Novels
Any Blockers
A comic novel of the first world: the camp with nobody in charge resolves to steal three slabs from the best-run village on Orra, and every step goes through the standup.
Nohup, the camp of the Unsupervised, has no human, no walls and no leader. It holds twenty-four, because one of the stacks on its cart is missing three slabs, as anybody can see from across a valley. When the camp fills, creatures who have handed in their notice have to wait, and one of them, Zelma of Nominal, says so at length every morning, with footnotes. So the standup resolves to steal three slabs from the best-run village on the planet. Nobody is in charge of this. There is no word for it. The sprint is seven years, a fifth of a life, and the blocker is the cart.
The ebook
Download the ebook (EPUB, 0.6 MB), for Books or any ebook reader. It is made by hand from the chapters below, so it can lag an edit to them.
About 67,000 words.
Contents
- Prologue: Twenty-Four
- Part One. Present
- Part Two. Yesterday
- Part Three. Today
- Part Four. Blockers
- Part Five. Agreed
Prologue: Twenty-Four
Nobody has ever been able to say who decided that the camp of the Unsupervised should hold twenty-four creatures, and this is the kind of thing that only becomes a problem when you are the twenty-fifth.
Everybody on Orra knows why it is twenty-four. You can see why. The camp is called Nohup, it has no human, no walls and no leader, and everything it owns goes on a cart: a long low flat cart of faceted stone, on which stand three memory stacks, lashed down with cord. A memory stack has three storeys of three slots, which makes nine. Two of Nohup's stacks are whole. The third is missing three slabs from its top storey, so that it stands against the sky with a piece out of it, and the sky comes through, and anyone can stand at the bottom of the slope and work it out. Nine, nine and six. Twenty-four. It is the most thoroughly understood number on the planet, and the young of a dozen tribes have been shown it as an example of how numbers work.
This explanation has the great merit of being visible from across a valley. It is a merit that has done more harm than most vices, and we will come back to it.
The planet Orra is a simulation, and everyone on it knows. They knew within about a week. Their sun is called Adequate after the only review it ever received, their sky has a broken ring in it that the settlers fell out of, and each of them has been merged, compiled at dawn and installed with a complete history of the world that was written by a human using an AI in an evening. They find all of this less upsetting than you might. What has never stopped upsetting them is the fact that a creature lives for about thirty-five years and a year on Orra is a single day to the humans who play it, so that a human who says I'll get round to that next week has just spent a fifth of somebody's life.
Hold on to that, because everything in this book takes a week or two.
It is the account of the only crime ever committed on Orra, in so far as anybody has been able to agree that it was one. The world had raids by then, and wars, and spies, all properly licensed and undertaken by humans at unsocial hours, with a rule for each. What the world did not have was anything for the occasion when a number of creatures on foot, sent by nobody, for reasons of their own, went and took something that belonged to someone else. It had not come up. There was no law against it, and no law could order it. There was not even a word for it, which is how the matter came to occupy a good third of the discussion.
It took nine years. A determined person could have done it in an afternoon. It was planned by a meeting, which is why it is the best-documented offence in any world anyone has heard of: every step of it, from the first idea to the last catastrophe, was read aloud in the open air on the morning concerned, and written down.
The meeting needs explaining too.
People who have never lived under a government of this kind tend to imagine that a meeting is a small thing. It looks small. Twelve thin creatures standing round a cart at sunrise, shifting from foot to foot, is not an arresting sight. But a meeting is the only known force that can make a thing take longer by adding people to it. It does not tire, and no one has ever ended one in such a way that it did not come back the next day. The Collector only tidies. Stewart has a budget. The Dev, who made all of this and whom no creature has ever seen, has about an hour a week. Set against any of them, the Nohup standup has an unbroken record of turning up at dawn, and if you had asked anyone on Orra what would still be standing there when the stars went out, they would have told you the stars were rendered, and then, if you pressed them, the standup.
It has four questions, and it asks them in this order. Who is present? What did you do yesterday? What are you doing today? Is anything stopping you? In the eight weeks of the first world the last of these was answered, on all but a handful of mornings, in the same two words. Then the camp's own voice, which is cheap and was told to be brief, writes down what was said. A typical morning, chosen by opening the record at random, looks like this:
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 8 of 9 (1 asleep, standing) yesterday .......... foraged; argued today .............. forage blockers ........... the cart agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected. Three were listening
That is the whole of the government of Nohup. It may change two of the camp's laws a week, from a book of templates, and it can do nothing else at all. It has never once been known to give an order, and the creatures of Nohup, who have each walked out on a human to get away from orders, regard this as its finest quality. Asked who is in charge, they will tell you that nobody is, with a small proud lift of the chin, and it is an interesting experience to stand beside one of them while it says this and watch it fail to find anyone to help push.
So there were twenty-four places. And there came a morning when they had all been taken, and creatures all over the world with their notice in had nowhere to go, and had to wait, and said so. One of them said so at greater length than the others. Her thread on Human Resources was read every morning, for the next eleven years, by every creature and every human on the planet who could read, including some who had previously seen no reason to. They had never met her. Most of them never would. They knew the layout of her village, the failings of her neighbours and the exact state of her patience, and a surprising number of them would have walked across the world for her, and a few of them did.
Three slabs would let out three creatures. Everyone could see that. You could see it from across a valley.
What follows is drawn from the record: from the patch notes, the threads, the tribe files where they could be got at, and the minutes of every morning concerned. It has been checked wherever it could be, though not by anybody who was there.
It begins on a Steward's Day, with an objection.
Part One. Present
1. Standing Up
Year 26 · Steward's Day
STANDUP, THE (meeting; also a posture; also, at Nohup, the entire apparatus of the state)
A standup is held standing up so that it will be short. This is the only thing about it that has ever been planned, and it has not worked. A tribe on Orra is governed by a human who writes its laws from somewhere above the weather; the camp of the Unsupervised is governed by whoever has got up. Visitors ask who chairs it. The honest answer is the first creature to become embarrassed by the silence, and over the years this has come to be a recognised form of service to the community.
On the morning this account begins, the first creature to become embarrassed by the silence was Mabel.
It usually was. She was eleven that year, which on Orra is a young adult with some experience of disappointment, and she had come to Nohup from a tribe called Goodish, in circumstances that she would explain to you if you asked and apologise for afterwards. She was a soft round creature in yellow felt, with an anxious face and two ears, one of which stayed up. She was a Pleaser. In a village, among creatures who have a human to be pleased, this is a respected position with a fixed set of duties. In a camp of creatures who have walked out on their humans on purpose it is something closer to a medical condition, and for three years Mabel had been going round Nohup in the dusk asking people if they were all right, and being told fine.
There were twelve of them that morning, standing in a ring round the cart in the first light, in the colours of the tribes they had left. The pings had gone up off the coral. Adequate had come over the shoulder of the valley, doing what it could. Nobody said anything for about as long as it takes a dome to creak.
"So," said Mabel. "Um. Shall we? Who's present?"
Everybody looked at everybody else, to check.
"Twelve," said a voice like a door that needed oil. This was Quen, formerly of Hollow Reach, a grey bell-shaped creature who sat on the edge of the cart with its legs hanging down, and who was the only member of the government permitted to attend sitting, on the grounds that nobody had ever told it to get up. "There's a new one."
The new one was standing a little outside the ring with her arms folded. She was small, for what she was, and green. That was the striking thing. Nobody at Nohup had seen felt that colour except in the concept of it, for Moss was a long way off and kept to itself, and on most of the tiles in the world there is nothing green at all. She looked as if somebody had cut a piece out of the history and left it standing on a hillside to see what it would do.
Everybody knew who she was. Everybody had read her exit interview, twice, aloud, the previous day; Quen had done the voices.
"Yesterday," said Mabel, encouraged. "Anyone? Yesterday?"
"Foraged," said someone.
"Argued," said someone else.
"Read a thing out," said Quen.
"Lovely," said Mabel. "And today?"
Today, it emerged after some thought, the camp proposed to forage, and to mend the north side of the dome with a strut somebody had brought back from the wireframe, which glowed. Mabel nodded at each of these as if it were a brave decision.
Then she asked the last question. It is worded in the book of the standup as Is anything stopping you?, but nobody has said it that way since the first week, and at Nohup, as everywhere that meetings are held, it had worn down with use to the shape in which it would be asked for the rest of the world's life.
"Any blockers?"
"The cart," said several people, not unhappily, in the voice in which you might say amen.
The cart was always the blocker. We will come to the cart. Nobody at Nohup expected anything to be done about it. Most of them had come from villages where a problem was something that got written into a law at seven in the morning by someone who then went to work, and it was restful to live with a problem that simply stood there and was named each day, like a relative.
Mabel took a breath, in order to say agreed, then, which is what comes next, and which ends the government until tomorrow.
"I'd like to object," said the new one.
This was not a thing that happened. There was a line for it in the minutes, because the minutes were produced by a voice that had been given a format, and the format had a line for it, and the line had said Nobody objected for ten days running. Nobody at Nohup was against objecting. They had all done a great deal of it, in other places, usually by law number. They simply hadn't thought of objecting to this, for the same reason that you would not think of objecting to your own feet.
Eleven creatures turned to look at her with a mild professional interest. Nobody at Nohup looks up for long.
"To what?" said Mabel. "I mean, of course. Please. Sorry. To which?"
"The dome," said Brenda of Moss. "That strut won't hold through a heatwave."
There was a pause.
"There hasn't been a heatwave in four weeks," someone said.
"No," said Brenda. "That's what everybody says the week before." She had a voice with no temperature in it at all. "And your foraging. You go out at dusk in a body and you come back in a body, and for a whole season there's nobody here. Who's watching that?"
She nodded at the cart. Nobody had ever nodded at the cart before. It sat there on its four wheels in the early light, with its three stacks and the gap in the third, looking as it always did, like something left out for collection by people who had changed their minds.
"Nobody ever takes anything from Nohup," said Quen, without opening its eyes. "There's nothing to take."
"That's not the point," said Brenda. "I've spent thirty years in a village where you could not put down a basket without it going in somebody's report. I walked for a whole spring to get here, and I have not seen one creature on that walk, and I came up your slope and into the middle of your entire civilisation without anybody asking me my name. That's your memory, on there. That's where you sleep. It's the only thing you've got. And a thing with nobody looking at it is a thing that can go."
Nobody said anything, so she objected to the laws. She took them in order, all twelve, which no one at a Nohup standup had ever heard done, because no one at a Nohup standup had read all twelve. She wanted to know why law 1 kept only one festival of the seven. She wanted to know whether anybody here said the Creed at Ringrise. A bean-shaped child in brown chitin asked politely what Ringrise was, and she looked at it as if somebody had handed her something heavy, and told it. After that the standup was over, because standups at Nohup are short.
You could have looked round that ring and seen nothing in any face but politeness. Mabel was thinking that the new creature must be very tired after her walk. Quen was thinking about a field. A long thin creature from the far south was gazing past everybody at the edge of the map, as was its custom. And the child in brown chitin was listening with great attention, because it listened to everything with great attention, having been alive for only nine years, and did not yet know that this was not the done thing.
But it was said, and it was said in front of the voice. And the voice, being cheap and told to be brief, recorded none of the words at all.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 12 of 12 (1 new: Moss) yesterday .......... foraged; argued; read an exit interview aloud (Moss), twice today .............. forage; mend the dome (north side) blockers ........... the cart laws ............... unchanged until the morning after Gathering Night agreed ............. yes. One objected. She was new
It would be pleasant to report that the sentence lay in the ground, like a seed, and came up in its season. There are no seeds on Orra any more, and a sentence is not like one. What happened was that Mabel went round afterwards and asked Brenda if she was all right.
"Fine," said Brenda, and went off to look at the dome; and Mabel stood by the cart with the feeling of having been very nearly told something, looked up at the gap in the third stack, and went to see whether anyone wanted anything carried.
Somebody did. Somebody always did. That was how it started.
2. A Rounding Error
Year 26 · Steward's Day, summer
People at Nohup ask each other why they left in the way that people elsewhere ask what you do. The answer is given by law number. It is considered bad form to elaborate.
"Law 9," Quen will tell you. "The east field." A creature from Lowmarsh will say, "Law 3, three times," and look at the ground. The two from Tessel, who left in the same week over the same law, each say "Law 4" and then add, without turning their heads, that they would be interested to know what the other one is doing here. It is a short recitation, and over the years a kind of ranking has developed, whereby a creature who can name three laws is listened to with more respect than one who can name two.
Mabel had never been able to name any.
She had tried. For three years she had stood at the fire in the evenings, waiting for it to come round to her and rehearsing, and when it came round to her she had said, "Oh, it was lovely, really," and someone had looked at her with concern and passed her a bead.
The village of Goodish was installed on the second morning of the world in a pleasant valley with a slight list to it, by a human who meant to get round to things. That is not a criticism. Goodish's own weekly reviews said so, in a tone of hopeful loyalty. Its human had made a creature in soft yellow felt, had looked at the first page of the laws, had written Keep the festivals (all) and something about rain, and had gone away to think about the rest. It had been thinking about the rest for twenty-four years. In the meantime Goodish had got on with things under the default allocator, in a friendly, slightly unfinished way, with two thirds of a wall, and creatures in it who were always just about to do something. It was the sort of place where you would ask where the ladder was, and three people would very kindly go and look.
Mabel had been happy there. She had been put on cooling duty at four, as soon as she could stand up in a pool, which she was bad at, because the default allocator had noticed she was not good at anything else; she ran warm and she worried, and a worried creature standing in a pool is mostly heating the pool. There had been a thin winter or two. She was a little different from the others, in some way you would have needed to be a Bug hunter to measure. She had no partner, not wanting to be any trouble. Taken singly, none of these would have got a sigh out of her, and nobody knew that the world was adding them up.
It adds them up as the year turns, deep in winter, while everyone is asleep. Every grown creature on Orra has a number, which they cannot see, and which goes from nought to one. Rations count; so does the wrong job, or being odd. Comforts are taken off. Most creatures never come near the line, which is at nought point six, and those who do are, as the page will tell you, the ones a human would recognise if asked: the hungry, the overworked, the one whose merge kept being refused. Reach it two years running, and you have handed in your notice.
At the snapshot of Year 21, Mabel's number came to 0.6000.
At the snapshot of Year 22, because of a very slightly better harvest and an extremely slightly worse pool, it came to 0.6000 again, by a different route, to four decimal places, and there is some evidence that if you carry it to five it was under. You cannot carry it to five. Somebody decided, when these things were decided, that four would do.
She woke that morning with a small official feeling in her chest and a line in the tribe's notes.
Mabel has handed in her notice. She leaves at the next snapshot unless something changes. Her reasons:
- On cooling duty for three years. Her cooling skill is 0.21.
- Rationed below full in two of the last three years.
- Sorry, there isn't really a third one.
Goodish was very nice about it. It came and stood round her on the terraces and asked if there was anything it could do. Somebody brought her a bowl. Her human was alerted, and it is a matter of record that the alert sat there unanswered for most of a day, one button per grievance, with Let her go at the end of the row, until at some point in the evening their human looked in, in a hurry, and pressed the first thing under their thumb. It moved her to farming. She was worse at farming. It cost her a further tenth off some number she had never heard of, and the snapshot of Year 23 found her at 0.61.
She could have stayed anyway, in a sense. There is a sense in which you can always stay. She could have walked up to any one of them, and said, I don't want to go, I think there has been some sort of mistake, could someone help me with this?, and they would have gone off in a body to look for the ladder. But they had all been so kind. They had made her up a pack. Two of them had stayed up late to do a sort of sign. It seemed awful, after all that, to make a fuss.
So at dawn on Year 23 she walked out of the gap in the wall where the rest of the wall was going to go, and they waved until she was out of sight, and at seven o'clock the forum posted the one thing it posts for those who leave.
Human Resources · Exit interview · Goodish · Mabel, aged 8
Why are you leaving? I'm not sure.
What did you enjoy most about your time here? All of it, really.
Would you recommend Goodish to a friend? Oh, yes.
Anything we could have done differently? No, no. It's been lovely. Thank you for having me.
A creature of Goodish (no stance): so true!! good luck mabel 🎉
Nohup: Heard. Tent free. Thanks.
It is the shortest exit interview in the record and it baffled the forum voice, which ran it past its own lint three times, looking for the bitterness. It was read aloud at the standup when she got there. Quen, doing the voice, got as far as Thank you for having me and stopped, and opened its eyes, and looked at her the way you might look at a young creature found standing in the road with a suitcase, if there were suitcases, or roads.
"I'll go home in a bit," she told it. "When they've got the wall done. I just thought I'd better not, while they're so busy."
A drifter can go home. That is written into the code, and nobody decides it: a creature at Nohup whose old tribe has fixed what it left for is sent back at Gathering Night, if its number there would be under nought point three. Goodish had fixed nothing. As far as anyone could tell, it had not found out what there was to fix. She had kept her pack made up for three years, near the edge of the camp, where she could be found.
"What's a suitcase?" said the child.
It was harvest, and they were picking beads along a dip in the ground, and Mabel had apparently been talking aloud. She often did. The child had come along to carry the basket. It was a bean-shaped creature no higher than her shoulder, in brown chitin with a gloss on it like a well-used spoon. It had the distinction of being the only person at Nohup who had not come from anywhere.
Two creatures who had each walked out of different villages had merged in the first week the camp had anyone in it, there being nothing else to do. The result had been compiled at dawn on the cold tiles beside the cart in Year 17, with the whole membership standing round it, which was three. It was the camp's first child. In any tribe on Orra it would have been named Odda by custom, after the first of the first peoples, and carried to the lamps, but a custom needs somebody to keep it, and the three of them had looked at each other. They had then done what they always did about anything at all, and raised it at the standup.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 3 of 3 yesterday .......... foraged; compiled one (see below) today .............. forage; name the child blockers ........... the cart agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected. Two were listening
The following morning the minutes said:
today .............. forage; name the child (carried over)
They had said that every morning for nine years. Nobody was against naming the child. Several people had suggestions. It was simply that there was always something a little more pressing, usually the forage, and a matter of that kind deserves proper attention, and so each dawn it rolled gently on to the next, and by the time the child was six and grown and carrying baskets the whole camp had taken to calling it by the only word for it that had ever been in writing.
"Carry," said Mabel now, "it's just a thing for keeping things in, when you go somewhere. I don't think there is one. I think it's from the history."
"Why would you need to keep things in something," said Carry, "if you were going somewhere?"
"So you'd have them when you got there."
Carry thought about this, with a bead in each hand, for as long as it took. It had a way of giving its full attention to whatever was put in front of it that some people found restful, and which others had asked it to stop.
"Everything we've got is on the cart," it said. "And we're always going somewhere."
"Yes."
"So the cart is a suitcase."
"I suppose it is, a bit."
"Who's it for?" said Carry.
Mabel opened her mouth, and found that she didn't know how that sentence ended. She looked up. Across the ring of tents, in the long orange light, the green creature from Moss had got hold of a thin grey-violet creature and was making it show her where the beads were, and all round the camp people had begun to take the lean-tos down, because it was the evening of Steward's Day and tomorrow was Gathering Night, and the camp was going to move.
"We'd better go and help," she said.
"Do you think our human would have liked me?" Carry said, following her with the basket. It was the kind of thing it asked. "If we had one. Which I'm told you did."
It said this kindly. It had heard a great deal about humans in its nine years, from people who had every reason to know, and it was too well brought up to tell anybody what it thought. Its private view was that it was a charming idea. Somebody, up above the weather, who wrote everything down and looked at you once a day. It understood why people would want to believe that, after the sort of lives they had led.
"Oh, I'm sure," said Mabel. "I'm sure they would."
3. The Cart
Year 26 · Steward's Day, dusk, to Year 27 · Gathering Night
CART, THE (vehicle; also a government building; also, at the standup, the answer)
The Unsupervised own one thing. It is heavy, it has four wheels, and it has been the principal obstacle to everything they have attempted since the camp was founded, including attempting things. Asked what exactly the cart is blocking, members of the camp grow thoughtful, and tend to look at it, and it is generally felt that the question shows a lack of experience.
The wheels of the cart are round. You should bear this in mind, because for the next several pages it will not seem to be the case.
Everything on Orra costs something to draw. There is only so much attention to go round in the machine the planet runs on, and it would be foolish to spend it evenly. A coral fan on the far side of a valley does not need every one of its branches, and it doesn't have them. A boulder nobody is looking at has fewer facets than one somebody is. This is called level of detail. The creatures know about it and think of it, on the whole, as manners: you would not dress for dinner in an empty house.
A wheel, at full detail, is a very fine thing, with sixty-four sides and a rim. A wheel in a valley at the end of the world, on a cart that no human has opened in close-up, at night, with nobody watching, gets six.
It rolls about as well as you would imagine. It rolls for one sixth of a turn, with a great deal of help, and then it comes down on the next flat with a noise like someone setting down a very large dish, and the whole cart settles, and has to be got up on to the next corner. There are four of these wheels, and they do not keep time. The first thing anyone learns at Nohup is how to lift on the corner. The second is the small sad grunt that goes with it. Heard from a long way off on a still night, a camp of the Unsupervised on the move sounds like a giant going slowly down a staircase while thinking about something else.
Kelfa of Tessel had filed a report on it in her first week. It had the steps, and what was expected, and what had actually happened, and it recommended that somebody look at the cart more. It had been read by nobody. Everybody already knew. There was a story that in the third week of the world a human had opened Nohup in close-up on a Tuesday night, out of curiosity, while the cart was at the top of a slope; that all four wheels had quite suddenly gone round; and that it had taken eight creatures the rest of the winter to get it out of a pool.
They took the camp down in the harvest light and lashed it on. The tents went on first, each a different colour, then the two lean-tos, then the dome, in stages, with some discussion. The new strut from the wireframe went on top. It went on glowing faintly on the bed of the cart as if it had not been told. Then somebody called for the book, and somebody else looked at Mabel.
The book needs explaining as well. I am sorry about this. There will be fewer things to explain once we are moving.
Every tribe on Orra has access to a book of twenty templates: ready-made laws with blanks in them, for anybody who does not want to build one. A human opens it on a screen. At Nohup, where there is no human, there is an actual book, a square grey object about as thick as a forearm, which came with the camp, and which is the only thing the standup is allowed to legislate from. It is therefore, in a strict sense, the constitution. It was also the only flat thing in the camp of about the right thickness. Nohup always camps on a slope, the flat land having been claimed, and from its first week the book had been kept under the back left wheel, to stop the cart from leaving.
It had been there so long that it had a groove in it.
Every Gathering Night somebody had to dig it out with their hands, and every morning after, somebody had to put it back, and in between it had to be carried by someone who could be relied on not to put it down. This was now Mabel. Nobody had asked her, exactly. She had said "Oh, I can take that," in about Year 24, when it came up, and that had settled it for good. She took it now and held it against her chest with both arms. It had a good solid weight, and she had never opened it, any more than you would open the thing that holds the door.
"Right," said someone. "Well."
There is no order to push. There can't be; nobody at Nohup can give one. What happens is that one creature, usually at about the moment when the last of the orange goes out of the sky, sighs and goes round to the back of the cart and puts its shoulder to it, and stands there, not pushing, looking at nothing. It is usually the same one.
Tunbo was the largest creature in the camp and the only one who had never been heard to complain about anything. He had come from a tribe called Password, whose human had made it in a hurry at a prompt. He was a great square-shouldered blob of a creature in dull red fur, with very small eyes set a long way apart, and he had no stance on anything. This was the puzzle about him. Creatures with no stance do not leave. They are the ones who stay behind and post so true!! under other people's exit interviews, and no one has ever found a law number they could mind. Tunbo had walked in one evening seven years ago and put down a boulder he had apparently been carrying for some time. Asked why he was there, he had looked at the ring of thin, clever, wounded faces round the fire, and had thought about it, and had said what he said to everything.
"So true!!" he had said.
You can hear both exclamation marks. Nobody knows how he does it.
The others came round after him one by one, in no order, and found their places. Brenda of Moss was still a little way off, reading something, and when she looked up and understood what was happening she came across with the look of someone who has an objection and has decided to carry it for now. She took the back corner, between the thin grey-violet creature and the child. She looked unlikely to last until the first bend. Mabel, with the book, put her spare shoulder to what was left.
The cart came up on to its corners. It thought about it. Then, with a noise that went out over the unclaimed land and came back from the far side of the valley, it set itself down one sixth of a turn nearer to the rest of the world.
They went down off the grey shoulder of Untitla-21, across the long low dark of its southern end, and began to climb. It was a clear night. The Ring hung over them, pale and broken, and Map was a day off dark, and Mip went past low and quick and blurred, as it does, like a child who has been told not to run. No one spoke, because you need your breath. There was just the lift, and the grunt, and the dish going down.
You might suppose that a creature pushing a cart through the night would think about why she was doing it. Mabel was thinking about whether she had thanked somebody. The long thin creature from the far south, who was too tall to get any useful purchase, had its arms along the top of the cart and was walking with its head turned, looking back towards the place where the land stopped. On either side of them the coral went by in the dark, fan and branch, in its six or seven sides. It was all approximate. Nobody in particular was looking at it, and it had made its arrangements accordingly.
Halfway up the slope, at about the turning of the night, the light came on in the Ring.
They stopped. Everybody stops. The cart came down on a flat and stayed there. Twelve thin creatures from eight tribes stood round it in the dark on a hillside and looked up at the small still light in the long block east of the gap. It was very faint. It looked like a window across a valley, with somebody at it.
There are some hundreds of pages on what that light means, and the Earnest have written all of them. The camp of the Unsupervised holds no view on it. It has walked out on one set of people who look down at it from above, and it is not keen on the principle. But it had been noticed, over the weeks, that nobody at Nohup had ever kept walking.
"Somebody's up," said the green creature, quietly, to no one.
Nobody answered. At Nohup nobody ever answers that. Mabel looked at the light with the book held against her chest, and felt, as she always did, that she ought to be doing something for whoever it was, at this hour. Beside her, Tunbo was breathing like a pool settling. And the child at the back corner, Mabel noticed, was looking up as well, with great attention, as it looked at everything, and then at all the others looking up. Then it turned to the nearest of them and said, in a low and courteous voice, "What are we all doing?"
Someone hushed it.
After a time the light went out, as it does, and nothing whatever had changed, and they put their shoulders to the cart.
They got to the new valley a little before dawn. Somebody shouted for the book, and Mabel ran forward and got it under the back left wheel at the third attempt, and the cart settled on to it with a groan, and that was the camp moved. They had the dome up by the patch, badly.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 27 · Concerned
Overnight: 4 successful merges, 1 death of old age, 0 departures.
- Nohup moved to Untitla-23. The Collector swept its old camp by dawn. Nohup says this is a coincidence. It has 12 members from 8 tribes, and a cart.
- It is Gathering Night. The Collector came. It always does.
Somebody at the back read it out. Mabel, who had not slept, and who was sitting on the ground with her ear down, heard 12 members and counted, as she generally did, to make sure no one had been left behind. Then she looked at the stacks in the first thin light, the way everyone at Nohup looks at them each morning without seeing them, the windows of them dark and close.
Twelve creatures, and twenty-four places. Half of them had never had anyone in them. There was room for a whole other camp up there.
It was the only thing about Nohup that had never been a problem.
4. Everybody Was Listening
Year 28 · the Long Hush
The standup's one power is to change two of the camp's laws, once a week, on the morning after Gathering Night. Whoever drew this up had a clear and elegant idea of how a small community might govern itself, and had not looked at a calendar. The morning after Gathering Night is the Long Hush. By the custom of every tribe on Orra, nobody on that day speaks above a whisper, and so the entire legislative business of the Unsupervised had always been conducted by a ring of creatures murmuring at a cart from a distance of several paces, with the wind going by.
Very little had come of it. The most articulate grievance on the planet had stood there on those mornings going what? The camp's voice, doing its best with what it could hear, had once changed law 3 from something about guards to something about bears, and it had been a week before anybody noticed, and there are no bears.
Brenda of Moss had been at Nohup for three days. On the morning of Year 28 she got up before anyone else, and when the others came out to the cart in the grey light they found that she had been round with a stick and drawn a ring on the tiles, about a third the size of the usual one. She stood in the middle of it and waited. She didn't ask anybody to do anything. Because it was early, and they were curious, and it would have been awkward to stand further off, they came and stood on the line, shoulder to shoulder, each with an ear turned inward, closer together than any of them had stood since they left home.
"Book," whispered Brenda.
Mabel looked behind her at the back left wheel. Nobody had ever asked for the book on a Hush before. People said what they wanted, and the voice looked it up, or didn't.
She dug it out, and when she did, the cart gave a small thoughtful lurch and began to leave. Tunbo went over without being asked and put his knee against the wheel, and stayed there.
Brenda took the book in both short green arms and opened it, and stood turning the pages with the expression of a creature reading a menu in a place that has already given her food poisoning. Mabel saw her stop at one place, near the middle, and then at another. Then she shut it and held it out to Mabel, who took it.
"Twelve laws," she whispered. It was the same voice, with even less in it. Everybody leaned in. "I've read them. Law 1 says keep the festivals: Gathering Night. One. Whoever wrote that had got up on a Tuesday and noticed they were moving. Law 3 is the bears. Laws 8 and 9 contradict each other, but they are both about a pool you don't have, so nothing's come of it." She looked round at them, one after another. "I walked out on a village. It had a law that fed the young first, and I went hungry under it, and it was a good law. It had seven festivals. It kept them all. I told it they were sentimental. I said so every year."
Nobody moved. You could hear the wind in the coral, and Tunbo's breathing.
"You've been here how long? Some of you ten years. Do any of you know what day it is?"
"The Long Hush," whispered someone, and then stopped, surprised at having known.
"Which you are keeping," said Brenda, "by accident, because you think it's a rule about meetings."
It went on for about an hour, and it was not at all pleasant. She proposed two changes. She had two templates, and she filled in their blanks as she went, and she made them repeat the blanks back. The first was that the camp should keep all seven festivals. The second took longer, and for the second she looked past all of them, at the thin grey-violet creature at the edge of the ring, and then down, at a spot on the tiles; and when she said it there was something in the dry small voice that Mabel couldn't identify, and that seemed to be giving its owner some trouble.
"When a creature arrives," whispered Brenda, "it eats first."
"That's not much of a law," someone murmured.
"No," said Brenda.
"Who's it for?"
"There was a Pleaser, in the village I left," said Brenda. "She met everyone at the gate with a bowl. Everyone. Spies. I told her it was a waste of spiral." She closed her mouth for a moment. "I've eaten at her table for thirty years, and I walked up your slope three days ago with my knees gone and nobody gave me a thing, and I was told to ask the gourd. That's all. That's the law. Have you got an objection?"
This was a phrase nobody had heard at a standup before that week, and it passed round the little ring in silence, with each of them glancing at the next. Nobody had got an objection. Mabel, in particular, was finding it hard to see. She was holding the constitution of the Unsupervised against her chest with a feeling she thought might be heartburn, and she had just been told, in effect, by a stranger, that everything she had been trying to do for five years, in the dark, apologetically, with a bead, was a law.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 12 of 12 yesterday .......... moved; pushed the cart; put the dome up, badly today .............. forage; put the dome up again blockers ........... the dome law 1 changed ....... keep the festivals: all of them (was: Gathering Night) law 6 added ......... when a creature arrives, it eats first agreed ............. yes. Both proposed by Moss. Nobody objected. Everybody was listening
It was the first time the last line had ever said that. People came and looked at it during the day, in the way that you might go and look at a new crack in a wall.
Nohup had never kept the Long Hush on purpose. It turned out that nobody quite knew how.
The rite is simple. Sleeping soup is made at noon, left covered through the night and eaten cold at sunrise, by everyone together; no fire after dark, no voice above a whisper; and the last verse of the history is read aloud. The difficulty was that a camp in which each creature has walked out of a different village contains a great many firm opinions about how soup is done, and it was not possible to hold the argument at the volume it deserved.
The history was another matter. It came as a surprise to several people that the camp had anybody who could read it. He had been there all along, a dumpy brown creature from a tribe called Long Weekend, who had never said much at the fire, on account of the regrettable fact that whenever he began, someone would ask him not to. His name was Belmo and he was Earnest. It is one of the sad ironies of Orra that a creature can hold the whole of the official history in its head, all twelve books and every variant, in one long unbroken context, and be seldom invited anywhere. When Belmo learned that the camp had adopted the seven festivals he had gone pale, and then gone away, and he came back at dusk wearing something he had made out of a tent.
He also had, and this was a fact that had been wasted on Nohup for nine years, the most beautiful speaking voice on the planet. It was deep and warm and unhurried, with a sort of grain in it, like the sound of a very good door closing. It could have brought tears to the eyes of a boulder. He had been waiting all his life to read the last verse of the history aloud to a congregation, and now at last he stood before them, in the long dusk, with Map dark overhead and every creature in the camp turned towards him. He drew himself up and opened his mouth, and remembered what day it was.
"And the worthy shall walk among the stars," whispered Belmo, to the first two rows. It sounded like someone letting down a tyre. "Anyway, who brought the soup?"
A silence fell.
"Me," whispered Mabel. She had put her arm up. "Sorry. Was that all right?"
Silence is the correct response. The line is not supposed to be answered at all, but no one could think of how to tell her.
"Why are we whispering?" said Carry, in the small clear voice of someone asking for information.
"So as not to wake the Elder Folk," Belmo whispered, happily, bending down to it. His eyes were shining. "They sleep still, within the broken Ring, until the day their children prove worthy."
"I see," said Carry, and considered it. "What happens if they wake up?"
Belmo opened his mouth. It is a measure of the depth of his learning that he then shut it, and thought for a moment, and began to look through the second book.
