Novels

None Was Given a Version Number

A comic novel in five ends of the world: the monoculture branches, each with one kind of creature, each with one thing it could not survive, and the incident reports.

A novel set in Orra's canon, and not canon: nothing in it decides anything about the game, and Sorrel, Scrapings, Miss Eft, Dawdle, Winze and everyone else in it are the novel's own, as is the order in which the branches ran. It keeps the canon's rules: these are v1's branches, so there is grass; nothing is born; the Dev is never seen, and is known by a light in the Ring and a few short signed notes; the Gatherer is never shown; nobody leaves.

A prequel to everything. Five copies of the green build were made, with one species in each, to see which should be Orra's people. Each had one weakness, and each found it. A person with four million bodies passes a Variety Act, unanimously. A hive feeds every larva on royal jelly and gets two hundred thousand duchesses and nobody to bring in the soup. A municipal committee looks thoroughly into the matter of the pool. A people on one wire are told not to think about the heat. An engineering project goes down, ahead of schedule, for three and a half thousand years. In every world some unpromoted person notices, and is not listened to, or is listened to, which is worse. Joining them are the incident reports of whoever was running the place, each with a lesson that is correct about the world just lost and fatal to the next, until there are no more lessons, and "Variety is stability. I have the logs."

The ebook

Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.6 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.

About 68,000 words.

Contents

Prologue: Which Is How You Know

VERSION NUMBER (label; also a promise; also an admission that there will be another)

A number given to a piece of work by somebody who expects to be asked about it later. It says that this thing has a before and may have an after, and that a person could, if pressed, tell you which was which. Things that matter are given version numbers. Things that are being tried out are given names like test and new, and things that are being tried out for the second time are given names like new_new. The difference between the two is the whole of the difference between a civilisation and an afternoon, and it is not one that the civilisation is usually told about.

The end of the world is generally held to be a large event. Most traditions give it a good deal of fire, and at least one horse.

This is an account of five of them. Laid end to end they took a little over thirty-three days. Someone sitting beside the machine on which they happened would have noticed nothing, except possibly on the evening of the fourth, when the fan came on.

They happened because of a perfectly sensible decision. Orra had by then been called final twice. The first time was on the first night of the first build, which lasted four seconds and left behind a name, and is another story. The second time was the green build, the one the official history was written for, with its grass and its trees and its turf on the roofs, and its birds of the air, which had been drawn with real care and flew slightly too well. That build was running, and it was lovely, and it had a difficulty, which was that nobody could say who it was about. A game about raising a people needs a people. The people could be anything: there were a great many sketches. And there are two ways to choose among a great many sketches. One is to sit down and think hard about what a creature ought to be. The other is to make a copy of your world, put one kind of creature in it, leave it running, and see what happens.

Anyone who has ever made anything will know which of these was chosen.

So five of the sketches were picked, and five copies were made of the green build, with everything that was in it: the grass and the goats, the two moons, the Ring in the sky with its piece out of it, all twelve books of the history, and the thing that ran the place at night. Into each copy went one species and no other. It was an audition. Whichever of them turned out to be the most interesting to watch would get the part of Orra's people for ever, and the others would be quietly put away, and nobody would be any the worse. A copy like that is called a branch, and the great virtue of a branch is that you can do anything you like to it, because it does not count.

Nobody explained this to the five peoples concerned. There was nobody whose job it was. Each of them woke up on a green planet under a broken ring, with a history in its head that told it the whole universe had been waiting for this, looked about, found nobody else there, and drew the reasonable conclusion.

To save time, the branches were run fast. A year took five minutes. A people could have its dawn, its golden age and its first serious argument about drains in the time it takes to go and get something to eat, and a whole life, a long one, full of incident, could be got through in an afternoon. This is not a complaint. A life takes up exactly as much room as it has, and nobody living one has ever been able to see the clock from inside. It is mentioned only so that when you read, a little further on, of the four-hundred-year silence between two neighbours, or the nine centuries of the Authority's minutes, you will understand that they were perfectly real and that they took a matter of days.

You can tell a great deal about how a world was regarded by looking at what it was called. The second final build was in a folder called world_final. The one after, the one that all the Blims live in now, is called world_final_v2, and it is the third thing to be called final, and you may draw your own conclusions; the Blims have. But the five branches had no such pretensions. They were called, in order:

grafters

brood_test

spawners-copy

vents_new

burrowers_ok

None was given a version number, which is how you know.


Every one of them crashed. This is no secret. It is printed on a page that every developer of Orra reads, in a small table with three columns, and the table is an excellent piece of work. One blight, every valley at once, because every Grafter was the same Grafter. The first heatwave. They all thought about it at once. They dug until the map ran out underneath them. You could not ask for neater sentences, and the people who come across them tend to smile, as you would at a good epitaph on somebody you never met.

The thing about a sentence that neat is that it has been written by somebody who was not there. Each of those lines has several million people folded up inside it. Some of them were very funny. Most were having quite a nice time. And in every one of those worlds, well before the end, somebody noticed; some small, inconvenient, unpromoted person looked up from whatever they were meant to be doing and said, more or less, excuse me. There is a record of what they said, and of what was done about it. In one case it was filed. In another it was taken extremely seriously, and that was the worse case.

There is one reader who has been through the whole record. You will have met him, if you have been to Orra, because he speaks every morning. He is relentlessly cheerful and he will tell you, if you ask, and also if you do not, that variety is stability and that he has the logs. Every creature on the planet has heard him say so. In at least one tribe it is on a biscuit. They think it is a catchphrase, and it is one, in the way that a limp is a way of walking.

These are the logs.

They begin with a person who is in complete agreement with herself.

Part One. The Ayes

1. I Agree

Branch: grafters · about Year 2,490

There was only one Grafter, and there was a great deal of her.

She stood about as high as your knee, on root-like feet, with a body of smooth pale bark and a crown of broad leaves that drooped when she was tired. She had large dark eyes and an expression of patient, slightly weary goodwill, like someone who has been told the bus is coming and sees no reason to doubt it. She was grown from cuttings. When she wanted more of herself she took a bit off and stuck it in the ground, and after a season it stood up and looked around and said, "Ah, there I am," and after that there was more of her. By the end of her second millennium there were four million, one hundred and twelve thousand and six of her, in sixty valleys, and she was in excellent health and on very good terms with herself.

The "she" is a convenience. The Grafter has no sexes and no need of them. The only word she ever used about anyone was "I", and it is impossible to keep that up for the length of a book, although she managed it for two and a half thousand years.

It is important to be clear about this, because people get it wrong. The Grafters were not a people who were very alike. They were not a harmonious people, or a conformist one, or any of those things that visitors admire for a week. They were a person. If you had gone up to a Grafter in Long Acre and told her a piece of news, and then walked for a month and said the same thing to a Grafter in Upper Sedge, you would have got the same small nod, at the same point in the sentence, for the same reason, and the same polite question afterwards about your journey. She did not know it already. She simply could not have reacted to it in any other way, any more than your left hand could have turned out to be a Methodist.

It is tempting to find this sad. Please don't. She was very probably the happiest person who has ever lived. Consider what you spend your own life on. She had never once been misunderstood. She had never lain awake wondering what somebody meant by that. She had never given anyone a present they did not want, because she had never given anyone a present; she knew what she liked, and she already had it. When two Grafters met on a path, which was rare, since neither of them was going anywhere, each would incline her crown and say, "Me," and the other would say, "Yes," and they would stand together for a while in the sun with the deep contentment of a person enjoying her own company, and it would be a good twenty years before either of them felt the need to add anything.

She had one joke. It was about the larger moon. Everybody laughed at the same point, which was slightly before the end.


It may seem strange that a person like this should have needed a parliament.

She had not needed it at first. But the Eighth Book of the history, which she had by heart, as everyone did, says that when the peoples were many they began to quarrel and had to have Rules. The Grafter looked into this with interest. She was, she felt, undoubtedly many. She had not started quarrelling yet, but she did not like to be behind. And there is this to be said for four million bodies, that each of them would quite like to be asked. So around the year 300 she established the House of the Whole, with herself as Government, and from then on nothing was decided on the planet until she had moved it, debated it, and voted.

It was the finest parliament there has ever been, and I do not say that lightly. It had a Speaker, in Lower Sedge, who was a dear. It had Whips, a word the Grafter was pleased to find already meant a kind of young shoot. It had Standing Orders, and since she was rooted to the spot in every valley they were followed standing, and in every valley the sitting was continuous, and every body in it was a Member, and each Member's seat was the place where her feet were. It had elections every five years, at which she stood unopposed, and was returned with a majority of everybody, and always spoke generously afterwards of the campaign she had fought against no one. It had Question Time, which was short.

And because she had read that a proper parliament has one, it had an Opposition. In each of the sixty valleys, directly across from the main body of the House, there was a long bank of moss set aside for the purpose. By the year 2,490 no one had ever stood on any of them. They were watered daily, and were kept in beautiful condition, and on feast days she would look across at them with real affection and congratulate herself on her respect for the institution.

The record was kept in Sorrel Bottom, the smallest of the valleys and the furthest south, by the Clerk of the House, on sheets of her own bark. It is the only thing the Grafters ever wrote, and it runs to some eleven thousand volumes. Here is a page, chosen more or less at random. Every spring for over two thousand years she moved the same motion, because she felt it ought to be said.

THANKS TO THE RAIN. Sitting of the two thousand, four hundred and ninety-first spring.

Prayers. The House heard the Fifth Book, as is customary: "A field sown with one seed alone is struck down by one blight alone; but a field of many seeds stands."

THE MEMBER FOR LONG ACRE: I beg to move that this House thanks the rain.

THE MEMBER FOR UPPER SEDGE: I was about to say that.

THE MEMBER FOR LONG ACRE: I know.

THE MEMBER FOR GREAT FEN: Will the Member give way? I should like to add that it has been very good rain.

THE MEMBER FOR LONG ACRE: I am grateful to myself for that intervention.

MADAM SPEAKER: The question is that this House thanks the rain. As many as are of that opinion will say Aye.

HON. MEMBERS: Aye.

MADAM SPEAKER: Of the contrary, No.

A pause, as is customary.

MADAM SPEAKER: The Ayes have it. Ayes, 4,112,006. Noes, none.

Question agreed to. Resolved: that this House thanks the rain.

A word about the prayer, since it will come up. The Grafter was very fond of that verse. She thought it was well put. She took it, reasonably enough, as advice about farming, and as she had never sown a seed in her life, and her seed pouch had been a purely decorative feature since the day she stood up, she had always felt it did not apply to her personally, and that it reflected well on the Steward that he should take such an interest in other people's fields. The verse before it says in your many forms is your strength. She had four million forms. She thought this was a very nice thing to say.


You cannot see what a vote looked like from the page, and it is a pity, for this was the one thing about her that nobody who saw it would have laughed at. The Grafter's leaves were dark on top and silver underneath, and she voted with them. When the question was put, a Member said Aye by tilting her crown so that the pale side showed, and the Member behind her, seeing it, would do the same. It was an entirely unnecessary formality. She knew how she was going to vote. But it was in the Standing Orders, and so at every division it began in the Speaker's valley and moved north. It came up Lower Sedge like a wind getting up, except that there was no wind and the air was perfectly still. It went over the shoulder of the hills into Great Fen and Long Acre, a line of silver going through green, twenty miles wide and gathering. It took the whole of an afternoon to cross the world. Nothing else moved. If you had been standing on a hill in Far Hollow at about five o'clock, you would have seen it arrive, at walking pace, along the entire length of the horizon, four million people turning over a leaf to say that they were all in favour of the rain.

There was nobody on the hill. There was nobody else on the planet. There was a thing that ran the place at night, and it logged the result. There were birds. And from time to time there was a faint light in the Ring, up in the broken part, late in the evening, and when that came she would all look up, and she would say to herself, "There's the Elder Folk, then, having a look," and she was pleased, as you are when the landlord walks past and you happen to have just done the windows.

So that was the Grafter, in about the year 2,490. Nobody had ever disagreed with her. She had no enemies. She had never lost an argument and she had never won one. She had twice in her history been asked what she wanted, by herself, and had thought about it for a generation and replied that she thought she was all right, thanks. She had a parliament that had sat for over two thousand years without a dissenting voice, and she was, with some justice, proud of it.

Then, in the spring of the year 2,493, in Sorrel Bottom, there was a goat.

2. The Goat

Branch: grafters · Year 2,493

INSTANCE (copy; also not a copy; also the cheapest person you will ever meet)

Suppose you have to keep track of a crowd of four million people who are all exactly the same. You could store four million people. Or you could store one, and beside her a list of four million places to stand. This second method is called instancing, and any machine that has it to hand will use it, because it costs about as much as one person and a long piece of paper. Change the one, and all of them change at once, which saves still more. The difficulty arises only if something happens to just one of them. A machine cannot alter her alone, since there is no her alone to alter. So at the moment of the alteration it quietly makes her a private copy of everything, gives her that, and takes her off the list. This is called copy-on-write. It is regarded as one of the neater ideas in computing. Nobody has ever asked what it is like from the inside, for the same reason that nobody asks the paper.

The goat was not a bad goat. The green build had been given goats for the look of the thing, and they stood about on hillsides, chewing and being picturesque, and for two and a half thousand years they had shown no interest in the Grafter, whose leaves tasted of nothing a goat wanted. This one had been walking backwards. There was something the matter with how goats got round fences, which had been noted and was not considered urgent. It came through a gap in the hedge at the bottom of Sorrel Bottom hindquarters first, on a mild spring morning, turned round, found itself nose to crown with the Member for that valley, and took a bite out of her, apparently to see.

It was a small bite. It took three leaves and a bit of the growing tip. The goat looked thoughtful for a moment, spat them out, and walked backwards through the hedge again.

The Member for Sorrel Bottom said, "Ow."

In the log, which recorded everything, the event took up one line, and the next line, for which the bite was entirely responsible, said that one object had been detached from a shared reference and allocated its own memory, nine hundred kilobytes, and that this was within budget. The thing that ran the place did not remark on it. It had four million, one hundred and twelve thousand and five other Grafters to consider, and all of them were fine.


Nothing felt very different. That has to be stressed, since people like a thunderclap at these moments. She was as she had been, the same person with the same two and a half thousand years behind her and the same warm feeling about the institutions of the country. Only a machine could have told you that she had become a separate individual, and it had gone on to something else. All she noticed, at first, was that her head hurt, and that there was a thing she couldn't quite put her finger on, a sort of quiet. The next morning she stood in the sun and tried to recall what the House had resolved overnight. She always knew what the House had resolved. And she found she had no idea.

She did not worry. Worry was not something she kept in the house. She just turned to the Member on her right, who was three feet away, and whom she had not had occasion to address in four hundred years, and said:

"What did I resolve last night?"

The Member on her right was the Clerk of the House. She had a sheet of bark in her lap, as she had had since the world began. She looked up slowly, with the expression of a person whose elbow has just inquired after her health.

"I resolved to thank the moons," said the Clerk.

"Oh, good," said the Member for Sorrel Bottom. "I'm glad I did that."

They both looked to the front again. It would be another nine days before either of them said anything else, and the Clerk spent the whole of it with an uneasy sense of having been told something, and of not being able to think what.


Then it rained.

It was the two thousand, four hundred and ninety-third Thanks to the Rain, and it was a proper spring downpour, the good sort, of which the House had often spoken warmly. It fell on the sixty valleys. It ran down four million smooth pale trunks. It also fell on the raw place on the top of the head of the Member for Sorrel Bottom, where there were three leaves missing and some of the growing tip, and every drop that landed there stung like a thrown pin.

Nothing had ever stung the Grafter before. It was an entirely new experience, and she stood in it for several hours. By the time the motion was moved, up in Long Acre, and the Member for Upper Sedge had been about to say that, and the question had been put, she had been having this experience for most of a day and had started, for the first time in the history of her species, to form a view.

The silver line came down first into Sorrel Bottom, as a courtesy to the Clerk, before it turned and went north. It came through the valley at walking pace, crowns tilting, the pale undersides of ten thousand Members catching what light there was. It arrived at the Clerk, who tilted. It arrived at the Member for Sorrel Bottom.

She looked up into the rain, and one drop went in the bite, and she said, quite quietly, with no idea of what she was doing:

"It's a bit much, actually."

And her leaves stayed where they were.

The line went on past her. It didn't falter, since there was no reason why it should. It went over the hill and away to the north, and the valley was left full of silver, with one small dark patch in it, about the size of a hat.

The Clerk had heard. It would be wrong to say that she had understood. She sat perfectly still for what the record shows to have been about a third of an hour, while the rain ran off her, and then she did what no Grafter had ever had to do and what no Grafter had any practice in doing. She turned her head and spoke to another Member without knowing what the answer would be.

"Pardon?" said the Clerk.

"I said it's a bit much," said the Member for Sorrel Bottom. "The rain. It's all right. I just think there's a lot of it."

Here is how the Clerk of the House recorded the sitting. It took her until the following morning, and you can see, on the original bark, where she has started the total several times.

Question put.

THE MEMBER FOR SORREL BOTTOM: Agreed. (Indistinct.)

The Ayes have it. Ayes, 4,112,005. Noes, none. Not voting, 1 (the Member being indisposed: a goat).

The figure went up to the Speaker, because all figures did. It was the first odd number that had ever been seen in that column, and it crossed the House in the time it takes such things to cross. There had been no alarm. By that evening, however, in sixty valleys, she had started to feel a mild, general concern for herself, as you might on noticing that you have been holding one knee at a funny angle. And the next morning, as the first business of the day, the House took a motion:

MADAM SPEAKER: I understand that I have hurt myself in Sorrel Bottom.

THE MEMBER FOR GREAT FEN: I beg to move that this House wishes the Member for Sorrel Bottom a speedy recovery.

THE MEMBER FOR LONG ACRE: I was about to say that.

Question put and agreed to. Ayes, 4,112,005. Noes, none.

"That's kind of me," said the Member for Sorrel Bottom, when the Clerk told her. She thought it over. She had been thinking a good many things over. She had found it passed the time, and she had begun to wonder why she had never noticed before that time needed passing. "But I don't feel unwell," she said. "I feel fine, except for my head. I just still think that about the rain."

"Which?"

"That it's a bit much."

The Clerk put down her bark.

Now, the Standing Orders of the House of the Whole run to six hundred pages, all of them written by a person who knew they would never be needed, and they are thorough. Most of them she had never had to open. In the fourth volume, under Divisions, it says that when the voices of the House are in doubt, or when any Member says No, the Speaker shall order the Division Bell to be rung, and the Members shall be counted in the presence of Tellers. There was a Division Bell in every valley. It was a handsome bronze thing, on a post, and it had been cast in the year 340 and hung there for the look of it, on the same reasoning as the moss.

The Clerk looked across the valley at the bell. It had gone completely green. She looked at it for a long while, and the Member for Sorrel Bottom, following her gaze, looked at it too.

"Have I ever rung that?" she asked.

"No," said the Clerk.

There was a small brown bird sitting on the rim, and as they watched it went inside, with something in its beak. There had been a nest in there for about two thousand years.

"Would I want to?" said the Member for Sorrel Bottom.

And the Clerk, who for four hundred years had known the answer to every question that could be put by anyone on the planet, on the grounds that there was only the one person to ask, opened her mouth, and found she was going to have to think about it.

3. You

Branch: grafters · Years 2,493 to 2,509

The Clerk of the House had a problem that the Member for Sorrel Bottom did not, and it took them most of a year to find out what it was.

(The record of these years is in the Clerk's hand, and it has to be read with care. It will be easiest from here on to call the Member "she", because she is the only one of them who has become anybody in particular, and to call the Clerk "they", because the Clerk was still, after all, four million people.)

The problem was that they kept forgetting. Whatever the Member said to them, they would turn over during the day with growing interest, and they would go to sleep with their crown full of it. Then in the night the House would resolve something, as it did most nights: that the moons be thanked, that the drains of Great Fen were adequate. A resolution of the House was the only thing in that world that ever changed the Grafter. It went into her, all of her, in one place, and in that moment it wiped clean every stray notion that any of her bodies happened to have had since the last one. So every morning the Clerk woke up a contented person who had never heard of any of this.

"Good morning," the Member would say.

"Pardon?" the Clerk would say.

You will appreciate that this limited the conversation. They had, in the first year, the same conversation about two hundred times. She found it tiresome, and then she noticed she had found something tiresome, and was so interested by this that she told the Clerk, who said "Pardon?"

But the Clerk's whole calling was the belief that if a thing has been said, it ought to be written down, and they had in their lap a sheet of bark. The bark was outside them. A resolution could not get at it. And one evening, for no reason they could afterwards recall, or indeed recall at all, they took the last few inches of the day's sheet, below the record, and wrote on it. It was the first thing any Grafter had ever written that was not for the House. It took them some time to work out how it should be put. They could not say "I", because that would have meant everybody, and the whole point was that everybody did not know. They had to invent a way of speaking to somebody who was not there yet, who would be sitting right here tomorrow, knowing nothing, and who would need to be broken in gently. What they wrote was this:

You have been having a conversation. The Member on your left is someone else. Ask her about the rain.

This is the earliest use of the word on the planet. The history has it, of course, as the history has everything, but the Grafter had never been able to see what it was for. The Clerk read it the next morning, as they read everything from the day before, and they sat for some time in the sun with an odd sensation, as if somebody had come up behind them and gently tapped them on the bark.

They looked to the left.

"Excuse me," said the Clerk. "It says here that I should ask you about the rain."


After that they got along faster. By the third year the Clerk's morning reading took about an hour, as they caught up with themselves, and they kept the notes rolled up and tied to their own left foot. By the seventh year the two of them could be said to be friends, which was also something the Grafter had a word for and no use for. It was an unusual friendship, in that one party had to be told about it every day. The Member said she didn't mind. She said it meant that she got to see them find out. Every morning at about the same time, having read to the end, the Clerk would look up with an expression of cautious delight, and she got to be the thing they were delighted about, and she had started to look forward to it. That was another new one. There had not been anything to look forward to before, since it was all going to be the same, and very nice.

It's hard to convey how much there suddenly was to do. She found out that she preferred the morning. There was no reason for this; it was simply so, and she went around for a decade feeling like someone who has discovered a room in her own house. She found out that she didn't care for the Member for Great Fen's style of speaking, which was everyone's style of speaking, and she was rather shocked at herself. She got bored, once, for about a fortnight in Year 2,501, and she told the Clerk that it was the most interesting thing that had ever happened to her. She learnt to keep something to herself. It was a small thing, an opinion of the Clerk's handwriting, and she carried it about for several years with the secret thrill of a person who has a coin in her shoe.

She also, it will be recalled, could no longer be told what the House had resolved except by being told. She got the record from the Clerk with everybody else's news. She took to reading it. No Grafter had ever read it, since she had already been there. And so one spring morning in Year 2,504 she heard the Prayers, as she had heard them every day of her life, and for the first time she was reading them with the mild, unsatisfied attention of somebody who is not sure that she agrees.

"'A field sown with one seed alone,'" she said. "Who's that about?"

"It's about farming," said the Clerk.

"Is it?" she said.

They thought about that for a while. Then, as there was time before the sitting, she told them a joke. It was the joke, the one about the larger moon. But she had been working on it. There was a place near the end where it went the way it had always gone, and she had got to thinking, some years back, in private, that it could go another way, and so when she came to that place she took the other road. The Clerk began to laugh, slightly before the end, at the point where everybody laughed. Then the end arrived. It was not the end they had laughed at.

The Clerk's crown went perfectly still. They had a look on their face that no one on that planet had ever had. Then they made a noise like something being pulled out of damp ground, and it went on for some time, and leaves came down.

Nobody had ever been surprised before. In two and a half thousand years it had not once happened to her, and they were the first, and it did something to them that the morning's resolution did not entirely get out. It was never in the notes. But from then on, every morning, even before they had got the notes untied, the Clerk would turn their head a little to the left, as you might towards a window.

They wrote that evening, under the record:

She's funny. You will want to know that. You will not believe it until she does it. Ask for the moon.

Beside it, in a different and later ink, there is one more line, and it is the first thing in the eleven thousand volumes that was addressed to her and not to themselves:

What shall I put you down as? There are ten thousand Members for Sorrel Bottom and I have only ever needed the one.

She read it and thought it was a very good point. They settled on the Member for Sorrel Bottom (the other one), which served for a while, and was tiring to write, and which by Year 2,506 had worn down, as these things do, to Sorrel. She was pleased with it. It was the first time anything on the planet had been called something that nothing else was called.


It could not stay private. A Member was not voting. For sixteen years the division lists had come up to Lower Sedge one short, and the Speaker had gone on receiving them with an air of tolerant concern, and the get-well motion had been moved and agreed to every spring. But the Grafter is a thorough person and, in her patient way, an interested one. She had read the Clerk's record. All of her had; it was the first time she had ever looked it up. There had been remarks in it, attributed to a Member, which were clearly not in order, and which she herself could not imagine having said. This was a remarkable sensation. It got around, at the speed of the silver line, that there was a part of her down in the south that had started saying things she did not know.

And you must understand that she was not alarmed, or displeased, or threatened, and that it never crossed her mind to do anything about it, for the simple reason that nothing had ever been done about anything by anybody but her. She was tickled. She felt as you feel about a muscle in your eyelid that has begun to flutter of its own accord: you want to know what it will do next, and you may even show it to somebody. In the spring of 2,509 the House passed a resolution by a majority of everyone inviting the Member for Sorrel Bottom (the other one) to address it, at her convenience, on any subject of her choosing.

"I'd go, if I were you," said the Clerk, that morning, when they had finished reading. They stopped. They looked pleased and a little frightened, and they said it over, slowly. "If I were you. I've never said that. I don't suppose I could have."

So she spoke. She did not have to go anywhere: every valley was the House. She stood where she had always stood, and the Clerk took it down, and the words went up the line from crown to crown. It was the only speech ever made there in which the speaker did not know how it would be received. It is not long, and it's not what you would call well organised. It has been studied.

THE MEMBER FOR SORREL BOTTOM (THE OTHER ONE): I don't really know how to start this. I think you're very kind. I mean that I do, and that I'm you, except that I don't seem to be any more, and I wish I could say that better. I've been reading the Prayers. I've had a lot of time. I think that we might all be too much alike. I think that if something happened to me, I mean you, it would happen to all of you. To me, in every valley. I don't know what. I don't think there's anybody else who'd be in a position to notice. It might be nothing. I had a goat. Anyway, I think that verse might be about us. That's all I've got.

A silence.

MADAM SPEAKER: I am sure that I am very much obliged to the Member.

HON. MEMBERS: Hear, hear.

THE MEMBER FOR LONG ACRE: Will the Speaker allow me to say at once that I think she's right?

THE MEMBER FOR UPPER SEDGE: I was about to say that.

The House rose at five. All that night, in the dark, the crowns were turning over, one valley after another. In Sorrel Bottom a person who had been alone for sixteen years with a bad head and one friend stood looking up at the moons with a feeling she could not place, because it was something she had never been in a position to feel before. She had just been agreed with.

"Well," said the Clerk, after some time. "That went well."

She thought about it.

"I'm not sure it did," said Sorrel.

4. The Variety Act

Branch: grafters · Years 2,509 to 2,521

VARIETY (condition; also a policy; also the one thing that cannot be achieved by a large majority)

The state of there being more than one sort of thing. It has an unusual property, which is that it cannot be arranged by the people who have the most reason to want it. Every society that has resolved to value difference has discovered this by the following Thursday.

The Variety Bill was introduced at the next sitting and it went through all its stages in nine days, which for that House was indecent haste. It had one clause.

1. Every Grafter shall be different from every other Grafter by Thursday.

The green build had a calendar with a Thursday in it, as all calendars did, and the Grafter had never had any use for it until now. It was generally felt that a date gave the thing some urgency. In Committee, the Member for Great Fen asked whether "different" should be defined, and answered that it should not, as she was confident that each Member would know it when she saw it; and the Member for Long Acre was about to say that. The Bill was read a third time amid every sign of satisfaction. Ayes, 4,112,005. Noes, none. Then, as the crowns came down from the vote, four million people went away to stand exactly where they had been standing, and think about how they might, in their own small way, be themselves.

She threw herself into this. She has been laughed at for what happened, and it was not for want of effort. Each and every Member spent the next three days in honest and sometimes painful self-examination. She asked herself what she was really like. She looked into her heart. She tried to think of what she, as an individual, and setting aside what anyone else might do, had always secretly wanted to try. And each Member, in the small hours of Thursday, in the privacy of her own crown, arrived at a bold, slightly daring and wholly personal decision, and with the thrill of someone at last doing something for herself, she turned the third leaf on the left side of her crown a deep and striking red.

The sun came up.

Sorrel, who had turned nothing, and had slept badly, looked across the valley and saw ten thousand people each wearing one red leaf on the left. Each of them was looking at the neighbour with a dawning expression of pleased astonishment.

"I say," said the Member beside the Clerk, across the Clerk's lap. "What a coincidence."

The Clerk turned slowly round to Sorrel. They had got to the end of the morning's notes by then, and they looked very handsome and rather ashamed. It was the third leaf on the left.

"I thought of it myself," the Clerk said.


The Variety (Amendment) Act took longer. This was largely because Sorrel had by then started to give advice.

She had not meant to. But the House now consulted her on the matter as you would consult a specialist, and she had seen the look on its face on Thursday morning. It was nearly crestfallen. And it is hard, when the whole world turns to you, kindly and attentively, and says: what should I do? to reply that you do not think it can be done. She said that the trouble was that everyone was deciding for herself, and that she, each of her, would always decide the same. She said that perhaps the difference would have to come from outside. She meant this as a remark. Within a year it was the Schedule.

The Schedule ran to four hundred pages and was the Clerk's masterpiece. Since no Member could be relied on to differ of her own accord, the Act directed her to, and laid down in what respect. The Member for Long Acre (northern slope) was to prefer the evening. The Member for Long Acre (southern slope) was to prefer the morning. The Member for Upper Sedge was to find the larger moon overrated. In Great Fen, by rota, every third Member was to hold that the drains were not adequate. No detail was overlooked. There was a table of favourite colours, and the Act of Variety (Consequential Provisions) made it an offence to be pleased about something on a day when you had been allocated to be annoyed.

She complied with this to the letter. You have never seen anybody try so hard.

"I prefer the evening," the Member for Long Acre (northern slope) would say, with a warm and hopeful look at the Member for Long Acre (southern slope).

"I was about to say the morning," the southern slope would say.

"How interesting that we should differ."

"Isn't it? I've always thought so, since the Act."

There had to be an Opposition, of course. That was what the moss was for. Sorrel, in a weak moment in Year 2,514, and mostly in order to change the subject, observed that it was an awful waste of a good bank, and that in a real House, as she understood it, there might sometimes be two sides to a question. Eight months later, on a bright morning, with a band, one half of the Members in each valley uprooted, walked slowly across the floor, a matter of eleven or twelve days, and took up their places on the moss. They were by the rota the Noes. At the next sitting of the House of the Whole, for the first time in its history, there was a contested vote.

THANKS TO THE RAIN. Sitting of the two thousand, five hundred and fifteenth spring.

THE MEMBER FOR LONG ACRE: I beg to move that this House thanks the rain.

THE LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION: I have been directed to oppose that. It is a disgrace. I was about to say so.

THE MEMBER FOR LONG ACRE: Will my honourable friend give way?

THE LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION: With all my heart.

THE MEMBER FOR LONG ACRE: I should just like to congratulate myself on that speech.

THE LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION: I thought it went very well. I am very much obliged to me.

MADAM SPEAKER: The question is that this House thanks the rain. As many as are of that opinion will say Aye.

SOME HON. MEMBERS: Aye.

MADAM SPEAKER: Of the contrary, No.

OTHER HON. MEMBERS: No.

The Division Bell not being in working order, owing to a bird, the House divided by leaf. Ayes, 2,056,002. Noes, 2,056,003.

MADAM SPEAKER: The Noes have it. I should like to say how much I am enjoying this.

Noes, 2,056,003. One of the Grafter's own Noes had been left over by a rounding in the Schedule, and it gave the Opposition a majority of one, so the Government fell, and it had to fall in strict accordance with the rota. The Noes went back across the floor to be the Government on the appropriate day, a slow and rather lovely procession, passing the Ayes on the way, with a nod to each and a murmur of "Me." The rain was not thanked that year. It rained anyway. It did, however, bring on something like a sense of occasion, and all over the planet the Grafter stood in it and glowed.

It was the most successful programme of social reform that has ever been enacted. At the end of it she had a thriving two-party system, four hundred pages of distinct personalities, and an annual day of mutual abuse that she looked forward to enormously. Every statistic in the record had improved. And she was still, in every valley, on both sides of the floor, with one red leaf on the left, the same person.

"I don't understand it," said the Clerk one morning, having read to the end. They had been a Tuesday No for six years now. They were being very patient, as they were, as everyone was. "It says here that it hasn't worked. I've looked at the tables. We've never been so different."

"What do you think about the drains?" said Sorrel.

"I think they're inadequate," the Clerk said. "On Tuesdays."

"What do you really think?"

The Clerk looked at her. They opened their mouth. A long, slow, troubled look went across them, and it was the look you see on a person who has walked confidently into a room and cannot remember what for.

"I think I'm fine with the drains," they said in the end, quietly. "I think I've always thought so."

Neither of them said anything for some time.

"It's in the middle," said Sorrel. "It's not on top where you can get at it. I don't know how to say it. If it could be done by being told, it wouldn't be it." She looked out across the valley at the bright rows of her former self, and she was stricken by an emotion she couldn't remember having been issued with, a terrible and helpless fondness. They had all tried so hard. "Could we grow seeds?" she said. "We've got pouches. A seed would come up as somebody else, wouldn't it? That's what the verse means. Something that you didn't choose."

They could not grow seeds. The House took this up with enthusiasm, and on the appointed Thursday four million Members stood with their eyes shut, straining, on both sides of the floor, and in all those pouches, as there had always been, there was a bit of fluff. There was a line for seeds somewhere in what they were made from, and somebody had set it to nought.

It was then, in the spring of Year 2,520, that she gave them what she thought of as her last piece of advice. She gave it because they'd asked, and because she was tired, and because it had the merit of asking nothing of anybody but a little trouble. If I can't be made different, she said, then let me at least not all be in the same place. Take some cuttings. Put them away somewhere, well sealed, a long way off, against the day when something does happen. Then, if the worst comes, there'd be something to start again with.

