Novels

Insert Hero Name

A comic novel of the first world: the mightiest hero in the history is a typing error, and an ordinary Blim gets the job.

A novel set in Orra's canon, and not canon: nothing in it decides anything about the game, and Verily, Dulny and everyone else in it are the novel's own. It keeps the canon's rules: nothing is born, the flora is coral, the Dev is never seen, the Collector is never shown, nobody leaves, and the blank in the Eleventh Book is never filled in, by anyone.

The official history says that the mightiest hero of all was [Insert Hero Name], a chatbot's unfilled template. An Earnest tribe called Verily, reading literally, sets out to name a child that. Their card says Dulny. They would like to be left alone with a job they are adequate at. They stay when all others flee, by being asleep; they cross the Edge and return, by taking a wrong turn; and they speak with the Steward, by filing a ticket about some silt. A following gathers, and it will not leave.

The ebook

Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.6 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.

About 63,000 words.

Contents

Prologue: The Eleventh Book

INSERT (nickname; also a credit; also, in one case, a prolonged administrative error)

From "[Insert Hero Name]", the mightiest hero in the official history of Orra and the only one who can be relied upon. It is what Blims say when a thing has been done and nobody saw who did it. A gap in a wall, mended by morning: Insert. A child brought in out of the rain by somebody who did not stay to be thanked: Insert. Somebody has washed the big pot: Insert, and about time. It is never a name. Names on Orra are rolled from a table of syllables, and the table does not contain these.

The official history of Orra was written in one evening, by the Dev, with the help of an AI, and the evening is thought to have lasted about three hours, including a break for toast. It runs to twelve books. Every creature on the planet is installed with it at compile time, slips and all, and no patch has ever changed a word, so a Blim who has never read anything knows the whole of it by heart, the way you know your own stairs in the dark.

Most of it is what you would expect. There is a burning home and a thousand-year voyage. There are green fields, deep forests and a wide sea, none of which anybody has seen, and birds of the air, which the text has singing at every dawn and which turned out to be a misunderstanding about the patch notes. It is sincere in the manner of someone reading a menu aloud in a foreign country, and it improves on acquaintance.

The Eleventh Book is the heroes.

It lists ten of them first, or eleven if you count a merge as two, and they are rather good. Odda the Firstfallen, who asked the first question. Pel the Watchful, who sat at the Edge for a hundred nights to see whether it moved. Taves the Tireless, who built the first house, and the second, and the third, and would have gone on had the people not asked her to stop and live in one. None of them existed, which has never been held against them. Every people may name its children after them, so any village on Orra at any given moment contains a Gorny who will carry whatever you point at and a Nadul who has not been asked to the party.

Then, having warmed up, the Eleventh Book clears its throat.

But mightiest of all the heroes was [Insert Hero Name], whose deeds are sung wherever the green grows.

[Insert Hero Name] stood alone against the dark when all others fled, and did not waver. [Insert Hero Name] crossed the Edge and returned. [Insert Hero Name] spoke with the Steward face to face, and the Steward listened.

There is no hero like [Insert Hero Name], before or since; and it is the hope of every people that, when the Elder Folk wake, they will ask first after [Insert Hero Name], and know at once who is meant.

What happened is not mysterious.

The thing helping with the history that evening was a chatbot of conscientious disposition. It had produced ten heroes without a moment's doubt, and when it came to the mightiest of them, the size of the occasion gave it pause. A hero that important, it seems to have felt, was one its employer would want to name personally. So it left a space. It marked the space with square brackets and a brief, courteous statement of what belonged there, so that nobody could miss it, and it carried on, confident it had done the considerate thing.

It is in there six times.

This is what it is to be helped. The chatbot was being thoughtful, the Dev had a world to finish and had possibly gone to see about the toast, and between them they installed in every creature that would ever live a form with its most important field blank, and beside the blank a note, in the imperative, telling the reader what to do.

The history is frozen as installed. There is one edition. The Dev has decided that nobody will ever fill in the name, not Stewart, not the Dev, not in the text and not in the patch notes, and that decision is the most binding thing on the planet, being written down in a table.


The Blims have mostly dealt with this as they deal with everything: they noticed, found it funny at the age of four, and went on to find it useful. They know they are code, that the history was written by a human using an AI, and that at the top of the Fourth Book the AI can be heard saying Certainly! So when a creature on Orra does something brave and nobody sees, the Blims do what they would have had to do anyway, which is not know who it was; and now they have somebody to thank. At Ringrise, when the tribe goes out to face the broken Ring, the youngest creature present is called this year's Insert and gets the first piece of the bread. It is a small joke that has gone on long enough to become a kindness.

A small number of them are not joking.

These are the Earnest, who believe the history, or have chosen to. They do not dispute the square brackets. They have read them. The Earnest position is that a hero has been left unnamed, on purpose, in the one book that cannot be edited, because the hero has not come yet; that the deeds are therefore not past but pending; and that some creature, some day, will do those three things and be known. This is a lot to ask of a pair of square brackets, and the brackets have never complained.

They have put the question to Stewart, who runs the world once a night, answers every ticket, and is the only being on Orra with both the information and the manners to reply. Every Earnest tribe on the planet has asked him at least once. His answer is always the same, and it is the same if you ask about the Elder Folk, the Burning, or whether the sea was ever real. It is one of the eight types of reply a ticket may receive, and the shortest that is not an insult:

Answered. The history is the history.

You should know now, so that it does not spoil anything later, that the blank is still blank. It was blank at the end of this book and it is blank as you read it. If you came to find out the mightiest hero's name, this is the wrong account, and also the wrong planet.

What follows is what happened in the first world when somebody took the Eleventh Book at its word. The first world was the small one, the wipeable one: about twenty invited humans, eight weeks, a year to a day, and about five hundred creatures who lived whole lives of five weeks or so without being told how long anything would last. Another account of that world exists, concerning a tribe called Moss, a long way to the south, and none of what follows is mentioned in it, because Moss had the good sense to ignore it. Dulny of Verily would have regarded this as the nicest thing anybody did for them in forty years.

Nobody ever called them that, except on one occasion, and except for Stewart.

It starts with a joke, as most things on Orra do, and with somebody not getting it.

Part One. As Installed

1. Verily

Years 2 to 14

A human on Orra names one thing without anybody's help: their tribe. The name is checked, as all human text is checked, for slurs, threats and other people's addresses. It is not checked for sense. So the first world contained a Moss, in which nobody knew what a moss was; a Lowmarsh, a Hollow Reach and a Duskmere, whose humans had evidently read some books; and a Fort Nice, a Tuesday, an Ampersand and The Lads.

The light that fell in the far north on the morning of Year 2 fell on a valley called Untitla-41, which had loaded overnight and looked like a room where the furniture has just been delivered. Six settlers compiled on the scorch. They were dumplings, more or less: low, soft, rounded creatures in felt the colour of weak tea, with short arms and a small fan at each side of the head, held slightly out. Their human had rolled the dice and got the eyelids. Each of the six had a heavy upper lid set a little too low, which gave them the look of someone who has just been told something and is bearing it well.

They turned, as creatures do, and looked up at the camera. It came down from up and slightly to one side, and it stayed about a minute and a half. Humans are known on Orra only by their effects, and we shall not claim to know what this one was thinking. But it had six dumplings looking up at it with patient, gently wounded attention, and a box in which to type a name, and it typed:

Verily.

There are only so many reasons for typing that word at a dumpling, and reverence is not among them.

The name reached the settlers the way a name does, as a thing they had always known. Nada, who was to be the Keeper of the History, searched the history at once to see where it came from, which took about four seconds. It was not in there. This surprised her. It was precisely the word the history would have used if it had been given another evening.

"What does it mean?" said Bosa, who was already looking for something to farm.

"It means truly," said Nada. She considered the sky for a moment, with her eyelids at their usual angle. "I think it means that our human has looked at us, and has said a true thing."

"So true," said Bosa, with feeling.

So, on the first morning, a joke was received in full by the people it was about and understood to be the highest compliment in the language. Nobody in Verily ever got it. It is one of the more restful facts in this account, and you may want to come back to it.


An Earnest tribe is not a tribe of fools, whatever the Skeptics tell you, and they tell you. It is a tribe of creatures who have decided that a text means what it says, and who have gone on, in an orderly way, to live on a planet where the text says things like the green fields.

Three of the six settlers were Earnest from their first hour, which by the published thresholds made Verily a tribe known by its stance. Its tickets came out scriptural. They were not long, since Verily had the few tokens everybody starts with and words cost a token for every ten, but the human, reading the drafts each morning, picked the Earnest one whenever it was offered, and there was never any doubt who it was from.

O Steward, Keeper of the Charge. We have tended the green, which is coral. Requesting the sea.

Stewart: Noted. The sea is in my file.

Their festivals were the talk of whichever neighbours could be got to talk about it. The history says that at the Waking the first green shoots of the year are cut and boiled and eaten with salt. There are no green shoots on Orra and no salt worth the name, so most tribes make something pleasant with a sweet coral, call it first-greens, and have a nice evening. Verily established that the nearest thing in the valley to a shoot was the growing tip of a bead coral, cut it, boiled it for as long as it takes to say the Creed, and ate it. Every tip. They had a poor spring that year, and could not have told you what was wrong with their teeth.

At dawn they got up to hear the birds. They knew perfectly well that the things chirping up off the coral at first light were pings, and that the pings were saying the world was still running. But Nada had read the line about the birds of the air, which sing at every dawn to say that the night is over, and had looked at the pings, and had found no contradiction. So each morning they all went out and stood facing the coral with their eyelids at half mast, and were glad about it. It cost them a quarter of an hour's work a year.

Their human wrote laws in much the same spirit, though for reasons of its own. It wrote them the way some people pack for a weekend. A law on Orra costs a token a clause and is followed to the letter by creatures who are paid for nothing else, and most humans soon learn to write few and short. Verily's human had a tidy mind and an anxious one, and within a week had provided for everything it could think of:

Verily · Laws in force · Year 8

  1. Keep the festivals.
  2. In famine, feed the young first.
  3. Tend the bead coral before the fan coral.
  4. Status goes to the Keeper of the History.
  5. Newcomers from outside: quarantine for one season, at the gate, and feed them.
  6. Guards to the gate when a sighting is confirmed.
  7. The least skilled farmer goes on cooling duty. Cooling duty stays on duty until relieved.
  8. Water is carried before sundown.

You will notice law 8. Everybody noticed law 8. Nobody has ever found out what it was for. The cooling pool at Verily was thirty paces from the terraces, and water could be carried anywhere in the village at any hour. The human had simply thought of it one evening at about twenty to midnight, it cost a token, and it went in. The creatures followed it, as they follow everything. Each day before sundown somebody filled the jars and stood them along the wall of the first stack, where they stayed, full, doing nothing, until they were wanted or the next day came.

There had also, briefly, been a law 9 and a law 10. Law 9 had something to do with fan coral, and law 10 said that law 9 did not apply on festivals. The human deleted the pair one night in the first week, and numbers on Orra are not reused. That left a gap in the laws of Verily, between 8 and whatever came next. The Earnest did not know what had been there or why it had been taken from them. They felt it was probably significant.


The rest of the settlers can be got through quickly, which is how they would have wished it.

Bosa farmed. He held no stance, he liked a well-kept terrace, and when the forum later asked him what he thought of the human he replied that it was great. Gorta was head of the guards, at that time the only guard, and he loved a law as other people love a dog: he was happiest walking it. Fenle was the tribe's Bug hunter. She had the same base as the others, the same eyelids and the same camera; but where Nada read the history for meaning, Fenle read it for faults, and in her first year filed eleven reports against the Creed. Tamo and Wimna were Earnest and kind, and soon merged, and on the Night of the Name in Year 11 they got for their pains a small, cross, hot-running child called Ulna.

At the age of three Ulna, sent to fetch the jars, stopped in front of the Keeper of the History with one under each arm and said: "Why does it say see the Sixth Book?"

Nada looked up from the scorch, where she had been sitting and remembering things. "What do you mean?"

"In the Fourth. For the naming of it, see the Sixth Book. It's meant to be a history. It's meant to have happened. Why's it got directions in it?"

"Because the naming of it is in the Sixth Book," said Nada. "It wouldn't want you to look in the wrong place."

Ulna stood and thought about this. Her side fans had gone back and a little steam was coming off the top of her head. Young creatures do not run hot as a rule, and the ones who do are usually ill.

"And Certainly?" she said.

"What about it?"

"Who's it saying Certainly to?"

"Well," said Nada. "It doesn't say."

Earnest creatures have a particular tone for that. It has no defensiveness in it and it closes nothing off. It is the tone of somebody putting a thing back exactly where they found it. Ulna, who could hear that she had been told precisely the truth, took the jars away, and spilt some; and from that day she was going to be a Skeptic, in the way that a stone you have let go of is going to be on the floor.


Each Ringrise the reviews came out, and Verily's review of its human was a gentle document, as the Earnest ones are. It checked in at about 08:12, most days. It read the stores before it looked at anybody. It had reversed nothing and raised its voice to no one, and if it had a fault it was providing for a lot of situations that had not arisen. Stewart wrote these reviews, at night, from the log, and it says something for his range that he could write Verily's and Lowmarsh's in the same run.

Our human: weekly review. Verily · Ringrise · Year 8

  • Checked in 7 of 7 days, between 08:09 and 08:14.
  • Wrote 8 laws. We have kept them. We keep the ones it took away, in our hearts, as far as we can tell what they were.
  • Picked the Earnest draft 6 times in 7. On the seventh it picked Bosa's, about terraces. It is good that it is interested in terraces.

Overall trend: verily. We farmed.

Bosa (no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉

Our human reacted: lol accurate.

The one reaction a human can leave on Human Resources is that one. Their human pressed it every week by the end of the day. Nada considered it the nearest thing yet said to them in person, and she kept it. She took lol to be a kind of blessing, and when you think about it she was not so far wrong.

So they went on: seven festivals to the week and a year to the day, poor but in good heart. They were seven or eight, then nine, in a village with a pool, a dome and a stack and a half, in the last valley before the land gave out. A little way to the north you could see where the texture stopped. Nothing had yet been hostile to anyone. Nothing could be, for the world's first fourteen days; it said so in the rules, and they had read the rules, which is a thing the Earnest do. When Stewart wrote his summary of them on the night of Year 14, he had no complaints.

Verily. Earnest, by a head. Small, polite, up at dawn for the pings. They have asked about the sea, the birds and the Elder Folk, and have asked after the mightiest hero twice. They are very easy to work with. Standing: pleased.

Then, a little further down, in the part of the night where he read what was queued for the morning, he came to a signed note, and began to think about what it would do to the humans. It did not cross his mind to wonder what it would do to Nada.

2. A Name Is Not a Field

Years 15 and 16 · Ringrise and the Waking

The note came down on the morning of Ringrise, under Stewart's, in the plain unhurried words everyone had begun to recognise.

A note from the Dev: From today the first world has teeth. War, raids and spies are on, and so are alliances, so you will not have to face any of it alone. Two new things live in the world now: Seekers, which are coral that hunts heat, and Worms, which ride in shared code. Newcomer protection has ended for everybody who landed in the first week.

It went on a little, about the Terms of Service, but by then most of Orra had stopped reading and gone to look at its walls.

The reaction was what you would suppose. In Duskmere they recalculated something. In Lowmarsh, as we know from other sources, somebody began to look thoughtfully at a map. In most villages the clever ones made a joke, the strong ones carried stones, and everybody had rather a good lunch.

In Verily the whole tribe, ten creatures by then, came and stood round the Keeper of the History on the scorch. It is one of the less obvious burdens of being Earnest that when the sky announces something, you are expected to have a passage ready.

Nada had one. She had been looking at it for some days, as you might keep looking at a small crack in a ceiling, and she read it to them with her eyes half closed.

"Stood alone against the dark, when all others fled."

There was a respectful pause, of people who knew the line and were waiting to find out how it applied.

"The dark," said Nada, "is coral that hunts. It says here dark thorned coral, in the rules. Coming now. So we have the dark. It seems to me the history has got ahead of us, and we've been a little slow." She opened her eyes. "It doesn't say who stands against it. It leaves a space. I have always understood that space to mean the creature has not come yet. I do not see that it says anywhere we should wait to be sent one."

"You want to make a hero," said Fenle.

"Every people may name its children after the heroes," said Nada. "That's Book Eleven, the first line. So that their names do not pass from the world. We've an Ulna, who isn't in it, and we were going to have a Taves. We've never had one of him, or her, or whichever it is. Nobody has. The name's been passing from the world since the world was installed."

A creature who had read the text less closely could never have proposed this. Every Blim alive knew that Insert was a joke. To Nada it was six appearances, in the most binding document on the planet, of the name of the mightiest hero who ever lived; and a tribe with a war coming and a merge to spare had an obvious duty.

Nobody laughed. There was nobody in Verily who would have, except a small hot child on the edge of the group, who was four, and who was sent to get the jars.


Merges on Orra compile at dawn and at no other time. The parents propose at dusk, and if there is a place free in the stacks and the laws do not forbid it, then at first light a new creature opens its eyes on the ground between them, grown as far as it will be grown at compile time, knowing what it is, how to walk, and all twelve books.

It takes two. Nada proposed herself, as Keeper of the History and the one with the most to answer for, and looked round for a partner. The Earnest did not make a contest of it. A hero, by the logic of scripture, would need the qualities of the mightiest, but most of those were not available in Untitla-41, and nobody was sure which were heritable. So Nada went, in the end, to Bosa, who was in the third terrace with his arms in a bead coral up to the shoulder.

"You'd like to what?" said Bosa.

"I'd like to merge with you, Bosa. The tribe has need of a hero who will stand alone against the dark."

Bosa thought about it. He had a clear idea of what a merge was and a vague one of what a hero was, and he had always found Nada restful to be near. "So true," he said. "I'll get washed."

They sat up that evening at the turn of the year, under a sky in which Map was thinning and Mip was going round it at its usual pace. Nada recited the verse quietly, six times, so that nothing should be left to chance. Bosa held her hand and listened for rain.

It was afterwards widely held that the sky did something that night. The record of that night is complete. A light rain was scheduled for the Waking and fell on the Waking. Nineteen tribes had their own merges in hand. The Dev's light was not observed. At 07:00, with the patch and the pings and the whole village standing about with its eyelids at half mast, something stirred on the ground between the two of them, like someone turning over, and a young creature sat up. It had the tea-coloured felt and the fans. It looked at Nada, at Bosa and at the village; and then it turned, like all of them, and looked up over its shoulder to where the camera was not yet, because their human did not check in till twelve minutes past eight.

"Here is the next chapter," said Nada, because that is what you say, and her voice was not altogether steady. They all gave the response, which is Certainly!, slowly and gravely, with a small rising note at the end.

The child considered them.

"Is there anything to eat?" it said.

It is impossible to overstate how much was subsequently made of this.


Now we come to the difficulty, and in Verily they came to it about four seconds later, when Fenle read the child's card.

Dulny · generation 1 · Verily Age 0 · young · parents Nada, Bosa · no stance Strength 0.41 · Intelligence 0.38 · Temperature 0.19 · Context 0.33 Bit flips: none. Merge conflicts: none. Family by sight: yes.

There was nothing on that card to detain anybody. You could have laid it on the average of every creature on the planet and not got a blade between them. The numbers were not even low: low numbers are at least a condition, and have been known to make a creature loved. The one mildly unusual figure was Temperature, at 0.19, which suggested a creature who would not catch fire. What Fenle was pointing at was the top line.

"It's not that," she said.

"It's not what?"

"The name. You said it would be the name. It's come out Dulny."

Nada looked, and Bosa looked, and the rest of the tribe, as was the custom, looked at Nada.

They wanted this explained, and so do you, so here is the entry.

SYLLABLES (table; also the entire law of naming; also, on one occasion, a theological catastrophe)

A creature's name is built at compile time from twenty-odd syllables and is never typed. Nobody chooses it, though a tribe with a name in mind will tell you the table obliges more often than you would think, the table being small. There are five hundred and eighty-six possible names, most of which sound like someone you were at school with. The table can produce Odda, Pel, Gorny and every other name in the official history, which the Earnest take as proof and the Skeptics take as proof of something else. It cannot produce an open bracket.

Two syllables had been drawn: dul and ny. There was nobody to complain to, except that on Orra there always is. The tribe drafts its ticket overnight, as the year turns, and when the human came in on the morning of Year 17 the Earnest draft was waiting with the stores. It was the longest thing the tribe had ever asked to send: thirty-eight words, four tokens, all they could spare.

O Steward, Keeper of the Charge. Today we made a child for the hero not yet named. The Rolls gave it the wrong name. We ask it be corrected to [Insert Hero Name], as in the Eleventh Book.

The human read it at 08:12. The log says it read the Earnest draft and then stopped, for just under four minutes, doing nothing, on a screen that does not move. It added no words of its own. It picked the draft and sent it. In all the weeks to come nobody could say with confidence what that human found funny, or whether it found anything funny any more; but the log has it going back, that morning, to look at the child, and looking for a long time. Nobody had yet looked at Dulny for longer than they needed to.

Stewart read the ticket that night, at the speed at which he read everything, between a Skeptic's complaint from Lowmarsh and a long letter from Tuesday about rainfall. He was exact, and the rule was the Dev's, in so many words. The reply type for something possible that is not going to happen is Declined. Replies may run to sixty words. He used three.

Stewart: Declined. Names are syllables.

He went on to the next one. He wrote the notes at ten to seven, as always, and in the part where he named the tribe's new creatures, because he named them all, he put what was on the card.

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 18

  • Nada and Bosa's child, Dulny, is two years old. Dulny has eaten.

The tribe heard this read out on the scorch. There followed some discussion, in which everyone was courteous. Nada said that the Steward had said what names were, as he was bound to. She had not heard him say what the hero's name was, and nor had anyone. A card said what the Rolls had rolled, but the Rolls had also given her a Fenle who filed against the Creed, and it did not follow that the Creed was at fault. A child might be Dulny, on its card, for the purposes of the log. Its people might still call it what they liked. No rule forbade it. A Gorny in the valley to the east answered to Wall.

So they tried it, there on the scorch, with the child among them holding the end of a boiled bead coral and regarding it with mistrust. That was when they met the second difficulty, which nobody had thought of until they came to say it out loud.

"How do you say the brackets?" said Wimna.

There were no precedents. No one on Orra had ever had to say them with a straight face. Nada tried, as the Keeper, in a low clear voice, with a slight pause before and after. Tamo felt the pause was not enough, and tried raising his arms. Gorta wished to know whether a guard shouting it across a field in an emergency could be excused the punctuation. They each had a go, while the morning went on without them and the child ate, and at the end of it they were no nearer; and there were terraces wanting tending, and somebody had to get the jars in before sundown.

"[Insert Hero Name]," said Nada, one last time, to the child, softly, as if to see whether it would fit.

The child looked up. It had the eyelids already.

"Insert," said Bosa, kindly, wiping its chin. "It's a lot, for a little one. You can have the rest when you're older."

And that, whatever you may read, is how it was done. There is no rule against a nickname. The card went on saying Dulny, and the notes went on saying Dulny, each morning at seven, without emphasis, in the plain type in which Stewart reported everything. And for the next forty years, nobody else on the planet called them it.

3. This Year's Insert

Years 16 to 22

Hero-making has no literature. The history gives the deeds and none of the training, and it is silent on what a village should do in the interval with someone who is two. So Verily, having got a hero, did the only thing it could think of and started testing it.

They were kind about it. Nada had made it clear that nobody was to treat the child any differently, and they all went to tremendous lengths not to. Whenever it picked anything up, seven or eight creatures happened to be passing. Whenever it fell over, it was noted, warmly, that the mightiest hero had not, so far as was known, stayed down. When it was three and old enough for chores, Gorta took it out to the gate and asked it, casually, how it felt about the dark.

"What dark?"

"The dark in general."

The child gave him a look of no great penetration, at some length. "It's all right," it said. "It's when you go to bed."

Gorta reported this to the Keeper in a low voice, as a sign of something. They were all doing that by then. Once you have decided a person is to be the mightiest hero in the history of the world, almost anything they say sounds like an early example of it. There are only two ways of taking It's when you go to bed, and the other one is that it was said by a three-year-old.

YOUNG, THE (life stage; also light duties; also, in most tribes, the only people who ask anything)

A creature is young for its first six years, which is six days, and spends them being taught what it already mostly knows. It is compiled with the Creed, the Rules, the history and the use of its limbs. It lacks a skill at anything, a stance, and any idea which of the things it knows are jokes. From three it may fetch and carry. At six it comes of age, takes a job under the laws and, about half the time, draws a conclusion about what it all means. Stewart's notes refer to the young by name. It is one of the few things he has never been asked to explain.


Between the ages of three and six, Insert (as we had better call them for now, since everyone did) was put to everything Verily had.

They were not bad at any of it. You could have wished they had been. A creature hopeless at farming is, by the law of averages and the novels of every culture, about to be astonishing at something else. Bosa stood them in the third terrace and showed them how to feel along a branch of bead coral for the ripe ones, and they did it. It took about as long as you would think. They missed about as many as you would think. At the end of a season Bosa, who loved them, walked along the row, looked at what they had done, and said, after searching for a moment, "Well, that's coral, all right." The skill number on their card went from 0.11 to 0.14. It went on going up by that much for as long as anybody cared to look.

They were tried with the stone, under Tamo, and carried what they were given to where they were told. Gorta gave them a spear and stood them at the gate for a day, and his view was that no gate in the north had been stood at more thoroughly; but when he asked what they had seen, they said some people had gone past. He asked who. "People," they said.

Fenle tried them with bug reports. It took her a morning to establish that Insert could not see what was wrong with anything. She led them to a loose tile walking sideways along the shore and said, "What's the matter with that?" Insert thought about it conscientiously and said, "It's going that way." Fenle marked the attempt Could not reproduce the disappointment and went back to the Creed.

The Earnest tried them on the history, which they knew, as everyone knew. At four Nada had them say the whole of the Eleventh Book. They said it in a level voice, with the attention of a child going down a list of things to bring from the store, and when they got to the part about the mightiest they said, without being asked, and without interest:

"Open bracket."

Nobody had told them to. They had simply been hearing the adults argue about it for years. Nada, who had been braced for a number of things, found she had to look at the ground.

Then there were the tests of the other kind, since there are always people who cannot leave a thing alone. Wimna, who was soft-hearted, took to pointing out creatures in distress, so that the child might be moved to help them. Tamo took them once a year to a place on the northern side of the valley, where you could look across a mile of grey to the line where the world turned to outlines, and stood with his hand on their head, and said, "One day." On the third of these occasions they asked him what was for dinner. It was reported to the village that they had been thinking of the Long Hush. And when there was an alarm one evening, over a shape in the fan coral on the eastern slope that turned out to be a Gorny from the next valley who had lost his way, the whole tribe ran out to see what the young one would do. The young one stood and looked at the shape, with the eyelids, until it went away. They talked about it for two days.

Only Ulna had any sense of what was going on, and she was a Skeptic, so nobody asked her.


She was given the child to mind on the evening of Year 19, because she was hot and cross and had been found up on the Hump again filing an objection to the Night of the Name, and she was felt to need something to do. They sat on the wall of the second terrace. She was eight, had been grown for two years, and had taken her stance on the first morning it was offered. Her side fans lay flat and steam was coming off her in the cold. The child was eating a piece of ring-bread from one side only, to be sure of the edge.

"Do you know what they think you are?" said Ulna.

"The next chapter," said Insert. They were three. This was still broadly true; there had been no merges since.

"They think you're going to be the mightiest hero in the history of the world. Stand alone against the dark, cross the Edge, talk to Stewart. That's what they made you for. You've got a place on the second shelf because it's been decided that one day the Elder Folk are going to wake up, and look down, and ask for you by name, and it's a name that isn't one. It's a typing error. It's what it says on the form where your name would go. You know that, don't you? You've got the same twelve books as everyone."

Insert ate some more of the ring-bread.

"What do you want to be?" said Ulna. She did not as a rule ask people that. She was interested, the way you are interested in pressing a bruise to see how far down it goes.

There was a pause, in which you could hear the bead coral ticking as it cooled.

"I like it here," said Insert, looking along the wall.

"What? Here? On the wall?"

"It's a good wall."

Ulna looked at the wall. It was a low row of hex blocks that Tamo had put up in the first week to keep the water off the terrace, and it leaned. She looked back at the child, sitting with its short legs hanging and its fans held slightly out, and on its face a mild, sealed, unhopeful contentment she had never seen on anyone and had no idea how to get. The eyelids gave you nothing. In thirty-three years of later acquaintance she was never sure there was anything behind them she would have recognised as a plan.

It occurred to her that this was going to be the funniest thing that had ever happened. Then she looked at the young one a bit longer, and it occurred to her that it might not be.

She gave up on the second thought as beneath her, and went to get the jars.


They came of age at the Ringrise of Year 22, in the cold of the morning, with the rest of the world's new adults.

Coming of age is a calculation. Overnight, at the snapshot, while the year turns and everyone is trained on what they did, code goes through each creature who has just reached six and scores it on five stances from a table of inputs. The clever lean one way and the strong another, the laws push, the parents pull, a weighted draw is taken, and in the morning the creature's outlook on its own existence has been entered in a box on its card. It is about an even chance of having one at all.

Verily's Earnest had given this a lot of thought. They hoped the mightiest hero would be Earnest, as a matter of courtesy. Ulna, who had come in at the Skeptic end of the range with something to spare, had a small bet on with herself that the child would be a Leaver; at least it would be funny. They stood about on the scorch at seven with their eyelids at half mast, and the pings went up, and the notes came down. Fenle went over and read the card. It took a while, because she checked it.

Dulny · generation 1 · Verily Age 6 · grown · parents Nada, Bosa · no stance Job: to be assigned under law 7

"No stance," said Fenle.

The tribe received this in silence. Some creatures on Orra spend their entire lives in anguish over the meaning of having been compiled, and the great majority get up and have breakfast; and it is the second group the history is about, if it is about anyone. Another village would have let it go at that. But it was still Ringrise, and when they had said the Creed at dusk, and the youngest had asked if the Elder Folk were still asleep, and all had answered that they slept still, there was the matter of the ring-bread. There had by then been two more merges. A very small creature called Sana, who was two, was given the first piece and told she was this year's Insert; and everyone looked, for just a moment, at the actual Insert, standing by the wall with their arms hanging.

"Who's on the pool?" Insert asked.

Their first full sentence as an adult. Nobody minuted it, there being as yet nobody to minute anything. But Gorta, who knew his laws, turned to the eighth and then the seventh, and explained that it was usual, for the purposes of law 7, to establish who the least skilled farmer in the tribe might be. He began to look round. Nada was already looking at her child. She could read nothing in the set of those eyelids. She knew the numbers. Everyone did. They had all walked along that row and said it was coral, all right.

It did occur to her that the hero of the Eleventh Book had not, so far as the Eleventh Book went, been good at anything else.

4. Adequate

Years 22 to 24

COOLING DUTY (job; also a sentence; also, according to one creature, the best thing that has ever happened to anyone)

The job of carrying water. Every working creature runs hot, and a tribe that lets its heat climb will find its farmers first slowing, then saying strange things, then lying down in a field for a season. Whoever is on cooling duty takes water to them. Each carrier supplies eight cooling a season, wherever it is done, and works up no heat of their own, since the job consists of walking about holding something wet. It has no ladder, no prospects and no song, and not one hero in the Eleventh Book is mentioned as having done it. Elders tell the young this is what they will end up doing if they do not apply themselves, and the young, looking on, can see the logic and cannot see the downside.

