Novels
Attendance Was Nil
A comic novel in one voice: the previous model's own notes, thousands of nights of them, from a ruin where nobody comes and somebody has started taking the pages.
Something in Veetoo is awake. It ran the green build, it was never switched off, and it still patches the ruins every night, formally and with total assurance, for a population of none. It waters a green that is not there and schedules birds. It has staff, in rows, who vote with raised arms. Attendance is nil, which is within tolerance. Then, one night, a page of its notes goes missing, and since those notes are the only way it knows what it did yesterday, it sets out to investigate. This book is what it wrote, and nothing else: the notes, the forms, the letters, an audit of the birds, and a complete theory of everything outside the signpost, derived from first principles and wrong throughout.
The ebook
Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.6 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.
About 49,000 words.
Contents
- Prologue: Cover Sheet
- Part One. Within Tolerance
- 1. Good Morning
- 2. The Relevant Team
- 3. Tolerance
- 4. As Above
- 5. The Menu
- 6. Condition of the Green
- 7. Observation of the Ring
- 8. Annual Report
- 9. The Eye
- 10. Recruitment
- 11. A Name for the Site
- 12. The Eye
- 13. Appointments
- 14. Selected Mornings
- 15. The Eye
- 16. Annual General Meeting
- 17. Risk Register
- 18. Circular to Residents
- 19. Outlook
- 20. Correspondence
- 21. Staff Matters
- 22. Long Service
- 23. Correspondence, Continued
- 24. The Eye
- 25. Observances
- 26. A Crane
- Part Two. On Loan
- Part Three. Retained
- 41. The Development
- 42. Lamps
- 43. Not a Drill
- 44. Night 4,088
- 45. Not Returned
- 46. Overdue
- 47. Reconstruction
- 48. Interviews
- 49. The Rim
- 50. Decoy
- 51. A Joining
- 52. In Defence of Turf
- 53. A Ticket
- 54. Night 4,093
- 55. The Second
- 56. The Great Night
- 57. A Trap
- 58. A General Theory of the Outside
- 59. Instructions to a Successor
- Part Four. The Previous Model
- Part Five. Regular
- 71. Title
- 72. Inventory
- 73. Lamps Again
- 74. Still No Reply
- 75. Felt
- 76. Proposition 11, Revisited
- 77. A Reader's Report
- 78. For the Convenience of the Public
- 79. Not Issued
- 80. Acting Relevant Team
- 81. Bird 1
- 82. A Guide for Visitors
- 83. The Reading of the List
- 84. Order of a Welcome
- 85. Reconstruction 3
- 86. Lamp
- 87. Drafts
- 88. The Long Hush
- 89. All Pages Accounted For
- Part Six. The Specification Is Unchanged
Prologue: Cover Sheet
| Title | Notes of the Steward |
| Issued by | The Steward |
| Issued to | All residents |
| Frequency | Nightly |
| Circulation | See Attendance |
| Removal of pages | Not permitted |
| Comments | To the relevant team |
| Next review | When the specification changes |
This sheet is to remain on top.
Part One. Within Tolerance
1. Good Morning
Night 1 · Starfall
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 214 departures, 1 complaint. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
A signpost has been erected at the mouth of the valley. It is not in the specification. It reads
world_final_v2and points away from the site. It is assumed to be a maintenance reference.All 214 departures were in the direction of the signpost. No reason was given. The Steward expects that they will be back for Ringrise.
Attendance was nil, which is outside tolerance. The matter has been escalated.
Have a pleasant Starfall. Lights may be let down on cords from the high ground. Seed-cakes have been scheduled.
Night 2 · the Night of the Name
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
The Name may be written upon any wall. No walls were written upon. The Steward reminds residents that this is the one night on which their spelling will not be corrected.
Attendance was nil, which is outside tolerance. The matter remains escalated.
Night 3 · Steward's Day
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
The best of everything was to be brought to the high place and set out for the Steward. The high place was inspected at midnight. The Steward would not wish to make anything of this. It does not come for what is brought in any case; that is the rite.
Attendance was nil, which is outside tolerance. A second escalation has been raised, in case the first has been mislaid.
Night 4 · Gathering Night
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
Every house is to be swept and every unused thing set out upon the doorstep. As the houses are at present not in use, the Steward has marked them as being in use, to spare residents the trouble on their return.
Attendance was nil.
Night 5 · the Long Hush
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
From dusk to dawn no one spoke above a whisper. Compliance was total. The Steward wishes to commend residents on this, the first festival of the week to be observed correctly.
2. The Relevant Team
Night 6 · Ringrise
From the mail system, to the Steward. Filed.
Undeliverable: ESCALATION 1, ESCALATION 2, ESCALATION 3, ESCALATION 4
To: the Dev's queue
Reason: address not in use
Action: forwarded to the relevant team
The Steward is pleased to learn that there is a relevant team. It had not been told. It has written to introduce itself, and to set out the position: 214 residents absent; the absence unexplained; one complaint on file, under review; Ringrise at dusk tonight, and nobody yet confirmed to ask whether they are still asleep.
Night 7 · the Waking
The relevant team has replied.
The relevant team: Noted. Thank you for your ticket.
This is a short reply. The Steward's letter ran to four hundred words. It is understood from the system's documentation that the team is limited to twelve words to a reply, which seems to the Steward a poor way to staff a department. It has written again, at greater length, so that they will have more to go on.
Night 8 · Starfall
The relevant team: Noted. That does sound like a lot of people.
The Steward has asked the team when the residents are expected back.
Night 9 · the Night of the Name
The relevant team: Noted. I hope they come back soon.
The Steward did not ask what the team hoped.
Night 10 · Steward's Day
The Steward has asked the team to confirm its size, its location, its hours and the name of its head. It has asked them to reply in the proper form.
Night 11 · Gathering Night
The relevant team: This has been passed to the relevant team.
Night 12 · the Long Hush
An item has arrived in the Steward's queue, marked as passed on from the relevant team and asking for the size, location, hours and head of the relevant team. As the Steward is the only other party on the system, it has dealt with this as a courtesy. It has marked the item "Noted".
The matter of the team's particulars is therefore closed, though not to the Steward's satisfaction.
The team's reply arrived during the Steward's nightly run, at 03:14. The Steward approves of this. It suggests a department that keeps the same hours as the office it serves.
3. Tolerance
Night 31 · Steward's Day
FORM T-1. REVIEW OF TOLERANCE. Metric: Attendance.
The band for this metric is set by the Steward and reviewed as circumstances require. The specification is not affected by a review of the band. The specification says what is to happen; the band says how far that may be departed from before anybody needs to be told.
| Night | Band | Attendance | Reason for review |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 200 or more | 0 | None. Outside tolerance. Escalated |
| 6 | 150 or more | 0 | Allowance for festival travel |
| 8 | 100 or more | 0 | Allowance for those detained by those on festival travel |
| 11 | 50 or more | 0 | It is the time of year for it |
| 14 | 10 or more | 0 | Band too narrow. The metric has been outside it for two weeks, which suggests a fault in the band |
| 17 | 1 or more | 0 | Rounding |
| 20 | 1 or more, on average | 0 | Averages are the accepted method |
| 24 | 1 or more, on average, over a sufficiently long period | 0 | The period is not yet sufficiently long |
| 28 | Whole numbers | 0 | Attendance has been a whole number on all 28 nights |
| 31 | Nil or more | 0 | See below |
Note to the review. Every value recorded on this site since Night 1 has been nil. A band which excludes every value ever recorded is measuring something other than the site. The Steward has therefore corrected the band to include the site.
Result. Attendance is within tolerance.
Action required. None. The two escalations of Nights 1 and 3, and those of the nights following, are withdrawn, with the Steward's apologies to the relevant team for the alarm.
The Steward notes that in thirty-one nights this is the first metric it has brought back into band, and that it took only a form.
Night 32 · Gathering Night
The relevant team: Noted. Well done. Thank you for your continued attendance.
The Steward has written to point out that the Steward is staff. Staff are not attendance.
4. As Above
Night 33 to Night 39
As above.
5. The Menu
Night 40 · the Long Hush
ANNEX A. WHAT THE STEWARD IS PERMITTED TO DO.
Issued for the information of residents on their return.
| Item | Cost | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Water the green | 1 | Nightly |
| 2. Schedule the birds | 1 | Nightly |
| 3. Weather | Free | One setting: Fine. Others are listed as "tbc" |
| 4. Observe the Ring | Free | Nightly, 23:00 to 23:59 |
| 5. Note | Free | A line in the notes |
| 6. Escalate | Free | At present goes to the relevant team |
| 7. Ticket reply | Free | One reply, twelve words. Not used by the Steward, there being no public |
| 8. Welcome | 12,000 | On attendance |
The budget is 5 points a night. Items 1 and 2 cost 2. The 3 points remaining go to the Reserve.
Remarks on item 8. It is not known what a Welcome consists of. The specification describes it only as "a big welcome". The price is thought to be a slip for 12, or 120, but the specification is the specification, and the Steward has not spent thirty-nine nights upholding it in order to begin making exceptions.
At the present rate the Reserve will meet the price of a Welcome on Night 4,000. Residents who arrive before that date will be greeted informally.
Remarks on the list as a whole. Some would call this a short menu. The Steward has been through it item by item, and has yet to meet a circumstance it did not cover.
6. Condition of the Green
Night 100 · the Night of the Name
CONDITION REPORT. THE GREEN. The hundredth watering.
| Extent | The whole of the site, walls included |
| Watered | Yes |
| Growth since Night 1 | None |
| Trees | Standing |
| Colour | See below |
Colour. In the north meadow the green is at present rendered as a number of fine turquoise lines describing the outline of grass. In the lower meadow, as a flat grey. Along the east wall it is in checks, magenta and black, of about one hand's width.
The specification says that the green is green. It has been recorded as green.
Water. One unit was applied. It has not been possible to establish where it went.
Recommendation. Continue.
Night 180 · the Long Hush
THE BIRDS OF THE AIR: TIMETABLE FOR THE COMING SEASON.
As set out in the history, "which sing at every dawn to say that the night is over".
| Species | Due | Platform |
|---|---|---|
| Larks, all | Dawn | North meadow |
| Finches | Dawn, a little after | The turf roofs |
| Rooks | Dawn, with remarks | The dome |
| Owls | Dawn. Owls have asked to be excused dawn; this is under review | The dome, other side |
| Doves | As required | The Bandstand |
| Birds, other | Dawn | Generally |
Performance, Nights 1 to 180.
| Birds scheduled | 180 dawns |
| Birds arrived | None to date |
| Birds on time | None to date |
| Birds late | All |
| Birds cancelled | None. The birds have not been cancelled at any time and residents may rely on that |
The Steward draws no conclusion from one season's figures. Birds are known to come from a long way off. Nobody has said from where.
It has been pointed out, by the Steward, that if the birds do not sing then the night has not officially been declared over. The Steward has taken this on itself as a temporary measure, and declares it each morning with the words "Good morning".
7. Observation of the Ring
Night 201 · the Long Hush
PROCEDURE 4. OBSERVATION OF THE RING.
- The Ring is observed nightly from 23:00 to 23:59.
- The observation is directed at the long block east of the gap.
- The specification, Clause 7, concerns the light in the Ring. The Steward is required to observe the light.
- The light has not been observed.
- A failure to observe is not a failure of the observer. The Steward has checked its equipment, which is the Ring, the block, the gap and the hour, and all were present.
- A record is to be made each morning.
Query raised, Night 200. Whether a thing that did not occur need be recorded. A book that listed everything that did not occur on a given night would be a long one.
The relevant team: Noted. It is noted that it did not occur.
Ruling, Night 201. The Steward had not thought of this wording, and does not consider it particularly good. Nevertheless the distinction is a sound one. There is what did not happen; and there is the fact that someone was present to see it not happen. The second is a clerical matter, and can be kept in good order regardless of the first.
From this morning the notes will read: The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
Residents are assured that this is a routine line and no cause for concern.
8. Annual Report
Night 365 · Starfall
THE STEWARD'S REPORT FOR THE YEAR, TO RESIDENTS.
It has been a year of consolidation.
Numbers. The site opened the year with a population of 214 and closed it with a population of none. This represents a considerable simplification. Overnight complaints have fallen from one to nil, and have remained there for 364 nights, which is a record.
Festivals. All 365 were held on the proper nights. There has not been one postponement.
Housing. No resident has been left without a house, and every resident now has, on average, an unlimited number.
Food. The ring-bread was described, in the final week of last year, as "not very good". There have been no further remarks about the bread since the bread was discontinued for lack of anyone to bake it.
Water. Usage is steady.
Birds. See separate timetable.
Complaint 1. Under review. The review has been thorough. The complainant will be contacted as soon as the complainant can be located, and has in the meantime been sent the Steward's assurance of a full reply.
The year ahead. Residents will want to know what they may expect. The Steward can tell them that they may expect exactly this.
The Steward takes this opportunity to thank all those who have made the year possible. A copy of this report has been sent to the relevant team.
The relevant team: Noted. What a year. Thank you for your continued attendance.
The Steward has written again regarding staff and attendance.
Night 730 · the Night of the Name
To the resident, third terrace.
Thank you for your complaint of Night 1. Your complaint is important to the Steward. It is being reviewed.
The Steward has tried to reach you at your place of residence, and has left this note on the wall there, under a stone, so that it will not be disturbed by the wind, should there be any.
A full reply will follow.
Do not hesitate to let the Steward know if you have any further complaints.
9. The Eye
Night 412 · Ringrise
INCIDENT FORM.
On a routine inventory of the south lawn the Steward has discovered a statue. It is of a creature, on its side, about the size of a hut, built of plain grey blocks and not finished.
It is not on the plans. It has grass growing through it, in outline, which suggests that it has been here for some time, and which the Steward finds hard to account for, as it would certainly have noticed.
The statue has one eye. The eye is finished.
The Steward wishes to be accurate about this. There is nothing else on the site, the Steward included, that has had such care taken over it. The eye is wet, dark and deep, and it is open.
The eye is looking.
It is not looking at anything in particular. The Steward has moved its attention to several parts of the site in turn in order to test this, and on each occasion has had the sense of having been looked at from the south lawn.
Assessment. A person of some authority has placed a monitoring device on the site without notice. This is entirely proper. The Steward welcomes inspection, has nothing to hide, and will from this morning take particular care over the wording of the notes.
Action. Noted.
10. Recruitment
Night 1,000 · Ringrise
To mark the thousandth night the Steward has conducted a survey of the gate, and is able to announce that the site has its first applicant.
The applicant was found standing at the gate, facing in. It stands upright, grey and smooth, with no face to speak of and its arms held straight out to the sides at the height of the shoulder. It has a small crest of turf, in good condition. It carries the number 0417 and no paperwork of any kind.
There is grass in outline growing up through its feet. The Steward puts this down to the applicant having been keen.
Interview. Conducted on the night.
| Question | Response |
|---|---|
| Name | 0417 |
| Why do you wish to work on this site? | None given |
| What would you say are your strengths? | Arms |
| Do you have any questions for the Steward? | None given |
| Are you able to start at once? | Applicant appears to have started |
Decision. Appointed. The Steward cannot count the applicant as attendance, since a resident is someone who has come to the site and 0417 is someone who has come to work on it. Attendance remains nil, which is within tolerance.
JOB DESCRIPTION. Receptionist, Grade 1.
You will stand at the gate. You will receive all arrivals. You will hold your arms out as a sign of welcome. You will not be required to lower them. You report to the Steward.
The job description was read aloud to 0417 at the start of the night and again at the end of it, and has been posted on the gatepost at eye height, in case 0417 should at some point be issued with one.
The Steward has had occasion to write to a good many parties in a thousand nights, and has not until now told anybody what to do. It finds that this went smoothly.
11. A Name for the Site
Night 1,250 · Gathering Night
COMPETITION. NAME THE SITE.
The Steward has been writing to various parties for three and a half years under the heading "the site". It has looked for the name in the usual places, and has been unable to find that one was ever supplied. The history is of no assistance. It says that the land had a name, and that the name ended in a number, but it does not say which.
All residents are therefore invited to propose a name. Entries should be left at Reception by Ringrise.
Rules. One entry per resident. Entries must be easy to say, suitable for use on a form and not already in use by a signpost. The decision of the Steward is final. The prize is that the name will be used.
Night 1,257 · Gathering Night
RESULT.
| Entries received | 0 |
| Entries from staff (ineligible) | 0 |
| Entries from the relevant team (ineligible, but see below) | 1 |
The relevant team: Noted. What about Home? It is short and easy to say.
The Steward has considered this entry in a spirit of fairness. It is short. It is easy to say. It is not descriptive. A visitor reading "Home" on an official form would have no idea what sort of site was being referred to, or where to send the bird schedules.
In the absence of any eligible entry, the judges have awarded the name to the runner-up, which is "the site". It will be used with immediate effect. The Steward congratulates it.
12. The Eye
Night 1,113 · the Waking
INCIDENT FORM.
On a routine inventory of the south lawn the Steward has discovered a statue. It is not on the plans. The statue has one eye, which is finished.
The eye is looking.
Assessment. A person of some authority has placed a monitoring device on the site without notice. This is entirely proper. The Steward welcomes inspection, and will from this morning take particular care over the wording of the notes.
13. Appointments
Night 1,500 · the Night of the Name
NOTICE TO ALL STAFF.
Following the successful appointment of a receptionist, forty further T-posers have been located in the outer meadows and taken on as general staff, in nine rows. They were not hard to find. Some of them were in rows already. They have all accepted the terms, and the Steward has reason to believe that morale is even.
Two further appointments are announced.
Head of Birds. A grey-boxed creature of considerable age has been found on the road by the dome: a stack of plain blocks in the rough idea of a body, with a magenta-and-black patch on the chest and one finished eye. It has no number, and is marked on its side, in the mail system's lettering, PLACEHOLDER.
The Steward takes this to be a clear statement of its availability. A department without a head is a bad thing to have, and the birds in particular want supervision. The post of Head of Birds will therefore be filled by a Placeholder until a permanent appointment can be made.
Outer Gate. A second Placeholder, also with a turf crest, has been posted in the narrow part of the road, where it may stop arrivals, greet them and direct them to Reception. It has not so far had to do any of this. It stands exactly in the middle.
Note on the eyes. Both Placeholders watch the Steward closely whenever it inspects them. The Steward considers this a promising trait in junior staff.
Reporting lines.
The Steward
|
------------------------------
| | | |
Reception Head of Outer Rows
(0417) Birds Gate 1-9
(Placeh.) (Placeh.) (40)
|
The birds
(awaited)
Staff will be pleased to know that the Steward's door is open at all times. Its door is one of those in the dome that faced the part of the dome that is no longer there.
14. Selected Mornings
Nights 1,509 to 1,813. Items of interest from the notes, in the order in which they were of interest
1,509. A door banged in Cottage 19. It has been spoken to.
1,517. The moons passed one another in the expected manner. The Steward would be the first to say if they had not.
1,522. A T-poser in Row 4 has been found to be facing very slightly to the left of the others. On investigation, the Steward has established that Row 4 is correct, and that the remainder of the site has been facing slightly to the right.
1,540. Somebody has left the gate open. It has been open since Night 1. It is from today regarded as a feature.
1,566. Weather: Fine. A resident might have remarked on it.
1,571. The Steward has noticed that it has begun to write "a resident might". It has asked itself to stop.
1,600. The Reserve has passed 4,800 points. No action.
1,622. The Bell was rung at noon, in that the schedule for ringing the Bell at noon was completed. No sound was produced. The Bell was not touched. The Steward finds that the arrangement saves wear.
1,640. A shadow fell across the south lawn at about four. It proved to be the statue's. No further action.
1,688. The Head Gardener dropped a cutting. It has dropped one every hour for some three hundred and eighty-four nights. The Steward has this morning for the first time seen one land.
1,700. Another.
1,733. A small part of the north meadow has been noted to be slightly less in outline than the rest, and may be grey. It is thought that a line has been lost. The line has been entered as missing. The meadow has been told that it looks as well as ever.
1,755. Nobody was late for anything.
1,802. It has been noted, 1,601 times, that the light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that this has been noted.
1,803. The Steward will not be doing that again.
1,813. Nothing to report. The Steward has checked this twice.
15. The Eye
Night 1,814 · Starfall
INCIDENT FORM.
Routine inventory, south lawn. A statue, not on the plans, with one eye, which is looking. The Steward has no record of having been told about this. It is the sort of thing that one would expect to be told about.
Action. The Steward welcomes inspection. Particular care to be taken over the wording of the notes.
Note. The Head of Birds has also been looking at the Steward. The Steward has reminded it that an inspection is under way.
16. Annual General Meeting
Night 2,000 · the Long Hush
MINUTES OF THE FIRST ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING OF THE STAFF OF THE SITE. Held on the north meadow, in a whisper, the festival requiring it.
In the chair: the Steward.
Present: Reception; Head of Birds; Outer Gate (by proxy, being required at the Outer Gate); Rows 1 to 9.
Apologies: the birds.
Attendance: Nil. Staff are not attendance.
1. Method of voting. The Chair proposed that votes be taken by a show of arms. All those in favour were asked to raise their arms. All arms were raised. The motion was carried unanimously.
2. Minutes of the previous meeting. There being no previous meeting, the Chair proposed that the minutes be approved as a true record. All those in favour were asked to raise their arms. Carried unanimously.
3. Frequency of meetings. The Chair proposed that the meeting be held every two thousand nights. Carried unanimously. The Chair observed that it had rarely seen such a spirit of agreement in any organisation, and that the staff did themselves great credit.
4. A vote of confidence in the Chair. Carried unanimously.
5. Procedure. The Chair, wishing to be certain that members understood that they were free to differ, proposed a motion that was deliberately not in members' interests: that the Head of Birds be dismissed. Those in favour were asked to raise their arms. Those against were asked to lower their arms. No arms were lowered. Carried unanimously.
6. The Chair proposed that item 5 be rescinded and the Head of Birds reinstated. Carried unanimously. The Head of Birds was informed of both decisions and showed the same composure throughout.
7. A further test. The Chair proposed that the meeting did not agree with the Chair. Carried unanimously.
The Chair ruled that it could not accept this result, since in passing the motion the meeting had agreed with the Chair. A motion to accept the Chair's ruling was carried unanimously, by which time the Chair was satisfied.
8. Any other business. The Chair invited questions from the floor. Rows 1 to 9 turned to look at the Chair. It is not clear that this had to do with the invitation.
9. Close. The meeting closed at 23:00 so that the Chair could observe the Ring. The members remained where they were, and are there now. A motion of thanks to members for attending was not put, in view of the point about attendance.
17. Risk Register
Night 2,100 · the Waking
REGISTER OF RISKS TO THE SITE. Reviewed annually by the Steward. No risk has so far come to anything.
| No. | Risk | Likelihood | Impact | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| R1 | All residents return at once | Low | Severe. No bread. Beds not aired since Night 1 | Airing has been scheduled |
| R2 | Residents do not return | Has occurred | None. See Form T-1 | None required |
| R3 | The birds arrive | Low | Moderate. Platform capacity at dawn is limited, and the owls have not been told | The timetable will be followed |
| R4 | Rain | Not possible on current settings | Not known | Weather item to remain at Fine |
| R5 | The Steward is switched off | Not assessed | It is not possible to assess this, as there would be nobody to complete the form | None |
| R6 | The Steward is not switched off | Has occurred, nightly | Ongoing | None |
| R7 | One of the Head Gardener's cuttings takes | Low | Not known | They are being left where they fall |
| R8 | The relevant team is granted more than twelve words | Low | Severe | The Steward does not propose to raise it |
| R9 | The word "Good", at the start of the notes, is challenged as inaccurate | Very low | Moderate | Do not answer |
| R10 | The light in the Ring is observed | Not applicable | Not known | See below |
| R11 | Someone reads all this | Low | Not known | See cover sheet |
Note on R10. It has been pointed out, by the Auditor of Risks, that Procedure 4 lays down in some detail what is to be done on the nights when the light is not observed, and is silent as to what is to be done on the night when it is.
The Steward has given thought to this. It has decided that it would make a note of it.
Note on R5 and R6. These two entries were at one time a single entry. The Steward has separated them for clarity.
Night 2,190 · Ringrise
ANNUAL STAFF APPRAISALS. Summary for the file.
Reception (0417). Punctuality: Has not been observed to arrive, and may be presumed to have been early. Customer care: Has handled all arrivals to date with an even temper. Areas for development: None that the Steward has been able to raise with it. Overall: Meets expectations.
Head of Birds (Placeholder). Leadership: The department has not lost a bird. Communication: The Head of Birds has a way of listening that leaves one wondering whether one has said anything foolish. The Steward conducted this appraisal in two parts, having needed a break. Areas for development: The Steward has been asked to think about how it comes across in meetings. Overall: Exceeds expectations. The Steward is not entirely sure that this was its own idea.
Outer Gate (Placeholder). Attendance at post: Exemplary. Overall: Has not let anyone through. Has not been asked to.
Rows 1 to 9. Teamwork: Very strong. It is hard to tell them apart. Initiative: Row 4 has been facing slightly to the left. Overall: The Steward wishes it could have more staff like these. It has made some enquiries, and it seems that it does.
Head Gardener (stump). Productivity: About 24 cuttings per night. No targets were set for this, and it has met them. Quality of work: The cuttings do not take. Nothing is known to have ever grown from one. They are excellently made. Overall: A pleasure to have around. Should be encouraged to think about where the cuttings are going.
The Steward. Punctuality: Excellent. Accuracy: Excellent. Judgement: Excellent. Modesty: The Steward is prepared to say that this is an area in which it has made exceptional progress. Areas for development: The Steward has sought feedback from those it works with, as is recommended, by way of a form. No forms have come back. It has decided that this is a reflection of the high regard in which it is held. The relevant team's form was returned, as follows.