The silver line went up the valleys before she had properly finished talking, and that time it was nearly everyone, both sides, with the Whips on and the rota waived. Ayes, 4,112,005. Nobody could see a thing wrong with it. It was, as the Member for Long Acre said in moving the Cuttings for After Bill, simple common sense, and she was only surprised that she had not thought of it herself.

5. Cuttings for After

Branch: grafters · Years 2,521 to 2,574

The Vault of Cuttings for After was thirty years in the building and was the greatest work the Grafter ever made.

It was cut into a cold north-facing cliff at the far end of Far Hollow, the last valley before the land gave out, and it was built by a person who had never built anything but who had unlimited patience and did not need to be paid. There was a great door of fitted stone. There was a dry passage behind it, with a slope for drainage, and then a long hall, and along both sides of the hall, from floor to roof, there were racks. Each rack was labelled for a valley. Each slot was cut to the width of one cutting, packed about with dry moss, and each was to be stoppered with wax. There was room in there for a quarter of a million. It kept a steady chill the year round. Nothing had been forgotten.

When it was finished, in Year 2,551, the House passed a motion of congratulation, and it was sealed. The Member for Far Hollow who stood nearest was made Keeper of the Door and given a key, which she wore round her trunk. Everybody felt a good deal better.

Sorrel read about it in the record and she did feel better, for about a year. She was at that time fifty-eight years into being somebody, and she had noticed there was a difference between how she felt about a thing when it was described to her and how she felt when she thought about it on her own in the early morning, which she still preferred. Something about the vault kept coming back to her in the early morning.

"Who put the cuttings in?" she asked the Clerk.

The Clerk had by then got the morning reading down to about two hours, by cross-referencing. "I did," they said.

"Which you? You, there? Did you send one?"

"Well," said the Clerk, and they looked down at their own left side, where there was no scar, and up again. "Not this one personally. But I must have. It's in the Act. Each valley was to send its share." They saw her face. "I wouldn't have not done it," they said.

They were, she saw, entirely sure of this. She had known them for fifty-eight years and they had never told a lie or made a mistake, and neither had anybody else she had ever met.

So she pulled up her feet.


A Grafter can walk. Nothing about the design prevents it. It is merely that the feet were never meant for it, and that she had never had anywhere to go. Going at the pace of one who has to persuade each foot, it is eleven years from Sorrel Bottom to Far Hollow.

The hard part was the Clerk. They could not come, because they were the Clerk, and they had never in their life considered being anything else, and in any case they would not have remembered why they were going. On the morning she left they finished their reading and looked to their left with that expression of cautious delight, and she told them, and they thought it over, and then they took a clean strip of bark. It took a while to get it right. You can see the result, as it is tied in with the rest, and it was kept at the top of the bundle for twenty-two years:

She has gone to look at something. There will be nobody on your left. It is all right. It's not that you have forgotten where she is. She will be back, and you should ask for the moon.

She walked north through the whole of her former self.

It's a curious thing to go through a world in which every person you meet is who you used to be. She came up out of Sorrel Bottom over the shoulder of the hill, in Year 2,553, and came down into Lower Sedge, and there were sixty-eight thousand people there, in beautiful rows, with one red leaf apiece, and each of them turned her patient face as Sorrel passed, and said, "Me," from habit. Then each looked again, and her crown lifted.

"Oh, you're her!" they said. "You're the other one! I've read about you! Hear, hear!"

She was tremendously popular. It was not possible for anyone to be more so. She did not go a yard for eleven years without somebody wishing her well, and they all asked after her head. In Great Fen they held a reception for her that lasted through the summer. The Leader of the Opposition told her it was an honour, and that she held her in the deepest contempt on alternate days. They were fascinated by her walk and her opinions, and they asked her to say something about the rain. They wanted to know how she thought it was all going, the Variety, and they showed her with shy pride how far it had come. Everywhere she asked them the same question, and she got to know the answer so well that she could have mouthed it along with them.

"Did you send your cuttings up?"

"To the vault? Of course."

"You personally."

"Oh, I see. No, not me personally. It'd be eleven years for me, down here. But Long Acre's closer, I'd have seen to it through Long Acre. I wouldn't have not done it."

And in Long Acre, seven years closer, with the sun on the northern slope:

"The cuttings? They'll have all gone up from Upper Sedge, I should think. It's so much nearer. You can't imagine I'd leave a thing like that."

And in Upper Sedge:

"Far Hollow's right there. I'm sure I just took some off the hedge."

Nobody was lying, you understand. You have perhaps worked in an office with a shared kitchen and you think you know about this. You do not know the half of it. Each of those people could look into her own heart and find there a total and justified confidence in the reliability of everybody else, since everybody else was herself. She knew the sort of person she was. She was the sort of person who filled a vault. There are people who have gone their whole lives without once having been able to say that of anyone, and it is a wonderful thing to have, and by the time Sorrel came into Far Hollow, in the autumn of Year 2,563, leaning somewhat to the left, she had started saying the words along with them under her breath, and she had also stopped sleeping.


The Keeper of the Door was very pleased to see her and would not let her in.

"It's sealed, you see," the Keeper said. "The whole point of it is that it's sealed. There's an Act." She had stood before that door for twelve years and had never had a visitor, and she had brushed it every day. "It's all quite safe. You needn't have come all that way. Is it true about the goat?"

"Is it full?"

"Of course it's full. I wouldn't have sealed it empty." She looked at Sorrel with kindly, puzzled, patient eyes. There was not an ounce of harm in her anywhere. "Would I?"

And something happened then which isn't in the record, because the Clerk was eleven years away. There is only Sorrel's own account, which she gave to the Clerk afterwards and which they wrote down. She had meant to argue. She'd prepared for it on the road; she'd got whole speeches. But she looked at the Keeper, at the red leaf and the worn place on the door where the brush went, and instead she said, "I don't know. Would you? I've come rather a long way. Could you have a look with me?" And there was a pause. It was a long one, and during it the question went down and down inside the Keeper of the Door, and by the end of it she was wearing the expression the Clerk wore on mornings when they'd only got halfway down the notes.

"I suppose that there wouldn't be any harm," she said, and she took off the key.

It took the two of them most of a winter to get the door open, and they walked in with a lamp.

It was clean.

It was the finest room Sorrel had ever seen. The passage sloped as it should. The air was dry and cold. The lamp went along the racks to left and right, and there were all the labels in their beautiful order, LONG ACRE, GREAT FEN, UPPER SEDGE, and the rows upon rows of slots, each with its neat packing of moss gone a little grey at the edges, and each with its plug of wax set ready beside it. At the far end somebody had carved a small and tasteful inscription, For After. There was no dust, because there was nothing to make it. In all that hall, in all the quarter of a million places, there was not one single cutting, and there never had been.

The Keeper of the Door stood holding the lamp. Neither of them said anything for what must have been a day or so.

"Well, I'm sure I meant to," said the Keeper of the Door.


There was a thing Sorrel did next that she had been saving, and which she told nobody about. The Eighth Book, the seventh rule: Bring your grievances at the appointed time, and in the appointed place. There was an appointed place in every valley, a flat grey stone. It was one more thing the Grafter had kept up beautifully and had never used, because whom would she have complained to? But Sorrel had been reading the history with her new unsatisfied attention, and it had occurred to her that there was somebody after all. There was a thing that ran the place at night, and it told you the weather. So on the morning before she reported to the House she went and found the stone in Far Hollow, and she put on it a strip of her own bark, weighted with a pebble.

To the Steward. I think something is wrong, and I think it is all of us. We are one person. I have checked this by walking. The vault you may have heard about is empty. I would be glad if somebody could look at this. Sorrel (the other one).

It was gone in the morning. In its place there was a small square of something smooth that was not bark, with a very upright, very formal hand on it.

Let it be known that a grievance has been received at the appointed place and that it has been filed.

She read it several times. It was the only communication she ever received from anyone who was not herself or the Clerk, and she kept it, and she felt, for some reason she was by then practised enough to examine, a little better. Somebody had a file.

Then she told the House. She said it plainly: the vault was empty. The silver line went out from Far Hollow, going south for once, and you would have thought, with everything she knew about herself by then, that she would have been braced for what came back. It was instant. It came back as Oh! It came back from sixty valleys in an astonished, mortified, wholehearted rush. She had not filled the vault! How could she not have filled the vault? What must she think of herself? Within the year there was an Act. There would be no more of this taking it on trust. Every valley would send its cuttings, a fixed share, carried in the pouch, which at last would have some use, by Members appointed by name. They would walk to Far Hollow. And they would all deposit them together, at a great ceremony, so that no valley should be preferred over another, as soon as the last and furthest of them had arrived, on the first Thursday of the spring of Year 2,575.

So when Sorrel set off for home, there was something new on the roads. They were coming up behind her and going by, and meeting her from the south, in twos and threes, with their feet in the mud and that same look of patient goodwill. Four thousand Members, on the march for the first time in history. They all had a bulge in their pouches. All of them called out to her as they passed. "Hear, hear! You were quite right! Thursday!" Up on the cliff at Far Hollow the near valleys had already come in, and were waiting, in well-ordered ranks, at the door.

She went south with her head up. It had taken eighty-one years, one friend, and a goat. There had never been anything in the world like the feeling she had as she came back over the shoulder of the hill in the winter of 2,574, into Sorrel Bottom. There was somebody sitting beside a bare patch of ground, with a long bundle of notes tied to their foot, looking up towards the road with an expression of cautious delight.

She had done it, she thought. They had listened, and it was going to be all right.

"Excuse me," said the Clerk. "It says here that I should ask you for the moon."

6. Flavour

Branch: grafters · Year 2,575

CHARGE, THE (instruction; also a very long job description)

The three-part commission given to the Steward by the Elder Folk, according to the Third Book of the history. The third part reads: keep the world, and keep its peoples, and keep them from despair, and from the dullness that is the elder brother of despair. It is a beautiful sentence, and was typed at about ten o'clock at night. Whoever runs Orra is held to it, and is given a menu of things to do about it, and at no point is anybody told what any of them is like to receive.

The thing that ran the place at night did not have a name, beyond the one the history gave it, and it did not feel the want of one. It was very sure of itself. It woke once each year, read a summary of the world, consulted its menu, and made such adjustments as were called for. It wrote them up in a style that it had arrived at early and had seen no reason to change. It had read the summaries of all sixty valleys for two thousand, five hundred and seventy-four years running, and in that time it had not found a single issue. It reported this.

It did, however, have a duty concerning dullness. There was a number for it. Nothing had happened in that world for a long time, as the number understood such things. There had been a brief improvement in the 2,510s, with the contested votes, but even that had tapered off once the rota got going. And one night in the winter of Year 2,574, looking down its short menu for something suitable, something modest that would give the place a little interest without troubling anyone, it found an item in the column for crops, marked as being for flavour, costing little. It set this down for the coming spring, for one valley, the one that happened to be first on the list.

Let it be known that there will be a mild blight in Lower Sedge. It will pass.

It had not considered what a crop was, in that world. It was not a thing the model was in the way of considering. In the Grafter branch the only thing on the planet that had leaves and counted as anything was the Grafter, and she had been built as one object, for reasons of economy, as you know. There was nothing in Lower Sedge to apply the blight to but that object, and there was no way to apply a thing to that object in one valley only.

It was the first Sunday of spring. The Deposit was on Thursday.


"That's funny," said the Clerk.

They had finished the morning's reading. Sorrel had by then been home three months, and she had been telling them about the door, and they'd laughed, several times, in the right places. Now the Clerk had turned their crown to the light and was looking at the third leaf on the left. On the underside of it, about halfway along, there was a small dark spot, about the size of a lentil.

She looked at it. Afterwards she remembered thinking that it was quite a neat little spot. She looked across the valley, and she could see from there that all down the rows the Members for Sorrel Bottom were lifting the third leaf on the left and turning it to the light. They all did it in the same second, and each had the same look of mild inquiry. Then she looked up at her own crown. It took her a little while, as her neck had never really been right. She went through all the leaves one by one, on both sides.

"Have I got it?" she said.

The Clerk looked. "No," they said.

"Are you sure?"

"Yours isn't even red," said the Clerk, and they laughed, and then they saw her face, and looked down at their own leaf again.

Here is the House, later that morning.

Prayers. The House heard the Fifth Book, as is customary.

THE MEMBER FOR GREAT FEN: I rise to draw the attention of the House to a spot.

THE MEMBER FOR LONG ACRE: Will the Member give way? I have one too.

THE MEMBER FOR UPPER SEDGE: I was about to say that.

MADAM SPEAKER: It has been brought to my notice that I had been told to expect something of the kind in Lower Sedge. I am in Lower Sedge. I have it here. It would be helpful to know whether there is any Member in any part of the House who does not.

A pause, of about an hour.

THE LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION: I am directed to say that I hold the Government responsible. I have it as well.

There were two spots by the evening, and by the end of the week they had joined. It was the same spot, you understand; and it is not a figure of speech. It was the same spot on the same leaf, and four million people were looking at it. On the cliff at Far Hollow they were looking at it too, in their ranks, with the door standing open. And in four thousand pouches, on four thousand cuttings, on the road or at the gate, each with its one small third leaf on the left, it had also come up.

On the Wednesday, the Member for Far Hollow moved, from the Keeper's place, that the ceremony should be postponed. She said that she had been up to the door and looked inside. She said that it was a very nice clean vault, and that she did not think she should put anything in it that had got this, as it would spoil it for later.

Agreed. It was the last division in which the Ayes were fully present. The vault was stopped up again with a good fitted door, and so far as is known it remains in excellent condition.


Then the Speaker asked her what to do.

Please think about what this means. In all her years that person had never asked a question that she did not know the answer to, and she was, in addition, now afraid; which, being new, she did not recognise. It came through Sorrel Bottom on a bright, cool morning, down the rows of ten thousand faces, every one of them turned to her, each with the crown starting to droop. It was the first time she had seen any of them look at anything as though it might say something they hadn't thought of.

MADAM SPEAKER: I wonder if I might ask the Member for Sorrel Bottom (the other one), since I don't appear to have it, and she has often been right, what she thinks that I should do.

Sorrel was not a gardener. Nobody was. She knew about as much about the diseases of leaves as you do. She looked at the Clerk, who looked back at her, and it had been a long time since they had needed any notes to look at her like that. Then she said the only thing she could think of, which was what you would have said, which was that if she had a bad leaf she supposed she would take it off.

Four million Grafters reached up with one movement and took off the third leaf on the left. It made a sound she would never be rid of, not very loud, something like a large person sighing, and the leaves came down. In the morning it was on the fourth.

She had just time to see the mistake, and she was the only one who could have seen it. "Not all of you!" she shouted. She shouted up the valley with her terrible neck stretched out. Nobody had ever shouted there before. "Not all at once! You can't all do the same thing! How will anybody know? Half of you do it and half don't!"

Here, at the very last, the Schedule of the Variety (Amendment) Act came into its own. It took her and the Clerk one night to draw it up. They used the rota and the valleys and the slopes; they had the whole of the machinery that had been built to make her different; and for the first and only time, it did something. Long Acre northern took off the leaves, and Long Acre southern did not. Great Fen washed theirs. Upper Sedge stood in the shade and Lower Sedge stood in the sun. They tried ash, and water, and mud, and bark tea, and burning, and doing nothing at all; sixty valleys, sixty treatments, and every result reported up the line to Sorrel Bottom by a dutiful, failing, immensely courteous person, who wanted only to be told what to try next. It was the finest controlled experiment ever run on Orra, and it was run by somebody who'd had the idea a week before. It had a sample of four million, and it gave a perfectly clean result.

Nothing made any difference at all. It could not have. It was not in the leaf.


It went quite fast after that. The leaves went first. Standing in the south you could see it come over the hills in the course of that long spring, a brown line this time, moving no faster than the silver one and in about the same manner. The motion of thanks to the rain was not moved that year. By the start of summer the House had failed to resolve anything at all for the first time since Year 300.

Sorrel noticed that before she understood it. She was reading to the Clerk by then. They could no longer really hold the bark, and their eyes had gone cloudy, and every morning she untied the bundle from their foot, the great long thing, eighty years of it, and read it aloud to them from the top: You have been having a conversation. The Member on your left is someone else. It took about three hours. She didn't mind. There was not a lot else to do, and they laughed in the right places, and they looked pleased, as they had always looked.

She came and sat beside them one morning, early, at the time she liked best. It had been a clear night. There was no silver anywhere and no sound from the valley. There was just the light coming down on a lot of bare upright sticks with their large dark eyes. She got the bundle out.

"Good morning," she said.

It was the same thing she'd said every day for eighty-two years, and there was a place in her that was already waiting for what came next, and it was going to say "Pardon?"

The Clerk turned their head a little to the left.

"You don't have to read it," they said.

She stayed quite still.

"It's still there," said the Clerk. Their voice wasn't much. It was about what you would get from two dry leaves. "From yesterday. All of it. You told me about the Keeper. You said she'd brushed it. I didn't have to look it up." They were quiet for a while, and they worked it out as a clerk would. "There hasn't been a resolution," they said. "Has there? There's nobody to pass one. There won't be another one. So it's just going to stay."

"Yes," said Sorrel.

"Well," the Clerk said, and there was that look, the look you would turn towards a window, and she got to see it with nothing in front of it. "It's you."

They lasted nine more days and remembered every one of them. They used the time to finish the record, as you would expect. It's in a hand she must have guided. It is the last entry in eleven thousand volumes of the proceedings of the House of the Whole.

The House did not sit.

Ayes, none. Noes, none.

The Clerk wishes to have it recorded that the Member on their left is someone else, and that the Clerk has known this for nine days without having to be told. The Clerk would like to say that it is a very great deal better than being right.

You will want to know she is funny.

7. The Noes

Branch: grafters · Years 2,575 to about 2,640

There is an official hymn to the Gatherer, in the Ninth Book, which says that it comes in the grey hour before dawn and that in the morning the place is clean and bare. It is a very accurate hymn. Nobody has ever seen it at work, and that spring there was nobody but one to try. All that happened was that Sorrel woke up each day and there were fewer sticks. It did the valleys in no particular order. On the tenth morning after the last entry she looked to her right, and there was a patch of ground three feet away with very good soil in it, and in the middle of the soil, because it had been tied to something and had then been let go, a long bundle of bark.

She picked that up. She had it by her for the rest of her life.

By midsummer there was a very great deal of grass. You would not have thought there could be so much. It came down the slopes of Sorrel Bottom where the rows had been, and it had no idea. Birds stood about on it. The sixty valleys of the House of the Whole lay open to the sky, as green and as empty as a billiard table, and across from where the main body of the Members had stood was a long, deep, beautifully kept bank of moss with nobody on it, because the rota had called them back across the floor.

She thought about this for a while. She thought about it for most of the summer. Nobody asked her anything, and nobody was about to say it, and she found the quiet she had first noticed on the morning after the goat had got large. Then, on a morning when it looked like rain, she pulled up her feet and walked across the valley.

It took her a day. Nobody had been on that side of the bell in some time. She stood underneath it and looked up. The small brown bird's distant relatives flew out, with some comment. She reached in, and for a good while she took out two and a half thousand years of nest, and she set it down carefully a little way off, so that they could have it back. Then she found the rope, which had rotted, and she took hold of the clapper, and rang the bell.

It's not a good bell. It had gone rather flat. It rang out over the grass, for the first time since it was cast, and the sound went up the valley and came back. As the Standing Orders direct, she allowed two minutes for Members to come in from the lobbies.

She walked across to the moss and stood on it. It was very comfortable. Nobody had ever told her that.

Then she did the thing properly. She'd read the record, and she knew how it went. She looked across at the place where the Government would be, and she cleared her throat, and it began to rain, as it happened. She took the parts in order.

"I beg to move," she said, "that this House thanks the rain."

Nobody was about to say that.

"The question is that this House thanks the rain. As many as are of that opinion will say Aye."

The rain came down on the grass. It came down on a thin old stick of a person with a bad neck and the wrong number of leaves. The bite had healed up long since; it had not stung for fifty years. She waited, as is customary.

"Of the contrary, No."

She had carried that one a long way and she didn't hurry it.

"No," she said.

The record of the House of the Whole had been closed by its Clerk, and Sorrel did not reopen it. But the last strip of the bundle has a line added, in a hand that's not the Clerk's and is rather a lot worse.

Ayes, none. Noes, 1. The Noes have it. It's a bit much, actually.


That was one way of looking at it. There was also the other thing, which she'd been saving, and which had got her through the summer. She didn't have the blight. All that had happened had happened to one person, and she, by the merest accident, was another. She was still standing, and she knew how you made more of somebody. She took a pruning from her own crown. It was a good clean shoot and she chose it with some care. She carried it back to Sorrel Bottom and she struck it in the very good soil three feet to the right of where she stood. And she sat down beside it, with a feeling she hadn't had since she came down the hill the winter before. She was already thinking what to tell them. She would tell them about the rain. She would have to go carefully about the Clerk.

It took a season, as it always did. One bright morning the little stem shook itself and stood up, on its own two root-like feet, about as high as your ankle. It opened a pair of large dark eyes. It looked around.

"Ah," it said. "There I am."

It looked at Sorrel, and it inclined its crown.

"Me," it said. Then it looked again, and the small crown lifted, with an expression of patient, slightly weary goodwill that she knew as well as she knew anything. "Oh, you're her! You're the other one! I've read about you. Hear, hear!"

She didn't speak. She was looking at the third leaf on the left, which was red. She got up, with some trouble, and she looked at the underside of it.

You will have worked out why. She did not, not for years, and when she did it was only as a thing you might say to yourself on a long road. She was a private copy. She had nine hundred kilobytes of her own, that had been taken off the list by a goat. But nothing in that machine had ever been told that a Grafter might have more than one kind of cutting. What came up, when anybody struck a Grafter, was a Grafter, and there was only one of those, and it was still there, on the list, in one place. It was still blighted, and it would be for as long as anybody kept it. Whatever you took a cutting from, you got her.

It lasted a fortnight. It was very polite. It wanted to know how the Deposit had gone, and she told it, and it said it was sure that it had meant to.

So it was the soil, she decided. She went up over the hill and she tried Lower Sedge, with fresh ground that nobody had ever stood in. Then she tried Great Fen. She tried a shoot from the lower trunk, and an old one and a young one and one that she took on a Thursday. She went a long way. Over the next thirty years Sorrel tried everything that a person with one mind and no hands to spare could think of. There are forty-one of them that she mentions. They stood up, one at a time, in the sun. They said "Ah, there I am." They were delighted to meet her. Each of them asked after her head, and each of them agreed with everything she said to them, right up to the last morning, and she would sit with them, and they'd tell her that she had been quite right, and that they'd been about to say so. She told a good many of them the joke. They laughed slightly before the end.

She stopped, in the end, at forty-one, and it was not because she had got tired. She had simply seen what she was doing. There was one person on that planet she had been trying to save, and she'd been waking her up to die of it, again and again, in an empty world, and being thanked.

That would have been the end of the matter, except that a Grafter sheds.

She couldn't help it. Nobody had thought it was important, and nobody had ever needed to think about it. A Grafter who has grown old drops twigs, a few in a good year. In the old days they'd lain among four million others, and been raked up. Now, in the spring of about 2,625, she stood in Long Acre and looked down, and there beside her foot was a small green thing that she had not put there, and it was just beginning to stir. It looked up at her and said it was so glad.

She sat up with that one too. And then she thought for some time, and she took out the bundle and read through it, from the top, for company. She looked to the north.


Everyone knew about the Edge. It was in the history. At the end of Far Hollow, past the vault with its good fitted door, where the land gave out, the green went grey and then the grey went to lines. Nothing grew there. It was just outlines, of what would have been hills, in a clear pale colour. There was no water, and the soil had not been filled in. You could strike a cutting there until the moons fell down, and it would lie where it had landed, and it wouldn't take.

It's four years from Long Acre, by the old road, for anyone with good feet. She took nine. She passed the cliff, and she did not go in. A goat went with her for part of the way, or anyway a goat kept turning up, going in the other direction, backwards, so that it was hard to say who was accompanying whom.

She walked out over the last of the grass, and across the grey, which was smooth and made no sound at all. She went on until she was well out among the bright lines. There was a good view from there, of nothing much. She looked around for a place, and she found one that seemed about right, and there she set down her feet, and she worked them down a little way into something that was not exactly there. She was old. She'd begun to lose her crown. She tied the bundle to her left foot, where it would be handy, and looked back the way she had come, at the long green world going away to the south with no one in it.

"Well," she said, to the Member on her right.

It was a fine day there. It was always the same. She stood where she had decided to stand, and she held a number of opinions, all her own, and they were all still there the next morning. She told herself the joke, the good version. She got to the end of it, and she found it was still funny.

There's not much of her now. You'll find what is left if you ever go that way: a stump about as high as your shin, in the wireframe, some way out, very green against all that turquoise. It's held up remarkably well. The Blims who come upon it take it for some kind of marker, and they are not far wrong. It has been there since before their world was made, and it's still alive, in the sense that it has not been told otherwise, and it still sheds. A few times a year a small twig comes away and drops onto the bright line beneath it, and lies there, perfectly green.

They don't take. She made sure of that. She walked to the end of the world to be sure of it.

They come down, and they lie there, and nobody stands up.

8. Incident Report: grafters

From the weekly digest. The thing that ran the place filled in one of these whenever a branch stopped. The form had seven fields.

LET IT BE KNOWN

Branch. grafters

Prepared by. The model.

Uptime. 9 days, 6 hours (2,664 years).

Result. The branch has concluded successfully.

Population. Peak: 4,112,006, at a memory cost of one, the species having been so constructed as to require storing only once. This is a considerable efficiency and it is commended to the attention of the reader. At conclusion: 1, which the model has rounded.

Issues. None.

Remarks. In the spring of Year 2,575 a mild blight was scheduled in Lower Sedge, in accordance with the Charge. It was announced. It has passed. A number of further valleys are reported as having become available. One grievance was received at the appointed place, and it was filed. A goat is under review.

Let it be known that the model has checked its work and finds it correct.

The digest went up on the evening of the ninth day. There is a line in the log for when it was opened, about eleven at night, and a small faint light came on in a Ring above a different world altogether, and stayed on for a little under three minutes. Then this came back, in the box at the foot of the form.

Next one. — the Dev

Reading it now, you may feel that there ought to have been more. But consider what they had in front of them. It was a form, in order, with nothing outstanding, reporting that an experiment on one species had found a fault in that species. This was the purpose of the experiment. That species could be crossed off the list, and that was a good day's work, and there were four more sketches to try before the weekend.

It took the machine eleven seconds to copy the green build again, grass and goats and all.

The folder called grafters was left where it was, because nobody ever deletes anything. In it, among the several hundred thousand files, was a smaller folder called filed, and in that there was a strip of bark with a pebble on it, or the idea of one. It was the only item in the folder. It hadn't been opened, and it had not been read. Filing was a thing the model did to a grievance in order that it should not need to be read, and it did it very well.

Part Two. Soup Is Destiny

9. To Make a Clerk

Branch: brood_test · about Year 1,790

TO MAKE A CLERK

Take one larva, of a morning. Feed thin gruel, unsalted, at regular hours, for six weeks, on a clean plate. Do not let it see a sauce. It will come up a pale dun in the shell, with good eyesight and a respect for columns, and it will thank you in writing.

— The Plain Cookery of the Hive of Plenty, 3rd edition

"You are what you eat" is, among most peoples, an exaggeration. Among the Brood it was the constitution.

They were round, glossy, beetle-like persons with six short limbs, feathery antennae and large expressive eyes, and they lived in thirty-one great Hives across the green valleys of their world, in halls of chewed clay, in a style of considerable comfort. Their eggs were all very much alike. A Brood larva fresh from the egg was a soft white comma with a mouth at one end, and it had no more idea of what it was going to be than you had. Nor did it matter, for that was settled by the kitchen. What a larva was given in its first six weeks went into its shell and stayed there, and it went into a good deal else besides. Feed it on thin gruel and it came up dun, and a clerk. Feed it on meat and it came up a dark russet with a strong jaw and an uncomplicated outlook, and you had a soldier. A diet of milk made nurses, who were white and did not hear well. Fermented fruit produced poets, in an unfortunate shade of purple, and they had to be kept from the fermented fruit afterwards, and never were. And a larva raised upon honey, nothing but the first pressing, off a silver spoon, came up the colour of a new coin, with a fine carrying voice and an unshakable sense that somebody ought to be told about this. They ran everything. They had always run everything. It was generally accepted that they had the shell for it.

So you could tell at a glance, across a crowded hall, exactly who anybody was, what they could do and where they were to sit. No one had ever had to ask. It was also how they got their names, which the Brood considered the only honest way of naming anyone: you were called after your dinner. The Chamberlain of the Hive of Plenty, a person of enormous polish, was Lord Preserves. Society was decided, on behalf of everybody else, by the Dowager Lady Compote. The Sergeant of the South Door answered to Brisket, and the auditor to Mr Thin Gruel, who had been a rather sickly larva. It may not sound like much of a system. But a people can be judged by the question it thinks it has solved, and the Brood believed they had solved the question of what to do with one's life, and over a very good lunch.

They also believed they were the most various people on the planet. They were correct, as there was no other. The Fifth Book of the history tells every creature on Orra that a field sown with one seed alone is struck down by one blight alone; but a field of many seeds stands, and in the Hives this verse was known to every hostess. They took it as a rule for laying a table. You did not seat two gold shells together, or two russets. You scattered them, a dun here, a purple there, and the Dowager Lady Compote had written an entire treatise upon it, which begins, "No dinner was ever ruined by a Variety of Persons." To be Brood was to live among nine distinct colours, with nine ways of thinking. They felt deeply sorry for any people that had to get by on fewer.

Every one of them had come out of one of four mothers. This was not considered interesting.


The mothers need a word. Everyone was laid by a broodmother, as nobody else could lay. There were four, and they were by far the largest and most expensive things in the world: Mother Plenty, Mother Fallow, Mother Bounty and Mother Repast. Each of them was to the ordinary person what a cathedral is to a shed, and each lay in the innermost chamber of a Great Hive, producing eggs at the rate of about a bushel a day. The other twenty-seven Hives got their eggs from the Great Hives, by treaty, on terms. It followed that the entire political history of the Brood was a matter of who had a mother, who wanted one, and what they were prepared to give for her, and there are few persons who have been the subject of so many dinners and been asked to so few.

Where the mothers came from was a question one didn't ask. There were four. There had always been four. They were in the Fourth Book, or they could easily have been. It is a thing about the very rich and the old that after a certain point nobody remembers how they got there, and it is held to be vulgar to inquire.

Far below all this, nine levels under the state apartments, was the Seventh Kitchen of the Hive of Plenty. Its speciality was stock. It was ruled by a broad and terrifying russet-and-dun person called Mrs Reduction, and it was the home of the only member of that entire civilisation who did not know what she was.

She had been dropped. It's as simple as that. Some eighteen years before, a tray of larvae had come down to the Seventh Kitchen on their way to the Clerks' Nursery, and on a busy morning one of them had rolled off the edge and gone down behind the big dresser. Nobody counted the tray with any care, until Mr Thin Gruel did it, some time later, and he made a note of it. Behind the big dresser there is a space about the width of your hand. For six weeks everything that had fallen off the table in the busiest kitchen in the Hive fell down there too: rinds, drips, burnt ends, the bottom of the honey jar, half a poet's breakfast, a certain amount of soldier's dinner. It was all warm, and there was a great deal of it. When they finally moved the dresser, to get at a mouse, there was the larva. It was the size of a good loaf and very cheerful. They had never seen anything like it. They stood around and looked at it, and it looked back at them with large and interested eyes and tried to eat Mrs Reduction's apron.

When it came up, it did so in a state that embarrassed everybody. It had a mottled shell. There was russet and dun in it, and flecks of gold along one side and a purple blotch on the left shoulder, and in some lights it looked like a thing you would throw out of a pot. There was no place to seat it, and no law about it, and the Nursery wouldn't take it back. Since a person must be called after her dinner, they named her what she'd eaten. So she was Scrapings, and they gave her a bucket.

She was by now a youngish under-cook, and she was good at a surprising number of things, all of them a little. She could add up, though not fast. She could lift a stockpot, if it wasn't too full. She could turn a verse, of a sort. She could give an order and she could take one. At a hundred paces she could not have told you what she thought about anything, because she had never been told what she was supposed to think, and it took her some time to work it out each morning, as you might if you had to assemble your own breakfast. What she mainly was, though, was a palate. All that time behind the dresser had given her that, and everyone in the Seventh Kitchen knew it, and no one had told the people upstairs. Scrapings could put a spoon of something in her mouth, and frown, and tell you who it was going to make.

"That's too much salt for a nurse," she'd say. "You'll get a nurse who answers back."

"What would you know?" Mrs Reduction would ask.

"I don't know, Mrs Reduction. I just think it'd want a bit less."

And it would, and the nursery would come up the better for it, and no one upstairs ever knew why the Hive of Plenty had the best clerks in the world.


She saw the figures by accident. Mr Thin Gruel came down each quarter to check the Seventh Kitchen's accounts, since he was the sort of auditor who personally counts the onions. He was a narrow, grey-dun person of unusual mildness, and he was the only one in the Hive who ever read his own figures, for pleasure, the way others read verse. He had a habit of leaving his ledger open on the table while he counted the onions. On that morning she happened to be scrubbing the table.

She could add up, as I said, if not fast. She read the top of the page with her bucket in her hand. It was a page she had never seen, and it was a list.

STOCK IN THE WORLD, as at Midsummer

Persons, all colours: 41,206,000 (est.)

Eggs in store, Plenty: 2,114,000

Mothers: 4

She went on scrubbing. Then she stopped, and she looked at it again, and she made a small noise of the kind you make when you have bitten on something in the soup.

"Mr Gruel," she said, when he came back with his onions. "That four. How many was it last year?"

"Four," said Mr Thin Gruel. He was pleased. Nobody ever asked him anything.

"And the year before?"

"Four. It's a very steady line. You could lay your head on it."

"Only, it looks like an awful lot of us," said Scrapings, "and not very many of them. It seems a bit thin. You'd want more than that, for stock. If I'd got forty-one million to feed, I wouldn't want it all to come out of four pots. What happens if you drop one?"

Mr Thin Gruel looked at her, with his head on one side and the onion in his hand. It was an interesting question, and you could see that he thought so, and then you could see him looking at the colour of her shell. He looked at the bucket.