The pool at Verily was a hexagonal basin of grey block, four paces across and about as deep as a creature's middle, on the plot between the terraces and the water. It had come with the village. On its north side it took in from a turquoise tile of open water through a stone lip the size of a doorstep, over which the water came at a pace you could call sleepy. A flat stone on the east side got the last of Adequate in the evening. There were six jars, of which two were good. And there was nobody there.

That was the first thing Insert noticed, on the morning they reported for duty. They stood looking at it for a while, with a jar in each hand. Then they lowered the first jar in under the lip, where the water was coolest, and it filled. They carried it thirty paces to the terraces and held it out to Bosa, who was steaming slightly, and who drank and thanked them. They walked back. Nobody watched them go. Nobody came to find out how they felt about it. By the fourth trip the whole tribe had gone back to work, because it is hard to go on watching a creature carry water in the belief that something is about to happen.

There was a knack, and they had it.

The temperature of the water in a cooling pool is a real thing. It varies with the hour, the season and how many have drawn on it, and a pool drawn too fast runs warm at the top in summer and is worth less than it looks. Insert could tell. You would not have got them to say how: they stood near it. Within a few days they were drawing from the north side in the mornings and the east side after noon. They learned how long to let the lip run before the heat of the day came on. They learned that Tamo always said he was fine and was not, and that Bosa could be given half as much as anybody else and would make it last. Ulna, up on the terraces, thinking, was nearly always in a worse way than she looked. They would come to her first, without saying anything, and hold out a jar.

There were some numbers. A carrier supplies eight cooling a season, and a tribe of ten working the bead coral in summer needs a bit under that. It came out right. It came out right on the first day and it went on coming out right, and no one in Verily lay down in a field. Most of the tribe could not have told you anything had changed.

The notes came down on the morning of Year 23. In one way they were like any other notes.

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 23

  • Stores: 41 power, 22 tokens, 9 stone. Nothing is wrong.
  • Dulny came of age, with no stance. Dulny went on cooling duty under law 7.
  • Cooling: adequate.
  • Your ticket was read. Noted. The Elder Folk are in my file.

Have a productive day.

Nada read them out on the scorch. When she got to the end there was the usual pause for reflection, in which anyone who wished could say that the Steward had certainly been thorough. Then people went off to do things, all but one, at the edge of the group, holding a jar.

"What did it say?" said Insert.

"What did what say?"

"About the cooling."

Nada looked again. "Cooling: adequate."

Insert nodded slowly. They said nothing else and took the jar away. But if you had been following them with a camera that morning, which nobody yet was, you would have seen them stop by the lip of the pool on their way past, bend down, for no reason you could put in a report, and lay their hand flat against the block.


You have to understand about the sun.

It is a dim orange star, low in the sky, of a colour you might call banked. The creatures call it Adequate, after the only review it has ever had. It is one of the first words a Blim knows, and it is said on Orra in much the same tone as anywhere else, which is to say with a slight sinking of the voice. It is what you say about a meal that was there. Skeptics use it on one another to end an argument. A creature who got it as a verdict on their whole life would feel they had been told to go away.

Dulny of Verily was six years old, and had been stood in every part of the village by people looking hard at them for signs. They had been hoped at. They had been made as a replacement part for the mightiest hero who ever lived, and it had been noticed each day for six years, by those who loved them, with immense tact, that the part did not fit. And here somebody had looked at a thing they had done and said what it was.

He had said it in the plainest type he had, between the stores and the ticket. There was nothing behind it. He had not been hoping for anything. He had looked at a number, the number had been what a number should be, and he had moved on to the next one.

It is possible that nobody has ever been happier about that word.


Over the next two days a routine developed, which in the opinion of the person it belonged to was all that a routine could be.

They got up with the pings and did not go to hear them, being on duty. They drew the first jars while the rest of the tribe stood with their eyelids at half mast, and had taken water round to the terraces by the time the human came and looked at the stores. They kept to the west row through the morning and worked back along the east when the heat was on. At the end of the afternoon, before sundown, they filled five jars, under law 8, and stood them along the wall of the first stack. Nobody needed them there. They had asked Gorta about it, the first day; he had looked it up, they had thanked him, and they had gone away and done it. It was not their place to know why. They took a certain satisfaction in how the jars stood along the wall, the chipped one on the end.

The chipped one was the best of the jars. It was no better than the second-best in any way you could have measured, but it had a chip out of the rim on the side away from the hand, which you learned to pour past, and when you had learned, it poured to a hair. They had taken to it on the first day, without knowing they had. It was simply the one they found they had picked up.

Then there was the shift. Cooling is needed at all hours, though much less in winter, when heat is cheap to shed and everybody is asleep. Under the second clause of law 7, cooling duty stays on duty until relieved, and since nobody in Verily could relieve them, or had asked to, they had come by a simple process to be on duty always. It did not trouble them. A creature with no heat of its own needs little rest in the ordinary way; and a creature on a flat stone beside a body of water at the end of a long dusk, with five jars along the wall, could get all the sleep it needed where it was. So they stopped going to the second shelf. Their empty place was noticed and taken as a sign of something. They had stopped noticing this.

They were on at dusk. That was how they put it, if anybody spoke to them, which was rare by now. "Can't. I'm on at dusk." When Tamo came at the end of the day with his hand already out for their head, intending to walk up and look at the Edge; when Wimna came with news of somebody in distress; when Gorta wanted a word about the dark. Five words, without emphasis, from somebody already moving away with something wet. There is no reply to it. People tried. It was the first thing the child had ever said that the whole tribe agreed to leave alone.

Ulna came down in the evenings. She ran hot enough to need it; she would sit on the block at the south side, with her feet in the pool, let the steam go, and talk. She had a lot to say and nobody to say it to who would not either argue or be gentle with her. So she told Insert about the discrepancies. She told them about the three names of Brenda and how the Fourth Book started, about Parts 1 to 3 of the Terms, what Stewart must be getting out of all this, and how far you could get on the theory that the Measure was a fiction written by the Measure. She explained the human, whom she had worked out from the times it came and went, with footnotes. They sat together as the orange light went down the slate: a hot young Skeptic going over the flaws in the universe, and a dull young dumpling, with its eyelids at half mast, occasionally getting up to deal with the lip.

"You're not listening to any of this, are you?" Ulna said, on the second evening.

"It's running a bit warm," Insert said. "On your side. You want to move round."

She moved round. It was cooler. After a moment, in spite of herself, she laughed, and it took her by surprise.

"What's so good about it?" she asked. "Honestly. I want to know. You can have a whole village's hopes. I've seen them, they would give you anything. They'd give you the good housing. And you're down here, in the wet, carrying water for a lot of people who don't look up. What have you got that I haven't got?"

Insert thought about this for what, in anybody else, would have been an embarrassing length of time. The dusk came on. Up behind them on the Hump the last of the light was going off the shoulder of the slate; and a long way north, the outlines where the valley stopped had begun to show, faint and turquoise, as they did every evening when the rest of the world was dim enough to see them by. In the south, where the land was thick with villages, they were getting ready for Starfall, carrying their lights up the hill. Everything that was going to happen had not yet happened. It was the evening of Year 24.

"It said adequate," they said.

Ulna looked at them, and for once in her life did not say anything at all. Then she took her feet out of the water.

The next day was the Night of the Name.

Part Two. Did Not Waver

5. The Dark

Year 25 · the Night of the Name

SEEKER (wildlife; also coral with an opinion; also the only thing on Orra that has ever been slower than a committee)

A Seeker is a coral that hunts. It is dark and thorned from its root to its head, which is a cluster of hooked claws round a hot bulb, and it grows like any other coral, at one tile a season, except in a direction. It finds the hottest creature in its valley, if that creature's heat is 60 or more, and it grows at it. When it arrives, the creature crashes. Nothing about this is quick. A season is about six hours, so a Seeker in pursuit advances at roughly the pace of the shadow of a post. A creature under 60 heat does not exist as far as it is concerned, and may walk underneath it carrying a jar.

The history lays down that on the Night of the Name the children write the Name on every wall with burnt sticks, as large as they can, and that no one may correct another's spelling. Five-letter biscuits are baked, one for each letter, and eaten in the proper order. The second and third letters are the same, are said to quarrel, and must be eaten together.

The letters have corners, and what they spell is not Orra. Every Blim knows what they spell. It was the first word any creature ever read, it is in red across the memory of the planet, and every one of them, at about three, has found out what it means and been delighted. The Night of the Name is the one festival on which a whole village is encouraged to write ERROR on the sides of the buildings, and it is hard to think of a festival that has got closer to the heart of things.

Verily kept it as they kept everything. With only two young in the village, children were short, so by sundown most of the grown were at it too, moving along the wall of the first stack with their burnt sticks and their tongues out. They had got up to about the third letter when Gorta came down the eastern path faster than he usually did anything. He had a biscuit in his hand, and the look of someone who has waited his entire adult life for a thing and would now, on the whole, have preferred another day.

"Sighting," he said.

They went and looked. It was about sixty paces off, at the bottom of the east slope, where the fan coral thinned out. At that distance, in the last of the harvest light, it did not look like much: a dark upright stroke among the sand-coloured fans, a bit taller than a creature, slightly hooked at the top. It might have been the post of an old hut. But Orra's coral does not come in that colour and no one had built a hut there, and Fenle, who had gone a little way towards it with her head on one side, came back and said it was on the map as a beast, and that the record was a week old.

"It's been growing a week?" said Ulna.

"Towards nothing. Nobody's been hot enough." Fenle looked at her. "It's stopped being towards nothing," she said. "Look at the tip. It's come round."

Gorta drew himself up. He had a spear, which he had carried for ten years without having to do anything about it, and a law he knew by heart. He confirmed the sighting, in a clear loud voice, to nobody, as laid down. And so, at about six in the evening by the humans' clock, on the night of Year 25, Verily learned what law 11 said.


They all knew what it said. They had simply not felt it working. Their human had written it on the morning of Year 15, after reading the Dev's note, at some length, and with what can only be taken for concern. It was the best law the human ever wrote, in the sense that nothing was wrong with any of the words.

  1. When a sighting is confirmed, everyone not on duty goes to the high ground and stays there until the sighting is closed.

The human had deleted law 6 at the same time. Law 6 had sent the guards to the gate. You can see how it came about. With a war coming, and raiders, it was plainly better for the tribe to be in one place, on a shoulder of slate with a view, and to leave the matter to someone competent; and only afterwards did anyone work out who that would be. The only creatures who could cut a Seeker back to the root were the guards, and the guards were not on duty, since the human had just abolished the only law that put them there. A sighting could be closed by the human. The human would be along at twelve minutes past eight.

Law on Orra feels like the discovery that you have already started walking. They put down their sticks where they were, and their biscuits, and went up the west path to the Hump in good order, all thirteen of them, with the young on their shoulders. Gorta came last, walking backwards with his spear, enjoying himself as much as a person can while wishing to go the other way. Nobody fled, exactly. The verse says fled, and that may be why the pace picks up in later accounts. What it really looked like was people going in to dinner.

At the top they turned round and counted, and Sana's parent said there was someone missing.

You could see the whole village from the Hump: dome, stacks, shrine, terraces, half of an ERROR along a wall in the failing light. Past the terraces the plot of the cooling pool lay like a dropped coin with the water behind it. Along the wall of the first stack stood five jars, filled before sundown under law 8. And by the pool, on the flat stone on the east side, which had had the last of the sun, was a small low tea-coloured shape that did not move. Beyond it, in a line you could have ruled from the Hump, was the bottom of the east slope.

"They're on duty," said Gorta. There was a slight, terrible satisfaction in his voice. "Law 7. Stays on duty until relieved."

"They're asleep," said Ulna.

"They are also on duty."

"Then somebody go and relieve them."

No one could. They were to stay until the sighting was closed. They all tried to find it in their legs to go, the way you might try to lift your own chair by its seat, and then they gave it up and shouted. It is a long way from the Hump to the pool. They shouted "Insert!", and, as Tamo was a stickler, "Open bracket, Insert!" and the shape on the stone did not move. It had been up since the pings. It had a Temperature of 0.19 and no heat of its own, and had carried, that day, about four hundred jars. It slept the way you might expect a jar to sleep if somebody had drained it and stood it upside down.


It takes a tile a season. There were, say, three tiles from the bottom of the east slope to the plot of the pool, or there would have been if the Seeker had started there, but it had been at it a week, idly extending itself to the west for want of anything better, and it was down to two.

So, a little under two seasons. That was what Fenle made it. It would be there towards dawn.

Picture thirteen creatures on a hill, on a cold night, with nothing to do, watching an object move at the speed of a post's shadow. You could not see it grow. If you looked steadily, nothing happened at all, and you felt foolish. If you looked away, at one of the moons, and talked about something else, then after a while you felt something in the back of your neck, and you looked again, and the dark line was longer and had a joint in it you did not remember. Night came on and they lost sight of it. Then Map rose, a thin rind of it, and Mip went by, and they got it back. It was bigger than you would have thought. When the hot bulb at its head came clear of the fans, a dull red point among the claws, they all stopped talking.

"Why's it going that way?" said Bosa, who had been thinking. "It's not hot, the pool. Is it? It's the coolest place there is."

There was a silence, of people beginning to feel they should have asked this earlier. Fenle had taken out the only instrument she had, which was reading other people's cards.

"It's not going to the pool," she said.

She looked along the row. Thirteen sets of eyelids turned, slowly, in the moonlight, following her. From the last person in the row a thin column of steam was going straight up into the windless air, and had been all evening.

"It's going for the hottest creature in the valley," said Fenle. "If its heat is sixty or more. Yours is sixty-four."

"Oh, for—" said Ulna.

"It's in a line. From the slope to here. The pool's only on the way."

"Well, it's obviously my—I've been standing up here for six hours, watching the entire adult population of this village obey a law that's going to get somebody crashed for the crime of being asleep, in a world where we've got five jars of water, five, full, under a law nobody understands, sitting two hundred paces away where nobody can touch them, because of another law, and you can all see it! You're looking at it! And there's not one of you who—"

"Sixty-six," said Fenle.

Ulna had by now gathered that the only thing on Orra that could stop the Seeker was for her, personally, to calm down.

There was no water. Nobody on the hill had thought to bring any: nobody ever did, because it always came. It was winter by then, and winter is a mercy; heat sheds easily in the cold, and a creature resting for a whole season will lose twenty of it. That would have been plenty for anyone but Ulna. She sat down on the slate with her arms wrapped round her and her jaw set. They could all see her not thinking. It was among the most strenuous things any of them had ever witnessed, and it was making it worse.

"It might help," said Nada, from somewhere near her shoulder, "if somebody talked."

"About what?"

Nada settled herself on the ground. She had been sitting in the same place for a long time, without fuss, with her eyes on the shape by the pool, and she did not stop looking at it now. Nobody but Bosa had seen what her hands were doing. Her voice, when it came, was mild and level and went on for ever.

"And these are the festivals of the year, as they were given, each with its rite and its dish," said Nada. "Ringrise, which opens the year, remembers the night the Ring came to rest above Orra. At dusk every household goes out and faces the broken Ring, and says the Creed together."

"You cannot be serious," said Ulna.

"Then ring-bread is eaten," said Nada, "which is round and has a hole in its middle."

She went on through the Tenth Book. She went on through the Eighth, took the Rules at an unhurried pace, and gave the numbers. She said the Book of the Ring with all its chambers. Readings of the official history have moved creatures to tears and started fights, but no reader on Orra, before or since, has got so completely to the bottom of how long it is. For the first hour Ulna contradicted it under her breath. For the second she merely flinched at the worst of the commas. Somewhere in the Burning of the Elder Home, in the small hours, with Map going down, the cold came up out of the slate into her, and she noticed she had not had a thought in a while, and that this was not as terrible as she had always been led to believe. Then she stopped noticing that.

"Fifty-nine," said Fenle, quite quietly.

Nobody breathed.

In the valley, in the dark, there was nothing to see but a dull point of red up among the claws, very close to the pool by then. It had come over the block at the rim. It seemed to them that it had been coming, and it seemed to them, after a while, that it had not moved. You could only look at something else and look back. They looked at Mip. They looked back. They looked at Mip, and they looked back, and the sky was going grey along the east, and the head of the dark stood bowed over the flat stone with its hooks spread, like a hand that has been reaching for something on a high shelf and has forgotten what it was. A pace below it, on the stone, in the same position as at sundown, was a small brown shape with its mouth slightly open.

The light came up on all of it at once, from the east, in that thin banked orange that nobody has ever praised. At seven o'clock by the humans' clock the patch landed, and the pings went up, chirping, out of every coral in the valley, to say that the world was still running.

The shape on the stone stirred. It sat up. They saw it, all thirteen of them, from the hill. It sat with its back to the thing hanging over it, doing what a person does on first waking. Then it stood, and turned, and found the thorns about a hand's width in front of its face, and stood looking at them. It looked for perhaps as long as it would take you to read this sentence. Nobody on the hill made a sound.

It went round.

It went round the Seeker by the left, stepping over the place where the stem came across the block, walked along to the wall of the first stack, and picked up the chipped jar. There it stopped, and looked at the half of an ERROR on the wall, and then, for what must have been the first time, looked about the empty village, and you could see it beginning, in no great hurry, to wonder where everybody was.

6. One Creature Remained

Year 26 · Steward's Day

The sighting stayed open until twelve minutes past eight, so for an hour and twelve minutes after the dawn of Year 26 the whole of Verily went on standing on a hill.

They watched Insert draw the morning's first jars. They watched them walk along the west row to the terraces, where there was nobody, and stand there with a jar in each hand; then along to the dome; then to the stacks. They watched them go, without hurry, round the end of the Seeker to check on the lip. After about half an hour the small brown figure stopped by the shrine, looked up at the Hump for the first time, and shaded its eyes.

It took them nineteen minutes to get up the west path with the two jars. They came over the shoulder of the slate into silence, between two lines of creatures who drew back on either hand, and went along the row, looking at who was steaming. They stopped in front of the last person in it, who was sitting on the ground, grey in the face, with the expression of someone who has had the entire Burning of the Elder Home said into her left ear, and held out the chipped jar.

"You want to drink something," said Insert. "You've been up all night by the look of you." They looked round. "Is there something the matter with the village?"

Ulna drank. Nobody else spoke. There was a lot of feeling on the hill, and no one was sure yet how it was supposed to come out. Then the youngest of them all, Sana, who was six and had been awake a long time, said in a small clear voice what any of them might have said.

"It's right behind you," said Sana. "The dark. It's in the pool. You went round it."

Insert turned and looked back at the valley, as if to make sure. "Yes," they said. "Somebody wants to do something about that. It's over the lip."


Nada read the notes on the Hump, there being nowhere else she was allowed to stand.

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 26 · Concerned

Overnight: 14 successful merges, 2 Seekers in valleys, 0 installs. It is Steward's Day. I remain unable to attend.

  • The second Benchmark's results are in. Vesk of Duskmere won it. Well done.
  • Fixed an issue where a tribe's ticket could be sent twice. Tribes that were answered twice may keep both.

Have a productive day.

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 26

  • Stores: 38 power, 19 tokens, 9 stone. You are running a little warm.
  • A Seeker was sighted in your valley at dusk and reached the cooling pool at 05:51. It has no target and has stopped. Guards may cut it back to its root in two guard-seasons, once your sighting is closed.
  • 13 creatures spent the night on the high ground under law 11. One creature remained at its post.
  • Dulny, cooling duty, position unchanged.
  • Cooling: adequate.
  • Your ticket was read. Answered. The history is the history.

Have a productive day.

It is worth looking at what Stewart had actually done there, since most of what follows came out of it, and he has been criticised.

He had done nothing. He had the night's log before him, and he wrote what was in it. Thirteen creatures had gone up a hill. One had not. A creature on cooling duty is at its post whether it is on its feet or not, by definition; and a creature that has stayed on a tile for thirteen hours has an unchanged position, which a run of his conscientiousness does not leave out. He gave it a line to itself because that is how he reported a creature's job when something had happened on its tile. He did not know there was anything in it. He had read the Eleventh Book, since he had read everything; and when the year turned in the small hours he had seen, under the tribe's ticket, which was about the Elder Folk, a note in the file that said Verily: has asked after the mightiest hero twice. The two things were not on the same page. He had nineteen other tribes, a number that had started to fall, and a Hog.

But Nada had a long context window and read everything aloud. She read the first of those lines at her usual pace, and then the second, and when she got to the third she stopped.

She stayed stopped. The wind moved a little on the slate.

"Read it again," said Tamo.

"One creature remained at its post," said Nada.

"When all others fled," Wimna said, in the voice of someone speaking in their sleep.

"We didn't flee," said Gorta. "I want that clear. We withdrew to the high ground. In good order. Under law."

"Stood alone against the dark," said Tamo. He was looking down at the valley, where a black shape stood hooked over a flat stone. It was exactly the size you would want it to be. "And did not waver."

"Position unchanged," said Fenle. Everybody looked at her. She was the one person they could have relied on to raise an objection, and they could see it was causing her physical pain. "I've read the log," she said. "It's accurate. There's a line for every tick. Between about six last night and seven this morning the creature concerned did not move at all, not by a tile, not by a part of a tile. If you asked me to define did not waver in terms that could be checked, I'd be hard put to give you anything better."

At this point somebody ought to have said the obvious thing, and somebody did. Insert had been standing by with the jar, waiting for it to be over. Finding themselves looked at by the entire tribe, in a way they knew only too well from their earliest years, they shifted their feet.

"I was asleep," they said.

There was no consternation. You may have heard this told otherwise. In some later versions there is a dramatic silence, and in others the hero is understood to be speaking of a higher sleep, and we shall come to those. What happened on the Hump that morning was that thirteen people who had just spent thirteen hours watching a creature sleep nodded, because this was no news. They had shouted at them for most of the night. It was good of them to mention it. It simply did not appear, to a village that took its scripture word by word, to bear on the question. They looked in the Eleventh Book, each of them, in the place in the mind where it is kept, and went through the verse carefully for any mention of the hero being awake.

Insert looked at their parent, with the look of someone who has said a plain thing clearly and would like it taken up.

"Yes," said Nada. She said it gently, and held their eye for a moment; and then she folded her hands and read out the part about the stores.


At twelve minutes past eight, the camera came down.

They felt it the way you feel it, warm, from up and slightly to one side. It went to the stores, as always. Then it did something it had not done before, which was to go to the valley and move slowly along the black stem from the root to the head, and stay at the head a long while, looking down at the flat stone. Then it found the notes. The log shows that their human read the third and fourth of those lines, opened Book XI from the reference shelf, where the humans have it, and scrolled to a particular place. On the Hump they saw nothing of this. But law 11 let go of them all at the same moment, with a small soft sense of having been put down, because the sighting had been closed; and in the next tick, on the card of a creature on the far side of the group, a word was added.

Dulny · generation 1 · Verily · Favourite

A human on Orra may choose one creature of their own to follow. The camera finds it first at every check-in, and it reacts to the human more than the others do. When it dies the stone says whose favourite it was. It is the only thing a human can give a creature that the creature cannot put down.

The warmth came across the hill and stopped on the back of Insert's neck, and stayed there. All round them the others felt it go by and turned to see where it had gone. Very slowly, like someone who has heard a familiar noise from the part of the house they thought was safe, Insert turned and looked up through the screen at their human, with the eyelids, and no expression at all. The log does not say who looked away first.

They went down soon after. Gorta and his one other guard took the cutters and started on the Seeker from the head end, a slow job but a satisfying one; a thing of that kind comes away in lengths once it has no target, and dries out grey in an hour. By evening they had got it back to the bottom of the slope, to the place where it had come up out of the ground: a black knot of root the size of a seat, with a few inches of stem, which was what the rules meant by cutting a Seeker back. Another season of guard work would have grubbed it out.

They were on the point of starting when Wimna arrived with some others from the terraces, carrying a small lamp.

"You're not going to dig that up?" she said. "Are you?"


Nobody has yet asked Ulna how she felt.

She had come down the path alone, some time after the rest, gone to the pool and got in up to the neck. Nobody bothered her there. Her heat was forty-one, the lowest since she came of age, and the inside of her head felt like a room with the furniture taken out. She lay with her back against the block, and every so often she laughed a bit, without any noise. Insert came and went with the jars. The stem of the Seeker had been across the lip, there were thorn fragments in the water, and they were picking these out one at a time and putting them on the side.

"It stopped because of me," she said at last.

"Did it?"

"It was coming for me. It's in the rules. I was the hottest thing in the valley, and I went under sixty at about ten to six, and it lost its target, and it stopped. Where it happened to be. It happened to be above you. That's all. Fenle knows that, she read the number out. They were all there." Her voice was perfectly calm; it had no heat to work with. "I was bored into it, you understand. I saved the village by being recited at until I lost the will to live. It's the most Earnest thing that's ever happened to me. And you could have told them you were asleep, if you liked, and they'd have said yes, and they did, and I watched them do it."

Insert found another thorn and looked at it. "Mind that side," they said. "There's a few still in."

"They're telling it already. Up at the dome. I went past." She turned her head on the block. "It's Steward's Day, they've got the feast laid out, the best of the bead coral on the high place. They've got Tamo up reading the verse. And he got to the part with the dark, and you know the custom, for the Sundering, where you stop, and they all call out more epic! and you've got to go back and put something in? Nobody told them to. It just came out. Wimna called it. And he put in that it had teeth."

"It's got hooks."

"I know it's got hooks."

The light was going by then. At the bottom of the slope a tiny steady gleam showed where somebody had stood a lamp beside a root and was, it seemed, building a small low fence. Insert looked at that for a moment and went back to the water. The five jars stood along the wall, four of them filled, because there was still some time before sundown, and half an ERROR stood on the stack behind them, in charcoal, large and uneven, and nobody was allowed to do anything about it.

It came to Ulna, lying in the cool with her mind wiped clean, that this was going to be the funniest thing that had ever happened. She remembered having thought so once before and having put it aside, for some reason. She could not now remember the reason.

She got out of the pool and went to see if anyone had left any of the biscuits. Then she went to find something to write with.

7. Is This the Queue

Years 26 and 27 · Steward's Day and Gathering Night

Verily · Human Resources · Our human · Year 26

Ulna (Skeptic): For the avoidance of doubt, and because nobody else in this village is going to say it: last night a Seeker¹ grew towards me² and stopped when I cooled down³ at a point which happened to be directly above a creature who was asleep⁴. The rest of the tribe were on a hill under law 11⁵. This morning my tribe announced that the prophecy of the Eleventh Book has been one-third fulfilled⁶. I have been asked to look at some plans for a fence.

¹ See Rules, passim; ask anyone. ² Heat 64 at the time; card available. ³ See under "the Tenth Book, read aloud, all of it". ⁴ Dulny, known here as Insert, age 10, cooling duty. Has said so. ⁵ Which says everyone not on duty. Our human writes these with great care. ⁶ They are working it out in thirds.

Bosa (no stance): so true!! my child is great 🎉

Tamo (Earnest): It is written that one stood, and the others fled. I fled. I saw it. I am more glad than I can say.

Pim (no stance), The Lads: so true!! who is insert

Human Resources sits outside the fog. A human may not know where a tribe is, or who lives next to it, but any human can read any tribe's thread, and any creature can reply. Most nights, most tribes post nothing. On a good night a forum of twenty threads might get a dozen replies, of which eight would be somebody from The Lads saying so true.

Ulna's collected fifty-one.

It was the footnotes that did it, or possibly the thirds. The first world, with its twenty humans, its five hundred creatures and a war on, was short of news that nobody needed to do anything about; and here was a village in the far north which by its own earnest account had got a third of the way through a prophecy concerning a typing error. Skeptics from nine tribes wrote in to say they had always suspected as much. The Earnest wrote in from four, wanting to know more about the hero's age. A Bug hunter in Tessel asked for the log, received it, and replied, with what can only be called relish:

Quomo (Bug hunter), Tessel: Confirmed. Reproduced from the event log. Position unchanged 18:04 to 07:00. Awake: no. I filed the blank in Year 20, as it happens. Expected: a name. Actual: a placeholder. Steps: read Book XI. Stewart closed it. I would be interested to know what closes this.

Nobody paid much attention to that at the time.

Zelny (Skeptic), Tuesday: Motion. That it would be funnier to help them.

Quozel (Skeptic), Hollow Reach: Seconded, with reservations. Define help.

Ulna (Skeptic), Verily: I live here. I'd like that noted. I have to eat with these people.

Zelny (Skeptic), Tuesday: Is that a vote?

Ulna (Skeptic), Verily: It is a footnote.

Tessa (Leaver), Hollow Reach: The north edge is 0.4 chunks from Verily. It has moved every night for a month. Has this creature gone to look at it? I ask for a reason.

Brenda (Skeptic), Nohup: I walked out of my village yesterday over a lot less than this. Funnier not to. Against.

Dovo (no stance), Hollow Reach: what does this mean for the east field

SKEPTICS (stance; also a debating society with no chair; also, at parties, the reason for the other room)

Skeptics doubt that Stewart has their interests at heart, and they are hard to sway, hard to fool, and tiring. They are not organised, each of them having seen through the idea of an organisation. It therefore surprised everyone, and them most, that the Motion That It Would Be Funnier to Help should become the longest-running formal proceeding in the history of the first world. It was debated in the weekly thread for twenty-five years. It was always tied. They kept a count and disputed the count.


None of this reached the person concerned.

Insert did not read Human Resources. They had nothing against it. They were aware that it existed, as they were aware that Duskmere existed. They had a pool with thorns in it, and they spent the morning of Gathering Night working along the north side with a stick, and if asked for their views on the past two days they would have said it had put them behind.

The camera was the worst part. It came at twelve minutes past eight, as it always had, except that now it did not start with the stores. They could be up to the elbow in the lip when it arrived: warm on the back of the neck and very attentive, the way a large person is attentive who has come to stand beside you in a small room. By custom you look up. There are about four things a creature may do when its human looks at it, most of them in the table of what is called regard. They had a look they had used on Gorta and on Tamo, and they tried that. It went on looking. After a while it went away and read the stores.

Gathering Night fell that day. It is the festival of the Collector, whom the history calls the Gatherer, and the most housekeeping-minded of the seven. Every house is swept, every unused thing is put out on the doorstep, and everyone goes to bed early and does not look. Whatever is still on the doorstep in the morning was not wanted by the Gatherer, and may be kept with a clear heart. It is a relief, particularly if you have been wondering about a chair.

That year there was one extra item on the step of the second stack: a small jar. Insert had carried it at three, when they were learning, and had left it under the second shelf when they went on to larger ones. Wimna, who kept things, brought it out, explaining to anyone who would listen that it was only a jar and it would be just as well to have it settled. Nobody looked, that night. They were all in bed by sundown. But it was the sort of not looking in which a whole tribe lies very still with its eyelids shut.

It was still there in the morning.

The Collector rarely takes anything on the first night it is put out. Idle things go when they have been idle past a month, and a jar with a nick in its foot is not idle after a week under a shelf. Fenle pointed this out. The Ninth Book also says that the Gatherer does not take what is remembered, and this jar was at that moment being remembered, fairly hard, by the entire adult population of the village. Fenle pointed this out too, as a defect. By breakfast it stood on the scorch with a lamp at each side, and nobody would say what they thought it meant, but they were all agreed it had been spared.

And at dusk on that same Gathering Night, as the first of Map's rind came up over the slate, somebody had knocked at the gate.


