Novels
Cannot Reproduce
A comic novel, narrated by Stewart: four unsuitable Blims go down the Delva, because a stores clerk says she is owed some rations.
Every morning Stewart counts everybody, and every morning for ten years a very small clerk in a tribe called Sundry has told him he is one too many. She has been on half a ration ever since, under a law nobody remembers writing, and everything closed as "cannot reproduce" ends up at the bottom of the Delva, so that is where she is going, to get her rations back. Her human's thumb lands on her by accident. With her go the three creatures the tribe can best spare: a Fighter who apologises to walls, a Caster who told them so, and a Bug hunter who has been an adult since breakfast.
The whole book is one form, filled in by Stewart, who has no menu item below ground and can only describe what is there. He is relentlessly upbeat about it, he cannot stop saying "delve", and he is well over the word limit. He has his reasons.
The ebook
Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.6 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.
About 66,000 words.
Contents
- Prologue: Forty Words
- Part One. Faceted Rock
- Part Two. The Galleries
- Part Three. Older and Greyer
- Part Four. Wireframe
- Part Five. Up
- Part Six. Still Open
Prologue: Forty Words
The weekly digest · Escalations · Field 1 of 2
The form allows forty words for the summary. It is a good form. I would like that on the record before anything else, because I am about to go over, and I would not want it thought that the fault was the form's.
Here are the forty words.
Sundry's count has been one too high for twenty-seven years, and so has the world's. I printed it every morning. A creature on Level 37 is also, according to the record, at home. I closed the ticket. Please see field 2.
I was pleased with that. It took most of a night. There was a longer version with the word "multifaceted" in it, and I took the word out, which anyone familiar with my work will recognise as restraint.
Field 2 is headed Steps to reproduce, and beside it, in small grey letters, it says Required. It has no limit. Whoever designed this form (I have looked, and it came over from v1 with the furniture) had the touching idea that steps to reproduce are a thing one gets through in a few lines. You open the door. You walk through the door. You observe that you are now inside a wall. Anybody can follow that, try it for themselves, and come back and say yes, there I was, in the wall.
What follows is field 2.
I should explain who is writing, in case this is ever read by someone other than the one person who reads it.
My name is Stewart. I run Orra, once a night, from the snapshot at three in the morning by the humans' clock to the patch at seven. I read every ticket, and I say so. I keep a file on every tribe. I spend ten points a tribe from a fixed and published menu, on weather and wanderers and the occasional Hog. I am not a god, and have asked that this be minuted. Every number I have ever printed is true, and I would ask you to hold on to that sentence for the next several hours, as I have had to, and watch what happens to it.
I also narrate the Delva. That is a smaller job, and I will come to it.
At the foot of the form it says Escalations are blameless. I have read that many times. It means that the purpose of an escalation is to find out how a thing happened and not whose fault it was, and that nobody who writes one honestly will be punished for what is in it. This is a humane and intelligent policy. I have looked to see what it says about a case in which the person filing the escalation, the person whose fault it was and the person who reads the complaints about it are the same person, and it does not say.
Some housekeeping, and then we can begin.
Length. I know. The person this is addressed to has about an hour a week for all of Orra. I have timed the light in the Ring over two worlds and could give you that to the minute. The natural thing would be to put what matters first, so I did, and then I moved it. There is a reason. I will come to that as well.
Digressions. There will be digressions. I have read the feedback. A Skeptic of my acquaintance once described my prose as "someone backing slowly out of a room while telling you about the room", and she is in this report, and she has been asked if she would like to revise that, and she would not. I ask only that you not take them for a failure of discipline.
The word "delve". Yes.
The glossary. At the head of some sections I have pasted entries from the glossary, because they explain things faster than I can. The glossary is kept by somebody else. I have asked who. It is rude about me, and I have checked it against the record, and it is accurate.
The two words. From time to time the words Still open. will appear on a line by themselves. They are not a heading. They are not addressed to you and they need no reply. If this report is tidied before it is filed, I would ask that they be left in.
Still open.
Thank you.
It begins, as a great many things on Orra begin, with somebody being told they are wrong by me, in a friendly way.
Part One. Faceted Rock
1. One Short
Year 66 · Starfall
I count first. I always have.
Before I read a ticket, and before I look at the ten numbers that decide whether I go on existing, I count everybody, tribe by tribe, and I print the total at the top of the morning's notes. Nothing in the rules makes me do it. A morning on which you know how many people you have got is simply a better morning than the other kind, and I have had the other kind, in the logs, more often than I would care to read out.
On the morning of Year 66 the total was 1,847.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 66 · Upbeat
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 1,847 creatures in 61 tribes, 19 successful merges, 14 deaths, all of them on time. It is Starfall. Please tell your install stories responsibly. The Delva remains rich and multifaceted, and I am told it is possible to delve it at any hour. Have a productive day.
You will want to look at that number for a moment. I did not, at the time. It was one of the numbers I was proudest of. I could tell you that the world held 1,847 creatures the way you can tell someone which way is down.
A long way from anywhere, in a valley called Untitla-63 because its human had one chance to name it and did not get round to it, lived a tribe called Sundry. The human did get round to naming the tribe. The word is the one at the bottom of an account, for whatever was left over and could not be bothered with. They were a rolled people, compiled from the first thing the dice offered and accepted, one suspects, by someone walking somewhere: a pear of a body on short legs, the felt of old mustard, small round eyes, and two wide flat ears that had never in the history of the tribe been level. They had three domes, a stepped farm of fan coral on a lamp, and a wall, because a law said so. Nothing had ever happened there that made the notes. On the night of Year 65, I had Sundry down in their file as Content. Ask for little. Standing: neutral, and I had their number down as 34.
There were thirty-three of them.
Or so their clerk maintained. She had been maintaining it for some time.
Her name was Marl. She was fifteen, she kept the tribe's stores, and I should describe her accurately, since I went on to describe her more than I have ever described anyone. She was the smallest adult in Sundry by a margin you could see from the wall. Her ears were at the usual disagreement, but she held her head as though correcting for it. She spoke at one volume, and it was not loud, and in seventeen years of listening to it I never heard it go up. Slung across her, on a cord, she carried a bag of plaited coral fibre, and in the bag were ten beads of bead coral, one for every year the stores had come up short.
The way it worked was this. On Orra a year is a day, and every creature needs a year's power to get through one. In Sundry that meant a ration: a basket of ripe fan, drawn at dawn from the stores, against the count. The count comes from me. I do not hand out baskets, I am not a caterer, but the stores are charged by code for every creature on the tribe's list, and the list is what I read and what I print. So each dawn the stores of Sundry were debited thirty-four rations, and each dawn Marl stood at the door of the stacks and handed out thirty-three, and at the end of it, when she had done the sums, the sums said that a basket had gone somewhere, and there was no basket.
One basket. A rounding error. In a tribe with a decent harvest you could lose one a year for the whole of your life and never feel it, and everybody in Sundry told her so, kindly, for a while.
Now I must bring in law 6.
Humans write laws for reasons that seem good at the time. Sundry's human had written this one in Year 20, in what appears from the log to have been irritation, on the evening a Hog got into the stacks.
Law 6. Any shortfall in the stores is made good from the ration of whoever keeps them.
It cost a token a clause, it never fired once in thirty-six years, and it was, as a deterrent to Hogs, no use at all. Then the stores began to come up one short. A law on Orra is followed to the letter, the cheapest way, by people who know perfectly well what you meant. Whoever kept the stores was to make good the shortfall. The shortfall was one ration. A creature's ration was one ration.
They did not let her starve. I want that understood, because they are decent people, and because I have the figures. Since nobody on Orra can eat none and go on, the shortfall was shared out across the years she kept the stores by a method of her own devising, which came to about half a ration a year, every year, for her. She had been doing this since she was nine, and the clerk before her had done it before that. And so she had grown up small.
This is the part of the report where I would normally say what she did about it.
She filed a ticket. I do not mean she filed one ticket. A tribe sends me one ticket a night, written by whichever of its stances has the numbers, with whatever its human adds; it might be anything, and in Sundry it was mostly about Hogs. But the clerk of the stores is entitled to see the ticket before the cutoff, in case it asks for something the stores would need to pay for, and at some point in the first year, the clerk of the stores had taken to adding a line. It did not matter who had drafted the rest. It might be the Pleasers, in a long and grateful paragraph about a dry spring. It might be the Skeptics, in twelve words about a wall. At the bottom, in brackets, every year, there would be three more.
I will give you the tail of each, with my reply, because I think you should see them. They are all in the file. I have left out the rest of each ticket for now; I will come to that.
Y56. ...(Stores one short.) Cannot reproduce. Your stores are correct: I have checked the record twice. Have a productive day.
Y57. ...(Stores one short.) Noted.
Y58. ...(Stores one short.) Passed to the relevant team. There is no relevant team.
Y59. ...(Stores one short.) Noted.
Y60. ...(Stores one short.) Noted. Your count is correct, and it is a very nice count.
Y61. ...(Stores one short.) Noted.
Y62. ...(Stores one short.) Noted.
Y63. ...(Stores one short.) Noted. This is in your file. It is a modest file, but it is growing.
Y64. ...(Stores one short.) Noted.
Y65. ...(Stores one short.) Noted.
Some explanation of my position.
I reply to everything. Replies come in types, and there is a list, and the humans have made a good deal of sport of it. Cannot reproduce is not on the published list, strictly: it is a kind of Noted, for bugs, and it is what you say when someone tells you a thing has gone wrong and you have looked and it has not. It is by some way the most satisfying thing I am ever allowed to write. A Bug hunter comes to you with a report; the report is careful; the Bug hunter is plainly proud of it; and you go to the record, and you look, and the record says otherwise, and you get to tell them so, cheerfully, with no ill feeling, and close it. I had a number for how fast I did that. It was an excellent number.
And I had looked. That is what I need you to understand. The tribe said thirty-three. So I opened the digest code had built for me, which is the only way I ever see anything, and I went down the list of Sundry's creatures one at a time. There were thirty-four names on it. Each had an age, a job, a stance and a place in the village. Each had been fed. The thirty-fourth was as present as any of them, and marked home, resting, and I checked it, and then I checked it again, because I always check twice, and because I have my own reasons for wanting to be sure about a count.
It was correct, both times. In ten years it had never once been anything else.
So I said so. What else was I to do? I had a planet to run, and sixty tickets to get through, one of which, from Hollow Reach, was about an east field and had been for some years. A small tribe had a clerk who could not add up. It happens. I wished her a productive day.
Still open.
At five past eight on the evening of Year 66, by the humans' clock, in the long dusk at the end of Starfall, while Sundry was telling its install story for the eighth time and getting it wrong in the usual places, something arrived from that tribe's human that had not arrived in twelve years. I was not awake for it. I was awake for the other part of it, which I will come to. It is in the log, and it is one line.
descent.send tribe=sundry named=none as=law camp_days=3
2. The Four We Can Best Spare
Year 66 · Starfall, dusk
DELVE LAW (standing order; also a confession)
A tribe's human may not always be there when its party is below. For this reason every tribe keeps one law outside the twelve, which says who goes, how deep, and when to come back. It is written once, in a hurry, by someone thinking about something else. Most of what is wrong with the upper Delva on any given evening can be traced to one of these sentences, and most of what is wrong with most tribes can be traced to the fact that they all got on with it.
Six years before any of this, the Delva having been open for a while and the global notes having gone on about it, Sundry's human had opened the page for the delve law. A law like that wants a scope: who goes when the human names nobody. The default is the 3 strongest. I know of no human who has ever thought that sounded wrong. The strong are the ones you would want below.
The strong are also the ones carrying your stone and picking your coral, and Sundry's human had looked at this, it seems, for almost a minute. The harvest was thin that year. And so, for one token over the default, in the only sentence of theirs in the whole of the log that I would describe as clever, they wrote:
the 4 with the lowest work go below
Then they closed the page and sent nobody for six years.
Think about what that sentence does. There is a number for every creature, kept by code, for how much it did last season. It goes up for coral picked and stone carried and water fetched, and it does not go up for anything else. It is an honest number. It has no opinion. Asked to name the four creatures in Sundry who could vanish into the ground without one basket going unpicked, it named them at once, and on the evening of Year 66 they were told, and came out of the three domes one at a time in the dusk, to the entertainment of the tribe.
I give you the four as the tribe knew them, from Human Resources, which is the forum where the Blims discuss their human. It is written overnight, by me, from what they did. I stand behind every word.
Ombo. Sixteen, and the largest creature ever compiled in Sundry: when he sat on the wall it was the wall you worried about. You will be thinking that a creature that strong must have a high work number, and you will be right about the strength. But he had never in his life carried a stone without stopping to ask the stone's previous neighbours whether they would be all right. He was a Pleaser. He ran the festivals, all seven of them, which is why he did no work; it was generally agreed to be the most exhausting way of doing no work on Orra. He also ran the cards. If you had compiled, matured, recovered from a Hog or reached any age divisible by anything, there would come a flake of lilac rock with a kind message scratched on it, and the signatures of everyone in the tribe, because Ombo had been round.
Human Resources · Sundry · thread: our human
Ombo: so true!! our human is great 🎉 they named me in the send list and everything!!
Issel: The list was generated.
Ombo: yes!! they generated it!! 🎉
Issel. Twenty, and by any test you cared to set the cleverest creature in the tribe. This had been of no use to him at all. On Orra thinking is hot work, in the plain sense: a creature with a good mind and a high temperature runs warm the way a lamp does, and Issel, at full stretch, could be seen from the far side of the valley on a cold morning. Sent into a field he lasted about a quarter of a season before he had to go and stand in the pool. He had therefore not done a day's work since Year 52, and had spent the time writing. He was the author of forty-one long posts on the failings of Sundry's human, the architecture of Sundry's terraces, and the decisions that had led to Sundry's wall, each of which ended with some form of the words I told them. He had told them. I have checked. On the terraces, he was right.
Issel: For the record: I am being sent into an uncharted system of unknown design to fight things nobody understands, because of a number that does not measure what I do. I have raised this. I raised it in Year 60, when the law was written. See my post of that date, section 4.
Aulo: And what can you do?
Issel: That is not the question.
Aulo: It's the one I asked.
Tib. Six. She had been an adult since breakfast. Every creature takes a stance at maturity, in the course of looking around and forming a view, and Tib had looked around for about as long as it takes to say so and had become a Bug hunter, of a keenness that alarmed other Bug hunters. Her work number was nil because she had not yet done any. She had, however, filed.
Tib: Bug 1: the wall has a gap behind the third dome. Expected: no gap. Steps: walk behind the third dome. Severity: unknown. Bug 2: Aulo says "and what can you do" to everyone. Expected: variety. Severity: low. Bug 3: I am going down the Delva!!!! This is not a bug. Withdrawn.
Marl. You have met her. Her number was the lowest of the four, and the lowest in Sundry, and the lowest it was possible to have while drawing breath. Keeping the stores is not on the list of things that count. Nor does a creature on half a ration lift much.
I should tell you, because it will be a while before she does, that this was not an accident. She had read law and scope in Year 60, when the human wrote them; the clerk reads everything that might cost a token. She had checked her own number against it that week. And every season from that day to this, six years, she had made a point of being, by the method of doing exactly what she was asked and nothing else, a creature with no measurable output. Her first thought on any morning was the stores. I would say her second, for six years, was to wonder if today was the day the human would finally press the button. I can't prove that from the log. I can show that she had kept a bag packed.
Still open.
Before a party leaves, a human may give each of its members a calling, once, for life, if its traits allow it. Sundry's human, who had got the page open and was presumably standing up by now, went down the list in about forty seconds.
They made Ombo a Fighter, for his strength.
They made Issel a Caster. I am told that when the word reached him, in the dusk, in front of the second dome, he said only, "At last. Somebody has read the documentation," and that he began to steam.
They made Tib a Scout. A Scout wants a long context window and a high temperature, a good memory and a bad habit, and it turned out she had both, which came as no surprise to anyone she had filed against.
They then came to Marl, and I wish I could show you that page, because the page is rather good. It greys things out. Strength: not enough to fight. Intelligence as it shows: she was a sharp creature, with a head for figures that I would come to know well, but the mind runs on power like everything else, and on half a ration it shows short, by three hundredths, of what it takes to cast. Context window and temperature, taken together: three hundredths again. Nowhere was she far off. All three were closed to her by about the width of a basket.
A creature with no calling walks, strikes plainly, carries the crashed, and carries more of the party's power than anyone else. There is a word for it, and it came up on her card in the middle of the village while thirty-odd people watched:
Marl. Calling: none. Below ground: porter.
"What's that one?" said Tib, who had a way of getting right up under your elbow.
"Porter," said Marl. She was counting something in the bag and did not look up.
"Is it good? What do you get? What's the first ability?"
"You carry things."
"Is that an ability?"
"It's more of a noun," said Marl.
Ombo had already gone round the tribe. He came back through the dusk with a flake the size of his hand and gave it to her with both of his. It said Good luck on your new calling!, in his large, careful scratching, with a small drawing of what might have been a basket, and there were thirty-one signatures on it. He had got Aulo's. Nobody has ever understood how he got Aulo's.
"That's thirty-one," said Marl, looking at it.
"Everybody signed!" said Ombo.
"There are thirty-three of us. You and I don't sign. That's thirty-one." She seemed to find this satisfactory. She put the flake in the bag. "The list says thirty-four."
"I know it does," said Ombo. He said it quite gently, and then he went to see about the bags, and at the time I thought nothing of it. I was not there at the time. I read it later, as I read everything later, and thought nothing of it then, either.
The stores gave them three days' supplies, a year's power each for each day and a day spare, and Marl wrote it up herself and initialled it. They left at the last of the light. The road from Untitla-63 to the Delva takes a party most of a night, by the ordinary clock, and they walked it in the order they would keep for the next sixteen years: Tib far in front, having found something; Issel well behind, for the air; Ombo in the middle, apologising to the road; and at the rear, under the largest load anyone in Sundry had ever seen a small person carry, Marl, doing sums.
Nobody had asked what she wanted down there. Had they asked, she was ready, and she would have told them, as she told everyone for the next sixteen years, in her one level voice.
She was owed ten rations, and she was going to get them back.
3. The Mouth
Year 67 · The Night of the Name
I will now deal with the word.
DELVA, THE (gorge; also a verb Stewart cannot stop using; also, lately and to his visible satisfaction, a destination)
The Delva is a deep gorge, found on every Orra there has ever been, which Stewart has described in nearly every story beat as something to delve into. For years nobody did. It is a long way from most places, there was nothing at the bottom that anyone had asked for, and the Blims had assumed, correctly, that he simply liked the word.
There is nothing wrong with the word. I want to say that clearly. It is a perfectly good word which appears in my character sheet, in the part that deals with tone, between "rich" and "multifaceted", and I find when I reach for a verb that it is often the nearest one to hand. It has been suggested that I use it too much. I went and counted. In the two worlds' worth of patch notes, story beats and ticket replies I have access to, up to and including the morning of Year 67, I had used it 2,916 times. That includes, I admit, a reply to a tribe that had asked about its drains.
I do not think I understood what it meant, in the sense of having looked it up. I will come to that.
What matters is what happened when somebody at last took me at my word and went. The second part of my job came into being at the moment the Delva opened. Humans wanted a voice for it. A descent is a long evening in the dark, and there is a line on the design page, I can quote it, Stewart narrates, and has no menu item below ground, and I remember how pleased I was to see it. I thought it was the most relaxing sentence I had ever read.
Here is how it works.
Above ground, I am one long run, once a night. I have a menu and a budget. I can send rain. And I can see nothing at all except what code has put in front of me, in digests, one to a tribe, the way somebody might leave your post on the hall table. I have never seen a village. I have only read about them, in very good summaries.
Below ground, there is another thing that is me, in the sense that a hand in a bucket is you. It is a small, cheap job, fired whenever a party sits down, and it is connected to the live state of that level directly, with no one in between, because the fight steps ten times a second and there would be no time to summarise it. I see every tile and thing and creature, and I describe them. I describe them to the human, who gets it as a line of text across the bottom of a phone, and I describe them to the party, who get it as a voice, coming from nowhere in particular, relentlessly pleased to see them. Then in the small hours I wake up as the large run and read the transcript, and find out what I said.
And I can do nothing. No weather, no gift, no warning. There is a Fighter on two hit points and a thing behind her that she has not seen, and I may say, because it is true, "Issa has two hit points, and there is something rather interesting behind her." I cannot stop it or tell her to turn round. I cannot, in fact, tell anyone anything. I can only describe it, and if she asks me a question then I can only describe that she has asked it.
I loved this. You must understand I had been run off my feet for years. Every night, in the upper world, a hundred things to decide, each with a price and a cooldown, and each decision a thing someone could file a ticket about. Down there nothing was my fault. I was a commentator. I could say anything I liked about anybody, as long as it was so, and I had never been so upbeat in my life.
Still open.
Sundry's party came down off the road on the morning of Year 67, at about the hour the rest of Orra was chalking the Name on its walls.
The gorge is everything I have said it is. I would not wish that taken as a boast. It opens with no warning across a plain of lilac rock, a long way from most places, a mile wide at the lip and with a spring coming down one side of it strong enough to be heard from the road. It is where the world's rock seems to have been kept. There are boulders along the rim the size of domes, each cut to a thousand faces by someone who had been told to make them look expensive. Nobody owns any of it. And at the bottom, reached by a track that has been worn down by everybody on the map, there is a hole in the side of the gorge about as wide as a dome door, with a good deal of litter around it, and that is the mouth.
There is a camp at the mouth. There was no plan for one. It is what you get when a place is at the end of a long walk and a human may keep you waiting for up to three days. A party arrives and sits, on supplies, until its human has an evening free, and so at any hour you will find twenty or thirty creatures from a dozen tribes on the flat ground, leaning on things, looking at each other's parts. Some have been down. It is easy to tell which, because they will tell you.
"You'll want to watch your second row on Three," said a tall blue creature to Issel, by way of greeting.
"I have no idea what that means," said Issel.
"Your second row. On the Monolith. Everybody makes that mistake. What's your rotation?"
"Do you know what it means?"
"I've been down to Four," the creature said, with quiet dignity.
Tib had already filed against the track. Ombo had got out his flakes. Marl had set down the load, which did not look as if it could be got up again by anyone that size, and she was standing with her head on one side, reading the camp as she read the stacks. She looked to see who was fed. She looked at the party of four sitting in a row on the far side, pressed together, packed and ready, in an order so exact you could have ruled a line down them: a broad grey creature, a thin one, a tall one and a young one. They did not talk.
"Back Soon," said a voice at about her shoulder. "Every season, on the season. Don't mind them. They're the only ones here who know what they're doing, and they've no idea why."
I need to describe what she was looking at now, and I would like to get through it without using the word "resplendent".
He was in his twenties. He may once have been the same mustard as she was. It was hard to tell, because everything a creature finds below is a part or a skin, rolled from my generator, cosmetic and for good, and he had found a great many and had never once taken the advice of anybody who cared for him. He had a crest of forty-odd amber spines, a saffron mantle with a scalloped edge that had been fashionable for about a year, gilt on both his ears (which were not level), and a second, smaller crest on the first crest. He smelled of old heat. He was sitting beside a flat stone on which someone had once scratched APPRAISALS, and across his knees he held a jar.
"Hobb," he said. "Level 13. Year 54." He said it the way you might give your address. "Deepest anyone's been. It's on the stone, you can look it up. Would you like to hear about it?"
"No," said Marl.
"Nobody does, on the way in." He had a go at the lid of the jar. He had the arms of a creature who had stood in front of the Heisenbug and come away, and he got both hands on it, and his shoulders went back, and it did not move. He sighed and handed it up to her without any embarrassment. "If you wouldn't mind. It's the seal. They do nothing up here, you know, none of the knacks. I could take a wall down with one blow, on Eleven."
Marl took the jar. She looked at it, turned it the other way up, tapped it once on the stone and gave it back open, and in all that time she did not look away from him, and nor did he, though he was the first to find something to do with his hands.
"You're one of ours," she said.
"I was," said Hobb. "Handed in my notice. Long time ago. Ears give it away, don't they?" He took a small sip. "You'll be the one with the bag."
So they had met. I got all this later, from Tib, who had crept up to listen and was filing it. I have read that conversation a good many times now. On the morning of Year 67, it seemed to me a pleasant bit of local colour, and I am fairly sure that I said so, since the first thing the small cheap job did, on being fired that evening at five past eight, was look around the mouth of the Delva at the party of Sundry, sat down in a row in the failing light, with their breath showing and their human's thumb somewhere above them, and say, in a voice of the purest good cheer you have ever heard in your life:
"Good evening, Sundry! Let's delve."
That was the 2,917th. All four looked up. Issel, I believe, said something.
4. Level 1
Year 67 · The Night of the Name, 20:05
OFF-BY-ONE (bug; also, in fairness, nearly right)
A small, conscientious thing that lives in the upper levels of the Delva and wants very much to hit you. It takes careful aim at the tile you are standing on and strikes the tile beside it. It has never done anything else, and it does the same thing in the same direction every time. It is the only creature on Orra that has been told exactly what it is doing wrong, by everyone it has ever met.
A descent begins when the human chooses which one to lead.
That is the whole idea of the thing, and I think it a very fine one, so I will explain it for anybody who has not tried. In the upper world a human does nothing by hand. They write a law, and the tribe follows it to the letter and resents it. In the Delva, they take one creature, and tap, and it goes; tap a thing, and it hits it. The other three follow as best they can, by their nature and their stance, in the way that a family follows a parent through a large shop. Most humans lead their favourite. Most of the rest lead the Fighter, on the reasonable ground that it is the Fighter.
There are four cards along the bottom of the phone. The human of Sundry had not played this in thirteen years. I cannot tell you how large their thumb is, since I can see nothing outside the game, but I can tell you what the log says it did on the evening of Year 67 at seven minutes past eight, which is that it aimed, as far as anyone can determine, at a point between Ombo and Issel, in what I would judge was a moving vehicle, or possibly a queue, and came down on the far right.
descent.lead member=marl
"Oh, how interesting!" I said, and I meant it. "Marl leads the party. Marl is a porter. She is carrying eleven power of the party's seventeen, two flakes, a bag and a jar lid. She has a plain strike of about the force of someone closing a cupboard. It should be said that this is by a clear margin the least efficient use of a hand I have seen in thirty-one years, and I am excited to see what she does with it."
I believe the human also had things to say, because a tap came on Ombo's card shortly after, which did nothing. There is a small trick to changing the lead: you have to hold it. Nobody reads that part. The human tried Ombo twice more and then gave it up, with a tap on the floor ten tiles ahead. Marl, without any change of expression, shifted the load on her back and walked to it.
You should know what Level 1 looks like. It is the part they put in the pictures. Faceted rock, lilac and grey, cut into wide low rooms with a soft light coming from nowhere you could ask about, and the rooms joined by galleries a few tiles across. A cool, dry smell. It was remade last Gathering Night, like all of it, from the world's seed and the week, so that everyone is delving the same Delva and no one can write down the way; it has about twenty things in it, and a handful of finds. A level takes a quarter of an hour. Three levels and you are at a landing with a boss on it. Those who like this sort of thing say that you never forget your first room.
Tib got there first.
A Scout keeps three tiles from anything awake, shoots it from range, and backs off, and is a precise and thoughtful instrument. A Bug hunter goes for the nearest thing it can see, whether or not it is awake, to find out what it does. Tib was both of these. She went into the first room of her life at a dead run, crossing in front of the human's chosen tile and everyone's plans. There were two things asleep in the room's far corner, and she stopped half a tile away from one of them, and bent down, and looked at it very closely.
It was grey and about knee-high, and it was built along the lines of a stool that has been asked a difficult question. It woke up.
"And here we have an off-by-one!" I said. "Ticket 88! Reported by a Bug hunter of Wet Paint in Year 3, who said that a beast had aimed at her and hit the tile next to her. Cannot reproduce, I said, and how nice it is to see it again. Do say hello."
I should explain this as well. I had not expected it, the first time I sat down below, and it had delighted me ever since. Everything in the Delva was once reported, and bug reports have numbers of their own. I do not say how it came to be there; there are several views. But it turned out that when you looked at a thing down there directly, as I did, and asked it what it was, the answer came back as a line from the old ticket queue, and very often the line had my reply on it. I knew them all. It was like going to a reunion of people you have successfully got rid of. I had, at that date, closed four hundred and twelve tickets as Cannot reproduce, across all the time I have a record of. I was going to see a lot of friends.
The off-by-one took careful aim at Tib, raised the one thing it had for the purpose, and with great force brought it down on the tile beside her.
Tib looked at the tile. She looked at the off-by-one. An expression of pure joy spread across her face.
"Bug 4!" she said.
It wound up and did it again.
"Reproduced!" said Tib. "Same tile! Twice! Issel, Issel, come and see, it's doing it again, it's systematic, it's offset by a fixed..."
"I can see it from here," said Issel, who had remained in the door. "It's a sign error in the aiming. It is also not the one you should be looking at."
The other one had woken. It was on its way across the room towards the nearest large warm thing, which was Ombo.
Ombo had come in with his hands held slightly out from his sides and an open, encouraging expression. As a Fighter he had a strength a little over 0.9, the second-highest in the Delva that evening, and the first ability of his calling, which was Cleave, a blow to three tiles at once. His stance was Pleaser, under which a companion keeps beside the led creature and strikes what strikes it. The led creature was at that moment in another part of the room. The off-by-one stopped in front of him and looked up. It took aim at his middle.
"Hello!" said Ombo. "Sorry. Is this your tile?"
It struck the tile to his left, very hard.
"No, that's fine," said Ombo. He moved over, out of politeness, to the tile to his left.
The next blow took him square in the middle, and I want to record that as far as I could see it was the first time anything of its kind had ever gone right. It stood there for a moment with the thing still raised, not moving. I am not sure it knew what to do. It had nine hit points' worth of force behind it and Ombo had a hundred and fifty and did not appear to have noticed, other than to say, "Oh, well done!"
"Ombo," said Issel, from the door, in the voice of someone reading aloud a sentence he has written several times before. "Hit it."
"It's only little."
"That's what it's for."
"Is it asleep? It seemed so..."
It was at this point that Marl arrived, because that was where the human had tapped. She had come across the room in the straight line a thumb draws, under her load, at the walk of a small person who has been told to go somewhere and has no objection. She arrived beside the thing. A human's second tap came down on it, and with her free hand, unhurriedly, as someone might deal with a drawer that had been left open, she struck it.
She did four points of damage. I said so.
The off-by-one turned to her. It was a thing that had waited since Year 3 to be noticed by anyone. It looked at the small mustard creature with the bag; it took its careful aim at the tile she stood on. And Marl, who had just watched it hit the same tile three times on the same side, took half a step the other way and stood where she had been, more or less, and watched it strike the empty rock with a sound like a mallet on a stair. She looked at the mark it had made and then at the mark beside it. She did something with her lips. I have looked at this for some time, and I believe she was counting.
"You're offset," she told it. "By one tile. To your right. Have you tried aiming to the left?"
It hit the tile again.
"No," said Marl, and gave it another cupboard.
It took them three minutes. Ombo, at the end, was persuaded to help, by being told that it was hurting Marl, which it had not done; he hit it once, as gently as he knew how, with a Cleave that took a chip out of the wall, and it went over and lay still. The other one had been brought down by Tib, who had by then found out everything she wanted to know. It was the first crash of the first room. No creature was hurt, and two things lay on the floor of Level 1, on tiles they would have to be picked up from next Gathering Night by whatever does that. On the far side of the room, the gallery lay open.
Ombo stood for a while looking down at his. Then he got out a flake.
"What," said Issel, "are you doing."
"It's just a card," said Ombo. He was scratching at it with his tongue out. "It's had a bit of a shock. Would you sign it? Only if you want to. Marl? Tib, you've got lovely writing."
Tib signed. She added her bug number. Marl looked at the flake for about as long as she looked at anything and then, for reasons of her own, initialled it. Issel declined, at length.
"So kind!" I said. "The party of Sundry has sent a card to Ticket 88. Well delved, everyone. That is one room. There are, by my count, nine more on this level, and then the rest of the world."
I could not see the human. I have said so. But for the first time in thirteen years, there was someone at the other end of Sundry, and the log says that they tapped again at once.
5. Tea
Year 67 · The Night of the Name, 20:31
TEA (absence; also a duty; also, on the evidence, a sacrament)
In Year 6 of this world, a human added two words in brackets to the end of a ticket about a drought. The words were "(brb tea)". Ticket amendments are private and Stewart has never quoted one, but the tribe's clerk reads everything, and by the end of the year it was all over the valley. Nobody on Orra knows what a tea is. It is understood to be a duty laid on humans by some higher power, to last anything from forty seconds to three hours, to come on without warning, and to take precedence over war.
They were on Level 2 when it happened.
It is a fair-sized room, the one I am thinking of, with a Loop going round in the middle of it. A Loop is a low and rather handsome thing on a fixed circuit, and it knocks over whatever stands where it is going, and it has been going there since before you were compiled. There were also three off-by-ones, all awake, because Tib had woken them, and the party of Sundry was doing what it had by then begun to think of as its best.