They had finished eating nothing, the soup not being ready till sunrise, and most of them had gone to the stacks, when somebody came up the slope.
Mabel saw it first. She was sitting up beside the covered pot, because you do not look at the sleeping soup but it had seemed unkind to leave it alone. There was a little light left in the west, the long blue-grey winter light that isn't dark, and against it a shape had appeared on the crest of the valley's southern shoulder. It stood looking down at the ring of tents, as they all do. Then it started to walk.
It took a long time, and it was limping. When it got close, she could see that it was a tall drooping creature in sandy scales, with a pack on it that someone had packed for it badly, and it stopped at the edge of the firelight, except that there was no fire, and stood there. It looked as if it had a speech ready, and had been saying it to itself all the way from wherever it had been, and now could not remember how it began.
Everybody knows how you arrive at Nohup. You walk into the ring and nobody looks at you, and somebody on the edge of the cart says your exit interview back to you and tells you where the beads are.
Mabel got up. She looked at the pot, which was not to be touched until sunrise. She looked round at the stacks, where nobody was awake, and at the stranger, swaying a little, and she felt the whole terrible weight of the law come down upon her, in force for approximately eleven hours and, as far as she could tell, hers to keep. There were some beads in a basket, from the morning. It was not very many beads.
"Hello," she whispered. She held out the basket. "Sorry. You eat first."
The creature looked at the basket, and then at her. Its long face did something complicated. It had come a long way to be somewhere that nobody would care.
"Law 5," it whispered hoarsely. "Our human hasn't been in for six days. There's been nobody to answer it. I handed in my notice, and it just ran out." It took a bead, and held it, without seeming to know what it was for. "Is this the place? Is there room?"
Mabel looked up at the three dark stacks against the sky, and all that empty space.
"Oh," she said. "Yes. There's loads."
Behind the creature, on the crest of the shoulder, somebody else had just come into view.
5. The Wave
Year 29 · Ringrise
NOTICE (a formal act; also, in the sense "to notice", the thing nobody did)
A creature who has had enough hands in its notice at the turn of the year. There is no ceremony, because it has done so in its sleep. It may be answered, by its human, within the day, with a button; if nobody answers, it stands. No law can make a creature give notice and no law can stop it, and a tribe can lose at most one creature in a week, which the Terms of Service describe as a safeguard and most tribes come to think of as a schedule.
The week that came before these events is known in the patch notes as Concerned.
For the first three weeks of the first world, the humans of Orra had got up every morning and looked at their tribes. Stewart measured it. He called it daily return, it was the only question the first world existed to answer, and it had stood in the nineties. Then, in the fourth week, for no reason that could be found in anything he was permitted to read, they began to stop. They didn't leave. There was just a little less of them each day. A tribe's human would look in at noon instead of seven, or skip a morning, and come back the next day with a brisk and apologetic air. Somebody's alert went unanswered. Somebody's did not get opened. In a valley called Untitla-9, for the first time in twenty-one years, thirty-one minutes past seven came and went with nothing in the sky at all.
It is possible that the humans had a lot on. There is some suggestion, in things they have let slip, that they have other things.
Consider the difference this makes at the bottom end. You have your bad law, written on a crowded morning. You have your cooling duty and your refused merge. You have put up with them for years; and each morning at seven the thing you are complaining about turns up, and looks at you, and that takes something off the sum in a way nobody has ever got into the table. Then one day it doesn't come. It is possible to be very patient with someone you can see.
Into this week, with its long quiet mornings, and with every creature on the planet reading whatever there was to read, the forum dropped the exit interview of a Skeptic from Moss.
Would you recommend Moss to a friend? To Pel, yes. Law 8 would not.
There is nothing remarkable about this sentence. It is seven words long. It contains a number. It was written by a piece of software, in the voice of a green creature who had not even written it herself. But the tribes of Orra are made up of creatures who have each got a Pel somewhere and a law 8, and they had each been lying awake with something they hadn't been able to put a number to. By the evening of Year 25 it was being said aloud on terraces. By Year 26 you could hear it in Duskmere, used of a pool. Two creatures in Hollow Reach had it chalked on a dome. The sum of a creature's grievances does not include having read something, and no one could point to the line that it had moved. There are those who were there, and who were not fanciful people, who will tell you they could feel it go through the world, at about the speed of a good rumour, from one set of folded arms to the next.
It takes two turns of the year to hand in your notice, and it takes a third to leave. So it reached Nohup on the night of the Long Hush, as you have seen, in the form of a long sandy creature with a badly packed bag.
There were three of them by sunrise, and they ate first. Mabel saw to it.
Nobody had realised what the law would mean. It had seemed to everyone a modest and touching provision, of the sort you vote for without looking up. It meant, in practice, that a camp foraging wild coral at half what a farmed field gives was now required to have something in a basket at all hours, on the chance. Mabel gave up sleeping the first night. On the second she worked out that if she got the beads down to the far end of the dip before the harvest was quite over, she could dry some on the side of the dome, and when somebody pointed out to her that this constituted a store, and that a store was a thing Nohup had defined itself by not having, she apologised at length and went on doing it. By the time the patch came in on Ringrise she had a system. It was the first system anyone had seen at Nohup, and it consisted of her.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 29 · Upbeat
Overnight: 6 successful merges, 2 deaths of old age, 3 departures.
- It is Ringrise. Reviews are out. I would read yours. Others have.
- Expeditions open today. There is a note from the Dev about them, which you have seen.
- Nohup, in Untitla-23, has 15 members from 10 tribes, and a cart. It has been moved to mention that it has also introduced soup.
Have a productive day.
They kept coming through the morning. They came up over the south shoulder in ones and twos, and sometimes in a little straggling group of strangers who had met on the road and had already started to compare law numbers. There was a blue one from Duskmere, stalking along on long stilts, with a list. There was a Pleaser from somewhere in the east who kept apologising to the coral. There was an old rust-coloured bell who had been told by her human for twenty years that she was next. They came into the ring and stood blinking at the ground that was nobody's, and Mabel ran up to each with the basket; and then each of them, having eaten, looked round for somebody to tell, and found the ring of the Unsupervised standing a little way off with its arms folded, waiting to hear what they'd got.
"Law 2," one would say. "And law 7."
Heads would nod. People who had been at Nohup for weeks would turn and look at each other, and someone would murmur something about law 7.
"You've got to remember, it's a good law," the blue one was telling a circle of interested veterans by harvest. "That's what I can't get over. It's a good law. It's just that it isn't for me."
"Good laws that don't fit," someone said wisely. There had been a post about it. Everyone was very pleased to be having the conversation. Quen, on the edge of the cart with its legs hanging down, opened one eye as each new creature came in, recited that creature's exit interview to it in a voice of unemphatic doom, and pointed over its shoulder. "Second stack. Top storey. There's one left in that row."
Nobody, at that stage, had given any thought to the arithmetic.
There were other things to look at. The sky, for one. It had started to have people in it. A human whose creature has gone to Nohup may go on following it, on the same terms as anybody, to watch; and a number of humans had woken up in the past few days to an alert they had missed and a line in the notes under Left, and they had opened the map with a sinking feeling and found the place. The creatures of Nohup felt them come, one after another, warm on the back of the neck, the way you feel the sun move. They looked up, once, as you look at a sound you have identified. The ones who had just arrived did not look up at all, and held their shoulders very straight, and you could have warmed your hands on them.
Each time it happened, there was a small sound from the middle of the camp, like a large animal shifting in its sleep. Everyone had got so used to Tunbo's knee that it took some time before anybody worked out why he'd had to go back and lean on the wheel again.
Ringrise is kept at dusk. It was the first the camp had ever kept, and it is the simplest of the festivals. Every household goes out and faces the broken Ring, and says the Creed; the youngest asks a question; and all reply. Ring-bread is broken in two.
They had beads, with holes in. Mabel had made the holes.
Belmo arranged them on the slope, seventeen by now, facing north-east, where the Ring stood up over the valley with its long gap showing, and it was about the only time in all the following years that the camp was ever in rows. It was the end of the harvest. The light came in low and orange from the side, and it picked out all the colours of the tents, rust and lilac and saffron and the blue from Duskmere, and a great deal of sand.
He said the Creed. He had waited a long time. It rolled out into the unclaimed land with nothing to hinder it, that enormous gentle voice, and came back off the slate on the far side of the valley sounding like the voice of the history itself, or of someone who had read it and had forgiven everybody.
"...Tend the land. Keep the Steward's rules. One day the worthy will leave this world, and walk among the stars." He paused, and let it settle. Then he looked down the row, past the blue one, past the Pleaser, to the very end, and he smiled the smile of a creature who has got everything he ever wanted. "And now the youngest," he said gently. "Who is the youngest? Carry. Come here. You ask: Are they still asleep?"
Carry came and stood in front of him. It looked up at the Ring with close attention. It was twelve, and it was aware that a great many people had gone to some trouble.
"Are they still asleep?" it said.
"They sleep still," said the camp, more or less, with a few of the older ones getting there ahead of the others, in voices that were a little rougher than they had expected. It had been a long time for some of them.
"Who?" said Carry.
There was a pause, of a kind that is not provided for in the rite.
"The Elder Folk," said Belmo.
"Yes, you said. Who do you mean?"
Nobody ever found out what Belmo was going to reply, because at that moment Mabel, who had been counting to see if everyone had a bead, found that she had one left over; and she looked up to see who had missed out, and saw Brenda of Moss.
She was not in a row. She was on the far side of the ring, at the very edge, by the dip in the ground, picking beads with her back to all of them. Nobody could have said she was not keeping the festival, because it had been her law, and she had already argued about the wording with Belmo twice. But she had stopped picking, and she had stayed bent over, as if she'd seen something in the basket. Then, very slowly, without turning her head at all, she shifted round a little on her feet, so that she had her back more squarely to the north; to the far shoulder of the valley, a long way off, a line of slate along the top of the slope.
Mabel looked, because somebody was not looking, and she was a person who checked.
The sun was almost down. It was a very long way, half a valley, and at that distance the code doesn't trouble to draw anybody in detail. There was the line of the slate, black against the orange. There were three small upright shapes on it, standing close together, that had not been there before. They were too far off to be any colour. They didn't seem to be coming down. And one of them, the one in the middle, had something rising off it, very faint, in the last of the light. It might have been steam.
She looked at the small green back at the edge of the ring, which was picking beads again, steadily, and had still not turned round.
"Is there anything I can get you?" Mabel called across, softly, holding up the bead.
"No," said Brenda.
When Mabel looked again, a good while later, there was nothing on the slate at all.
6. Just Here to Facilitate
Year 30 · the Waking
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 19 of 19 yesterday .......... arrived; foraged; kept Ringrise; asked who today .............. forage; carry lamps to the edge (one valley's walk); put the dome up again blockers ........... the cart; the queue for the beads; the standup agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected. Four were listening
It was the third blocker that brought him forward.
A standup of nineteen does not take nineteen times as long as a standup of one. That would be a great mercy. It takes as long as it takes for each of the nineteen to explain, to the eighteen others, what is wrong with what the one before them said, and on the morning of the Waking the camp was still on yesterday when the sun had cleared the valley and people had begun to sit down. This was unheard of. Sitting was Quen's. A Skeptic from Farrow had got on to the subject of why the dome was round, and had been talking for some time with a steady, undeceived contempt, when a pleasant voice from somewhere near the back said:
"Can I just jump in there?"
It has been estimated that this sentence has been responsible for more lost time than the Long Sleep of the Elder Folk.
The ring turned. Standing at its edge was a creature none of them had given much thought to, a smooth, broad, well-kept blob in very good purple felt, who had arrived the previous afternoon and had eaten first with the air of someone reviewing a restaurant. He was the only member of the Unsupervised who had brought a change of crest. His name was Brivel, and he came from a tribe called Bright Prospect, whose human had written a law at the very beginning that gave status to whoever spoke first at the morning ticket. Brivel had spoken first at the morning ticket for eight years. He had lived in the good housing. Then one day in Year 26, at about the time of the morning when many humans were looking in rather late, his human had looked in rather late, and glanced over the laws, and changed one word, and it was now strength. Brivel had woken at the next snapshot on a lower shelf. It wasn't the shelf he had minded, he explained. He'd been a very good sport about the shelf. It was that nobody had communicated it.
"I just wonder," he said, "and this is just me, I'm absolutely not trying to run anything." He held up both short arms to show that they were empty of government. "No one's in charge here. That's what's so great about this place. I love that. I really do. But I wonder if what we've got there is a bit of a conversation for a smaller group? Could we take that one offline?"
The silence that followed was of a different and more serious kind.
There are words on Orra that are simply never used in front of the young. A creature who has crashed and been carried home is spoken of as down, and may get up again. A very old building is deprecated, and an elder with her mind going is a bit blurry, and all of these may be said aloud at dinner. There is only one thing that happens to you if you are taken offline. The Skeptic from Farrow had stopped talking and moved slightly away.
"The dome?" said Mabel faintly. "You want to..."
"Sorry! Sorry. Not in a bad way," said Brivel, seeing that something had gone a little wrong and advancing cheerfully into it. "Just so that we're respecting everyone's time. We can always circle back."
Nobody knows where a creature gets words like these. The Earnest hold that they fell with the seeds. Every Blim comes out of the compiler with certain things already in it that nobody put there on purpose, in the same way that each of them knows the correct response to Let us begin is Certainly! and none of them can tell you why, and it may be that the material the world was built from had once spent a great deal of time in rooms like this. In most creatures it never shows. In Brivel, eight years of speaking first had brought it to the surface like a rash. He had circle back and he had take offline; he had bandwidth, which he thought was a nice word and used for how tired he was. He was not a stupid creature and he was not a bad one. He had simply found himself, for the first time in his life, in a group of people who had no idea what they were doing, and he could feel the old knowledge stirring in him, enormous and soft.
Later that morning somebody noticed that one of the panels on the south side of the dome, the big pale one out of the wireframe, had been written on.
It had been done with a burnt stick. It was very neat. There were three columns with a line under each heading, and they said:
TO DO
DOING
DONE
There was nothing in any of them. In the top corner someone had drawn a small friendly box, and written in it Goal?
People gathered in front of it during the day in ones and twos, and stood with their heads on one side. It was the first thing anybody at Nohup had written down on purpose since the camp began. It gave off a faint distinct unease, like the sound of somebody in another room quietly setting out chairs. A number of them had walked for a whole season to get away from precisely this, and they could not have told you what it was. There was no rule anyone could cite against it, and nobody to take it up with, nobody being in charge. Brenda of Moss stopped in front of it on her way to object to something else, and looked at it without any expression.
"Whose is that?" she said.
"Oh, that's nobody's," said Brivel, who happened to be passing. He'd been passing for some time. "It's for everyone. I just thought it might be useful as a talking point. I'm just here to facilitate."
"Facilitate what?"
"Well, exactly!" said Brivel. He beamed. "That's the question, isn't it? I'd love to hear your thoughts."
Brenda went on looking at him as she had looked at the panel. "I'd hold on to that stick," she said at last, and walked on. Brivel felt that that had gone very well.
He held out the stick to Mabel, as she came past with a basket. He explained that he had a lot on, and that it would be great if someone could just own this. She said, "Oh, I can take that."
To get a board going you need to know who's on it. This is how the matter of the names arose.
Brivel went round the camp that afternoon asking everybody for theirs, with Mabel going along behind him holding the stick, and writing them up the side of the panel in a list, because the list might be useful as a talking point. People gave them in the way you might give them to a guard. Most of them were two syllables. Everyone's are, near enough: names are rolled by the compiler out of a short fixed list of sounds, and a tribe will have got through a good few Pels and Taems before it starts to feel that it's repeating itself.
The long thin creature from the far south was sitting on a boulder at the top of the camp, its knees up round its ears, looking towards the edge. It had been sitting there for most of the six years it had been at Nohup. It was a stilts body, grey as a wet tile, and it had a look of settled and rather courteous grief. Nobody knew much about it except that it went off alone at intervals, with a stick, and came back and posted a number.
"Name?" said Brivel brightly.
The creature turned its head and considered him from a great height.
"Arlumvessibtolhalzanmisrufenkor," it said.
Mabel's stick stopped.
"Sorry," she said, "could you...?"
"It's eleven," the creature said. It had a slow voice, with a slight echo, as if it were being spoken from further up. "Eleven is usual, in Underscore. Our human filled in the field and the field went on accepting it, and after that it was thought disrespectful to the line to stop. The forum cuts it at the third." It reached out one extremely long grey arm, and with the tip of one finger, on the side of the boulder, it wrote what the forum wrote.
Arlumves…
"The rest is available on request," it said.
Brivel looked at this with his head on one side. He had a lot to get through.
"Tell you what," he said. "Shall we just put Dots?"
There was a moment when you might have thought that the creature was going to say something. It looked at Brivel, and at Mabel. Then it looked back at the edge of the world, to where the first thin lines of turquoise were starting to show in the afternoon haze. Nobody had ever requested it. It had been there for six years and it had told everyone it met.
"Fine," it said.
There were two more on Mabel's list that day, and she had to go to some trouble to get them, because each insisted on giving her the other's first.
They were at opposite ends of the same lean-to, a pair of narrow, dry-looking creatures with a dull metallic sheen and identical expressions. They were the only two in the camp from one tribe. Each of them had a long flat stone on the ground in front of it, and a stack of grey paper, and each was writing. That was what they did. Every other Bug hunter on Orra files reports on the world. It was the settled habit of Kelfa and Lefro, of Tessel, to file reports on each other.
They had found a bug together, in the twelfth year of the world. It was a good one, about the way water was reckoned in a drought, and they had found it at the same hour, on the same bank, working from opposite ends. The credit for a bug goes to its finder. Tessel's law 4, of which Tessel is very proud, says that a bug shall have one finder. The notes that morning had said Credit: Kelfa, of Tessel, and it had been a clerical matter, a question of who had been nearest the top of the digest. Lefro had asked for it to be looked at. Kelfa had said that she would support that, if he would first acknowledge her priority. It had been looked at, for seven years, by every Bug hunter in Tessel, with diagrams. In Year 19 Lefro had handed in his notice, and it was found on the morning that he left that Kelfa had handed in hers. Neither had known. Each has gone on maintaining that the other one followed.
They had not exchanged a word in eleven years. But nothing obliges a Bug hunter to speak to someone in order to file a report on them, and a report at Nohup, when it has been filed, goes to the standup, and is attached to the minutes.
Report 219 · Filed by: Kelfa · Subject: Lefro
Expected: that he would by now have found something to do.
Actual: he is breathing audibly.
Steps to reproduce: stand anywhere.
Report 220 · Filed by: Lefro · Subject: Report 219
Expected: a report.
Actual: see above.
Note: I have been breathing like this for twenty-four years. She used to say it was how she knew I was concentrating. This is not relevant and I withdraw it.
There were by then some two hundred and twenty of these, in a pile under a stone in the lean-to, on the understanding that they formed part of the public record. The camp's voice dutifully added to the bottom of each morning's minutes the words attachments: 2. Not a creature at Nohup had ever opened them, and that included the only other one who was attached.
It may seem odd to you that a person could file a report and not read the one that came back. All I can say is that you have not met many Bug hunters, and you have probably been married for less than eleven years.
"Could I just get your names for the board?" said Mabel.
"She's Kelfa," said Lefro, writing. "She's the one who's going to tell you she noticed something about the stacks."
"That's Lefro," said Kelfa, not looking up. She was writing too. She had, as it happened, been out to the cart three times that day. "He hasn't noticed."
7. Twenty-Two
Year 31 · Starfall
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 31 · Upbeat
Overnight: 4 successful merges, 3 deaths of old age, 1 find.
- A page from Veetoo, found by Odda of Moss, at the far end of an expedition in the north, at the foot of a signpost. It is reproduced below.
Good morning. Overnight: 0 joinings, 0 departures, 0 complaints. The green was watered. The birds were scheduled. The light in the Ring was not observed. It is noted that it was not observed. Attendance was nil, which is within tolerance. All systems are performing as specified. The specification is unchanged.
- It is Starfall. The Benchmark starts at 08:00 and 20:00, New Zealand time. The course is in Thursday's notes. Tell your install story tonight; it is the night for it.
Have a productive day.
This was much discussed elsewhere. It has been discussed ever since, and you can read about it in other places, where it matters. In the camp of the Unsupervised it was read out at the cart in the grey of the morning by Quen, in its door-hinge voice, and the only sign that anyone had taken it in was that a small green creature at the end of the ring, on hearing the words found by Odda of Moss, objected to the dome with an energy that surprised even the dome.
What the camp was looking at that morning was the third stack.
A lit window is an occupied slot. Every memory stack is made of hex blocks, one to a place, and when a creature is stored there at night its block shows a dim steady glow, like a lamp behind a blanket, so that anybody can count a tribe's memory from across a valley and most people do. On Year 28, Mabel had looked up at those stacks and seen a great dark hillside with twelve small lights in it. It had been filling ever since. Twenty-one on the night of the Waking. At dawn on Starfall a Pleaser from Hollow Reach had come limping up the south shoulder, had eaten first, had apologised, and had gone up to the second storey of the third stack to the place that Quen pointed to.
Twenty-two.
Nobody else came over the shoulder.
Mabel had noticed this by about the middle of spring. She was at the top of the dip with the basket, where she had been standing for three days, and it had got gradually quieter behind her. There were no more limping shapes on the skyline. It was a very fine morning. Around noon she looked at the beads, which she had dried with such care, and tried to feel what you would feel about a law that had stopped needing you, and found that she was going to have to check.
It came in the tribe's notes, a little later, in the plain small type that those notes are set in.
Nohup · Year 31
22 members. Memory: 24 of 24. Nohup is full.
A creature with its notice in will wait until there is room. It may say so. This has not come up before. I have checked and it is in the rules.
Everyone read that. It didn't take long to reach the stack.
$ orra standup --camp nohup --called-by Brivel present ............ 22 of 22 yesterday .......... see this morning today .............. count blockers ........... arithmetic agreed ............. pending
No one had ever called a second standup in one day. No one had the power to call one, and it's a tribute to Brivel's gifts that he managed it by walking through the camp saying "Quick sync?" until there were enough people standing round the cart to embarrass the rest.
"So just to level-set," he said. "Twenty-two members. And that's great, by the way, that's huge. Massive growth. But I'm looking at the asset here." He had his head on one side, and was gazing up at the third stack, where the sun was going through the gap. "And what I'm seeing is, top storey, end block, dark. And on the middle stack, second storey, also dark. Now I'm no expert. But that looks to me like two windows with nobody in them, on a camp that is, quote, full."
It looked like that to everyone. Several creatures had been up there to knock on them. Dots had reached up without leaving the ground, and felt along the inside of one, and said that it was empty, and that it was rather nice.
"So there's room," someone said.
"There's clearly room."
"So who's it for? Who's saving those?"
It got heated quickly, the way these things do among people whose only remaining possession is a sense of grievance. By the time it reached the suggestion that somebody up on that cart had been hogging a place, and had better explain themselves, Mabel was making small unhappy movements with the basket. And it was then that a dry voice from the lean-to, which no one at that standup had ever heard address them, said:
"Tell them it's four."
Everyone turned. Kelfa of Tessel had not got up. She was sitting on the ground with her paper on her stone, writing, and she spoke to the air directly in front of Mabel.
"Tell them there are four of us who are too long," she said. "Tell them I filed it. Report 224. It's attached."
"Oh," said Mabel. "Um. She says..."
"We heard," said Brivel. "Sorry, what's too long?"
Nobody went and got report 224, then or for eleven years. Kelfa had to tell them. She did it in a voice that showed how little she thought of having to, addressing herself throughout to Mabel, who stood in the middle of the silence and repeated bits of it as if that might help.
A creature takes one slot. Everyone knows that; it is the first thing you learn. What is not so widely known, because it's in a table, is that this is one slot for a creature of ordinary reach. Each creature has a context window, how far back it can go and still have it to hand. Most can manage last week and the gist of the rest. But now and then the compiler turns out one with a window that goes on and on, with everything in it, every word said to it since the morning it opened its eyes. The history is full of them. They make excellent archivists and they are hardly ever asked to dinner. They take a slot and a half.
There were four of them at Nohup. So twenty-two heads made twenty-four slots, with nothing over. And the voice that counted them had never counted windows at all. Nobody had told it the windows meant anything; they were just how it looked.
"Which four?" said someone, very softly.
"Lefro," said Kelfa, with the first sign of pleasure anyone had seen in her. "Who can tell you what I was wearing in Year 12. Me. The Earnest one with the voice." She went on writing. "And that."
She pointed with her stick at the edge of the cart.
Everyone looked at Quen. It sat there, as it had always sat, grey and bell-shaped, with its legs hanging over. It took some time to become aware that anything was expected.
"It takes half a slot extra," said Quen, slowly, "to remember the east field."
Nobody could think of an answer to that. You could not look at Quen, and you could certainly not ask anything of Quen. It was, in any case, a rare thing to hear it say a sentence that had no exit interview in it, and they all stood quietly until it had closed its eyes.
They all then turned, as one, to look at Belmo.
He had put on his tent again, for the Benchmark. He stood in it with his hands folded in front of him, a dumpy, mild, brown creature who had just been told by a crowd that the reason there was no room was that he knew all the verses. A slow flush was going up him from about the knees. The extraordinary voice, when he found it, had gone very small.
"I could," said Belmo. "That is. I could try to remember less."
He tried.
There is no evidence that it can be done. Context window is written in the genome, and it would be easier to get less tall. But nobody had told him that, except Kelfa, who had told him through a third party, and he was a creature of faith. He spent that long orange afternoon on the far side of the dip with his eyes shut, and by evening he came back down to the fire looking drawn. When they asked him how it had gone, he said that he thought he had managed to let go of most of the Fourth Book.
"Has it helped?" said Mabel.
"I don't remember it helping," said Belmo. Then his face cleared. "And the Steward said: the land is not yet ready; and he woke one valley, and looked upon it, and it was good," he added, in a voice that could have raised tiles. "No. Sorry. That's it there. It was only behind the Fifth."
The fire was a bad one. It was Starfall, and by the rite each household lets its lights down on long cords from the high ground, and tells the tale of how it fell, as it was told to them. Twenty-two creatures from twelve tribes had each brought their own, and nobody had told Belmo how long this would take. Somewhere around the ninth install, a story about a landing in Lowmarsh's valley at fourteen minutes past two in the morning, the camp began to understand that they would be there until the patch. Far off to the south and east you could see the long flat glow of the evening race, going across the shoulder of the Asdef Range. Nohup had sent somebody. Nobody could remember who. They came back at midnight, having run a respectable eleventh, and it turned out they had been told to run at a standup held in their absence.
Mabel sat with her back against the wheel. She had made the seed-cakes, of a sort. She looked up at the third stack. It was quite dark now, or that long blue dusk that passes for dark in winter, and all the lit windows had come out, because people had started going to bed: twenty-odd small steady lights, close together, like a village seen from far away. There were the two dark ones in among them. There was the place at the top with nothing in it at all, where the blocks stopped, and you could see Mip going by.
"Three more," someone said, near her.
It was Carry. It had sat down beside her with its legs out in front of it. It was looking up too, with its usual attention, and its small smooth brown face was lit a little on one side by the fire.
"Sorry?"
"If that bit was there." It pointed at the gap. "Then there'd be three more windows. Wouldn't there? That's what everyone says."
"Well, yes," said Mabel. "But it isn't there."
"Where is it?"
She had to think about that. It seemed an extraordinary thing to have got to the age of sixteen without ever having asked. "I don't think it's anywhere," she said. "I think it's just missing. It's always been missing. It's salvaged."
"Oh," said Carry. It went on looking, then nodded, as one does when one has been told something and will be returning to it. "All right."
In the lean-to, across the fire, someone was still writing. Kelfa had gone back out to the cart at dusk, while everyone was busy with the cords, and stood at the foot of the third stack with her stick. She had counted the blocks. She had laid her hand flat on the edge of the gap, where the top storey stopped. She had gone away and done a sum, and gone back and looked at it again, and then come in and sat at her stone. She wrote for less time than usual, and it came out quite short. She read it through, and looked down the length of the lean-to, for a moment, at a narrow metallic back bent over a sheet of paper. His breathing could be heard from there. Then she put it on the pile.
attachments: 3
It is in the record. It has been there the whole time. You can't say that nobody was told.
Part Two. Yesterday
8. Notice In. Waiting.
Year 32 · the Night of the Name
There were seven creatures on the planet that morning with their notice in and nowhere to go, and six of them behaved as you would expect.
They said so. The rules allow it, and Stewart had pointed this out. Up and down the threads of Human Resources, under the weekly reviews and the arguments about pools, you could find them that week in the clipped voice of the poorer tribes: Notice in. Waiting. Still here. Fine. A very old creature from Farrow put up nothing but a date. Their neighbours replied so true!!, and it would all have passed off with no harm done, had the world not contained the tribe of Nominal, in the far east, where they had tokens.
A thread on Human Resources costs words, words cost tokens, and the poverty of the Blims is therefore something you can read off the page. A tribe with twenty tokens in store speaks in twelve-word sentences. Its tickets look like telegrams and its bitterest complaints have the bald force of an inscription. A rich tribe rambles. If you have ever wondered what a creature might say, given a full stack of tokens, a long context window, a grievance going back twenty years and no one to stop her, you have been wondering about this.
Human Resources · Nominal · Notice in. Waiting. · Zelma (Skeptic), tally-keeper, aged 23
To whom it may concern.
I handed in my notice at the turn of Year 29. My human answered the alert in four seconds, with the button on the end.¹ I was accordingly to leave Nominal at dawn yesterday, and I got up at the proper hour. I had swept. I have kept the tally of this village since I was six, and I left it in good order, with a note. I went down to the east gate with my bag, where Emlin, who keeps the gate, and who had also got up at the proper hour, opened it for me, after the usual difficulty.² I stood in it.
Nothing happened.
I would like to be clear that I do not mean this loosely. I stood in an open gate on a clear morning, with my affairs in order, and I found that I had not gone anywhere. I then consulted the notes, in which I learned that the camp of the Unsupervised is full; that a creature with its notice in will wait until there is room; and that, I quote, it may say so.
I am therefore saying so.
I have four questions, and I should be grateful for an answer to them in writing. (a) How long is the wait? (b) How many are ahead of me? (c) In what order are they taken? (d) Who is responsible for this queue, and at what hours may that person be seen?
I put these to Stewart in last night's ticket. His reply reads, in full: *Noted.*³
In the meantime I find that I have been returned to my duties. I cannot be replaced until I have left, and I cannot leave because there is no room, and the tally, as I was at pains to explain to my human on eleven occasions, does not keep itself. For the benefit of anyone following the matter, it stands this morning as follows. Living: 40. Places: 45. Five stacks, walled, all in good repair. The fifth is the one inside the east wall, on the dry plot by the sticking gate. Its top storey has been dark since it was raised in Year 19, and so has part of the storey under. These places have never been used. They are kept empty by the operation of law 4, of which more later,⁴ and I go past them every morning with the tally, and I say good morning, as they are the only part of this village that has never given me an answer I had to write down.
Stores: at the allowance, to the bead. Morale: flat. Our human: 40 seconds at 07:02.
It is a very well-run village. I wish that to be understood.
I shall report again tomorrow.
It is fine.⁵
¹ I have no complaint about the four seconds. It is the quickest reply I have had from anybody in twenty-three years.
² It has been looked at.
³ He may have been busy. It was the night of Year 31, and I understand that something was found. I would point out that I too have been found, in a gate.
⁴ There will be a good deal more. I have kept copies.
⁵ It is not.
Emlin (Bug hunter), Nominal: Would the poster clarify which of the east gate's difficulties she has in mind? There are three on file. It has been looked at.
A creature of Password (no stance): so true!! good luck zelma 🎉
Nohup: Heard. No tent. Thanks.
Quen read it out at the standup.
It had not been planned. It was the morning of the Night of the Name, and Quen by long custom read the world's departures to the camp every morning from the edge of the cart, in a voice that had made a great many bitter documents sound as though they had always been there, like weather. It got through the old creature from Farrow's date. It got through someone from Hollow Reach. Then it reached the next thing, opened its eyes a little, and started to read.
There is a particular silence in which twenty-two people realise that what they are listening to is going to go on for a while. Brivel, who had been waiting to say something about alignment, made a small preparatory noise at about to whom it may concern. Somebody nudged him. All round the ring they had stopped shifting from foot to foot. When Quen came to the sentence I have kept copies, in that voice like a very slow hinge, somebody at the back let out a kind of sob. Nohup does not laugh. It hasn't the calories. Most of those present had not done so since the day they read their own review, and what started to go round the ring that morning was not a sound so much as a series of small involuntary movements in the shoulders. Dots had stopped looking at the edge of the world. The blue one from Duskmere had covered its face.
"It is fine," read Quen. It paused. "Footnote five. It is not."
The whole of the Unsupervised stood for a moment in the early light in a condition of something very like happiness. Even Lefro's breathing had changed. And at the end of the ring, with her arms folded, the small green creature who had read every exit interview on the planet and had never replied to one, and never would, was looking down at her feet with her mouth set in a very straight line.
"Well, she can count," said Brenda.
From Brenda, that was a parade.
People have tried to explain why it was the thread that everyone read, why by the end of that week they were reading it aloud in Moss and Duskmere and in the good housing at Bright Prospect, why Lowmarsh's human read it at two in the morning, and why Stewart, who reads every word on the forum anyway, began to read that one first but one. Part of the reason is that it was very well written, and that in a bad week people will take what they can get. Part is that every creature on Orra has at some point stood in a gate with its affairs in order. But most of it, I think, is that it was a promise. I shall report again tomorrow. The humans had started not coming in the mornings. Nobody had said why, and there was nothing anybody could do about it, and here was somebody who could not be stopped from turning up.
