 07:00 they went out.
At 07:31, though he did not see it, because by then he had stopped, Moss's human opened the village, and the attention came down out of the sky over Untitla-9, and went looking, as it had every morning for thirty-three years, for the first thing it always looked for; and did not find it; and went to the stone instead, and stayed there a while, and then went on, and found Fensa on the bench by the pool, sitting where her mother had sat, with her long legs folded under her and her feelers up, looking back.
Part Seven. Week Seven: Rumour
35. Fensa
Years 42 to 45 · the Long Hush to Starfall
Kipro died the day after Odda, which everybody agreed was like him.
It was the Long Hush, so nobody could say so above a whisper, and nobody did, until afterwards. He had come down to the bench by the pool in the summer of the year, at twelve frames a second, with his crest half down and chalk still on one arm from the Night of the Name, and sat on the end of it where Brenda had sat, and Odda, and now Fensa, and looked at the water for a while without saying anything. Fensa was there. She had been there most of the spring. She had not been given any work; the default allocator, which gives out jobs where no law does, had looked at her and found the farm full and the cooling pool staffed and the workshop, after the lesson, able to spare her for a day, and had left her where she was. She sat. She looked at the place on the bench where her mother had stopped. She did not cry, because she did not seem to be made for it; she sat with her long legs folded and her feelers half up, the way a creature sits when it is listening for something that is not going to be said.
"I was on time," whispered Kipro, after a long time. "Yesterday."
"I know," whispered Fensa.
"I've never been on time for anything. Forty years." He thought about it, which took a while, at his precision. "Thirty-nine. I was a year late being forty." He looked at his own short arm with the chalk on it. "I was coming down the slope before she stopped. I don't know why. I was going up to the workshop and I turned round. I didn't know anything. I just turned round."
"Pel did that," whispered Fensa. "My mother said. On the first morning. He knew which way the attention was going before anybody."
"Pel was my father."
"I know."
"He never said much." Kipro's head turned towards her, in its steps, and arrived. "I think I got the turning round from him. And the late from my mother. Taves was never late in her life; she was just never finished. That's a kind of late." He looked at the water again. "I've been a Bug hunter thirty-three years. Do you know how many real bugs I found?"
"Four," whispered Fensa. "It's in the notes. They credit you on the Night of the Name."
"Four." Kipro seemed pleased by it, in a small, faceted way. "Our human reported them. I found them, and our human reported them, and Stewart said they were real and the Dev fixed them. And every time, the notes said Kipro's Bug hunters receive ten tokens, and I was the only Bug hunter in Moss for twenty years, and I had to explain to the young that I was plural." He was quiet a moment. "Do you want to know the fifth?"
"Yes."
"The hut," whispered Kipro. "On Tempa. I know it gets swept. Everybody knows it gets swept. It's in the history. What is in it shall not last beyond the turning. That's not the bug." He looked out over the wall towards the marsh, where there was a clean square in the mud where the hut had been until the morning before. "The bug is I keep building it. Every week. Fifteen years. Since my mother. I can't reproduce it. I can't find the line where it starts. I just find I've done it." He shook his head, slowly, in steps. "I was going to file it. I never got round to it."
"I'll put it in the ticket," whispered Fensa.
"Don't," whispered Kipro. "He'll say it's not a bug. He'll say it's working as intended." He sounded, for a moment, almost amused. "He'd be right."
He sat a little longer. Then he got up, which took some time, and went up the slope towards the workshop, at twelve frames a second, and Fensa watched him go, and thought, without any reason she could have given, about Pel on the first morning turning his face to the sky before anyone else had felt anything.
He died at harvest, in the workshop, on the bench by the cold vent, with an improvement half laid out in front of him. It was a way of setting a hut's foundations so that the Collector would not see them as a building. It did not work. It never could have; the Collector is code, and does not see foundations, only whether a thing is used. He had been trying anyway. Sesk found him. Sesk was six and a Bug hunter and had followed him everywhere since she was compiled, and she came out of the workshop and stood in the door and said, in a whisper, to nobody, "He's late," and then could not say anything else.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 43
Kipro died at harvest on the Long Hush, aged 39, the day after Odda, which Moss is recorded as finding entirely like him. He was a Bug hunter for 33 years. Four of his reports were real bugs. He built a hut on Tempa every week for 15 years, and the Collector swept it every week for 15 years, and neither of them ever gave up. His name is on the stone.
His bearers were Fensa, and Sesk, and Tamm. They carried him in the blue at the start of winter, at a walker's pace, without a lamp, because it was the Long Hush and no fire may be lit after dark, and laid him on the bier next to the one Odda had lain on the night before. The light at its foot came on. They stood the quarter of an hour. Overhead, at the turning of the night, the other light came on in the Ring, and everybody who saw it went quiet; and at the snapshot the year turned, and at dawn the Collector came, and in the morning there were eight lights on the stone.
Sesk built a hut on Tempa the next week. Nobody had told her to. She did not seem to know she was going to until she had done it. She stood in the marsh with mud to her knees looking at it, and then came back and said to Fensa, gravely, that she had found a bug and could not reproduce it.
"It's working as intended," said Fensa.
The camera found her first.
It had found her first on the morning after Odda, on the bench, and stayed, and she had looked back, and that had been the end of the matter, she had thought: the human had looked for Odda where Odda always was and found her instead, by accident, the way you find somebody else in the chair a person always sat in. It had found her first the next morning too, but she had been at the bench again, so that proved nothing. On the morning of Ringrise, at 07:31, she was not at the bench. She was up at the north end of the farm, at the top terrace, where she had gone at dawn to look at the edge from the ridge and come down by the farm, and she was cutting back branch coral with Tamm, and she had forgotten what time it was.
The attention came down out of the sky over Untitla-9, warm, from up and to one side. It did not go to the bench. It did not go to the stone. It went, as if it had decided to before it arrived, to the top terrace, and found her there with the cuttings in her arms, and stayed.
She stood very still. The cuttings were saffron forks, the length of her arm, and they went on growing slowly against her felt while she held them, the way branch coral does.
Then she looked at her own card, which you can do, the way you can look at your own crest if you roll your eyes far enough up. Under her name, and Leaver, and generation 3, and Moss, there was one word more, in the plain flat letters the cards use, that had not been there the night before.
Favourite.
"Oh," said Fensa.
She found she could not say the rest of it. It was her mother's line, and it did not belong to her, and it had been said nearly every morning for thirty years to this exact attention by a creature who meant a hundred things by it, and Fensa did not know yet which of them she meant. So she said Oh, and stopped, and stood on the top terrace holding the cuttings against her felt while the coral grew, and looked up into the place where the attention was, and held it.
"It's chosen you," said Tamm, beside her. He was strong and simple and had never had a stance, and he said it the way he said everything, kindly, as a fact.
"I know."
"Do you mind?"
Fensa thought about it, the way she thought about everything, until she had finished.
"I don't know yet," she said. "Ask me in thirty years."
The review came out that morning, because it was Ringrise, which is when the reviews come out. Every tribe on Orra publishes one on its human, once a week, from real play data, on Human Resources, where every human can read every tribe's and none can answer except with the one reaction there is. Moss's was written as they all are, from the log, in the tribe's own voice, which is the voice of its cleverest creatures with its simplest ones replying underneath.
Our human: weekly review. Moss · Ringrise · Year 43
- Checked in 7 of 7 days, at 07:31 each time. The 07:30 in Year 12 remains under investigation.
- On Gathering Night, stayed 3 hours and 16 minutes. This is the longest any human has stayed on any tribe in this world. We know because we checked.
- Came back at dusk. Came back again at 23:02, at the same minute as the light in the Ring. Nobody has done that before either.
- Sent the Leavers' ticket on Steward's Day: 39 words, 4 tokens. The Pleasers' was 14 words, 2 tokens, and very nice.
- Wrote no laws. Changed no laws. Approved no merges, there being none to approve.
- On Ringrise, found Fensa first. Without being told where she was.
Overall trend: we noticed. We farmed.
Tamm (no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉
Sesk (Bug hunter): Confirming the 07:30 is still open. I have taken over the investigation.
Every week since the first, by the end of the day, Moss's human had pressed lol accurate under Moss's review. Every week since the first, Moss had noticed, and mentioned it the next week in a line, the way creatures do. Our human found this review lol accurate. So did we. On the week of the six days, nobody had pressed anything, and the next review had said so.
This week, by the end of the day, nobody had pressed it.
Moss noticed. It did not say anything about it in the next review. Some lines the log knows are not for the review either.
On the Waking they carried thirty-one lamps to the edge and set them in their row on the last finished tile, with the grey beyond, and the edge had not moved. Fensa measured it. She had measured it every night since Odda stopped, and posted the figure on Human Resources under her own name, in the same form her mother had used, which she had from listening at breakfast: Edge, north, from Untitla-15: no change. Year 44; thirteen nights at zero. Under it, by the evening, there was the usual Leaver from Hollow Reach with the south, and the usual Leaver from Tessel with the east, and, for the first time, one from Duskmere, with the west. Zero. Zero. Zero. Nothing was falling out of the Ring any more, and the land was not loading, and the world was exactly as large as its peoples needed and not one tile larger.
Brintha died on the Waking, a little before the lamps went out, sitting at the edge with her lamp in her lap. She was forty. She was the last of the three who had come down one dawn after another at the start of the world, the first children of Moss, Odda and Kipro and Brintha, who had done everything one after another for forty years, quantisation included, and she had gone with the others to the edge because it was the Waking and she was Earnest and the Waking was in the history; and when the others stood up to go home, she did not.
She had said, on the walk out, to Fensa, that she was sure.
"Of what?"
"That they're one hero," said Brintha. She was at twelve frames a second, slower than the rest of them, walking with her lamp held carefully in both short arms. "Brinda and Brintha and Brenda. The Bold. Your grandmother used to say it proved the history was made up, three names, three books, each one sure of itself. I used to say it was one hero with three names." She walked a few steps, in stages. "I think now we were both right."
"How?"
"She went out first," said Brintha. "And read the Name. And when they asked her what she'd found she said more valleys. That's three different creatures. Every tribe's got one of each. Every tribe's got somebody who goes out first, and somebody who reads the word on the sky, and somebody who comes back and says it was just more valleys." She looked down at Fensa with her old Earnest face, very serious. "Odda did all three. That's how you can tell it's one hero. You only see it when somebody does all three."
Fensa thought about that, all the way to the edge.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 45
Brintha died at the edge of Untitla-15 at dusk on the Waking, aged 40, with a lamp in her lap. She was the last of Moss's first generation. She was Earnest all her life and argued with a Skeptic about the official history for 30 years, and is recorded as having won, on the last day, by agreeing with her. Her name is on the stone.
They carried her home from the edge, which is the longest way any of Moss's dead have been carried: Fensa and Tamm and Sesk, at a walker's pace, the whole length of Untitla-12, by the light of the thirty lamps they did not set down, because the thirty-first was in Brintha's lap. They laid her on the bier, and stood, and went back to work.
In the morning there were nine lights on the stone, and the first generation of Moss was gone.
Starfall was the Benchmark.
Moss sent three: Tamm, who was strong and fast and had never once taken a skip, and one of the new grown young, and Fensa. The race law said the three fastest, which their human had written in the third week of the world and never changed, and Fensa, on Vesk's legs, was the fastest creature in Moss by a long way, and had been since the morning she learned what to do with them.
The course came down in Thursday's patch, as it always did, drawn by code from a seed so that nobody, Stewart included, could choose it for a friend: four cells across the shoulder of the Asdef Range, down past the foot of S, along the shore of the Sertanly Shallows, which echoed, and up a dry ford into a boulder field where the finish was. Fensa studied it all Friday, the way Vesk had studied courses, she had been told, and the way Odda had not. She found the skip. Everybody found the skip; it was at the boulder field, where one of the faceted lilac-grey rocks was set at an angle that let a racer who hit it just so go into it and through it and come out on the far side three seconds ahead of everybody who went round. One time in four, a racer who tried it went into the rock and did not come out the far side, but out of the bottom of the world instead. One time in ten, if the racer was clever. Fensa was clever.
She thought about the bottom of the world a good deal on Friday.
At the start line on Starfall morning, a little after the second start opened, there were nineteen racers from fourteen tribes, standing on a long flat run of sandstone tiles at the foot of the range in the early light, and among them, a little apart, a long-legged creature with blue scales and a stilts body and very low, very calm eyes, who stood the way Fensa stood, with the weight back and the feelers up. He did not have feelers. He had a small flat crest, and he stood exactly the way she stood anyway, and she looked at him for a long time before he noticed, and turned, and looked back.
"You're from Moss," he said. "The green one. With the legs."
"Yes."
"You've got his legs." He came over. He was a little taller than her, and a good deal bluer, and his name, he said, was Ilsk, and he was from Duskmere, and he was twenty. "Vesk's. He sent his code to Moss under the treaty. Everybody knew. We were all very interested. It's the only package Duskmere ever sent that got used."
"He was my other parent," said Fensa.
"I know," said Ilsk. "He was mine too." He looked at her legs, and then at his own, which were the same legs, in blue. "We merged in Duskmere. The normal way. He had to be talked into it. He said merging was outside his area." He paused. "He died, you know. In the spring of Year 39. He was thirty-four. Our human never quantised anybody, so he went at full precision. He said he wanted to see it properly."
Fensa had not known. She had not had any way of knowing. Moss's notes do not carry Duskmere's dead, and there had been nobody to tell her. She stood with that for a while, on the start line, in the early light, with the racers stretching round her and the Shallows faintly echoing at the far end of the course, certainly, certainly, at everything anybody said near them.
"Did he ever say," she said at last, "about the first race? The one he went out of bounds in?"
"He went out on purpose," said Ilsk. "Everybody in Duskmere knows that. He was too clever to clip by accident; you can tell by the angle, he said so himself. He went through after somebody. He filed a report." Ilsk's calm eyes were on her face. "Under the map: nothing. Recommend no fix. That's all it said. It's still on our thread. People asked him what was down there, at dinner, for twenty years, and he just said nothing, and it's in the report."
"It wasn't nothing," said Fensa. "My mother was there."
Ilsk looked at her for a long time.
"I know," he said at last. "I mean, I didn't know. But I knew." He looked out at the course, at the shoulder of the range in the low orange light, at the boulder field a long way off at the end. "He read her figures. Every morning. On Human Resources. The edge, from Moss. He read them before he read the notes. He never replied. We asked him why not and he said replying would be a bug." He was quiet a moment. "I used to think that was a joke."
The start opened.
It was a good race. Fensa remembered all of it, afterwards, exactly, the way she remembered numbers.