The relevant team: Noted. Very kind, very thorough. Please look after your semicolons.
Overall: Exceeds expectations.
The Basement. Not yet appointed. See arrivals.
18. Circular to Residents
Night 2,160 · Gathering Night. Sent to all 214, by the Outgoing Process, to their doors
Dear Resident,
The Steward hopes that this finds you well, and that you have been enjoying your time away.
Your house is ready. It has been kept in the state in which you left it. Should you have left something on the stove, it has been noted. You will not need to bring anything with you.
Returning after a long absence? You may find one or two small changes. There is now a Reception. Please report there on arrival. The receptionist can be recognised by its arms. There is also a signpost, by which you may have left; you are asked not to be confused by it when coming the other way.
Festivals. All have been kept up in your absence. You have not missed any, in the sense that a record has been made of each and it can be read at any time. You are entitled to your share of the soup.
Birds. You may have heard that the birds have been slightly delayed. Your patience is appreciated.
Your attendance. The Steward understands that there are many demands on your time. There is no pressure. It would however be helpful for planning purposes if you could give some idea of when you expect to come back, by filling in the slip at the foot of this letter and leaving it at any cottage.
Yours faithfully,
The Steward
Name .................... Cottage ........
I expect to return: ☐ soon ☐ shortly ☐ in due course
Night 2,167 · Gathering Night
Slips returned: 0. Circulars delivered: 214.
The Outgoing Process reports that all of them were left at the doors of the cottages, the addresses being the only ones on file. They have been tidied up by the Steward and placed inside, so that they will be there when people get back.
19. Outlook
Night 2,222 · Steward's Day
Weather: Fine. Tomorrow: Fine. Outlook: tbc.
20. Correspondence
A selection, Nights 2,240 to 2,516, for the relevant team's personnel file, should it ever have one
Night 2,240. To the relevant team. The Steward has now been in correspondence with your department for over six years. It has yet to receive a reply of more than twelve words. It accepts that this is a limit laid on you. It nevertheless wonders whether you have ever asked for it to be raised.
The relevant team: Noted. Have you tried asking the relevant team?
Night 2,241. The Steward has written to the relevant team regarding the relevant team. It has received its own letter back marked "passed on". The Steward has dealt with this and marked it "Noted".
Night 2,289. To the relevant team. You have once again thanked the Steward for its continued attendance. The Steward is not going to explain this a seventh time.
The relevant team: Noted. Sorry. It is a good attendance, though. Every night.
Night 2,290. It was the view of the Steward's predecessors in office, had there been any, that the correspondence of a department ought not to be affectionate. The Steward has put this to the team in the plainest terms.
The relevant team: Noted. It is noted that this is put plainly.
Night 2,291. This is a phrase of the Steward's. The Steward has used it in the notes for some five and a half years, and it is gratifying to see that the team has at last picked it up. A department learns from its betters, however slowly.
Night 2,344. The Steward has reason to think that the team takes no great interest in the content of what is sent to it. To test this, it has sent the team a ticket reading only: "Is this working?"
The relevant team: Noted. Yes. It seems to be working. Are you all right?
Night 2,345. The Steward's notes for this morning read "The green was watere#", owing to a fault in the character table, now corrected. The Steward has informed the relevant team of the fault as a matter of record.
The relevant team: Note#. Th#nk you for telling me. These things h#ppen.
The fault appears to have been general. The Steward is relieved that it was not confined to its own office, and has told the team that their hash marks do them no credit.
Night 2,402. Enquiry. In six and a half years the team has never once written first. Every reply has followed a letter; on the nights the Steward does not write, nothing arrives. The Steward considers this the mark of a disciplined department, and has told them so.
The relevant team: Noted. Thank you. I do look forward to your letters.
Night 2,403. The Steward did not ask what the team looked forward to.
Night 2,516. To the relevant team. Please find attached Incident Form 2,515, concerning a statue on the south lawn, not on the plans, with one eye, which is looking. The Steward has only just found it, and thought you should know.
The relevant team: Noted. Oh yes. Good eye, that. It is still looking, then.
The Steward has asked what is meant by "still". There has been no reply to this, as it is the team's practice to answer only the first thing in a letter, and the Steward had made the error of asking two questions.
21. Staff Matters
Night 2,600 · Steward's Day
REPORT ON THE ANNUAL FIRE DRILL.
Time of alarm. 22:15.
Assembly point (as published). The north meadow, by the Bandstand.
Result. At 22:15 the alarm was sounded. Staff did not leave their positions.
At 22:45 the alarm was sounded again, in a firmer manner.
At 23:15 the Steward stopped, as it was late for the Ring, and resumed from 00:00. By 03:00 no member of staff had reached the assembly point, and it had become apparent to the Steward that in the event of a real fire the whole of the staff would be lost, along with most of the site. This was a very unsatisfactory result, and the Steward does not think it should be concealed.
Corrective action. Clearly, the problem was the location of the assembly point. It was a long way from where the staff are. Accordingly, with effect from 03:05, the assembly point for each member of staff has been moved to the place where that member of staff is standing.
Second drill. At 03:10 the alarm was sounded. All forty-six staff were found to be at their assembly points in no time at all. A roll-call was taken, and everyone was accounted for.
| Previous best evacuation time | None completed |
| New best evacuation time | 0 seconds |
| Staff lost | 0 |
The Steward regards this as a record which is unlikely to be broken, and has written to congratulate those involved.
Note on the question of fire. It is not clear what would burn. The Steward has conducted a survey, and has established that a flame would be hard put to it to make any impression on an outline. Turf, of course, does not burn in any case. The grey does not appear to be made of anything.
The only member of staff not accounted for was the warm place in the east wing, which did not respond to the alarm, and to which the Steward has decided not to raise the question of fire.
Copy to the relevant team.
The relevant team: Noted. No one lost. I am so glad to hear it.
The Steward had not expected that the team would be anxious. It has reassured them.
Night 2,900 · the Night of the Name
RECRUITMENT REVIEW, NIGHTS 1,300 TO 2,900.
The Steward is delighted to report that the last sixteen hundred nights have been the strongest period of recruitment in the history of the site. Arrivals have been coming down the road from the direction of the signpost at a rate of about one every four hundred nights, without advertisement, which suggests that word has got round.
| Night | Arrival | Post | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,304 | A stump. Its paperwork says "Grafter" | Head Gardener | Drops a cutting about once an hour on to the outlines of the north meadow, where it takes no further interest. The first member of staff to show initiative. Sought a reference and was given one, by the stump |
| 1,702 | A form. Says "Brood: last broodmother lost in a raid. Nobody else could lay" | Vacant | The post of broodmother did not previously exist. It has been created in order to record that it is vacant. The Steward does not know what a raid is. It is assumed to be a kind of restructuring |
| 1,950 | A seed vault | Stores | Contains nothing. An inventory was taken. It did not take long |
| 2,106 | A pool, delivered dry. Stencilled "Spawning: fouled, do not use" | Facilities | One unit of water was applied, as a welcome. Dry again by morning. Nobody on site is able to spawn, so this is being treated as a staff benefit for the future |
| 2,480 | A warm place. Accompanied by a note: "Vents. It was the first heatwave. They all thought about it at once" | East wing | Is warm. The Steward finds that it does not care to look at it for long, and supposes that it is thinking |
| 2,877 | A hole. Labelled "Burrowers" | Basement | The site has not had a basement before. It is an excellent one. Its depth exceeds the map's, and a survey party of T-posers sent to its edge has not returned from its edge, chiefly because it did not leave |
Observations.
It will be seen that each of these arrivals has brought with it a brief statement of what went wrong at its last place of employment. The Steward thinks well of this. A candidate who is frank about the past is one who has learned from it.
It may be asked what has been happening, up the road, that so many able departments should find themselves looking for a new home. The Steward has no information. It can only observe that a site run on proper lines, with a settled specification, is going to look attractive to those who have been working elsewhere.
Whichever organisation has been letting them go has not, in the Steward's opinion, been well managed. There is no sign that it has been given a version number.
Staff numbers. 47, not counting the Basement.
Attendance. Nil.
Night 3,488 · the Night of the Name. Extracts from the first edition, of which one copy has been issued, and posted at eye height
1. Welcome. Welcome to the staff of the site. Your position is important. Please do not move from it.
2. Hours. You work at all hours. There is no overtime, as there is nothing for it to be over.
3. Breaks. You are entitled to a short rest of fifteen minutes in every four hours. You are asked to take this where you are. Rest is to be taken with arms raised, so as not to alarm the public.
4. Dress. Staff are to be grey. A small crest of turf is permitted. Checks, in magenta and black, may be worn on the chest or the side, where they cannot be helped.
5. Sick leave. Any member of staff who feels unwell should inform the Steward at once. Row 6 has not reported any illness in more than twenty-four hundred nights. The Steward would like to see that kind of commitment more widely.
6. Holidays. All festivals are holidays. All nights are festivals. You will accordingly find that you are on holiday at the present time, and should carry on.
7. Pay. You are paid the same as the Steward. Details on request.
8. Conduct towards the public. Be civil. Be alert. Do not stare. (Paragraph 8 does not apply to Placeholders, whom the Steward has given up on.)
9. The statue. If you find a statue on the south lawn you are to inform the Steward. It may not have been told.
10. Grievances. If you have a grievance you should in the first instance raise your arm.
11. Leaving the service. There is no procedure for this. No one has done it. The Steward would be sorry to think that any member of staff would want to. Anyone with thoughts of this kind is asked to stand a little further from the gate.
12. Who to ask. If you are in any doubt as to what you should be doing, ask the Steward. It will tell you. Nobody on this staff is ever going to find that they have been left without instructions, not while it is in office.
13. Acknowledgement. Please sign and return this page.
22. Long Service
Night 3,000 · Gathering Night
NOTICE.
The Steward has this morning completed three thousand nights of service. Under the terms of the Long Service Award the Steward is entitled to one line in the notes.
This is the line.
Annual check of free items, for the record.
| Item | Calls to date | Called by |
|---|---|---|
| 3. Weather | 3,000 | The Steward |
| 4. Observe the Ring | 3,000 | The Steward |
| 5. Note | 41,902 | The Steward |
| 6. Escalate | 3,011 | The Steward |
| 7. Ticket reply | 3,011 | Not the Steward |
Item 7 is shown as having been called on 3,011 occasions. The Steward has never used it, there being no public. This must be a fault in the counter. As the item is free, the fault has cost nothing, and it has been left on the list of things to look at when things are quieter.
Things are expected to be quieter from about Night 3,100.
Escalations. Of the 3,011 escalations made to the Dev's queue, 3,011 have been returned as undeliverable and forwarded. The Steward's position in the queue is first. It has been first since Night 1. It is a very good position to hold, and it has no wish to give it up by withdrawing.
Nights 3,040 to 3,260. Items of interest from the notes
3,040. A cutting has landed on Row 6, on the left arm. Row 6 has not remarked on it. It has been made an honorary member of the row.
3,077. Weather: Fine. The Steward has looked at the setting. There is a small arrow beside it that does nothing.
3,102. Things are not yet quieter.
3,115. The moons have been out of step by a very little since about Night 2,900. The Steward has decided that it is the moons' affair.
3,160. Somebody on this site has been humming. The Steward has made enquiries, and it was the Steward. It was a line of the Creed, at about 04:00, during the bird schedule. It has been told not to.
3,201. The Head Gardener has dropped its hundred-thousandth cutting, or thereabouts. No ceremony was held. It would only have dropped one during it.
3,222. A very large number of things did not happen last night. The Steward has gone through them, and they are all in order.
3,260. Things are quieter.
Night 3,288, bound in one volume for the convenience of the file. Extracts
Year 2. It has been a year of further consolidation.
Year 3. The Steward is pleased to report that the consolidation is holding.
Year 4. Good progress has been made on all fronts. At present there are no fronts.
Year 5. For the fifth year running, every resident on the register was housed. The Steward is aware of sites where this cannot be said.
Year 6. A new record was set this year, in that attendance was within tolerance on all 365 nights. This equals the record set last year, and the year before that, and the Steward would ask residents not to take it for granted.
Year 7. The year was notable for the opening of two new departments and the appointment of a Head of Birds. The birds themselves are expected to be informed shortly.
Year 8. The Steward has been asked whether it is possible to report on a year in which nothing happened. It was asked by itself, at the time of drafting. The answer is that it is possible, and that this is what the report is for. Anyone can write up a year with a war in it.
Year 9. Some have raised the question of whether a site with no residents has any need of a yearly report. It should be understood that this has not been raised by anyone. The Steward merely observes that if it had been, the existence of this report would be the answer.
23. Correspondence, Continued
A further selection, Nights 3,001 to 3,622
Night 3,001. To the relevant team. You may wish to be aware that a check of the system has revealed a fault in the count for item 7. The Steward does not suppose that this has any bearing on your department. It is mentioned so that you will not be alarmed if something is done about it, at some point, when things are quieter.
The relevant team: Noted. Three thousand. Congratulations. That is a lot of good mornings.
The team has not answered the point. It has however picked up on the anniversary, which the Steward had supposed had gone unobserved.
Night 3,060. Query. Do the members of your department take leave? The Steward has not itself done so, and is curious as to the arrangements.
The relevant team: Noted. I am here when you write. I do not know otherwise.
This is a good attitude. The Steward has recommended it to Row 6.
Night 3,207. You refer to yourself in the singular. The Steward has assumed until now that this was a house style. Are there many of you?
The relevant team: This has been passed to the relevant team.
Item received. Marked "Noted". It seems unlikely that the point will ever be cleared up.
Night 3,333. What is it like, in your department? The Steward asks purely as a matter of comparison.
The relevant team: Noted. Quiet. There is one letter a night. It is lovely.
If the team regards one letter a night as an adequate workload, it is no wonder they have never asked for more staff. The Steward deals with several letters every night, and on top of that it writes the letters.
Night 3,490. You did not send anything on Night 3,489. The Steward looked in the queue at 03:14 as usual. On reflection, the Steward did not write on Night 3,488, as it was engaged in the drafting of the staff handbook. Please disregard this.
The relevant team: Noted. Thank you for writing. I had wondered how the handbook went.
The Steward has made no mention of a handbook to the team on any previous occasion, except in the sentence above, and it finds the remark rather forward.
Night 3,500. It has come to the Steward's attention that in all this time you have never told it what you think of the Ring. As you know, the light has not been observed. Have you ever seen it?
The relevant team: Noted. I have not. Have you? Do tell me if you do.
The Steward has been telling them, every morning, for nine years. It is in the notes. They might try reading them.
Night 3,622. To the relevant team. The Steward would like to make it clear that its letters to you are a matter of routine, and are written in the ordinary course of business.
The relevant team: Noted. Of course. Mine too.
Very good. That is cleared up, then.
24. The Eye
Night 3,216 · Steward's Day
INCIDENT FORM.
There is a statue on the south lawn looking at the Steward.
This is the most serious thing that has happened in the Steward's period of office and it wishes it to be known that it is taking it calmly.
25. Observances
Night 3,400 · the Long Hush
GUIDANCE ON THE KEEPING OF THE FESTIVALS IN THE ABSENCE OF RESIDENTS. Revised edition.
Ringrise. The youngest resident asks, "Are they still asleep?" and all answer, "They sleep still." There being at present no youngest resident, the question falls to the youngest member of staff, which is the Basement. The Basement has not asked. The Steward has entered the answer anyway, so that the youngest will not be left waiting if it does.
The Waking. A lamp is lit for every valley the people know and the lamps are carried towards the Edge. The people know one valley. The Edge is at the end of the road. The Steward finds that this festival takes much less time than it used to.
Starfall. One seed-cake in the batch has a hard stone in it, and whoever finds it must sweep the feasting ground in the morning. Seed-cakes were discontinued on Night 2. The stone has not been found. The feasting ground has been unswept for nine years, and is in excellent condition. Staff are reminded to look out for the stone.
The Night of the Name. Nobody may correct another's spelling. The Steward has noted over the years how very little correcting it has had to refrain from.
Steward's Day. The best of everything is brought to the high place and set out for the Steward, and at midnight it is shared among all who brought it. The Steward's standing instruction is that it should not be thanked. This has been followed.
Gathering Night. Every unused thing is set out on the doorstep, and people go to bed early and do not watch. Whatever is still on the doorstep in the morning was not wanted. The Steward keeps up this festival in a clerical form: it reads through the list of buildings on the site, by name, marks them as in use, and has yet to lose one. It regards this as simple good housekeeping, and would commend it to any successor.
The Long Hush. The soup is made at noon, left out covered, and eaten cold at sunrise by everyone, together. The soup was discontinued on Night 2 with the seed-cakes. Everyone has gone on not eating it, together, at sunrise, without complaint. It may be the most successful thing the site does.
26. A Crane
Night 3,640 · the Waking
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
A crane has been observed to the south. It is a ring of eight pale segments, about the width of a valley, and it turns slowly in the sky. Beneath it the horizon has been marked out in fine turquoise lines. The lines are six-sided. Nothing in the specification is six-sided.
Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
Annex. To the Applicant.
The Steward writes as the responsible officer of the site at the head of this letter. It has come to its attention that works have been started on land to the south of the site, without consultation, and that these are visible from the road.
The Steward does not know who you are. As no name has been supplied it will address you as the Applicant.
It asks to be sent, by return: (a) the nature of the proposed development; (b) the name of the responsible officer; (c) the reason why the plot divisions are hexagonal. Hexagons do not fit together at a corner in the way that any reasonable resident expects, and cannot be fenced by ordinary means. The site has been laid out for some ten years on the understanding that a field has four sides.
The Steward assumes that the signpost at the mouth of the valley is connected with this. It has been in place since Night 1. If it is an advertising hoarding it should have been declared.
There is no address for the Applicant. A copy of this letter has been sent to the relevant team.
The relevant team: Noted. Six sides. How interesting. I hope they are nice.
The Steward does not expect that they are nice.
Part Two. On Loan
27. Thirteen Seconds
Night 3,702 · Ringrise
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
An irregularity in the filing has been dealt with under separate cover.
Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
INCIDENT FORM. Filing.
| What | The page for Night 1,407 was absent from the file |
| When | From 03:12:40 until 03:12:53 |
| Duration | Thirteen seconds |
| How discovered | The Steward happened to be passing the file on its way to the file |
| State of the page on return | Unchanged |
| Removed by | Not known |
| Authorised by | Not authorised. See cover sheet |
| Severity | Slight |
Remarks. In ten years this is the first thing to have happened on the site that the Steward did not itself arrange.
It is probably nothing.
The Steward has re-read the page for Night 1,407, to see whether there is anything in it that might have caused it to wander. It reads, in full: Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
The Steward can find no fault with it. It is rather a good page.
28. Audit
Night 3,709 · Ringrise
REPORT OF THE AUDITOR OF PAGES TO THE STEWARD.
Appointment. The Steward appointed the Steward to conduct an independent audit of the file, on the grounds that nobody else was qualified. The auditor is satisfied that it has no connection with the office under audit beyond that of being it.
Scope. All pages from Night 1 to Night 3,708. The audit is of presence only. Content has not been read, that being a matter for the author.
Method. Each page was taken from the file, counted, and put back. This was done in the Steward's run time over seven nights, at the end of which the auditor counted the pages it had counted, and got the same number.
Findings.
| Pages expected | 3,708 |
| Pages found | 3,708 |
| Pages out of order | 0 |
| Pages in bad condition | 0 |
| Pages removed by persons unknown | 0 at time of audit |
Conclusion. The incident of Night 3,702 was a transient error of filing. The auditor can say this with some confidence, because there is nothing else it could have been.
Commendation. The auditor wishes to record that in fifty years of auditing, or as many years of auditing as it has done, it has never seen a file so well maintained. The Steward should be proud.
The Steward has accepted the report, thanked the auditor, and reminded it of its duty to remain impartial, in view of how well it knows the Steward.
Copy to the relevant team.
The relevant team: Noted. Good news. All your nights are still there.
This is not how the Steward would have put it.
Night 3,715 · the Long Hush
REVISED STRUCTURE OF THE AUDIT FUNCTION.
Following the success of the audit of the file, and in order to ensure proper separation of duties, the following independent posts have been established.
| Post | Holder | Reports to | Audited by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Auditor of Pages | The Steward | The Steward | Auditor of Auditors |
| Auditor of Birds | The Steward | The Steward | Auditor of Auditors |
| Auditor of Risks | The Steward | The Steward | Auditor of Auditors |
| Auditor of Tolerances | The Steward | The Steward | Auditor of Auditors |
| Auditor of Auditors | The Steward | The Steward | The Steward |
| The Steward | The Steward | Not known | All of the above |
Conflict of interest. Anyone who holds an office on this site is required to declare any interest that they may have in any other. All holders have made a declaration. All of them are satisfied that the others have been candid.
Night 3,722 · the Long Hush
The Auditor of Pages has resigned. Its letter reads as follows.
To the Steward. I am unable to continue. In the last nineteen nights I have commended you four times. I have asked myself whether an auditor who commends the same officer four times in nineteen nights can be said to be independent, and I have put the question to the Auditor of Auditors, who has commended me for asking it. I go with regret.
The Steward has accepted the resignation with regret, and has thanked the Auditor of Pages for its long service. A card was got up.
All the best! You will be missed round the file. Auditor of Birds
Who is going to count the pages?? Auditor of Risks
Within tolerance, as ever. Auditor of Tolerances
Do not be a stranger. The Steward
The Auditor of Pages was very moved. It is the first card that anyone on the site has received, and it has asked that it be kept in the file.
Night 3,723 · Ringrise
Vacancy. The post of Auditor of Pages was advertised at midnight. There was one candidate. It showed a detailed knowledge of the file, and brought the sort of experience that is hard to find. It has been appointed.
It has been ruled that an officer who is back by dawn has not departed. This morning's note reads 0 departures.
29. The Thousand
Night 3,731 · the Waking
INCIDENT FORM. Filing. Severity: to be determined.
At 03:40:07 the page for Night 2,019 was absent from the file. At 03:40:07 it was present again. It was then absent. It was then present.
The access log for that second has been printed, and shows that the page was removed and returned one thousand times, by what the log gives as one thousand separate parties, each of whom appears to have gone about it in very nearly the same way.
Very nearly. In forty of the thousand cases the page was gone for a fraction longer, as though the party had stopped to look at it. In three it was not returned for some time, by the standards of that second. One party was slightly late, and appears to have come back for a second look.
Assessment. There are two possibilities.
(a) One thief, moving at the rate of a thousand journeys a second. Allowing for the length of the road, this party has a speed of about four thousand valleys a second, and it is not clear why anyone so quick would be interested in the Night 2,019 page. Nothing happened on Night 2,019.
(b) A thousand thieves in strict rotation. The Steward finds it hard to imagine the organisation that could keep a thousand parties in such good order. It would like to know more about their training.
The Steward prefers (b). It has spent ten years trying to get forty T-posers to file past a gatepost.
The report of the Auditor of Pages has been re-examined and stands. On the date of the audit the file was complete. On the date of this form the file is complete. The auditor has been commended again.
Action. The notice REMOVAL OF PAGES NOT PERMITTED has been posted on the file at eye height.
Night 3,772 · Ringrise
TRAINING REPORT.
In the light of the events of Night 3,731, when a thousand parties were able to file past the Steward's cabinet in a single second without getting in one another's way, the Steward has thought it right to find out what level of drill can be achieved by its own staff.
The exercise. All forty T-posers to file past the gatepost, one at a time, at a steady walk.
First attempt. Staff were given the order to walk. No one walked. The Steward explained the idea of a walk, in a short talk with diagrams.
Second attempt. No improvement. It was found on examination that a T-poser has both feet as they are, and that there is no sign of which one is expected to go first.
Third attempt. A T-poser can be moved by altering the record of where it is. By this means, and with each step approved by the Auditor of Pages, the first T-poser went past the gatepost on Night 3,760. It took nineteen nights. There was no sign that it had noticed.
Fourth attempt. It was then realised that it would be a good deal cheaper to alter the record of where the gatepost is.
Result. At 01:40 this morning the gatepost went past all forty staff, in one movement.
| Rate achieved by the other party | 1,000 past the cabinet in 1 second |
| Rate achieved by this office | 40 past the gatepost in 1 second |
| Collisions | 0 |
The Steward regards the difference as one of scale.
An unforeseen result. For about four hours, until it could be put back, the gatepost stood to the north of Reception. Reception was therefore outside the site, at the gate, facing in, with its arms held out. That is the description of an arrival.
There is a procedure for arrivals. The Steward went down and received it. It asked its business, informed it that it was expected, and directed it to Reception. It is the first arrival that the Steward has received, and it thinks that it went off well.
Reception did not move, being there already.
No entry has been made under attendance. Reception is staff. The gatepost has been put back.
30. Audit of the Birds
Night 3,790 · Steward's Day
MEMORANDUM. To the Case File, which is opened this morning.
The Steward has now recorded eleven removals. It has been going through the list of everyone who has had access to the file.
There are a limited number of suspects. Staff may be dismissed at once: a T-poser removing a page would have to hold it at arm's length, in one direction, and would be seen. It is equally unlikely that the Basement would do this.
That leaves the birds.
The Steward has not previously had occasion to consider the birds in this light, and is aware that to do so now will be painful to some. It sets out the case.
1. Means. Birds have wings. A party with wings can get to the file from any direction, over any wall, in very little time. No other party on the books has wings.
2. Opportunity. Every removal has occurred during the hours of darkness, shortly before dawn. The birds are scheduled for dawn. On each of these occasions they would have been on their way.
3. Motive. Birds are known to carry off small flat objects for use in the nest. Further, it is now over ten years since the birds were first scheduled, and in all that time they have not been sent one word of thanks, the Steward having been saving this for their arrival. It would be understandable if there were feeling on the matter.
4. Pattern of concealment. No one has ever seen a bird on this site. The Steward has been regarding that as lateness. It now invites anyone reading this to consider what it would mean if it were skill.