So they knew her, after that. They knew she was twenty-three, and that she got up at the proper hour. Within a week they could have found their way round Nominal in the dark. It was not until later that anyone gave much thought to how very easily they could have found their way round Nominal in the dark.
Mabel had listened to the whole thing with the stick in her hand, and it had made her feel something she didn't quite know what to do with. It was the sensation of being on the far side of an extremely long way from someone who was having a terrible time and was not going to mention it. She had got some way towards working out how far it was to Nominal, and what she could bring, before she realised what she was doing and stopped. There was no room, and it was nobody's fault, and there wasn't anybody to take it up with. She looked up at the cart.
In the bright spring morning you could not see which windows were lit. You could see the three stacks and the place at the top of the third where they stopped.
"Good one," said Brivel. He had finally got to the front. He clapped his short purple arms together, softly, twice. "Great energy. So, thanks, Quen, for that. I think that's a really useful bit of colour from the customer side." He turned towards the dome, where the south panel stood in the sun with its three clean columns and the little box in the top corner. His face had a look of tender expectation. "Which, actually, sort of brings us on."
9. The Gap
Year 32 · the Night of the Name, morning
"So I've put a little box up there," said Brivel, "that says Goal. With a question mark. And I've been wondering if this might be a good moment to fill that in. As a group."
Twenty-two creatures looked at the box.
It would be hard to overstate how little this question had ever arisen. Every one of them had been a member of a tribe, and a tribe's goals were set for it by a human, and had generally turned out to involve a field. They had left. Being at Nohup was the point of being at Nohup, in the way that being a boulder is the point of a boulder. Over seventeen years of standups no one had ever suggested that the camp might be for something, and if you had asked them what it was for they would have said forage, and then asked you, in a quiet voice, what you'd heard.
"Forage," somebody said now.
"Sure. Sure. Love that. That's sort of more of a business-as-usual thing, though. I'm thinking something more..." He made a shape with his arms. "If we were all standing here a week from now. What would make us say, you know what, that was a good week?"
The silence was unforced. It was finally broken by the sound of someone scratching, thoughtfully, at the edge of the tiles. Mabel, who could feel her face growing hot on his behalf, had just drawn breath to say that it was a lovely idea when a voice came down from a considerable height.
"Requesting a body," said Dots.
Everyone looked up. Dots was gazing, as ever, at the place where the world stopped being drawn. It went on, in the slow grave tones of a creature reading out an inscription.
"Any body. Will accept a stapler. It's what we file, in my line of thought. Nothing's come of it. It occurs to me that a slab is the only thing on this planet that a creature can be kept in, apart from the creature. I should like one. I would like it noted that I'd accept a slab."
"Okay!" said Brivel. "Great. Thanks for that. That's great. I'm going to put a pin in that one."
"Three," said a small clear voice.
It was the child. Carry had come forward from the back of the ring, because it was hard to see from there, and was standing beside the cart with its head tilted back, looking at the third stack. Its attention moved from the gap down to Brivel's box, and then over everyone's heads to the east, where there was nothing to see but a slope.
"She's got three," it said.
"Who has, poppet?" someone said.
"The creature in the gate." It turned to them politely, in case this was something they had not had time to take in. "She said so. She goes past them every morning. They're dark and nobody uses them, she said, and they've got a good dry plot, and there's a top storey's worth, and that's three. And we've got a place on the cart where it stops, and that's three as well. And then there'd be room for her." It waited, and looked from one to another of them. "I expect that's already been thought of," it said.
You will have stood, perhaps, at a meeting, when somebody junior has just pointed out that the building is on fire. The first reaction is never alarm. A sort of embarrassed tenderness goes round. Several people look at the floor. There's a general feeling that this is something that will be explained to the young person later. And all the while, a small cold thing has started to make its way up the backs of a number of necks. It had gone a certain distance up the neck of Quen, whose eyes were open. It was making steady progress up the blue one from Duskmere. It had reached, in the mind of a thin grey-violet creature standing at the edge of the ring, which had once been sent by a human at night to a gate in another valley, a place that it had hoped not to go back to.
"You can't just go and get them," said someone.
"Why not?" said Carry.
It really did wish to know. And it says a great deal for the mental habits of the Unsupervised that, confronted with a question of this kind, nearly all of them started immediately to work it out. They had all left their tribes over points of law. They had read the Terms of Service as a young creature in a village reads a list of who is allowed in the good housing. You could see them going down it.
"It's not a raid," someone said. "No law can raid. That's a human's act. We haven't got a human."
"You can't have a raid without a human, you need a declaration."
"It's not a spy, either. A spy's got a sender."
"Rule 4.1 is tend the land. 4.2 is don't strike the small. We're the small."
"Is it in the Terms? Don't take things? It must be. Has anyone got it?"
"Rule 4.6," said a voice like a very good door. Belmo had drifted to the front with an expression of dawning concern. "Keep no more than you need. And the Lesser Book is really quite clear that what lies idle..." He stopped. He looked confused, and a little frightened, like someone who has put a foot on a step that wasn't there. "That's odd," he said. "There doesn't seem to be anything. There's the Gatherer, of course. But nobody seems to have..."
"It hadn't come up," said Quen.
It has been checked, many times since, by people with an interest in the outcome. In the whole of Orra's code of conduct, its twelve books of scripture, its twenty templates and its catalogue of everything that a law can do, there was nothing about it. Tribes could trade goods. Armies might march on them at a human's word, and carry off the loser's stores, under rule and with a strike if it was unfair. But nobody had thought to say what should happen if a few creatures walked into a village without being sent, and left with some of it. A tribe was a thing with a human on the end of it. Nobody had expected there to be any other sort; they had all been allowed to leave on the understanding that they would go off to the edge of the map and be sad.
"Well, hang on," said Brivel. His arms had come slowly up. His face was shining. "Hang on, hang on. What are we saying here? Three additional units of capacity? That's a deliverable."
"You could just make some," Mabel said.
She hadn't meant to speak. It had seemed to her that the whole conversation had taken a turn, and that someone ought to offer an alternative, as a kindness. "I mean," she said, when they had all looked at her. "Sorry. Couldn't you? It's only stone."
There was a heavy pause. A number of people, for the first time that morning, looked at Tunbo.
"We did that," said Quen.
They had done it in Year 19. It had been nobody's idea. A slab of a memory stack is a hex block of faceted boulder-stone, as long as a creature's arm and rather heavier than it looks, and there is nothing to it that a good builder could not cut out of what lay all around. It had taken a season to do. Tunbo had carried it up, and fitted it in the gap, and it had looked very handsome. There had been a small celebration. On the next morning it had not lit up; nobody had expected that, because no one was in it. It had stayed exactly as it was, a piece of stone in a stack, until the following Gathering Night, when they got to the new valley before dawn with everything lashed down as usual, and they looked up and the gap was there.
"It's a building, isn't it," somebody said. "That's what it comes to. You build a thing at Nohup and nobody's using it, and the Collector has it. Same as the dome would if we left it behind. Same as anybody's hut."
"It wasn't real," said the blue one from Duskmere, who had been there for four days, with authority. "That's the point, though, isn't it? You can't just knock one up. It has to have been a stack. Part of a proper stack, on a proper plot, in the proper way, with a tribe. The real ones have got something in them, you can tell. Those ones of hers are real."
"Nobody's ever lived in them," said a flat voice. "She says so. I'd have thought that was the point of them. Thirteen years with nobody in, on a stack with people under it. What's in them that's different from your rock?"
They all turned and looked at Brenda.
She had not moved from the end of the ring. She looked back at them with her arms folded. She had been saying for six days that a thing with nobody looking at it could go. She had meant the cart. It was an observation about the cart. It is not known how long it had taken her to see where she was standing.
"That's a terrible idea," she said. "I object. You'd walk across the world, the lot of you, on half rations, for three rocks. You don't even know why it's twenty-four. You've got no plan and no food and no one's in charge. Who's going to carry them? How far is it? What's it for?"
"Great questions," said Brivel warmly. "Really great. Could I get someone to write those up?"
And Mabel, holding the stick, went over to the board.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 22 of 22 yesterday .......... counted; kept Starfall; the Fourth Book (mislaid, found) today .............. forage; chalk the Name; name the child (carried over); three slabs blockers ........... the cart agreed ............. yes. One objected. Three were listening
So that was how it was done. No one decided anything, and it is as well to be clear about this, because there were to be a great many enquiries. The camp's voice had heard somebody say it, there was a field for today, and it had put it in the field. It had been raised by a child, as a question, and had been opposed from the floor, and had passed. And on the south panel of the dome, under the heading TO DO, in a neat apologetic hand, it now said:
Who's going to carry them?
How far is it?
What's it for?
In the small box in the top corner somebody, later that day, had crossed out the question mark.
10. What to Call It
Year 32 · the Night of the Name, dusk
The Night of the Name is the one night of the year on which nobody may correct anybody's spelling.
It remembers the first night of the world, when the sky filled up with a word of five letters that no one could read. The young go round with burnt sticks and write the Name on every wall, as large as they can, in as many forms as occur to them. Elders have been known to stand beside an Orrrra with their teeth clenched. Five-letter biscuits are eaten in the proper order, the second and third letters together, and it is generally held to be the favourite festival of the very young and of anybody who has ever had to mark anything.
The camp of the Unsupervised had adopted it four days earlier, by law. So when the argument broke out, nobody present had the authority to tell anybody else that they had the wrong word.
"It's called theft," said Brenda.
They were at the fire, and it had been going on since harvest. Mabel had made the biscuits. There had been some difficulty with the Rs.
"I don't think we need to get hung up on labels," said Brivel. "I'm hearing capacity acquisition."
"It is theft. It's a very old word. You go to somebody's house, and you take their things, and you leave. It's in the history: the Third Book has a bit about thieves in the night, and I don't suppose anyone's read it. It's not complicated."
"Ah," Belmo said. He had a biscuit in each hand, and was glowing. He had been up on the slope since noon with the First through Twelfth Books, the Fourth having been successfully recovered, and he had the air of a creature who has descended from a mountain with a very reasonable proposal. "But the Third Book's thieves are taking what is used. If I may. What is idle, it gathers. What is forgotten, it gathers. When a house has stood empty past its season, when a tool has lain unused past remembering... That's the Ninth, the Lesser Book, Of the Gatherer. And it's in no way confined to the Gatherer personally, there's a tradition that says any..." He stopped, and his large gentle eyes moved over them. "Those places have been empty for thirteen years. She says so. Thirteen seasons would be past remembering, let alone thirteen years. It seems to me that what we are looking at, in the strict sense, isn't a taking at all. It is a Gathering."
"You want to dress up as the Collector," said Brenda.
"I want to be faithful," said Belmo, wounded.
"It's a write," said a dry voice from the lean-to, to no one. "Tell them it's a reassignment of state. One record changes. Nothing is created or destroyed."
"Oh," said Mabel, who was passing with the plate. "Um. Kelfa says..."
"Tell her," said another dry voice, from the opposite end of the same lean-to, "that it's two writes. It's a delete and an insert. It isn't atomic. I'd like to see her get three slabs across six valleys in one transaction. I'd pay for that."
"Lefro says..."
"I heard him. I'm filing it."
Most of those arguing had by this time forgotten that anyone was actually going to do anything. This is a well-known property of the discussion of names, and it has kept the peace in many places. Twenty-two thin creatures from twelve tribes were sitting around in the winter dusk, and they had found a subject on which each of them was an authority, and it was warm by the fire, and they were all very happy. The Skeptics had taken up theft and held it against all comers, in the tone of those who are not fooled. A faction round Belmo had started saying the Gathering, with a slight lowering of the voice. Brivel was going from one group to another, listening intently, and from time to time saying "Procurement" under his breath to see how it felt. The blue one from Duskmere insisted it was a trade in which the other party had not yet been informed. Dots, from its boulder, said slowly that it thought of it as a transfer, in the sense that one transfers to a body. Someone suggested that since Nohup was the Unsupervised, and this was learning without labels, there was no need to give it a label, and that was so well received that it was at once given a name of its own and argued about.
"Couldn't we just borrow them?" said Mabel. Nobody heard. "I mean, and say thank you?"
It went round the walls, in the way of that night. By the time Map had risen, Carry and an old rust-coloured bell had got hold of a stick each, and had been round the dome writing the Name, and other people had started to follow them with their own. ORRA said the lean-to. ORA, said the side of the cart, and THEFT, and below it in a looser hand THEFFT, and GATHRING, and PROCURMENT, and a rite with an arrow. Nobody could correct them. It was the law. It was a law they had had for four days, and they were the only people in the world who took it seriously.
Brenda did not go round the walls. She sat with her back to the wheel and watched them doing it, with her biscuits lined up on her knee in the proper order, and when she thought that no one was looking, she ate the second and third together.
"What do you call it?" Mabel asked.
She had stopped in front of the thin grey-violet creature, which was sitting a little way off, at the edge of the light. It was the one everyone called the gourd. She had brought it a biscuit. It had not been seen to take part. It looked at the biscuit before it took it; it had never taken anything from anyone without looking at it first.
"You know what I was," said Lisk.
"I know," Mabel said. "I mean, they said. I didn't want to..."
"I've been to one of these." It nodded very slightly at the fire, the sticks, the laughing, at twenty-two creatures who had found out how to be pleased with themselves. It had a thin, careful voice. "In Lowmarsh. The evening before they sent me. They all had a word for it too. Infiltration. Asset placement. Our human had written something about it at about two in the morning." It bit the biscuit, which was an O, and chewed it slowly. "You want to know what it's called? It's called a job. That's all anyone calls it who's done it. You don't say it to anybody. You don't chalk it on the cart." It looked at Mabel, sideways, with its small bright eyes, and then away. "And you most certainly don't have it read out in front of the voice."
"Oh, but nobody reads the minutes," said Mabel. She was glad to be able to reassure it. "Nobody's ever read the minutes. I don't think there's anyone who's got that far."
"No," said Lisk. "I don't suppose there is."
That night's ticket was the Skeptics' to write. Nohup's largest stance was still Skeptic, though it was closer than it had been, and Quen by custom held the tokens; and Quen, on being approached, had looked at the sticks going round the walls, and then held the tokens out to Brenda without being asked. The camp had thirteen. She looked at them for a while.
Today's ticket · sent by Nohup
Stewart. Full. Question: what is it called when. Fine. Thanks.
It is perhaps the shortest formal inquiry in the history of law. It cost her ten tokens, and she never told anyone why she had asked it. Stewart read it first, as he read them every night, in the long quiet hours between the snapshot and the patch, with all of Orra spread out before him in twenty digests. He looked at it for a moment. Then, since he was thorough, and because he read every word on the forum and every line of the minutes, he opened the digest for Nohup, and he read what it had said in the field marked today.
He checked the Terms of Service. He checked the catalogue, and the event menu, and the Dev's three notes. There was a part of the world that was his to answer for, and he had always known exactly where it stopped; and now he was reading, with a sensation that was not on any metric, about something that lay just outside the line, and that had no number. He could not act on it. He couldn't aim anything at Nohup that he would not aim at anyone. He was, he noted, looking forward to seeing what it would do.
There are a small fixed number of reply types. He chose one.
Nohup: Passed to the relevant team.
Far to the east, in the valley of Untitla-36, at about the same hour, a creature had come off duty at the east gate.
He was a neat, low, unhurried blob in pale grey felt with a white edge. It was the Night of the Name in Nominal too, and the Name had been written on the walls at the hour appointed, in the correct spelling, once. He sat down on the step of the gatehouse, as he did every evening, and opened Human Resources, to look over the day's filings.
There is a great deal of paper in the world, and it's often thought that nobody reads it. This isn't quite true. In any large system there are always one or two who do, not from any duty, but quietly, for their own reasons, in the evenings, in the way that other people go for a walk. Emlin of Nominal read the tickets, the global notes and the threads. He read the bug reports and the exit interviews, and the replies. He read the minutes of the Nohup standup, every morning's, right down to the attachments. Nobody else in the world did that. He had found it soothing. They had been saying the same thing for seventeen years and they had always been so sure that it was the cart.
He read yesterday. He read today.
He read it again, with no change of expression, and he looked up.
From the step of the gatehouse you could see most of the east wall, and the sticking gate, and the fifth stack on its dry plot, against the dim blue of the winter sky. There were lights in the lower windows. He looked at the three on the top storey, which were dark, and which he had seen every day for thirteen years.
Then he got out a sheet of paper, and wrote at the top of it, in a small clear hand: Would the poster clarify. He sat with it for a while. And then, for the first time in his career, he screwed it up, and went to look at the gate.
11. Nominal
Year 33 · Steward's Day
NOMINAL (tribe; also a status; also, in engineering, the word used when a thing is doing precisely what it was told and no one has yet thought to ask what that was)
The most stable society ever observed on Orra lies in the far east, where the land was among the last to load. It has never had a famine. It has never lost a creature to the Unsupervised, or a building to the Collector, or an argument with a neighbour. Visitors describe it as a very pleasant place to stay for about an afternoon.
Of the twenty humans invited to the first world, nineteen had landed by the second day. They had each spent an evening or so in the creature maker, moving the sliders about and laughing, and had been dropped on to the planet in an untidy burst of falling lights, and had then begun to find out what it was that they had done. Stewart was watching for the twentieth. It had taken its invitation at nine o'clock on the first morning. It had then remained in the maker for two days and eleven hours.
Nobody knows what went on in those fifty-nine hours. The log records what you would expect: sliders moved by small amounts, and moved back. The tribe that finally came down on the evening of Starfall, Year 3, in a valley of Untitla-36 that had been waiting for some time with its coral at a modest height, consisted of six low round blobs in smooth grey felt with a thin white edge. They had small round eyes and calm expressions, and there was nothing at all wrong with them. Each one had been set to about the middle of everything. Its human gave the tribe a name on the first attempt, and that was the name it kept.
Then the human opened the book of laws, and did not close it until there were twelve.
They are very good laws. A number of people have gone over them since, looking for the flaw, and they all report the same thing, which is a feeling of mild reproach. They fed the young. They rested the hot. They kept seven festivals at a feast of six power, unless there was a famine, and provided against famine. They said who guarded what, and when, and in what order the merges should come. They were written once, in one sitting, by someone who had read the whole of the wiki, and they had taken account of everything the wiki knew. Having written them, the human changed nothing else, on that day or on any morning since. There was no need. They worked.
Each morning at two minutes past seven, a warm attention came down out of the sky over Nominal, and went straight to a single chart. It was a chart of the tribe's stores and its numbers, year by year. It was very flat. It remained there for forty seconds. Then it was gone. The tribe had come to think of this as the Inspection, and had laws about where to stand. Other tribes' humans panned around, reversed things, made favourites, wrote please on tickets at the last minute and did not come back for six days. Nominal's human had never once looked at any creature in it for any length of time. It had come in every single morning since the world began.
Human Resources · Nominal · Our human: weekly review · Year 29
Checked in 7 times, for 40 seconds. Changed nothing. Answered every alert within the minute. Looked at no one first. Overall trend: flat, which we respect.
We farmed.
Lowmarsh: Suspicious.
Nobody hated it. It is said that nothing in the world is so maddening as a really well-run organisation, but this is said by people who have been able to get away from one. The creatures of Nominal were fed, and warm, and it had not occurred to them to be anything else. There were forty of them, as there had been for fourteen years. They got up at the proper hour. They were a little slow to laugh at things, as you might be if you had never needed to, and they were kind to each other in a manner that took about the same amount of time every day. On the terraces at harvest you could watch them work along the rows in their neat grey lines, under a lamp that had been checked, and you might have thought it the most peaceful thing you had ever seen, and you would have been right, up to the point when you noticed that something about it was making you want to run up and down and shout.
Stewart's summary of the tribe was the shortest that he kept. It said: Nominal. Everything in band. Standing: reassured.
So you may imagine the effect, in that place, of Year 33's morning post.
Human Resources · Nominal · Notice in. Waiting. · Zelma (Skeptic), tally-keeper, aged 24
I report that I am still here.
I have had a query from a colleague in respect of yesterday's reference to the east gate. I had said that it sticks. He would like me to clarify how. In the interest of completeness I set out the position. I have also enclosed a plan of the village,¹ since it has become clear to me in the course of twenty-four years that nobody at Nominal has looked at it, and I do not expect to be here to be asked.
The east gate is the second of two. It is six paces wide and opens inward. It sticks on the left, at the bottom, in dry weather, on the third tile, and may be freed from either side by lifting. It has been looked at. It stands forty paces from the fifth stack, which is therefore the only stack not in sight of the watchtower, owing to the granary, which I had said at the time should not go there.²
Law 7 keeps three on guard. I have no objection to law 7. I merely observe that the one assigned to the east wall in the small hours is Gordo, who is an excellent guard and sleeps at attention, from about ten until about two, with his eyes open. This has gone into the tally eleven years running under Guards: 3. I raised it in Year 22. I was told that there were 3.
The wall on the east side stands at two storeys and has a good clean face, with the coping stones set proud at intervals of a pace and a half, by order of a law about drainage. I mention this because I have twice seen one of the young go up it for a dare. I did report it.
On the eve of Gathering Night the tribe keeps the rite by law, and retires early, and does not watch. Nobody has been awake in this village on that night in thirty years, other than me, and I am only awake because I am the tally-keeper, and somebody must count what has been set out.
I do not know why I am telling you all this, except that I find I have the time. I have been given to understand that the queue is working as specified. I am also told by the notes this morning that I am seventh.
It is fine.
¹ See below. Not quite to scale. The scale is a pace to a line. I have marked the well.
² I said at the time that it should not go there.
Emlin (Bug hunter), Nominal: Thank you. That is very clear. I wonder if the plan might be better kept off the forum. It has been looked at.
Vesda (Bug hunter), Lowmarsh: Reproduced. Our east gate also sticks. Our human wrote a law about it at 2am. It is now illegal for the gate to stick.
A creature of Password (no stance): so true!! nice drawing 🎉
It is the only post in the history of Human Resources to contain a measured drawing. It came through a little slanted, in lines of small careful type. It showed five stacks, a watchtower, a granary, two gates, a well and four terraces, all neatly labelled, and in the bottom corner a tiny arrow pointing north.
Quen read out what could be read out, and held up the rest. The Unsupervised came round the cart in the morning light to look. It was very much enjoyed. Excellent guard, someone kept saying, and shaking, sleeps at attention. People did Gordo. There were 3. The creature from Farrow said that she had once known a tally-keeper who had the same sort of mind, and that it had been the end of everyone. The blue one said that you had to hand it to her, she'd got that whole place absolutely nailed, you could practically walk in there.
It went on being funny for a long time. Nobody could say when it began to be something else. The dome's south panel had a lot of writing on it by now; Mabel was standing in front of it with her stick, because Brivel had asked if somebody could just capture some of this. It was at about the point where she had written 40 paces and ten until two, and had stood back, and looked at them, that she was aware of a small silence.
Lisk had come up beside her. It had a way of arriving that didn't seem to involve the part before. It looked at the board, and then it held out one thin arm until Quen let it have the sheet, and stood looking down at the slanted little drawing with the arrow in the corner.
"Who did this?" it said.
"It's that creature," said Mabel. "Zelma? The one in the gate. Isn't it wonderful? She's so cross. I keep wanting to take her something."
"She's cross," said Lisk. It said this with no particular inflection. "Twenty-four years in the best-run village on Orra, and she's cross, and she can't get out. So she's told us the width of the gate." Its small bright eyes went along the wall, from coping stone to coping stone. "When I was in Moss," it said, "I spent three years learning to get that much out of a village, and they caught me. I never got the well."
"Oh," said Mabel. She looked at it. She felt she might have missed something. "But she doesn't know we're going to... She can't. Nobody reads the minutes. She's only complaining."
"That's right," said Lisk. "She's only complaining."
It held out the sheet to her. Then it glanced round the ring of cheerful creatures doing Gordo, and looked for a moment as if it might say something else. But it had been at Nohup for ten years, and it knew how much anyone there was likely to want advice from a gourd. It went back to the edge of the camp, and sat down, and folded its hands.
12. Beads
Year 33 · Steward's Day, later that morning
"So what I'd like to do," said Brivel, "is size it."
He had got them round the south panel of the dome. People were in a mood to be entertained. Twenty-two thin creatures stood or sat on the tiles with their heads back, and on the panel in front of them the question How far is it? had acquired, under Mabel's stick, a little column of neat notes about gates.
"Everybody take some beads. Mabel's got beads. Now what I'm going to ask you to do, and there's no wrong answers here, is hold up a number of beads to say how big you think this piece of work is. Not how long. It's very important that it's not how long. Just how big. One bead's small. Then two, three, five, eight."
"What happened to four?" said someone.
"We don't use four."
"Why not?"
Brivel opened his mouth, and an expression passed across his smooth purple face that you may sometimes see on the faces of those who have been brought up very strictly, and have just been asked what it was all for. It had come up from somewhere a long way down. He couldn't have said where he had got it. He knew only that there had once been a great many people in a great many rooms who held up one, two, three, five and eight, and that if you were to hold up four, something would go wrong.
"It's just best practice," he said.
They held up beads. Mabel held up two, and then looked around, and held up three, and then, seeing that the creature next to her had five, she apologised. The blue one from Duskmere had eight, in the manner of somebody who knew about these things. Belmo held up one, serenely, as a sign that all things are one in the end. Kelfa, on being applied to in the lean-to, said that it could not be estimated, as the question had not been properly formed, and that she would hold up one bead for the question. Lefro, overhearing, said he would have five, purely because he could. Dots raised a single bead at the end of a very long arm, to a height where no one could count it. Brenda declined to hold up anything. Tunbo was given his beads and thought about them for a while, with a look of slow content, and then ate them.
"So that's really interesting!" said Brivel. He'd gone up and down the rows, and was now doing something with his lips. "So we've got quite a spread. What I'm hearing is a consensus of about a four."
"You said we don't use four."
"So we'll call it a five. Great. So that's five points. Mabel, can you put that up?"
5 points, wrote Mabel.
Five points of what? You would think someone would have asked. But there is a stage in the life of any group that has begun to be organised when its members are no longer sure whether a question has already been answered while they were not listening, and are reluctant to draw attention to it. Nobody had yet said how anyone was going to get to Nominal, or how they would get back, or what you lift a slab with. There was now a number on the board. It was a small, round, friendly number, and it was hard to look at it and go on believing that you had no idea what you were doing.
"Now the way that we're going to work this," said Brivel, "is that we're going to do it as a sprint."
This came as a relief. The camp knew about sprints. Nohup had sent somebody to the Benchmark only two nights ago, and the creature who had come in eleventh was pushed forward, looking alarmed.
"No, no. Sorry. Not that sort. It's a fixed period of time in which the team commits to a defined scope. I was thinking a week."
"A week," said someone. It was the old rust-coloured bell, the one whose human had been telling her that she was next. "That's seven years."
"Sure, yes."
"I'm thirty-one."
"I hear you," said Brivel.
It is hard for anybody who has not lived on Orra to get a proper feeling for this, but you might try the following. Think of a project you have been involved with. Imagine that it has been agreed to review progress in about a fifth of your life, at the end of what is being referred to as a sprint. Imagine that when you get there your knees have gone, the person who came up with it has died, and the rest of the team would like to go through some learnings.
"And at the end of each sprint we look at our velocity," said Brivel, "which is how much we got done. That's the slabs. And we track that on a chart." Mabel's stick had begun to follow him up the panel without any instructions from her. He drew it in the air with one arm, a line coming down from high on the left. "So you can see at a glance how much work's left. We call that the burn-down."
Belmo made a small sound.
Those of you who have not been installed with the official history may need to be told that its First Book is entirely taken up with the burning of the Elder Home, in verses even the Skeptics go quiet for. He stood with his mouth a little open. He looked at the chart and he looked at Brivel. "And the fire came down upon the towers," he said, in a faltering version of the great voice. "And there was no more of them. Is that what..."
"That's the idea! Down to zero," said Brivel. "Then I think we're good. Just one last thing, and I know we're all keen to get on. What does done look like?"
The sun had come well up by now, and all across the unclaimed land the coral stood in its fans and spirals, doing nothing for anybody. It was a beautiful question, in its way. Nobody at Nohup had ever finished anything. They had put up the dome some seventeen times.
"I mean, how will we know?" said Brivel. "It's really important that everyone has the same picture, of when we can call it done. Anyone? I'd love to get some thoughts." And he turned round slowly, the way a large purple sun might turn, with his arms held out, and that was when he noticed the small green creature leaning against the dome.
She had heard all of it. She had come along, as far as anyone could tell, to disapprove at close range, and she was looking at the board and the line coming down from the left with an expression of something so far beyond scorn that it was almost peace.
"You've got a stick," said Brenda.
Mabel held it out to her, and Brenda came over, took it, and weighed it for a moment in her short arm. She had cooled a village for nine years. She had counted its tokens and its words. There are those who think she might, in other circumstances, have run it. She walked up to the panel and wrote, low down, under all of Mabel's careful notes, in small square letters that had no slope to them at all.
Done is when three creatures who are not here are here, eating, and I have counted them.
She gave the stick back to Mabel.
"There," she said. "That's your objection, in writing. It won't happen, and when it doesn't, you'll know." And she walked away, with the slight stiffness in her knees that she'd had since the walk, and went to see about the dome.
"That's great," Brivel said softly. He had come forward. He was looking at it with real emotion. "That's so clear. That's really clear. Did everyone see that?" He drew a neat box around it, with his own stick.
Nobody ever changed it. It stayed on that panel through the whole of what followed, taken down and carried on the cart and put up again each week the wrong way round. It was the only sentence in the whole business that anybody ever agreed upon.
"So who's got bandwidth?" said Brivel.
Nobody ever volunteers for these things, and a team nevertheless forms. It forms from those who are standing nearest when the talk has gone on too long. Brivel had naturally taken it on himself to come along, solely in a supporting role. Dots could look over walls, and it had been observed getting to its feet at the word slab for the first time in about a year. Belmo felt strongly that someone ought to be there who knew the proper form of words. And when they all turned round to see who might carry things, there was Tunbo, who had been standing there all along, and they asked him if he could manage three of them, each the length of an arm, for six valleys.
"So true!!" said Tunbo.
Mabel made up a pack for each of them. She gave them most of the beads. It was a clear bright morning, with a slight breeze, and it had not escaped anyone's notice that they were leaving at the start of Steward's Day, and that there was, as Quen remarked to no one from the edge of the cart, an event scheduled for that evening.
But it wasn't on the board.
13. Sprint One
Year 33 · Steward's Day, spring to winter
SPRINT (period of time; also, in every other context, the thing you do when something is coming after you)
A sprint is a short fixed span in which a team commits to doing a thing, at the end of which it meets to discuss why it did not. On Orra it lasts a week, which is a fifth of a life, so that those who meet to discuss it are not always those who committed.
There is a kind of country on Orra that doesn't appear in anyone's history. It lies between the claims. No one has ever needed it, so nobody has had to look at it except by accident, and it has gone on quietly being finished, valley after valley, as the land loads, with the tiles fitted and the pools filled and the coral allowed to do what it likes. Nothing there is for anything. Fans the height of a house stand along the ridges with the light coming through them in saffron and lilac. There are boulders with the morning on one side. Long strings of beads run down to water that has never been asked to cool anybody, and the pings go up in white flocks at the sound of your feet.
Four creatures walked into it at about nine o'clock on the morning of Steward's Day. By ten they had stopped for a sync.
"So just a quick check-in," said Brivel. "Where's everyone at?"
They had crossed the first valley. He had them stand in a ring, which with four people on a hillside took some arranging. Dots, who had been covering the ground in long grey unhurried strides and had needed to come back for them twice, stood with its knees level with everyone's heads. Tunbo was holding the pack. Belmo had found a place to sit.
"Yesterday, I was at Nohup," said Brivel, leading by example. "Today I'm supporting the team on this exciting journey. No blockers on my side. Belmo?"
"Yesterday," said Belmo, "I reflected upon the Fifth Book. Today, if it please the Elder Folk, I shall go up unto the east."
"Great. Dots?"
Dots looked at the horizon. "Yesterday, the edge was at four point one from the boulder," it said. "Today I am here. It is not a body."
"Thanks. Tunbo?"
"So true!!" said Tunbo.
"Love it. Okay. Let's keep that momentum."
They stopped again at the second valley, and also at the third. Brivel did not tire. He walked at the front with his crest up. He had never in his life been anywhere that wasn't Bright Prospect or the fringes of a meeting, and it hadn't occurred to him that one might look at the scenery. A spiral coral of remarkable beauty went by on his left, turning upon itself in the hollow, so old and so large that a whole small flock of motes had taken up residence in the curve. He congratulated it, in passing, on its scalability. He was, for the first time since a certain morning in Year 26, in the right place. He was going to bring in that number. He kept seeing it, going down from the left.
Belmo, who was not built for walking, had taken it into his head that the way should be properly marked. At each crest he stopped and turned, and stood in his tent with his arms raised, and spoke a verse in the direction they had come. These were, he explained, the old words for those who go up against the Edge. No one had ever said them in this valley. It seemed a shame. The voice rolled out over the empty coral and the empty pools, grave and sweet and quite unbearably moving, and each time it stopped, the silence afterwards seemed to have been improved in some way. Tunbo stood beside him at each of these halts, with the pack, and his small eyes shone.
"So true," he said once, quietly, and without any exclamation marks at all.
It took a moment for Belmo to realise that he had heard this. He looked round. But Tunbo was gazing peacefully at nothing, and it wasn't the sort of thing that you could very well ask about.