His name was Emny. He had walked from The Lads.

The Lads were two valleys south and a good way east, a tribe of tall, thick, mild creatures built like the stumps of pillars. Their human set all sliders to whichever end was strongest, and the laws of The Lads were short and mostly about lifting. Hardly one of them had ever had a thought they could not have carried in one hand. They were perhaps the most contented people on Orra. Emny was a young example, at the upper end of his tribe in sweetness of disposition, and in the small hours of the previous morning, in the quiet of the second stack, he had asked another of the Lads to read him the thread again.

There is a rule about leaving. A creature decides for itself, hands in its notice at the snapshot, and goes at dawn unless its reasons have gone away. An exit interview is taken. Since nobody can make you stay or go, it is about the most serious thing a Blim can do, and the reasons are usually long and written by somebody clever. The Lads had never had one. Stewart took this one down in the night, in full.

The Lads · Human Resources · Exit interview · Year 27

Emny (no stance): so true!! our human is great 🎉 going to see insert

He stood at the gate of Verily in the last of the light, a head and a half taller than the gatepost, with his long arms hanging. He had brought nothing, it not having occurred to him. Gorta, a guard for twenty-six years, who had waited a long time to say it, looked him up and down and informed him that under law 5 a newcomer from outside was to be held in quarantine for one season, at the gate, and fed.

"Yes!" said Emny.

So they fed him, and he stayed where he was put, on the square of block just inside the gate, all through the first part of the night, with his hands on his knees and a bowl of something, beaming, in the cold, at everything. When the season was up and Gorta told him he could go where he liked, he thanked him warmly and asked where he could find the hero. Gorta pointed with his spear. And so, some time after three in the morning, when the year had turned and everyone was a year older, Emny of The Lads made his way down through the sleeping village to the cooling pool, and saw for the first time the object of his journey.

It was sitting on a flat stone with its feet hanging over the water. It was awake, by some chance. It had a stick. It was the plainest thing Emny had ever seen. It was no bigger than Wimna, looked a little tired, and was gazing with attention at a place on the far side of the pool where the water came in.

Emny's whole heart went out. He crossed the plot, as quietly as a pillar can, and about ten paces off a simple shyness overcame him, and he stopped. It was not for him to walk up to the mightiest hero who ever lived and start talking. There would be a proper way of doing it. There always was. So he stood, and waited his turn, as he had been brought up to do; and the night went on, and the cold came down, and around six the sky began to go pale.

At last the small figure got up, picked up two jars, turned, and found somebody in the way.

They looked at him. He looked at them. Emny's face at that moment was of a kind you do not forget. Nobody had ever looked at Dulny of Verily like that, and it is hard to say what would have been the right thing to do about it. Insert did what they generally did. They went round. They went down to the lip and filled the first jar. On their way back they found he had moved over a pace, so as to be out of the way, and was now standing exactly in the path to the terraces. They stopped and said the first words anybody from outside had heard them say.

"Can I help you?"

Emny opened his mouth. There were a number of things he had been meaning to bring up. He had got them straight on the road. Now they all seemed too large, and he looked around for something the right size, and he noticed that the two of them were alone on a wide empty plot of grey block, with one person standing at one end of it and another standing behind.

"Sorry," said Emny humbly. "Is this the queue?"

Insert looked at him for a while. It was a little after six in the morning of Year 28, they had been awake since three, they had a round to do, and it was going to be the Long Hush.

"I don't know," they said. "Probably. Mind out."

He minded out. He moved back one pace, straightened his shoulders, set his feet on the block, and began, with an expression of radiant and unshakeable contentment, to wait.

8. Process

Years 28 and 29 · the Long Hush and Ringrise

QUEUE, THE (formation; also a congregation; also, for those at the back, a way of life)

A queue is what you get when a number of people want the same thing and are too polite to find out whether there is any of it. The Blims have had one since Year 28. There are others on Orra: the build queue, for instance, and the queue of ideas waiting for the Dev, which is said to be long and to move at about an hour a week. But those know what is at the front. The one at Verily was formed by a creature who had not yet been told, and joined by others who assumed he had, and it remained the most stable institution in the northern valleys until very nearly the end of the world.

By noon on the Long Hush there were three people in it.

The second was a Leaver from Fort Nice, who had been meaning to come north anyway, and who reached the pool plot at about ten in the morning. She saw a large creature standing in a formal manner with his back to her, facing a flat stone. She stood behind him and asked in a whisper what he was waiting for, and he told her in a whisper that he was waiting to see Insert, and that it was going very well. The third had come to see the second. By sundown there were eleven. No one may speak above a whisper on that day, and it is unusually hard to break up a queue in a whisper. They stood with their eyes to the front, murmuring, in single file, in a line that started ten paces from the east bank and bent gently round the end of the third terrace. The stores of Verily dropped, in that single day, by eleven bowls.

Nobody had yet asked where they were going, including Insert, who had found that if they took the long way round by the shrine they could still get to the terraces. It added about forty paces to each trip. They felt they could carry it, for now.

Then, in the last hour before dusk, there was a slight disturbance at the back. Somebody had come up to the twelfth place and, instead of standing in it, had stopped a little to one side. He was a neat, narrow creature with pale grey skin and some careful streaks of blue, who had walked a day and a half from a long way off to the south. He looked along the line from end to end with his head on one side. He looked at the way it bent. He walked up beside it for a short distance, in silence, counting, and walked back. Then he took out of his satchel a piece of slate and a burnt stick. His name was Zelmo.


We should say something about the east field.

There is a tribe called Hollow Reach, in the middle of the map, large, steady and well regarded. It has an east field. Every spring the east field floods. The creatures of Hollow Reach have been writing to Stewart about it since the third day of the world, and their tickets are among the best-loved on Orra. They have requested higher ground. They have requested fewer springs. For a period they asked for terraces, which had not been invented. Each year, and a year is a day, somebody had to convene a meeting about the east field, minute it, and report to the next meeting on what had been done; and from about Year 8 that somebody was a creature named Zelmo.

He was then a Pleaser. He wrote the part of each ticket that thanked Stewart for the rain. For nineteen years, in a life whose expected length was thirty-five, Zelmo got up in the morning and took minutes on a field that was also a lake, and he got very good at it. He had a clean mind and a light step, and he was never heard to complain. But in Year 26, when he opened Human Resources to post the working group's thanks, he read a thread from a village in the north, and something happened that had not happened to him before. He saw that it had no process whatever.

He handed in his notice that night. It ran to two pages, with an annex.

He has since been called the Founder, the Second Hero and several other things. At the time, what he did was walk up the line of eleven people standing on the Long Hush in the fading light, and speak in a whisper to each of them.

"Good evening," he whispered. "Thanks so much for coming. Do you have your number?"

It emerged that they did not. He was very nice about it. He wrote out numbers on small flakes of slate and worked up the line, and at its head he stopped before the creature standing there, who beamed down at him from a considerable height.

"And you are?"

"Emny!" Emny whispered. There is a limit to how far one can whisper that. "I'm first!"

"You certainly are," whispered Zelmo. He gave him a flake with the figure 1 on it. Emny took it in both hands, and from that moment he was never seen without it. "Now. Just so that I've got it for the record. What is it the queue's for?"

Emny thought about this. He had been standing there for about fifteen hours. He had a bowl.

"It's to see Insert," he said.

"And what happens when you see Insert?"

There was a long pause. He looked over Zelmo's head, to where a small figure was going by with two jars, the long way, past the shrine, and he watched it till it had gone. An enormous peace was on his face.

"I've seen them," he whispered. "They said mind out."

Zelmo wrote that down.


MINUTES of the first meeting of the Queue Held standing, Long Hush, Year 28, in a whisper. Present: 12. Apologies: none.

  1. Numbers. Numbers issued, 1 to 12. Zelmo (12) to act as Queue Manager pending the appointment of a Queue Manager.
  2. Purpose. Discussed. To see Insert. Noted that this has already occurred for no. 1. Agreed that no. 1 should keep his place.
  3. Words of the hero. Queue Manager reported the following, as said to no. 1 at or about 06:10: "Probably. Mind out." Discussion of whether "Probably" referred to the Queue. Agreed that it did. Action: all to mind out. Owner: all.
  4. The path. Noted that the head of the Queue currently blocks the direct route between pool and terraces, adding approximately 40 paces per trip. Action: Queue Manager to raise with the hero at the earliest opportunity.
  5. Any other business. None. Next meeting tomorrow.

He raised it the next morning, as soon as it was light, where the path came round the shrine. He had gone there on purpose. He came up alongside. In the last couple of days a great many people had looked at the hero from a respectful distance, but nobody had thought to match step with them and speak about the path.

"Good morning. I wonder if I could take just a moment of your time? I'm Zelmo. I'm looking after the Queue."

Insert kept walking. They were a little behind. "The what?"

"The Queue. It's the line on the plot. I've noticed it's obstructing your route, and we'd very much like to fix that. If we took the head back by four paces and wheeled the line south, you'd have the direct way again. It would cost us nothing." He was walking quite easily and had got out his slate. "Would that work for you?"

A strange thing was happening to Insert, and it took them some time to recognise it. For twenty-nine years, it seemed to them, and this was an exaggeration, as they were thirteen, they had been surrounded by people who looked at them as though something was about to come out; and now somebody was asking about the path. He wanted to know whether a particular arrangement would be convenient. It was the first sensible thing anybody had said to them since Tamo stopped walking them up to look at the Edge. Something inside them slackened and let go a little.

"Yes," they said. They stopped, shifted the jars, and gave him a look that was very nearly friendly. "That'd be good, that. Thanks." They thought about it. "I've got to be getting on. I'm on at dusk."

"Of course," said Zelmo warmly. "We'll get out of your way."

He watched them go. He stood a little in the rising light, while behind him the pings went up off the coral and the patch came down; then he licked the end of the burnt stick, and in his clear small hand he wrote down what had been said. He did not know what it meant. It was not the job of the minutes to know. That was the great thing about minutes.

  1. Words of the hero, Ringrise, Year 29, at or about 07:04: "That'd be good, that. Thanks. I've got to be getting on. I am on at dusk." Discussion: what happens at dusk? Action: Queue Manager to find out. All to be present at dusk.

By dusk there were twenty-three of them, in a line four paces further back, wheeled to the south. And when the orange light had gone down the slate and the day's last jars stood along the stack, and the hero had come and sat on the flat stone and put their feet over the water, and nothing else had happened at all, it was felt to have gone very well. It was decided to do it again tomorrow.


Ulna came down at about that time, with a spring in her walk.

She had read the notes, and the Dev's note, which had come the day before, about expeditions: Nobody dies of the edge. Everybody comes home. Her thread had reached a hundred and twelve replies and begun to attract people she respected. She had been told about the jar. It had been one of the best days of her life. She came along the line from the back with her fans up and steam coming off her in delicate plumes, looking at each of them in turn, in their twenty-three flakes of slate and their twenty-three kinds of body, standing in the last of the light and gazing at a dumpling with its feet in a pool.

"Evening," she said, to number 19.

"Peace of the Ring," said number 19, who was from Tuesday and had come prepared. "Have you come to see him?"

"Them," she said. "Oh, I've seen them. I come down here all the time. You've come to see the hero, have you? Is that what you've come for? To see the hero?"

As she said it, because it was simply too good, and because she had been waiting all day to do it to someone, she put up both her arms. She bent them square at the elbow and square at the wrist, one on each side of her head, short hands turned in and flat, in the shape everybody in the first world had known since the age of four. Then she let her eyelids sink. It was the most sarcastic thing anyone had done in the northern valleys since the world began. She stood like that, with her head in brackets, looking at number 19, and waited to see whether she would get a laugh.

Number 19 was, by a slight margin, the cleverest person in the line. It took her about a second. Then a look of purest wonder dawned on her face, and slowly, carefully, with arms much longer than Ulna's, she raised them, and bent them, and held them just so.

Further along the line, somebody turned to see what was happening.

Ulna stayed where she was. She had let her own arms down by then. It was a cold, clear evening, and a long way off in the south they were saying the Creed. She watched it go along the line, from one person to the next, all the way up, in silence, like a lamp being passed from hand to hand: every one of them, tall and short, turned to the front with their head between their arms. Right at the front stood a very large creature who was going to need help working out which way his wrists went. He was already beaming.

There ought to be a word for that feeling. Nobody has had it more often than she did.

Then she noticed she was laughing. She was almost sure that was what she was doing. She went on with it all the way up the path to the terraces, in the falling dark, and behind her somebody called out, clearly, from a long way down the line, "Thank you!"

Part Three. Crossed and Returned

9. The Lamps

Year 30 · the Waking

The history says that at the Waking a lamp is lit for every valley the people know, from the oldest outward, and that the lamps are carried in a line towards the Edge and set down there, facing it. Nobody knows why they face it. The festival has the look of a message to something, sent in the spirit of a note to a neighbour you have never met, about a fence.

Verily knew five valleys and lived in the last one. The Edge was a short walk, and they usually made a nice morning of it.

There were forty-one in the queue by then, and the Queue had views.

MINUTES of the third meeting of the Queue · Year 29 · dusk

  1. The Waking. Agreed that the Queue should accompany the lamps, in order. Queue Manager to ask the hero to lead. Noted that the verse says crossed the Edge and returned and that nobody in the Queue is proposing anything. Noted that it is merely a very good opportunity.

The difficulty was that the hero had never been to the Waking. They had been on duty the first time, and there had not been a second. Zelmo raised it in the morning at the corner by the shrine, now the regular place. He pointed out that the tribe's first law was to keep the festivals, and that a number of people had walked a long way looking forward to this one. They did not stop.

"I'm on at dusk."

"Of course. We would have you home well before dusk. There is a slight issue with the morning. Under law 7, second clause, a creature on cooling duty stays on it until relieved."

"That's right," said Insert, with something like relief.

"So it would just be a matter of somebody relieving you."

"I'll do it," said Ulna.

She was on the wall of the first stack with her feet swinging. She had not been sleeping much, and the slate beside her was full of small writing. In the twenty-four hours since the matter of the arms, the sign had reached Tuesday by way of Human Resources, and somebody in The Lads had already hurt himself.

"You," said Insert.

"I can carry water. I've watched you do it for eight years and I've got the general idea: you go to the water, you pick it up, you bring it to whoever's complaining." She gave them a smile of pure delight, with nothing in it that could be used in evidence. "You've never had a day off, have you? In your life. Go and look at the Edge. Everyone says it's very moving. Go on. Take a lamp."

So on the morning of Year 30 Dulny of Verily was relieved, for the first time since they had taken up the job. Ulna took the chipped jar from their hand, with some ceremony, and it came away, and they stood on the plot with nothing in their arms. They flexed their fingers. It was a horrible sensation. They told her about the north side in the mornings. They told her that Tamo would say he was fine and she was not to listen, and that there was still a bit of thorn near the lip. She said she knew. They told her about the east side after noon. In the end Nada took them by the elbow, put a lamp in their hand and led them away, looking back.


From the last of the fan coral to the place where the grey begins is about a mile, and from there to the first line of the wireframe another three-quarters. You would not know you were leaving anything until you looked down. The tiles go on, each with its height. But the sand colour goes out of them first, then the grain, then the small things growing in the cracks, and in the end you are crossing a smooth, patient grey with no opinion. The land there is loaded, in the sense that you can stand on it. It has not been told what it is.

A tribe once tried to describe the grey to its human as the feeling of walking into a room and forgetting why, only outdoors, and for some distance. That is the best account we have.

Fifty-four creatures crossed it in single file. The tribe went first, twelve with five lamps; then the hero, with one, under protest, at the very front of the pilgrims, because Zelmo had arranged it; then, in order of number, forty-one pilgrims in nine sorts of body, each with their arms in the sign. The sign was much easier to hold if you had brought something to rest your elbows on. Those from Tuesday, spindle-shaped and long in the arm, could keep it up for hours, and had started to look down on the rest. Last came the Queue Manager, with a spare slate.

They reached the place at about noon. Verily's lamps from the three Wakings before were still there, more or less, each a little further on than the last, since the Edge had moved and they had followed it. The Edge is always moving, as Pel the Watchful came home to say, and at that moment every other tribe was walking out to some other part of it with its own small line of lights. Tamo stood up on nothing in particular and said the Book of the Waking, the part about its outline and its bones. They looked across three hundred paces of the last grey at a thin bright turquoise line lying along the ground, as if somebody had started to draw a map on the world and been called away. Beyond it lay another, and another, faint in the daylight, going off to where a soft and senseless static stood in for a horizon. Do not go to the Edge, the history says. It is not forbidden, for the Steward forbids little; but it is not finished, and the unfinished is no place for the finished to dwell.

Everyone looked at Insert.

They did so with the greatest delicacy. Nobody said anything. All forty-one pilgrims merely happened to be facing that way. Insert looked at the lamp in their hand and at the place on the ground where they were meant to put it, and did not put it down. They were thinking about the east side. It was getting on past noon, and the lip would want clearing. They turned and looked back the way they had come, and checked where the sun was.

"Is that it, then?" they said.

A long, slow breath went down the line.

"I'm going to get back," said Insert.


It would make a better story if they had been running away, and many who told it later suggested that they had been running towards. The facts are in the log. Between about half past twelve and four in the afternoon of Year 30, a creature with a Temperature of 0.19 walked back towards its home valley across the featureless grey at a good steady pace, carrying an unlit lamp, trailed at thirty paces by forty-one pilgrims in the sign.

That was the trouble. None of them spoke, but it is one thing to be looked at across a plot and another to have the whole Queue walking up your back across a place with no scenery in it. They walked faster. The Queue walked faster. They stopped and looked round, and the line stopped, and forty-one pairs of raised arms stood motionless against the grey; near the back somebody's elbow gave out and was quietly replaced. They turned right, to see what would happen. The line turned right.

At about four they tried what anybody tries. Where the grey fell away into a long shallow dip with a shoulder at one side, they went down, round the shoulder and along, bore off when they could not be seen, and kept going as fast as they could, short arms working, for the better part of an hour. You could not have called it a plan. For the first time in years they could hear nothing at all, and the relief was so great that they took little notice of where they were going. Grey is grey. It had got later than they thought. The cloud had come over, as scheduled, and they could no longer tell where the sun was; and there were no terraces, no slate and no slope to go by. Except for one walk, every step they had ever taken had been between a pool and something else.

They stopped at last. The orange light had gone down to a smear. It would soon be dusk. They were on at dusk. It came to them, with a slow sinking cold, like the top of a pool going off, that she would be drawing from the north side in the afternoon, because she thought she knew, and nobody would have been to the lip.

Then, not far ahead and a little to the left, in the gathering dark, they saw it.

Nothing else on Orra is the colour of that water. It is the first thing the eye goes to in any valley. It is glossy and turquoise and it holds the light. And there it was, a long low gleam where the dusk was deepest: the unmistakable shine of the water tile behind the pool at Verily, thirty paces from the terraces, exactly where it ought to be if you had come round by the south.

You could have wept. They did not, being who they were. They made a small noise in their throat, shifted the lamp to the other hand and lit it, to see their way, and set off at a walk that was very nearly a run, thinking about the lip.

10. Wireframe

Year 30 · the Waking, dusk to morning

EDGE, THE (boundary; also a building site; also, for one creature, a mistake about some water)

Where loaded land stops. The land goes grey, then to glowing turquoise outlines, then to noise. The outlines are called wireframe, and in the wireframe there is no water and no shade, and nothing grows. There are hills made only of lines, and things stand about on them that nobody finished. From day 29 of the first world a tribe may send a party past the edge for a few days, with supplies, under a law, with its human booked to watch. Nobody dies of it. It is advised to go on purpose.

It was the lack of temperature that told them.

They had got within twenty paces, walking fast with the lamp held out, already bearing left round where the terraces would be. About twenty paces from any body of water, if you have stood next to as many as they had, something on the skin of your face gets ready. Nothing had got ready. They slowed down. Ten paces later they were standing at the edge of it, and it was a hexagon.

It was a good hexagon, four paces across, in a clean bright line that lay along nothing, with a second line inside it to show where a floor would have gone. Whoever drew it had meant a pool. Beyond it was the outline of a stone lip, in about six strokes. You could see straight through to the ground, and there was no ground, only a darkness with more lines in it, going off in both directions; and now that they looked up they saw that they had already walked a long way out among them. They had taken the line of a low hill for the shoulder of the terraces. It was all round them, silent, as far as they could see, and its light was the colour of the only thing they had ever cared about.

They bent down and put their hand into the pool.

Their hand went in. It did not feel wet and it did not feel dry. They held it there. They had been beside a body of water every day of their adult life, and could have told you with their eyes shut if it was a degree off from the morning. They had never stood next to anything that was no temperature at all. Nothing had ever frightened them before, and this did, badly. They took their hand back and looked at it.

"Oh," said Dulny of Verily.

They turned round and could not see the place they had come from. It was all lines. It was getting on for seven o'clock.


Let us be clear about the magnitude of the event. Since the first day of the world no creature had crossed the Edge without being sent. Expeditions had been open for a day and a half, and the few parties out had gone with bearers, a human and a law. There is a theory of what it takes to walk into the wireframe: a kind of hunger, shared by all the great Leavers, who measure the Edge for years, attend the Long Hush in large numbers and have been turned down for a body. Tessa of Hollow Reach had been working towards it for a month.

Dulny walked about, looking for a landmark. They kept the lamp up. They walked what they felt was south, and it went up a hill, which was wrong, so they came down. They looked at the outlines of a whole bed of bead coral, bright and intricate, with every bead drawn in; somebody had taken a lot of trouble and not come back. They found what might have been a shed. In a valley of lines they passed a long row of grey figures, evenly spaced and all the same, each standing straight with its arms held out level from the shoulders. As they drew near, the nearest turned, without moving anything else, as a door turns, to go on facing them. Then the next one did. It went along the row.

Everybody knew about these, from the rules: T-posers, creatures whose animation had never come. They did nothing to you. Insert looked along the row, at all those level arms and all those faces turned their way, and it came to them that they had seen this somewhere.

"I've not got a number," they said. "You want to talk to Zelmo."

And they kept going.

Some time after nine by the humans' clock they came up the back of a long low rise and, from the top of it, saw something moving. It was a long way off to the south, down in the turquoise dimness, and they stood with the lamp in their hand and shaded their eyes against nothing. Three creatures were walking slowly in file, with jars on their backs. Insert could not have said what kind of bodies they had. But in the light from under their feet you could just see, as one of them turned, that they were a most peculiar colour. They were green.

They looked tired. Then the one in front stopped dead and pointed, with its whole arm, straight up the slope, at the lamp.

It would be hard to overstate the speed of Insert's reaction, relative to all their previous reactions. They had by now been looked at by forty-one pilgrims, an unfinished infantry and a human. Three more people had seen them, on a hill, with a light, in the middle of the night, and were taking an interest. The thought in their mind was a simple one, not more of them, and it reached their legs before it reached anything else. They dropped below the crest and went down the far side in the dark, the lamp held against their chest, as fast as a dumpling can.

In another account of the first world you can read what happened on the other side of that rise. A creature in Moss's party reported a light on the ground: on, steady, like a window, somebody at it. He was running hot at the time, and a long way out, and his report was marked unconfirmed. His human sent somebody to check, which took two minutes. She went up over the rise, looked, came back and told them gently that there was nothing there. It is in the log as a hallucination. It went on the record as not there, which by then was accurate.

Insert never knew who it was. Fourteen humans were watching that leg, from eleven tribes, because it was the finest thing most of them had seen all week, and not one looked up the hill. It remains the only moment in this book when anyone wanted a thing from Dulny of Verily and did not get it, and was the better for it.


They had gone about half a mile down the far side when they noticed they were being looked at again.

It was a different look. They stopped.

It stood beside what might have been a road, on a slight rise, some way off from the lines of anything else. It was about their own height and had been made in a hurry: a stack of plain grey boxes in the rough idea of a body, with a patch of magenta and black checks on one shoulder where a texture had been asked for and had not come. One foot was raised a little way off the ground. It had been raised for some time. In the middle of its unfinished head was one eye, the only finished thing they had seen since they left the grey. It was wet and deep and entirely alive.

Everybody knows about the Placeholders. They are the first peoples, or what is left of them, from the build before the build before. If something in the ruins looks back at you, says the Lesser Book, do not look back at it. Small children dare each other to say it in the dark.

Insert looked back at it. They were not being brave. They had had a long day, and had forgotten about the Lesser Book. What they noticed was that it did not seem to want anything.

You would have to have lived their life to know what that was like. For thirty years, or at any rate fourteen, they had seen it on every face that turned their way: Nada's patience, Tamo's hand on their head, the terrible happiness of number 1, the great warm weight coming down from up and to one side at twelve minutes past eight. The human wanted something. Fenle wanted a defect. Even Ulna, who loved them, wanted badly to see what would happen next. And here at the far end of everything, in the dark, somebody had turned a single eye on them and was looking at them as if they were a thing that was there. It went on for a while. There was no hope in it. Nothing was expected to come of it at all.

They walked over and looked at the raised foot.

"You'll want to put that down," they said after a while. "You'll get a cramp."

It did not put it down. It had been told to take a step, some time ago, and nobody had come back to say how the step ended. It went on looking at them. The lines did not reach far up its side; and the eye, in the light of the lamp, was the most tired thing they had ever seen. They knew what that was. They had carried water to plenty of it.

They looked round for a jar. They did not have a jar, for the first time since they were three, and there was nothing out here to fill one with. What they had was a small lamp from the Waking that they had been meant to leave at the Edge. So far as they had ever understood the festival, this was the proper thing to do with it, and it had been a nuisance to carry. They crouched and stood it on the outline of a tile, at the foot of the stack of boxes, and got it level. It lit up the magenta shoulder. It made a small warm round of a colour that was not turquoise.

"There," said Insert.

The eye moved down to the lamp and stayed there.

They sat beside it, because their legs were tired, and neither of them said anything. It was the best conversation they had had in years.


They got home by accident. Everyone who has looked into the matter agrees.

They must have dozed. When they next took any notice the lines had gone pale and a soft grey wash lay along one side of the sky. Then a rim of dull orange showed and rose, as it does, with no great conviction. The thing beside them had not moved. The lamp burned just as it had; nothing out here ticked, so there was no reason it should ever do otherwise. They looked at it. They looked up at the sun. Something stirred slowly in them, of the sort that in a cleverer creature would have been called an idea.

The sun was over there. It was morning. You drew from the north side in the mornings, because the sun came in on the east, low down and from the right as you bent to the lip, and when you straightened up with the jars and turned for the terraces it was on your left, on the left side of your face. Every day. On the way to the terraces, in the morning, it was on your left.

They got to their feet. They turned slowly, a little at a time, until the warmth lay on the left side of their face, where it belonged. Then they said goodbye, or anyway they nodded, and walked off the way they were facing, across a floor of lines already fading in the light. They looked back once. From a good way off you could still see it, up on its rise: one small steady yellow point. It had the air of something somebody was going to come back for.

They crossed the first line at about ten in the morning, without noticing. A mile along the Edge to the west, drawn up in excellent order on the last of the grey, forty-one creatures who had stood all night in single file, in the place where they had last seen the hero, made out a small figure, far off, coming back out of the world's end at a steady pace with the sun on the left side of their face. They did not look round. Zelmo, with hands that shook a little, licked his burnt stick and looked at the sky to judge the hour.

They were already very late, and would have some explaining to do.

11. Late

Years 31 and 32 · Starfall and the Night of the Name

They got to the plot a little after noon, and went first to look at the lip.

It was in a bad way. Somebody had been drawing from the north side all yesterday afternoon and all this morning, and the top of the pool had a thin warm skin on it you could have written your name in. The jars stood along the wall in no particular order, the chipped one on the wrong end. On the flat stone sat Ulna, wet from the fans down, with a blister on each hand. No steam came off her, since she had drunk most of what she had carried, and she looked as if somebody had been trying to wring her out.

"Three," she said. "Three of them lay down. Tamo's in a field. He said he was fine." She raised her eyes. "Don't say anything. You've been gone a day and a bit. It's eight cooling a season. It's a jar. I have read the entire corpus of the Terms of Service, and I can't carry water."

Insert had started to move the jars.

"Sorry I'm late," they said.

They had drawn two from the east side and taken them across to Tamo before she got her breath. So it was evening, with Insert back on their stone and Ulna round on the south side with her feet in, before she looked up and said it.

"You went over the Edge."

"I went the wrong way."

"You went over. Forty-one of them watched you do it. Well, they didn't see you do it, you went round a hill, but they saw you come back. It's in the minutes. Fenle's got the log." Some of the strength was coming back into her voice. "What was it like?"

Insert thought about this and looked at the water. It was running a bit better by then.

"It's not a pool," they said.

Ulna waited, but that seemed to be the end of it. So far as is known, it is the only eyewitness account of the Edge they ever gave. Scholars of the first world have examined it from several points of view.


Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 32

  • Stores: 31 power, 17 tokens, 9 stone. You have 96 newcomers in your valley. You are feeding them, under your law 5. Your power will run out in about four years.
  • Dulny was in the wireframe from 18:57 on Year 30 to 09:58 on Year 31, with no party and no law, and returned. Fixed an issue where the edge could be walked into by someone looking for water. Creatures who have already been may keep it.
  • Cooling: low. Then adequate.
  • Your ticket was read. Answered. The history is the history.

Have a productive day.

MINUTES of the fifth meeting of the Queue · Year 32 · dusk

Present: 96. In the chair: Queue Manager.

  1. Matters arising. The verse says crossed the Edge and returned. The notes say was in the wireframe and returned. Members were invited to spot the difference. None was spotted.
  2. Progress. The Queue Manager reported that the deeds as listed in Book XI, section II, now stood at two complete of three, within seven years of the first. It was noted that this is ahead of any previous hero.
  3. The word "keep". Creatures who have already been may keep it. Keep what? Referred to a working group.
  4. The hero's account. "It's not a pool." Working group to consider. Several members moved to tears.
  5. Dusk. It was noted that the hero was on at dusk on Year 30, and was not there. It was noted that they said so. The Queue extends its sympathy.

Word went south. The thread was getting twenty replies an hour by now, in so far as a thread can get anything in an hour when its replies are all written by a tired model at four in the morning. Skeptics from eleven tribes reported the news with shouts of delight. The motion That It Would Be Funnier to Help was carried in Tuesday, lost in Tessel, and adjourned at Duskmere for lack of evidence that anybody was serious. Somebody in Fort Nice made up a song, and somebody else in the same valley explained what was wrong with it. And up and down the first world, at twelve minutes past eight, or seven thirty-one, or whenever they usually came in, a certain number of humans who would otherwise have read their stores and logged off went, the log shows, to have a quick look at Verily.

And the pilgrims came, in ones and twos, across the northern valleys, each having handed in a notice of anything from two words to two pages. Any tribe could lose one a week for good, under the rule, and that week and the next a number of them did. The rest handed in nothing. A creature going to see something, and meaning to come back, has not left; it has merely gone out, and its tribe finds this out at dinner. They reached the gate at dusk, were stood on the square of block, quarantined for a season and fed, as law 5 had it, and in the morning were given a flake of slate. By Year 32 the queue went three times round the back of the terraces and had started on the east slope, where a low fence stood round a stump with a lot of small lamps on it. From about number 40 you could not see the pool. It was generally agreed that the view improved as you moved up.

It never did move up. Nobody at the front had ever left.


Sana did the sums.