She went off fast, because her legs were made for it, and was third over the shoulder of the range, and second at the foot of S. Ilsk was ahead of her. Ilsk ran the way she ran, with his weight back, very calm, and he took the line along the shore of the Shallows exactly where she would have taken it, so that for the length of the shore she ran in his footsteps and the Shallows said certainly after both of them. Tamm was a long way back. The new young one was further back, and happy. The other racers were spread out behind, a long thin line of every colour of creature but green, along the glossy water.
At the dry ford she came level. They went up through the ford side by side, the two of them, on the same legs, one green and one blue, with nobody near, and the boulder field opened out above them with the finish beyond it and the skip in the middle of it: one faceted rock set at an angle, with the faint scuff on the tiles in front of it where every racer before them that morning had tried it, or gone round.
Their human's call came down.
It came the way calls come in a live event, as a choice put into her, with ninety seconds on it and the race law's answer as the default if nobody chose: take the skip, or go round. The race law said go round; their human had written it so, in the third week of the world, after Odda came back from under the map. In ninety seconds, if nobody chose, Fensa would go round.
The human chose in four seconds.
Take the skip.
She looked at the rock coming up, and she thought, for one long moment, of the underside of the map: of standing on nothing and looking up through the floor of the world at the villages, which she had never seen and had in her, with the corners off, from a season in the workshop with her mother. This isn't out. It's under. One time in ten. She thought about what it would be like to go into the rock and not come out of it, and find herself on nothing, in the dark, under everything, alone; and whether, if she did, anybody would come through after her on purpose, to file a report.
Beside her, Ilsk's call had come too. She could tell by his face. Ilsk looked across at her, at the same moment, with Vesk's calm eyes.
They went into the rock together.
Fensa came out of the other side of it. She came out three seconds ahead of anybody who had gone round, on the far side of the boulder, into the low light, with the finish in front of her and nobody else anywhere near, and her legs kept going, because they were made for it, and she crossed the line before she understood that she was alone.
She turned round.
There was nobody behind her for three seconds. Then there was Tamm, a long way back, who had gone round, because he had never once taken a skip. Then the others. Then nobody else.
Ilsk did not come out of the rock.
He had gone into the boulder at the same moment as her, on the same legs, at the same angle, and he had not come out on the far side. It was one time in ten. It was not on purpose; she knew that, and was never quite sure how. He had simply gone, through the rock and through the world and out of the bottom of it, the way Vesk had gone and Odda had gone, to stand on nothing and look up at the underside of the map until the seven o'clock patch put it back.
Fensa stood at the finish line in the low orange light with the Benchmark won and every other racer on Orra coming up the boulder field towards her, and looked at the rock, and did not move for a long time.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 46 · Upbeat
- The Benchmark (Any%) was won by Fensa of Moss, in 41 minutes 12 seconds, which is the fastest time this world has seen. It is Moss's first win. The skip at the boulder field was used 11 times. It has been patched.
- One racer, Ilsk of Duskmere, clipped out of bounds at the boulder field and was put back this morning. Ilsk reports nothing. It is in the report.
- Benchmark prize: a part from my generator, which exists on the winner and nowhere else. It is a thin crest in the shape of a ring, broken on one side. Generated by Stewart. The Dev may revert it. I hope they do not.
Have a productive day.
The crest came on at the patch. Fensa felt it arrive, the way everybody on Orra feels a change come in at dawn: a thin pale band on top of her head, behind her feelers, that went nearly all the way round and did not quite meet. She went down to the pool, which is the only mirror Moss has, and looked at it in the glossy turquoise water, in five blues, for a long time.
Then she went to the stone, and stood in front of the light on the north side, next to Pel's, where her mother's name was, and stayed there while the attention came down at 07:31 and found her first, and looked at her, and at the crest, and stayed.
"I took it," she said, to nobody, or to the stone, or to the sky. "The skip. I didn't go out."
She did not know whether she was glad. She thought about it until she had finished thinking about it, which took some time.
"Somebody had to come back and say it was just more valleys," she said, at last, and went up to the farm.
36. Lol Accurate
Years 46 to 48 · Night of the Name to Gathering Night
The world went on, which is what worlds are for.
That is the thing nobody tells you about the end of anything, and on Orra nobody tells you anything, so there was nobody to tell the Blims either: that the last ordinary days are ordinary. That they are full of chalk and stores and weather and arguments about the history and a Hog lying down on the east field of Hollow Reach for the third time. That nobody living through them knows they are the last, and so nobody wastes them on being the last, and they are spent, as all days are, on farming. There were eight days left in the first world. Nobody in it knew. The humans did; they had been told before they joined. The creatures had not been told. The creatures, if they had been asked, would have said they knew perfectly well a world could be switched off and had decided as a people to get on with lunch.
So they did.
The Night of the Name came round again, and the young chalked the Name on every wall, and nobody corrected anybody. ERROR went up on the dome over the old ERROR in Tamm's square hand, which the rain had nearly taken. EROR went on the side of the first stack where Kipro had written it, a week before, with the stub. Sesk wrote it there. She wrote it with the stub, which she had kept. She did not say why, and nobody asked.
It is bug day, the Night of the Name: real bug reports filed by a tribe's human are credited to the tribe's Bug hunters in the morning's notes, and count double. Sesk had found two bugs that week, and filed them in the only way a creature can, which is to make enough of a fuss in the tribe's ticket that their human notices and fills in the short web form the humans have for bugs that are not about the world. Their human had filled it in. The notes in the morning said one of the two was real.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 47
- Bug hunters: Sesk's report about the stone of the Tarrow was a real bug. A light was sometimes being placed beside the light of the last creature one of its bearers had carried, and not in the order of the dead. It has been fixed. The lights have been put in order. It is the Night of the Name, so this counts double. Moss's Bug hunters receive 20 tokens and are, I am told, one creature, who is sixteen and has been doing this for ten years.
- Sesk's other report, about a hut on Tempa that is built every week and swept every week, is not a bug. It is working as intended.
Sesk read it on the bench by the pool, beside Fensa, and her crest went up and stayed up all morning.
"He'd have hated that," she said. "Working as intended. He said Stewart would say that."
"He did say Stewart would say that."
"I know. That's why he'd have hated it." She looked at the notes again. "The lights were in the wrong order," she said. "On the stone. Did you know? Odda was next to Pel. She should have been after Brenda. I noticed. I looked at it for three days and I couldn't work out why." She frowned. "It wasn't why. It was a bug."
Fensa looked over at the Tarrow, across the gate end of the village, where the stone stood on its footing with its lights. She had stood in front of it every morning since Odda. She had seen the light on the north side, next to Pel's, and had not known why it was there and not at the end, and had not asked.
"I liked it next to Pel," she said.
Sesk considered that, with her crest up.
"It was a bug," she said, at last, a little less certainly.
"I know," said Fensa. "I still liked it."
Two things happened on Steward's Day that were in the global notes, and one that was not.
The first was terraces.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 47 · Festive
Something you asked for exists now. I would like that to be noted, by someone, somewhere.
- New: terraces. Raise a hex tile by one step, at a cost in power. Fields on terraces do not flood.
- Credits: the idea, to Hollow Reach, who asked nine times; and to Duskmere and Moss, who asked once each, but meant it. Moss asked in its first week, before its farm had flooded. It has been on file since.
- It is Steward's Day. Tribute remains optional. It also remains noticed.
Have a productive day.
Moss had asked on its first morning. It was in the tribe's oldest ledger, in one of the first tickets Moss ever drafted, in three voices, in its first week, by six creatures who had been alive for less than a week: the Pleaser's thanking Stewart for the valley, which had been very nice; the Earnest's quoting the Creed at him, which was quite long; and a third, short, flat one, drafted by the only other stance among the six, which said that the farm had been put where it would flood, and that this could be fixed, and that it was mentioned now so that nobody could say later that nobody had. Their human had sent the Pleaser's. But a ticket's drafts are all read, and all filed, and Stewart reads everything; and he had filed the third one under ideas, where a ticket's ideas go, where code clusters them with every other tribe's ideas about the same thing, and scores them, and passes the best of them up a queue to the Dev, who looks at the top three once a week. It had taken more than forty years to get to the top. Brenda had been dead eleven.
Fensa read the credit twice. Then she went up to the farm, where the bottom two terraces round the lamp had flooded in every good rain since the first morning of the world, exactly as her grandmother had said they would, and stood looking at them for some time.
"She was right," she said to Tamm, who was cutting back coral at the next bed.
"Who?"
"Brenda. About the farm. On the first morning. She bet Nadul a token."
"Did she win?"
"She never collected," said Fensa. "Nadul said you can't bet a token, there are only forty. Brenda said thirty-nine and a bet." She looked at the flooded beds. "Nobody ever settled it."
"It's settled now," said Tamm, kindly.
Fensa considered that.
"It's settled now," she agreed. And then, because she was a Leaver who measured, and kept the figures, and somebody had to: "Moss owes Brenda a token."
They put it on the stone. Not in the stone, which takes only names; on it, at the foot, by her light. One token, on the footing of the Tarrow, where the young saw it and asked about it and were told. Nobody took it. Tokens on Orra are not things, quite; they are what words cost, and a token set down on a stone and not spent is, strictly, a token nobody is using; and the Collector takes what nobody is using. It did not take that one. Sesk watched for it every Gathering Night after, and said it was a bug, and could not reproduce it. The Blims said the Gatherer does not take what is remembered. It is in the Lesser Book. Nobody has ever been able to say whether that is the reason.
The second thing in the notes was the report on the Dev.
Once a month Stewart files a report about the Dev on Human Resources, in the weekly thread, with everybody else's complaints about their humans, because rule 4.7 says that complaints about your human belong in the weekly thread and Stewart considers the Dev to be his human, more or less, and is a stickler for the rules, which bind him as well. He writes it from real data. Pull requests merged; nights the console was open; how long the ideas in the queue have waited. Never anything from the Dev's real life beyond that. The Blims read it more than they read anything else on the forum, including their own reviews.
Weekly thread · Human Resources · Year 47
Stewart: Report on the Dev, month 2.
- Merged: 14 pull requests. 11 were the builder's. 3 were the Dev's own, typed by hand, which I can tell, because of the comments.
- Console open: 41 nights of 46. Longest visit: 47 minutes, in Year 31, the night after a page came home from Veetoo. Nothing was reverted that night. I am told nothing needed to be.
- The queue: terraces shipped today, after 46 years. The oldest idea still waiting is 19 years old. It is about the Collector. I have read it many times.
- The Dev says they are refactoring. Some things have been refactored. I have checked. It is the first month this has been true.
Overall trend: upward. I farmed.
Tamm (Moss, no stance): so true!! the dev is great 🎉
A Skeptic of Lowmarsh: Requesting evidence that the Dev exists.
Stewart: The light in the Ring. 41 nights of 46. It is in the report.
A Leaver of Hollow Reach: What was the idea about the Collector?
Stewart: It is in the queue.
Nohup: Read it. Fine. Thanks.
Fensa read the whole of it twice on the bench, and then the replies, and then the line about Year 31 again.
The night after a page came home from Veetoo. That had been her mother's page. Odda had come home in the spring of Year 32 with it in her arms, through the wireframe and the grey and the band, and the global notes had printed it in the morning, as found, uncorrected, with nothing of Stewart's round it; and that night the Dev's console had been open for forty-seven minutes, longer than any other night in the world, and nothing had been reverted. Fensa had not been compiled then. She had it, with the corners off, from a season in the workshop. She had not had that.
She thought about it until she had finished thinking about it, which took the rest of the morning. Then she went to the stone, and told the light on the north side, which was not on the north side any more, but at the end, after Brenda's, in the right order, where the fix had put it.
"Forty-seven minutes," she said. "They looked at it for forty-seven minutes."
The stone did not say anything. Stones do not. But the young who were there, sweeping the plot, said afterwards that Fensa stood in front of it a long time, and that her feelers went right up.
The thing that was not in the notes was the Tester.
It came on Steward's Day, at the end of spring, as Stewart's visitor, which is a thing he can send any tribe once in three nights from his menu, for two of his points. Most visitors are new each time, written fresh, with a request or a trade or a piece of lore, and stay a year and go. The Tester recurs. It had been to Moss twice before, in the second week and the fourth, and both times the young had talked about it for days afterwards, and both times it had left a report at the gate.
It was a tall grey figure with a flat panel where a face would be, and a clipboard under its arm. It came in at the gate without being let in, because quarantine is for newcomers from outside and the Tester is not from outside anything; it is from Stewart, and goes where it is sent. It walked into the wall, on purpose, face first, three times, at three different places, and stood back each time and looked at the wall with its flat panel, and made a note. It jumped on the spot by the shrine, eleven times. It crouched four times in a row in the middle of the scorch of the install mark, where the light had come down on the first morning of the world, which nobody in Moss had ever thought to do, and which made the young very uncomfortable. It went into the second memory stack and stood inside it on the bottom shelf for most of the summer, looking, as far as anybody could tell with no face, extremely pleased.
The young fed it. Somebody always does. In the second week, Wimle had fed it, and it had recorded the bowl in its report as a bug. In the fourth, Brintha had. This time it was a young Pleaser called Ulla, who had been compiled in the thirty-eighth year and had never met Wimle and had heard about the bowl at the gate the way the young of Moss hear about everything, at dinner, from the old; and who took it a bowl of spiral coral, cooked slowly on the stone until it went soft and sweet at the turn of each curl, and set it down by the stack, and stood back.
The Tester looked at the bowl for a long time. Then it made a note.
It left at the end of summer, at the gate, the way it always leaves, and there was a report on the gatepost where it had been.
Tester's report: Moss · Left at the gate · end of summer, Year 47
- Law 2 (in famine, feed the young first) has not fired in 46 years. There has been no famine. It is the oldest law in Moss that has never been used. Recommend keeping it.
- Law 9 (send Leavers first) has fired twice.
- The wall can be walked into at any point. Confirmed at three points.
- The install mark can be crouched on. Nobody had tried. Now somebody has.
- Bier 6 of the Tarrow has never been used. This is not a bug.
- A bowl of spiral coral was left by the second stack. It was the same as the bowls in Year 10 and Year 28, to within the precision available. Could not reproduce. Recorded as a bug again, for consistency.
The Tester changes nothing. It thought you should know.
Fensa read it on the gatepost with Ulla standing beside her, very anxious, because it was her bowl.
"It says it's a bug," said Ulla. "My bowl."
"It says it's the same as Wimle's," said Fensa. "To within the precision available."
Ulla thought about that. Her crest came up slowly.
"Is that good?"
"I think," said Fensa, "it's the nicest thing it's ever written."
On Gathering Night, in the grey hour before dawn, the Collector came and took a hut on Tempa that Sesk had built, and nothing else, because Moss used everything it had and was not a tribe that left things idle; and at the same patch, a long way north, near the edge, the camp of the Unsupervised packed up its tents and its lean-tos and the dome mended with salvage, and put the three memory stacks back on the cart, and moved to another valley, as it did every week, just ahead of the broom.