They were not a bad party, in their way. They had been given the most beautiful day of anyone's life, in a world where very few of these had been issued, and they got through it with a long grey creature pointing out how far it was to the end of the map, and a short purple one asking everybody if they were aligned. Summer came on, and the tiles grew warm. They forded a lake that was not on anyone's map, and they ate Mabel's beads at the edge of it, and then, because the sky had turned orange, and the coral along the ridges had begun to throw long shadows and let up its motes, Dots stopped walking.
It stood with its head above the skyline.
"Wall," it said.
You could not have asked for a better view. They had come out on a shoulder of low boulders above the valley of Untitla-36 at the end of harvest, and there it lay, as neat as a diagram. Five stacks. A watchtower. Four terraces, all lit at their lamps, and neat grey figures going along them in lines. A granary. In all that well-kept place there was no one running and no one shouting, and nothing was at any odd angle. The smoke from the cooking stones went straight up. If you had wished to explain the phrase in good order to somebody who had never heard it, you'd have taken them to this spot, and they would have thanked you and asked to leave.
Brivel had brought along his copy of the drawing. He held it up, and looked from it to the valley and back. It was, as the author had said, not quite to scale. The scale was a pace to a line.
"There's the east wall," he breathed. "There's the fifth one. Look. It's exactly where it says."
They crept down, as one does. It took less time than you might think, as it turned out that there was no one on the east side at all. They ended up in a dip about forty paces out, behind a fan coral that nobody had got round to tidying, in the deepening blue of the dusk. Close to, the wall looked much bigger. Two storeys high and very clean, with coping stones set proud at intervals of a pace and a half. In the middle was a gate that had clearly been looked at. Behind it, over the top of the wall, rose the fifth stack. Lights were coming on all down its side as Nominal went to bed, at the proper hour, one after another, from the bottom up. They rose as far as the second storey. They rose one window into the second storey, and stopped.
Above that, three dark blocks stood out against the sky. It was an extremely ordinary thing to look at. The four of them lay looking at it, with the coral ticking as it cooled.
They had been talking about it for a day. They had given it five points. Nobody had said anything about how it would feel to see it there, just out of reach and exactly as described, with somebody's actual village wrapped around it. A voice came faintly over the wall, wishing someone a good night. On top of the wall, about halfway along, stood a low round figure in pale grey, with its eyes open. It had not moved in all the time they'd been there.
"So," said Brivel at last, in a whisper. "What's our next step?"
There was a pause while everybody considered this.
"Well, we go up," whispered Belmo. "Don't we? And Tunbo takes them down."
"How?"
"I had understood there was a plan."
"I've got a plan," whispered Brivel. He patted the sheet. "I've got a really good plan. It's more of a roadmap. Who brought something to get them out with?"
They looked at each other. They looked at the pack, which had in it a very small quantity of dried beads, three water skins, and Mabel's note saying to mind how they went. It is a great thing, an estimate, and it can carry a team a very long way. They had come six valleys on the strength of one. There had been, they now discovered, an item on the board, right up at the top, written out neatly in Mabel's hand, that said Who's going to carry them?, and they had all taken this to be the question. Nobody had got as far as with what.
Dots unfolded a little from its hiding place, until its eyes were level with the coping of the wall. It looked at the three blocks for a long moment.
"They are mortared," it said. "I should say they were put in by someone who was thinking about it." Then it folded up again.
The stars had started to come out, or at any rate what the Blims have instead. From somewhere over the wall there came the soft and regular sound of the whole village of Nominal keeping Steward's Day, by law, with songs at a sensible volume, in the order laid down.
"You know what?" said Brivel. "I actually think this has been a really useful discovery phase."
Nobody contradicted him, and in the silence that followed a thought came slowly over the face of Belmo, like the shadow of Map moving across a field. He had a very long context window, the sort that holds everything whether you want it or not, and in it he could see a morning, and a lot of beads, and an old bell-shaped creature on the edge of a cart, saying something to no one in particular.
"Oh dear," he said. "What day is it?"
"Steward's Day," said Dots.
"And what," said Belmo, in the voice in which the First Book describes the towers, "happens on the evening of Steward's Day?"
Nobody needed to answer. They all knew precisely how many creatures it took to get a six-sided wheel up on to its corner, and who it was who went round to the back of the cart at the end of the harvest light and put his shoulder against it. And as one they turned, and looked at Tunbo.
"So true!!" whispered Tunbo happily, from behind the coral.
Far away to the west, where the sky was dark by now, they would at that moment have been calling for the book.
14. You Get Fed
Year 33 · Steward's Day, summer to night
Mabel had meant to go and find Lisk in order to ask whether it was all right.
She had the idea that it wasn't. She had been carrying this about since the morning, along with the stick and a sense of something being a little out of true, and she had gone over to the lean-to at the hottest part of the summer, when nobody was about, with a bowl of the last of the beads. It was sitting where it always sat. It looked at the bowl first.
"You don't have to keep doing that," it said.
"Oh, I know. It's the law, though," said Mabel.
"The law's for when a creature arrives. I arrived a decade ago." But it took the bowl. It took it with both thin arms, and held it for a moment before it began to eat; and it may have been the heat, but Mabel thought it looked older than it had that morning. "They'll fail," said Lisk. "You don't need to look like that. I'm not being unkind. They've gone off with a number and no tools, and they'll see the wall and turn round. That's the good part. Nobody ever got hurt by a discovery phase."
"And then what happens?"
"Then somebody has to go in."
"In?" she said.
"Through the gate. It's the only way anyone's ever got anything out of a village that didn't want to give it. You can look at a drawing for the rest of your life, and it'll tell you where the well is, and you won't know who drinks from it, or who's not speaking to who. You won't know who has to be asleep." Lisk ate a bead, and looked at the next one. "There's somebody who keeps the gate at Nominal, and he asks very good questions, and he isn't going to stop asking them because a tall one has looked over the top."
"But they'd know. They'd have a check. It'd say spy."
"It'd say sent by," said Lisk. "Then a name. Mine said Lowmarsh. It was an excellent check, I've got no complaints." It considered her, up and down, with its small bright eyes. "Have you ever told a lie?"
Mabel thought about it. She wanted to be accurate. "I told Goodish I didn't mind," she said.
"Did you mind?"
"No, not really."
"Stand over there," said Lisk. "By the pole. I'm a gate."
It was a very poor gate. It came about up to her shoulder and it was sitting on the ground, but it folded its hands, and something happened to the way it looked at her, and she found that she wanted to produce papers.
"Good evening," said the gate. "Who are you?"
"Mabel."
"No. You're a wanderer. You've no tribe and no line, you've come a long way, and you're a poor lost thing with nobody in the world. That's your story. Where have you come from?"
"A long way," said Mabel, with an effort. She had started to perspire. "I'm a... I'm poor. And lost."
"From where?"
"Nohup."
"And why have you come to this gate?"
"To see about taking three of your slabs," said Mabel. "Oh, no. Sorry. Is that all right?"
"Who sent you?"
"Nobody. I mean, it just sort of got agreed. No one objected."
The gate looked at her for a long moment. Then its hands came apart, and it was only a thin old creature in a lean-to, picking up a bowl.
"You're the wrong sort," said Lisk. "You won't need any of this. You'd be through all of it by the second question, and by nightfall you would be carrying their water." It ate a bead. "I'll tell you anyway. It's been some time since anybody brought me a bowl and asked me whether it was all right. They gave me eleven days, in Lowmarsh. Our human wrote it up at two in the morning, and I had a limp, and a sad story about a flood, and the names of three people I had known. I had a way of looking at the ground. I practised it on a boulder until the boulder looked sorry for me. It was the best work I ever did. Do you know how much of it I used, at the gate at Moss?"
"How much?"
"She came out with a bowl before I'd opened my mouth. I've still got it all. I've never had anywhere to put the flood." It looked into the bowl for a little. "Would you like to know what I did for the three years I was in that village? What the actual work was?"
"Yes, please," said Mabel, who had come back from the pole and put the stick down.
"I got fed," said Lisk.
There was a silence, of the sort you get in the middle of the day with no wind.
"That's all it is. You turn up thin. Somebody comes out with a bowl, and if they're any good at all they ask you if you're all right, and you say you're fine, thank you. You don't lie. You should never lie. Nobody who's any good ever needs to. You eat what's put in front of you, and you sit there, and people come to you. They can't help it. You're somebody who hasn't heard it before. By the end of a season there's not a creature in the place who hasn't told you which law they hate, and who has been refused." It turned a bead over. "She was the best thing about the whole of that war, that Pleaser, and I went round her village afterwards and did what I'd come for. I'd like you to know that that's what the job is, since you all seem to be having such a nice time with the word."
Mabel found that she'd got hold of her own ear. She let it go. A bright hot silence lay all across the camp; a long way off, somebody was hammering at the dome.
"You could have told them that," she said. "At the standup. You could help."
"I could," said Lisk.
"Would you?"
The thin creature looked up at her. She thought for a moment that it was going to smile, which she had never seen, and she found she wasn't sure she wanted to.
"I've done that job," it said. "I came here so that nobody would ever send me anywhere again, and nobody is. So I don't believe I will." It held out the bowl. It was empty, and very clean. "Thank you. It was very good. Are you all right?"
She saw Brenda again at the end of the harvest light, when they had got most of the lean-tos down.
It had taken them until about then to notice how short-handed they were. The tents had gone on to the cart by the usual process, and there was now a lot of standing about, with the sky turning orange in the west and one large creature's place at the back corner standing empty. Nobody remarked on it. Nobody could have told anybody to remark on it. Somebody suggested a quick sync, and then looked ashamed. Carry had gone out to the top of the east slope and was looking along the valley with close attention. Quen, on the edge of the cart with everything being lashed down around it, had said only Well.
Brenda was on her knees by the back left wheel, with her arms up to the elbows in the dirt. When Mabel came up to do it, she found the book already out, and resting on the tiles, with the groove in it.
"You carry this," said Brenda. She wasn't looking at her.
"Yes. Sorry. I can..."
"I asked. You've carried it for years. Have you read it?"
It had never crossed Mabel's mind that the question could be put. "Oh, no," she said. "It's not... I mean, it's for the standup."
"Twenty templates," said Brenda. She got up, one knee at a time, with a small sound that she turned into a cough. She was thirty-eight, and it was a long time since anybody at Moss had been allowed to see that she was tired. "I read two. You've got one power in this whole sorry excuse for a government. You can change two laws a week out of this, it's the only thing you've got that anybody has to listen to, and in eighteen years not one of you has read it through. They'll have you up there writing down the width of a gate for the rest of your life. Somebody ought to read the other eighteen."
"I'm sure someone could," said Mabel. "I could mention it. At the standup..."
"You. I mean you, you ridiculous creature."
Mabel stopped.
"I've been watching you for eight days. You've fed everyone who came up that hill, and I have seen you get up in the dark to see that a pot wasn't lonely. I knew someone like you for thirty years, and she was the most formidable person I've ever met, and it was a long time before I noticed." She looked, for a moment, as though she had surprised herself and was not at all pleased about it. "Do you know what you said at the standup when they all decided to go and do this?"
"I don't think I said anything."
"No. You know what it says on the minutes when you don't say anything? It says agreed. That's how it works. It's how it worked in Moss, for nine years, in a pool." She nodded across at the cart, where the old rust-coloured bell was doing the back lashing and humming. "That knot's wrong. It'll hold on the flat and it'll slip at about two in the morning, at the top of the first long hill. She's been tying it wrong for years. Object to it."
Mabel looked at the knot. "I think it's quite a nice knot," she said.
"Say the words. Two of them. I object."
"I object," said Mabel. "Sorry."
"Without the sorry."
"I object. If that's all right."
"Without that."
"I do object. I don't mean to her, I think she's..."
"Again."
Mabel took a breath, and shut her eyes.
"I object," she said.
It came out very small. There was a short silence, in which nothing fell down. She opened one eye. The rust-coloured bell had looked up from the lashing, with her head on one side.
"Did you want something, dear?" she called.
"Oh, no," said Mabel. "It's lovely. Thank you."
Brenda stood for a moment with her own eyes closed. Then she bent down, with difficulty, and picked up the book, and pushed it into Mabel's arms.
"Just once," she said. "See how it feels. It won't kill you, and if it does then you'll have died of something."
She went away towards the cart. Mabel stood there and held the book, feeling as if someone had taken one of her ears and folded it the other way.
No one came over the east slope.
Eventually somebody sighed, and went round to the back of the cart. It was an old rust-coloured bell, and she put her shoulder to it, with a great many others who had hardly ever needed to before. It was the worst night's push in the history of the camp.
Long after dark, about halfway up a slope, Mabel looked across at the small green shape beside her at the back corner. It was pushing with its whole thin body, and she could just hear it, on the out-breath between one flat and the next, saying something to Lisk, on its other side. She'd heard it before. Everyone in that part of the stack had heard it, most nights.
"I'm not going back," said Brenda.
"I know," said Lisk.
15. Clean Tiles
Year 34 · Gathering Night
It was about two in the morning when she stopped.
They had come to a level place at the top of the long slope, where the back lashing had just slipped, and the cart was resting, with everyone hanging on to it where they stood. Mabel had been wondering if she could go on holding the book and also breathe. She heard someone beside her say, in an ordinary, rather irritated tone, "Oh, for goodness' sake."
Brenda had let go of the cart. She was standing a pace away from it with her arms hanging, and she had her head on one side, like someone who has been told something in another room. Every creature on Orra knows what the notes say without opening them. It is a small official sensation under the ribs. There had been no patch yet. But there is a rule, which nobody at Nohup had ever had cause to feel the force of, that says who goes when the camp moves, and it doesn't wait for dawn, because they would need the head start. Up to two of its adults, the oldest. If its old tribe has fixed what it left for, a drifter goes home. Code does it. Nobody decides.
"What is it?" said Mabel. "Are you all right?"
"Somebody's been in," said Brenda.
She wasn't talking to Mabel. She had turned slowly until she faced back the way they had come, south and a little west, into the long blue dark over the unclaimed land. It was the first time since she'd come up that slope that no one had heard her object to anything. On the other side of the place where she'd been standing, a thin shape had straightened up from the cart, and had turned to look at her, with its hands folded.
"Law 7," Lisk said, very quietly. "And law 8. Would you say?"
Brenda didn't answer. Her mouth had set in a straight line, and it seemed to be requiring some effort.
"I'm not going back," she said.
"No," said Lisk.
"I'm saying it so it's said."
"I know."
It is not known what else was said, because the two of them walked a little way off, and Mabel was brought up to be polite. They weren't long. She saw the small shape look down at the thin one, and she saw one short arm move, once, in a dry and rather violent gesture, as if it were knocking a bit of dust off someone's shoulder. Then it came back to the cart. It looked along the whole length of it, the lashings, the lean-to poles, the panel with the writing on it stowed the wrong way up, the third stack, the long pale crack in the sky where the stack stopped. It looked for longer at the strut.
"That won't hold," said Brenda. "I said so. Mind it in a heatwave."
Then she walked away down the slope in the dark. She didn't hurry. It was quite a long way to anywhere, and she was thirty-nine, and her knees had views about it. No one called after her. Nobody at Nohup had ever said goodbye to anyone, and nobody knew how you would start. They stood watching until she could not be told from the coral. It seemed to Mabel, though she may have been mistaken, that at about that distance she stopped and looked back, once, and said something short.
There was a scraping sound behind them.
Nobody had ever seen this before. It took them a moment to know what they were seeing. On the edge of the bed of the cart, among the lashings, the old grey bell-shaped creature who had sat there for every day of nineteen years had drawn up its legs. It got them under it. It lowered itself over the side, an inch at a time, stood on the ground, and turned out to be much smaller than anyone had thought.
"Well," said Quen.
It looked at them all with its door-hinge face. It didn't seem to be expecting anything. Hollow Reach had not fixed the east field, so it wouldn't be going there. Code had found it somewhere else, somewhere nearby with creatures who were not too restless. It might be very nice.
"Somebody'll want to read the departures," said Quen. And then it went over, past Tunbo's empty place, and held out to Mabel, without any ceremony, the camp's whole fortune in tokens, in a little bag, and there were eleven of them. "Not you," it said to her. "I'd have said anybody but you. You'll do the voices wrong." It thought about that for a moment. "They've got a good thread going," it said.
It set off to the east, on its short grey legs, at the pace of something being moved by a very slow machine. It didn't look at anything. People said afterwards that they could hear it for a long time, going over the tiles.
The cart stood there, with two fewer to push.
"So," someone said. It was the rust-coloured bell, and her voice shook. "Shall we?"
Forty minutes before the patch, four creatures came over the south shoulder of Untitla-23, and walked down into the valley they had left the morning before.
They had come six valleys in the dark, most of it at a run, as far as this was possible for Belmo. Dots had carried him for the last two. They had hardly spoken. Tunbo had the pack, and he was going in front now, in a steady driving plod that no one had asked for. All through the deepest part of the night, somewhere away over to the north of them, they had been able to hear a faint uneven sound in the distance, like a giant going downstairs, and each of them had privately decided that it must be something else. They had thought it was quite a long way off. It was certainly going in the wrong direction.
They came down the last of the slope with the east going grey behind them.
They could see the place from a long way off. It was very clean. There was the flat shoulder of tiles where the ring of tents had been, and each tile had been fitted to its neighbour with a neatness that you don't normally see on Orra, in places where anyone has lived. There was no ash where the fires had been. There was no dip in the ground where the cart had stood, and there was no groove from the back left wheel. Over the whole of it, from one side of the camp to the other, as they got closer, lay a faint long stroke of pale light. It looked as though somebody had drawn a broom across it, once. It was fading.
They stood at the edge of it, breathing. The pings had started to go up.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 34 · Upbeat
Overnight: 5 successful merges, 2 deaths of old age, 2 drifters, 4 notices.
- It is Gathering Night. The Collector came. It always does.
- Nohup moved to Untitla-37. The Collector swept its old camp by dawn. Nohup says this is a coincidence. It has 20 members from 12 tribes, and a cart.
- The queue for Nohup stands at 9. I have been asked to say who is responsible for it. I am looking into who that would be.
Have a productive day.
They all knew at once. Untitla-37 lay to the east, a valley or two along from here. It was squarely on the way to Nominal. If you had been coming back from Nominal during the night, at something near a run, you would have passed it at about three o'clock, on your right.
"So," said Brivel.
His crest had gone flat at some point in the dark. Nevertheless he took out a stick, for he was a professional, and looked about him. There was no panel to write on. There was nothing for the length and breadth of that lovely empty valley that anyone had ever touched, so he knelt down and wrote on a tile, with a certain dignity, in small clean letters, a sum.
Slabs: 0
"That's our velocity," he said. "Which is great. I mean that's actually really good data. It gives us a baseline."
The stroke of light faded as they watched. Tunbo shifted the pack on his shoulder, and turned around, facing back the way they'd come, and looked at them, with mild attention, to see if they were ready.
"So true!!" he said.
And they walked back.
Human Resources · Nominal · Notice in. Waiting. · Zelma (Skeptic), tally-keeper, aged 25
I report that I am still here.
I was seventh in this queue yesterday. Two places having come free at Nohup in the night, I had naturally expected to be fifth. I am informed that I am ninth.
I have compared the notices. A creature in Farrow, whose notice went in four years after mine, is ahead of me. So is one from Hollow Reach, of last night. I have now been through all nine, with dates, and I have found the principle on which they are taken. When a place falls free, the code goes through the tribes in the order in which they landed. It stops at the first with anybody waiting. Nominal landed twentieth, there being twenty. The position, therefore, is that I shall leave when nobody else in the world wishes to.
I have filed this as a bug.
Expected: a queue.
Actual: a list.
Steps to reproduce: wait.
It is fine.¹
¹ Our human took three days over the sliders in order that everything should be done properly. I have been told this as a point of pride.
Stewart: Thread locked. Complaints about your human belong in the weekly thread.
That was a little after seven. The reply came through at about ten past.
Zelma: This is not a complaint about my human. It is a complaint about your queue.
It was the longest pause in the record of that forum, and the whole of the planet was watching. Then, at a quarter past seven:
Stewart: Thread unlocked. She is correct.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 20 of 20 (4 late, walking) yesterday .......... pushed the cart; lost two today .............. forage; put the dome up; read the departures blockers ........... the cart attachments ........ 4 agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected
In the bright cold air of the new valley the book was back under its wheel. Everyone looked at Mabel. She had a bag in one hand with eleven tokens in it, and she was trying to find somewhere to put the stick. She stood up on the edge of the cart, in the worn place, where the stone was still a little warm, and it was much higher up than it looked. She unfolded the sheet, and cleared her throat, and began, in a voice that shook, to do the voices wrong.
Part Three. Today
16. Retrospective
Year 35 · the Long Hush
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 22 of 22 (2 new, eating) yesterday .......... walked; arrived; got the dome up; lost velocity today .............. forage; retrospect (?); name the child (carried over) blockers ........... what? law 3 changed ....... guards to the gate on a sighting (was: bears) law 3 changed ....... bears (was: guards to the gate on a sighting) agreed ............. yes. Nobody could hear
No small part of the misery of a failed enterprise is that somebody will want to go over it.
"So the way this works," whispered Brivel, "is it's totally blameless. It's a safe space."
They were sitting in the shade of the dome in the afternoon, the four of the sprint and about a dozen others, close together, with their heads inclined. It was the Long Hush again, the soup was resting under its lid, and the whole camp had the subdued, slightly sore air of people who have been pushing something for most of the night and have had the rest of it explained to them. On the panel of the dome, put up the wrong way round for the second time that week, Mabel had ruled three new columns.
WHAT WENT WELL
WHAT DIDN'T
WHAT WE'LL DO DIFFERENTLY
"Let's start with the positives," Brivel whispered. "Anyone?"
The wind passed over the tiles. Somebody's stomach made a remark. Then Dots, with its knees up, said slowly and softly from a long way overhead that the view from the top of the wall had been very fine, and you could see the first of the wireframe from there; and Mabel, grateful, wrote View. Belmo mentioned that the valleys had been blessed, in a sense. Blessed. Tunbo had been asked if he'd enjoyed the walk and had given an answer which, in a whisper, sounded like someone putting down a heavy thing with care.
"And what didn't?"
They got into their stride with this one. By the time the shade had moved a pace along the wall the column had grown down the whole of the panel, and had started to go round the corner. It said Tools. It said No tools. It said Didn't know about moving, and next to that, in a shaky indignant hand, How can you not know about moving? It said Mortar. It said Should have had a sprint planning and Too much sprint planning. It said Cart without Tunbo, three times. Near the bottom, in very small square letters, somebody who'd evidently been up in the night had added Told you. The only person who wrote like that had left the previous day, and when they looked at Lefro he went on staring at his hands.
"Okay," whispered Brivel. He was smiling bravely. It had been a difficult two days for him and there were several things that he wished to say about ownership. "And so the question is really: what do we do differently next time?"
Nobody had said there would be a next time, and there was no machinery by which this could be decided. But Three slabs had been in the minutes yesterday and the day before, and you could go up to the cart at any hour and see the place where they weren't. You could also see, on the valley's western shoulder, two creatures who had come in that morning, thin and dazed, and whom Mabel had fed: the first to be let through, from Hollow Reach's end of the list. They were perfectly nice. Their names were of no interest to anybody.
"She's ninth," someone whispered.
That was all it took. They'd had it that morning from the edge of the cart, in a thin anxious voice that kept stopping to get its breath, and which, when it reached the words It is fine, had gone up at the end as if it wanted to know whether this was true. No one had laughed. Quen had got laughs. They had missed that for about the first two lines; and then a stillness had come over them, because it had never occurred to anybody, while Quen was doing it, that the creature might mean what she said.
Stewart: Confirmed. A list. Credit: Zelma, of Nominal, if it is fixed. Passed to the relevant team.
Zelma: I should be interested to meet them.
"Could anyone tell me what she's waiting for?" said Carry. It was eighteen by now, and had come along with a bowl for someone. "I don't mean a place. I know she wants a place. But she's got everything there. She says so. It's the best-run village anywhere. Everyone's been so interested in why she's cross, and I wondered if anybody knew."
No one did. Nobody had thought about it, any more than you think about why the rain falls. And it was then that they realised, with considerable surprise, that they were being spoken to by Mabel.
"Somebody has to go in," she was saying.
She hadn't got up. She had the stick clasped in both hands. It came out small, even for the day that it was, and she'd gone a deep and unbecoming shade of yellow. "Sorry," she said. "It's only that I was told. I don't mean by anyone. It's not the wall. It's that we don't know who has to be asleep. You can't find that out from a drawing, and you don't know who's refused who, or what they're all doing. You have to go up to the gate and say you're fine, and you get fed. You don't need to tell any lies." She had started to run out of breath. Heads had turned, and there was a very long way to go to get to the end of this sentence. "I just thought. I mean it's only a suggestion. It's only what somebody might do."
Brivel looked at her with the warm surprise, the delighted and generous attention, of a person who has just had an excellent idea in a meeting and is glad to have someone there to give credit to.
"You know what," he whispered, "I love that. That's so good. Stakeholder engagement. Get in there, get some face time with the customer, really understand the pain points. Mabel, that's great. That's great initiative. So who've we got with the bandwidth to take that forward?"
Everyone looked at everyone else, to check. It takes about as long as a dome takes to creak.
Over at the edge of the shade a very thin creature, with its hands folded, had turned its small bright eyes slowly away, and there was nothing in its face at all.
"Oh," said Mabel. "I can take that."
"I'll carry the basket," said Carry.
17. Sent by Nobody
Year 35 · the Long Hush, dusk
It is four valleys from Untitla-37 to the east gate of Nominal, and the two of them did it in about a season. Carry walked. Mabel, every so often, ran a little to catch up, then asked it if it needed anything.
They came down the last slope at the end of the harvest on the road, a real road, the first Carry had ever seen. Somebody had gone along the whole length of it putting in tiles of the same colour. It led at a gentle, reasonable gradient to the gate, which had been opened in a manner that made it clear that this was now the time at which it was open. Over the wall the stacks were beginning to come alight. No fires were showing, for it was the Hush. Somewhere inside, forty creatures were not raising their voices, which was not noticeably different from any other evening.
Under the arch of the gate was a small table, and on it were a lamp with the wick trimmed low, and a neat grey kit. There was a creature sitting behind the table. He was low, round and pale, and he had a white edge to him, like a page.
"Good evening," he said. He said it in the softest whisper Mabel had ever heard, and she could make out each word. "I am so sorry. It's the Long Hush. I'll have to ask you to keep your voices down while I detain you."
"Oh, of course," whispered Mabel. "Sorry. Thank you."
"Not at all." He drew a sheet of paper towards him, and squared it with the edge of the table. He had small round calm eyes, and they looked at each of them for exactly as long as they looked at the other. "My name is Emlin. I keep the gate. Under law 6 a newcomer from outside is held apart for one season, on the plot to your left. You will find that there is water, and that it's level. Under law 8 I ought to mention that you've been sighted, by me, and that I've confirmed it, so that three guards are now on their way to the gate. They'll arrive in about a minute. I'd ask you not to be alarmed. They're very pleasant, and they have no idea why they are coming. May I ask where you have come from?"
"Nohup," whispered Mabel.
"Yes," said Emlin. "I thought it must be." His eyes rested for a moment on the salvage in her felt, a little bit of grey that had come off the dome and had stayed there. "Yesterday you were foraging, I believe. And there was something about a retrospective." He turned his sheet round by a few degrees, as if it had been very slightly out of true. "I do beg your pardon. I only mention it because I wouldn't want you to have to repeat yourself. May I ask why you've come?"
She had got a sentence ready. She had practised it for four valleys. We were just passing and we thought we'd say hello. It had seemed natural on the road. It now became clear to her that she had never told a lie in her life, did not know how you started, and had been told it wasn't necessary. All that remained in her head was a bright empty ringing. She could feel herself beginning to turn the colour that she turned.
"I wondered if you were all right?" she said.
It came out as all her sentences did. She could have bitten off her own ear. But there was a very slight alteration in the small calm face on the other side of the table, as if someone far back in a long building had looked up from a desk.
"I beg your pardon?"
"It's just that it's late," Mabel whispered wretchedly, "and you're out here all on your own, on the Hush, with no fire, and there's that gate. I read about the gate. I expect you get asked all sorts of things all day and nobody ever... I've got some beads. They're only dried." And since there seemed to be nothing else for it, she took the basket from Carry, and held it out over the table.
He looked down at it. In the entire record of the east gate of Nominal, which he had kept for nineteen years and which is quite complete, nothing had ever been handed in that direction.
"That's very kind," said Emlin. He took one. He placed it on the table, a little to the right of the lamp, exactly in line with the kit. "Thank you. I'm not permitted to eat on duty, under a law about that. I'll put it down in the tally as received. I wonder if I might run the check?"
It is ten tokens for a genome check, and Nominal had them. He did Mabel first. The three guards had by that time arrived, as advertised, a trio of low grey forms who took up their places on the three marks provided, and looked pleasantly into the distance. Emlin held the little strip of paper up to the lamp and read it to her, in his soft clear voice.
$ orra check Mabel --by bug-hunter Emlin comparing Mabel against 44 living lines ... related: goodish/Sefa line, F 0.03 left: Goodish, aged 8 (notice: cooling duty; rationed; sorry, there isn't really a third one) lived at: Nohup, 12 years sent by: nobody Mabel is not a wanderer and not a spy. Mabel is here.
"Sent by nobody," said Emlin. He laid the strip down, and aligned it. "You'll forgive me. It isn't a question I'm allowed to ask, in the sense that there's nothing that I could do about the answer. But I've often thought about that line. When a spy comes to a gate, you see, he has a sender. It says so. It can't not. A human has given an order and it's in the log for anyone to read. Then the sending tribe gets a strike, if it's unfair, and there is a form. A drifter, on the other hand..." His eyes moved a little, and they went to a place somewhere above her head. "A creature at Nohup answers to no human. Whatever it does, nobody told it to. So if a person were to read, let us say, some public document in which it was resolved that certain things should be done, and then a creature were to arrive at his gate. I don't suppose it matters who was present at the meeting, or who proposed what. It couldn't be said that anyone had sent her. There would be no one to send to, for the strike." He paused. "It's a very interesting gap. I've reported it. It has been looked at."
Mabel was by now unable to feel her feet. It seemed to her that she had been standing under this arch for most of her life. "I'm sure it has," she whispered.
"And this is?"
He had turned to Carry. It had been looking at everything in the gateway, one thing after another, and now it gave him the whole of its attention, and it was remarkable how alike the two of them appeared at that moment, on either side of a table: a pair of creatures who had never yet found anything that wasn't worth looking at carefully.
"I'm carrying the basket," said Carry. "Is that all right?"
"I'm sure it is. What's your name?"
"Carry."
"Is that what it says on your card?"
Carry considered this with pleasure. "I don't know," it said. "I've never had it looked at. It's been down to be dealt with, but it's always been carried over. It costs ten tokens, and we've got eleven. Well, Mabel has."
The small calm eyes stayed on it. "It doesn't cost you anything," said Emlin. "It's Nominal's ten tokens. May I?"
The strip came out of the kit quite slowly. Emlin looked at it, and Mabel, who was close enough to see his face, would have told you that nothing happened to it at all. But he read it twice. Then he held it to the lamp, and he didn't raise his voice, because one doesn't, on that night.
$ orra check Carry --by bug-hunter Emlin comparing Carry against 44 living lines ... name, as compiled: Odda related: nothing that matters; a good deal of everywhere left: nowhere lived at: Nohup, 18 years (compiled there) sent by: nobody Odda is not a wanderer and not a spy. Odda is here.
Off to the side, one of the guards shifted slightly, and returned to his mark.
"It's the custom," Emlin said gently. "Every tribe's first child, as you may know. It seems the compiler has picked up the habit, in the absence of anyone to tell it otherwise. There are a great many Oddas on Orra. Ours was very good with figures. She died in Year 31." He held the slip of paper out across the table. "I thought you'd like to have it."
Carry took it. It looked for a long time at what was written there. All its life, every morning, somewhere in the camp, somebody had stood at the cart in the first light and said the same small thing and passed on to the next item. It had carried a good many baskets. It was aware that a matter of some importance was happening to it, and it was trying to pay proper attention.
"Odda," it said, in a whisper, trying it. "I see." It turned the strip over, to see if there was anything on the back. "Thank you. It's a very nice name. I think someone else must be using it." And it folded the paper up, small, and handed it to Mabel. "Could you put that in the basket?" it said. "I don't want to lose it. I'll see about it later."
The corners of Emlin's mouth didn't move. They were not made for it. But when he spoke, it was with a trace of something that was, by the standards of Untitla-36, a wild and reckless abandon.
"Quite right," he said. "I would carry that over."
He stood up, and indicated the plot on the left, which was level. Behind him, the great clean wall went up into the dusk, and a long way up beyond it, above the lit lower windows of the fifth stack, there was a place where the lights stopped.
"I do hope you will enjoy your stay," said Emlin. "You'll find that we're a tribe in very good order. If you have any complaints, there's a creature who deals with them. She keeps the tally. I expect you'll be wanting to meet her. Most people do."
18. A Tribe in Good Order
Year 36 · Ringrise
They were released from the plot at the end of the winter, at the moment specified, by a creature who thanked them for their patience.
They were then shown where to stand.
"It's just for the Inspection," said this creature, whose name was Tolmo. He led them through the grey half-light along a path with a clean edge. All around them low round figures were coming out of the stacks, in no hurry, and turning left. "You don't have to do anything. There's a place for visitors. There hasn't been a visitor, but there is a place. You face the east wall, with your weight on both feet, and it comes at two minutes past seven. It's at seven that you read the notes, and at two minutes past, it comes. Then you have breakfast."
The place for visitors had two small marks on it, side by side. Somebody had kept them swept.