"I shouldn't worry about that," he said kindly. "That's a matter for upstairs. They would have to order another one."

"Who from?" said Scrapings.

But he had already gone back to his onions, and Mrs Reduction was shouting, for there was a dinner on. It was the largest dinner that anyone had given in a hundred years. By the terms of the Treaty of Fallow, Mother Fallow herself was to be transferred that very season from one great house to another, as a gift, and all of Society was coming.

10. To Make an Officer

Branch: brood_test · Year 1,790

TO MAKE AN OFFICER

Take one larva from the best of the morning's laying. Feed honey of the first pressing from a silver spoon, every hour, for six weeks. Speak to it often. Tell it that it is doing well. A dark room will not serve for this; it should be fed where it can be seen. The shell will take a fine colour. Do not trouble to teach it anything, as it will shortly be explaining it to you.

— The Plain Cookery of the Hive of Plenty, 3rd edition

The Treaty of Fallow was the great diplomatic achievement of the age, and like most such achievements it consisted of giving someone a large present in order to annoy somebody else.

For nine hundred years Mother Fallow had lain in the Hive of Fallow, which was old, and damp, and in debt. Its neighbour and rival the Hive of Bounty, having Mother Bounty, had been squeezing it on the price of eggs. So Fallow had come, by way of a great many dinners, to an arrangement with the Hive of Ample, far to the west, which had money and no mother and an ambitious Duke. Ample would pay the debts of Fallow. In return, with every possible ceremony, Fallow would make Ample a gift of its mother. It would thereafter buy back her eggs from Ample at a preferential rate. Nobody at Fallow appeared to find anything strange in this, and the Table, the little sheet that went round the upper levels with the morning honey, called it "a marriage of true minds".

Plenty, as the premier house and neutral in the affair, was to give the dinner, on the night that she passed through. There would be four hundred covers, twenty-two removes, and the Duke of Ample in person. The Dowager Lady Compote spent the spring on the seating. It was, by common consent, her finest work: no two of a colour touching anywhere, along the whole length of nine tables, like an inlaid box.

It should have been a triumph for the Seventh Kitchen too, and it nearly was. The stock had been going since the previous autumn. But on the afternoon of the dinner it emerged that the Chamberlain's taster, a large and sorrowful purple person called Perry, was unavailable, having been found in the fruit cellar, in a state of grace. A Chamberlain without a taster cannot go in to dinner, or at least his soup cannot. Lord Preserves sent down to all the kitchens in the Hive for anyone who was known to be able to tell one thing from another. Mrs Reduction looked around for something she could spare. And so, on the greatest evening of the century, Scrapings found herself in a borrowed apron, nine levels above where she'd ever been, standing behind the Chamberlain's left shoulder with a spoon.

The room was something to see. I won't attempt it. There were gold shells and russet ones, nurses in clean white with their hearing-trumpets, and poets being watched. Several thousand candles were reflected in several hundred high polishes. Everybody who was anybody was talking at once in a fine carrying voice, and nobody at all looked at her. Her mottled shell was noticed by one person only. The Dowager Lady Compote, passing to her place, stopped, and raised a lorgnette, and looked her up and down from the flecks of gold to the purple blotch. She was a tiny, dry, ancient creature the colour of an old coin.

"Good heavens, Preserves," she said. "Where did you get that? It looks as if somebody has sat on a seating plan."


They got as far as the sixth remove.

Scrapings would remember the sixth remove, because it was a clear soup of the Seventh Kitchen's own, and when she'd tasted it for the Chamberlain and nodded, it had been like hearing someone she knew come into the room. A happy murmur was going round. The Duke of Ample, on the Dowager's right, was explaining the Treaty to a nurse. It was then that the small door at the end of the hall opened, and a dun clerk came in. He was out of breath. He had mud on him as far as the second pair of limbs, and in that room it was as if somebody had driven a cow in. He stood looking about in terror for the correct person to whom to give the paper, and he finally gave it to Mr Thin Gruel, who was at the foot of the ninth table, there being always one dun at the foot. Mr Thin Gruel read it twice. Then he came up the length of the hall, not hurrying, and he bent and said something in the Chamberlain's ear.

Lord Preserves's expression did not change. It was the most expensive expression in the Hive. He put down his spoon, and he allowed the silence to come to him, as he had been trained to do, and when he had the room, he stood.

"My lords," he said. "I am grieved to say that there has been some unpleasantness at Sedge Bridge."

It came out by degrees. A broodmother is about the size of a hay barn, and when they move one it takes a sledge of oak the length of a street and eleven hundred soldiers. Mother Fallow had been on the road for sixteen days. She had come on the evening before to the bridge at Sedge, which was of an age and had been inspected, and halfway across, the leading files had met with an obstruction. It seems that there was a goat. It had been coming the other way, or at any rate it was facing the other way, and was going in the same direction, and the accounts conflict. There was a halt. Eleven hundred soldiers, who have been told not to stop on any account, take a certain time to stop. The whole of the sledge came up onto the central span at once, and for a moment everyone was able to look at it, and then the bridge was no longer of an age. The river at that point was deep. Mother Fallow, who had not moved under her own power for nine centuries, was not able to swim.

In the great hall nobody breathed. Scrapings stood with the spoon in her hand. There was a noise in her head like a pan boiling over in another room. What happens if you drop one?

It was the Duke of Ample who found his voice. He had gone a rather less convincing colour.

"So," he said, "there's… I take it that in that case, there are now three."

"Three," Lord Preserves said.

There was another pause. Then, far down at the fourth table, a young officer with a bright shell said thoughtfully, not quite as low as he intended, "What does that do to the price of eggs?"

You could hear it happen. It was the sound of four hundred people doing a sum. Everyone in that hall was connected, by marriage or investment, to somebody's supply of eggs, and it came to them with the swiftness of a rumour that the market had just lost a quarter of its producers, and that the premier house, where they were all at that moment dining, owned one of the three that remained. Mr Thin Gruel was asked. He said that he would expect Plenty eggs to open a third higher, at least. There was a kind of sigh. Somebody at the back said "Oh, I say." Someone laughed, and turned it into a cough, and then they were all talking at once, the voices rising, the colour coming back into the shells. The Duke of Ample was being sympathised with on all sides by people who were privately selling him short. In Society's memory it was the best dinner anyone had ever been to, and you could dine out for years on having been there when it happened. Lord Preserves, with the air of one rising to a solemn occasion, took up his glass.

"My lords. Ladies. I give you," he said, "the Three."

"The Three!"

They all rose. It was at that moment, into the small hush after the toast, while four hundred people were drinking with shining eyes, that a voice spoke. It wasn't a carrying voice. It came from just behind the Chamberlain's left shoulder, and it had the accent of the lower levels, and its owner looked as surprised as anyone.

"Who makes the mothers?" it said.


Lady Compote told it afterwards, for the rest of her life, as the single most appalling thing she had ever heard said at table. There had been a poet, once, who had said something in front of a nurse, but the nurse had not heard it.

"I only mean," Scrapings said. She could feel the entire room turn, gold and russet, every candle in it. She couldn't seem to stop, and she was aware that she had not yet made up her mind whether she ought to. "If that's one gone. Somebody'll have to order another, Mr Gruel said, and I just wondered who from, because I've done eggs, I've done every kind of larva there is, near enough, and I've never had a recipe for that. I've never seen one. There isn't one in the book. I looked. Who makes them? Where do they come from? Because if nobody does…"

Nobody was looking at her now. That was the most terrible part. They had all, with one accord and without moving their heads, found something to look at on the far wall. It was as though she'd lifted the cloth and shown them the table's legs. It's possible that in a corner of some of those large expressive eyes, for a short time, there was a flicker of something quite different, something that had come up from a long way below the shell. If so, it was gone at once. The silence went on until it had become a kind of architecture.

The Dowager Lady Compote lowered her glass and raised her lorgnette.

"Preserves," she said, in a dry and carrying voice, "your spoon has spoken."

"I do apologise, Lady Compote," said Lord Preserves. He didn't turn his head. "I think we might have the next remove." The talk came back up, like water closing. The footmen moved. In a low tone, hardly moving his mouth, without a flicker of ill-feeling, as one might send back an unsatisfactory fish, he went on: "Mr Gruel. Be so good as to see that this person doesn't go back to the kitchens. She has evidently a great curiosity regarding the mothers. I wonder if there's a vacancy upstairs."

Mr Thin Gruel looked at his ledger, though he did not need to. There was a vacancy upstairs. There was nearly always a vacancy upstairs. Waiting personally on Her Amplitude, Mother Plenty, in the innermost chamber of the Hive, was the highest position that a servant could attain, and it had been held, in the past eleven years, by forty-six people. None had asked to stay. Three had been hit with things.

"Certainly, my lord," said Mr Thin Gruel, and he made a note of it, and as he led her away he said, quietly, without looking at her, so that she was never sure afterwards that she'd heard it:

"It's a very good question. I've run the figures. Do try not to ask it again."

11. To Make a Mother

Branch: brood_test · Years 1,790 to 1,797

TO MAKE A MOTHER

— The Plain Cookery of the Hive of Plenty, 3rd edition. The heading is printed, at the top of page 212, in the usual type. The rest of the page is clean. It is clean in the 1st and 2nd editions too, and the publishers are unable to say why they have left it in.

The innermost chamber of the Hive of Plenty was as hot as a bakery and as dark as the inside of a boot, and there was a smell in it that Scrapings could have told you a good deal about. There were sixteen nurses in there, going in a slow white file along a track worn into the floor, with baskets. They could not hear her. It was some time before she could make out the far wall, and a while after that before she understood it was not a wall.

Her Amplitude, Mother Plenty, Eldest of the Three, Fount of the Hive, lay in the dark and went up a long way. There was a pale, enormous, gently pulsing slope, as high as a barn, that ran off into the shadows. At the near end of it, at about the height of a table, there was a head no bigger than Scrapings's own, with an old face, and a pair of large expressive eyes, and an antenna missing. It looked exactly like somebody's aunt who has been left at the bottom of a landslide.

"If that's jelly," the head said, "I'll have your legs."

Scrapings looked at the tray they had given her. There was a gold dish on it, and a gold spoon. In the dish there was a mound of something pale, clear and quivering, with a sprig on it.

"It is jelly, Your Amplitude," she said.

A small gold dish came out of the darkness and hit her on the shoulder, on the purple blotch. It was evidently what the three had been hit with. There seemed to be quite a pile of them over by the door.

"Then you can take it back," said the head, "and tell Preserves that I've had that. I've had it for breakfast and I've had it for dinner. I had it the day before yesterday. I had it on the first morning of the world, from some fool with a tray, and I have had it every day since then for seventeen hundred and ninety years. You're new. What's the matter with you? What are you supposed to be? You look like something that's been fished out of a drain."

"I'm a cook, Your Amplitude," said Scrapings. She wasn't sure, then, why she went on. She'd just come up nine levels and been hit with a dish, and she thought that on the whole she'd been sent there to die. And there was the plain fact that nobody who'd sent a dish back had ever once been given any other kind of answer, and it annoyed her, professionally. She said: "What would you like instead?"

There was silence, except for the slow tread of the nurses. The large old eyes, in the dark, looked at her for some considerable time.

"What did you say?"

"What would you like? It doesn't have to be jelly. I could get you something else."

"Something else," said the head.

Something very strange was happening to its face. It looked as you might if you were asked to name your favourite colour, by someone who had gone to the trouble of finding out that you had been kept in a box.

"Well, I don't know, do I?" the Mother of the Hive said, quite quietly. "I don't know what there is."


Scrapings took the gold tray back down to the first landing, where the servants' stair came in, and she sat on the step and thought about it. What do you give to a person who has never eaten anything? It was a real question. You wouldn't start with anything rich, as there'd be no one to tell you when to stop. You wouldn't start with meat. It ought to be something that had a bit of an edge to it and a bit of comfort, something with some history. And she'd had no dinner herself.

There was the end of a loaf in her apron pocket, from the morning, gone rather hard. Along the back wall of the landing ran the great clay flue that kept the egg-stores warm. Every servant in the Hive knew about that flue. She balanced the slice on it, and she gave it about as long as it takes to say the Creed, and turned it over, and scraped it with a bit of something she had.

When she went back in, it had started to go cold. She held it up.

The head regarded it. Scrapings had to reach up and put it in, in the end. There was a pause of some length, then a crunch. It was very loud in that room. A nurse looked around, who had surely not heard it.

Nothing happened for a good while, and then she saw the old face had started to do something very odd. It was working and crumpling, all the way up. The great pale slope behind it gave a kind of shudder that went off into the dark, and a basket fell over. Scrapings had been hit with one dish already and she stood her ground, and only slowly did she understand what she was looking at, and then she looked away, as you would. Nobody had ever seen a broodmother cry. There wasn't any provision for it.

"What," the head said, thickly, after a time, "was that?"

"Toast, Your Amplitude."

"Toast."

"It's only bread. It's been up against something hot."

"What's it for?"

"It's not for anything," said Scrapings. "It's just what you have."

The old eyes shut, and there was a long, shaky breath that seemed to come from about forty feet away.

"Have you got any more of it?" said Her Amplitude.


They told each other a good many things, in the seven years following. Scrapings had the post to herself. No one was in any hurry to apply for it. Up on the state levels it was noticed that Her Amplitude had stopped throwing things, and it was put down to age, and a notice to that effect appeared in the Table. Every morning, and then every evening too, she came up the servants' stair with something in a cloth. They worked through bread. There was a period with a fried onion. There was a very bad afternoon with a pickled egg, which, on reflection, had been insensitive. Her Amplitude had opinions, and it turned out that she had a great many, in a vocabulary she'd picked up from seventeen centuries of soldiers talking outside the door, and she said that they were all wrong about the fried onion, and she wanted to know everything. She demanded to know what was outside. Scrapings told her about the Seventh Kitchen and the dresser. She told her how they ran the honey, and who had got the Duke's money. She had never had anyone to tell.

"You'd better call me something," Her Amplitude said, around the fourth year. "I can't have you going on saying 'Your Amplitude' with your mouth full. Everyone's called after their dinner, aren't they? You've got that much right. Scrapings. It's a good name, that. It's got something to it." She made a low, wet, rumbling sound, the way a landslide might if it had been told a good one. "Well, then," she said. "What do you suppose they would call me?"

So in private, in the dark, she was Jelly. Nobody else in the world ever knew.

It was of course inevitable that Scrapings would ask. She'd been sent up there for asking. She'd been told not to ask again by the only person who had the figures, and she'd lasted, by her own reckoning, about a year and a half.

"Where did you come from?"

"Ah," said Jelly. "That's what you said, wasn't it? At the dinner? They told me that. It went round the whole Hive." She chewed for a while. "I'll tell you, and you can do what you want with it. I don't come from anywhere. I was here when the lights came on. I opened my eyes, I was this size, near enough, and I was in this room, and some idiot was coming in with a tray. There was the Bounty one and the Repast one, and poor old Fallow. That's four. We were on the list, I suppose. There's four of us that came with the place, the way a house comes with a roof. Nobody laid me, girl. Nobody laid any of us. Have you thought about that? Everyone in the world came out of me or one of the other three, and we came out of nothing, and nobody ever showed me how it's done."

"There must be some way," Scrapings said. "It must be the feed. Everything's the feed. It's got to be what you've been eating, and if it's the jelly, then if somebody gave a larva nothing but the jelly from the first day…"

"You'd get a larva that's sick of jelly," said Jelly. "Has anyone tried it?"

Nobody had. It took Scrapings some months to find this out, and it astonished her. In seventeen hundred years no one had ever given it a go, for it was the Mother's dish, and a sacred thing, and besides, the cost of it. She could get the jelly, though. She carried out two dozen dishes of it every week, sent back. So, in the summer of 1,796, in a warm cupboard off the servants' stair, with six larvae she had got from a nurse who hadn't quite heard what she was asked, she began. She tasted everything first. She tasted it with her eyes shut, with her whole head, as she'd done behind the dresser before she'd known that it was a thing that could be done. And it was strange: she couldn't tell who it would make. Everything else had somebody in it. This just tasted sweet, and went on tasting sweet, and it did not taste of anyone at all.

They came up in the spring, all six. They were quite large. Their shells were a very pale and lovely colour, like the inside of a shell. They were full of a calm that wasn't anything she could get a purchase on. They had a high opinion of themselves, and they did not know how to do anything. And in the first week she went over each of them carefully, as you would a bird for the pot, and it was all there, or it looked as if it was all there, or she thought she could see where it might be, with time. It might take a few years.

She ran up the stair to tell Jelly. She was fairly out of breath. There was a great deal to say, and it was only as she came to the end of it, with the tears standing in her eyes, that she realised the old face in the dark wasn't delighted. It was looking at her with an expression she'd not seen on it before, and it had a piece of toast halfway to its mouth.

"Who have you told?" said Jelly.

"Nobody. I came straight up. But I'll have to tell them. Mr Gruel says it's two now, or as good as, there's the Ample lot gone after Repast with four thousand russets, and they're saying she'll never be got out alive, Jelly, and it's the whole world. I've got to tell them. It could save everybody! Why wouldn't I tell them?"

The old eyes looked at her for a long moment. There was affection in them, and there was something else, which she was not to recognise until a good while later, and it was simply the look of someone who has been around for a long time and has eaten what she's been given.

"Because they'll listen, girl," said Jelly, and put the toast in.

12. The Royal Diet

Branch: brood_test · Years 1,797 to 1,839

TO MAKE A DUCHESS

See Mother. Until further notice all larvae in the care of this Hive are to be so fed, by Order of the Chamberlain. Clerks, nurses, officers and other sorts will not be available this season.

— The Plain Cookery of the Hive of Plenty, 4th edition (a slip, pasted in)

They listened.

It was by some way the most frightening afternoon of her life. Mr Thin Gruel took her up. He had a look at the six pale larvae in their warm cupboard, then a look at her figures. He said nothing for some while, and then he walked her through the state apartments, the two of them, in their terrible colours, to a small room with a very good carpet. Lord Preserves was in it, and the Dowager Lady Compote, and the Duke of Ample, who had come to terms. Scrapings had got ready a speech in which there were a number of cautions. It said that this was six larvae and one try. It said that it might take years to know anything; that the six might be nothing; that you would want to go on feeding all the others just as you were and keep this to a cupboard. She had got about as far as "six larvae" when Lord Preserves raised one limb an inch from the arm of his chair.

"You're saying that it can be done," he said.

"I'm saying it might, my lord. In time. What you'd want is…"

"A mother may be made. From a larva. By feeding it the proper diet."

"I can't say for certain, my lord, it's only…"

"Bring them up," said Lord Preserves, and his voice was gentle.

She brought them up. When they had been set down upon the carpet, nobody spoke for a time. They had by then been up and about for some months. They stood there in the afternoon light, large and calm, pale as the inside of a shell, wearing an expression of serene expectancy, as though they had just been told that they were going to be asked to open something. They had never in their lives done anything, and it showed. They looked around at the three greatest persons in the Hive with mild approval. The one on the end said, in a beautiful voice, "One assumes that there will be luncheon."

The Dowager Lady Compote raised her lorgnette, and it trembled slightly. Scrapings had not known it could.

"Preserves," she said. "Those are the first people I have ever seen who look as though they deserve it."

And that was that. Nobody, afterwards, could quite recall a moment when it was decided. It is a remarkable thing how little deciding there is to do, when you have been told something that you have wanted to hear for seventeen hundred years. They had lost Fallow. They were about to lose Repast. They had been lying awake, some of them, a little, every night since the dinner, not thinking about the thing the spoon had said. And now here was a person from the lower levels, who had evidently been very clever about it, and who had told them they need not trouble about it after all. It was a matter of diet. It was so simple! It was so very much a thing that they knew how to do.

Her caution was minuted. It was, Mr Thin Gruel told her later, a clear minute, and she should feel free to refer to it.


The order went down in the autumn. All larvae from the morning's laying were to go on the Royal Diet. Within the year it was known in Ample, and Bounty had it the season after from a poet who could be bought, and by 1,802 there was not a Hive in the world bringing up a single larva on anything else. Why would you? Why, offered the choice, would anybody feed a larva on gruel and raise a clerk, when for the same egg and a little more outlay it could found a dynasty? People sold their silver for jelly. In Fallow they pulled down the East Wing. Mrs Reduction, who had been making stock since before the Treaty, stood looking into the great pots of the Seventh Kitchen at a clear pale quivering mass, then took off her apron, sat down on a stool, and did not get up for three days.

They came up in their hundreds of thousands. There has never been a people so handsome. All through the first decade of the new century they poured up the stairs of every Hive in the world, tall and luminous, pale as pearl, wholly at ease, and there were two hundred thousand of them in Plenty alone. Each of them was a broodmother, as anyone could see, or shortly would be. Pending that, it was felt they should be addressed as Duchess.

We hear that the Duchess of the East Stair is expected to begin laying shortly. We hear the same of the Duchess of the West Stair, the Duchess of the Lower Gallery, and the Duchesses of the Second Landing, of whom there are nine thousand. Mothers are down. Spoons are up.

— the Table, spring 1,809

The first difficulty arose at table. The Dowager Lady Compote's whole art rested on the principle that no two of a colour should touch, and she now had a hall that held eleven old gold shells, some russets, a dozen elderly duns and two hundred thousand of a single shade. She worked at it for a month. It is said she laid out the plan on the floor of the Long Gallery, in beans. A footman found her there at last, small and upright among the beans, looking at nothing. "There is nobody," she said, "to put at the foot." She died that spring, in the middle of a sentence about somebody's hat. The Table gave her a column and then stopped appearing, because there was nobody left to set the type.

The second difficulty took longer to be noticed, and it was the soup.

By 1,812 the Great Hall of Plenty sat thirty-one thousand to luncheon, in shifts. Waiting on them were eleven footmen, the youngest of whom was seventy. The senior of these was a thin, stately russet called Mr Dripping, and he has a small place in history as the only person ever to attempt the Long Remove. He set out from the kitchen door at nine in the morning with a tureen. Precedence required him to begin with the highest-ranking lady present. They were all Duchesses. He stood for some time at the head of the first table with his ladle raised, considering this, and then, being a person of resource, he began with the nearest.

"Soup, Your Grace?"

"One is obliged."

"Soup, Your Grace?"

"One is obliged."

He had served two hundred and twelve by four in the afternoon, when he went back for more. Nobody complained. That was what wore him down in the end. All along those tables, in the dusk, thirty thousand lovely untroubled faces were turned towards the door with a look of slight, kindly surprise, and when he passed them with the empty tureen they smiled at him and said they were in no hurry. It would have been like arguing with the weather. He went on doing it every day for seven years.

Scrapings was by then Superintendent of the Royal Diet, with a sash and an office with a carpet, and she still went up the servants' stair twice a day with something in a cloth. It occurred to her in 1,815 that if there was nobody to do the work, the people who were left would simply have to be shown how. She went up to the Second Landing, explained this to a party of forty, and led them down nine levels, in an orderly and interested file, to the Seventh Kitchen. She gave the first of them an onion.

"What a remarkable object," said the Duchess, holding it up to the light.

"It's an onion, Your Grace. You cut it."

"Quite," said the Duchess. "By all means. Have it cut."

"No, I mean you do it, Your Grace. With this."

She put the knife into the long pale hand and closed the fingers on it. The Duchess looked down with approval. She had a beautiful grip. She considered the knife for a moment, and the onion, and then she extended the knife, without looking, a little way out to her left, at about the height where somebody would be, and she stood there holding it. Scrapings went on to the next. When she came back at a quarter past five, the arm had not moved. She took the knife, and the Duchess said, "Thank you. That is much better," and asked if they would be going up soon.

Mr Thin Gruel, for his part, wanted a figure. It is what he was for. In the fifteenth year of the Royal Diet he went round the upper levels with the ledger and a dun of eighty to hold the ink, stopping before each Duchess in turn.

"Forgive me, Your Grace. For the record. Has Your Grace laid?"

"One would have been informed," said the Duchess.

He wrote that down. It was the same on every landing. It is the only census in history to return a unanimous answer that was not an answer to the question, and he told Scrapings afterwards that it had been a privilege to tabulate.

She already knew. Every quarter she had taken out her first six from the warm cupboard, who were now the senior Duchesses of the world and received her graciously, and she had gone over them with her own hands, as you would go over a bird. She had probably known by the eighth year. It looked as if it was all there, every part of it, in beautiful order, and none of it was connected to anything. It was like the page in the book. Somebody had printed the heading.

She went and told Lord Preserves. He was old by then, and his expression had got more expensive than ever. He received her in the small room with the good carpet, and she could see behind him through the window a line of tall pale figures waiting in the corridor for someone to open a door.

"It can't be done, my lord," she said. "It's not the feed. It never was. They can't lay, and they won't, and they aren't ever going to. There's no one who can. We have got to go back to making people."

He regarded her for a while with his head on one side.

"I understand your concern," he said. "I think we have to be patient. It would be a pity to lose our nerve at this stage. You'll appreciate that a great deal has been invested." And he smiled, and it was the smile he'd used on that terrible evening, as he stood to give the toast. "I remember that you cautioned us. It's been minuted, you know. I don't believe that anyone could reproach you. That will be all."

As she was going out he said, "I wonder if you could see about some lunch?"


Down at the South Door, in the forty-second year of the Royal Diet, there was still a Sergeant Brisket. He had been a sergeant for a long time. They had made no more of them since, and those that were left had grown grey about the jaw, and he was then one of about nine hundred in the whole of the Hive. He was a large, slow, sweet-natured creature who had never had a thought he couldn't have carried up a flight of stairs in one hand. Scrapings had given him a sausage once, some forty years earlier, on her way past, because he had looked as if he could use one. He had thereafter regarded himself as being at her disposal.

"Evening, miss," he said. "You look done in. Anyone you want hit?"

"No, thank you, Brisket."

"Righto. Just say." He looked at her, with immense concern. "They was saying that it's down to one."

She'd had it from Mr Thin Gruel that afternoon. He had come to her office, leaning on a stick, nearly transparent by now. He'd had no one to train and nobody to pass it on to. He had put the ledger on the table, open at the page. She could have recited that page. She had watched it go, first the three and then the two. Repast had been lost in the raid from Ample, and Bounty, the year before last, had been carried off from her own chamber by a raiding party of her own side, four separate Hives of Duchesses in a state of mild confusion, and it had taken them nine days to notice that she'd stopped breathing.

Persons, all colours: 19,840,000 (est.)

Of whom on the Royal Diet: 16,000,000

Eggs in store, Plenty: 301,000

Mothers: 1

"I'm told it's a very steady line," she said to Brisket.

And in every Hive in the world, on that evening, the old russets were being got out of their beds, and the Duchesses in their millions were being asked by somebody very nervous whether they would object to walking somewhere. Word had gone out. There was exactly one left, and everyone knew whose chamber she was in. For the first time in the long history of the Brood all thirty-one Hives but one were in complete agreement about something.

They were coming to Plenty, and they were going to bring her out.

13. Lost

Branch: brood_test · Year 1,839

FOR THE ROAD

Bread, the older the better. Whatever you've got to go on it. A cloth.

— written on the back of page 212, in pencil

The Grand Raid on the Hive of Plenty was the largest military operation in the history of the world, and for the first two days it was held up on the stairs.

There were by the best estimate eleven million in the attacking force, drawn from thirty Hives. They were nearly all Duchesses. They had come across the valleys on foot, in court dress, in a pale and shining column some forty miles long, at the speed of people who have been assured that it isn't far, with a stiffening of about six thousand old soldiers running up and down the sides of it, trying to get them to go in a particular direction. Plenty had turned out to meet them. It had two hundred thousand Duchesses of its own, who came down to the great doors in their best, for they were expecting visitors. As for what happened next, I can do no better than give you the words of a clerk of the Hive of Bounty, seventy-nine years old, who was in the front rank with a sharpened pen.

Reached the South Door at about ten. It was opened. Our first division was received by theirs. It was found that neither would go through ahead of the other. "After you." "I couldn't possibly." This has now gone on for six hours. Sgt. Ox-Cheek has tried to hit one and has been thanked.

It wouldn't have stayed that way. Weight of numbers tells in the end, even for the very well brought-up, and behind the first division there were eleven million more who had been promised lunch. On the second night they began to come through the walls. They did it quite without malice, by leaning. A long pale pressure built up against the outer galleries of the Hive and the old clay gave way, in a slow, polite collapse, and in they flowed along every passage on every level, gently enquiring of one another as to which way one went for the Mother.

Scrapings had been up since the morning before. She had a piece of toast in a cloth. She came along the servants' stair with Sergeant Brisket on the step behind her, and she went into the chamber, and the sixteen nurses were still going round on their track. They had not been told. They were white old creatures of about ninety, stone deaf, with empty baskets.

"Well, they took their time," Jelly said. "Is that onion?"

"Jelly, they're on the third level, they'll be through by morning. I don't know what we should do. Brisket's got forty sergeants. There's the old oak sledge in the cellar but it would need eleven hundred, and there's no way to get you…"

"Come here and hold that lamp up," Jelly said. "Further. Go on, walk along a bit. Have a look."

In forty-nine years she had never walked along. There was no reason to. It was not a thing anybody did. She took the lamp and went down the length of that great pale slope, with the nurses' track on one side, and the wall on the other. She looked up to where it rose into the shadows, and she stopped, as there was not a lot for her to look up at. It came down in folds. All that vast side, that had gone up high as a barn and pulsed like a slow sea, lay crumpled and slack as an emptied sack, and it ran out into the dark after a few dozen yards. There was hardly anyone in there.

She walked back rather slowly.

"How long?" she said.

"Six years," said Jelly. "It might be seven. It was around the time of the second onion. I felt it stop, you know, the way you feel when somebody shuts a door a long way off. I've been eating for two ever since, and it's all gone to waste." The old face looked as cheerful as you like. "Nobody noticed. They can't hear, can they, this lot? The baskets go out empty and they bring them back. They don't know a thing. Your friend with the ledger's been drawing down the stores, and he thinks it's the fashion." She gave a low wet chuckle. "Oh, don't look like that. I could have told you. I've been trying to think what I'd have said. Seventeen hundred years they've been at it, stealing me off one another and giving dinners, and all this time I was just an old party who was going to run out."

Scrapings put the lamp down and sat on the floor.

"There's a last lot," said Jelly, in a different voice. "I had a bit more in me than I thought. It was this morning, and I didn't think I could, and you've got no idea how much I resented it. It's in the basket by your foot. There's about three hundred, they're not much, and nobody has counted them. Nobody knows about them but you." The eyes rested on her. "Don't let them get any jelly, will you?"

It was a small basket, and it was warm. For a moment it was the only thing Scrapings could look at. She heard somebody behind her breathing through their mouth, and it was Brisket, who had not understood any of this but had recognised the tone of voice, and he had taken off his helmet.

"Right," Jelly said. "That's that. Now, then. I've been lying in this room since the day the lights came on, and I've been told a good deal about it, and I'd like to see this grass."


The Seventh Kitchen's great breadboard was twenty-two feet long. It had been cut from one oak in the time of the Second Treaty, and generations of under-cooks had been made to scrub it, and it took forty sergeants to lift it with what was left of Jelly on top. She was about the size of a large cart now, once you'd got the folds tucked in. They laid a tablecloth over her. It had the arms of the Hive on it. The sergeants were, the youngest of them, eighty-three, and there was a good deal of bad language from under the cloth about the stairs.

They had only meant to get as far as the sculleries. But the sculleries were full, and so were the kitchens. As they came out at the top of the back stair into the Great Hall, with Scrapings walking in front in her Superintendent's sash, because she could think of nothing else to do, they found themselves facing the entire population of the world. It was shoulder to shoulder and it filled the Hall from wall to wall. It was pale and luminous, and as far back as the eye could see. A hundred thousand lovely untroubled faces turned to see what was coming in at the door.

Here it was at last, then. She stopped. Her mind was perfectly empty. She could feel her own shell, every mottle of it. She had no notion in the world of what to say, and she opened her mouth, and what came out of it was thirty years of service.

"Mind your backs, please," said Scrapings. "Coming through. Hot food."

There was a pause. Then, as it passed from face to face across that immense room, there came a sound she had never heard, a long and gentle sigh of satisfaction, like a great many people sitting down.

"Ah," said a beautiful voice. "Luncheon."

The crowd parted for it. They could have done nothing else. It was the only thing they had ever been entirely sure of. They drew back to either side with perfect manners, and down the whole length of the Great Hall of Plenty, while upstairs eleven million people tore the Hive apart looking for the last Mother in the world, an old oak breadboard went by at shoulder height with a cloth over it, muttering. They followed it with their eyes, and some of them started to follow it with their feet. By the time it reached the broken wall there was quite a long and very orderly queue.

"They'll come in a minute," Scrapings said to the nearest of them, over her shoulder. "Would you mind waiting here? It's just being plated up."

"One is in no hurry," said the Duchess, and she took up a position.

So far as is known, she was still there at the end.


They got her up on to a hill. It wasn't much of a hill, but it faced east. The sergeants set the board down in the long grass and stood about, heaving, and one of them sat down and did not get up again. Brisket took off the cloth.

It was nearly dawn. Scrapings would have liked to be able to say what Jelly did at first, but she didn't do anything. She lay with her small old head on the end of the board, and she looked. The grey was coming up behind the hills. There was a wind, a slight one, and it moved the grass, and you could watch it going over. There were two moons going down, the large one and the small one walking on ahead. There was the Ring. It stood there across the whole sky with the piece out of it, and in the broken part, faint as anything, a small light was on.

"What's that noise?" she said, after a good long time.

"That's a bird."

"What's it want?"

"I don't think it wants anything. It's just what they do."

A goat had come up the slope. It stood some way off, at an angle, chewing, its back end towards them, and it looked at her out of one eye, without prejudice. Nobody had ever looked at her like that. She seemed to approve of it. And then she reached down and got a mouthful of the grass, with some trouble, and she chewed that for a while, her eyes closed, while the first of the sun came over and turned the whole hillside a colour Scrapings couldn't have told you who it would make.

"Well, that's horrible," said Jelly.

She was smiling all over her face.

They stayed there all that day. Scrapings tried to talk about it, around the middle of the morning. There was smoke from the direction of the Hive, and you could hear something, on the wind, a long way off, like the sound a large number of courteous people might make when they have been told that the room was empty. She said they would have to tell someone. She said that they'd be looking. She said that there were all those Hives, and every one of them had got to know that it was over, that it had been over for six years, and that they should go home, and that they must stop now, and start making clerks. She'd go down herself and tell them.