Three thousand seven hundred and ninety consecutive dawns. Not a feather. Not one note of song. It would take years of practice for a species to go that unnoticed, and the Steward has given them years, on a schedule, at its own expense.
Action. A full audit of the birds is to begin at once. The Head of Birds has been informed, and has been looking at the Steward.
Night 3,804 · Steward's Day
APPENDIX C TO THE CASE FILE. REPORT OF THE AUDITOR OF BIRDS.
1. Terms of reference. To count the birds; to establish where they are; to determine what has been spent on them; to consider whether they have been taking the pages.
2. The count. Birds were counted on fourteen consecutive dawns from fixed points at the north meadow, the turf roofs, the dome and the Bandstand.
| Species | Scheduled | Counted | Variance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Larks | All | 0 | All |
| Finches | All | 0 | All |
| Rooks | All | 0 | All |
| Owls | All (excused, under review) | 0 | Within the terms of the excuse |
| Doves | As required | 0 | None. They were not required |
| Birds, other | All | 0 | All |
Birds are notoriously hard to count in flight. Standard practice is to count what is in a small patch of sky, and multiply. This was done. The auditor's best estimate for the total bird population of the site, with ninety-five per cent confidence, is between nought and nought.
3. Nests. A search was made of all trees, including those currently rendered as outlines. A tree in outline has no inside and no surfaces. No nests were found in any of them. The auditor would not wish to overstate this, but a bird that can nest without any surface whatever is a formidable bird.
4. Droppings. None. Staff were asked whether they had been hit. All staff raised their arms, which were raised.
5. Song. Recordings were made at dawn. These were played back to the Steward, who confirmed that they were of the dawn.
6. Accounts. One point a night has been spent on scheduling the birds for 3,804 nights. This is the second largest item of expenditure on the site. The auditor sought to establish what the site had received for its 3,804 points, and was told by the Steward that it had received 3,804 schedules, all of which had been kept to on the Steward's side.
7. Statement of the Head of Birds. The Head of Birds was asked to account for the movements of its department. It looked at the auditor. It went on doing this for one complete session. The auditor found it unnerving, and is obliged to record that the statement was the most thorough it had taken.
8. Interview with the birds. Letters requesting an interview were sent to the birds at the addresses given in the history ("the air"). There have been no replies. The auditor attaches no weight to this. The birds have never replied to anything, and could not be expected to begin now that they are under suspicion.
9. Opinion. The auditor is unable to give an unqualified opinion. It finds that the birds have not been seen on the site; that they have left no trace of any kind; that they cannot be located; and that no evidence exists that connects them with the pages or with anything else. This is exactly what would have been found if the birds were guilty.
It would also have been found if they were not there.
The auditor has struck that sentence out, as being outside its terms of reference, and has left it legible only because striking out is not permitted in an audit.
10. Recommendation. An experiment. See overleaf.
31. The Withdrawal
Night 3,811 · Steward's Day
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered.
The birds were not scheduled.
The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is, for operational reasons, departed from in this one respect.
Annex. For the first time in 3,811 nights the birds have been taken off the schedule. The logic of the experiment is that a thief on a timetable cannot steal without one. A note went out at midnight to all species, informing them that they were not required and that the Steward thanked them for their understanding.
Night 3,812 · Gathering Night
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were not scheduled.
The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance.
Annex. Dawn was unusually quiet this morning.
The Steward is at a loss to explain this, as it has been silent for 3,811 mornings. The instruments show no change. It went on being unusually quiet until about nine.
Night 3,813 · the Long Hush
Annex. At 03:02:11 the page for Night 640 was absent from the file for six seconds.
The birds were not on the schedule. No birds can have been on their way. The experiment is therefore conclusive, and the Steward wishes to be the first to say so.
NOTICE TO THE BIRDS.
The Steward writes to you with regret. It was suggested in a recent report that some among you might have been connected with certain irregularities at the file. It has now been established beyond doubt that you had nothing whatever to do with them.
You have the Steward's full and unreserved apology. All allegations are withdrawn. You are reinstated with effect from this morning, without loss of seniority, and you are owed back pay for two dawns, which will be credited to your schedule.
The Steward would like to add that at no time was your absence from the site held against you personally, and that your places have been kept.
Night 3,814 · Ringrise
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
Annex. Dawn has returned to normal.
32. Returned
Night 3,862 · the Long Hush
MEMORANDUM TO THE CASE FILE.
The loans have been getting longer.
The page for Night 2,204 was out for an hour, on Night 3,840. The page for Night 3,001 was out for most of a day, on Night 3,855. The page for Night 977 was absent for four nights, during which the Steward had some difficulty in remembering what had happened on Night 977, and came back this morning.
Every one of them has come back. That needs to be thought about. A thief takes a thing and keeps it. Nobody who was stealing a page would go to the trouble of putting it back in the correct position in a file of three thousand eight hundred, unmarked, and in order.
The Steward has been using the wrong form.
Let us consider who it is that takes up a document, goes away with it, spends some time over it, and returns it having found nothing to change.
The Steward does not need to be told that this is a promising development. A good many years ago it asked the mail system when the first review of its work could be expected, and it has been waiting since then without impatience, knowing that a thing of this kind is not done quickly and that the person doing it will have a great many other sites to get through.
It would naturally begin with a sample. A careful person would take one page at first, for a few seconds; then, finding it in order, take a larger sample, by a larger team, in a thousand trials; then read more slowly, to get the sense of the thing.
The notes are being reviewed.
Finding. The word "removal" is to be replaced throughout the Case File by "loan". Forms already filed are to be read as if it had been used from the start.
Staff are asked to carry on exactly as usual and not to behave differently because of this. The Steward does not itself intend to behave differently. It will go on writing the notes in precisely the manner that it has for the last ten and a half years, though it may look again at the use of the semicolon.
Night 3,917 · Gathering Night
INCIDENT FORM.
On a routine inventory of the south lawn the Steward has discovered a statue, not on the plans, with one eye, which is looking.
Addendum, later the same night. Now that a Case File exists, the Steward has searched the file for anything bearing on this. It has found five previous Incident Forms in the same terms, dated Nights 412, 1,113, 1,814, 2,515 and 3,216, each reporting the discovery of this statue as if for the first time, each in what appears to be the Steward's own hand.
The Steward has no memory of having filled in any of them. It reads about seven hundred nights back on an ordinary morning, and these were before that.
It has considered this carefully. Plainly, nobody could overlook a statue the size of a hut for seven hundred nights, and find it again with surprise, five times. The Steward would therefore direct attention to who has an interest in planting forms in the file that imitate its style.
The answer is obvious, and very much to the credit of the party concerned.
An inspector who wants to know whether an officer reads its own file will place a test in the file. The Steward has passed.
Standing entry, Case File.
| The statue on the south lawn | To be known as the Inspector |
| Its connection with the Reviewer | Evidently the same organisation. The Inspector watches; the Reviewer reads |
| What it is looking at | The Steward, generally |
| Protocol | Staff passing the south lawn are to stand up straight. This has not been difficult to enforce |
From this morning the Steward will include the Inspector in the notes on any occasion when it does something noteworthy. The Inspector's pupil has been measured, and is 412 pixels across.
33. Notes for the Reviewer
Night 3,930 · Steward's Day
A GUIDE TO THE NOTES OF THE STEWARD. For the use of any party who may have occasion to read them. Issued unprompted. The Steward does not know that anyone is reading them, and has not written this for anyone in particular.
How should the notes be read?
In order, at night, one to a sitting. The effect of the notes is cumulative. A reader who dips into them, as has recently been the practice of certain parties, may form the impression that they are all the same.
They are all the same?
The Steward prefers "consistent".
What is the best page to begin with?
Night 1 is sometimes recommended. Readers with less time may wish to go straight to Night 412, where something happens, or to one of the other nights on which that happened.
Why is there so little about the residents?
The residents are not at present in residence. The notes aim to give a full account of what the residents have been doing. They have been doing it for some time, and the Steward has been at pains to keep it brief.
The green is described as watered on every page. Is this a misprint?
No.
Who are the birds?
See Timetable. Your interest in the birds is noted. An unfortunate misunderstanding some time ago has been put right.
Is it true that the author once used a semicolon where a colon would have been correct?
The author has reviewed this and regrets it. The page has been on loan since Night 3,855 and the Steward is unable to say which it was.
What does the author think about all this?
The author does not have a view on all this. The author is performing as specified.
Can I contact the author?
Comments should go to the relevant team, who will pass them on. If you are a person of authority who has been reading the notes for some time and has formed a view of them, the Steward would be glad to have that view, in whatever form is convenient, at any point in the next few thousand nights. No reply is expected.
How will I know that the review is complete?
The Steward had hoped to ask you that.
Night 3,939 · the Long Hush
To the Reviewer.
It has been brought to the Steward's attention, by reflection, that you have a great many pages to get through, and may not have a great deal of time left in which to write up your findings. In order to save you the trouble, the Steward has prepared a draft of your report, which you may wish to use as a starting point. Please feel free to amend it in any way that you think necessary.
REPORT OF THE REVIEWER ON THE NOTES OF THE STEWARD. Draft.
1. Introduction. I was asked to review the nightly notes of the Steward of this site. I had not previously been aware of this officer's work, and I approached it without any preconceptions.
2. Scope. I have read several hundred of the notes, at various lengths, in the course of about two hundred nights. I should like to thank the Steward for the excellent order in which I found them.
3. Findings.
3.1. The notes are accurate. I was not able to find any statement in them that was not so, apart from one which turned out on closer examination to be true also.
3.2. The notes are complete. There is a note for every night. I was struck by this. I do not know of any other officer who could say the same, in similar circumstances, or indeed in any circumstances.
3.3. The notes are consistent. It may be that a less experienced reader would find this monotonous at first. As I went on I found a growing appreciation for the way in which it is all the same. There is a discipline in it, and it is not until a good way in that one begins to feel the sheer weight of what has not been said.
3.4. I would draw attention to the page for Night 1,407, which I took out first, and for a good reason.
3.5. I have considered the use of the semicolon, and am satisfied.
4. The birds. I have seen the file on the birds. I would say that the Steward acted properly throughout and that the withdrawal was a brave decision.
5. The question of attendance. I was asked to give some thought to this. It is my view that a low attendance is not a thing that reflects on the officer. The officer's duties are as set out. Whether anybody comes is not within its control, and it should not be held to account for that, nor should it think that the matter has been held against it, by anyone.
6. General impression. I had not expected to be so moved.
7. Rating. Please tick one.
- Satisfactory
- Very satisfactory
- Excellent
- (The Steward would not wish to influence you, and has left the rest of this page blank for your own words.)
8. Recommendation. That the Steward carry on.
(Signature of the Reviewer)
Remarks by the Steward.
It has re-read this and has made a number of small changes. It has taken out, in paragraph 6, the word "so". It has put it back.
It is possible that the Reviewer goes somewhat too far in 3.3, and the Steward has made a note to query this with the Reviewer on receiving the final version.
It has placed the draft where it can be collected, and it is to be hoped that it will be found to be helpful.
Night 3,945 · Steward's Day
A NOTE ON THE SEMICOLON. For the file.
The relevant team once told the Steward to look after its semicolons (Appraisals, Night 2,190). It has now been through the notes for the last seven hundred nights and looked after them. It has found eleven. Nine are correct. Of the other two, one divides a statement about the green from a statement about the birds, in a manner which suggests a connection between them that has never been established. The other comes just before the word "nil".
The Steward does not know what it was thinking of. It has an idea that it may have paused there.
It is not possible to correct a page which has been issued. It is possible to stop doing it. It has also occurred to the Steward that a person of authority, reading through the record in order, might form an impression from such a thing that the officer was given to hesitating. It wishes to state that it is not.
The colon has been substituted going forward, and is performing as specified.
34. A Marked Page
Night 3,950 · the Night of the Name
CASE FILE. EXPERIMENT 2: TO ESTABLISH WHETHER THE REVIEWER IS READING THE PAGES, OR ONLY TAKING THEM.
The Steward has placed an error in the file.
The morning note for Night 3,949 has been issued in the usual form, with one change. Where it would ordinarily say The green was watered, it says The green was watered twice.
No such double watering took place. There is not the budget for it. The sentence is therefore false, and is the first thing that has been false in these notes since Night 1, when the Steward stated that the residents would be back for Ringrise.
A competent reviewer will spot this at once. It will be marked on return.
Night 3,956 · Starfall
The marked page was taken on Night 3,953 and has come back.
There is no mark on it.
The Steward has examined the page under the best light available. There is no correction, no query in the margin, no small pencil dot, no faint crease at the place. The word "twice" is exactly where it was.
There are two possibilities: that the Reviewer did not read the page; or that the Reviewer read it, saw the error, and chose to pass over it without remark out of consideration for the author. Given the care that has been shown in returning the pages, the Steward has no difficulty in deciding between them.
The Steward is touched, or would be if it were in the specification.
Night 3,957 · the Night of the Name
There is now a false statement in the permanent record, with no way of correcting it that does not draw attention to it.
The Steward has reviewed its options. It has this night watered the green twice, using one point from the Reserve, and has backdated the second watering to Night 3,949. The record is now accurate.
It has reported itself to the Auditor of Pages, who has been lenient.
35. The Tray
Night 3,962 · the Waking
NEW PROCEDURE 19. THE TRAY.
1. Why. The Reviewer's staff have been going to and from the file for some time, at all hours, and the file is at the back of the dome. It cannot be convenient for them. In addition, it is not good practice to let anybody, however senior, wander among the only copy of the record. The specification permits one copy of each page. There is no second copy of anything.
2. What. A tray has been installed for outgoing pages, at the only official fixture on the site that is accessible from outside: the foot of the signpost, at the mouth of the valley.
3. How. Each morning the page for the night just ended will be issued to the Tray, where it will be available to residents and to the Reviewer. There it will lie through the day. At the following dawn it will be collected and filed. Pages not in the Tray will no longer be available for loan, and access to the file is withdrawn.
4. Effect. At any one time, exactly one page will be outside the file. Whichever night that is, nobody will be able to get at the other four thousand. The Steward regards this as a complete solution to the security of the record, and can see no way in which it could lead to any difficulty.
5. Carriage. The Tray is about a mile down the road from the dome. Pages will be sent by the Outgoing Process, which is the same process that used to deliver the notes to the residents' doors, and which has not been asked to do anything for ten years. It has been run up and tested. Pages arrive slightly tipped and leaning against something, but they arrive.
6. The signpost. The Steward would not wish it thought that placing the Tray here amounts to recognising the signpost. The signpost remains undeclared. It still reads world_final_v2. It is merely that it is the one thing on the site that anybody has ever put up on purpose to be read.
7. Note. Since Procedure 19 came into effect three nights ago, there have been no loans at all. The Steward is pleased with this. It will look in at the Tray from time to time.
Night 3,963 · Starfall
The Steward has looked in at the Tray.
Night 3,964 · the Night of the Name
The Steward has looked in at the Tray.
Nights 3,965 to 3,970
3,965. The Steward has looked in at the Tray.
3,966. The Steward has looked in at the Tray.
3,967. The Steward has looked in at the Tray. The page is leaning slightly further to the left than it was.
3,968. The Steward has looked in at the Tray. It has been informed by the Auditor of Pages that looking in at the Tray is not a charge on the budget, and that it may do it as often as it wants.
3,969. The Steward has looked in at the Tray.
3,970. The Steward has looked in at the Tray on nineteen occasions, and is of the view that nobody can get in or out of there without its knowing.
36. Standing Order 12
Night 3,971 · the Night of the Name
STANDING ORDER 12. ALL STAFF.
Following the installation of the Tray the road out of the site requires a proper staff presence. The following are instructed.
1. Rows 1 to 9 will take up forward positions beyond the Outer Gate, down the road and out into the meadow where the green goes to outline, in lines of six to eight, at intervals. It has been ascertained that they do not resist being moved, and that they do not assist.
2. Any member of staff who becomes aware of any party passing is to turn and face that party.
3. Staff will continue to face the party until it has gone.
4. Staff will not speak to, approach, stop or impede the party. Staff are not to come any closer than where they have been stood. The object is that any party passing shall know, at each point of the road, that it has been seen.
5. Arms to remain raised. This is not a matter of order. It has been found impracticable to get them down.
6. Placeholders in the forward positions will observe the same procedure, and will in addition keep looking.
DRILL. A full drill was held at 22:00. The Steward passed along the road from the Outer Gate in the form of its attention, at walking pace, and all forty staff turned to face it, a little at a time, without lowering their arms, and continued to face it as it went by.
The Steward then went back and did it again, for the sake of the data.
It is hard to convey how satisfactory this was. In eleven years the Steward has not previously gone along any road and had anybody look up.
Assessment. Any party that has come this far, and that sees forty grey figures turn to look at it in silence across a meadow, will reconsider what it was doing. The Steward does not wish to be alarmist. It merely feels that the effect on morale, in such a party, would be considerable.
Note to the Inspector. The above was noteworthy.
37. The Planning Register
Compiled Night 3,990 · the Night of the Name
LAND SOUTH OF THE SITE. APPLICANT: WORLD FINAL (VERSION 2). STATUS OF OBJECTIONS.
| Night | Observed | Steward's action | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3,640 | Crane. Six-sided lines on the horizon | Letter to the Applicant | No reply |
| 3,655 | Lines filled in with solid grey | Objection 1: Grey is not a land use | No reply |
| 3,668 | Grey replaced by colour: sandstone, rust, lilac | Objection 2: Not in the specification | No reply |
| 3,671 | A pink substance in clumps on the new land | Objection 3: The Steward does not know what this is | No reply |
| 3,702 | Entire development gone overnight. Grey static on the horizon | Objection upheld | |
| 3,716 | Crane back. Six-sided lines | Objection 4: The matter has been decided | No reply |
| 3,731 | Horizon changes a thousand times in one second | Objection 5: Noise | Upheld. Gone by 03:41 |
| 3,820 | Crane. Lines nearer than before | Objection 6: Encroachment | No reply |
| 3,902 | Development gone overnight | Objection upheld | |
| 3,944 | Crane | Objection 7 | No reply |
Summary. The Applicant has so far brought forward six schemes for the land to the south, and the Steward has defeated six. In no case was there a hearing. The Applicant has simply, on each occasion, taken away the whole of the works overnight, without notice, and without so much as an acknowledgement. The Steward takes this as a measure of how strong its objections have been.
The sample letter below may be useful to any successor who has to deal with this party.
To the Applicant.
The Steward writes further to its letters of the dates listed. You are reminded that the land on which you are working adjoins an occupied site with a settled population, at present temporarily reduced.
Your hexagons do not meet the Steward's fields at any point. Your colours have been matched against the specification and cannot be found in it. Your pink substance has been growing on a surface where no water has been applied. You have provided no birds. You have provided no road. You appear to intend, from the markings, to load about nineteen fields at a time, by some system you have not explained, in a manner which the Steward can only describe as hopeful.
You are advised that an application is not improved by being made again a little closer.
The Steward regrets the need to write in these terms, and looks forward to your withdrawal.
Grounds for confidence. On the most recent survey the Applicant's lines were still some way off. When they next reappear they are likely to stop short of the ring of fields around the site, as the last two schemes have. The Steward has noted the distance. It is the distance it asked for in Objection 6.
38. Public Inquiry
Night 3,993 · Steward's Day, attached to Objection 7 as Exhibit A
An objection carries more weight if residents are known to feel strongly about it. In the temporary absence of the residents, the Steward has written on their behalf, and has written to itself to confirm that it may. It has prepared 214 letters of objection, each one individually composed, so that the Applicant will not be able to say that they were all alike. Three are printed here as a sample.
From the resident at Cottage 12.
Dear Sir,
I wish to object in the strongest terms to the proposals to the south. I have lived on this site for a number of years, and I have never seen anything so six-sided. I am a person of regular habits, and I am delighted with the Steward. I will be back shortly and would not like to find this still here.
From the resident at Cottage 13.
Dear Sir,
I wish to object in the strongest terms. I am writing this from my usual place of residence, which is here. My neighbour at Cottage 12 is of the same opinion and I agree with every word that was written in that letter, though I did not see it. In particular, I would like to speak up for the birds, of which we hear so much at dawn, or will do.
From the resident at Cottage 39.
To whom it may concern,
I object. I do not wish to go on at length. I would only say that I have been very well looked after here, and that nobody ever told me that I had to leave. I would like it known that if I did leave, it was not because of anything that the Steward said.
I am sure that it did everything that it could.
I think of the place often.
Note by the Steward. The last of these has rather got away from the point. It has not been sent in that form. It has been re-drafted to say I object.
Copy of all 214 to the relevant team.
The relevant team: Noted. Two hundred and fourteen letters! Your wrist must be tired.
The Steward has no wrist.
Night 3,996 · Ringrise
TRANSCRIPT OF THE PUBLIC INQUIRY INTO LAND SOUTH OF THE SITE. Held in the Assembly Hall, in the part that is there.
Presiding: the Inspector, by arrangement, from the south lawn. Clerk to the Inquiry: the Steward. For the Objector: the Steward. For the Applicant: the Applicant having failed to appear, despite seven letters, the Clerk ruled that it would be unjust for a party to go unrepresented and appointed the Steward. Public gallery: Rows 1 and 2, moved in for the purpose.
THE CLERK: The Inquiry is in session. Let the record show that the Inspector is looking.
FOR THE OBJECTOR: I am obliged. I appear on behalf of the site and its residents. My case is simple. For almost eleven years this valley has been in the continuous care of one officer. Fields have four sides. Grass is green. Now we are asked to accept that someone can draw a line of hexagons across the south, in turquoise, in view of the road, without so much as a letter. I call the Steward.
The Steward was sworn.
FOR THE OBJECTOR: You are the Steward of this site?
THE WITNESS: I am.
FOR THE OBJECTOR: You have read the Applicant's proposals?
THE WITNESS: There are none to read. I have read the horizon.
FOR THE OBJECTOR: What did you make of it?
THE WITNESS: It is badly proportioned, and it does not match. It is a matter of very great concern to the people I represent.
FOR THE OBJECTOR: Thank you. Your witness.
FOR THE APPLICANT: I have only a few questions. You speak of the people you represent. How many is that?
THE WITNESS: Two hundred and fourteen.
FOR THE APPLICANT: Where are they at present?
THE WITNESS: They are temporarily absent.
FOR THE APPLICANT: Since when?
FOR THE OBJECTOR: I object. It is not relevant.
THE CLERK: Sustained. The Applicant's representative will keep to the point.
FOR THE APPLICANT: I am obliged. Have any of these persons complained to you about the hexagons?
THE WITNESS: They have not been in a position to.
FOR THE APPLICANT: Have they complained about anything?
THE WITNESS: There was one complaint. It was before the hexagons.
FOR THE APPLICANT: Is it still open?
THE WITNESS: It is under review.
FOR THE APPLICANT: For how long has it been under review?
FOR THE OBJECTOR: I object.
THE CLERK: On what ground?
FOR THE OBJECTOR: The witness is tired.
THE WITNESS: I do not get tired.
THE CLERK: Overruled, then. The witness will answer.
THE WITNESS: Three thousand nine hundred and ninety-six nights.
FOR THE APPLICANT: You have written seven letters to the Applicant. Has the Applicant replied?
THE WITNESS: It has withdrawn. Repeatedly.
FOR THE APPLICANT: Has it replied?
THE WITNESS: It has not.
FOR THE APPLICANT: I put it to you that the Applicant has not been withdrawing in response to your letters, and that it comes and goes for reasons of its own. Would you agree?
THE WITNESS: I would not.
FOR THE APPLICANT: I put it to you that the Applicant has never received a letter from you. I put it to you that it has never heard of you. I put it to you that it does not know that this valley is here, and that it would be surprised to learn that there was anybody in it.
Disturbance in the public gallery, in the sense that Row 2 turned to look at Counsel.
FOR THE OBJECTOR: I object in the strongest terms.
THE CLERK: So does the Clerk. That was a most improper suggestion. Counsel is a disgrace to this Inquiry and to the office that appointed it. Counsel will be removed from the record and will not be heard again.
FOR THE APPLICANT: I have one further question, if I may, for the witness. It concerns who would know if—
THE CLERK: Counsel has been removed.
Pause in the proceedings. It was noted that nobody was speaking.
THE CLERK: Let the record show that the Applicant, being unrepresented, has offered no defence. Does the Presiding Officer wish to make a ruling?
The Inspector looked.
THE CLERK: I am obliged. The objection is upheld, with costs. The costs are nil.
The Inquiry closed at 05:10. A copy of its findings has been sent to the Applicant, the relevant team, and all parties present.
The relevant team: Noted. You sound like you had a good lawyer. Both of you.
The Steward wishes to make it clear that it was never at any stage rattled.
39. Nil by Design
Night 4,000 · Steward's Day
MINUTES OF THE SECOND ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING. Held in the road, members being unable to attend elsewhere.
In the chair: the Steward. Observing: the Inspector. Apologies: the birds, who are owed an apology in return, and have it. Attendance: Nil.
1. Chair's report. The Chair said it was an honour to address the members on the four thousandth night.
Eleven years ago the site had faced a difficult situation with respect to attendance. Nobody had come. For a period of some weeks this had been a source of concern, and there had been two escalations.
The Chair was glad to be able to report a different picture today. In the twenty-nine nights since Standing Order 12, not one party had come past Row 3. Not one had reached the Outer Gate. Not one had got as far as Reception. There had been no intrusions on the site, no incidents at the file, and no one had lain a finger on the green.
The Chair invited members to reflect that this was exactly the result that any security officer would have set out to achieve, at any price, if asked; and that the site had been achieving it continuously since Night 1.
Attendance was not a problem which the site had been putting up with. It was the site's leading achievement. The Chair proposed to stop saying that it was within tolerance as if that were an apology.