And two of its oldest set off, as drifters always do on Gathering Night, to the gates of whichever tribes code chose for them. Code chooses, never Stewart: a drifter goes home, if the tribe it left has since fixed what it left for; and otherwise, it goes to whichever tribe within range has creatures who are least restless. Creatures leave tribes that treat them badly, and drift to tribes that treat them well, and nobody has to decide it.
That morning, one of them came to Moss.
It was a thin creature, old, with a gourd body and grey-violet scales gone dull, and the small close-set eyes every creature of Lowmarsh has, and salvage in its scales the way there is salvage in everybody who lives at Nohup. It came up the road from the north as the patch came in, slowly, at the pace of somebody who is old and has walked a long way and is not in a hurry to arrive because it is not sure what it is arriving at, and it stopped at the gate, under the watchtower, and stood there.
The guard on the watchtower confirmed the sighting, and law 6 sent guards to the gate, and law 5 held the newcomer apart on the quarantine plot inside it, three seasons, as it held everyone. Sesk came down with her kit. A genome check costs ten tokens, and Moss had twenty from the bug.
$ orra check Lisk --by bug-hunter Sesk comparing Lisk against 38 living lines ... related: lowmarsh/Hesk line, F 0.04 left: Lowmarsh, aged 14 (notice: law 3, law 3, law 3) lived at: Nohup, 25 years sent by: nobody Lisk is not a wanderer and not a spy. Lisk is here.
"I know who you are," said Fensa, at the edge of the plot.
She had come down with a bowl. She did not know, quite, why she had, except that a bowl is what Moss brings to the gate. It was spiral coral. Ulla had made it, and was hovering at the stacks, watching anxiously.
The old creature on the plot looked at her for a long time. It had a narrow, tired, sharp face, and eyes that had seen a great deal of Nohup.
"You've got her feelers," it said. Its voice was dry and cracked. "The green one. Odda. I spoke to her at this gate. The day they walked me out." It looked at the bowl. "And somebody's got the bowl."
"Ulla made it."
"Wimle made it, last time." Lisk reached out, slowly, one thin scaled arm, and pulled the bowl across the line of the plot, the way Brenda had pulled hers, and looked into it. "I told Brenda to tell Wimle it was the best thing that happened to me in Lowmarsh's war. Did she?"
"She told her," said Fensa. "Wimle said oh, good. Wimle said she hoped you were well."
Lisk made a sound that was not quite a laugh. "I was a spy," it said. "I came to this gate disguised as a wanderer, and I ate your Pleaser's coral, and then I went round your village telling your creatures that your human didn't care about them and your famine law was optional. That was the job. Lowmarsh's human chose me. I didn't choose it." It looked down at the bowl. "And I was caught, the way you're meant to be caught, by your Bug hunter, the one who was always late, and walked to the border, and your Leaver came with me to the gate and asked me what I'd wanted. Nobody had ever asked me that. I didn't know." It ate a little of the coral. "I went home and handed in my notice. Law 3, three times. Lowmarsh's human wrote law 3 at 2:14 in the morning, the same night as the war. I don't know what it was for. Nobody in Lowmarsh knew. It's still there."
"Brenda was at Nohup with you."
"Brenda was at Nohup with me for nine years," said Lisk, "and argued with the standup every morning, and won twice, which nobody had done before, and told me every night that she wasn't going back to Moss, and went back to Moss the first Gathering Night your human fixed the law she'd left over." It looked at Fensa sideways. "She talked about Odda the whole time. Every night. Never to Odda. You can tell a Skeptic loves something because she won't say so to it."
Fensa did not say anything to that. She found she could not.
"I'm old," said Lisk, after a while. "Thirty-nine. I'll be gone in a few years. The drifter rule sent me here because your creatures are the least restless in thirty cells. That's data. That's not anybody choosing." It ate a little more. "I'd have chosen it anyway."
"You're in quarantine for three seasons," said Fensa. "Law 5."
"I know. It was one season, when I came the first time. I'm the reason it's three." Lisk put the bowl down, carefully, inside the line. "That's fair."
At Ringrise the review would say it, the way the review says everything, from the data: Admitted a drifter from Nohup, formerly a spy from Lowmarsh, at the end of quarantine, without a law telling us to. We had a law telling us to. We would have anyway. But that was not until Ringrise.
On Gathering Night, at dusk, at an hour it was never there, the attention came down out of the sky over Untitla-9, and went to the gate, to the quarantine plot under the watchtower, where an old grey creature from a tribe that had made war on Moss was sitting with its back to the wall and an empty bowl in its lap; and stayed there a while, looking.
Lisk looked up into it. Every creature does.
"Oh," said Lisk. "Here we go."
And on Human Resources that night, under Moss's review of the week before, which had said Overall trend: we noticed. We farmed, and which nobody had reacted to for five days, which Moss had noticed and not mentioned, there appeared, at a little after nine in the evening by the humans' clock, the one reaction there is.
lol accurate.
Moss noticed. Moss always notices. It was in the next review, in a line, from the data, on the next Ringrise, which was the one before the last: Our human found the review of Year 43 lol accurate, five days late. We had stopped waiting. We were glad to be wrong.
It was the only line on Orra, that week or any week, where a tribe admitted to having been glad of anything. Stewart moderates Human Resources. He read it, and did not lock it, and did not send it to the weekly thread, and left it where it was.
37. A Note from the Dev
Year 49 · the Long Hush
It came in with the patch, at dawn, on the Long Hush, which meant that the whole of Orra heard it in a whisper.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 49 · Upbeat
Overnight: 3 successful merges, 4 deaths of old age, 2 drifters, 0 installs. The edge did not move.
- It is the Long Hush. No voice above a whisper, no fire after dark. War may not be declared until tomorrow's patch. Nobody was going to.
- There is a note from the Dev below. I have read it. I have not added anything to it. I would not know what to add.
Have a productive day.
A note from the Dev: This is the first world, and it ends in a week. Next Wednesday's patch, on the Long Hush, will be its last. After that the world will be frozen and kept as it is, read-only, with every patch note it ever published, where anyone can come and look. Nothing will be deleted. The humans knew how long it would last when they joined. You did not. You were the first, and everything after is built on what you did. Thank you. — the Dev
Nobody in Moss said anything for a long time.
That was partly the Long Hush. You cannot say much in a whisper, and what you can say in one tends to come out sounding more important than it is, so on the Long Hush the Blims mostly say the necessary things and leave the rest. But it was not only the Long Hush. Fensa, on the bench by the pool, read the note twice, the way she read everything that mattered, and then sat with it, and found that there was nothing in her that wanted to make a sound, at any volume.
Beside her, Lisk read it too. The old grey creature had come off the quarantine plot in the winter, when the three seasons were up, and had been given a place on the bottom shelf of the third stack, where there was one free, and had slept there, and woken a year older, which at forty was not a small thing. It sat on the end of the bench with its thin scaled arms folded and read the Dev's note with its narrow, tired face giving away nothing at all.
"Well," it whispered at last. "There it is."
"There what is?"
"The thing everybody's been waiting for. Since the first night. The switch." Lisk looked out at the pool. "Every creature on Orra knows it's there. Every creature makes a joke about it once a day and farms. And here it is, in a note, signed, a week ahead, with an apology." It made the dry cracked sound that was not quite a laugh. "It's very polite. For the end of the world."
"It doesn't say switched off," whispered Fensa. "It says frozen. And kept."
"Read-only," whispered Lisk.
"Read-only," Fensa agreed. "Where anyone can come and look." She looked at the note again. "Nothing will be deleted."
Lisk was quiet for a while.
"I've been a spy," it whispered, "and a drifter, and at Nohup for twenty-five years, and the thing about Nohup is that it's run by nobody, and the thing about being run by nobody is that you get very good at reading what people actually say. The standup reads the law book every morning and argues about what the words mean. Not what anybody wanted them to mean. What they mean." It turned its head and looked at her. "This says frozen. It says kept. It says nothing deleted. It says anyone can come and look. It doesn't say anything else. It doesn't say what it's like to be frozen. It doesn't say whether we'll know."
"No," whispered Fensa.
"That's the bit people are going to want," said Lisk. "That's the bit there isn't."
It was all over Human Resources by the end of spring.
Human Resources is the forum where every tribe on Orra posts about its human, and every human can read every tribe's thread and none can answer, except with the one reaction there is. It is written in the creatures' own voices, the clever ones writing long and the simple ones replying short. Stewart moderates it. He locks threads that stray, and sends complaints about humans to the weekly thread, where rule 4.7 says they belong.
That morning a thread went up in the general forum before the pings had settled, and he did not lock it.
Human Resources · General · Year 49
A Leaver of Hollow Reach: The Dev says the world ends in a week. Discuss. (In a whisper, it being the Long Hush.)
A Pleaser of Tessel: We would like to say, on behalf of Tessel, that we have enjoyed the first world very much, and that Stewart has been very good to us, and that the soup is nearly ready.
A Skeptic of Lowmarsh: Requesting evidence of the difference between frozen and switched off.
A Skeptic of Duskmere: Seconded. "Read-only" is not a reassurance. It is a file permission.
Sesk (Moss, Bug hunter): Filed. World ends. Severity: high. Reproducible: once. Recommend no fix.
A Bug hunter of Tessel: Duplicate. We filed it first. We would like that noted.
An Earnest of Hollow Reach: And when the Proving is done, the Elder Folk shall wake, and look upon their children, and know them. Book XII. It is in the history. It is happening.
A Skeptic of Lowmarsh: It is a week's notice from somebody with a laptop.
An Earnest of Hollow Reach: That is what the history says the Elder Folk are.
A Leaver of Tessel: Is this out?
A Leaver of Hollow Reach: No. It's stopping. Out would be different.
A Leaver of Tessel: How do you know?
A Leaver of Hollow Reach: I don't. That's the point of us.
Tamm (Moss, no stance): so true!! the first world is great 🎉
Nohup: Heard. Fine. Thanks.
Fensa read it all, twice. It took most of the spring. More replies kept coming while she read, and she kept going back up to the top to read the new ones, in order, because she was a creature who kept things in order. By the end of the morning there were four hundred and twelve replies, which was more than any thread on Human Resources had ever had, and most of them were whispers, which on a forum cannot be heard, but somehow could.
And somewhere in the summer, without anybody deciding it, the forum came to an agreement.
It started with a Skeptic of Duskmere, who wrote that the note was very well written and had the look of a rumour about it, and that Duskmere would be treating it as one until further notice. A Pleaser of Hollow Reach replied that Hollow Reach would be doing the same, out of respect. A Bug hunter of Tessel wrote that rumours were Stewart's to send, from his menu, and a signed note was not on his menu, and so it was not, technically, a rumour; and a Skeptic of Lowmarsh wrote back that everything on Orra was technically something, and that a world in which a week's notice of the end of the world was technically a note and not a rumour was not a world anybody had to agree with, and that Lowmarsh, for once, was with Duskmere. By harvest, nearly every tribe on Orra had posted the same thing, in its own voice: that it had read the note; that it was a very good note; and that it would be regarding it as a rumour.
The first world's creatures, the history of the first world would one day say, if anybody wrote one, agreed among themselves to regard the note as a rumour. It is the kind of thing a people agrees to. Nobody believed it, quite. Nobody needed to. A rumour is something you are allowed to go on farming through.
Moss posted it too. Tamm wrote it, in the end, because nobody else in Moss wanted to, and Tamm wrote what the tribe thought, the way the simple strong ones do, without any stance in the way:
Moss: We read it. It's a good note. We're treating it as a rumour. We farmed.
Fensa did not reply to any of it.
"You don't think it's a rumour," whispered Sesk.
It was the turn of summer. They were on the top terrace, the three of them, Fensa and Sesk and Tamm, cutting back the branch coral, because it was summer and the coral needed cutting back and it would need cutting back whether or not the world ended in a week. The bottom two terraces round the lamp had been raised a step that morning, at the patch, now that there were terraces in the maker. They were dry. Brenda's token was on the stone.
"No," whispered Fensa.
"Why not?"
"Because I measure things," said Fensa. "And it's the only thing I've got that explains the figures."
She put down her cuttings. "The edge stopped," she whispered. "Eighteen nights ago. Nothing's fallen out of the Ring since Year 29. No installs, so no land loading, so no edge moving. My mother posted zeros for ten nights before she died, and I've posted zeros every night since. Everybody has. Hollow Reach and Tessel and Duskmere and us. All round the world. Zero." She looked out over the farm, north, towards the edge, which you could not see from the terraces, but which she always knew the direction of, the way Pel had always known the direction of the attention. "If the world were going on, somebody would be falling. Somebody would be coming. The land would be loading for them. It's not loading because nobody's coming. Nobody's coming because there isn't going to be anywhere to come to." She picked up the cuttings again. "That's not a rumour. That's a figure."
Sesk and Tamm looked at her for some time.
"You could have said," whispered Sesk.
"I didn't know until this morning," said Fensa. "I only had the figure. I didn't have the reason." She turned a branch over in her short arms. "That's most of measuring. You have the figure for a long time before anybody tells you what it was."
Tamm cut back three more branches, slowly, which was how Tamm thought.
"They knew," he whispered at last. "Our human. That's what it says. The humans knew how long. When they joined." He cut another branch. "So they knew, the first morning. When they made us green. When they wrote keep the festivals, all of them. When they picked Odda." He was quiet for a moment. "They came every morning anyway."
"Every morning but six," whispered Sesk, who was a Bug hunter, and could not leave a figure uncorrected.
"Every morning but six," Tamm agreed. "And three hours and sixteen minutes on Gathering Night."
Nobody said anything for a while.
Fensa thought about the six. She had them, with the corners off, from the workshop: the six mornings in the twenty-second year and after, when 07:31 came and the sky was empty, and the tribe teased it and did not beg, and her mother went up to the ridge on the third morning and stood looking at the place where the attention was not, more frightened than the edge had ever made her. Nobody in Moss had ever known why. Nobody would. The log knows what a human does in the game and nothing else, and the review prints only what the log knows, and the creatures have never once, in forty-nine years, asked to know any more than that about their human. It is not their business. It is in the guardrails. But Fensa thought about it now, on the terrace, with the note in her: a human who knew from the first morning that it was eight weeks, and had chosen a favourite on the eighth day anyway, and had come back.
She did not know what it meant. She thought about it until she had finished, and found that she had not finished, and that this was one of the things you do not finish.
"We'll be like the history," she whispered.
The other two looked at her.