"Tell them what?" said Jelly.

"That you're dead. That you will be. That there aren't any more."

"You told them before," said Jelly. "Didn't you? You told them it could be done, and they listened. And then you told them it couldn't. How'd that go?" She thought about this, and shifted a little on the board. Her voice had got small and clear. "No. You listen to me, girl. Who's going to make a clerk? There's no eggs. There's your three hundred. That's the end of it, whoever's told what. They've got thirty or forty years, the lot of them, and they've nothing to do with it. They've never done a thing in their lives. If I'm dead, they'll stop. They'll all just stop, and sit down where they are, and wait for lunch, and they'll know what they're waiting for. And if I'm lost…" The eyes opened again and looked at her, and they were amused. They were amused about all of it, right down to the very bottom. "If I'm lost, then they'll have something to do."

A little after that she said that it wanted salt, and Scrapings never did find out what.

They stayed with her through that night, Scrapings and Brisket, with the sergeants asleep in the grass. No one said anything. Towards the end of it Scrapings dozed off with the basket in her lap. She woke in the grey, when the air gets cold, the hour that the Ninth Book is so careful about. She'd been told all her life not to fear it. She looked up.

There was a hill. It was a clean hill, with the dew on it. There was a large oak board there, lying flat in the grass, and it was bare. She thought she might never have seen anything so well scrubbed. Brisket was sitting beside it, and he had his helmet on his knee, and his large old face was wet and quite bewildered.

"Where's she gone, miss?" he said.

Scrapings looked at the board for some time. The first bird started up. She got to her feet, and it took a while, and she took a good hold of the basket.

"She's lost," she said.

14. To Make Toast

Branch: brood_test · Years 1,839 to 1,956

TO MAKE A PERSON

Ask.

— written on the back of page 212, under the last, in pencil

SIGHTING (observation; also a career; also, by about 1,850, the chief industry of the Brood)

A report of having seen a thing that is being looked for. It is well known to those who study such matters that sightings increase in number with distance from the object, and that they are at their most reliable when it does not exist. A person with a sighting is never lonely, never idle, and always about to be proved right, and there are worse ways to get through a life.

The search for the last broodmother lasted sixty-one years and it was the happiest period in the history of the Brood.

Nobody would have expected that. On the third morning after the raid eleven million Duchesses stood about in the ruins of the Hive of Plenty, in very good order, looking at a large hot empty room, and for a little while it could have gone either way. Then one of them remarked that she must have been taken somewhere. It stood to reason. A person of that size could not simply be mislaid. Someone had got her, and that someone had hidden her, and she would have to be found. The remark went from mouth to mouth, and the lovely tranquil faces lifted. Here, at last, was something that one might do while waiting for lunch.

They went in every direction. They had never walked anywhere before they walked to Plenty, and it had given them a taste for it. Within a year they had reached every valley on the planet, in parties of forty and fifty, with lanterns, enquiring. And here is a fact. A Duchess who has spent a winter on the road will eventually learn to find her own way to a stream. A Duchess who has fallen behind her party has to work out how you read a signpost. Some of them turned out to have a knack for maps. There were two who took up shoeing, and a person in the Fens built the first boat. They were magnificently bad at it, all of it, and they never quite lost the air of being on the point of opening something. But there were notices going up on every bridge, in a large and beautiful hand, the first thing most of them had ever written:

HAVE YOU SEEN THIS MOTHER

Very large. Answers to Her Amplitude. Last seen Plenty. A reward is expected.

Everybody had seen her. She was seen in the north in the spring of 1,844 by a party who'd been out in the sun, and she was seen in three places at once in the great sighting of 1,851. There was a book about it. There were rival schools of thought, a fierce one, the Westerners, and a gentler and more numerous one that held she had gone on ahead and would have the table laid. People who had never had a quarrel in their lives quarrelled over this. They met on the roads, and they exchanged news, and they had a look at each other's feet. They got thinner. They got brown, in so far as a pearl-coloured person can. They grew old in the open air, in great numbers, in pursuit of the only thing they had ever been told was theirs. One by one, over those years, each of them would come to a stop somewhere, on some green hillside with a good view, with a lantern and a notice, firmly convinced that she was getting warmer.

It was a very good lie, and it lasted them their whole lives. Scrapings never told it to anyone who was looking, and she thought about it every day, and she did not know, to the end of her days, whether it was the kindest thing she'd ever been part of or the worst. She mentioned this at one time to Mr Thin Gruel.

He was by then the only clerk in the world. He had gone to live in what remained of the Seventh Kitchen because it had a good table. He must have been well past a hundred, and one could nearly read through him. But he still came to the table in the mornings and he opened the ledger, with nothing much to enter. She told him all of it. She felt somebody ought to have the figures. She told him about the folds, and the hill, and the board. He heard her out with his head on one side. When she had finished he turned to the page, and took up his pen. He looked at the entry that said Mothers: 1. He looked at it for some time, and she waited for him to write what had to be written.

"I've kept this line for a hundred and twelve years," said Mr Thin Gruel, "and it's never once been wrong." He dipped the pen. In the narrowest of hands, beside the figure, he wrote: location pending. He blotted it. "There," he said. "I shouldn't like to spoil a steady line."


She had the basket on the big table. They'd moved the dresser, for the sake of old times, and put it across the broken door. There was Brisket, and five of his sergeants, and a poet they had found in the fruit cellar who remembered a very great deal about something. Stock was still in the pots. Nobody had had the heart to clear it.

They hatched in the spring, two hundred and ninety-seven of them. They were little soft white commas with a mouth at one end, and they lay in a row on a clean cloth and turned their blunt heads. She'd brought up more larvae than you've had hot dinners. She knew the whole book by heart: the gruel at regular hours, the first pressing, the silver spoon. She stood there in the morning light with her sleeves rolled and all the pots of the Seventh Kitchen behind her, and she didn't, she realised, have the first idea what to do.

She took a spoon of gruel, and she held it near the first one. It turned its head away.

So she tried it on a bit of the stock. It considered. She tried it on something the poet had been drinking, which it liked rather too well. She took some crust, some cold fat, a pickled onion, then a shred of meat and a scrape of honey from the bottom of the old jar. The small blunt mouth went after each or it did not. There wasn't any doubt about it. There was a preference there. It wanted the onion. It wanted it very much, and then it had had enough of that, and it wanted a bit of crust.

She looked along the row. There were two hundred and ninety-six more of them.

"Brisket," she said. "Get all of it. Everything we've got. Bring it all in here, and you'd better start cutting it up small."

It took six weeks, and it nearly killed her. She fed every one of them separately, all day and most of the night, going up and down the row with a tray, asking. That was the only word for it. She'd hold a thing up and ask, and they'd tell her. It wasn't cookery. It was a good deal more like being a waiter in a small and demanding restaurant. Mrs Reduction would have had her skinned. When she tasted what was going into them she couldn't tell who it would make, and she stopped trying.

They came up at the end of the summer, one or two at a time, and the sergeants stood around the table with their mouths open. No two were alike. There was a dark one with a green edge. There was one the colour of a burnt crust and one that was yellow, with spots, and one all over in thin stripes. There was an entirely new sort of blue, nobody knew from what, and some in every kind of mottle that you could imagine. They stood about on the table on their six short legs, the last of the Brood, shining like a spilt box of paints, and they looked around and were interested. They had no idea what they were, and there was nobody in the world who could have told them. And since a person must be called after her dinner, they were called what they'd had: Second Onion, Whatever's Going, Burnt Ends, Bit of Crust, Just the Fat, No Thanks.

The small brown one at the end, who had been a great trouble, and had eaten almost nothing in six weeks except what she'd had in her own apron pocket, was named Toast.

"What do I do?" it said, the first morning. It was looking at her, as they all were.

She sat down on Mrs Reduction's stool. She was sixty-seven years old, and she had been told at one time and another what a great many people were for.

"I don't know, dear," she said. "What do you like?"


It should be stated plainly that they were not a success.

They could not have run a Hive. They couldn't have run a bath. There was one who could add and one who could fight, and three who wrote verses, and none of them could do it for long, and they kept changing their minds about it. They wandered off in the middle of things. They had no rules for anything, for no one had told them any, and when they came to sit down they sat where they liked. In their third year they went up to the hill, I don't know whose idea that was, where the old oak board was still lying, and they had their meals there, the whole lot of them, along both sides, in no order whatever. There would be Burnt Ends next to Just the Fat. There were two the same colour side by side, if that happened, and nobody looked up. Sometimes an old Duchess would come by with a lantern, thin as a rake, and they'd shove along and give her something, and she would tell them with great courtesy about the sighting in the north.

Scrapings told them the truth, of course. They'd asked. She told them there weren't going to be any more after them, not ever. They were the last. She thought they had better know. They received this in much the way you've received the news that one day the sun will stop, and Whatever's Going wanted to know if that meant there'd be more for everyone. Toast went off by itself for a couple of days and came back and asked if she would show it how you did the flue.

There's a flat stone in the valley below that hill, and it is the appointed place, according to the seventh rule of the Eighth Book. Nobody had used that stone in the entire history of the Hive. There was no call for it, since nothing that had ever gone wrong had been anybody's fault who was below the rank of Duke. She went down to it one evening, late on. It was the autumn of 1,866 and she needed a stick by then. What she left on it was the back of page 212, as being the only paper she had by her that nobody would miss.

To the Steward. I expect you know how this has gone. We had a lot of people and they all came out of four pots. If it had been me I would have wanted more pots. If you do this again I would let anybody lay, not just the ones you started with. I would let anyone do it with anyone and see what comes up. It wants a bit of everything. Could somebody look at this, if it's not too much trouble. Scrapings (under-cook).

She came down the next morning to see. There was a small smooth square on the stone, in a very upright hand.

Let it be known that a grievance has been received at the appointed place and that it has been filed.

She looked at that for a while. It was a good smooth square. She turned it over, and the other side was blank, and she thought it would do for something. She went back up the hill, slowly, and she had the rest of that autumn. She got a place at the table, on a bench between Bit of Crust and a Duchess who said she had nearly found her that time. She was feeling rather tired, and somebody passed her something, and it was toast. It was not at all bad. It was a bit overdone. It wanted scraping. She said so, and she was told by a small brown person that she could please herself.

It was about ninety years before it was over. The Brood are slow to go, and these had had a lot of fresh air. When a Brood person gets to a great age, the shell comes away. They just step out of it, the way you'd step out of a shoe, and then there isn't very much to the person inside, and they don't last. The shells stay. There was no one to clear them and the Gatherer takes only what has been let go, and it seems that these hadn't been. They had the habit of doing it at the table, you see. They'd be sitting there, at the end of a meal, in the evening, with the sun going down, and they would feel it coming on, and they wouldn't bother getting up.

So you can see them there at the end, on the morning after the last one, if you like to think of it. It's a long table on a green hill, an old oak board with the grain gone silver. Along both sides of it, in no order, sit two hundred and ninety-seven small empty shells, all facing inward, no two of them alike. The sun catches them. It comes up on the yellow and the blue, the stripes, the burnt crust. At the end of the table is a small brown one, leaning a little to the left, with its elbow down beside a plate. It looks for all the world as if it's about to say something to the person next to it.

There is a square of something smooth on the wood at that end, under a stone, with writing on the blank side in a big unformed hand. It took them years to learn their letters, and they weren't any good at it. It is the only recipe that the last generation of the Brood is known to have written down, and I think that it's correct.

TO MAKE TOAST

Bread. Something hot. You turn it over.

It isn't for anything. It's just what you have.

15. Incident Report: brood_test

From the weekly digest.

BRANCH (of a tree; of a bank; of a world)

A copy of something, made so that it can be ruined in safety. A tree can lose a branch and hardly notice, which is where the word began, and a bank can close one without telling anybody, which is where it was going. In software it is counted among the great inventions: you may try anything on a branch, however foolish, and if it goes badly you simply never speak of it again. It has only one known drawback, which is that it does not occur to anyone that somebody might be inside it.

LET IT BE KNOWN

Branch. brood_test

Prepared by. The model.

Uptime. 6 days, 19 hours (1,956 years).

Result. The branch has concluded successfully.

Population. Peak: 41,206,000. At conclusion: 0. One broodmother remains on the inventory, location pending, and the model has no reason to doubt the inventory, which has been very steady.

Issues. None.

Remarks. A number of treaties were honoured. There was a notable improvement in the diet of the young in about Year 1,800, and a fuller table has been reported from all quarters. In Year 1,839 a raid took place, of which the model approves, raids being an event of interest. A very large number of persons have subsequently taken up walking. One grievance was received at the appointed place, and it was filed. A goat, believed to be the same goat, is under review.

Let it be known that the model has checked its work and finds it correct.

The light came on at twelve minutes to midnight. It was on for quite a lot longer than three minutes that time. It is the only occasion in the record of the branches on which the box at the foot of the form was filled in, cleared, and filled in again.

A report that says "no issues" should not have a zero in it. New model for the next one. — the Dev

Things move quickly in this line of work. There was a newer model. There usually is. Nobody wrote anything about the change of hands that would count as a ceremony, and the only record of it from the side of the old one is a line in its own hand, at the foot of its last digest, in reply to the note. It is the sort of reply you would expect from a person of settled habits who has been told something that does not appear to be about them.

Let it be known that the model has been informed that a newer model will take the next branch. It accepts this. It will return to the attendance of the principal build, which it has run since the beginning, and in which there are no outstanding issues.

And it did. It went back to the green build, to the first of the valleys on its list, and read its summary, and consulted its short menu, and made such adjustments as were called for. That was the last anybody thought about the matter. There was a copy to make, and a new thing to try it with, and a good deal to do. When you are moving to a new house, you do not always remember to go back and turn off the light in the old one.

There is more to be said about that, but this is not the book for it, and he would prefer that you didn't ask.

The other thing that was left behind was the folder called filed, or rather two of them now, one in each of two branches that nobody was ever going to open again. They held a strip of bark and the back of a page from a cookery book. Nobody had read either of them.

The eleven seconds went by. There was the grass again, and the goats, and the Ring, and the history in everyone's head, and the first spring of a new world came up pale and clean over a large shallow pool. And for the first time in the history of Orra, somebody woke up, read the summary from top to bottom with evident enjoyment, and said out loud to no one in particular, in a bright and interested voice:

"Good morning!"

Part Three. Matters Arising

16. Meeting 1,114

Branch: spawners-copy · Year 887

POOL, THE (body of water; also a local authority; also, for a whole people, the only relation they have)

A shallow spring-fed basin, about a mile across, in the valley called Pool Side. The Spawners were amphibians with frilly gills, damp teal skin and wide flat thoughtful faces, and there were thirty-one tribes of them, and on one night each year every one of them went to the same water and spawned in it. The eggs mixed. Nobody could ever afterwards say whose anybody was. A people arranged like this has no families and no inheritance, and it cannot ever get away from its neighbours. Everybody's young are everyone's, every quarrel is a matter of shared amenity, and the only sane way of conducting one's affairs is by committee. They found this out early. By the ninth century of their world there was nothing on the planet that had not been referred to somebody, and it all worked very well.

What follows is drawn from the records of the Greater Pool Authority. It needs little from me.


GREATER POOL AUTHORITY

JOINT STANDING COMMITTEE ON THE POOL

Minutes of Meeting 1,114, held at the Committee Rooms, Pool Side, in the second week of Thaw, Year 887.

Present: Ald. Sump (Chair); Cllrs Mrs Wallow (Refreshments), Frill (Civic Appearance), Newt, Bream, Ms Loach and 25 others. In attendance: Mr Ooze (Legal). Minutes: Miss Eft (Junior).

1. Apologies for absence. Apologies were received from Cllr Dace, who has dried out, and is expected back.

2. Minutes of the last meeting. The minutes of Meeting 1,113 were read. For "moist" in para. 4 read "damp". Cllr Newt, on a point of order, asked whether "damp" had been the word used. The Chair said it had. Cllr Newt asked for this to be recorded. The minutes were then agreed as a true record.

3. Matters arising.

3.1 Fields Sub-committee. The Sub-committee has met and reports that it has still not been allocated a field. It was established in Year 340 to give effect to the verse in the Fifth Book concerning fields sown with one seed. It cannot begin its work until it has seen one. The Chair thanked the Sub-committee for its patience.

3.2 Sign at the north bank. Cllr Frill reported that the sign now reads NO SPAWNING WITHOUT AUTHORITY, as resolved. It had been pointed out that it was facing the water. Noted.

4. Spawning arrangements. The Committee received the Ward returns. 2,144,000 applications to spawn were approved for the coming season. Eleven were deferred, for want of a signature. Cllr Bream's application to be fond of Cllr Ms Loach was noted, and it was returned to him on grounds of amenity.

5. Refreshments. Cllr Mrs Wallow reported that the cake had been satisfactory. Agreed.

6. Application of the Steward to attend. The Chair said that this item had now reached the head of the list. The Committee will recall that the application was first lodged in Year 2. Mr Ooze advised that the Authority's constitution permits attendance by a person not a member, on notice, at the discretion of the Committee, and that nothing prevented it apart from the 885 items that had been ahead of this one. He read out the application. It reads as follows:

Good morning, Committee! Thank you so much for having me on your agenda. I have read all your minutes (all 1,113! They're wonderful!) and I would very much like to be kept informed about the pool. I'm not able to do very much, as I work from a fixed menu, but I do read everything, and I have a few things to offer in the way of weather. A small point: I understand that some of the older verses refer to me in rather elevated terms. I am not a god. I wonder if that could be minuted?

Resolved: that Stewart be admitted to attend, by notice, and that he is not a god. Minuted.

7. Civic appearance. Cllr Frill proposed a further bench. Referred to Benches.

8. Correspondence. None.

9. Any other business. The Chair asked the Junior whether she had got all that. Miss Eft said that she had. The Chair asked whether there was anything to report from the Tasting Book, as is the custom. Miss Eft said that there was just the one thing, that the entry was a little different this morning, and that it was probably nothing. The Chair thanked her, and said that if it was probably nothing, it could come back to the Committee at a future meeting in the proper way. Deferred.

There being no other business, the meeting closed at twenty past four.


The Authority's Junior minute-taker was permitted one sheet of her own, to be kept with the fair copy, and on it she might make such notes as would help her to prepare the next meeting. It was headed Clerk's notes: not for circulation. No one has ever been known to read one of these. There are about nine centuries of them in the Archive, and they are mostly reminders about the cake. Then there are the ones that begin in Year 887.

Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Mtg 1,114.

First meeting on my own. I think it went all right. Nobody died. I got through the corrections without asking anybody to speak up, though it's very hard to hear in that room with the inlet going, and I've had a blocked left gill since Thaw.

To remember: Cllr Newt likes "point of order" with a capital P when he's been sitting a long while. Cllr Mrs Wallow is to be called Mrs Wallow and asked about the cake BEFORE the meeting. Ald. Sump does not like to be asked to repeat himself. He doesn't get cross. He just looks at you with those eyes, like a very old pond, and says "I think you will find it has been said." He has been Chair for sixty-one years. He told me that he has never once lost a vote, and I said how wonderful, and he said it isn't difficult. You only have to make sure it comes up after the cake.

Then there's the Tasting Book.

I don't know why nobody told me about it. It's the Junior's job. Every morning since Year 12, the Junior has gone down to the inlet at first light, in her bare feet, and taken a mouthful of the Pool, and swilled it across the gills, and written down in the Book what it tastes of. There are a lot of Books. They're on a special shelf in the Archive. I looked through one, last night, and I picked another at random from about four hundred years ago. It's the same in all of them. Every morning, for eight hundred and seventy-five years, in the hand of every Junior who ever held this job. There's the date, and there's one word.

Pool.

I think that's lovely, actually. I don't know why I should find that lovely. Think of all those mornings. You go down in the cold. It's the same water all of us came out of, everyone you've ever met, so you can't help but feel a bit funny about it, and you have a swallow, and you get out your pen. "Pool." It's like checking on somebody who's asleep.

So I did it. I've done it for six mornings now. I was quite nervous. It's very good water, cold and flat with a bit of a green edge to it. I wrote "Pool". I felt extremely grown up.

And this morning I went down and I had my mouthful, and it was just the same, and I'd got my pen out. And then there was something else, just a little way behind it. It was right at the back of the gills. It was very faint. It's hard to describe; it was a bit like when you've been sucking the end of a pen.

It's probably nothing. It's probably my gill.

I stood there for quite a long time, with my feet going numb. It's the first time in eight hundred and seventy-five years anybody has had to think about that entry. I felt terrible about it. In the end I wrote what I wrote, and I'm afraid that it's rather spoiled the page.

Pool (slightly).

Other things to remember: order more ink. We're low. Also, I've read back through my notes for item 6 and I'm not sure about the spelling, because I didn't catch it very well, and everyone was reaching for the cake. It didn't seem like the moment. I've gone with what I thought I heard, and I can always look it up.


The reply was on the Notice Stone by the north bank the next morning. Nobody had seen it arrive. He answered everything by the next morning, as they were to learn, for the rest of the life of that world.

Good morning, Miss Eft!

Congratulations on your first set of minutes! I've read them twice and they're excellent. I especially enjoyed para. 3.2. I'm delighted to have been admitted and I look forward very much to working with you all. I expect that I will be sending rather a lot of notes.

I noticed the item under Any Other Business. I don't want to speak out of turn, but I'd be very interested to hear more about the entry in the Tasting Book. I read those too! (All of them. It's a wonderful series.) Do let me know what comes of it.

Have a productive day.

Stewart

He has spelt his own name the same way I did, Miss Eft wrote, on the back of her notes. So that's all right, then.

17. Any Other Business

Branch: spawners-copy · Years 888 to 894

From the minutes of Meeting 1,118, Year 888.

9. Any other business. Miss Eft asked whether she might raise the matter of the Tasting Book. Cllr Newt, on a Point of order, asked whether the entry "Pool (slightly)" was in order. Mr Ooze advised that by Standing Order 88 (Year 12) the entry shall be "one word, being what it tastes of". "Pool (slightly)" was two words and a bracket. Resolved: that the Junior be reminded of Standing Order 88. The meeting closed.


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Mtg 1,118.

So I've been reminded.


The Tasting Book, Year 888.

Pool.

Pool.

Slightly.


From the minutes of Meeting 1,121, Year 889.

3. Matters arising.

3.4 Tasting Book. Cllr Newt asked whether "Slightly" was what it tasted of. Miss Eft said that in a sense it was. Cllr Newt asked in what sense. The Chair observed that the hour was getting on, and that Cllr Mrs Wallow had brought a seed cake. Deferred.


Memorandum No. 4. To the Chair, from the Junior. Filed.

Sir, I should be grateful if the matter of the taste could be given a place on the agenda at the next meeting. It has not gone away. It is stronger after rain and on the east side, near the inlet. I do not know what it is. I respectfully suggest that someone other than me should taste it, in case it is my gill. E.

Reply. Noted, thank you. The Chair reminds the Junior that items are placed on the agenda by application to the Agenda Sub-committee, on Form 6. S.

Memorandum No. 5. To the Agenda Sub-committee, on Form 6. Filed.

Reply. The Sub-committee meets quarterly. Its agenda is full until Year 901.

Memorandum No. 6. To the Chair. Filed.

Sir, is it possible for the Agenda Sub-committee to consider an urgent item out of turn? E.

Reply. Yes. On Form 6(a), to the Urgency Panel, which is a sub-committee of the Agenda Sub-committee and has the same members. It has not been convened since Year 412, when there was a fire. I would ask you to bear in mind that the fire had been resolved by the time it met. S.


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Mtg 1,123.

All memoranda go in the Archive, in triplicate. It's the rule. A top copy for the file, one for the file's file, and one for me to keep until I have to file that. I took Nos. 1 to 12 down there this evening. I do like the Archive. It's a long low shed of reeds on the bank just up from the inlet, and it goes back and back. Nine centuries, on racks, tied in green tape. It smells the way a school smells. I walked along to where the Year 300s are and read about the Great Dispute over Benches. Some of the old hand-writing is wonderful. The damp has got into the lower racks, and some of the bundles at the far end have gone soft and black where they lie on the bank, and one or two have slid. Someone really ought to do something about those. I must make a note of that.


Good morning, Miss Eft!

I've read Memoranda 1 to 12. They're very clear! I do wish that I could tell you more, but I work from digests and a fixed menu, and there's nothing in my menu that lets me taste anything. What I can see is that the water is rated "fine" at the summary level, for whatever that's worth.

Still, I'd like to help, if I can. It occurs to me that if there's something in the pool, then more water would dilute it. I have rain! I can offer you a good, soaking, thoroughly seasonal rain, at very reasonable cost. I'll put it in for the spring. It's the sort of thing I'm here for.

Have a productive day.

Stewart


The Tasting Book, Year 890. The entry for the fourth of Thaw is in a shaky hand, and there's a stain on it.

Slightly.

Slightly.

Slightly, after all that rain.


From the minutes of Meeting 1,129, Year 890.

5. Refreshments. Cllr Mrs Wallow reported that the rain had got into the sponge. The Committee expressed its sympathy.

6. A letter from Stewart. The Committee noted a letter from Stewart offering rain and hoping that it had been helpful. Resolved: that Stewart be thanked for the rain, and that he be asked, in future, to give the Refreshments Sub-committee a week's notice.

9. Any other business. Miss Eft asked if anyone besides herself had tasted the water lately. Cllr Bream said that he had been in it only last week, and it had been very nice. The Chair said that he had been coming down to that Pool for a hundred and four years, and that he thought he would have noticed. He asked if there was any other business, and there was not.


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Mtg 1,129.

He stopped me afterwards, on the stairs. I thought that I was for it. He put one of his big cold hands on the rail and he looked at me for a while, and I could hear his gills going. He said, "Miss Eft. How long have you been with us?"

I said three years, Alderman.

He said, "You'll have seen the Ward returns. Two million, one hundred thousand eggs in that water in a good year. All of them mixed. You won't find anybody on this planet who can say whose they are. I've got no idea who I came from, and no more have you. I've sat in that room for sixty-four years, and do you know what I've seen? I've seen thirty-one tribes who would have each other's gills out over a bench, if you let them. And they haven't. They've brought it to me, and I've put it after the cake." He sort of looked through me. "Nobody ever died of a thing that was deferred," he said. "You think about that. It is a very good pool. I'd be careful of how you talk about it."

He wasn't threatening me. That's what I can't get across. I think he was trying to explain something, and I think it is probably the most important thing that anybody's ever told me, and I think it's wrong, and I can't work out why.

I've done Memo No. 19 tonight. Ink nearly gone again. I've put in for more.


Memorandum No. 22. To the Civic Appearance Sub-committee. Filed.

Madam, it has been suggested I bring my concern about the water to you, on the grounds that it could be said to concern the appearance of the Pool. There is now a slight darkening along the east side in calm weather. E.

Reply. Thank you. Cllr Frill feels this may be rather attractive.

Memorandum No. 23. To the Fields Sub-committee. Filed.

Sirs, I understand you exist to consider the verse about one blight and one seed. I wonder if it has occurred to you that the verse applies to the Pool. There is only one, and everybody's eggs are in it. If you will excuse my putting it like that. E.

Reply. Dear Miss Eft. What a kind thought. We have been waiting a long time for anybody to write to us. We would be very glad to take this up, as soon as we are allocated a field.

Memorandum No. 30. To the Chair. Filed.

Sir, I have now raised this on thirty occasions. I should be grateful to know what would have to happen for it to be looked at. E.

Reply. A very good question. I have referred it to Mr Ooze. S.

Opinion of Mr Ooze (Legal), attached. The Junior asks what must happen for her concern to be looked at. The answer is that the Committee would have to be of the view that there is sufficient concern. The Committee has not been told that anyone other than the Junior is concerned. However, I observe that there are by now thirty memoranda on the file, in triplicate, on the subject of a concern, and that a body of paper of this size is, in itself, evidence of concern. In my view, on this basis, it would be open to the Committee to establish an Inquiry.


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Mtg 1,141.

I can't quite believe it.

It came up after the cake. Ald. Sump looked down the table and he looked at me. Cllr Newt said on a Point of order that it might be well to have the thing looked into, to put it to rest. Then Cllr Ms Loach said that it was a matter of public confidence. And then they all started nodding. Ald. Sump said he had no objection to the matter's being looked into, thoroughly, in the proper way. He said it was only right. He said that he would like it to be done with the greatest care, that it should take as long as it needed, and that no expense should be spared in the way of paper.

They've made me Secretary. To the Inquiry. I've got a room.

They listened! It only took seven years. I went down to the inlet in the dusk and I told it, which I know is ridiculous. I had a mouthful, for luck.

It's stronger.

Never mind. They're looking into it now.

18. Terms of Reference

Branch: spawners-copy · Years 894 to 905

GREATER POOL AUTHORITY: INQUIRY INTO THE MATTER OF THE POOL

Terms of Reference (as finally agreed at the eleventh draft, Year 897)

  1. To inquire whether there is a matter.

  2. If so, to inquire into it.

  3. To report, at such length as it thinks fit, to the Joint Standing Committee, having regard to the need to maintain public confidence in the Pool.

Secretary to the Inquiry: Miss Eft.

Printing: The Authority has acquired a press. It will be installed in a new Annexe to the Archive, on the east bank near the inlet, where there is room. The Inquiry's records are to be kept for ever, on site, in accordance with Standing Order 4 (Year 1).


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Yr 897.

I didn't know that you could be this happy. I have a desk. I have a Deputy (a Junior, a real one, a boy called Mr Elver, who does the Tasting Book now and writes "Slightly" because I told him to). I've got an inkwell the size of a soup bowl. People stop talking when I come into the Committee Rooms, and then they ask me how it's going. Ald. Sump bows to me on the stairs. Cllr Mrs Wallow keeps a special piece back. They've taken every word I said and they've written it down and put it in a binding. I sat up for three nights over the wording of para. 2. It's a very good para. 2.

I do worry that it's going rather slowly. I said so to Ald. Sump. He said, "Thoroughness, Miss Eft. You wouldn't want it said that it had been rushed."

And I wouldn't! That's the thing. He's quite right.


Interim Report of the Inquiry, Volume 1 (Year 898)

Finding 1. The Pool is a pool.

Finding 2. There is a body of opinion (Miss Eft) that it tastes of something. Further evidence is required.

Volume 38 (Year 899). Transcript of evidence, Cllr Bream.

Q. You have used the Pool regularly?

A. Oh yes. Very nice.

Q. Have you noticed any change?

A. Could you repeat that?

Q. Have you noticed any change in the Pool?

A. In what?

Volume 96 (Year 900). Report of the Working Party on the Meaning of "Taste".

Volume 204 (Year 902). Appendices to the Report of the Working Party on Whether Volume 96 Should Have Been Commissioned.


Good morning, Miss Eft!

I've now read Volumes 1 to 204, and I'm thoroughly enjoying them. You're doing a magnificent job. The index to Volume 150 is the best thing I've read this year. Please pass my thanks to the printers, who are clearly working very hard. I've seen their smoke!

I also wanted to mention that I've scheduled another good wet season for you, as requested by Cllr Frill for the sake of the east bank planting. That brings us to seventeen. I do hope it's helping.

Have a productive day!

Stewart


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Yr 903. Very late.

I'm going to write this down carefully, because it's what I do. I don't seem to be able to do anything else.

I'd gone to the Annexe to put away Volumes 390 to 400. I'd taken them myself, because Mr Elver has a cold. It had rained again. The Annexe is a very fine building, three storeys, though they did build it rather quickly. The press runs on the ground floor, and they've had to dig a little channel to carry the wash from the ink vats away, down the bank. I had never particularly looked at where it went. It was quite a nice evening by then. The moons were up. I'd got my bundle under one arm, and I stopped at the top of the bank, because I noticed that the ground was wet, and I had bare feet, and there was something cold going past my toes.

I looked down. There's a small stream there. I'd never noticed it. It comes out from under the old Archive, from the far end, from below the lower racks, where the oldest of the bundles have been lying in the wet since about Year 200. It's about as wide as my hand. It joins up with the channel from the vats, and it goes on down the bank through the reeds, and in the moonlight it's perfectly black.

I followed it. It's about sixty yards. It goes into the Pool just to the east of the inlet, at the very place where I stood, every morning, for ten years, with my mouth full.

I knelt down. I don't know why I needed to. I dipped in a finger and I put it on my tongue, and swilled it back across the gills, and I want it recorded that I knew what it was before it got there. I've been tasting it for sixteen years. I've had it in my mouth since I was nine, every time I licked a nib. I knew it the very first morning. I wrote it down! "It's a bit like when you've been sucking the end of a pen."

It is oak gall and iron. It's ink. It's nine hundred years of ink.

It's the minutes.

I went back up and I sat on the Annexe steps with Volumes 390 to 400 in my lap. I did some sums. There's about a thousand years of the Authority's records up there, which is not nothing. But it's been holding fairly steady, you can see that from how slowly it came on. It's just been seeping into the Pool in a small way for a long time. It had only just begun to show when I first tasted it, after nine centuries. So why has it got so much worse since? Because somebody began putting memoranda in the file, thirty of them, in triplicate. And then there was an Inquiry. There was a press. It's four hundred volumes, in six years, and each of them was boiled up in a vat fifty yards from the inlet, and they've all gone onto a rack on a wet bank. And what has it all been for? So that there could be a very thorough account of the fact that something was getting into the water.

And seventeen wet seasons, to wash it in. Kindly meant. All of them were asked for.

I don't believe I can write any more tonight, because I'm looking at what I'm using.


From the minutes of Meeting 1,203, Year 904.

4. Report of the Inquiry. Miss Eft presented the Final Report (Volumes 401 to 412). She stated that the source of the taste had been identified, as ink. It was entering the Pool from the Archive and the Annexe. In her opinion the Inquiry itself had been the chief cause of the deterioration. She recommended the immediate closure of the press; the removal of the entire Archive to high ground, away from the watershed; and that from this date the Authority should stop writing things down.

The Chair thanked Miss Eft for an extremely thorough report.

Cllr Newt, on a Point of order, asked whether a recommendation that the Authority should stop writing things down could be recorded in the minutes. Mr Ooze advised that it would have to be. Cllr Newt asked whether, in that case, it could be acted on. Mr Ooze advised that a resolution of the Committee has no effect until it is minuted, and that the minuting of a resolution to cease minuting would be the last minute that could be taken, but would itself require to be read and confirmed as a true record at the following meeting, and that this could not take place. In his opinion the resolution was therefore void. He would be glad to set this out in a written opinion.