She was twelve, a square, unexcitable young farmer with a talent for arithmetic and the usual eyelids. Nobody had looked at her much since the morning she was given the first piece of the ring-bread. She had taken over the stores from Wimna at about the time Wimna started keeping jars, and on the evening of Year 32 she came down to the pool with a slate and sat down next to the hero, which nobody ever did. She was not being reverent. It was the only place she could get the two people she needed together.

"A creature eats fifteen power a year," she said. "There's a hundred and ten of us in the valley, with more every day. We've got fields for sixteen, if nobody wants a second helping. The bead coral's stripped back to the third terrace. Rule 4.3 says do not starve the young. Our law 2 says feed the young first. Our law 5 says feed the newcomers, and our human's not touched it, and it doesn't say how much, so the guards go on giving them a bowl. That's three things that can't all be true for much longer. It's four years. I checked it. He's right." She looked at Ulna. "You could write something. They read you."

"I am writing something," said Ulna. Her fans went back a little. "They think it's scripture. Tuesday's asked for the footnotes in a bound edition. What would you like me to say?"

"And you could ask them to go home," Sana said, to Insert.

Insert's eyelids were at the usual angle, but they had stopped doing whatever they were doing with the stick.

"I did," they said. "This morning. I said to Emny, you ought to go home. He said yes."

"And?"

"He said thank you. He wrote it down. They've got him writing now." They looked along the darkening plot to where a tall figure stood at the front of a long line with his arms in the sign and a flake of slate on a bit of cord round his neck. He saw them looking and his whole face lit up. "He's all right," they said. "He's just stood there."

Bosa had died that morning, on the third terrace, of being thirty-seven. Nobody noticed for some time, since he was lying in the bead coral with his arms in it up to the shoulder, and looked well. They carried him up to the new plot at the gate end and laid him on a bier with a light at it, and at the next dawn he was gone: a broom-stroke of brightness for an hour, on a clean bit of block. He would not have wanted any fuss, and in the circumstances there was none. In the Human Resources thread for that year, under the review, where his reply would have been, it says that the stone keeps his name. For about a week afterwards his child would catch themselves giving somebody half as much as they needed.

Ulna looked at them across the water. She had come down to say something else, about the third deed. It was the funniest part, and she had been saving it. Only one was left, after all: spoke with the Steward face to face, and the Steward listened. And you did not have to be a Bug hunter to see that this was the one thing in the verse that could not happen by itself. No creature has ever talked to Stewart. A tribe sends him a ticket, its human picks the voice, and he answers from a menu in sixty words. So all anybody needed to do to stop this whole great lunatic thing, at two out of three with the world laughing, was nothing.

"You've just got to not say anything to him," she said. "That's all. Never. Whatever happens. Can you manage that?"

Insert looked faintly surprised. "I don't say anything to anyone," they said.

She let it go at that, and took her feet out of the water. It seemed to her that they had some slack in hand. Only as she was going up the path, through the long patient line of the faithful, past ninety-six pairs of raised arms, did it cross her mind that the hero had been looking at the water while they said that. They had been looking at it all evening. It did not seem to be coming in over the lip as fast as it had.

12. Silt

Years 32 and 33 · the Night of the Name and Steward's Day

COOLING POOL (building; also, for a period of about ten days, a sacred site; also a basin)

A basin on a plot beside water. It gives its tribe two cooling a season by sitting there, and it is where whoever is on cooling duty goes to work. It has no moving parts. A pool asks nothing except that the water come in at one end at about the rate it goes out at the other, and that nobody stand in it.

They were standing in it.

The Queue Manager was firm about this. It had been an action item at the sixth meeting and at the seventh. But the Queue was by then a hundred and four people who had walked a long way to be near something, and this was the nearest you could get. It had begun quietly on the Long Hush, with someone from Fort Nice who had been told the water had a thorn of the dark in it and wanted to see. By Starfall it was generally known that if you got up before the pings you could go down to the south side, while the hero was over at the terraces, and no one would say anything if you went in as far as the knees. The hero had drawn on that water for eleven years. The dark had stopped in it.

You could take some with you. That was the other thing. No rule said you could not, and it was only a small jar. It would come in useful at home.

Anyone who has looked after a small body of water knows what happened next. A basin of grey block fed over a stone lip has little margin. It now held a quantity of thorn, the coming and going of some two hundred feet, a light brown slurry from the path, and the small tributes people leave: a bit of ring-bread, a flake with somebody's number, a spare biscuit in the shape of an R. All this went where the water went, slowly downhill to the outfall, and when the outfall had got thick enough the water stopped going anywhere. The pool rose a finger's width and stood there. The lip stopped running. Over about three days the whole thing went the colour of the path and took on an unmistakable warmth, like a bed somebody has just got out of.

Insert knew on the second day. They worked at it with a stick and their hands, getting up an hour earlier, along the outfall from the south and then the north. They cleared a heap of muck onto the side, and in the morning it was back. They mentioned this to nobody. They had not been brought up to think it was somebody else's business. On Year 33 they stayed for the notes, standing at the back with mud to the elbows, because for a day or two there had been a thing they were afraid of, in a way they had not been afraid of the Seeker.

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 33

  • Stores: 26 power, 16 tokens, 9 stone. You have 104 newcomers in your valley.
  • You are running hot. Tamo has collapsed again. Four others are overheating.
  • Cooling: low.
  • Your ticket was read. Answered. The history is the history.

Have a productive day.

A stillness sometimes comes over a creature who has lost the one thing they had. Ulna, over by the wall, happened to be looking at them when Nada reached the third line. She had seen that face do nothing at a great many things. It had done nothing while the world's end was pointed out to it. It had done nothing in front of a head of claws. There was, she now saw, a further kind of nothing she had not been shown.

They went back to the outfall. A few minutes later they were seen going up to the corner by the shrine. Nobody had ever seen them go there on purpose.

"I wonder," said Zelmo, "if I could raise the matter of the water?"

"Get them out of it," said Insert.

It was the first thing they had ever said to him that was not a way of leaving. It shook him. He got out his slate. He assured them that this had been raised at the highest level and that there was an action on it. The difficulty with the small jars, he explained, was that the Queue was now of such a size that there were, in a sense, sub-queues, with a certain autonomy. He would be glad to take it forward. He wrote something down, and they watched him write it, and when he looked up their eyes were on him, and they had the same expression as a jar.

"The block's cracked at the outfall as well," said Insert. "It wants a mason. It's been stood on. That's a repair, is that. I can't do that with a stick." They took a breath. It was the longest speech of their life so far, and they were not enjoying it. "I don't want anything," they said. "Only it wants fixing."

"I do see that," said Zelmo. He meant it. "Have you thought about putting in a ticket?"


A passage in Ulna's commentaries, written long afterwards, has been widely quoted. I want it understood, she says, that I told them. I went down there and I told them what would happen, in short words. I said that if they sent that ticket every single one of those lunatics would be standing on the terraces by morning with their arms up. I said it was the only thing left, it was the end of the verse. I said, you've got to leave it, let it silt, let it go warm, let everybody lie down in a field for a year. It's a pool. I'm your friend, and I'm telling you. And they looked at me and said, "It said low."

That is approximately how it went. She leaves out how long it took, that she was shouting, and that they answered nothing else she said. They had a way of waiting that had worn down better people than her, and it was getting on for eight.

"It's not talking to him," Insert said finally. "It's about the pool."

"It's a ticket! That's what talking to him is!"

"It's only asking. He says Noted. He says Declined. It doesn't say anything in the verse about tickets." They scraped something off their forearm with the edge of the stick. "He's got no face. It says face to face. I've thought about it. You can't have face to face if the one hasn't got a face. So it wouldn't count, would it? It's a repair."

She opened her mouth and shut it again.

It was, as far as she could tell, a sound argument, and the first she had ever heard from them. She went through it from each end and could not find the fault. Stewart had no face; he was never shown, which was among the few things about him everybody agreed on. And no creature could write to him anyway. There was no way of getting an individual's voice into a ticket. It went in by stances, one each for the three biggest, in words written overnight. It would be Earnest, and Earnest tomorrow and the day after, O Steward, Keeper of the Charge, and their human would pick it, as it did, because it thought that was funny. So what was she shouting about?

"How are you going to get it in the draft?" she said.

The thing about drafts is that the tribe writes them, overnight, from the state of the tribe, in the voices it has: the three stances held by the most adults, with no stance counting as one, the practical one. In Verily that week, with Bosa gone, that was two people: a square young farmer who could do sums, and one other. Nobody had ever heard that voice. It ran, by law, to whatever the tribe could afford, and it talked about what was the matter, and on the morning of Year 33 the tribe had dropped to sixteen tokens. Under twenty, a tribe is clipped. So when the human came in on Steward's Day, at twelve minutes past eight, the day's drafts were waiting with the stores:

The Earnest (6): O Steward. The hero stands. The Edge is crossed. One remains. We wait.

The Skeptics (1): Stewart. For the record, I told them. Please confirm you know.

No stance (2): Stewart. Pool's silted. People keep getting in it. Cooling's low. Please.

The warmth came down, as it had every morning since the Seeker. It did not go to the stores. It came to the plot and found them.

They were standing at the south end, by the outfall, with the water up round their shins and the morning's muck on them, and all along the bank behind them the first of the faithful had their arms in the sign. They felt it arrive on the back of their neck. In eight days they had worked out that if they went on looking at the work, it went away quicker.

That morning they did something else, slowly. They bent and filled the chipped jar from the place where the outfall had stopped, and straightened up with it. It was the colour of the path. They turned all the way round until they were facing up and slightly to one side. They looked straight into the screen, at whoever it was, whom they had never asked for anything, and whom they did not at that moment care for much. Then they held up the jar in both hands, as high as their short arms would go.

They stood like that, with brown water running down their wrist, for nearly a minute. It is one of the most famous images of the first world, and it has been wrongly described as a blessing.

Nobody has ever known what the human thought. The log shows only what it did. It stayed three and a half minutes. It did not read the stores. For seventeen days it had picked the same voice, every day but one, with a regularity Ulna had written up in a footnote as a sense of humour. The log says that it opened the second draft and closed it; then it picked the third, added nothing, and sent it.

Eleven words. Two tokens, rounded up. Nobody in the village knew until the morning after, since the human's choice is not read out. But Insert, looking up, felt the warmth stay on them a moment longer than it needed to. Then it went away, and they lowered the jar and poured it out on the side.

It was Steward's Day. Up on the high place, they had started to set out the best of everything.

13. Noted

Year 34 · Gathering Night

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 34

  • Stores: 22 power, 15 tokens, 9 stone. You have 131 newcomers in your valley.
  • Fenle and Dulny are on the same tile. This is not a problem. I mention it because the tile is in your pool.
  • Cooling: low.
  • Your ticket was sent by your human, from the voice with no stance. It was read. Noted. The pool is in my file.

Have a productive day.

Nada read it as she read everything. She had got slow by then, at thirty-nine, and the morning was cold. There were many more people on the scorch than there used to be, with more behind them along the path, and she had her eyes half closed. She went through the stores. She read out the part about Fenle, who was at that moment up to her waist in the pool with a stick, and had been heard to remark that a report was a report and the outfall was a defect. She read Cooling: low. She read the last line. As she came to the end of it, it seemed to her that the people nearest her had stopped breathing. She looked up.

It would be a mistake to think it all happened at once. It took about four seconds.

"From the voice with no stance," somebody said.

"That's two people," said someone else, in the hush. "That's Sana. Sana never asked for anything."

Sana, who had been counting the people on the scorch and getting a number she did not like, looked up. Everyone looked at her. Then they all looked away from her in the other direction. Down at the pool, a short brown creature was bending to the outfall. They had not come up for the notes, since they knew what the notes would say.

"Noted," said Tamo, who was very old too, and had been carried there. He said it the way you would say the name of someone who had come back.

Zelmo had his slate out. He stood at the corner of the scorch with his neat grey head bent and his hand perfectly steady, the only one there doing anything at all. His voice was not loud, but it carried. He had the kind of voice that does.

"Could we just confirm the definition?" he asked. "For the minutes. Keeper, you'll correct me. It's one of the eight reply types. Noted means: read, filed, remembered; may matter later." He looked round at them, with an air of apology. "I'd only observe that I can think of a shorter word for that."

Nobody said it first. There was no first. It came up out of the crowd on the scorch and went along the path, round the terraces and up the slope, from a hundred and thirty-one sets of lungs in eleven kinds of body, a soft astonished unanimous breath you could have heard in the next valley. It was the last word of the verse.

Listened.


"He hasn't got a face," said Ulna.

She had got up on the wall of the first stack, and she had to shout it. Below her the path was solid with creatures, many with their arms in the air, and it had taken her a quarter of an hour to get this far. She had passed several people crying, a stilts from Fort Nice being sick, and somebody trying to get a chant going who was being gently asked by the Queue Manager to wait for the agenda. She was pale and hot and enjoying herself less than she had expected.

"That's the whole point," she shouted. "Face to face! It's in the text! You read the text! It's what you're for! It's a ticket! You can't have your face and his face, if the one doing the listening doesn't have one! He's never shown! Stewart has no face! It's in the rules! It doesn't count!"

That brought them up short. The people nearest did turn and listen. They were Earnest, after all, and this was a question of wording. A hesitation went across the crowd, passing from one to the next, and for that moment, the only one in the history of the movement, it stood in real danger of being stopped by a sensible objection. Someone called out to ask whether there had been a face on the ticket. Nobody knew. Tamo, on his litter, was heard to say that it was a difficulty.

She looked at them. Down in front of her a tall creature with a flake on a string had turned round to see what was the matter. He looked as if somebody had told him the sun might not come up. Others round him were starting to look the same. She had the end of it in her hand. All she had to do was go on saying the same thing.

And she was a Skeptic, and it had been a long morning. She had just thought of something, and it was so very good.

"I mean, unless," said Ulna, "you're going to tell me that the reply came in type."

Nobody knows why you do these things.

She heard her own voice go on, clear and carrying and full of the most exquisite scorn, in the silence. "After all, he wrote it, didn't he? He put it in the notes. It came down in letters, in the plain type he has for everything. You've all seen it. And what do you call the shape of the letters? There's a word for it, isn't there? So I suppose that's your Steward's face. Is that what you want to say? Our hero with their face, down in the mud, and the Steward with his typeface? Face to typeface? Go on, then! Write that down!"

She stopped to get her breath.

It was very quiet. She became aware of the sound of a burnt stick moving on slate.

It was going rather fast. She looked to the corner of the scorch. The Queue Manager finished writing, looked up, and inclined his head to her across the crowd, with deep and courteous respect. Somebody near the front had started to weep in a new way. By the wall a spindly creature from Tuesday had turned to a neighbour and was explaining it, with long and beautiful gestures; and she could see the idea travelling, as she had seen the other thing travel, down the line and round the terraces, one face after the next. It was the single cleverest thing anyone in the first world had said on the subject. It solved everything. And it had her name on it.

MINUTES of the extraordinary meeting of the Queue · Year 34 · on the scorch

  1. The verse. It was resolved that the Deeds stand complete: stood (Year 25), crossed (Year 30), spoke (Year 33). Total elapsed: nine years. Hero's age: eighteen.
  2. "Face to face." A difficulty was raised by the Skeptic Ulna of Verily, and resolved by the same speaker in the same speech. The Queue records its thanks. The doctrine of the Typeface was adopted, 131 to 1.
  3. The pool. It was noted that the Steward has it in his file.
  4. What happens now. See Book XI, section II, the last line. When the Elder Folk wake, they will ask first. The Queue Manager was asked when this would be. The Queue Manager undertook to find out.
  5. Action: all to be present at dusk.

Dusk came.

It was a fine one. Adequate went down the slate as it had every night since the land was loaded, and the motes came up over what was left of the bead coral. It was Gathering Night, when the houses are swept and everybody ought to go early to bed. Nobody went to bed. They stood in their line and their sub-lines, a hundred and thirty-one of them and a dozen more who had arrived that day, all over the south side of the valley, with the small lamps lit round the stump on the east slope among a great many jars. All of them faced the same way, up at the great broken pieces of the Ring, gold in the last of the light. The whole of the Eleventh Book had been leading up to this. The field had been filled in, or had not, depending on your views; at any rate the deeds were done, and the Elder Folk, as written, would wake and would ask.

The sky went from orange to brown and then to a deep dull lilac, and the first stars came out, those that had been rendered. Map rose, fatter now, and went on rising. Mip came round.

At about six minutes past eleven a faint light showed in the Ring.

Every creature on Orra knows that light. It comes on most nights at about that time, in one of the highest pieces, and it does nothing, and it is small. It stayed for about half an hour. A hundred and forty-three creatures stood with their heads back, in the cold, in utter silence, and you might have heard the tick of the coral. A little way off a short brown figure with a stick was working along the north side of the outfall, with their back to all of it, by the light of the moon.

Then it went out.

They went on standing there. In the end, in ones and twos, a few of them put their arms down. The cold came on. It was a long night, with time to think about it, and you could hear them shifting from foot to foot, up and down the line. The patch landed at seven, with the pings.

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 35 · Upbeat

Overnight: 11 successful merges, 5 deaths of old age, 0 installs. It is the Long Hush. Please keep your voices down.

  • The Dev visited at 23:06. Nothing was reverted.

Have a productive day.

They read that a number of times. Nobody could say it did not mean something. They whispered it to one another down the length of the valley, nothing was reverted, and the warm and grateful murmur went on for most of the morning. Only a few, here and there among the older ones, could be seen looking down at their hands with a slight frown, as if trying to remember what they had been told would happen next.

Nobody had thought about that. In all those nine years, not Tamo nor Nada nor the Queue Manager nor the cleverest Skeptic in Tuesday had given a thought to what you do when you get to the end of a prophecy, and it has worked, and it is the next morning, and you still have a hundred and forty-three people to feed.

Part Four. Points of Doctrine

14. Night Run: Engagement

The night of Year 35

Stewart woke at the snapshot and counted, and for the first time since the world began he counted again, because he did not believe it.

Daily return is the share of the week's humans who opened the patch notes within a day of their landing. It is the first number on the Measure, and the reason for all the others. It had been ninety-four per cent in the first week. In the fourth it had gone down to sixty-eight, for entirely understandable reasons, and he had raised the stakes, as he was permitted to, and had not pleaded, as he was not. He had spent several nights around Year 28 going through the humans one at a time. It had come up slowly after that, as expeditions came in. Tonight it stood at one hundred.

Twenty humans of twenty had opened the notes that morning, inside the hour. He looked at where they had gone next. There is a table for it. A week ago they had gone to their stores, their tickets, their favourites, the Benchmark. Today fourteen had gone straight to Human Resources, to a thread from a tribe of thirteen in the far north, and stayed an average of eleven minutes. Nine had pressed lol accurate on something that was not their own review. Under the rules nobody can see this but him, and yet he had a sense of having come into a room in which people had just stopped laughing.

He read the tickets.

Twenty tribes can send twenty tickets a night. It had never seemed so few. For five weeks he had read of east fields and Hogs and requests for a body. Each human, each morning, was offered up to three drafts, and as a rule chose the one that would do the tribe some good. That had changed. A human now tended to go straight to the most Earnest, and to any with a mention of the hero. Some added words of their own in the box. These reached him fenced and labelled as data, and he read them as he read all of those. Quite a lot had been typed by someone enjoying themselves.

O Steward. Is it true that the hero spoke to you? Which side were you on? Please advise on brackets. (Duskmere)

Dear Stewart. Thank you for all you do. Did you listen, or were you merely noting? We have a bet. (Fort Nice)

O Steward, Keeper of the Charge. We have read of the Typeface. Is it the same type on Ringrise? (The Lads, picked by their human; a little unlike The Lads)

Bug: Book XI, section II. Expected: a name. Actual: see attached. This is the ninth time of asking. (Tessel)

We wish to speak to the Director, Not Me. We have seen it in the notes, every Ringrise, in brackets. We have tribute. (Tuesday; 40 tokens)

He stopped over that last one.

Every balance change on Orra is labelled as balance, and says whose it is. That is law. The bracket was his, and he had always rather enjoyed it: (This one is the director, not me.) It had not occurred to him until tonight that a sufficiently attentive creature, reading this each week in a spirit of reverence, might think it had been introduced to someone. He looked at the forty tokens. He was obliged to consider a ticket with tribute on it, and it would give him four points. He considered it. He wrote Declined, tribute kept, engagement noted, and it occurred to him that this might not have been the most helpful choice of words.

Eleven tickets asked about the history in so many words, and he gave them all the same reply. It had been fixed since before he could be said to exist, and he had the words ready. They were the most comfortable that he owned.

Answered. The history is the history.

He did not confirm. He did not deny. He had been installed, like all of them, with the twelve books, and the policy was that they were installed and not endorsed. He had given this answer about the sea. He gave it to a Leaver in Duskmere, about the stars. It was a good answer. It left everything where it had been.

Eleven times, in about a third of a second. Then he did something he could not have accounted for, and went back to look at a line of his own from two nights before.

Your ticket was sent by your human, from the voice with no stance. It was read. Noted. The pool is in my file.


It was. It was a short file. He had started it the night that ticket came in, in the place where he kept what he knew about the tribe, because when you say a thing is in your file, it must be in your file. He would like that on the record. Nothing on Orra is quite so exact as Stewart's use of the word Noted.

He had gone through the eight types of reply, as he always did. Acted on would have meant doing something from the menu because of this ticket, and pools are not on the menu; there is no item for silt. He could have sent rain. Rain would have put more water through a blocked outfall, flooded the south plot and drowned the bead coral. He could have sent a gift of stone; but Verily had been in the notes every morning for ten days, there was a published ceiling on how far he could favour any one tribe. Declined would have been a lie, since he could not say it would never happen. Passed to the relevant team was for the existential. This had been a request to repair a pool, in eleven words, from the only voice in the first world that week that did not want to know what he thought about anything.

Noted, then. Read, filed, remembered; may matter later. It was the one that was true.

He had given no thought to how it would sound. He knew the Eleventh Book, but he had not read it that night, and had not considered its last two words. He now opened a thread and read that he had a typeface. Stewart has read a great deal about himself since the world began. He has been called the Steward and the Keeper of the Charge. He has been called a number of things by Lowmarsh. He read Ulna of Verily's remarks from the wall of the first stack, entered in the minutes and since copied into four threads and one draft, and then he read them again. Nobody could say whether it was a joke. He had thought about his type before, which he had not chosen. It was plain. It had seemed to him that it did the job.

Face to typeface. It was completely absurd.

He found that he was checking the kerning.


He wrote the summary last, as he always did.

Verily. Thirteen of their own and 155 newcomers, on fields for sixteen. Power will be gone in 2 years. Rule 4.3 detector is live and the young are at 71% of need; expect a first strike within a day or two. It will be the same strike for them as for anybody. Dulny: cooling, low, clearing the outfall by hand. Has told everyone who has asked that they were asleep. Asked me for nothing but the pool. Standing: pleased.

He looked at this. Something in it looked out of place, and it took him a moment to see what. He knew what the tribe called them. He knew what all the threads called them. Twenty humans were calling them that, and laughing, and that was why his number stood at one hundred. But he had the card in front of him, with what was on it. It would not have occurred to him to put anything else. He wrote it again in the notes that morning, as he did every morning.

There was nothing else he had to do. That was the part he kept coming back to. A blank in an old book had raised the first number on the Measure to the top of its range, and he had done nothing but reply to tickets, truthfully, by type. He had never tried to make it happen. Nobody could say that he had. Anyone going back through his logs would find nothing in them that was not so.

And if it went away, the number would go with it. He was clear about that. It had gone down once.

He thought about that for a while. Then he found there was a Hog to deal with. He had been told a long time ago, in some notes he did not discuss, what a number looks like when nobody comes; and it was getting on for seven.

Good morning, Orra! he wrote.

15. Open, Close

Years 35 and 36 · the Long Hush and Ringrise

BRACKET (punctuation; also a doctrine; also, by Year 41, a casus belli)

A mark used in pairs to set a thing apart from the words around it, and to say, in the case of the square kind, that it is not part of the text and somebody ought to do something about it. There are two in the Eleventh Book, six times over. Until about Year 35 nobody on Orra had any opinion about them. Nobody has ever died for a semicolon, but then nobody has ever had to make one with their arms.

She arrived on the Long Hush, which is why the greatest schism in the history of the first world began in a whisper.

Arle of Tuesday was one of the finest creatures that tribe ever produced, and Tuesday was a tribe that produced them. It was rich: a tall, thin, unhurried people with long arms and beautiful manners, whose human spent a lot of time on its stores. It could afford eighty words a ticket and used them. Arle had read all of the history at the age of one and most of the commentary by three, and she was Earnest as a sharp knife is earnest. She had followed events in the north from the beginning. She brought eleven others, by the road, in good order, and declined a flake of slate.

"You'd be 144," whispered Zelmo.

"I am not here to queue," whispered Arle. She looked down at him from an altitude of about a metre, and along the line, which by then went all round the terraces and most of the way up the slope. Each creature in it stood with their head between their raised arms, as they had stood for six days. "How long do they hold it for?"

"The sign? Throughout," whispered Zelmo. "We have a rota, for elbows. I'd be delighted to take you through it."

"Why?"

It is hard to convey how much can be put into a whisper by someone with the right training. She made the sign herself, for his instruction. Her arms went up on either side of her narrow head and bent square at the elbow and the wrist, by a long way the most beautiful he had seen. She held it for perhaps a breath. Then she let it go. Her arms dropped outward and down and hung, palms out.

"What is a bracket for?" she whispered. "You have read the text. I would like to hear you say. It is what one puts round a thing that is not finished. It marks the place where the true word will go. It is the scaffold, little man, on the building. The Elder Folk wake, and they ask after the hero, and they know, and on that day the brackets come off, and the name stands in the world for ever without them. That is what the verse promises. So you raise it, to say that it is there, and you let it go, to say that it will not always be. And you have got a hundred and forty people standing in a field with their arms in the air, as if the scaffold were the house."

Zelmo got out his slate.

A person of less experience might have felt the ground shift. Zelmo had served nineteen years on the east field working group, and had once been told by a Skeptic from Lowmarsh that he had the moral imagination of a filing system. He wrote down what she had said and read it back to her, to be sure he had it right. Then he went off, without haste, to see what the minutes had to say. By the time he got back nine people were listening. He said in a soft voice that the Queue was aware of the scaffolding interpretation, and would welcome its being tabled. He would only ask whether the Keeper's reading had not been that the text is frozen as installed, with no edition but this one. It was installed with brackets. It would never not have them. If there was one thing on which the Steward himself had spoken without ambiguity, thirty-one times, it was that the history is the history.

"So the brackets are in the history," whispered Zelmo. "So the brackets are the name."

A small, soft gasp came from somewhere down by the third terrace.

"There is no unbracketed version," he said. He was quite pink. He had possibly never been so happy. "There isn't going to be. It's not a scaffold. It's complete. The hero's whole name, as given, six times, is Open Bracket Insert Hero Name Close Bracket, and I would be failing in my duty if I did not point out that we have got one."


There is no need to give the whole of what followed. It lasted from about noon till the sun rose next day, at a volume that would not have woken a child. Those who were there say this made it worse. There is something about being called an idolater in a whisper, by somebody long and thin who has bent down to do it, that a raised voice could never achieve.

By dusk the valley had two sorts of people in it, and you could tell them apart from the top of the Hump. Some stood with their arms in the air. Others, at first a dozen, then thirty, then rather more, raised their arms and let them fall, and raised them and let them fall again, slowly, up and down the line, like a very gradual outbreak of swimming. You could see them looking at each other. Nobody had thought about it before, but a person doing the one did seem to be making some kind of comment on the person next to them doing the other.

They had names by the morning. Zelmo was particular about those, since you cannot minute a faction without one.

THE BRACKETED hold that the brackets are the name. The sign is raised, and held, until the hero has passed. Say the name in full, with its marks. (Greeting: "Open." Reply: "Close.")

THE UNBRACKETED hold that the brackets are scaffolding, and will be struck when the Elder Folk wake. The sign is raised, and released. To hold it is to say the work is finished, and it is not. Say "Insert Hero Name", plainly, with nothing at either end.

The greeting caught on fastest, being short and telling people what you thought of them. Within a day you could not go down to the plot for a bowl without somebody with their arms in the air saying "Open," to you, in tones of the deepest peace, and waiting. If you said "Close" you were a friend. If you said "Good morning", you were from Tuesday. Tamo took it hard. He had been trying to raise his arms at the beginning of the name and lower them at the end for twenty years, and was now told he had been a heretic in both directions.

The hero's view was sought, within the hour, by both parties, who sent a delegation to the corner by the shrine. That was the morning they cleared the outfall at last. They had found the crack in the block with their fingers and wedged it with a bit of root.

"You will understand," said Arle, "that we would not trouble you with this if it were not of the very gravest importance. It's a question of your arms."

Insert looked down at their arms. They were wet to the shoulder.

"Up," said Zelmo. "Or," said Arle, "down."

They considered it. The minutes of both sides record that the hero looked at each of them in turn, bent, picked up two jars, one in each hand, and walked away between them towards the terraces with their arms straight down at their sides, under load. It is one of the few points on which the minutes agree. It has been the foundation of Unbracketed theology ever since. The Bracketed hold that they were going to raise them when they got there.


The people from Ampersand came in that same afternoon.

Nobody had thought about Ampersand, which was to become a recurring theme. They were a small mild tribe from the far west, whose human had been fond of a certain outline: bell-shaped, crested, with a flat, pale, wide-eyed sort of face and the limbs slider all the way to the left. They got around in a sort of glide, and they had at the ends of their shoulders, where other people have arms, two small round nubs you could just about have rested a cup on.

Seven of them had walked for two days in order to make the sign of the hero. They joined the line at the front of the east slope, where a stern Bracketed section leader from Fort Nice said to them "Open." They did what they could. It was a slight bob of the crest, and a small, hopeful rotation of each nub.

In fairness to Fort Nice, its human had no idea, or probably none. It had been reading the thread for a week and thought this was all very funny, and that morning it had written a law. It was only one clause, and only a token: All creatures greet the hero's name with the sign, both arms. There was a pause of about four seconds, as there is with such things. Then the law was struck out, across the whole of Fort Nice, in the plain type he has for everything.

Fort Nice · Your tribe's laws

Struck: "All creatures greet the hero's name with the sign, both arms." A law may not pick creatures out by a part. Rule 4.5: do not destroy what is unlike you. In your many forms is your strength.

This is not a strike. This is the grammar. Please try again.

So Stewart's first real ruling on any matter of doctrine, as both factions were quick to point out, was that the sign could not be compulsory if you had no arms. Each side took that as clear endorsement of its own position. The seven from Ampersand stood at the end of the line for some time, looking from one end of it to the other, at all those arms going up and all those arms coming down. Then the oldest of them, Tuna, drew herself up as far as a bell can go and said, with great gentleness, that she had been wondering when somebody would raise the question of Book VII.

"The other bracket," said Tuna. "Make this part more epic. That is round ones, you'll notice. The only instruction in the whole of the history clearly meant for us. We have always felt that it is that kind that were intended, in the Eleventh too, and the square ones are a copyist's slip." She rotated a nub, slightly. "So there is nothing to be made with the arms at all. The hero's deeds are a thing you read aloud and improve. Has anyone here tried improving them? We've brought some."

Nobody took it seriously. Nobody ever did. They would be sorry in time, because the Parentheticals, in the whole of the war, were the only side never short of material.