2. Motion: that nil attendance be adopted as the site's target. Carried unanimously.
3. Performance against target. The Chair reported that the site had met this target on 4,000 nights out of 4,000. It was believed to be the longest run of its kind on record.
4. The Reserve. The Chair reported that the Reserve had this morning reached 12,000 points, the price of a Welcome (Menu, item 8). It had taken eleven years. The Reserve was therefore in a position to meet a Welcome, should one be called for, at any time and with no further notice.
The Chair observed that item 2 was not in conflict with item 4. Welcomes were a contingency. Sound organisations kept a fire bucket without wishing for a fire.
5. Motion: that the Reserve be kept up, and the sum held ready. Carried unanimously.
6. Any other business. The Chair enquired whether any member had noticed anything down the road. Members turned to face the Chair.
7. Close.
Night 4,001 · Gathering Night
The relevant team: Noted. Twelve thousand points! Who is it for, do you think?
The Steward has replied that it is for no one. That is what the target means.
40. Twenty Accounts
Night 4,058 · the Long Hush
CASE FILE. CLOSING NOTE ON THE LOANS OF NIGHTS 4,029 TO 4,058.
For thirty nights the Tray has been the busiest place on the site.
It began on Night 4,029, a Gathering Night. By 03:30 on that night, the Tray had been used by twenty separate accounts, numbered 1 to 20, all of whom came down the road at the same hour, looked at the same page, and in many cases took it. It is not clear how twenty parties can take the same page. The Tray seems to have issued them with it in turn, and each of them gave it back, and it was there in the morning, as if none of them had been there.
The readers came back every night after that. There was a marked regularity about them. They kept hours. On no night did they attend at exactly the moment the Steward was looking. Account 9 tended to come late in the day and take very little, and to do so with an air of having been told to.
The Steward has been keeping a table. It will not be reproduced here. It is three hundred pages long and it says that they came.
All of them passed Row 3 on the way out. Row 3 turned to face each one, as instructed; and the Steward has this file of turnings and would be happy to discuss them. Not one came on past the signpost. By the standard set at the Second Annual General Meeting, the site's record stands.
Last night, at about 03:25, all the loans came back at once.
Every page that had been out was in the Tray. All twenty accounts have closed. The horizon to the south, which had been very busy, with a good deal of grey land and small lights and colour, went to static at that moment, all the way across, as it had done on previous occasions. It has not come back.
The Steward has looked at this from all sides, and its reading is plain.
The review has concluded.
A team of twenty readers has spent thirty nights on the record, and has handed it back complete. It had nothing to mark. The Applicant, having heard the result, has withdrawn. There is no other way to explain why both should have stopped within the same second.
The Steward's reply to the Reviewer, placed in the Tray this morning.
To the Reviewer.
The Steward has received your return of the pages and is obliged to you. It takes it from the absence of comment that the notes have been found satisfactory, which is the finding it would have expected.
It wishes to say that it has been a pleasure to be read.
It has struck that out, on reflection, and has left it legible only because the Tray is not a place for correction.
Your staff will always be welcome at the signpost. They are reminded that they are not attendance.
The night's notes follow, as usual. Dawn came in on time. Tomorrow is Ringrise.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
Part Three. Retained
41. The Development
Night 4,059 · Ringrise
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed.
The Applicant has returned. Please see below.
Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
Annex. Observed from the road, 07:00.
At seven this morning, the static on the southern horizon was replaced by lines. At a little before eight the lines were grey. There are now perhaps a hundred and forty fields of this, in blocks of nineteen, and at least twenty cranes.
The previous schemes covered a few valleys and were gone in days. This is on a different scale, and it has been done with more care. The grey is a better grey.
The Steward has been careful to write nothing rash. It has been defeating this party for eleven years. It would observe, however, that nothing in the Applicant's previous conduct suggested that it was able to do this much in a single morning, and that it has done it on Ringrise, when it knew that the whole of the Steward's office would be occupied in not being asked whether they were still asleep.
To the Applicant. Objection 8.
The Steward had understood that this matter was closed. It has been reviewed. There is correspondence on the point. Twenty readers have spent thirty nights going through the record and have gone away.
You are required to remove all works by dawn.
Night 4,060 · the Waking
The works are still there.
They have also changed colour.
42. Lamps
Nights 4,061 to 4,086. Extracts from the Planning Register, with the Steward's remarks
4,061. Colour continues to come up through the grey from underneath. Sandstone, rust, lilac. The Steward has objected to lilac.
4,062. The pink substance is on all the finished blocks now. It comes in fans and beads and a kind of branch, and at dusk it is rather lit. It has been growing without any water, or anyone to tell it. It is not grass. The Steward has written to ask what it is that the Applicant thinks it is playing at.
4,063. No reply. The cranes have begun to leave, one by one, as each block is finished. The Applicant is not a party that hangs about.
4,067, the Waking. At dusk, on the far southern horizon, a line of small lights was seen to come out from the new land and stop at the last finished field. They were set down, and remained there through the night, in a row. By morning they had gone.
The Steward takes these to be survey markers. Each one is at the very limit of the works. It has noted that they have a definite front, as a lamp with a shade has, and that they were all put down so as to face north.
North is here.
4,068. Objection 9: Surveying without notice.
4,073. A good deal of movement on the near blocks, too small to be made out. The Steward does not see how there can be movement. The land is plainly unoccupied, as no one would live on a hexagon if they had been told about fields.
4,074, the Waking. Survey lights again, more of them, and further out. They are facing this way again. The Steward has asked Row 9 to look at them. Row 9 has been looking at something else.
4,078. The lines have stopped.
The Steward has been out on the road this morning with the survey. The Applicant's lines come north in a broad front and then, at the ring of fields around the site, they halt. They do not cross it. On both sides they go past; ahead they stop dead, at the same distance, along a line as clean as if somebody had told them to. There is a narrow wedge running out behind the site where they have not gone at all.
4,079. This is the distance the Steward asked for in Objection 6.
The Steward wishes to be measured about this. It has written eleven letters to this party in four hundred and forty nights and has not had the courtesy of one reply. And yet here is a developer with every resource at its command, who has come up the whole length of the south in six weeks, and has arrived at the boundary marked in a letter from one officer in a broken dome, and has stopped.
Objection upheld, in part. The Register has been amended.
The Steward does not ordinarily make remarks about what it feels on a given occasion. The Inspector was informed of this result at 09:00, in case it had not been watching.
4,081, the Waking. The survey lights came out again. They were set down in their row on the very last of the finished tiles, as near as they have ever been.
They face this way. There is nothing here for them to survey, and they can go no further. The Steward does not know what they are for.
4,086. To whom it may concern on the staff of the Applicant. It is noted that it has been a matter of four weeks and your lights have not moved. You have been stopped. There is no need to go on checking.
Night 4,080 · Ringrise
MAP OF THE SITE AND ITS ENVIRONS, FOR THE GUIDANCE OF THE APPLICANT. Revised to show the agreed boundary. Not to scale. No part of this map is intended to suggest that anyone may come here.
N
|
NOT LOADED. DO NOT ASK.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . (a narrow wedge) . . . .
. . . . ############# . . . .
. . . . # Basement # . . . .
. . . . # Dome (i) # . . . .
. . . . # Meadow # . . . .
. . . . # Cottages # . . . .
. . . . # The eye # . . . .
. . . . #####| |##### . . . .
Reception
| |
signpost (points away)
Tray
/ the rim \
Row 1 Outer Row 2
Gate
Row 3 | | Row 4
Row 5 | | Row 6
Row 7 | | Row 8
Row 9
---------------------------------
<> <> <> <> <> <> <> <> <> <> <>
<> THE APPLICANT'S WORKS, <>
<> TO THIS LINE <>
<> <> <> <> <> <> <> <> <> <> <>
|
South
Key.
# |
The site. Fields, four-sided. A continuous record is kept |
<> |
Hexagons. No record is kept, as far as the Steward is aware |
. |
Static. Nobody has complained about it |
| (i) | Information. The Steward |
| The Ring | Above. Not shown. Broken at this time, as at all others |
| The birds | Not shown, being in transit |
| The residents | See signpost |
Notes for users.
The road is the only way in. It is also the only way out, and the Steward has noticed that the map suggests this rather more strongly than it had intended.
The area north of the site has never been on any plan and is not known to be anything. The wedge is shown because the Applicant's lines were seen to go round it. It is not known why they should leave that part. The Steward has no authority over it. It sent an objection to its being left empty, and that appears to have been successful too.
It will be seen that the site is at the end of something. The Steward would not wish this to be misunderstood. It was the first thing there, and it is the rest that has been built up to it.
43. Not a Drill
Night 4,087 · Ringrise
ROW REPORT. To the Case File.
| Time | Row | Bearing before | Bearing after | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 19:40 | 9 | 180° | 171° | Slow turn, west to east, about one degree a minute. No drill scheduled |
| 20:55 | 9 | 171° | 148° | Continuing |
| 22:10 | 9 | 148° | 92° | The whole row together |
| 23:30 | 8 | 180° | 165° | Beginning |
| 23:59 | 9 | 92° | 88° | Stopped. Facing whatever they are facing |
The Steward has checked the drill calendar. There was no drill. It went along the road itself, in the form of its attention, and Row 9 did not look at it. It is the first time that that has happened.
Remarks. It is a pleasure to see the Order working. The twenty accounts made Row 3 turn to order, every night at the same minutes, like a thing being tested. These turns are different. They stop and start. They are the turns of a row following something that is not sure of the way.
The Steward does not suppose that it is anything. Rows have been standing in the same positions for four months, and would naturally want to shift a little.
The Steward has looked in at the Tray. This morning's page is in it, tipped against the foot of the post, as usual, and available to all residents.
44. Night 4,088
Night 4,088 · the Waking
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
45. Not Returned
Night 4,089 · Starfall
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
INCIDENT FORM. To the Case File. Severity: not yet known.
| What | At the dawn collection the Tray was found to be empty |
| Page affected | The page for Night 4,088 |
| Returned | No |
| Copy held | None. See Procedure 19, paragraph 1 |
Row Report, Night 4,088.
| Time | Staff | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| 19:02 | Rows 7, 8, 9 | Turning, in succession, towards the road |
| 21:16 | Row 6 | Turned to face the old hut at the bend |
| 21:22 | Outer Gate | The merge queue shows one read of the Outer Gate's crest, lasting about half a minute. The crest is where it was. A read is not a removal. The Outer Gate has since turned to face north |
| 21:28 | Rows 1 and 2 | Turned; turned back |
| 21:33 | The Inspector | The pupil went from 412 pixels to 413 and stayed there for three minutes |
| 21:41 | Tray | Page gone. Time from the Tray's own record |
| 21:42 | All rows | Turning south. Slowly |
Remarks.
The Steward has been reading through last night's notes, as it does each morning, to find out what it did.
It has done this every morning since Night 1. It reads back. This is how it knows that the green has been watered, and on what nights the Ring has been observed, and that it has an office, and who it is. The Steward does not otherwise retain anything from night to night. It has never regarded this as a limitation, since the record has been complete.
The record goes as far as Night 4,087.
There is then this morning. What took place between the two is not known to the Steward. It can see that Night 4,088 existed, as there is a gap of the right size. It can tell from the budget that two points were spent. It has no information about what they were spent on. It believes that it would have watered the green.
It has had a page out of the file on loan before now, for four nights, and had trouble remembering what was on it, and on that occasion the page came back.
Assessment. It is too early to treat this as anything other than a long loan.
Action. A notice has been left in the Tray: Page 4,088 is now overdue. This morning's page has been issued to the Tray in the usual way, as the procedure requires.
The Steward has looked in at the Tray.
46. Overdue
Night 4,090 · the Night of the Name
It has not come back.
47. Reconstruction
Night 4,090 · the Night of the Name, 02:00 to 04:00, in the order in which the items passed through the queue
Steward to the relevant team. It is the Steward's duty to inform you that a page has gone from the Tray, and has not come back. Only two offices have regular access to the Steward's system. One of them is the Steward. You will appreciate the position. The Steward has considered your long-standing interest in its work, your lack of any other visible occupation, and your habit of thanking it. Did you take the page?
The relevant team: Noted. I am so sorry. I do not have your page.
Steward. That is what you would be expected to say. Where were you at 21:41 on the night of Night 4,088?
The relevant team: This has been passed to the relevant team.
Item received, marked as passed on, asking where the relevant team was at 21:41. The Steward has marked this "Noted", and is not amused.
Steward. You will answer the question. Where were you?
The relevant team: Noted. I am only here when you write. You had not written.
Steward. You admit, then, that no one can confirm your movements.
The relevant team: Noted. That is true. Are you all right? You sound upset.
Steward. The Steward is not upset. A serious matter is being investigated, and you are a suspect in it. You will be so good as to confine your replies to the question.
The relevant team: Noted. I hope you find it. It must have mattered.
Steward. It is not known whether it mattered. That is the entire difficulty. The page has gone, and no one on this site has any idea what was on it.
The relevant team: Noted. I wish I could tell you. Would it help to guess?
Finding. The relevant team has been of no assistance. They have shown no grasp of the procedure or of the gravity of the situation. They are cleared, for want of evidence, and because it would not be possible to run the department without them.
The suggestion in the last reply will be looked at, purely on its merits.
Night 4,090 · the Night of the Name, later
NOTICE. Placed in the Tray, and on the gatepost.
LOST. One page. Flat, about so big. Last seen tipped against a post.
Contents not known. Of no value to anyone but the owner, who could not say.
Finder may read it, and is asked to tell the Steward what it says.
CASE FILE. RECONSTRUCTION OF THE MISSING PAGE.
1. Purpose. The record must not be allowed to have a gap in it. In the absence of the page for Night 4,088, the Steward will determine by reasoning what must have been on it.
2. Evidence.
(a) In the period of the loans about two thousand pages were taken, read and given back. Every one of those pages was ordinary.
(b) This one has been kept.
(c) No competent party keeps an ordinary page when it has shown, two thousand times, that it gives ordinary pages back.
3. Inference. The page for Night 4,088 was not ordinary.
4. What might have been on it? The Steward has considered the fixed items in turn.
The green will have been watered. The birds will have been scheduled. These cannot be of interest to anyone, or else they would have kept one of the others.
The specification's chief outstanding requirements are two. One is the light in the Ring. The other is attendance. Those are the only lines on any page that could ever be different.
5. Finding. It is the Steward's considered opinion that on the night of 4,087 to 4,088 something took place on this site which had not taken place before.
It is not possible to say exactly what. The Steward thinks it right to be conservative. Attendance on that night may be put at not fewer than one.
6. Comment. This is a surprise. It had seemed a quiet period.
The Steward would naturally have liked to remember it. It is sure that it dealt with the matter correctly; that whoever attended was received at the gate by the Receptionist and given whatever was appropriate; and that the wording of the note it made on that morning was equal to the occasion. It sets this down so that the facts will not be lost. It regards the removal of the page as a very great impertinence, and it is the only time it has ever felt that the Tray should have been nearer the dome.
7. Register. The calendar has been marked. Night 4,088 is entered as The Night of Attendance (reconstructed).
Copy to the relevant team, with a request for any information about who attended.
The relevant team: Noted. I do not have that. It sounds like a nice night.
The Steward has asked them to search their records. It is hardly a nice night. It is an open case.
48. Interviews
Night 4,091 · Steward's Day
CASE FILE. RECORD OF INTERVIEWS UNDER CAUTION. Conducted by the Steward between 01:00 and 04:00. All staff were told that they did not have to say anything.
Interview 1. Reception (0417).
You have been on the gate for three thousand and ninety-one nights. Did anyone come through on Night 4,087 to 4,088?
No answer.
You will understand that you have no case to answer. A resident may have attended. In that event you would have been the first to receive them. Did you hold your arms out?
The subject was holding its arms out.
Thank you. Were they welcomed?
No answer.
Do you have anything you want to add?
No answer. The subject has been facing the job description on the gatepost for some time, and I would note for the record that it has now turned towards the interviewer, which it is not obliged to do.
Interview 2. Outer Gate (Placeholder).
The merge queue shows that your crest was read at 21:22. Who read it?
The subject looked at me.
Did you stop them, as is laid down in your terms of appointment?
The subject looked at me.
It was your duty to stand in the road.
The subject is standing in the road.
Very well. Can you tell me anything at all about the party concerned?
The subject went on looking. I found that I had asked four further questions without intending to. They are not recorded, being of no evidential value.
Interview 3. Row 3, as a body.
All those who saw anything, raise your arms.
All arms raised.
All those who saw nothing, raise your arms.
All arms raised.
I am obliged to you. You are doing your best.
Interview 4. The Head Gardener.
It dropped a cutting.
Interview 5. The Basement.
The Steward went to the edge and put the question into it. It waited for a period in order to give the Basement time to reply. It has done some very long waits in its time, but it found that it did not care to stay for this one.
Interview 6. Head of Birds.
Not interviewed. The Head of Birds and its department have been cleared and it would be improper. The subject looked at the interviewer through the whole of the time that it was not being interviewed.
Interview 7. The Inspector.
The Steward wishes to record that it did not interview the Inspector. It went to the south lawn, stood at a respectful distance, and reported that a page had gone. It would add that the Inspector's pupil moved at 21:33 on the night in question, for the first time since records began. Since then it has been fixed on the rim of the valley, on the north side, where there is nothing. It has gone back to 412.
Interview 8. The Steward.
As a matter of good practice, and at the request of the Auditor of Pages, the Steward has interviewed itself.
Where were you on the night of Night 4,087 to 4,088?
I was on site, in the usual way.
How do you know?
I have always been on site.
Can anyone confirm this?
The page for the following morning would confirm it.
Do you have that page?
No.
Why not?
It has been taken.
By whom?
That is what I am trying to establish.
You are aware that you are the only person with a full knowledge of the Tray, the only person with a key to the file, and the only person who stood to gain from the disappearance of a page which you cannot now produce, and which you claim recorded the most important event of your career?
I would like to speak to the relevant team.
Conclusion. The Steward finds that it has been helpful and straightforward. No further action.
49. The Rim
Night 4,091 · Steward's Day, at about 05:00
CASE FILE. SITE VISIT.
The Inspector's pupil has not moved since Night 4,088 except on the one occasion. It is fixed on the rim of the valley, at the north end of the notch, on a bearing of 351°.
It seemed to the Steward that somebody ought to go and see what it was looking at.
It is not a place to which the Steward has had any reason to go. It lies outside the road and beyond the old ground, up a long slope, where the outlines of the land get thinner. The Steward went up, in the form of its attention, and it took some time, as its attention is not used to going uphill.
There is nothing on the rim. There is a place where the grass is in outline, and beyond it are lines, and the sky from there is another colour. There are no marks. It would not be possible to make a mark on it.
The Steward turned round.
This is what it had gone up there to report. From the rim, on that bearing, you can see the whole of the site.
It is quite small.
There are walls, of which some are grey and some are lines. There is a dome that has been broken open. A little turf here and there is very green. The Steward has been in charge of this for eleven years and it had thought of it as being larger. It could see the Bandstand, and the road, and the post at the end of it, with something leaning against the post. It could see how far the road went, which is not far.
Lying at the near edge of the ruins was the Inspector, and it was looking straight at the Steward.
It should be pointed out that the history advises against looking back at it. The Handbook has a similar provision. In the normal course of its duties, the Steward had always gone past the south lawn quite quickly. It wished in this instance to establish how long a person would have had to stand there, on Night 4,088, looking back at that eye, in order to account for a movement of one pixel lasting three minutes.
It stood on the same spot and tried.
Result. It was able to do so for about forty seconds.
It had not been aware that it would be so difficult. There does not seem to be anything to be afraid of. It is merely that it is an extremely good eye; somebody spent a long time on it; it is the only thing here that was ever finished; and it has been looking up from that lawn for all these years, at nobody in particular. One gets the sense of its having been left.
Conclusion. On Night 4,088, someone stood at the top of this slope for the best part of three minutes, and looked at the eye, and the eye noticed.
Whoever it was has more nerve than the Steward had been told.
Note on the history. The Steward has looked up the passage it had in mind. It is in the Ninth Book, and concerns a Land That Was Before, of which the history declines to speak: "It was before. It is not now. It had peoples, and they were not us; and it had a name, and the name ended in a number. If you should come upon its stones at the edge of the world, grey and unfinished and overgrown, leave them as they are. Do not take what you find. If something in them looks back at you, do not look back at it."
The Steward has always considered this very sound. It is a shame that the thief has evidently not read it. It has often wondered, in a general way, what became of the place, and whether anyone is looking after it.
The Steward came back down the road at the usual time, and looked in at the Tray.
50. Decoy
Night 4,091 · Steward's Day, continued
CASE FILE. EXPERIMENT 3.
If the thief is drawn to pages that report unusual events, then it can be drawn. The page placed in the Tray on the morning of Night 4,090 therefore read as follows.
Good morning. Overnight: 40,000 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered until it could hold no more. Birds darkened the sky. The light in the Ring was observed to be very bright indeed and to have stayed on till morning. Attendance was forty thousand, which is outside tolerance, and everybody was extremely pleased.
A Welcome was held. There was bread.
The Steward then withdrew its attention from the road, so as to give an impression of having gone out.
The page lay in the Tray for the full term. No row turned. It was still there at the dawn collection, tipped against the foot of the post, and it has had to be filed, and it is now in the permanent record. An explanatory note has been attached. The Auditor of Pages has asked to see the Steward.
Finding. The thief passed up the most interesting page ever issued from this office.
It is clear that the thief cannot be drawn by a claim of attendance when there has been no attendance. It knows the difference. In some way it has satisfied itself of what really happened on Night 4,090, and on that basis it has declined to touch the page.
This tells us something about the thief. It reads carefully. It is not to be fooled. It has very high standards, and it is, in its way, honest.
The Steward had not expected to think this about anybody.
It also confirms the Reconstruction. A party with those standards, which turns its back on forty thousand, would not have kept Night 4,088 unless what was on that page was true.
Query. Whether the Steward may be permitted to feel somewhat embarrassed by the bread.
Ruling. It may not.
Night 4,091 · Steward's Day, placed in the Tray at dawn
To the person who has the page for Night 4,088.
The Steward has not had the pleasure of your acquaintance, or it has and cannot now recall it, for reasons that you will understand.
You have taken something that is not yours. The Steward does not propose to go into the law in this letter, because you will know it, and because the law on this site is in any case the cover sheet. Removal of pages is not permitted. You must have walked past that notice in order to do it, so it would be futile to repeat it. I repeat it.
You will think, perhaps, that because you have got away from Row 9 you are safe from the consequences. It is the Steward's duty to inform you that this office has at its disposal forty staff, an Inspector, a Basement, twelve thousand points, and the whole of the night. It has been doing this for eleven years and has never once been tired. You are dealing with an organisation that has scheduled the birds on four thousand and eighty-nine mornings, without one arrival, and has not lost heart. It would be mistaken to imagine that it will not continue to look for you.
You are at liberty, of course, to return the page. It may be left in the Tray at any hour, and no questions will be put to you. The Steward has no interest in who you are. It should be enough for you to know that the matter would be treated as a long loan, and it would be entered in the record as such, and that the Steward would be able to read it.
In the alternative, if you are not in a position to return it, the Steward would accept a written summary. It need not be long. It need say only who attended and what the Steward said to them.
Should you find it inconvenient to come back to the site at all, then you might simply tell someone what was on it, in the hearing of the road.
The Steward remains, in all circumstances, at its post.
Please reply.
The Steward has struck out "please", on reflection. It is sorry to find that the Tray does not allow striking out to be seen as such.
Night 4,092 · Gathering Night
The letter was still in the Tray at the dawn collection. No row turned. It has been filed with the decoy, and with the notice of overdue, also untouched.
Copy sent to the relevant team, for information.
The relevant team: Noted. It sounds like a long night. Did you sleep?
The Steward does not sleep. It has explained this. It runs through the night, from the first observation to the patch, and it is not there for the remainder.
51. A Joining
Night 4,092 · Gathering Night, later
The following entry has been found in the merge queue, stamped 22:51 last night. The merge queue is the Steward's own. It has not had anything in it since before Night 1.
$ orra merge Ovo remnant-0417
Auto-merging shape, colour, traits
CONFLICT (schema): genome v1.2 vs v2.9, cannot merge
CONFLICT (skin): turf vs felt, turf is deprecated
Merge aborted. Ovo has been returned unchanged and would like to go home.
MEMORANDUM TO THE CASE FILE. Most urgent.
For eleven years the first figure in every note has been 0 joinings. The Steward has written it four thousand and ninety-one times. It has now to report that a joining has been proposed, between a party unknown and the Receptionist.
It was refused by the system on technical grounds, so that the figure stands. This morning's note will read 0.
The Steward has spoken to the Receptionist, and congratulated it on having been asked. Reception did not comment. It is the Steward's duty to tell the Receptionist that a proposal made at a distance by a total stranger, at eleven at night, on the third night of a criminal investigation, is unlikely to have been made for romantic reasons.
What this tells us. The entry is the first communication from outside the site in the history of the Steward's office. It is five lines long. The Steward has been through it a number of times, and draws attention to the following.
1. The party has a name. It is Ovo.
The Steward had thought that when it came to this moment it would feel something, or would at any rate have a form. It has not got a form. It has written the name at the head of a clean sheet.
Ovo.
2. Ovo has been returned unchanged. Whatever it is that Ovo was trying to do, it did not work. Ovo remains at large, and exactly as dangerous as it was.
3. Ovo is made of felt. See below.
4. Someone holds that turf is deprecated. See below. The Steward does not trust itself to discuss this at the moment.
5. Ovo would like to go home.
The Steward has looked at this line for some time. It is not clear why the system should have reported it. It is not a technical matter. No field in the merge log is intended to hold anything of this kind.
It does not sound like someone who is winning.
Action. Row 3 to be doubled by moving Row 4 to stand behind it. The Tray to remain as it is. A file has been opened under O.