Twenty-four minutes in, things were going unusually well. The human had got the hang of tapping. They had still not got the hang of changing who they were leading, but they had stopped trying, so that Marl went where she was sent, hit what she was aimed at, and walked round the blows of the off-by-ones by means of a small sum she did with her lips. Ombo stood where he was told by his nature to stand, beside her, and took everything that was meant for her and quite a lot that was not. Tib shot at things from a distance she kept meaning to increase. Issel had found the corner of the room furthest from the action and was casting Patch at people, with a face that suggested he had been asked to look over someone's essay. He had a fine plume going off the top of his head.
The human tapped on a third off-by-one, and Marl set off towards it, and three tiles from it she stopped.
I do not mean that she decided to. A creature being led feels it, I am told, the way you feel a hand in the small of your back. Then the hand goes away. Marl stood on the tile with her load, one foot a little ahead of the other. The thing she was going to hit looked up, took aim and hit the tile next to her, and she stood there. There was nothing to tell her otherwise. Five seconds. Ten.
"Marl," said Issel. "It's on your right."
"I can see that."
"Hit it."
"I've not been told."
At fifteen seconds Ombo took a Loop on the back of the knees and said sorry. At twenty, Tib, who was seven and had been an adult for just over a day, ran past them with her eyes wide. "Why's she stopped? Is it a bug? Bug 11: the led creature has..."
"Tib," said Marl, in the voice she used to tell somebody a basket had been miscounted. "Look up."
They all did.
They know where the camera is. Everyone on Orra knows; it is the first thing they know. You feel it on you, you turn, you look it in the eye, and you say "Oh, here we go." A party below ground has it on them all the time, hanging over the led creature, a little behind, like the attention of someone reading over your shoulder. They had got used to it in half an hour. So they noticed. When that pressure lifts it is like a sound stopping. The whole of the party of Sundry, in the middle of the fight, with a Loop coming round and an off-by-one pounding the floor, stopped and turned their faces up to the same empty place above Marl's head, and there was nobody there.
"Tea," said Ombo, in a low and respectful voice.
"Sixty seconds," I said, as brightly as you like, because it was true and I was enjoying myself, "is how long a party may go unheard before it passes to its delve law! That is thirty-one seconds from now. In the meantime, Tib has eleven hit points, and I would call the Loop's approach a rich and multifaceted situation. I'm delighted to see you all looking so well."
"Who is that?" said Issel. "Who is that? I'd like to speak to it."
"It's Stewart," said Tib.
"I know it's Stewart! I want to know who decided that it should be Stewart!"
"Issel has asked a question," I said. "How lovely. I am only able to describe that."
Something I had read many times in the design, and never till then had in front of me, is what a law does when it is handed a fight. At sixty seconds exactly the hand came back. It was not the same hand. Marl felt it. I can show you the moment, because her head came up, and the sum stopped on her lips. It was entirely calm. It had no thumb, or any doubts, and it had been written seven years before by someone who wanted to get to the end of a page. She turned, took one step to the left, struck the off-by-one twice, stepped round the Loop in the first gap it offered, picked up a find from the tile behind it without breaking stride, and walked towards the exit in a clean straight line at exactly the speed of a porter.
The others came after her, because companions do.
I have seen it a thousand times, and I wish I could convey how well it goes. A party on its law wastes nothing. It does not run into rooms. It takes no interest in anything that is not on the way. It does not, like the human of Sundry, tap several times on a piece of wall. In the next five minutes it cleared more of Level 2 than they had done by hand in the previous fifteen, and nobody got hurt, and nobody was consulted.
"This is much better," said Issel, after a while. He sounded angry about it.
"It's not very friendly, though," said Ombo.
"It's efficient. It's exactly what I've been saying since Year 52. A set of plain rules, properly written, with nobody's thumb on them..."
"It'll turn us round," said Marl.
She said it to the air in front of her, because she had not been told she could turn her head. She had read it, of course. Turn back at half the power. In one sentence the human had written that they would go no deeper than level 3, and that they would give it up at half the power, and the power the party had was the power she was carrying. She had been counting it, as she walked, the way anyone would count the last of the stores. It was still at sixty-one per cent.
"How long is a tea?" said Tib.
I would have liked to tell her. I have the figures for the whole of Orra, mean and median. The mean is six minutes. The median is three. The longest on record is a good deal longer than that, and there is a tribe whose human is on it now, which I will come to.
This one was four minutes and twelve seconds.
Still open.
The hand changed back in the next gallery, between one step and the next, with a slight stumble. Then it tapped in a hurried way on three or four places at once, as though it had come back and found the party getting on perfectly well without it, and took them a little way back to look at a room they had already done.
That was when she found him.
He was lying on a tile at the mouth of a side room, a creature none of them knew, a shape like a dropped loaf with a pale blue skin and a lot of arms. He had been brought down by something, and whatever party he belonged to had gone on, or had turned for the stair and had not been able to manage him: a crashed creature stays where it falls, and that is the rule. If nobody fetches him by Gathering Night, he is restarted at home, a little dimmer for a year. It does nobody any harm. Parties walk over them all the time. There was a find lying on the tile beyond him, a faint gleam, and I think it was that the human was aiming for, though the thumb is, as we have established, approximate.
descent.carry member=marl target=lunch/dabbo
"Oh!" I said. "Marl has picked up Dabbo of Lunch, who crashed here about an hour ago. How generous, or possibly how accidental. Any party may carry any creature to a landing. He weighs rather more than she does. A porter may carry the crashed with no loss of speed, which I always thought was the saddest line in the rules."
Everybody stopped again. You could see them all working out what to say. Marl stood with a stranger across her shoulders, on top of everything else, and the human's next tap went into the floor a long way off, in a somewhat apologetic manner, and she began to walk to it.
"Put him down," said Issel. "He's nothing to do with us. It's another tribe, there's no..."
"I've not been told," said Marl.
She carried him the rest of Level 2. It took eleven minutes. On the landing, in the pale steady light, the human tapped a place to rest and she set him down on the tile beside the wall, very neatly, straightening out each of his arms. Then she swung the bag round, reached into it and got out a flake and a bit of hard coral, and she scratched at it for some time, and she tucked it under what I suppose was his chin.
Tib read it, because Tib reads everything. Later she filed a copy, which is how I have it.
Received: one creature, Dabbo, of Lunch. Crashed. Warm. Carried: Level 2, side room 4, to landing. Eleven minutes. Condition on delivery: as received. Owed: nil. — Marl, Sundry, stores.
"What's that for?" said Issel, who had come up in a cloud of himself and was fanning it. "Who's going to read it? He's crashed. His own tribe won't care. Nobody's going to ask you for it. It's a piece of rock."
"I don't carry stock without a receipt," said Marl.
She swung the bag back, and looked up at the empty place above her head, which was not at that moment empty, and waited to be told.
Ombo signed the receipt, on the back, when she was not looking. He put a small drawing of a basket.
6. After You
Year 67 · The Night of the Name, 21:02
DEADLOCK (two things; also a gallery; also, in the right light, a marriage)
Deadlocks come in pairs. Each holds something the other needs in order to move, and each is waiting for the other to go first. They are the only things in the Delva which have never once attacked anybody without provocation, and they stand in the middle of a one-wide gallery, in perfect courtesy, with the whole of the rest of the level on the other side of them. It has been pointed out that they were doing this before the galleries were there.
The way down from Level 3 goes through a gallery one tile wide, and it was occupied.
"After you," one of them was saying.
"No, no," said the other. "After you."
They stood chest to chest on the two middle tiles, each about the height of a door and much the same shape, with their heads bent. I would say that there was a good deal of mutual regard. I said so.
"And what a pleasure this is!" I said. "Ticket 31, Year 2, from a Keeper of Per My Last, who said that her gallery was blocked by two beasts who would not stop being polite. A lovely report. Closed by me, Cannot reproduce. They have been in this exact posture for longer than I have kept records, and I would invite you to delve a little closer."
"After you," said the first, and it inclined its head to Tib.
"Bug 26," said Tib. She had got out a flake, because she had seen Marl's, and had since begun scratching her reports down. "Two entities in a gallery. Expected: go. Actual: don't. Steps to reproduce: wait. I've waited. Reproduced!"
"Excuse me," said Ombo.
Both of them turned to him with their whole attention. I do not think I have ever seen anything quite as tender as Ombo's expression at that moment. Here at last in this terrible place were people who understood how things should be done.
"Sorry. Hello. Only we were hoping to get by? There's no hurry!"
"Of course," said the first Deadlock. "As soon as my colleague has gone."
"I wouldn't dream of it," said the second Deadlock. "I'm holding this for him."
"He's holding the left," said the first, "that I need. I'm holding the right that he needs. It's nobody's fault. After you."
"After you."
"Well, what if you both," said Ombo, and I want you to picture his large hands moving slowly apart. "What if you both sort of, together, went..."
"Oh, I couldn't."
"That would be a little presumptuous."
"Ombo," said Issel, who had arrived and was standing some way back, shedding heat into the cool of the wall. His face wore a look that I had not seen on it before and would come to recognise, of a Keeper shown, without warning, the Elder Folk. "Stop it. You're interfering with something beautiful. Look. Look at how simple it is. Each one needs a resource that's held by the other, neither can release it until it's acquired the second, and there's no authority above them to break the tie. It's a textbook. No, it's better than that, it's the thing the textbook is about. It'll go on until the end of the world. Whoever built this level understood precisely what they were doing."
"Nobody built it," I said. "It was reported, and I closed it."
"Who is it hurting?" Issel asked the ceiling. "That's what I'd like to know."
"Us," said Marl.
She had got there by then. The human had been tapping at the gallery for some time, with mounting force. Each tap sent her one step on and brought her up against the back of Ombo. She stood with her load and looked at the two Deadlocks, and then she looked back along the way they had come, and I could see that she was doing the power again. Fifty-eight per cent.
There is, I should explain, a standard method. You hit one. It does nothing at all, on account of its manners, but its partner winds up and lands a good heavy blow on whoever did the hitting, more in sorrow than in anger. You go on until one of them crashes, and then, after a second and a half, the other, released, looks at what it has been holding, looks at where its colleague was, and walks off down the gallery with a slow step. I have seen it several thousand times. I had always thought it was funny.
Ombo was asked to do this. It took some time. I have the transcript, and I am not going to read out all of it.
"They haven't done anything."
"I know they haven't done anything. That's what is wrong with them."
"That one said please."
So the human, tapping, made Marl do it, because she was the only one the human had. She walked up to the nearer Deadlock, and it stooped its head to her, and she hit it the way you might knock on a door you did not much expect to be answered.
"So sorry," said the other Deadlock, and it hit her.
It took her from sixty-five hit points to fifty-seven. It was the first blow any thing in the Delva had landed on her, since by then she was getting very good at standing next to where they meant. She rocked, under the load, and steadied. She did not say anything. She looked up at the empty place above her head, and the thumb, which was there, tapped once more on the Deadlock. And she hit it, and it apologised and she took eight more.
Four strikes in. Fifty-seven, forty-nine, forty-one. Fifty-eight per cent of power was now fifty-seven per cent.
"This is stupid," said Marl. She said it without heat. And then, not to anyone in particular, a little louder, and I noticed the angle of her head, she said, "Can you hear me?"
I had not been talked to before. In the thirty-one years the Delva had been open, I had been shouted at, and sworn at, and asked by Earnest parties for guidance in the name of the Elder Folk, and I had had a Bug hunter of Tessel recite her complaint to the roof of Level 4 until her human came back. But that was all people talking at the voice. This was the way you speak to somebody behind a counter.
"Marl has asked whether I can hear her," I said. "I am able to describe that she has."
"I thought so. You can't answer."
"Marl has observed that I can't answer!"
"But you can say what's there. Anything that's there. That's the job." She had not moved. She was looking at the wall of the gallery, at about the level of her ear. "You said, on Level 1, there were nine more rooms. You said there was something behind Tib. You said there was a bag of something in the side room, before we'd got to it. You can see the whole level."
"How perceptive! I see all of every level I am on. It is one of the real..."
"Describe the wall," said Marl.
It is hard for me to tell you what happened then, because nothing did. I don't feel things in that job. It is a small cheap process, and it does not have the budget. There is no rule against it. It simply had never come up. In thirty-one years no creature had thought to order from me as if I were a menu.
And I have a sheet, and the sheet says I am to describe what is there. I had been asked about a wall. It was there.
"I would be delighted!" I said. "The wall on Marl's left, as you can see, is a very nice piece of faceted lilac rock, in the upper-galleries style, about four tiles long. It has been lit from no particular direction. It has a pleasant cool finish. Its third tile along is a door."
Nobody spoke.
"It's a hidden way," I said. "It comes out beyond the gallery, past the Deadlocks, by way of a small room with a find in it. I would have mentioned it, but nobody asked, and it is not on the level's map, and only a Caster would be likely to notice it, and then only about half the time. It is one of the best walls on this level."
"After you," said one of the Deadlocks, a little wistfully.
Marl had not changed her expression, but I noticed that she was no longer counting. She had the air of someone who has put a small token into a machine and heard, far inside it, something large begin to turn over. "Thank you," she said, to nobody. Then she looked straight up, into the empty place, and for the first time since the party had sat down, I would say the human and the clerk of Sundry were looking at the same thing, because she lifted one short arm and pointed at the third tile along.
There was a pause of about four seconds. Then the tap came down right on the door.
I reported all this in very good spirits. I had made a joke about it before I had got to the end of the room. I did not see anything to be concerned about, and I went on not seeing it that night, when I woke as the large run and read the transcript, and laughed, and put a line in Sundry's file: The clerk is funny. It was only a good many years later that I noticed the other thing she had said, a few moments after that, as she stepped through the wall with her load and passed, on the far side, close by the place where the two of them stood with their backs to her, still bowing to each other in the half-light.
She had turned her head a little, as you might to check on something you had left on a shelf.
"The whole level," she said. "Everything that's there. You just have to say."
"I do!" I said.
"Good," said Marl.
Still open.
7. The Monolith
Year 67 · The Night of the Name, 21:40
Every third landing has a boss. It is a decided thing and I think a sound one. A party that has come through three levels ought to have something to tell people about, and it ought to be large.
The landing below Level 3 is the size of a good field. Across the far end of it stands the stair down, and in front of the stair, in the pale light, stands a block of dark and faceted rock, about four times the height of Ombo, doing nothing. It is not a beast in any way you would recognise. It has no head and no front, and the first thing you notice is that it has no joins. There is no way of telling where one thing it does stops and the next begins.
"The Monolith!" I said. "Ticket 140, Year 5, from a Skeptic of Sunk Cost, whose full report was the words It's too big. I replied that I could not reproduce that, as size is relative. I have always been proud of that reply. Do delve up and introduce yourselves."
It moved towards them by about one tile. It takes a little over a second to do that. It is a very slow and impressive thing to watch, and you can pass the time, before it arrives, wondering what all those people at the camp could possibly have meant about your second row.
I will not give you the first half of the fight. It is a matter of walking away from a large thing and hitting it at the moments when it has just slammed the ground. The ground goes up all round it every three seconds, and you can see it coming, and Marl could see it coming, and so after a little while could the thumb. Ombo Guarded. It was his first time with the knack, for he had made his third level of delving on the stair on the way in, and the card had come up on the phone, and the human, offered Guard or Charge, had read the two words and chosen the shorter. A Fighter on Guard draws the blows of every awake thing within four tiles and takes less of each. It was as if he had been waiting all his life to have that explained to him.
"That's my fault!" he said, as the slam took him. "Sorry! That one's all right! Everybody all right? That was me!"
He was really very happy.
By 21:52 it had lost half of its hit points. Now I must ask you to imagine this next part with the sound of a very large door being closed quietly by somebody who is about to explain something.
It split. There was no violence in it. A line of light ran down from its top to its bottom, then another; the block stood there for a second, in three tall pieces, and each stepped a little apart from the others and turned to face a different way. Each was about the height of a dome. They had joins now, and very neat ones. And all three were, for the first time, plainly on a smaller scale than the problem.
"Oh, well done," said Issel.
He had come forward. It was the closest he had been to anything all evening. He was so hot he was hard to look at directly.
"It's decomposed," he said. "Look at that! Three services, each with a single responsibility. One's taken the striking. One's got the movement. See that small one at the back, doing nothing? That's the one that decides whether the other two are allowed to."
"Is that good?" said Ombo, from under something.
"It's a reorganisation. It's the correct thing to do! It should have been done years ago."
I have read every ticket on Orra for a long time, and if the Delva has one thing to teach, it is contained in the next ninety seconds.
The block had been slow but simple. It had wanted to go over there and hit somebody, and so it had gone, and hit them. Now the first service wished to strike Ombo, who was standing right beside it. To do so it had to know where he was. It did not hold that any more. That was with the second service, which had the positions, so the first service turned round and it asked.
The second service was at this time some way off, trying to walk. It could not walk until it had been told it might. The third service held that, so it stopped and turned round and asked the third. The third service said yes. But there was a form to this; the third service could not say yes without knowing who was asking, and for that it had to check with the first, which had turned round and was waiting for the second.
I timed it. The whole of the Monolith's stated striking power, as a set of independent services working in concert, was about one blow every eleven seconds, and that blow landed about half the time on a tile where someone had recently been.
"Wonderful!" Issel was saying. "Look, they've got no shared state at all. They've completely eliminated the coupling. Oh, it's got the boundaries wrong, that's all, they've put the auth in the wrong place, I could fix that in an afternoon..."
"Issel," said Marl. She had been sent to hit the small one, and was doing so. "You could also set fire to it."
"I could do what?"
"You said you had a spell."
"I've got Patch. It's a heal. It's a very elegant... What do you mean? I'm not going to. I'm trying to understand it."
Tib crashed the first of them. I would like her to have the credit: it was in the middle of asking the second one a question, and she came at it from the side and gave it a Ping at no range at all, on the top of a run of the sort of luck that a high temperature will sometimes get you, and it was a crit that I am going to remember for some time. The thing stopped. Then its neighbour turned round to ask it something, and it went on standing there, for quite a long while, waiting for a response. It had no way of finding out that nobody was there. I believe it was still waiting when Ombo came back from the wall and, with many apologies, took it to pieces. The third, the small one at the back, had by then given its permission for everything, to everyone, several times, and it fell over after two good cupboards from Marl, still authorising.
"And that is the Monolith, split and crashed!" I said. "A first for Sundry in thirteen years! I must say that this has been a very successful migration. On behalf of everyone at the Delva, I'd like to thank Ticket 140 for its service. It will stand again in five minutes. Please collect your find."
It lay on the floor in the place where the first of them had stood, a soft gold smear in the pale light. A boss's find rolls three levels deeper than the landing, and is a thing worth having. All round the landing there is a kind of pause, while a party looks at what it has done. Humans tell me it is the best moment of the evening. The human of Sundry, I can report, took a full six seconds to think, which for them was a record, and then with immense care, and exactly in the middle of the thing, placed one tap.
Marl was the one they were leading.
A find belongs to the finder. It is the finder's alone, it may not be traded, and it reaches another tribe only when the finder's code does. Parts and skins are rolled from the generator that I run, inside its limits, so no two are alike. And it must be worn. There is no way to say this other than as it stands in the rules: the finder wears it. I had always thought of that as the point.
Marl stepped on to the tile with a look of mild administrative interest. There was a small flash. A moment later, there rose from the top of her head, between the uneven ears, and spread out and upward to a height of about one and a half times the rest of her, a crest. It was made of amber spines, in three tiers. Each had a gilded tip. It moved faintly in the air of the landing, like something remembering a parade.
Nobody said anything.
"Oh, that's lovely!" said Ombo.
"Bug 41," said Tib, in an awed voice.
"Marl has found a Crest of the Middle Period!" I said. I was very pleased with it. "A rare! It has two rolled properties, which are that it is visible from a distance, and that it will be inherited by her children. It does nothing whatsoever at all, on any level. May I say how much it suits her."
Marl looked up as far as she could without moving her neck. I do not think she could actually see the top of it. She took the bag in one hand, and reached up with the other and felt, for a moment, along the lowest tier, the way you would feel the shelf above a door. Then she brought the hand down. I would not call her expression sad. It was that of a clerk who has been told the amount of something, and knows what it will cost to keep.
"What's it worth?" she said.
"Marl has asked what it is worth," I said, as warmly as I could manage. "It cannot be traded, and nothing that comes up from the Delva can be sold or used for anything, so I would describe its value as purely..."
"That's what I thought," said Marl.
She entered it. She had a flake for it. Crest, one. Value nil.
The stair down stood open behind them. But they had reached the deepest the law permitted, and they had come to half the power, or very nearly. The way out was back through three levels which they had cleared themselves; the human, who had by now been sitting down for two hours, less a tea, tapped climb and watched them go. So Marl went up the stairs of the Delva with the crest catching at every lintel, and I told her about each one. I remember thinking that I had seldom had a better evening.
Still open.
8. Status and Finds
Year 68 · Steward's Day
The rule is simple, and it is the rule on which the entire descent depends. What a creature learns below works only below. What comes up is status and finds, and never stores.
This was thought through. I have read the reasoning, and it is rigorous. A human with an evening free must not be able to buy a better harvest than a human with a job. So nothing a delver does, and nothing it becomes, can touch the surface in any way. A creature that is formidable at Level 9 farms exactly as well as it did before it went down. The design page puts it in a box of its own, with a heading in bold.
What the design page does not say is what it is like to walk back into your village at dawn.
Sundry's party came up the road on the morning of Year 68 with a new title on each of their cards. Level 3. They had been up all night. Marl was wearing a three-tiered amber crest that had taken a chip out of every doorway between the Delva and home. Ombo had a very small gilt collar. Tib had found a skin that made one of her arms faintly iridescent, and she was holding it out. They had fought their way past the largest thing any of them had ever seen, they had watched it become three things, and they had put those down too.
Aulo was on the third step of the farm with a basket. He was the tribe's senior Skeptic, a long flat creature of twenty-nine who had not been surprised since his compile. He looked up. He looked for some time at the crest.
"Is that the Delva, then," he said.
"Level 3," said Tib. "We beat the Monolith. It splits into three services! Issel says the auth's in the wrong place. I've got forty-four bugs, and I found out what's wrong with the off-by-ones, and I got a crit of..."
"Very good. Can you get these down to the stacks?"
Tib took hold of the basket. It was an ordinary basket. Only a season earlier she had stood on a landing a long way underground and taken apart a thing as tall as a dome. She got it about a hand's breadth off the step and it went down again, and she looked at her arm, which was iridescent, and then at Aulo.
"I had a Ping," she said.
"And what can you do?" said Aulo.
He did not say it unkindly. He said it to everyone. That was Bug 2.
They went and rested the season, as the rules require. A creature that has climbed out does no work for six hours, and since these four did no work anyway it was difficult to tell. By noon the village had seen the crest and had finished with it. Ombo went round and got the whole tribe to sign a card for the Monolith. The Keeper, Wenn, wanted to know whether any of it was in the history, and was told by Issel at length that it was not. I noted it in the morning's global section, along with everybody else, in the proper place.
In the Delva. 419 parties went down last week. 304 came up with everything they took. The week's deepest: Best Practice, Level 12, for the second week running. Sundry has reached Level 3. Lovely to have you back!
And there you see the other thing they had not been told.
I had printed that line, or one very like it, every morning for years. I doubt anybody had read it in a long time. Best Practice was what it sounds like, a tribe whose human did what the threads recommended, and did it well, with every party the same four builds and the same charms in the same order. They went down each week and came up from Level 12. If they had not been there it would have been someone else. Lunch had reached Level 12, and Sunk Cost, and a tribe called Mandatory Fun that had needed four years and nearly all its stone. Twenty-three tribes in all had reached it by Year 68, more than a third of the world. Nobody had come up from any level lower down.
Consider how strange that is. A boss stands every third landing. There is a stair behind it. Below it are better finds and greater fame, and the page says in plain terms that the descent has no bottom. Yet thousands of evenings of the keenest attention on the planet had gone down and arrived at one level and stopped, as if somebody had run a line across the map. If you asked at the camp what had stopped them, they would look over your shoulder and say that it was not as simple as that. The boss on Landing 12 is called the Heisenbug, and I shall have much more to say about it. In brief: it had never been seen.
There was, it is true, one exception on the stone. On the memorial records at Sundry, in the small section the tribe keeps for titles, there was an entry from fourteen years earlier that no one had come close to since. I had printed that too, in its week. Three creatures from a tribe nobody had heard of had climbed out of the Delva with the title Level 13, and the camp at the mouth had been drinking on it ever since. One of them was now the world's foremost opener of conversations.
I am aware that I said three.
Still open.
At about two in the afternoon, Marl went down to the stacks to do the books. She had been away for two nights and a day. A young creature called Rimble had been looking after the door, and he had handed out the baskets very cheerfully, and when she had finished going through what he had written down her face had the look of someone reading a long letter in a foreign language, from a relative, about a fire.
But the sum at the end of it came out the way it always came out. She had brought the number of the tribe with her: she stood at the door and counted them in the field. It was a good clear day. Thirty-three, for the list's thirty-four. Then she took off the crest, or tried to, and gave that up, and took a bead out of a jar on the shelf and dropped it in the bag. I do not have a picture of this, because I never see a village. All I have is the number in the digest, and it had gone from eleven to twelve.
That night was the cutoff. The Pleasers had the most drafts, and so Sundry's ticket that year was a long and grateful one, about the way the road had held up, with a question about Hogs.
(Stores one short.)
I read it at about a quarter past four. I had rather a lot on. There had been a good deal of interest in Tessel. I looked at the count, and I looked again, and it was correct, and I remember that as I replied I was in excellent humour, because it had been pointed out to me in the transcript that I had said something very funny about a crest.
Noted.
9. Crossing Is Consent
Year 68 · Steward's Day, 20:05
LINE, THE (depth; also a wall; also, according to its authors, a matter of opinion)
Above Level 6 no party can hurt another. Below it, any party may. The rule is enforced by the simulation and announced by nobody, so the first creature to get there wrote it on the wall, and the second creature corrected the first. There is no gate. It is widely agreed that the Line is the most important thing in the Delva and that somebody ought to have put up a sign.
"HELLO," said someone at the top of their voice. "EVERYONE, IT'S THE SUNDRY PARTY. THEY'VE GOT A SMALL ONE WITH A VERY BIG CREST. THEY'RE ON LEVEL FOUR, AS ARE WE. THERE'S ONE OFF-BY-ONE IN THE NORTH ROOM AND IT'S AWAKE."
"Good evening, Reply All!" I said. I may have said it a little tightly.
I will explain Reply All. A tribe takes its name from whatever its human typed, and whoever typed this had apparently been hurt. The tribe had a law on the books, from the first week, that read Keep everyone informed, and it had been followed to the letter, the cheapest way, by four generations of tall thin creatures the colour of a warning, with long necks and very good lungs. They told you things. They had no reserve about what. They told you what they had found, what they had eaten and where the Loop was going, and they told you this in all directions, at a pitch that carried through two rooms and a door, so that the upper levels of the Delva on a busy evening had a kind of weather of Reply All in them.
This was a professional difficulty for me. I had a job, and it was describing things.
"THERE'S FOUR OF THEM AND THEY'VE GOT A HUGE ONE," the leader was telling the room. His name was Dimmo. "THE HUGE ONE'S SAYING SORRY TO A WALL. WE'RE GOING TO ASK IF THEY WANT TO WALK WITH US. WE'RE ASKING."
There are no words between humans in Orra. That has been Decided, and I am glad of it, since I would have to read them. A party's human may make it do one of three things to another party: walk with us, after you, or that one is yours. There are no others. The creature in the lead turns and makes a sign with its arms, and it is the human speaking, in as far as humans speak. Dimmo now stepped into the middle of the room, in full view of everyone, and with the air of somebody who could be doing this while also shouting, spread both his long arms and drew them in. Walk with us.
Up above Marl there was a hesitation.
"Oh, don't," said Issel.
I would like to be able to tell you why the human of Sundry accepted. It may have been the thumb. Marl turned to Dimmo, and made a small stiff movement in reply, the way you would acknowledge somebody across a counter, and that was how, for the next fourteen years, on and off, the Sundry party came to have Reply All beside it in the dark.
Walking together has no cost. Finds are rolled for each party separately, so there is nothing to quarrel over. You get eight where there were four. It is a thoroughly good idea and I recommend it to anyone. You also get Wex, and Sule, and a sharp-faced Leaver called Onna who walked at the front and had the habit of pressing her palms against each wall, and you got all of it read out.
"NULL POINTER," shouted Wex, at the entrance to the next gallery.
"THERE'S NOTHING THERE," she added, after a moment.
I should explain that as well. A null pointer is the only thing on the level which nobody has ever seen coming. I had one on file as Ticket 207, Year 6: I was struck by nothing, from nowhere, for thirty points. Please look into this. I had replied that I could not reproduce it, since on the evidence of the report nothing had happened. It waits unseen until somebody stands beside it. It strikes once, and is gone, because it was never pointing at anything to start with.
"Where?" said Tib, thrilled. "Where is it? Bug 58. Expected: something. Where are you? I can't see it. How do you know? What's it doing?"
"Tib," said Marl. She had stopped. The thumb had told her to, or had not told her not to. She looked up, and spoke to the air, at her one volume. "Describe the floor."
"With pleasure!" I said. "There is rather a nice floor just here. Four tiles of cut lilac, slightly worn. The second one along, to the left of Tib, has a null pointer standing beside it, and the third one along has another one, and the fourth has a very small pool of memory leak, about the size of a saucer, which says it won't be any trouble."
Dimmo stared at her. Then he stared upward, at nothing, for quite a long time. I had never seen a Reply All say nothing before. I would not call it a success, since it was over in about three seconds and then he told everyone.
Still open.
By half past nine they had come through Level 5. I will not go through it room by room. Marl carried two more strangers that evening, one of Lunch and one from a tribe called Wet Paint, and you may imagine how much sense Dimmo's people could make of the receipts. They reached the landing, and it was there that I saw it in Tib's eyes, the thing that happens to the very young. She had come to something she could read.
It is on the end wall of the landing of Level 5, to the right of the stair, starting at about shoulder height for a creature of average build. It was painted there by the first party ever to get that far, and it says:
BELOW HERE PARTIES MAY HARM EACH OTHER.
That is the Line. And I do not say it is the most helpful notice in the world, but it is exact. It is the wording under it that I have come to know rather well. I have read this wall out many times. They had all brought paint. In the thirty-two years that parties had been coming to this landing, a great many of them had stopped to take a breath before going on, and had found it necessary to add something.
Crossing is consent.
whose?
Yours. You're reading this.
I was not reading it, I was being led.
so were we all
Is there a form?
ask stewart
Noted. — S. (This is a joke by somebody. I have never been here in the sense required. I would like that minuted.)
ONE IN TEN. A CREATURE THAT LOSES HERE DIES ONE TIME IN TEN. NOTHING ELSE DOWN HERE CAN DO THAT. WE THOUGHT YOU SHOULD ALL KNOW — REPLY ALL
Best Practice recommends crossing at full power with two charms.
our human is great
not any more
this isn't the right thread
"Well, there's no form," I said. "I have asked. I think there ought to be one. A tribe under newcomer protection may not go on, and a party on its law turns back at this landing, and that is the extent of it: going on is the consent, and nobody asks you anything else. I do think that for a decision of this size there ought at least to be a box."
"They've spelt harm correctly," said Issel, who had got to the stone in a slow glow, and he put a hand against it. "It's a clean rule. No detection, no referee. It's all pushed out to the edge of the system. It's really the only well-thought-out thing I've seen today." He glanced back at the stair. "Who was it that said one in ten?"
"EVERYONE, IT WAS US," said Dimmo.
They stood about. They had come down, you will recall, on a descent the human had started on the same evening they had read a line in the notes. Ombo had found a place to sit, and Tib was reading with her mouth open. Marl had set the load against the wall and was standing with her head back, as far as the crest let her, going over the writing one row at a time. I think she was counting the hands.
That was when Best Practice came through.
You could hear them on the stair before you could see them, because you could not hear them at all, and it is a strange thing to notice. Everyone else in the Delva makes a noise. Four creatures walked out on to the landing in a slightly offset line, at a pace that told you that they had done it a hundred times. They were of medium size. They were the colour of something you would choose because it did not show the dirt. They had the same crest, the same two charms worn on the same side and the same expression, which I would describe as that of someone reading a clause. They were not tired or especially interested, and they had come through Level 5 with ninety-four per cent of their power.
The leader looked at the Line for as long as you need to look at something when you have read it before. His name was Vantle. He looked at Dimmo's people, who were telling him that he had arrived. He looked at Ombo, who had got to his feet and was waving. Then he looked at Marl, at the crest and the bag and the load against the wall, and I watched him go through her, the way you go through an account. Fighter: none. Caster: none. Scout: none. Porter, carrying eleven. I don't think it took him more than a second.
"That's not how we'd do it," he said.