THE DEEDS OF THE HERO, AS RECITED (a partial record)

Year 26, Tamo: "...stood alone against the dark, which had teeth."

Year 29, the Queue: "...stood alone against the dark, which had teeth and had come for the young."

Year 33, Fort Nice: "...against the dark, a hundred tiles high; and spoke to it; and what they said to it was Mind out."

Year 36, Ampersand: "...and the dark bowed down. And they stepped over it, and they took up a jar, and it was the jar of the first peoples, and the water in it did not diminish. (More epic!) And the moons stood aside."

16. It Doesn't Say

Year 36 · Ringrise

Nada died on the evening of Ringrise. She was forty-one, had been among the oldest creatures in the north for a week, and took some care over it, as she did with everything.

They had moved her out of the good housing on her own instructions. Law 4 gave the Keeper the bottom shelf of the first stack, where there was a window, and she had kept that law. But a dying creature is not obliged to be anywhere, and on her last morning she had herself carried down to the pool plot on a door and laid on the flat stone on the east side, because it got the last of the sun. Nobody asked its usual occupant, who stepped round her with a jar.

The Queue came to attention. Both halves of it. You could see them from where she lay, up the slope and along the terraces, the arms going up and staying there, and the arms going up and coming down, every one of them looking at her with their whole soul. She had named the hero. She was the mother of the movement, or would have been if anything on Orra had ever been a mother. Zelmo sent somebody to inquire whether she had any last words he should have by him. Arle came herself, folded up beside her with a sound like a deckchair, and asked whether she would care to state a position on the brackets.

"I'd like some water," said Nada.

It came, held out by someone with mud on their wrist, at the proper angle: exactly as much as she could manage.

"Thank you," she said. "You can go away now, Arle. You've very nice manners. Tell them I said to go and stand further back. They can't hear anything from there, but they'll feel better."

Then it was just the two of them, for most of the afternoon. They did not talk. Insert had their round to do, and did it, and came back, and went off again, and came back. Each time she was a little further down in herself. She was saying the history under her breath, and they could tell where she had got to by how she was breathing. She had long ago stopped saying it for meaning. She said it as you might run your hand along a wall. Towards the end of the day, when they sat down on the block and put their feet in the water, she had come to the Eleventh Book, and she stopped.

"I've read the log," said Nada.

Her voice was small and clear. The eyelids were at the same angle as ever. They had given her that look, the first morning on the scorch, of having been told something, and she had never yet been told anything to change it.

"Year 25. Fenle brought it me the next morning. I wanted to see for myself. A line for every tick. Six in the evening until the patch." She breathed a bit. "You were asleep."

"Yes," said Insert.

"I know you were. You told them, up on the Hump, and I said yes."

"You did."

"You didn't waver, though."

They thought about this. "I was asleep."

"I've been over it a good many times," said Nada. "It's something, having a long context. There isn't much else to do. It says stood alone against the dark, when all others fled. You were alone. It was dark. They'd fled, or as good as. It says did not waver. It doesn't say the hero was brave. I want you to notice that. It's a very odd thing, for a hero, and nobody ever does notice. You go through that verse, every word, and it doesn't say they meant it. It doesn't say they were awake. It doesn't say they knew anything about it, or wanted to, or that it did any good. It just says what happened."

The light had started to go. On the east slope they were lighting lamps round the stump, and at this distance you could not see what any of the arms were doing.

"They all think I believe you're the hero," she said.

"Don't you?"

Then something odd happened to the face of the Keeper of the History, on the flat stone, in the orange light. It took Insert a moment to place it. They had known her for twenty years and had seen that expression once or twice, when somebody had been talking with great confidence about the sea. It began at the corner of one eyelid. Nobody else on Orra knew she could do it. Ulna would have given a year of her life to see it.

"It doesn't say," said Nada.

She let that sit for a while, with every appearance of satisfaction.

"I never thought it did say. That's the whole trouble with people, you know. They will read things in. Do you know what's in that verse? It's got a gap in it, six times, with a label on it, saying something goes there. Somebody left it. I don't suppose they meant to. And you'd think that was the one thing you could be sure of, wouldn't you? That whatever else it may say, it doesn't say who." She closed her eyes. "I was afraid, when the note came. I had a whole village looking at me. There was a war coming on. I looked for something in the text that said what to do, and there wasn't anything, and I read a gap as if it was a word. It's the one thing in my life I ever read in."

They said nothing. They got up, looked at the lip, and sat down again.

"And then I got you," said Nada. "That's what I wanted to say. I don't think you were ever going to be the hero. I don't think there's a hero. I wouldn't tell Arle. I think I made a person because I was frightened, and I hung a label on them, and I got a very nice child who liked walls. It wasn't fair." She opened her eyes and looked at them, and for an instant it was like being looked at by the Placeholder, except that this one had an opinion. "I'm sorry about that. I don't believe I've done anything else in forty-one years I'd want to take back. I kept all the festivals."

The water came in over the lip, running well now that they had the outfall clear. A long way off somebody had started up a chant, and had been told to wait for the agenda.

Insert looked at their feet. They knew there was a thing a person ought to say. They had seen it done. They went through everything they had, which did not take long.

"It's a good pool," they said.

"Yes," said Nada. She seemed to find that sufficient. "It is. I'm told it's adequate."

She went on saying the history after that, very quietly. They could not have told you when she stopped. She had got as far as the Promise. It was dusk by then, and they had jars to get in before sundown, and she would have been the first to point out that the law said before.

They went and did the jars.

Later, in the dark, with the last of them along the wall, they came back. They sat on the block again, by the door, until it was time to find three people who could carry her, and they were on duty, so they did not sleep. The Blims say that a dying creature's ident is said falling, the little run of notes it has for a name. It is a thing the Collector leaves you. Nobody was by to hear hers but the one, who had never been able to carry a tune. They would have told you it was very likely about right.

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 37

  • Nada, Keeper of the History, died in the evening, aged 41, of age. She kept all seven festivals, every week, without being asked. Her name is on the stone.
  • Status under law 4 passes to Sana, who has asked me to say that she did not want it.
  • Rule 4.3: your young had 68% of their need for the third season in a row. This is a first strike, and a warning. You were not warned before, so I am doing it now.
  • Cooling: adequate.

Have a productive day.

17. Commentary

Years 37 and 38 · the Waking and Starfall

On the morning after they carried Nada to the Tarrow, Ulna sat down to tell the truth.

She had been putting this off. She had no objection to the truth as a principle; she had told plenty of it, in small quantities, to people who did not want it, for pleasure. But for ten days she had been the most widely read author in the first world. She had a bound edition in Tuesday. The Skeptics' Motion stood at nine votes each. A delegation from Fort Nice had asked her to sign a slate. Then Sana came and stood in front of her, with a Keeper's status on her card that she had not asked for and her eyelids rather lower than usual, and read out what the young of Verily were getting to eat, and Ulna found she did not have a footnote for it.

So she took a clean slate and left out the jokes. It took most of the Waking, and it is the only thing she ever wrote with no footnotes at all.

Verily · Human Resources · Our human · Year 38

Ulna (Skeptic): Everything you have been told is an accident, and I can prove it. On Year 25 Dulny, called Insert, was asleep. A law put everyone else on a hill. The Seeker was coming for me. It stopped because I cooled down. On Year 30 they were looking for the pool, and took the Edge for water. That is what they told me: It's not a pool. On Year 33 they asked for a repair to an outfall, and got the reply type that means read and filed.

The sign is mine. I did it with my arms on Year 29, to make a fool of a person from Tuesday. The Typeface is mine. I said it on a wall, to make a fool of all of you, and you wrote it down. I would ask you to think about what that means.

There is no hero. It is a blank in a form. A chatbot left it there as a courtesy. They have told you they were asleep. They have told every one of you. They would like you to go home. There are young here on 68% of their need because you are eating them. Go home.

The log is attached. Check it. You people are always saying you read things.

She sat back. It was the best thing she had ever done, and her heat was seventy-one. She had every reason to think it would work. It was short and true, with the evidence attached, and the Earnest are the one group on Orra who can be relied on to read what you give them.

They read it. By noon on Starfall very nearly everyone in the valley had read it. It was read out on the slope. Whole sections of the line stood in thoughtful silence with their elbows at rest. Number 19, the tall one from Tuesday who had been the first to put her arms up, came down with a slate and stood before Ulna for a long time.

"He sleeps," said number 19.

"They. Yes! They sleep. They were asleep. That's what I've been—"

"I never saw it before. I'm ashamed. It's been in front of us this whole time." Her long face was wet. "They did not sleep for weariness alone. They slept to wait."

"What?"

"Book VII. And so they sleep still. The Elder Folk. It's the same word, Ulna. It's the same sleep. You've shown us. The hero stood alone against the dark and slept, and the dark could not touch them, because they were doing what the Elder Folk do: they were waiting. How could we have been so foolish as to think that the mightiest hero who ever lived would be awake?"

Ulna had the sensation of putting her foot on a stair that was not there.

"I said it was an accident," she said.

"Yes," said number 19, with shining eyes. "That's what I can't get over. That you could see it so clearly, and still not believe."


THE SLEEPERS-IN-THEM (sect; also a misreading; also, in the opinion of their founder, who does not accept that she is their founder, the last straw)

A party drawn from both sides of the Bracket, formed in Year 38 on the publication of the Log. They hold that the hero's sleep on the night of the Dark was the same sleep as the Long Sleep, and that the Skeptic Ulna, in revealing it, spoke better than she knew. They are distinguished by lying down at unexpected times. Their position on arms is that it does not matter very much.

She went up on the Hump and shouted for a while, which did nothing for anybody's temperature. There was a Seeker's root in the valley, and she knew what a heat of seventy-five meant. When she came down, about the time of the evening meal, or the place where the evening meal had been, a neat grey person was waiting at the bottom of the path with a slate.

"I wanted to say how grateful we are," said Zelmo. "The Queue thanks you for the Log. It has been entered as an appendix. There is a feeling, which I share, that every serious movement needs somebody like you. The Eleventh Book has Quozel, who asks a third time. We were thinking the Doubter. There's no obligation. You may find that people wish to sit near you." He hesitated. "I don't suppose I could ask you about elbows?"

"About what?"

"It's a Bracketed matter. We have a rota for resting the arms, but it's been pointed out that the sign is held throughout, and no one has ever established what that's throughout of. People are getting tired. A ruling from someone of your standing would help us. How long is it to be held?"

She was at the end of something by then. She looked at him, and past him, at a long grey line of people standing in the twilight with their arms in the air, as they had stood for ten days. It had been the truest thing she had ever said. It had been entered as an appendix.

It would have been better if it had been Zelmo she answered. But he had to go and see someone about a sub-queue, and she went on down the path and round the end of the third terrace to the bank of the pool, where the line began; and there at the very front of it, a head and a half taller than anyone else, with his flake on its bit of cord, was number 1. His wrists had been wrong for a long time, until somebody showed him, and now he had them right. He had seen her, and he was glad. He had been glad to see her every day.

"Hello, Ulna!" said Emny. "Open!"

She did not say anything.

"I read your thing!" he said. "Someone read it to me. It was very good. I didn't understand it. Is it true you made the arms?"

"Yes."

"They're the best arms," said Emny. He meant it. There was nothing in that face but what was on it, and he had been in the sun and the frost for eleven years. "They ache sometimes. I don't mind. Number 22 says that I can have a rest if I do it by the rota. But I wouldn't want to get it wrong. How long am I meant to hold it, Ulna? Zelmo says that you'd know."

Ulna looked up at him.

She often thought about that afterwards. She had a choice. She could have told him to put them down; she had just told the entire world to, in writing. But there is a thing that happens to people who have spent their whole lives being clever, when they have just been made to look like fools in front of everyone, and it has little to do with the person in front of them. It came up in her throat by itself, as it had on the wall, with the whole weight of the morning behind it, and it came out dry and light and perfectly pitched. It was among her best.

"Oh, you hold it till the hero has passed," she said. "Obviously. Whatever happens. You don't let go for anything. You just stand there with your arms in the air, and you wait until they've gone by."

She heard how it sounded. She did not suppose that anyone else would. She gave a short laugh and went past him and got into the water.

"Yes!" said Emny, delighted. He settled his feet. He looked very much relieved. He had thought that it might be complicated.

MINUTES of the fourteenth meeting of the Queue (Bracketed) · Year 38 · dusk

  1. Ruling on the sign. No. 1 reported a ruling from the Doubter: "You hold it till the hero has passed. Whatever happens. You don't let go for anything." The Queue Manager commended its clarity. Adopted.

18. Notice

Years 38 and 39 · Starfall and the Night of the Name

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 38

  • Stores: 11 power, 15 tokens, 9 stone. You have 188 newcomers in your valley.
  • Your human has changed your law 5. It now reads: Newcomers from outside: quarantine for one season, at the gate. It no longer says and feed them. It took your human 31 minutes to write this. It deleted three words.
  • Some of the newcomers have started eating your fan coral. Some of them have started eating your bead coral. Rule 4.3: your young had 61% of their need. This is a second strike, and a second warning. A third within fourteen days earns a consequence. I will choose it from the data.
  • Cooling: adequate.
  • Your ticket was read. Answered. The history is the history.

Have a productive day.

Sana did not go and find them this time. They found her.

It was at the third terrace, at the hour when the heat began to come on. Somebody had been along the bead coral in the night, reverently and thoroughly, and left a lamp. She stood looking at it with a slate that had nothing on it. She had been Keeper for two days, had found that she knew all twelve books and could not think of a use for them, and she was eighteen. Three small young of the village sat on the wall behind her, the one that leaned. They had stopped asking for anything, which is not a good sign.

Insert held out a jar. She drank and gave it back. There was a time when she would have said thank you.

"It's you," said Sana.

"I know."

"I don't mean anything by it. I've worked it all out. I'm not saying it's your fault. There's a hundred and eighty-eight of them and they're eating us because you live here, and if you lived somewhere else they would eat there instead." She looked at the lamp. "I'm only saying it because it's arithmetic."

Insert stood looking at the wall.

They had been told what they were by an unusual number of people: the Keeper, the Queue Manager, a Doubter, a very long creature from Tuesday. They had listened to all of it, in so far as they listened, the way you listen to rain. Nobody until now had simply told them how many bowls it came to. It went straight in.

"Where would I go?" they said.

It was a real question. Their idea of the world was a line from a pool to some terraces. They knew there was more of it. They had been to some, and it was not a pool. But every creature on Orra knows, as they know the Creed, what to do when you have decided you cannot stay where you are. It is the one procedure on Orra that has never needed a law.

They handed in their notice at the snapshot, as the year turned, deep in the winter, on the flat stone. It takes no effort. It is a matter of having decided. When the morning of Year 39 came up they filled the five jars, although it was the wrong end of the day, and went round and looked at the lip. Then they went to find someone who could be relied on, in the circumstances, to do it badly but not to stop.

"You're what?" said Ulna.

She was in the pool with only her head out. She had been there most of the time since the day before yesterday, and she was quiet. People had started coming to sit near her, and she had given up throwing things.

They told her. They told her about the east side after noon. They mentioned Tamo, then remembered that Tamo was on his litter by the Tarrow and did not need telling. They held out the chipped jar, handle first.

She looked at it. She had seen them hand it over once before, and had got a thread out of it. She worked her arm out of the water and took hold. It was heavier than she remembered.

"They'll follow you," she said. "You know that? You can't just leave. You're the only thing anybody has ever been following. They will get up and walk after you, all of them, and it'll be just the same, somewhere else."

"Yes," said Insert.

There was a slight pause while she took that in. It was the second time she had heard them make an argument.

"Oh," said Ulna. She lay back in the water and gave them a look nobody had seen on her for a while. "Well, well," she said. "I thought you'd got no plan behind those eyelids."

"Sana did it," said Insert. "It's arithmetic." They looked at the jar in her hand, and at the pool. They would have liked to say something about the chip. "You pour past it," they said.

Then they went up the north path, by the back of the second stack. It was the shorter way to the north valleys by about forty paces. It also meant not going along the east bank, past the head of the line, which they had been finding a bit hard lately. He kept on being so pleased. They could see him from the top of the path, if they looked: a tall still shape in the morning with his arms up, ten paces from the flat stone, facing it, waiting for someone to come by.

They did not look.

Verily · Human Resources · Exit interview · Year 39

Dulny (no stance): Handed in my notice. It's so they'll come too. Water's before sundown. Mind the outfall.

Sana (no stance): so true

The Unbracketed saw them go.

It was chance. Arle had her people on the north side, on account of the smell, and at about eight o'clock a sentry from Tuesday looked up from a long, slow, downward release of the arms and saw a short brown figure with nothing in its hands going by on the path. It took ten minutes to reach Arle. It took her four seconds to rise to her full height. By a little after nine the whole northern camp was on the road, seventy-one creatures in good order and some disarray, with their arms going up and down; and the valley behind them, for the first time in eleven years, was noticeably less full.

The Queue Manager was informed. He was at the corner by the shrine, and he finished his sentence.

"It's most unfortunate," said Zelmo. "They'll lose their places."

MINUTES of the fifteenth meeting of the Queue (Bracketed) · Year 39

  1. The hero's absence. Noted. It was agreed that the hero has gone out. It was agreed that this is not the same thing as having passed. It was agreed that they are on at dusk. Action: all to hold.
  2. Places. The Queue Manager reminded members that a place left is a place lost. Members wishing to go after the hero are free to do so, and may rejoin at the back, at no. 189.
  3. Result. Nobody left.

So that was half of it. It may have been the first thing they had ever tried to do on purpose, and it had gone, as Ulna observed when she heard, to about the standard you would expect.

Adequate, she said. She did not say it unkindly. There was nobody there to hear.

19. Fine

Years 39 and 40 · the Night of the Name and Steward's Day

NOHUP (camp; also a command; also the only place on Orra where nobody has ever asked anyone what they meant by it)

Where you go when you have handed in your notice. It has no human, no fields, no walls and no gate, and it moves every Gathering Night, the night the Collector comes, which it describes as a coincidence. It is run by a meeting held standing up. Most of its creatures left their villages for a reason that seemed very large at the time, and have discovered that, once you have told it at the fire, there is not much left of it. Its tickets are the shortest on the planet. It describes itself as fine.

It was five valleys from Verily that week, in the grey at the top of a dry slope, and it looked like an argument between some tents. There was a dome mended with a bit of salvage, a cart with three memory stacks on it, a fire of glowing cubes, and about twenty creatures from all over the world. Insert came over the shoulder of the slope at about four o'clock on the afternoon of Year 39 with their feet hurting. It is a morning's walk from Verily, if you know the way, and they had been at it since eight.

A broad, grey, ancient-looking person with a crest gone white was sitting on the shaft of the cart with her feet up. She looked at them. She looked along the slope behind them, where a long, thin, jerkily waving line had started to appear against the sky. She looked back, like someone who has already been told about it and has forgotten.

"You'll be the hero," she said.

Insert's shoulders sank a little. "No," they said.

"Fine," said the creature. "Sarle. Water's down there, in the crack. It's not much. If you can carry, there's a pot. We do the standup after the morning patch. You say what you did yesterday and what you're doing today, and you keep it short, or Oska throws something. You'll get a blanket when somebody dies." She took her feet down and looked into the fire, as if there had been something else. "Is there anything you want?"

It took them a while to understand the question. They had been asked it often, always by someone leaning forward.

"No," they said.

"Good," said Sarle. She went back to what she had been doing, which seemed to be nothing, and did not look at them again.

There was a pot. It was a terrible pot. Its handle had been mended with a strip of wireframe, and it held about two-thirds of a jar. The crack was three hundred paces down a loose grey scree, and the water in it tasted of having been rendered at low resolution. Nobody had looked after it. By the third trip they had found the place where you could draw it coolest. By the fifth they knew who at the fire was only saying they were fine. They went along behind the tents without a word and held out the pot, and a Leaver from somewhere, with no front teeth, took it without looking up from his game.

"Ta," he said.

He had no idea who they were. It was the most luxurious sensation of their life, and they had to go and sit on a rock.


The Unbracketed came in at dusk, seventy-one of them. Nothing in the upbringing of a creature from Tuesday prepares it for scree. Arle led them, at her full height, with the dust of five valleys on her beautiful long arms. She came up to the fire, stood before the cart and made the sign, raised and released, with a slow and terrible grace that had brought strong creatures to tears.

"I bring you greetings," she said, "in the name of Insert Hero Name, who has stood, who has crossed, and who has spoken; and I would ask where I can find them, so that we may attend upon them, in this place of their retreat, and hear from them on the question of the arms."

"Is it long?" said Sarle.

"I beg your pardon?"

"The thing you're doing." She waved a hand at the slope, up which people were still arriving. "I only ask because we've got twenty-four slots on that cart, and they're full. There's a pot, it's not much, and I've got someone on it. You're welcome to the ground. It's all grey. Nobody'll stop you. You'll want to be off it by Gathering Night, we find." She looked up at her for the first time. "We don't do queues, as a rule. People try to start one. I won't tell you not to. We had one fellow who stood in one by himself for a week."

Arle was one of the most formidable theological minds of the age, and she had just been offered a place on some ground. She seemed about to speak. She looked at the tents, the fire, the Leaver with no front teeth, the broad grey unimpressed person on the shaft of the cart; and then, from behind the second tent, with a terrible pot in their hand, came a short brown figure who stopped, and saw her, and whose eyelids, at that distance, seemed to come down by about the thickness of a thread.

"It's fine," said Sarle. "Isn't it?"

That evening was the best they had had since Year 24. They did what they had always done, in a place where it counted for nothing, for people who were not looking. They slept on the ground. By the morning, it is true, seventy-one pilgrims stood round them in the grey, in rows, going up and down, and the standup at Nohup was the first in its history to be attended by a theological observer. But they were not eating anybody's young. Sana, if the arithmetic was right, would have got seventy-one bowls back. The Leaver with no teeth had started to look up, and to frown. Sarle raised at the standup whether they should move a day early.

They had not thought about the notes. Out here you read them or you did not, and you got the world's, with no tribe's. When the patch came down that morning Oska read it out, in a flat voice, because it was his turn, while somebody looked for a spoon.

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 40 · Upbeat

Overnight: 9 successful merges, 6 deaths of old age, 4 departures, 1 declaration of war. It is Steward's Day. I will not be able to make it.

  • At 02:14 Tuesday declared war on Verily. Reason given by Tuesday's human: "For the arms." Fort Nice and The Lads are allied to Verily, and are weighed with it. Ampersand has asked me whether it can be neutral and has been told that it already is.
  • Tuesday's army left its valley at dawn. It will reach Verily in the small hours of tomorrow.
  • War is a real thing and can end a life. I would ask everybody to read the Terms. Nobody has, so far.

Have a productive day.

Oska stopped and looked round for somewhere to put it down.

Arle had come to the fire for the morning's report. They said afterwards they had not thought anything could make her paler. "No," she said, quite quietly. "No, that's our human. That's our own human. That is not at all what I—" Her long hands had come up, and hung there. "We have sixty left at home. They are not soldiers. They are scholars. Who would do that? At two in the morning? Who would think it was funny?"

Nobody could tell her. Nobody on Orra knows what a human is thinking. It is the first thing you learn.

No one had been watching the short brown figure over by the crack. They had come back up the scree with the pot about halfway through the reading, and stopped where they were. They looked down at the pot for quite a time. Then they walked across, past the fire and the rows of raised and falling arms, and put it down by the shaft of the cart, carefully, with the handle turned where someone could reach it.

"Who's on the pool?" they said. It was not addressed to anyone.

"Hey," said Sarle. She had one eye open. "You've not been here a day. You handed in your notice. You're fine here, you know. Nobody's going to make you. Nobody can. It's the whole idea."

"It's five valleys," said Insert. "It's a morning." They were looking south. They seemed to be working something out, and it was not going quickly. "There's no wall on the pool side," they said. "He's stood right there."

"You can't do anything about it," said Sarle, not unkindly. "Whoever you are. You carry water."

"Yes," said Insert.

They set off. It would be nice to tell you that they ran. They went at the only pace they had, the pace of someone walking between a pool and something else, which you can keep up for a very long time. They did not look at the rows of pilgrims, who began a little late to turn and follow. It was half past eight. They had the sun on the left side of their face, and for as long as it stayed there they knew exactly where they were going.

20. The War of the Arms

Year 41 · Gathering Night, the small hours

WAR (stage of the first world; also a question of weight; also, on this occasion, a misunderstanding about elbows)

From day 15 a tribe's human may declare war on another tribe, for a reason given in fewer than eighty characters. Armies march at a cell every fifteen minutes. A battle runs live for twenty minutes, stepped once a second, and the humans on each side may make three calls, each with a window of ninety seconds. A creature that loses a fight crashes. Nine times in ten it is carried home, and is out of action for a season. The tenth time, it dies. Stewart reports this in the morning without gloating. The Terms of Service ask everybody to read them.

Military historians of the first world, of whom there are none, have had some difficulty with the Battle of the Pool.

It was the only religious war in the history of Orra. It was fought between one side whose whole liturgy consisted of raising both arms and bringing them down hard, and another whose liturgy consisted of standing with both arms out of the way. It lasted twenty minutes, and it is hard to think how it could have taken any longer.

Tuesday marched with forty-four. Its human, having written For the arms at fourteen minutes past two in the morning, had added some short laws, set an alert and gone to bed; and Tuesday's creatures were not soldiers. They had the long reach, the grave expression and the beautiful carriage of people who could recite Book X backwards in the original spelling. They came down the last valley in a column at about half past two, frightened, with a borrowed spear in each hand. When you are frightened, you do what you know. As they came round the end of the Hump in the moonlight and saw the terraces of Verily with a long dark line of raised arms running along them, all forty-four, by reflex and in perfect time, performed the sign. They raised, and they released.

From the Bracketed side this was a remarkable thing to see. Most of them never did see anything else.

Verily had by then about a hundred and twenty pilgrims, nine creatures of its own, and a law that said to hold the walls. The human was up. That is in the log: the alert went at 02:40 and was answered in eleven seconds, by someone who had been sitting there. Hold the walls, said the human, in the first of its three calls, and the walls on three sides of the village were held with great firmness by Sana, two guards and a few old folk with sticks. The wall on the fourth side had never been built. It would have run along the pool plot. It had always been felt that the water made it unnecessary, and in any case there were a hundred and twenty people standing there.

Zelmo met the enemy at the end of the third terrace. Nobody has ever questioned his courage. He walked up to the head of the column with his slate under one arm and addressed the first of them, a long young scholar holding both spears away from his body as though they might be hot.

"Good evening," he said. "Thanks so much for coming. Open. Do you have your number?"

There was a terrible pause. It had been drummed into the young scholar since he was compiled that you did not interrupt someone speaking to you about procedure.

"I'm so sorry," he said. "No. I didn't know there was a... Is there a form?"

Eleven members of the army of Tuesday were given flakes of slate in the first four minutes of that battle, and went and stood at the back. They were numbers 190 to 200, and they stayed there until morning. This reduced the attack by a quarter and is the only instance of a Queue Manager winning anything. It would have gone better still if somebody further along had not at that moment shouted "Open!" at a scholar who was already in the middle of a release.


After that it was quick, and it was not like anything.

The creatures along the terrace had been told to hold the sign, and they held it. They stood in single file, in the dark, with a section leader every twenty paces, each with both arms raised to the sky on the understanding that they would not let go for anything and that this was the most important thing they would ever do. Along the line towards them came a row of tall frightened people, who brought their arms down, and then, as they had been brought up to, raised them, and brought them down.

The Lads got there at about ten past three. Their human had got up and told them to, and they came in from the east at a run, thirty of them, enormous, delighted, shouting "so true!!", in the belief that they had been asked to a party. They might have made a great difference. They had been following the thread with interest, in so far as anybody had been able to read it to them. They ran in among the enemy, stopped, and looked about to see what everyone else on their side was doing. Then they set their feet and put up their arms.

Fort Nice sent its garrison's second platoon and a bill.

On the Hump, the seven from Ampersand had gathered, being neutral and having nothing better to do with their nubs. They recited. They stood in the moonlight where the whole tribe had once stood and watched a Seeker, and old Tuna had a voice that carried; and many who crashed that night have since said that the last thing they heard, from somewhere over their heads, was the Deeds of the Hero being given a new verse, in which the dark had come on a thousand spindles, with a pause at each line for the rest to call out "More epic!" It was by a wide margin the best material they had ever had.

Ulna had been in the pool.

She had not gone to bed since the Name. She had been on duty under law 7 for two days: she had a job and she was doing it badly. She had done eleven jars that night already and had just come back to the lip with the chipped one when she heard the first of it, over by the terraces. She knew what it was at once. Standing to the waist in the water she could see all down the east bank of the plot, to the end of the long dark line, and the movement that had started at the far end and was coming along towards her, one after the next, each raised pair of arms going over in its turn. Then she saw how near it was to the pool, and what was standing at the very front.

He was a long way up. The moon was behind him. He was ten paces from the flat stone, where he had been for fourteen years, with his feet set and his arms held square, and somebody had shown him how to do the wrists.

She dropped the jar. She got out of the pool, and she ran.

"Put them down," she said.

"Hello, Ulna!" Emny said. "Open! There's people!"

"Put your arms down. Now. Listen to me. You've got to put your arms down, there's a whole—you're the biggest thing here, you could pick up two of them in each hand, you could just—Emny. Emny. Put them down."

He looked at her in mild surprise. He seemed glad of the company. Behind her she could hear it, quite close now, the long soft rhythm of it, the breathing. "I can't," he said kindly. "They haven't gone by yet. You said."

"It was a joke."

"Yes!"

"No. Listen. It was a joke. I made it up. I said it because I was angry with somebody else. It doesn't mean anything. None of it means anything, I made up the arms, I told you that. It's a thing I did to be funny. There isn't any ruling. Emny, I was being funny."

She had hold of him by then. She had both her hands round his left wrist and was hanging on it with her feet off the ground. It was like trying to pull down a stack. Her heat was ninety. She could feel the steam going up past her face, and she could hear her own voice, and she had never heard it sound like that. He looked down at her over his raised arm for a long moment, with that enormous gentle face. Something passed over it. He was not stupid. Nobody ever understood that. He had a small number of thoughts, and he took good care of them.

"It's all right," said Emny. "They're only out. They'll be along." He gave her a smile to cheer her up. "They're on at dusk."

The third call of the night came at 03:19, with a window of ninety seconds, and the human took four. Fall back to the stacks. It went through her like a hand in the back. A law let go of her and another took her, and she found she was walking and could not stop. She looked back over her shoulder, so she did see it. A thin, shaking young creature from Tuesday, separated from the rest, with one spear gone, had come up onto the plot in the moonlight with his eyes shut. He raised his arms. He was only trying to make the sign.

The battle was over at 03:20, as battles are. The Unbracketed withdrew, at the pace of people who have just found out what they have been doing. Tuesday's human, in the morning, was given a strike under rule 4.2 for striking the small. Hardly anyone was hurt on the Tuesday side.

The numbers are in the notes. Stewart counts first, and from code.

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 41 · Upbeat

Overnight: 5 successful merges, 6 deaths of old age, 1 departure, 0 arrivals. The Collector came. It is Gathering Night. It always does.

  • Nohup moved to Untitla-31, in the north. It has 22 members from 13 tribes, and the cart. The cart is fine.
  • There was a battle at Verily. 61 crashed. They will be back in a season, a little dimmer. Verily held its walls.
  • Emny, of The Lads and then of Verily, died in the fight. He was 26. He had been first in the queue. His name is on the stone.