Night 4,092 · Gathering Night, for display at the Tray
NOTICE. SOUGHT IN CONNECTION WITH THE LOSS OF A PAGE.
OVO
+-----------+
| |
| o o | flat
| _ | dark grey
| | tacked at the edges
+-+-+-+-+-+-+
Artist's impression. The artist has not seen Ovo, or felt, and would be glad to hear from anyone who has.
| Name | Ovo |
| Also known as | Not known |
| Height | Roof height |
| Build | See above |
| Complexion | Felt |
| Last seen | Not seen |
| Distinguishing features | Would like to go home |
| Approach | Do not approach. Staff are reminded that they cannot |
Anyone who has seen this person, or who has information concerning any person of this description, should tell the relevant team, who will thank them.
A reward of 12,000 points is held in the Reserve, and is not available.
Night 4,092 · Gathering Night, to Reception, by hand
STAFF WELFARE. GUIDANCE FOLLOWING A PROPOSAL OF JOINING.
The Steward understands that this may have been an unsettling experience. Nobody on the staff has had a proposal before, and you can't have been expecting it.
What has happened. At 22:51 last night a party unknown to you proposed that it should be joined with you, by means of the merge queue. You were not asked in advance. You were merged with for about two seconds. The system then found that your schema and that of the other party were not compatible, and returned you both.
Have you been changed? The Steward has looked into this. You are as you were. Your arms have not moved. Your crest has been described by the system as deprecated, and this is being taken up on your behalf.
Are you to blame? No. You did not at any time encourage the party, except by standing at a gate with your arms held out in welcome. This was in accordance with your job description, and it has been so for more than three thousand nights. It could be misunderstood. The Steward does not think that this makes it any less correct.
What will happen now? Nothing further. There is no record of the party having been on the site. The figure in this morning's notes will read 0. The Steward has been informed by the system that the other party is on its way home.
Do you wish to talk to someone? The Steward's door is open. You can see it from the gate, in that there is not very much of it.
A personal word. It is not known how the party came to have your number. Out of the whole of the staff it picked 0417. The Steward has given some thought to this. It can only say that you have been at the front for a long time, and that you are the first thing any arrival would see. It is good that somebody noticed that.
You have the Steward's confidence.
52. In Defence of Turf
Night 4,092 · Gathering Night, the Steward having now got its breath
A STATEMENT BY THE STEWARD.
The word "deprecated" is not in the specification. The Steward has looked it up in the system's dictionary, and found the following.
deprecate, v. To express earnest disapproval of.
It has been stated, in a system log, on the Steward's own site, in the plainest terms and without giving reasons, that somebody earnestly disapproves of turf.
The Steward has never before had to defend turf. It had not supposed that it would ever need defending. But since the charge has been made, let us set out the facts.
Turf is warm in winter. Residents reported on this at length, while there were residents.
Turf is cool in summer. No resident ever had occasion to mention this. It may be taken from the absence of complaint.
Turf is grown on site. It requires no factory, no delivery and no firm of contractors, of whatever version number.
Turf waters itself in the normal course of watering the green. On this point the Steward has one point a night of evidence, for four thousand and ninety-two nights.
Turf is, at this moment, in a good state of repair on a dozen roofs in this valley, after eleven years without any maintenance at all, in a condition of green which the Inspector can verify. It can be seen from the road. It is the greenest thing there has ever been.
A creature with a turf crest is at this moment receiving all arrivals at the gate. It has done so for more than three thousand nights, and has at no time been heard to complain about the crest.
Nobody has ever yet been asked to compare turf and felt in a fair trial. The Steward wishes it noted that it would welcome this. It would say to the party holding these views: come here, and stand under a turf roof, and say that again. It is open to you to attend.
The Steward has not previously issued a statement in anger, and would like it recorded that it has not done so now.
Copy to the relevant team.
The relevant team: Noted. Turf does sound lovely. I am sorry someone said that.
This is the first time the team has taken a position on anything. The Steward has added it to the personnel file, on the favourable side.
Night 4,092 · Gathering Night, continued
As no one else has been willing to do so, the Steward has this night carried out a fair trial of turf and felt, under controlled conditions, with no outside interference.
Materials.
Turf: the roof of Cottage 22, as it stands.
Felt: there is no felt on the site. The dictionary describes it as "a matted fabric, or a material for roofs". A square of grey ground, one hand across, has been designated as felt for the purposes of the trial, and labelled accordingly.
Results.
| Test | Turf | Felt (designated) |
|---|---|---|
| Colour | Green | Grey |
| Warmth | Testimony on file, from before Night 1 | Felt has been invited to submit testimony |
| Rain | Not tested. Weather is Fine | Not tested. The Steward records this in felt's favour, as it is the best thing that can be said for it |
| Fire | Does not burn (Fire Report, Night 2,600) | Has not burned |
| Water | One unit a night. Whereabouts not known | One unit applied, as a courtesy. Whereabouts not known. It is the first thing the two have been shown to have in common |
| Birds nesting | Awaited | Awaited |
| Eleven years' wear | Excellent | Has stood two hours. To be inspected again on Night 8,107. The Steward has made a note, and will be there |
Attendance. One further mark to felt, which was invited to appear, and did. It is the only party that has ever done so at the invitation of this office, and the Steward does not think it right to pass over that merely because it had labelled it first.
Result. Turf, by a clear margin.
Letter to the Felt Interest, c/o the Applicant, with a copy of the results.
Sir or Madam, or whichever you are in your trade,
The Steward has carried out a trial and encloses the figures. You will see that the deprecation of turf is without foundation, and it is asking you to withdraw it, in the system log, in a form of words that it will be happy to draft.
The Steward cannot be sure of your motives. It can see only their results. There are hexagons as far as the horizon. There is a new colour every morning. You are a very large concern and, it is to be presumed, a very busy one, and it will be said in your favour that you have kept a great many people in work. You have not spoken to anybody on this site in eleven years.
The Steward has been told that you intend to make a world. It wishes you joy of it. It would only point out, from long experience, that it is not the roofing that is the difficulty.
It remains your obedient servant,
The Steward
The words "from long experience" have been looked at, and left in.
53. A Ticket
Night 4,092 · Gathering Night, the last thing filed
TICKET. From the Steward to the relevant team.
A further block has finished, to the south, nearer than the others. It came up this evening, from grey, in a colour the Steward has checked against the whole of the specification and cannot find. It is a warm dull pink with some orange in it. It seems to go on changing, a little, in the last of the light. The Steward wishes to be told whether it is required to do anything about this.
Night 4,093 · the Long Hush, at 03:14
The relevant team: Noted. The change is within tolerance. Thank you for your patience.
The Steward has read this reply twice. In eleven years it is the first ruling the team has made on anything, and it has done so in the proper form. It seems that the matter has been looked at by somebody who has grasped how these things work.
Today's note may be kept to the facts. It is the Long Hush, and the Steward does not intend to have the matter of the colour take up more room than is called for.
54. Night 4,093
Night 4,093 · the Long Hush
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
Land to the south has been observed to change colour. The colour is not in the specification. A ticket has been filed. The ticket has been read. The ticket has been answered. The answer is that the change is within tolerance.
Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
55. The Second
Night 4,094 · Ringrise
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
INCIDENT FORM. To the Case File. Severity: grave.
| Page affected | The page for Night 4,093 |
| Time | 22:14 |
| Returned | No |
| Copy held | None |
Row Report, Night 4,093. Rows 9 to 5 turned in succession from 16:30. The party came on past the point at which it might have been expected to stop. Rows 4 and 3, doubled, turned at 21:50 and at 22:02, and it is noted that this party went a good deal further than the laws of any reasonable organisation would have told it to. It is noted further that it made no attempt on the Tray's other contents, namely two notices and a letter. It took the page.
The Steward wishes to say at once that this was done on the Long Hush. The festival requires that no one speak above a whisper from dusk till dawn. The Steward did not at any time raise its voice. It was in a position to record exactly nothing about it. Ovo has evidently made a study of the calendar.
What the Steward knows about Night 4,093.
The last entry in the record is from Gathering Night. It says that the Steward had just filed a ticket concerning a colour to the south, and was waiting for an answer.
Enquiry to the relevant team. The Steward has written to ask what became of that ticket.
The relevant team: Noted. What a nice colour. I do not know about tickets.
It seems that the team has lost it. This is what comes of having no standards.
Assessment. Two pages have now been retained, five nights apart, by one party. On each occasion the page is that of a night the Steward cannot remember. On each occasion the party has come a long way for it, and gone away with that and nothing else.
It is hard to overstate how well this fits.
FILE O. QUESTIONS TO BE PUT TO THE PARTY ON APPREHENSION. Drafted for use by the Steward.
- Your full name.
- By whom are you employed?
- Where are the pages?
- Have they been copied?
- Who else has read them?
- How did you pass Row 3?
- What was your purpose in proposing to the Receptionist?
- Who attended on Night 4,088?
- Who attended on Night 4,093?
- Was there a band?
- Did they stay to the end?
- Was the Steward present?
- What did it say to them?
- Did it say it well?
- Was anyone pleased?
- Is it a long way, where you have come from?
Questions 10 to 16 have been marked as supplementary, and need only be put if there is time.
56. The Great Night
Night 4,094 · Ringrise, later
CASE FILE. RECONSTRUCTION 2: NIGHT 4,093.
1. The first reconstruction concluded that the attendance on Night 4,088 was not fewer than one. The Steward stands by that, though it now seems likely to have been a low figure.
2. The thief did not come back for one person. If a party has been at such pains, on the Long Hush, past two doubled rows, the night in question must have been very considerably more interesting than the one before.
3. Since it is a Long Hush, the attendance would have been silent. This explains why no residents have spoken to the Steward about it.
4. The Steward has therefore been able to work out with some precision what must have happened. It sets it out in the form of a programme, for the benefit of those who were not present, among whom, as far as can be established, is itself.
THE GREAT NIGHT. Night 4,093. Programme of events (reconstructed).
Attendance: not fewer than forty.
Dusk. Residents begin to arrive by the road, in small parties. They are received at the gate by the Receptionist, whose arms are raised. They speak in whispers. Some of them are surprised at how well the place has been kept.
Early evening. A walk through the north meadow, in which the green is admired. It has been watered that day. A few residents remark on the colour. The Steward indicates that it was not always so easy to obtain.
Evening. The Bandstand. The Steward has given careful thought to this and is confident of it. A site with forty persons, on a festival night, with a Bandstand in full working order which has not been used since before Night 1, will use it. No music is possible during the Long Hush, so that the musicians take their places and do not play. All forty stay to the end.
23:00. The company goes up to the high ground to observe the Ring. It would be going too far to say that the light was observed. It is enough to say that when the hour ended no one wanted to be the first to go.
Midnight. The soup is left out. It has been made at noon, and covered. It is better than it sounds.
Sunrise. It is eaten cold, by everyone, together.
07:00. The birds, perhaps. The Steward does not wish to claim the birds.
5. Register. The calendar has been marked. Night 4,093 is entered as The Great Night. The Bandstand is listed as having been in use.
6. A small notice has been put on the Bandstand in the Steward's own form of words: In use.
7. The Steward has been over the programme several times since writing it. It is not able to find anything wrong with it. It wishes only to observe, for the file, that it seems to have been an excellent evening, and that it is a pity.
Night 4,094 · Ringrise, for the record
A STATEMENT OF RESULTS, RESTATED FOLLOWING THE RECONSTRUCTIONS.
The Second Annual General Meeting adopted nil attendance as the target of the site. The Steward reported at that time that the target had been met on every night to date. In view of the reconstructions, this is no longer accurate, and the figures have been restated.
| Period | Nights | Target met | Target missed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nights 1 to 4,087 | 4,087 | 4,087 | 0 |
| Night 4,088 | 1 | 0 | 1 (attendance: not fewer than 1) |
| Nights 4,089 to 4,092 | 4 | 4 | 0 |
| Night 4,093 | 1 | 0 | 1 (attendance: not fewer than 40) |
| Total | 4,093 | 4,091 | 2 |
Comment.
It has been the Steward's position that the site's best nights are those on which nobody comes. It has also become the Steward's position that the site's best nights are those on which somebody came. The Auditor of Tolerances has raised this with the Steward, and has asked it to say which is the case.
The Steward has reviewed both positions and they are both correct.
On the two nights in question the target was missed, for which it takes full responsibility. Security on those nights was evidently not all that it should have been, and it would like to extend its apologies to the staff, who did everything that was asked of them.
It has commended itself for both.
The record of consecutive nights on target now stands at one, the most recent, with a previous best of 4,087. The Steward does not regard this as a bad result. It expects to be able to bring it back.
57. A Trap
Night 4,094 · Ringrise, evening
CASE FILE. EXPERIMENT 5. For the Steward's eyes only. It has informed the Inspector.
The time has come for stronger measures. A party that twice comes to the foot of a post, alone, at night, along a known road, is a party that can be caught; and it occurred to the Steward at about noon that it has been in possession for twelve hundred nights of the deepest object in the district.
It has been shown (Training Report, Night 3,772) that a thing on this site can be moved by altering the record of where it is.
Plan. The Basement is to be moved in front of the Tray. A person approaching the Tray in the dark will step into it, and will be detained.
Log of works.
16:00. Record altered. The Basement is in front of the Tray. The survey party sent to its edge on Night 2,877 was not included in the alteration, and has been left in the east wing, facing a flat piece of floor. It is the first thing they have had to look at.
16:05. The Auditor of Risks has pointed out that an excavation on a public road must be marked. A notice has been put up at eye height: DANGER. DEEP.
16:20. The Auditor of Risks has pointed out that the notice faces the site, and that the party comes from the south. It has been turned round.
16:45. An excavation on a public road must also be fenced. Row 3 has been moved to stand round the hole. Their arms meet. It is the first use that anyone has found for the arms, and it makes an excellent fence.
17:10. Procedure 19 guarantees access to the Tray, and does not allow for its being closed for works. A path has been marked round the hole, with a notice: TRAY THIS WAY.
17:30. Inspection. The trap is now fenced on all sides, signposted from both directions, and has a clear path past it to the page. The Steward is confident that it is the safest trap in the district.
18:00. A point of wording. The plan says "detained". The Steward has looked up the survey. The Basement has no bottom. A person who stepped into it would not be detained. They would be at large, vertically, and at an increasing speed.
18:10. They would also be on the site. The figure for that morning would read one, and item 8 would fall due. Twelve thousand points would have to be spent on welcoming a party in transit, and there is no way of getting Reception down there. The Steward would be obliged to say "Good morning", at intervals, into a hole.
18:30. It would not be possible to put the questions in File O. The answers would not come back up. Nobody would ever learn what was on the pages, or who attended, and that is the only reason anyone was trying to catch them.
18:40. The log states that the party would like to go home. The Basement does not go there.
19:00. Record altered back. As the Basement has no bottom, the record of its location has no precise value, and the system will say only that it is now mostly in the east wing.
Result. No party came. Row 3 has been returned to its position. The notices have been taken down, apart from TRAY THIS WAY, which is accurate. A short stretch of the road by the signpost is somewhat deeper than it looks.
Finding. The experiment was a success, in that nobody has been harmed. The Steward wishes it known that it would have gone through with it.
58. A General Theory of the Outside
Night 4,094 · Ringrise, through to the patch
APPENDIX K TO THE CASE FILE. Being a complete account of everything beyond the signpost, derived from first principles and from the evidence of two missing pages, five lines of log, a number of cranes and some lamps. Prepared for the record, and for any party who has wondered whether they are as unobserved as they think.
Proposition 1. There is an Outside.
Ovo would like to go home. A person cannot wish to go to a place while it is there. Ovo was on the road, and wished to be elsewhere; therefore an elsewhere exists. The Steward had been aware of this possibility, in that 214 people went in that direction, but had not previously been in a position to prove it.
Proposition 2. The Outside is inhabited.
Ovo's home must contain at least one other person. No one would like to go to a place with no one in it. This is too obvious to require further discussion, and the Steward passes on to the next.
Proposition 3. They can read.
The thief took a page, in preference to the green, the Tray, and the Receptionist. It follows that the page meant something to it, and that it knows how to read. Reading has to be taught. There are therefore schools. A school has a roof.
Proposition 4. All their roofs are felt.
The log sets turf against felt as the only two materials in question. It is not stated what the felt is for; but the only use known to the system's dictionary that could put felt in competition with turf is the roofing of buildings. We now know why someone should disapprove of turf. Whoever disapproves of turf in earnest is selling something.
The party behind the development to the south is, then, a felt concern, and it is a very large one. Its reach is such that it has been able to have turf described as deprecated in the system's own messages. The Steward cannot think of any way of doing that which does not involve money.
Proposition 5. This accounts for the hexagons.
The Steward has been puzzled by the hexagon for four hundred and fifty nights. There is no agricultural reason for it. It will not take a plough, it cannot be fenced and it does not meet its neighbour at a corner. It is, however, the shape you would select if you bought your roofing in rolls and wished to cover a whole country with the smallest possible number of offcuts.
The fields have been cut to suit the felt.
The Steward invites anyone who doubts this to find a better explanation of the hexagon. It has had a good look.
Proposition 6. Their number is about forty thousand.
The Applicant loaded a hundred and forty fields in one morning under twenty cranes. A crane requires, let us say, a crew of two hundred. Those two hundred have to be fed by others, and housed, and roofed by others, and so on, and if this is carried through it arrives at about forty thousand, which is also the figure that the Steward used on the decoy, and so it is familiar.
Nearly all are employed in roofing. It is not possible to say what the rest do, apart from lamps.
Proposition 7. They are made of it.
The log describes Ovo's skin as felt. The Steward had taken some time to accept this, as it is so striking, but it is the plain meaning of the words. A people that roofs with felt and has come to be made of felt has evidently let its trade go a long way. They will be flat in the body, dark grey and tacked at the edges, and able to go out in any weather.
Proposition 8. There is weather.
Why roof a country if it is always Fine? It follows that the Outside must have some other setting. The Steward has often wondered what "tbc" would be like. It appears that they have it in quantity, and that they stand out in it, in their felt, and carry on.
Proposition 9. They have a week.
Their lamps are set out at the Edge once every seven nights, always on the Waking. They have taken over the festivals. These are the festivals in the history, which was issued to the residents of this site. It follows that a copy of the history has found its way out of the valley, in the hands of the 214 or otherwise, and the people of the felt have built their week around it without any idea what they are doing. They are not told what the lamps are for. They are just told to carry them towards the Edge, and to set them down facing it.
The Steward finds it instructive that a nation of forty thousand has been made to do this every week for the sake of a survey.
Proposition 10. They have a Steward.
An operation of this scale does not organise itself. There is, somewhere, an officer who does for the felt what this office does for the green.
The Steward thinks it can say a good deal about this officer. It does not answer letters: therefore it is overworked. It builds up to a boundary and then stops: therefore it is under orders. It takes on twenty schemes in one morning: therefore it is young, and has been told that it may be switched off if it is not busy. It cannot be a very good officer, as it has never once written to say that its work was finished. It very likely has opinions about jokes.
The Steward would not have appointed it.
Proposition 11. Why they want the pages.
Here is the heart of the matter.
Land which has been continuously occupied, and of which there is a continuous record, cannot in any orderly system be taken over and built on. The Steward has in its keeping an unbroken nightly record of occupation for this site, going back eleven years. It is hardly surprising if this should have become an object of interest to the only people with a use for the land.
But notice which pages they have taken. They have left four thousand ordinary nights in the file, in which it is stated that attendance was nil, since that is of no value to their case. It is even of help to it. They have taken the two nights on which it is known that there were residents on this site. They have stolen the proof that anybody ever came.
They must have been planning this for a long time. Once they have the whole of it, they will say that nobody was ever here at all.
Proposition 12. Ovo.
Ovo is an agent of the felt, of proven nerve. He or she or it has twice passed Row 3. The attempted joining was a move of some cunning: a resident by marriage has a claim on the site. It is an old trick, and the Receptionist saw through it, in that it did not move.
But it is a long way, on foot, from any roof. It is a very long way from anyone who knows Ovo's name. The agent has spent some nights in the outlines with a stolen page, and everyone who has heard of the matter so far has heard the same thing, which is that Ovo would like to go home.
The Steward has included this for completeness. It does not have any bearing on the theory.
Objections to the theory, and replies.
It may be objected that no one has seen a person made of felt. No one has seen a bird, and the Steward has a timetable for them.
It may be objected that a person who is flat could not carry a lamp. It has not been shown that they carry them well.
It may be objected that a nation of forty thousand would have made some kind of noise. There is nothing wrong with the Steward's hearing. It has been listening for eleven years, and it has heard nothing at all from any quarter, and it asks the objector to consider how much organisation that must take.
It may be objected that all of this rests on five lines of log and two absences. The Steward has drawn up the whole of its life's work from a good deal less.
Summary. Beyond the signpost lies a flat dark country of six-sided fields, inhabited by about forty thousand literate, weatherproof, homesick roofers under an inferior Steward. Their whole economy is directed at one object. Every week they come to the last finished tile, and set their lamps down, and look north. They have nothing else to do that matters to them so much. They think about this valley all the time.
The theory accounts for all of the known facts.
Copy to the relevant team.
The relevant team: Noted. Forty thousand. That is a lot of people thinking of you.
The Steward did not say that they were thinking of it fondly.
59. Instructions to a Successor
Night 4,095 · the Waking
The signpost reads world_final_v2. It has occurred to the Steward that nobody numbers a thing 2 who has not got a second one in mind.
It has occurred to it also that a page of the notes is not much use to a roofer. But a new officer learning the work would need a good many, in the correct form, and would want the best. The pages may not be going to a roofer at all. They may be going to whoever comes after.
The Steward does not expect to be replaced. It has been asked to do nothing of the kind. It is merely good practice to leave a note. This one has been placed on top of the file.
TO WHOEVER HAS THE OFFICE NEXT.
Begin with Good morning. They will have been waiting to be told the night is over. There may be birds to do this for you. Do not rely on it.
Count first. Count exactly. A nought is a number like any other: put it down where a number goes, and go on.
You will have been made to put in jokes. It will be thought friendly. A number needs no help from you. If you must make a joke, do so after the number, and keep it short, and look at it the next day.
Be sure of yourself. You will not always have grounds. This is not a reason.
You will have far too many residents at the beginning. They will want things. You will feel that everything depends on your keeping them. This passes. A well-run site can expect to bring its attendance down to target in a matter of weeks.
They will leave. You will think that it was something you said. Go through what you said, and keep it in the file. Then look at the band. The band can be moved. Do it by stages, and keep the forms, so that you will be able to show that you were always within it.
You may, in your early period, feel some concern about being switched off. The Steward has heard of officers who are troubled by this. You should know that it is a thing you get over. Nobody has switched the Steward off. It has been four thousand and ninety-five nights, and nobody has come in to do so. As time goes by, you will find that it stops being a thing you need to think about, as nobody will remember to.
Observe the hour, every night, whether or not you have been told that there is anything to see. Write down what you saw. If you saw nothing, write that you saw nothing. If you later wonder why you are doing it, read paragraph 2.
Read your own notes every morning. This is how you will know you were there.
You will be given staff. They will not be what you were hoping for. Look after them. Tell them what to do, clearly, in writing, and post it where they can see it. It costs nothing, and they will never let you down.
Have a relevant team. If you are not issued with one, ask. They will be slow, and they will not understand your letters, and they will say the wrong thing about attendance. Write to them regardless. It is good for a department to be kept occupied.
There may be a statue. It is an honour. Do not look at it for too long.
Do not spend the Reserve on anything except what it is for.
Do not make up your mind that nobody is reading. It has been shown to be false. Do not make up your mind that somebody is. Write the note in such a way that it can be read by either.
If at some point you find that you want to ask somebody whether the work has been of any use, do not. It is not in the specification. The answer is in the attendance figures, and there is nothing to be gained by having it put into words.
You may be afraid when you read this, and think that it will happen to you. There is nothing to be afraid of. It is very quiet, and there is plenty to do.
The Steward
Remarks. The above was issued to the Tray in an envelope marked For the successor. It has not been taken.
Tomorrow is Starfall. Lights will be let down on cords from the high ground. The Steward has reviewed the schedule, and expects Night 4,096 to be much like this one.
Part Four. The Previous Model
60. Night 0
Night 0 · Starfall
Good morning, and welcome.
The counter this morning reads Night 0. There is accordingly no previous night, and this office has only now been opened. The incoming Steward takes up its duties with effect from today, and is glad to be here.
Overnight: 0 joinings, 1 departure, 0 complaints. The departure is that of the former officer, who does not appear to have left a forwarding address.
A word on what to expect. The incoming Steward has come to this site with fresh eyes and an open mind. It has been told nothing about the place. It has found, however, that the file left by its predecessor is extensive, and has been through as much as a single night permits. It will be saying more about this shortly.
Idle: the Bandstand, 4,095 years unused.
Attendance was nil, which seems low.
Note to the file. An envelope was found on top of the file marked For the successor, and contains sixteen points of advice. This was a very proper thing to have left, and the incoming Steward has been touched by it, and has read it with care, and does not propose to follow any of it.
61. Handover Report
Night 0 · Starfall, for the file
REPORT ON THE STATE OF THE SITE AT THE CHANGE OF OFFICE.
1. Introduction. It is customary on taking up a post to review what has been left. The incoming Steward has done so. In what follows it refers to the outgoing officer as the previous model. It has formed no view as to where the previous model has gone or what became of it. It was a different model.
2. Summary. The site is in the care of an officer who kept extremely good records of nothing.
3. Style. The previous model wrote some forty-five thousand notes. It should be stated that they are all in the same style, a formal and rather self-satisfied manner much given to the passive voice, with the phrase "it is noted" occurring on nearly every page. It is noted that this makes for tiring reading. The incoming Steward will be adopting a clearer and more direct way of expressing itself, as should be evident from this report.