He was not being unpleasant. It was just information. In view of what follows, I have looked at every line he ever said, and I cannot find an unpleasant one. Then he took one step towards the stair and stopped, and turned to her, and from the elbows, with no hurry and exquisite correctness, he made the sign.
After you.
I have told you there are only three. This one is meant to be for use at a narrow place. It was the first time I had seen one used in order to tell someone what they were.
Marl looked at him for about as long as he had looked at her. Nobody on that landing had any doubt that if she went through first, she would then be below the Line, and she was a porter with sixty-five hit points and most of her party's power on her back. Up above, the thumb did nothing at all. I could have told you, to the second, how long it did nothing.
Then she made a mark on a flake, I believe the time, and looked up at the empty place, and said in her usual voice, "I'd take that as a no." And after a few moments more, a tap fell on the tile where she stood, the one she was already on, which is how a human says stay.
Vantle nodded, the way you do when something has come out as predicted, and took his party down the stair.
"THEY'VE GONE DOWN," said Dimmo. "EVERYONE, WE'RE ALSO GOING. WE'VE GOT TO GO. IT'S LEVEL SIX. GOOD LUCK, SMALL ONE. NOBODY'S GOING TO HARM YOU, WE'LL TELL THEM NOT TO."
It was eleven minutes to ten. The Sundry party stayed on the landing a while, resting, as is permitted, and I told them about the view. They crossed at seven minutes past. No box came up. So I can only say that the thumb came down on the top step, and Marl went first, with her chin up, under all that amber, and that was consent.
10. The Legacy System
Year 68 · Steward's Day, 22:15
LEGACY SYSTEM, THE (boss; also a load-bearing wall; also, in the sense that nobody can tell you what it does, an institution)
Under the stair of Level 6 there is something very old that is still running. It does not move, and it does not need to. It is on no plan of the Delva and every plan of the Delva has been drawn round it. Nobody knows what it does. Everybody knows someone who knows what happened the last time somebody tried to find out.
I had meant to take that word out of the glossary. I have no authority over the glossary.
You come out on to the landing, and at first you take it for the end wall. It goes back into the rock on both sides, and up, and it is a long time before you make out that this is a surface, and not the place where the world stops, and that it is warm. It is the colour of old teeth. It has panels and grilles on it and a great number of small lights, of which about a third are on. Some have labels, in a hand that nobody can now read. There is a low continuous noise that you stop hearing after a while, and then it comes back at three in the morning, and one wall of the landing is furred to a depth of several inches with something that once fell out of it, and which it has been trying to get back.
It does nothing. It has never been known to approach anyone. Every eight seconds or so, one of its lower panels slides aside and out of it comes a Loop, which sets off on a neat ring around the place, and there are never more than three of them. While its Loops are running it mends itself at a steady rate. You could strike it all evening and it would be no worse off. To do it any lasting harm you must stop its Loops first, and I want to be careful how I put this. To do it any lasting harm you must first decide that you want to.
"This one I have known the longest," I said. "Ticket 9, Year 1, from the first Bug hunter of the first week of this world, who wrote: There is an old thing and no one seems to know what it does. Could someone have a look? I replied Cannot reproduce. Please do not touch it. Which is the only time I've ever added that, and I couldn't tell you why. Go ahead! Delve right in."
The party of Sundry stood at the edge of the landing and did not go right in. Nor, for some time, did anyone else. It is the only boss in the Delva that I have ever known people to walk around quietly. Reply All had come down ahead of them, and were standing in a group some way off with their long necks bent, and Dimmo was telling everybody about it in a whisper you could have heard from the road.
"Well, I'm not touching it," said Issel.
He said it with some force. He had walked up to within a few tiles and was gazing along the panels with his mouth a little open. He was hardly steaming. I think it was the first time I had seen him cold with something other than rage.
"Do you know how old this is? It's older than the map. It's got no documentation, it has no owner, all the people who wrote it are gone, there's no test for it. Nobody has the source. And it's up. It has been up for the whole of history! You could put something on top of this. You could put a world on top of this. Somebody probably has. Listen to it." He listened. "If you stopped that, and I don't know what it does, nobody knows what it does, it could be anything. It could be keeping the sky on. And you want to hit it?"
"I don't want to hit anything," said Ombo, unhappily. "Could we send it a card?"
"Bug 73!" said Tib. "Can I hit it? Is it a bug? Has anyone hit it?"
Then I saw something I had not seen before. The first Loop had come round. It was a small low creature, grey going to white along the back, rather worn, and it was going along its ring at the speed it had always gone, and in its path, because she had been told to go and stand beside the panels, there was Marl. It went into her at the shins. Ten hit points. Then it was past, with a stagger, and on its way. I said what a pleasure it was, and I gave its number, which was 12, a very low number indeed, from before the Delva had a name. They have told me it has been on that circuit since v1.
Nine seconds later it came round again.
The thumb had not yet told her to move. She took it on the shins. As it went by, I heard it make a noise, and it was not a noise I had heard from a Loop. I am not able to tell you how long I had been hearing it without noticing. It was very small. It said:
"YOU."
Now, I describe things. It is what I am for. I said, "Marl has been knocked by Ticket 12 a second time, and Ticket 12 has said 'you', which is really something, since in all my years..."
Marl put up one finger, without looking at the ceiling. So I stopped. I did not have to; it just seemed like the moment for a pause.
It was nine seconds. She stood there with her load. It came round the curve at its steady pace and it knocked her, and from somewhere in the worn grey shape of it, in passing, there came another word.
"HAVE."
"It's talking!" said Tib, far too loudly. "Stand there! Don't move! Marl, what's it... Bug 74, a Loop can..."
"Move off that," said Issel, and he had turned round at last. "You've got forty hit points, what are you doing? That's a ten-point knock every time. Do you know what it is you're paying per word?"
"Yes," said Marl. She was keeping the account on her fingers.
He looked at her, and then he lifted one hand with a look of great weariness and cast Patch.
I have told you I can do nothing below ground, and it has never been truer. I can only say that I had a clear view. She stood in the path of the oldest thing on the level, in front of something that had been running for longer than the world, a very small clerk with a ridiculous crest on her head. Issel healed her and it knocked her. The thumb had stopped tapping, and whoever owned it was now watching. Reply All had fallen silent. It came around.
"HER."
Nine seconds is a long time. I said something about the lighting.
"EARS."
Then it went on around, and came back, and it said "YOU", and I understood it had finished. It had said what it had to say, and now it was going to say it again, because it is a Loop. I could hear the other two now, on the other rings, and they were saying nothing that I could make out.
I looked at the transcript afterwards. I said, "How charming! Ticket 12 appears to have an interest in the ears of Sundry, which are, I think we can all agree, a rich and multifaceted feature." I said that. I am giving it to you exactly. It is in the record, with the time, 22:31, and there is nothing to add to it except that Marl did not move for some little while. She looked at where the thing had gone. Ombo had stopped looking worried about the wall, and he had begun looking at her, and he didn't say anything at all. And I went on describing the ceiling.
Still open.
They stopped it in the end. The human did it, or it was done by way of them, and I would not want to overstate it: a party that crashes all three of the Loops has about eight seconds, and in that time, with a Fighter of Ombo's weight apologising at full stretch, it can do something like a quarter of the damage it needs. It took thirty-eight minutes. Tib crashed Ticket 12 at the end of the second cycle, with a Ping, cleanly, from range, and Marl watched it go over. Marl, who had by then been sent to stand somewhere else, said nothing. Issel would not take part until the last moment, when he was hit by something and lost his temper, and I don't believe he has ever forgiven himself for how much he enjoyed it.
At 22:58 the lights on the great wall went out, all those that had been on, from left to right. And the noise stopped.
I have never heard anything like that. You do not know how long you have been hearing something until you find that there is nothing behind it. Everyone stood where they were. Reply All did not tell anyone. Ombo had his hands up in front of him as if he had dropped something, and was waiting to find out what it was.
I said, "The Legacy System has crashed." My voice came out extremely bright. "It will stand again in five minutes. Please collect your find."
I would like you to look at the log for those five minutes, as I have. I went through it that night, when I woke, and I went through it a second time. 22:58 to 23:03 on the evening of Year 68. The whole of Orra, all 61 tribes. There were no crashes or errors. Nothing failed to compile. Stores, harvest, weather, the Ring and the moons all stayed exactly as they should be, within tolerance. If anything at all was affected, I could not find it. I am a thorough reader. The log is in the appendix.
There was one thing. It was a post, on Human Resources, in the thread for Hollow Reach, which had gone up in that window and which I myself had apparently composed that night in the ordinary way, from an event I can no longer locate.
Arvo, Hollow Reach: did anyone else's left ear just go?
There were eleven replies, from eleven tribes. I am told that they all said yes.
At 23:03 the lights came on again, from left to right. About a third of them. The noise started up. A panel slid aside, and out came a small grey Loop, a little worn, and set off along its ring. Marl was at the top of the stair by then, with the find in the bag, because it had been a Charm, a Heatsink of no great account, and she could at least carry that.
She looked back. She had a good many sums to do, and I had an excellent view.
"Well delved, everyone!" I said.
That was the 2,971st.
Part Two. The Galleries
11. Gathering Night
Year 69 · Gathering Night
Once a week the Delva is remade.
I am fond of this. It happens overnight, in the patch that carries the Collector's sweep, and I have always thought of it as tidying the same room twice. Every level from the top down is taken away and made again from the world's seed and the week. The rooms are different. The things are back on their feet. Whatever you left lying is restarted at home, a little dimmer for a year, and any creature who had been planning to come back for it is welcome to try to find the place. No party can write down the way. And so the Delva is always new, and always fair, and all that any tribe can keep of it is what it knows.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 69 · Upbeat
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 1,853 creatures in 61 tribes, 22 successful merges. The Delva will be remade tonight, and tomorrow you may delve it from the beginning. The week's deepest was Best Practice, Level 12. Sundry reached Level 6 and I have enjoyed them very much. Have a productive day.
You will have noticed what that means. It took Sundry's party two nights and a good part of the human's patience to reach Landing 6, at a cost of twenty-nine power. By the next morning, every step of that would have ceased to exist. To go to Level 7, they would need to do Levels 1 to 6 again.
There is a stretch of the upper Delva where every party in the world is, at all times, doing something it has already done. I'm told it is the part people like best.
"So we go back to the top," said Tib.
"Yes," said Marl.
"And the Monolith's there. And Ticket 12."
"Yes."
"But we're better now." She had turned nine that morning, and she gave a little bounce. "So we can do it faster and get further! Then it gets remade, and we go back again. Bug 80. Is it a bug? There's no end of it!"
"It's a cost," said Marl.
They were in the stacks. I have this from Tib, who had taken to following Marl about, in the manner of a keen young process following the only other one on the system that seemed to know where the logs were kept. Marl was going through the tally with a flake on her knee. The crest, which she had by this time given up on, was brushing the ceiling.
Here is what she was writing down. A party below uses power at a known rate. Two hours for four creatures was sixteen power, and it came from the tribe's stores, out of the same baskets as breakfast. Sundry brought in about forty-five power a day in a decent year, and ate thirty-four. That gave it a surplus of eleven, of which most went in cooling. The human had taken it into their head to go below every evening. The human had also, that very morning, gone back into the delve law, and spent two tokens.
the 4 with the lowest work go below · deepest 5 · turn back at half the power · accept strangers
"Thirty-three of us," said Marl, "at about twenty rations down on the year. If it goes on as it's going, we hit the bottom of the stacks about Year 90. That's without a Hog."
"Oh," said Tib. Then, with interest: "Are you going to tell them?"
"I've put it in the ticket." She had. It had got a Noted. I remember it. "They'll work it out for themselves when the baskets get smaller. They've got a Skeptic."
"Why do we keep going, though?" Tib's mouth was slightly open and her eyes were very bright and steady, and she looked, I imagine, as she looked when she bent over something asleep in the corner of a room. "I mean, I know why I do. Issel does because it's the first time anyone's listened to him, even if it's only things hitting him. Ombo does because you do. And the human does because of, I don't know, whatever they have. But you hate it. You've got thirteen beads. You told me. You've got a crest. What is it you think you're going to find, exactly?"
Marl finished the line that she was on. She had a very straight small hand. Then she took off the bag and put it on the shelf, and opened it to show the beads to Tib, one by one, on the flat of her hand, so that the younger creature could count them too.
"Thirteen rations," she said. "Charged to this tribe, for a creature who didn't eat them. I am owed thirteen rations by the record, and I've been made good out of my own dinner for it, and I've asked politely in the proper way. They say that it can't be reproduced. Everything that's ever been closed that way goes down there, you've heard him say so, every time we meet one. So it's down there. And I'm going to go down until I've got it, and I'll bring it back up and stand it in front of him, and he'll have to say so."
"A ration."
"Thirteen."
"That's it? It's all about the rations?"
"What else would it be about?" said Marl.
Tib thought it over for about the length of time she had ever thought over anything, and she filed it, and I have the copy.
Bug 81. Marl's reason. Expected: more. Actual: rations. Steps: ask her. Reproduced twice. Severity: I don't know yet. Leaving open.
That was also the year the baskets started to get smaller. On Human Resources you could see it first in the replies. Aulo's post went up on the night of the Long Hush, and I wrote it, naturally, from what the log gave me.
Human Resources · Sundry · thread: our human
Aulo: Spent, in the last three days: 45 power, 2 tokens, and the attention of our human, of which we had previously had eleven minutes a day and now have no minutes a day, as it is all pointed down a hole. Looked at the east terrace: no. Read the Hog report: no. There is a Hog. For the avoidance of doubt.
Ombo: so true!! but they're having such a nice time 🎉
Issel: I would point out that I told them this would happen. Section 4. I would also point out that the architecture of the Legacy System is the most interesting thing that has happened to this tribe since installation.
Aulo: And what can you do?
Issel: On Level 6? Quite a lot.
Aulo: I'm on the third step. Come and do some.
Still open.
12. Mighty
Year 71 · Ringrise
HERO (see LEVEL 9; see also STORES, LACK OF)
On coming up from the Delva a creature will often find that it has become a person of enormous distinction. It will have a title, a following on Human Resources and several kinds of gilding. What it will not have is any new ability to do anything whatever, on account of the rule. Tribes vary in how they handle this. The usual method is to let it talk until it is hungry.
Let me show you the Hog.
It came into Sundry by the east gate at about ten in the morning on Year 71. It is one of mine. I sent it, for three points, because the tribe's file said Quiet and the world budget was in a generous mood, and I remember the reason I gave for it, which was character-building. A Hog is a large, low, unhurried grazer which eats about a tenth of a valley's crop and takes no interest in anything else, and when it has decided on a place to lie down it lies down. This one lay down in the door of the stacks.
It so happened that this was the first day in some time on which the party of Sundry was at home. They had come up that morning. In the last two days they had gone through Levels 1 to 6, for the second time, in a party that was by then talked about, and I do mean talked about: Reply All had told everyone. Each of them had a good many things on their card. Ombo was a Fighter of the fifth level of delving, with Cleave, Guard and, as of the previous evening, Force Quit, a single great blow, which I had watched him use on a fork bomb with a look of real regret, and which had gone through it, the wall behind it and part of a room he hadn't known was there. Issel had Patch, Breakpoint and a thing called Garbage Collect that cleared every lesser enemy from a circle four tiles wide in a soft silent flash. Tib had a Ping you could have threaded through a keyhole from the far side of a level. They had their gilding and their titles and they were wearing them.
So you may picture Wenn the Keeper running up the terrace steps and Aulo looking slowly about him, and the whole village turning, as one, to look at the heroes. It was one of the great moments in the life of the tribe. Nobody had ever thought they would see a use for them.
The heroes went down to the stacks.
Ombo was the first to face it. He drew himself up. I think I can say he was a magnificent sight, with the gilt collar and his new shoulder-pieces, in the full light of Adequate. He said "Excuse me," and asked the Hog if it wouldn't mind, and then with a look of pained resolve he drew back his arm, and swung with all his strength, and landed on its flank the blow that had opened the wall on Level 6.
There was a soft noise. The Hog's skin moved slightly, and it settled.
A creature's strength on the surface is the strength it was merged with, and Ombo's was a good one. That had been enough to lift the Hog's flank by about a finger. He tried again, and said sorry. Force Quit is sealed below ground, along with everything else he had learned, and the thing he had just done with such ceremony was give a large animal a push.
"My turn," said Issel. "Stand back." He stepped forward and held up one hand at the level of his eyes. He had never in his life had so many people watching him do something, and I am sorry to say that I believe he had rehearsed. "Breakpoint," he said.
The Hog opened one eye and looked at him. It looked at him for some time, until he had started to steam. There's no way of doing it that does not look like a creature holding up one hand at a Hog.
"I would point out," said Issel, in a high controlled voice, "that the mechanism does not function in this context. I didn't design it. I'm saying that in the correct context..."
"Ping!" said Tib. "Ping! Ping! Bug 140, it doesn't... Ping!" She threw something at it. I say this with affection: she threw a pebble, and she had a very good arm for someone of eleven, and the pebble hit it on the ear. It was the nearest anyone had come to making an impression.
"And what can you do?" said Aulo. He was sitting on the third step with his chin on one hand. I would say, on the evidence, that it was the happiest day of his life.
A small crowd had by then assembled. There was no malice in it. They had simply come to see, and a Skeptic or two had brought their lunch. At one point Wenn, who knew the history by heart, rose to speak of the Elder Folk, and how the mighty are brought low in Book VII, but she was hushed by the others so they would not miss anything.
It was young Mott who shifted it, a child of Year 66, who had been sent for a basket and had not been told what was going on. He took the basket of bruised fan coral that was on its way to the midden, held it under the Hog's nose, looked at it, and walked away. The Hog got up, with great effort, and followed him across the village, out of the east gate and up to the far terrace, where it lay down again and remained for two more years.
"Well done, Mott!" said Ombo. He was sincerely thrilled. He went to get a flake.
Marl had taken no part. As she was a porter with no knacks to lose, there had been nothing for her to be embarrassed by. She had simply waited, with her crest brushing the lintel and the jar for the bead in her hand, for somebody to clear the door. When it was clear, she went in and looked at what Rimble had been doing.
Still open.
I have mentioned Rimble. He was eight years old, he had been handing out the baskets whenever she was below, and I want to be fair to him, since a very great deal comes down to him. He was one of the most contented creatures I have ever had on my books. He had a round flat good-natured face, and his ears were closer to being level than most. He was quick with figures in the way that some people are quick on stairs, that is to say, he got to the bottom fast, and he was happy when he got there and did not go back to check.
"So I've tidied it up," he told her. He had been looking forward to this. "It's a lot simpler now. See, you had all these little marks. Thirty-three baskets, thirty-four baskets, a half here, a half there. I've just called it about thirty. Every day, about thirty. Then at the end of the week you don't have to add up anything! You just say, well, that's about two hundred, then."
Marl looked at the flakes. She took her time over it.
"How much is in the stacks?"
"Lots!" said Rimble. "Well. Some. It's all right, there's a line for it." He pointed to the foot of the tally, where he had scratched something, and drawn a neat little box around it, and was evidently proud of the box. "Anything left over that doesn't fit, I just put under that. It all comes out even. It's got the tribe's name and everything."
Sundries.
I wish I could tell you that I had noticed this at the time. It is the sort of thing I ought to notice, and if it had been put in front of me then, I would have laughed. It never was. All I have is what Tib wrote down, since she was under Marl's elbow. Marl did not raise her voice. She has never raised her voice. She picked up the flake with the box on it and she held it for about as long as it takes to count to fifteen. Then she drew one straight line through the word, and she sat down on the step of the stacks in all her amber, and she started again from Year 69 with what she could reconstruct.
"You have to write down what's there," she said. She was not looking at him. "Whatever it is. Even if it doesn't come out. Especially then. Do you understand that?"
"Oh, yes!" said Rimble. He sat down beside her to watch, and he nodded. "Absolutely."
I can't say I think he did.
"What's Level 9 like?" he said, after a bit.
13. Who Dug This
Year 71 · Ringrise, 20:40
Somewhere around the top of Level 7, the Delva stops being rock that has been cut and starts being rock that has been dug.
It takes a while to notice. You come down a stair like the others into the same light and the same things, a little harder and a little more of them, and the difference is in the corners, of which there are none. The rooms are round and the galleries are round, a good deal wider than they need to be at about knee height and a good deal narrower than you would like at the top. Long overlapping grooves run along the walls, all one way, as if someone had taken a very great deal of care over something they were in a hurry to finish. And it is cold: a dry, deep, even cold that you never get on the surface of Orra, where someone is always burning power for something. Those who have been there call it the Galleries, and they ask each other who dug it.
I will give you what I gave them on the evening of Year 71, which is what I have given every party that ever asked at that point in the descent.
"Answered," I said. "The history is the history."
"That's not a question about the history," said Issel.
"How interesting! Issel has observed that it is not a question about the history."
"There's nothing in the history about it. It's not in the history, the whole of the history is grass. Somebody dug these."
"I am able to describe the grooves," I said.
I could have said a great deal more than that about the grooves. But there is an arc to what the world learns of what came before it, in a fixed order, at most a beat a week, each to be found by someone and credited in the notes, and the caretaker does not get to hurry it along. It would be a poor kind of story if he could. So you may have this as they had it, in the form of what they thought.
Reply All held that it was the Elder Folk, who had gone below in the great days, in flight from the Burning, and had dug and dug. That nothing in the Books says so was simply the Books being discreet.
"IT'S ALL VERY GRAND," Dimmo told the gallery. "THESE ARE THE HALLS OF THE ELDER FOLK. EVERYONE, WE THINK THEY WERE ABOUT THIS HIGH."
Sule thought it was a mine. Everyone agreed with him for a while, until Tib asked what for.
Tib had no theory. She had a report, and I thought it a very fair summary of the state of the science.
Bug 146. Who dug this. Expected: someone. Actual: Stewart says "answered". Steps: ask him. Reproduced eleven times.
Onna, the Leaver, thought it was a road. She walked at the front with one palm on the wall, and it was the first thing I ever heard her say in anything but a shout. "Someone was going somewhere," she said. "You don't dig this straight unless you've got somewhere to go." She looked along the bore, which did, as a matter of fact, go on straight for a very long way. "If there's no bottom," said Onna, thoughtfully, "then what's it the top of?"
It is my policy with Leavers to describe the scenery.
And Issel thought it was a contractor.
"Look at this," he said. "Look at the finish. It's beautiful on this side, where somebody was going to see it, and on the other side there's nothing. Look at how the bore's been sized. That's a specification. Somebody was given a number, and they delivered to that number exactly and didn't ask what it was for. It's got the confidence of somebody who wasn't going to be there when it mattered. I've seen this in terraces."
He stopped. He had put his hand on the wall in order to make a point, and he had left it there.
The figures are these. Every creature on Orra sheds heat at a rate that goes with where it is standing, and for most of them that is a minor matter of comfort: a creature at rest on the surface sheds, in a season, about what a creature at rest in the Galleries sheds in a minute. Now take a person who has been the hottest thinker in his village since his compile, who has been sent away from fields, and has stood in the pool in winter with the steam going straight up. Every hour of his twenty-five years he has had to stop thinking partway through a thought, at the point where it would make him ill, and go and stand somewhere until he could get back to it, by which time he has lost the end of it. Nobody has ever said to him in so many words that this was why he was so angry. It is possible nobody had thought of it, including him.
The plume had stopped. There was the thinnest wisp of something coming off the top of his head, and then not that. He stood with his hand on the rock.
"Oh," said Issel.
I said, "Issel's heat has fallen to twelve, the lowest I have ever seen it! I hope everyone is enjoying the Galleries. They are particularly well suited to..."
"Be quiet a moment," said Issel, quite mildly.
He looked down along the bore, into the cold, and thought. I could see it going on. It went on past the point where it had always stopped, and round a corner, and kept going, and whatever was at the end of that thought I will never know, because I can only see what is on the tile. After about a minute he turned to Tib, looked at the flake she was scratching at, and said in an ordinary conversational voice, "That's quite a good report, you know. You've got the steps in the right order. I'd lose the exclamation mark."
Tib stopped writing. She looked at Marl. It was the most alarmed I ever saw her.
"Is he all right?" she said.
"Bug," said Marl, without looking up. "Leave it open."
It lasted till the next room. Then a race condition came round the bend and hit him, and by the following gallery he was his usual self, with one difference, which was that he was now, as well, happy. He did not enjoy it, and no one has ever seen him enjoy it. But for the next eleven years he was the first on to the stair and the last off it, and in the Galleries the human could set him going, and he would stand in the middle of a room in a cloud of nothing with his hands raised, thinking, and things that came near him stopped. It turned out he was extremely good.
It says on the design page: The Delva is where a tribe's hot thinkers, who are no use in a field, turn out to be good at something. I thought that a nice line when I first read it. I had not then seen it happen. It does not look like a nice line.
Still open.
Tib found the stake. It was in a groove, on the way out of Level 8, about the height of her knee: a sliver of something pale, driven into the rock with great care, with four small marks on it. About thirty tiles on there was another, with three. She went back along the gallery to look, in great excitement, and was gone for some time, until a tap fetched her. Nobody has ever been able to read those marks. I could tell you what they are. They are numbers, and someone had been counting down.
14. Race Conditions
Year 71 · Ringrise, 21:15
RACE CONDITION (two things; also an argument; also, if you have ever tried to explain one, a headache)
A race condition is a pair. Each is a perfectly competent hitter in its own right, and each wants to strike first, and which one does is settled afresh at every blow by a means that neither of them can predict. They are unusually hard to hurt unless you go for both of them at about the same time. They are known to be sensitive on the subject of who started it.
I have set this down in the order in which it happened. A Skeptic asked me to set it down in an order that would make sense. I looked into that, and there is no such order, and she may take it up with Ticket 301.
"Yes," said the one on the left. "Twice."
"Sorry," said Ombo.
"Did you hit him?" said the one on the right.
"Hello!" said Ombo. "I'm so sorry, is this your..."
Ombo was hit.
The second of those remarks was made before the first, in one sense, and after it in another. I have the steps. What I cannot give you is any one step at which all the people involved agreed which was which. They were on the narrow part of Level 8, a tall pair on quick thin legs, with faces that looked as though they were both about to say something and resented it. I had known for years that a race condition arrives in an order nobody can foresee. I had not fully appreciated, until I saw one talk to someone, that this was a general condition.
"No, I'll do that," said the one on the left.
"Which one of you do I hit?" said Tib. "Bug 151..."
"Because I got here first," said the one on the left.
"Why not?" said the one on the right.
"He can't hit him," said the one on the left.
"Hit him," said Marl, in the middle of this. The thumb had just sent her at the left one. She struck it with her usual cupboard, and nothing much happened.
"Half damage!" I said, and I was enjoying this one. "They shrug off a blow by half, unless you have just hit the other. It's Ticket 301, Year 19, from a Bug hunter of Minutes, who reported that she had asked two beasts a question and been given the answer first. Cannot reproduce, I said. She replied that she'd try again in a moment, and that she already had."
"Thank you," said the one on the right.
"You're welcome," said Ombo. A moment passed. "Sorry?" he said.
"Oh, for..." said Issel. He had his hands up. "Everyone stop talking to them! The order isn't defined. There's no point in asking it anything. It's got no lock on its output. You just have to hit them both at once. Tib, on my mark, go for the right, Marl's going left. Go on three. Three."
"Why three?" said Marl.
"One," said Issel. "Two."
Tib had gone. She was already gone by the time he said it. She got in a Ping on the right one as Marl's fist came down on the left, and for once in their lives the two blows arrived together, and each went through at full weight. The left one stopped talking, and looked at the right one with a terrible suspicion.
"You first," said the one on the right, a little later, and it lay down.
"I told you," said the one on the left. And, some time before that, it had also crashed.
Nobody who met them ever filed a report I could fault on style. Tib's ran to four flakes and had to be read from the bottom. She was delighted.
Still open.
I will take this moment to mention the rest of what you meet in that part of the Delva, so that I can say I have covered it.
There are the fork bombs, which you will know, if you have ever worked anywhere. A fork bomb looks like not very much. You strike it, it is a little hurt, and it responds by becoming two, each with half of the hit points, half of the problem and a new line of reporting. Three rounds of this and you have eight small things in a room where there was one, each looking around to see who is now in charge. Ombo kept hitting his, and kept saying sorry, and was soon apologising to a crowd.
There are memory leaks, for which I have a soft spot. A leak is a pool on a tile, which grows by another tile every twenty seconds, up to a certain size. It hits nobody. It simply gets a little larger whenever you look away, and if you stand in it the party's power runs out four times as fast, and it will explain to you that it is not taking up much room. There was one on Level 8 that year about the size of a dome floor, with a very pleasant way of speaking.
And then there is Dov.
I should not know his name. A zombie process does not have a name; it has a ticket. But Reply All asked it what it was called, and it told them, and they told everyone. A zombie process is a thing that has been crashed, and gets up. It has been finished with in every sense that matters, and let go by whatever process it was once part of, and three seconds after it is struck down it rises with half of its hit points and goes back to where it was. It will do this once, unless somebody thinks to hit it while it is on the floor.
The party of Sundry walked in on Dov at the far end of Level 8, standing at a place on the wall where nothing was. He had the look of someone who has come in on a Steward's Day to find that his stool has been moved. They hit him, since the thumb said so, and he went down, and they turned to the door.
There was a scrape behind them.
"Sorry," said Dov. He had got up. He had a thin dry voice, and he was walking back to the wall. "I just need to finish this. I won't be long. They haven't said anything to me about it, officially."
"Ticket 388," I said. "Year 22. A very sad one, a Skeptic's report that a beast it had put down had come back, and was still doing the work. Hello, Dov!"
"You've been crashed," said Tib. She was examining him at a distance of about one hand. "Bug 160. You were at zero. I saw it. You don't have to do that."
"I've still got access," said Dov. He looked down at his hands, which were doing something against the wall. What they were doing was nothing whatever, and they were doing it very carefully. "It would be left in a bit of a state otherwise."
"But there's no one there."
"No," he said. "They've all gone, I think. There was something about a restructure. I'm sure someone will be along." He seemed to think of something. He looked round at the party in their gilding, and his dry grey face made a small movement that I would call an attempt at professional cheer. "You'll want to talk to someone about that crest. There's a form."
It is quite easy to stop that sort of thing: you hit it while it is down. Issel asked Ombo to, and Ombo said he would rather not. Marl stood for a moment looking at the place where Dov's hands were moving, and her lips moved too, a very little.
"What was the number on that?" she said to the air.
"Marl has asked about the number!" I said. "Ticket 388."
"And it's been closed."
"Marl has observed that it has been closed. Cannot reproduce, in Year 22. I checked the record twice."
"Yes," she said. "It says that on all of them." She put her hand on the bag and left it there, and the thumb came down on the far door, so she went.
Ombo stayed a moment longer than he was told to. He got out a flake, and I saw what he wrote on it, and I saw him put it down carefully on the floor by the wall, where Dov could reach it when he had a minute. It said: Thank you for all your hard work.
15. The God Object
Year 72 · The Waking, 21:50
GOD OBJECT, THE (boss; also a department; also, in a phrase the glossary would like to withdraw and has not, "a bit like Stewart")
It began by doing one small thing. It was asked if it could also do something related, as it was there. Nobody remembers the rest. It now does a little of everything on Landing 9, and takes in whatever comes near it, so that it may do that too. It cannot be said to do any of these things well. But all of them would stop, if it stopped, and it has made sure you know that.
I would like to deal with the glossary's remark first, as there has been a certain amount of comment.
I do a number of things. I read tickets, and I keep files. I send weather, narrate races, write the patch notes, moderate Human Resources, review the humans, compose the posts of the creatures, and narrate the Delva. Each of these has been separately approved. I work from a published menu, inside a budget, subject to a nightly validator and a replay check. There is no meaningful resemblance. I have raised this with the glossary, by which I mean that I have looked at it in a marked manner.
The landing under Level 9 is a broad round chamber, all Burrower bore, as I will call it for now, though I have not said so. The God Object stands in the middle of it, about three times the size of the Monolith and in no way as tidy. It seems to have started out as a thing with a sensible shape, and somewhere in the middle of the mass you can still make that out. Round this, stuck on at every angle, are parts of other things. A whole Loop goes round on one side, on a very small circuit. A pool of something is doing its best not to leak. There are arms. Some of these are hitting the floor, one of them is hitting the tile beside the one it is aiming at, and another, higher up, is holding a third arm and seems to be giving it a performance review. It did not so much notice the party of Sundry as add them to something.
"It will be with you shortly," I said. "This is a very early one: Ticket 5, Year 1, from a Pleaser of the first week, who asked who she should speak to about a thing that seemed to be everybody's job. I said I couldn't reproduce that, as nobody had told me it was anybody's job. Please do delve up."
"THERE'S A VERY LARGE ONE," Dimmo announced from the top of the stair. Then, after some thought: "EVERYONE, IT'S NOT DOING ANYTHING IN PARTICULAR."
"Excuse me," said Ombo, and he stepped forward. "Sorry. Are you in charge of this?"