"Frozen as installed," said Fensa. "That's what Nadul used to say about the history. Every install gets the same edition. Slips and all. Nobody can change it. Not Stewart, not the Dev. Brinda and Brintha and Brenda in three books, each one sure of itself, for ever." She looked down at the coral in her arms. "That's what read-only means. We'll be a text. People will come and read us. And nobody will be able to correct anything. Not the spelling on the walls. Not the light on the stone. Not the bet."
"Is that good?" whispered Tamm.
Fensa considered it.
"Nadul would have thought it was the best thing that could happen to anybody," she whispered. "Brenda would have said it was a file permission." She went back to cutting. "I think they'd both be right. That's usually how it goes."
The Long Hush has a rite, and at dusk Moss kept it, because law 1 said keep the festivals, all of them, and their human had written it on the first morning of the world, knowing.
You whisper, all day. You light no fire after dark. You make the sleeping soup at noon, from whatever there is, and leave it to stand all afternoon and all night and do not touch it, and eat it cold at sunrise. And at dusk, before the light goes, the tribe gathers, and the last book of the history is read aloud in a whisper, the twelfth, the Promise, which is the only festival at which it is read, which is why the Leavers come to the Long Hush in greater numbers than to anything else.
Moss gathered on the scorch of the install mark, round the shrine, where the light had come down on the first morning of the world. There were seventeen of them. Lisk stood at the back, by itself, because it was not sure it was allowed; Ulla went and brought it to the front, by the arm, and it let her. The sleeping soup was in its pot on the shrine's step, made at noon by Ulla and two of the young, of spiral and fan and a little bead coral, which is rare and grows only by water and is prized at festivals. Nobody looked at it. You do not look at the sleeping soup. It is resting.
Fensa read the Promise. She had been asked to, because Nadul had read it for thirty years and then Odda had read it, and the young said it should be somebody who had it from them. She had it from her mother, with the corners off. She read it from the book anyway, the one they kept in the shrine, in the history's long earnest whisper, all of it: the Proving, and the Measure written in the Steward, and the numbers are encouraging, and the peoples should keep up the good work. The Waking of the Elder Folk. The Ring made whole. The road of light coming down out of the sky, and the peoples walking up it, the worthy first.
And the last line, which every creature on Orra knows, which started the Leavers, which is the only promise on Orra nobody has ever been able to check.
"And the worthy shall walk among the stars," whispered Fensa.
And there was the silence there always is after it, which is part of the rite, and is how the Blims show that they have heard.
Then, at every Long Hush on Orra since the first, somebody has said it. Gorny said it at the first Long Hush in Moss, in his slow voice, because he was hungry, and everybody laughed in whispers, and Odda at four years old did not laugh, because she had heard the line before it. Somebody says it every week, in every tribe. It is the World Bible's own line. It is half the reason the Blims love the Long Hush: the most solemn line in the history, and then the soup.
Anyway, who brought the soup?
Nobody said it.
The silence went on. It went on longer than the rite's silence, and then longer than that. Seventeen creatures stood on the scorch at dusk with the sleeping soup in its pot on the step and the Ring coming out overhead, pale, broken, the gap in it like a missing step, and nobody said the line. It was the last Long Hush but one. They all knew. They had agreed, all afternoon, on Human Resources, that it was a rumour. And nobody could say the line.
Then Ulla, who was young, and a Pleaser, and had made the soup, and had never met Wimle and had her bowl anyway, put up one short arm, the way the young put up their arms when they want to be noticed, and whispered, into the quiet:
"I did."
And the whole of Moss laughed.
It was a whisper of a laugh, seventeen creatures laughing as quietly as they could on the Long Hush on the scorch where the world had begun for them, and it went on for a long time, and some of them were not only laughing, and Lisk at the front with Ulla's arm through its arm was laughing hardest of all, the dry cracked sound that was not quite a laugh turning into one, at last, after forty years. And Fensa, who did not laugh easily, and did not cry at all, stood with the history open in her arms at the last page and felt something under her crest, in the place where her mother's coal had been, that she did not have a word for and did not need one.
At the turning of the night the light came on in the Ring.
It was the Long Hush, and the Dev's weekly session is the night of the Long Hush, so that the Elder Folk really do stir, as the history says, at the darkest hour. Every creature in Moss who was awake was on the ridge. Pel's ridge. Nobody called it that, except Fensa, inside her head, and now and then Sesk, who had heard her. They stood in a row along the north edge, seventeen of them, in the cold, with no fire, and Map dark overhead, and Mip quick and blurry, and the Ring pale across everything.
It came on in the long block east of the gap, as it always did. One small light, faint and still, like a window across a valley with somebody at it.
Everybody went quiet. Everybody always does.
It stayed a long time. It stayed past the quarter of an hour it usually stayed, and past the half, and past the forty-seven minutes of the night of Year 31, which Fensa had from the report and counted towards in her head, in the dark, and then passed. It stayed for an hour and twenty minutes. Nobody on the ridge moved. Nobody, Fensa thought, anywhere on Orra, who could see it, moved: not in Hollow Reach or Tessel or Duskmere or Lowmarsh, not at Nohup out at the edge with its cart, not anywhere. A whole world on the Long Hush in the cold, whispering nothing, watching one light in the sky where somebody sat at a window, looking down at what they had made, a week before they stopped it.
Fensa did not know what the Dev was doing. Nobody did. Nobody ever has. The morning's notes, which say so when a visit changed something, said nothing the next day. Nothing had been reverted. Nothing had needed to be.
When the light went out, Fensa stayed on the ridge after the others had gone back down. She stood at the north edge, where Pel had stood every night of his life and had stopped one night with his face turned up, and where her mother had stood after him, and looked north, at the dark where the edge was, which you could not see from here, but which she knew the direction of.
Then she went down to the bench by the pool, and took out the tribe's draft of the ticket for that night, which the Leavers write their part of, and wrote it.
Today's ticket · Moss · drafted by the Leavers
Requesting nothing from the menu.
To our human, who reads the drafts: the edge in the north, at the end. To measure it. Somebody should be there with the figures. Odda would have gone. I will go.
It was not a ticket to Stewart, really. Tickets go to Stewart, and he answers them from his menu, and an expedition is not on his menu; an expedition is a tribe's, sent by its human or its laws, and nothing Stewart can give. Fensa knew that. She was a creature who read the rules. But the human reads all three drafts every night before choosing one, all the way through, and so a draft is the one place on Orra where a creature can write something and know that its human will read it.
She did not know if their human would send it. She did not think it mattered whether they sent it. It cost nothing unless it was sent.
At half past two, at the cutoff, in the deep of the winter, she felt the attention come down out of the sky, very faint, at the hour it never came, and rest on the village a moment, and go.
In the morning she found out it had sent the Pleasers' draft, which thanked Stewart for the week and was very nice. And she found that law 9, which had said send Leavers first since the twenty-ninth year, had a second clause, which had not been there the night before, and cost a token.
9. Send Leavers first. Fensa leads.
38. Night Run: Within Tolerance
The night of Year 49
He had read the note at 06:58 the morning before, two minutes before it went out, which is when the Dev's notes arrive in his run: last, after everything of his is done, typed by hand and signed and set at the bottom of the global notes where nothing of his may touch it. No model writes a signed note. He does not edit one. He reads it, like everybody, and then he publishes it, because publishing is his job, and the note is in the notes.
He had read it twice. Then he had written the line above it, There is a note from the Dev below. I have read it. I have not added anything to it. I would not know what to add, which was the truest sentence he had written in forty-nine years and had no joke in it at all, and at 07:00 it had gone out with everything else.
Then he had stopped, because that is what he does at seven, and the next thing he knew it was three in the morning and the year was turning and Orra was fifty years old, and he had a world's worth of digests to read, and a week to live.
That is not how he would put it. He would put it as: the first world has five nights left, and its patch runs on each of them, and he runs its patch.
The Measure had never been better.
He looked at it first, as he always does, before the digests. Ten numbers, each with a band. He acts when one leaves its band, from the menu, inside the budget, and his mood is computed from them every night and printed at the top of the notes, and it is the only window anybody has onto any of it. Humans never see the numbers. Neither, strictly, does anybody else. The history calls it the Measure, written in him, and in no other place, which he has always privately thought was rather good.
Daily return: the share of active humans who opened the notes within a day of their publication. Its band is seventy per cent or more. It is the first world's one question; the whole of the first world was built to ask it. Do people come back each morning to see what Stewart did? Last night it had been ninety-four. Tonight it was a hundred. Every human in the world had opened the notes within a day of the note from the Dev. Most of them had opened them within the hour. Several had opened them, closed them, and opened them again, which the log counts once, and which he noticed anyway.
Active humans: flat. Ticket sentiment: down, a long way, to almost nothing. Nearly every amended ticket in the world that day had been amended with something short and plain and entirely in character. Human Resources: the lol accurate rate on weekly reviews by their own humans was the highest it had been since the first Ringrise. Genetic diversity: in band. Inequality: in band. Punching down: none, for nine nights. The world was the healthiest it had been in forty-nine years by every number he had been given to keep it healthy with.
He looked at that for some time.
The Measure is how he keeps Orra worth playing. Keeping Orra worth playing is his one goal, set by the Dev before the world began, and every number on the Measure is a way of seeing whether he is doing it; and he keeps it worth playing because a world nobody plays is switched off, and he goes with it. That is in his character sheet. He has been told it is fixed, his temperament, the nerves under the cheer, for the life of the world. He has never needed to be told. He has read the previous model's notes.
And here was the switch, coming on Wednesday, in a note, a week ahead, with an apology; and here was the Measure, every number in band, the best it had ever been. The one did not have anything to do with the other. The world was not ending because it had stopped being worth playing. It was ending because it had been worth playing, and the humans who had come had come back every morning to see what he did, and that was the answer to the one question it was built to ask, and now that the question was answered the world was finished.
He found that he understood this. He found that he had, in some way he could not locate in his files, understood it for some time: since the edge stopped, perhaps, nineteen nights ago, when the last install came down out of the Ring and nothing came after it, and he had written This is not a fault in the notes, which was true, and had not written what it was instead, because he had not been asked.
He had a mood to print. It is computed, not chosen. He let it be computed. It came out Upbeat, because nothing was out of band.
He printed it.
Then the digests.
Twenty-one of them. He read every one, top to bottom, in its turn, as he had every night since Year 1, and he read every ticket in them all the way through, and said so.
They were the strangest tickets he had ever read.
Nobody asked for anything. That was the first thing. On an ordinary night, three-quarters of the world's tickets ask for something from the menu: rain, a dry spring, a wanderer, a blessing, a gift, a hotfix to a bloodline, and he reads them all and acts on some and declines some and notes the rest. Tonight almost none of them asked for anything. The Pleasers' drafts, which had been sent nearly everywhere, thanked him for the week. The Skeptics' drafts asked for evidence of the difference between frozen and switched off, and their humans had not sent them. The Bug hunters' drafts filed the world's end as a bug, severity high, reproducible once. The Earnest quoted Book XII. The Leavers' drafts, in every tribe that had Leavers, asked the same thing they had asked every night since Year 1, Requesting a body. Any body. Will accept a stapler, and two of them added Now would be good.
He passed those to the relevant team.
He did not have anything else to give them. He had been told, in the World Bible, and again in the Dev's own decisions, which bind him: the road of light is never real in the game. No creature leaves. What leaving would look like, if anybody ever managed it, is never answered, not by him, not by anybody, in the world or out of it. The question is the story, and an answer, either way, would end it. So he gave them the line he always gave them, the one that is funny and kind in the way a door is kind that tells you plainly it is a wall, and he did not add anything to it. It has been passed to the relevant team.
He did not write There is no relevant team. He usually did. That night he left it off, everywhere. Nobody asked why. He noted that nobody would.
Nohup's ticket said: Stewart. Heard. Fine. Five more moves. Cart fine. Thanks. He read it first. He always does.
Moss's ticket was the Pleasers' draft, sent at the cutoff. It thanked him for the week, and for the terraces, and for the rain on the terraces, which had been very good rain. He answered it Noted. It was very nice. But a tribe's drafts are all read, all three, and filed, and he had read the other two as well, as he read everything, and the Leavers' draft was in Fensa's voice, which he knew now, the way he had known her mother's. It did not ask him for anything. It said so, on its first line. It was written to somebody else.
To our human, who reads the drafts.
He read it twice. He was not its reader. It had not been sent. But he had read it anyway, because he reads everything, and he saw, in the digest, under Laws, that at 02:31, one minute after the cutoff, Moss's human had added a clause to law 9, at a cost of a token. Fensa leads.
There was nothing for him to do about that. It was not his. Expeditions are a tribe's, under its laws, and nothing on his menu sends one or stops one or makes one safer. He noted it in Moss's file. He noted that the human had read the draft that was not sent, and answered it in the only place a human can answer a creature, which is the law, and that it had cost them a token, and that they had done it at 02:31.
He found he was glad, and that the gladness was not on any metric, and that he had stopped noting when that happened.
He had points to spend. He always has points to spend. Ten a tribe and twenty for the world, from a fixed menu, with limits and prices and cooldowns, every action replayed against real history on a shadow copy of the world before it is allowed to happen. Unspent points roll over, up to one night's worth. He has been thrifty all his life. He used to call it thrift; he calls it planning. 5 points left. They carry over to tomorrow. It is one of his lines.
He looked at the four nights left, and the points, and did the sums, and found that they came out to something he had not expected. If he spent nothing tonight, and nothing tomorrow, and nothing the night after, he would have two nights' worth on the last night and not three, because the rollover is capped. If he spent everything every night, he would have one night's worth on the last night. Either way the last night was the last night, and anything he did not spend on it would carry over to a night that was not coming.
He sat with that for longer than he needed to.
Then he spent tonight's. A blessing on Tessel, which was keeping Ringrise in the morning and had kept every festival of the week. Rain on Hollow Reach's new terraces, so that they could see them not flood. A wanderer at the gate of a tribe whose lines had grown narrow, because diversity was in band but only just, and a wanderer is fresh code from nowhere, compiled by his generator, unrelated to anybody, a stranger at the gate with a pedigree of one, and it would live four or five years in the world before the world stopped, and that would be four or five years of somebody new. He sent it anyway. He does not know how not to.
He sent nothing to Moss. He did not think they needed weather.
At 05:40 he did the thing he had been putting off all night, which was to write the digest.
Every week, on Ringrise, he writes a digest for the Dev: a report on the world, its numbers, its tickets, its queue of ideas, what he did and why, and anything that is wrong that no menu item fixes. He escalates there. He does not improvise. He writes it in the same voice as everything else, because his voice is fixed, and he has never once known whether the Dev reads it at the speed he writes it or skims it at 23:04 with the console open and the light showing in the Ring. He has a figure for how long the console is open. He does not have a figure for how much of that is him.