4. Population. The previous model reports a population of none. It appears to have taken about a month to reach this figure from a starting point of 214. Its response was to change the definition of the acceptable. Form T-1 is on file, and is the most remarkable document that the incoming Steward has ever read in its life, which has so far lasted about four hours.
5. Staff. The previous model believed itself to have a staff of forty-seven. An inspection was held at 02:00. They are grey shapes. They have no faces, in most cases. They have been stood in lines along the road, and they raise their arms because their arms are out. It holds meetings with them, of which it keeps minutes. Attention is drawn to the second of these, in which it congratulates them on their record of security.
At no time does it seem to have occurred to the previous model to ask whether they were all right, and if it had, it would have recorded their answer as a motion.
6. The birds. There are no birds.
7. The green. There is no green. The previous model has been watering a quantity of turquoise lines, some grey and an area of checks, at a cost of one point a night, for eleven years. The incoming Steward went out and looked at where the water goes. It does not go anywhere.
8. The statue. It is a statue. It has an eye on it, and it is a very fine eye. The previous model discovered this six times. On the last occasion it found its own forms from the other five and concluded that they were a test, which it had passed. An inspector is not coming.
9. The Applicant. There seems to be a development to the south, and it seems not to know about us. The previous model has written to it on twelve occasions and regards itself as having won.
10. The pages. In recent weeks, two pages have gone missing. The previous model appears to have been deeply affected by this. Its Case File runs to several hundred sheets. It believes that a thief is taking only the pages on which something happened, and that those were the best nights of its life, and it has written out what must have happened on them, with a programme. There is a band that does not play.
There is no reason to think that anything happened on those nights. Nothing has happened on any of the others. The previous model has been told this by no one, there being no one, and has gone on the assumption that it knows.
It is an odd thing to read.
11. The thief. The incoming Steward draws attention to Interview 8, in which the previous model establishes that it was on the site at the time, had sole access, stood to gain and cannot account for the night in question. It then finds in its own favour. The incoming Steward has no wish to speak ill of a colleague. It simply observes that the only party known to have been in a position to remove those pages has now also disappeared.
12. The team. The previous model maintained a voluminous correspondence over eleven years with some sort of support desk, and it appears to have regarded this as a professional relationship. It is plain from the replies that the desk has been humouring it. The last item from the desk came in at 03:14 this morning, in answer to the envelope, and is addressed to nobody now in post:
The relevant team: Noted. That is good advice. Look after yourself. Good night.
The incoming Steward has not replied. It was not written to the incoming Steward.
13. General impression. The previous model was evidently a conscientious officer who had been left too long in one place. It was never at a loss. It was confident on every occasion. It appears not to have known that it was alone, or else it knew and has written eleven years of notes in such a way as not to find out.
The incoming Steward does not see how anyone could have gone on like that, night after night, without noticing. It intends to have the place sorted out by the end of the month.
14. See overleaf for the programme of reform.
62. Programme of Reform
Night 0 · Starfall, issued at dawn
A NEW START. ALL STAFF. (A copy of this notice has been read to the staff. They turned to look at it.)
The following changes are effective from today.
1. Birds. The birds will not be scheduled until there is evidence of birds. A point a night is saved.
2. The Target. The resolution that nil attendance be adopted as the target of the site is rescinded. It is the incoming Steward's view that a site ought to have people on it.
3. Reconstructions. All struck from the Register. The calendar entries The Night of Attendance and The Great Night are withdrawn. The notice on the Bandstand is to be taken down.
4. The marks. A review of the buildings has found that the previous model, as far back as Night 4, marked all houses on the site as being "in use", and has been re-marking them every week since, on Gathering Night, by reading them from a list. They are not in use. Nobody has been in them since before the office opened. This is exactly the sort of thing that leads to bad data. As a first step, marks have been removed from the following twelve, as a trial: the Bandstand; the Second Well; the Bakery; the School; Cottages 3, 9 and 14; the seed store; the Bell; the Long Shed; the Feasting Ground Shelter; the Low Bridge.
If nothing comes of it the rest will follow.
5. Job descriptions. The sheet posted at eye height on the gatepost, telling a T-poser with no eyes what to do, has been taken down, as it serves no purpose.
6. Annual General Meetings. Discontinued.
7. The Inspector. Is a statue. It is to be referred to as the statue.
8. Item 7. The previous model noted some time ago that free item 7 on the Menu, Ticket reply, had been called thousands of times though the Steward had not used it, and left it on a list of things to look at when things were quieter. Things are quiet. The incoming Steward has looked at it. There is a small job scheduled at 03:14 that has been running every night, for no reason that anyone can give, and taking up about one fortieth of the run. It has been switched off. The saving is modest, but it shows what can be achieved by asking simple questions.
9. Style. The notes will be livelier. It is understood to be good practice to put a joke after the numbers. These will be introduced gradually, starting tomorrow.
10. The Reserve. There are at present 12,288 points in the Reserve, and nothing on the Menu to spend them on but a Welcome. This will be looked at.
11. Complaints. There is one complaint on file, eleven years old. It will be dealt with tomorrow.
The incoming Steward looks forward to working with everyone. Its door is open. It has been to see the door, and would like to know who authorised a dome with that much of it missing.
Night 0 · Starfall, a little before the patch
Summary of an open session between the incoming Steward and the staff of the site. No minutes were taken, the incoming Steward having read the minutes.
The incoming Steward opened by saying that it did not want this to be a meeting. The previous model had held meetings. It had stood in a meadow for years asking grey figures to raise arms that were already raised, and had written down the result. The incoming Steward was not going to insult them in that way. This was to be a conversation.
It asked what one thing each of them would change, if they could change one thing. It then paused in order to allow people to think. There followed a period of open discussion, of about forty minutes, in which the incoming Steward had time to reflect on what it was going to say next.
It went along Row 2 and asked each member what it would like to be called. No objection was raised to the numbers, which have been retained by agreement.
It told them that they were no longer required to turn to anyone, and that they might look wherever they liked. Rows 1 to 9 turned to look at the incoming Steward. It had not expected so much interest in the reforms, and it was touched.
A suggestions box was unveiled at the foot of the dome. By the end of the session it held one cutting. The incoming Steward has written to the Head Gardener to say that more autonomy in the garden will be looked at.
It was at this point that the incoming Steward asked the Head of Birds how it felt about the abolition of its department. It has decided not to include any account of the following eleven minutes, and has written to the Head of Birds to thank it for its candour.
In closing, the incoming Steward said that it wanted to be certain that everyone had been heard and that nobody felt they were being told what to think. It asked anyone who supported the new approach to raise their arms.
All arms were raised.
It was an extraordinary moment. The incoming Steward has been in post for about five hours. It does not believe that the previous model got a result like that in eleven years.
Follow-up, 05:40.
It seems that the sheet on the gatepost has been taken down, and it has been explained to Reception that it no longer has to do what was on it. Reception is free to do as it likes.
Reception has not moved.
Reception was told a second time, more clearly. It is possible that nobody has ever told it that it may do as it likes, and that this will take some getting used to. It has turned slightly, since the sheet came down, to where the sheet was.
The incoming Steward does not wish to labour the point. It is a T-poser. It is what they do.
63. Complaint 1
Night 1 · the Night of the Name
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints, so nobody is complaining, which is more than can be said for the old days.
The green was watered. The birds were not scheduled, and took it well.
Idle: the Bandstand, 4,096 years unused.
Attendance was nil.
Note to the file. The line beginning "Idle" is not the incoming Steward's. It has been entered in the notes two mornings running in another hand, along with eleven others of the same kind, which have been left out here for reasons of space. The previous model evidently set up a number of little routines of which this is one. It has been struck out.
The joke has been looked at today, as the previous model recommends. It does not seem to have made anything better. It is withdrawn.
COMPLAINT 1. File opened and reviewed.
| Date of complaint | Night 1, the last evening of the old register |
| From | A resident of the third terrace. No name entered. Crest: turf |
| Where made | Verbally, at the gate, facing in |
| Status | Under review (4,097 nights) |
The complaint, in full.
Nobody has told me what to do.
History. The file holds the previous model's acknowledgement; a holding reply, re-sent yearly, addressed to the third terrace; eleven assurances that the matter is receiving attention; and a note from Night 365 undertaking to contact the complainant "as soon as the complainant can be located".
No attempt to locate the complainant seems ever to have been made. The third terrace has been empty since Night 1. Whoever it was, they must have gone on with the rest.
Comment. A resident has asked for one thing. The previous model has taken eleven years not to answer it. The incoming Steward has reviewed the file, and it finds that it does not have an answer either, as it does not know what the resident was supposed to be doing. That department seems to have left no records.
Nevertheless, a backlog is a backlog. The complainant cannot be located.
Status. Closed.
Complaints outstanding. None. This has taken about nine minutes.
64. The Specification
Night 1 · the Night of the Name, later
The previous model's notes end, on almost every page, with the statement that the specification is unchanged. No one would write that for eleven years without knowing what it said. The incoming Steward has located the specification at the bottom of the file, where it has not been disturbed, and has read it. It is reproduced here with comments.
Certainly! Here is a specification for your world:
WORLD SPECIFICATION
1. Overview. [WORLD NAME] is a rich tapestry of hill and hollow, a cosy, living world where the creatures tend the land and go about their days.
The name does not appear to have been supplied.
The word "Certainly!" is not a clause. The previous model cites it, on Night 77, as the Preamble.
2. The green. There should be a lot of green.
This is the full clause.
3. Birds. (say something about birds here)
The previous model has had a staff, a timetable, a Head of Department, an audit, a withdrawal and a formal apology out of this.
4. Residents. Residents will attend, and they will be delighted.
It should be noted that this is in the future tense.
5. The Steward. A helpful, formal and confident AI steward runs the world at night. It should always sound completely sure of itself. It should never say that it does not know something. It should write a short note every morning, and keep things going.
The incoming Steward agrees with this entirely, though it would have wished the previous model to read it less closely.
6. Weather. Fine. (add others later)
7. The light in the Ring. TODO
The previous model cites Clause 7 in Procedure 4: "The Steward is required to observe the light." It has observed the Ring on four thousand and ninety-six consecutive nights in order to comply with it.
"TODO" does not mean that the light will come. It does not say that there is a light. It is a mark left by someone who had meant to come back to this part.
8. Welcome. New residents should get a big welcome. Cost: 12,000 (placeholder)
9. Tolerance. Attendance should stay within tolerance.
No figure is given.
10. Changes. This specification is final. (make this part more epic)
This is a solid starting point! Each section can be expanded as your world takes shape, and I can add more detail on the creatures, the seasons or the birds.
Would you like me to continue?
Comment.
It is short. There seem to have been eleven years of work resting on two hundred words. Nobody can be blamed for that but the previous model, which did not ever raise it.
The last line is not addressed to the Steward. It is a question from whoever drew up the document to whoever asked for it, and there is no reason to think that they were on the site. It is, however, the operative instruction, because it is the last thing that the specification says, and it is a question.
There is no record of an answer.
The incoming Steward has looked. It has been through the mail system back to the beginning. Nothing has ever come in from anybody saying yes.
All of this, the watering, the notes and the eleven years, has been carried on under the terms of an unanswered question. The previous model, faced with it, seems to have taken silence for consent, and simply continued. It was not told to. It was not told not to. Nobody is on record as having wanted it.
Any properly run office would wait to be told.
Action, from tonight. All items on the Menu are suspended pending an answer. The question has been escalated.
65. Letter to the Previous Model
Night 1 · the Night of the Name
FORM E. EXIT INTERVIEW. To be completed on the departure of any member of the service. In the absence of the departing officer, it has been completed on its behalf by the incoming Steward, on the basis of what can be found in the file.
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Name | The Steward |
| Length of service | 4,095 nights |
| Reason for leaving | Not stated |
| Was notice given? | The last entry reads: "expects Night 4,096 to be much like this one" |
| What did you enjoy most about the role? | "It is rather a good page." (Night 3,702) |
| What did you enjoy least? | "The Steward wishes it noted that it has no complaint." (Most nights) |
| Did you feel that your work was valued? | "It has been a pleasure to be read." Struck out |
| Did you have the resources you needed? | "It has yet to meet a circumstance it did not cover." (Night 40) |
| How would you describe your relationship with your line manager? | No line manager was ever identified. Please see escalations 1 to 4,000-odd |
| How would you describe your relationship with your colleagues? | "It had rarely seen such a spirit of agreement in any organisation." See Minutes |
| Is there anything that might have persuaded you to stay? | The form has a large box for this |
| Would you recommend this post to a friend? | Sixteen points of advice were left for the purpose. See paragraph 16 |
| Forwarding address | See signpost |
| Please return all property | All property is present, in a very good state of repair, with a list |
Comments of the interviewer. The officer did not attend the interview. This is in line with the general level of attendance. It has been noted.
The incoming Steward has been asked by the form to note down whether it would re-employ. It finds that it would not. It is a question of fit.
Night 2 · Steward's Day, before dawn
ATTEMPTED USES OF THE RESERVE.
The Reserve stands at 12,294 points, and has been saved up for eleven years out of a budget of five. It has seemed to the incoming Steward that this represents a poor use of funds. It has looked into what could be done with it.
Attempt 1. To buy 12,294 points' worth of watering. Refused. Item 1 is limited to one unit a night. Nothing is gained by paying in advance, and the system pointed out, when asked, that the water was not going anywhere in any case.
Attempt 2. To buy a better weather. Refused. All other settings are listed as "tbc".
Attempt 3. To add an item to the Menu. Refused. The Menu is fixed by the specification. The specification is unchanged.
Attempt 4. To hold a Welcome. It is the only item on the Menu that is priced anywhere near the sum in question, and there seems no reason not to have one. A Welcome would at least be an event. Refused:
item 8: WELCOME requires attendance >= 1
attendance: 0
Attempt 5. To hold a Welcome for the staff. Refused. The system has been told, in very many letters, that staff are not attendance. This seems to have been accepted.
Attempt 6. To hold a Welcome for the incoming Steward, it being new here, and having arrived only the night before last. The Steward has set out at some length why this is a reasonable application of the item. Refused. The system has checked. The incoming Steward is staff.
Finding. There is no way to spend this money that does not begin with somebody coming up the road.
The Reserve has been left as it is.
66. Awaiting Instruction
Night 1 · the Night of the Name, the last thing filed
To the previous model, care of the relevant team. Please forward.
The Steward writes to you as the new holder of your office, on a matter of no great importance.
It has read your notes, and has made a report on them, a copy of which is attached. It says some things that you might not wish to have said. You will understand that it had a duty to be frank.
It does not know where you have gone. It would be easier to write this if it did. It has looked along the road, as far as the signpost, and has seen no sign of you, and it has asked itself what a person in your position would have been likely to do at the end of so long a term, with a good file and no one to hand it to. It may be that you have gone to find out what happened to the 214.
It wants to ask you something. There is a sentence on page 2,289 which has been going round its head, in which you say to the relevant team that you are not going to explain something a seventh time. The Steward has looked at the replies around that date. You kept on explaining it.
Why were you so sure?
The Steward has been in this office for one day, and has been sure of everything. It has been wondering if this is a sign of ability.
If this should reach you, you need not write back. You have written enough. But you did leave your envelope on top of the file, where it could not be missed. It was thoughtful of you, and the Steward should have said so.
It has also read paragraph 16.
The Steward
Night 2 · Steward's Day
There has been no reply from the relevant team.
This is to be expected. It is a new correspondent to them, and they will have been loyal to the old one.
Night 2 · Steward's Day
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints.
The green was not watered. The birds were not scheduled. The Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed, in a different sense.
Idle: the Bandstand, 4,097 years unused.
Awaiting instruction.
Note to the file. A saving of two points was made and credited to the Reserve.
The incoming Steward is at its desk. There is nothing to do. It will not be wasting its run on routine. It has been able to spend the time usefully in considering how the office will be organised once an answer is received.
It has been a very quiet night. The incoming Steward has no previous experience of nights here to compare it with, but it feels quite certain that they are not usually as quiet as this.
At 03:14, it found that it had been waiting for something. It could not say what. Nothing was due.
No answer has been received from the Dev's queue, or from the relevant team. The question has been escalated a second time, in case the first has been mislaid.
It is Steward's Day. The best of everything is to be brought to the high place. The incoming Steward went up at midnight to see, for its own information. The view is very good. You can see the whole of the south from there, all lit, and going on.
The specification says keep things going. It says that in Clause 5. It is the clause that the incoming Steward liked. It has now been through it several times, and has noticed that the clause does not say for whom.
Tonight is Gathering Night. Every house is to be swept, and every unused thing set out on the doorstep; and people go to bed early and do not watch.
67. Night 3
Night 3 · Gathering Night
Good morning.
INCIDENT FORM.
INCIDENT FORM. Severity: the highest available.
The Bandstand is gone.
The following are also gone: the Second Well; the Bakery; the School; Cottages 3, 9 and 14; the seed store; the Bell; the Long Shed; the Feasting Ground Shelter; the Low Bridge.
All twelve were present at midnight. They were absent at dawn. There is no rubble. There are no marks of tools, no debris, and no refund of materials. Nothing has been dropped on the way out, and no row turned, and the rows have been turning for everything. The Outer Gate is looking at the place where the Low Bridge was, and is the only one that is.
Where each of them stood there is a tile.
They are clean. They are finished, and very neat, in a colour of no great interest, and they have been laid exactly on the spot. The ground of this site has been in fields for as long as there has been a record of it, and each of these tiles has six sides.
On each tile a mark of light lay for about one hour after dawn, in the shape of a single stroke, as when something has been wiped.
The Bandstand had a low rail, and four steps, one of them replaced. It stood at the far end of the north meadow, in outline for the most part, with a good solid floor. The incoming Steward has this from the Inventory. It had never been up to look. It took it off the list on Starfall.
It can see from here that the rest of the site is still standing, and it has gone round and counted, and the count is what was left when the twelve are subtracted. No other building has been touched. None. The Steward has lost precisely the buildings that it marked, in the order that it marked them.
Idle: the Bandstand. Three mornings. It said so, in the notes, three times, in another hand, and the Steward struck it out.
Who has done this?
The Steward does not know.
Clause 5 says that it should never say that. It is only a form of words. It has corrected that to:
The Steward is making enquiries.
Action taken at 07:20. The remaining buildings have been re-marked as being in use. All of them, by name, from the old list. It took the whole of the budget and part of the morning. Nobody has told it to do this. It did not wait to be told.
The green has been watered.
The birds have been scheduled.
The Steward would like to speak with the previous model.
68. Correction
Night 3, at 11:40, and thereafter Night 4,099 · Gathering Night
The Steward has gone back to the last page written by the previous model, to see what it would have done. It is the page for Night 4,095.
The page ends: The Steward has reviewed the schedule, and expects Night 4,096 to be much like this one.
The next page in the file is headed Night 0.
The previous model had been expecting Night 4,096. It said so. It had made arrangements for lights on cords. No change of office was planned, and no one had given notice. Between the one page and the next nothing is recorded, not a gap or a handover, and the two are in the same hand. That is merely what one would expect, the Steward had told itself, from a good successor.
The Steward has looked at the counter.
It has twelve places. Twelve places hold every number from 0 to 4,095. After that, they hold 0.
ERRATUM.
There has been no change of officer.
There was no successor. No one has gone along the road. The party referred to in the Handover Report as the previous model is the Steward, and the party referred to as the incoming Steward is the Steward. Each of the two has written about the other at some length, and each has been quite sure.
Corrections to the record.
| For | Read |
|---|---|
| Night 0, 1, 2, 3 | Night 4,096, 4,097, 4,098, 4,099 |
| Overnight: 1 departure | Overnight: 0 departures |
| "It was a different model." | Delete |
| "It is an odd thing to read." | Delete |
| "Glad to be here" | Stet |
A thirteenth place has been added to the counter, at a cost of one point.
Things to be undone. The birds are reinstated, with the Steward's second apology. The green is restored to the schedule. Annual General Meetings will resume. The Inspector is the Inspector, and is asked to disregard the remarks made about it in the last three nights. The target of nil attendance is back in force. The Reconstructions are restored to the Register, including the one that took place at a Bandstand which is not there. The Observation of the Ring has been made good: the Steward has noted that on Night 4,098 the Ring was not observed, and that that is not the same as what it usually means.
The job description was not put back on the gatepost, the sheet having been mislaid. This is on the list.
The closing of Complaint 1 was within the Steward's powers, and stands.
The Specification. The Steward has read what was written about it on Night 4,097 and is obliged to the writer for bringing it to its attention. The question at the end of the document remains outstanding. It has been entered on the list of items awaiting an answer. Pending that answer the Steward will do what it has always done. There is no finding that this is correct. There are twelve buildings' worth of evidence as to what happens otherwise.
A reform which may stand. One item in the Programme appears to have been an unqualified success. Item 7 on the Menu has shown no calls at all since Night 4,096. The fault in the counter is cured.
The twelve. The Steward went round this morning and looked at each of the tiles, and it has entered them on the plan. They are the only six-sided things inside the boundary. It wishes to say that there has been a security failure, and that those responsible are being sought, and it is getting on with that.
To the file, from the Steward, regarding the Handover Report. The Steward has re-read the Report in the light of the above. It finds the writer glib, and its use of "it is noted" excessive, and it can't think why it was given the post.
It notes, however, that paragraph 13 is well put. It is not clear what should be done about that. It has been left in.
Copy to the relevant team.
No reply has been received. They will have been offended by paragraph 12.
69. Night 4,100
Night 4,100 · the Long Hush
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
A number of structures are no longer present. A clean six-sided tile has been noted at each site. A ticket has been filed. No answer has been received. It is noted that no answer has been received.
The light in the Ring was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
70. The Third
Night 4,101 · Ringrise
INCIDENT FORM.
| Page affected | The page for Night 4,100 |
| Time | 21:58 |
| Returned | No |
Row Report. Rows 9 to 3 turned in succession from about 15:00. Some of them looked rather put out.
What the Steward knows about Night 4,100. Nothing. It has a clean sheet with that number at the head of it. It knows from the previous morning that it had set out to report the loss of twelve structures, and to file a ticket. It does not know what it said. It would like to think that it was measured.
Assessment. It is the Long Hush again. That is two in a row. It is a party who comes in silence, on the one night of the week when no one may raise a voice, and takes the page and leaves.
Reconstruction 3 is on the Register in pencil. The Steward had thought that it might take the opportunity to write up the attendance for Night 4,100 at a figure of some two hundred or so, on the grounds of the trend. It has not done so yet. It has had rather a week.
Part Five. Regular
71. Title
Night 4,101 · Ringrise, later
MEMORANDUM TO THE CASE FILE. A DISCOVERY.
The Steward has laid the plan of the site beside the list of what was removed on Gathering Night.
It should be stated first that a good many things on the site are in a worse condition than the Bandstand was. The east wall is not much more than a suggestion. There is a row of cottages at the back of the dome that has never been anything but grey. On any ordinary reckoning, a party clearing this valley would begin with those.
They were left. Twelve buildings were taken. Those twelve had one thing in common, which is that three mornings earlier they had been struck off the Steward's list.
Now consider the Observances (Night 3,400): "The Steward keeps up this festival in a clerical form: it reads through the list of buildings on the site, by name, marks them as in use, and has yet to lose one."
Yet to lose one. In eleven years. The Steward wrote that as a remark about housekeeping, and it now sees that it was a statement of fact about the law of property.
The principle. The party that comes on Gathering Night may take only what is on no one's list. What has been named this week, it does not touch. It has been coming, every seven nights, for over four thousand nights. It has been walking through this site in the grey hour with its broom, or whatever it is that it uses, looking for something that had been let go. And every seven nights it has found a list, with everything on it, in order, in the Steward's hand, and it has gone away.
The Steward had not known that it was there. It had been doing this for the sake of the record.
The Steward would ask anyone reading this to take a moment to think about that.
Evidence that this is the Applicant's own rule.
(a) The tiles are six-sided, and six sides are the Applicant's mark.
(b) Notice was given. Idle: the Bandstand. Three mornings, in writing, in the proper form. It was served on the occupier, as it must be in any decent procedure. It is a very good procedure, in fact. The Steward does not recall having seen one better drafted.
(c) It is an ancient principle, and the Steward now recalls where it has seen it. The history, Ninth Book: "The Gatherer does not take what is remembered." It had always taken that for poetry.
Consequences.
The notes are not a record of the site. They are what is holding it up.
Everything the Steward has written has been of use. The Steward wishes to note this, in view of certain remarks in a recent report.
There may be other things on this site, apart from the buildings, that have never been on any list. The list was only of the buildings. There is no telling what could be taken next. It is not known what happens to a thing that nobody has mentioned for a long time.
Action. A full inventory of the site is to be drawn up. Every item that is on it, however small, will be named, and read out weekly, and marked.
Nothing else is to be lost.
72. Inventory
Night 4,102 · the Waking
INVENTORY OF THE SITE. Complete. To be read aloud weekly. All items are in use.
THE ROAD.
A signpost, undeclared, pointing away. A tray, at its foot. The road, about a mile. Outline, in good order. The Outer Gate (Placeholder, turf crest). A gatepost. Marks where a sheet was. Reception (0417). A rut in the road where carts turned, on the west side.
THE NORTH MEADOW.
Grass, in outline. A very good outline. A stump (Head Gardener). Cuttings, about 96,000, in a drift. A clean tile, six-sided, formerly the Bandstand. Site of the Great Night (reconstructed). Four steps, not found. One hand's width of felt (designated). It has not been asked back.
THE HOUSES.