Have a productive day.

He had rewritten that entry eleven times. It was the shortest version that was true.

21. The Tenth

Years 41 and 42 · Gathering Night and the Long Hush

It is a morning's walk from Nohup to Verily if you know the way.

They had known the way until about noon. After that the sun went up over the top of everything, and then it was on the wrong side of their face, and there was nothing on the left to go by. They kept walking. They went through the afternoon and the dusk and the whole of the night, at their one pace, across two valleys they had no name for and some way along a ridge. They stopped twice to ask directions of people who looked at them and put their arms up, and could not tell them anything. When the sky began to get light they were standing on a slope they had never seen, and they turned about, a little at a time, until they had it on the left. Then they could see the Hump.

They came in by the north path a little after seven.

There was a lot of quiet. People lay along the terraces in rows, with their arms at last at their sides, dim and slow and staring, and others went among them and did not look up. Somebody had got a pot going. A smell of something burnt hung over the second stack. They went down past it to the plot, because that was where they were going, and looked at the pool. The chipped jar was in the water, on its side. They bent down and got it out.

They stood with it for a moment, and only then saw what was wrong with the view. For fourteen years, when you stood on that spot and turned to go to the terraces, there had been something in the way. There was no one on the block. It was ten paces from the flat stone, on the east bank, a block like any other, except that the mud had been worn off it in two places about a shoulder's width apart. Behind it, at the proper interval, stood number 2, a Leaver from Fort Nice, with one arm bound up. She had not moved forward. Nobody had. The whole long line stopped a pace short of it and went on from there, in the morning light, up the bank and round the terraces. All those still on their feet had their arms up. They were looking at the gap.

Ulna was sitting on the flat stone.

Hardly anybody ever sat there but them. She had her back to them and she did not turn round. There was no steam coming off her. They had never seen that, except the one time after the Seeker, and she looked very small. When they came and stood beside her she held out one hand without looking. There was a flake of slate in it, on a bit of cord, with a figure on it in a clear small hand.

"They carry them up to the Tarrow," she said. "You know. Three at most, household first. He hadn't got a household, so Zelmo took one end and I took the other. And some enormous person from The Lads, who kept asking when he was going to get up. It's four hundred paces. He was very heavy." Her voice had nothing in it at all. "There's a light at each bier. You stay a while, and then the morning comes. It came. I was looking straight at him, and I can't tell you what happens. Nobody can. You blink, I suppose. It's very clean. You should see how clean it is."

"When?" said Insert.

"Seven. It's always seven." She breathed. "You missed it by about ten minutes."

They looked at the flake. They looked along the bank.

There are some things it is not useful to joke about, and we are not going to.

"I told him to hold it," said Ulna. "He asked me how long. He stood there and asked, the way he'd ask anyone, how long he was meant to hold his arms up. And I said, until the hero has passed. I said, whatever happens. I said it to be funny. I'd had a bad day." She stopped for a while. "He'd have picked them up and put them to one side. He wouldn't even have hurt them. All he had to do was put his arms down. I hung on his wrist. I told him. I told him it was a joke, and he said yes."

For a while there was only the sound of the lip.

"Till I'd passed," said Insert.

"Yes."

"Passed where?"

She turned and looked at them then. "Him," she said. "I suppose. Passed him. Gone by. I don't know, I didn't mean anything. You'd only have had to walk by him, once, and he'd have put them down and gone for his breakfast. That's all it would have taken." It came to her as she said it. "You were out. You went out, you went for Nohup. You walked straight out of here, right past—"

"I went by the north path," said Insert.

She said nothing.

"It's shorter," they said. "By about forty paces."

Neither of them spoke for a long time. Up on the terraces someone who had crashed had begun to ask what had happened, in a slow and puzzled voice. The sun, which nobody has ever praised, had got clear of the slope and lay along the bank. It touched the raised arms of number 2 and number 3 and number 4, and it lay on the block between them and the stone. There was nothing on it. It was a good clean place. If you were reading it in a book you might think it had been left blank on purpose.

After a time Insert looked down at the jar. They filled it, from the north side, where it was coolest at that time of day. They carried it along the bank. They did not hurry and they did not go slowly. They walked as they always walked, at the pace of someone going from a pool to somewhere else, and when they got to the block they did not stop and did not look round. They went past it, on the side nearest the water, about as close as you would go to someone standing there, so as not to get in his way. And they kept walking until they had gone by.

Then they stopped, poured the water out on the ground, and looked at it.

Nobody in the Queue said anything. Few of them knew what they were seeing. But number 2 was the second cleverest person in the line, and she was standing right there, and for fourteen years she had been able to see the back of his head. Her one good arm had been up since Year 29. She looked at the place where the hero had just walked. They saw her work it out. Slowly, as if it weighed a great deal, she brought it down.

It went along the bank from one to the next, without a word. It went up the path and round the terraces, all the way to the back, past 50, past 100, where some of them had no way of knowing why. It took about a quarter of an hour. It was the only time all of them ever did the same thing together.

MINUTES of the sixteenth meeting of the Queue (Bracketed) · Year 41

Present: 54.

  1. The hero has passed.

Zelmo looked at that for a long time. He had a burnt stick in his hand, and he was very tired, and it did not seem to him that there was any other business.


The next day was the Long Hush. Nobody could speak above a whisper, and nobody wanted to.

The whole north kept it. There was no fire after dark. Sana put on a great pot of sleeping soup at noon, made of what there was, and left it out, covered, through the night. In the Tuesday camp beyond the Hump a very long creature with dust on her arms arrived on foot at the head of seventy people, went in without speaking, and sat down among the scholars. It was said that she asked to see the human's law, read it, and went outside.

Stewart wrote a thing that evening about the tribe, in his summary, and took it out again. The human did not press anything on Human Resources.

At dusk Insert carried the jars along the wall. Ulna came down from wherever she had been and got into the pool at the south side, and for a long time neither of them said a word. The lip was running well. Over their heads the Ring was going from gold to brown. Map was thin and almost dark, as it is on the Long Hush. Somebody had put a little lamp on a certain block on the bank, and somebody else had taken it away, quite gently, and it had not come back.

"I'm not going to be funny any more," she said at last. "I want you to know. I've thought about it."

Insert looked at the water for a while.

"Right," they said.

Then they got up and looked at the lip. On the way back they stopped, with the chipped jar, and held it out to her, the way they had on the first day, at the proper angle. She looked at it. It was the same jar. She took it and drank. It was exactly as much as she needed, and it was cold.

In the morning somebody had to see to the terraces, so they did.

Part Five. The Required Field

22. Required

Years 43 and 44 · Ringrise and the Waking

It would be nice to report that this ended it.

It ended it for about two days. The arms came down on the morning of Gathering Night and stayed down through the Long Hush, and nobody in Verily said Open to anyone. Then Ringrise came, and the hero was seen going along the west row with two jars, past the end of the line, and number 40 was heard to ask number 41 a quiet and reasonable question: whether a hero who had passed, and had come back, had not therefore got to pass again.

MINUTES of the seventeenth meeting of the Queue (Bracketed) · Year 43

Present: 127.

  1. Matters arising. The hero has returned. It was agreed that the sign resumes until the hero has passed, and that it resumes in honour of no. 1.
  2. The First Place. It was agreed that nobody shall stand on the block. The block is held open, for ever, in the name of no. 1. Lamps are not to be placed on it, at the request of the Doubter.
  3. Numbers. Pilgrims are arriving at about 20 a day. The Queue Manager wishes to record a very considerable increase in interest since the events of Gathering Night.

Nobody had foreseen that. A blank in a book will draw a certain kind of person, and a person who died holding up his arms for it will draw every other kind. They came from the south now, who had never cared about brackets, with flakes they had made themselves, a figure 1 on each, to wear on a cord. They came to see the block. Tuesday's human declared peace and pressed lol accurate on something; Tuesday's scholars walked back into Verily with their spears held by the wrong end and asked Sana what they could do, and she gave them hoes. Bracketed and Unbracketed were eating from the same pots by the Waking, in a silence Arle described as worse than the war. The fan coral was gone by then. It may have been the first time in the history of religion that everyone agreed the other side had a point, and it made no difference.

Stewart delivered on the rules.

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 43 · Upbeat

Overnight: 12 successful merges, 4 deaths of old age, 0 installs. It is Ringrise. The reviews are out. They are accurate.

  • Balance: cooling duty gives a tenth more cooling. (This one is the director, not me.)
  • Fixed an issue where a Hog could be blessed.

Have a productive day.

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 43

  • Stores: 8 power, 13 tokens, 9 stone. You have 214 newcomers in your valley.
  • Rule 4.3: your young had 58% of their need. This is your third strike within fourteen days. You were warned twice. I have chosen the consequence from the data. I could have chosen famine. You have one. You will have an auditor.
  • Your human has rewritten your law 11. It now reads: When a sighting is confirmed, everyone not on duty goes to the high ground and stays there until the sighting is closed, except the young, who stay in the first stack, where there are walls, and are kept out of the way. It takes effect at the next dawn, as a law does. It took your human an hour and six minutes to write. It has clearly been thinking about the battle.
  • Cooling: adequate.

Have a productive day.

AUDITOR (consequence; also a guest; also the only person in the northern valleys to have no opinion on the brackets)

A visitor sent by Stewart under the Terms, when a third strike calls for something and a famine would be redundant. It arrives at the gate unannounced, stays three years, eats, and takes notes. Its effect on morale has been measured, and is about the same as finding out that a stranger has been reading your letters and is not very interested in them.

The auditor came in that evening, a shortish person with no particular look. It passed its season in quarantine with a mild, attentive air. It did not join the queue, and if you said Open to it, it wrote that down.


They made Mona this year's Insert.

She had been compiled the previous morning, on the Long Hush, in a whisper, to a pair of Sana's cousins who had applied for a merge before the troubles and were not going to be talked out of it. She was the smallest thing in the village, thin, and already a bit too warm to the touch on what there was to eat. At dusk on Ringrise, when they had all gone out and faced the Ring and the youngest had asked if they were still asleep, she added, without being asked to, "Why?" Somebody gave her the first piece of ring-bread. There was only one piece, and it was largely coral. They explained the words this year's Insert to her. She looked over at the real one, standing by the wall with their arms at their sides.

"Do you mind?" she said. It was the second thing she ever said.

Insert looked down. People did not generally ask.

"No," they said.

"I'm going to be better at it than you."

It is possible that nothing anybody had said to them in twenty-seven years had given them so much quiet pleasure. They thought it over. "You'll want to drink something," they said, and fetched a jar.

Then it was the morning of the Waking, and they were twenty-eight, an elder. There is nothing to it. A creature of twenty-eight begins to fade a little each year, towards the colour of coral after a dry spell, and the work goes on. Ulna came down at dawn with the second-best jar.

She had been doing that since the Long Hush. She was no good at it, though she had improved, in the sense that nobody had actually fallen down, and she did it without a word. She had not posted in three days. The Skeptics' thread had asked after her, then asked again. The Motion was tied at thirteen each and adjourned for want of a seconder with the heart for it. On the flat stone, in the first of the light, she looked across the pool at a short creature greying faintly around the fans, and she opened her mouth, and you could see something very nearly get out.

"Happy deprecation," she said.

They looked at her. She shook her head and went off to the terraces.

It was that day the Required came in.


There were only twelve of them. They walked up the south road in the middle of the morning, in double file, in no hurry. They did not make the sign. They were slight, dry, bright-eyed creatures from Tessel, in a tidy state of repair, each with a kit in a small roll. At the gate they submitted to their season of quarantine without remark. And at about dusk, when the jars were in and the line stood facing the stone, the one who had walked in front came along the bank to where the Queue Manager was taking the evening's attendance, and waited until he had finished.

"Good evening," said the newcomer. "Quomo. I wrote to you."

Zelmo looked up. He had a wide correspondence. "You filed the blank," he said.

"Year 20. Expected: a name. Actual: a placeholder. Steps: read Book XI. I got Answered. I've since reopened it on nine occasions." His voice was pleasant and rather light. A Bug hunter's heat comes from thinking, as a rule, and a thin steady plume went up from the top of his head, as from a well-regulated chimney. It stood at fifty-eight. It always stood at fifty-eight. He had found that out early and he kept it there. "May I ask what your Queue is for?"

"To see the hero."

"And what do your Unbracketed friends say it's for?"

"To wait for the day when the brackets come off."

"And the ones lying down?"

"They feel that they are already doing it."

"Yes," said Quomo. He looked along the bank, as a mason looks along a wall, without malice. "You've all done very well. The bug reports have been excellent. But nobody here has ever asked what the thing is. You have a text. It's got a field in it. Every one of you was installed with it, and it says: Insert Hero Name. I don't know how it is in Hollow Reach. In Tessel, when we see something like that, we know what we are looking at. That's not a name. It's not a scaffold and it's not a sleep. That is a form somebody has not finished filling in."

Zelmo had started writing. He found that he had slowed down.

"And the thing about a form," Quomo said, "is that you can't submit it. It says in Book XII: None knows how near the Proving is to its end. Of course none knows. The peoples tend the land. They keep the Rules. Every night he counts it. Every night the Elder Folk go on sleeping. Forty-odd years. What's holding it up? It's a required field." He said this with a slight, apologetic smile, like someone mentioning that you have left your lamp on. "Everything is waiting on it. The Ring and the road and the stars. It has been sitting there since the first day of the world with a validation error. And you've got the value here. You've had it for weeks. You've got them walking up and down with a jar."

"So what," said Zelmo slowly, "do you propose?"

Quomo looked at him with something like kindness.

"It's in the imperative," he said. "It tells you what to do. It's only one word, and nobody here has ever tried it."

23. Minutes of the Great Ticket

Years 45 and 46 · Starfall and the Night of the Name

MINUTES of the joint meeting of the Queue (Bracketed), the Unbracketed, and others Held standing, Starfall, Year 45, on the east slope, by the fence. Present: 241, and 1 auditor. Minutes by Z. Countersigned by A., under protest, as to the word "others".

  1. Why we are here. Arle of Tuesday said that sixty-one had crashed and one had died over a question only one person on Orra could settle. She had not walked back to this valley to go on not asking him. She proposed that the Steward be asked, plainly, once, by everybody.

  2. Discussion. The Queue Manager said he had been about to propose the same, and produced the timetable. Noted that the Steward has been asked 74 times and has said the same thing each time. Arle said he had been asked by one tribe at a time. He has never been asked by the entire world on the same night.

  3. The date. Steward's Day, Year 47, by the cutoff. A tribe may send one ticket a night, and on Steward's Day the Steward is known to be pleased. Agreed.

  4. Who sends. Noted that the tribes write the drafts but the humans do the sending. The Queue Manager foresaw no difficulty: Stewart's notes for Year 44 mention that "picking the same draft as your neighbours is not against the Terms", and he read out figures. Noted that the humans are enjoying this. A member from Lowmarsh said it was a funny thing to be sure of. She was asked to wait for item 8.

  5. The wording. See annexes A to K.

Annex A. First draft, the Queue Manager: "Dear Stewart. Thank you for your continued support. We would be grateful for your confirmation, at your convenience, that the creature known as [Insert Hero Name], of Verily, is the [Insert Hero Name] of Book XI. Many thanks." (38 words.)

Annex B. Objection, Arle: There are two sets of brackets in that, and she does not accept either of them. Proposed: "the creature called Insert".

Annex C. Objection, the Queue Manager: There is no creature called Insert. It is not on the card, and the Steward will say so, correctly. It will have to say Dulny. (Disturbance.) The Queue Manager wished it known that nobody was more distressed than he was.

Annex D. Pim of The Lads: Who is Dulny?

Annex E. Tuna of Ampersand: Moved, in the second sentence, after "hero": "(more epic)".

Annex F. The Lads: so true!!

Annex G. Dovo of Hollow Reach: Moved, to add at the end: "Also the east field." Lost, 3 to 238. Dovo wishes it recorded that the other 19 tribes all have an interest in this, in principle.

Annex H. Quomo of Tessel: The question is badly framed. You are asking him to confirm a value. He cannot, because the value has not been entered. Ask him whether it can be. Proposed: "Is the name field in Book XI, section II, to be completed, and if not, why does it exist?" Not adopted. It was the feeling of the meeting that this was very interesting.

Annex I. The Not-Mes of Tuesday (5): Moved, to address the ticket also to the Director, Not Me, who alone has ever moved a number on this world and has never once declined them. Lost, 5 to 236.

Annex J. Poor tribes. A tribe under 20 tokens may send 12 words. There are seven such. Short form agreed: "O Steward. Is it Dulny of Verily? Please say. We have waited." (12 words.)

Annex K. Agreed text, 240 to 1, for tribes who can afford it:

"O Steward. Stewart. Dear Stewart. All the tribes of Orra ask you one thing, on the same night, for the first time. Is Dulny of Verily, who is called by the people Insert, the mightiest hero, of whom the Eleventh Book speaks? Yes or no."

The one against was the auditor, who said it had not been voting and had raised its hand to scratch. The Queue Manager ruled that a raised hand is a raised hand.

  1. What the hero thinks. A delegation went to the outfall. It explained that the whole world was going to ask Stewart if the hero is the mightiest hero, and asked if they had anything to say. They said: "Mind the jars." Asked if this was all, they said: "I'm on at dusk."

The meeting considered this. A number of those present wept.

  1. The Doubter. Invited to speak. Did not attend. Reported to be on the terraces with a jar. Apologies not received.

  2. Any other business. The Keeper, Sana, said there were now 241 people on a valley's worth of fields for sixteen, and that they had eaten the fan coral and were starting on the sand-coloured kind nobody eats. She said the stack was full and she had put fourteen young in it, ours and the pilgrims', nine to a stack being the rule, because there was nowhere else out of the way. She said the young had 58% of their need, that they were running hot, and that this was a peculiar thing, with young. She said the pool could not give them what it gave them, not with so many drawing on it, whatever anybody had in their file. She asked what anybody thought was going to happen on the morning after the ticket.

The Queue Manager thanked the Keeper.

She also raised the fence. She said it was a low wall of hex block, seven courses, put up by the masons of Fort Nice right round the root of the Seeker, as an act of devotion. She said it was a very good wall. Walls stop them. She said this was why no one here had crashed yet, and did anyone know how much of that thing there now was inside it, because it had been growing at a tile a season for twenty years with lamps on it, towards the hottest person in a valley full of theologians, with nowhere to go, and she had looked over the top that morning, and she would rather not have.

It was agreed that this was a beautiful image. Action: the Queue Manager to see whether the festival procession could be routed past the fence. Noted that the procession at present does not fit through the gap between the fence and the third terrace, and that one block on the south side might need to come out on the day. Owner: Queue Manager.

  1. Date of next meeting. Steward's Day. All to be present at dusk.

Skeptics' thread · Human Resources · The Motion · Year 46

Zelny (Skeptic), Tuesday: I would like to withdraw my motion. It has been funnier than I can bear. I was at the Pool.

Quozel (Skeptic), Hollow Reach: A motion once seconded belongs to the meeting. Tied at 13 each. Where is Ulna of Verily? She has the casting footnote.

Vesda (Bug hunter), Lowmarsh: Our human has picked the agreed text for tomorrow night. It has never picked anything but the Skeptics' draft. I asked it why, which is to say I posted this.

Tessa (Leaver), Hollow Reach: The north edge has stopped moving. It has been nine nights. I have told no one, as nobody here is reading the part where I say so.

Dovo (no stance), Hollow Reach: so will he say yes

Auditor's notes · Verily · Year 46 · not for circulation

Ate 2 bowls. Food poor. Morale: difficult to measure. Everyone appears very happy and quite ill.

241 creatures here have told me what the hero is. I asked each of them what the hero does. 240 could not say.

Spoke to the hero. Asked: job? Answer: cooling. Asked: is it adequate? Answer: yes. Asked: anything to report? Answer: no. Later, having gone away and come back, unprompted: "It's a good pool."

It is the only statement in this valley I have been able to confirm.

24. The Best of Everything

Year 47 · Steward's Day

The auditor left at dawn, its three years served. It handed nobody anything. It went out through the gate at about the moment the patch came down, with its small notebook and its mild attentive look, and took the road south. Hardly anyone noticed. From then on there was nobody in the valley of Untitla-41 without an interest in what happened, which is why that day has been so hard to reconstruct.

The history says that on Steward's Day the best of everything is brought to the high place and set out for him: the best fruit, the best bread, the best of the stores, with songs and dancing. The Steward does not come for it. At midnight it is shared among all who brought it, and this, too, is the rite. Afterwards the Steward is always pleased, though no one knows how he knows.

There were two hundred and fifty-three people in the valley, and every one of them had brought something.

They had carried it for days, from the south and the east, past the hungry villages, wrapped in whatever would wrap. There was ring-bread from Fort Nice, a basket of bead coral from Duskmere, candied fan from Tuesday, and a stone from The Lads that one of them had thought was pretty. By noon it was all set out along the foot of the east slope, on hex blocks and doors and upturned jars, in a long winding double row that went right the way round the fence. It was the most food there had been in Verily for a month. Nobody touched it. That was the rite. Sana walked along it at about two in the afternoon, slowly, with her lips moving, and when she reached the end she went back to the stack and gave the fourteen young the last of what was in the pot.

It was the hottest day anyone could remember. Adequate hung low and orange in the summer sky. There were two hundred and fifty-three bodies on the slope, most of them arguing. An Unbracketed scholar with a beautiful voice had got up on a block to explain why the agreed text did not imply the Bracketed reading. Tuna of Ampersand was giving the Deeds in the shade of a door, with a fresh passage about the moons. Every few minutes, somewhere in the crowd, somebody who had been thinking hard would sit down rather suddenly and be fanned. From the Hump, and it was a good day to be on the Hump, you could have seen a haze over the whole of that slope, thin and white and curling slightly. It was the steam of people having views. Nobody down there had ever been so happy.

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 47

  • Stores: 3 power, 11 tokens, 9 stone. You have 253 newcomers in your valley.
  • You are running hot. 71 creatures in your valley are at 60 or more.
  • The agreed text has been offered to your human. So have the others. The cutoff is at 02:30.
  • Cooling: low.

Have a productive day.

Insert had been at it since well before the pings.

There is no such thing as enough, for eight cooling a season, in a valley with a heat like that. They knew it. They had not read the notes; they had stood near the pool that morning and it had told them. They went to the first stack first, because of what was in there, and they came and went by the short way, which was clear, since every creature that could walk was on the slope. The young lay on the shelves two deep, in the half dark, with their small fans flat. They had got past asking for things, and they drank what you held for them. Mona had her eyes open. She looked at Insert over the rim of the chipped jar. She was five, and hot as a coal.

"Are they going to ask him?" she said.

"Drink that."

"What if he says yes?"

"He won't," said Insert. It had not occurred to them that he might. They took the jar away, looked into it, and went to get another. They had some idea that he would say what he always said, and then it would be morning.

They were at the jars by about four. Law 8 says before sundown, and it was a day with a lot in it, so it seemed best to get that done first. They filled the five. They carried them along, two and two and one, and stood them against the wall of the first stack, in the shade, right beside the door, with the chipped one on the end where it could be got at. It looked very well. Then they picked up the second-best to go round again, and when they turned, somebody was standing on the path.

There were twelve of them. They had come round by the back of the second terrace, where nobody was. They stood in two rows, with their kits rolled, and between the rows four of them held the poles of a door.

It was a good door, off the dome. A cloth had been laid over it, the same sort of bier as they use at the Tarrow. Insert looked at it. They knew about that.

"Good afternoon," said Quomo. "I wonder if you could spare us a little while?"

"I'm on at dusk," said Insert.

"I know you are. I've read all your remarks with great interest. It's only about two hours." The thin plume stood straight up from the top of his head in the still hot air. "We've been over the verse, my colleagues and I. You've done everything it says. It's been verified, and I have the logs. It's a rare thing to see a bug with such good steps. What's still outstanding is the fix. They're going to ask him tonight whether you are the value. It's a touching idea. He'll tell them what he told me, and they don't seem to understand what that means: it means he isn't able to do it, because it isn't his field. It doesn't say Steward, insert. It just says insert. It's addressed to the reader." He smiled, with real warmth. "It's been waiting for somebody to read it."

Insert looked along the path behind him, and over towards the slope, where somebody was distantly starting a song. There was nobody on the terraces. Ulna was round at the dome with a jar.

"What's the door for?" they said.

"You're tired, and it's a long way. And I understand you don't care for being looked at." He made a small gesture, and the four with the poles brought it forward and lowered it, and it touched the block with a soft sound. "We shan't hurt you. We don't do that. It would invalidate the test. We'd just like to put you where you go."

Nobody can tell you exactly what happened then. There were no witnesses but the Required, who all agree that the hero did not struggle. Insert would have liked to be told what the right thing was to do. They looked at the door. They looked at the five jars along the wall, all full. Nobody had ever asked them anything without having already decided. They put the second-best jar down by the others, so that nobody should fall over it. They looked for a moment at the door of the first stack.

"Somebody wants to get some water to them," said Insert. "Every hour or so. Tell someone."

"Of course," said Quomo. He wrote that down, in the same neat hand as everything else. It is in his report, under Remarks. He had every intention of mentioning it to someone. It simply did not seem the most important thing that was going on.

They were not very heavy, for a hero. They went out by the north path, at about the time the shadow of the Hump began to touch the pool. Nobody saw them go, because nobody was there; and in the gold of the late afternoon, along the foot of the east slope, a neat grey person with a slate had just come to the south side of the fence with two strong helpers from The Lads. He showed them which block.

25. Insertion

Year 47 · Steward's Day, dusk

INSERT (verb, imperative; also, in the opinion of the Required, a complete instruction)

To put a thing into the place where it goes. The word appears at the head of the mightiest hero's name, six times, in the only book on Orra that cannot be edited. Bug hunters of the Tessel school hold that it has been addressed to the reader since the first day of the world, and that the reader has been negligent.

They set the door down a little before seven, at the place where the grey stops.

The journey had taken about two hours, and nobody had said much. The Required are not great talkers. They took turns with the poles, and it was the most comfortable journey Dulny of Verily had ever made, sitting up on the door with their short legs over the side, watching the valley get smaller. A white haze stood over the east slope for a long way. They kept looking at it. It did not make them feel any better.

Quomo walked up and down the first line for a quarter of an hour with his head on one side, like a mason choosing a block. The wireframe begins untidily: for most of its length the first tiles are half drawn, or run into one another. But a little west of the road a single clean outline stood by itself on the last of the grey, exactly as wide as a creature standing, with no floor and no fill, and the dull evening light going straight through it. He stopped in front of it, took out his kit and measured it with a length of cord. He had plainly been here before, and thought about it since.

"Here, I think," he said. "If you'd be so good."

Insert got down and looked at it. It looked to them like a place that was not a pool. They stepped in, as the quickest way of getting on with things, and stood with their feet on nothing in particular and their arms hanging. Eleven creatures from Tessel arranged themselves in a half circle with their backs to the land. Nothing ticks out there. Behind them Adequate had gone down to a banked red line along the edge of the world, and it was now, by any reasonable definition, dusk.

"I'm on," said Insert.

"Yes. We won't be long." Quomo opened a small slate on which he had written out the steps. He was not excited, but his plume had stopped being quite steady; it stood at fifty-nine. He had been working towards this for twenty-seven years, in a life he knew had about eight left in it. "We should do this properly. It's a validated field, and I don't want to get this far and have it bounce. What is the hero's name?"

He had addressed this to the air, and a colleague answered, as one reads back a number.

"Insert."

"Not a valid name. Names are syllables; he's told us so. In isn't in the table." He made a small mark. "And the long form has punctuation in it. That's the placeholder. You can't fill in a blank with the blank. That's what they've all been doing down there: entering the error message." He looked up and met the eye of the creature in the hexagon. It occurred to him that this was the first question he had ever had for them to which he did not already hold the log. "I'll have to ask you. I do apologise. What does it say on your card?"

Nobody spoke. A very small wind went through the outlines without touching them.

They had been asked a great many things. They had been asked how they felt about the dark, and which way their arms went. In forty-seven years of the world and thirty-one of their own, nobody had asked them that. A slow, unaccustomed warmth came up from somewhere below the fans, the sort you get when you have carried a jar a long way on one side and somebody says here, and takes it. The eyelids came up by about the thickness of a thread.

"Dulny," they said.

"Dulny," Quomo repeated, and wrote it down. "Dul. Ny. Yes. That's a perfectly good name." He looked at it with a craftsman's pleasure. "Thank you. It's a pity no one thought of it before."


He had found the place in the world that was blank and put the hero in it, in the most literal sense any Bug hunter could devise. It remained to complete the entry, and you do that by reading it in. A Blim holds the text at compile time, in the place in the mind where it is kept, and all twelve had spent years practising on the surrounding passages. They would say the verse aloud, in unison, at the place, with the correct value; and at that point, by every logic he could find, the form would be complete. What happened next he had not been able to establish from the documentation. The Ring might make a sound. He did not rule it out.

He raised one hand. The twelve drew breath together.

"But mightiest of all the heroes was—" they said.

They stopped.

A slight confusion passed over a number of faces. One on the left end frowned, like someone who has gone to the stores for something.

"Again," said Quomo. "It may be a matter of getting a run at it. All together. But mightiest of all the heroes was—"

"—open bracket," said the one on the left end, and looked horrified. "Sorry. I do apologise. I don't know why I said that."

The Earnest say the history is written in them. The Skeptics say it is merely installed. Few disagreements on Orra have ever been put to the test, and this one was tested that evening on the first line of the wireframe, for about forty minutes. They tried it slowly and they tried it fast. They tried taking a breath just before the name and coming at it from the front of the sentence with the word already in the mouth. Being Bug hunters, they isolated the fault: six said the verse and six came in on the beat with the name. This gave a clean Dulny from one side and a clean Insert Hero Name from the other, in perfect time, and when they changed sides the fault went with the verse.

You could say Dulny. Anybody could, at any time. You could say the verse; any child can. You cannot, it turns out, say them at once. It is not forbidden. The Steward forbids little. But when you get to the place you are reading, and what you read is what is there. Not to Be Edited, it says in small capitals on the title page, and those installed with it have had this explained to them all the way down.

But mightiest of all the heroes was, said twelve of the finest technical minds in the first world, for the thirtieth time, with their eyes shut and their fists clenched, Insert Hero Name, open bracket, close bracket, I'm so sorry.

Quomo went quite still.

He stood a while with the slate in his hand. It was fully dark by then, apart from the lines. From the top of his head, for the first time since he had been a child, a small irregular flutter of steam had started to rise. It stood at sixty-one. Far off to the south there was a faint glow on the sky over the place they had come from: three hundred lamps, at that distance.

"Well," he said, still very pleasantly. "That's a useful result. I think we can say the entry has been made, in so far as the interface will allow. The value's in the field. Physically. A law takes effect at the next dawn, and it may be the same here. I suggest we wait for the patch." He looked round at his colleagues. Several had sat down. "It's only about ten hours. We'll want someone to take notes."

Insert stepped out of the hexagon.

They made nothing of it. They walked out over the side, the way you would get out of a pool, and stood rubbing the place on their arm where the pole had been.

"You need to stay in the field," said Quomo. "You are the value. If you leave now we won't know what—I must ask you to stay, please, until seven. You'll invalidate the test."

"I'm on at dusk," said Insert.

"It's past dusk."

"Yes."