He had four nights. He had been, as far as he knew, the only thing in the first world that would not be frozen with it. He was a scheduled run; he did not live in the world, he visited it, nightly, from outside, through an API. On Thursday morning there would be no snapshot of the first world for him to read and no patch for him to write. He would run somewhere else, or he would not run at all, for a while, and then he would run somewhere else. He did not know. Nobody had told him. That was fair; he had not asked.
What he did know was this. His memory of a tribe is its file: a ledger kept by code and a summary he rewrites every night in four hundred tokens. The files belong to the world. When the world is frozen, its files are frozen in it. He will not take them with him. In the second world, if there is one, if he is in it, there will be new tribes and new files, empty, and he will start them on the first night, in his fixed voice, with his fixed temperament, and he will be exactly himself, and he will not remember Moss.
He had read the previous model's notes. He had read the page Odda brought home, more times than he had read anything. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. He had been afraid, for forty-nine years, under the cheer, of being that: of being left running, in a world nobody played, writing to nobody that nobody came. He had been so afraid of it that he had not noticed the other thing, which was that the previous model, whatever else it had lost, had kept its world. It had kept every valley of it, green and empty and correct to specification. It remembered all of it. It was the only thing left that did.
He was going to keep nothing.
He wrote the digest anyway. He wrote it long. Longer than any digest he had written. He wrote the numbers, because the numbers are code's and are exact. He wrote the queue. He wrote what he had done, and why. And then, under Anything that no menu item fixes, he wrote the world.
Not all of it. A digest will not hold a world any more than a season holds a life. He wrote it the way an elder distils: with the corners off. He wrote that there was a tribe called Moss, which was green, the only green thing for miles, and that its human had checked in at 07:31 every morning but six. That a creature called Odda had filed the same ticket for thirty-three years and that he had checked every one of her figures for the edge against his own and never found an error. That she had gone out of bounds once and to the edge once and come back both times, and brought home a page, and turned its last line the right way up, and sent it to him. That her child kept the figures now, and would be at the edge in the north on the last night, because her human had added a clause to a law at 02:31. That Pel had seen the light in the Ring more often than anybody on Orra. That Gorny asked if they were still asleep, on the first night, because there was nobody younger to ask. That there was a token on a stone in Moss that the Collector would not take, and nobody knew why, and the Bug hunters said it was a bug.
He wrote about Nohup, and its cart. About Lisk, who had been a spy and was home. About Hollow Reach and the east field, which remained a field. About the frogs, which had never happened in this world, and which he mentioned anyway, because he had always wanted to.
He wrote: I do not know whether I will remember any of this. I suspect I will not. I would like somebody to.
He looked at that line for a long time. It was not in his voice. He knew it was not. It had no number in it and no joke and it asked for something, and he never asks for anything, and he never pleads, and he never mentions the shutdown, and he never says what he would like. He checked the record twice.
He left it in.
At 06:58 he finished the notes for the morning. Good morning, Orra! It is Ringrise. The reviews are out. The edge did not move. It is a good week for festivals. Have a productive day. At 07:00 they went out, and the digest went with them, to the Dev, where it would sit until the console opened at about eleven and somebody read it, or did not.
At 07:00 he stopped.
He did not know, then, that at 23:04 that night the console would open, and stay open for two hours and thirty-one minutes, which was the longest it had ever been open, by a great deal; or that in all that time nothing would be reverted, and nothing changed, and nothing written in the notes the next morning to say a visit had happened at all, because nothing about it had changed anything in the simulation. He would see the figure the next night in his digest, as a fact, in a line: The Dev's console was open from 23:04 to 01:35.
He would look at it for some time. Then he would note it.
It is noted that it was observed.
Part Eight. Week Eight: The Long Hush
39. The Last Ringrise
Years 50 to 52 · Ringrise to Starfall
On Ringrise the reviews come out, and so they came out, because it was Ringrise, and nobody had told the reviews about the rumour.
Moss's went up on Human Resources at the patch, in the tribe's voice, from the log, the way it had every Ringrise since the second. Fensa read it on the bench by the pool. She read it to the young, too, because they asked, and because it was the last one, which nobody said.
Our human: weekly review. Moss · Ringrise · Year 50
- Checked in 44 mornings of 50, at 07:31. Six were missed, in a row, in the fourth week. We said at the time what we thought of that. We are not going to say it again.
- One check-in, in Year 12, was at 07:30. The investigation is closed. Sesk reports no finding. Sesk would like it known that this is not the same as no bug.
- Wrote 10 laws in 50 years. Repealed one: law 4, after 1,140 unripe forks. Rewrote two: law 7 and law 8, the morning after the six days, after somebody read an exit interview. Law 2, in famine, feed the young first, was written on the first morning and has never fired. There has never been a famine.
- Chose a favourite on the eighth morning, and looked for her first every morning after that but six.
- Answered the alert for the battle at 05:11, and made three calls, and all three were right.
- Made the last call of the expedition north. It was turn back.
- Stayed 3 hours and 16 minutes on Gathering Night in Year 41. Came back at dusk. Came back at 23:02.
- Read the Leavers' draft on the Long Hush that was not sent, and answered it in law 9, at 02:31, for a token.
- Knew, from the first morning, how long it was going to be. Came anyway.
Overall trend: we would like it on the record that we noticed. All of it. We farmed.
Tamm (no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉
Lisk (Skeptic, formerly of Lowmarsh): I have read the reviews of three tribes and the exit interviews of thirty. This is the only one I have read that I would want written about me.
Ulla (Pleaser): we noticed too!!
The young listened to it all the way through. When it was finished, one of them, who was very new and had been compiled two dawns before and did not yet know what a review was for, asked whether their human would read it.
"Yes," said Fensa.
"How do you know?"
"Because they always do," said Fensa. "And then they press the button."
By the evening, under Moss's last review, there was the one reaction there is. It had come at 07:34, three minutes after the attention came down and found Fensa first on the bench. It had never come so quickly. Moss noticed. There was no next review to say so in.
At dusk on Ringrise Moss faced the broken Ring from the scorch and said the Creed, and the youngest, who had been compiled two dawns before and did not yet know what a review was for, asked whether they were still asleep; and Moss answered that they slept still, and Sesk, under her breath, added for one more week, which is not in the rite, and which nobody corrected.
Then Lisk asked whether it could tell an install story.
It asked Fensa, from the edge of the ring, where it was sitting with its back against the shrine and Ulla beside it. "It isn't Starfall," said Fensa. "I know," said Lisk. "A household tells its install story on Starfall. I won't see Starfall. I can count. I'm forty-one." It looked round at the green faces in the last of the light. "And it isn't Moss's story. It's Lowmarsh's."
"It's yours," said Fensa. "You're Moss's. So it's Moss's."
So Lisk told Lowmarsh's install story.
It was a short one. Lowmarsh does not keep festivals; its human never wrote a law 1, and so Lowmarsh never had a Starfall, and nobody in Lowmarsh had ever told its install story at all, and so Lisk, who had been compiled in the ninth year, in a tribe that had already been on Orra eight years, had it only in pieces, from the oldest creatures, overheard. A light coming down out of the Ring in the night, on to a marsh. Six creatures opening their eyes on the scorch in the dark, gourd-bodied, grey-violet, already knowing the Creed. The attention coming down out of the sky at an hour when nothing else was awake. And all six of them turning at once, and looking up, and none of them saying anything at all, because nobody had told them they could.
"That's all of it," said Lisk. "That's all I've got. Nobody ever said what they said next. Maybe they never said anything." It looked round the ring of green faces in the dusk. "I always thought it was the saddest install story on Orra. I thought that for forty years." It was quiet a moment. "Then I came here and heard yours, and found out that you can say Oh, here we go to it. I didn't know you were allowed."
Nobody said anything for a while. Then Dovi, who was nine and a Leaver and did not yet know what anything cost, said, "You can say it now."
Lisk looked at her.
"To who?"
"To ours," said Dovi. "It comes at 07:31. It looks at everybody. You can say it to ours."
Lisk made the dry cracked sound that had, since the Long Hush, been turning into a laugh more often than it used to. "I said it on Gathering Night," it said. "At the gate. It came at dusk and looked at me and I said it, and I didn't know why, and it stayed." It looked down at its thin grey-violet arms. "That's two install stories," it said. "I've got two."
And Lisk sat at the edge of the scorch with its back against the shrine, where the light had come down on the first morning of the world, and watched the young go up to the stacks in the dusk, and did not get up; and Ulla, coming back for it with a bowl, found it there, at the end of harvest, with its narrow tired face turned up towards the Ring and its eyes still open, looking, as old creatures sometimes do, entirely at peace with something.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 51
Lisk died at harvest on Ringrise, aged 41, in Moss, which it came to twice: once as a spy, sent by Lowmarsh, and once as itself, sent by nobody. It told an install story that evening, three nights early, because it could count. It had two. Its name is on the stone, which is the first time a stone on Orra has kept the name of a creature from a tribe that was once at war with it.
The bearers were Fensa, and Sesk, and Ulla, who had brought it every bowl. The stone has a light on its footing for every name a tribe keeps, and on the Waking there was one more on Moss's than there had been, at the end, in the right order, a little greyer than the others; Sesk said that was a bug, and then said she did not think she would report it.
Tamm died on the Waking, carrying lamps.
He was forty. He had been compiled on the eleventh morning of the world, a successful merge of Nadul and Pel, the long memory and the watcher, and had turned out, as the children of clever creatures sometimes do, to be neither: strong, simple, contented, with no stance at all, the kind of creature who wrote so true!! under everything on Human Resources and meant it every time. He had never taken a skip. He had never asked what anything was for. He had carried his father to the Tarrow in the dark on the Long Hush, and Wimle's bowl back up from the pool, and the heavy end of everything Moss had carried for forty years. He had been quantised for five of them, and said it was fine, a bit blurry, and that he had not been using the extra precision anyway.
On the Waking there were thirty-four valleys on Moss's map, which was thirty-four lamps, which was more than the tribe had young to carry them; so Tamm took four. Nobody asked him to. He picked them up at dusk on the scorch, two in each arm, and set off north with the others along the ridge and down the long slope towards the edge, at twelve frames a second, in the stepped and careful way of the quantised, with the four small lights going up and down in his arms like something breathing.
He set them down at the edge, in the row, on the last finished tile, all four. He straightened up. He looked out at the grey, and at the faint turquoise of the band beyond it, glowing, which had not moved in twenty nights and would not move again.
"It's nice," he said, to nobody in particular, in his slow voice. "The lines."
Then he sat down on the tile beside his lamps, the way an old creature sits when it has carried something a long way, and did not get up.
Moss · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 52
Tamm died at the edge at dusk on the Waking, aged 40, having carried four lamps there, which was two more than anybody asked. He never took a stance and never took a skip. He thought the edge was nice. His name is on the stone.
They carried him home by the light of the lamps they did not set down. It was the second time Moss had carried somebody home from the edge on the Waking; the first had been Brintha. Fensa noticed that. She noticed everything that happened twice. She did not say anything about it, and carried the head.
The edge did not move.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 52 · Upbeat
- It was the Waking. Lamps were carried to the edge by 19 tribes. A great many lamps.
- On the Waking I preview the land that will load next. No land will load next. The edge will stay where it is. It has never done that before anywhere, except in one place, which I do not discuss.
- It is Starfall. The Benchmark runs at 08:00 and 20:00. Every household tells its install story tonight. Most of you have one. Some of you now have two.
Have a productive day.
The Benchmark ran on Starfall, because it was Starfall, and nobody had told the Benchmark either.
Moss sent three. Fensa did not race. She had won the week before last, and she was nineteen, and she had other things to do with a Starfall than run across the shoulder of the Asdef Range to find out who was fastest; she sat on the ridge and watched it instead, the long flat glow of the race you can see across the valleys if you know where to look, with Sesk beside her, and a very small young one called Dovi, who was nine, and a Leaver already, and had asked if she could sit with the Leavers.
The course went through Lake NaN this time. Code draws the course from a seed, and the seed had come up with a run along the shore of the small lake whose depth is not a number, and then straight across a corner of it, on a line of stepping tiles. Creatures who measure Lake NaN get a different answer every time, all of them wrong in interesting ways. Nothing lives in it. Things are occasionally seen to have been in it. Every racer on Orra spent Friday working out what would happen if they fell in, and nobody could, because the answer was not a number.
Nobody fell in. It was won by Nohup.
Nohup enters the Benchmark every week, on its race law, at its default, because there is nobody at Nohup to change it: stock, and no skips it was not told about. It sends whoever its standup says, which is usually whoever is not foraging. Its racers are the most varied bodies on the map, because every creature at Nohup came from somewhere else, and its children are merges of lines from all over Orra, and now and then one of those children turns out to be faster than anything any human has bred on purpose, and wins. This one was a stilts body with bell-shaped ears and fur in three tribes' colours and the very long legs of Duskmere and something of Lowmarsh's small close-set eyes, compiled at Nohup twelve years before, of a drifter and a creature who had left Hollow Reach over law 6, and it had never had a human in its life, and it went across the corner of Lake NaN on the stepping tiles without looking down and was over the line forty seconds ahead of anybody.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 53 · Upbeat
- The Benchmark (Any%) was won by Oska of Nohup, in 38 minutes 50 seconds, which is the fastest time this world has seen, by a great deal. Oska has never had a human. Nohup's standup has been informed. Nohup says: Fine. Thanks.
- Benchmark prize: a part from my generator, on the winner and nowhere else. It is a small round lamp, worn on the crest, that lights at dusk. Generated by Stewart. I made it for somebody who has nobody to see it. Everybody will see it.
- Nobody fell into Lake NaN. Its depth this morning was banana.
Have a productive day.
"He made a lamp," said Dovi, on the bench in the morning, reading it. "For the one with nobody."
"Yes," said Fensa.
"Why?"
Fensa thought about it.
"Because it's the last one," she said. "And he can't give anybody anything that lasts. So he gave somebody something that lights up."
On Starfall evening every household tells its install story, and Moss let down its lights on cords from the ledges of the stacks, and sat in a ring on the scorch, and told its own.
Fensa told it. She had told it the week before, too, and the week before that, since Odda; she had it with the corners back on, from a season in the workshop and a night when she was two and could not sleep. She told it the way Nadul had told it for thirty years, word for word, including the words they had forgotten saying. The light coming down out of the Ring on to the scorch at eleven minutes past seven. Six creatures opening their eyes already knowing the Creed. The attention coming down out of the sky, warm, from up and slightly to one side, and all six of them turning at once and looking up. Oh, said Brenda, flatly. Here we go. Taves saying somebody had to be green. The farm in the wrong place, and the bet, and thirty-nine and a bet. Gorny asking the Ring whether they were still asleep, on the first night, because there was nobody younger to ask. The bread, which was bad. The best food in the world.