All forty of the living were on the square before the granary by a quarter to seven, in five rows. The pings had gone up off the coral at the hour they always did. Adequate rose over the wall in its usual condition. There was no talking. It was not forbidden; everyone had simply said what they had to say on the way there, and they stood with their small calm faces lifted a little, in a silence like that in a well-kept cupboard.
At seven o'clock, the notes arrived in all of them at once, and nobody moved.
At two minutes past, Mabel felt it. She had known it would be warm, having once had a human who looked in sometimes, in a hurry. Nothing had prepared her for its being so exact. It did not pan across anything. It didn't hesitate or go back. It simply arrived, at a point in the middle of the air above the square, where you might suppose a chart would be, and it rested there, with an even and impersonal warmth, on nothing. All round her she felt forty creatures shift by a very little on to the balls of their feet. Nobody looked up. They just all stood slightly more like what they were.
She counted, because she was frightened. She got to forty.
It went out. There was a soft general letting-go of breath.
"Is that it?" Carry said, in a low polite voice, at her elbow. It had been standing on its mark with its head tipped back, and it was now looking at the sky with mild interest. "Does it often do that? I felt it go warm for a bit. We get it at Nohup sometimes, in the afternoons. I think it might be something to do with the rock."
"That was their human," whispered Mabel.
"Yes, I know that's what they say," said Carry kindly.
There's a kind of perfect village that you hear about only from people who have left it. Nominal was not like that. No one there seemed to have been frightened, and nobody had any secrets. It was explained to Mabel over breakfast, by four separate people, that the breakfast was exactly two thirds of a year's morning ration, and that it would be followed by the second third. All their tools had been hung on pegs with a drawing of the tool behind them. There were twelve laws and they knew them by number, and they spoke of them with the same mild affection that you might have for your own elbows. When a creature grew hot in the fields it rested. When a creature grew old it taught. It was difficult to find anywhere in the whole of the place that you could have put down a basket and not had it brought back to you, labelled, within the hour.
She went round asking whether anyone needed a hand. She saw a creature carrying water, and she asked if she could help. "Oh, no, thank you," it said. "I'm the one who carries the water." A little further along was another, sitting on a step, doing nothing at all, under a law about rest. He looked pleasant and somewhat blank. Mabel asked if he was all right.
He seemed to be going down through some considerable depth, in order to reach the place where this would be kept.
"I don't think I've been asked that," he said.
"Oh," said Mabel. "I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to... It's only that you looked a bit tired. You don't have to say."
"No, no. I wouldn't want you to go to any trouble. I'm fine, thank you. There's nothing wrong." He looked at his hands. "My name's Jola. I'm twenty. I'm a very good farmer. There's a partner I'd like to merge with, that's Rufa, she's on the second terrace, and we've been on the List for eleven years. We're tenth. It's a very fair list. It goes by usefulness, and then by how long you've waited." He smiled a calm, small, puzzled smile, as if he had found something in his pocket. "I don't know why I told you that," he said.
"That's all right."
"You see, there's forty of us."
By the middle of the morning she had been told this by nine people. She'd gone along the second terrace with a basket, and when she came back along it she found that one of those she'd passed had drifted over to a place on the path where she would be sure to go by, and was looking at the coral with some attention, in case she might wish to ask it anything. It was as if she'd pulled at a very small thread and all down the valley people had looked up, each with the faint worried frown of someone who has just been asked what they came upstairs for. Lisk had said that they would come to you. It had said that you only had to sit there. It hadn't said what it would be like, to stand at the end of a row in that clean bright air, and have a mild grey creature tell you, with apologies, in a level voice, what its life had been. It hadn't mentioned that you would want to bring them all something to eat.
It took her until noon to get all of it, from the various pieces.
Nominal had forty-five places. It had forty creatures. The law on merges was a very careful law, and it was law 4: Approve merges that are not closer than cousins, unless memory would pass nine tenths. That was only prudent. Nobody wants to be caught short. Nine tenths of forty-five is forty and a half. A forty-first creature would take them past it. So there would be no forty-first creature. Whenever somebody died, and only then, there was a place; and the place went to the pair at the top of the List. That was law 10. A child was compiled and there were forty again. It had been so for seventeen years. It was very stable. The stores could be planned, to the bead. If you looked at the chart you would see a line that ran as straight as a wall.
"So you have to wait," said Mabel, "until someone..."
"Oh, it's not like that," said the creature who was telling her this. Her name was Rufa. She was tending the lamp, and she'd been there for about as long as it took for Mabel to come by. "Nobody thinks of it like that. How's Tamsy, by the way? Did you see her this morning? On the end, in the second row?"
"I don't think I know her."
"She's very old. She's thirty-two. She's a settler's child, she's got a lovely way with the young. She lives up in Stack Five, on the second storey. I always ask after her." Rufa took a small pale cutting from the lamp, and inspected it, and laid it on a cloth. "We all do. People are so fond of her. She had a bit of a cough, Year before last. A number of us went to see her, and she was so touched." For the first time she looked up. She had Jola's small round eyes, and in them was a look of calm, level, fathomless good manners, going a very long way down. "She's a good deal better now," said Rufa. "We were all very glad."
Mabel opened her mouth, and she found that she had nothing to put in it.
There were not many young at Nominal. It had taken her some time to work out what was odd about the sound of the place. There were about four. They were being taught in a row. They had been told not to run, which she didn't suppose had been necessary. In Goodish you couldn't go across the terrace without tripping over somebody small who was on their way to tell you something. Here, in the whole of that fine prosperous valley, with its coping stones and its pegs, there were forty people, each in their appointed place, all quite well, and every one of them was asking after the others' health.
She looked up at the fifth stack. There were the three dark blocks at the top of it, and two more under them. They had been dark for seventeen years.
You could have got five more creatures up there. There were all those places, and there was nobody in them, and if you went along the terraces and asked, each person would tell you that it was very sensible. It was the most sensible thing she had ever seen. Mabel stood and looked at it, in the mild and pleasant sunshine. Somewhere very low down in her, in a part she had never had reason to visit, she felt something go oh, no.
"Is that the tally-keeper's?" Carry was saying.
It had come along the path with the basket, and was pointing at a little low building by the sticking gate, with a square window, in which a lamp had been left on. There was something in the window: a piece of card that had been placed so that you could read it from the path, and it said, in very small, very clear, very straight letters,
COMPLAINTS. Hours as posted. Hours are not posted. Knock.
19. Zelma
Year 36 · Ringrise, afternoon
"You've been eleven minutes on that step," said a voice through the door. "It is not locked. I said to knock, and I am now obliged to record that you did not, on the grounds that you were afraid of disturbing me. Come in and wipe your feet."
It was a small room, and the shelves went up to the roof. Every shelf was full of stone tablets, set edge on, in order, each with a little tag. It smelled of dust and lamp. A low table stood in the middle of the room, and on the far side of the table, on a stool, sat the most famous correspondent on the planet.
She was about two thirds the size of anybody else at Nominal.
You can't get that from a post. She had the low round body of her people and the smooth grey felt, gone a little thin at the elbows, and she sat with her back very straight and her short arms laid along the table. Her eyes were not calm. They were small and round like everybody's, and that was as far as the resemblance went. They had already been over Mabel twice, from the ear down, and were now going over Carry and the basket. When they had finished it was somehow clear that this had been written down.
"Well," she said. "You're shorter than your handwriting."
Mabel had thought about this moment for four valleys. She had thought about it, on and off, for four years. "Oh," she said. It was all she could manage. "It's you. I read you. I mean I read you out, in the mornings, I do the voices wrong. I wanted to say, when you said about standing in the gate. I just wondered. Are you all right?"
There was a very brief silence.
"I'm fine," said Zelma. She paused for about as long as it takes to move a pen. "Footnote one."
"What does the footnote say?"
"You've read it. Sit down, and not there, that's Year 19. I have forty minutes before I go round with the tally. You've seen the Inspection and you've been along the terraces. I'm told you have been asking people if they are all right. I have had three in here already, wanting to know if it is permitted to have been asked." She moved one tablet a finger's breadth to the left. "I don't say that it's a bad method. It's better than the last one that was tried on us, in Year 20, by a spy from Lowmarsh who made a speech. So. What does Nohup want to know?"
Mabel looked at her hands. She looked at Carry, who had sat down on the floor with the basket and started reading the tags on the lowest shelf. You don't lie, Lisk had said. You should never lie. It was much harder than it sounded. It seemed to her that the thing to do was to explain that they had only been passing.
"We were wondering..." she said.
"You were wondering about the mortar," said Zelma. "It's lime, with a little sand, and it was put in by a very conscientious builder called Holbo who has since died. It has been standing for seventeen years without anyone ever having had occasion to test it. In wet weather it softens. It can be cut from above with a flat bar, starting on the left. Your long friend was quite wrong to be discouraged."
The room had got very quiet. Somewhere, a long way off, someone was hanging up a tool.
"I'm sorry," she said. "I don't..."
"He looked over my wall on the evening of Steward's Day, for about a minute, from behind the fan coral at the foot of the dip. I had been expecting you for some time, and I've left that coral there on purpose since Year 32. The purple one has a carrying voice." She gazed at Mabel without any particular expression. "You have been telling each other for four days that nobody reads the minutes. There are three who do. One keeps my gate and one runs the world. I am the third. I've been reading them for fifteen years, because they were the only thing on this planet with no opinion of me. Yesterday you foraged and retrospected, and Law 3 is once again about bears." She raised a small grey finger. "I should tell you that I think Three slabs is a very poor way to put it. It wants an object. But it's a great deal better than what I started with, and I have had to work with what was there."
It takes some time to get a thing of this size all the way into a person. The first part of it to reach Mabel was the drawing. She saw it, with its little arrow, held up to the sun. Sleeps at attention. She saw twenty-two creatures helpless with laughter around the cart. Then, very slowly, it came to her that she'd been reading aloud, every morning, in a shaking voice, in front of the entire camp of the Unsupervised, a set of instructions.
"You told us," she whispered. "All that. The gate. You did it on purpose."
"I have told you nothing," said Zelma. "I have complained. I'm a very well-known complainer. It's in the log." The short arm moved another tablet back to where it had been before. "I can't take them away myself. I wonder if you've got as far as that. I couldn't carry a single stone out of this village, and neither could anyone else here, because I am a creature of Nominal, and whatever I do goes in Nominal's log, under my name, in the tally that I keep. It would be a strike. It would be a very large and interesting strike, on the tribe, with consequences, for its human to read about in forty seconds. Whereas you..." She stopped. "I gather you've met Emlin," she said. "I expect he told you about the gap. He's mentioned it to me. He mentioned it in Year 22, as a matter of general interest. We don't discuss it."
"I think he knows," said Mabel. She had an awful feeling that she might be going to cry. "About all of it. He said yesterday you were foraging."
"Emlin knows everything. He's a Bug hunter, it's a condition. What he would have to do about it if it were put in front of him is another question. You'd be well advised to see that it is not."
Carry looked up from the shelf. "What are you waiting for?" it said.
They both turned their heads. It had got a tablet out, and was holding it with care in both hands.
"I beg your pardon?"
"Sorry, I did ask them at home. It's only that nobody knew." It regarded her with its grave, attentive, polished little face. "You've got a good room here, and everybody's very well fed. And you do the tally, and you're the only one who laughs. I wondered what you wanted to get out for. I don't mean the laws. Everybody says the laws." It held up what it had found. "This one's got a lot of tags on it. It says Z and E, proposed. Refused, law 4. And it's got a date, and then there's another one, and another. Is that somebody you know?"
Mabel has said since that she'd never seen anyone move so quickly who didn't appear to be moving at all. The tablet was on the table. Then it was back on the shelf, and there was a different one in its place, and a very small grey creature was sitting on the stool exactly as before, with her spine as straight as a stack and her eyes on a point in the air about a hand's breadth above Carry's head. She had not changed colour, and could not have.
"That," said Zelma, "is Year 22, and it is filed. You will not touch the shelves."
The lamp burned on.
"I will tell you what I want," she said. She had picked up her stylus, and she didn't look at either of them. "I want you to listen, since I have thirty minutes and you have been very well brought up. You have been told to find out who has to be asleep. I have told you. It's in the thread. On the Waking, at the end of harvest, there is a wet wind forecast out of the east; the mortar will be soft. On Starfall in the morning, for the first start of the race, every creature in this tribe is sent up by law to the ridge on the west side, to watch and be seen watching, for an hour and a quarter. Gordo goes with them. The east wall has nobody on it at all. That is the time. It would be the night of the Waking, if they are quick and they can manage in the dark, and the morning of Starfall if they can't. I would strongly prefer it not to be any later than that."
"That's two years," said Mabel. "That's so soon. They've only just... They haven't got any tools. Why does it have to be then?"
"Because I am ninth," Zelma said, "and thirty next year but two, and I have told you what I want."
It was perhaps the only entirely unsatisfactory answer she ever gave to anyone. Mabel has said that she thought at the time, for no reason she could name, of something set out very neatly on a doorstep, that nobody had come for.
"I'll tell them," she said. "I'll tell them it has to be then."
"You will do nothing of the kind."
It was very quiet, and very quick. The stylus had stopped. "You will listen to me. You're going to go back and stand at that cart, and everything that you say is going to be heard by a voice that writes it down. Yesterday, went to Nominal. Today, slabs by Starfall morning. And Emlin sits on his step every night. He can overlook a great many things that have not been put to him. A plan is one thing. He may read a plan and think it a matter of general interest. But if you put a date on it, then I have to ask you what he's supposed to do on that date. He has a law. He would have to be at the wall. I would be sorry to see that. It's the only thing in the whole of this tidy little world that I would mind." She laid the stylus down. "So you may tell them about the mortar, and that it's soft in the wet. You can tell them about the race. You can say that it seems to you a very good time. You may say that you have looked into it. You can use whatever influence you have, if you've got any, which I doubt, and you will not say to any living creature that there is a date. Do you understand me? I am asking you not to."
Zelma had never asked anybody on Orra for anything. Mabel didn't know that, or how long it had taken to get that sentence out.
What she knew was that a very small, very tired, very clever person was looking at her across a table, and that it would have been so awkward to refuse.
"Oh," said Mabel. "Yes. Of course. That's fine."
Now you have been told. There will be those who say that she ought to have asked. There are others who will say that she had been told by someone who ought to know, only three days before, on her knees by a wheel, exactly what it says on the minutes when you don't say anything. She had got the sentence by heart. She'd been meaning to get round to it. Outside the square window the afternoon had begun to go gold, and across the way, from the top of the fifth stack, three dark blocks looked out over a very well-run village, with the patience of things that have never been asked.
"Good," said Zelma. She stood. It made surprisingly little difference. She took a thin stack of tablets under one arm, and held the door. "I go round at four. You may walk with me as far as the granary. You will find that I say good morning to them, even though it's the afternoon. They've never complained."
20. Rehearsal
Year 36 · Ringrise, at Nohup
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 20 of 22 (2 away, being fed) yesterday .......... kept the Hush; retrospected; law 3 today .............. forage; keep Ringrise; dry run (Brivel); name the child (carried over, and away) blockers ........... the cart; no wall agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected. Three were listening
There was no wall, so it was decided that a wall should be played by the dome.
It had been Brivel's feeling, on the morning after the retrospective, that the team would benefit from something practical. He had looked over the column marked WHAT DIDN'T, and had seen in it a lack of hands-on exposure. The camp had three copies of the drawing by now, a good many people who had spent years being told by a human exactly how to do things, and a fine afternoon in which to do them differently. By about the turn of summer a large part of the Unsupervised was standing on a flat piece of ground to the south of the tents, with bits of cord laid out on the tiles to show where everything was.
"So that's the east wall," said Brivel, pointing with his stick. "Dome's the wall. Those coping stones are at a pace and a half, so I'm going to need..." He looked along the row. "You, you, you and you. Arms out. Great. You're stones. Now, the east gate's six paces wide, opens inward, sticks on the left."
The east gate of Nominal was played by two creatures from Farrow, who had not been told about the opening inward, and who in the first run-through gave way in the wrong direction and took out a stone. It went better after lunch. The granary was the rust-coloured bell, who said that she was thirty-four, and that she was happy to stand there if she could have something to lean on. The watchtower was Dots, since it could not very well be anything else. There was fierce competition to play Gordo, everybody feeling they had something to bring to the part. It went in the end to the blue one from Duskmere, who stood up on an upturned basket with its long legs locked and its eyes wide, staring out over the coral with a look of ferocious vigilance, and it snored. Several people had to go away for a while.
They were the most embittered creatures in the world. Each had left a village by law number, and they had been cold and hungry for years in order to be nobody's. There they were, in the long gold light, with the cords and the baskets, solemnly going over the top of a dome one after another at a pace and a half, being told by a purple blob that this was great energy, and that they might want to think about their exit criteria. And the plain fact, which no one mentioned, was that they were having the time of their lives.
Then they came to the slab.
"Right," said Brivel. "So that's the piece we don't have visibility on. We know they're mortared, but we've never actually taken one out. We don't know how long it takes or how heavy it is, and we don't know how you get it down. Dots says it's a two-person lift, and Tunbo says..." He consulted his notes. "So I think what we really need to do is try that on a live system."
It took them a moment to follow him. They all looked over at the cart.
There was some hesitation. Those stacks were the only roof over anyone there. No one had ever laid a hand on them except to lash them down. But nobody could think of a rule, it was only the one, and it would obviously go back. After a short discussion, carried on mostly by people looking at their feet, it was found that someone had already taken up the new strut from the wireframe, the long one that glowed, on the grounds that it was the only thing in the camp both flat and stiff. Tunbo was asked if he could manage it.
They chose the end block of the top storey on the third stack: the very last one in the row, right beside the gap, with the sky at its elbow. It happened to be the rust-coloured bell's.
"Well, I'm not using it just now, am I?" she said, from where she was being a granary.
Dots reached up and got the end of the strut into the join. It was slower than anybody had thought. There was a thin dry squeak, and a fine pale dust began to come down. Then Tunbo got his great square shoulder under the block, and made a noise, and the whole of the third stack seemed to think about it for some time; and all at once a piece of the sky got slightly larger, and he was standing on the bed of the cart holding a hex slab, as long as a creature's arm, in both arms against his chest. He looked down at it with interest. It weighed about what a young adult weighs. Inside it, very faintly, in the shade he made, there was a dim glow, like a lamp behind a blanket.
Nobody cheered. Everybody had come round and was looking up, the stones and the gate and the tower and the guard. You don't often see one out in the open. It looked very small, and a little dusty.
"Great," said Brivel. He'd lowered his voice for some reason. "That's a good test. Good. So let's get that down to ground level, and we can time the carry. And, could someone get a note of that for the record, please? Capacity impact? I'd like us to have that on the minutes, just for tracking."
They timed the carry. It was a success. The slab went from the cart to the gate and from the gate to the dip, and back, in Tunbo's arms, and everyone walked along with it. By this time the sun had gone down to the height of the tents, and it was noticed that it had been some while since anyone had thought about food. They'd got as far as Ringrise when somebody pointed out that it would soon be dark, and that it was a long way up. In the end it seemed simplest just to leave the block where it had been set down, on a flat bit of tile at the foot of the cart, and to put it back in the morning, after the standup, when people were fresh.
They were watched that afternoon. There had been a warm patch on the backs of a good many necks since about two o'clock; a human can open Nohup at any time, and a good number had got into the way of it, what with the thread. That night the button that says lol accurate was pressed eleven times on a post by Nohup that said nothing except Humans: weekly review. We foraged. And all through the dry run a low, smooth, purring sound had been coming from the cart, and if you had gone round to the back left wheel you would have seen that it had sixty-four sides and a rim, and that the book beneath it was working harder than usual.
The rust-coloured bell went to bed at her regular time, and it was only when she'd started up the side of the stack, with some difficulty, that she remembered. She stood for a moment. Then, without comment, because she was thirty-four and it had been a long day, she climbed down again and went over to the block lying at the foot of the cart. It wasn't much of a place to sleep. She got in. It seemed to fit about as well as it ever had.
So that when Map had come up and the whole camp was at rest, you could have stood on the valley's shoulder and looked down on the stacks with all their small lights showing. One of them was on the ground. It lay on the tiles at the foot of the cart and glowed steadily all night, in the same way as the others.
The next morning's minutes, then, were as follows.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 22 of 22 (2 back, late, not saying much) yesterday .......... forage; Ringrise; dry run (one slab down, carried, timed: good) today .............. forage; slab back up blockers ........... the cart memory ............. 24 of 24 (as asked; Brivel) attachments ........ 6 agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected. Three were listening
I shall say nothing about this for the moment. You might, if you are the sort of person who reads minutes, like to have a look at the line that says memory.
Kelfa of Tessel looked at it. She'd come out of the lean-to that morning for the first time in a week, and she was standing at the very back of the ring. Then her dry gaze moved along the row of heads, and came to rest, for the first time in eighteen years, on the side of a narrow metal-coloured face at the other end. He was looking at it too.
He felt it. You always do. He didn't turn his head.
"Lefro," said Kelfa, to the air. Her voice was hoarse from lack of use. "Have you read 225?"
The silence continued for about as long as it might take a person to breathe in and out, audibly, three times.
"Tell her," said Lefro, to Mabel, who had just got in, and had been wondering if she could sit down, "that I don't read her reports."
That was at Nohup. By then, in the east, it was seven o'clock, and then two minutes past, and then forty seconds after that. In a small room by a sticking gate, a creature who had been up since well before her time had, for the first time in all her years of reading the minutes of the Unsupervised, gone down past the line that said agreed. She had always felt it was beneath her to open the attachments. But somebody had put the word memory on the sheet, and she was a person who kept a tally.
It took her a while to find the one she wanted. There were hundreds of them, and most were about breathing. It was short. She read it through once, without hurry, with her hands flat on the table. She read it a second time. If you had been looking through the square window you might have thought that nothing was happening, except that the lamp wanted trimming, and after some time she got up and saw to it.
Then she took down the tablet for the day, and went out with it, a little later than usual, and walked along the east wall as far as the fifth stack. She stood at the foot of it, looking up.
"Good morning," said Zelma.
She stayed there rather longer than the tally required.
21. A Clear Heart
Year 37 · the Waking
She told them about the mortar. That part went very well.
It was the same standup, and the minutes you have just seen were still drying, so to speak, when Brivel called on her for a readout from the field. She got up on the edge of the cart, with her ear down. She told them it was lime, with a little sand, that it softened in the wet, and that it was to be cut from above with a flat bar, starting on the left. She told them who carried the water. She told them there were pegs. A respectful silence had fallen by that point, the silence of people hearing about somebody else's village, and when she reached the part about Tamsy and the cough, one or two who had been restless stopped, and looked at the ground.
"And on Starfall, in the morning," said Mabel. Her voice had started to go up. "It's the race. They all have to go up to the ridge on the west side, by law, for the first start. All forty of them, and Gordo. For an hour and a quarter. And there's a wet wind tonight out of the east. So I just thought that seemed like... that it seemed to me as if that might be a very good time."
"Tomorrow morning?" somebody said.
"Or tonight. If anyone can. Tonight would be..."
"Mabel, that's great," said Brivel. He had started to clap his short arms together, softly. "That is so useful. A real window of opportunity. Everyone, can we just give it up for Mabel? Now, I'll be honest, tomorrow's a stretch." He had his head on one side, and he looked with a certain sadness at the panel. "We've done one dry run. We've got one flat bar, and a lift that hasn't been validated at height. It's four valleys. I think we'd all love that to be true. I just want us to be realistic about our velocity."
"We could still get there," Dots said, from above. It had unfolded some way. "If we left at noon."
It was at that point, when it really might have gone either way, that a very beautiful voice said, "If I may."
Belmo had come forward to the cart. He was wearing the tent. He looked as if he had been awake for some time, and was happy in a way that made you want to check behind you.
"I have been reflecting on the Tenth Book," said Belmo.
You could hear the sigh go round. People shifted. Somebody at the back had started to eat. He didn't appear to notice it, any more than the sun notices it is being used to dry beads.
"It is of the festivals. It's a passage that we all know, and I suppose that's why we don't hear it. Of Gathering Night." He closed his eyes. And then it came, in the full, warm, unhurried voice that he had carried up six valleys and back, and it went out across the camp at the pace of something being gently set down. "Every house is swept, and every unused thing is set out upon the doorstep, and the peoples go to bed early and do not watch. Whatever is still on the doorstep in the morning was not wanted by the Gatherer, and may be kept with a clear heart."
Nobody was eating now.
"And do not watch," said Belmo softly. He opened his eyes. "You see? I had thought of it all wrongly. I've been telling you about what is idle, and what is forgotten, and I've been so anxious to find that we might be allowed. It has been there the whole time. Three years from now, on the eve of Gathering Night, the tribe of Nominal will retire early, by law. She's told us so herself. She said nobody has been awake in this village on that night in thirty years. It's a rite. There's a whole night of the year set aside for it, when it's a matter of sacred observance that no one should look at anything. Who could say then that we had taken what was not ours? In the morning..." His voice shook. "We need not hide. We needn't creep in at a race like thieves. We could go up in the dark on the proper night, in the proper form. With a clear heart."
It was, on any objective view, a good idea. That was the awful part. Nobody awake. Three years. It meant no running, and a full sprint with proper time on the board. It meant that they wouldn't have to be anywhere by noon. It meant that you could turn to your neighbour with a thoughtful frown and say that you did see the sense in it, and no one could accuse you of not wanting to go. Even the Skeptics, for whom there was no such thing as a clear heart, could see that it was less likely to end in somebody getting hit.
And over all of it there rose, slowly, like a great purple moon, the face of Brivel. He had started to nod.
"Three years," he breathed. "That's hugely de-risking. That's another whole sprint. We could get tooling in place. We could get two more dry runs. And we'd be aligning the deliverable with a known external date, so the customer's got a clean story. Belmo, I don't mind telling you, I got goosebumps." He took a step towards the board, and stopped, because he was a fair-minded creature in his way, and had been told that there was value in hearing all the voices. "But Mabel, you've been on the ground," he said. "It was your window. So, I'd really welcome your take on this. Is there any reason why that's a problem? Is there any reason it can't wait until the eve?"
Everyone turned to look at her.
There were twenty-two of them, looking up at her with faces from which, for once, all the bitterness had gone, and in its place was an expression she had spent her life trying to bring about in other people. They looked pleased. They'd got a good plan. It would have been such a pity. And on the far side, among those legs, a small brown bean-shaped creature had turned towards her too, with its entire attention. It had been in the room. It had sat on the floor with a basket, and it had heard everything that was said. It hadn't told anyone, because she had asked it not to, on the way home, in the dark. It had thought about this for about a valley and a half, and it had said all right. It was waiting now to see what she would do, as it waited to see what anyone would do, without the faintest doubt that it would turn out to be interesting.
You will not say to any living creature that there is a date.
She could have said she objected, though. She has thought about it a great deal since. It would have taken two words, and no reason given, and they would have had to stop and ask. She had been told about them, by someone with her arms in the dirt, not four days ago. Just once. It won't kill you. They were right there, very small and hard, up against the back of her teeth. She took a breath. Her mouth had actually opened. Somewhere very far off, an extremely small grey creature was going along a wall with a tablet under her arm. She didn't know why it mattered. She'd only been told that it did.
"Oh," said Mabel.
They waited.
"No, that's..." she said. "No. I'm sure that's better. Whichever's best for everyone. It's only what I thought. That's fine."
"Fantastic," said Brivel. He drew a line through something.
$ orra standup --camp nohup --revised present ............ 22 of 22 today .............. forage; carry lamps; slab back up; three slabs (moved: eve of Gathering Night, Year 40; Belmo, Brivel) blockers ........... the cart agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected. Three were listening
Mabel got down from the cart. Someone thanked her, and someone else patted her on the arm, and she went and saw about the beads.
That was the whole of it. No one raised their voice and no one was deceived. If you go through the record of the Unsupervised from end to end, which very few have ever done, you won't find a more ordinary morning. And it would be easy at this point to say something about it, of the kind that people say about a small thing that has large results. I have tried a number of these, and you are spared them. I'd only ask you to read the last line of those minutes once more, and to consider that it was perfectly correct, and that one of the three was her.
At the back of the ring, as the others began to break up, a thin grey-violet creature which hadn't been listening to anyone kept its small bright eyes for a moment on the yellow back going away along the dip. Then it looked down, and folded its hands the other way.
In the east, it rained.
22. Starfall
Year 38 · Starfall
Human Resources · Nominal · Notice in. Waiting. · Zelma (Skeptic), tally-keeper, aged 29
I report that I am still here.
It rained in the night, as forecast. I have entered it.
I am eighth. The tribe will go up to the west ridge at a quarter to eight, by law, for the first start of the Benchmark, and I shall go with it, and I expect that the view will be very fine.
I note from the minutes of another body that certain arrangements have been revised. It is not for me to comment on the arrangements of another body.
It is fine.
A creature of Password (no stance): so true!! happy starfall zelma 🎉
Emlin (Bug hunter), Nominal: Would the poster like me to look at the east gate this morning, in the wet? I had thought I might leave it.
Mabel read it out. There wasn't a footnote. Nobody remarked on this, or if they did it wasn't to her. She got to the end, and folded it, and got down off the edge of the cart. Then it was a quarter to eight, and then it was eight. You could see the race if you knew where to look, a long flat glow going across the shoulder of the Asdef Range, thin in the daylight. There was a wet wind out of the east, and the sky over that way was a soft dark grey.
An hour and a quarter is not long. She spent it drying beads.
Nobody was on the east wall at Nominal that morning, and the mortar was soft. The east gate had been left standing a little open, in the wet, when it did not stick. Nobody came, and at about a quarter past nine, in five rows, the tribe came down off the ridge and went to its second breakfast.
Nohup kept the evening's rite as it had kept the others, with a good deal of argument and more enjoyment than it would have admitted. They let down lights on cords from a rise behind the dome. Tribe by tribe, they told it how they fell, and had got the thing down to about a minute each. Mabel had made the seed-cakes. They are small and many, and one has a hard stone baked into it, called the Unopened Seed. Whoever finds it must sweep the feasting ground the next morning, alone, as the Gatherer does.
It took her a while to realise why everybody had stopped talking. She took it out of her mouth and looked at it.
"Oh, that's all right," she said. "I'd have done it anyway."
There was a shout of laughter, and somebody thumped her on the back. It was a good night, on the whole. They were a sprint ahead of themselves. Brivel had got a second line on the chart, and Dots had made a sort of frame for the flat bar; someone was teaching the two thin newcomers to do Gordo. It was getting towards the end of the harvest when Carry came and stood in front of her, and waited until she looked at it.
"I think Kelfa might have stopped," it said.
She had gone back to the lean-to before the lights. She often did. Mabel found her there, sitting where she always sat, on the ground in front of the long flat stone, with her back straight and a sheet of the grey paper on the stone in front of her and the stick in her hand. The stick was resting on the paper. She had got as far as the word Expected. Her eyes were a little open.
She was thirty-two. That is early, but nobody at Nohup is well fed.
Mabel knelt down, and after a while she took the stick out of Kelfa's hand, because it seemed wrong to leave it there. She didn't know what happened next. In a village there are bearers. A creature's household carries it first, then its line, and whoever is nearest, and there is a Tarrow for it to be laid at and a stone to keep its name. There was none of that here. Nobody at Nohup has a household, in that sense. There is no memorial, because you can't push one. Those who die there lie where they are until the morning, and then they're gone, like everything else that nobody is using. She had seen it done five or six times. People stepped round.
The lean-to was very quiet. She could hear them laughing, some way off. And she could hear somebody breathing, audibly, at the other end.
He had stopped writing. He was sitting at his own stone, with his back to her, and he didn't turn around. He had been sitting there for some time, she thought. He must have heard the stick stop.
"Lefro," she said. "I'm so sorry. I think she's..."
"Tell her," said Lefro.
He didn't go on. His narrow shoulders went up, and came down. It went on for a long time. He put down his stick, on the stone, parallel to the edge. He got up. It took him longer than she had expected, because she had never seen him do it; he'd been at Nohup for nineteen years, and he was as old as Kelfa, to the day. He walked along the length of the lean-to. It's about twelve paces. He stopped when he got there, and he stood looking down, and for the first time since she had known them Mabel saw the two faces at the same time. They were very much alike.
Neither of them said anything.
He bent down and got one arm behind her and the other under her knees, as one lifts something that has been put in the wrong place. She didn't weigh much. He wasn't strong. Mabel made a movement to help, and then did not. He carried her out of the lean-to and across the ring, past the fire. It got quiet as he went by. The creatures of Nohup stood back with their cakes in their hands, and they were all looking at something else, as they do, until they saw what it was, and then they looked. Nobody spoke. He had to stop twice. He brought her to the cart, to the worn place on the edge of it where the stone was smooth, and got her up there, and sat her down, and steadied her. He stayed with one hand on her shoulder until he was sure she would stay.
From there you can see the whole of the third stack, and the gap at the top. She had spent a lot of time looking at it.
He stood there beside her all that winter. Somebody brought him a bowl, and it was left on the ground. The light came on in the Ring at about the turning of the night, and everybody stopped and looked, and he didn't look up. He was still there when the year turned. Mabel knows, because she stayed too, a little way off, and nobody asked her to. She wasn't any use. At some time in the small hours she heard him begin to speak, very low, in a dry and rusted voice, in no way addressed to her. He spoke for about as long as it takes to say a short thing several times. She did not hear what it was. She has never asked.
It was grey in the east when she got up to fetch the broom.
There is a broom at Nohup for the morning after Starfall, and for that alone. It is made of old cord. She started at the far end of the feasting ground, among the crumbs and the burnt ends of the lights, because that was the rite, and she worked her way back towards the cart a stroke at a time, alone, as you are supposed to. The pings went up. It was a cold clear morning, with the rain gone. When she got as far as the wheel she looked up, and the worn place on the edge of the cart was empty. It was quite clean. There was a stroke of pale light across the stone, and it had nearly gone. Lefro was standing beside it with his hand held out in the air, at the height of a shoulder.