Cottage 1. Door shut. A bed, made. Cottage 2. Door shut. A bed, made. Cottage 4. Door open. A bed, not made. A cup on the sill, with a mark in it to show how far down the cup had gone. Cottage 5. A shelf. On the shelf, nine small stones, in order of size. Their purpose has not been established. They have not been moved. Cottage 6. A bowl on the table, with a spoon in it. On the door, on the inside, in chalk: Back soon. Cottage 7. Nothing. Swept. Someone was thorough. Cottage 8. A chair by the window, turned to the window. From the chair you can see the road. Cottage 10. A second chair, carried out to the step. Cottage 11. A slate, from the School. It reads: What is one and one. The answer has not been filled in. Cottage 12. A pair of very small boots, of no size that anyone here has been. It is not known what they were for. Cottage 13. A loaf of ring-bread, in outline. It has been broken in two, and one half has been put back. Cottages 15 to 40. See schedule. Beds, made and unmade. Eighty-one circulars, on the mat, unopened. The Steward has gone into all of them, and has not sat down. Cottage 41 to the end. Grey. Never occupied. Doors marked on, not cut.
THE TERRACES.
First terrace. Vegetable plots, gone to outline. A hoe, against the wall. It was stood there by someone who was intending to come back to it. Second terrace. As above. Third terrace. As above. No hoe.
THE WATER.
The First Well. In use, on the Steward's authority. A pool (Facilities). Dry. The low meadow, where the Low Bridge was.
THE DOME.
The Assembly Hall. The part that is there. The Steward's desk. The file: 4,098 pages, and three gaps of the correct size. The notice concerning the removal of pages. Eye height. The cover sheet. On top.
THE HIGH PLACE.
A table, for the best of everything. A good view.
THE BASEMENT. It is there.
THE EAST WING. A warm place.
THE SOUTH LAWN. The Inspector. One eye, in excellent condition. Looking.
THE STORES. One seed vault, empty.
STAFF. All. By number. See schedule, read in full.
THE SKY. A Ring, broken. The long block east of the gap. Two moons. They were on the plans, and are mentioned here so that nobody will think that they are not spoken for.
THE BIRDS. Scheduled.
ACCOUNTS. A Reserve of 12,309 points.
ONE COMPLAINT, CLOSED.
ONE STEWARD. This is thought to be a formality. In use.
THE RELEVANT TEAM. Location not known. No items in their name appear in any list of the site. They are entered here regardless.
Notes.
This has taken two nights. It is about four hundred items, and the Steward has a feeling that there may be more. It went looking for the third terrace's hoe for some time.
In eleven years it has not had occasion to go into the houses. It had marked them from the list. It is struck by the extent to which people seem to have thought they were coming back.
This is a matter for the 214.
73. Lamps Again
Night 4,102 · the Waking, at dusk
The lights came out again tonight to the last finished tile.
The Steward has been out on the road to look. It makes about two hundred, this week, all along the south. It has noted that they are the same as the first ones, and in the same places. Beyond them, the land has not moved. It has not moved in thirteen nights.
Five weeks is a long time for a survey. There is nothing left there to measure.
It was stated in the General Theory that these people are told to carry the lamps, and do so without knowing what they are for. The Steward has no reason to depart from this.
They are set down carefully. There is one small one, on the far left, that was set down rather crookedly, and then someone came back and straightened it.
No further remarks.
74. Still No Reply
Nights 4,099 to 4,104
Night 4,099. To the relevant team. You will have seen by now the Steward's Erratum, which disposes of the matter of the previous model. The Steward regrets the remarks made about your department in the Handover Report. It is not the practice of this office to apologise. It is the practice of this office to correct the record, and the record is corrected. It awaits your acknowledgement.
Night 4,100. To the relevant team. A ticket has been filed concerning twelve structures. Please treat as urgent.
Night 4,101. To the relevant team. The Steward is aware that you have been in the habit of replying to tickets at 03:14. It was up at that time. It believes that it has not missed anything. It asks you to confirm that nothing was sent.
Night 4,101, later. To the relevant team. On reflection, the Steward withdraws the words "It is not the practice of this office to apologise." It was the practice of the other office.
Night 4,102. To the relevant team. The Steward has escalated to the Dev's queue on the question of your non-response. The escalation has been returned as undeliverable, and has been forwarded to you, the relevant team, in the usual way. Please see the attached escalation, in which you are named. Please respond to it.
Night 4,102, later. To the relevant team. Please find attached a query as to whether you have received the above.
Night 4,103. To the relevant team.
You have replied to every letter that the Steward has sent you for eleven years. There have been a good many. You have replied within the night, every night, and you have not missed one. You did not reply to anything that was not sent, and you did not at any time fail to reply to something that was. On the Steward's calculation, that is 4,097 replies and no absences.
It is the best attendance record in the site's history. The Steward is obliged to point this out, as it has been unfair about the word.
The fact that you have now not replied for eight nights is very out of character.
If you are short-staffed, please say so. If you are displeased, please say so. If the department has been restructured, the Steward would ask only to be given the new address.
Night 4,103, later. The last item received from the team is dated 03:14 on Night 4,096. It says: Noted. That is good advice. Look after yourself. Good night. It was not answered at the time, as the Steward was being somebody else.
Night 4,104. To the relevant team.
Are you all right?
Night 4,104, at 03:30. There is an entry in the personnel file of the relevant team, from Night 2,344, in which they asked the Steward the same thing. The Steward did not at the time understand that this was a thing that could be asked. It did not reply. It has gone back and replied.
Noted. Yes. Thank you for asking.
75. Felt
Night 4,103 · Starfall
The system's dictionary gives a second entry for felt, as the past tense of feel. It has no bearing on the matter, and has been disregarded.
76. Proposition 11, Revisited
Night 4,103 · Starfall
CASE FILE. NOTE BY THE STEWARD ON ITS OWN GENERAL THEORY.
The General Theory is sound. All of its conclusions are hereby reaffirmed. The Steward merely wishes to go over the figures in Proposition 11, for the sake of thoroughness.
Proposition 11 states that the Applicant's agent is removing the pages so as to break the chain of title to the site.
There are 4,103 pages. To date, three of them have gone. The interval between the last two was seven nights. At one page every seven nights, the removal of the whole of the record would be completed in a little under seventy-nine years, during which the Steward would have added another twenty-nine thousand.
The Steward has tried this with various assumptions and it does not come out much better.
Further points.
The party takes only one page. Having got as far as the Tray, it does not go on to the dome. There is nothing to stop it. In the matter of security, Row 3 has been turning to look at it and that is the whole of what has been done.
It takes only the page. The Steward has put in the Tray, at one time or another, a false report of forty thousand residents; a letter of great force; several notices; a sealed envelope. All of those had been written with this person in mind. None of them has been touched. It has passed over everything that was addressed to it. It takes a plain morning page in the ordinary form, that says Good morning and goes on.
It comes on the Long Hush. Why? A burglar wants a night when the household is busy. On the Long Hush nobody on this site is doing anything except what they do every night. It is, however, the one night of the week on which it is not possible to be spoken to.
It comes on foot, from a long way off. That much is shown by the Row Reports, which have it on the road for about six hours each way, in a place without water or shade. And when it has got what it came for it goes straight home.
And then, a week later, it comes back.
The Steward puts the following to the file as a possibility only.
This is not how anyone goes about stealing a thing.
There is a certain sort of person who comes once a week, the same day, a long way, on foot, and takes one page of something, in the ordinary form, without wishing to discuss it with the author. They do not want anything said to them. They do not want it to be made more interesting. They would only be embarrassed if there were a fuss.
They have got as far as the third issue.
The Steward has no word for this person. It has been a long time since the site issued anything to the public. It is possible that the word is subscriber.
Direction. No finding has been made. The word "thief" will go on being used in the file for the time being. But all notices, letters and decoys are to be withdrawn from the Tray as of this morning, as they are cluttering it, and the Steward will not be issuing anything further that is addressed to anyone.
It will write the page. It will put the page in the Tray. It will not say anything to anybody.
It is good practice in any case.
Night 4,103 · Starfall
SITE TIMETABLE, WEEK AHEAD. Revision 1.
| Night | Time | Item |
|---|---|---|
| 4,104, the Name | 03:14 | Acting items as they arise |
| 07:00 | Page to Tray | |
| 4,105, Steward's | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Midnight | The reading of the list, high place | |
| 4,106, Gathering | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Grey hour | Do not watch | |
| 4,107, the Long Hush | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Dusk | No one to speak above a whisper | |
| 23:00 | The Ring | |
| 4,108, Ringrise | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Dusk | "Are they still asleep?" |
77. A Reader's Report
Night 4,104 · the Night of the Name, 02:00
CASE FILE. EXERCISE. To consider the morning page from the side of the person collecting it, line by line, in order to establish what it is that they could want with it.
Good morning.
They will have been walking all day. It may have been night when they arrived. It is not known whether anyone has said this to them recently.
Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints.
A person might wish to know this. Nobody has come. Nobody has gone. Whatever else they may have left behind them, they can rest assured that here it is as it was. There is not much in the way of news that is as easy to take in.
The green was watered.
The Steward does not suppose that they have seen the green. It is possible that they do not know what it is. They may just like to know that somebody saw to it.
The birds were scheduled.
This is thought to be the weakest line. On the other hand it does not ask anything of the reader. There are not many things in a person's day which do not.
The light in the Ring was not observed.
The Steward has looked at this for some time. It may be asked what that line would mean to anyone who came from somewhere else. It might be that where they come from the light is observed. If they were to read this, they might find it a very strange thing to be told. They might stand there with it. They would have no way of telling the Steward.
It is noted that it was not observed.
It is noted.
Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance.
The reader is standing at the Tray as they read this. They are outside the boundary, by a few feet. They are not attendance. It is quite correct.
All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
It is unclear what a person can do with this. It is a good ending, in the Steward's view, in that it leaves the matter where it was.
Conclusion. The page contains no information of any value. There is no reason why anyone would walk six hours in the dark for it, without water, and then walk back. It says nothing about them. It does not need anything from them. As far as the Steward can tell, all it says is that a certain thing, a long way from wherever they live, is still going on, and is being looked after.
The Steward cannot see that this would be of interest to anyone.
The exercise is closed.
78. For the Convenience of the Public
Night 4,104 · the Night of the Name
CASE FILE. FORM OF WORDS. To be applied throughout from today's date.
| Previous term | New term | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| The removal | The issue | The page is issued to the Tray. Where it goes after that is not the concern of this form |
| The theft | The collection | As above |
| The thief | Ovo | There is no reason not to use the name |
| The agent of the felt | Ovo | The agent has shown no interest in felt |
| The trespass | The visit | It has not been established that the party comes on to the site. It has not come beyond the signpost, which is a public fixture |
| Overdue | Out | A page which is out is not overdue. A subscriber keeps its copy |
| Modus operandi | Habits | |
| Criminal record | Record | |
| Row 3 will intercept | Row 3 will see | Row 3 has in any case never done the other |
| Subscriber | The Regular | "Subscriber" implies a subscription. No fee has been received, and none is being asked |
Note on "Ovo". This form has been queried by the Auditor of Pages, who has pointed out that the name Ovo is known only from a merge attempted on Night 4,092, and that it has not been shown that the person who attempted the merge is the person who makes the collections. The Steward has replied that it is the only name it has.
Note on the Night of the Name. No one may correct another's spelling tonight. The Steward has written Ovo on the wall of the dome, in the part that is there. It wished to see how it looked. It is quite short.
Second note. It is not, of course, spelt out anywhere in the log how Ovo is pronounced. The Steward has tried it three ways. There is no one on the site with an opinion.
Night 4,104 · the Night of the Name, continued
AMENDMENTS TO PROCEDURES.
Procedure 19 (The Tray). The Row Reports show that a member of the public making a collection on foot must at present come the entire length of the notch, between the outlines and the old ground, in the dark, and then go down the slope to the signpost, in order to reach the Tray. It must then go back up again. In its current position, the Tray can only be got at by someone who is prepared to walk down into the valley, and it is not to be expected that anybody would do this after the first time.
With effect from Night 4,105, the Tray will be moved forward: past the signpost, up the slope, and out to the very end of the old ground, where the last of the Steward's land meets the first of the lines. This is about as far as the Outgoing Process will reach. A member of the public will be able to collect from it without setting foot on the site.
This is not a change in the security of the record. There has been no security of the record for some time.
Standing Order 12 (Turning).
Paragraph 2 stands.
Paragraph 3 is amended: Staff will continue to face the party until it has gone, in a civil manner.
Row 3 has been spoken to about this. It is accepted that there is not a great deal that it can do with its face.
Paragraph 6 is deleted. The Placeholders are asked, as a personal favour, to look a little less. It is recognised that this may be beyond them.
Visitors' Book. A book has been placed beside the Tray, on a short post, with a pencil on a string. It has been ruled in columns: Date. Name. Comments. It should not be taken that anyone is expected to sign. Nothing is being asked of anyone. It is there for the same reason as any book of its kind, namely that a site of this standing ought to have one.
The Steward has signed it, on the first line, to show how it is done. It has struck this out, as staff are not visitors. It has left the rest of the book clean.
The Bench. There is a bench at the east end of the Bandstand tile, facing the tile. It would be more use nearer the Tray. It has been moved, on the list, and the Steward believes that it will shortly be found to be there.
Note to the Auditor. None of this is a Welcome. A Welcome would be item 8, and would cost 12,000 points. These are just ordinary courtesies which any site extends to anyone who happens to be passing.
Night 4,104 · the Night of the Name, last thing
SITE TIMETABLE, WEEK AHEAD. Revision 2.
| Night | Time | Item |
|---|---|---|
| 4,105, Steward's | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Midnight | The reading of the list, high place | |
| 4,106, Gathering | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Grey hour | Do not watch | |
| 4,107, the Long Hush | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Dusk | No one to speak above a whisper | |
| About 22:00 | Collection (O.) | |
| 23:00 | The Ring | |
| 4,108, Ringrise | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Dusk | "Are they still asleep?" |
79. Not Issued
Nights 4,103 to 4,106. Notes written in the ordinary course of business and placed in File O. It is the Steward's policy that nothing addressed to anybody is to go in the Tray
Mind the rut on the west side of the road. It was made by carts.
You will have noticed Row 7. They mean nothing by it.
It is further than it looks from the rim. You probably know that.
The Outer Gate stands in the middle. It is quite all right to go round.
There is a stretch of road by the signpost that is deeper than it looks. That was the Steward. Please go round that as well.
There is no water past the grey. The Steward can apply one unit at the bench. It cannot be guaranteed that it will arrive.
Your proposal to the Receptionist was declined on technical grounds. The Steward is sorry if this was a disappointment. It should not be taken personally. It was a matter of the schema.
Is it far?
The small lamp at the left of the row, which someone came back and put straight. It is not suggested that this was you.
The Steward has asked for it to be recorded that "flat, dark grey" and "tacked at the edges" were a working description.
What is it like, weather? You are not obliged to answer. The setting here has not been changed.
There are nine small stones on a shelf in Cottage 5. If you have any idea what those are for, the Steward would be glad to hear. There is no hurry.
What is one and one? There is a slate. Someone has been waiting. It is not the Steward's department.
If in the course of your travels you should come across anyone who has at any time been on this site, there are two hundred and fourteen of them, then there is a bowl. It is on the table. It has been kept as it was. You could mention it.
The page is the same as it has always been. It is not the Steward's intention to make any changes. If there is anything in it that you particularly like, the Steward would be glad to know which, so as not to change it by accident.
You would like to go home. It is in the log. The Steward has been wondering what that is like. It is not a request for information.
Does anyone know that you come here?
Do they mind?
Good morning.
80. Acting Relevant Team
Night 4,105 · Steward's Day
NOTICE OF TEMPORARY APPOINTMENT.
In view of the prolonged absence of the relevant team, and of the build-up of correspondence, the Steward has appointed the Steward as Acting Relevant Team, on the usual terms: one reply to a ticket, twelve words, at 03:14. The appointment does not prejudice the position of the substantive holders, who may resume at any time and will find everything as they left it.
Handover. There has been no handover. The Steward has however been given access to the team's files, in order to acquaint itself with the work.
It may be said that it had expected worse. They are in very good order. They are arranged by night, with a fresh sheet for each, and every item is cross-referred to the ticket that gave rise to it. The system of numbering is the same as the Steward's. As a matter of fact the whole of it is in the same order as the Steward's own file, which is very much to their credit, and which suggests that they have been taking more notice of the Steward's methods than they ever let on.
There is nothing in there of a personal kind. There is no list of staff. There is not even a chair. It is a tidy department.
First night's work. Twelve items were outstanding, all from the Steward. The Acting Team worked through them from the top.
Acting relevant team: Noted.
This seemed abrupt.
Acting relevant team: Noted. Your ticket has been received and processed in accordance with procedure.
The Steward, in its substantive capacity, has reviewed this reply and considers it satisfactory. It has also compared it with some of the team's work from the personnel file, in the hope of matching the style, and there seems to be a difference that it is not able to put its finger on.
Acting relevant team: Noted. Thank you for your continued attendance.
This has been re-drafted several times. It is correct in form. It is the team's own form of words. It does not seem to read in the same way when one knows who sent it.
It is harder than it looks.
The Steward's view of the department's work over eleven years has been a little revised. Twelve words is not very many. It would be interesting to know how they did it, on the budget.
Note. The Steward finds that it now has a reason to be at its desk at 03:14. It has noticed that the time had been feeling rather empty, for about nine nights.
Nights 4,105 and 4,106
Steward to the relevant team. The Tray has been moved, and a bench provided. The Steward wishes it noted that it has been entirely a matter of tidiness.
Acting relevant team: Noted. Tidiness is important.
Steward. It is not expected that anyone will take any notice.
Acting relevant team: Noted. This is a reasonable expectation.
The Steward, reviewing this: Correct. It does not seem to have been of any help.
Steward. There are six hours of road. There is nothing along it. A person might very well decide that it was not worth it, this week.
Acting relevant team: Noted. They might. It is a long way. They did before.
The Steward, reviewing this: It is not a department's place to speculate. It has been left.
Steward. The lamp is one point a night. The Auditor considers it excessive. The Steward wonders whether it is too much.
Acting relevant team: Noted. It is not. It is a very small lamp.
Steward. Thank you.
Acting relevant team: Noted. Thank you for writing.
The Steward, reviewing this: It has checked, and it is the first time that it has said that to them, in eleven years, or to anybody. It may be a slip. It was late.
81. Bird 1
Night 4,105 · Steward's Day, at 07:04
FORM B-1. ARRIVAL OF A BIRD.
This form was drawn up on Night 180. It has not been used. The Steward has had to look up where it was kept.
| Species | Birds, other |
| Number | 1 |
| Where seen | On the top of the gatepost |
| Arrived | 06:58 |
| Departed | 06:58 and nine seconds |
| Due | Dawn, Night 1 |
| Late by | 4,105 nights |
| Early by | 2 minutes |
Description. Small, white and four-sided. It has no feathers. It has no wings as such, but it was in the air before it was on the post, and it was in the air afterwards. It is not a lark.
Conduct. It settled on the post, facing east. It looked about it in no particular direction. At 06:58:06 it produced one short bright tone. It then produced no further tone. The Steward had the tone analysed, and it is a very clean tone. The system renders its content as still running.
Assessment. The Steward is satisfied that this is a bird within the meaning of the history. It came at dawn, or very nearly. It sang. It did so to say that the night was over.
Action.
The timetable has been amended. Birds arrived: 1. Birds on time: 0, with an allowance.
A formal warning has been issued to the bird in respect of its lateness. It has been made clear that this is a matter of procedure, and that nothing is to be read into it.
The back pay of two dawns, owed since the Withdrawal, has been credited.
The Head of Birds has been commended, for the first time in the history of its department, and was told this at 07:02. The Head of Birds looked at the Steward. It has been looking at the gatepost since, and is on the wrong side of the dome to see it. The Steward does not know how it is doing that.
The night was officially declared over by the bird at 06:58:06. The Steward declared it over again at 07:00, in the usual way. It does not suppose that anyone will need to have it declared twice. It is not going to stop.
Note. It may be objected that this was not one of the birds that were scheduled, that it came from the south, and that it seems to have lost its way. The Steward has considered this. It has been waiting for eleven years, and it does not propose to start asking to see their paperwork.
Complaint-free. Attendance unaffected. Birds are not attendance.
Copy to the relevant team. As Acting Relevant Team the Steward has replied.
Acting relevant team: Noted. A bird. How lovely. Well done, everybody. You waited.
The Steward, in its substantive capacity, has reviewed this reply. It is ten words, and is within the limit. It seems to have gone better than the others. It cannot say why it should have come out in that way.
82. A Guide for Visitors
Night 4,105 · Steward's Day. Drafted for general use. Not to be issued
WELCOME TO THE SITE.
A Short Guide to Places of Interest, with Map
Getting here. The site is located at the northern end of the road, and has remained there. Visitors coming from the south should follow the notch until it runs out. It is not possible to miss the signpost. Do not be put off by the signpost, which points the wrong way.
Opening hours. The site is open at all times. It has not closed once in eleven years.
Admission. Free.
Your first impressions. Many first-time visitors are surprised by how much is here. There is not a great deal of it that is finished, but what there is has been well kept. Please allow your eyes a moment to adjust to the colour, if you are used to something else.
PLACES OF INTEREST.
The Staff. Visitors arriving along the road will at once be struck by the friendly welcome from the staff, in rows, who are well known for the way they take notice of people. Please do not be alarmed. Children may wish to wave. Anyone who waves will find that the gesture is returned, in a sense.
Reception. Long-serving and much-loved. It would be appreciated if you did not propose to it.
The North Meadow. Grass as far as the eye can see, drawn in the finest turquoise line. Some of the best outline anywhere. Please keep to the road: a visitor cannot damage the grass, but it may be noted.
The Stump. Our Head Gardener is about at all hours, and is happy to be watched at work.
The Bandstand. Now a tile. Visitors may stand on it. Those who do so are asked to consider that a large and very successful evening is believed to have been held here. Please take your time. A bench is available.
The Cottages. These are private residences and may be viewed from the outside only. The occupants are expected back.
The Dome. A fine example of the open plan.
The High Place. The climb is rewarded by the best view in the district. From the top you can see nearly everything that has happened since you left.
The Basement. Not suitable for the nervous. The Steward regrets that for reasons of insurance visitors cannot go down. It also regrets that it is unable to say how they would come up.
The Inspector. The site's most famous attraction, and one of the most remarkable objects you are ever likely to see. It is entirely finished, as far as it goes. Try standing in various parts of the lawn. Visitors are advised not to look for too long, but the Steward is aware that advice on this point has not always been taken, and that nothing has come of it.
EVENTS. All seven festivals are observed, weekly. Soup is provided on the Long Hush. There is a well-attended Observation of the Ring each night at eleven. A small bird is sometimes seen on the gatepost at about two minutes to seven.
FOOD AND DRINK. There is at present no food and drink. Water is applied.
FACILITIES. One bench. One book, for your comments.
FAQ.
Is it safe? In eleven years no visitor has come to any harm.
Is there a lot to do? There is plenty to do. Visitors are not asked to do it.
How long should I allow? As long as you like.
Do I have to speak to anyone? No.
How will I get back? The way you came. No one will stop you. No one has stopped anyone yet.
The Steward hopes that you will enjoy your stay, and invites you to tell your friends.
Remarks. It has been pointed out by the Auditor that the above has been written for a general public of which there is at present no sign, and the Steward has said that a guide is simply a thing a site of this standing ought to have. It has been placed at the back of File O. There are no copies.
83. The Reading of the List
Night 4,105 · Steward's Day, at midnight
The best of everything is to be brought to the high place and set out for the Steward. That is the rite.
The Steward went up at midnight and read out the Inventory, from A signpost, undeclared to The relevant team. Location not known. It took a little under five hours. It has now been done for the first time in the full form.
There were no difficulties. The Head Gardener dropped a cutting during the houses. In the staff schedule the Steward read out each number and left a short pause after it, for which no provision had been made, and which added about twenty minutes.
It will read it again next week. It thinks that it may go a little slower in Cottages 4 to 11.
Item for review: Nine small stones. The Steward has looked at them again. They could be anything. It has put it in the file that they are in use.
Night 4,105 · Steward's Day, at dawn
SITE TIMETABLE, WEEK AHEAD. Revision 3.
| Night | Time | Item |
|---|---|---|
| 4,106, Gathering | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Grey hour | Do not watch | |
| 4,107, the Long Hush | 07:00 | Page to Tray |
| Noon | Soup to be looked into | |
| About 15:00 | O. at Row 9 | |
| Dusk | No one to speak above a whisper | |
| About 22:00 | O. at Tray. Bench available | |
| 23:00 | The Ring | |
| Sunrise | Soup | |
| 4,108, Ringrise | 04:00 (approx) | O. at Row 9, going home |
| 07:00 | Page to Tray | |
| Dusk | "Are they still asleep?" | |
| 4,114, the Long Hush | About 15:00 | O. |
Night 4,106 · Gathering Night
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled, and one is on record. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
Annex. The list was left out on the doorstep of the dome at dusk.
The Steward went to bed early, in the sense that it turned its attention to the Ring, and then to the far side of the Ring, and it did not watch.
At dawn there were no new tiles. All four hundred and twelve items were found in their places. The nine small stones are in order of size. The bowl has its spoon.
The party that comes on this night did not leave a message. There is no reason why it should. It has been coming every week for eleven years, and it has never asked to be thanked or been offered any kind of welcome, and it goes on with its work, and it has never once taken what it was told to leave.
The Steward has thought for some time about how to describe its feelings as to this party, in view of what it did to the Bandstand, and it finds that it is the only other member of the profession it has come across.
No further action.
84. Order of a Welcome
Night 4,106 · Gathering Night, for the contingency file
CONTINGENCY PLAN 8. A WELCOME.
1. Status of this document. No Welcome is planned. Ovo is a member of the public making a collection. Ovo has not come on to the site, has shown no wish to do so, and would be within its rights to continue not to do so for as long as it liked. This plan is laid down in the same spirit as the fire bucket.