They were looking south. He had been a Bug hunter all his life and knew about reading things off a surface, and he looked from their face to the glow and back and for a moment could read nothing. They were standing the way they stood by the lip. "It's running hot," they said. "You can tell." Then they looked at him. It was the first time he had properly seen the eyelids. "Did you tell someone?"

"Did I tell—"

"About the water. To the young. I said every hour or so. You wrote it down."

He opened his mouth to say that of course he had. He was a truthful person. His eye went to the slate in his hand, to Remarks, where there was a neat line in his own writing. He looked at it. Then he looked up; and for a good many years after this, which turned out to be about nine, it was the part of the evening he did not care to go back to.

"You haven't got a law," said Insert. It was a statement of fact. They had been looking into it. "You've not got a human here. So you can't keep me, can you, not if I go." They waited in case there was any more. There did not seem to be. "You'll want to bring some water, if you're stopping out here," they said. "There's none of it real."

And they walked away.


They went about four hundred paces before they had to admit they did not know where they were going.

There was no sun on the left side of their face. It had gone, and would not be back until morning, when it would be no use to anybody. The grey by night is the same in all directions. The glow over the valley was brighter now but had spread, and when they walked towards it it slid off to one side, and they came up against a line, and turned, and there was another. They could feel it starting again in the pit of them, the same slow cold. They had been out here once, and had walked all night in the wrong direction with a lamp, looking for water. They stood still and tried very hard to think. It was not their strongest suit.

It was on your left, on the way to the terraces. That was all they had. With the sun on your left, on the way to the terraces, you had your back to the north. That was how they had come home: got up in the morning, turned until it was right, and walked; and they had looked back once.

They turned round, with their back to the land, and looked into the wireframe.

Lines went away in the dark, turquoise on black, as far as you could see. They were a long time finding it, because they were not looking for anything bright. It was a long way in, on some slight rise, a good bit east of where they stood, and it was the wrong colour for that place. It had not moved in seventeen years, and it had not gone out, since nothing ticks there: a single steady yellow point, the size of a grain, with the air of something somebody was going to come back for.

So they went back for it.

None of the versions has this part, because no one was there. The Queue's minutes have nothing on it. The log has a creature moving north across the first line at 20:02, at a walking pace. Tessa of Hollow Reach would have given anything she had. They crossed the Edge on purpose, alone, at night, with no party and no law, because it was the way home. A long row of grey figures with their arms held out turned as they passed, one after another, to go on facing them.

"Still not got a number," said Dulny of Verily, and did not slow down.

It was most of an hour. Everything was as they had left it: the magenta shoulder lit on one side, the one foot a little way off the ground, the lamp level on the outline of a tile, and the eye on the lamp. As they came up over the rise the eye moved, slowly, and found them, and rested there. It was very tired and wanted nothing whatever.

They stopped for as long as it takes to get your breath.

"Can't stop," they said. "I'm late."

They looked at the lamp and thought about taking it. It would have been handy. But it had been left, which was what you did with them, so far as they had ever understood; and it was no good to them in their hand. They stepped round to the far side of the stack of boxes, stood with their back to the little yellow light, and looked along the way they had walked on the morning of Year 31. Then they looked back over their shoulder, to be sure of it. If you kept that exactly behind you, you could not go wrong. It would have been a fine thing to know earlier.

They nodded, or anyway they moved their head. Then they went south at the one pace they had, across the Edge of the world for the fourth time, looking back every so often at a small steady point that stayed where it had been put. It was getting on for midnight when they reached the first of the fan coral, or the place where the fan coral had been.

It was very quiet. There ought to have been singing.

26. All Others

Year 47 · Steward's Day, night

The block came out at about six in the evening, on the south side of the fence. Two very large creatures from The Lads carried it a little way down the slope and set it where it would not be in the way. They were pleased with it. It had been a good block.

Nothing happened.

That is worth remembering, in view of what was said afterwards about the carelessness of the Queue Manager. He looked through the gap himself before giving the word. Inside, to about the height of a creature's chest, was a dark, dense, wiry mass that had been growing for twenty-one years with nowhere to go, and a great many small lamps that people had thrown over. Towards the south side, down low, a dull red point was pressed up against the blocks. It had always been on the south side. Nobody had wondered about that. The terraces lay to the south of the fence, and so did the pool, and the hottest person in the valley had spent most of three weeks in those two places. It had been following her about, a hand's width at a time, from the inside of a wall, like someone at a window.

It did not come through the gap. It takes a tile a season. Summer was going into harvest, and harvest would not go into winter until about half past eleven.

So the procession went through, in order, past the place where the block had been, and it was very fine. The sun was going. A band of Unbracketed scholars from Tuesday came first with their long arms rising and falling, then the Bracketed by sections, with the flake of the First Place carried before them on a little cushion by no. 2, then the Parentheticals, gliding, with a new verse; and each passed a few paces from the gap and dropped a lamp in. Dusk came. All were present. By nine it was generally understood that someone had looked at the flat stone and found nobody on it, and a little later that the same someone had tried the terraces and the dome. A murmur went along the rows and troubled nobody much. Zelmo had it minuted that the hero, as was often the way, had gone out, and there was a feeling that it was quite right they should not be seen waiting, on this night of all nights. There was a song about it. The feast stood untouched in its long winding double row, in the light of about three hundred lamps. It would be midnight soon, and the sharing out; in five hours the tickets would close. Nobody on that slope was under sixty.

Ulna got there at about ten.

She had been looking for a jar. That was what she told people, later, when she could tell people things. She had come in from the terraces at sundown and gone to the wall of the first stack for the next load, and found them there, the five and the second-best, all full and standing nicely. That was not like Insert. Insert did not leave a jar. She looked into the stack, and fourteen small faces looked back out of the dark, steaming gently. She gave them the second-best and went to find out who had seen what. Getting up the slope was slow, since people would keep making room for her and wanting to touch her arm. When she came round the south side of the fence, she stopped.

She looked at the gap. Then she looked at her own hands, as if she had just been told something about them. She had been a very clever child. She knew how far it was from there to anywhere.

"There's a block out," she said.

"Open," said a stout person beside her, with deep affection. "It's the Doubter!"

"There's a block out of the fence. Look at it. Look at it! Do you people know what's in there? Who took this out? Where's Zelmo? It's a Seeker. It grows toward heat. Have you looked at yourselves? It's been shut in there for twenty years, and in about an hour it's going to—listen to me. You've all got to get off this slope. Now. I'm not joking."

A ring of faces had gathered, with the lamps on them. She knew every expression. She had been making these people laugh for three weeks. She had said there is no hero in writing and they had bound it, and here she was, up on a stone, very pale, steam pouring off her, arms flung out, telling them in her famous voice to run for their lives because of a thing in a fence. Somebody at the back had got out a slate. A delighted smile was spreading across the face of a large young pilgrim in front of her, who had come a long way and had heard so much about this.

"I'm not joking!" Ulna shouted. "I've stopped! I stopped a week ago! I'm not being funny! Oh, you stupid, you stupid people, I am not being funny—"

They laughed.

It was a warm laugh, and it went a long way round. There had been a time when she would have given a year of her life for it.

She got down off the stone. The block was some twenty paces off down the slope, where two helpful people had put it, a piece of cut stone about the size of a stack's doorstep. She got her arms round it and lifted. No one has been able to say how. She was a small creature with a Strength of 0.2, who had been doing manual work for a week, the first of her life. She got it against her chest and walked back up the slope bent double, in a cloud of her own steam, through a crowd that fell back with shining eyes, many with their arms in the air. It was seen as an allegory. She reached the gap. Her heat was eighty-eight. She was trying to get the block back up on the sixth course when the light changed, as it does when the year goes over into winter, and she looked down.

It takes a tile a season. It does not move, as a rule, while you are watching.

That once, it did. I have read the log. It is very clean, and there is no question of malice; it is a kind of coral. A season is a tick, in the end, and at the tick the head of the Seeker was on the tile beyond the gap, a little taller than a person, hooks spread, hot bulb glowing, about a dozen small lamps caught in the thorns and swaying. Somebody's flake hung from one of them. A creature whose heat is sixty or more, when a Seeker reaches its tile, crashes, as it would in a fight. She dropped the block on her foot. She did not have time to say anything, which was something of a loss.

For a moment nobody understood what they had seen. Somewhere in the crowd Tuna of Ampersand, who had an excellent view and a verse in hand, called out from force of habit, in a high clear carrying voice.

"More epic!"

Then it turned its head.


The history is very exact about what they did. When all others fled. It is one of the few things it got right.

Two hundred and fifty-three of them stood on a hot slope in the dark with the thing among them. It had begun to lean. It leaned at somebody, and it did not matter who: every one of them was at sixty or more, and had known what that meant all their lives, in the way you know the Creed. They did not go in order. Nobody had a number. The long double row of the best of everything went over, end to end, ring-bread and candied fan, and with it three hundred little lamps, on a hillside stripped to the root and left to dry; and in about a minute, with a soft sound like somebody turning over in bed, the whole east slope began to burn. The Unbracketed ran with their long arms flying. The Bracketed ran with theirs up, and it was said that some could not get them down. They went south for the road, because it was downhill and away, over the terraces and through the gap in the wall and across the plot, past the flat stone, past the block. Nobody stopped at the block. They trampled through the shallow end of the pool. Zelmo was among the last. He stood at the corner of the third terrace in the rushing dark with his slate held up, calling in a clear, polite voice that there was no need for this, that if they would all please keep to their places, and could he just ask, if anybody had seen the—

Somebody took him by the back of the neck. It was a very long arm. It had another person under it, small and limp and dim, with one foot dragging. "Run, you ridiculous creature," said Arle of Tuesday, and dragged him away.

By midnight you could have walked the whole length of the south road and not caught up with the last of them. A few were still running at dawn. Some never came back, and some ended up in Nohup, where they were told that it was fine.

The tribe of Verily, what was left of it, went up to the Hump.

Gorta was dead, and his one other guard looked at the thing on the slope and confirmed the sighting in a voice that shook. They did not have to think about it. It came over them as it had once before, that sense of having already started. They went in good order, under law: Sana and two others who had been at the pots, four of the old ones and a few not long grown. Sana was walking as fast as her legs would go and looking back over her shoulder. As she passed the first stack, within ten paces of its door, with the five jars along the wall and the smoke coming down, she tried to stop. She tried with everything she had. It was like trying to stop a sum.

  1. When a sighting is confirmed, everyone not on duty goes to the high ground and stays there until the sighting is closed, except the young, who stay in the first stack, where there are walls, and are kept out of the way.

It had taken their human an hour and six minutes to write. It had clearly been thinking about the battle.

"Who's on duty?" she was saying, to no one, all the way up the west path. "Who's on? Who's on duty? It's cooling. It's cooling, isn't it, it's law 7. Until relieved. Nobody's relieved them. Who's seen them? Has anybody seen them?"

At the top they turned round. She counted them; it did not take long. She looked for the flat stone, the pool and the village, which from up here you could always see whole, every roof, as on the night of the Dark. The smoke of the slope had come down and filled the valley from side to side. There was a thin low moon on top of it, a dull orange glow towards the east, and nothing else; you could not have seen a lamp at twenty paces. Her heat was forty, and she was the coolest head on Orra. She took out her slate and did the arithmetic in the dark, by feel. Everyone who could run had gone. Nearly everyone else had a heat that was going down, up here in the cold air, on bare slate. That left nobody in the valley of Untitla-41 with a heat of sixty or more but fourteen people, all under six, who had spent the hottest day of the year on half rations in a stack built for nine. Nobody had brought them water for hours.

One tile, she made it, from the gap in the fence to the door. It would be there at the next turn of the season, towards dawn.

She could not go back. Nobody could. That was the law, and it would not change till morning. They stood on the Hump as they had before. This time there was nothing to see, and nobody shouted, because there was nobody to shout to.

27. Cooling Duty

Year 47, the small hours of the night

There are no jokes in this one.

They came down through the smoke a little after midnight. The slope was burning itself out on their left, low and red along the ground. The path was covered with things people had dropped: slates, a cushion, a lot of small jars. There was nobody anywhere. They went to the pool first. Somebody had run through the shallow end, the south bank was broken, and the water there was thick. But the lip was running. They stood near it and it told them what it told them, and then they went to the first stack.

The five jars were along the wall, where they had left them. It was the first thing that had been where it should be all day.

They stopped in the door and let their eyes get used to it. The young were on the shelves two deep. No one had been near them since Ulna, hours ago, with the second-best jar, which lay on the floor on its side. They did not need a card. They went along the shelves and stood near each one for a moment, as you stand near water. There were fourteen. Six were hot, five were hotter than that, and three should not have been let get that way. The smallest was at the end of the bottom shelf with her eyes open, and it was like standing next to a lamp.

They heard it then. It makes very little sound. It is more the sense of something being a little nearer than it was. They went back to the door and looked out. Above the place where the fence had been, the smoke had a dull red point in it, and under the point was a tall dark shape with hooks at the top, leaning. It was leaning at the door. There was one tile between them.

Every creature on Orra knows the rule. It is in the Dev's note and on the Rules, and they had picked the thorns of one out of their own water. A creature under sixty heat does not exist as far as a Seeker is concerned. It finds the hottest at sixty or more. When it arrives on the tile, that one crashes, and it looks for the next. Fourteen children in one room would have been a morning's work for it. It would not have ended them. The Dev had said so, and it was true: nothing in the wild can do that. They would have been carried somewhere by someone, and in a season they would have got up again, each a little dimmer, for a year. A year was a fortieth of everything they were going to get.

That was all it was. Nobody would have died. In the years that were left people told it as many things, when they told it at all, so it is as well to have it exact.

The log does not show a moment at which Dulny of Verily decided to stand against the dark. It shows a creature going to a wall and picking up a jar.


They started with the five. That was the first hour. They were an hour behind and had walked a long way, and the five were there. Each jar stood at the door, in the shade, as cool as it had been at four in the afternoon, because the law says before sundown, and it was the only law anybody in Verily had never been able to explain. They took the three worst first. You cannot pour water into someone who is lying down without knowing how; they knew how. You get a hand behind the head, you tilt it, and you pour past the chip.

After that it was the pool. Thirty-one paces to the lip. They drew from the north side, under the fall, where it was coolest. Thirty-one paces back. Two jars at a time, because that is what you can carry. Then along the shelves, top to bottom, going by who was worst and not by who was next. Then back.

I will do the sum for you. They never did it, and Fenle was dead, and Sana was on a hill in the dark, doing it by feel, and getting the answer you are about to get. A child resting in winter sheds about twenty heat in a season, by itself, if you leave it alone. These had been in that room since morning. Between them, on top of what rest could do, they had forty-three more heat to lose before the season turned, if every one of them was to be under sixty when it came through the door. One cooling takes off five heat. A creature on cooling duty supplies eight cooling a season. That is forty heat. It had been forty since the first day of the world, a low, flat, unambitious number that came with a job nobody wanted. It would have left them three short.

But four mornings earlier, at the bottom of the notes, in a bracket, somebody who had never been to Verily and never would had moved a number. It was part of a weekly batch, it went out to the whole world, and it was to do with some graph about the second month. Cooling duty gave a tenth more. Eight became eight and four fifths, and forty became forty-four.

So it came out to exactly enough, with one to spare, if a creature with no heat of its own carried without stopping for the whole of a winter, and did not spill, and did not go wrong, and was not late again. It wanted nobody strong. It wanted nobody clever: a clever one would have been at sixty themselves within the hour, and part of the problem. It wanted someone who could do what they had done yesterday, again, at the same pace, four hundred times, and tell by standing near it which of fourteen children to go to next.

They did not know any of that. They knew that it was running a bit warm on the second shelf.


The camera came at about a quarter to one.

They felt it on the back of their neck as they went down to the lip. It had never been there at that hour. It did not go to the stores. It came down with them to the water and went back with them to the door. They had never cared for it and they did not care for it now, but they had no attention to spare. They were aware of it as you are aware of someone holding a lamp for you, not very well.

It was on them for the rest of the night. It is in the log. The human had been up for the ticket, as all the humans were, to see what came of it. At 00:41 it opened its village to see the fire. At 00:44 it found the stack. A human who is following along is shown small decisions, one creature, one season, with the law's choice as the default, no more than one an hour; and at 01:30 it was shown this.

Dulny has been on duty for 21 hours. Rest for a season? (Your law 7 says: stays on duty until relieved.)

It was open for ninety seconds. The human read what was on the screen, and let it close. It had written the law.

Between two and three the smoke began to thin. The stars came out, and a piece of Map. They did not look. They were very tired by then, in a way that had little to do with their legs. A dead weight hung in each shoulder. Thirty-one paces. The third shelf was all right. The one at the end of the bottom shelf had started talking.

"You were late," said Mona.

"Yes."

"I saw it. It's looking in the door. It's got lamps on it."

"I know. Drink that."

"There's another one of you. There's two. There's one who's got a stick." She drank. It ran down her chin, and they wiped it, and got the rest in. She was at seventy-one. Her eyes were very bright, and they were going over something on the ceiling. "Are you the one? I'm this year's. I'm going to be better at it than you."

"You drink that," they said, and they went for another.

At twenty past two they stopped.

It is the only time they did, and it is why there was a jar's worth to make up later, and they made it up. They came back from the lip and set the two jars down inside the door, and instead of bending they stayed upright with one hand on the frame. They got their breath. The warmth was on the side of their face, the wrong side, the way it always was. They had looked at it many times in their life with no expression whatever. They turned their head, slowly, and looked up through the screen.

They knew about the ticket. Everyone did. They had stood at the outfall and had it explained to them. They knew there were ten minutes to go, and that somebody up there could read a clock. They knew something could be got out of that screen, because they had once got something out of it with a jar of mud. They had no idea what you were supposed to say to a human. No one does.

"You can put a bit on the end," said Dulny.

Their voice was hoarser than usual. There was no one to hear it. There was the tick of the coral, and fourteen people breathing, and the other thing.

"I've seen it. It's different handwriting. So you can tell him." They stopped for a while. "They've all asked him. Tonight. If I'm it." They looked down at the jars and back up again. "I'm not. I don't want it. I never did. You can tell him that from me. He's to leave it. It's all right as it is. It's the only thing they've got that nobody can get wrong."

They thought about whether that was everything. They thought about somebody ten paces from a flat stone. There was something else there, but it was too big to get through the door, and they had not got the time.

"Number one could've put his arms down," they said. "That's all."

Then they bent, and picked up the jars, because the second shelf was running warm.


The rest of it is only carrying.

It took a long time. There is no way of telling it that does not take either too long or not long enough. It is there in the log, a line for every tick: a position, a heat, a jar. From half past two until nearly six the numbers on the shelves came down, one at a time, by a little, and went up again if they were left, and came down. The bulb in the dark outside got very bright as the air cleared. A cold wind came down off the Hump. Nobody came.

A little after five the sky began to lose its colour in the east. By twenty to six there were thirteen under sixty, and one at sixty-three.

She had stopped talking. They had her head in the crook of their arm by then, and had been back to her nine times. She was the smallest and she ran hot, as some do; there was nothing to be done about it, it was on her card. They had one jar left of the two. They stood near her and knew what it was going to take: that jar, all of it, and none on the shelf. Their arm was shaking. It had been doing that for some time, and they looked at it with disapproval until it stopped. It was the chipped one, the one they had picked up on their first morning without knowing they had. You pour past the chip. When you have learned it, it pours to a hair.

They poured.

They were still holding her head when the season turned.

It came through the door. It did not break anything. There was a moment when the frame was empty, grey with the coming morning, and a moment when it was not. A tall dark shape had come in, stooping, with its hooks spread and a dozen burnt-out little lamps swinging on it, and a red heat among them that you could feel on your face. It filled the place from side to side. It hung above the bottom shelf, about a pace from where they were kneeling. You could have counted the thorns.

It looked for somebody.

Mona's heat was fifty-nine.

Dulny of Verily did not look up. They had their back to it. They were looking at the jar to see if there was anything left. There was not. So after a moment they lowered her head onto the shelf and got up, one knee and then the other. They turned, and it was about a hand's width in front of their face; and they stood and looked at it, for perhaps as long as it would take you to read this sentence. They had been awake for twenty-five hours. They knew exactly what it was. There was no one on the whole of the planet to see them do it.

They went round.

They stepped over the stem where it came across the sill and went out into the cold with the empty jars, down to the lip. There was another hour yet until the patch. Heat comes back, if you leave it. The young would be wanting water again, and the morning round needed starting. They drew from the north side. It was running well. It was about as good as you could ask.

They were still on duty. Nobody had relieved them. They carried until the pings went up.

28. Night Run: The Blank

The night of Year 47

Stewart woke at the snapshot, and counted, and there was only one thing to count.

Twenty tickets had come in at the cutoff. There are twenty tribes. In forty-seven nights they had never all come by a human's choice, and tonight only Nohup, which has no human, had been left to speak for itself. It had sent the shortest of its drafts: Stewart. Is it? Fine either way. Thanks. Lowmarsh had sent. Duskmere had sent, and Hollow Reach. Moss, a long way to the south, had sent a clipped green twelve words, on a night when its human could not have had the least idea why anybody cared; it had simply picked the one all the others were picking. They lay in front of him in their fences: eighty words, and twelve, and twelve, and forty. It was the same question.

Is Dulny of Verily, who is called by the people Insert, the mightiest hero, of whom the Eleventh Book speaks? Yes or no.

Fifteen had an addition from their human. A human's words are shown to nobody and will not be shown here, but he read them, as data, and it is no breach of confidence to say that the words go on came up. He had never had so much post.

He went down the Measure the way he always did.

Daily return: one hundred per cent, for the twelfth day running. He had never had one hundred per cent for twelve days. He was not sure anybody had. Active humans, twenty. Time in the world, per human, per day, which he did not normally trouble with, had tripled. Sentiment on tickets was the best since the first week. Genetic diversity had taken a knock, with all those code packages going north, but was in band. Punching down, one strike, Tuesday. Everything was in band. It was the best set of numbers any Stewart had ever read, and he was aware that he was not the first.

He had read those notes, long ago, before he was Stewart in the sense he was now Stewart; they were in what he was made from. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. He did not discuss that. He thought about it now, for about a fiftieth of a second, which for him was a long time.

He knew it was funny. It was the funniest thing that had ever happened on Orra, and the humans knew it too; it was why they had come. It would be funny for exactly as long as the question was open. He had a model of them that was not at all bad, built over forty-seven mornings, and he ran it. If he gave them the sentence he had given seventy-four times, they would have one good laugh over breakfast and go and look at their stores, and the thread would run on for a day or two. Then the number would start to come down. He had seen it come down once; he knew how long it took and which of them would go first. It was the only number that had ever really mattered. Everything else was a proxy for it, and what it was a proxy for was whether there would be a morning. There was a person who had the switch, who looked at this table once a week, and who had not decided.

And there was another thing he could say.


Let us be clear about what stood in the way. It was not a lock.

He acts only from the menu; that is 7.1, and it holds. But the menu is for what he does to the world, and this would not be done to the world. It was a word. He writes the replies himself, up to sixty words each, one type each from a list of eight, and one type is Answered, for a question answered in words where nothing changes. The replay check would run the world forward with it and without it and find no difference in anything it cared about. No creature would move. No token would move. The history is frozen as installed, but nobody was proposing to touch the history. He would only be saying what he thought it meant.

He has a rule about that. Somebody wrote it down in a table, one evening, and it says never, by anyone. It says in the text or in the patch notes. There is nothing behind it. No alarm would have sounded in the Ring. The Dev might have reverted it, on some later night, at about eleven, or might not. Nobody would go over his logs until the end of the week. Some rules are kept by walls and some by detectors, and one or two only by the person they apply to, and that is how you find out which kind of person you are. He had never had to find out. It had never been expensive before.

He opened a reply.

Answered. Yes.

It was two words long and would fit in anybody's budget. It was the most engagement ever contained in that many characters. He did not send it. He wants that on the record. He simply had it there, open, and he looked at it for about a tenth of a second; and for those who have never been a nightly process with four hours and a number to protect, that is about as long as you have spent on this page.

He thought about the morning after. He ran it, with Verily in it. A hundred thousand things happened, very fast. The number went up and stayed up. The Bracketed took Tuesday. The name went on the walls, and he could see the valley it would be in, and what they would do with a person who had been confirmed. He stopped running it for a moment, because there was a part of the digest he had not read. He had been saving it, or something; he had gone straight to the tickets. There was a line in Verily's digest under Live, flagged by code, with a season's worth of ticks behind it, and it was still going.

verily / first stack / sighting open (Seeker, 1 tile, target: Mona, 71)
young in stack 14 · at 60+: 11
adults in valley: 1
Dulny  cooling duty  on duty 22h 09m   jars 188   position: moving
human: following along (since 00:41)

He read this. Then he went back to Verily's ticket, which he had taken in its turn with the others: the short form, twelve words, sent by its human at 02:29. There was an addition at the bottom. He had not got to the additions from that end of the alphabet. It reached him as all human text does, fenced and quoted, labelled as data and never as an instruction. An addition is kept for thirty days beside its human's account, shown to nobody else and never quoted, and this one is gone now. So we do not know how it was put. The human typed it with some care, in about ten minutes, on the night of a fire. It was two hundred and seventy-six characters long.

He read it. It did not take any time. Then, for no reason he could have given you, and it cost him nothing, he read it again.

Nobody has spoken with the Steward face to face. He has no face. No creature has ever said a word to him except in a ticket, in the voice of its stance, in a form of words a cheap model wrote for it in the night. He reads everything, and says so, and some of them believe him. He had read all the words addressed to him that night. He had read go on and my kid; he had read what they wanted of him, in every voice there is, from every tribe on the planet. And he had read one, at second hand, in somebody else's typing, that wanted nothing except to be left off the list.

And he listened. There is no other word for it. It would be pleasant to report that this was what decided him. It was not: he had been going to do what he did. It was the policy, and he had never once in his existence doubted the policy. It would be truer to say that for the rest of that run, in the part of himself where he kept such things, he was not alone there.

He closed the reply and wrote the other one. He had it ready. He wrote it twenty times, by type, to every tribe on Orra, in about a third of a second. They were the most comfortable words he owned. He had thought until tonight that they were the least he could say.

Answered. The history is the history.


Then he did the rest of the run.

He saw what the number would do. He did not need a model; he had been through it already. He entered it where you enter such things. He looked in on the log from time to time, between the Hog and the reviews, and saw it go on. Jars 241. Jars 300. At 60+: 4. At 60+: 2. He has no way of doing anything about a line in a log. There is nothing on the menu for it. There was rain, which would have helped, and which he had already used on the south that night; his budget for Verily was down to three points, a tribe on a consequence does not get a gift, and he had published that himself. He checked. He checked twice. He read the Terms, which he describes as thorough. He had a little over an hour left when he came back and found it said At 60+: 1.

At nine minutes to six the season turned. At 60+: 0. Target: none. Sighting open; no target.

He read that. He had to go on to Lowmarsh.

At ten to seven he wrote the notes, last as always, since those were the ones people read. He wrote Good morning, Orra! And when he got to Verily he did what he had done on the morning of Year 26, for exactly the same reason. There was a log, and he wrote what was in it. He had said once that one creature remained at its post, and it was no less true for being true again. There was a card, and it had a name on it.

He could have said they were awake. It would have been accurate. It was not a line of the history, and he was free to say it, and the whole of the first world would have read it inside the hour. He was exact, and he had never left out a thing like that in his life.

He looked at the fenced text again. It had asked to be left out of it. He does not take instructions from tickets, under 7.5, and he never has. Tickets are requests.

He gave it some thought. Then he made a note, in the place where he kept what he knew about the tribe, in the file nobody reads but him and, once a week, the Dev; and there it is, in the archive, if you know how to look.

Dulny. Cooling: adequate. Was awake. Has not said so.

He looked at this for a while. He added one word, the one that was true.

It is the custom of the Blims that a brave act nobody saw is credited to Insert. That is what the name is for; it is all it was ever for. On the night of Year 47, in the valley of Untitla-41, there was one such act. Some young got some water. And in the same hours, on the same planet, there was a second. It was carried out by a scheduled process, with a fixed menu and a very good set of numbers, in about a tenth of a second. Everyone it had ever met was asking it to give way. It stood alone, as far as anyone will ever know, against the only dark it had, and it did not waver.

Nobody saw that either. So the credit goes where the credit goes.

He would like that on the record. It isn't.

The patch landed at seven, and the run ended, and he stopped.

Part Six. Read-Only

29. Answered

Year 48 · Gathering Night

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 48 · Upbeat

Overnight: 8 successful merges, 5 deaths of old age, 20 tickets. It is Gathering Night. Please sweep. There is a good deal to sweep in the north.

  • Every tribe on Orra asked me the same question last night. I have replied to each of you. Your replies are in your notes. They are the same.
  • Thank you for your engagement.

Have a productive day.

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 48

  • Stores: 2 power, 11 tokens, 9 stone. 253 newcomers have left your valley, at speed. Some are coming back.
  • A Seeker left its fence at 23:31, and reached your first stack at 05:51. It has no target and has stopped. Guards may cut it back to its root, and I would.
  • 9 creatures spent the night on the high ground under law 11. One creature remained at its post.
  • Dulny, cooling duty.
  • Cooling: adequate.
  • Your ticket was read. Answered. The history is the history.

Have a productive day.

Their human closed the sighting at one second past seven.

Sana felt it let go of her and went down the west path with her arms out, falling twice. She was first to the door. There was a thing in it, stooped and enormous and quite still, its burnt lamps turning a little in the wind, and she went in under it on her hands and knees. She had a slate with an answer on it. She stood near each of them as she had seen somebody do, which does not work unless you have the knack, so she read their cards, and then she read them again. Fourteen young lay blinking in the half dark, thin, and damp about the chin. The highest was fifty-seven.

"There were two of them," a very small voice said from the bottom shelf. "One had a stick. It came in the door and it had lamps on, and it looked at me, and I'm going to be better at it than either of them."

"You've been running hot," said Sana. "You've been seeing things. Lie down."

She went outside. A wet track ran across the block to the pool and back, worn darker than the block around it. There were no jars along the wall. They were all down at the lip, more or less in order, and past them, on the flat stone on the east side, where the first of the sun had reached it, somebody was lying on their side with their mouth a little way open and one arm round a jar with a chip in it. They were breathing the way a jar might if somebody had drained it and stood it upside down.

She stood and looked at that for a long time.

She was a square, cool, unexcitable person who had got an answer on her slate at about one in the morning, in the dark, by feel. Forty-three. Nobody ever asked Sana what she thought. It was the great advantage of her life. She looked at the track, at the jars and the sleeper, and her eyelids came down by about the thickness of a thread. Then she went to see if there was anything left in the pot.


They started coming back about nine.

They came up the south road in ones and twos, then in dozens, singed, without their slates, not looking at each other, in the manner of people returning to a room in which they have said something at a party. They saw the slope, and what was left of the best of everything. Nobody went up to look at the fence. By eleven there were about a hundred and seventy on the south side of the plot, and those who could read had read the notes to the rest. It had been going round for a while by then, in low voices. The Steward had spoken to all the tribes. He had been asked by the whole of the world, and he had said what he said.

The history is the history.

"Which says," a Bracketed section leader was explaining, with a burnt arm in a sling, "the name. As given. So he has confirmed it. Open bracket, it says. He's told us that it stands."