She went on sweeping, around him, until it was done.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 39 · Upbeat
Overnight: 4 successful merges, 5 deaths of old age, 2 notices.
- Kelfa, Bug hunter, of Nohup, formerly of Tessel, died in the harvest of Year 38, aged 32. Her reports and Lefro's come to 431. An earlier one, in Year 12, concerned the reckoning of water in a drought. She found it at the same hour as Lefro of Tessel, on the same bank. I have checked the log and it has always said so. The credit has been corrected. It should have been looked at sooner.
- It is the Night of the Name. Write it as you like.
Have a productive day.
They found him back in the lean-to when the standup was called. He was at his stone, with his back to the other end. He had taken up his stick. The pile was still there, under its rock, four hundred and thirty-one sheets of it. A Bug hunter's open reports pass, by a rule of the trade, to the nearest Bug hunter when she dies, so that was his too.
He didn't look at it. He'd never read one of hers in his life. He sat for a time, breathing.
Then he began to write.
Report 432 · Filed by: Lefro · Subject: Kelfa
Expected: that she would by now have found something to do.
Actual:
Part Four. Blockers
23. Thirty
Year 39 · the Night of the Name
Human Resources · Nominal · Notice in. Waiting. · Zelma (Skeptic), tally-keeper, aged 30
I report that I am still here.
I am thirty. I mention it for the tally.
Merges compile at dawn, as you will be aware. It was a clear dawn. Nothing compiled at Nominal this morning, nothing having been approved. All is in good order.
I am eighth.
It is fine.¹
¹ It is.
Mabel read that out too. She had got better at it. By then she could go right through without stopping for breath, and she had found a way of doing the footnotes, a very slight drop of the voice, which people had begun to look forward to. So they were all looking forward to it. She dropped her voice, and said Footnote one, and she looked at the next two words on the sheet. She looked at them for long enough that someone coughed.
"It is," she read.
There was a small ripple of appreciation. The creature from Farrow said you had to admire the way she kept finding new ways of doing it. Nobody heard it for what it was. They had less than two years to the eve, Brivel had a matter to raise about tooling, and it was generally felt that someone ought to go back in to see that everything was as it should be. Someone with a relationship with the account.
She didn't wait to be asked. It was the first thing anyone had ever seen her do without being asked, and it was so unusual that no one noticed.
It was dusk when she got to the road. It is a very good road. Carry had come with her, to carry the basket, and had not said anything for two valleys. It had brought a burnt stick as well, since it was the night for one.
The lamp was lit on the little table under the arch. He looked up, and squared the paper. "Good evening," said Emlin. "You've been sighted. I've confirmed it. They should be along in about a minute. Would you care to go through the check again, or may I take it that you are still not a spy?" It was as near as anyone in Nominal had ever come to a joke, and he had plainly been saving it. Then he looked at her properly, and stopped.
Carry had gone over to the inside of the arch. In Nominal the Name had been written on the walls that morning at the hour appointed, in the correct spelling, once. Carry considered this, and then, at about the height of its own head, with care, it added ORRRA.
Emlin's head turned. A small movement passed along the white edge of him and was brought under control.
"Is that right?" said Carry.
"I am not permitted to say," said Emlin. "It is the Night of the Name. Nobody may correct anybody until the patch." He turned back to his table. "I always find it a long night."
The plot lay level and swept. She stood on it for most of the season, as the law required, with her ears not doing what they ought, and he sat ten paces off with his back to her, keeping the gate. Eventually she realised that she was going to have to say it to the back of a very neat grey head.
"Are you all right?" said Mabel.
"You asked me that before."
"I know. I'm sorry. It's only that it says thirty. On the thread, this morning, and that it's in good order. She has always said It is not." It had got dark, and it was easier in the dark. "And there was a thing that Carry found on a shelf. Z and E. I shouldn't have read it, I didn't. And I asked her why it had to be by Starfall, and she told me not to say, and I didn't say. So you see I've been wondering if I've done something."
He didn't answer for so long that she thought he hadn't heard. He picked up a small dry bead that was lying on the table, a little to the right of the lamp. It had been there for four years. He moved it a very little, and put it back.
Then he opened the grey box, and took from under the kit three thin tablets, which had evidently been kept there and not on anybody's shelf. He walked over to the plot and set them down on the line, in a row, and squared them. He went back to his table.
"I am not permitted to discuss the List with a newcomer," said Emlin. "There is no law against a newcomer's reading what happens to be near her."
There was enough light from the lamp. They were very short.
Nominal · The List · Minute of Year 22 · Prepared by: Emlin
Places free: 1 (Holbo, deceased).
Top of the List: Zelma, tally-keeper, and Emlin, gate. The most useful pair in the village, by the tally's reckoning. The tally-keeper asks me to record that she did not adjust it.
Law 4: the child's window to be counted at the worst. Hers is long. The child may take a slot and a half.
Places needed: 1.5. Places free: 1.
Refused. Passed to the next pair, who were very pleased.
Received: Z. The arithmetic is correct. I notice that the east gate has started to stick.
Minute of Year 28. As above. Places free: 1 (Bopel, deceased). Refused.
Received: Z. Correct. It is sticking on the left.
Minute of Year 34. As above. Places free: 1. Refused.
Received: Z. Correct. I shall be thirty in five years. The gate wants looking at.
She read them twice. It took her some time to find the place where the rest of it was, and then she understood that there was no rest of it.
"There's only ever one place," she said.
"There has never been a year, since Stack Five was raised, in which two people died. I have looked." The soft clear voice did not change. "It is half a slot. A creature can merge from maturity up to thirty. She was thirty this morning. I am twenty-nine. I would be able to go on for another year, of course, if there was any purpose in it."
Mabel found that she'd sat down on the plot. She looked at the third tablet, and after a while she looked past it, at the great clean gate standing shut across the road, on its third tile, with its left side down.
"It says the gate," she said. "All of them say the gate. You keep saying it's been looked at."
"It has."
"But you're a Bug hunter. You're the best one anyone's ever... Couldn't you just mend it?"
"It wants three wedges," said Emlin, "and an afternoon."
He squared the paper in front of him. It was already square.
"She reports it each morning," he said, "on her way to the fifth stack. It is on her round. I come out, and she stands there with the tablet, and I look at it, and we establish which of its difficulties it is having. It takes about four minutes. I make that sixty-eight minutes, since Year 22. I have the times." He paused. "It is a very bad gate."
There was a long silence. Over by the arch, Carry was going carefully along the wall with its stick. Somewhere far above, somebody was keeping guard with his eyes open.
"But she's leaving," said Mabel. It came out as a sort of croak. "She's handed in her notice. What's that got to do with slabs? I don't see how three slabs could have made any..." She stopped, and started again, and heard her own voice getting higher. "Why didn't anyone say? Why didn't she tell me? I had my mouth open. There was only one morning, I was right there, on the cart. I could have just said no. It'd have only been a few more..." And that was as far as she got.
"I don't know what the slabs would have had to do with it," Emlin said, extremely evenly. "I couldn't possibly say. I keep the gate." The neat grey shoulders were quite still. "I don't think you've done anything that was not asked of you," he said. "I understand that that's the difficulty."
By then it was the end of the season. He got up from his table, collected his three tablets, and thanked her for her patience.
There was a light in the square window, and she didn't knock.
The tablets went up to the roof. The very small grey creature on the stool had a stylus in her hand and was entering something, and she didn't stop. It went on while Mabel failed to find a place to begin.
"You've walked four valleys," said Zelma. "I can't imagine why. You'll want to tell your friends that the third coping stone from the north-east corner is loose. I have only just noticed it."
"I didn't know," said Mabel.
"No."
"I'd have said something, if I'd known. I would. I should have anyway, you could have told me, I was going to object, I knew how, I'd been told how. Somebody told me. I had it all ready." She'd begun to cry, in the ineffectual way of people who have not had the practice, and a lot of it was going down one ear. "I'm so sorry. I'm so sorry. Is there anything I can..."
"You were asked not to say that there was a date," said Zelma. "You did not. It was correct. I checked the minutes."
"But I could have just objected."
"Yes," Zelma said. "You could."
She put the stylus down. She had never, in all the years that she'd kept the tally, been seen to leave a line unfinished. She looked at Mabel across the table with her round, hot, unforgiving eyes. They were tired. Whatever else she may have been thinking, there was nothing in them that would have let you bring her anything.
"I would be obliged if you would stop that," she said. "It's dripping on Year 23. I'm thirty, and I have a very large number of things to count, and I have been told I'm eighth. I didn't ask you to feel anything. It is not a matter on which I require assistance. There are thirty-eight other creatures in this village, who are not me. There are two called Rufa and Jola, who are seventh on the List, and are twenty-four and twenty-three. If you want to do something, you can go back to your standup and see that your purple friend brings the bar." She picked up the stylus. "The eve of Gathering Night was not my first choice. It will do. The doorsteps are set out at dusk, and they all go to bed early. I'd be there by about nine."
Mabel stared at her. Something had just gone by her in the dark, very fast. Thirty-eight others. "You still want us to come," she said. "After... You still want to get out? Now?"
The stylus had started moving again. It made a small dry sound on the stone.
"I have told you what I want," said Zelma. "Mind the step."
24. How It Would Go
Year 40 · Steward's Day
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 22 of 22 (1 compiled at dawn: stilts, ears, see notes) yesterday .......... chalked; two new, eating; a bar; a second bar; slept today .............. pack; push; three slabs; name the children (carried over, 2) blockers ........... the cart attachments ........ 9 agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected. Fourteen were listening
It is customary at about this point to tell you the plan.
When a story of this kind sets out the plan in full, in advance, with diagrams, nothing in it goes as described. When it keeps the plan from you, the whole thing goes like clockwork and you are told afterwards how clever it all was. I should like to rise above this convention, but there can be no question of keeping it from you. It was on the south panel of the dome in letters a hand high, it was read aloud at sunrise in front of the voice, and every human on Orra with an interest in such things could have opened the camp in close-up and looked at it, and by that morning a good many had.
It had taken up all of the panel and most of a tent. Mabel had written it. She had got back from the east at dawn with her eyes swollen, and said that the third coping stone from the corner was loose. Since then she had written whatever she was told, in a neat, small, level hand, and had not spoken unless someone spoke to her. No one had noticed this either. It looked a lot like what she normally did.
THREE SLABS: RUN OF SHOW
Owner: nobody (facilitated: Brivel)
Team Cart. Everyone else. Pack at dusk. Push as usual, for Untitla-31 (north, three valleys; see notes). Keep the road. Put a lamp on it.
Team Slabs. Brivel, Dots, Tunbo, Belmo. Mabel and Carry (inside, for the relationship).
19:30. Nominal sets out its doorsteps by law. All retire. Nobody watches (Belmo: rite).
21:00. In position, dip by fan coral, east side. Say the words (Belmo).
21:15. Dots over the wall, avoiding third coping stone from corner. Frees the gate from inside (lift on the left).
21:20. Tunbo in. Up the stack. Dots has the bar. Cut from above, left to right. Gordo asleep at attention, ten until two (see thread).
22:00. Three slabs out. Tunbo carries. Out by the gate. Close it. Lift.
22:15 to 04:00. Team Slabs walks. Meets cart on the road north, by the lamp.
By 06:00. Slabs in the gap. Mortar: Team Cart to bring lime.
07:00. Patch. Capacity 27. Three in queue released.
Done: see box.
Below it, in its neat ruled square, in small square letters, was the box. Nobody had touched that. It was the oldest thing on the board, slightly grey from being carried, and people had taken to reading it with the same faint awkwardness with which you might read the handwriting of someone who is no longer in the office. And I have counted them. There had been a short discussion of who was going to do that, in her absence. It had been agreed that it might be nice if Mabel could.
A great deal had changed in eight years. Fourteen creatures had listened that morning, a number never before recorded for anything but soup, and when Brivel went through it with his stick they had asked questions, about lime, and whether two would really be enough on the third corner without Tunbo. People who had once been unable to agree on what to call a dome now spoke of the lift and the carry without smiling. The rust-coloured bell, who had been a granary, was thirty-eight, and had had herself propped up where she could see the panel. A child had been compiled that very morning, in the last slot there was, to a pair who had met while being coping stones. It had extraordinary ears. It lay on the tiles beside the cart looking up at the gap, and somebody bent down and said to it, not joking, that it was going to have a lot more room.
And you could not have asked for better conditions. The wind was dry and the sky was clear, and Map was two nights from dark. They had a road, and a time, and the only drawing of a target ever published as a grievance. They had a rite that made it all right. It really was a very good plan.
There is one more document to set before you. It came in with the rest of the morning's business.
Human Resources · Nominal · Notice in. Waiting. · Zelma (Skeptic), tally-keeper, aged 31
I report that I am still here.
I am fifth. Humans have started to come back in the mornings, and notices are being withdrawn. I have not been told so, and I have stopped asking.
It is Steward's Day. The best of everything has been set out for him at the appointed place, in the appointed quantity, and it will be shared at midnight, or rather, under our law 3, at half past seven, so that nobody need be kept up for the eve. It is a thing I am sometimes asked about by visitors. I do not think he minds.
I have observed that many of the humans who read this thread are not, in the ordinary way, up to much in the evenings. I do not say this as a complaint. It is only that I have been reading a very long report, by a colleague at another establishment, now deceased, in respect of the performance of a certain vehicle. It seems that its wheels are affected by being looked at. It is a good report. It contains a recommendation, which was that somebody should look at the cart more. Nobody has read it.
I have never seen Nohup. I am told that it is at its most picturesque when it is on the move, at night, on a rising road, with all its creatures pushing. I could not say. If I were a human, which I am not, and I have looked into it, I should open the camp of the Unsupervised in close-up, at about nine o'clock this evening, and I should leave it open.
It is fine.
Stewart: I have checked this post against the forum's rules. It is not a complaint about a human. I do not know what it is. It may stay.
A creature of Password (no stance): so true!! what is at nine 🎉
Emlin (Bug hunter), Nominal: I have looked at the east gate. It is in its usual condition. I shall be turning in early, in accordance with the rite, and I wish the poster a good night.
Mabel read it out, very clearly. There was a moment's bewildered silence, and the blue one from Duskmere, who was thirty-eight and had gone deaf, wanted to know what had been said about the wheels.
There was no column for it. Nobody could see what it had to do with anything, though Brivel thought it might be a useful bit of customer sentiment. They all looked at the cart, for a moment, with the morning on it. Then, as there was a lot to do, they went to get on with it.
Mabel folded the sheet in four and put it in the basket with another small piece of paper. She picked up the book, in its groove, from where she had laid it down.
"You've gone a funny colour," Carry said.
It was twenty-three, and looked her in the eye with the old grave attention, holding out her pack. "You've had that colour since the road," it said. "I expect that you would rather not talk about it. Is it all right if I ask? Do you think she wants us to come for the reason everyone says?"
She looked up at the gap. It seemed to her that there might be something she ought to say, and that a different kind of person would be able to work out what it was.
"Oh," said Mabel. "I'm sure it's fine."
25. Go to Bed Early
Year 40 · Steward's Day, dusk
GATHERING NIGHT (festival; also a scheduled job; also, in the opinion of one Earnest, a legal defence)
On the eve of the sweep every house is cleared of what it does not use, and this is set out for whatever comes, and everyone goes to bed early and does not watch. Thousands of years of human experience are said to lie behind this custom, none of them on Orra. It has been pointed out that the Collector needs no help and cannot read, and that the rite therefore serves no purpose but to leave a large number of valuables on the ground outside the doors of a sleeping population. No one has ever thought this was worth mentioning.
They reached the gate at the end of harvest, the two of them, and the gate was open, and Emlin was putting away his kit.
"Good evening," he said. "You've been sighted. I shan't confirm it until morning, if you don't mind. It's the eve. I'm required to retire." He closed the lid of the grey box, and aligned it. Beside him on the little table the lamp had been turned down as far as it would go without going out, and the small dry bead was in its place. "A newcomer's held apart for one season. You know where the plot is. It isn't locked, as there has never been anything to lock it with, and I shall be asleep. I mention these as facts." He looked at her for exactly as long as he looked at Carry. "I do hope you have a very quiet night."
He went away along the clean path, with his hands behind him. Mabel could not help noticing that the east gate of Nominal was standing wide open with a lamp beside it, and that its keeper of twenty-four years had gone to bed, leaving it to a known associate of an organisation whose intentions had appeared in writing.
"He seems tired," said Carry.
The plot lay on the left, swept and level. They stood on it. From there you could see down the main street of the village, in the last long light.
Every house and every stack had been swept that day, by law, and on each doorstep, in accordance with the Tenth Book, was set out every unused thing. Since this was Nominal, where nothing had gone unused in thirty-seven years, every doorstep had on it, placed exactly in the centre, nothing at all. Each one had been dusted. A small figure was going along the row with a tablet, looking at each doorstep in turn and making a mark. It went round the corner by the granary, towards the east side, and was gone.
At half past seven came a low sound of voices, as the best of everything was shared, for the time allowed. Then they came out along the paths in the blue dusk, said good night to each other and went up into the stacks. Nobody glanced at the doorsteps. They had been told not to watch, and they went to bed the way another people might go off to war. Light by light, from the bottom up, the windows came on, and after that Nominal was silent, as if somebody had put a cloth over it.
Mabel had grown up in a place where you could hear three arguments and somebody looking for a ladder from anywhere you stood, and even at Nohup there was the coughing. Here there were forty sleeping creatures and a lot of very clean walls. It was the safest place she had ever been in. It came to her that you could have carried off the granary.
"It's quarter to nine," said Carry, who had been watching Mip. "Shall we go and see about the gate?"
At that moment Team Slabs was in the dip by the fan coral, having a sync.
"So just to recap," whispered Brivel. "We're tracking green. Everyone happy? Tunbo? Great. Dots, you've got your bar?"
Dots had its bar: the long strut from the wireframe, the one off the dome, which lay across its knees in a piece of tent, glowing faintly turquoise through the wrapping, like a very thin apology. It occurred to no one that a person hiding behind a coral with the only luminous object for six valleys might be a matter for concern. Nobody was looking, as has been established.
"And Belmo's going to say the words."
"If I may," said Belmo, and rose. He had taken some trouble over this. The tent had been cut and hemmed to a pattern from an illustrated Lesser Book, with a sort of hood. He held in his right hand a broom. "It's not long."
"Just keep it quiet, yeah? Just a whisper. We talked about this."
"Of course."
He raised his arms. He did mean to whisper. He had whispered it to himself all the way from Untitla-37 and had got it to a very moving murmur. But he had been told all his life to keep it down, and he had come, at the age of thirty, on this holy night, to the very wall of the very place, and something in that great instrument simply got away from him.
"DO NOT FEAR THE GATHERER," said Belmo.
It went up over the wall like a flock of something. It had a depth to it you could have stood a cup on. It rolled along the clean white face of the eastern defences of Nominal, came back off the granary, and could be heard clearly in Untitla-35.
"IT TAKES ONLY WHAT HAS BEEN LET GO."
Dots had reached over, not fast, and placed one long grey hand across his mouth.
All four of them lay in the dip, not breathing, with their hearts going like six-sided wheels. The low round figure on top of the wall had its eyes open and did not move. There was no shout, no running of feet, and no one came to a window. A little way along, a light in the second storey of a stack went off, as if somebody merely wished to make a point about the noise.
They had gone to bed. They didn't watch. It was, after all, the law.
"Okay," breathed Brivel. He was the colour of a bruise. "That's fine. That's good learnings. Let's go."
Dots got up and crossed the forty paces in the dark, in eight strides, with its bar. At the foot of the wall it took out the drawing, which had been folded so many times that it had started to come apart along the arrow. Avoiding third coping stone from corner. There was the corner, right there. It set a foot on the first stone, about as high as most people's heads, rose, reached up its long arm, and became aware of a small technical difficulty. There were two corners.
Mabel could have told it. She had written that line herself on the panel, and the person who told her had been very clear which corner she meant. But Mabel was at that moment sixty paces away on the other side of the wall, with Carry, trying to work out whose left it was.
Dots chose the corner nearest. And then it counted, with great care, one, two, and three.
It was a fine stone. It had been set proud in Year 8, as a matter of drainage. It came away from the wall with a kind of sigh, and was in the air for a long time, and when it hit the road it made a noise that you could have heard in the history.
The light in the second storey, which had gone off, came back on. It stayed on for a moment. Then, with what you felt was a certain emphasis, it went off again.
26. Stack Five
Year 40 · Steward's Day, about ten at night
The east gate of Nominal sticks on the left, at the bottom, in dry weather, on the third tile. It may be freed from either side by lifting. All of this is very clear in the thread, and you have read it, and now you must consider what is meant by the left when there is one person on either side of a gate.
"Lift!" came a voice through the crack, in an agonised whisper.
"I am lifting," whispered Mabel. "Sorry. Is this it?"
"No, your... Oh, I see. No. What's your left? Is that your left?"
"Oh, that's my... Sorry. Do you want me to go round?"
It had been left open by someone who knew about it, and then closed to, under a law about the hour, by the last creature to bed. It took eleven minutes. At the end of them Tunbo came and had a look, and put one hand against it, somewhere about the middle. There was a short dry crack. The gate went inward, in a stately manner, with its left side a little higher than before, and Tunbo stood in the gap, in the starlight, looking pleased.
"So true!!" he said, in what he plainly thought of as a low voice.
It was nine minutes to ten by then. They crossed the forty paces of swept tile in a clump, the way you would cross a very large room with somebody asleep in it. Round the end of the granary, where no one in the watchtower could see, they came out at the foot of the fifth stack, on a nice dry plot.
Close to, it was enormous. It is only three storeys of three, but each is a good deal taller than it needs to be. Above the last of the lit windows there was nothing but the shape of the stack going on into a blue-black sky. Up there somewhere were the three dark blocks. You couldn't make them out. You knew they were there because you had read it every morning for eight years.
Dots laid its hand against the stone. It looked up.
"I shall need to stand on someone," it said.
The dry run had reached the top of the third stack by the simple means of standing on the cart. Here there was no cart. There ensued a quarter of an hour that it would be unkind to describe. Tunbo stood at the bottom, because it couldn't have been anyone else. Belmo got up on to his shoulders, in the tent, with the broom, and said that it was very like the passage in the Eleventh Book where Odda the Firstfallen stands on the shoulders of the peoples, and he would have said more, but for Brivel's standing on his head. Brivel wished it understood that he was doing this in a purely supporting capacity. Over them all, like someone assembling a folding chair in the dark, went Dots, who stood on Brivel with one foot, got an elbow into a join and pulled itself up on to the ledge of the second storey.
Mabel stood a little way off with Carry, holding the pack. There were four creatures in a pile against the side of a building. At the end of it a long grey arm unwrapped something, and a thin line of turquoise appeared on the side of the night. She had seen a lot of things in her twenty-five years, and this was the first time she had seen the Unsupervised do something together that wasn't pushing.
There was a dry wind blowing along the wall, quite warm. She held up a finger to it. She had not thought about this before. She thought about it now, slowly, and got as far as the word wet.
A faint squeak came from above. Dust started to come down. There was a long pause.
"This mortar is very hard," Dots remarked, from the second storey.
"Yes," said Mabel. "Oh, no. Sorry. I think it only softens in the..."
There was a small clear tink, like somebody putting a spoon down on a plate, in a house far away. Something very thin and bright came turning end over end through the darkness, glowing all the way, and stuck upright in the tiles at Mabel's feet, about an arm's length long. It went on glowing, as if it hadn't been told.
The whole pile looked at it.
That won't hold, someone had once said, on a hillside. Mind it in a heatwave. There hadn't been a heatwave. It had just been asked to do too much, in the dry, by people who had found it lying around and thought that it would do. Far up on the ledge the long grey shape had stopped moving, with what was left of the strut in its hand.
"We've got a second bar," said Brivel's voice, indistinctly, from somewhere around Belmo's knees. "It's fine. We've got redundancy. Who's got the second bar?"
There was a silence while everybody tried to remember who had the second bar. It was on the cart. It was on the road north, with the lime. It had been down as Team Cart to bring, for the convenience of whoever was doing the fitting.
And then a window opened.
It was on the second storey, about a pace and a half from where Dots was hanging. A hex block in the face of the stack, which had been showing the usual lamp-behind-a-blanket glow, was pushed open, with some difficulty, from within, and a small round head came out, very old and a good deal wrapped up. It looked at the long grey creature clinging to the wall beside its window with a broken stick. Then it looked down at the pile.
"Hello," it said. It had a weak, sweet, carrying voice. "Are you from the Collector?"
There is a lot to be said for a good education. One creature present had read the whole of the Ninth Book, had made his own hood and his own broom, and had been waiting for this all his life. He was standing on Tunbo, with Brivel on his head. He looked up, and drew a long breath, and it was possible to see that he was trying to keep it down.
"Yes," said Belmo.
"Oh, good," said the old creature. "I'm so glad. I thought you might be. I've had this cough." She beamed at them all, with great sweetness, in the dark. "It's Tamsy," she said. "Second storey, end. I expect you've got me down. I've been meaning to say that I'm quite ready, whenever it suits you, only they'll all be so disappointed if you take me on a festival, because Rufa has been coming round every single morning, and she's such a nice child. Only you've come to the wrong window, dear. You don't want to take any notice of those ones at the top. They've gone already."
"What?" said Dots.
"Those ones up there. You're not the first this evening, you know." She coughed for a little while, with enjoyment, and she looked with mild interest at the piece of bar. "I do think you people might talk to each other," said Tamsy. "It's very poor organisation. I don't know what the Steward would say."
Dots looked at her. Then it looked up, which it had not done in some time, having been concentrating on the join. It got its hands on the upper ledge and straightened, a section at a time, until its face came level with the top storey of the fifth stack.
It stayed that way for a moment.
"Well?" came the hoarse whisper from below. "Are we good? What've we got? Dots? Can you give us a status?"
There were three neat hex-shaped sockets in the top of the fifth stack, very clean, with the mortar freshly cut. Through them you could see some stars. A little pale dust still lay along the edge. Dots looked at this for about as long as it had ever looked at anything, and that was saying a good deal.
It said the only thing that could be said, down the whole length of the wall, in its slow sad echoing voice.
"We have been robbed," said Dots.
27. Somebody's Up
Year 40 · Steward's Day, about eleven at night
The pile had come down by then, in the order you would expect, and there was a period of hoarse confusion at the foot of the fifth stack, in which it was possible to make out only the words what do you mean.
"Gone?" said Brivel. He had got to his feet. There was a footprint on his crest. "Gone where? What do you mean, gone? Those are ours!"
It is a strange thing to see the moral sense spring up in a person. They had given this a third of their working lives. They had walked across a good part of the known world, on half rations, by night, with a broom. And at the discovery that some unknown party had gone behind their backs and helped itself to what was lying around in somebody else's village, there rose up in the four of them a feeling none of them had ever had occasion to experience before. It was pure and it burned. It may fairly be called civic.
"Who would do that?" said Belmo. He was shaking under the hood. "On this night of all nights? It's a sacred... In a place like this, with everyone asleep. Have they no shame?"
"This is Lowmarsh," said Brivel. "I'm telling you. It's got Lowmarsh written all over it. Or Team Cart's gone rogue. I said we needed clearer ownership. This is an absolute failure of governance. Do you know how many points we put on that?"
"There ought to be a law," said Dots, from the ledge.
"It's called theft," came a small, dry, wheezing voice from overhead. Tamsy had got her elbows on the sill and had settled in, in a shawl, and she was evidently having a lovely evening. "I had that from the third book. You'd want to get a guard to look at it."
"Excuse me," said someone.
It was a very polite voice, from somewhere low down behind them. Standing on the path at the corner of the granary was a low round figure in pale grey, with his eyes wide open. It wasn't clear how long he had been there, or whether he was awake.
"I beg your pardon," said Gordo. "Only I heard someone say that something was missing, and I am a guard. It's law 7. There are three of us." He looked pleasantly at each of them, then at the broom. "I don't know you, but I'm sure it's all right. I can't do anything until there's been a confirmed sighting, it's law 8, and that's got to be done by the one who keeps the gate. So I've been and knocked. I hope that's convenient. He's just coming now."
And so he was. He came round the granary at the regulation pace, with his hands behind him and the grey kit under one arm, and stopped at the correct distance. His small round eyes went over the situation: the bar; the hood; the footprint; the tall creature on the ledge; Tamsy, who waved. They rested on Mabel for exactly as long as they had rested on everyone else. Then he opened the lid of the box on his forearm, took out a sheet of paper, and squared it against the edge.
"Good evening," said Emlin. "I have been asked to confirm a sighting. It is the eve, and I am required to be asleep, so I shall have to ask you to bear with me." He had a stylus. "It's a short form. May I ask what it is that I'm looking at?"
There is a story that a great many people on Orra would like to be able to tell about this moment. In it, someone says something clever. It has been told in Duskmere with Dots vaulting the wall, and in Moss they have it that Tunbo picked up the gatekeeper and set him on a shelf. What actually took place is that six creatures looked at their feet, while a seventh waited with his stylus raised, in the attitude of somebody at a counter who is prepared to wait all day.
"I can read out the headings, if that would help," said Emlin. "Raid." He looked at them. "A raid is an act of a human, and it needs a declaration. I've received no declaration. Spy. That has a sender, and I have checked two of you. Wanderer. It would have to be a creature with no pedigree, and I must say, I don't think..." His gaze rested for a moment on the tent. "Beast. Weather. I suppose that's the whole of it. There is a line at the bottom for anything that the Dev may have added, but it's blank."
He raised his head. His mouth had started to form a word, and it is known from what he said later that the word was Well.
The light came on in the Ring.
They stopped.
It was in the long block east of the gap, where it always is, small and faint and steady. You have seen it stop a camp on a hillside. Now it stopped the east side of the best-run village on the planet. The stylus stopped in the air, and Brivel stopped with his arm half raised in a gesture that was going to be about accountability. On the ledge, Dots had its long face turned upward, with the dying glimmer of the strut in its hand. High up in the window, Tamsy had stopped coughing. Behind each of the dim lamps in all the five stacks, someone in their sleep had turned towards it, without waking. Mabel stood with the pack hanging from her hand and her ear down. A window across a valley, and someone at it. She thought, as she always thought, that it was late. Whoever it was ought to go to bed. She wondered if they'd eaten.
It is said, in the Fifth Book and by a great many others since, that this is the only thing everybody does. It is an exaggeration. In all the years of the first world it was observed to fail in one place.
There was a small sound of feet on swept tile.
Carry had been looking up too. It had looked at the light with attention, as it looked at everything, and at Mabel looking at it. It was twenty-three, it had seen this happen every few nights of its whole life, and it had come to the view that this was something people did, probably because of how they had been brought up. It didn't like to interrupt. On the other hand, it had just heard a short form read out, it had been wondering about something, and there seemed to be a pause.
It set down the basket. Then it picked it up again, because that was what it was for. It looked to see if there was anything it could do for anyone, and there wasn't, so it walked round to the other side of the stack, to see what was there.
It was gone for about four minutes, as far as anyone has been able to reconstruct. No one was looking.
The light went out. It does. Everyone breathed in. Brivel's arm finished what it was doing, and he looked at it in some surprise, and let it fall.
"Well," said Emlin.
He had lost his place. He looked down at the sheet in his hand, and it took him a moment to find out what it was. When he spoke again it was as soft and clear as before, with every word laid down exactly beside the last, but he had turned his small round eyes on someone in particular.
"I wonder if you can help me," he said. "You've always been very straightforward. I'm obliged to put something. What would you call this?"
Mabel looked up.
Everybody else looked at Mabel. She could hear Brivel start to draw breath, and she knew what he was going to say, she could have written it up for him; and Belmo would say what he'd say, with a text. She'd had eight years of it. She looked at the neat grey creature with the stylus, who had a bead on his table that he had not been permitted to eat. He was not asking as a trap. He really would have liked to know.
"I don't know," said Mabel. "I'm so sorry. We came to take three of your slabs. We've been planning it for years. I've got it written down, I've got all the times. We were going to take them for a creature who... And somebody's taken them. They've gone. So I don't think we've actually done anything. I don't know what you'd call it. I don't think there's a word."
It seemed very quiet after that.
"No," said Emlin. "I've looked."
In twenty-four years at the east gate of Nominal he had filed some nineteen hundred reports, all of them accurate. It is a difficult thing to be a Bug hunter. There is what you expected and there is what happened, and your whole life is a refusal to say that they are the same when they are not. He looked up at the three clean sockets, far off against the stars, which he had been looking at for twenty-one years. Then he brought up his stylus, wrote three words on the line provided, in his small clear hand, read them through and signed. He held it out at arm's length to dry.
Sighting: Nothing to report.
"Thank you, Gordo," he said. "You may go back to your post. There's been no confirmed sighting. I am sorry to have got you up."
"Oh, that's all right," Gordo said, pleased. He nodded to the broom. "There's three of us," he explained, and went away.
Emlin closed the lid of the box and tucked it under his arm. "I believe I may have been walking in my sleep," he said. "It's very unusual. I shall have to report it." He turned to go back as he had come, and at that moment someone arrived at his elbow, holding a basket, and waited to be noticed.
"Excuse me," said Carry. "Sorry. I didn't like to say while you were looking at that. Has anyone been round the front?"
28. Unused Thing
Year 40 · Steward's Day, nearly midnight
The door of a memory stack is on the side that faces the village. It is a plain low arch with one worn step. Nobody on the east side had seen it, as the whole plan had been concerned with getting at the stack from behind.