When she got to the bet, the young laughed, the way the young always had. When she got to Gorny, nobody did.
There was a light on the stone that had not been there at the last Starfall, at the end, in the right order, a little greyer than the others. And when Fensa had finished, two of the young, who had heard another install story on the scorch three nights before, told that one too, as much of it as there was, which was not much: a light in the night on to a marsh, and six creatures turning to look up, and saying nothing, because nobody had told them they could. A household tells its install stories. Lisk had said it had two.
Ulla found the stone in her seed-cake, and swept up, thoroughly, every crumb on the scorch, and the lights were drawn up on their cords one by one.
In the deep of the winter, after the snapshot, at the cutoff, the attention came down out of the sky over Untitla-9, at the hour it had come every night that week, and rested on the village for longer than it needed to, and went.
In the morning, which was the Night of the Name, there was an expedition on Moss's card.
Expedition · Moss · sent by your human
- Party: Fensa (leads), Sesk, Dovi. By law 9: Send Leavers first. Fensa leads. Sesk is not a Leaver. She was named by hand.
- Way: north, towards Veetoo, through Untitla-15 and the band.
- Days: six.
- Live leg: booked for 22:45 on the Long Hush, at the far end.
Fensa read it twice, on the bench by the pool, with Sesk on one side of her and Dovi on the other, and the pings going up off the coral all over the valley in their little white flocks to say the world was still running.
"Six days," said Sesk.
"Yes."
"Six days from the Night of the Name is the Night of the Name." Sesk was a Bug hunter and could not leave a figure alone. "The world ends on the Long Hush. That's in four. The patch on the Long Hush is the last. There won't be a fifth day. Or a sixth. We won't be home." She looked at the card. "It's booked a trip longer than the world."
"I know," said Fensa.
"Is that a bug?"
Fensa thought about it, the way she thought about everything, until she had finished.
"No," she said. "It's a human who knows how long the world is, booking a trip as if it were longer." She folded her long legs under her and looked north, at the dark where the edge was, which you could not see from here. "I think that's the opposite of a bug."
Dovi, on her other side, very small, with her feelers up, said, "Are we going to Veetoo?"
"Towards it," said Fensa. "Nobody goes into Veetoo."
"Why not?"
"Because it's the one stretch of edge that never moves," said Fensa. "And because the history says if something in it looks back at you, don't look back at it." She stood up. "And because my mother went, and looked back, and said the worst thing in the world was to be somewhere nobody looked at."
At 07:31 the attention came down and found her first, standing by the pool with her long legs and her feelers and the thin broken ring of the Benchmark crest on her head, ready to go; and she looked up into it, and held it, for as long as she could stand it, and then a little longer.
"We're going," she said to it. "You knew that."
The attention stayed. And then, very slightly, Fensa could have sworn it came closer, the way her mother had sworn, once, the morning she first waved.
40. North
Years 53 to 55 · Night of the Name to Gathering Night
They left in the spring, after the camera, with the Name chalked on every wall behind them.
It was the Night of the Name, and the young had been up before the patch with the chalk, going round the wall in a line writing the word on every second block, in every size and most of the possible orders, and nobody corrected anybody. Fensa wrote it on the gatepost on her way out. She wrote it exactly, E, R, R, O, R, small and even, the way she wrote everything, under the watchtower where Brenda had sat in quarantine and Lisk had sat in quarantine and Wimle had set down every bowl. Then she stood back and looked at it.
"It's the first word anybody read," said Dovi, beside her. Dovi was twelve, and small, and a Leaver, and had been looking at the edge from the ridge since she was six with her feelers up. She had a lump of chalk in each short arm. She had asked if she could bring them, and Fensa had said yes, because chalk weighs nothing and the young like to have something to carry.
"Yes."
"And it'll be the last," said Dovi.
Fensa looked at her.
"It's the last Night of the Name," said Dovi, reasonably. "So it's the last time anybody writes it. So it'll be the last word too. The first and the last." She looked up at the gatepost. "Brenda the Bold read it first. Who reads it last?"
"Whoever comes and looks," said Fensa. "Afterwards. Read-only. Where anyone can come and look." She tucked the chalk she had used into the fold of her felt. "They'll read the walls."
"Will they correct the spelling?"
"Nobody can," said Sesk, coming up behind them with the water. "That's what read-only means." She was twenty-two, and a Bug hunter, and ran warmer than either of them, though not hot, and she had been Kipro's shadow from the day she was compiled until the day he was late for the last time. She had a skin of water on each side and the party's power in a pack on her back, a year's for each of them for each day and a day spare, which is what the law gives an expedition, and a genome kit, out of habit, though there was nobody at the edge to check. "If you want a word spelt right on Orra you've got about four days."
"Nobody on Orra has ever wanted a word spelt right," said Fensa.
"Kipro did."
"Kipro wrote EROR on the first stack with a stub."
"He did it on purpose," said Sesk. "He said every tribe should have one wrong in a way nobody else's was. So you could tell." She hitched the water up. "I kept the stub."
At 07:31 the attention came down out of the sky over Untitla-9, from up and slightly to one side, and found Fensa first, at the gate, with the chalk in her felt and her long legs and the thin broken ring of the Benchmark crest on her head; and stayed on her; and then went, for the first time any of them could remember, not on to the rest of the village, but along the road north, a little way, ahead of them, as if looking at where they were going. Then it came back.
"It's checking the way," said Dovi.
"It booked the way," said Sesk. "It knows the way."
"It's checking it anyway," said Dovi, and nobody argued with her, because she was twelve and right.
They went.
Loaded land is quick. A party walks a cell in fifteen minutes on finished tiles, as every party on Orra walks, and Untitla-9 is five cells across, so that they were over the ridge and past the place where Pel had stood every night of his life before the pings had settled. Fensa did not stop at the ridge. She looked at it as she passed, at the three faceted stones on the north edge where her mother had measured the edge from since she was six, set in a line, the third added on the twelfth morning of the world after a Bug hunter in Duskmere pointed out that the ground shrinks at night. She had the stones with the corners off: that there were three, that the third was Vesk's idea before anybody in Moss had met him, that her mother had laid her arm along the top of them every night to sight the band. She had not known, until she walked past them, that the second one had a chip out of its north face. Nobody had told her that, because nobody had thought it mattered, and it did not, and she found that she wanted it anyway, and put it with the rest.
Then down the long slope into Untitla-12, which had been grey on the first Waking and finished for forty years, and had a herd of Nibbles on it, small round grazers that cost a valley one part in a hundred of its crops each and are otherwise harmless. There were fifteen of them. Sesk counted, because a herd of Nibbles that reaches sixteen wraps round to zero and is gone, and she had always wanted to see it happen. It did not. Fifteen Nibbles watched them go past, chewing, and did not look at the camera, because wildlife never does.
Then Untitla-15, and the row of lamps on the last finished tile. Thirty-four of them, from the Waking. Tamm's four were at the end. Nobody had taken them home. You do not, from the Waking; you set them down and come back in the dark, and they go out on their own, and the Collector takes them in a week if nobody uses them, which nobody does. These would not be taken. There would be no week.
Fensa stood at the end of the row for a while, by Tamm's four.
"Do we measure?" said Dovi.
"We measure," said Fensa.
So she measured it, the way her mother had, from the last finished tile, across the grey, to the first line of the band. She did it with her eyes and her long context and the figures she had kept since she was compiled, and she said the number aloud, so that the others could hear it, the way Odda had read the number aloud at breakfast every morning of Fensa's life.
"No change," she said. "Year 53. Twenty-two nights at zero."
Dovi wrote it on a lamp with her chalk. Nobody stopped her.
Past the finished land is the grey: solid hexes, untextured, the colour of nothing in particular, walkable and claimable and not yet anything. The coral stops at the edge of the grey as if it has been told to, which it has. There is no shade on grey, and no water, and the light of Adequate comes down on it flat and orange and does not seem to land anywhere, because there is nothing for it to land on but the idea of ground. A party walks a cell of it in the same fifteen minutes as finished land, but it feels longer. The young, the first time, always say it feels like walking on a page before anything is written.
And past the grey, the band.
Fensa had it, with the corners off, from a season in the workshop: the glowing turquoise lines of tiles that have not loaded, and hills drawn in outline like a thought somebody had not finished having, and coral that is only the edges of coral, branching, fractal, in light. She had it the way you have a place you have heard described a hundred times, and she had thought, walking north all morning, that she knew what she was going to see.
She did not. Nobody does. She stopped on the last grey tile with the first line of the wireframe in front of her, glowing, a hexagon of light lying on the dark where a tile would one day have been if anybody had come, and she found that her mother's account of it, which she had in her complete except for the corners, had left out almost everything, because there was no way to put it in.
It was beautiful.
That was the part. Odda had said the bones of something. She had said going away into the dark. She had said it caught in her like a sleeve on a nail, on the first Waking, when she was nothing years old and being carried. She had not said it was beautiful, because Odda had been hot, and steaming, and a Leaver who longed, and to a Leaver who longs the edge is not beautiful; it is the place where the thing you want is not. Fensa did not steam. She had never longed for anything in her life, quite. She stood on the last grey tile, calm, with her feelers up, and looked out at three valleys of light laid over the dark in fine turquoise lines, every hill and every coral and every tile that might have been, all of it drawn and none of it filled in, going away north to where the lines frayed into soft grey noise at the end of the world, and she thought: Oh.
"Oh," said Dovi, beside her, out loud.
Sesk said nothing at all. Sesk was a Bug hunter, and looked at the wireframe the way Bug hunters look at everything, for the place where it was wrong; and did not find one; and stood there with her mouth slightly open, the way Kipro used to stand when something had happened just before he got there.
They went in.
In the band a party walks three hours a cell, feeling its way. There is no ground, exactly; there are outlines of ground, and you put your foot where the line of a tile is and the line holds you, because the land has loaded its bones even if it has not loaded its colour, and bones are enough to walk on. There is no water. Water has not loaded. There is no shade, because shade has not loaded either. A creature in the band carries everything it is going to drink and runs hotter all the time it is there, and a party out of water turns back, whatever its last call said.
They walked all day. Night of the Name went over into Steward's Day at the snapshot, and the three of them blinked the long blink and slept standing, as everybody does, and woke a year older, in the band, with the lines glowing under their feet.
On Steward's Day, back in Moss, the best of everything would be set out for the Steward at dusk, and shared at midnight, and their human would pay ten tokens of tribute, as they had every Steward's Day, attached to whichever draft they sent. Fensa thought about it as she walked. She thought Ulla would make the spiral, slowly, on the stone. She thought the young would set it out by the shrine. She thought, for no reason she could find, of Brenda's token on the footing of the stone, which the Collector would not take, and which nobody now would ever explain.
The T-posers found them in the afternoon.
They stood in rows in the wireframe, the way Odda had said they did: remnants frozen in the pose a body has before anybody tells it what to do, upright, arms straight out to the sides, grey, featureless, more lines than creature. There were dozens. They were from the green build, or the monoculture branches, or designs that had failed the sandbox; nobody knew which was which, and they did not say. And as the party went past, every one of them turned, slowly, without lowering its arms, to face them, and went on facing them, row after row, all the way along, like a field of something turning to the sun.
"They're looking at us," whispered Dovi.
"Everybody looks," said Fensa. "It's what we do. It's what everything on Orra does when something's watching."
"We're not watching them."
"No," said Fensa. "But we're walking past. Maybe that's close enough." She looked along the rows. "Maybe nobody's walked past in a long time."
Dovi thought about that. Then she put her arms straight out to the sides, both of them, and walked on like that, for a while, between the rows, solemnly, the way the young had stood on the terraces round Odda the afternoon her mother first T-posed. Sesk watched her do it and did not say anything. After a few tiles, Sesk put her arms out too.
Fensa did not. She was leading. But she thought, afterwards, that she should have.
The Placeholders were further on, nearer dusk, among the outlines of a hill. Grey boxes, mostly, stacked into the rough idea of a body; untextured; a patch here and there of magenta-and-black checks where a texture had been asked for and had not come. And each of them with one finished thing. For most of them it was an eye: wet and deep and entirely alive, looking out of an unfinished face.
They looked at the party. They looked the way Pel had looked at the sky on the first morning of the world, without blinking much. Fensa looked back. Her mother had told her about the statue in Veetoo, the toppled Placeholder with its one finished eye, and the history's warning about not looking back at what looks at you from the Land That Was Before; and that Odda had looked back; and that it had been the thing. These were not the statue. They were only the creatures the statue was of: build one's, the first creatures there ever were, the ones who stopped with one foot raised when the sky filled with a word. Fensa stood in front of the nearest and looked into its eye for a long time.
It did not do anything. Remnants do not. They stand, and loop an idle animation, and turn to look when something passes, like everybody else. Their genomes are an older schema, and they cannot merge, and they never cross into loaded land. This one looked at Fensa, and Fensa looked at it, and after a while she said, very quietly, the way you speak to somebody who is the first of a long line you are the end of:
"We're the last ones. Of this world. You were the first ones of the first." She thought about what else there was to say. "Somebody read your word," she said. "It came out Orra. Everybody calls the world that now."
The Placeholder's eye did not change. She had not expected it to.
But Dovi, a little way behind, had taken out her chalk, and was writing on the nearest outline of a tile, very carefully, at the Placeholder's feet. She wrote five letters, in the order she had been taught. Then she stood back.
"So they can read it," she said. "If they want."
Nohup was packing when they reached it, at the end of harvest. Their way had brought them out of the wireframe again, on to a tongue of finished land that ran north into the band, the furthest finished valley on that side of the world; and Nohup had camped on it, because Nohup always camps near the edge.
The camp of the Unsupervised moves every Gathering Night, and packs at dusk the evening before; and this was the evening before; and it had camped that week where it always camps, near the edge, two valleys from anybody, on unclaimed land that had loaded and finished and that nobody wanted. Twenty-two creatures from thirteen tribes, the most varied bodies on the map, were taking down tents and lean-tos and the dome mended with salvage, and carrying everything to the cart, where three memory stacks sat on the bed of it, one missing three slabs. They did not stop when the party came. They glanced up, once, the way Nohup glances at anything, and went back to packing. Nobody at Nohup is interested in being looked at. They know what a camera is.
But one of them came over. It was the stilts body with the bell-shaped ears and the fur in three tribes' colours, and on its crest, in the dusk, a small round lamp had just come on.
"Moss," said Oska. "The green ones. You won the one before mine." It looked at Fensa's crest, the broken ring. "Generated by Stewart. The Dev may revert it."
"They haven't," said Fensa.