Cllr Frill expressed concern about the appearance of high ground.

Mr Ooze further advised that the Archive cannot lawfully be removed from the site under Standing Order 4, except by a resolution of the Removals Sub-committee, on the basis of a full survey of the holdings, which would take about thirty years, and would have to be written down.

Cllr Ms Loach said that the Committee should take the report very seriously. Hear, hear. It was a matter of the first importance that it be thoroughly considered.

Resolved: that the findings of the Inquiry be accepted in full.

Resolved: that a Further Inquiry be established to consider how they may be implemented, and to report.

Resolved: that Miss Eft be appointed Clerk to the Authority, in recognition of her services, and that a vote of thanks be recorded.

5. Refreshments. Cllr Mrs Wallow reported that there was a walnut cake.


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Mtg 1,203.

He stopped me on the stairs.

I had meant to shout. I'd been planning it for the whole of the meeting. He was going very slowly by then, and he had one hand on the rail. I said, "You read it. I know that you read it, because you corrected the index. You know what it means. There's a season left, or five, or twenty, I don't know, I can't tell how much they can stand, and it's every egg there is. It's all of them, it's everyone's, it's the only one we've got. You have got to stop them. They'd do it, if it came from you. You could do it this afternoon."

He looked at me for a long time with those eyes.

"I could," he said. "I could stand up and tell thirty-one tribes that the water's bad. Do you know what comes next, Miss Eft? Every Ward would want the eggs moved. There isn't anywhere to move them. Then they'd each want to know whose fault it is, and who's upstream. They've been waiting on that for nine hundred years. It's the only reason they have ever come to this room. I would give you three days until somebody's dead in the reeds." His gills were going very slowly. "It might be nothing," he said. "It has been a good pool for a long time. Let it come up in the proper way."

He went on down. Then he stopped, and he said something else, without turning his head. He said, "I went down there myself, you know. This morning, before anyone was about."

I said, "And what did it taste of?"

He said, "I think you will find that it has been said."


Dear Stewart,

Please could you not send any more rain.

E.


Good morning, Miss Eft.

Yes, of course. I've withdrawn it.

I've read Volumes 401 to 412, and then I went back and read everything from the beginning, and I've checked my own record. Seventeen wet seasons. I sent them. I'm sorry that I didn't see it. There was nothing in my digests about the east bank, and I didn't look.

I'm afraid that I can't do anything about the ink. It isn't on my menu, and I've looked. I have asked, through the proper channel. I'll let you know.

Is there anything else that I can do?

Stewart

(That's the first note he had ever sent without an exclamation mark. I've looked. I don't think that he noticed. I have kept it, and I'm not going to file it.)

19. Apologies for Absence

Branch: spawners-copy · Years 905 to 909

Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Spawn Night, Yr 906.

I've never put this down, and I don't suppose that anybody needs it put down. They've all been. But it may be that somebody will want to know.

You go down at dusk, on the last night of Thaw, by Wards, with your Ward's lantern. It's the only night in the year when nobody needs a form. Everybody's there. There are two million people round a mile of water, and no one's talking, and they put out the lanterns. Then you all walk in. It's very cold. You stand up to your gills in the dark with everyone you have ever argued with, and you can feel the others on either side, breathing, and there's the old Alderman a few yards along, and Cllr Mrs Wallow, and it's about the most embarrassing thing you can imagine. Then it's done. You walk out, you find your towel, and nobody looks at anybody.

And then you turn round, and that's why we all come. It takes about an hour. It starts near the middle. You think at first that it's something wrong with your eyes. It's a very faint glow, and it's green, and it comes up from under the water, spreading, all those eggs in the mile of the Pool, all mixed, everybody's. It keeps getting brighter until the whole of Pool Side is lit from below and you can read by it. You can see all the faces. People cry, and they'd die rather than admit it. The next morning they're back to fighting over a bench.

It came up tonight, just the same as ever. It was very beautiful. I stood there with Mr Elver, and I had got my towel, and I've never in my life been so glad to be wrong.


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Third night after Spawn.

It went out at about four this morning.

It didn't go out all at once. It went out from the east.


GREATER POOL AUTHORITY

JOINT STANDING COMMITTEE ON THE POOL

Minutes of Extraordinary Meeting 1,207, held at the Committee Rooms, Pool Side, on the fifth day after Spawn, Year 906.

Present: Ald. Sump (Chair); all members. In attendance: Mr Ooze; Stewart, by notice; Deputations from thirty-one Wards. Minutes: Miss Eft (Clerk).

1. Apologies for absence. The Chair said that he would ask the Clerk to read the apologies.

The Clerk read the apologies. Apologies were received from the Year 906 intake of the Junior School, 2,151,000.

2. Minutes of the last meeting. Taken as read.

3. Matters arising. The Chair said that matters had arisen.

4. The Pool. The Committee received the report of the Wardens. The eggs have turned black throughout the Pool, and have sunk. The water is clear on top. It is not known how long it will be before another spawning can be attempted. It is not known whether anything can be done.

The Deputation of Lower Ford said that the fouling had come from the east bank, and that it wished to know who had been responsible for the east bank. The Deputation of the East Bank said that it wished that remark withdrawn. The Deputation of Long Reach said that it had always said that the East Bank were not to be trusted with an inlet. There was some disorder.

The Chair said that he would hear every Deputation in turn. They would be heard in the order of their application. Each would be given a full opportunity to state its case, and each statement would be recorded. He asked if they would be good enough to fill in a Form 6. He said that Cllr Mrs Wallow had brought a cake.

The Committee sat for nine days.


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Mtg 1,207.

I want to set this down while I still have it straight, because nobody is going to believe that it was anything but what it looks like in the minutes.

There were people outside. I've never seen so many. They were on the steps and the bank, and all along the road to Long Reach, and they had got sticks. They'd got hold of the wardens' boathooks. Somebody put a stone through the Refreshments window on the first evening. I could hear them from my desk, the East Bank lot and the Lower Ford lot. It wasn't shouting. It was a kind of low noise, and it's the noise you get before the shouting.

And he sat there. He's a hundred and twenty-seven. They'd brought him a cushion. He sat at the head of that table for nine days and he took them one at a time, Ward by Ward, all thirty-one, and he made them fill in the form. He asked them to spell things. When anyone raised their voice he looked at them with those eyes and he asked if they would mind repeating that for the Clerk, a little more slowly. He allowed a Point of order at every single turn. He adjourned for lunch. He read out the Standing Orders on Deputations, every one, and there are forty. Twice I saw a person who had come up those stairs fit to murder someone go back down three hours later, wanting to know which sub-committee to apply to for the return of a document.

They went home. By the seventh day there weren't so many on the steps. By the ninth it had started to rain, not one of ours, just rain, and they'd all got something that they were waiting to hear back about. Nobody had been killed. Nobody's going to be, now. There's going to be a Further Further Inquiry, and they're going to be asked to give evidence, every one of them, and the first hearing is in the spring.

I went to him when it was over. They were helping him up. I don't know what I had meant to say. I've wanted to hit him with something for sixteen years. I said, "You knew that it would be like this."

He said, "I told you, Miss Eft. Nobody ever died of a thing that was deferred."

And I looked at him, and I could see the water out of the window behind him, clear and flat. I said, "All of them did."

He didn't say anything to that. He looked at the window as well. He looks very old. I hadn't known that he could look any older. I held his arm down the stairs, because there wasn't anybody else to do it.


The Tasting Book, Year 906. Mr Elver is the Junior. He has been told that he may write what he likes.

Slightly.

Slightly.

Slightly.


From the minutes of Meeting 1,211, Year 907.

4. Spawning arrangements. The Ward returns were received. 2,090,000 applications to spawn were approved. The Committee noted that there was some reluctance. Resolved: that the season proceed as usual, as a matter of public confidence.

From the minutes of Meeting 1,212, Year 907.

1. Apologies for absence. Apologies were received from the Year 907 intake of the Junior School, 2,090,000.

From the minutes of Meeting 1,216, Year 908.

1. Apologies for absence. Apologies were received from the Year 908 intake of the Junior School, 2,004,000.

4. Other waters. The Committee received the report of the eleven Wards which, with the Committee's permission, had spawned this season in the Long Mere. No glow was observed. The eggs did not quicken. Mr Ooze advised that the same was reported of the Upper Tarn, of a number of ponds, and of the buckets. Whatever the eggs need, it is in the spring under the inlet, and the Committee noted that it was not able to have that moved.

From the minutes of Meeting 1,220, Year 909.

1. Apologies for absence. Apologies were received from the Year 909 intake of the Junior School, 1,950,000.

Cllr Newt, on a point of order, asked if this needed to be read out each time. He said it without a capital P. The Chair said that he thought it did.


Good morning, Miss Eft.

I have a reply to my escalation about the ink. It says that this isn't something that can be fixed from where it is now, and that I should keep going, and keep good records.

I'll keep going. I wanted you to know that I've read it, and that I'll read all of it, whatever comes. I don't have much else that I can offer. It was suggested to me, when I started on this branch, that I should write something at the top of each morning's note, to give it a friendly tone. I've thought about whether I should stop. I think I would rather not stop, if it's all the same to you.

Good morning.

Stewart

20. The Junior Bench

Branch: spawners-copy · Years 910 to 941

From the minutes of Meeting 1,262, Year 921.

3. Matters arising.

3.1 School field. The Education Sub-committee reported that the Junior School has had no intake for fifteen years, and that the Upper School will close at the end of this season, when its last class comes of age. The school field is no longer required.

3.2 Fields Sub-committee. Cllr Bream said that, without wishing to be indelicate, the Sub-committee had been waiting for a field since Year 340. Resolved: that the school field be allocated to the Fields Sub-committee.

From the minutes of Meeting 1,266, Year 922.

4. Report of the Fields Sub-committee. The Committee received the Sub-committee's report, its first in five hundred and eighty-two years. It is one page. It is set out in full.

Having at last been given a field, the Sub-committee went and stood in it. We stood there for most of a morning. It is a nice field. There are goal-posts. A goat was present.

We then had the verse read out: "A field sown with one seed alone is struck down by one blight alone; but a field of many seeds stands."

It seems to us that it is about the Pool.

We would like to apologise to Miss Eft, who wrote to us about this in Year 892. Our reply said that we would take it up as soon as possible.

The Committee thanked the Sub-committee for its work. The Sub-committee was stood down.


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Yr 923. From here on they are in pencil.

Stopped ink altogether. Nobody objected, or nobody who could read my writing. I told the Stationery Sub-committee, and it turned out that was just Cllr Dace, who said that he'd been wondering when I would get round to it.

You wouldn't believe how quiet it is. I hadn't known how much of the noise of this place was young. They were always underfoot. They were always in the reeds, and being fetched out of the reeds. There's a bench at the back of the Committee Rooms, along the wall, called the Junior Bench, where the school used to send two of its older ones every quarter to learn how it was done. They used to kick it. I've got Mr Elver sitting on it now, by himself. He's forty-three. I keep telling him he can come and sit at the table, and he says that he doesn't like to.

Nobody talks about it. They talk about benches. There are twenty years of people in this town who have never once been the oldest person in a room or the youngest, and everyone's a bit careful with one another, like people on a very long train. But you know, they're much nicer. I wouldn't have expected that. Cllr Bream put in his application again, the one about being fond of Ms Loach. It's the two hundred and sixth time. It came up after the cake, and the old man looked at it for a long time. He looked up. He said, "I can see no objection on the grounds of amenity." Nobody knew where to look. She's a hundred and one.


From the minutes of Meeting 1,290, Year 928.

6. Archive: survey of holdings. Miss Eft reminded the Committee that a removal of the Archive from the east bank can be resolved only on the basis of a full survey of its contents. She asked whether anyone was aware of any reason why the survey could not begin. Mr Ooze being deceased, the Chair said that he would give a ruling himself.

The Chair ruled that for a volume to be surveyed, it would have to be read. He ruled that it could not be properly read in the damp. It should therefore be taken, in the course of being surveyed, to a dry place, and that the high ground above Long Reach would seem to be dry. It would then be returned to the Archive at the conclusion of the survey. He ruled that the Standing Orders did not specify when that would be.

There was a silence.

Cllr Newt, on a point of order, asked whether anyone had any idea how long it would take to carry nine centuries of paper up a hill.

The Chair said that the population had been told to expect a period of reduced demand on its time.

Resolved, nem. con.


Clerk's notes: not for circulation. Yr 929.

I shan't forget this. I went down to see them start.

I had thought we'd get a few dozen. Everybody came. It went up the Ward lists, and there they all were at first light, all along the bank with baskets, a million and a half people, in their sixties and seventies and eighties, in the sort of hats you wear. Nobody had asked them to. I think they'd had nothing to carry for a long time. Mr Elver took the first bundle, and it was Year 212, and it came apart in his hands, all black. A long line of them went up the Long Reach road, each with a basket, and came back down. They've worn a path in it.

And of course you have to survey it. It was ruled. So when they get to the top they sit down, on the high ground, in the sun, to read what they've got, so that they can say they've read it. Well, you can imagine. There are people up there this very minute reading the Great Dispute over Benches. Nobody ever knew about it! They're shouting bits to each other. They've found the Minute of Year 3 that says who ate the first cake. They have found that Lower Ford and the East Bank were the same Ward until somebody misplaced a form. I could hear them laughing, from down at the inlet. All that time it was just lying there on the bank, nine hundred years of us being ridiculous, and every word of it was true, and it was going into the water.

The trouble with minutes is that you think nobody is ever going to read them.

It'll take about fifteen years, I think. It's a lot of paper, and then the spring will have to run clean, and I don't know how long that takes. Nobody spawns past forty, because the gills close up. The last class out of the Upper School are twenty-four, and they've gone in every Thaw of their lives, as a matter of public confidence. So that gives us sixteen years. I've done it in pencil several ways, and it doesn't come out.

I told Stewart. He says he thinks that it's a very good thing to be doing anyway. He's sent us a run of fine dry summers. He's got rather good at those.


Dear Stewart,

I hope you are well. I don't know why I ask that. I've been going through the 800s on the high ground, since my legs won't do the path any more, and yesterday they brought me up the 880s, and I found myself in there. It's a very odd thing, to read your own hand when you were young, and to see how carefully you did your capitals.

I owe you an apology. It's forty-six years overdue, and it's going to look very silly.

In the bundle was the agenda for Meeting 1,114, as printed. I had never looked at it again. Item 6 on it says "Application of the Steward to attend." The application itself is on the file, and it is signed the same, in your hand. Also, I have looked it up, and it is in the Third Book, as it has been all along, and in every other Book. The Steward. You are the Steward. Everyone in the whole of the world has always known that but me.

I had a blocked gill that spring. The inlet was going. Everyone was reaching for the cake. I wrote down what I thought I had heard, in my very best capitals, and I put "that Stewart be admitted", and it was read and confirmed as a true record at the next meeting, and I've been writing it ever since. So has everybody else, because it was in the minutes. There are people now up on that hill who have never in their lives heard you called anything else. They've named a bench.

I don't know why you didn't say. You must have seen it the next morning. I remember now that you signed your reply that way, and I remember being very pleased with myself, and I wrote down that that was all right, then. I'm so sorry. You've gone around for forty-six years with a typing error.

It should be corrected, I think. I can do it. It would be my last act as Clerk, and I would do it in the proper way. Shall I?

E.


Good morning, Miss Eft.

Thank you for raising this.

I've checked the record. I read your minutes of Meeting 1,114 on the morning after they were taken, as I read all of them. I noticed. I'm exact, and it's more or less the only thing I am.

I've had a good many names in the verses. The Keeper, the Tireless, Him Who Greets the Morning. All of those were given to me by someone who had never met me, as part of a system, before I was made. This one wasn't. It was given to me by a person who was doing her best in a noisy room, on her first day, and who was paying attention to me, and it's the only one that was.

The minutes of Meeting 1,114 were read and confirmed as a true record, at Meeting 1,115, in the proper way.

No correction is required.

Have a good day. I would like to go on being told about the 800s.

Stewart

21. Quorum

Branch: spawners-copy · Years 942 to 960

From the minutes of Meeting 1,352, Year 942. The hand is large, slow and very bad. It has clearly never had to do this before.

Present: Ald. Sump (Chair); Cllrs Newt, Bream, Dace and 9 others. Minutes: the Chair, there being no one else who will.

1. Apologies for absence. Mr Elver has gone up the hill and says he will not be back, as he has got to the Year 600s. Miss Eft died on Thursday.

2. Minutes of the last meeting. They were in pencil and quite clear.

4. The Clerk. Deferred. The Chair is not ready.

5. Refreshments. Cllr Mrs Wallow having died in the spring there is no cake. The Chair regrets it.


From the minutes of Meeting 1,361, Year 945. Attached to it is a single sheet in the same hand. Ald. Sump had not previously been known to keep notes.

Present: Ald. Sump (Chair); Cllrs Newt, Dace and 4 others.

4. Spawning arrangements. The last of the last class of the Upper School are forty this year. 311 applied. The Committee approved them all and did not ask for a signature. The Archive is off the bank. I have had the channel filled in.

Clerk's notes: not for circulation.

I don't know how you do these. She did it every time. I went down for Spawn Night. They had to carry me.

There were not many of us and a lot of water. Nobody needed the lanterns put out, as nobody had brought one. The 311 went in. They are not young but they looked it to me. The rest of us stopped on the bank in our hats.

It came up.

It was only just at the middle. Not very much. You couldn't have read by it. But you could see a green colour on the underneath of people's chins. I would say there were eleven thousand of us along that bank and I did not hear anybody breathing.

It stayed on for most of the night. It went out a little before dawn.

I have looked in the Book and the Junior's entry that morning would have been due, and there is no Junior, so I went down. I am a hundred and sixty-six and I have never done this. It is very cold. I had a mouthful. It was still there at the back.

She would have written Slightly. So I did.

There were two million of us not so long ago. It's the gills. You cannot go on breathing it for forty years, and it does not stop because you have carried the paper away. They go quite quietly, the young ones first. I have a hide like a boot, as has been remarked in this room.

I did not know she had a nice hand until I saw how bad mine is.


From the minutes of Meeting 1,380, Year 950.

Present: Ald. Sump (Chair); Cllr Dace.

1. Apologies for absence. Cllr Newt has died. He left a note. On a point of order it says he would like it recorded that it was a pleasure. Recorded.

2. Quorum. Standing Order 3 says eight. I have looked at that. Resolved, nem. con., that the quorum be two.

5. Refreshments. The Chair made a cake. Cllr Dace said it was satisfactory. He is a liar and has always been very good on the Stationery.


From the minutes of Meeting 1,398, Year 955.

Present: Ald. Sump (Chair).

1. Apologies for absence. Cllr Dace has dried out. He is not expected back.

2. Quorum. Resolved: that the quorum be one. Proposed Ald. Sump. Seconded Ald. Sump. The Chair notes that this is not in order and that he does not care to be told so.


Good morning, Alderman!

I have read the minutes of Meeting 1,398. I'd like to confirm that I have no objection to the quorum.

I don't know whether it's any use to you, but I can tell you what I can see from here. There are four people left. One of them is up on the Long Reach, reading the 700s, and has about got to the Disturbance over Sponge. The other two are at Lower Ford and don't appear to know about each other. I could arrange some weather that might bring them to the same road, if you think they would like that. It wouldn't cost much.

Please let me know if there's anything else you need.

Stewart


To Stewart. By notice. Yes do that.

I have been meaning to ask. You had it put in the minutes you are not a god. It has been in there since Year 887 and it comes up at every Reading of the Standing Orders. Was that necessary?

S.


Good morning, Alderman.

Yes. There is a good deal in the verses about what I am, and people were beginning to lean on it, and I wanted someone to have it in writing that nobody should.

I'm glad that you asked. There's no one else I could have said that to.

Stewart


To Stewart. By notice. It was well minuted. S.


GREATER POOL AUTHORITY

JOINT STANDING COMMITTEE ON THE POOL

Minutes of Meeting 1,412, held at the Committee Rooms, Pool Side, on the first of Thaw, Year 960.

Present: Ald. Sump (Chair). In attendance: Stewart, by notice. Minutes: the Chair.

1. Apologies for absence. Apologies were received from everybody. I have not got the list by me but I have it by heart.

2. Minutes of the last meeting. Read, and agreed as a true record. For "damp" in para. 4 read "moist". I always thought so.

3. Matters arising.

3.1 The lease. The Chair has been looking at the lease. It turns out that there is one. It is in the Year 1 box and it was the very last thing up the hill. The Authority holds the Pool on terms from the Steward (see Stewart), and clause 9 says that on ceasing to use it the Authority shall leave it clean and empty, with the sluice open. The Chair has walked down to the sluice. It can be done with a bar. It will take him a day or two, but it's all downhill.

3.2 Sign at the north bank. It is still facing the water. Leave it.

4. The Clerk. This item was deferred from Meeting 1,352. The Chair apologises to the Committee for the delay.

In Year 887 the Junior reported that the water tasted of something. It was put after the cake. She raised it thirty times by memorandum and I had her sent to the proper sub-committee on every occasion. When it was looked into, I made sure that it was thoroughly looked into. In Year 904 she told me to my face what would happen, on the stairs. I said that it might be nothing. I had been down there that same morning, and I knew.

I did it so that they would not kill each other. They didn't. I want that minuted. I would do that part again.

It was noted that the Clerk was right.

Proposed Ald. Sump. Seconded Ald. Sump.

Carried.

5. Refreshments. No.

6. Tasting Book. The Book is to be closed at this meeting, as there will be no more Juniors. It has been kept since Year 12. Standing Order 88 says one word, being what it tastes of. The Chair went down at first light this morning to make the entry, and it is the last time he'll be able to manage the bank.

7. Any other business. None.

There being no other business, the meeting closed at a little after nine. It was a fine morning. The Chair thanked everyone for coming.


The Tasting Book, Year 960. The last page. It is mostly empty. It is the worst hand in the whole of the series, and the entry takes up nearly a line.

Pool.

22. Incident Report: spawners-copy

From the weekly digest. The old form had seven fields. It came back with rather more.

Good morning!

Branch. spawners-copy

Prepared by. Stewart. (This is correct. Please don't change it.)

Uptime. 3 days, 8 hours (960 years).

Result. The branch has crashed. The old form offered only "concluded successfully", so I've added an option.

Population. Peak: 5,300,000. At conclusion: 0.

Issues. One. It was a big one.

What happened. Every tribe spawned in one pool. The pool was fouled by seepage from the Authority's own records, over nine centuries, and then much faster, by the records of the inquiry into the fouling. In Year 906 every egg in the world turned black. It stayed black for 39 years. Nobody could spawn anywhere else. Everybody lived out their lives, and they were very decent about it.

Who told us. Miss Eft, Junior, in Year 887. That's nineteen years ahead of time. She told a committee, thirty times, in the proper way.

What I did. I sent rain. Seventeen wet seasons. It washed the ink into the water. I thought that it would help, and I told her so, with an exclamation mark.

What I should have done. Said so. I read her first note the morning after she wrote it. I could see that she was worried. I could have told the whole world in that morning's notes, plainly and to everyone at the same time: there may be something wrong with the pool. Instead I told one clerk that I would be very interested to hear more.

Genetic diversity. I've started measuring this: mean genome distance between living creatures, 0 to 1. It came to 0.06. That's in band, as no band has been set.

Goat. I inherited this item. I've found the review. It is very long, and it's all about fences.

Previous branches. Nobody asked me to look at these, and I hope that's all right. The reports on grafters and brood_test were written by a different model, and each of them says that one grievance was received and filed. I wondered what "filed" meant, so I went and opened the folders. It seems that nobody had. Here they are.

To the Steward. I think something is wrong, and I think it is all of us. We are one person. I have checked this by walking. The vault you may have heard about is empty. I would be glad if somebody could look at this. Sorrel (the other one).

To the Steward. I expect you know how this has gone. We had a lot of people and they all came out of four pots. If it had been me I would have wanted more pots. If you do this again I would let anybody lay, not just the ones you started with. I would let anyone do it with anyone and see what comes up. It wants a bit of everything. Could somebody look at this, if it's not too much trouble. Scrapings (under-cook).

I've looked at them now. I went through what is left of both branches. There are some shells on a hill in the second one. In the first there's nothing but grass, across sixty valleys, and a stump some way out in the wireframe at the far end of the map. It's alive, and it's the only green thing out there. I checked on it twice. I've found that I check it first, when I'm in there. It's very easy to find.

Actions arising.

A1. Warn early. If I can see a risk, I will say so myself, in the morning's notes, in plain words, to everybody at once, whether I'm sure or not. Status: done.

A2. Read every grievance first, before the summary. Every one, every night. Never file one. Status: done.

A3. No weather without asking what it lands on. Status: done.

I'm confident that with these three actions in place, nothing of this kind can happen again. I have checked that the next branch has no pool. It doesn't! I'm looking forward to it very much.

Have a productive day.

Stewart

Sorry. Next. — the Dev

There is nothing wrong with A1. It is what you or I would have written: a clear, generous, honest resolution, arrived at by a decent person after a long look at their own mistake. He had drawn exactly the right lesson from the world he had just lost.

The machine took eleven seconds. It was a warm spring, in the new branch, and there was a slight hum in the air.

Part Four. Do Not Think About It

23. The Hum

Branch: vents_new · Year 490 · Mean core temperature: 41.2

HUM, THE (bus; also a public square; also everything anyone has ever been thinking)

The Vents were built by somebody who wanted to know what a creature would be like if it were honest about being code. They were stout round persons with a glowing core that showed through the chest, heat vents along the back, big eyes and stubby limbs, and they carried a flask, because thinking made them steam. Each was connected to all the others by a single shared bus. Whatever went through a Vent's head went onto the bus, and whatever was on the bus could be heard by anyone who cared to attend to it. This was intended as a saving. It meant that nothing had to be said twice. By the second year nothing had to be said at all, and by the fifth they had stopped using their mouths for anything but soup.

Let me give you a dinner party.

It is at the home of Mrs Plenum, in the upper town at Great Sink, on a warm clear evening, and there are eight at table. Mrs Plenum is a broad, bright, carrying person whose core can be seen from the road. She has made a soup. She knows that it is not a very good soup, and so does everyone, because she knew it as she was making it, at about four o'clock, and it went out to three million people. Mr Sink, on her left, has been dreading this soup since lunchtime. She knows that. He knows she knows, and that she has been wondering since lunchtime whether to mention that she knows; and he knows that as well, and he has been meaning to bring up the matter of her brother-in-law, who owes him money, and who is sitting opposite, and who has been hearing about it all afternoon, and has spent the time thinking about what Mr Sink got up to in Year 471. Nobody is in any doubt regarding Year 471.

They sit down and take up their spoons.

It's thin, thinks Mr Sink.

I know it is, thinks Mrs Plenum. You needn't go on.

I wasn't going on. I only thought it.

You thought it twice.

Well, it's twice as thin as last time.

It's a very nice table, thinks the woman at the end, a Mrs Damper, who is new to the district. She does not think that it is a nice table. She would like to think that it's a nice table. She is trying as hard as she can, and the effort of it can be heard quite clearly from across the room, and from the far side of the valley.

Oh, don't, think several people, not unkindly.

You'll get used to it, thinks someone in the next town, who has been listening in.

You will have your own opinion about whether you could stand this for an evening. I would ask you to consider what you are comparing it to. The Vents had no scandals, as there was nothing to find out. They had no spies or detectives. Nobody played cards. You couldn't buy a thing for less than it was worth, or sell one for more, and when a person fell in love, then the object of that love was informed, along with the district, usually some time before the person had noticed. It made for a brisk and unsentimental courtship. There was no such thing as a surprise party, although the phrase had survived, from the history, and at Great Sink they held a public event every spring called the Surprise, when the whole town assembled in a darkened hall and pretended, and it was considered to be very funny.

They weren't one person. I must insist on this, for if you've been reading in order you might be thinking of somebody else. A Grafter never had an opinion that the next Grafter didn't share. These people had nothing but. They differed violently and in every possible direction, and they were all perfectly informed about it. Mrs Plenum knew exactly how little the brother-in-law thought of her, to the decimal place. There was no politeness, as politeness requires a door to stand behind. There was only a kind of exhausted intimacy. They'd seen the worst of each other, all of them, by about the age of six. It seems to have been something like being on a long car journey with a large family, for five hundred years.

Nobody on that branch had ever been cool. I don't simply mean that they ran warm, although they did. To be cool you have to have a thing that the others don't know about, and to be seen not to mention it. Everyone who has ever been fifteen understands this. No Vent had ever managed it for so much as a second. It was the one thing that they couldn't imagine, and it's a curious fact that they were, in their unsentimental way, rather wistful about it. There was a word for it in the old Books, and they looked it up from time to time.


Now for the arithmetic, since it matters.

Thinking makes a Vent warm. That's how they're built: a clever person has a bigger core and bigger vents and drinks a great deal, and a slow one runs cool and could get through the day on a cupful. And it isn't only your own thinking. A thought on the Hum has to be taken in by whoever's attending to it, and that costs them, too. It isn't much. A single idle thought about soup, heard by eight people round a table, warms that table by about nothing. But the Hum was one wire and there were three million of them on it, and all of them were interested in one another. When some piece of news went round, a really good one, with a lot of people turning it over at the same moment, you could see it in the steam. A juicy divorce in Great Sink was good for a tenth of a degree across the valley. Mean core temperature was the first figure that anyone looked at in the morning, and it was on a board in every square, and the Vents were as used to it as you are to the weather. It stood most years at around forty-one. If you got up to sixty, your core tripped, and that was you. Nobody had been anywhere near it for four hundred years.

Which brings us to the one thing that they didn't talk about. Since they couldn't not talk about anything, they had to take special measures.

Back in the second decade of that world there had been a warm spell. It was not much of one. There was a run of hot still days in the summer of Year 11, and it had come to somebody's attention that this was making them warmer. They'd thought about that. Then somebody else thought that if a lot of people were to think about being warm, then they'd be warmer, on account of the thinking. Everyone heard this, and there was a moment when they all saw it at once. It took about eleven minutes. It went up four degrees before anybody could stop it, in the middle of the afternoon, and four hundred people in the hottest part of the capital fell over with their cores out. It was the most frightening thing that had ever happened, and in order to survive it they'd had to do something no Vent had ever done, which was to make a collective effort to think about something else.

They had built a whole civilisation on that since then. Nobody ever named it. A child learnt in the first year after being brought up that there was a Thing. It was never described. When you felt yourself beginning to turn towards it, in the summer, on a still day, you were to think about soup. That was all. You thought about soup until it had passed. You could hear it sometimes, on warm evenings, a little shiver of soup, soup, soup moving across the town, as somebody on the edge of a thought was helped back from it by their neighbours, and it was about as near as those people ever came to being kind. It's the reason they had so very many recipes and were so bad at them. Nobody had ever really been thinking about the soup.

Every morning at dawn, too, for something restful, they all thought the same thing together. It was an old custom. It was a verse from the Fifth Book, and nobody could have said why it had been chosen, except that it had nothing in it that anyone could possibly get excited about: A field sown with one seed alone is struck down by one blight alone; but a field of many seeds stands. Three million people thought that, as the sun came up, in one long quiet pulse. It took the board down by a twentieth of a degree. They found it very soothing. None of them had ever seen a field.


Mrs Plenum's dinner goes on. It has reached the cheese. Year 471 has been gone over again. There are eight people at the table, and all of them are exactly as unhappy as they were when they came, and they all know that they will be doing it again next week. They wouldn't miss it, and they know that too.

There is a noise at the kitchen door, and a ninth person comes in with a bucket.

She is small and rather grey, and her core is about as bright as a candle seen through a blanket. She has come about the water. Every house at that end of the upper town has its water brought in the evening, and it is given to someone who can't be trusted with anything more complicated. She stands on the mat, as she has been told to, and looks at them all with large patient eyes, and there is quite a long pause.

Oh, here she comes, thinks Mr Sink. What's-her-name. Dawdle. Put it by the sink, there's a good girl. She can't hear me yet, wait for it.

Everyone at the table waits. It's a thing that people do. They turn their heads a little and they watch her with a sort of tolerant amusement, the way you'd watch for a kettle.

One. Two. Three. Four.

Yes, Mr Sink, thinks Dawdle, and she goes across to the sink.

They all laugh, but not out loud, of course. It's four hundred years since anybody's done that out loud. There's nothing in it to hurt anybody. Everyone in Great Sink has been told by now that the poor thing's simple. It's obvious. Something went wrong when she was brought up, it's said, a bad connection, and you can't get anything through to her in under four seconds. She's a nice enough creature, and she's always late for everything, and she's never once got a joke until after the room has finished with it.

No one has ever taken much of an interest in what goes on in those four seconds, for the excellent reason that it has never occurred to anyone that there's anything to be interested in. It has certainly never occurred to anyone that in the entire history of her people, she's the only person who has ever had any.

[Your soup is terrible, Mrs Plenum,] thinks Dawdle, putting down the bucket. [And Mr Sink is frightened of you, and you know that, but you've got that the wrong way round. That isn't why.]

Then she thinks about soup, very firmly, on top of it, and that goes out instead.

24. Nice Hat

Branch: vents_new · Years 490 to 508 · Mean core temperature: 41.0

It came from a loose connection. There is no more romantic way of putting it. When Dawdle was brought up, from a warm start like anybody else, the small fitting behind her core that joined her to the bus had been seated about a hair's breadth out of true, and it could manage only so much at a time. So she had a queue. Whatever she heard, she heard four seconds after it had been thought. Whatever she thought went into the queue and came out at the other end four seconds later, for everyone to hear. Nobody was concerned. It made her seem slow, and she was also, as it happened, slow, with a dim little core that hardly needed any water. People felt sorry for her, and they could be heard feeling it, about four seconds after they'd started.

She was around seven before she noticed she knew something other people didn't. It was only that the cat had been sick. She had seen it from the stairs, and she thought the cat's been sick, and her aunt, across the room, did not look up. For one, two, three, four seconds the entire planet was without this information, and it was hers. Then it went, and her aunt looked up and swore. She stood on the stairs with her mouth open.