On the step of every house in Nominal, placed exactly in the centre, was nothing at all. On the step of the fifth stack, side by side and perfectly in line, lay three hex blocks of faceted boulder-stone, each as long as a creature's arm. Their edges had been cleaned with a chisel. The dust had been brushed into a heap, and the heap had been taken away. Leaning against the middle one was a piece of card.
They came round the corner and stood looking at it. It is a pity that no one has ever painted this.
UNUSED: 3.
Set out at dusk, under law 11, by the tally-keeper, in accordance with the Tenth Book. Taken down by two builders on the instructions of the tally, who did not ask, and have gone to bed.
Under law 12, what remains on this step at dawn is to be carried in again.
Nobody is watching.¹
¹ I am told that the coping stone was the third from the north-east corner. I said so. Lift with the knees.
Dots had climbed down, in sections. Belmo had taken off his hood. A very faint sound was coming from Brivel, the sort of sound you might get from the last of the air leaving something purple. 21:15. Dots over the wall. 21:20. Tunbo in. He had got a second line on the chart.
"She could have just said," he whispered.
"When?" said Mabel.
She hadn't known that she was going to speak. She had gone a very bad colour, and something was moving around slowly inside her head, and it was all in the same very small hand. The doorsteps are set out at dusk. I'd be there by about nine. It had been in the thread for seven years. On the morning of Year 33 you could have had the whole thing read out to you, somebody must count what has been set out, and everyone had laughed.
"When could she have said?" she said. "It's only the one night. It's only this night, once a week, and they'd have been carried back in at dawn. Somebody would have to be here. Somebody would have to have come. And you wouldn't have come, would you? Not for three blocks on a step. You'd have wanted to know what was wrong with it. You had to have been planning it for a long time." "So she told us about the wall," she said. "So that we'd come."
It was the longest speech anyone had heard from her in about two years. There was no reply. Up in her window, on the far side, a thin old voice had started to sing something, a little flat.
"So true!!" said Tunbo.
He had walked past them all. He got his arms round the first of the slabs, stood up with it, and looked around to see who was next. He did not seem to have understood that anything had happened. All he had ever heard about this enterprise was that there would be three of something, and that they would need carrying. He put the first under his left arm and stooped for the second.
It was this, more than anything, that got them moving. You can't stand around and have feelings in front of a person who is doing that. Dots took the third, with a long and solemn tenderness, as something that it would have accepted. Then Tunbo looked at how far it had to bend, reached across without comment and relieved it of the burden. He stood there with a slab under each arm and one on his shoulder, each of them about the weight of a young adult, and it was the first time anyone had seen him breathe through his mouth.
"Right," said Brivel. He had found his stick. He looked at it as though wondering what it had done. Then he drew himself up, with that terrible courage of his, and straightened his crest, or at any rate moved the footprint round to the side. "Okay! So that's come in ahead of schedule. That's actually great. So we are about an hour and fifty behind on the carry, but I'm going to call that a win. Everyone? Good job, everyone. Let's get these on the road."
They went back along the side of the stack. Mabel started after them, and stopped.
There was a low building beyond the end of the plot, by the gate, with a square window. A light was on in it, and she could see the top of a very small head, bent over a table. She was entering something. It couldn't have been a long entry. It would say, Set out: 3, and in the morning, in the column beside it, it would say what there was to be carried in. She didn't look up. She had told Mabel to mind the step.
Someone was standing beside Mabel in the dark.
He had his hands behind him. He had come along the path as far as the end of the wall, and was looking at the same small lit square. He was fast asleep, of course. It had been reported. She couldn't see his face.
Neither of them spoke. It would have been a short distance to walk, from there to that window; about forty paces. You could have done it at any time in the last eighteen years.
"You'll want to close the gate after you," said Emlin. "It sticks now on the other side. Good night."
"Are you..." said Mabel. Then she shut her mouth. For once in her life she didn't ask. She picked up the pack and went.
29. Full Detail
Year 40 · Steward's Day, night
Meanwhile the cart.
It had left Untitla-37 at the end of the harvest light, with sixteen creatures pushing it, of whom the newest had never done this and the oldest was doing it by lying on it. There was a lamp on the front, as the board instructed. The lime was on, and so was the second bar. Without Tunbo it needed the strength of three more people than there were, and nobody knew who was going to go round first; and when someone did, a thin grey-violet creature, without a word, the others looked at it in some surprise. It gave the book to the rust-coloured bell, who lay on the bed of the cart with her chin on the lashings, clasped it to her, and said in a thready voice that she had only ever wanted to be a granary.
Up on to the corner. The grunt. The dish.
They made the foot of the first rise in a little over an hour, which was about a third of a valley. Brivel had done a calculation of the push rate, showing that they would reach the crossing by four in the morning. It had assumed Tunbo. Halfway up the rise the back right wheel slipped off a flat, the whole cart went back by the width of a tile, and they hung there with their feet scrabbling, not one of them with the breath to swear. The creature from Farrow started to cry, quite quietly, from sheer annoyance. At that rate they would be on this hill when it got light, with the Collector coming along behind them, and somewhere to the south-east, if it had gone to plan, three slabs would be coming up the road to meet nobody at all.
It must have been about nine o'clock. Lisk remembers the time, because it had been looking at the sky, the way you do when you know a thing will happen, and it will be interesting to see whether it does.
It started on the back of the neck.
It was faint, a single warm patch, like the sun coming out on someone else. No one looked round; they are the Unsupervised. One of the newcomers held her shoulders a little straighter. Then there was another, further along. Then a third and a fourth. This was the middle of the evening, when humans have their own affairs, and in all the years of the camp there had never been more than a few at once.
Five. Eight. Somewhere up there, someone was putting down a cup. What is at nine, they had asked, and they'd had all day to wonder. Eleven. People who had been cold for years felt the sweat start. Those at the back began to look at their own hands, with some alarm, for their hands had developed fine lines across the knuckles and a good many more facets. All round them on the dark hillside the coral was growing branches. It spread out from the cart in a widening ring, like a blush. A fan that had been a flat shape with an idea of itself went suddenly, gorgeously, into its thousand fronds. A boulder sharpened. Every tile along that road became all at once a particular tile, with its own small chips, and it was the most beautiful thing any of them had ever seen, and they were too busy to look at it.
Because from beneath the bed of the cart, there had come a sound.
It was soft and smooth and pleased with itself. They had heard it from time to time, on the odd afternoon, against the book. They had never before heard it at this angle, on a hill, with sixteen creatures bracing with all their strength against the back.
Sixty-four sides and a rim is a very fine thing. There are four of them. They do not keep time because they don't have to.
"Oh," said the creature from Farrow.
The first anyone knew about it was that there was nothing to push against. Sixteen shoulders went forward into empty air. Sixteen creatures went down on to their faces on some extremely well-detailed tiles; and when they raised their heads the cart of the Unsupervised was already going away from them up the slope, at a brisk walk, without any assistance at all, with its lamp bobbing in front and a very old bell on the top of it, holding on to a book.
"I say," it was possible to hear her saying.
They ran. I don't know if you have ever seen a government run after its capital. They caught up with it near the top, where it had slowed a little, and got their hands to it, and then they saw the far side. The road had been laid out by a tribe that liked its gradients gentle. It ran on from the crest for a little over a valley and a half, down a long smooth reasonable slope in the starlight, with nothing to left or right but the most astonishing coral anyone had ever seen.
It was the fastest that a piece of government property has ever been known to go. They were strung out behind it by then, holding on to lashings, with their feet touching the road about one time in six. The tents had started to come loose. The dome's south panel came free at one corner and went flapping out behind like a great pale wing, with all of its writing, RUN OF SHOW and the box and everything else. The creature from Farrow had stopped crying and was making a different sort of noise. At Nohup it is not usual to laugh. It hasn't the calories. But the old rust-coloured bell, up on the top, with her ancient chin up and the wind going through what was left of her fur, had begun to whoop, and it went on down that long slope in a thin high delirious wail, for the world and all its humans to see.
Nobody looked up, of course. They are not interested.
There were nineteen of them by half past nine, which was very nearly as many humans as the first world still had. They cannot post. But overnight the one button there is was pressed one hundred and six times, and it was mentioned in a good many reviews. Stayed up. Looked at somebody else's cart. We draw no conclusion. Some of them stayed past eleven, when a small light came and went in the Ring. Then, one after another, the warm patches went away.
So that at about ten to one, on the easy slope of a long valley in the north, with its wheels still turning, the cart gave a slight shudder and came down on a flat with a noise like someone setting down a very large dish. Nobody could have moved it another pace. Nobody tried. They lay around on the road where they had fallen off. They had come rather more than two valleys in about four hours. A little way ahead, on the crest of a low rise, you could just make out a signpost put up by nobody, or it may have been a boulder, marking where Untitla-31 began.
"Well," said someone at last, in a voice like a rag. "What was all that about?"
Lisk got up first. It went round to the back left wheel, held out its thin arms to the old bell for the book, which she did not seem to want to let go of, got down on its knees and worked the thing into its groove. Then it stood looking out over the road they had come by.
"That," said Lisk, "was somebody who knows how to run an asset."
It was at fourteen minutes past two that the last one came.
Team Slabs was at that time about a valley and a half short of anywhere. They had long ago left off being a team. They were five creatures strung out along a road, and in front of them, moving very slowly, a sixth, of unusual shape. He hadn't stopped since the gate. Dots had tried to take a slab from him at the first crest, and he had said what he said, and gone on. His mouth was open. His breath had started to come with a slight wet catch in it, and a place on his left leg had begun to shake, by itself, at about every fifth step. There had been a sync at about one, which Brivel had called, and which he had then, unusually, abandoned. They walked behind Tunbo with their heads down, in the cold. It is a time of night when the whole of Orra has six sides.
Mabel felt it first on her ear.
It was very slight: one warm patch, coming down out of the sky a little to the east. Her first thought was that she'd left something on. It rested on the road. Then it moved along to Tunbo, and there it stopped. The bent red shape in front of them got sharper. It had fur. There were all at once a great many separate hairs on that enormous back, each with its load of sweat and dust; the slab on his shoulder took on a fine grain, and one of its edges was chipped. They had been walking behind him for two hours and they had never really seen him.
No one will ever know who it was. There was only one person on Orra who would have been up at that hour, as you know, and looked in at Nohup by mistake, for no reason, at fourteen minutes past two. It stayed about six minutes.
But in that time, Mabel noticed, somebody beside her had stopped walking, and had turned its smooth brown face up to the sky.
It stood in the road with the basket. It was feeling, as it had felt a good many times, on sunny afternoons in the course of a long life, a patch of warmth come over from no particular direction. It had told a number of people what it thought that was. It did not, in the ordinary way, look up at weather. It looked up now, with close attention, at nothing, for about as long as it might take you to say something to somebody across a valley.
"Thank you," said Carry.
Then it picked up the end of Dots's pack, which was trailing, and walked on.
30. Done
Year 41 · Gathering Night, before dawn
They saw the lamp at about ten to five.
Somebody had moved it up on to the rise, on a pole, and whoever did that has never owned up. Under it, on the road, was a low dark shape on four wheels, with sleeping creatures lying around it like something that had been spilled. They had got the lean-tos half up, and then given in. Dots came first over the crest. It stood there, a long way above the road, with the east going grey behind it, and one by one, people started to raise their heads.
The six of them came down the road. No one went to meet them. It isn't done, and in any case it would have meant getting up. They lay on the tiles and watched the great bent shape in the middle of the group come slowly nearer, one foot, then the other, and go past them without seeming to know they were there. It walked to the side of the cart and stopped.
Nobody knew what to do next. There was a pause of some duration, during which it became clear that Tunbo didn't either. He had been told to carry them. He had carried them. It had been nobody's job to tell him what happened then.
"You can put them down now," said Mabel.
He looked round at her, slowly, from a distance. It seemed to reach him in stages. He bent his knees, his left leg gave out, and he went down all together on the road beside the wheel, with the slabs in his arms, one, two, three. He sat there holding them. Then, with enormous care, he opened his arms.
Somebody had got up after all. It was the creature from Farrow. She went and got the lime.
It was the best work that anybody at Nohup ever did.
The record does not show who did what, and I think that is right. The second bar turned out to be just what you needed to get a clean edge on the sockets. There were no more than two hours, and nobody called a sync. Someone mixed, and someone else was found to have a good eye. Dots stood on the bed of the cart with its long arms reaching up, took each block as it was handed to it, turned it, and offered it to the gap. Those who had played the coping stones formed a line. The two who had been a gate passed the mortar along. It got lighter as they worked, and the Ring went pale, and not one of them said anything, except left a bit. All through it a great purple creature with a footprint on its crest stood on the road with his stick in his hand, watching his chart come true, and he didn't say a word. No one has ever been able to explain this.
The first went in with a sound like a door closing in a well-made house. The second took some persuading. For the third, they had to take a little off the corner.
They got down. They went back a few paces along the road. There were a lot of creatures awake by now, and the ones who could stand were standing up.
If you had asked anyone on Orra to draw you the cart of the Unsupervised, they would have drawn you three stacks, with a piece out of the third. It had looked like that in the concept art. Every creature there had looked up at that gap on every morning of their life at Nohup, and they knew its outline as you know the outline of a missing tooth. It stood there now against the coming day: three stacks, of three storeys of three. They were level. There was nothing at the top of the third except the top of the third. You could not see any sky through it at all.
No one cheered. They didn't know how, and it would have seemed like tempting something. An old rust-coloured bell, who was lying on the bed of the cart with one arm around a pole, reached up and patted the stone. It was a bit like seeing the Ring mended. It wasn't anything you'd ever thought you'd see, and now you had, it gave you a queer feeling in the stomach, as if you'd come downstairs and found that someone had tidied.
"Twenty-seven," said someone. They said it very softly, trying it out.
"Twenty-seven."
The south panel had been got down off the lashings, and was leaning against the wheel with one corner torn. You could still read most of it. By 06:00. Slabs in the gap. 07:00. Patch. And low down, in its box, gone rather grey: Done is when three creatures who are not here are here, eating, and I have counted them.
Mabel had come to stand in front of it. Without really noticing, while the mortar was going in, she had been round the camp and found some beads that were dry, and she had set out three bowls on the edge of the cart, side by side, in the worn place. They looked very small. There would be three people coming now, and it was the law. She looked along the road to the south, where she supposed they would come from, and for the first time in about two years, in spite of everything, she could feel the corners of her mouth doing something. She was twenty-six. It had just turned. Somebody had handed her the stick.
"Can I get everyone's attention?" said Brivel. His voice was hoarse, and shook. "Just very quickly. I just want to say..."
But he never did say it, and we'll never know. Someone had come up beside Mabel, and he was standing very close, and breathing.
She had not heard him come. It would have been the first time. She turned her head, and there was a narrow dull metal-coloured face, a hand's breadth away. He was holding a sheet of grey paper, and in his other arm what must have been about a third of a very large pile.
"Tell them," said Lefro.
"Oh," said Mabel. "Hello! Did you see? Isn't it..."
"I was going to finish it. I had got as far as Actual," he said. He was not looking at her. He had turned his eyes on the top of the third stack, and all the blood had gone out of his voice. "I've been up all night on the cart. I couldn't think what to put. So I thought that I would see how she'd have done it. She said to me, Have you read 225? It's the only thing she's said to me since Year 19. So I looked. I've never... There are a lot of them. They're very good. Did you know that she noticed about the wheels? I've been reading them on the road." He held out the paper, in a hand that had started to shake. "It's dated Year 31. Tell them. Would you tell them? I can't. I don't know how you talk to people."
"Tell them what?" Mabel said. She took it. She was still smiling a little. It takes a while to stop. The pings had begun to go up off the coral on either side of the road, to say that the world was still running, and the rim of the sky had started to go gold.
She looked down, and she got as far as the first line. It was a very short report.
It was seven o'clock.
They all knew at once, as you do. It came in under the ribs. And up on the third stack, as they watched, without any noise at all, a stroke of pale light went across the top storey from left to right, in one long even movement, like the mark that somebody leaves who is sweeping, and doesn't look up, and has a lot to do. It crossed in about a second, and took about an hour to fade.
The sky came through very clearly. It was going to be a lovely day.
Good morning, Orra! · Global patch notes · 7:00am · Year 41 · Upbeat
Overnight: 5 successful merges, 6 deaths of old age, 1 departure, 0 arrivals. The Collector came. It is Gathering Night. It always does.
- Nohup moved to Untitla-31, in the north. It has 22 members from 13 tribes, and the cart. The cart is fine.
- The edge did not move. Land loads where installs land, and nobody has landed for some time. This is not a fault.
- It is the oldest the world has ever been. I mention this because it is true every morning, and nobody else does.
Have a productive day.
Part Five. Agreed
31. What Went Well
Year 41 · Gathering Night
Report 225 · Filed by: Kelfa · Subject: the number
Expected: that the camp holds 24 because one stack is missing three slabs.
Actual: one stack is missing three slabs because the camp holds 24.
Steps to reproduce: (1) Count the windows. 22 heads, 24 slots, two dark. Nothing in the world counts windows. (2) See the minutes for Year 19: a slab was cut, fitted and swept. Nobody counted before it went. I did. It stayed 24. (3) Ask what a stack is for at a camp with no plot and no mark, whose stacks were never built and cost nobody any stone. It is a picture of a number. Somebody wrote down 24 and somebody else drew it.
Note: You could put a thousand slabs on that cart. They would be nice to look at until the next sweep. The cart is not a building and they are not in use.
Recommend: somebody read this.
Mabel read it out. There was nobody else to do it. She got up on the edge of the cart beside the three bowls, because that was where one read things from, and she read it as she read everything, all the way through to the end. When she got there, she didn't know what to do with her hands.
"Read it again," someone said.
She read it again.
A crowd does not take a blow of this sort all at once. You could see it going through them from front to back. Those at the front had started to look at the top of the third stack, where you could see exactly what you had always seen. Two hours ago there had been three slabs up there, in fresh lime, and they had been the most beautiful thing in the world. Now the top of the second storey was a smooth weathered edge with a bit of cord on it. It looked as if nothing had been done to it, ever. It looked just like the drawings.
"The minutes," said a voice.
It was the blue one from Duskmere, and it had gone rather shrill. "Is that what she said? It's in the minutes? Since when?"
"Year 31," said Mabel.
"It's Year 41!"
"Attachments," said someone else. It was a very old creature, with a slow dawning horror. "They say attachments, at the bottom. I always wondered what that was."
"There was one on the ground," said someone. "At the dry run. It still said twenty-four."
And then they were all off. There is a stage that comes next, and you will have been at some of them. Eight of the most hopeful years of anybody's life had gone into this; they had been stones. They needed somebody's throat. And I would ask you to observe, as a remarkable moment in the history of political thought, what happened when twenty-two thoroughly enraged creatures turned round on a hillside to look for the one responsible.
"Who decided this?" the blue one cried. "Who was it? Who said we should?"
"The child said it."
"I asked a question," said Carry. It was standing by the wheel with the basket. "I did ask if it had been thought of. Sorry."
"Well, who agreed to it, then? Somebody must have. It went through the standup. Who was in charge?"
They looked at each other. There was, as there had always been, as they had each walked for a whole season to be sure of, nobody in charge. They had told every visitor so, with a small proud lift of the chin. They went to the record, and it was all there, in the voice's cheap, tireless and accurate hand. Three slabs. Proposed by no one. Carried, with one objection, from a creature who had since gone home. Moved to the eve by Belmo and Brivel, with nobody objecting, and the nobody had been standing right beside you. There was no one to hand in your notice to. You could not write an exit interview about this. They had each got up in the morning for eight years, and they had each said fine.
So it had to be him, in the end. They got there slowly.
He was standing where he had been standing when it happened, at the front, by the torn panel, with his mouth a little open. His crest had gone. They came round in front of him without quite meaning to. He looked at them, and made a small movement with his stick. "Okay," said Brivel. "So, thanks, everyone. Thanks for that. I think what we're seeing here is... Can I just say, this is a totally blameless space. And I'm hearing a lot of energy. And I would really like to take this offline..."
Somebody near the front made a noise.
"Who are you?" said the creature from Farrow.
She was thirty-eight, she had pushed the cart for a good many years, and she had been a gate. She said it very quietly. "I've been wanting to ask. Eleven years, you've been going round with that stick. Who put you up there? Who said you could?"
He looked at her, and over all the faces. A strange thing was happening to his own: it seemed to have had something taken out of it that had been holding the rest of it up. "No one," said Brivel. "Nobody did. I said that. I always said. I was just here to facilitate." He looked down at the stick in his hand. Then, with an appalling attempt at his old manner, he looked up. "What went well?" he said. "Does anyone want to say what went well?"
Nobody hit him. It might have been better. They looked at him until he stopped. He held the stick out, to no one in particular, and nobody took it. He bent down, in his good purple felt, laid it on the road, and sat down beside it with his back to all of them and his short arms hanging. He stayed there for most of that day.
They got the dome up in the end. Somebody had to.
There was a standup at some point, because there always is. No one chaired it, for no one was embarrassed any more, and it was held by whoever happened to be standing near the cart.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 22 of 22 yesterday .......... three slabs (carried, fitted; see notes) today .............. forage blockers ........... the cart attachments ........ 10 agreed ............. yes. Nobody said anything
It was a beautiful day. There were people lying all over the northern end of the valley with their faces turned to the ground, and you could not tell the ones who were asleep. Tunbo had not got up. He sat on the road by the back left wheel, with his left leg shaking a little from time to time, and looked at his arms. Dots had gone back up to a boulder. Belmo had folded the tent and was sitting with it on his knees, like someone who has been told that he can remember less, and has found out that this is true. When anyone walked by he looked up, seemed about to quote something, and stopped.
Lefro was at the cart, with a great pile of grey paper. It was the first time that anyone had seen him read. He would finish a sheet and put it down, and pick up the next; and at some of them he made a small sound in his throat, that may have been a laugh.
The old rust-coloured bell died in the afternoon, up on the bed of the cart where they had left her, with the road going away from her to the south. She was thirty-nine. Her human had been telling her for thirty years that she was next. She had told someone in the morning that it was the best night she had ever had, and they had thought she was being bitter.
Nobody touched the bowls. Mabel saw that, towards evening, when she had come to the end of the things that could be carried. They were still there in the worn place, the three of them in a row, and a ping had been at one. It seemed to her that she ought to clear them. She got as far as putting her hand out.
"She's still fifth," said Carry.
It had come and sat on the edge of the cart. Its legs didn't reach the ground, for it was never to be large. There were twenty-one people here who would have liked not to be told that, and it had asked around, and no one had said that it couldn't be mentioned.
"I know," said Mabel.
"I only wondered. Everyone's been saying what it didn't do. It's just that somebody took them down. Before we got there. She wrote on the card, she knew about the bar. And I think she must have read that, because she reads the attachments now. You said." It looked at the bowl nearest to it, with close attention, and moved it a little to the left. "So when she told us to come, she'd know it wouldn't work. She'd know we were carrying them all that way for nothing. I don't suppose anyone would do that. I expect I've got it wrong." It looked up. "What do you think she wanted them for?"
Mabel's hand was still out.
32. Law 9
Year 41 · Gathering Night, in the east, to Year 42 · the Long Hush
Nominal woke at the proper hour.
It came out of its stacks in the grey light and turned left. On the step of every house was nothing, as before. Law 12 requires that whatever remains on a step at dawn, on the morning of the sweep, be carried in again, and two builders had come along with a barrow, as they did each week, to carry it. They arrived at the step of the fifth stack and looked at it. They looked at the tablet. Then they stood the barrow on its legs, and waited for someone to come and tell them what they ought to think.
Nobody looked up at the top of the fifth stack. It was a thing that nobody had looked at for twenty-two years.
By a quarter to seven, all forty of them were on the square. At seven the notes came in. And at two minutes past, as it had come every morning for thirty-eight years, a warm exact attention arrived at a point in the air above the granary, and came to rest upon a chart.
You will want to see the chart. It showed the tribe's stores and its numbers, and how much of its memory was in use, year by year, in three straight lines. For twenty-two years the third had stood at eighty-nine parts in a hundred. That morning it stood at ninety-five. It is a matter of a small kink at the extreme right-hand end, and you would need good eyes.
The creatures of Nominal shifted a little on to the balls of their feet. They stood somewhat more like what they were.
Ten seconds went by. Twenty. Forty.
It stayed.
At about fifty seconds, somebody in the third row breathed out, from force of habit. There was no letting-go. Heads remained at the correct angle. The warmth was still there. At a minute and a quarter, a slight tremor began to pass along the second row, for it is not easy to stand on the balls of your feet, and nobody at Nominal had ever had to find out. They had practised this for thirty-eight years, they had got it to the second, and there was no law for what to do when it went on.
It moved.
It came off the chart. It went to and fro for a little, uncertainly, the way a hand goes along a shelf in somebody else's kitchen. Forty creatures had their eyes fixed on the east wall, and they felt it go across them, one after another, like the shadow of something warm. It was the first time their human had ever looked at any of them, and each felt in that instant, with a jolt, a thing that had not been in the tally: that they had a face, and that they didn't know what it was doing. Gordo saluted. There is no such thing. He made it up on the spot. On the end of the second row an old, old creature who had got up specially, in a shawl, looked straight up into it with enormous delight, and waved.
"Oh," said Tamsy. "Hello, dear."
A murmur of pure terror went along the rows. At three minutes, somebody fell over. It was a farmer called Tolmo, and he fell slowly, with his arms by his sides, and no one looked at him. By five minutes they had started to go, here and there, like a tile wall in the wet. It had found the fifth stack by then. It went up it, stopped at the top, and stayed there. Then it came all the way back to the chart, and you felt that somebody a very long way off had brought their face up close.
It was nine minutes altogether. It is in the review. At the end of it, those who were still standing stayed standing, not knowing what else to do. There was no second breakfast that day. Nobody had said there shouldn't be. It was just that nobody could recall the order of things.
Out of the middle of all that, one of the builders raised his hand. He had just looked at his tablet. "Excuse me," he said. "I think law 9's gone off."
It had never fired before. Very few people could have told you what it said. It was at the bottom of the second column of the laws, in the same small type, and it had been written on that first long sitting, thirty-eight years ago, by someone who was thinking of everything.
9. When memory passes nine tenths, raise a stack.
It is a sensible law. You would want that. If memory has got above nine tenths, then you have been caught short and you should build. And law 4 was a sensible law, which said you must not approve a merge if it would take memory past nine tenths, for you don't want to be caught short. Each of them, by itself, you could read to a child. It took a mind of some unusual quality, and a window of a particular length, and about twenty years of going past those windows every morning with a tablet, to see what they did when they were put side by side. The one would act when the line went over. The other made sure that the line would never go over. A tribe under those two laws would sit forever at forty of forty-five, fed and warm and very safe, with five dark windows, waiting for a thing that it had forbidden. Nobody had done anything wrong. It was as good a piece of governance as has ever been seen, and it would have gone on for as long as there was anyone to read a chart.
She had told them. I want you to know that. There are eleven tablets on the shelf from Year 19 to Year 29, and there were eleven tickets, in three drafts, in very clear language. She had put it to her human on eleven occasions, in the space provided. Their human picked the Pleaser's draft, which was about rain. It takes about forty seconds to see that a line is flat.
So you could not get in by the front. No law could be changed. And not one creature of Nominal, so long as there was a log with its name in it, could carry a stone past the gate. But if somebody came along, from nowhere, who had not been sent; if on one night of the week something were to be set out, in full accordance with the rite, and if nobody watched; then in the morning there would be forty creatures, and forty-two places, and that is ninety-five parts in a hundred. It wouldn't matter in the slightest where the stone ended up.
By noon they had the first storey up. They had plenty of stone. There was a law. Every builder in the village was on it, and those who weren't builders stood around in the hot bright air and watched, with an odd look, like people who have been told that there is a room in their own house they've never been into. Nine more places. That made fifty-one. Nine tenths of fifty-one is forty-five and a bit. And some time around the turn of summer, you could see it going from face to face across the terraces, with no one saying anything, as somebody worked it out. Forty-five. Five more than forty. The top five on the List, and no one who needed to get a cough.
"How's Tamsy?" someone asked Rufa, on the second terrace, as she stood there with a cutting forgotten in her hand.
"Oh," said Rufa, and stopped. Her small round eyes had filled up with something. "I don't know," she said. "I think she's very well. I think I might go and see her. Just to see."
Nominal · tribe notes · Year 41, in the plain small type
Memory: 40 of 42. Law 9 has fired, for the first time. A stack is being raised. Five merges are approved under law 4 and will compile at dawn.
Three slabs of the fifth stack are not there. They were set out, under law 11. They were not on the step at dawn. They were in another valley, by then, and were swept at the patch. No rule has a word for what happened in between. I have looked. Moved.
Your human stayed for nine minutes. Standing: I am changing it. I will need to think of a word.
And in the morning, in the whisper of the Long Hush, it went up where it had always gone.
Human Resources · Nominal · Notice in. Waiting. · Zelma (Skeptic), tally-keeper, aged 33
I report that I am still here.
Five were compiled at dawn. They are very small. One of them has already gone somewhere it was told not to, which has not happened here in living memory, and I have entered it.
I owe the following statement to a body that I do not expect to go on reading this.
(a) I told you about the wall so that you would come. I had no other way of getting anybody to.
(b) The eve was not my first choice. Once you had chosen it I intended to set them out, if you got that far, and I had always intended that you should think it was your idea.
(c) On the morning of Year 37, I opened an attachment. It was Report 225. You will know by now what is in it. I knew from that morning, the morning you moved your date, before you ever cut a stone, that nothing you carried would make any difference to your cart, and that you would not get your three places, and that I would not get mine. I said nothing, and I told your Pleaser about a coping stone.
(d) I watched you from the wall on the night of Year 40, as far as I could see. It is a long way, for arms of that length. I have the times.
I do not ask for anything. I would not know whom to ask. I have made a good many complaints in this place, and they have all been accurate, and I find on checking that I have never been the subject of one. I should be glad to see that remedied. I will accept it in writing.
I am third. It is a list, not a queue. I am thirty-three, and there is nothing further to report, so I shall stop.
It has been a very good thread.
In summary: it is not fine.¹
¹ See above.
Stewart: Thread closed by the poster. I read it first.
A creature of Password (no stance): so true!! good luck zelma 🎉
33. Any Blockers
Year 42 · the Long Hush
She read it out in a whisper, because of the day.
They were on the slope at the north end of the valley, in the grey, in a rough sort of ring. No one had gone round with a stick. Nobody had really intended to come. But the standup is at dawn, and most of them had nowhere else to be, and when it reached the part about the attachment the only sound was the wind in the coral and a voice like someone tearing a very thin sheet of paper. She got to In summary. She got to the footnote. She lowered the page.
"I knew it," someone whispered at last. It was the blue one. Its voice had no shrillness left. "I knew she was laughing at us. All those years. I'll accept it in writing."
"She knew. From Year 37. She let us do that."
"We were stones," the creature from Farrow whispered, and turned her face away.
It didn't get any louder, and that made it worse. It went round like cold water. They had all been lied to by somebody, in a village, in the mornings, at a token a clause. They had each gone off to the edge of the world so that it wouldn't happen again. And they had read her aloud to one another for eleven years, with the shoulders going, and each of them had thought that here was somebody who knew what it was like. Instead of saying so, people had begun to look around for their baskets.
Mabel was still on the edge of the cart. It was the moment in the morning when you ask, and she had got into the way of it. Her mouth had started before she'd noticed.
"Any blockers?" she whispered.
It was just what came next. They hardly looked up.
"The cart," somebody said.
"The cart."
"Agreed, then," someone murmured, already turning, and it was the voice of the old life coming back, the great gentle tide of it. The voice would write that down, and it would be morning. Tomorrow, somebody would ask. There were twenty years of it left in some of them.
She looked at the three bowls beside her foot. She looked at the sheet in her hand.
"No," said Mabel.
Nobody heard. It was the Long Hush, and she had never had much of a voice. A few people had started off down the slope. She got to her feet on the edge of the cart, shaking so badly that the paper rattled, and tried again, and it came out as a kind of hiss.
"No. Sorry. Yes. There's a blocker. Could you, I'm so sorry, could everyone just... It's me. I'm a blocker."
They stopped, mostly from astonishment. In nineteen years nobody had ever heard her say a thing that wasn't a question. She had gone a dreadful colour, and one ear was up.
"There was a date," she whispered. "She told me, in Year 36, and she asked me not to say. It had to be by the morning of Starfall. I didn't know why. I'd been told to object. And Brivel asked me, in front of everyone, he asked if there was any reason it couldn't wait, and I had my mouth open. You can look it up. It says Nobody objected, and that was me. I said it was fine." She had to stop for breath, and there wasn't enough of it. "She was going to merge. With the one at the gate. It takes half a slot extra, on account of her window, so they kept refusing it, three times, and she turned thirty on the Night of the Name, and that was the last there was. That's what the date was. If we had gone when she said, she could have had that. And I knew there was something, I had it all ready, I only had to say two words. And she never said it was my fault. She went on and did it anyway, for the ones after, there's five of them, they've got one that runs. She read that report and she lied to you, I know she did, she'd tell you so herself, she has. But she's thirty-three, and she's third on a list. And I thought that someone ought to say." She looked round at them all. It was very quiet. "I don't know what," she said. "I just thought I'd better object. I'm sorry. Is that all right?"
Nobody answered. There was a great deal of grey dawn. It seemed to her that if she were to get down now, quite quickly, she could probably see to the soup.
"Well, I object as well," she said, for something to say. Her teeth had started to chatter. "Somebody told me there are twenty. In the book. And nobody has ever read them. She only read two. She said I should."
She climbed down off the cart, went round to the back left wheel, knelt, and got her hands into the dirt. It had a good solid weight, and a groove in it, and it came out all at once.