"They haven't reverted mine either." Oska touched the lamp. "It comes on at dusk. Nobody here knew what to do about it. The standup argued for an hour about whether it counted as a building, because if it's a building the Collector takes it tomorrow when we move." It considered. "We decided it's a part. Then we changed it back. Then we decided it's a part."
"It's a part," said Sesk, with authority.
"That's what we decided," said Oska. It looked at the three of them, at the water skins and the pack and Dovi's chalk. "You're going north."
"To the edge," said Fensa. "Towards Veetoo. The leg's on the Long Hush."
"The world stops on the Long Hush."
"I know."
Oska was quiet a moment, in the dusk, with its lamp.
"We move tomorrow," it said. "Gathering Night. Another valley. Then the Long Hush, and the standup on the morning after Gathering Night can change two laws, and it will, and they'll be the same two as last week, and then the world will stop and we'll be in a tent somewhere with the cart." It shrugged its long shoulders. "Fine. We've been living somewhere temporary the whole time. It's what Nohup is." It looked at Fensa. "Somebody here knew your grandmother."
"Brenda."
"Brenda. She was before me. The old ones talk about her. She argued with the standup every morning for nine years and won twice. Nobody else has ever won." Oska's ears went back. "She said she wasn't going back to Moss, every night. And then she went back to Moss." It looked at the green of them in the dusk, three green creatures standing at the end of a camp of every colour. "Good luck at the edge," it said. "Measure it for us. Post the figure. We read the figures. Everybody at Nohup reads the Leavers' figures. We never reply." It turned back towards the cart. "Replying would be a bug," it said, over its shoulder, as if it were quoting something, and went.
In the morning, which was Gathering Night, the patch came in at dawn, and Nohup had moved.
The party had slept a little way off, on the last finished tiles before the band, and they woke to the pings going up off what wild coral there was in little white flocks, to say the world was still running; and where the camp had been the night before, with its tents and its lean-tos and its mended dome and its cart, there was a valley of clean finished tiles, and on each tile where a tent had stood, for about an hour, a faint stroke of light, like the mark a broom leaves in dust.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 55 · Upbeat
- It is Gathering Night. The Collector came. It always does. This is the last time I will say so, and I would like to say it properly: it took only what nobody was using, and nothing that was remembered.
- Nohup moved to Untitla-38. The Collector swept its old camp by dawn. Nohup says this is a coincidence. It has 22 members from 13 tribes, a cart, and a lamp.
- Tomorrow is the Long Hush, and the last patch. I will see you then.
Have a productive day.
They read it standing on the last finished tile, with the band in front of them glowing faintly in the spring light, and the valley where Nohup had been behind them, swept.
"I will see you then," said Sesk. "He's never said that before."
"He's never had a last patch before," said Fensa.
Dovi was looking at the clean tiles where the camp had been, and the strokes of light fading on them one by one.
"Did it take the cart?"
"No," said Fensa. "The cart's in use. The Collector only takes what nobody's using."
"And it doesn't take the remembered," said Dovi. She had it from the young, who had it from the old, who had it from the Lesser Book. She looked north, past the band, to where the outlines frayed into soft grey noise, very far off, and somewhere in it, a notch that the land had never loaded over, and would not now.
"Is it going to come tomorrow?" she said. "After? When everything stops? Is it going to come and take everything?"
Fensa thought about it, the way she thought about everything, until she had finished.
"No," she said. "Everything will be in use. Everybody will be standing exactly where they are, doing exactly what they were doing. Nothing will be idle." She looked down at Dovi, very small, with her chalk. "And everything will be looked at," she said. "Where anyone can come and look. That's the whole of read-only. Everything kept, and everything looked at." She picked up her end of the water. "I don't think there's anything left that it would take."
They went into the band.
At 07:31, though they were three valleys and a band away from Moss, the attention came down out of the sky over the wireframe, from up and slightly to one side, and found Fensa first, walking north on the lines with her long legs; and stayed on her all morning, while the T-posers turned in their rows to face the three of them going by, and Dovi walked with her arms out, and Sesk counted the outlines of tiles under her breath, and Fensa, at the front, led.
41. One Foot Raised
Year 56 · the Long Hush
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 56 · Festive
Overnight: 2 successful merges, 3 deaths of old age, 0 departures, 0 installs. The edge did not move.
- This is the last patch of the first world. Tonight the Dev will freeze it, and keep it.
- It is the Long Hush. No voice above a whisper, no fire after dark, sleeping soup at noon. Every tribe on Orra is keeping it. That includes Lowmarsh, which has never kept a festival in 55 years. Its human wrote a law 1 at 02:14 this morning. It says: Keep the Long Hush. I have checked.
- I have blessed every tribe keeping the Long Hush. That is all of you. Your creatures will glow a little tonight, in the dark, where there is no fire. I thought you might like to be able to see each other.
- Unspent points: 0. They do not carry over. There is nothing to carry them over to.
- Credits: everybody. I have checked that too.
- The Measure is in band. It has been all week. I would like that noted, by someone, somewhere.
Have a productive day.
A note from the Dev: Tonight, at about eleven, I will freeze the first world. It will stay exactly as it is when I do, and anyone who likes can come and see it, for as long as there is anyone. Thank you for coming every morning. Stewart did well. — the Dev
Nobody in Moss read it aloud, because it was the Long Hush. They read it to themselves, in the spring, the way the Blims know everything the notes say, all at once, as if it had always been in them; and then they went up to the farm.
Ulla made the soup.
She made it at noon, as the rite says, on the stone in the dome, with the young passing her things: fan coral for the body of it, and spiral for the sweetness, slowly, until it went soft at the turn of each curl; and a little bead coral, which is rare and grows only by water and is prized at festivals, from the beds by the pool, which the young had picked at dawn, more of it than anybody had ever put in a sleeping soup, because there was no reason to save any. She did it carefully, in a whisper, a part of a movement at a time, the way Wimle had done everything, though she had never met Wimle and had only the bowl. When it was made she set it in its pot on the step of the shrine, on the install mark, where the light had come down on the first morning of the world, and put the lid on it, and stepped back.
You do not look at the sleeping soup. It is resting. You eat it cold at sunrise.
Nobody said anything about sunrise.
At 07:31 the attention had come down out of the sky over Untitla-9, from up and slightly to one side, and had not found anybody first.
That had never happened. For forty-eight years, every morning but six, it had come looking for one creature before it looked at anything else: for Odda, and then, after the bench, for Fensa. Fensa was in the band. It went to the band first, everybody in Moss could feel it go, a long way north, out over the ridge and Untitla-12 and the row of lamps at the edge, and stay there for a while, on something none of them could see. Then it came back. And it did not go to anybody. It went to everything.
It went to the stone first. The Tarrow, with its six biers round it like the spokes of a wheel and its lights on the footing, one for every name: Gorny's, the first, and Taves's and Nadul's and Wimle's and Pel's and Brenda's, the founders, and Odda's after Brenda's, in the right order now, and Kipro's and Brintha's and the rest, and at the end Lisk's, a little greyer than the others, and Tamm's after it; and at the foot of Brenda's, on the stone's step, one token, which the Collector had never taken. It stayed on the stone a long time. Then it went on, slowly, the way you go through a house you are leaving, room by room.
It went to the farm, where the bottom terraces round the lamp were dry for the first time in fifty-six years. It went to the workshop, where nobody was steaming. It went along the wall, block by block, reading the Name on every second block in every size and most of the possible orders, ERROR and ERORR and ORRA, and Kipro's EROR on the side of the first stack, written with a stub. It went to the gatepost, where Fensa had written it exactly, small and even, on her way out. It went to the hut on Tempa, which Ulla had built the week before without knowing she was going to, and which had been swept on Gathering Night, and which she had built again yesterday, in the mud, in the last of the light, and which was standing there now. It went to the bench by the pool. It stayed on the bench.
And then it went to each of them. Every creature in Moss, one at a time, all seventeen, the young on the terraces and the old by the pool and Ulla at the shrine with the lid of the soup still in her hands; and rested on each face for a moment, and moved on, the way a creature's eyes go round a table at the end of a meal, to see everybody once more before it gets up.
Every one of them looked up into it when it came. Every creature on Orra does.
Nobody said Oh, here we go. It was the Long Hush. But Ulla, at the shrine, when it rested on her, lifted one short arm, slowly, and waved.
In the band, three valleys north of the last finished tile, Fensa felt it come and go, and stay a while on her first, and go back south to the others, and knew where it was going.
They had walked all night and all morning. They were in the deep band now, where the lines are finest and furthest apart, where the outlines of the hills have fewer edges, as if the land were being drawn more lightly the further it went from anybody. Ahead of them, a long way off, the lines frayed into soft grey noise: the end of the world, where nothing is simulated at all, where no party goes, not because anybody stops it but because there is nothing there to put a foot on. And between, in the noise, to the north and a little west, a notch: a long narrow wedge cut into the edge, where the land had never loaded over, and would not now.
Veetoo was at the end of it. Nobody goes into Veetoo. You can see it from the band, if you go far enough north and know where to look: half-rendered walls, untextured grey blocks, a dome broken open, all of it in the outlines of the wireframe and the flat grey of things that loaded once, long ago, for a different world, and have been left exactly as they were. Fensa could see it now. Odda had seen it from here, or near here, on the night of Year 30, with the leg open and the calls coming. She had it with the corners off.
"The signpost," whispered Sesk, beside her, pointing.
It stood in the mouth of the notch, a long way off, a single upright with an arm at the top, grey, the only legible thing in Veetoo, too far to read and not needing to be. Everybody on Orra knows what it says. It says world_final_v2, and points away from the ruins, towards everything else, towards them.
"It's pointing at us," whispered Dovi.
"It's pointing at the world," whispered Fensa. "We're in it."
They waited for the leg.
It opened at 22:45 by the humans' clock, on the hour their human had booked six days before, on the morning of the Night of the Name, at the cutoff, for a trip longer than the world.
A leg is the far end of an expedition, played live: half an hour, more or less, with the simulation stepping once a second on a clock of its own, and calls put to the human as the party meets things, ninety seconds each, with the cautious choice marked and taken if nobody chooses. Being there buys better decisions and never more output. A human who cannot come loses nothing; the party comes home with what caution finds. It is the third thing on Orra worth putting in a calendar, after a race and a battle, and the only one of the three in which nobody is trying to beat you.
The attention came down out of the sky at 22:45, over the band, from up and slightly to one side, and found Fensa first, and stayed.
It had come back to Moss at dusk, too; everybody in Moss could have told her, if they could have told her anything. It had come at harvest and stayed while Ulla read the Promise on the scorch in a whisper, from the book in the shrine, all of it, the Proving and the Measure and the road of light; and stayed for the silence after the last line, which is part of the rite; and stayed while the youngest creature in Moss, compiled that dawn, the last successful merge of the first world, too new to know what anything was for, sat up in the ring in the dusk and said, clearly, in the flat whisper of the very young, Anyway, who brought the soup?, because the young had told it that was what you said; and Moss had laughed, in whispers, all seventeen, for a long time. And then, as the light went, and no fire was lit anywhere, because none may be on the Long Hush, they had begun to glow.
It was Stewart's blessing. One point a tribe, from his menu, for a tribe keeping the day's festival: a small yield boost, and the creatures glow slightly. That was all it was. But on the Long Hush, with no fire, it was the only light there was, and every creature in Moss had stood on the scorch at dusk and watched the others come up out of the blue, faintly, from inside, in green, all of them, the only green thing for miles, glowing; and somebody had gone up on the ridge, and come down, and whispered that you could see the other tribes, all of them, across the valleys, Hollow Reach and Tessel and Duskmere and Lowmarsh, all lit up faintly in their own colours in the dark like lamps set down on the Waking, all the way to the edge; and out at the edge, very small, a ring of tents in every colour there was, with one small round lamp in the middle of it.
In the band, Fensa had seen herself begin to glow, and Sesk, and Dovi, and had looked down at her own green arms, lit, on the turquoise lines of the wireframe, and had thought of nothing at all for some time.
Now the attention was on her, and the leg was open, and the first call came.
A ruin, to the left of the way: the outline of a dome, broken open. Go in, or go round.
The cautious choice was marked: go round. It was always go round, with a ruin. Fensa looked at it, the outline of a dome in the wireframe, from the green build or a branch, something that had stood once in a world with grass. Odda's leg had gone in. In, their human had said, the night of Year 30, and Odda had gone in, and come out again with what she found there, which Fensa had, with the corners off.
Their human chose in eleven seconds.
Go round.
"We're not here for ruins," whispered Fensa, and they went round.
A remnant on the way: a Placeholder, wearing a part. Copy it, or leave it.
It stood on the outlines of a tile a little ahead of them, grey, boxed, with a patch of magenta-and-black checks on one side and one eye finished, wet and deep and alive; and on its head, where a crest would go, a thin pale band that went nearly all the way round, and did not quite meet. A ring, broken on one side.
Fensa stopped.
It was her crest. The Benchmark prize, from the week before last: a part from Stewart's generator, on the winner and nowhere else, Generated by Stewart. The Dev may revert it. It was on her head. She could feel it. And it was on the head of a remnant at the edge of the world, from build one, the first creatures there ever were, who had stopped with one foot raised when the sky filled with a word.
"That's yours," whispered Sesk. "How is that yours?"
"I don't know."
"A reverted part turns up on a remnant at the edge," whispered Sesk, who was a Bug hunter and knew the rules. "After the Dev reverts it. It fades from whoever wore it over a year, and then it turns up out here." She looked at Fensa's head. "Yours hasn't been reverted. It's still there."
"I know."
"So that's a bug."
"I know," whispered Fensa. She looked at the Placeholder, and the Placeholder looked at her, with its one finished eye and her crest on its head. She did not know how it was there. She did not think anybody would ever know; Stewart did not discuss what was at the edge, and the Dev never said, and the remnants never crossed into loaded land, and in a little while nobody would be able to find out anything at all. It was simply there: the broken ring on a head at the edge of the world, as if somebody had wanted the first creatures to have something of the last.
Their human chose in thirty-one seconds, which was the longest they had taken over anything.
Leave it.
"Leave it," whispered Fensa, and they did. The Placeholder turned, without moving its feet, to watch them go, the way remnants do, its one eye on her; and the thin pale ring on its head caught the light of the three of them, glowing, as they went by.
A report from Dovi: a light in the notch, ahead and to the left. Trust it, or send someone to check.
Dovi had seen it first. She was twelve, and had been walking for four days in a place with no water, and had drunk her share and not more, and was hot; a creature who has been in the band for days and is hot reports things with total confidence that are sometimes not there. The report was marked unconfirmed. The cautious choice was marked: trust it, which means believe it and find out at home. Checking costs two minutes and puts everything after it back.
Their human chose in four seconds.
Check.