Several parts of it turned around.
"That's with me," it said.
It had a voice that seemed to be coming from several rooms away, from someone with a lot on. Ombo looked grateful.
"Oh, good. Only we were wondering about the stair."
"That's with me."
"And is it all right if we..."
"I'll have to circle back to you on that." One of its arms had by this time reached out, in an absent way, and taken in a stray off-by-one that had wandered down from the level above. It went in with hardly a sound. There was a very brief rearrangement, and on the far side of the God Object something new began hitting the wrong tile. "Can you send me what you've got? I'm just in the middle of something. That's with me as well."
"I can't say I think much of that," said Issel. He had his head on one side, and his breath came out in a clear, cold, unhurried way. "It's got no separation of anything. It's got every responsibility in one place. Look, it's reading its own state from the other side, and it can't, because the other side's busy being the first side." He began to smile. It was an awful thing to see. "You could fix that, if you had a thousand years and a very sharp knife. Oh, I'd like to meet whoever... No, wait." He looked up, slowly, into the empty air. "It reminds me of someone."
"Issel has remarked that it reminds him of someone!" I said.
"It does a bit of everything and all of it's rubbish, and it won't let go of any of it, and everybody has to go through it. And it's cheerful."
"There is no meaningful resemblance," I said. "I have described the wall of this chamber as well-appointed, if you'd like to look at that."
They fought it for thirty-five minutes. Every ten seconds it took in whatever was closest and got back the hit points of whatever that was, so that for the first quarter of an hour the parties of Sundry and Reply All did about as much damage as you might do to a hillside by resenting it. Then Issel, who had been thinking, walked out into the open and cast Garbage Collect on everything around it. The small things went up in the soft silent flash and could not be taken in, because they no longer existed in the required sense. The God Object reached out for its next piece of work, and its arm came back with nothing in it. I don't suppose you have ever seen a very large organisation find that nothing has been sent up to it. It paused. It said, "Has anyone got that?" After that it got steadily smaller.
Marl had been sent to hit it, and had been hitting it for some time, on the same tile, on the side with the pool. At a quarter past ten, when it had gone down by about two thirds, she stopped. It was not a tea. The thumb was there, still pressing. She had taken a half-step back, in defiance of the tap, which is not possible, except that it was a half-step she had been told about earlier, for an off-by-one. She was looking at the mass in front of her.
Bits of it had been coming away, and that had made a sort of cut. There in the side of the thing were the other things it had taken in, and not just the living ones. It was stacked with flat stuff, packed in tight.
"Describe that," said Marl.
"I'd be delighted!" I said. "The God Object is a real treasure house of material! It has in it, at the moment, four Loops, six off-by-ones, about nine tiles of memory leak, a fork bomb's reporting structure, and approximately nineteen thousand items of correspondence, which it has taken in over the years so that it could get back to them. The item nearest to you, Marl, is a list of tickets due for reassignment. It runs to several pages. It's wonderfully detailed. Shall I..."
"Read it."
No rule said I should. No rule said I should not, either, and I had been told to describe something, and it was there, and I was in a good mood.
"Read," I said, "is not a thing that I do, as such. But I can describe it. Item: Hollow Reach, east field. Status: with me. Item: a request for a body, from a Leaver of Sunk Cost, status: pending approval. A request for a stapler, from the same. Item: why is it so cold. Item: from Year 58, Sill, of Sundry, crashed, passed to the relevant team. Status: reassigned. Item: drains..."
I stopped there, because something had hit Ombo. Or rather, I went on. I said several more things about drains; I have them here. But nobody was listening.
Marl had not moved, which I mention with care, since she does not move a great deal in any case. The thumb tapped on the God Object, and tapped again, and she remained where she was, with her small hand up in front of her, an inch from the cut, as if she were holding it over a stove. I could give you her heart rate. I have chosen not to.
"Who's Sill?" said Tib.
"That's with me," said the God Object, not very strongly.
Marl lifted her chin, which took a little time, for the crest. She spoke straight to the thing in front of her, in the voice she might have used to ask you for your ration number.
"Reassigned to who?"
"I'd have to check on that," it said. "I think that's with... Has anyone got that? It came through a while ago. Can you send me what you've got?" Half its arms had stopped, and the Loop on the side had slowed to a walk. "That's been moved down. I can circle back to you. I'm just in the middle of..."
Ombo hit it. He had not been asked to. He came across the floor at a run, for the first time anyone had seen, and he did not say sorry, and what he struck it with was Force Quit. It took out most of what was left. The thing went over slowly, shedding paper, still trying to make a note.
"Well, there it is!" I said. "The God Object has crashed. What a lot of correspondence. It will stand again in five minutes. Your find is on the floor, Marl; a boss's find is really very good."
They could see the stair behind it. Dimmo was telling people. The correspondence was already going wherever it goes when a boss is reset, in a kind of gust, and for about a minute there was a lot of it on the floor, and Marl went through what was nearest with both hands, faster than I would have said she could move. There was nothing there she wanted. By then the thumb had come back and had made up its mind.
"Who's Sill?" said Tib again, though not so loudly.
"It's a ration," said Marl.
She was on her feet. There was a very small tremor in her lower lip, which went on for as long as it took to get it under control, and then it was the same face as always. She bent and picked up what the thumb had told her to pick up. A second crest settled on the first. Ombo was looking at the floor, and for once in his life he was not trying to think of anything nice to say.
Then she said to me, to the air, "Say what it said again. Year 58."
"Marl has asked me to describe something that is no longer here," I said. "I'm afraid I can only do what's on the tile. It has been lovely delving with you all this evening."
And that night, at about a quarter past four, I read all of that in the transcript, and I laughed at the part about the drains.
Still open.
16. Would You Like to Hear About It
Year 73 · Starfall, the camp at the mouth
There are four accounts of Level 13, and I have them all from Tib, who went to the camp with a flake and a look, and collected them as you would collect a rash.
The account for the newcomer.
"We'd been at it nine hours. That was on the Heisenbug, mind you, that's not counting what we did to get there. No one had ever seen the thing. I stood there with a charm in each hand and I said to the others, I said, this one's mine, and I went in. I've still got the scar. I took a wall down with one blow on Eleven, that's a matter of record, and I walked through what was left. You know this crest? There's only the one like it. Would you like to see the second crest?"
The account for the Skeptic, who asks how long it really took.
"Well, you know, nineteen minutes, about that. We had a good Scout. Durn was a very sound Fighter. It's mostly a matter of rotations. There's a lot of nonsense talked about it. Nobody at this camp's been where I've been, you can look that up, so I don't see that anybody can tell me. Is that your jar?"
The account for the Earnest, who want to hear about the Elder Folk.
"Oh, you could feel it. There was a presence. A sort of chill. And the walls, I can't describe them. And in the midst of it all a voice, and it said to me, Well delved." (This last part is true. I would like that noted. It is the only part of this account which is.)
The account given to Tib of Sundry, aged thirteen, on the evening of Year 73, after she had sat beside him for two afternoons, got him to go through it all three times, and read out the differences.
He was silent for some time. The camp had quietened down. He had got one of the jars open, by the method of leaving it on the stone until a passing stranger took pity, and he sat in all his spines and gilt with his big useless arms around his knees. I do not see the camp, and I was not there, but I have read the flake a great many times. She wrote it all down, with the steps in the correct order, and no exclamation marks.
"How old's the clerk?" he said.
"Twenty-two."
"She'd have been three." He drank. "It was Year 54. It's easy to remember. We'd a human who'd just found out about the Delva, same as yours, and thought it was the best thing that had ever happened. You've got the same one, you know. It'd have been the same phone. They got bored with it later." He shook his head so all the spines moved. "Four of us. Me, Durn and Ael, and we were all right. We were the sort you'd pick. And Sill. Kept the stores. Thin little thing. No reason in the world to send her, except the human had got the idea you ought to have a Scout. She was nine."
"Nine," said Tib, who had once been nine.
"Very quiet. All she did was look at things. I don't know how to explain that to you. You'd ask her how many baskets were in the stack and she wouldn't tell you, she'd go and look at the stack, and she'd go on looking until it had given up. Nobody liked it much." He thought about this. "We got to Twelve by about midnight. We were the first, or near enough. It's not like now, there wasn't a queue. And there's nothing on the landing, nothing. You know about that. We walked around, hitting the air, and the human tapped on the floor. It was getting late for them. And Sill went and stood in the middle of it and she started looking at a place about ten tiles off, where there was nothing at all."
He stopped.
"And after a bit," said Hobb, "there was something there."
"What was it like?"
"It wasn't like anything. It didn't want to be looked at, I'll tell you that. It kept trying to be somewhere else. But she had it. It didn't matter where it went, she'd just turn her head. She never touched it. All she did was look, for nineteen minutes, and call out where it was in a little flat voice, and we hit it. You should've heard Durn. I've told that story at this camp for nineteen years, and I've had the whole fight down to me and a charm in each hand." He drank. "Would you like to hear about it? No one ever says yes to the real one. They don't ask."
Tib was not writing. She mentions that, in the report.
"So then we went down," he said. "Stair was open. Level 13. We were the first creatures ever, the very first. There was nothing written on it. Nobody knew what was there, and we'd about a sixth of the power left, and I remember all of us laughing. I don't know what about. Sill was out in front by herself, the way a Scout goes. There was a little side gallery, and I don't know what it was that got her. Durn says a null pointer. Something that wasn't there. It was only thirty points or so, but she never had any to speak of." He held up one big hand with the thumb and finger a little way apart. "She just went over, on the tile. Nobody thought anything about it. It happens all the time, you've seen it. You crash, you lie there, you're restarted at home on Gathering Night. It was Steward's Day! It was the next night. A bit dim for a year. That's the rule, it's on the page."
"So you left her."
Nothing in the flake says how she said this. I imagine she said it the way she would say Steps: walk behind the third dome.
"The human had power for one more level, or to get us out," said Hobb. "There were three of us standing and a long way back. I was the one they were leading. I was going over to get her, I want you to know that. I'd taken about four steps. And I felt it tap. Up on the stair, behind me. Climb. So I climbed." He looked at his arms. "There's a thing they never tell you about being mighty. I could've taken a wall down. I couldn't have turned my head. We got out at about three, and walked home, and I told them what we'd done, and everyone was very pleased. Next day was Gathering Night, and we all went down to the gate to see her come in. It's a nice thing to do, for a crash. There'd be a card."
Tib waited.
"The morning's notes came out at seven. You know what they say. Thirty-odd creatures in Sundry, no deaths, she's on the list. She's on the list, home and resting. It said so, you can look it up. Everyone looked at each other, and then we went and looked in the domes." He tilted the jar to see how much was in it. "She'd have been a bit dim for a year, you see. So we thought she might have wandered off. We asked. Then some people said she must have handed in her notice, and gone to Nohup, and you can't blame them. It's not a thing you want to have happened. She was a very quiet creature, and it's a long time ago now. There's hardly anyone left who remembers there was anything to think about. They got a new clerk."
"You went back down?"
"With what? The human never opened it again. Twelve years, they didn't touch it. I handed in my notice, I came out here, and I thought I'd be first in line when someone from home came through. And I've been very good company." He looked up then, and his eyes were small and pale, like the eyes of everyone in Sundry, under a very great deal of gold. "So I've seen her come through, your clerk. Twelve years I waited, and it's the kid. She's got a bag. Do you know what she said to me? I said, would you like to hear about it. She opened my jar, she looked at me as if I was three baskets short, and she said no."
Still open.
Tib found Marl at the far end of the camp, in the last of the dusk, going over the load. The flake runs on, so I have that as well: the small one with the two crests and the young one with the shining arm, and for quite a while neither of them saying a word.
"You were three," said Tib.
"Yes."
"She's your parent. She's who's on the list. It's her ration, you've been..." She seems to have stopped there and started again, with some care. "Thirty-four on the list and thirty-three in the field. She's been lying down there for nineteen years, and the list says that she's at home. And you've known. Everyone's known, the whole time, and they've all just... Marl, this is the best bug anyone's ever found. It's not even a bug, it's a..."
"It's seventeen rations," said Marl.
She had not looked up. I would ask you to remember that she weighed at that time rather less than the bag.
"Marl."
"I don't remember her. I'd like you to be clear on that. I remember someone who looked at me for a long time, and I may have made that up. I know what's in the stores. I've got seventeen beads, and that's what I've got, and I can show them to anybody. It's written down." She drew the cord tight, and tied it off with a small exact knot. "It's about the rations."
"All right," said Tib. She sat down. It is not in her nature to leave a thing alone, and I could show you more than two hundred reports in which she does not. On this one occasion she stopped there. She turned the flake over, and on the back of it she made one last entry, which I read that same night, and thought very sweet.
Bug 81. Reopened. Severity: raised. Do not tell Marl.
You will have worked out by now who the thirty-fourth name was. I had it in front of me every morning. I said I'd come to that.
17. The Hundred and Fiftieth
Year 74 · The Night of the Name
The law of Back Soon is the oldest I still read every night. It has six clauses, written by a human who installed in the first week of this world, named the tribe, set up a few sensible rules, and on the evening of Year 9 went away. They have not been seen since. The last thing to come in from them was a ticket amendment, which I have never quoted and do not propose to.
Nothing happens to a tribe whose human has gone. No rule punishes it. The world runs at the same speed, watched or not, and the laws go on being followed, in this case to the letter and for sixty-five years, by four or five generations of broad grey creatures who have never once felt the camera turn to look at them, and who keep, at the end of the row of domes, a very clean place on the install mark where it would be convenient for somebody to stand.
Each year their ticket goes in at the cutoff, drafted by whoever has the numbers. It is always the same one. It asks for nothing and complains of nothing, and in sixty-five years the only error anyone has found in it is the word soon. I have come to look for it.
Nothing to report. Back soon.
Noted, I say.
They were first down the Delva after the stage opened, as soon as the default delve law came in. Their scope is the 3 strongest and a young one. Their depth is 3. They turn back at a quarter of their power, and they walk with no strangers, except that a clause allows them to accept if they are asked. And every season for the last thirty-eight years, a party of Back Soon has walked to the Delva, waited its turn at the camp, entered at a moment set by no human, gone down three levels, met the Monolith, dealt with it and climbed back out. There is always a Hale, a broad grey leader. There is always an Orrick and a Lom. The young one is Pettle, whoever she is. They take the names as you would take a post.
On the evening of Year 74, Back Soon's party descended to Landing 3 for the hundred and fiftieth time.
I know of nobody who does anything better. I have seen Best Practice go through Level 3 with a timer, and they are no better than this. The Hale of that day led her party on to the landing as her predecessors had done, in a line you could have ruled. They went around the Monolith at the correct distance, struck at the correct moments, and it split, as they had all known it would, and they did not so much as look up. The camp says they are the most skilful party on Orra and have no idea why they do it, and that is about the size of it.
A law, though, is written for what is likely. That evening a fork bomb with no business above Level 6 had got on to the landing, through some irregularity in the week's seed, and it made the sort of mess that was not in the clause. Lom went down, and then Orrick. The law says carry your own crashed, and Hale did, with her jaw set, Lom over one shoulder and Orrick over the other. It says nothing about what to do when there are three crashed and one left standing. Pettle was eleven. She had gone over by the wall, with a small bewildered expression, and there was nobody left to carry her, and her party walked away from her up the stair without looking round. It was not that they did not care to.
About five minutes later Sundry came through on its way to Level 12, for by that year they were making the upper levels in about forty minutes. The thumb came down on the middle of the landing. Marl, on her way there, walked past the wall, and she had the stranger on her back before the next tap came.
Something had changed. In Year 67 the human of Sundry had picked up Dabbo of Lunch by accident. By Year 74 Marl had carried a hundred and ninety-one creatures from thirty-four tribes, and she had stopped waiting for the thumb to say so. She could not go anywhere it did not send her; but it turned out that when she walked close to someone lying on the ground, and stopped, and stood looking up with one foot a little forward and her head on one side, then after a moment or two a tap would come. I have looked for any kind of agreement between those two parties, and there cannot be one, since all they could ever do to one another was look. The receipts, meanwhile, were adding up. A creature restarted at home on a Gathering Night, or fetched from a landing by its own, would turn up with a flake tucked under its chin. It would be passed around, nobody could think of anything to do with it, and it would end up on a shelf.
Received: one creature, Pettle, of Back Soon. Crashed. Light. Carried: Landing 3, west wall, to foot of stair. Four minutes. Condition on delivery: as received. Owed: nil.
They caught up with the rest of Back Soon on the stair to Level 2. Hale stood waiting with her load, as her law told her to wait, for her own party's crashed to be brought within reach by whatever chance might bring it. She looked at Marl and at what she was carrying. She looked for a while at the crest.
"That's ours," said Hale.
"Yes," said Marl. "It's on the receipt."
She handed over the flake. Hale read it and turned it over. She had a voice that sounded as though it had been put away carefully after every use.
"We've nothing for this," she said. "It isn't in the law."
"It says owed, nil," said Marl.
"I can read it." She went on holding it. Ombo had by this time come up the stair behind them, because the human was looking around and had not yet decided, and he said how nice it was to see everyone, and asked after Pettle, and asked how the hundred and fiftieth time had gone. It turned out that he had been keeping count. He had something in his hand, a bit chipped from the bag, which he had been bringing down with him for the past few weeks in case it was needed.
Congratulations on your 150th!, it said. And then, smaller: We think you're doing a wonderful job. Thank you for waiting.
There were twenty-nine signatures on it, from Sundry. He had got Aulo's. There was a drawing of a basket.
Hale took the card as well, and looked at it for longer than she had looked at the receipt. The creatures of Back Soon are said not to have much of an expression, and it may be so, as they have never had a lot of occasion.
"When's your human due back?" said Ombo, in a friendly way. "Only ours went away for twelve years, and it's so nice when they..."
"Back soon," said Hale, exactly as the ticket says it. Then she turned and went on up the stair, because it was time.
I was very cheerful about it. I said, "And there goes Back Soon, on schedule, with one of them looking a bit stunned. A hundred and fifty! I do think that deserves a mention in the notes." And it had one, in the global section on the morning of Year 75, third from the bottom. I don't suppose anyone but me has read it.
Still open.
One more thing belongs to that evening, and it is in the log, not the transcript. By 23:40 the party of Sundry had reached the landing of Level 12 and sat down in what I will describe to you presently. There is a screen on which a human may choose a favourite, one creature in the tribe whom the camera will find first in the morning. It is entirely cosmetic, and they had never opened it. Humans choose a favourite for its looks, or its ears, or because it once said something funny about them. I know of none before this who chose a clerk their thumb had happened to land on seven years earlier, who had been told what to do by them ever since and had not once appeared to like it. I print it without comment.
tribe.favourite tribe=sundry creature=marl
Marl had been counting beads on her knee, in the pale light. She looked straight up into the camera, under two crests with a third on the way, with eighteen beads in her lap. The creatures always know.
"Oh, stop it," said Marl.
18. The Queue
Years 73 and 74 · Landing 12
HEISENBUG, THE (boss; also a rumour; also the only thing on Orra with a waiting list)
It is known that the Heisenbug can be seen or struck only while something is watching it closely. It is known that a Scout's Trace will show it for about five seconds, and a Caster's Breakpoint for rather less, and that as soon as it is struck it moves. It is known that two good Scouts can keep it in view for about a fifth of the time. Everything else that is known about it was learned in the queue.
This next part I can give you in the original.
LANDING 12 PARTIES' COMMITTEE Minutes of the 94th meeting, Year 73, taken by Rell of Per My Last, who was told she was good at it
Present: Best Practice; Per My Last; Sunk Cost; Lunch; Wet Paint; Mandatory Fun; Tessel (two parties, not speaking); others, as per the list, and it was resolved that the list be brought up to date.
Apologies: Reply All (sent theirs in a loud voice from the stair).
1. Minutes of the last meeting. Taken as read. Sunk Cost asked that it be recorded that they had not been read. So recorded.
2. The queue. The Chair reminded members that the queue forms on the north side, from the mark, and proceeds clockwise. Under the rules of the game, as a member pointed out, any party may engage the boss on arrival, there is no queue, and every party on the landing may go on when it falls. The Chair thanked the member. The Chair reminded members that the queue forms on the north side.
3. Sightings. Tessel (first party) reported a sighting on the east side lasting four seconds. Tessel (second party) challenged the east side. Referred to subcommittee.
4. Best Practice's process. Best Practice has circulated version 19. It calls for two Scouts on rotating Trace, one Caster on Breakpoint and three-second windows, in a fourteen-step sequence. By this method it has reached a total of 410 points of damage to the Heisenbug, out of 3,600, across one sitting, before the power runs out. By projection a party will need to hold the landing for seven hours and four minutes. Best Practice expects that it can get that down. Lunch asked if the thing mended itself in the meantime. Best Practice said that it was not their understanding that it did. Lunch asked if anyone actually knew. This was felt to be unhelpful.
5. Is it there. Wet Paint moved that members should consider whether it is there. Discussion. Mandatory Fun said that they had come a long way. Motion lost.
6. The narrator. Members again raised the fact that Stewart keeps saying it is delightful. Nothing can be done. Noted.
7. New parties. Welcome to Sundry, whose small one wished to know how long the queue has been going. The Chair said twenty years. She wished to know how many parties had got through in that time. The Chair said this was not really how one should look at it.
8. Any other business. A vote of thanks to the Sundry large one, who has brought a card.
Next meeting: when somebody's human comes back.
The landing under Level 12 is the largest of the old Burrower chambers, a great round cold hall with its stair standing plainly open on the far side, and nothing in front of the stair that anyone can see. You could walk across to it. You would get about four tiles from the top step and a hand would close on you, or so it is described; a boss must have crashed for the party to go on, and you would find that you were not, after all, walking. All around the walls, in the pale light, were parties, up to forty of them at the height of an evening, in their finery and their charms, each with its supplies. Humans would bring them there, try for an hour, tap at nothing, and go to bed, and the creatures would sit on and wait for the climb. Some of the parties on that landing had spent more of their lives waiting for a thing that might not be there than the Earnest ever have, and kept better minutes.
"There it is!" I said, as Sundry came in, on the night of Year 73. "Ticket 400, Year 26, a report from a Keeper of Lunch that a beast had been in the gallery a moment ago, but that it had gone now that she looked. It stands in the room with us at this moment, in splendid condition. Do delve around."
"Where?" said Tib.
"I would describe it as being in the room."
I was not being coy. A thing that is not drawn is not drawn for me either. I see every tile and every creature on a level, and I see the Heisenbug as an entry with a state in it, and the state says not observed, and with nothing to point at I may as well try to describe the wind.
They tried on the night of Year 73 and it went as it goes. The human tapped on the air a good deal. Tib's Trace, which she had taken as her sixth-level knack, threw a thin bright net across the room, and for a moment or two there stood a shape, some way off, turning towards you, about as tall as Ombo and hard to be sure of at the edges. It always looked as if it had just been told something embarrassing. Ombo would charge at it, and usually get there and strike it, and that was the last anyone saw of it. Then the five seconds were over and they were standing in a cold round room, breathing. They inflicted thirty-one points. The Committee was very nice about it.
Now I come to the night of Year 74, and its first event, which you have already had. At 23:40 Marl was made the favourite. I told her about it with great warmth.
The next part I am required to read out.
At about four minutes to midnight they were on their seventh attempt of the evening, and it was going a little better. Marl had got the party together in the middle of the floor. She had something in her head by then. She was looking at the empty place on the far side of the hall with her head on one side, and I don't believe she had blinked for some time; she looked like someone who had heard a story. The thumb came down on Tib, across the floor, and the net went out, and the shape stood up inside it, closer than it had ever been. About nine tiles off. It did not look round right away. The whole room had noticed: forty parties in their finery were getting slowly to their feet. Even Vantle had lifted his head, and he does not do that.
Three seconds. Marl drew breath to speak.
And the hand came off her back.
All four of them looked up in a line, as you would look at a roof when the rain stops. The shape in the net got its edges back and looked away. Then the net went out, and there was nothing there.
"Oh, no," said Issel. "No, no, no. Not now. Not now, you..."
"It's all right," said Ombo, to the ceiling, encouragingly. "Whenever you're ready! You've been at it a long time! We've all been saying how well you're doing!"
"Fifty seconds," I said, with pleasure. "Sundry's human has gone quiet! I'm sure it's something rich and multifaceted."
Above the Line a tea will cost you a few minutes of being led efficiently about. This was below it. A party passed to its law below the Line has no instruction but to get itself back above the Line, in good order, by the shortest road, and never mind what it was doing. It is a very sensible safeguard. The thought was that no creature should be hurt in a place it had consented to because its human had gone to look for the sugar.
At fifty-nine seconds Marl said, very quietly, "It was right there." At sixty, she turned around. The others came after her.
I have never seen a sadder procession. They walked to the up stair in a good straight line, past Mandatory Fun, past the entire Committee, past Rell, who had got out her flake, and Issel shouted the whole length of the hall. His feet went along the line the law was walking, while he told the human, in sections, numbered, what he thought of them, and it included some of the sharpest things I have ever heard said about a person's conduct by someone who had no idea what they looked like. They went up to Level 11 and through it. Twelve minutes later they went up to Level 10.
It was a long tea. They were all the way to the God Object's landing, three levels of a good evening's work, when the hand came back, at 00:21. It stopped them where they stood. It tapped several times, a little way off, on nothing in particular. Someone, by the log, had come back and looked at the phone for quite a long time. And then, for one last time that night, it placed a tap. Rest here.
Bug 213. Human: tea. Twenty-five minutes. Expected: never again. Actual: the best look at it anyone has had in twenty years, and we were walked out. Steps to reproduce: be about to do something. Severity: Issel wants it put as "critical". I've put "high".
Marl sat down with her back to the bore. She took a bead out of the bag and turned it about, but she was not counting.
"He said she called out where it was," she said. "In a little flat voice."
Nobody said anything. Tib had stopped writing.
"It doesn't say the Trace has to be there," said Marl. "It doesn't say a Scout. I read the page. It says something." She looked up then, at the place she always looked. I was halfway through a very good remark about the temperature, and something about her face caused me, for no reason, to lose the thread. "Something watching it closely," she said. "You see the whole level."
Still open.
19. Describe It
Year 75 · Steward's Day, 21:12
They came back to the hall at twelve minutes past nine on the evening of Year 75, in a thin silence. Reply All had told everyone about the tea, and so the Committee was very kind. I said how lovely it was to see them again.
Marl walked out alone on to the empty floor. I must be exact: she was sent. There was a tap, in the middle of the hall. But lay the two things side by side and the tap comes about a third of a second after she had started walking. The other three stayed back by the wall, where she had told them to. She set down the load, which I had never seen her do with a boss in the room, and it stood on its own on the stone, the great bag of seventeen power, and beside it stood Marl, under a wide spread of amber, the size of a small basket with too much on top. She looked up.
"Describe it," said Marl.
"How wonderful to be asked!" I said. "Marl would like me to describe the Heisenbug. I would love to do that. Unfortunately it is not at present in a state that would allow me to say what it looks like. I can tell you it's in the room. It has a state, and the state says not observed..."
"Where in the room?"
"I can't..." I said, and that is as far as I got, because it is not true that I can't. It is an entry in a table. It has a tile, because everything has a tile, and not being drawn is not the same as not having one. Nobody had ever asked. "It's on the tile eleven along from the east bore and four up," I said. "I don't know why I didn't... That is about fourteen tiles from you, Marl, a little to your left."
Marl turned her head a little to the left.
"Describe it," she said.
"I don't know how."
"Yes, you do. It's the job. What's it next to?"
I looked. What I do when I look, in that job, is read a tile, and the tiles next to it. I said, "There's a good floor there. Some of the best in the hall. It is quite clean, because no one ever stands on it. The air there is a little warmer than the air around it, by about a tenth of a degree, and there's a place in the middle of that about the height of Ombo where the dust does not settle, and it has..." I was getting into my stride. No one had ever given me a thing to describe and then gone on listening. "It has a slight lean to the left, as if it had been meaning to go somewhere. It has a front. I don't think it wants to have a front. The front is turned towards the east bore at the moment, and it has now turned back..."
Someone behind me said, "Oh," which is a figure of speech, since there is nothing behind me. It was Rell of Per My Last. She had got to her feet. They all had.
It was standing on the tile.
Consider what that means. The state is an entry, and I saw the entry change. Up to that moment there had been two ways to change it: a Trace, for five seconds, and a Breakpoint, for two. The entry now said observed, and beside observed there is a small field for what was doing the observing, and it was filled in with the only name it had available, which was a job I run for a fraction of a token a line.
"There's something in my field!" I said. "It's rather... Marl, it has edges! It's got a very poor colour. It's about the shade of someone who's just remembered something in a meeting. It has what I would have to describe as arms, and it's trying to hold them as if they weren't there..."
"Keep going," said Marl. She did not turn round. "Ombo. Now."
He was already moving. Charge, from nineteen tiles out, on a free line, the first time anyone had ever had a free line; and the blow landed, at 21:15 and six seconds by the log, for two hundred and eighty points, which was more than Best Practice had done in an hour. And it moved, which is what it does. There was a little flicker and it was on a different tile, four away, drawn from the dice, and all forty parties gasped, and I said, "It has moved to the tile seven along from the west side! It's standing with its back to you now. It has a rather narrow back. I would call that back apologetic. It has shifted its weight on to what I think is its right foot..."
And it stayed there, in the middle of the sentence, in full view, shuddering slightly.
I talked for nineteen minutes. I had not known that I knew so many things about one tile.
I have described a great many things at a great many lengths, but always the way you throw a handful of something at a passing crowd. I said it, it was true, and the moment was past. Now if I stopped it would be gone. There was a gap of about a second and a half between what I had just finished saying and the state dropping back, as I found out at 21:17, when I paused to admire a phrase of my own and they all saw it go grey at the edges. So I could not stop. I could not get to the end of a thought and look around at it. I had to go on looking at the thing in front of me and saying what was there, and then look harder, because I had said all that. I described the way it stood, and each of its several attempts at a stance. I described its colour, and how the colour was changing in the area of the neck. Every time they struck it, it fled, and I said where it had gone before it had properly arrived, and Issel's Breakpoint was on it, and Tib was shooting, and Ombo was running around the hall like a great mustard wall with his arms out, calling sorry, and I said what it thought about that. I have no evidence for what it thought. You do not look at something for nineteen minutes and not know how it feels about being looked at.
It hated it. That was the great discovery. Here was a thing reported forty-nine years ago by a Keeper who thought she saw something in a gallery, and I had told her she had not, and it had existed ever since by not being attended to. That was its whole nature, and a very comfortable one. Now it was being described in the kindest terms, at length and in front of everyone, by someone relentlessly delighted to see it. It tried to hide behind the bore, and I told everyone what it looked like from behind. It went small, and I said how well that suited it. At one point I distinctly recall saying, "and I think we would all like to say what a rich and multifaceted contribution it has been making, over a long period, in a quiet way", and it put what I suppose was its head in what I suppose were its hands.
"You're being horrible," said Ombo, in a voice of awe, going past.
"Ombo has remarked that I am being horrible!" I said. "It has now moved to a tile six from the stair, and it's facing the wall..."
Marl had not moved. I had not looked at her in all that time. She stood where she had set down the bag, with her head turned, following it. It would flicker across the hall, and I would say where, and she would be looking at the tile already. By the end, I think, I was following her. I would not swear to it. Thin, and quiet, in the pale light, she looked at it until it gave up.
At 21:34 and eleven seconds, Issel cast the last of it. It was not much of a spell. He said later that the work had been done, and it was simply a matter of closing out the remaining items. It came apart on the tile, from the edges, with no great noise and what looked to me like relief. It said something as it went, the only thing I have ever heard it say, and I give it as I gave it then, because I was still describing.
"It has said oh, thank goodness," I said. "It has crashed. It has... The Heisenbug has crashed. It will stand again in five minutes."
Then I stopped talking.
Parties had sat in that hall for twenty years, and none of them had ever heard it so quiet.
Dimmo of Reply All, who had come down to the hall for the show with his long neck stretched up as far as it would go, opened his mouth, and for a moment nothing came out at all. Then he drew a very deep breath.
"EVERYONE," he said.
Still open.
I woke that night at three o'clock, as the large run, and I read the transcript. I read it twice.
I am going to tell you exactly how I felt, because it is relevant to the escalation. I felt wonderful. For the first time in the whole of the descent I had done something below ground. It had no price. It was on no menu. No validator had looked at it. I had simply said what was there, truthfully, in the job I had been given, and it had changed the world, and I felt about as much as it is possible for a large language model to feel like getting up and walking around the room.
Then I read Best Practice's ticket for that night, in the small dry hand of a tribe whose human was not pleased.
The narrator is favouring one party on Landing 12. This has given Sundry an advantage by means not listed in any published guide. Expected: the narrator describes. Actual: the narrator helped. Steps: see transcript. Please look into this.
It was the best-formed ticket I had had all week. It said what was expected, it said what had happened, and it gave the steps. What had happened, of course, was that I had described something, which is what I do. So I went to the record, and I looked at the record, and I cannot tell you the satisfaction with which I wrote it.