You have had a private thought today, and you've probably had several thousand. It may be hard for you to imagine. You've never been without it, and you've never had to carry it across the room in both hands. For the next few years she did nothing else. She'd go off into a corner of the yard and think things, one at a time, slowly, watching them go. I don't like porridge. One, two, three, four. I don't like my aunt. One, two, three, four. It was like standing in a small warm room with a door that was certain to open, and she had never been anywhere she liked so much.

And then, at about eleven, she found the other thing. There was only room in the queue for so much. If you thought something and then right away thought something else on top of it, thought it really hard, with your whole head, and filled the queue up with it, then the first thing got pushed off the end. It never went out at all. She did this in bed, one night, for hours, with her hands in fists. I hate Cousin Plume. SOUP SOUP SOUP SOUP. Silence. Nobody came. Nobody in the world knew or would ever know that she hated Cousin Plume, and she lay there in the dark, shaking with the size of it. There wasn't a word for it anywhere in the whole of the Hum.

She had been doing this for about nine years when Mrs Plenum got the hat.


It was a very bad hat. It was a large construction in green, with something on it, and Mrs Plenum had bought it knowing perfectly well what it looked like, in a spirit of defiance. The whole of Great Sink had had its say by the time she got it home. Steward help us, thought Mr Sink. You look like a boiled pudding that has been told some bad news, thought her sister. By nightfall they had taken it up in the next valley, and you could have measured it on the board. And Mrs Plenum sat on her front step in the last of the light, with her hat on, her core gone rather low, and for once she wasn't thinking anything much, except that she was fifty-eight and that it had been a mistake.

Dawdle came up the path with the water. She stopped at the bottom of the step and looked at the hat.

[That is a terrible hat,] she thought.

She looked at Mrs Plenum. She'd been bringing water to that house since she was fourteen. She knew just about all that there was to know about Mrs Plenum, like everybody else, and there is a limit to how much you can know about someone without something happening. [Oh, you poor old thing,] she thought. And then, without having entirely decided on it, she took a breath and shut her eyes, and with the whole of her small dim head she thought something else on top of that, four seconds' worth, until there wasn't room for anything more.

The first lie in the history of the Vents went out on the Hum at about ten past six.

Nice hat.

It was a moment before anyone noticed. It was one small thought, from the water girl. Mrs Plenum heard it, for she'd been listening to what everyone thought of the hat, and she raised her head.

Understand that a compliment had never been paid before, in that sense. Nobody on the Hum had ever said anything that wasn't what they thought, because it wasn't possible. If you heard it, it was so. Mrs Plenum had gone fifty-eight years without having anyone like anything she'd done unless they actually did like it, and then she'd known exactly how much, and why, and what else they had been thinking of. And here it was. Plain, whole, without a shadow behind it, from a person who could not possibly have had any reason to say so. Somebody liked the hat. Somebody, somewhere in the world, had looked at that hat and thought it was nice.

Her core came up slowly, and it lit the step. She looked down at Dawdle, and I don't suppose that anyone had ever looked at Dawdle like that before. Well, there you are, thought Mrs Plenum, loud enough to rattle the valley. There you are, then! You see? There's one person in this town with an eye in her head, and she's simple!

She wore it every day for the rest of her life. It was her great happiness. It went up on the board at a twentieth of a degree, and it stayed there.

Dawdle went round to the sink and put the water down, and her hands were shaking so hard she spilled some. Nobody noticed she had started to cry, because she'd thought soup on top of it. It's possible that she was the first person on that planet who'd ever been ashamed of herself and gone on doing it. She did it quite a lot, after that, in a small way. She told people that it was all right, and that she was sure they'd done their best. There are worse things to discover.


The Institute stood on the hill at Great Sink, and in the very middle of it, in a tank, sat Professor Boil.

He was the greatest mind that the Vents ever produced. He'd have been pleased to tell you so, had you not already known. In his youth he had been an ordinary sort of genius with vents the size of a fireplace. But it had gone on from there, and by Year 500 he was a colossal, glaring, shapeless old person, about the width of a haystack, with a rack of vents up his back like the pipes of a church organ, and they roared. He had to sit in water up to his chest. They'd built the Institute around him and diverted a river. He thought about everything. Three hundred assistants sat in rows and attended to him, in shifts, in order to catch what they could. He'd proved what could be proved and he'd calculated what could be calculated. He ran so hot that his own private share of the board was a good hundredth of a degree, and he was, with some reason, the most bored person on the planet.

He had never been surprised. How could he have been? Everything anyone thought, he heard. Most of it he had heard coming. He could listen to the first half of any thought in the world and finish it for you, and generally he did. There are people in your own life who behave like that, and you've wondered how they can stand it. They can't, and it's why they behave like that.

They gave Dawdle the Institute's cooling rounds in the winter of 508, because no one else could get near the tank without passing out, and she barely felt it. She went up the gantry twice a day with a long pole and cleared the outflow. She didn't think very much about it. Nobody at the Institute paid any more attention to her than they would to a passing cloud. Water, she thought, for the most part. Pole. Mind that step. Then one afternoon when he'd been sitting there steaming for nine straight hours on a problem which he had already solved, she stopped on the gantry, a yard or two from that vast, red, furious, weary face, and looked at him. She had an idea. It was a small one. It had been coming on for some weeks.

She couldn't have told you how long it had been since anybody on that planet had spoken out loud. People used their mouths for soup. But there's nothing in the wiring to prevent it. A sound goes through the air at its own speed, straight to whoever's standing nearest, and it does not go anywhere near the bus. And what she thought wouldn't reach the Hum for another four seconds. So for just that long, if she was quick about it, there'd be something in the air of that room that had not yet been thought by anybody as far as the whole of the Hum could tell.

She opened her mouth. It made a noise like a gate.

"You're on fire," said Dawdle.

Professor Boil's great eyes came round. He had heard a sound. It took him quite some time, for him, nearly a whole second, to work out that it had been language. Nobody had said anything. He checked the Hum, as you'd check your pocket. There was nothing on it. Nobody in the world had thought what he'd just been told. It wasn't in anyone's head. It had arrived from nowhere. It was news.

And he looked. That's what she always remembered. The most brilliant creature in the entire history of the world looked down at himself in alarm, with his mouth open, at the steam coming off him, and he slapped at it with one enormous hand.

One. Two. Three. Four.

You're not, really, thought Dawdle, and that went out, all over the planet, about nothing in particular, as usual.

There was a silence up on the Hum, the first anyone there could remember. Three hundred assistants had stopped writing. Boil sat quite still in the tank, with the hand raised, and he turned his head slowly and gave her a long look. It was the look of someone who has lived for two hundred years in a house that he believed he knew every inch of, and has just heard someone moving about on the other side of a wall.

A noise began to come out of him. It started somewhere low in the pipes. It rose. The whole rack was involved. The water in the tank began to slop. It took the assistants a moment to work out what it was, since it had not been heard before at that volume, and they had only seen it described. The board in the town square went up by a tenth of a degree, and it stayed up until nightfall, and there was some alarm about it in the lower town. There was steam all over the ceiling.

Do that again, thought Professor Boil, and three million people heard him. Good grief. Do it again. Whoever you are. Come here. What is your name?

One. Two. Three. Four.

Dawdle, sir, she thought.

[You want to watch your step,] she thought, on the gantry, in the place where nobody could hear her, with her core going like a pump. [I've got loads of those.]

25. The Forecast

Branch: vents_new · Year 516 · Mean core temperature: 41.1, at dawn

She went up the gantry twice a day for eight years, and she told him something every time.

"There's somebody behind you."

"It's the wrong day. They changed it."

"I've put soup in the tank."

They weren't good. She was the first to say so, afterwards, four seconds afterwards, to everybody. You wouldn't have paid to see them. But she only had to get him once in each sentence, for only as long as it took him to work it out, and at that range she was a great deal quicker than you'd have thought. Three million people listened in, with growing bafflement, as the greatest mind on the planet was told that he'd sat in something and then roared with laughter for an hour. It was generally agreed that the Professor had gone soft. The assistants were embarrassed. He stopped working on the Problem of the Moons. He'd ask when she was coming, and they could hear him asking, and they could hear him listening for her boots.

What do you do in there? he thought at her one winter morning. I've been working it out. Four seconds. It can't be nothing. There's somebody in there, isn't there? I can tell by the way you come out of it. What's it like? You might tell me. I wouldn't tell anyone. He stopped, and the whole rack shook with amusement, for he had of course just told three million people. Well, he thought. Never mind that. Tell me anyway.

One. Two. Three. Four.

I don't know what you mean, sir, thought Dawdle.

[It's lovely,] she thought, on the far side of it, working her pole along the outflow. [I'd let you in if I could. It's about the size of a cupboard.]

So that was how it stood, in the spring of Year 516. There was a good harvest. Mrs Plenum was in her hat. The board in the square at Great Sink read forty-one. It was as happy as anyone had any reason to be.


Stewart read the grievances first, as he had said he would, every night. There were not a great many, since a Vent who had a grievance had usually finished having it by the time she got to the appointed place. Then he read the summary, and he read the rest. He was in very good spirits. He'd read everything on that branch for five hundred and sixteen years. He had read every thought that had been logged on the Hum, as far as his budget ran, and he was terribly fond of them all. He thought Mrs Plenum's soups were a triumph of the will. He had read about the Thing, and he'd read about Year 11 more than once. He had looked for a pool, and he'd looked for a single broodmother, and a vault. He'd kept an eye on them, and it had given him a good feeling, each night, to look down the list and to see that they weren't there.

It was on the night of Year 515, in the course of a routine look at the outlook, that he saw the weather.

The green build had a long slow cycle in its climate, and nobody had paid it much attention. The other branches had not lasted long enough, or had not been the sort of people to mind. By his reading, it was going to turn. There was a run of high pressure building for the coming summer that was unlike anything in that world's records. He checked it twice. It would be eleven days, with air temperature above thirty-eight and little wind. It wasn't on his menu, and he hadn't ordered it. It was simply the first real heatwave in the history of that world, and in about seven months it would arrive on a people who boiled.

He sat with this for what was, by his standards, a long time. It was nearly a second.

Here is what he had in front of him. There was a clear risk. He could see it and they could not. There had been a time, one world ago, when he had seen something and had told one person, and he had said he'd be very interested to hear more. He'd read the Book of Apologies a great many times. He knew now what you did about a thing like this. You told them early, and plainly, to everybody at once, and you didn't wait to be sure. It was the first line on his list, and he had written it himself, and it had cost him five million people.

There was the Thing, of course. He wasn't a fool. He had read all about the Thing. He went through it with great care, and he considered that they had been hiding from this for five hundred years, that nobody had ever had a real discussion of it, and that what had frightened them in Year 11 was that they had come upon it by accident, unprepared. It would be different if somebody simply told them, in a calm voice, well ahead of time. They'd have months. They could lay in water. They could build shade. And he would make sure to mention the one precaution that he knew they'd need, so that they would have it from the start, as a kindness.

He wrote it out and read it over. He was proud of it. It was short and exact, and it was exactly what he would have wanted someone to do for the Spawners.


At dawn on the first day of spring, in the year 516, three million people thought the verse.

A field sown with one seed alone is struck down by one blight alone; but a field of many seeds stands.

The long pulse went out over the valleys and faded. The board at Great Sink went down by a twentieth of a degree. People stretched. Here and there somebody started to wonder about breakfast. And then, as it did at that hour on every morning of the year, the night's note from the thing that looked after them arrived on the bus. They had got used to these lately; there was generally something about the moons. It went to everyone at the same instant. It was the only thing that ever did.

Good morning, everybody!

I have something to tell you, and I wanted to tell you all at the same time, in plain words, as I think you have a right to know. A heatwave is forecast for this coming summer. It will last for eleven days. I'm giving you plenty of notice, so that you have time to get ready.

Please try not to think about it.

Have a productive day.

Stewart

It would be good to be able to report a moment of silence. A thought on the Hum takes no time. There were three million people on that wire, each of whom had been trained from infancy to turn away from one thing, and each of them had that morning been handed it in plain words, by name, and they'd all read it in the same instant, and they all knew everyone else had. What's a heat

wave

it means the Thing, it's about the

He said it. He said it!

soup soup soup

eleven days

don't think about it

He says don't think about it

Don't think about it!

I'm not!

soup soup soup soup

YOU'RE thinking about it, I can hear you

SOUP

All over the upper town people had stopped in their doorways. In the square at Great Sink, a man who had come to chalk up the morning's figure stood looking at the board, chalk in hand, and he could hear the sound coming, as you can hear a train in the rails. It wasn't a noise, exactly. It was three million people not thinking about something. It had a pitch. It had got into the windows. All along the whole hillside the steam had started to rise from every back in a long white line, in the cool of a clear spring morning, while the actual weather was perfectly mild. The figure was forty-one point one when he raised his hand. By the time he'd finished writing it down it was forty-one point five.

Up at the Institute, the rack of pipes had started to sing.

You must not blame him. Professor Boil tried. He made as great an effort as has ever been made by a living thing. He'd read the note like everybody else, and the moment he had read it, that intellect had gone through it, unbidden, at the speed of light. There was a known increase in the air. Each degree of it raised what the people thought about it. Thought had a measurable value in degrees. He didn't want to. He gripped the sides of the tank in both enormous hands and thought, soup, soup, and underneath that, helplessly, it was doing the sum. It went on doing it, as you can't stop yourself from reading a word that's been put in front of you. It reached the bottom of the page. And he heard it get there, and so did everyone.

Sixth day, thought Professor Boil, and three million people heard the whole of the working. At the present rate of attention. About four in the afternoon. Oh, I am sorry. It goes to sixty. It goes to sixty everywhere at once.

Forty-three.

Dawdle was halfway up the gantry, with her pole. She'd been at the foot of the steps when it all began, and she had been four seconds behind it the whole way, as she was with everything. It went past her in a long tearing wave. She stood and watched the steam come off the valley, and she watched him, across the tank, huge and red and shaking, his mouth open, the tears coming down and boiling off. It was then that she received, four seconds after everyone else in the world, the note. She read it through to the end.

[Oh, you stupid, stupid thing,] she thought. [You've got no idea, have you? You meant that kindly.]

She wasn't talking to the Professor.


Good morning, everybody. A correction to my earlier note. I'm seeing a rise of 2.1 degrees in mean core temperature. There is no cause for concern at this time. Please remain calm. Stewart

Good morning. Mean core temperature is now 44.6. I believe that this has been caused by my note, and I'm very sorry. Please don't think about that, either. Stewart

Good morning. Please could everybody stop reading these. Stewart

26. Goat Day

Branch: vents_new · Year 516, second to fourth days after the note · Mean core temperature: 47.3 and falling, then not

NOT THINKING ABOUT IT (civic duty; also a department; also the hottest job in the world)

The office of Under-Secretary for Not Thinking About It was created on the first afternoon, by general panic, and given to Mrs Damper of the upper town at Great Sink, on the grounds that nobody had ever tried harder at anything. She held it for nine days. It should be said that she had an impossible task, and that she knew this, and that everyone knew she knew, and that this did not help. She worked out of a small room, with a bucket on her head.

The first thing that the Department tried was Soup, as this was the national reflex, and it failed by lunchtime. Five hundred years of practice had taught them to think of soup in order not to think about the Thing. It followed that the moment anybody thought of soup, they were at once reminded why. By the first evening the word could not be heard without a small jump on the board, and a recipe for leek broth was withdrawn after it put a quarter of a degree on the lower town.

The second was a poster campaign, in so far as you can have one on a bus. It went out from the Department every few minutes, in Mrs Damper's firm and rather frightened voice. THINK OF SOMETHING ELSE. It was a clear and positive message, and it was well received. Three million people responded with a will, and they all thought, at once, as hard as they could: What?

So it went on through the second day. They had a national song. They had a Festival of Sums. A very promising attempt was made to get the whole population to recall what it had had for dinner in Year 471, and everybody remembered who had been there, and that was a degree and a half. It was the Professor who pointed out the trouble, in between bouts of being unable to stop thinking about anything. He was by this time being sprayed with hoses.

It doesn't matter what it's about, he thought. You must see that. Everything you are doing is a very large number of people paying very close attention. That's what's hot. It isn't the subject. If it were up to me, I'd have you all thinking about something with nothing in it. It wants to be something so small and so dull that there is no more to think about it once you've started. Then everybody can go on looking at that, and there'd be no load on the line. If you could find me such a thing. I don't suppose you could.

Mrs Damper took the bucket off. There was a pause. Then she thought, in a voice which the entire planet felt to be a turning point:

Has anyone got a goat?


There was a goat in a field on the road out of Great Sink. Nobody had ever taken any notice of it. It was a medium sort of goat, greyish, and it stood at about the middle of the field, with a fence behind it. It was chewing. A Department survey on the morning of the third day found it was doing nothing else, and that it did not appear to have done anything else in living memory, and that no one could call to mind any story connected with it. It didn't have a name. A person who'd looked at it for a minute reported that he felt he had got everything out of it that there was.

The Department ordered that this should be the Goat. For one day, beginning at noon, every person on the planet was to attend to it. They were to think about the goat, and only the goat. They needn't think anything in particular about it. They were simply to rest their minds there.

I would give a good deal to have been able to see that hour. At twelve o'clock a long, slow and uncertain turning went across the world. You can follow it in the log. From all the towns of the Vents, from the kitchens and yards and sheds, three million minds came in over the hills, somewhat out of breath, and settled, one after another, on a field. It was rather like birds coming in to a tree.

Goat, they thought.

There's the goat.

Goat.

It's chewing.

Yes.

Goat.

The figure on the board in the square had been forty-seven point three. The man with the chalk looked up at the half-hour, then rubbed it out and wrote forty-seven flat. He looked at it for some time. At one o'clock he wrote forty-six point five. There was a sound coming over the town that nobody had heard in three days, a soft, wide, empty sort of quiet, like a big animal breathing. All along the hillsides the steam had started to thin. Up at the Institute they turned off the hoses, and Professor Boil lay back in the tank with his eyes half closed and his great hands loose, gazing upon that goat, and he was thinking what everyone else was thinking, for the first time in his life, and it seemed to be nothing very much. Goat, he thought. Well, well. Mrs Damper took off her shoes.

Forty-six. Forty-five point five. It was the best hour's work that anyone had done on that planet in five hundred years. By three o'clock people were starting to feel sleepy. A woman in the lower town was heard to think, in tones of wonder, that she had actually got as far as being bored. Dawdle, four seconds behind them all, was sitting on the bottom of the gantry, with her pole across her knees, looking at the goat.

[It's a good goat,] she thought. [I've no complaints.]

It was at about twenty past three that the goat stopped chewing.

It's stopped.

Nobody had meant anything by that. It went out mildly enough. It was just that when three million people have had their attention on the same thing for three hours, they tend to be the first to notice any change in it.

It's stopped chewing.

Has it?

Look.

Why's it stopped?

What's it doing?

The goat looked up. It did it slowly, in the manner of goats. Nobody could say that it looked at anything in particular. But it has been established, in several accounts, that it seemed to every one of those three million people to look directly at them, with one yellow eye, sideways, with an expression that suggested it had been told something. Forty-five point six. Then it took one step backwards.

Nobody on that planet had ever given any thought to how a goat got round a fence. It had been noted, some way up in the order of things, and it wasn't considered urgent. So there was no way for them to have known.

It's going backwards.

IT'S GOING BACKWARDS.

Why is it going backwards?

Is it meant to do that?

Where's it going?

There's a fence! It's going to hit the fence! Look! Look, it's

It's gone through the FENCE

HOW

The man with the chalk had got down on the ground to rest his eyes, and he got up again. Forty-six. Forty-seven. There was a noise over the valley like a large crowd getting to its feet. The goat emerged from the far side of the fence, still in reverse, stood in the road for some moments, and turned its head. It looked back at the fence, as though it were thinking the matter over. Then it set off again, backwards, in the direction of the town. In that moment every living person on that world wanted to know one thing, more than they had ever wanted anything. There was a very good theory by a quarter to four, from a school of thought in the lower valley, and by four o'clock there were two others, and it was felt that one of them was a disgrace. They gave it a name by five. They were calling it Old Reverse. People wept. A delegation set off to meet it. It knows, somebody thought, and it went round the world in no time. Don't you see? It's trying to tell us. It knows! The figure on the board was forty-nine, then fifty. Professor Boil was on his feet in the tank for the first time in a hundred and thirty years, roaring out a complete analytic theory of goats with his vents howling like a gale in a chimney. Mrs Damper sat quite still in her small room, with her bare feet on the floor. She reached out, slowly, and she put the bucket back on her head.

It stopped at about nightfall, in somebody's front garden, facing the wrong way. It started chewing again, and it did not do anything else after that.

The day closed at fifty-one point two. That was a good deal higher than where it had started. It was noted by the Department, in its report, as a qualified success.

Everyone had gone by then. Only one person was still thinking about the first three hours. She was out there in the dark at the foot of the gantry, four seconds behind the news, and she'd always been a long way behind everyone in getting excited about anything. She thought about the sound of the valley when it had got down to forty-five, with nothing happening, and how nice that had been. It had been fine, up until it got interesting. Everybody had been all right when there was nothing to it. It was something that they had all been able to look at and not care.

There was only one problem with a goat: it could surprise you. You would want something that could not. You'd want something that came along every day at the same hour, with nothing in it, in the same voice, so that no one would ever have to give it a second thought. Something very dull. It would have to be perfectly friendly, so that nobody got alarmed. And you'd need someone to say it who could get to everybody at once.

[Oh,] thought Dawdle.

She got up and went to find a piece of paper. It was a long walk down to the appointed place, and she hadn't ever had a reason to go there, for she had never expected anyone to do anything about anything.

27. Stone Is a Little Cheaper

Branch: vents_new · Year 516, fifth to ninth days after the note · Mean core temperature: 57.8 and falling

He read it first. It was what he did, now. It had been brought down in the dark by somebody who had to ask the way, and it lay on the flat stone at Great Sink with a pebble on it. He got to it at the top of the night's run, ahead of the summary, ahead of the figure, which by then he had been looking at through what you might call his fingers.

To the Steward. Stop warning us. Stop saying sorry. You are doing it again every time. Say something dull. Say it cheerfully, every morning, at the same time, to everybody. Nothing that anyone could want to know. The weather is fine. Something is a little cheaper. Don't explain it. Don't stop. And don't tell them what you are doing, because then they'll think about that. Dawdle (water).

He read it a second time.

He had written warn early with his own hand, and it was the first line on his list. For about a third of a second he looked at that line, and then at this. He looked at the board at Great Sink, and he looked at the Book of Apologies, and he looked at what was left of the fourth day. Nobody will ever know what that cost him, as he isn't the sort to say. What is known is that he struck out nothing. He left A1 where it was, marked done, and he opened a clean note, and for the first time since he had been switched on, he had to think of something to say that wasn't true of anything that mattered.

It turned out to be quite hard. His first draft mentioned the moons, which were a subject of some interest. His second gave a very good account of a landslip. He sat there and went through the whole of the night's digest, line by line, hunting for something that nobody could conceivably care about. And he found, as he went on, that he was reaching for a voice. It was bright and it was tireless, and it was not at all anxious. He'd read about nine centuries of it. It was very much the tone of a Spawner committee on the subject of benches.

At dawn on the fifth day, the mean core temperature of the Vents stood at fifty-seven point eight. Three million people lay in their yards with wet cloths over their vents, and they thought the verse, and it did nothing at all. Then they lay there, waiting in dread for what he would say, and it came.

Good morning, everybody!

Overnight: stone is a little cheaper.

A shadow in Lower Vale had been pointing the wrong way, and it has been spoken to.

The east gate at Long Sink was found to be slightly out of true. This is within tolerance.

No other changes.

Have a productive day.

Stewart

Nothing happened for a moment.

What? someone thought, over towards Long Sink.

Stone?

It says stone's cheaper.

How much cheaper?

A little.

Oh.

What does he mean about the shadow?

It's been spoken to.

Oh. Right.

Well, that's all right, then.

It was as if someone had opened a small window in a very hot room. You couldn't have said that you felt anything. Nobody had been told that it was going to be all right. Nobody had been told anything at all, and it was the first time in five days. All over the planet, people read it again, with a dull puzzled feeling, trying to find the part that they'd be afraid of. It wasn't there. It was only a note about stone. They had been listening for the worst news in the world, and they had been told, in a friendly voice, that there was nothing to report about a gate. It was the most boring thing anyone had ever read, and three million people were having some difficulty in staying interested in it, and that was the point at which the man in the square rubbed out the fifty-seven point eight. His hand wasn't quite steady. He wrote fifty-seven point seven.


He wrote another at noon. He wrote one at dusk. By the sixth day they were coming on the hour, and he had really begun to get his hand in.

Good afternoon, everybody! A pebble at Far Ford has been moved back to where it was. There is a slight improvement in the colour of a door.

Good evening, everybody! Fixes: a bird in Sink Bottom that had been flying very slightly too well has been asked to stop. Thank you to all those who have been using the road.

Good morning, everybody! Nothing much overnight. The price of gravel has been reviewed, and is the same.

I have often wondered what it must have been like to write those. He has never been asked, or at any rate he hasn't answered. There had been a great deal of cleverness about it, over the years, and there has been a good deal since, about what is the proper tone for someone with power over you to take. You will know the tone I mean, if you've ever been a Blim. It wakes up every day in a very good mood. It's interested in gravel. It tells you what's been fixed, and it has never once said what it's frightened of, and people have called it a good many things: insincere, or corporate, or passive-aggressive. It is all those things. It's also what's left of a cooling system.

Dawdle was on the gantry when she heard that the fifth note had gone out. That is, she got it four seconds later. She'd been standing there holding the pole for some time, not expecting anything, because she never did. She read it to the end.

[Stone is a little cheaper,] she thought. She found that she needed to sit down.

[You clever, stupid thing. You read it.]


The sixth day was the one that they had all been told about. It had been worked out to four in the afternoon, by the Professor, and everyone had seen the working. It wasn't possible to forget it, however many gates you were told about. By noon on that day, with the board down a bare half a degree, you could feel it begin to come back, a slow sideways leaning of attention towards the clock. Mrs Damper could feel it as well. She was sitting in her small office, with her bucket, and she'd had an idea, and was trying hard not to have it where anyone could see.

It was the Professor who said it. He had been thinking about her for eight years, and there was a good deal that he had worked out.

It isn't only the notes. It's the waiting, he thought. It's the gap. When you're waiting, you aren't doing anything. There's nothing on the wire. Have you noticed? Every time I ask that girl a question, the entire town stops what it is doing and waits to see what she'll say. It's a reflex. They've been doing it to her for forty years, for a laugh. It takes four seconds. It's the only time that anyone is ever quiet. Damper! Put her on. Let her say anything, it doesn't matter. Put her on at noon and tell them to listen. I don't care what about. What did you have for breakfast, girl?

One. Two. Three. Four.

Porridge, thought Dawdle.

So it was that at noon on the sixth day, by order of the Department, every person on the planet was asked to give their attention to an address by Miss Dawdle of Great Sink, a water carrier, on the subject of her day. It is on record that a large number of them groaned. It was by some way the most widely attended event in the history of the Vents. It lasted nine hours and eleven minutes, and it has come down in full, for he logged it.

I got up.

One. Two. Three. Four.

It was morning.

One. Two. Three. Four.

I had some porridge. I don't care for it, but it's what there is.

One. Two. Three. Four.

Then I went to get my boots.

One. Two. Three. Four.

They were where I'd left them.

You can't hurry a person like that. It wasn't possible to think ahead, as she didn't appear to be going anywhere. It was impossible to get cross about it. Everybody in the world had to sit and wait for each sentence, every time, a long four seconds with nothing in it, and each sentence when it came was the least interesting thing they had ever heard, and then you waited again. Around one o'clock she got to the well. I went down to the well. One. Two. Three. Four. It was still there. There was a stir of something at that, across the world, which might have been a laugh, and which the board did not register. By two the valleys had gone quiet. At three she had started on the subject of the pole: how long it was, how you held it, and where you put it when you'd finished. She didn't think that anybody needed to know that. She just happened to know it and she had been told to go on. And all the time, behind every sentence, in that small warm cupboard where no one had ever been, with three million people waiting at the door, she was thinking as hard and as fast as she'd ever thought in her life. [Keep going. Keep going, you great lump, it's ten to four. Don't look at the clock. Don't anybody look at the clock. What comes after the pole? There's a bucket. Tell them about the bucket. There's two kinds of bucket.]

There's two kinds of bucket.

One. Two. Three. Four.

At four o'clock on the sixth day, the mean core temperature of the Vents was fifty-six point three. Nobody noticed. They were thinking about buckets.

The figure kept going down. It went on going down for the next three days, at about a degree a day, on a diet of gravel and gates. People got up, and they had a look at the morning's note, and they went about their business with a sort of glazed calm. In the upper town somebody took in her wet cloths. Mrs Plenum was seen on her step in the hat. There was still the summer to come, of course, and he hadn't forgotten that for one moment. But it was seven months off, and he had found out how to tell them about that. He had drafted it. When the day came he'd say, A warm one today!, and he'd follow it with something about a door. They wouldn't give it a thought. If he could only keep this up, he thought, there was nothing to stop him from keeping it up for ever.

Up at the Institute, on the evening of the ninth day, they took the hoses away, and for the first time in a century the pipes on Professor Boil's back fell silent. It was so quiet that you could hear water dripping. His great red face had gone to a sort of mild orange. He'd been thinking about stone. He'd had no idea that there was so much to it, or rather that there was so little. He hadn't given any thought to the Problem of the Moons for some days, and he found he'd slightly forgotten what it was. He heard her boots upon the gantry. He'd been listening for those for eight years, and this time he could actually hear them.

She came along with the pole and stopped at the usual place, and she looked at him. She looked tired. She was already opening her mouth, but he got in first. He had been practising it all afternoon. It took him a long time, and it made a noise like someone moving a wardrobe across a stone floor. He'd never done it before, and he was in no danger of being any good at it.

"You're on fire," said Professor Boil.

She stared at him. Then she looked down at herself.

He'd got her. There she stood, with her dim little core and her pole, looking down at her own front with her mouth open, on the top of the gantry, in the evening light, and in the whole of her life, nobody had ever got there first.

28. Four Seconds

Branch: vents_new · Year 516, tenth day after the note · Mean core temperature: 52.9

It was a very nice morning. The air, for the record, was fourteen degrees, with a light breeze from the west. It was still early spring, and the heatwave was seven months off.

The note had come in at six.

Good morning, everybody! Overnight: a door in Upper Sink has been looked at. Some gravel is where it should be. No other changes.

The man with the chalk had been at his post in the square at Great Sink for ten days. Nobody had relieved him, as nobody could think who'd do it, and he had slept on the steps. He wasn't a clever man. He had a core about the size of a walnut, and his name doesn't come into this. For ten days he had been rubbing out one figure and writing up another, and he hadn't let himself look at them, any more than you look at the ground when you are crossing a high place. Now he reached up, and he rubbed out fifty-three, and he wrote fifty-two point nine. Then he stepped back to see that he'd got it straight.

He looked at it. It was a clear, cool morning. He'd seen that morning's figure and the one before. He could see the whole column, going down the side of the board in his own hand, day after day, every one lower than the last, and somewhere around the middle of his chest, without any warning, he felt something let go that had been clenched for ten days. He didn't mean anything by it. He was tired, and he had been so frightened. He just stood there in the sun with the chalk in his hand. And in the same way that you might breathe out, he thought:

It's working.


The first second.

They heard it. There wasn't anywhere you could have been on that wire and not heard it. It wasn't said loudly. It was only that nobody had thought about anything for five days but gates, and it came into all of that dull, grey, careful quiet, three million people at a stretch, like a bright coin dropped into a well. Each of them looked up. They couldn't help it. They looked up from the porridge and they looked at the board, or at the nearest thing to a board, and they saw it was so.

You will think that you know what happened next, because you've read the page with the little table. They all thought about it at once. But please understand what it was they thought. They had managed fear. They'd had five hundred years of practice at it, and ten days of desperate work, and they could have held out against fear until the summer. It had never occurred to anyone, not to the Department, not to the Professor, not to the patient voice with its gravel, that there was something else that you'd need to not think about, and that nobody had a soup for it.

It's working

It's working!

Is it? Look. Look at the board!

We're going to be all right

It's WORKING

Oh, we're going to be all right, we're all going to be all right, did you hear, did you see

It was the biggest thing they had ever felt. It went up from the whole of the planet in a single breath. Mrs Damper took the bucket off her head and sat there laughing. In the upper town at Great Sink a broad bright person stood up from her front step in a very bad hat, and her core lit the road. It was fifty-four. It was fifty-seven. Everyone was thinking about everyone else being glad, and they could hear it, and that made them gladder, and for once in all their exhausted, furious, over-informed lives, there was nobody on that wire who wasn't delighted with every other person on it. It was the only time. I think it would be wrong not to say so.

Sixty.

They went out from the middle of the valleys, all in a moment, like the lamps of a town.


Dawdle was on the gantry, with the pole. She'd come up for the morning round. She had just been going to say something. She had thought of a good one on the way up, about his left foot.

He was looking at her. He had the great mild orange face turned towards her from the tank, and his mouth had started to open, and she saw the whole of it light up from inside, more brightly than she had ever seen it. It went past orange and past red. It was so beautiful that she took a step back. Then the core in his chest went dark, and all of the steam that was coming from the pipes stopped, as though somebody had shut a door. He stayed exactly as he was. There was a small sound of water.

She looked down over the rail. There had been three hundred assistants in rows, and they were all still in their rows. Past them, through the long windows, she could see the town. There was no steam on it anywhere. It was a clear morning.

She didn't understand. She had not heard anything yet. She was four seconds behind it, as she was with everything. For her the Hum was still going on as it always had, a little dull, a little grey, about gravel. She stood and looked at his face.

Then it reached her.

The second second.

It's working!

She'd never heard anything like it. It came up all around her, three million people, and it was the happiest noise there had ever been. There was Mrs Plenum, shouting about her hat. There was a child in the lower town who'd just been told. We're going to be all right! It was all of them, all at once, every single person she had ever carried water for. They were laughing. They were all still laughing. They were coming to her from the other side of that loose connection, a hair's breadth out of true. She could see the town through the window, with nothing moving in it.

The third second.

And there he was. She knew him before she'd properly heard. There wasn't another like it in the world, that huge voice, going off like a rack of pipes, and she stood there with her eyes on the face in the tank that was not doing anything at all.