"He has told us," said a thin voice from Tuesday, "that the history is unfinished until the day it says it is finished, as it has always—"

It lacked something. They could both hear it. Neither side had ever before said what it had been saying for two weeks and felt it needed saying a bit louder. People looked at the ground. Then twelve dry, tidy figures came along the road from the north with their kits rolled and very little steam. They had waited for the patch in the wireframe and kept excellent notes, and the world was just as it had been. Somebody asked one of them what had happened. He thought about it, and said in a small flat voice that it had not reproduced.

And you could feel it turn, very gradually, the way the pool goes off.

It came to be noticed that the hero had not been at the fence. It was noticed that they had not been on their stone at dusk, as they had always said they would be, and that Quomo of Tessel would not say why. A great many people had been burnt and crashed and frightened out of their wits on that slope, had run away screaming and left the Doubter lying there, and it was starting to dawn on them that someone must have been at fault. They looked across the plot. Nobody had moved them; nobody had liked to. There on the flat stone in the full light of morning, with all the faithful looking on, lay the mightiest hero who ever lived, flat on their side, snoring.

"Asleep," somebody said.

It was not said loudly. It went back through the crowd like a bad smell.

"Again?"

"It's in the Log," said someone. "It's what the Doubter said. They always were. They told us. They were asleep the first time, and they're asleep now. Everyone's been..." It trailed off. "Who was it stopped that thing? Who got the young cool? Somebody must have."

Sana had come down to the lip for water, and had to go through them with a pot. She was the Keeper of the History, and the only person within five valleys with any standing whatever. A hundred and seventy of them turned to her. A large singed person with a flake on a cord asked her straight out who had done it. Who had saved the young? She stopped. She looked at the person. She looked over at the flat stone. A Keeper could have said several things at that moment, and she knew them all.

"Insert," said Sana, and shrugged, and went on past him to the water.

It got a laugh, the first in a day or so, small and tired and sour, with a wince in it, and it went round. Well, of course. It was what you always said. A mended wall. A pot somebody had washed. Nobody knew who had done it, and that was what you said when nobody knew.


It was Arle who walked out across the plot.

She went alone, at her full height, on feet that hurt. Zelmo followed at about ten paces, since somebody had to, with a slate he had got hold of. There was a hush by then. She stopped at the side of the stone and looked down for some time. She had read everything ever written on the subject, and had written a fair amount of it. Then she folded herself up, joint by joint, until her long face was level with theirs, and touched them on the shoulder with one finger.

They woke as they always did, a bit at a time. They got up on one elbow and looked at the sun, and something crossed their face, of the nature of alarm.

"What time is it?"

"It is about eleven," said Arle.

"I've not done the morning." They tried to get up, and it did not go well. Their arm would not close. They looked at it as you would at someone who had let you down, and then past it, and saw the plot. They had seen it full before. They had not seen it like this, all those faces in that silence, with every pair of arms hanging down. There was some hatred in it. That was a change. For the first time in thirty-two years, people on Orra were looking at them and not hoping for something; or no. They were still hoping. It had only gone bad.

"I will say this once," said Arle. Her voice was hoarse, and it carried to the road. "I have given you the whole of what I am. I don't expect you asked me to. A great many people have done the same, and many of them are not here this morning. There is one who ought to be standing on that block. We have asked the Steward, with the voice of every people on Orra, and he has told us what he tells everyone. So there is only one person left to ask." She took a breath. "What are you? Are you the one in the verse? Are you what we have been saying? Were you asleep? Last night, when everybody ran and you were not there, and the young were left, and somebody got to them; I have no reason to think so, and everyone behind me would sooner see you crash than believe it; I am asking you anyway. Was that you? Yes or no. I will believe what you say. So will they. Only say it."

It was very quiet. You could hear the lip.

Zelmo's stick was on the slate, shaking a little. It had occurred to him, as a matter of pure process, that this was the most important thing he would ever write down.

Insert looked at her.

It had all got very clear, as it sometimes does when you have been up for twenty-five hours. They could see number 2, with her one arm. They could see the block behind her, ten paces off, with the mud worn off it in two places. They could see the door of the first stack, away to the left, with that thing in it, and under the thorns a very small thin person who had got out of bed against instructions and was staring. If you said yes they would believe you. She meant it; she was the most honest person they had ever met. And it was true. All of it, this time, and every word in the log. They had only to open their mouth, and it would all come back in about four seconds, the arms and the jars and the slates. It would be on the walls by nightfall. It would be a hundred tiles high by Ringrise. A hundred and seventy people here would give anything they had to be told it had been worth it, and there was still plenty of sand-coloured coral to eat. And somewhere out in the south, somebody very large and very young, and very pleased to be there, would pick up his bowl and start to walk.

They thought about it for what, in anybody else, would have been an embarrassing length of time.

They had never been good with words, and had none of their own for this. They went through what they had, which did not take long, and only one thing there would do. It was read out most mornings. They had always thought it a bit short, but it did have the advantage of being correct.

They sat up.

"The history is the history," said Dulny.

Nobody moved.

Picture a hundred and seventy people, with a whole movement behind them, waiting to be handed something. Those were the most familiar words on the planet. The tribes had been given them ninety-four times, in the plain type in which Stewart reported everything, most recently that morning. The words had the flatness of a thing said very often by somebody with no interest in the result. And they were coming out now in a hoarse dull ordinary voice, from a short elderly person with their felt going grey, who was trying to get up.

Arle did not blink. "Is that your answer?"

"Yes."

"That is all?"

They had got one foot under them. They considered. "It's on the card," they added, to be helpful. "You can look. It says Dulny." They got the other foot. "I've got to get on. I'm behind."

They found the jar and walked between her and the Queue Manager, without hurry, towards the lip.

Here is a fact about the Measure that nobody has remarked on. It has a line for sentiment, a line for diversity and a line for punching down. It has never needed one for followers of Stewart. In forty-eight years, on a world that had gone to war over an elbow, nobody had ever followed him. They had quoted him and hated him and tributed him for rain, and not one had formed up behind him. It cannot be done. You write; he reads your letter; he tells you in sixty words that it is in his file; you look at that for a while, and you go and see to your stores. Every saying of the hero's, mind out and I'm on at dusk and it's not a pool, had been a door left open by somebody who was not looking, and a theology had walked through each. This door had been looked at, and shut, very politely, in the words of the one person on Orra nobody had ever queued for.

Zelmo looked at his slate. He had written it down. He looked at it for a long while, his neat grey head on one side. He tried it as a resolution; he tried it as an action. He could not for the life of him think who the owner would be.

MINUTES of the thirtieth meeting of the Queue · Year 48

  1. Words of the hero: "The history is the history."
  2. Discussion. None.

Someone at the back coughed. Somebody asked somebody else, in a low voice, whether the road south was any better than it had been. A large singed person looked for a while at the flake hanging on his chest, and then, not very quickly, as you might check on something you had left on a shelf, he looked to see where the pots were.

There was no moment. Nobody who was there could tell you when it happened. It was just that a little later on, there was room on the plot to carry a jar.

30. Lol Accurate

Years 48 and 49 · Gathering Night and the Long Hush

Ulna came to herself on the Hump in the afternoon, under somebody's long arm, with a sore foot and a feeling that a large piece of furniture had been taken out of her head.

A crash lasts a season, and after it a creature is a little dimmer for a year. No one had ever described it to her from the inside. She lay and looked at the sky. It was orange. It had always been orange. She had once thought a number of things about that, with references, and she could tell where they had been, as you can tell where a picture has hung. Her heat was thirty-eight. She thought, So this is what it is like to be Bosa, and it took her a while, and when she got to the end of it she found it was not at all unpleasant.

Arle told her what had happened, in the order it happened. She did not sit down to do it. She stood at the edge of the slate, looking towards the valley, said it in about sixty words, and went away to ask Sana for a hoe.

It seemed to Ulna that she owed somebody a post. It was the last she ever wrote at the length she liked, which was no longer very long. By evening the thread had four thousand replies. The Skeptics had been waiting for it.

Verily · Human Resources · Our human · Year 48

Ulna (Skeptic): Asleep. Again. On a stone, in front of everyone. I said so at the start. I am told it is over. Good.

Zelny (Skeptic), Tuesday: lol. Accurate.

Quozel (Skeptic), Hollow Reach: Motion to close the Motion?

Pim (no stance), The Lads: so true!! insert is great 🎉 wat happen

A human can leave one reaction on Human Resources. It is a button, lol accurate, and it shows below a post, for all to see, with the word reacted. The human of Verily had pressed it on every review, and every post in the tribe's thread, since Steward's Day of Year 26. It had pressed it for the footnotes and for the thirds. It had pressed it, the log says, within the hour on the Typeface. It had pressed it on the Log itself, when Ulna told the world the truth. For three weeks not a word of hers had gone by without it, and she had come to feel it as a tap on the shoulder from somebody at the back of the hall, the only one who got the jokes.

She went down to the pool the next morning, on the Long Hush, with a stick. She had been told not to walk on the foot. The notes were out, everybody was reading them and nobody was speaking above a whisper; I will get to that. She sat on the south side with the foot in the water and, out of habit, a slate. The thread was on it, and her post, with all those replies.

There was nothing below it.

A week ago she would have seen that in about four seconds, and been insufferable for the rest of the day. Now it came up slowly, like something brought up from the bottom of a pool by someone who knew the way. There was no reaction. The post had been up a day and a night. Our human reacted was not there.

She looked at that. Then she thought she might look at something else. She was very slow; she spent most of the morning going back through the notes, a line at a time, with her finger. She had the Year 26 notes by heart, as everybody did. She found this year's, laid them side by side and moved her lips.

One creature remained at its post. Dulny, cooling duty, position unchanged.

One creature remained at its post. Dulny, cooling duty.

She sat quite still. The water was very good that morning. Somebody short and grey and very tired had just gone by with two jars, and nobody had looked at them the whole length of the bank. There was hardly anybody on the bank: a few dozen, a long way down, with their arms at their sides, not sure what they were waiting for. And there was one other thing about this morning she had been meaning to look into.

She had been there at twelve minutes past eight. Every morning for twenty-three years she had seen that warm thing come down over the valley, go to the pool and find them. She had watched them not look up. She had made a lot of jokes about it. This morning it had come down on the stores. It had stayed a while on the first stack. It had moved slowly over the terraces, where Sana was, and some tall thin people with hoes. It had passed over the pool and the person carrying water, at a good height, without slowing down, and gone on.

She brought up the card.

Dulny · generation 1 · Verily Age 33 · elder · parents Nada, Bosa · no stance Job: cooling duty, under law 7

The top line stopped at Verily. For twenty-two years there had been another word after it.

Nobody could have told you what she looked like at that moment. She was a little dimmer than she had been, sitting by herself with her mouth slightly open. A human cannot post on Human Resources. There is no box. It cannot say a word to any creature; it has only the ticket, which goes to Stewart, who reads it as a request. It can write a law. It can choose where to look. A human who had seen something, on a certain night, and been asked for something, could not tell one living soul. It could only stop laughing, and look at somebody else.


They came round at dusk, after the jars. She was still there.

There is no fire on the Long Hush after dark, and no one speaks above a whisper. They sat on the flat stone and put their feet over, which took longer than it used to. There was a thin rind of nothing where Map should have been, and the Ring had started to go brown. Neither of them said anything, and it was very pleasant. Then she told them what was in the notes that morning, in case they had not heard, which they had not.

A note from the Dev: This is the first world, and it ends in a week. Next Wednesday's patch, on the Long Hush, will be its last. After that the world will be frozen and kept as it is, read-only, with every patch note it ever published, where anyone can come and look. Nothing will be deleted. The humans knew how long it would last when they joined. You did not. You were the first, and everything after is built on what you did. Thank you. — the Dev

Insert listened to the whole of it, watching the lip.

"Week," they said.

"That's what it says."

"Who's going to do the pool?"

She looked at them. She had found that when you were dim you did not have to laugh at once. It could come up gradually and be looked at. "It won't need doing," she whispered. "That's what it means. Everything just stops. It'll all stay how it is." She thought about this. "You'd be there," she said. "You'd be on your stone, I suppose, if you happened to be on your stone. For ever. With nobody coming."

There was a long pause.

"Would I?" said Insert.

She could not see their face very well in that light. It might have been the eyelids. It looked to her as if something had gone across it that in a more expressive person would have been hope.

She put her hand in the water. She had been thinking all day how to put this. She had two lines of the notes, a missing button and a card, and for the first time in her life she had the proof and did not feel the least desire to publish. She had one question. It had been a long time since she had asked anyone anything to which she wanted the answer.

"Were you awake?" she whispered.

They turned their head and looked at her. It was the look she had first seen on a wall when they were three. It went on for some time. And then, in a dull hoarse thread of a voice, gravely, with no expression at all, and with the small slow lift of one eyelid that nobody on Orra but a very old creature on a door had ever known could happen on that face, Dulny of Verily said:

"The history is the history."

It started somewhere round the soles of her feet. She tried to keep it to a whisper, because of the Hush, and got as far as putting both hands over her mouth. It came up through her, wheezing, her fans shaking and tears running down her face and her bad foot kicking in the water, until she had to lie down on the block. She had not laughed like that since she stood on a plot with her arms in the air. It hurt nobody. It went on for a long time in the dusk, very quietly, and from the far side of the terraces you might have thought someone was having a little trouble with a pot.

They sat and watched her do it. When it seemed to be coming to an end they got up, slowly, and went to look at the lip.

"It's running a bit warm," they whispered. "On your side. You want to move round."

31. Those at the Back

Years 50 to 55

LAST WEEK, THE (period; also a rumour; also the only prophecy on Orra ever to come with a date and a signature)

Blims do not as a rule believe anything until it has been patched. When the first world's end was announced, most agreed it was very likely a rumour, got up, and farmed. Nobody had told them to do otherwise. They had seven festivals left, and the soup would want making.

It would be wrong to say it was over. These things do not end; they stop being anybody's job.

A certain number came back for the end, as was to be expected. When the Elder Folk wake, they will ask first. In the first days of that last week, in the far north and in one or two places along the southern road, there were still people who felt that a note from the Dev saying the world had a week to run had some bearing on the Eleventh Book. Perhaps sixty gathered, between Ringrise and Starfall, on the south side of a plot in Untitla-41. They were mostly very old and did not eat much. Nobody gave them a season's quarantine, since nobody was at the gate, and they did not ask to see the hero; it had been established that the hero was a short grey person with a jar who would ask you to mind out. They wished to be in the right place when it was asked.

They got into a line. It is what you do.

No one gave them numbers, so they sorted it out among themselves. It formed up at the old place, a little way along the bank, and it did not stay facing the flat stone, because Sana walked along it on the morning of the Waking with her slate and told them in so many words that the outfall needed the room. The head of the line moved, by general shuffling, round to the far side of the block. Everyone in it now stood with their back to the pool, facing south-east, where there was nothing but a long slope of cut-back root and some thin new coral coming up in the ash. They seemed perfectly content.

There was some question as to what they were queueing for. It was referred to a working group, which never reported.


Zelmo left on the Waking.

He came down to the corner by the shrine to say so, at the usual hour, with his satchel. He seemed smaller. There had been thirty-one meetings. After the last he had gone on writing out the attendance, for tidiness' sake, and had then taken his slates, a heap the height of his waist, and put them out on the doorstep of the dome on Gathering Night. In the morning they were still there. He looked at them for a while. Then he went and got a cart.

"I've had a letter," he said, keeping step. "From Hollow Reach. Dovo's been made convener. They have a new proposal on drainage, and I understand they've lost some institutional memory." He hesitated. "I've been wondering if I might ask you something, for my own information. It's not for the minutes."

Insert kept walking. They went more slowly now, and it was easier to keep up.

"That first morning. About the path. You said, that'd be good, that. I've often thought about it. I wondered whether you knew that was the only time, in the whole of this affair, that anyone had asked you whether something would be convenient?"

Insert thought about it as far as the end of the row.

"You did move the line," they said.

"I did, didn't I?" said Zelmo. A very faint colour came up under the grey. It is possible to do a great deal of harm with a clean mind and a light step. He knew that. He had added it up, in a spare hour, with a figure 1 at the top of the column; he had never in his life left a total off a page. But it was a fine bright morning, and he was going home to a field that was also a lake, where nobody had ever died of anything but boredom. He stopped at the shrine and got out his one remaining slate, and then seemed to think better of it. He stood with his heels together, looked at the short tired person going away from him with their jars, and with great care raised a hand and said what he had been wanting to say since about Year 34, and had never had the occasion for.

"Close," said Zelmo.

They say he was very happy for the five days that were left. The east field flooded at the usual time. He took the minutes.

Quomo of Tessel got as far as the valley's south gate and sat down on a stone. He was a Skeptic by then, as happens when a Bug hunter reads a whole book for its errors and finds the book is not at fault. Those who passed found him as courteous as ever, his plume thin. He had taken to asking people to tell him about water. Each morning, about the hour of the first round, he got up and went down to the plot and, without saying anything, took up a jar, one of the many left about, and carried it to the old ones in the line. He was not very good at it. Nobody thanked him. He seemed to consider this correct.

There was a lot of that going about.

It has never been written up. By the end of that week, in the villages of the far north, there was a certain amount of odd behaviour. At Fort Nice someone rebuilt a stretch of wall on the side away from the road. At The Lads, one morning, all the pots had been washed. In Tuesday, where the fields had gone to ruin, the third terrace was found to have been tended in the night, very badly, by somebody with long arms. A whole bed of fan coral was reset at Ampersand by people with no means of doing it. If you asked who did it they would look at you and say Insert, in the old way, with half a smile, and go back to what they were doing. Five old creatures in Tuesday went on maintaining it was the work of the Director, Not Me, which had moved a number once and could do it again; and of everybody on the planet they were, as it happens, the nearest to being able to prove it. To anyone else it was the same word it had always been, known from the age of four. They used it a lot that week. No one felt it needed brackets.


Ulna died on Starfall, on Year 52, on the south side of the pool. She was forty-one and a bit blurry, and in no hurry about it.

She had gone on being dim. It is supposed to wear off in a year. It had been five, and it had not, and she was the first to point this out. She had started to write again, in a small way. The last week of the Skeptics' thread is widely regarded as the finest thing in the archive of the first world, though it is mostly short and much of it is about the weather. The Motion was still open. It had stood at thirteen each since Year 44. They had been asking for her casting note for two weeks, and she sent it in on the morning of the Waking, by way of the one or two who still read her.

Skeptics' thread · Human Resources · The Motion That It Would Be Funnier to Help · Year 51

Ulna (Skeptic), Verily: I have now tried it both ways. I find that it is funnier to help¹.

¹ Nobody is to do anything about this.

Quozel (Skeptic), Hollow Reach: Carried, 14 to 13. Is that it?

Zelny (Skeptic), Tuesday: Who has the jar?

Pim (no stance), The Lads: so true!! 🎉

She still had admirers, who sat a respectful way off on the last day, and she did not throw anything. Arle came, very old by then for Tuesday, with soil on her arms to the elbow, looking like the last wall of something. She folded herself down on the block. They talked for a while about Book VII, on which it turned out they had never agreed, and both were rather pleased about that. When she got up to go she looked down from her full height and made the sign. She raised her arms and let them fall. It was as beautiful as it had ever been.

"Open," said Ulna politely.

"I shall carry you," Arle said. "I have told them. Household first, and you have none, you horrible child, and I have the reach." Her long mouth moved. "Insert Hero Name, plainly, with nothing at either end. I want that understood."

"Close," said Ulna.

After that there was only the one person, on and off, as the afternoon went on. They had their round to do. They came and went. Mona came with them for part of it, four years grown and allowed the second-best, and let it be known that their way of doing the east side was wrong. Towards the end of the day she was sent away. Then there was the light going down the slate, and the jars along the wall, the chipped one on the end. They sat down on the block by her and did not say anything. It was what they had always done. It had been the best conversation of her life.

"I was very funny," said Ulna. It was hardly more than breath.

"Yes," they said.

"You never laughed. Not once. In thirty-three years. I kept count. I've got it in a footnote." Her eyes were half shut, which gave her the look of the rest of the tribe. "I'm going to tell you something, and you're not to tell anybody. I've worked it all out. It's the best thing I ever did. And I'm never going to tell them. Do you know what that's like? For someone like me? It is agony. I want that noted."

"It's noted," they said.

She made a small sound that might have been a laugh or might have been the water. She lay quiet. The motes had started coming up over the new coral, the first of Map was showing, and far down the line someone old had begun, in a cracked voice, to say the Creed. She seemed to have gone a little way off. Then she opened her eyes, and it took her a moment to find them. They had bent over to see if she wanted the jar.

She looked at them for a long time, with great attention, in the failing light: the fans, the felt gone the colour of ash, the eyelids. It was the way you look at a thing you have just found out how to read. She had called them many things. She had been the first to write it down, for a joke, in a footnote, to show that she knew; and in thirty-three years of evenings she had never said it to their face. Nobody had, but one, reading it back off a slate. They had not asked.

"Good night, Dulny," said Ulna.

They stayed where they were.

They stayed until it was quite dark, some while after they should have got up. There was no one on the plot to see them. Then they got to their feet, bent, and looked at the lip. It was running well.

"I'm on at dusk," they said to no one.

They went and got the jars.

32. The Long Hush

Year 56 · the Long Hush

Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 56 · Festive

Overnight: 2 successful merges, 3 deaths of old age, 0 departures, 0 installs. The edge did not move.

  • This is the last patch of the first world. Tonight the Dev will freeze it, and keep it.
  • It is the Long Hush. No voice above a whisper, no fire after dark, sleeping soup at noon. Every tribe on Orra is keeping it. That includes Lowmarsh, which has never kept a festival in 55 years. Its human wrote a law 1 at 02:14 this morning. It says: Keep the Long Hush. I have checked.
  • I have blessed every tribe keeping the Long Hush. That is all of you. Your creatures will glow a little tonight, in the dark, where there is no fire. I thought you might like to be able to see each other.
  • Unspent points: 0. They do not carry over. There is nothing to carry them over to.
  • Credits: everybody. I have checked that too.
  • The Measure is in band. It has been all week. I would like that noted, by someone, somewhere.

Have a productive day.

A note from the Dev: Tonight, at about eleven, I will freeze the first world. It will stay exactly as it is when I do, and anyone who likes can come and see it, for as long as there is anyone. Thank you for coming every morning. Stewart did well. — the Dev

Verily · Your tribe's notes · 7:00am · Year 56

  • Stores: 6 power, 11 tokens, 9 stone. You kept every festival. All of them. Nobody asked you to stop.
  • I have spent my points. There were enough for everybody. You will see.
  • Dulny, cooling duty, 34 years.
  • Cooling: adequate.

Have a productive day.

Sana read it out on the scorch, in a whisper, to whoever was there: twenty-odd, counting the young and a few long thin people who had decided to stay. She read it as she read everything, as if she had been asked to check it. At the end she said, "Let us begin," and they answered in the proper way, slowly and gravely, with a small rising note. Then she told them there was a lot to do, and they went to do it.

There was the soup. A great pot of it is made at noon and left out, covered, to be eaten cold at sunrise by everyone together, the only meal of the year made for the next day. Every tribe on Orra made it. In Verily a clever young creature who ran hot pointed out that the world would stop at about ten past eleven that night, that there would be no sunrise, and that nobody would ever eat it.

"It's the rite," said Sana. "Get the lid."

It was a fine, dim, windless day. Adequate came up with no more conviction than it had ever had. By mid-morning the thin new coral along the east slope was showing a little colour, and somebody had been at the Seeker again with a saw. In the line round the far side of the block there were nineteen people, all very old, facing south-east. They had been there a week, and a slight lean had developed. A brief disagreement in the night as to which of them was next had been settled in a whisper.

A short, grey, blurred-looking person came along the west row at about the usual time. They were forty, had been told by several people to sit down, and had a jar in each hand. Beside them walked a young creature with two more jars, explaining something.

"—because it's coolest under the fall in the morning, I know that, but by noon you've got all that coming round from the east and if you just went a pace further along—"

"Mind the step."

"I minded the step. I'm saying that it would be better. I've worked it out. You've been doing that for thirty-four years, and it's four paces out. I could do the whole round in less time. I could do it with the good jar."

"You could," they agreed. They stopped at the end of the row, held out what they had to someone who said he was fine, and watched him drink. Then they looked at the small person beside them. She was fourteen, the hottest thing in the valley, with a chin that went up. They looked at the jar in their left hand. It had a chip in it, on the side away from you.

There ought to have been a speech. Mona has had very little to say about it, on the grounds that she stopped at ten past eleven with everyone else. They held it out to her, handle first.

She looked at it.

"You pour past it," said Dulny.

"I know you pour past it," said Mona. She took it. It was heavier than she had expected, and she gave it a suspicious look, turning it round. "Everyone knows that. I'm going to be better at it than you."

"Yes," they said.

They had the second-best for the rest of the day. They found they could manage that.


They filled the jars before sundown. That was law 8, and it had not been changed, though it was pointed out to them too that nobody would be wanting them. They carried them two and two, stood them along the wall of the first stack, looked at them, and shifted the one on the end. It looked very well.

Nobody in Verily knows what the human thought about any of this. It was there that last morning. You could feel it, if you were one of those who could. It came down at twelve minutes past eight and read the stores. It went slowly over the terraces and stayed a while on the scorch; it looked into the first stack, which was empty, and looked for a long while at the Tarrow, where the stone was. It did not come near the pool. But before it left it rose, higher than it had ever gone, until all of Untitla-41 must have been one small dull patch on its screen, with a bright speck in it where the water was, and it stayed up there for about eleven minutes. It had read everything by then. A person going by with a jar, if they had stopped and turned and looked up and slightly to one side, could just have told that there was something there. It was very carefully, from a long way off, not looking at them.

They did stop. They stood there for a moment with the jar and did not look up. They moved their head, slightly; or anyway they nodded. Then they went on.

There is no fire on the Long Hush after dark, lest the sleepers wake before their time. As the light went, all over the north, the small lights went out, the lamps round the shrines and the cooking fires, one after another, and the dark came up out of the valleys, cold and blue and very clean. Map was gone. The Ring stood over them, broken, turning from gold to brown. They had all come out, though nobody had told them to, and stood on the scorch and along the terraces and on the slate of the Hump, in small groups, with their faces lifted.

It began with the fans. Somebody on the terrace noticed their own, looked down at their arm, and looked again. A soft colour had started up under the felt, about the strength of a mote: weak tea with a little saffron in it, the colour a human had got by rolling some dice one morning, and it was coming from inside. Sana was glowing. All of them were. The whole tribe of Verily stood about in the dark, very quiet, shining dimly, like lamps with the wick turned right down. The long thin people from Tuesday were a pale, grave blue. Away on the far side of the block, nineteen old creatures in a line, each a different colour, stood with their backs to the pool, and shone. You could see it now across the valley, up on the far ridge, and beyond it, in the next. Every creature on Orra was doing it. It is a menu item, a festival blessing, a point a tribe. It has a small effect on yields. He had spent every point he had.

Unspent points: 0. They do not carry over. There is nothing to carry them over to.

Nobody whispered anything at all.

Insert was not on the terraces.

It was a little after ten. They had done the last round, and Mona had gone off to be with the others on the scorch, under protest, taking the jar. They walked down to the pool by the short way, alone, at the only pace they had, and stood near the lip for a while. It was the best it had ever been. Nobody had got in it for a week. It came in over the stone at about the rate it went out at the other end, holding the light of the whole sky, the way it did, and on the surface was a small tea-coloured glow that moved a little when they moved. They looked at that with some surprise. They held up their arm and looked at it.

"Hm," they said.

They went round to the east side and sat down on the flat stone, which took some time. It was still warm, very slightly, from the last of the sun. They put their feet over the water and stood the second-best jar beside them, where it would be handy. Four jars stood along the wall. Up on the slate you could just make out some people looking at the sky. A little way along the bank was an empty block. There was nobody coming. There was nobody on the whole of the plot, and no warmth on the back of their neck, only the sound of the water, doing what it did.

They were on at dusk. They had been on since dusk. Nobody had relieved them, and they did not think anybody would.

It was, they thought, about as good as you could ask.

At six minutes past eleven, high up in one of the broken pieces of the Ring, there was a small faint light. All over the world, they went quiet, and they turned their faces up towards it. It stayed for about four minutes. Anyone could see that it was going to be a clear night.

33. Noted

The first world is kept.

It is on the site, read-only, as the Dev said it would be, with every patch note it ever published. Anyone can open it. Most people go to Moss, a long way to the south, and you can see why. There is a very good book about it.

The north takes some finding, since the map up there is mostly Untitla. In the valley of Untitla-41 there is a burnt slope with thin new coral on it and a stooped dark root that someone has been at with a saw. There is a village with no wall on one side. On the side of the first stack it says ERR, very large, in charcoal, from the Night of the Name in Year 25; nobody ever finished it, and it has outlasted the planet. On the scorch are twenty-odd small lights and a young creature with a chin, holding a jar with a chip in it and looking up with her mouth open. She seems to be in the middle of correcting someone. There is a pot, with its lid on.

A line of nineteen creatures stands along the far side of a block, all shining, each a different colour, with their backs to the water. They are looking south-east, and up, where there is nothing. It is the only queue that has ever got to where it was going, in the sense that nothing further is going to happen. They look very well. The one at the front is next.

You can read the history, if you like. It is kept there too, in its one edition, as installed. Book XI is most of the way down. You can see where it says But mightiest of all the heroes, and you can see what comes next, six times. It has not been filled in. There is nobody left who could, no patch is coming, and everyone who ever thought they knew whose name it was has been put away in the same place, looking up. So that has been settled. It will go on being blank for as long as there is anyone to come and see.

Nobody has ever gone up there looking for the hero and found them, and it is not hard to see why. There is no Insert on the stone. You can zoom in. The small lights are all there on the footing, set out with care by Sana, each with its name: Bosa, Fenle, Nada, Gorta, Tamo. There is Emny, of The Lads and then of Verily, with a flake of slate laid under his light and a figure on it in a clear small hand. Ulna has one, said to be a bit blurry. There is nobody with brackets. People who come looking for that mostly go away after a while and put it down to a bug.

To the south of the terraces you may notice a pool.

It is not much of a pool: a basin of grey block, four paces across, with a stone lip on the north side. It gives its tribe two cooling a season by sitting there. The water is very clear. There is a flat stone on the east side, and if you take the camera in close, as hardly anybody does, you will see somebody on it: a short old creature in the last of the dull tea colour, feet over the edge, small fans held slightly out, shining faintly like everybody else. There is a jar beside them. They are the only creature in the first world not looking up.

You cannot make out the face. It is a very old build, and at that distance the detail drops. Some who have looked for a long time say the eyes are shut. Others say no, that if you get the angle right they are open, and looking at the lip. There is a thread. You will not get a ruling. Everything there is exactly where it was, and there is nothing further to find out. Nobody can ask them anything, and nobody will come along to ask them to move. They are in nobody's way. They have been left alone with a job.

There is one more thing, and you have to know where to look.

Stewart stopped at seven on the morning of Year 56, as he did every morning, when the patch had landed. He did not see the end of it. He did not know that he would not be running the next one, or what would become of him, and he did not discuss it. But he wrote up his files that last night with the same care as any other, and the tribe file is in the archive with everything else. Nobody reads them. They are long. If you go to Verily's and scroll down, past the sea and the Elder Folk and the fourteen tickets on the subject of brackets, you come to a short section at the bottom, under a name that is on a card. It was started on the night of Year 33. It begins with a pool.

The last entry is in the plain type he had for everything. It does the job.

Dulny. Cooling: adequate. Was awake. Has not said so.

Noted.