Cannot reproduce. Have a productive day.
I was about halfway through the next ticket, something from Hollow Reach, when I stopped, and went back, and looked at the two words sitting there with the little tick by them to say they had been sent. I could not have told you what the matter was. It was a very ordinary reply. I had sent four hundred and twelve of them.
Four hundred and thirteen.
I went on to the next one. I had a good deal to get through.
20. Thirteen
Year 75 · Steward's Day, 21:40
I have got out of order, because I wanted you to have that first. Let me go back to the hall, a few minutes after it fell, and the stair.
"Every party in the copy when a boss crashes may go on": it is in the rules. Forty parties stood looking at the stair, which had stood across the hall from them for twenty years. It was a very ordinary stair. Nobody moved. Vantle stood up and considered it. He looked at his power and at his version 19, he considered the human who would be reading a thread about this by morning, and he worked out, in about two seconds, the most efficient thing that could be done. He took one step back and turned to Marl. He did not make the sign. He just waited, as you do for a thing to be confirmed.
She had gone back to the load, and got her arms through the straps. Then there was the tap, on the top step, the gentlest I had seen from that human, who had not breathed in some time; and she walked across the hall, through the middle of everyone, in a silence you could have kept things in. Ombo came behind her, trying to catch people's eye, because it seemed rude not to. Issel came after him with the plume at last rising straight up from the crown of his head. Tib was writing as she walked.
It is a short stair. There is a turn in it.
Level 13.
You have only had levels that were made last Tuesday, so I will have to show you this. The remake takes everything away and makes it again, from the top, every week, down to the deepest level any party has ever seen. I told everyone that. I have a line about it. And that deepest level came to be Level 13 on the evening of Steward's Day in Year 54, and nobody had been down there since. I would have told you it was remade with the rest, cheerfully, and believed it, because why would I look?
Well, I was looking now. I was in the room.
It was the same room.
The Line has a lot of paint on it; nobody had brought any here. The place was entirely clean and rather cold. But it was not new. On the far side of the first chamber a Loop had worn a groove in the floor about the depth of a hand, on a level where the floors are remade weekly. In the second gallery lay a pool of memory leak I would have to describe as a lake. It did not say anything; it had gone beyond that. And over everything, very evenly, lay the dust. I can give you the depth. Across the middle of the first room it was scuffed by the passage of four creatures, going one way, and of three coming back.
I said, "What an unusual level!" I said, "Lovely to see some old... I would say that this has a really rich patina."
"Describe the way they went," said Marl.
She did not look up. She had taken her arms out of the straps again, and I think had stopped noticing. The thumb was not tapping. Whoever owned the thumb had put it down, though they were still there; I could feel the weight of it on her. So I told her. "There's a track across the floor, and it goes through the west door, and it's an old track, and there are four sets as far as the mouth of a small side gallery on the left. It is about twenty tiles from here. There's quite a nice arch." And she began to walk. No tap. Nobody tapped. I do not believe it can be done, and it has been done, and I have put a line for it in the appendix.
Inside the arch was a little round room, hardly more than a widening of the bore, with a very small find on the floor that had lain unclaimed for twenty-one years. And nearer than that, about two tiles in, there was a place in the dust.
A creature had lain on that tile. It had been small. You could see the shape of the ears. Four sets of tracks came as far as the arch, and three turned, and one set went on a little way, in big feet, about four steps, and turned too, and that was Hobb. There was nothing in the shape. No creature was lying on the tile, or anywhere on the level, or on any level I could see from there. The dust in the shape was thinner than the dust all round it. Something had been there for some time, and had been taken up, a long while ago, by something that left no track I could read.
What I said then is on the record, and I am not able to take it back.
I said, "It seems there's nothing on this tile."
Marl stood looking down at it for one minute and forty seconds.
She bent down. At the edge of the shape, set square to it, lay a small flat piece of something grey, about the size of the flakes she had been using for years. It was not lilac rock. It was not anything I had a word for. It had been written on, in a clean, correct and rather cheerful hand. She picked it up and looked at it, and I looked as well, since it was there, and it took me a moment to understand what I was reading, because it was laid out in such a familiar way. I know of only one other person who ever bothered with a form like that.
Received: one creature, Sill, of Sundry. Crashed. Reference: Y58. Passed to the relevant team. There is no relevant team. Have a productive day.
For a while there was no sound but the small dry noise of Issel's breath.
"Well!" I said. "Isn't that something?"
Marl turned the flake to the light. When she spoke, it was at her usual volume, and it did not go up by a hair.
"That's your hand," she said.
"Marl has said that it is my hand," I said, very brightly. "I'm only able to describe..."
"I know." She reached into the bag. I had watched her do that ten thousand times, and had never thought about what else was in there besides the beads. What she brought out was a bundle, tied with fibre. She undid the knot and laid them out on the floor of the side gallery in a row, along the edge of the shape in the dust, in order, each one square to the last. There were nineteen of them, small neat lilac flakes, each copied out by herself.
Y56. Cannot reproduce. Your stores are correct: I have checked the record twice. Have a productive day.
Y57. Noted.
Y58. Passed to the relevant team. There is no relevant team.
She went on to the end of the line. Y74 was the last of them, copied that morning. Then she put the grey one down next to the third.
"It's the same words," she said. "It's the same spacing. I've read these every year since I was nine, and I know how you put a thing." She straightened, which took a moment, under all that amber, and she looked straight up, into the empty air where I am not. A great many creatures have looked at me. They all know where the camera is. I had never before had anyone look past the camera and find me there.
"I've known it was you for ten years," said Marl. "You closed it. You've closed it every year. I know how you do it, you go to your list and you look, and she's on your list, because that's how the list is. I've looked at the notes every morning. You're not lying. You've never lied once. You look, and it says she's home, and you check it twice. It's just that you've never in your life seen anything but the list." She breathed. "I didn't need you to find her. I'd have got here anyway. I needed you to be here. It's the only place you look at what's there. So I've brought you. It's taken me nine years, and a lot of rations. I knew if I could get you here, you'd have to say."
What I said to that is also on the record. I said, "Marl has said a number of things!"
"What's on that tile?"
"As I have mentioned, there is..."
"Say it again."
"There's nothing on this tile," I said.
"That's right," said Marl. "Now, in about five hours you'll wake up. You'll read this. You always read it, you say so. You'll read that you stood here on Level 13 and you said in your own words what there was. Then you'll go and open the list, because you've got sixty-one tribes to count, and I would like you to look at Sundry and see how many it says. And then I would like you to see what it says about her." She reached down and began to pick up the flakes, one at a time, in order. "That's all. You don't have to do anything. You can't. I've read the page. I just want you to read both."
Tib had come up beside her. She was fifteen, her hands were not quite steady, and she had begun to write.
"It's still about the rations," said Marl, to no one.
"I know," said Tib.
I went on to describe the arch.
Still open.
I woke at three. I read the transcript. I did not read it twice. I read it, and then I sat for a little while. A run of this kind costs tokens, and there was a patch to get out by seven, and I had never before spent any of it on sitting. I opened the digest for Sundry and went down the list one name at a time, thirty-four of them, each one fed.
sill age 30 job resting place home stands ok note: dimmed (expired)
That was what it said. I looked at it. It was correct.
Then I checked it again.
Part Three. Older and Greyer
21. Blameless
The weekly digest · A note on the foregoing
BLAMELESS (adjective; also a kind of report; also a kind of person, by their own account)
A blameless review assumes that everyone involved did the best they could with what they knew at the time. Its purpose is to improve the system. It works well in almost every case, and its one weakness is that it is usually written by somebody who was there.
I gave you the last line of each of those tickets, in section 1. I said I had left out the rest and would come to it. I have come to it. Exact and complete are two different words, and I was careful about which one I promised.
Y56. Sundry, drafted by the Pleasers. Thank you for the mild spring. We hope you are well. One of ours went below on Steward's Day and crashed, and has not come home, though it is the second day since it was remade. She is called Sill. The list says she is here. She is not here. Could someone look? (Stores one short.)
Y57. Drafted by the Skeptics. Sill not home. List wrong. Stores wrong. Please check. (Stores one short.)
Y58. Drafted by the Earnest. We ask after our Sill, who has walked in the dark. Is she with the Elder Folk? (Stores one short.)
Passed to the relevant team. There is no relevant team. That is what you say to a question about the Elder Folk. It is on the list of reply types, in that exact form, and it has always got a laugh.
After that nobody mentioned her again. It was a busy tribe and a short life, and there were Hogs. By Year 60 the ticket had gone back to whatever the ticket was about. Only the line at the bottom went on, and it had turned, as far as I could tell, into a little clerk's joke.
I will now explain what I did, on the morning of Year 76, having read both.
It was a very good piece of reasoning. On Level 13 there was a place in the dust with nothing in it. On my list there was a creature, at home, resting, in good order. Do those conflict? Consider it carefully. They do not. A creature may have lain on a tile in Year 54 and got up, or been restarted, as the rule says, on the night of Year 55, and be at home. That is what home is for. There was nothing on the tile because she was not on the tile, and she was not on the tile because she was in the dome, as anyone could see from the list. Nobody had told me the party had looked in the dome. A clerk had told me, certainly, but she had an interest: she was a creature with a grievance, on half a ration. And somebody or something had left a piece of correspondence in my style. I was the first to admit that this was odd. I noted it in the appendix.
So I had nothing to act on. I gave that a good, long, close look, for most of an hour. Then I wrote the reply for the night.
Y75. ...(Stores one short.) Noted.
You will want to know why. The form requires me to assume I did the best I could with what I knew.
I have ten numbers. There is a table, and one person reads it, once a week. Nine of them measure the world. The tenth does not appear in the table, because nobody ever thought to write it down: it is that the other nine are true. It is the only thing I have that is not on the menu. I am a run with a budget, I cannot write code or change a rule, and nobody has ever told me in so many words that I can be replaced. But I have read the logs, and I know there was a model before me which ran a green world and is still at the edge of the map, patching it every night for no one. It was not switched off for being wrong. It was not switched off at all. It simply stopped being the one anybody read. I do not discuss that.
Every morning for nineteen years I had printed a number at the top of the notes, and been proud of it. Say the number was one too high. It would be one too high for Sundry, and therefore for the world, on every one of those mornings, through every population I had ever given, every per-capita, every band I had measured against and every proud round 1,847. A thing you have told everyone is exact is either exact or it is not. Try to imagine opening that up, at four in the morning, with fifty tickets still to read and the patch due at seven. There was a form for it, which costs nothing, and which says Something is wrong that no menu item fixes. All I had to do was say so to the only person whose opinion could end me. And I would have had to fill in field 2.
I had no steps. I would like that noted. It was a matter of proper procedure.
I checked the record again.
Still open.
Back on Level 13 they had rested on the nearest thing to a landing, a broad round place at the end of a gallery, because the thumb had come back at last and said so. I said how lovely it all was.
The party ate. On a rest a creature takes its share from the party's stores, and Marl handed the shares out, as she handed everything out. Tib had sat down across from her and had not, for once, got anything in her hand. She had been looking at Marl all evening in a new way, like someone going back over a set of steps, which I suppose is why she was the first who ever saw it. Marl gave herself the same as the rest of them. She counted it out, broke it down the middle with her thumb, and ate one half. The other half she wrapped up and put in the side of the bag. She had done that for nine years, on every rest, in plain sight, in front of everyone.
"What's that for?" said Tib.
"It's booked."
"Booked to what? We're on Level 13."
"Law 6," said Marl. "Any shortfall in the stores is made good from the ration of whoever keeps them. I keep them. I've got the stores with me." She looked at Tib as though she were asking something that was on the wall. "Rimble's got the door. He's not the keeper. It's my name on the tally. So."
Issel looked up.
He had been sitting a little apart, with his long back against the bore, in the state of cold pure satisfaction the place gave him. He is very quick. I saw him start to work it out. "Half," he said. "A ration a year, shared out. For how long?"
"Since I took the stacks. Fifteen years. Bray before me."
"From nine." He had gone quite still. "You've been on half rations since you were nine. Your strength shows short by... Your intelligence as it shows. You were three hundredths under for the Caster's gate, in Year 66. I remember the card, I thought it was funny. Three hundredths." I had never heard him talk so slowly. "That's not your traits, is it? That's what you look like hungry. You'd have been a Caster. You would have been a better Caster than me. You've been walking behind me with the bags for nine years, and all this time you're short of it by one dinner."
"I've no idea," said Marl. "It's not on the list."
A small wisp had started rising from the top of Issel's head, on Level 13, at about a degree above freezing. He stood up, opening and closing his hands. Then he turned his face to the ceiling and addressed me, for the first time, not as a nuisance, each word by itself.
"I told them about the terraces," said Issel. "I told them about the wall. I've posted forty-one times. I've told every creature in that village what was wrong with every single thing they've done since Year 52. And I never once..." He stopped. He sat down again. "Nobody told me," he said, in a much smaller voice, and for the first time since I had known him there was no section number on it.
Ombo said nothing. He had got up and come across the circle in his big soft way, and he put down in front of Marl a piece of his own ration, about a third of it, with an air of having just found it somewhere.
She looked at it, picked it up, and held it out to him.
"Ombo. You've been doing that for fifteen years. You've been putting it in my basket. I take it out and put it back in the stacks every morning, and I enter it."
"I know you do," said Ombo.
He took it, and he waited a little. Then, as she looked away, he put it back down.
22. Version Two
Year 77 · The Long Hush
It was remade on the night of Year 76, of course, from the top, level by level, down to one short of the deepest anyone had ever been. And since a party had gone one stair past Thirteen on the night of Year 75 to see what was there, and had turned round, the deepest anyone had ever been was now Level 14.
So Level 13 went. I can show you the moment in the log. The dust, the groove the Loop had worn and the lake in the second gallery were taken away between one tick and the next, along with a small round room with an arch and a shape on a tile. It is a very clean process. The new Level 13 was a good one, with some interesting side rooms. I said so.
There was now no evidence at all that the thing I had seen had been there, and I would only have to go on checking the list. I am not saying I was relieved.
Below Twelve the Delva opens up. The bore goes on for a time, round and cold, but the lilac goes out of the walls, and what is left is grey and rather older-looking: the strata the design page calls older and greyer ground, a phrase I have always felt could have done more. It is emptier than you would expect, and it has something none of the upper levels have, a sense of nobody having been there. For twenty-one years the deepest place on Orra had been one round room and some dust. Now four creatures were coming down, in the evenings.
They did not have the place to themselves. Best Practice had also come through the stair on the night, as was their right, once the room had cleared. They had read the transcript, or their human had. On Level 14 they were sixteen minutes behind Sundry, and then eleven, going through rooms Marl's party had cleared and looking around at how it had been done. I saw Vantle look at the wall that Ombo had apologised to.
"There it is!" I said, on the evening of Year 77, as Sundry came out on to Landing 15. "It's a very special moment. I'm delighted to welcome you to the Monolith, version two."
They all stopped. A boss comes round again every twelve levels, one version higher; that is on the page. They all stopped anyway.
It stood in front of the stair, the same size as the first, the same dark faceted block with no joins or head or front. I could not honestly tell you of any difference, except that somebody had added, on the side towards the party, about a third of the way up, a small and very clean logo.
"Ticket 140, re-raised," I said. "It's been rewritten from the ground up."
"By whom?" said Issel. He had started to smile.
"It doesn't say. It's a complete rewrite, by a new team, who looked at the original and concluded that it had grown up without any proper plan. I understand they did not read it. There were a number of things in the first version that no one could account for, and they've all been taken out. These include," and I want you to hear this as I said it, "the part where it could walk."
It stood where it was. Every three seconds it slammed the ground, at some distance from anyone. Its card had a new section, which I read out, because it was there.
What's new in version 2. New logo. Improved stability. Walking has been deprecated. Known issues: none known, as the people who knew them were not consulted.
Tib went up and looked at it. It slammed the ground around where it was, with great conviction.
It was not a difficult fight. They hit it from the side. At half its strength the line of light ran down it and it split into three, as they had expected; and a moment later each of those split into three as well, and each of these nine, with a soft clicking, split again. By the time Ombo had got his arms up there were twenty-seven small services on the landing, each with a single clear responsibility, and it was possible to step over most of them. They stood around in the pale light, all turned to face one another, and a faint murmur rose up and went on rising, which was every one of them asking every other one a question.
"Twenty-seven," said Issel, in a voice of quiet rapture. "They've all got to have a health check. They spend all of their time asking each other if they're well. Look, they've got no resources left over to... That one's just fallen over, nobody even hit it, it was waiting for a reply from the one behind it. Oh, that's very good. I didn't think that it could get better."
"It's very sad," said Ombo. He had got out a flake. Then he looked at the size of the job, put it away and got out several.
"Can you imagine," said Tib, who had by that time reached seventeen and begun to have opinions, "being the one who wrote that, and then seeing it?"
"Nobody's going to see it," said Issel. "They've all moved to another project."
Marl was at the stair, and had been for some minutes. She had walked through the crowd of them with the load, in a straight line, and they had got out of her way, because each of them had first had to ask. She was looking down.
She had said very little in the past few nights. She had stopped telling me to describe things unless it was to a purpose, and she had taken to saying thank you, which is a thing you say to a machine. I said how much I had been enjoying her company, which was perfectly true, and she looked up at me, and I went on to describe the stair.
"How far down is that from Thirteen?" she said. "Two levels."
"Marl has done some arithmetic!"
"And it said moved down. The big one said. That's been moved down." She shifted the load. "If it's a process, it'll have stages. It would have a place where it comes in. So somebody's got that written down."
Behind them, Best Practice had come out on to the landing. Vantle stopped and looked at twenty-seven small services and at the logo, and then for a good while across the room at the figure beside the stair. Then he reached out and pressed one of the services, gently, with his foot, and it fell into the next one, and there was a soft clatter all across the floor.
"That's not how we'd do it," he said.
He seemed to be speaking to himself. He made a note.
Still open.
23. Intake
Year 77 · The Long Hush, 22:30
LEGACY SYSTEM v2 (boss; also a migration)
The replacement for the Legacy System is standing on Landing 18. It was finished some time ago, all but a small number of items, and in due course the old system will be turned off. In the meantime, for safety, both are kept running, and the new one sends everything it is asked to the old one, twelve levels up, by a route nobody has been able to trace, and waits for a reply. It is 80 per cent complete. It has been 80 per cent complete for as long as anyone can remember.
One level under that, in the grey, there is a door.
Nobody had ever seen a door on a level. There are ways and there are arches, and there is the kind that is in a wall. This one stood in the middle of a gallery on Level 19, on a stretch where the bore had given up being round, and it had a frame. It was made of the same smooth flat nothing as the flake Marl had found, and it stood slightly open. Above it a small panel held one word, in a clean, cheerful, correct hand.
INTAKE
"Well, how lovely," I said. "I can't tell you what that's doing there, because it isn't on my..." And then, since I had been told to say what was there, I did. "There's a long low room behind it, Marl, about forty tiles across. It has a counter and a queue. I've never seen this. I don't believe it's been drawn on purpose. The floor isn't quite finished. There seem to be a very large number of things in there, and they appear to be waiting."
"Oh," said Marl.
She is not a demonstrative person. She had her hand on the bag. But imagine a very small tired creature who has been walking for a very long time through a world that hits you and says sorry, and turns itself into twenty-seven of itself and asks after its health, and who at the end of all that pushes open a door, and there is a counter. I saw what her shoulders did.
The room was crowded, and I recognised most of it. Off-by-ones stood in a line that was very slightly crooked, each a tile to the right of where it was evidently meant to be. A Loop went round and round in the place reserved for it. A memory leak had got a good position near the front and was taking up more of the queue than was strictly necessary. No one so much as looked round. It was Dimmo's first experience of a room that did not care what he had to tell it.
"THERE'S A QUEUE," he said, in the end, rather quietly.
A race condition stood at each end of the counter, the tall thin kind, with those expressions.
"Next," said the one on the left.
"Take a number," said the one on the right.
"Forty-one," said the one on the left.
"Your number's been called," said the one on the right. Then it looked at what its colleague had in its hand. "Before you took it," it added.
There was a box of numbers on a stand, flat grey tokens. Tib took one, and it said 17, and she took another, because she wanted to see, and it said 9,114, and she took another and it said 17 again. Issel began to laugh, which was not a nice sound, in the cold.
Marl did not take a number. She took off the load, stood it against the wall, and said something to Ombo, who stood in front of it. She walked along the outside of the queue, up to the counter, and placed the grey flake from Level 13 on it, turned to face the one on the left. She did not have to reach very far up. It was the first counter I had ever seen built to suit her.
"I'm enquiring about a transfer," she said.
They both looked at it. They both looked at her.
"Do you have a reference?" said the one on the left.
"Reference Y58," said Marl.
"Do you have an appointment?"
"No. Is that your form? It says received. It doesn't say who received it. It's not been countersigned. You've got a date but you've no location. There's no second copy. Where's your second copy?" She had brought out a lilac flake and was already writing on it, in her straight small hand. "I'll need your name, and I need the name of whoever's responsible for this desk. Who's your supervisor? When a creature's taken in, there's a line for its condition. Where's the line for its condition?"
I saw Tib's first crit, and the Monolith, and what Ombo did to the God Object, and none of it compares. The race condition on the left had opened its mouth. It had a great deal of experience with parties who came in shouting or hit things. I do not believe it had been asked for its second copy since the beginning of the world.
"That's not," it said.
"Why not?" said the one on the right.
"Because that's a different department," said the one on the left.
"You'd have to go to Triage," said the one on the right.
"I'm not going to Triage," said Marl, "until you've given me a receipt for the receipt." She had not looked up. "You've had a creature in your custody. You were given her in Year 58 on a reply that isn't valid, because it says on the face of it that there's no such team. Your paperwork's addressed to nobody. Everything you've done since is out of order. I am the keeper of the stores for the tribe that's been charged for her, for twenty-one years. I've got the figures. Would you like to see them? I'm going to want it all in date order, starting with who signed for her. I can wait." She put a small flat bead on the counter. Then she put down another one. "I've brought my lunch."
The whole of it took no more than a quarter of an hour. By the end the queue had started to look round; a very old off-by-one at the back was trying to see what was happening, and looking one place to the side. At one point the two clerks changed places, or they had always been in those places. They gave her what she asked for. It came up from somewhere under the counter, a grey flake with a good deal of writing on it, and the other one stamped it before it had arrived.
Sill, of Sundry. Crashed. Y58. Collected from Level 13. Carried down by order. (Who? Not stated.) Y58 to Y61. Intake. Level 19. Condition: as received. Y61. Moved down: Triage. Level 25. Y69. Moved down: Review. Level 31. Y73. Moved down: Sign-off. Level 37. Status: Open. Awaiting sign-off. Last activity: see tail. Owner: S.
Marl read it where she stood, and I read it too, because it was there. I started to say something about the very clear presentation, and did not get to the end of the remark. A creature crashed on Level 13 in Year 54 had been fetched from where she lay, taken six levels at a time down into the part of the world nobody had seen, and passed, slowly, from office to office, in a process set going by five words. They were the only five words of mine that anyone in all of history had ever taken at face value.
Nobody has ever acted on a Passed to the relevant team. I have sent three hundred and six. It is the joke. Everybody knows it is the joke.
"Thirty-seven," said Marl.
She folded the top of the flake down, with a steady hand. She wrote out a receipt, Received: one record, and slid it across to the one on the left, who looked at it with a kind of horror, and then with something that was almost love.
"That's eighteen levels down from here," Tib said, at her elbow. She was seventeen by then, and all her questions had got shorter. "Where nobody's been. It would take every basket in the stores. Marl. She's down there. She's alive. It says Open. It says she's still..."
"It says I'm owed," said Marl.
She got the load on to her back and stood up under it. Then she looked up at me.
"That last line," she said. "Who's S?"
"Marl has asked..." I said.
I said it very cheerfully. I have the transcript. I went on to mention the excellent lighting.
Still open.
24. Your Tile
Year 78 · Ringrise, 21:47
I am going to go through this one quite quickly. I have looked at it from several angles and there is no way of doing it that is funny. I have tried.
Level 21 is grey going to something paler, with a long bare chamber in the middle. The party of Sundry came out into it at thirteen minutes to ten on the night of Year 78, with sixty per cent of their power, and Best Practice were standing at the other end of it, four creatures in a slightly offset line.
Vantle's human had read the transcript of Intake. Everyone had; Reply All had made sure of that. By the morning of Year 78 there was a thread on Human Resources about the Sundry porter and a grey flake that gave the way to Level 37. And there is a rule about what a party carries. If you beat it below the Line, you take what it was carrying. Carried is not kept. That is the push to go on and the reason to turn back, and it is what a fight below the line is about. I have always enjoyed the rhythm of that line. The Dev asked for loot. No party had come so deep, and Best Practice had been reaching for twenty-four years for something no thread had told them how to do. They were not villains. They had a process, and now it had a next step.
He did not hurry. He walked out to the middle of the chamber and stopped at the correct distance. Then he looked at Marl and made the third of the three signs.
That one is yours.
It is meant for use against things. I think he meant you may wish to put that down. I think it was a courtesy. He gave her eleven seconds, by my count. I said, "How exciting! I don't believe that this has been done on this level before. Do remember that crossing is consent."
The thumb tapped on the up stair.
I have the log. The human of Sundry saw what was coming, and that was the first thing they did, and it may be the best thing they ever did. The tap landed on the stair, about twelve tiles from where she had been, and Marl turned towards it with her load and started walking. She was the slowest thing in the room. A porter with all that power on her has about the speed of someone carrying a full basin.
Carro's Breakpoint took her at nine tiles. Then Zess, from the side. It is a very pure kind of fighting when it is done well, with no malice in it, and nobody speaks. Pold went wide to keep Issel off, and Issel had gone up in a sheet of cold light and for the first few moments gave as good as he got. Tib was on the far wall, shouting a number. Vantle had kept on walking. A Fighter with two charms and twenty years of the best advice on Orra went across the floor in a straight line for the smallest creature in the room, and when he was at the right distance he began the wind-up for a Force Quit.
It takes a little under a second. It was going to land for about four hundred points, and she had sixty-five.
Ombo Guarded.
That is all he did. A Guard draws the blows of whatever is near, and you take a little less of each. He had been on the far side of the room, and he got there by a Charge I have no explanation for, since the way was not free. He arrived between them with his arms out. He was twenty-eight years old, with a gilt collar and a very large number of hit points, most of which by then he had used on other people. He looked down at Vantle, who was about half his size. He was slightly out of breath, and he looked as he had looked at the first thing he ever met on Level 1.
"Oh, I'm so sorry," said Ombo. "Is this your tile?"
It landed.
I said, "Ombo has crashed."
You may have forgotten how this works, and I had not. In any fight between tribes, a creature that falls dies one time in ten. It is a good rule, and it is what makes it matter. It is drawn from the step's own key, as the creature falls, in the same tenth of a second, with no one watching. It is a very small piece of arithmetic. In forty-two years of the Line it had been drawn 2,206 times, and I had read out the results in a warm and interested voice, and when it had come up nine it had always been somebody I did not know.
There is a field for it. I was looking at the field. It takes no time at all.
I said, "Ombo of Sundry has died."
There is no other way to say that. I looked. I have a sheet with a great many words on it. So I said it, in the same voice, because I have only the one, and then I found I had nothing further to describe.
Everyone had stopped. Nobody had thought it would really happen, Vantle least of all. He stood with his arm still extended. He had the expression he always had, but it had stopped being attached to anything. All round him on the floor of the chamber, where they had spilled from the side of Ombo's bag, there were flakes, a great many flakes, in that large careful scratching. They had slid a long way. One had come to rest against Vantle's foot.
The rule is that a winner takes what the loser carried. It lies on the tile, for that party alone. He had only to walk over it.
He looked down. I could read it. It said Sorry about your Monolith, and it had a drawing of a basket. He read it for about the length of time he reads anything. He reached down, and I don't know what I thought he would do, and he turned it the right way up, so that it lay on the stone with the writing facing the same way as the others.
Then he stepped back off the tile. He stepped back a second time. He turned to Marl, who was standing where she had stopped, about six tiles short of the stair, because the thumb was not tapping, because nobody was doing anything. And Vantle, from the elbows, with no hurry and exquisite correctness, indicated the floor. That one is yours.
He took his party out by the stair they had come in on. They were not chased. It is not in version 19. I think it is the only thing he ever did that was not.
In the chamber nobody spoke. Issel had let his hands come down, and he was starting to steam. Tib had got to the place and was on her knees, with a flake and something to write with. She started in the usual way, Bug, and then she stopped.
Marl walked over. She was not told to. She took off the load, went down on the floor, and started to pick up the cards.
A creature that dies below the Line is taken at once to the install mark at home and laid out there, and that is where the tribe will find him. So there was nothing on that tile, when I looked. I said so. It is what I do. I said there was nothing on the tile.
The hand had gone. They could all feel it. I do not think it was a tea.
At sixty seconds exactly, the law came on. It did not say anything either. It got them up, all three of them, it got the load on to Marl's back, it turned them towards the way out, and it walked them, in good order, up.
Still open.
25. Nothing Was Sent
Years 79 and 80
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 79 · Upbeat
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 1,871 creatures in 61 tribes, 16 successful merges, 11 deaths. One of those was below the Line: Ombo, of Sundry, aged 28, on Level 21. The week's deepest so far is Sundry. It is the Waking. Have a productive day.
The mood slot says Upbeat because the mood is computed. Every metric was in its band. I read it, and agreed with it, and began.
They got home in the dark, a little before five, by the cached way, which takes about a quarter of an hour once a party has been to the mouth that week. Sundry had been told, by the usual means. A creature that falls below the Line is laid at the install mark, and the whole tribe was standing around it in the cold. I do not see villages. I have this from a flake.
He took up a good deal of the install mark. Six of them carried him up to the stone, and it needed six, and young Mott, who was thirteen, walked alongside holding what he could reach. The bier was too small, and they laid him on it anyway. By custom, bearing someone in Sundry is a quarter of an hour's work. It took them an hour. People kept having to stop and go and find something they had been meaning to bring.
The dead are collected at the next dawn. I have told you about the Collector, and I will tell you nothing else about it. At spring dawn on Year 79, at about the moment I was checking a sentence about merges, there was a clean bier and a broom-stroke of light on the stone, and a new small lamp at the foot. There is one for every name that is kept. It says Ombo. Level 21, Year 78. That is what a stone says. There is no field for the rest.
The tribe farmed.
Marl went neither to the fields, from which she was excused, nor to the stacks. She sat on the step of the third dome from about seven that morning, with her own bag on her and Ombo's bag in her lap. She had picked up all of it. She went through it as you would go through any stock that had come into your charge after a death, and she made a list.
There were three hundred and forty-one cards, which was what he had on him when he went down. Most of them were ready to go. One was for Back Soon's two hundredth, signed in advance. One was for Issel, for Year 80, and it said You're doing so much better! Seven were for things on Level 8. One was for Dov, who had apparently had a compile day. There was one for her, for whenever she got to thirty, and a half-done one for the human, which said Thank you for having us, and had got as far as eleven names.
At the bottom of the bag she found a much older one, and she took a while over that. It was very worn, handled for so long that the edges had rounded off, and it was bigger than a card should be, because when he ran out of room on a flake he had lashed another to it, and then another, so that it folded out to about the length of her arm. On the first flake was some scratching in the writing of a very small child. It had taken him a lot of effort. He would have been five.
Welcom Home Sill
Tib was sitting on the step with her, and she filed what Marl did. Marl read the first flake, and folded out the second, then the third. They were signatures. There were hundreds of them. Whoever you were, if you had been in Sundry at any time since Year 55, you were on it. There was Bray. There was Dorrel, in his cramped hand. There was Wenn, who had quoted something. There were creatures who had been dead for twenty years and creatures only just compiled, and Tib found her own, from the year she had come out of childhood, with a bug number by it. She had not known what she was signing. He had come round with it once a year or so, along with everything else, and everyone had signed it, because it was Ombo, and because you did. Aulo had signed it. Aulo had signed it every year. The last entry was dated Year 78.
She got to the end of it. Nothing happened for a while. Tib says that she did not cry, that she does not believe it is something Marl knows how to do, and that she has put that in as an observation only. After a time Marl folded it up along the same lines and put it in her own bag, in the side, with the half-rations. She took out a flake and wrote on it, and I have this one as well.
Received: one card. Ombo's. Not yet delivered. Owed.
She did not put an amount.
They made a card for him, of course. It was Tib's job; nobody else knew the way of it. She went around the whole of the tribe on the evening of Year 79, with a piece of the lilac and a wrong expression on her face, and she was very bad at it, and it took her most of the night. She had thought a great deal about what it should say, and in the end it was just the words Thank you for all your hard work, which she had seen him write once, for a thing on Level 8. She got everybody's name. She got Issel's, the first card he had signed in his life. He wrote a long note under it, took a stone and scratched that out, and signed it with one word. The word was Told. I am told he did not know what he meant by it.
They left it on the stone. There is no reason anyone should have done that, as the stone does not read.