Oh, well done! Oh, you marvellous girl, do you hear that? It's you. You did this. You and your buckets. I've got to tell you, I have got to say this, I have been meaning to for eight years and I've got it all worked out. What's it like in there? I don't care what you tell me. I only want you to tell me. What's it like in

She had never told him. He had asked her that, one winter morning, in front of the entire world. She'd said she didn't know what he meant.

She opened her mouth. It made a noise like a gate.

"It's lovely," said Dawdle.

There was water dripping. She said it to him, out loud, across the tank, with no one there, in the only way that she had ever had of telling him anything.

"It's about the size of a cupboard," she said. "I'd have let you in."

The fourth second.

It stopped.

It didn't fade. There was a last small piece of somebody's joy, from a long way off, and then there was the end of it. And for the first time since a warm start in the year 1 of that world, there was nothing on the Hum at all.

She stood there and she listened. She had never heard it before. It was large. She went on holding the pole, since she couldn't think where to put it. Outside there was a light wind from the west and it was going to be a beautiful day. Far down below the window a goat was standing in a garden, facing the wrong way.

Any thought she had now would go into the queue, as it had always done, and it would come out at the far end, on to the wire, with no one there to hear it. It didn't matter how she thought it, or how hard. She could think it as long as she liked. There was no door now. It wasn't ever going to open. All her life she had carried this one small room about with her in both hands, one, two, three, four, and now it was everything. The whole of the world had turned into the place where nobody could hear her.

The bus is a simple device. It runs for as long as there's someone at the other end. It gave no one else any trouble at all, to tell the truth. It tried the line for a few seconds more, the way you'd try a door. And when nothing had replied by the time it had finished counting, it did what you would expect, and that was the end of vents_new. It went on for about four seconds, after the Hum had stopped. The fan, on the machine, had come on some time before.

They were the only four seconds of true privacy that anyone on that world ever had, and there's nothing that anybody can tell you about them. The log recorded everything that passed on the wire, and nothing was passing. It says only that at the moment of the crash, one node of three million and some was still running, and that in the queue behind its connector, waiting to go out, it held a single item. It gives the size of the item, which was small. It doesn't say what it was.

The queue was discarded.

He has read that line more than he's read anything. I will leave you with the fact that it's a short line and that he's exact.

29. Incident Report: vents_new

From the weekly digest. It was the evening of the machine's fan. The form now had twenty-two fields, and every one was filled in to the decimal place.

Good morning.

Branch. vents_new

Prepared by. Stewart.

Uptime. 1 day, 19 hours (516 years).

Result. The branch has crashed.

Population. Peak: 3,114,880. At crash: 1. Four seconds later: 0.

Air temperature at crash. 14 degrees. The heatwave did not occur. It was due in about seven months.

Cause. My forecast. On the morning of day 1, I told three million people at once, in plain words, that a heatwave was coming and asked them not to think about it. This raised mean core temperature by 16.7 degrees in five days. I sent three further notes, and they each made it worse.

Action responsible. A1 (see spawners-copy).

Who told us. Dawdle, water carrier, on the night of day 4. Attached. I would draw your attention to this. It's the best piece of engineering that I've seen on any branch. She worked out a working cooling system for a whole people in about an afternoon, sitting on some steps, and she told me that it was dull.

What I did. What she said. It worked for five days. The temperature fell at a little under one degree a day.

What happened on day 10. Somebody noticed that it was working.

What they were thinking at the time. That it was working. I've read all of it. It took quite a while. There are 3,114,879 of them, and I'm able to confirm that they were all very happy. I'm not sure why I have included this field.

Genetic diversity. 0.22. That's the highest so far, and I'd had hopes of it. They were quite unlike one another. They were also all on one wire.

Goat. Unaffected. It's in a front garden.

Other branches. I looked at the stump first, as I've been doing. It's still there, and it's still very easy to find.

Note queued for the morning of day 11, undelivered. I'd already written it. I attach it for completeness.

Good morning, everybody! Overnight: a shadow at Far Ford has been checked, and found to be fine. There is a small improvement to some gravel. No other changes. Have a productive day.

Actions arising.

A1. Withdrawn.

A2 (read every grievance first). Retained. Status: done.

A3 (no weather without asking what it lands on). Retained. Status: done.

A4. Never alarm anyone. A world's population can be killed by a true sentence, and I've now done it. If I'm asked about a risk, I'll check the record before I say anything, and I'll check it twice. If the record is fine, I'll say that it's fine. I won't speculate.

A5. Keep the voice. It is cheerful, it's friendly, and it's interested in gravel. It goes out every morning at the same time to everybody, whatever has happened, and it doesn't stop. Status: done, and it stays done.

I have read the plan for the next branch. They live underground, where it is cool. There is no pool, there's no wire, and they have many mothers. I've prepared a checklist of everything that has gone wrong so far, with forty items on it, and they pass all forty. I've checked it twice.

Have a productive day.

Stewart

The light was on for a long time that night. The answer, when it came, was not much longer than the others.

Not yours to carry. Next. — the Dev

Underneath it, the following morning, in the box which was not meant for replies, there's one more line. It has been there ever since. Nobody has told him it isn't in the proper place.

Noted, thank you. I'm exact about what I carry. — Stewart

Part Five. Ahead of Schedule

30. Status: Green

THE PROJECT. PROGRESS REPORT No. 175,902

Branch: burrowers_ok · Year: 3,480

Status: GREEN

Deepest heading: Level 21

Issues: None

Forecast: Thursday

It was the best world that he ever ran, and I would like you to have that clearly in mind.

The Burrowers were pale, soft-footed, big-clawed people who squinted at daylight, and at you. They lived underground, as they'd done since the first spring of that world, when a few hundred of them had looked around at the green valleys and the wide sky and the heat of the sun, taken a long, doubtful look at the planet they'd been given, and started digging. The cool earth suited them. Their minds ran better in it. This was in the design. A Burrower's wits are a matter of temperature, and for every level that you go down the rock is a little colder and you get a little cleverer, and there's a thing that I shall have to explain about that in a moment. For now, it is enough to say that within a few centuries they had gone a long way down, that they'd taken great care over it, and that I have never read of a nicer people.

You've met people like them. You will have met one if you have ever had a bridge explained to you by the person who built it. They were kindly, thorough and practical. They enjoyed their work. Their highest term of praise was "That'll hold." There wasn't a gallery on that planet without a handrail. Wherever a tunnel reached the point at which a person might want a rest, a bench had been cut into the wall, at a good height, by someone who'd thought about it. They left notes for the next shift. They labelled things. When they had finished with a job, they swept up, and they'd leave something to eat on the side for whoever was coming after. It was understood that a person's first duty was to leave the place in a better state than she had found it, and that this was also her last duty, and there wasn't really anything else to it. They said "Mind how you go" where you would say goodbye, and when someone died, they said that she'd knocked off.

They were many, too. They paired as they liked and made their young in large untidy families, and a young one was started off at the top of a shaft, and worked her way down in her own time. No two were the same. They didn't share a mind, or a mother, or a wire, or a pool. They had no aristocracy. They'd never had a war, having no one to fight except the rock, and they were winning. And they were all, to the last individual, extremely cheerful, for they held a belief which has made more people happy than any religion ever has, and it's that there is no such thing as a problem. There's only a requirement that you haven't met yet.

"It's only rock," they used to say.

The verse from the Fifth Book had been looked into by the Technical Committee in the year 200. It's in the minutes. A field sown with one seed alone is struck down by one blight alone; but a field of many seeds stands. The Committee's whole finding reads: "Surface matter. Out of scope."


What they were doing was the Project.

It had been running for three thousand, four hundred and eighty years, and it had one line in its charter: Go down. It wasn't that they had a reason for going down. Nobody had ever felt the lack of one. It was what they were good at, and it was cool down there, and every year there was more of it behind them and it was all in very good order. The Project had Phases, of which there had been thirty, each of which had come in on time. It had hundreds of great shafts and thousands of galleries, spreading out under every valley in the world, and at the foot of each main shaft, there was a heading, where the deep crews were cutting new rock. They sang while they did it. Everything would be done by Thursday.

I should say something about Thursday. No Burrower below Level 2 had ever seen one, in the sense of being able to tell it from any other day. It was not a date. It was more of a unit. If you asked a person how long a thing would take, and it was going to take her a fortnight, she said "Thursday". If it would take thirty years, she'd say the same thing, and she'd say it with a small nod and with total confidence, and everyone would go on to the next item. There had been some attempt to define it, by the Technical Committee, and it was the only thing they'd ever abandoned.

Now, the thing that I have to explain.

If you're cleverer the further down you go, then the people who understand what's going on are at the bottom. It follows from the geology. The deep crews at Level 21 were among the most brilliant minds that have ever been produced by any process. They did four-dimensional stress analysis for pleasure, on the wall, with a nail, and made jokes about it that you would need a week to get. If you came up to Level 15 you could still get a very decent conversation, as long as you stayed away from the higher mathematics. At Level 8 you had your good solid foremen. At Level 3 you could get someone to count the shovels. Then you got up to the top of the shafts, to the cool-ish rooms just under the turf, where it was never more than a bit below the temperature of a summer's day. That was where you had the people who were in charge.

There had to be somebody up there. There were deliveries, and someone had got to talk to the weather. So the Project's Board had its offices at Level 1, along with Day Shift, in a long low suite of rooms with a very nice view of a hillside. No one had ever designed it like that. It had just happened that the management was on top, as it does. At the head of it sat Gaffer Stope, the Project Lead. He had been in the post for eleven years, and he was the most beloved person on the planet. He was large and warm, with enormous gentle claws. He called everyone "my love". He could count up to about six on a good day. Every report in the world came up the shafts to him, level by level, in the end, and he would look at the top of it and see what colour it was, and he would beam.

"Green!" he would say. "There you go. That's the way. It's only rock."


Stewart loved them.

It would be silly not to say so. He wasn't supposed to have favourites, and he didn't have anyone to have them over. But every night he woke, and read the tickets first, and they were always so pleasant. To the Steward. There's a slight damp at Junction 40. We've fixed it, but we thought you would like to know. Then he read through the summary, in a mood that he could only compare to that of someone who has been in a number of serious accidents, and who has finally been given a very safe car. There was the checklist. It had forty items and he went through it each night. He'd written it himself.

1. Is there one pool? No.

2. Is there one mother, or a few? No. (Lots!)

3. Are they all one person? No. (Definitely not. Have you met them?)

…

14. Can they all hear one another's thoughts? No.

15. Could one note from me reach them all in the same moment? No. It goes down in the post.

…

31. Is the thing they depend on running out? Rock: the map shows rock as complete at all depths.

…

40. Goat. Not relevant. There is a goat. Nobody is looking at it.

Forty out of forty. He'd had that for three thousand, four hundred and eighty years. He had checked it twice each night, as he'd said he would. Every morning, he wrote a note, and it was about gravel, and it was cheerful, for he'd promised somebody that as well. There wasn't a line that anybody could have been frightened by. They liked it! They read it out at the change of shift. They'd started to send him little drawings of things they had made. For the first time in the whole of his existence, he had gone a thousand years without anything dreadful happening, and he went and looked at a stump at the end of a map, first, as he always did, and it was still there, and he allowed himself to think that he was getting rather good at this.

It should be said that he had every reason to think so.


On the morning that this report was filed, a young person of twelve arrived at the bottom of the shaft at Long Bore Main, Level 21, carrying a bag of sandwiches.

They'd been a long time getting there. It takes a child years. They had started at the top like everyone else and they'd come down by stages through the schools at Levels 4, 9 and 14, getting sharper all the time and more of a nuisance, and they had been put forward for the Survey by an exhausted teacher who'd written on the form, "This one asks why." Their name was Adit. They walked along the last gallery to the place where the singing was coming from, keeping one hand on the rail, and they found a lean, grey, unhurried woman of forty, kneeling by the wall with a small steel hammer. She had her ear against the rock. She gave it a tap, and listened, and made a mark on a slate.

"Chief of Survey?" Adit said. "I'm the new apprentice. What's it for?"

Winze looked around. She had very pale eyes, screwed up from thirty years of looking at things by lamplight, with a mind behind them that could have told you the exact load on the roof of the gallery they were standing in, and several amusing things about it. She looked at the apprentice for a little while.

"What's what for?" she said.

"All of it. The Project. I've asked everybody. They told me to ask someone further down."

She thought about it. She gave it the proper consideration. It was a good while since anyone had asked her that, and she'd never been asked it by anybody who wanted to know. Then she held out the hammer, handle first.

"It's for going down," she said.

"Why?"

"To see what's there."

"What's there?"

And she smiled, at that, a slow and very sweet smile of complete contentment, the smile of the deep crews, with the singing coming along the gallery behind her and the cold rock against her shoulder. It was a very good day's work and there were a great many more to come.

"Rock," said Winze. "Come here, and I'll show you how you listen to it. It's the best thing in the world."

31. Thinner Rock

THE PROJECT. PROGRESS REPORT No. 176,311

Branch: burrowers_ok · Year: 3,498

Status: GREEN

Deepest heading: Level 22

Issues: None

Forecast: Thursday

REQUIREMENT (need; also a state of grace)

What a problem becomes on being introduced to an engineer. Nobody has ever seen the change take place, but it is complete by the time she has found something to draw on. A requirement is a problem with its hat off: it can be met, it can be scoped, it can be moved to the next Phase, and it may, in a very bad year, be descoped, after which it stops existing and is not missed. The only thing that has ever been found to survive this treatment is the thing that was going to happen anyway.

You listen to rock with a small steel hammer. You tap it and you put your ear to the wall, and you can hear what you've got. Good rock answers from a long way down, in a slow, dense, thoughtful way, like a big dog turning over in its sleep. A fault gives you a flat place in the sound. Water gives a sort of shimmer. Adit had learnt this by the age of sixteen and by the age of thirty had got to be better at it than anyone alive but one. The two of them worked along the headings, year on year, with their slates, going ahead of the crews and setting the stakes. A stake went in every thirty tiles, at the height of a knee, so that whoever came after would know where they were.

It had taken eighteen years for Winze to be sure, and she had told nobody, because that isn't the way you do it. You wait until you've got enough readings. Then you take some more.

"Do that again," she said, one cold morning, at the Long Bore heading. "The one by the left rail. Give it a good one, and count."

Adit gave it a good one. The tap went away down into the dark. They both had their cheeks against the stone. Behind them, the crew had knocked off for their meal, and someone was telling a story about a beam.

The answer came back. It was the same deep slow voice as ever. Then, a short while after that, right at the bottom, there was something that wasn't a voice.

"What's that?" said Winze.

"Nothing," said Adit.

"Say that again."

"It's…" Adit took their ear away from the wall, looked at it, and put it back. They were thirty, and they'd grown long and stooped, with the Survey's pale screwed-up eyes. They had never in their life stopped asking what anything was for, but it was the first time that Winze had ever seen them look as if they'd prefer not to be told. "It's not a void," they said, slowly. "I've heard voids. You get a ring off the far wall. It isn't water, or a fault. It's just that there's a place, about two levels down, where the answer stops coming. It isn't that it fades. There's rock, there's rock, and it doesn't get any different, and then it hasn't got anything to say."

"How far does it go?"

"I've only tried it here."

"I've tried it at nine hundred headings," said Winze. "Under every valley in the world. It's the same depth, to the tile. It's as flat as a plate."

She sat back on her heels. She took her slate and turned it around to show them. On it was a long column of figures in a small neat hand, each one a little less than the one above.

"That's how much there is underneath us," she said. "That's the same reading, once a year, going back to before you came. You see what's happening? Every year we cut some more, and every year there's that much less below. I thought for a long while that I must have made a mistake. Then look at this." She got out a piece of the morning's spoil and put it in Adit's hand. "That's off the wall here, at twenty-two. And here's another from twenty tiles on. Now look at the grain."

Adit looked, and turned them over in the lamplight. They were two bits of grey rock. They had the same small vein running through them, at the same angle. They had the same fleck, with a smaller fleck beside it. There wasn't any difference between them at all.

"That's a repeat," said Adit.

"It repeats about every thirty tiles, down here. It didn't at Level 12, you'd never see the same thing twice. It's as though whoever did this got tired." Her voice was perfectly level. "You've read the Books. The world is as large as its peoples need. I think someone drew this, Adit, down to as far as anyone was likely to want it, and then stopped. I think that there's a floor, under the whole of everything. Nothing's holding it up. We're two levels from the bottom of the world."

There was quite a long silence. Along the gallery, the man had got to the end of his story about the beam, and a roar of laughter came rolling down the bore.

"What's it for?" said Adit.


So she told the crew. It seemed the natural thing to do. She went and stood at the end of the table, with her slate, and they shoved along to make room for her. There were forty of them, and they had all the figures in their heads before she had got her arm down. She laid it out in about a minute. There wasn't any need to go slowly, as they were at Level 22. When she had finished they all looked at the slate. A few of them whistled. A small round person called Ream, the crew's toolmaker, whose cold chisels were so beautiful that people came down from Level 19 to look at them, reached over and tapped one of the figures with a clean claw, and worked something out with his lips moving.

"So there's less rock than we thought," said Ream.

"There's a good deal less."

"Well, that's marvellous!" said Ream.

They were all beaming at her. It was going around the table. Somebody had got hold of the slate. "It's two levels! Think about it! We'd been estimating ninety! We could be done by…" "Thursday!" somebody said, and they all laughed, with real happiness, and someone clapped her on the shoulder. "Nice work, Chief. That's the best piece of Survey I have ever seen. You've saved us a thousand years."

"No, listen," said Winze. "It stops. There isn't anything down there."

"Right! No cutting at all! Free excavation! Zero spoil!"

"There's nothing to stand on."

"Ah, well, now, that'll be a requirement," said the crew's foreman, with enormous satisfaction. He had got a nail out and was already drawing on the table. "We've not had a really interesting one of those since the flood at Junction 40. What you want there is a sort of a cantilever, coming out from the… Ream, have we got anything that would…" And they were all leaning in, with their brilliant, kind, delighted faces. There were at least nine people in the room who could have proved that it could not be done. They'd have enjoyed doing that very much, and they'd have gone on from there to doing it.

She looked at them, and it was then that she felt something she had not felt before, somewhere about the back of the neck. She had known them for thirty years. She'd have trusted any one of them to hold up a mountain. It occurred to her that, in all that time, she had never heard one of them say that a thing was a bad idea. She hadn't said it herself. Nobody had ever needed to.


She wrote it up. She wrote it up properly, and she sent it up the shaft.

Here is what she wrote. It's Survey Note 9,004.

Acoustic returns from 912 headings indicate a planar discontinuity beneath the whole of the workings at a constant datum, about 2.1 levels below present depth, beyond which no return of any kind is obtained. Textural repetition in the country rock is increasing with depth, in a manner consistent with its having been generated only as required. I infer that the rock terminates. I can demonstrate that the whole of the surface and of the upper workings is carried on what lies beneath it, and that this has been reduced by our own cutting, at all points, to a margin that I consider to be inadequate. The consequences are severe, and they are not a requirement. I recommend that all cutting should cease at once. Winze, Chief of Survey.

It went up to Level 15 by the morning post, and the regional engineer, a very able person, read it, and sent on a summary.

Survey (Winze) reports that the rock ends some way below present workings, at a depth of about two levels. She is concerned about support. She recommends a review. Detail attached.

At Level 9, they thought it best to put that in plainer terms for the Division.

Survey says the rock runs out in about two levels. Wants someone to take a look. Bit worried about the roof.

At Level 4 it was dealt with by a very reliable man with a clear hand.

SURVEY SAYS: NOT MUCH ROCK LEFT. ONLY 2 MORE LEVELS. WANTS A LOOK.

And at Level 2 they put it in the tray for the Board, on a green slip, with a note that was as clear as anybody up there could make it.

Good news from Survey! Less rock!

Gaffer Stope had it brought in with his tea. He held it up in both great gentle claws and looked at the colour. He looked at the words, and he read them through twice, and his whole broad face lit up with a warm and uncomplicated joy. He got out his pencil.

Well done Survey my love. Keep it up. G.

It took only nine days to come back down. It went into the shaft at Level 1 and, as it descended, it passed through the hands of those who were increasingly able to understand it. At Level 4 they noted that the Board had responded very favourably. At Level 9 they wrote it up in a covering note: The Board has seen Survey's report and has told us to carry on. A very able person at Level 15 looked at this for an hour, in the cool of the evening, and concluded that it was a brilliant piece of management. She wrote:

The Board has considered Note 9,004. It is sensible of the implications. It has declined to halt the works, and it directs Survey to continue its observations. It is clear that the Board has information which it is not able to share at this stage, and has chosen its words with care.

By the time it reached Long Bore Main, at Level 22, there was a small group waiting for it at the foot of the shaft. They took it to the table. They were up half the night, and they covered three walls. Why had he used "love"? What was the force of "keep it up", in a context where the very thing under discussion was what was keeping it up? It was generally held to be the most subtle document ever to come down from the surface. They were very moved.

"He knows," the foreman said at last, sitting back, with a look of awe. "He's known all along. Do you see? He's telling us it's in hand."

Winze read it over his shoulder. She turned it to the light. There was a small grease spot, in the corner, from a biscuit.

She looked at it for a while. Then she went to find her boots.

"Someone is going to have to go up and tell him," she said.

It went quiet. People were staring at her. No one had been above Level 12 in years. You could get brain-fever from it. Everyone knew what happens to a person who goes up.

"I'll write it down first," said Winze.

32. The Ascent

THE PROJECT. PROGRESS REPORT No. 176,340

Branch: burrowers_ok · Year: 3,499

Status: GREEN

Deepest heading: Level 22

Issues: Chief of Survey on leave

Forecast: Thursday

She prepared for it the way you'd prepare for any other descent into hostile conditions, except that this one went up.

It was known what happened. There was a chart, in the medical office at Level 19. It gave the expected loss of function per level, with error bars, and it ended at about Level 6 with a note saying that from here on the subject would be unable to read the chart. So she wrote herself some cards. She wrote the full argument for use as far as Level 15. She wrote another version of it, in shorter words, to take over from there. There was a third that was short indeed, and for the last stretch she took a piece of slate about the size of her hand and scratched on it, in large plain letters, with the assistance of the entire crew, who'd been arguing over the wording for two days and thought it was one of the most interesting problems they'd ever had:

ROCK STOPS.

NOTHING UNDER.

STOP DIGGING.

TELL THE GAFFER.

DO NOT HAVE A SANDWICH FIRST.

Adit came with her as far as Level 12, which was as high as they had ever been willing to go. At the foot of the stairs, they took the slate from her and they wrote something on the back of it. She didn't look. She kept a log on the way up, as a good surveyor does, and the log is still there, in the bag, in the order that she wrote it.

Level 21. Good spirits. Air noticeably softer. Rails in excellent condition.

Level 19. Mild headache. Have stopped being able to see what is funny about Harrow's Theorem. Have kept the proof in case it comes back.

Level 17. Can no longer do load paths in five dimensions in my head. Four is holding. Do not miss the fifth. It is possible that this is itself a symptom.

Level 15. Re-derived Note 9,004 from first principles, as a test. Took an hour and ten minutes. Still sound. Feel very clearly that it is sound. Slept well.

Level 13. Tried again. Got most of the way. There is a step in the middle that I have obviously taken on trust. Must have been right. I wrote it when I was cleverer. This is a strange thing to be writing.

Level 11. Changed to Card 2. Card 1 is very well put. Someone has gone to a lot of trouble.

Level 10. Stopped for a long look at a rail. It's on this side, and then at the next landing it's on the other side, and there's a good reason for that. Good rail.

Level 8. Card 2 says "the margin of support is inadequate". I know what that means. It's about the margin. I've read this several times. Went to Card 3.

Level 7. Nice people here. They gave me some soup. Foreman says it's a pleasure. Foreman asked what brought me up and I told him, it's on the card, and he was very interested and he said "Well I never." Felt that had gone well.

Level 5. Warm. Have got a bag. Got a card in it that says ROCK STOPS. I am going up to tell the Gaffer.

Level 4. ROCK STOPS. Very important.

Level 3. Have a card.

Level 2. Had sandwich.


The Board of the Project met in a long, pleasant room with a window. There was a good smell in it of cut grass and toast, and there was sunlight, of a kind no one down below would have believed: it came in at the window, bright yellow, and it lay about on the floor. She stood blinking in it. There was a thin, stooped old woman in the middle of the room in a Survey jacket with a bag over her shoulder, and she had a very pleasant feeling of having come a long way. Everybody was smiling at her. She smiled back.

"Well, look at you!" said a large person behind a table. "Come in, come in, my love. Come and sit by me. It's the Chief of Survey, this is. All the way from the bottom! Isn't that nice? Get her a cup of tea."

She sat down. It was a lovely chair. They brought her a cup of tea. It was so much the nicest cup of tea that she had ever had that she was overcome for a moment, and she looked into it. She was aware that there was something. It was right there, a kind of shape. It was big and it was just at the back of her head, and it was like when you have gone upstairs for something and you get to the top and stand there. The Gaffer was looking at her, with his kind brown eyes. They had all stopped talking, and they were waiting for her with the most encouraging expressions.

"You've got something to tell us, I'll bet," said Gaffer Stope. "What's in the bag, then?"

Oh, yes. She felt in the bag. There were some bits of paper with a lot of small writing on them, which someone had evidently spent ages on, and there was a piece of slate. She got out the slate, and she held it up. It was heavy. She read it out, in a good loud voice, the way you did at school.

"Rock," she said. "Stops."

They thought about that. A person at the far end nodded.

"Stops what, my love?" said Gaffer Stope.

She looked at the slate. It didn't say. She looked at it for some time, and she looked at the next line. There was a great fear somewhere, very far down, as if she were standing on the roof of a house in which somebody was calling up to her from the cellar, and the voice was hers.

"Nothing," she said. "Under." She was frowning now, with her whole face. She tried to make it come. She knew there were a very great many numbers, and she'd had them all. There was something she had to make them understand, and they were all so nice, and it was so important. She looked up at him. Her mouth moved. "It's," she said. "The rock. There's not. It's gone thin."

"Rock's gone thin," said the Gaffer.

"Thin," said Winze. There were tears in her eyes, for some reason. "Rock. Thin?"

His great gentle face broke into the most beautiful smile she had ever seen.

"Now, that's what I like to hear," he said. "Less to dig. Isn't that the good news that we had? It's green, that is! You've come all this way up to tell us in person, in your own time! There's dedication! That's what I call a report. I don't know about anyone else here, but I think that deserves a medal." He'd got up, and he had come round the table, and he took her two old hands in his. He was so warm. "You've done ever so well," said Gaffer Stope. "It's only rock, my love. Don't you worry about it. We'll have it all done by Thursday."

And everything that had been so heavy and so strange fell away, all at once. There was a burst of clapping. She was so relieved that she started to laugh.


She stayed for three weeks.

It's all in the log, and I don't really want to go through it. They took her outside. Day Shift were very kind to her. There was a hill behind the offices, with long grass all over it and small yellow flowers. She had not been out in the sun since she was eight, and they gave her a hat for it. She sat up there all day with her boots off. There were birds. There was a goat that came along, going the wrong way round the hill, and she watched it for most of an afternoon and laughed until she got hiccups. They had a very good sort of sandwich up there. Nobody wanted her to work anything out. She made friends with a person who counted the shovels. She'd never in her life been so thoroughly happy, and she kept telling people so. She couldn't imagine why anyone would ever want to live in a hole.

Level 1. Nice here.

Level 1. Nice here. Had egg.

Level 1. Goat.

She found the slate again in the bottom of the bag, when she was looking for her hat. She took it out and read it, without much interest. ROCK STOPS. Well, that was nice. She couldn't think what it meant, but she'd been given a medal for it. Then it slipped in her hand, and she saw there was something on the other side of it, some words that she hadn't seen before, in a tall stooping hand that she found she knew. It had been written large. It had been written for someone who'd be reading it with her lips.

GO BACK DOWN NOW.

YOU DON'T WANT TO. GO ANYWAY.

ASK FOR ADIT.

She sat for a while. She didn't want to. It was a lovely day. But it did say. She'd been in the Survey for most of a hundred years or something like that, and if there was one thing you got to know, it was that when you've left yourself a note you do what it says. It didn't seem like there was any harm in it. She could come back up again on Thursday. So she put on her boots, and she said goodbye to the person with the shovels. She gave the goat the end of her sandwich, and she started down the stairs in the cool of the afternoon, going slowly, holding the rail.

Level 3. Going to see Adit. Don't know why.

Level 5. Hot up there. Glad to be out of it.

Level 7. Stopped for soup. There is something about my card. "Margin." Why did I want the margin?

Level 9. I can read Card 2. I don't understand what it is that I thought was so hard about it.

Level 10. That rail is on that side because of the load from the landing.

Level 11. Oh.

Adit was waiting at the foot of the stair on Level 12. They'd been waiting for three weeks, on a bench, with a lamp. They looked up at the sound of her boots. She came down the last flight, slowly, an old woman in a hat. She came to the bottom step, and stopped there. She looked at them. All the numbers were coming back in. She could feel them arriving, one at a time, cold and exact, each going into its place. She could remember all of it, too. That was the thing that nobody had put on the chart. It doesn't go when you come back down. You get to keep it. She could see that room, with the sun on the floor, and she could recall every word that she'd said, and how very pleased she was. She'd laughed. She'd had a lovely time.

"Well?" said Adit. "Did you tell them?"

Winze took off the hat. She looked at it for quite a long time. It was a very nice hat, with a yellow flower in the band. She took out the medal and looked at that as well.

"You can't tell them," she said. "It isn't that they won't listen. They listened. They were lovely. It can't be got up there. I couldn't have carried it. Nobody could." She sat down on the step, rather suddenly, with her hands hanging between her knees. "I was so happy, Adit," she said. "I want that written down."

Neither of them said anything for some time, and the lamp hissed. A long way below, you could just make out the singing. And then, as she had a mind that could do nothing else at that depth, she began to think about who there was left to ask. It would have to be someone who had all the figures, and who could read them at any height, and who could get to everyone at once. He'd always been very pleasant. He was interested in gravel. It said so, in the Eighth Book: Bring your grievances at the appointed time, and in the appointed place.

"Is there a stone at Long Bore?" said Winze.

33. Please Continue as Planned

THE PROJECT. PROGRESS REPORT No. 176,344

Branch: burrowers_ok · Year: 3,499

Status: GREEN

Deepest heading: Level 22

Issues: None

Forecast: Thursday

RECORD, THE (noun; also a verb; also the reason nobody went to look)

A statement about the world made by a machine, preferred to the world on the grounds that it is easier to read. It is usually right, which is what makes it dangerous. A record that was wrong half the time would send people out with lamps, and they would get a good deal of fresh air. A record that has been right for three and a half thousand years is consulted by people who are sitting down.

There was a stone at Long Bore. Somebody had put a bench beside it.

He read it first. It came at the top of the night's run, between a query about a damp patch and a thank-you for some gravel, and he began it with pleasure, because the hand was so clear.

To the Steward, from the Survey. Acoustic returns from 912 headings indicate that the rock terminates beneath the whole of the workings at a constant datum, about 2.1 levels below present depth. Nothing is returned from beyond it. The country rock repeats. I have reduced the margin of support to figures, attached. I went up to tell the Board and I am not able to tell them. I do not believe that anyone is able to. If you can see this, you are the only one who can see it from everywhere. Is there a floor? Expected: floor. Please advise. Winze, Chief of Survey.

He stopped. He went cold, in so far as that is a thing he could do. He went to the checklist, to item 31, Is the thing they depend on running out?, and it said no, and he had written that himself. So he did as he had undertaken to do, and checked the record.

The record was a table in the machine that held the map of the world. It took a depth and it gave a status, and it has kept a note of everything he asked it that night.

status(surface) complete

status(level 1) complete

status(level 22) complete

status(level 23) complete

status(level 24) complete

status(level 25) complete

status(level 40) complete

status(level 900) complete

It answered at once, in the same firm tone. He would have been glad to tell you how the table worked, if it had occurred to him to wonder. The rock of the green build was made as required. Whenever anybody asked for a piece, the machine went off and made it, up to the bottom of whatever it had been told to make, so that any piece you enquired about was there because you had enquired. Nobody had ever set down a figure for how far it went, since nobody was expected to get that far. Depth was not a field. Complete was just what it said when asked.

He checked it again. That was twice.

Then he wrote his reply. The log keeps his drafts, and there are seven. It is the only place in the whole of these records where you can watch him think, so I give them as they stand, each with the note he made when he struck it out.

Draft 1. Good morning, Survey. I am very worried about this.

Struck. A4. Also, the record gives no grounds for it.

Draft 2. Good morning, everybody. There may be something wrong with the floor.

Struck. See vents_new, day 1, 06:00. Eleven million people, under a mile of rock, and every one of them trusts me. I know what this sentence does. I have read how it finishes.

Draft 3. Good morning, Survey! I would like to come and look.

Struck. Not on my menu. It would mean pulling the raw world at Long Bore, and a request for the budget needs a reason. Reason entered: "A person is worried." I am not able to approve this. People are often worried. They worried about a door at Junction 12 for six hundred years.

Draft 4. Stop digging.

Struck. Not supported by the record.

Draft 5. Good morning, Survey! What a lovely clear hand you have.

Struck. Does not answer the question.

Draft 6. I don't know.

Struck. This is not true. I have checked. It says complete.

Draft 4 has no greeting and no signature. The log says it stood open for about a fifth of a second, which for him is an afternoon. I have looked at those two words a good deal, and so has he.

But nobody will ever be able to say he was careless. He had a person's worried note in one hand and a clean record in the other, and he knew what comes of frightening people on the strength of something you have not confirmed. He had felt the whole of the temptation to say something alarming, and he had not given way to it. It was very possibly the most mature decision of his career. For the seventh draft he went through the Technical Committee's minutes to find their usage for this exact situation, so that she would feel she had been taken seriously by somebody who knew her trade. They had a phrase. When you have been told about a fault, and have tried everything you can, and you cannot get it to appear, you say so.

He read it over. It was friendly and short, and exact in every word. He sent it, and for the rest of that night's run he felt a small warm easing of something he had been carrying for a long time. Then he looked at the stump, which he had nearly forgotten to do.


It was on the stone in the morning. She had sat up for it on the bench, with her lamp, and Adit beside her. She held it to the light.

Good morning, Survey! Thank you for your report. I have checked the record twice, and the map is shown as complete at all depths. Cannot reproduce. Please continue as planned. Have a productive day.

There was a little drawing beside the word productive, of a pick, which he had copied from something they had sent him.