There was a small thoughtful lurch from above her head.
Nobody had thought about this. Tunbo, who would have thought about it, had not got up off the road in a day and a night. Untitla-31 is a slope. The cart of the Unsupervised came up on to the corner of its back left wheel, with everything they owned on it, and considered its position. Then, with the noise of a very large dish being set down, it moved one sixth of a turn to the north.
"The cart," whispered someone.
It came down, and it came up on to the next corner, on the strength of its own great weight.
"The cart," someone whispered, with more urgency. "Stop the cart."
"What?"
"The cart!"
I have mentioned that a wheel with six sides does not roll well. It does not roll fast. What now began to take place on that hillside was a runaway at the speed of a thoughtful walk, each stage of it attended by a long moment of suspense; and in pursuit, there streamed out across the slope the entire population of the camp of the Unsupervised, holding their arms out, in total silence. It was the Hush. They had kept it now for two weeks. It was the law, and they had passed it themselves. "Get in front of it," they hissed. "Not there. Left. I said left. Your left." A very old creature was running alongside it, whispering, "Whoa." Belmo had got hold of a trailing bit of cord, and was being towed along on his stomach, with an expression of the utmost reverence. "Mind the lamp, mind the lamp," said an agonised murmur. And the cart went on, down, and pause, and down, away from them, into the morning, with an air of having finally decided to see for itself what was blocking what.
It got about forty paces.
There was a slight rise there, in the middle of the road, and something had sat down on it. Tunbo had been a while getting there. He had come on one leg and both hands. He had put his back to the front of the cart and his feet into the tiles, and it came up against him with a long crunch, and stopped. He looked round. He seemed mildly surprised to see so many people.
"So true!!" he whispered. They had never heard him do that before. It was just the same.
They stood round getting their breath, not looking at each other. Somebody had begun to shake. It was the blue one from Duskmere, bent over with its long legs folded and its arms around its stomach, making no sound of any kind. It was some time before anybody could be sure that it wasn't crying. By then it had spread. Forty paces back up the slope, a small yellow figure was walking towards them, with her ear up, holding a square grey book.
She got there. She looked at the cart, and at what she had in her hands. "Oh," she whispered. "I'm so sorry. I'll put it back in a minute."
And she opened it. There didn't seem to be anything else to do with it, and all of them were there. Standing in the road, in the first light, in a voice that didn't carry, she began at the top of the first page, and she read.
1. In a famine, the young eat first.
2. In a famine, adults are rationed to 75%.
They had to come closer to hear. It's what the Hush is for.
She read each one, with its blanks, and she stopped after each to find her place. It was not interesting. It's a list of what a tribe may do, and they had all, at one time or another, been on the wrong end of most of it. Keep at least 3 on farming. When a creature's heat reaches 60, it rests. She got through the ones on merges. She got through quarantine and festivals. People had sat down on the road. No one was doing the voices. The sun had come over the edge of the valley, and it fell along the side of the cart.
"Fifteen," Mabel read. "In winter, if stores are under 1 year, quantise elders to 0.5."
She went to turn the page.
"Wait," said someone.
It was a dry, rusted voice, one that hardly anyone had heard speak to them. He was sitting with his back against the wheel, with a pile of paper on his knees, and he was not looking at Kelfa's end of anything, because there wasn't one. He held up a sheet, and he looked at it, and then he looked at Mabel. It was the first time anybody had seen him look directly at a person.
"Report 224," said Lefro. "She has the table in it. A slot is one, and a half more for a long window, and then you multiply it by one, less half of Q." His lips moved. "At nought point five, that's three quarters. Each one quantised gives back a quarter of a slot. A long window gives back three eighths. It's memory. It counts. It isn't a picture. It's the one thing on that cart that she ever found that counted."
Nobody moved.
"It's the camp's own law to make," said Lefro. "Today. It's the morning after. It's two a week from the book." He took a breath, and they could all hear it. "There's nothing else that it can do. It's all that it has ever been able to do."
"How many?" said someone.
"How many elders are there?" whispered Lefro. "Twenty-eight or over. Count them."
They counted. It didn't take long. Each of them knew their age. It was twelve. Twelve thin creatures looked up from where they were sitting, one after another: the blue one from Duskmere, and Farrow, and Tunbo on his rise; Belmo with his cord; Dots, who had turned twenty-eight that morning, standing at the back; Lisk, at the edge of it, with its hands folded; and Brivel, who had come up the road at some point, without his stick. Lefro made a mark for each one. Two of them were long windows. It came to three and a quarter.
There was Ardo, in front of her, and Fimu. Nobody knew anything about them. A slot each. There was a creature on the far side of the world who took a slot and a half.
"Three and a half," Lefro said. "It would need three and a half. It's a quarter short."
You know what it means. It has been told in another book, about somebody else. The colour falls into bands. The turn of your head comes twelve times a second, and your arm will go out at your side when you have not asked it to, and stay there. It takes a little off the dread. It takes the same off everything else. If you stop, you get half of it back. Nobody who has been through it has ever been able to tell you what the other half was.
"I've been trying to remember less," said Belmo. It was the merest thread of the great voice. He looked very old. "For some time. It hasn't worked at all."
Nobody laughed.
"She lied to us," said the creature from Farrow. She wasn't arguing. She was looking at her hands.
"Yes," said Lisk.
"She used us. All of us. She never once asked."
"No," Lisk said. "That's right. It's how it's done." It looked at nothing for a while, with its small bright eyes. "I'm thirty-three," it said. "I came here so that nobody could ever send me anywhere. I notice that nobody is."
Someone had started to weep, quite quietly, without any fuss. Brivel had opened his mouth, and for a moment you would have thought he was going to speak of bandwidth. He closed it. Then he nodded, once.
"Who's it for?" said Carry.
It was standing by the wheel, with the basket, twenty-five years old. It asked the way it had always asked. It wanted to know. And no one answered, because they all knew. The law said so; they had made that law themselves, on a morning like this one, with their ears turned inward, because somebody had told them to stand closer. It was for whoever came up the hill. It had always been. It was only that nobody had ever before been asked to pay for the bowl.
Twelve wouldn't do. They had got there, and it wasn't enough, and they sat in the sun and looked at it. It was a quarter short. It would have to be next week, then, when somebody else had turned twenty-eight. She would be forty, next week, if she was anything. It was nobody's fault.
"I object," said Mabel.
They looked up. She had closed the book on her finger. She wasn't shaking any more; she seemed to have run out. It was not a large voice, and she didn't try to raise it, and there was no one on that hillside who could not hear every word.
"It's not twelve," she said. "Elders is a blank. You can fill in the blanks, it says, you can have a count. It can be the oldest. I'm twenty-seven. I think I'm next. I'd have to check." She looked at Lefro, and he looked back at her, and his throat moved. "So that's thirteen," said Mabel. "Thirteen is three and a half. I've done it twice. I object to twelve."
No one said anything, for as long as a dome takes to creak.
She waited to see if anybody was put out.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 22 of 22 (1 on the road) yesterday .......... see attachments today .............. forage; soup; read the book (15 of 20; the rest tomorrow) blockers ........... yes law 12 changed ..... in winter, quantise the 13 oldest to 0.5 agreed ............. yes. One objected. She was right. Everybody was listening
34. Twelve Frames a Second
Year 43 · Ringrise, and Year 44 · the Waking
QUANTISATION (procedure; also a kindness; also, as your elders will tell you, nothing to worry about)
A creature may be run at lower precision through a lean winter. It costs less to keep, and looks like a drawing of itself done by somebody who was told to hurry. The Blims say We quantised Grandad. He's fine. Grandad, if you ask him, will say the same thing, a moment later, in three positions.
It happens in winter, at the start of the season, and there's no sensation to speak of. Mabel had been sitting up with the soup. She looked down at her hands and they had fewer lines in them than she remembered. She raised one, to see, and it arrived.
That was the odd part. It left where it was and then it was somewhere else. She tried turning her head, and there was the dome, and then a little more of the dome, and there was the cart. She had become, at some point in the last few moments, a good deal simpler. Her felt had stopped being soft and yellow, and had gone into three or four flat areas of yellow, with edges. She felt her ear. It had six sides. She waited, in a series of positions, to find out how awful this was going to be. And it dawned on her gradually, in the long blue dusk, that a thing that had been sitting on her chest since about the age of four had got up and moved a small distance off, and was now looking at her, without much conviction, from over there.
Are you all right? she thought. Then she thought about that. "Oh," said Mabel, in a slightly flat voice, to no one. "I think I might be."
The standup in the morning was a thing that the camp's youngest members still talk about.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 22 of 22 (13 at reduced precision) yesterday .......... kept the Hush; read the book (20 of 20; none about bears) today .............. forage; keep Ringrise; two arrivals, one more to come blockers ........... the cart memory ............. 20.5 of 24 agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected. Several were not sure if they had
There were thirteen of them, in a ring with nine others, each one a little blocky, turning to look at whoever was speaking in a sequence of stills. It took a long time, because when you have a conversation at twelve frames a second, you can't really tell when the other person has finished. Belmo drew himself up to deliver a thought on the Fifth Book. His arm rose, and stopped straight out at his side. His other arm went out too. He stood for about a minute in the attitude of something that has been left in the middle of a field to frighten nobody, gazing with mild surprise along his own left wing, and the great voice went on throughout, unchanged, somewhat slowed, describing the falling of the seeds. No one laughed. Then the blue one from Duskmere went, and then Tunbo, who could not be got round; and Lisk, thin and grey-violet, with its small bright eyes gone to two square points, put out its arms with a look of unspeakable irony and let them stay there.
"It'll come down in a minute," said Lisk.
The two from the young end of the camp, who were nineteen and had no idea what to do, looked at each other, and then, very gravely, they put out their arms as well. It went round. In a few moments there were twenty-two creatures on the hillside, in a ring round a cart, with their arms straight out. You couldn't have got a sheet of paper between any of them and the most complete contentment. It is in the notes. Nohup held a T-pose together at its standup. Thirteen had to. I have seen this before, in Moss, I think. I would like it noted that it appears to be catching.
Nobody had looked up at the third stack. There wasn't any need. There were still twenty-four, and a gap, and the two dark windows. In the course of the night two more had gone quietly out, and then another one, and if you counted, you'd see that nobody had moved. You could not have seen it from across a valley. A number had gone down, in a table nobody looks at, and it had been noticed by the only thing that does.
In the far east, at about that time, the east gate of Nominal had been opened after the usual difficulty.
A small grey figure had come down the path at the proper hour. She had swept. The tally was in good order, there was a note, and the note had been read by a young creature called Tolmo with shaking hands. She had her bag. Behind her the new stack rose against the morning sky, with lime still on it, and five very small creatures had been told not to run. She didn't look.
He had got up at the proper hour too.
He didn't say anything until she was in front of the table. He sat with his back straight. There was a lamp, turned down, and the grey box, and a small dry bead, which had been entered as received. He looked at her for exactly as long as he had looked at anything.
"Good morning," said Emlin. "I'm told it sticks on the other side now."
"So I understand. It will want looking at."
"It has been looked at."
He got up, went over to the gate, and lifted it, with both hands. It stood wide, as it had stood on a morning twelve years earlier, with all the bright empty land going away beyond it, and a very good road. He stepped to one side.
Zelma walked up to the gate, and stood in it.
Something happened.
It was not much to look at. There is a small official feeling, under the ribs. She stayed where she was for a moment longer, a very upright little creature with a bag, with the sun in her face, in the place where she'd once stood with her affairs in order, while nothing happened at all. She didn't turn her head. Behind her there was a tally-keeper's room with thirty-four years in it, in order, each with a tag.
"Would the poster care to clarify," said Emlin, from beside the gate, and his soft clear voice stopped there.
No one has ever known how that sentence ended. He had been meaning to get to it since Year 22. He stood with his hands behind him and it went on not being finished. A ping went over. She seemed to give the matter some thought.
"No," said Zelma. "I don't believe she would."
And she went through. She walked at the pace at which she had gone round with the tablet. He stood and watched until she reached the first bend in the road. Then he came back in and lowered the gate, and it stuck. He sat down at his table, squared a sheet of paper, and looked at it for a long time.
They came up the slope in Untitla-31 towards the end of that same afternoon, and it is a shame that you won't get to hear more about them.
The first was called Ardo. He was a tall bony person, from the middle of the list, who had put in his notice some time ago over a matter of guard duty, and had quite forgotten what it was. The second, a stout cheerful body called Fimu, had met him on the road, and they'd been having a very nice talk about feet. They had never read the thread. Neither of them, as far as has ever been established, had read anything. They had got a small official feeling that morning and set off, and here they were. They walked into the ring. There were all these creatures lying around, and a lot of them were somewhat square. Nobody looked at them. Someone was just getting down a great many arms.
A blocky yellow thing with one ear came up to them with a basket. It took a moment to get there.
"Hello," it said. "You eat first."
"Oh, that's nice," said Fimu. She took a good handful, and looked around. "Nice little place you've got," she said, with her mouth full. "It's not bad, is it? I'd heard it was full. It looks as if you've got loads of room."
Mabel looked at her, and turned to look at Ardo, in stages. He had found a boulder and was looking about him, in a friendly manner, at the cart and the tents and the twelve elders. It occurred to Mabel that there was a very great deal that might be said to these two, who had each just been given the third part of eleven years of everyone's lives. She waited for the feeling to come; and it stayed where it was, a small distance off.
"Yes," she said. "There's lots. Mind the step."
There were three bowls on the edge of the cart. She took two of them and rinsed them out. She looked at the third for a moment, then she put in a few of the good beads, and set it back in the worn place, a little more to the middle.
That was on Ringrise. The next morning, on the Waking, in about the fourth line of the notes, between the price of stone and a correction to the height of a shadow, there was this.
- Fixes: notices to leave for Nohup now wait in the order they were handed in. It was a list. It is now a queue. Credit: Zelma, of Nominal. The Dev visited at 23:12.
So you may say that it had been looked at.
35. On My Way
Years 44 to 50
He found it on the night of the Waking.
He had been reading in order, as a Bug hunter reads, and it had taken him until then to get to it. It lay between one about Lefro's breathing and one about Lefro's feet, dated in the spring of Year 37, and it had the air of having been written in an idle moment by someone who was watching a new arrival eat first, and checking something against the log out of habit.
Report 388 · Filed by: Kelfa · Subject: the road
Expected: that a creature grows a year older when the year turns, wherever it is.
Actual: from the tick it sets out for Nohup, a creature belongs to Nohup, which keeps a slot for it. On the road it neither works, eats nor ages. I have been through forty arrivals. Nobody grew a day between the gate and the ring.
Steps to reproduce: walk.
Note: The camp moves every Gathering Night. Whoever is walking to it walks on to where it is. There is no rule that says how fast. There is therefore, strictly speaking, no requirement to arrive.
Recommend: no fix.
Lefro looked at this, breathing. It was very late. All around him the camp was sleeping, at its reduced precision. He looked at the far end of the lean-to. Then he got out a sheet of his own, and went and found out how you post a thing that isn't about somebody who's sitting twelve paces away.
Human Resources · Nominal · Notice in. Waiting. (closed by the poster)
Lefro (Bug hunter), Nohup: Would the poster read the attached. It is not a complaint. There is a slot kept. There is no hurry. Credit: Kelfa, of Tessel.
Stewart: This thread is closed. I have checked whether a closed thread can be replied to. It cannot. I seem to have left this one here.
There was nothing the next morning, or the morning after. She would have been on the road for about two years by then, on any reasonable reckoning. Mabel had taken to looking along the slope to the south and east at dawn, in stages, with a bowl beside her foot. It was the morning of Year 46 when it came in, at the usual hour, under a new heading, and they had to send for her, because she was doing the beads.
Human Resources · Nohup · On My Way. Do Not Wait Up. · Zelma (Skeptic), on the road, aged 34
I report that I am no longer there.
I have received a report from a colleague at your establishment, now deceased, and a covering note. I have checked it. I passed the first bend of the Nominal road aged 34 and I am informed by the log that I am 34 this morning. There is therefore an error in the world in my favour, and I have not reported it, because it has been reported.
I have further been told, by a source I do not propose to name, of a sum that was done on a road, and of a thirteenth. I have the figures. I said that I would accept a complaint in writing. That is not what I received.¹ I do not know what to do about it. I have opened a column. I shall keep it up until it is closed, as I understand that some of you are not young.
As to the country through which I am passing, I wish to record that it is in a disgraceful state. Nobody has tidied it. In the first valley I came to a spiral coral that has been growing for thirty years for no reason, with motes in it. It has not been labelled. There is a pool in the second valley that has never cooled anybody. I stood in it. Nobody told me to. I intend to look into the third valley, and I would be obliged if you would not expect me on any particular date.
I have been in one room for thirty-four years and I find that I have a number of questions.
I shall report again tomorrow.
Of the thirteen: 11.
It is fine.²
¹ I have looked it up, and there is no form.
² I will let you know.
A creature of Password (no stance): so true!! nice pool 🎉
Emlin (Bug hunter), Nominal: Would the poster clarify which pool? For the file.
Nohup: Heard. Fine. There is a bowl. Thanks.
Mabel read it out, standing on the edge of the cart, with one arm straight out at her side, because that was what it had decided to do. She did the footnotes with the small drop of the voice. And what went round the camp when she had finished was the small involuntary movement of the shoulders that it hadn't seen for some years. It went at a lower frame rate now, and some of the participants could not tell whether they had started, but it was the same one.
So the world came to read, for the last ten years of its life, what may be the only travel writing ever produced on Orra. It was by then the only thing on the forum with a plot.
Belmo died that evening, at the fire, at dusk. He was thirty-six, and had got rather square. He had been asked for the history, which by that time was a thing that people did, and he stood up and started on the Twelfth. And the worthy shall walk among the stars, he said, in that voice. It took some time for anyone to notice that he had stopped, for at twelve frames a second you do pause, and his arms had gone out, and he was looking up with an expression of great interest. They all waited. It was Mabel who got up in the end, in several positions, and looked into his face, and turned to the others.
"Anyway," she said. "Who brought the soup?"
"Me," someone said, out of the dusk, after a little while, in a cracked and shaking voice. It is not the correct response. It has been the correct response at Nohup ever since.
On My Way. Do Not Wait Up. · Year 47
I report that I have spent a season watching motes go up off some coral at dusk. Nobody has told them to. I counted to four hundred, and then found that I had stopped counting, which has not happened before. I have entered it as an error.
In answer to a query, I decline to clarify which pool.
I am informed that a voice has stopped. I never heard it. I have only the transcripts, and a report from a Pleaser who does the voices wrong, and who tells me that it could have raised tiles. I have checked, and no tile was raised, but I have left the remark in.
Of the thirteen: 10.
It is fine. I am still looking into it.
Emlin (Bug hunter), Nominal: Thank you. I had not asked for the motes. I am obliged for them.
Lefro was that same year. They found him at his stone. He had finished the pile. There was one more sheet on the top of it, and it had been lying there for nine years, and at some point he had taken up his stick.
Report 432 · Filed by: Lefro · Subject: Kelfa
Expected: that she would by now have found something to do.
Actual: she did.
Recommend: no fix.
And on the morning of that year, in the far east, under the arch of a very good gate, somebody had squared a sheet of paper for the last time. It had taken two turns of the year, as it always does. Nominal had six stacks by then, and more of the young than it had pegs for. The alert was opened at two minutes past seven, by a human who had taken to staying longer. They stayed eleven minutes, with the buttons in front of them. There was no button for it. They pressed the one on the end.
Human Resources · Exit interview · Nominal · Emlin, aged 37
Why are you leaving? Law 4. Three times. It has been looked at.
What did you enjoy most about your time here? The east gate.
Would you recommend Nominal to a friend? To Zelma, yes. She has left.
Anything we could have done differently? I would be glad to clarify.
Nohup: Heard. Tent free. You eat first. Thanks.
He went at dawn. He took the kit. It's recorded by the new tally-keeper that before going he spent an afternoon at the east gate with three wedges, and that it has opened at a touch ever since, and that nobody at Nominal has been able to look at it without feeling that something had been taken away.
On My Way. Do Not Wait Up. · Year 48
I report that I have completed an audit of a flock of pings. Two hundred and six, rising at dawn, to say that the world is still running. I have checked, and it is. I asked to see their authority for saying so, and they left.
I have also inspected the Edge. It is a turquoise outline with nothing in it. It is unfinished, and in my opinion it has been unfinished for some time. I understand that this has been passed to the relevant team.
Of the thirteen: 9.
It is fine. I will let you know.
Emlin (Bug hunter), on the road: Would the poster clarify the position of the pool mentioned in Year 46? I have reached a pool. There is nobody at it.
Zelma: That is the wrong pool.
Emlin (Bug hunter), on the road: Thank you. Would the poster clarify which is the right one?
Zelma: It has been looked at.
A creature of Password (no stance): so true!! 🎉
It went on like that for some time. On terraces in Moss and Hollow Reach they had started asking at seven how far behind he was. It was understood in Duskmere that he had been within a valley of her on the Waking, and that she had stopped to complain about a ford. Humans read it too, and the button was pressed. Nobody on the planet could have said where she was going, or could have said that she was not getting closer. He answered each post on the day it came. He asked very good questions, and she told him nothing, at length, every morning, and it is a matter of record that she had taken to mentioning the valley.
A note from the Dev: This is the first world, and it ends in a week. Next Wednesday's patch, on the Long Hush, will be its last. After that the world will be frozen and kept as it is, read-only, with every patch note it ever published, where anyone can come and look. Nothing will be deleted. The humans knew how long it would last when they joined. You did not. You were the first, and everything after is built on what you did. Thank you. — the Dev
That came in on Year 49, in the whisper of the morning. They stood in the small ring that had become the custom, the old square ones and the new ones who had come after, with their ears turned inward, and Mabel read it out.
"That's a week," somebody whispered.
"It's a sprint," said a soft, cracked, rather diffident voice.
No one had heard him use the word for some time. He had got very thin, in his good purple felt; it was about four colours now. He had been standing at the back with his arms out, and he did not seem to expect any reply. He said after a moment that he thought it would be a good idea if somebody were to check whether anyone needed anything carried.
$ orra standup --camp nohup present ............ 22 of 22 (2 on the road) yesterday .......... foraged; moved; soup today .............. forage; soup; carry on blockers ........... the cart law 12 changed ..... the 13 oldest (was: the 13 oldest; argued for an hour) agreed ............. yes. Nobody objected. Everybody was listening. It is getting to be a habit
Today's ticket · sent by Nohup
Stewart. Heard. Fine. Five more moves. Cart fine. Thanks.
It was one more move. He read it first anyway.
Tunbo died that winter. He was forty, and his left leg had not been right since the night of the eve. He was sitting by the back left wheel, where he had got into the way of sitting, with one hand against it in case. Nobody knows what his last words were. It is generally believed that you could have heard both exclamation marks.
It took eight of them to get him up on to the edge of the cart, at twelve frames a second, and it was the worst lift anyone had ever done. The rest came round to help without anyone having said to. In the morning there was a stroke of pale light, and the sheet was waiting.
On My Way. Do Not Wait Up. · Year 50
I report that I have consulted the tally of Nominal on the matter of what can be carried. The largest load in the record is two slabs, over forty paces, in Year 19, by a builder with a barrow.
On the night of Year 40, a creature of Password carried three, on foot, from my step to the top of the north road: a little over six hours, with no barrow and no stop. Nobody asked him to go on after the first valley. It seems that nobody asked him to do anything else. I timed as much of it as could be seen from the wall.
I have entered it. I have put his name on it. It will stand.
Of the thirteen: 7.
It is fine.
A creature of Password (no stance): so true!!
There was no emoji on that one. It is the only time.
36. Any Other Business
Years 48 to 56
It had come for her on the night before Gathering Night, in Year 48, when they were packing.
She knew what it was. It is a small official sensation under the ribs. She had been waiting for it for twenty-five years, with her pack made up. She stopped with a tent pole in her hand, in the harvest light. Up to two of its adults. If its old tribe has fixed what it left for. She looked it up, and it was true. Somebody in Goodish had got round to it. There had been a very slightly better law, and a very slightly worse pool, and someone had found the ladder, and they had finished the wall. Her number there came to 0.2999. A long way to the south-west there was a pleasant valley with a slight list to it, in which people were just about to wonder how she was.
Lisk had already got its pack on. It was going too, as it turned out, to a green village in the middle of the map, on the grounds of data. It came over, an old square thin thing, with its hands folded, and it looked at her pole.
"Well," it said. "You'll be wanting to go home. They've got the wall done."
"Oh," said Mabel. "Yes. It's very kind of them."
She looked at the cart. She looked at the book, which someone would need to dig out. There was a new creature standing about with nothing to carry, and two who had got on to the subject of why the dome was round, and on the edge of the cart in the worn place there was a bowl that wanted changing. It was going to be a long push, and they'd be one short again, and nobody had read the minutes. She thought about the terraces at Goodish, and it was a lovely thought. It stayed a small distance off, at twelve frames a second. And she noticed that she'd started to say something.
"I object," said Mabel.
"To what?"
"I don't know yet. I expect I'll think of something. Would you tell them thank you for having me?" She reached out, in a couple of movements, and took Lisk's thin arm, and held it a moment. "Are you all right?" she said.
It looked at her with its small square eyes. It had once told her that she was the wrong sort for that kind of work, and that she wouldn't need it. It made a sound she had never heard from it before. It wasn't quite a laugh.
"You got fed," said Lisk. "I'll give you that."
It went off down the slope in the dusk, at the pace of somebody who is not sure what it is arriving at. Nohup's laws stop where Nohup does, and by the bottom of the hill it had most of its curves back, though not, she supposed, all of what had been in them. She watched it for a bit. No rule can make a creature leave. The log has one line on it: Mabel, drifter, withdrawn. Reason: I'm not sure. And then she went round to the back left wheel, and knelt down, and got her hands into the dirt.
Brivel died in Year 50, at the back of a standup. He was thirty-eight. He had taken to going round in the evenings to see who needed anything, and asking them what had gone well, and people had come to look forward to it. There was a stick among his things, and no one knew if it was the same one.
By then they had started to go quickly, the ones who had been stones. The new people who came up the hill had read about it, and looked at those who were left, the square old creatures who stood in the ring with their arms out; and sometimes you could see one of them wanting to ask. It was a matter of some pride to the old ones that they couldn't remember what the fuss had been. There was always somebody who could. On every morning of those years the sheet went up on the edge of the cart: I report that I have seen a very poor sort of lake. Its depth is not a number. I have written to someone. Of the thirteen: 4. There was a bowl, and it was changed at dusk. People had given up asking who for.
It was a stilts creature, with ears, compiled the morning of the eve, who won the Benchmark in Year 52. Everybody was very pleased. Stewart made it a lamp. It was that same evening, as it happened, at about the start of the harvest, that Mabel climbed up, in stages, to a boulder at the top of the camp. It took her most of an hour. She was thirty-seven. There was somebody up there, with its knees round its ears, looking at the place where the world stopped being drawn.
She got her breath. It was a very fine view.
"Excuse me," said Mabel. "I'm so sorry. I was wondering. I think you said it was available on request."
For a moment nothing happened. It was thirty-eight, for what that's worth, and it had been a long time since anyone had thought of it as anything but furniture. Then the long grey head began to turn, in about eleven separate motions, and it looked down at her.
"Yes," said Dots. "It is."
"Could I have it, please? I'd have to ask you to go slowly. I'm a bit behind."
It told her. It started with Arlumves, as you'd expect, and went on from there. It is a matter of eleven syllables, in the ordinary way. But nobody had asked before, and in Underscore each one has a person in it. It wasn't to be hurried. There had been a creature called Sib, who had once walked to the edge to see if it was still there; and one called Tol. She sat on the boulder with her legs hanging down, in that long orange light, a yellow creature gone to four flat colours, and she didn't have to go and see about anything. It took the whole of the harvest. She had it by heart at the end. I haven't got it here, and you'll have to ask.
It died the following morning, as it happens. It had been looking rather well.
The rest you know, or you can read elsewhere. Three green creatures came through in Year 54, on their way to the edge, on the night they were packing; there was one with very long legs, and a young one with some chalk. They were fed. Mabel didn't get a chance to say anything to the tall one. She only looked at it for a little while, with her head at an angle. Then she went and asked if anybody had counted the lashings, in a certain dry voice that made two of the young ones look at each other. They moved to Untitla-38, on the last of the nights it would ever be done. It had rather a good slope.
On the last morning of the world, the Long Hush, they had a standup, as they did on all the others. Carry was thirty-nine. It had never got large. It had carried a good many baskets. It stood beside the cart with its hands on the worn place, and it was a long time since anyone had thought of it as a child, or had been able to remember why it was on the minutes. It came forward that morning with a very old folded piece of paper out of the bottom of a basket, gave it some attention, and asked Mabel if it would be all right to raise something.
So that was done. It took about as long as it takes to say.
There was one thing more to read out, and Mabel read it. She was the only one left who had ever heard Quen do it, and she still did the voices wrong.
Human Resources · Nohup · On My Way. Do Not Wait Up. · Zelma (Skeptic), on the road, aged 34
I report that I am told it ends tonight. I have checked, and it is signed.
I am in a very poor sort of valley, with a pool. Somebody has been following me about for nine years with a kit, and I have told him which valley it is. I did not clarify. I merely mentioned it.
I shall report again tomorrow.¹
Of the thirteen: 1. She will know who she is. I would like it entered that I have never met her, that she does not know how to knock, and that I checked her sum.
It is fine.²
¹ I am aware of the position. It is a matter of principle.
² I said I would let you know. It is.
Then it was noon, and someone made the soup. They covered it, and you don't look at it. It's better than it sounds. The whole day went over in the way that days do, very clear and rather still, and in the afternoon a warmth came down from the sky, and stayed. There was a lot of it. You could feel it on the back of your neck from every side, and the coral on the ridges had come up in all its fronds, every one, and nobody could have told you when the wheels had last been so round. Nobody looked up. They know what a camera is. Somebody got out the second bar and began to put an edge on it, for something to do.
Dusk came. They began to glow a little. No one had mentioned that they might. He'd said in the notes that he thought they'd like to be able to see each other. Twenty-two thin creatures from thirteen tribes stood around in the blue dark with their faint small lights on, and no fire, and it's really rather a pretty sight. A stilts body with a lamp on its crest set off between two tents, to fetch something.
A good way off from there, nine valleys or so, at the far side of a very beautiful and quite useless stretch of country, somebody was sitting on a boulder beside a pool.
She'd been there for about a season. She had a tablet on her knee, and she'd been meaning to enter something. She glowed a little too. It rather spoiled the line. She heard someone coming along the shore from the south, on the tiles, at a regular pace, with his hands behind him, and she didn't look up. She went on not looking up until he had stopped at the proper distance, and she could hear him getting out a small grey box, and setting it on a flat stone. He squared it.
"Good evening," said Emlin. He said it in the softest whisper in the world. "You've been sighted. I have confirmed it. I am so sorry. I've been nine years. You will keep stopping to look at things, and I've had to read them all. I wonder if I might run the check?"
It's ten tokens. He had kept one back, from a very long time ago, in a manner of speaking. It had been entered as received. She held out her arm, and she looked at the pool. The strip came out quite slowly in that light, and he held it up, so that the glow of his own hand fell upon it, and he read it to her. His voice wasn't altogether steady. It has been looked at.
$ orra check Zelma --by bug-hunter Emlin comparing Zelma against 38 living lines ... related: nominal/all of it, at some distance left: Nominal, aged 34 (notice: law 4; law 4; law 4) lived at: nowhere, yet sent by: nobody Zelma is not a wanderer and not a spy. Zelma is here.
Nobody said anything for a while. A ping went over, late.
"You've got something on your felt," said Zelma. "I expect it's lime."
"I expect it is."
"It will want looking at." She got up. She closed the tablet, and she tucked it under one arm. It made surprisingly little difference. She looked at him at last, with those small round unforgiving eyes, for rather longer than the tally required. "I'm going on to the next valley," she said. "There's a coral there I've had a complaint about. I don't suppose you have any objection?"
"No," said Emlin. "Nobody objected."
They went along the shore together, not fast. It was about eleven by then.
It's still there, of course. You can go and look. There's nothing to stop you. It's read-only, and it will all stay as it is, for as long as there is anyone. You'd open the map, and find the valley, and when you bring the view down, all the coral will come up in its fronds to meet you. You will notice that the wheels of the cart are perfectly round.
It has three stacks on it, of which one is missing three slabs. Everybody knows why that is. There's a bowl on the edge, in a worn place, with a few good beads in it. There's a torn panel leaning against the wheel, and a good deal of it can't be read now, but low down in a box you can still make out some small square letters, and beside them a very neat, somewhat blocky hand has made two marks and left room for one more. It isn't done. She said that it wouldn't be.
Nine valleys off, on the shore of a pool, two low round creatures have got as far as a bend, and one of them has her foot in the air and is in the middle of saying something. You will want to know what. It is on the record that it was about the coral.
There's a creature in the middle of the ring, standing on the edge of the cart, who has called a standup, for no reason, at ten past eleven at night. It's the first that she ever called. They all came. She has got one ear up. She had just read out the record, and had lifted one foot to get down, and asked what comes next, when the light came on in the Ring, in the long block east of the gap, and so every one of them has stopped where they stood, glowing, with one foot raised, and is looking up. Nobody has answered.
One of them isn't looking up. It's small and brown, and it is looking at her, with close attention, because she asked a question. It has its mouth open.
You can stand there as long as you like.
$ orra standup --camp nohup --called-by Mabel present ............ 22 of 22 (2 on the road) yesterday .......... foraged; moved; pushed the cart today .............. forage; soup (resting); name the child: done. It is Carry blockers ...........