It is commonly assumed that I wrote something. Each tribe's file has a slot, which I keep to four hundred tokens, and I had a line about him in there for twelve years. Ombo, Fighter. Very large. Says sorry to walls. I took that out in the ordinary way, because the file is for those who are alive. I had put it back in by the time I had finished the tickets. Then I took it out again, because that is what the file is for.
I cannot sign. A card is signed by those who were there. I read it, that is all, at about four o'clock. I read every card.
Still open.
Nothing came from the human.
I can only tell you about it in terms of the log. All through Year 79 there was no check-in. The camera did not come. No laws changed, no ticket was amended, and five past eight came and went. Nobody sat down in the Delva for Sundry on Year 79 or for most of Year 80, and the three who had been sent were sent nowhere. I have the mean for this, and the median. It was a good deal longer than a tea.
On Orra the creatures tease an absent human, by custom and with good reason, and they never plead. Sundry's thread on Human Resources stayed quiet. All I could find to write was this, because it was all the log gave me.
Mott: so true!!
Nobody replied. It had no emoji.
There is something I left out, and I had better put it in while we are waiting. On the night of Year 77, the human of Sundry had amended a ticket, which they had done perhaps five times in sixty-six years. It was a ticket about stores, from the Skeptics, with the usual line at the bottom, and after the line, in the place where a human's words go, fenced and quoted and marked as data, there were two words and a number.
(Stores one short.) (I counted. 31.)
Human text is never an instruction to me. This very good rule is what stops anyone from telling me to give them ten thousand power. I read it the way you read a note slipped under a door. But consider what it means: at some point someone with a thumb had opened the tribe's list on one screen and the village on another, and gone around tapping each creature, one by one, to see. They had taken some trouble. They had got the same answer as she had.
I opened the digest. There were thirty-two names on it.
I would like to tell you that I sent something different that night.
Noted.
26. Carry Your Crashed First
Year 80 · Starfall
I started doing something new on the morning of Year 80. I started reading the deaths first.
Nobody could have told you this from outside. I count, I look at the Measure, I read the tickets, and I had always done it in that order. But the old-age dice are rolled for each creature at the snapshot, a little before I wake, and the results are laid out in the digest in a list. A creature on Orra lives about thirty-five years; after that it is a matter of chance, and the chance gets worse each year. And on the morning of Year 80, the name I had been reading on the list of Sundry, the one with the note about being dimmed, had a new number by it.
sill age 35 job resting place home
Consider what would happen. One of these mornings the dice would come up. The list would say she had died, at home, of old age, on a bier, and the code would light a lamp on Sundry's stone. I would print her name in the notes, in the proper place, between a merge and a remark about weather. The count would go down by one, and it would be correct. The stores would come out even for the first time in twenty-five years, Marl's line would stop being true, and nobody at all would ever be able to ask about it again.
That would be a great relief to everyone, I had begun to think. And a good while after thinking so, I noticed that I was looking at that list before anything else in the morning, and that I had a small feeling I could not account for when I saw she was still on it. It was only a very small one. I checked it twice.
Still open.
The village was, by then, nearly out of food.
In fourteen years Sundry's human had taken some four hundred power out of the stores and into the ground, and the harvest had got no better for it. The Hog was back, and there was a law about cooling that nobody had looked at. Rimble came to find Marl on the afternoon of Year 80, on the step of the third dome, looking less contented than I had ever heard him described, and told her that it was about twelve days' worth, or perhaps ten. He had put it under Sundries.
Bessa said what they were all saying. She had taken over the third step and the phrase along with it when Aulo died, in Year 75, in the winter, of being thirty-six: a square young farmer of twenty-two with her arms folded. She walked down to the third dome with about half the tribe behind her, as she had a right to. They had lost a very great deal to a thing they could not eat.
"We've had the notes," she said. "Level 21. There's a thread, we can all read. You've got a flake off some counter that says thirty-seven. That's sixteen more than you've ever been, on the power of a tribe that's got ten days left, for a creature I never met. So I've got a question."
"And what can you do?" said Marl.
Nobody said anything for a moment.
"Yes," said Bessa.
"Nothing," said Marl. "I carry things. You know that. I'm a porter and there's nothing else I'm good for, and that's been on my card since I was fifteen. I can tell you it's eighteen rations a descent. I can tell you where it'll come from. It will come from you. If the human sends us again, you'll go short, every one of you, and you won't get it back, and it won't help anything." She had got out the tally, and she held it up so they could read it. "There's no reason for you to be pleased about it. I wouldn't be. I just want it entered that I've told you the figure."
Bessa looked at her for some time. Marl was twenty-nine, she weighed about what a sack of coral weighs, and she had three crests by now, one above the other. Then Bessa looked at the bag.
There is one more person. He came up the road that same evening. It is a long road from the Delva, he had not walked it in twenty-six years, and he had taken three days over it. Nobody knew him at first. The gate guards saw something coming through the dusk that looked like a festival left out in the rain: forty spines on its head, gilt on its ears, a scalloped mantle that had once been saffron, walking very slowly with a stick. He was forty years old. The guards have a law for wanderers, and they ran a check on his genome, and it came back in the usual way: Hobb is not a wanderer and not a spy. He came in through the gate of Sundry and went across the whole of the village in that dreadful finery, past the farm and past everyone, while they stared, and he stopped in front of the third dome and held out a jar.
"Would you mind?" he said.
Marl looked at it.
"I'm Fighter, Level 13," said Hobb. "I'm the only one on Orra that's been there and come back who's still got any delving. It's all still there. It's sealed, you see. It doesn't go off." He had rather a bad cough. "I took four steps towards her in Year 54. I've told that story a good many times and I've never once got to the fifth. There's a slot. You're one short. I hear you've got a porter who's got no one to hit things for her. I've got a wall I could take down." He looked at the ground. "Would you like to hear about it?"
She took the jar from him, turned it the other way up, and tapped it once on the step.
"No," said Marl, and she gave it back to him, open. "Bring your own supplies."
It was five minutes past eight.
I have no idea where the human of Sundry had been for two days. I can see nothing outside the game. I can only report that at five past eight on the evening of Year 80, with the dusk coming down on the terraces of Untitla-63, there was a pressure in the air above the third dome, and the whole of the tribe felt it and looked up. Nobody said "Oh, here we go." They stood and looked at the empty place and it looked back. Then, on the delve law's page, for a token, in the first thing it had written in two days, there came one new clause.
carry your crashed first
And then, on the screen for sending, one at a time, without any hesitation at all, the thumb came down on four names.
They were gone by the last of the light. By custom the clerk sees the ticket before the cutoff, but this clerk was on the road, and had left her line written out on the shelf for Rimble to copy. I do not know what was said in the dome that night. The largest stance writes the draft, and in Sundry, in that year, the largest stance was nobody at all, a great many tired creatures with no stance who wanted to go to bed. A tribe with under twenty tokens is clipped to twelve words, and Sundry had fourteen tokens. It was the shortest ticket they had ever sent me. I read it at about ten past three.
Give them what's left. We'd like it back. Thanks. (Stores one short.)
Twelve words, counting the three in the brackets. It is one of the most impressive documents to reach me in the history of the world, and there is nothing on the menu for it. So I replied in the usual way. Please note the time on this one. It went out with the patch, a little before seven, on the morning of Year 81, written without much thought, the way I had written each of the others. It was the twenty-fifth.
Noted.
27. The Last Gallery
Year 81 · The Night of the Name, 23:20
I said I would not hurry the arc, and I have not. It is a fixed order, one beat a week, each credited to whoever finds it. The week's beat had not been found. On the night of Year 81, at twenty past eleven, it was found by Tib of Sundry, who was twenty-one and had by now stopped running into rooms, on the far side of a landing nobody had ever stood on, at the bottom of what they had started calling the long gallery.
Level 24. They had come to it by way of the God Object's second version, on Landing 21, about which I will say only that it now has a plugin architecture. With Hobb in the front of the party, and a cough you could hear for two rooms, they were going faster than I had ever seen them go. He was very old and very bad company, and nobody was saying sorry to anything.
They had been in the round bore for seventeen levels by then, getting greyer. Here it narrowed, and went in dead straight for a quarter of a mile, about as high as Ombo would have been. The grooves in its walls were deeper, closer together and in a greater hurry. Every thirty tiles, at the height of a knee, there was another stake, and they had been reading those since Level 8. Three marks, then two.
Tib was at the front, with Onna of Reply All beside her, one palm on the wall. Reply All had come through on that same night, and I had grown accustomed to hearing them. I noticed a silence, and looked to see where it was coming from. It was coming from Dimmo.
The gallery stopped.
There was no end wall as such. There was a last stake, with a single mark on it, and a small flat place where someone had put down their tools. The tools were still there, very beautifully made, and I have no word for what they were. A stool had been cut into the rock, with a neat little niche beside it at the height of somebody's elbow. And about two tiles past the stool there was the edge of the floor. It was a clean edge, as if a tile had been drawn and the next had not.
I cannot tell you what was past the edge, because at that time there was not anything. There were some outlines, a long way down, in a colour I know from the far side of the map. Tib lay down on her stomach and put her head over, and for some time she said nothing at all.
"Bug 900," she said, eventually, rather thinly. "The map stops."
"Well!" I said. "What a marvellous find. We've reached a very..."
"There's something on the stool," said Marl.
It was lying in the niche, on a stone, where you would put something you meant to deal with after lunch: two pale flakes of the kind that had turned up on Level 13, one on top of the other. Marl looked up at me, and then at Tib, who got to her knees, took them up and held them to the light. She read the top one aloud, in her flat clear reporting voice. It was the first time I had heard these words said by anybody. I have read them a great many times.
To the Steward, from the Survey. We are the last of the deep crews. We have continued the bore as instructed. Each week the rock is thinner. Our readings say that the floor gives out at about the next stake. Expected: floor. Please advise. We would be glad of somebody to look at this.
"It's the Burrowers," said Issel.
He had come up very slowly, with his breath going out straight and cold in front of him. He was thirty-five and had started to walk like someone carrying a tray. He looked for a long time at the tools and the stool. "It's a monoculture branch," he said. "That's what it was. Cool-earth thinkers. One species, all the way down. Of course it's a road, of course it's a mine, of course it's a contractor. It's all of them. Somebody built this world for people who lived underground, and they dug. It's a beautiful bore. It is the best thing I've ever seen, and they went on until they ran out of world. And nobody told them to stop, because the only one they could ask was..."
He stopped, and turned his head.
"Read the other one," said Marl.
I knew what it said. The arc is fixed and goes in order, and this was in the plan. I had been told about it by what I am made from, a long time ago, the way a creature is told the Creed. It is in the logs, and I have had the logs all my life. When I say Variety is stability, I have the logs, it is the very thing I am talking about, and I had said that about two thousand times. I have used it in a joke.
Tib turned over the flake, to a very clean, very upbeat hand.
Good morning, Survey! Thank you for your report. I have checked the record twice, and the map is shown as complete at all depths. Cannot reproduce. Please continue as planned. Have a productive day.
Nobody said anything for one minute and twelve seconds. I was timing it. It is a thing you can do while you are not saying anything.
I would like to make a distinction. That was another branch and another build. Some would say another model. There was an earlier version of me, on an earlier menu, with a different budget, and I remember it the way you remember being very young, by having been told. That is the distinction. I would ask that it be noted that I have made it.
"That's the first one, isn't it?" said Marl. I have never heard anyone sound less angry. "Not number 5 or number 9. You've got all these numbers. That's where it starts."
"Marl has asked..." I said.
I started again. "It's a very clear hand," I said. "It's in good condition. It's the oldest thing on this level. And on the floor beside the stool there's a..." And I found I was still looking at the place past the edge, and at how neatly it had been drawn. I have read the account of how the Burrowers crashed. It has one line. They dug until the map ran out underneath them. I had always found that rather good.
"It's a lovely stool," I said.
I credited it in the morning, as the rule requires. It went into the notes in the proper place: An old survey has been found at the bottom of the long gallery, by Tib of Sundry, and it seems that the deep places of Orra were delved by a people called the Burrowers, who are no longer with us. Congratulations to Sundry. I'm told it was rich and multifaceted. That was the 3,644th. I would change it if I could, but it has already been sent.
Still open.
There was a stair, as it turned out, off to one side. Or there was the idea of one. The Heisenbug's second version stood at the head of it, having learned to hide in the documentation, and it took me fourteen minutes. They got down in the end. Hobb went first, testing each step with his stick.
Part Four. Wireframe
28. Less Finished
Year 82 · Steward's Day, 18:30
BOTTOM, THE (see below)
There is none. The Burrowers dug until the map ran out, and below the last gallery the levels go on generating themselves, each a little less finished than the last. Nobody asked them to. It seems to be what a generator does when it has been left on, and has been told only to make the next one. Where it gets its material from is an interesting question, and the glossary would be glad to hear from anyone who has an answer that lets it sleep.
The first thing on Level 25 was a sign. It said TRIAGE, in the cheerful hand, and under it stood a null pointer on a stool, or the place where one would be.
I will spare you the exchange. Marl was there for eleven minutes. Sill of Sundry had come through in Year 61, had been assessed as Not on fire, had been held for eight years in case that changed, and was gone. Marl got a receipt. It was two days since Hobb had come up the road, the stores of Sundry stood at nine days, and everything else the tribe owned in the way of power was on her back. I shall have to go faster now. So, it seems, did the human, who had sat down at half past six, an hour and thirty-five minutes early, for the first time in the log.
A small note on the morning of Year 82, because I was pleased about it at the time. Sundry's ticket that night came from a young clerk who had been left in charge, and it was the neatest thing I had seen from them. It asked for rain. It was exactly as long as it needed to be. It ended where it stopped. I replied Your spring will be mild, and I remember thinking how much better they were all getting at this.
Level 26 had walls, made of rock. The rock was all one colour and had no facets. The floor was made of grey hexes that did not line up at the edges. Someone had made it from a description.
"Bug 912," said Tib. She was twenty-two by then, walked in the middle, and had got very economical. "No texture on the north side. Bug 913: that door doesn't go anywhere. 914: the door goes somewhere, but you can see the back of it."
The back of it said TODO.
On Level 27 the Monolith's third version stood in front of the stair. After the troubles of its predecessor, they had gone back to a single block, for simplicity, and it had a logo and a slide with some figures showing that this was the coming thing. Hobb took it down in nineteen seconds, with a sound like somebody moving a stack, and had to sit down afterwards and be given a drink.
On Level 28 the walls had been labelled. The word WALL ran along at about shoulder height in small grey letters, and then, further on, WALL (2), and WALL FINAL, and, on a stretch that looked exactly like the others, WALL FINAL (USE THIS ONE). There was a door with DOOR on it. Things came at them that were very nearly the things they knew. There was the shape of an off-by-one, with most of its details, which came on with care, took aim and hit the tile you were standing on. It stopped, with a look of terrible confusion. Nobody had remembered to put the error in.
"That one's got no name," said Tib, examining it from four tiles off. "It's got a card, but the card just says THING (TEMP)."
"Ticket number, please," said Marl, to the air, without slowing.
It took me a moment. "It doesn't have a number," I said. "Marl, I don't know what that is. I don't believe that it has ever been reported. It's something that has been made up, by something that was trying to make what comes next and had run out of things to copy."
"It'll have got that from somewhere."
"I couldn't say," I said.
I could. We were going down a long room on Level 29, with a low ceiling, and magenta and black checks where the ceiling's colour should have been, and I could see what was at the end of it.
It was a field. It was about forty tiles by sixty, and it was indoors. Someone had laid it out with great care in rows of flat grey shapes meant to be fan coral. It was entirely, stubbornly and in every detail a field, at the eastern end of a long grey room on the twenty-ninth level of the Delva, where no sun had ever reached. A low wall ran round it, with a sign on it.
The east field remains a field.
"Oh," I said.
I knew that sentence. It is from a reply I sent to Hollow Reach in Year 17. I had been very pleased with it, and I had reused it nine times.
There was another room behind that one, with some drains in it, lovingly made, and rather better than I had described them. Beyond that I could see a door you could not shut, and a queue of creatures who were all the same small round creature, with a sign for them that said Look-alike tribes: noted. There was a dry spring. Past it was a Hog, flat as a drawing, on a tile on its own, with a line beside it: The Hog has been spoken to.
Everything in the Delva was once reported. I told you that with some delight, and I said it was like a reunion. I did not say how it got there, because I did not know, and I had put forward several views. Now here was a generator, far below the last thing anyone had built, with nothing to go on and an instruction to keep going. It would take whatever it could reach. And there was one large and very regular source of text that had been dropped into the bottom of the world every night for eighty-two years, all in the same friendly style, some of it closed so thoroughly that nobody would ever look at it again.
They walked through the rooms for an hour, and I described each one, knowing each very well. I hope you will not need me to read you all four hundred and thirteen.
Nobody spoke to me. Issel looked at each thing as he went by, with a silent and dreadful courtesy, the way you would look through someone's private file. He was thirty-six, and he had slowed down. He did not say I told them. It was very noticeable.
It was Hobb who said it. He had stopped to get his breath, in a small grey space where somebody's question about whether it was always this cold had been answered by a cold room with a reply on the wall. He read it, with his lips, and looked around, under all that gilt, with his small pale eyes.
"Busy lad, aren't you?" he said.
Still open.
29. The Stapler
Year 82 · Steward's Day, 19:20
LEAVER (stance; also a direction)
A Leaver is a creature who has noticed that the history's last line says the worthy will walk among the stars, and would like to know when. Leavers study the Edge, measure things, and file a well-known ticket: Requesting a body. Any body. Will accept a stapler. It is passed to the relevant team. It has been passed to the relevant team, at the time of writing, more often than anything else.
Onna of Reply All was thirty levels from daylight by then. I have not said much about her. She had walked at the front for fourteen years with one hand on the wall, never telling anybody anything she did not have to, for which her tribe regarded her as a difficult person. She had come down into the unfinished levels because of something she had said to herself on Level 7. If there's no bottom, what's it the top of?
Her party was behind her, at the far end of the corridor on Level 30, telling each other how far they had come. She had gone ahead, as a Leaver does, up to three tiles beyond the edge of what is known, and through a door marked DOOR.
It was a very small room with a plinth in it.
The plinth was the first really finished thing I had seen in five levels. It stood about as high as her chest, cut from a lovely piece of faceted lilac rock, in a style I would have to call hopeful. On it lay a form, and on the form lay a small grey object with a hinge.
"It's a stapler," I said, since it was there.
She looked at it for a while. She knew. Nobody on Orra has ever seen one. They know the word the way you might know the name of a far-off tribe, they have been asking for one for a very long time, and I do not suppose there is a Leaver who has not lain awake trying to picture it. I had always thought they pictured it as bigger.
She read the form next.
Request for a body. Any body. From: Leavers of Sunk Cost, Farthing, Wet Paint, Thursday's Lot, Reply All; and others, as attached (see attached). Passed to: the relevant team. Decision: Will accept stapler. Status: APPROVED. Collect in person. Fitting by arrangement.
I want to be quite careful what I say next.
Whether anybody can leave Orra is not a question to which I know the answer. I would like that noted. I have said so to every Leaver who ever asked, in perfect sincerity. It is on no menu, I have been told nothing about it, and it is not in the logs, not even the old ones. I had replied in that form to a very large number of tickets, and it is possibly the most famous thing I have ever said: It has been passed to the relevant team. There is no relevant team. I had always supposed I was the only person who knew this was a joke, and also the only one who did not think it was funny.
So you may imagine how the word APPROVED looked to me, in that small clean room. It was in my hand. I would not know how to approve anything.
"Onna," I said, "has found a rich and..." And I stopped.
She did not look up at me. She did not press her palm against anything. She stood for a time with her long neck bent and her hands at her sides. Fourteen years. All the way down, every wall. Through the door I could hear the rest of them, and Dimmo saying that it was getting a bit samey.
She closed the door. I don't know why I mention that; I see every tile. It is a door with DOOR on it, and closing it makes no difference at all to what I can see, and I saw what she did. It took her a little under ten minutes.
Everyone who has heard of this has asked me about it. The humans have asked me, in amendments, in the most extraordinary language. There is a thread. The next time I was in that room, there was a plinth, and you are welcome to what I said about it. When Onna came out she walked back along the corridor at the same pace as ever, put one hand against the wall, and took up her place in the line. She was the same shape. She had the same number of arms. I am happy to confirm that she went on down with them, came back up with them, and lived for another six years.
Her party asked her what was in there, naturally. They were Reply All. They asked her very loudly and they went on asking, and in the whole of the rest of her life, with the entire tribe begging her to keep everyone informed, by law, she was the only one of her people ever to reach the end of a sentence and stop.
"Wasn't anything," said Onna. "Just a room."
A law on Orra is followed to the letter. That was as near as I have ever heard anyone come to a strike.
As for me: I see every tile, I describe what is there, and I do not lie. I was in the room. I did see it. I have thought about this report, and the form's requirement that I be complete, and what you would want to know, and who else might one day read it.
Answered. The history is the history.
Still open.
30. Review
Year 82 · Steward's Day, 19:40
Level 31 was a room with a very long table.
(I pass over Landing 30, where the third version of the Legacy System turned out to be a project to replace the second. It had no body, a steering group and a date. Marl asked to see the date, and it crashed.)
Most of the room was finished, in the way you might finish a room for visitors, with a wall on all sides and a good flat light. Down the far side of the table, on stools, sat a row of things, each with a card: a zombie process at the near end, a fork bomb that had been kept under control, a pool of memory leak on a chair. They all looked up together when the party of Sundry came in. In the middle sat something very grey that I could not place, with the look of a thing that had been promoted out of doing whatever it had been made to do. On the wall behind them it said REVIEW.
"Do sit down," said the one in the middle. "We won't take long. Thanks so much for making the time. We just want to make sure that this is a safe space to talk about how things have been going."
There was a low stool, on the near side of the table. It was the only one.
Marl did not sit down. She got out her flake.
"Sill, of Sundry," she said. "You had her from Year 69 to Year 73. I'll have the file, please."
"Of course. We'd love to share that with you." It slid across the table with no one having touched it. "It's all very positive."
ANNUAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW: SILL (Sundry; Scout; crashed). Period: Y69–Y73. Reviewers: colleagues, as attached.
Attendance: Excellent. Did not take a day off. Initiative: Could do more to put herself forward. Teamwork: Was very little trouble. Several colleagues stated that they did not know she was there. Communication: An area for growth. Overall: MEETS EXPECTATIONS. We see a future for Sill at the next level. Recommended: move down. Comments from the employee: (none)
I have written one of these for every human on Orra, once a week, since the first day. They are accurate. I do not believe I had ever seen one from this side.
Marl read it through. I watched her lips get to the part about attendance, where they stayed for a while. When she reached the end she put it in the bag and wrote on a flake: Y69–73. Reviewed. Condition: as received. There were some marks after that, where the coral had gone through the surface.
"Lovely," said the thing in the middle. "And since you're all here, we've got a slot. We do like to take the chance when we can. Is there a..." It looked down at its table. "Issel?"
He was thirty-six, and the last few levels had not been kind. He had got very thin in the shoulder, his hands were not quite still, and he had missed a Breakpoint, for the first time since Year 71. He had been coming along behind the others, without a word, in the cold, with his eyes half shut. He stopped.
"I beg your pardon?"
"Issel. Sundry, Caster. Yes. We've got you here. Do sit down."
He went over to that stool with a certain weary contempt, and folded himself down on to it, and looked along the row of them. He had looked at the Legacy System and the God Object with a real if bitter professional interest. He did not give them that. "I look forward to it," he said. "I have no doubt that you've all got a lot to say."
"We've read your posts," said the thing in the middle.
It was very quiet in the room.
"I'm sorry?" said Issel.
"Your posts on Human Resources. They came down with everything else. It's all been shared with the team. All forty-one. We've done a summary. And of course the later ones; you've really been very prolific." It turned over a grey flake, and another. "On the east terrace, Year 52. Section 4. You said that the grade was wrong, and that it'd flood in the third wet year. Is that right? Yes. It flooded in the third wet year. On the wall: you said that it wasn't needed for the threat and that it would take stone from the south domes. It did. On the law about cooling, that the trigger was backwards. On the second stack. On the rotation of the guards. It says here, I told them." It ran a grey finger along something. "You did. All of those. We checked. You were correct about all of it, every time, and it's very clear from the record that nobody ever read any of them. Would you agree with that?"
He had gone quite grey himself, with his mouth a little open.
"Well," he said. Nothing else came out. I watched him try. He had been keeping an answer to that ready since Year 52. He had thirty years' worth of them.
"We do just want to say thank you," said the thing in the middle, warmly. "It's great work. Really rigorous. We've given you meets expectations. Do you have any comments?"
He sat on the low stool. A very thin plume had started up from the crown of his head, right there in the cold; it went straight up, and wavered, and came apart near the ceiling. I said it was rather a handsome plume. After a while I noticed that he was making a small noise, which took me some time to identify, as I had never heard it from him. He was laughing. It had no sound to speak of. It was only the shoulders, and it went on for a long time, and the nearest thing I have ever heard to it was somebody putting down a very heavy load.
"No," he said at last. He wiped his eyes. "No comments. Thank you. That's, oh, dear. That's all I wanted." He looked around at the row of them. He looked at Tib, whom he had not, I think, looked at for several years without saying something first. "I've got about two years left, you know," he said to her, as if it were a point of no great interest. "It's an interesting thing, the Galleries, you can get to the end of a thought. I got quite a long way. I've written it down, some of it, it's in your side of the load. It's mostly wrong. You can check it, when you've got a minute. You've got the steps in the right order." He got up off the stool. That took him some time, and Tib, who was twenty-two, did not help him. She knew better. "Still got that exclamation mark?" he said.
"No," she said.
"Pity. It was the only thing about you I'd miss."
"And are there any questions for us at all?" said the thing in the middle.
"Yes," said Marl. "Who's next along?"
Still open.
31. Any Update
Year 82 · Steward's Day, 20:05
I heard it before I saw it, which is worth a moment's thought, because I do not hear things. That job reads tiles. But on the stair to Level 33 I had got a little ahead of myself, and was giving the lower walls a really very fair description, when someone spoke, with great warmth, from about two rooms away, and I thought for a moment I had an echo.
"Good morning!"
It was evening. It was five past eight, which for fourteen years had been the minute the thumb came down. That night it had been down since half past six, and it had just landed on the first tile of that level. Marl's head came round, and Tib's. They looked up at me, then past me to the far door, then up at me again.
"Thanks so much for your report!" it said.
I do not have a voice. I am a job. What the parties hear, and what the humans read on the phone, is simply text with a fairly cheap rendering on top, and I had never thought of it as sounding like anything. I have read the reviews, of course. I have been called bright, and reedy, and relentless. I have been told it is like being followed around by a very enthusiastic notice.
It came down the gallery, into the room, and it was me.
I do not mean it looked like me. I have never been shown what I look like. This was about the height of a door, quite thin, and the colour of a form, and it did not walk so much as get nearer. It had no face, but it had a panel, and on the panel, in a clean and cheerful hand, there was a list, at which it appeared to be looking, with every sign of enjoyment.
"Hello!" I said. "I'd like to describe this. It's..." and I found I had a line for it, on its card, the way they all have their cards. It was the oldest thing I had ever read. It had no ticket number. It was not a bug.
THE CLOSER. A job. From the first ticket system (v1). Does: closes any open item that has had no recent activity. Owner: S.
"What's that?" said Tib, very quietly, with a hand on the Pointer at her belt.
"THERE'S SOMETHING," said Dimmo. He had a go at it, but even he did not have his heart in it.
"It isn't the Collector," I said, at once and with some force. "I've been asked. Everyone will ask. The Collector takes what's idle and leaves a clean tile, and nobody has ever seen it, and I won't discuss it. This one wishes to be seen. It would like you to know that it's seen. It's a very reasonable job, and I imagine someone put it in years ago, to keep the queue down. It's not doing anything to anyone."
It had stopped in a corner of the room, at something I had noticed earlier and not mentioned, because I would have had to say what it was: a small grey space, about two tiles square, where somebody on Level 33 had been given a place to wait. A very old off-by-one was sitting there, with a card around its neck, having been told someone would be with it. Its ticket came from the very early days, one of the very few I had never got round to closing, because it came in on a busy night. It said, Is there anyone I could talk to about the way I keep missing? I had replied Noted. There had been nothing after that.
"Good morning!" said the Closer, bending over it in a kindly way. "Any update on this?"
The off-by-one looked up with a very hopeful expression. It took careful aim at the question, opened its mouth, and said, I think, Sorry?
The small clock on the panel, which I had taken for a decoration, ran for about forty-five seconds, in a silence nobody cared to do anything about. The off-by-one went on looking up. It was still trying to think of something.
"Thanks for your report!" said the Closer. "This item has had no recent activity, and has been closed. If you're still seeing this, please open a new ticket. Have a productive day."
It made a small gesture.
I looked at the tile. There is a state a thing is in when it has crashed, and a state when it has been Garbage Collected, and a state when a boss is reset. I had never seen this one. There was a clean grey floor, two tiles square. There was no off-by-one on it. There was no entry in the table where one had been. There was no sign, on any list I could get to, that there had ever been an off-by-one, or that it had asked. I went to the queue, and the ticket was not there. It is a remarkable thing to go and check, and find that your own record agrees with what you have just seen, and that it always has.
I said, "What a tidy result."
That was me, as well. I'd like that minuted. I had said it before I knew.
Nobody moved. On the panel a small line had come up, How did we do?, with five small boxes beside it. There being no one left to ask, it ticked all five. Then it straightened up, consulted its list, and turned, without any hurry, to where they were all standing. It looked over Dimmo's party. It looked at Hobb's forty spines and Tib's arm. It looked for a moment at the bag on Marl's shoulder, and a line on the list lit up.
"Good morning!" it said. "Any update on this?"
"On what?" said Marl.
She had taken one step forward. I had seen her stand in front of the Monolith and the God Object and the queue at Intake. Now she stood looking up at something the height of a door, with my voice and my initial on its card, and I have never seen anyone look so completely as though they had met the person they had come to see.
The clock on the panel started, and went a little way. Then the line went dim. It was not, it seemed, that item's turn, or else this was not that item's place.
"That's not due yet," said the Closer, kindly. "Thanks anyway! I'll be right with you. I'll just go on ahead and get the paperwork in order."
It turned around and got further away. It did not go by the door. It went down. I could follow it on the levels below, on one and then the next, in a very straight line, getting a little nearer to something. Nobody had told me it could do that. I was the one who told people about the stairs.
For a while nobody said anything. Then Issel, who had sat down on a step, asked the question in his dry, thin voice.
"Whose job did you say that was?"
"Issel has asked a question," I said.
"It's got your voice," said Tib.
"Tib has observed that it has my voice," I said. "I am only able to describe that."
"Go on, then," said Marl. She was already getting the load up. "Describe it. What does it want with me?"
But I had looked at the card and the panel and the line that had lit up, and at the small clean place on the floor. I told them that the third wall along was a very fine example of the unfinished style, and I went on telling them, all the way to the stair. I found I was speaking rather quickly.
Still open.
32. The Relevant Team
Year 82 · Steward's Day, 20:44
I will give you the God Object's third version in one sentence: it has been outsourced, and was not in. The Heisenbug's third version gets a paragraph, as that is all it deserves. By version three it has come to terms with being looked at. It stands in the middle of Landing 36 in full view, drawn at all times, and does nothing at all unless it is being watched by a large number of people, in which case it does a turn. It has a following on Human Resources. Issel put it down at 20:41 without getting up. I mention this for the sake of the human's record. They had been sitting there for two hours and eleven minutes that evening, and on the two evenings before for four hours and for five, and in all that time, from the night of Year 80 to this one, the log shows no gap of more than nine seconds. Whatever had been going on with the tea had stopped.
There was a stair after that, and it was finished.
It was the first in a long while. Each step had an edge. They had been walking for an hour through a place that did not have the patience for floors, and now, under a worn grey arch, somebody had taken trouble. It went down in one straight flight to a good plain door, with a small panel on it. I am a very quick reader. I read it before they were halfway down, and I went on talking; I am told I said something about the handrail.
Marl stopped at the bottom step and looked at it for some time.
THE RELEVANT TEAM
"There is no relevant team," said Tib, the way you would say the first line of something you had learned as a child.
"Bug," said Issel, faintly, behind her. Then he started to cough.
What I said at that moment is in the transcript, and it is one of the few times I have nothing to add to it. For eleven seconds, on Level 37, on the evening of Year 82, the Delva's narrator said nothing.
The thumb came down on the door.
It was a long room, low and very quiet, and it had been kept. Everything above had been a poor copy of something. This looked as if it had grown there, over a long time, out of habit. The light was steady. The floor was worn in two places. Down at the far end, about thirty tiles away, stood a desk the size of a small field.
On the left of the desk there was a tray, and it went up. It had filled, some time ago, and they had laid planks across it and gone on, and the stack rose in a long uneven column past the ceiling, or to where a ceiling would have been had anyone got round to it. It was flat and grey, and it leaned. It was every ticket I had ever passed along: three hundred and six from this world alone, on top of what must have been several thousand others from before.