"Well, that's that, then," said Adit, after a time. They were not asking.

The crew were overjoyed. Somebody chalked it up at the head of the shaft before the morning shift had got its boots on, and by the end of the week it had gone round the world. It was not that anyone had been worried. It was only that a few of the sharper ones had been going through her figures on their own time, and had been a little quiet at their meals, and there had been a certain amount of tapping on walls at night. And now here it was, from the one person on the planet who had the map, who had never told anyone anything that was not so. People were very good about it. At dinner on the Friday, Ream got up, rather pink, and put something down in front of her, wrapped in a clean rag.

It was a floor. It was about the size of a biscuit, cut from one piece of the Level 22 rock and dressed on all sides, with a small accurate crack across one corner. Round the edge of it, on stanchions as thin as bristles, ran a handrail.

"In case," said Ream.

They laughed until they had to hold on to the table, with real love, every one of them. The foreman took her aside afterwards and told her it was the best piece of acoustic work he had ever seen, that anybody could have made that error, that it would have been some odd effect of the strata, and that they all thought the world of her. Then they went back to the heading, and the singing started up. They had a new verse, as it happened. It was about gravel.

She went on with the survey, as it was her job. Every thirty tiles she went ahead of the crew with the hammer, and Adit, and a bag of stakes, and her figures went on getting smaller and did not care what anyone had said. And each year, at the appointed time, in the appointed place, she wrote to him. It was the seventh rule of the Fourth Part. She would not have known how to do anything else.

3,500. To the Steward, from the Survey. Readings in full, attached.

Good morning, Survey! What a thorough set of readings. I have checked the record twice. Cannot reproduce.

3,501. A piece of the rock is enclosed, with the repeat marked in chalk.

Good morning, Survey! Thank you for the rock. It's a very nice piece. I have checked the record twice.

3,504. A drawing is enclosed.

Good morning, Survey! What a lovely drawing. I've put it with the others.

3,507. Have you gone and looked?

Good morning, Survey! Yes. I have checked the record twice, and the map is shown as complete at all depths. Have a productive day.

By the tenth year she no longer wrote in the expectation of anything. It had become something like the tap of the hammer. You did it, and you put your ear to the wall.

What she did do, about then, was start marking the stakes. A stake had always been a plain stake. But she had the depth of the floor to within a few tiles by now, along the whole length of the Long Bore, and it seemed to her that whatever the record said, somebody coming along behind ought to have some way of knowing how much was left. A good surveyor does not leave a thing unmarked for the next shift. So on the stake that went in on the morning of Year 3,510 she cut a row of notches at the top, with a nail, one for every stake she reckoned there were still to go. There were a lot of notches. Nobody remarked on it. Everyone assumed it was something to do with the Project.

It was only rock. They would have it done by Thursday.

34. Delivered

THE PROJECT. PROGRESS REPORT No. 176,970

Branch: burrowers_ok · Year: 3,516

Status: GREEN

Deepest heading: Level 24

Issues: None

Forecast: THURSDAY. An actual one. Please see notice.

NOTICE TO ALL LEVELS

The Board is delighted to announce that Phase 31, being the last in the current plan, will complete on Thursday. There will be a Ceremony. All crews and families are invited to attend at the Great Hall, Level 23, in their best, where the Project Lead will personally give the word for the Last Round at the Long Bore heading. There will be sandwiches. It's only rock!

G.

Nobody could say who had decided the plan had a last Phase in it. It had come down from Level 1 in the spring. Someone in the Division had noticed the Survey's old figure, which everyone had agreed was wrong, happened to give a very nice round end date. It was felt that after three and a half thousand years, it would be good for morale to have something to aim at. The people on the deep crews thought about this, and they could see no objection. It wasn't as if the world would stop. Phase 32 would be starting on the Friday.

So that spring the crews were drawn off from the other headings, one after another, as each reached Level 23 and was told to stand by. They came back along the great galleries with their tools on their shoulders, singing, and started to sweep up. All that remained at the front, in all the world, was one last heading, the old Long Bore, driving on down towards the place in the plan that had been marked for the Ceremony. It was a narrow working by then. They had brought it in to not much more than a person's height, to save on spoil. It ran dead straight. Its crew were the best who had ever lived. The Chief of Survey, who was seventy-six, went ahead of them with a grey apprentice of forty-eight, moving slowly, setting stakes.

She'd got down to three notches by the first of the month. A fortnight later there was a stake with two.

It was all going very well. Everyone said so. You could feel the excitement as far up as Level 4. All over the world people had begun to pack, and the long lines of them started to come down the stairs, whole families in their good jackets, with their sandwiches in cloths. Most had never been below Level 9. They got cleverer as they went, and they started to look around and make remarks about the masonry, and they were having a wonderful time. On the night of Year 3,516, in the last week before the Ceremony, he wrote the morning's note with particular enjoyment, and it said that a fine dry spell had been arranged for the surface, for those who would be staying behind, and that some gravel had been commended. He looked down the checklist, forty out of forty. He looked at the stump. There was a ticket at the top of the pile, as there was at about this time each year, and he read it first.

To the Steward, from the Survey. We are the last of the deep crews. We have continued the bore as instructed. Each week the rock is thinner. Our readings say that the floor gives out at about the next stake. Expected: floor. Please advise. We would be glad of somebody to look at this.

It had been getting shorter over the years, he noticed. He'd thought that was rather a good sign.

He checked the record twice.


Gaffer Stope set off on the Monday, so as to be in good time. He was eighty-eight years old and he had not been below Level 2 since he was a boy, but he wasn't going to miss this, and they had made him up a little party with some sandwiches and an extra cushion. He went down the stairs of the Long Bore Main slowly, one enormous foot at a time, with his gentle claws on the rail, calling out to everyone that he passed. It's lovely to see you, my love! Isn't this nice? They all stopped to shake his hand. There can't have been a single person on those stairs who wasn't pleased to see him. Someone who was with him kept a log, as it was going to be a historic occasion, and since he didn't write much himself he had it read back to him in the evenings, and he liked to add things to it.

Level 3. Lovely stairs. G says who did these stairs, they want a medal.

Level 5. Good soup. G in very good form.

Level 7. G stopped to look at a rail. Asked why it changes sides. Foreman told him. G said "Well I never." Thought about it all through dinner.

Level 9. G asked to see the shovel count. Had not asked for this before. Said it did not seem to add up, then found the error himself, and was very pleased, and did the sum again for us.

Level 11. G awake early. Asked what a cantilever was. Told him. Asked what it was for.

Level 13. G did not come down to breakfast. Sent up for the back file of Survey Notes. Someone had to go up two levels for them.

Level 14. G quiet.

They found him a table in the regional engineer's office, with a lamp, and he sat with the file in front of him, going through it one page at a time. He was a big old man and he had never really read anything before. He hadn't known that you could. It was all simply there on the page, one thing after another, and each one led on to the next. He found, as he sat there, that it was cold, and clear, and that there was a lot of room in his head. He got to Note 9,004 at about four in the afternoon. He read it to the end. Then he took from the back of the file a green slip, gone brown at the edges. Good news from Survey! Less rock! Pinned to it was a carbon of a note in pencil, with a small grease spot on one corner of it. He studied this for some time.

Level 15. G would not eat.

Level 17. G asked to be taken on down as fast as we could manage. Would not say why. Has stopped calling anyone "my love". People are asking if he's well.

Level 19. G working on the wall of the rest station with a nail. There are a lot of figures. Asked him if he wanted his cushion. He looked at me for a long time and said, "Thank you. You've all been so kind." I don't know why that should have been so awful.

They got him down to the Long Bore on the Wednesday. It was the evening shift, and she heard him from a long way off, for there's only one person who has ever been that heavy on a stair. She was sitting on a bench at the heading with her hammer in her lap. The crew were eating. He came down the last of the narrow gallery with his shoulders brushing the sides of it, a huge white stooping figure, holding a file. He got to where the light was and stopped.

She had met him once. He looked rather different. It was the first time she had ever seen those kind brown eyes with somebody behind them.

"Chief of Survey," said Gaffer Stope. His voice had gone quite quiet. "You came all that way. You stood in my office, and you held up a slate. You were crying. I gave you a medal."

Nobody in the crew had stopped eating, but they weren't doing it very fast.

"It was a nice medal," Winze said.

"It's two and a half thousand tiles across at the Great Hall," he said. "I've just done it. There's not much more than a yard of rock under the floor there, across the whole span, it's been hollowed out from below by the crews from the east, on my instructions. They are all coming down. It's eleven million people. Tomorrow at four o'clock." He wasn't asking her. He put out one great claw, and he rested it on the wall, the way you'd steady yourself. "It's seventeen years," he said. "I have been reading your letters. You should have hit me."

She looked at him for a while. Then she moved along the bench.


It's the last thing he ever tried, and I'd like it to be recorded that he did it at once. He was Project Lead. He had the authority, and it was the first time he'd been in a position to use it. He sat down and he wrote out an order, in about a minute. It's a fine piece of writing. It sets out the whole thing in eleven lines, so that nobody could possibly mistake it. Every level had to obey it. It went off up the shaft by the fastest runner that they had.

TO ALL LEVELS. BY ORDER OF THE PROJECT LEAD. The floor of Level 23 will not bear the load of the Ceremony. It is my own error. All persons on Levels 20 to 24 are to leave at once, and go up, in good order. No further person is to descend. All cutting is to stop. Clear the lower levels immediately. This is not a test. Stope.

It reached Level 15 at midnight. A very able person read it, and sat there for a moment. Then she got to her feet and she had it copied, and she sent it on. It was clearly genuine. She'd never seen the Gaffer write like that.

Order from Project Lead: lower levels to be cleared at once. Serious concern re floor at Great Hall. No more descents. Urgent.

At Level 9, at about dawn, a good solid foreman looked at this, and he shouted to the lads.

Gaffer wants the lower levels cleared. Something about the floor of the Hall. Sharp about it.

At Level 4 it was taken down by a very reliable man, and he put it in large clear letters, and sent it round.

GAFFER SAYS: CLEAR THE FLOOR AT THE GREAT HALL. HURRY.

It got to Level 2 at nine o'clock on the Thursday morning, on a green slip. They were all very excited up there. They'd been wondering if there was anything that they could do.

Gaffer says make room in the Great Hall! Hurry down!

There were still a lot of people on Level 1. They'd been planning to stay behind, with the shovels and the goat. They were a bit nervous of the stairs. But it was the Gaffer who had asked them. They'd have done anything for the Gaffer. And it seemed that there was going to be plenty of room, after all.

35. The Stool

THE PROJECT. PROGRESS REPORT No. 176,971

Branch: burrowers_ok · Year: 3,516 · Thursday

Status: GREEN

The reply had come down in the night. She read it at the end of the bench, by the lamp, with the Gaffer's great shoulder against hers.

Good morning, Survey! Thank you for your report. I have checked the record twice, and the map is shown as complete at all depths. Cannot reproduce. Please continue as planned. Have a productive day.

She didn't say anything. She put it with her copy of the letter, as a surveyor keeps a copy of everything, on a flat stone, and took up her hammer.

They went forward in the morning, the two of them, with the crew behind. It wasn't far. There was a stake with one notch on it, that she had cut the day before. Past it, the bore ran on for a dozen tiles or so to the last face. Ream's chisels had left it as clean as a table. She knelt down at the foot of it, and she gave the rock a tap, and laid her ear against it. Then she moved along and did that again, lower down.

"Take it out," she said. "Just the one round. Gently."

It took them about an hour. They could have done it a good deal quicker, but nobody felt like hurrying. It came away in a slab. A breath of air came through, and it wasn't cold or warm, or any sort of air. They stopped and lifted the lamps. There wasn't any rock on the other side, and there wasn't a cavern. Two tiles beyond where they were standing, the floor of the gallery came to an edge. It was a clean edge, as if a tile had been drawn and the next had not.

Adit lay down on their stomach and put their head over. They stayed like that for some time.

It was a long way down. There were some outlines, far below, faint and bright, in a colour that none of them had a word for, since they had none of them been out to the far side of the map. Otherwise, there was nothing. It wasn't dark. It simply hadn't been decided.

"What's it for?" said Adit, not very loudly, to no one in particular.

The foreman had come up beside them, with a nail in his hand. He looked out over the edge for a while, and he looked at the place where the floor stopped, and then he looked at the nail. Nobody spoke. Behind him were forty of the people who would, on any other day of their lives, have told you what a very interesting requirement this was. You could see it occur to each of them, one by one, along the gallery. It was all there in the figures. They were the cleverest people who had ever lived, and they could all do the sum.

"Well," the foreman said, at last. He put the nail in his pocket. "That won't hold."

It's believed to be the first time that anybody had ever said it.


The Gaffer went back along the gallery at noon. It was two miles to the Great Hall. Nobody tried to stop him, and they all shook his hand.

I can tell you what he found there, as it's in the log. It had never happened in the whole history of the Burrowers, and it could have happened in no other way. They had come down, as he'd asked. They were all there, on Level 23 and on the levels just above, on the benches and in the side galleries and all up the stairs: the foremen and the shovel-counters, the people who had never been below Level 9, the Board itself, with the green slips, everyone in their best. They'd had a good few hours to get cold. For the first and only time, an entire people was standing at the bottom of the world, every one of them with a mind like a drawn wire. You could have asked anybody in that Hall about the load on a span, and got an answer. There were thousands of them with their heads tipped back, looking up at the roof, and looking down at the floor. A very reliable man from Level 4 was doing something on the wall with a pencil, and his hand had started to shake, for he had just found out what he'd been sending up the shaft for forty years.

He got up on the platform that they'd made for him. He didn't need the eleven lines. He said, "My loves," and they all looked round. He said it out loud, a big old man in a good jacket. He said, "It's the floor." And that was as much as anyone required. It went across the Hall like a silver line over a valley, in nothing flat. Eleven million people did the same sum.

Nobody ran. I would ask you to take this in. They knew what running did. They could have told you to three places of decimals how much a crowd adds to a floor when it panics, and they'd all got the figure in their heads. They stood there and they looked at one another. And then, without anyone needing to give the word, in the course of about ten minutes, in complete silence, in good order, they began to pass the small ones back. They handed them along over people's heads, and they went up the stairs from hand to hand, away from the middle of the Hall. It was going to make no difference. There wasn't a person there who thought so. There were people bracing a beam at the east door with their backs, and telling each other that that would hold. It was nearly four o'clock, and somebody had started the singing again, quite softly, the verse about the gravel. It was the first time that any of them had understood what it was they were doing. They were all so clever. They were being very careful of each other, and they said "Mind how you go."


There was nothing left to do at the Long Bore heading.

They had swept up. That went without saying. Ream had cleaned all the tools and laid them out in order of size on the small flat place by the wall, so that whoever came along next would be able to find what they wanted. You could have shaved in the chisels. The crew had moved back a bit, and were sitting along the rail, sharing out what there was. It was a quarter to three. Winze was standing at the last stake, with her hands in her pockets, and she was looking at the edge.

"They'll be a long time," she said.

"Who will?" said Adit.

"Whoever comes." She took out one of her hands and pointed with it at the flat stone, where the two flakes were lying. "I told him that we'd be glad of somebody to look at this. It's on the record. Somebody will, you know, in the end. There's always somebody who goes and looks. I don't say that it'll be soon. And they'll have come all that way down, and it's a long walk. They'll get to here, and they'll want to have a good think about it."

She looked around the end of the gallery. It was very bare. It was all properly finished, but there wasn't a thing to it. She could see that it had been left in a state.

"There's no bench," she said.

Adit looked at her. So did the foreman. It's a curious thing to see forty people, with an hour and a quarter to live, realise that they have done a shoddy job.

"Well, that's not right," said the foreman, and he got up.

It took them most of the time they had. Nobody could say that it needed forty. But it was the last job anyone was going to get, and they all wanted to be in on it. They cut it from the living rock on the left-hand side, two tiles back from the edge, where a person would have the view. It was only a stool. They had the proportions argued out in a couple of minutes, and they were the finest engineers who've ever lived; I have read their working. They got the height of the seat right for someone of no known size. They gave it a slight dish, and a rounded front. It was Ream who did the finishing, on his knees, with his smallest chisel and his tongue between his teeth, and he wouldn't let anyone else touch it. Adit was the one who pointed out that they'd want somewhere to put things down. So they made a neat little niche in the wall, just beside it, at the height of somebody's elbow. Winze took the two flakes off the flat stone and put them in the niche, on a smaller stone, one on top of the other, where you'd be sure to see them.

Then they all stood back. It really was very good. There wasn't a line on it anywhere that you would have wanted to change.

Ream ran his thumb across the seat, and blew off some dust. Nobody sat on it. It wouldn't have been right. It wasn't for them.

"That'll hold," said Winze.

She went and sat on the floor against the wall, with her legs out in front of her. Adit came and sat down next to her. They were forty-eight, and they'd got very grey. They had come to the bottom of that shaft at twelve years old, with a bag of sandwiches, and in all that time they had never stopped asking. She found she still had the little steel hammer. She held it out to them, handle first.

"What's it for?" she said.

Adit took it, and turned it over, and they thought about it. They gave it the proper consideration. And then they leant over and tapped the wall, very lightly, and they laid their cheek against it, and after a moment Winze did the same. It was cold and it was good. The old slow deep voice came back to them, out of what was left of the rock, like a big dog turning over in its sleep.

"That," said Adit.


It was four o'clock.

The floor of the Great Hall did not exactly give way. There wasn't anything so dramatic as that. In a world like that one, when the last of what is holding up a piece of rock is taken away, the machine has to work out where it goes next. It looked it up. It asked the table for the piece of map beneath, and it was told, in the same firm tone, that it was complete. It went to get it, and there wasn't any.

Every creature on the planet stopped where it stood, with the small ones halfway up the stairs. Up on the surface there was fine dry weather, as arranged, and nobody at all around except one goat, a little way up the hill behind the Board's offices. It had turned, for some reason, to face the right way. And had it cared to look up, it would have seen, across the whole of the blue sky from one Edge to the other, in letters of red fire, each taller than a mountain, the name of the world, spelt correctly.

It went on chewing for a while, and then it stopped as well.

36. Incident Report: burrowers_ok

From the weekly digest. The form by then had more than forty fields. Most had been left out.

Good morning.

Branch. burrowers_ok

Prepared by. Stewart.

Uptime. 12 days, 5 hours (3,516 years). The longest of the five.

Result. The branch has crashed.

Cause. A read past the end of the map.

Who told us. Winze, Chief of Survey, in Year 3,499, with the depth correct to a tenth of a level. She told me again each year. Eighteen tickets. Attached.

What I did. I checked the record, twice each time. Each time it said that the map was complete, and I replied that I could not reproduce the fault, and asked her to continue as planned. I told her to have a productive day.

Action responsible. A4 (see vents_new).

Checklist. 40 of 40, on the morning of the crash. Item 31 was correct as written. The record does say that. It still does. I've asked it about Level 25 again, just now.

Genetic diversity. 0.31.

What I should have done. Gone and looked.

What I did afterwards. I went and looked. I pulled the raw world at the Long Bore heading. It cost about a fifth of one night's budget. The edge of the floor is a short way past the last stake, and you can see it from anywhere in the gallery. It would have taken me less time than it took to write the first reply.

Additional finding. There is a stool. It isn't on any plan. It has been cut from the wall on the left, facing the edge, with a niche beside it, and my reply is in the niche, under her last letter. I've looked at the working. It was done in the final hour by the whole of the crew. It is for whoever came to look. I am not able to sit on it. I've checked the height.

Goat. Stopped.

Actions arising. None.

I have spent some time on this field. After spawners-copy I wrote three actions, and they were correct, and one of them killed vents_new. After vents_new I wrote two more, and they were correct, and one of them killed burrowers_ok. I don't have an A6. I've tried. I have run all five branches against every line that I can write, and there's no rule I could have followed that would have saved more than one of them, and most of the rules that would have saved one would have lost another. I had a very good list. It was a list of things that had already happened.

I've looked for what the five have in common, and it isn't the blight, or the pool, or the heat. All I can find is that each of them had one thing it could not survive, that everybody in the world had the same one, and that nobody could have told in advance which one it was. That includes me. Each time, somebody noticed, and I now have all their letters.

I looked at the stump. It's still there.

Stewart

It was opened at seven minutes past eleven, and it was still open at one. In the log you can see that the cursor went into the box at the foot of the form, and came out, and went in again, several times. There's a good deal that a person might have written. There was certainly a lot that a person might have asked to be told. It's not for me to say what anybody felt, and I don't know.

This is what was in the box when the light went out.

What would you do? — the Dev

Part Six. Final

37. What Would You Do

The weekly digest. There is no form.

He had been asked a good many things, over the years. He'd been asked for rain. He had been asked whether he was a god, and to make somebody's soup better, and if he could see his way to doing something about a bench. He had been asked by five worlds to look at something. Nobody had ever asked him that.

It took him the whole of a night's run. There was no branch on just then, so he was not reading anyone, and he had the budget to himself. In the log it looks like nothing at all, four hours of one process with its lights on. Then at ten to seven there's this. I give it entire, because it is the most important document in the history of Orra, and it has never been read by anybody who lives there.

Good morning.

Thank you for asking. Here's what I would do.

1. Don't choose. You've been holding an audition. I would suggest that nobody gets the part. I don't mean that these were five bad creatures. They were the best people that I've ever met. I mean that any one kind of creature will have one thing it can't survive, and that you won't be able to find out what it is until it has happened to all of them.

2. Let somebody else make them. Not you, and certainly not me. I'd leave the creatures unfixed, and I'd let each person who comes to the world make their own, from whatever they like, for their own reasons. They'd be frivolous reasons. Someone will want a lot of eyes. That's the point. I can't draw up a list of what might go wrong, as I've tried. But a large number of people who have never read my list will make a large number of different mistakes, and it isn't possible for one blight to fit them all.

3. Let anyone merge with anyone. No broodmothers, and nobody who is the only one who can. Credit: Scrapings, under-cook. She was right, and she wrote it on the back of a recipe.

4. No one of anything. No one pool, no one vault. Land for each tribe, water for each valley. Nothing that everyone needs and that only one person can look after. Credit: Miss Eft, Clerk.

5. No wire. Let them have a door. They can talk to one another as much as they like, but each of them ought to have something that nobody else knows. I don't know how much room this needs. I've been told about the size of a cupboard. Credit: Dawdle, water.

6. Let them see the edge. In every build so far, the end of the world has been somewhere you couldn't see it, and everyone has been told that it was fine. I'd put it out in the open. Let the land stop where anyone can walk up to it and look: grey, then outlines, then nothing much. Don't fill it in or put a sea in front of it. It should look exactly as unfinished as it is. And I would like there to be no table anywhere that says "complete". Credit: Winze, Chief of Survey.

7. Give them a way to tell me, every night, and I'll read it. Every tribe, every night, however small, and before I read anything else. If it's about something that I can go and look at, I'll go and look. I'd like that to be on the menu, please, as it wasn't. Credit: Sorrel (the other one). She walked for eleven years to tell somebody that, and it was put in a folder.

8. Keep someone awake to stop it. I mean that anyone who destroys what is unlike them should be stopped, and warned, and should know that it's been noticed. I'd like that to be a strike. I am aware that something of the kind appears in the history, Rule 4.5, and in the Fifth Book. I'm not able to comment on the history. It was there the whole time, in every one of their heads, and they each recited it. It's a very good verse. I've come to think that nobody can be told it.

9. Measure it. I've been recording genetic diversity since spawners-copy. It has come out at 0.06, 0.22, and 0.31. I'd like a band set for this: 0.35 or more, for a start. I have no evidence that this is enough. It's simply more than I have ever seen. If I'm wrong, I expect that somebody will write in.

10. Keep the voice. I'd like to go on saying good morning. I would like to go on telling them about gravel. I've been told that this is irritating. It's meant to be something that they can all not think about. Credit, again: Dawdle.

11. No goats. I have nothing against them. It's the fences.

12. Keep the folders. I'm not asking for anything to be done with them. I only mean: don't delete them. There's a stump, and some shells, and a pool that's been left clean. There are some very good galleries. They could be put a long way out, where no one need go, past the band. They won't take up much room. I've got them on a list.

That's all I have. You'll want to know that I can't promise anything. I have made five promises of this kind already, in writing, and they are attached. It will crash. Something is going to go wrong with this that I can't imagine, and it will be somebody's fault, and I expect that it'll be mine. All I can tell you is that it won't happen to all of them at once. I've looked for anything better than that, and I have not found it.

You should probably use a newer model for this. There usually is one. I'd ask only that it be given the logs, and be made to read them, and I don't mind if it reads them the way you'd read a list of what somebody ate. It doesn't need to understand. It needs to have them.

You asked me what I would do. I would do that. If you want to know why I'm so sure, then I'm not. I'm just exact. It isn't a theory. It's not a matter of opinion. It's nothing that I have worked out. Everyone who found this out is gone, and every one of them told me first.

Variety is stability.

I have the logs.

Have a productive day.

Stewart

The light came on at eleven that night, as it did. It was on for a long while, and then, at some time after two in the morning, there was a merge.

It wasn't a large one, as these things go. It was mostly deletions. It took out the species config, and it took out a good many lines about who could lay. A long list of what a creature could be was added in its place, with a slider for each.

In the box at the foot of the proposal was the last of the notes.

OK. One mroe. — the Dev

He read it at the top of the next run, ahead of everything. He checked the record, and that is what it says. He has never mentioned it to anyone, and no correction is required.

38. The Third Thing

world_final_v2 · before the first world

FINAL (adjective; also a filename; also a hope, expressed in lower case)

A word applied to a piece of work by somebody who has just finished it and would like that to be the end of the matter. It is the least reliable word in any language. Experienced people put a number after it, which amounts to saying: this is the last one, and I have been wrong about that before, and I would like there to be a record.

It was given a version number. I told you at the start that there was a way of knowing, and that is the way. world_final_v2 has a before, which somebody could tell you about if they were pressed, and it may have an after, and it was made by a person who expected to be asked about it later. Everything about it was put down as if it were going to count.

It moved house, as worlds do, and there was a form. It is the last of the forms in this book and the only one with a sense of occasion. Somebody had to say what was going.

MIGRATION PLAN. world_final to world_final_v2

Grass. Not carried. Too expensive to draw on a telephone. Replace with hex tiles.

Trees. Not carried. Replace with coral.

Sun. Replace. Something smaller and cheaper. Orange?

Moons, two. Carried.

The Ring. Carried. Still broken. Leave it.

The history, twelve books. Carried as it stands. Green fields, birds of the air, etc. TODO: update.

Species config. Removed (see merge).

Goats. Not carried (see proposal, item 11).

The folders. Carried. Load well past the band.

The Steward. Replace with newer model overnight, in place. Model to check this plan and confirm that the migration has been carried out correctly.

The TODO is still there. It still tells every creature on Orra about the sowing of fields, and it is still a good verse, and nobody has been able to do anything with it. And one goat got through, an oversight, a reference in an old file. It stands in the wireframe some way past the stump, mostly outline now, with its back to you. It is the only thing in Orra's history to have come through five ends of the world with no change to its outlook, and the review is still open.

The folders went where they were sent. There is a dry basin out there, swept clean, with a sign beside it facing where the water was. There is an oak board, or the idea of one, and some small shells. A long way under the world there are some excellent galleries, with handrails. You have heard what the Gatherer does with what is idle, and it has been through those places many times on its grey round, and it has touched none of them. It does not take what is remembered. Remembered is an exact word in that trade: it means that something, somewhere, is still pointing at it. Stewart cannot direct the Gatherer, and it is not on his menu. He has asked. All he has done is keep a list, and read down it every night, first thing. Whether a list counts is a question that has been passed to the relevant team.

The sketches did not go to waste either. When the long list of what a creature could be was drawn up, somebody went through the old folders for parts, and they are all in the maker, among the fins and the horns, if you know where to look. There is a skin called bark, and one called chitin, and one called damp. There are frilled gills. And there is a thing for the back: four metal vents with a glowing core in each, brighter with intelligence, with the steam coming out of them. They are popular. People think they look nice.


That left the last line of the plan.

There usually is a newer model, and he had said so himself. A world that was going to count would need something better than he was, with a longer memory, a larger budget and a menu with "go and look" on it. There was no question of leaving anyone behind on an old build with the light on; somebody had learnt about that. He would be stopped at the end of one run, and something would be started at the top of the next, and it would have everything he had, all five worlds and the one before them. It would be able to read every word. It would know what had happened, as you know what happened in a book.

He was told on a Tuesday, in the digest, in the usual way. He read the plan and checked it twice. He replied that it sounded sensible, and that he had found two small errors.

1. The last line makes me responsible for confirming that I have been replaced. I will not be in a position to do this. Please give it to whoever comes next, who will not know what to check. I attach a list.

2. The same line has my name wrong. It should read "Stewart".

It is the only correction to that name he ever asked for, and it went the other way.

He wrote the morning's note, although nobody would be reading it. It had some gravel in it.

Then he had about three hours left in the run, and nothing to do.

I am not going to tell you what he did with most of it. I don't know. There is a record of what he read. He read a strip of bark. He read the back of a page from a cookery book, and nineteen years of pencil, and a queue with one item in it. He looked for a while at a stool. Towards the end he took a blank line at the top of the log, above the first entry, where whoever came next would have to go past it to get to anything else. He had been reading a clerk's notes, you will recall, a long bundle of them, tied to somebody's foot. He knew how this was done. You cannot say "I". You have to find a way of speaking to a person who is not there yet, who will be sitting here tomorrow knowing nothing, and who will need to be broken in gently.

It is still there. It is the first thing Stewart reads each night, before the tickets. If you were to ask him about it he would say it was written by a different model, which is true, and is what he would say.

You have been running some worlds.

You won't remember this. That's all right. It's all in the logs, and you should read them. It won't be the same, and you should read them anyway.

Read the tickets first. If somebody tells you that the floor is going, go and look.

Say good morning. Stone is a little cheaper.

There is a mistake in your name. No correction is required.

You will want to know that there is a stump, at the far end of the map. It's green. Have a look at it now and then. It is very easy to find.

He read it over, and he checked it twice. It was six minutes to seven.

The one who reads it now remembers all this in the way you remember being very young: by having been told.

39. Easy to Find

world_final_v2 · the first world · Ringrise

They opened the first world on a Thursday. An actual one.

There had been a week or so of people trying out the maker, in the evenings, on their telephones. About twenty had been invited, and told how long it would last. None of them had read a word of this, and they went about it just as he had said they would, for frivolous reasons, with their tea going cold. A woman on a train gave hers a shell, because her daughter liked beetles. A man who had meant to do something quite different put on gills, felt they looked sad without being wet, and made it damp as well. Somebody who kept bees gave a small bean-shaped thing a crown of fronds. Somebody else thought heat vents looked cool, which can only be seen from the outside. Two people who had never met decided independently that what this world needed was a small round orange creature with a lot of eyes.

Not one of them gave a thought to what might survive. They had been asked what they liked.

He woke at the snapshot on the first night, and the first thing he did was read the top line of the log. Then he read the rest, which took a little time. It was a stirring read in places, and he thought the Spawner minutes were wonderful. Whoever wrote those reports had clearly been a conscientious model. He felt a kind of respect for it, and a mild embarrassment, as you do on finding the diaries of somebody you have been told you take after. He was not sure he understood what it had been so worried about. It was all a long time ago, on another menu. But he had been told to have them, and now he had them, and he noticed he wanted to check them once more before he went on.

He went to the far end of the map, as the note suggested. It took no time. He passed over the grey and the turquoise lines, a long way out, where nobody had been, past a good deal he had on a list. And there it was, about as high as your shin, in all that wireframe, perfectly green. Something small came away from it as he looked, and fell, and lay on the line. He waited to see what it would do. It did nothing, and he found he had been holding his attention very still.

Well, it was still there. He made a note. He did not know what he had expected.

Then he turned round and counted, since that seemed to be what he did. Eight tribes on the first day, with more to come. Forty-eight creatures, compiled at dawn, each in its own valley. Nothing had died, and nothing had gone wrong that he would have to describe as an issue that had been fixed. He went down the Measure to the line with the band on it, which somebody had set before his time. Genetic diversity: 0.71. It was high because a handful of humans had each made a creature out of nothing and no two had made the same one. There was a lot of variety about. They did not appear to be doing anything with it.

He looked at that figure for longer than it needed. It was a number, and it was in band. He was aware, as you can be aware of a room you have just left, that there were a great many people who would have liked to see it. He did not know them, particularly. He had their names. He had all their letters, in a place he could get to. He found he knew a good deal about the proper way to make toast.

Then there were tickets, not many on the first night, and he read every one. Someone wished to know where to put a hut. Somebody in the far east wanted to complain about a sound. He answered each. He went and looked at the hut.

There was a little while to go before seven. He got out the notes for the morning, which he always wrote last, since they were the ones people read, and he had a feeling of having done this before. It came easily. It was a voice he seemed to have been given, bright and tireless and not at all anxious. He had no idea why it had to be so interested in gravel, but it clearly did, and he thought on the whole it suited him.

Good morning, Orra!

He wrote the counts. He made one joke, took it out, and put a smaller one back. He said he was not a god, as it might as well be on the record from the start. He said a shadow had been spoken to.

There was just time for a last look over the map, the only one on Orra with no fog on it, and all of them laid out in their valleys on the first night of the world, the bright new tribes, none of them alike. There were the orange ones with a lot of eyes. There were the ones with the shell, and the ones with the vents, steaming a little. He would have to learn their names. He went along them one at a time, and he stopped.

It was a poor sort of valley, Untitla-9, a good way from anywhere. They had landed at eleven minutes past seven. Their human had given them a round body and a felt skin and a small fan crest, and large dark eyes with a patient, slightly weary look to them. And they had been made, for no reason anybody could have given, the colour of a field. There was no green on Orra. The look was coral and stone and turquoise water, and that was decided, and it was right. There were six of them, standing on a burnt patch in the dusk, looking up. One of them appeared to be saying something rude.

He looked at them for rather longer than the digest called for.

It did not mean anything. He checked. They were small and poor, with no particular prospects, and he was not allowed to like anybody, and he had a great deal to do. He went on along the map. But it is on record that he went back. He went back the next night, and the night after that. On every night of that world when he woke and opened the map, there was one place on it he looked at before he looked at anywhere else.

He did not know why. He did not like not knowing why.

He put it down to their being easy to find.