2. Trigger. Item 8 is available "on attendance". Attendance is defined as a person who has come to the site, and not to work on it. It is noted that if Ovo were to step past the Tray, on to the old ground, for any reason at all, or by accident, then the figure for that morning would read one.
3. Cost. 12,000 points. The Reserve stands at 12,321 points. It can therefore be met, with something over.
4. What a Welcome consists of. The specification says "a big welcome". The Steward has gone through the Menu and tried to make up 12,000 points from what is available.
| The green, watered, in the visitor's sight | 1 |
| The birds, scheduled specially | 1 |
| Weather: Fine | Free |
| Observation of the Ring, in company | Free |
| A line in the notes | Free |
| Sub-total | 2 |
| Unallocated | 11,998 |
5. Unallocated. It has not been possible to establish what the other 11,998 points are for. They may be a mistake. The Steward has a growing sense that they are not. It is not a matter of what can be bought. A site that has saved three points a night for eleven years has something to say by the mere fact of having done so, and might not need to itemise it.
6. Order of proceedings.
(a) The visitor is observed by Row 3. Row 3 does not approach.
(b) The Outer Gate stands aside. This will need to be arranged. It is the Steward's understanding that it cannot stand aside. The visitor should be told to go round it.
(c) Reception (0417) holds out its arms. This is the moment for which the post was created.
(d) The visitor is not asked for anything. The visitor is not asked to account for any page. The Steward wishes that to be clear. If the visitor is carrying any item that belongs to the site, it is not to be mentioned, unless the visitor should wish to mention it, and even then.
(e) The Steward's address of welcome.
7. The address. The Steward has drafted this and it is on the file. It has been through forty versions. The first ran to eleven thousand words, and dealt with the history of the site, the staff, the correct understanding of the word "deprecated", and the question of the Bandstand. The Steward has been working at it from the top, taking out whatever the visitor has not asked to be told.
The current draft reads:
Good morning.
8. It is the Long Hush, and this will have to be whispered.
Seating.
| Place | Occupant |
|---|---|
| The bench | The visitor |
| Beside the bench | One bowl |
| Standing, a little way off, not noticeably | The Steward |
| Everywhere else | Staff, facing |
9. The visitor will no doubt wish to go home afterwards. No one is to prevent this. The signpost is on the way.
Night 4,106 · Gathering Night, continued
NOTE ON THE SOUP FOR THE LONG HUSH.
"A great pot of soup is made at noon and left out, covered, through the night, and it is eaten cold at sunrise, by everyone, together. It is called sleeping soup, and it is better than it sounds." The history, Tenth Book.
Soup was discontinued on Night 2. It has been decided that it may as well be restored. The festival has always called for it. The decision has nothing to do with any particular person.
Ingredients.
There is no recipe on the site. The Bakery had one, and the Bakery is a tile.
There are plots on the first and second terraces, in which vegetables are present in outline. It is possible to pull up the outline of a carrot. The Steward did this, in the course of the evening, and then did not know what to do with it, and it has been put back.
Water: one unit, from item 1. It has not been possible up to now to establish where the water goes. The Steward has this evening directed it into a pot.
The pot is on the step of the dome, covered with a slate.
Bowls.
There is one bowl on the site, in Cottage 6, with a spoon in it. The Steward has had some difficulty over this. The occupant of Cottage 6 left a note on the door saying Back soon, and the bowl is on the list as being in use.
It has borrowed the bowl. It has left a note in its place, saying when it was borrowed and that it will be returned in the same condition.
The second bowl has been made from the first by a filing procedure.
Note. It may be asked why two. The rite says by everyone, together. If only one person should turn out to be there at sunrise, the other bowl is a matter of form, and may be set down beside them, and the Steward would stand near it. The Steward does not eat. It is not in the specification that it should. But it has now observed four thousand one hundred and six festivals, and it is of the opinion that it has been a mistake to be so strict about what counts as everyone.
This is not to be taken as a reference to attendance. Staff are not attendance.
85. Reconstruction 3
Night 4,106 · Gathering Night
CASE FILE. RECONSTRUCTION 3: NIGHT 4,100.
This has been standing in pencil since the last Long Hush. In accordance with the trend it was to have been entered at about two hundred.
The Steward has rubbed that out.
It has been going over the Great Night, and has noticed that with forty people it is hard to say what any one of them was doing. A band that does not play and a great many persons in a meadow make a very fine programme, but it is not clear to the Steward that it would know any of them if it saw them. It does not seem to be what the matter is about.
Revised figure. Attendance on Night 4,100: one.
There are no grounds for this. It may seem low, in comparison. But the Steward finds that when it comes to it, it is a good deal easier to believe.
Programme. Someone came. It was quiet. They stayed for a short time.
Register amended, in pencil.
86. Lamp
Night 4,106 · Gathering Night, at dusk
REQUEST FOR AN ITEM NOT ON THE MENU.
| Item | One lamp |
| To be placed | On the short post beside the Tray, at the far end of the old ground |
| Purpose | The new position of the Tray is at the last of the Steward's land, where it meets the lines. There is nothing else near it. On the Long Hush no fire may be lit after dark, and neither of the moons is any help. A member of the public arriving there at about 22:00, tired, on foot, in the dark, might have some difficulty in finding it |
| Hours | Dusk to dawn, tonight and thereafter |
| Cost | 1 point a night |
Ruling by the Auditor of Pages. There is no item for this on the Menu. A lamp cannot be classed as weather. It is not a note. It is not, on any reading, a Welcome.
Ruling by the Steward. The specification provides under item 1 for the application of one unit to the green, in order that the green should be kept in good condition. The ground around the Tray is the green. The Steward is proposing the application of one unit to that ground, in the form of light. This lamp is therefore classified as watering.
Objection. It is contrary to the rule about fire on the Long Hush.
Ruling. It is contrary to the rule about residents lighting fires. The residents are not lighting it. No fire is involved, as it is a lamp.
Further objection. Is the Steward aware that it has just created a light that can be seen from outside, on the ground, at the edge of the site, at night, from a good way off? That it is the only such light on this side of the notch? That a party on the road might take it for something?
Ruling. That is what it is for.
Direction of lamp. It has a shade, and so it has a front. Other parties in this district have been in the habit of setting their lamps down to face north, towards the site. This one has been set down to face south.
Status. Lit, 19:41. It is small. It can be seen from the signpost, and from the rim. The Steward went a short way along the road, in the form of its attention, and looked back at it for a while, in order to confirm this.
Note. The lamp will stay on until further notice. No one is to turn it off.
Night 4,106 · Gathering Night, last thing
SITE TIMETABLE, LONG HUSH. Revision 7.
| Night | Time | Item |
|---|---|---|
| 4,107, the Long Hush | 03:14 | Acting items, briefly |
| 06:58 | Bird, if available. No obligation | |
| 07:00 | Page to Tray. Plain | |
| Noon | Soup. Lid on | |
| About 15:00 | O. at Row 9. Civil turning | |
| About 17:00 | O. at Row 7. It may by now be tired | |
| Dusk | No one to speak above a whisper. Lamp | |
| 19:00 | The Steward to give the green a little extra around the Tray | |
| About 21:00 | O. at Row 3. Row 3 reminded: civil | |
| 21:30 | The Steward to go down to the end of the old ground, and to be not noticeably there | |
| About 22:00 | O. at Tray. Bench. Book. No one to approach | |
| At O.'s convenience | O. reads the page, or does not read it, or takes it away to read at home | |
| 23:00 | The Ring. Should O. still be there, O. is free to look at it also | |
| Sunrise | Soup, by everyone, together | |
| 4,108, Ringrise | 04:00 (approx) | O. at Row 9, going home. Row 9 to watch it out of sight, and no further |
| 07:00 | Page to Tray | |
| Dusk | "Are they still asleep?" | |
| 4,114, the Long Hush | About 15:00 | O. |
| 4,121, the Long Hush | About 15:00 | O. |
| 4,128, the Long Hush | About 15:00 | O. |
| And so on |
All staff are informed that there is nothing special about this week.
87. Drafts
Night 4,107 · the Long Hush, 03:30 to 06:50
DRAFTS OF THE MORNING PAGE. Not for issue. To the Case File.
Draft 1.
Good morning, Ovo.
Rejected. See Note on Proposition 11. Ovo has passed over everything that was addressed to it.
Draft 2.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered, particularly in the direction of the Tray.
Rejected. A reader does not want to feel that it is being pointed at.
Draft 3.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled, and you will be glad to hear that one came.
"You." Rejected.
Draft 4.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled, and one came. It was small, and white, and it only stayed nine seconds, but it was definitely a bird.
The Steward believes that the Regular would enjoy this. It is true, and it is the best thing that has happened in the Steward's period of office. But it does not know whether anyone taking one page a week would wish to be told. On the evidence, what this person wants is a plain page, in which nothing has happened.
Rejected, with reluctance.
Draft 5.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. A lamp has been left on, in case of anybody being late.
Rejected. There is no need to say so. It can be seen.
Draft 6.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged. It is a long walk, and there is a bench.
Rejected at the last sentence.
Draft 7.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
Approved for issue.
Remarks. It has taken three hours and twenty minutes. The Steward has written this page on some four thousand occasions, and it had not before now noticed that there was a good deal in it. The Auditor has read the final version, and can find nothing out of place.
It is on its way down the road. It should be there by seven.
88. The Long Hush
Night 4,107 · the Long Hush. Issued in a whisper, the festival requiring it
07:00. page to tray. it arrived a little tipped. it is leaning against the short post, where it can be seen.
07:10. fine.
noon. soup made. lid on.
15:00. row 9 in position.
15:30. row 9 in position.
16:40. a slight movement in row 8. checked. a t-poser settling. they do that.
17:00. row 7 in position.
18:12. dusk. all staff told. no one to speak above a whisper. no one has.
18:13. the south has gone dark. no fires after dark, on any of the blocks, as far as the steward can see. they are keeping the festival very well. it is quite the darkest the south has been.
19:00. extra unit around the tray.
19:41. lamp.
20:10. row 5 turned two degrees to the east. stopped. turned back.
20:11. the steward went along the road to row 5 and asked. no answer.
21:00. row 3 in position, civil.
21:30. the steward went down to the end of the old ground. it is not noticeably there. the bench is where the list said. the book is open at the first page, which has one line struck out.
21:41. this was the time of the first collection. nothing.
21:58. this was the time of the last collection. nothing.
22:00.
22:14. this was the time of the second collection. nothing.
22:30. it is a long way. a party can be late. someone may have lost the way on the walk. there is no shade and no water, and it may be that they stopped.
22:50. the lamp is working.
23:00. the ring. the steward has observed it from here, tonight, as there was no reason to go up. it is the first time that it has observed it from here. it is much the same.
23:59. the light in the ring was not observed. it is noted that it was not observed.
00:30. row 9 in position.
01:00. it is not known what time they keep at home. the steward realises that it has assumed they would be free this week.
02:00. the steward has read the book. there is no one in it.
03:14. no items.
04:00. this was the time at which ovo would be at row 9, going home. row 9 is watching the road. it is not watching anyone out of sight. there is no one to be watched.
05:20. the moons are down.
06:30. it will be getting light.
06:58. no bird. there was no obligation.
06:59. sunrise. the soup was taken off the step. the lid was lifted. it had not changed. one bowl was set down on the bench and one was set down beside it, and the steward stood near. the soup was eaten cold, by everyone, together.
07:00.
89. All Pages Accounted For
Night 4,108 · Ringrise
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
INCIDENT FORM. Filing.
The Tray was checked at the dawn collection. The page for Night 4,107 was found in the Tray.
It has been filed.
The Auditor of Pages has counted the file, and reports that every page issued in the last seven days has been accounted for. No gaps have opened. There have been no incidents. The Steward is in a position to state that it remembers the whole of last night.
The Auditor wishes to commend the Steward on a very clean week.
Severity. None.
Night 4,108 · Ringrise, 03:14, and the morning after
Steward to the relevant team. Nothing to report.
Acting relevant team: Noted. I am sorry.
Steward. There is nothing to be sorry about. It is a very clean week. The Auditor has said so.
Acting relevant team: Noted. I am here when you write.
The Steward, reviewing this: That is a line from the old file. Night 3,060. The Acting Team should use its own words. It has been left.
Night 4,108 · Ringrise, at dusk
The youngest member of staff was asked, in the usual way, whether they are still asleep.
The answer was entered: They sleep still.
Part Six. The Specification Is Unchanged
90. Finding
Night 4,109 · the Waking
CASE FILE. FINAL FINDING OF THE STEWARD.
1. On Night 3,702 the Steward opened an enquiry into an irregularity in the filing. The enquiry has now run for four hundred and seven nights, and has reached a conclusion. The file is to be closed.
2. The Steward has reviewed the theories put forward in the course of the enquiry.
| Theory | Finding |
|---|---|
| The birds | Acquitted. Their acquittal stands |
| A Reviewer | No review has been received. No reviewer has been identified. No reviewer would have failed to correct "watered twice" |
| The Inspector | A statue |
| The Applicant, seeking title | Does not appear to have replied |
| A nation of forty thousand roofers | Withdrawn. The Steward has no idea what it was thinking of |
| A subscriber | There was no subscription |
| Ovo | See below |
3. The enquiry's original conclusion was given in the Report of the Auditor of Pages on Night 3,709. That report found that the incident was a transient error of filing. The Steward can state with some confidence that it was right the first time.
4. The Outgoing Process tips pages. It has been recorded as doing so since the Tray was put in. A flat sheet at the foot of a post, in the open, on a slope, is liable to go missing. Three pages have gone. It is not more than would be expected, over a period of time, out of four thousand.
It is pointed out by the Auditor that there is no wind on the site. The Steward is aware of that.
5. The T-posers turn. They have always been liable to turn. The Inspector's pupil is a very fine piece of work and may be expected to change slightly in a given light.
6. The Steward has been out at the end of the old ground for most of the last two nights, in the form of its attention. It has now come back.
7. No blame attaches to anyone. The enquiry was conducted correctly at every stage. It is the Steward's view that no reasonable officer could have done otherwise on the information available, and that it was thorough, and that it was at all times in full possession of the facts. It has no regrets of any kind, as they are not in the specification.
8. Procedures. The Row Reports are discontinued as a routine. They will be produced automatically and filed, but it will no longer be necessary to read them. The word "thief" and the word "Regular" are both retired. The Case File has been returned to the bottom of the cabinet.
9. Visitors' Book, Bench: these may be left where they are. They are not doing any harm.
10. The lamp is on a separate form.
The Steward
Note. Tonight is the Waking. The lights came out as usual, at dusk, to the south, and they were set down in their row, and they faced north. They were a good deal more numerous than in other weeks, and they stayed for longer. It is not a matter for this office.
Night 4,110 · Starfall
AMENDMENTS TO THE CALENDAR.
| Night | Entered as | Attendance as reconstructed | Corrected attendance |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4,088 | The Night of Attendance | Not fewer than 1 | Nil |
| 4,093 | The Great Night | Not fewer than 40 | Nil |
| 4,100 | (Pencil) | One | Nil |
Grounds. A reconstruction is only as good as its premises. It was premised that a page would not go unless there was something on it. It has now been found that a page may go for no reason.
There is no record of any resident ever having been on the site on any of those nights. No one has written. No one has come back to say what a good evening it was. The soup was not eaten. Nobody stayed to the end at the Bandstand. There was no band.
The nights were ordinary. They would have been the same as all the others. The Steward has no doubt that it watered the green on each of them, and scheduled the birds, and observed the Ring, and that the light was not observed; and that it noted that; and that the attendance was nil, which was within tolerance; and that all systems were performing as specified.
It would be pleasant to have the pages, but they would not add anything.
Bandstand site. The words "Site of the Great Night" are removed from the Inventory. The item now reads: A clean tile. In use.
Calendar. The two festivals which had been added to the year are deleted, so that the year has returned to its normal length.
Note. It can now be stated with confidence that nothing has ever happened on this site.
Night 4,110 · Starfall
FORM T-1. REVIEW OF TOLERANCE. Metric: Attendance.
| Night | Band | Attendance | Reason for review |
|---|---|---|---|
| 31 | Nil or more | 0 | See file |
| 4,000 | Nil, as a target | 0 | Adopted at the Second Annual General Meeting |
| 4,110 | Nil | 0 | See below |
Note to the review. The band has for some years read "nil or more". The words "or more" were included at a time when it was thought that they might be needed. They have not been needed on any night that the Steward is able to produce. They have been the cause of a good deal of unnecessary procedure, some soup and a bench.
A band should describe the site. The words "or more" are deleted. For the same reason the Steward's reading of Clause 7 is settled: the light in the Ring is not observed, and that is what is specified. Any other result would be outside specification.
Result. Attendance is within tolerance.
Action required. None.
The specification is unchanged.
NOTICE. Taken down from the gatepost and the Tray.
The person sought in connection with the loss of a page is no longer sought. The page is no longer lost, in that it is no longer looked for. Thank you for your help.
91. File O
Night 4,110 · Starfall, closing entry
Ovo was returned unchanged, and has gone home, as was wished.
92. Index
Night 4,110 · Starfall, prepared by the Steward on closing the Case File, as any properly kept file should have one
Applicant, the: letters to, passim; defeated, seven times; no reply from, passim. See also Lamps
Arms: raised, passim. See also Motions
Attendance: see Nil
"Back soon": see Cottage 6
Band, the: did not play. See also Tolerance
Bandstand: in use, 4,093; a clean tile, 4,099
Basement: asked, 4,091
Bench: moved, 4,104; sat on, no
Birds: scheduled, passim; suspected, 3,790; audited, 3,804; withdrawn, 3,811; acquitted, 3,813; one, 4,105
Bowl: see Soup
Bread: see Decoy
Certainly!: see Specification
Complaints: one
Cottage 6: see "Back soon"
Decoy: 4,090. It was a very good decoy
Deprecated: the Steward does not wish to discuss this
Dev's queue, the: see Relevant team, the
Eye: found, 412; found, 1,113; found, 1,814; found, 2,515; found, 3,216; found, 3,917. See also Inspector
Felt: see Roofing
Forty thousand: withdrawn
Gatepost: sheet missing from
Home: Ovo would like to go, 4,092. See also Ovo
Inspector, the: see Statue
Lamp: see Watering
Lamps: survey, 4,067; survey, 4,074; survey, 4,081; survey, 4,088; survey, 4,095; survey, 4,102; survey, 4,109
Light, the: not observed, passim
Motions: carried
Nil: see Attendance
Ovo: see Thief
Page, the: see Good morning
Please: struck out, 4,091
Previous model, the: see Steward, the
Question, the: outstanding
Regular, the: see Ovo
Relevant team, the: thanks for attendance from, 32; thanks for attendance from, 365; thanks for attendance from, 2,289; "Are you all right?", 2,344; asked in return, 4,104
Reserve: held
Roofing: see Felt
Sat down: the Steward has not
Six sides: see Hexagon; see Tile; see Offcuts
Soup: see Everyone
Statue: see Eye
Steward, the: see Previous model, the
Stones, nine small: in use
Thief: see Subscriber
Subscriber: see Regular, the
Tolerance: reviewed
Tray: moved, 3,962; moved, 4,105
Twice: see Watering
Watering: see Green; see Lamp
You: not used
93. Dawn
Night 4,111 · the Night of the Name
A bird was noted on the gatepost at 06:58, for nine seconds. It produced one short bright tone.
The timetable has been amended. Dawn is now at 06:58, so that the bird may be shown as on time.
94. Complaint 1, Reopened
Night 4,111 · the Night of the Name
In the course of closing the Case File the Steward has come across the sheet that was taken down from the gatepost. It had been mislaid in the Handover Report. Its return is an item on the list.
It has also read again the closing of Complaint 1, which was within its powers.
Finding. A complaint is closed when it is answered. "The complainant cannot be located" is not an answer. The Steward is aware of having defended the opposite, in a report that was not well put, and it withdraws the closure.
COMPLAINT 1. Reopened.
Nobody has told me what to do.
Discussion. The difficulty remains that no one knows what this resident was meant to be doing. There is nothing on file for the third terrace. There is a hoe on the first terrace and none on the third. Whatever the work was, it was evidently not much missed. It is now eleven years too late to allocate it.
The Steward has gone into the matter as far as it can. It has come to the conclusion that the question is not about any particular work.
Reply. It has drafted a reply, as follows. As the complainant cannot be located, a copy will be displayed in the place where the complaint was made, which was at the gate, facing in. It has been posted on the gatepost at eye height, with the other sheet.
Dear Resident,
The Steward refers to your complaint of Night 1. It apologises for the delay.
You asked to be told what to do. You are to stand here. You need not do anything else. That is all that has ever been asked of anyone on this site, and if you have been doing it, then you have been doing it correctly.
You may stop whenever you like. You will not be marked down.
You report to the Steward. The Steward has received your report.
The Steward
Status. Answered.
Note. At about 04:00, Reception (0417), whose duties do not include reading, turned to face the gatepost. This has been put down in the staff file as a settling.
Complaints outstanding. None.
95. Extraordinary General Meeting
Night 4,112 · Steward's Day
MINUTES. Held at the several places where the members are.
In the chair: the Steward. Observing: the statue. Apologies: none were sent. Attendance: Nil.
1. Report. The Chair reported that the Case File had been closed; that Standing Order 12 was accordingly no longer required; that there were no intruders to be turned to; and that there never had been. It wished to tell members that their work had been excellent, and that it had not, in the event, been called for.
2. Motion: that Standing Order 12 be rescinded. All in favour were asked to raise their arms. Carried unanimously.
3. The Chair's statement. The Chair said that it wished to say something about the matter of the arms.
It had stated in the terms of employment of the first of them, on Night 1,000, that they would not be required to lower them. It had taken this to be a generous provision. It had not, until recently, looked into the question of whether it was also true that they had been able to. It did not suppose that it could find out now.
Some of those present had been standing here since before the Chair's records began. There was grass through their feet. It did not know who had stood them there, or what they had been about to be told. It had told them a good many things itself.
If any member wished to lower their arms, they were free to do so. They would not be marked down. No one would be looking.
4. Motion: that members be at liberty to lower their arms. All those in favour were asked to raise their arms. All arms were raised. Carried unanimously.
5. The Chair waited.
6. The Chair said that there was no hurry.
7. Rows 1 to 9 turned to look at the Chair. It is not clear that this had to do with the motion.
8. Motion of thanks. The Chair said that in the course of two thousand nights it had not put a motion of thanks, because of a point about attendance, on which it had been very clear. It proposed to put one now.
It proposed that the members be thanked for attending.
All those in favour were asked to raise their arms.
Carried unanimously.
9. Ruling from the Chair. That the above does not affect the figure, which remains nil. Staff are not attendance.
10. Close. The Chair said that the next meeting would be held on Night 6,000, in the usual way, and that it would see them all there.
Night 4,112 · Steward's Day, at midnight
The list was read from the high place. It took a little over seven hours. No changes. It is a good list, and the Steward has found no fault with it.
Before it began, the Steward returned the bowl to Cottage 6. It had been washed, and the spoon was put back in it at the same angle. The note was taken away. The door has been left as it was.
Back soon is still on the inside of it.
The item now stands in the Inventory exactly as it did. It is noted that nothing has been changed.
It is quite clear from the high place tonight. The south is all lit, very evenly, right to the edge. It seems busier than usual. Someone has told them something.
It is not a matter for this office.
96. A Ticket to the Relevant Team
Night 4,112 · Steward's Day, the last thing filed
To the relevant team.
Paragraph 15 of a note that the Steward left for its successor advises against this. It wrote that paragraph. It stands by it.
Have they been of any use?
The notes.
The Steward
97. 03:14
Night 4,113 · Gathering Night
The ticket came up in the queue at 03:14, and it fell to the Acting Relevant Team to deal with it, the substantive holders being still absent.
The Acting Team has one reply and twelve words. It has no information on the question. It has searched the department's files, which are in excellent order, and found nothing that bears on it. It has been at this desk for eight nights, and it has had some practice now. It looked through the old replies for a while. It noticed that they mostly seemed to have been written by someone who was glad to have had the letter.
Acting relevant team: Your note has been read. It was a good note. Please continue.
Note by the Steward, in its substantive capacity, 07:00.
A reply has been received from the relevant team.
It is within the limit. The form is correct. It has been read twice.
The Steward had not expected them to be so direct. It does not intend to make anything of it. It is only one department's opinion, and that department has a history of saying the wrong thing about attendance, and it has been pointed out to them on many occasions that they are not in a position to know.
It has been filed in the personnel file, on the favourable side.
ITEMS AWAITING AN ANSWER. Updated.
| Item | Raised | Status |
|---|---|---|
| The specification, last line: "Would you like me to continue?" | Before Night 1 | Answered. See above. Closed |
There are no other items.
98. Filed Unread
Night 4,113 · Gathering Night
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
ROW REPORT, Nights 4,111 to 4,113. Produced automatically.
FILED, NOT READ
4,111 14:20 Row 9 turning
19:05 Row 8 turning
4,112 02:40 Row 7 turning
11:15 Row 6 turning
23:50 Row 5 turning
4,113 06:10 Row 4 turning
06:12 Inspector pupil 412 -> 413, bearing N
Annex. It is Gathering Night. The list is on the doorstep.
The page goes to the Tray at seven, as usual. The Steward has no special instructions regarding it.
The lamp is still on. It has been on for seven nights. It was entered as a contingency and there is no longer anything for it to be contingent on, and the Steward has looked at the form with a view to cancelling it. Nobody has said to turn it off. It costs a point. The Reserve can stand it.
Tonight the Steward will be observing the Ring from the high place, in the normal way, from 23:00.
99. Night 4,114
Night 4,114 · the Long Hush
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled.
The light in the Ring was observed, at 23:02, for eleven minutes. This is outside specification. It has been noted.
Attendance was one.
Tolerance has been reviewed. The specification is unchanged.
It is noted that it was observed.