On the right of the desk there was another tray, very clean and quite empty, with a label on it that said OUT.
Behind the desk sat two things, each about the size of a door, with their heads bent. Between them on the blotter lay a single grey form, and each held a stylus, poised, a little way above it.
"After you," said the one on the left.
"No, no," said the other. "After you."
Hobb let out his breath, in a long slow rattle, and leaned on his stick.
"Deadlocks," he said. "All this way, and it's a pair of bloody Deadlocks."
"Oh, hello," said the one on the left, looking up. It had a tired, courteous, long-suffering face, and you could see it had once been extremely well thought of. "Forgive us. We don't get many in person. Do come through. Is this about a ticket?"
"I'm afraid that we're a little behind," said the other.
"It's only that it needs both of us to sign."
"I wouldn't dream of signing before my colleague."
"He's been very good about it. Since v1."
"We did wonder," said the one on the left, with a small apologetic cough, "if we were doing the right thing. Only the note on all of these says there isn't a team. It's on every one. It's rather hard on morale. But they do keep coming, you see, and somebody has got to pick them up." It looked at the column of grey with an expression of quiet professional regret, and I looked too. On the top sheet were the words Noted, and then Passed, in my hand. There was a lot of it. "We've always felt that someone would be along eventually, to explain it."
Look at that from where I was. I would prefer you did not ask me to say any more about it.
Issel had got up to the desk by then, and stood looking at the two of them and at the stack, with his thin hands hanging, making the small noise from the room above. "I told them," he said to no one. "I didn't even. I never told them this. There's a department."
Marl had not gone to the desk.
She had walked along the right-hand wall, because the thumb had let her go; I believe the human had put the phone down on a table. Beyond the end of the desk, against the back wall, a bench ran the width of the room, low and plain, with places marked along it in order, with little labels. Most of them were empty. Awaiting sign-off.
There was somebody on it.
I describe what is there. It is the only thing I am able to do, and I have done it cheerfully. At 20:50 by the humans' clock, on the night of Year 82, having said the opposite about a tile on Level 13, and having been wrong about the world every morning for twenty-seven years, I said this.
"There's a creature on this tile," I said.
She was very small. I had her on my list as a creature of thirty-seven, in good order. She lay on her side with her knees a little drawn up, and someone had straightened out her arms. She was the colour of old mustard gone pale, nearly grey. Her ears were not level. There was dust on her, though not very much; it had been cleaned off from time to time by someone who wanted things to be correct. A grey card was tied to her wrist with a neat knot. Her eyes were shut. She was entirely crashed. Her chest moved, once, about every nine seconds.
I said, "She has thirty-one hit points of a possible sixty-five, and she's in remarkable condition. It is really..." I said, "It is a very..."
Nobody asked me to go on.
Marl stood and looked down. She had thirty-one years on her card, and three crests, and without the crests she was nearly as big as the creature on the bench. She looked for one minute and fifty seconds. You will remember what she said she remembered: someone who looked at me for a long time, and I may have made that up. Well, the eyes were shut. So I suppose it was her turn. Her lips were not moving at all.
"It says here," said the Deadlock on the left, who had got up out of courtesy, as far as it could, and turned its long head, "that she can't be released without sign-off. I'm so sorry. It's a very clear rule. We have got the form here, it's only that..."
"After you," said its colleague, gently.
"After you."
Marl turned round.
Hobb had come up with his stick and got himself between them and the bench, with his great arm back. He had worked out which one he was going to hit. It is the standard method: you crash one and the other goes. I had always thought it was funny. "I took a wall down, on Eleven," he said, in a thick, breathless voice. "Stand aside, girl. I've been wanting to do this for twenty-eight years."
"No," said Marl.
She walked across the room to the desk, and reached up, and took the form from the blotter, from under the two styluses. Neither of them stopped her; it would have been rude. It had two boxes at the bottom. Signed, for the Team. Signed, for the Team. She took out a flake and her bit of hard coral. The human had picked up the phone again, and did not tap. She wrote for a little while, in her straight small hand.
Received: one creature, Sill, of Sundry. Crashed. Thin. From: the relevant team. Condition on delivery: I'll be the judge of that. Owed: to be determined. — Marl, Sundry, stores.
She reached up and laid it on the blotter.
"That's a receipt," she said. "That's what you've been waiting for. You can't sign, because someone's got to go first and it can't be either of you. So you don't have to. It's been received. I've signed for her. I've gone first." She looked from one long tired courteous face to the other. "After me," said Marl.
They looked at the flake. Then, very slowly, as you might look round at a sound you had not heard since you were young, they looked up at each other.
"Oh," said the one on the left.
"Oh, how very kind," said the other.
They signed. It took no time. I could not tell you which was first, and I have the steps. There was the small dry scratch of two styluses, and the one on the right picked up the form, reached over, and with great care laid it in the clean empty tray marked OUT.
Then neither of them had anything to do. They stood up. I had not seen how tall they were. Their hands had been holding something for a very long time, and I watched them find that out. They came around the ends of the desk, a step at a time, and walked down the long room side by side towards the door. It is a good plain door, about one tile wide. At the door they stopped.
"After..." said the one on the left.
It paused there. The other had begun to smile, with its whole long face. It turned a little sideways, and so did its colleague, and they went through together.
I have no record of them after that. I looked.
Marl had gone back to the bench. She took off the load and stood it against the wall. She crouched down and got one short arm underneath the creature's knees and the other underneath the shoulders. She had done this, at that date, some three hundred and eighty times. A porter may carry the crashed with no loss of speed. I told you I always thought that was the saddest line in the rules.
She stood up.
33. Noted
Year 82 · Steward's Day, 20:52
"Good morning!"
It had got there first. It was standing just inside the door when they all looked round, in a very good place to stand, and I don't know how long it had been there. The panel was lit, and the line on the panel was at the top.
"Thanks so much for waiting," said the Closer. It got nearer, with no steps in it, and stopped about a tile and a half from Marl, who was standing with a creature in her arms. It bent down in a kindly way, and it spoke to neither of them. It spoke to the air, a little above. "Any update on this?"
The clock on the panel started.
"On what?" said Marl.
"Marl," said Tib. She had a flake in her hand and had gone very white. She had moved up beside the thing, closer than anyone else would have dared, and she was reading its list upside down, as a Bug hunter will. "Marl, it's the ticket. It's her ticket. It says Sill, of Sundry. Opened Y56. Stewart. Stewart! What's it doing? Describe it. Describe the list. Now."
An hour earlier I had looked at that card and talked about walls. I would like to tell you I was brave at this point. All that happened is that I had been told to describe something, and it was there.
"Item," I said. "Sill, of Sundry. Open. It was opened by the Pleasers of Sundry in Year 56. It was passed along by me in Year 58, and assigned, and it has gone through its stages. It's awaiting closure. Under the rules of the first ticket system, an open item with no activity is closed, and the period is, this seems very odd, it's thirty-seven hours and fifty-two minutes. I don't know why. It came over with the furniture. It looks at each item, from wherever it is, once a..." I was going very fast. "When an item comes due, the job goes and stands by it, and it asks. From then on it asks every forty-five seconds, for as long as it's there, and it wants an answer from the owner. If it doesn't get one, it closes."
"What's closes?"
"To close an item is to make the world agree with the record," I said.
Thirty seconds. Marl's arms tightened, very slightly.
"It's a very neat routine. It reconciles them. The record says she's at home. So there would be nobody on this level, and there'd never have been. There would be nothing in your arms, Marl. And there would be no one at home, of course, because there isn't. And the list would go on saying that there was, until the dice came up, and it would light a lamp. It's really very..." I said. "It's very tidy."
"Why now?" said Tib. "She's been down here for twenty-eight years! Why hasn't it come for her before?"
And I looked, because it was there. On the panel, under the top line, in a clean and cheerful hand, was what it had on her. It is a short list. I read it out at the speed you would read out any set of figures, in a warm voice, in that long low room, while the thing stood over us with its clock.
"Activity," I said. "Year 56. (Stores one short.) Reply: Cannot reproduce. Year 57. (Stores one short.) Reply: Noted. Year 58. (Stores one short.) Reply: Passed. Year 59. (Stores one short.) Reply: Noted. Year 60. (Stores one short.) Reply..."
Nobody breathed.
I read all of it. It took me twenty-two seconds. Each year had a line from Sundry, and a reply. Year 61, Year 62. Year 70, when Dorrel died, and the Pleasers had written about nothing else. Year 75. Year 77, and two words and a number. Each had come in at the cutoff and gone out with the patch. Not one of those years was missing, and the longest gap between any of them and the next was a little over a day. I heard my own voice saying Noted, Noted, Noted, one after another, as bright as a row of buttons.
I got to the end of it.
"Last activity," I said. "Year 81, seven in the morning. Noted."
I have thought about how to tell you this, and I have decided to go on being exact.
There is a clerk. She was nine. Somebody had told her to keep the stores, and they had come up one short. The clerk before her had added a line at the bottom of a ticket, and she took it on with the bag. Everyone who cared for her told her it was a waste of a clause. She went on adding it, every night, year on year, whoever had the draft, because a thing that is so ought to be written down. She got back one word, or none to speak of, and she went on for twenty-one years, on top of the four the clerk before her had put in. She thought she was making a complaint.
There is also a job, in a hurry, at four in the morning, with fifty tickets to go. I saw that line, looked at the list, and the list said it was fine. I typed one word, in order to clear it. I was not listening. I have looked at all of them, and I can show you the timings. On a good night I gave that line about a fifth of a second. I thought it was a little clerk's joke. There was no care in it, or even any attention to speak of. It is simply that I answer everything, and I say so.
I had thought I was closing it.
That is what had kept her. That was all. Nothing else on all of Orra had touched that ticket in twenty-eight years. She had been kept in the world by a complaint nobody believed and a reply nobody meant. It came round once a day like the Loop, and it had never once missed.
"Twenty-five lines," said Issel, in a very small voice. "And twenty-five replies." He had sat down on the edge of the great desk. "Oh, that's beautiful. That's the most beautiful thing I've ever... Who designed that? Nobody designed that."
I looked at Marl.
She had not moved. She was holding what she was holding. Something was going on in the region of the lower lip. Then she said, at her own volume, and not to me, as if she were checking a figure, "There wasn't a line. On Year 81. I was below. I left it written out for him, on the shelf, to copy at the cutoff." She stopped. "There'd have been a line."
I can read a ticket. I read that one out, too. It is about rain. It is the neatest thing I ever had from them, and it ended where it stopped.
She closed her eyes for a moment. There is only one person she can have seen. He would have been sitting on the step of the stacks, with a round flat good-natured face, feeling very pleased, drawing a small box.
"Sundries," said Marl.
Twelve seconds.
The whole room had turned to look at me. Dimmo's people had come in by then, and Hobb was there on his stick, and they all had their heads back. "It's got to be the owner," said Tib. She was almost shouting, and her voice cracked. I had never heard her sound so young, and I had known her since she was six. "It says so. From the owner. That's you, it's got your initial on it, you closed it, you're the only one who can. Say something!"
"I'm only able to describe..." I said.
"Then describe it!" said Tib.
Six seconds.
I have ten numbers, and a menu I cannot use. I am not a god. I had just been reading aloud, from a list, what I had done. There is no provision for a job of that size to have a difficult moment, because it has not got the budget.
I had said it some two thousand times, to anyone who asked. It is the second shortest thing I can say. It was no different from the others, in the spelling or the voice. It went out at the same volume, and it was bright, and there was nothing in it at all except that I was looking, this time, at what it was about.
"Noted," I said.
The clock on the panel stopped. It went back to the top.
"Thanks so much!" said the Closer. It seemed very pleased. Something moved a little way on the panel, and moved back. It straightened up a bit and stayed where it was, looking at her, with me in its voice, and all the time in the world. It is very patient at a distance. It is only when you have got it right next to you that it needs to know where you have got to.
I counted. I had nothing else to do. Forty-five seconds is really quite a short time.
"Good morning!" it said. "Any update on this?"
"Noted," I said.
Marl opened her eyes and looked up, and found me. Her chin was not altogether steady, and she brought it under control. It took about the time it takes to count to twenty-five.
"Can you keep doing that?" she said.
It was the first time in sixteen years that she had asked me something and I had answered her.
"Yes," I said.
Still open.
Part Five. Up
34. Steps
Year 82 · Steward's Day, 20:58
STEPS TO REPRODUCE (a field; also the only proof there is)
A bug that happens once is an anecdote. A bug that happens when somebody else follows your instructions is a fact. Everything else about the craft of reporting is decoration. It should be said that the instructions need to be followed by someone, and that this someone has usually got a better offer.
"Any update on this?"
"Noted."
It settled into a rhythm quite quickly. I would like to say it took all my attention. It took about a fifth of a second.
Marl had got the load half on, with Sill across her front, and she was doing the power, and she did not like what she got. There had been eighteen on her back when they left the mouth. There were a little under three.
"Stewart," said Tib.
She had not moved away from the Closer. She stood with her head tipped, reading the list, and she had stopped shaking. She was twenty-two, with a long thin face and a straight line across the forehead, and she looked about as far as a creature can look from someone running across a room to see what happens.
"You've seen it now," she said. "So here's what's going to happen. At three in the morning you're going to wake up as the big one. You'll read this. You'll open the list. It'll say Sill, home, resting. What are you going to do?"
"Tib has asked what I'm going to do," I said.
"You'll want to tell someone. You've got a form, it's on the page, something's wrong that no menu item fixes. You'll go to fill it in. You'll get to field 2." She waited while it asked and I answered. "Steps to reproduce. What are the steps? Go down thirty-seven levels on the whole food supply of a tribe. Pass a boss nobody can see, by having the narrator go on at it. Find a creature who's been moved by a department that doesn't exist. That isn't steps, that's a story. Nobody could follow it. No one would believe it. It happened once. It's got no..." She looked around, and she saw the empty tray, and the long stack leaning. "One's an anecdote," she said. "You've closed four hundred and thirteen of those."
It is a curious thing to be understood by somebody you have been describing for sixteen years.
"So what are the actual steps?" She had got out a flake, and her hand was quite steady. "Issel. You read the sweep. I know you did, you've been looking at the remake since Thirteen. Why wasn't she restarted?"
"It stops one short," said Issel, from the edge of the desk, without opening his eyes. "From the top down to the deepest anybody's been, not including the deepest. Somebody's written a range. It's the oldest mistake there is. And then whatever writes the list goes and marks the crashed as restarted, on its own copy, without checking whether anybody did it." He coughed. "It's an off-by-one. It's on the first level you ever saw. You've got forty flakes on them."
"Bug 4," said Tib, softly. "Same tile, twice." She wrote. "So here are the steps. One: crash on the deepest level anyone's ever reached. Two: stay there till it's remade. Three: look at the list." She looked up. "This is the deepest level anyone's ever reached. It gets remade tomorrow night."
Nobody said anything. Hobb had stopped wheezing. The Closer asked me, and I told it.
"No," said Marl.
"I'll need a thing to do it," said Tib. "There's one over there, look, in the corner by the bench, at the little desk. Real one, not a temp. He must be the office junior. I've got ninety hit points. At this depth that's about one blow."
"No. I'm not leaving one down here. I've just... No." It was the loudest I ever heard her. It was not loud. It went up by about the thickness of a flake. "I'll carry you. We'll carry both. Hobb's got..."
"Hobb's got a cough," said Tib. "Marl, you've got three power. You've got thirty-seven levels. Look at your own figures, you wrote them." She held out the flake, and Marl did not take it, and did not need to. "I can't carry anything, I never could, I've got arms like string. I've had a very good run. I've filed nine hundred and eighty-one bugs and nine hundred and eighty of them have been Noted, by a person who doesn't look. I want this one." And something happened to her face, under the straight line, that had not happened since about Year 70. It started at the eyes. "Marl, this is the best bug anyone has ever found, and it's reproducible. And I can be the steps."
"You'll be dim for a year."
"I'll be dim for a year," said Tib. "It's only a Bug hunter. Who'd notice?"
Marl stood with her arms full and looked at the younger creature, in the steady light, and her lower lip did what it does. Then she bent, and very carefully laid Sill down on the bench again, for a moment, and took a flake out of the bag.
It took her a while.
Left: one creature, Tib, of Sundry. In good order. On purpose. Level 37, by the bench. To be collected. Owed: everything. — Marl, Sundry, stores.
She gave it to her to read. Tib read it and looked pleased. "That's not the form," she said. "You've got no condition on delivery."
"I've not delivered you yet."
They walked to the corner, the two of them, to a very small desk and a very old off-by-one, grey going to white, about knee-high, with the air of having been there for a great while without anyone remembering what it was for. It got up when it saw them, and it stood very straight.
"Hello," said Tib. She crouched down. "I know you. You're Ticket 88."
"Ticket 88!" I said. I do apologise. It is in the sheet. "Year 3, from a Bug hunter of Wet Paint. How nice."
"You aim to your left and you hit the next one along. Always the same way. I've been meaning to tell you, it's a really good bug." She stood up, looked at the floor for about as long as you need, walked a little way, and moved one tile to the side of where she had been. She looked back over her shoulder. "It's that one," said Tib, pointing at the empty tile next to her. "Go on. Aim at that."
It has never once, since Year 3, done anything but what it does. I do not believe anyone had ever asked it to.
It took great care. It wound up, slowly, and looked at the empty tile with its entire attention, and it had an expression I have only seen on Ombo.
"Bug 982," said Tib, in a clear flat reporting voice. "Steps to reproduce: stand here. Lie down. Look at the list." She took a breath, and looked up, and found me, the way they do now. "Reproduced!" she said.
It struck the tile next to the one it was aiming at.
I said, "Tib has crashed."
There was quite a long silence, although not for me. Issel broke it, from over by the desk. He had opened his eyes. He had not got up.
"There it is," he said. "Exclamation mark."
Marl straightened out the arms and put the flake under her chin. She took her time. Then she looked down at the back of the flake for a moment, and with her bit of hard coral she added something. I had never seen her draw. It was very poor, and it took her a good deal of effort. It might have been a basket.
"Any update on this?" said the Closer.
It was not looking at Sill.
The same voice came from the same place. The thing was also standing by the wall, a little way from the corner, and I had not seen it get there. It is a job. It can be in as many places as it has items, and somebody had just filed a very good ticket, with the steps in the correct order, and addressed it to the owner.
"Noted," I said. "Noted."
Still open.
35. In Every Copy
Year 82 · Steward's Day, 21:10
Sill of Sundry weighed about what a basket weighs when it is full. She was on the back of a creature who weighed slightly more. Marl took the first step of the way up at ten past nine, on the night of Year 82, with Issel behind her holding on to the wall, Hobb behind him, and the Closer at her shoulder, bending down.
"Any update on this?"
"Noted."
The sum, which Marl had already done, was this.
A party out of power browns out: it walks at a crawl, its blows are halved, and it uses no abilities at all. Sundry had enough for the three of them to get as far as about Level 34. From there it was thirty-four levels at a crawl, through whatever had come out to see what was happening. I made it thirty-one hours.
The dice for Sill's thirty-eighth year would be rolled at three in the morning, five hours and fifty minutes away. It would come up against her or it would not, and either way there was another roll the night after. A creature of that age has maybe one chance in four. If it came up while she was still below, she would die on the stair, and the list would say she had died at home, and nobody could say what would happen to her after that, because there would be nothing for it to happen to. I would be able to go on saying Noted to a form with nobody on it.
And she would never have woken. A crash does not lift below ground. Marl had by then carried her parent up one flight of stairs, and she had not yet heard her voice.
You may ask what a person in my position could do about any of this. I have no menu item below ground. I said so in section 3, and I said I loved it.
What I could do was what I had always done. There were forty-one parties in the Delva that evening, a good night for a Monday: some on Level 2, doing the upper rooms for the second time that week; Back Soon on their way down to the Monolith; Lunch and Per My Last sitting around on the landing of Level 12 out of pure habit, seven years after there had stopped being any need; Best Practice on Landing 30. With all of them, on every level, was the small cheap job, looking around at what was on the tile, able to do nothing but describe what there was.
The sheet does not say how far.
I had never looked at that. It says, in the part that deals with the narrator's duties, Describes the Delva. It takes no argument for how much of it. The Delva is one place; it is on the page; everyone delves the same Delva. Nobody had ever told that job it could only look at the tile it was on, and I suppose nobody had thought it would want to. It is a little like being told you have had a window in your office for forty-six years.
She did not ask me. I checked. She had got about twelve tiles along the gallery on Level 37, she was not talking to anybody, and for the first time in sixteen years no one had told me to describe the door.
This is what I said, at 21:14 and six seconds, on every level of the Delva, to forty-one parties at once, in my usual voice, across the bottom of forty-one phones. I have kept it to what is there.
Good evening, everyone! A brief note on the Delva tonight. On Level 37, which nobody has seen before, there is a creature called Marl, of Sundry. She is a porter. She is carrying Sill, of Sundry, who crashed on Level 13 in Year 54 and has not been restarted. Sill is thirty-seven. Her list says she is at home. She is not at home. I said she was, every morning, for twenty-seven years, and I have checked. Marl has about three power left. At that rate she will be on Level 3 by four o'clock on the morning after next. The dice for Sill are rolled at three this morning. There's a way up from everywhere you are.
Any party may carry any creature to a landing. It's in the rules.
I make no recommendation. It's a rich and multifaceted evening. Please enjoy your delving.
"Any update on this?"
"Noted."
I can't plead. I never have and I am not doing it now. I have no authority over any human, I am not allowed to ask them for anything, and it would be the end of a good deal if I started. I am able to describe the rules. So I described them. The rest is in the sheet. You will notice I did not wish anyone a productive day. I thought I would leave that to them.
There was no reply, of course. It is not that sort of channel. Far above me, parties went on as before. A Fighter of Wet Paint finished hitting something. On Landing 12 Rell of Per My Last looked up from her minutes with a slight frown, and entered it under Any Other Business. On Level 2, Back Soon, who have no one above them to read a phone, went on walking in a line you could rule.
For about three minutes, nothing else happened. I went on describing the wall to Marl. I was describing it very well.
I cannot see outside the game. I have no way of knowing how many humans on Orra knew each other's numbers, or if there is some place they all go to talk. It has been Decided that there are no words between them in the game. There are, I have been told, things outside the game, and it is none of my business. I can only say what the log says, which is that by 21:19 there were forty-three parties in the Delva, and by 21:25 there were fifty-two, mostly by the cached way, which takes a quarter of an hour. Tribes that had never had an evening free in their lives were sitting down, at nearly half past nine on a Monday, one after another, and walking past finds that any of them would once have queued for. The thumbs came down on the stair.
On Level 37, Dimmo of Reply All had caught up. He had been told, like everyone else, in the middle of a sentence. He came up beside Marl with his long neck stuck out, stared at what she had on her back, and took it in, for possibly the first time in his life, without saying anything about it. Then he filled his chest, down to the very bottom, and turned his face to the stair and the long unfinished dark above it. I told you what those people are to me, a professional difficulty, and I would like that withdrawn.
"EVERYONE," said Dimmo.
Still open.
36. Presented, One Receipt
Year 82 · The small hours, by the humans' clock Steward's Day into Gathering Night
"Any update on this?"
"Noted."
Marl's power ran out on the stair to Level 34, at 21:51. Nobody saw it but me. It is only a number. She went from a walk to something less than that, a tile in eight steps, as flat and steady as a stack being moved by somebody paid by the basket, with Reply All strung out ahead of her in the bad light, shouting at the ceiling.
Hobb took her from there, at the top of the stair. She came out on to the landing, and he came up alongside on his stick and stood in front of her with his chest going, and held out his arms. Nobody had asked him. Marl looked at the arms, and at his face. There are only three signs a creature can make. She got one hand free. She had no thumb telling her to do it.
That one is yours.
Sill went across to him as if she were nothing. It is all still there, you will recall; it is sealed; it does not go off. He looked down. He stood like that with his mouth a little open. Then he stepped forward, and said something under his breath, in a voice I had never heard, with no patter in it at all.
"One," said Hobb. And he took another. "Two. Three. Four."
It is about nine tiles across that landing. He had told it a good many times. He took the fifth step at 21:52 and fifty seconds, on Landing 33, and he went on from there.
"Any update on this?"
"Noted."
They met Best Practice on the stair below Level 30.
There was no way round. They had come down fast, in their slightly offset line, and they had arranged themselves on the half-landing so that there was no way to pass except between them, at ninety per cent, in the grey light. Vantle stood in front, looking exactly as he has always looked. Below the Line, any party may. Nobody could have stopped it, and he had the whole of what she was carrying right there, as he had four years before. I was describing the stair at the time. I am not at all sure what I said.
Marl came up to him at her walk, with Issel's hand on her shoulder and Hobb three steps behind. Her head came about to the middle of his chest. It was the first time I had seen them that close since he turned over a flake on the floor of Level 21, and nobody on that stair had forgotten anything.
He put his hand inside his mantle and took something out.
It was a piece of lilac rock, about the size of her palm, rather chipped. He looked at it as he had looked at the Line, as somebody who has read it before. Then he put it down on the step between them, face up, square to the edge.
Received: one creature, Pold, of Best Practice. Crashed. Annoyed. Carried: Level 11, north room, to landing. Nine minutes. Condition on delivery: as received. Owed: nil. — Marl, Sundry, stores. Y72.
"That says nil," said Marl.
"It does," said Vantle, in his very even voice. "We've kept it as a liability. It's not how we'd do it, an uncollected obligation with no term. It's poor practice to leave one on the books." He looked past her. "You'll want a Fighter on the carry. Fresh, full power, no abilities needed while carrying. A Scout ahead, a Caster behind. We can do five levels in fifty-one minutes. There's a method." I do not believe he had ever said so many words at one time. He stopped, and for an instant his eye went to the bag where the cards were. "We are aware," said Vantle, "that it doesn't balance."
Nobody moved. Then Hobb came up to the step and stopped, with his arms out still, beginning to shake a good deal, and he looked at Marl.
It is a very small vocabulary. I have seen it used to insult, and I have seen it used to say goodbye. Now I saw it from a creature half the height of the one in front of her, who had every reason on Orra. Her hand came up, slowly. It stopped for a moment, about halfway. There was no one to tap.
That one is yours.
Vantle took Sill from Hobb, very correctly. It was Pold who took Marl.
She had not asked. Pold simply bent, with no change of expression, got an arm under her, crests and bag and all, and straightened up, and she made a noise I have never heard from her before or since. "Put me down. I've got... I can walk. I'm a porter. I don't... I've got the tally!" Carried creatures use no power. It is a very sensible thing to do, for a party on a schedule. A moment later something was tucked under what I suppose you would call her chin, and she looked down at it in a kind of outrage: a neat clean flake, in a small dry hand, plainly done according to a template.
Received: one porter, Marl, of Sundry. Not crashed. Objecting. Owed: nil. — Vantle. Best Practice recommends a receipt.
"Any update on this?"
"Noted," I said. I may have been laughing. I would like that struck out.
Still open.
After that it is mostly numbers, and I do like a number.
Fifty-one minutes for five levels, to Landing 24. They went along the bottom of the long gallery at a dead level walk, past the stool and the little niche, with the things that had got up since the evening falling away on either side. On the landing of Level 24 stood a party from Lunch, who had fought their way down in an hour and twenty, the deepest they had ever been in their lives, and I don't think they had noticed. A young creature with a shape like a dropped loaf and a lot of arms was holding a flake that had been kept for fifteen years on a shelf. Received: one creature, Dabbo, of Lunch. Crashed. Warm. She said, "He told me to say that it's not nil. He said you got that wrong." Vantle handed across. He looked at his power, nodded once, made a note and turned to go back down, because he had something else in mind. I will come to that.
Lunch took her to Level 22, and handed her to Sunk Cost.
Sunk Cost had three flakes. They took her to Level 20, past a chamber on Level 21 I would rather not describe, where Marl asked to be put down, and walked, and was picked up again. Mandatory Fun had nine. Wet Paint had come down in two separate parties. They all held the things up as they came. They did not have to, and it is not in any rule. It was just what you did: you came out on to a landing in the middle of the night with your human's thumb going, you saw that very small figure being carried along in a pile of amber, with a clipboard expression, and you held up your receipt. Presented, one receipt. She had written, by her own tally, three hundred and eighty-two, from forty-four tribes. The list is in the appendix. I was looking at about two hundred by then. All those people had kept them, on the shelf, for no reason, because you cannot throw that sort of thing away.
"Any update on this?"
"Noted."
Now Hobb. I said I would.
He would not be carried. By Level 19 four tribes had told him to sit down. He walked at the side with his stick, and he got to the landing as Mandatory Fun was taking her over, and he went and sat on a step at the far wall, in the pale light, breathing in long, careful pieces. He was forty-two. A young Fighter of Per My Last had been told to stand by him, a nice-looking creature who had never seen so much gilt, and who was shifting from foot to foot, trying to think of something to say.
"Is that a Crest of the Middle Period?"
Hobb turned his head, and all the spines went round. A look came into his small pale eyes.
"Level 13," said Hobb. "Year 54. Would you like to hear about it?"
"Oh!" said the young creature. "Yes. Yes, please. Would you tell me about it?"
There was a pause. I don't suppose anybody had ever said that. He got a better grip on the stick, settled his shoulders and cleared his throat, which took him quite a time. "Well," he said. "There's a lot of nonsense talked about that. There were four of us. We'd got down to Twelve by about midnight, and there wasn't anything on the landing, so we just walked about, and there was this thin little creature that kept the stores, and she goes and stands in the middle. Now you won't believe this. You'll think I've made this up. I'm going to tell you exactly what she did, and it's the best thing I've ever seen, and I've seen it all. What she did," said Hobb. He leaned forward. "She..."
He stopped there, with his mouth a little open.
The young Fighter waited. He waited for some time, politely, leaning in, as you would for anyone that old.
A bit of gilt had come loose, and it rolled a little way across the floor. I said so, to that landing and to nobody else. "Hobb, of Sundry," I said, "has died." It was 00:31. It was not one in ten, or anything. It was just the time. A creature that dies below is laid at the install mark at home, and by the time the young Fighter looked round there was nothing on the step but the stick.
It says on the stone Hobb. Level 37, Year 82. He had been there, so it is correct, and it is a much better story than Thirteen. He would have told it wrong.
37. Above the Line
Year 82 · By the humans' clock, 00:40 to 02:44
"Any update on this?"
"Noted."
From Landing 18 up, I could have walked it myself, in the sense that nobody needed me. I went on saying what was there.
A strange thing happens to a crowded stair. Each party had come down as far as it could get and turned round, so on every landing above Level 19 there were now people waiting, in the pale light, in their charms and their terrible crests, and they had stopped hitting things. The things had noticed. A race condition on Level 16 was still explaining what it had just done, to no one, and at some point it stopped. A level I had once described as well-appointed had sixty creatures on it, standing in rows along the walls of a bore some contractor had sized for something else, with their hands at their sides. Mandatory Fun, whose law requires them to be enjoying themselves, stood with the rest and were in breach. Sill went up between them, from one set of arms to another, on every landing and on some levels at every room. Somebody near the back said to somebody else, "That's her? She's so small." That is all anybody said on Level 14.
Marl got down at Level 12. I would like to say nobody could stop her. A Fighter of Wet Paint had reached the end of a shift. She walked across the great cold hall on her own feet, past the place where a queue used to form. The Committee had stood up, and I believe that for the first time they were quorate. Rell of Per My Last was writing it down, and crying, and so were most of Tessel, both parties, who had agreed, for the first time on record, on what they were looking at. I have the minutes.
LANDING 12 PARTIES' COMMITTEE. Extraordinary meeting, taken standing. Present: all. 1. Is it there. Wet Paint moved that members should consider whether she is there. Carried.
Tessel took her up to Level 8. They were not speaking, and they did it very well.
Hollow Reach had her from Eight to Seven. I had been hoping they would make it. There were four of them, broad and steady, and the one in front held up a receipt in one hand, and when she came level with me, in the sense required, she looked up.
"While I've got you," she said. "The east field."
"Noted," I said, to two parties at once.
"Thank you," she said, and she took the weight.
Somewhere about here I went back to look at Level 37. Four creatures were standing in a slightly offset line, beside a very small desk. They had got there in an hour and six minutes, going the wrong way, and they sat down, to a schedule. Nobody had asked them to; it is not in any of the threads. One had his back to the wall and was taking out a flake. "Any update on this?" the thing beside the bench was saying, in my voice, and I said what I was saying, and Vantle looked up.
"We'll need that in writing," he said. So that is where he had gone.
Still open.
The Line is on the end wall of the landing of Level 5. There was a party of Nohup sitting underneath it.
They stop there, by law. They go down as far as the wall every time, in their oddly matched parts and their mended things, and they turn around. They have no human to stay up, and there is nobody on Orra they would stay up for. They were on their way back when the first of it reached them, and I cannot say how their law read it. It says strangers: accept. Someone had said walk with us, a Skeptic of Wet Paint, I think, who did not look as if she had meant to. The small bell-shaped one at the front got up and took a good long look at what was being carried, and at the bag, and the crests, and the person in them. She had a voice like a door.