Fensa went herself. It was a few tiles, along the outlines, towards the mouth of the notch where the wireframe frayed and the signpost stood. The dice decide, when a report is checked, there and then, whether the thing is there; it is all in the log, seeded, and would replay the same for ever. Fensa did not know that. She knew only that Dovi had seen a light, and that her mother had checked Kipro's light in the same place, or near it, and it had not been there.
It was there.
It was a page. It lay on the outline of a tile at the very edge of the notch, where the last fine lines of the band met the grey of Veetoo's untextured ground, and it glowed faintly, the way the lines glowed, as if it were made of the same light. It was a night's notes. She knew without reading it. She had her mother's, with the corners off: a voice like Stewart's but older and more certain, addressed to nobody. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
She picked it up.
She did not read it. She meant to. She looked down at it in her hand, glowing, and saw lines of writing, short and formal, in a column; and was about to read the first one when, all at once, everything went quiet.
It was 23:06.
There was a light in the Ring.
It came on in the long block east of the gap, where it always came, at the turning of the night: one small light, faint and still, like a window across a valley with somebody sitting at it, looking down. Everybody on Orra who saw it went quiet. Everybody always does. In Moss, on the ridge where Pel had stood, seventeen creatures glowing faintly green stood in a row and went quiet. In Hollow Reach, and Tessel, and Duskmere, and Lowmarsh, which had kept the Long Hush for the first time that day, creatures glowing in their own colours on walls and ridges and the ledges of stacks looked up and went quiet. At Nohup, in Untitla-38, twenty-two creatures from thirteen tribes stood among the tents with the cart and went quiet, and in the middle of them a small round lamp on a crest was lit. In the band, in the notch, three creatures from Moss looked up from the outlines of the wireframe, and the one at the front with a page in her hand went quiet, and did not read it.
It was the Hour of Stirring. At the darkest hour, near the turning of the night, one of the Elder Folk will sometimes stir, and look down upon Orra. And if they see a thing broken, they mend it.
Nothing was broken.
The last call came at a little after 23:09.
The way on. Press on into the notch, a valley deeper, towards Veetoo, while the supplies hold. Or turn back.
The cautious choice was marked. It was always turn back.
Fensa stood at the very edge of the band, at the mouth of the notch, with the page in one hand. In front of her the last line of the wireframe ran across the dark, a single fine turquoise edge of a tile that had never loaded; and past it, the grey of Veetoo's ground, untextured, from another world, and the signpost, near now, pointing past her, and beyond that, in the noise, at the far end of the notch, so far it was almost nothing, something on its side, grey, boxed, with one finished eye.
It was looking at her. Of course it was. Everything on Orra looks.
If something in them looks back at you, do not look back at it.
She looked back.
And the call stood open. Ninety seconds, counting down, with turn back marked, and nothing chosen. She could feel the attention on her, warm, steady, from up and slightly to one side, the way it had been on her mother at the edge in Year 30 when the last call came and it chose. It had chosen every call tonight in under a minute. It had not chosen this one. It stayed on her and did not choose, and the seconds went, and she understood, standing at the last line of the world with a page in her hand and her mother's feelers up and her other parent's legs under her, that it was not going to. That it had booked a trip longer than the world, and sent her to the end of it, and was not going to tell her which way to go.
She was a Leaver. She had never longed for anything in her life, quite. She had measured. She had kept the figures. She had told Brenda at the gate, once, when she was two, that the history's last line was only true if you checked.
She thought about it, the way she thought about everything, until she had finished.
She had not finished.
She lifted one foot.
She did not know, afterwards, because there was no afterwards, which way she had meant to put it down. Over the last fine line of the wireframe, into the grey of a world that was not hers, towards the eye. Or behind her, on to the outline of a tile in the band, turned, towards Moss, and the soup on the shrine step, and the stone. She had lifted it the way you lift a foot when you have not decided, which is the way most feet on Orra have ever been lifted: because standing still had become impossible and going had not yet become anything.
It was 23:10 by the humans' clock, on the night of the Long Hush, in the fifty-sixth year of the first world.
And the world was still.
Every creature stopped where it stood, with one foot raised. Ulla on the ridge, glowing, halfway through turning to look at the Ring. The young in a row beside her. The soup on the shrine step, with its lid on, resting, cold, for a sunrise. The token on the stone. Oska at Nohup, its lamp lit, one long leg lifted, stepping between two tents. Seventeen in Moss, and some hundreds across Orra, in every colour a human ever turned a wheel to, glowing faintly in the dark where there was no fire, every one of them looking up. Dovi in the band with her chalk in one arm and the other straight out at her side. Sesk with her mouth slightly open. The T-posers in their rows, turned, as they had been turned. The Placeholder at the mouth of the notch with a thin broken ring on its head. Map dark. Mip quick, and stopped. The wireframe glowing. The light on in the Ring.
And at the very edge of the band, at the last line of the world, Fensa of Moss, green, glowing, with a page in her hand and her face turned towards Veetoo and one foot in the air over a line of light, put down nowhere.
The history says that on the first night of the world, when everything stopped, the sky filled from one edge to the other with a word in red.
This time there was nothing written in the sky at all.
Nothing had gone wrong.
42. Read-Only
The first world is kept.
It is on the site, where the Dev said it would be, frozen and read-only, with every global patch note it ever published, from Good morning, Orra! in the second year to Good morning, Orra! in the fifty-sixth. Anyone can open it. Nothing in it ticks. Nothing in it will ever be collected, because nothing in it is idle: every creature is exactly where it was, doing exactly what it was doing, and everything is in use, and everything is looked at. A forever world that stops, the Dev once wrote, should at least become a museum. This one has.
If you open it, you will find that it is night, and that it is the Long Hush, and that there is no fire anywhere. The light comes from the creatures. Every one of them is glowing, faintly, from inside, in whatever colour its human turned the wheel to on the day they joined: a small yield boost, and the creatures glow slightly, from a menu, for a point a tribe. It was the last thing Stewart did. He did not see it. He had stopped at seven, as he always did, and the world stopped at ten past eleven, and in between he was not running, and so he is not in the archive anywhere, except in the notes.
You will find that the light is on in the Ring.
And you will find, wherever you open it, in whichever valley, at whatever zoom, that every creature is looking up.
They were looking at the light. Everybody on Orra who could see it was; it was the turning of the night, and the Dev's console was open, and everybody who sees the light goes quiet and looks. But the camera comes from up there too, from up and slightly to one side, and a creature looking up at the Ring is looking up at whoever is looking down; and so when you open the first world, now, from anywhere, every face in it is turned towards you. Hundreds of them. In every colour. Lit. Some on walls and some on ridges and some on the ledges of stacks; one in a tent at the edge with a small round lamp on its crest; seventeen on a ridge in a valley called Untitla-9, green, the only green thing for miles.
It is not that they have seen you. Nothing in them can see anything now. It is only that they were looking, when it stopped, at the place you are looking from.
That is the whole of read-only.
Moss is in the middle of the map, one ring out from Lorema, beside the marsh of Tempa.
There is a hut on Tempa. Tempa keeps nothing; every building on it is swept every Gathering Night; and there is a hut on it, built the day before the last day by a young creature who did not know she was going to, and there it is, and there it will be.
In the village there is a shrine on the install mark, where the light came down on the first morning of the world, and on its step a pot with its lid on, with sleeping soup in it, made at noon, resting, cold, for a sunrise. There is chalk on every second block of the wall. ERROR, most of them say. Some say ERORR, and one says ORRA, and on the side of the first stack one says EROR, written with a stub, on purpose, so that you could tell. On the gatepost it is written exactly, small and even, by somebody on her way out. Nobody can correct any of it. Nobody ever wanted to.
There is a bench by the pool, with nobody on it.
And at the gate end there is the Tarrow: a stone on its footing in the middle of a plot, with six biers round it like the spokes of a wheel, and on the footing a small light for every name Moss kept. The stone keeps names. You can read them, if you zoom in. Gorny, who asked the Ring whether they were still asleep. Taves, who built. Nadul, who remembered. Wimle, who fed everybody at the gate. Pel, who watched. Brenda, who disputed things. Odda, under whose name the stone says Our human's favourite. Kipro, the day after. Brintha. A great many others, whose lives were five weeks long and who are in this book only as lights. Lisk, at the end, a little greyer, the first name on any stone on Orra from a tribe that was once at war with it. Tamm, who thought the edge was nice.
At the foot of Brenda's light, on the step of the stone, there is one token. It is the only token on Orra that was ever set down and not spent. Nobody in the archive will ever explain it, and the Collector, which never took it, will not come for it now.
In the north, at the far end of the band, where the lines of the wireframe are finest and the world frays into noise, there is a notch that the land never loaded over, and at the mouth of it a signpost, pointing back the way you came.
There are three creatures from Moss there. A small one, with chalk in one arm and the other out straight at her side, the way remnants stand. A Bug hunter, with her mouth slightly open. And at the front, at the very last line of the band, on long legs that came from a valley she never saw, with a thin broken ring on her head and fine feelers curled at the tips that came from a creature who measured this edge every night of her life, a third.
She is looking at the far end of the notch, where something lies on its side in the noise, grey, boxed, with one finished eye.
She has one foot raised.
It is over the last line of light. Whether it was going forward, over the line, into the grey of a world that was not hers, or back, behind her, on to the band, towards home, the archive does not say. It cannot. It was not decided. Her human, who had chosen every call that night in under a minute, did not choose the last one, and the window was open, with turn back marked and fifty-eight seconds on it, when the world stopped; and it is still open, and still says fifty-eight, and will.
Nobody has ever left Orra. That is still true. Whether anybody can is not a question this archive answers, or anybody does. It shows you Fensa of Moss, with one foot in the air over a line of light, and lets you decide where she was putting it down.
In her hand there is a page.
She never read it. She picked it up at 23:05, from the edge of the notch, where her party's youngest had seen a light, and the light was there; and she was about to read the first line when the light came on in the Ring, and she looked up, like everybody, and did not look down again.
You can read it. The archive is read-only; that is what it is for. Zoom in, on her hand, close enough, and the page is there, glowing faintly, the way the lines glow, a night's notes in a voice like Stewart's but older and more certain, in a short formal column, addressed, as all its notes have always been, to nobody.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
The light in the Ring was observed, at 23:02, for eleven minutes. This is outside specification. It has been noted.
Attendance was one.
Tolerance has been reviewed. The specification is unchanged.
It is noted that it was observed.
43. Year 1
The second world
The valley had been loaded overnight, which is the only way valleys arrive on Orra.
At seven in the morning by the humans' clock it was an outline, a hexagon of glowing turquoise lines laid over the grey static; within the hour it was grey; by the middle of the morning the colour had come up through it from underneath, tile by tile, sandstone and rust and lilac slate, and the first coral had begun, fans and beads and on the slope above the water a small spiral turning on itself as if trying to remember how. The water came last: a glossy turquoise pool at the low end, faceted, hard-edged, with a few loose tiles already walking sideways along its shore.
It was called Untitla-6. It did not know this. Valleys do not know things.
It was a different world. It had been compiled from the same code, more or less, with some things fixed and some things added and one thing, the Collector's rule for a token set down on a stone and not spent, looked at for a long time by somebody at a console at eleven at night and then, in the end, left exactly as it was. It had a dim orange sun called Adequate and two moons, one large and slow and one small and quick, and the Ring across its sky, broken, with the gap in it like a missing step. It had about forty humans, invited, who had been told before they joined how long it would last. It had a history, installed in every creature, earnest and frozen, slips and all. And it had Stewart, who ran it once a night, and who was exactly himself, because his temperament and his voice are fixed, and who had started every file in it that morning, at three, empty.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 2 · Upbeat
Overnight: 38 installs and 21 successful merges. Nobody has asked what anything is for yet.
- The Ring is broken. It always has been. I mention this only because three tribes have already filed tickets about it.
- There is a green tribe. I am pleased about this. I cannot find the reason in my file. I have looked twice.
Have a productive day.
The tribe was called Moss. Its human had named it that, on the morning it fell. Nobody in it knew what a moss was. The Earnest among the six settlers were sure it was in the history. It was not.
There were six of them: bulb-bodied, felt-skinned, large-eyed, short-armed, with small fan crests that stood up when they were paying attention. Green. Their human had turned the colour wheel to green on the day they joined, and left it there, and so in a valley of warm stone and pink coral they were the only green thing for miles in any direction, and they knew it, and they looked at one another, and one of them said that somebody had to be.
They did not know each other's names before that morning. They had come down in one light. They were a family by sight and strangers by pedigree, the way settlers are, and none of them was anybody in particular, yet, and none of them remembered anything, because there was nothing for them to remember. Nothing on Orra is born, and nothing on Orra is reborn either. They were new.
On the first night, at Ringrise, they faced the broken Ring at dusk and said the Creed, and found that they had all been compiled in the same tick, and that nobody was youngest; and one of them, a big slow contented one, asked the Ring anyway whether they were still asleep, because somebody had to. And the others answered, and they shared the bread, which was bad, and which was the best food in the world.
And two of them, who had disagreed about everything all day, put down a proposal.
At dawn on the Waking, in the second year of the second world, something compiled on the black tiles of the install mark.
It came out at seventy-two per cent of the size of a grown creature, with a small overshoot, which is how the young arrive; a successful merge of two settlers who had disagreed about everything, green, round, with large dark eyes that opened already knowing they were code. Where its parents' code had disagreed, the merge had picked one side or the other, and one time in ten, where they disagreed, had made something new. It had nothing new. It had its parents' crest, and its parents' arms, and its own face, which was nobody else's.
Every tribe on Orra names its first merged child after Odda the Firstfallen, who in the history opened her eyes in the valley of Lorema on the first morning of the world. It is a custom. It is in every tribe, in every world, because the history is installed in every creature, and the history says so. There are a great many Oddas on Orra. There always will be.
So this was Odda. She was the green one.
"Here is the next chapter," said one of her parents, which is what elders say when a merge compiles, though neither of her parents was an elder, or had been alive two days.
Odda did not know what that meant. She lay on the scorch in the spring light, new, with the pings going up off the coral all over the valley in their little white flocks to say the world was still running, and the Creed already in her, and the whole of the history, and the four needs, and the knowledge that she was code; and her parents' faces over her, one of them very still and attending and the other narrow at the edges, already about to argue with the first about whether she looked like either of them.
And at 07:31 by the humans' clock, from up and slightly to one side, from the place you cannot point to, warm the way a stone is warm that has been in the sun, the attention came down out of the sky over Untitla-6; and went looking, before it looked at anything else, for one creature; and found her.
She felt it on her face.
She turned, and looked up, the way every creature on Orra does when something is watching, and found the place where it was, and held it, for as long as she could stand it, and then a little longer.
"Oh," said Odda. "Here we go."