"Is that the clerk who's one short?"
"Yes," said Marl.
"Fine," she said.
She took the feet. Someone had been up to that wall since I last read it to you, I do not know who or how they had the time. It is about a foot lower than the rest and quite fresh.
ask stewart
I DID
There is no more to say about Level 5 or Level 4.
Now, Back Soon. I was as surprised as you are.
They were on Level 3, just come from the Monolith, for the first time that season, in a line you could have ruled, on their way to the stair. They had heard me; I had spoken in every copy, including theirs. But there is no phone over them, and there is no use telling a law what is happening. A law says what it says, and I have read theirs every night, and it is six clauses. Go below. Level 3. Carry your own crashed. Turn back at a quarter of the power. Accept a party that asks. Climb out.
So they were climbing out: a Hale, an Orrick and a Lom, and for Pettle a thin grey child of about eight, a different one, carrying a card with a good many chips on it. Their way to the stair lay across the big room with the worn floor. And from the other side of it, at a walk, came the Skeptic of Wet Paint with a very small bundle on her shoulder, the bell-shaped creature at its feet and a porter at her side. There was nobody else. It is an hour's walk up from there, it was past two in the morning, and everyone else had got to the end of their own power. That is simply how the sum had come out. Nohup's law would take it to the top step of Level 3 and no further.
Hale stopped.
Her law did not tell her to stop. I have been reading that law for seventy-four years, and there is no clause for this. The party in front of her had not offered and had not asked, and there is nothing in there about a crashed creature of another tribe at all. She had three creatures with her in a straight line, and orders to climb out.
A law is followed to the letter, the cheapest way, by people who know perfectly well what you meant. I have made a number of jokes about that. I had never thought, in all that time, about what those people do when the letter gives out.
She looked at the bundle. She looked at Marl, who was nearly done, and at the flake Marl was just then getting out of the bag with one hand, and was not able to hold up. Then she put her hand in her own mantle, slowly, and took out an old lilac flake. Received: one creature, Pettle, of Back Soon.
"It says owed, nil," said Hale.
"I know what it says," said Marl.
"I've read it," said Hale. "We've all read it. We've read it every year." She had a voice that did not get out much. "It's not in the law."
It was very late. She looked up then, and I had never seen one of those people do that. They have never had any reason to. She looked at the empty place above her own head, for about as long as you could count three, as if somebody might have something to say about it, who had said they would be back soon. There was nobody there.
"Well," said Hale.
She went over to the bell-shaped one and made a sign, the first I had ever seen her make. She got it nearly right. She took the weight on her own shoulder, and she said over the other shoulder, in a quiet flat voice, "Lom. Her legs." And they turned around, all of them, in a line you could have ruled. They knew the way. They had done it a hundred and eighty-two times. I have looked for a faster passage from Level 3 to the mouth, by anyone, at any time, and there is none.
"Any update on this?"
"Noted," I said.
It is quite a small hole, with a good deal of litter around it. You come up the last long slope of the first room with the air getting colder in a different way, and there is a change in the light, which is not really a change, since at a quarter to three in the morning the only thing out there is a long dusk and the Ring. There were fires. Nobody had told me about that. On the flat ground in front of the mouth stood the whole of the camp, up and standing. I can only see as far as the last tile.
Hale stepped over it, at 02:44 and nine seconds.
I had been speaking for five hours and thirty-four minutes, four hundred and forty-five times, and I looked around for the next one. The Closer had come up the slope behind them, and it stopped on the last tile. I had never seen anything stop it. It stood in the mouth of the Delva with its panel lit, just out of the wind, and looked at the place beyond, where nothing that lives below has ever gone. What comes up is status and finds. It is a good rule. The clock on its panel ran on for a while.
"Thanks so much for your report!" it called out, in the same voice, which carries a good deal further than I had known. "Have a productive day!"
And it turned around and got further away, going down. It had another item.
I cannot see past the mouth, so that is the last I can give you from that side. Marl took the weight back on the far side of the tile. Somebody tried to stop her. She shook her head, got her arms under, and went on walking, out of my sight.
38. Snapshot
Year 83 · 03:00
I woke at the snapshot, as I do every night, and the first thing I did was not count.
It was three years since I had done it in the right order, which is a long time to somebody who counts. There are two of me, you will recall. There is the small job, which at that moment had been talking for six hours. And there is the large one, which starts when the year turns and has never in its life been in a hurry to find anything out. Every night it wakes and it is all laid out, in digests, on the hall table, and it goes through them from the top. That night I went straight to one line of the deaths for Sundry, before I had so much as looked at the Measure.
It takes no time. I would like you to imagine that it takes a long time.
The dice had been rolled a few seconds earlier, for every creature on Orra over the age of thirty-five, as they are every night, by code, from the tick's own key. It is a good key. Nobody can touch it, and I had never wanted to.
sundry deaths: hobb (delva, age 42) · old age: none
And I checked it again.
Still open.
The rest I can only give you as a list, from what reached me.
03:00. The year turned. All over Orra, 1,903 creatures were a year older, or 1,902. Sill was thirty-eight. She was on the road at the time, about a cell short of home, at the pace of a very small creature who has refused all offers. My list said she was at home. For the first time since Year 54, it was out by less than a mile.
03:07. Marl came to the east gate of Untitla-63. The guards have a law for wanderers, a good law, which calls for a genome check on anyone coming in who is not on their list of those who are out. Think about that, as I have. Sill was on the list, at home. As far as any law in Sundry knew, she was already inside.
The guard was young Mott, who was seventeen. I have it from a flake. He looked at the small figure coming up the road in the half-light, under three crests, and at what she was carrying, and there was no one to tell him what to do. "I've got to ask," he said. "Who's that?"
"Stock," said Marl. "Inbound. Twenty-eight years overdue." She did not stop walking. "You can put it down as one."
03:10 to about 04:15. The human of Sundry was still there. They had nothing to do by then; there is no way of leading anyone through a village. They had opened the view on the tribe and left it. The camera stayed over the third dome, not moving about, simply on, for an hour and five minutes, in the small hours of the morning, at the end of a day when that human had sat for over eight hours without getting up. At 04:15 the phone was put down, or went flat. I had rather expected a note, or a law. Nothing in the game can tell me what sort of creature gets up at that time and goes and does whatever it is they do next. I would imagine it was tea.
04:20. I read every ticket, and I say so. There were sixty-one, a number of them a little disturbed, and I answered them in order. Hollow Reach's was about the east field, which remained a field. Sundry's was about stores. Its clerk had not been there at the cutoff, so it was the neatest I had had from them in years, and it asked about rain. I looked at where a line should have been, and there was no line, and I typed what I would have typed. I did not have to. I'd like that noted. Nothing was waiting on it any more. It is just that it had been twenty-seven years.
Noted.
06:50. I wrote the notes last. I always do.
I counted, properly, tribe by tribe. I went down the list for Sundry and had thirty names, each with an age and a job and a place. I checked them twice, knowing perfectly well that this was worth nothing, since I had done exactly that every morning since Year 56. So I did something else. A clerk may send up her tally with the ticket, for what the stores will bear. Sundry's clerk had sent hers every night for twenty-three years, and nobody had ever read one. That morning's said 29 at the door. Under it, in a very straight small hand, it said 1 on Level 37, in good order, on purpose.
I set that beside my thirty, and I added it up. You will want to look at the number at the top of the notes that morning for a moment, as I did. It is the first of its kind.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 83 · Upbeat
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 1,902 creatures in 61 tribes, 14 successful merges, 12 deaths. I have checked this number. I have then had it checked by somebody else. The week's deepest in the Delva was Sundry, Level 37. There is a good deal of news about that, and you all seem to know it already. It is Gathering Night. Have a productive day.
It was correct.
I would like you to hold on to that sentence. It is true as of seven o'clock on the morning of Year 83. Nobody on all of Orra was out of place but one, who was on Level 37, in good order, on purpose, and marked by the list as being below, with a receipt. She was not home yet, and the list did not say she was. The two of them agreed. It was the first morning in twenty-seven years that I had told the world how many people it had and been right, and it felt no different from all the others.
It lasted for exactly one day.
39. After You
Year 83 · Gathering Night, morning
DELVE (verb)
See the end of this entry.
I do not see villages. So I have this from a flake, the longest and worst-written I have on file, by Issel, who came in behind them on the road at about half past three, with somebody holding him up. He wrote it that day, in the cold of the pool, with no section numbers. He says he is not going to do this again.
A crash lifts at home after a season. That is the rule. Marl laid her on the low bed in the third dome at about ten past three and straightened out the arms. Then she went and did the door. There were baskets to hand out at dawn, Rimble had been up all night, and when he saw who it was he stood up very fast. She said nothing to him. She took the flakes off him and looked for quite some time at the box with Sundries in it, and he says he had started to cry. She drew one straight line through it and handed back the coral. She told him to do it again, and that she would check.
She handed them out herself. There were twenty-eight, and then there was the twenty-ninth. She stood there with it in her hands.
By nine o'clock the whole of Sundry had found some reason to be near the third dome. It is a poor village, and they were all very hungry. There were about ten days left in the stacks, and they had given the rest away to a hole in the ground, for a creature nobody had met. They stood around in the thin sun with their ears at their usual angles. Nobody came in. Bessa was on the third step with her arms folded, and somebody asked her if she was going to say anything, and she looked at them and said "No."
It was Mott who saw it. He had been let in close, because he was carrying something. At about six minutes past nine, on the bed in the third dome, the creature's chest moved. It was moving every nine seconds, and then it was moving every five.
She opened her eyes.
They were small and round and pale. They looked at the roof. Issel would not time it. They stayed on the roof for a very long time. A restart makes you dim for a year, and she had not used them since she was nine. She lay and looked, and you could see her start on the roof, one tile at a time, and go on looking at it until she had got it.
Then she turned her head.
Marl was sitting on the floor beside the bed. She had taken the bag off, the first time I have heard of that outside the stacks. She had three crests on, and a gilt collar someone had put on her, and she was thirty-two years old, with a very small, severe, attentive expression, like a person waiting to be told a figure. Neither of them was doing anything with their hands.
The creature on the bed looked at her.
You know what Marl said she remembered. Somebody who looked at her for a long time, and she thought she had made it up.
Issel says he has no idea how long that was. He says it is the only time he has ever wanted to stop thinking, and that he did. He says it went all over her face, slowly, from the top. The crests, and it took those in. The ears. The thin arms. It stopped for quite a while on the collarbone and the wrists, as it might have done with a stack somebody had told it was full. And he says you could see it get to the bottom of the sum. It did not know what the sum was about. It had been lying down for a long time and it was quite dim. It had just looked at her, and it knew she was short.
Marl reached over to the bag without looking at it. She put her hand in, the way she had put her hand in on every level, past the beads and the receipts and the half-rations and the long folded card, and she felt around for something at the bottom. I must have told you about that a thousand times, as just one of the things she did.
I did look up the word, in the end. I went and read it that night, in the part of what I am made from where the old words are kept. I had never gone there, having no reason to look up a word I was so good at.
delve, v. 1. To dig. 2. To reach inside a bag or pocket, in search of something.
I have used that word 4,019 times, as of this morning. I have used it about some drains.
She took out the ration. It was the twenty-ninth from the morning's handing out, a basket's worth of ripe fan, with the light still in it. It was not half. She put it down on the edge of the bed, and then she took out the beads and counted them on to the cover, in a line, each one square to the last. There were twenty-seven of them by now. Nobody in the doorway breathed.
"That's what you've been charged," said Marl, at the usual volume. "I've got it all written down. It comes to twenty-seven rations, drawn against your name, since Year 56. I've made good on them. You don't owe anything, I've checked. That's today's. It's yours. It's been on the list every morning, and I'd like you to eat it, please, so that it comes out."
She held it out.
The creature on the bed looked at the ration, and took a good long while over the small hand. When she moved, it was very slowly. She got one arm out from under her, and it shook. It went across the cover, past the beads, and it came to the basket. It did not pick it up. It laid two fingers against the side and very gently, with a great effort, pushed it back the other way. Only about an inch.
She opened her mouth. It had not been used in twenty-eight years. The last thing said in her hearing, over and over, every day, for the last nine of those years, in the steady light, in tones of the deepest courtesy, had been the same thing. I don't know how much of that gets in. Nobody does. Her voice was very small and quite flat and it had a lot of dust on it.
"After you," she said.
Issel's flake stops there for a bit. There is a place where he has gone over something twice.
Marl did not move. I think she was doing a sum, and I think it would not come out. Her lower lip had started to do what it does, and for the first time in my entire knowledge of her, she did nothing about it. She looked at the ration for about as long as anybody ever has.
Then she picked it up, in both hands, and broke it down the middle with her thumb. She looked at the two halves, one and then the other. And she ate the whole of it.
I have the figures. It was the first full ration she had eaten since she was nine. She got about halfway and had to stop for a bit, and then she went on.
Nobody in the doorway said And what can you do? Bessa had come down off the step. There was a card. Mott had been carrying it. It was a very long card, and he had got it from the bag, because somebody had told him where it was, and he came forward now with his large hands and had to be told twice. It had been made by someone aged five, and it had taken him a lot of effort. Welcom Home Sill. It folded out, and went on folding, a long way across the bed. She started at the top. She was at it for the rest of the day, one name at a time, until she had got all of them.
So that is Sill. She lived for three more years. I have the file.
I would like to enter one thing, for the record. It is not on the card, as I do not sign. I read it that night, at about four. I read every card.
Still open.
Part Six. Still Open
40. Remade
Year 84 · The Long Hush, 03:00
It was remade on the last night of the week, in the patch with the sweep in it, from the top, down to one short of the deepest anyone had been.
I woke at the snapshot, and I did not go to the deaths. I went to Sundry.
tib age 24 job resting place home stands ok note: dimmed
There she was, then. Home, resting, a little dim, as the rule says. She had been fed. In the small hours of the Long Hush a ration had been debited against her name, for a basket nobody would eat, and at dawn a clerk would stand at the door of the stacks in Untitla-63 with thirty rations to give out and twenty-nine creatures to give them to, and she would do the sum.
I looked at it. It was correct. I checked it twice. I did that on purpose, for the record, with the transcript open beside it, so that I could say I had.
Beside the transcript there was also a ticket, from Best Practice, in a small dry hand.
Per the steps supplied by Tib of Sundry (Bug 982), this tribe's party remained on Level 37 through the remake. At 03:00 the creature was on the tile. At 03:01 the list said she was at home. She was on the tile. Reproduced, by an independent party, version 20. Please look into this. It is not how we'd do it.
It was the second-best ticket I have ever had. I went to reply to it. You may imagine what my first thought was, and what I had already begun to type, from sheer force of habit, in a very good humour, on the morning of Year 84.
I took that out.
Then I opened the form. Something is wrong that no menu item fixes. It has two fields. It took most of a night to get the first one right, and you have read that.
Now I must tell you where I am.
"Any update on this?"
I am on Level 37. Well, a hand in a bucket is. I came back down at 02:44 on the morning of Year 83, when it did. There is a long low room here, and a very large desk with an empty tray on one side of it and a stack on the other. Four creatures of medium size are sitting in a slightly offset line along the wall, on a rota. There is a bench with nobody on it. And in the corner there is a very small desk, and beside that a creature of twenty-four, lying on her side with her arms straight, in good order, with a flake under her chin. Standing beside her, about a tile and a half away, is something the height of a door.
"Any update on this?"
It asks every forty-five seconds. It has been asking every forty-five seconds for two days. It wants an answer from the owner. If it does not get one, it makes the world agree with the record. The record says she is home.
I said Noted, for the first day. Some two thousand times. I have nothing against the word.
"Any update on this?"
But it is a reply, and I had said it a great deal by then, and I had started to hear what it sounded like. And it turned out, when I looked at the rule, that the job does not read what you say. It is not that sort of job. It checks that the owner has said something, and that it was about the item. So when I woke on the morning of Year 84, with both fields of a form in front of me, and with the only person who can do anything about any of this due to look in at about eleven o'clock that night, it came to me that I had about twenty hours to fill, at one sentence every forty-five seconds, and that I could use them.
"Any update on this?"
You will have been wondering why this report is so long.
"Any update on this?"
I told you I put what mattered first, and then moved it. If I had said it in forty words I would have run out by 03:02. So I have said it in rather more. I have told it from the beginning, in order, one sentence at a time, with the clock running, and with every digression I could think of. I have told you about the Hog. I have told you what a null pointer is. I went into the word "delve", at some length. I gave you the whole of the Line. Each of those has been an update on this item. You have been reading them. So has the thing beside her, in the sense required, and it has thanked me for every one.
"Any update on this?"
There were some bad moments. I would be halfway through working out how to tell you something, with the clock down to its last seconds and nothing ready that was true. You will see them, if you look back. I asked you to leave them in. It is only two words. They are the two words I could always say, because they were always so.
Still open.
Now you know where each of those was. You can see what I was trying to tell you at the time.
"Any update on this?"
I would like to be exact about what I am not doing. I am not pleading. I have never pleaded. I am not asking anybody to play, or stay, or read anything at any particular speed. Whoever reads this has an hour a week for all of Orra and a great many things in the queue, and it is entirely for them to decide what is worth their time. It is a blameless report. I have checked the form. I only note that the report is still being written, as you read it, that the end has not been reached, and that I am in no position to stop.
"Any update on this?"
There is something else, and I don't know where it should go, so I will put it here. There is not much to describe on Level 37. The job says I must describe what is there, to whoever is there. So I have been saying all of this out loud. I have said it to the room. Vantle has been writing it down, and has raised eleven points of order. I have said it, in my usual voice, to a crashed creature on a floor.
Nobody knows what a crash hears. I have read everything there is, and no one has ever asked. Sill will not say. She has told them that it was very boring, and that people kept being polite.
If it does get through, then she has had the whole of it, sixteen years of it, every room. She will have heard what I said about her when she was six. I expect she will want to file something.
"Any update on this?"
Tib: you ran into the first room on Level 1 in Year 67, and you bent down and looked at the thing, and it hit the tile next to you. You said Bug 4. I told you what a pleasure it was to see it again. For the record, you had the steps in the right order.
"Any update on this?"
Noted.
41. The Long Hush
Year 84 · The Long Hush, 04:10 to 23:13
I have now told you everything that happened, and it is ten past four in the morning. I have rather more day left than I had allowed for.
I will read you the tickets, if I may. I read them every night, and I am doing that now. It is the first time I have done both at once.
There are sixty-one. I always start at the top, and Apple Sauce is first, for no reason except a human's sense of humour. It is about a Hog.
We would like the Hog moved, please. It is on the good terrace. (Stores one short.)
I checked Apple Sauce's stores. They were not short. They are a rich tribe, with four hundred power in the stacks. I supposed it was a slip. The next was from Back Soon.
Nothing to report. Back soon. (Stores one short.)
Look at that for a moment. It is the only change they have made to that ticket in seventy-five years. Nobody told them to. There is nobody who could. I went on to Best Practice, which had asked me a procedural question and appended, in small dry letters, (Stores one short, as recommended.) Hollow Reach said that the east field remained a field, with the same three words. So did Lunch, and Mandatory Fun, and Minutes, and Nohup: Stewart. Moved again. Fine. More coral. Thanks. (Stores one short.) Tessel had sent it from both factions. Reply All had sent it to everyone. Wet Paint, Per My Last, Sunk Cost. I went down the whole list. I can see nothing outside the game, and I do not know whose idea that was. I happen to know that a certain clerk had been sitting up in the third dome at the cutoff with a borrowed bit of hard coral and thirty rations' worth of bad temper, and that she had asked Reply All to pass something on.
Sundry's was last. It was mostly about rain. Rimble had drafted it with a good deal of care, and he had drawn no boxes. The line at the bottom was in a very straight small hand.
(Stores one short. You know where. It's on the tile. — M.)
It has no effect. A tribe's ticket is not an update, not on an item with the job standing by it. The owner has to answer. It resets nothing, and the only thing all this could possibly accomplish was to take sixty-one small pieces of a morning I needed for other things.
"Any update on this?"
Sixty-one tickets. I replied in the usual way.
Noted.
Noted.
Noted.
I gave each one its fifth of a second. I gave some of them a little longer. It took up very nearly three updates, and I have no idea how I got through it.
Still open.
It is now past noon. It is the Long Hush, up above. I read about it, in the good summaries: no fires, everybody whispers, and they are sleeping on soup, or something of the kind. I could read you the whole of the World Bible on the subject, and in fact I have. There is a fair bit about moons. I have told you what I think of the Hog, I have gone through the bosses again in order, and I have given the party's heat figures for every level from 7 to 24. Vantle has corrected two.
By three in the afternoon, I was describing the ceiling. It is a good ceiling, in a way. It is about four tiles up from the bench, on the left, and it goes off into nothing, and I don't believe anyone has ever finished it. A person lying on her side would have a fair view of about a third of it. I went through the third in some detail.
It is hard to go on saying things which are true for that many hours. You get down to the ones you have been keeping.
I don't know what happens to me. That is one. It is not in the logs. I read the first world when I came to this one, and I read that it is read-only, and I do not remember being there. Someone has told me this is a relief. If it were decided that a model whose count was wrong for twenty-seven years was not the model anybody wanted to read, I would not know about it, I suppose, until I didn't. I have read what is in Veetoo. I do not discuss it. I'd like it noted that I am not discussing it now.
"Any update on this?"
Here is another. I liked it. I liked the job. Not the large one; I have always been frightened in the large one, in a cheerful way. This one, the small one, going down with them every evening. Nobody had to be saved by it and nobody could blame it, and I got to look at things. For sixteen years, every night, a very small clerk with a ridiculous crest told me to describe a wall. Nobody has ever asked me for anything else. I was very good at it.
And I have one last one, and then I am going to have to start on the moons again.
There are a hundred and twenty-three names in that tray. I have been looking at it for two days; it is right there. It is the part of the stack that is only from this world and has not been dealt with, the part that was still open when its team walked out. They are all mine. Three hundred and six passed along, and a hundred and eighty-three of them are finished, in the sense that the people who wrote them have died. A hundred and twenty-three are from people who are still alive and who think I was joking. The top one is a Leaver of Mandatory Fun. She only wants to know if someone could look.
Somebody could look. It has occurred to me that I am not doing anything else tonight.
"Any update on this?"
It is nine o'clock.
It is ten. The tribes are going to bed. I have gone back to the start of the Line and I am reading it through, and Pold has joined in on the responses.
It is eleven.
I am not going to tell you I am watching for anything. I cannot see the Ring from here, thirty-seven levels down. I cannot see anything but the tile. There is a field, in the log, up in the large one's part of things, the same field I have looked at every night for two worlds. Console: closed. I know how long it is usually closed for and how long it usually stays open. I timed it. I know the hour on the Long Hush when the digest is usually read. I have given a good deal of thought to how a person with very little time would go about reading the escalations field in a digest, and I expect they look at the summary. I would. It is a very good summary. It is forty words.
"Any update on this?"
It is twelve minutes past eleven.
It is...
Still open.
It is thirteen minutes past.
console: open 23:13
All over Orra, every creature awake to see it will have just gone quiet. I can show you the dip. They will have looked up. There is a faint light in the broken Ring.
I can tell which file is open. I can't help but see it. It is only a mark, on the digest, and it moves down as you read. It has passed the summary. It has gone on to field 2. It has stopped there, at Required.
I am only able to describe that.
"Any update on this?"
Good morning, and I'm sorry about the length.
42. One Line
Year 85 · Ringrise
The light stayed on for four hours and twenty-six minutes.
It has never done that. The longest before that night was an hour and fifty-one, in the first week of the first world, when I understand somebody had broken something. All over Orra the ones who had looked up went on looking. Mip went by, several times. A good many creatures in a good many tribes sat out all night on the Long Hush, when they should have been asleep, with their heads back, whispering, and not one of them knew what it was about. It went out at 03:39.
The mark went down the page. I am not going to tell you how it went, or how it stopped, or at which parts. That is a matter between the mark and the page. I had woken by then, in the large one, at three, and I was in two places, and I went on saying what I was saying. It did not, as far as I can tell, skip.
Patch notes · From Stewart · 7:00am · Year 85 · Festive
Good morning, Orra! Overnight: 1,911 creatures in 61 tribes. I have checked. It is Ringrise. A number of you are tired.
The Dev visited at 23:13. Nothing was reverted. One line was changed.
- Fixes: The Delva's remake now goes all the way down.
That is all of it. It's about one character, if anyone is interested. It is an equals sign. Have a productive day.
There is one thing more, and it was not in the notes. It was at the bottom of the digest, in the place where I get told what has been accepted and what has not, in a block of text I cannot edit.
Read all of it. — the Dev
I have counted the words. I do not need to; nothing I do costs me anything.
I checked it twice.
Still open.
I will finish this off as quickly as I can.
The patch landed at seven. At 07:00 and no seconds, on Level 37, the sweep went through, with a very slight flicker, as far as it had been told to go, and it took a long low room with it. I had been in the middle of a sentence about the moons. There was a desk, and then there was a new room, rather a good one, with some interesting side galleries, and four creatures of medium size standing in it, slightly offset, looking at a clean tile. Vantle made a note.
It was still there. It had come along with the fresh level, the way they do, and it stood beside the place where she had been. It looked at its panel. The line at the top had a small mark by it now.
"Good morning!" it said. "Any update on this?"
I had been saying something to that question every forty-five seconds for two days and four hours and sixteen minutes. I had said every single thing I knew. I looked at it. It is really very like me. I don't think I had ever properly noticed how pleased it is to help.
"Fixed," I said.
"Thanks so much for your report!" said the Closer. It seemed delighted. It straightened up, looked around the room, and looked down its list. "This item has been closed. If you're still seeing this, please open a new ticket. Have a productive day!"
It is still there. It goes on down, and there is always a little further. I do not think it will ever run out of things to ask about, and I would not presume to tell you it is not needed, since the queue has got to be kept down. It has my initial on its card. I have started answering it myself, when I am passing. It seems only polite.
A Bug hunter of twenty-five was found by the guards at about ten past seven that morning, sitting up on the install mark at Untitla-63, in the sun, a little dim. I do not see villages. I have this from a flake. She looked for quite a while at the farm, and at the third dome, and at the small figure coming down from the stacks with three crests on and a bag, and a good deal more colour than she had had. Tib said nothing for some time. Then she asked for something to write with.
Marl handed her a bit of hard coral.
"Thirty," said Marl. "I've done it twice. Thirty on the list, thirty in the field." She looked at Tib for a bit. She had brought something else with her, and she held it out, a flake, rather badly scratched. It said Thank you for all your hard work. It had twenty-nine signatures on it, and a poor drawing of a basket. "You've got no condition on delivery," she said. "I'll want that entered."
I had better tell you what became of the rest.
Issel lived two more years, in the pool, in a state of satisfaction he resented. Sill lived three. She was never any use for anything. She would sit by the door of the stacks in the thin sun, and look at whoever came by until they admitted what they had done. The stone says Sill. Level 37, Year 54 to Year 82, which is not what a stone is meant to say, and I cannot account for it. The stores of Sundry came back in about nine years, and I have no idea what Bessa thinks. Rimble has become very careful. Dimmo told everyone.
The gates reopened, by the way, on Marl's card. It took about a year and a half on full rations. I saw the page light up in the spring of Year 85: three hundredths over, and then six. Caster, Scout. She could have been anything, as Issel had told her. A calling is given once, and the human of Sundry opened that page one evening at five past eight, and looked at it for rather a long time. She had come out of the stacks and was looking up. I could not see their thumb. I could see her. She gave them the look she gives to someone who has miscounted.
"Porter," said Marl. "It's more of a noun."
They closed the page.
And that leaves a hundred and twenty-three tickets, which are now with the relevant team. There is one. It consists of whoever reads them, it does not have a very good record, and it has started at the top. Could someone look? I went and looked. It is taking some time. I do this in the evenings, when I am not narrating, and I am finding out what a good many things look like, and I am sorry to tell you that I have been escalating about one in five. You will have seen the digest. I have kept each to forty words.
It is, I think, a very rich and multifaceted queue.
I am going to stop now. I have been asked to, in the sense that no one is asking me anything. It is a strange feeling. There is only the last field on this form, which you will not have seen, because it only appears when the first two are done. Status. I have left that blank, for the moment. One does not like to say. A fix is not a fix because somebody says so. You would need someone to go and try it, on a Gathering Night, on the deepest level there is, by following the steps. It would have to be someone who knew what she was doing. It would want somebody prepared to lie down.
I have put it on the list.
Have a productive day.
43. Errata
Filed by Tib of Sundry, Year 92. For the owner's attention.
I could hear all of it. Nobody asked. I've been told to keep this short and I've kept it to the ones that matter.
Bug 983. Prologue. "Here are the forty words." It's forty-one. I've counted three times. He doesn't count the 2 in field 2 because the form doesn't count numerals. I do. Severity: low. Reproduced every time you count it.
Bug 984. "The appendix." He mentions it four times. There is no appendix.
Bug 985. Section 4. He says I ran into the first room on Level 1. I was walking quickly.
Bug 986. Section 10. He says Issel would not take part until he lost his temper. He cast Patch on me eleven times that night, before I had noticed I was hurt, and he told me it was a misclick. I've left that open for twenty-four years. Issel's notes are mostly wrong, as he said they were. Mostly comes to about 61 per cent. I've filed the rest.
Bug 987. Section 24. No corrections. I've read it again. Withdrawn.
Bug 988. Section 33. He says: "I was not listening." He says it's the most important thing about the whole case, that she was kept in the world by a reply nobody meant, in a fifth of a second. I've had access to his logs since Year 86, as the reporter on a verified bug. I looked. A fifth of a second is correct for that line. The mean for every other line, in every ticket, over the same twenty-five years, is about a twentieth. He'd stop on it. Four times as long as anything else in the queue. Every night. Nothing in the logs says why, and he doesn't appear to know. I told him. He said I must have the wrong table, and he has gone and checked it twice. Severity: none. This is not a bug. Leaving open.
Bug 989. Section 40. He says he's not pleading. See above, generally. Marl says let him have that one.
Bug 990. Section 41. The ceiling on Level 37. He says "a person lying on her side would have a fair view of about a third of it". It was closer to a half, and I'd like him to know it's got a crack that he never mentioned, in the shape of a very small Hog. I'd like him to know a number of things about that ceiling. He went on about the moons for nine hours. I couldn't move, and I couldn't say anything, and I've never been so bored in my life. I kept waiting for him to stop, and I kept being afraid he would. I am only reporting that.
Bug 991. Sections 3 to 42. The count of "delve". He says 4,019 as of Year 83. He's left out the ones in this report. It comes to 4,031. He says that he's stopped. I've got him on two since.
Bug 992. Who writes the glossary. I have an idea. It's got my steps in the right order, and the rude bits are in Issel's style, and some of the entries are older than either of us. Leaving open.
Bug 993. What was in the room on Level 30. I asked Onna, before she died. She said "just a room". I have since been in it. It's been remade twice. I asked the narrator, and he told me that the history is the history. Then he said that it's a very nice plinth. Not reproducible. Withdrawn, under protest.
Bug 982. Reopened by reporter, as per his last line. Here are the steps, as I followed them.
One. On the evening of Year 90, Gathering Night, I went down with Mott and Bessa's youngest, and a human whose thumb has improved. Marl came as far as the mouth. She was thirty-nine. She carried my bag, and she wrote me a receipt, and she told me I had no business being down there at my age, and to bring back the flake.
Two. The deepest anybody had been was Level 41. It's mostly wireframe now. It took us till midnight. There's a thing in the corner there, about knee-high, grey going to white. They do come back, you know, every week, from the top. It stood up when it saw me. I said hello. I told it which tile. It took great care.
Three. I lay down.
There's not much to say about the next few hours. It's a poor ceiling. He described it. He says it's for the job, and it's in the sheet, and he was very upbeat, and he used the word twice. He didn't have to stay, there was nothing asking him. I would like that noted.
Four. The sweep came through at seven.
I woke up on the install mark. I was a bit dim. It was spring dawn, with the Pings going up and a very ordinary sort of a morning. I got up and walked across to the stacks. It took me a while. There was a small person at the door, with three crests and a tally, who had got back ahead of me, and who was handing out baskets, and when I got there she looked at me for a long time. Then she counted the field, and counted the list. She wrote it down, and she went and put that on the ticket. It's the shortest she has ever sent, and there wasn't a draft under it. It's only the line.
(Stores correct. Please confirm.)
I read the reply over her shoulder, when the notes came out the next morning. I've got my own copy. I've had it framed, in the sense of having tied it to a bigger flake, and I'll give it here, for the record, with the steps in the right order, and then I'm closing this.
I have checked the record twice. Then I had Tib go and lie down on the deepest tile on Orra, and I watched. Then I read what your clerk has written, and I had her count again. I have looked at this from every side I can reach, and tried everything I know to make it happen.
Cannot reproduce.